Kavita Verma (10/ICE/025) Prateek Roshan (10/ICE/033) PLATE GIRDER BRIDGES 27 April 14 A PRESENTATION ON Girder bridges Flexure or bending between vertical supports is the main structural action in this type. Girder bridges may be either solid web girders or truss girders or box girders. Plate girder bridges are adopted for simply supported spans less than 50 m and box girders for continuous spans upto 250 m. Cross sections of a typical plate bridge is shown below:- Figure: Plate girder bridge section What is a plate girder bridge?
A plate girder bridge is a bridge supported by two or more plate girders braced together to the required stiffness. The plate girders are typically I-beams made up from separate structural steel plates which are welded or, in older bridges, bolted or riveted together to form the vertical web and horizontal flanges of the beam. PLATE GIRDER BRIDGES
Plate girders became popular in the late 1800's, when they were used in construction of railroad bridges. The plates were joined together using angles and rivets to obtain plate girders of desired size. By 1950's welded plate girders replaced riveted and bolted plate girders in developed world due to their better quality, aesthetics and economy. The use of plate girders rather than rolled beam sections for the two main girders gives the designer freedom to select the most economical girder for the structure.
ADVANTAGES OF USING STEEL FOR GIRDERS Reduced dead loads. More economic foundations. Simpler erection procedures. Shorter execution time. Faster and easier rehabilitation. Durability. CLASSIFICATIONS OF PLATE GIRDER BRIDGES There are three classifications under this grouping:- These are deck type, through type or semi-through type. DECK TYPE BRIDGES It refer to those in which the road deck is carried on the top flange or on top of the supporting girders. The deck slab or sleeper may cantilever out to some extent beyond the extreme longitudinal girder. The bracing of the top flange or lateral support of the top chord under compression is also required. Figure: Deck type The semi-through bridge, has its deck midway and the deck load is transmitted to the girder through the web of the girder. The deck lies in between the top and the bottom of the main load carrying members. The bracing of the top flange or top chord under compression is not done and part of the load carrying system project above the floor level In this also, the main girders are on the either side of the deck.
Figure: Semi-through type In through type bridges, the decking is supported by the bottom flange of the main supporting girders provided on either side .i.e. the carriageway rests at the bottom level of the main load carrying members (girders). In the through type plate girder bridge, the roadway or railway is placed at the level of bottom flanges.
Figure: Through type PLATE GIRDER BRIDGES
If large embankment fills are required in the approaches to the bridge, in order to comply with the minimum head-room clearance required, the half through bridge is more appropriate. This arrangement is commonly used in railway bridges where the maximum permissible approach gradient for the track is low. In this case the restraint to lateral buckling of compression flange is achieved by a moment resisting U-frame consisting of floor beam and vertical stiffness, which are connected together with a moment resisting joint. PLATE GIRDER BRIDGES
Half through is adopted when the cost of additional embankment to raise the rail level is high. If the construction depth is not critical, then a deck-type bridge, is a better solution, in which case the bracings provide restraint to compression flange against lateral buckling. PLATE GIRDER HIGHWAY BRIDGE
A plate girder highway bridge will consist of the deck slab (normally of reinforced concrete) and stringers running longitudinally and resting on transverse floor beams, which in turn rest on the plate girders.
The photo above is the underside of a steel deck plate girder span. The steel girders are nearly twice as tall as the concrete girders, but they also span longer distances between piers. PLATE GIRDER RAILWAY BRIDGE
In the case of a railway bridge, the plate girders carry the wooden sleepers over which the steel rails are fastened. The girder bridges will be braced laterally at the level of the top flange and the bottom flange, besides cross bracings to resist the lateral load due to wind. The cross bracings consist of angles and are provided at the ends and at intervals of about 5m.
Figure: Plate girder railway bridge Initial design of main plate girder is generally based on experience or thumb rules. Such rules also give a good estimate of dead load of the bridge structure to be designed. For highway and railway bridges, indicative range of values for various overall dimension of the main girders are given below: Overall depth, D: L/18 D L/12 (Highway bridges) D: L/10 D L/7 (Railway bridges Flange width, 2b: D/4 2b D/3 Flange thickness, T: b/12 T b/5 Web thickness, t: t D/125 Here, L is the length between points of zero moment.
FATIGUE EFFECT
Under cyclic load, experienced by bridges, flaws in tension zone lead to progressively increasing crack and finally failure even though stresses are well within the static strength of the material. It may be low cycle fatigue, due to stress ranges beyond yielding or high cycle fatigue, at stresses below the elastic limit. IS: 1024 gives the guide line for evaluating fatigue strength of welded details, that may be used to evaluate the fatigue strength. Stress concentration may lead to premature cracking near bracing stiffener and shear connector welds. Proper detailing of connections is needed to favourably increase design life of plate girders. LATERAL BRACING FOR PLATE GIRDERS Plate girders have a very low torsional stiffness and a very high ratio of major axis to minor axis moment of inertia. Thus, when they bend about major axis, they are very prone to lateral-torsional instability as shown in figure.
Adequate resistance to such instability has to be provided during construction. In the completed structure, the compression flange is usually stabilized by the deck. Figure: Lateral torsional buckling If the unrestrained flange is in compression, distortional buckling is a possible mode of failure and such cases have to be adequately braced. Thus, lateral bracings are a system of cross frames and bracings located in the horizontal plane at the compression flange of the girder, in order to increase lateral stability. Figure: Distorsional buckling BEARINGS Bridge bearing is an element of superstructure which provides an interface between the superstructure and substructure. This interface is vital because superstructure undergoes dimensional changes and deformations due to various factors which are listed as follows: Thermal expansion/contraction Elastic deformation under live load Seismic forces Creep and shrinkage of concrete
Settlement of supports Longitudinal forces - tractive/ breaking Wind loads. The bearings transmit the load received from the decking on to the substructure and are provided for distribution of the load evenly over the substructure material which may not have sufficient bearing strength to bear the superstructure load directly. These also allow for longitudinal movement of girders due to longitudinal forces of moving loads and temperature variation. BEARINGS Figure: Typical Semi-through railway bridge FABRICATION OF STEEL GIRDERS Construction of composite welded steel plate girder type ROBs ** at Barnala (Punjab) and Budhwala (Punjab) level crossing by the Indian railway in Ambala division.
**ROBs:- The structure crossing the railway track and carrying road way above is called a Road Over Bridge. TESTING OF STEEL PLATE FOR FLAWS Primarily necessary step If internal flaw present in steel plate it can grow due to bending moment and shear force.
DIGISCAN-322 ultrasonic testing equipment used at BARNALA (PUNJAB) Ultrasonic Testing (UT) uses high frequency sound energy to conduct examinations and make measurements. Ultrasonic inspection can be used for flaw detection/evaluation,dimensional measurements, material characterization.
Worker checking for flaws in Steel plate at site
Figure: Diagram showing how Testing equipment works and data appears on the screen.
CUTTING OF STEEL PLATE This is a operation done at the site to get the desired shape of steel plates being use in the construction of deferent components of the structure. Oxy-fuel gas cutting is use for this purpose at site. Oxy-fuel cutting are processes that use fuel gases and oxygen to cut metals. LPG is used as fuel gas at site for the cutting purpose.
Oxygen and LPG Gas cylinders at the site
PUG CUTTING MACHINE
Pug cutting machine is automated flame cutting machine which is used for cutting of ferrous metal sheets and plates . An aluminium track is designed over which the machine moves and the speed of this machine can be adjusted according to the thickness of the cutting metals by electronic control switch.
Pug cutting machine over aluminium track being used in Fabrications of 46m span composite girders of Br. No 92-B at Barnala by Northern Railway.
Being small in size and light weight, the machine can be easily carried to the worksite and placed directly track fixed on the on the plate to be cut. It cuts with rectangular and smooth surface with minimum wastage of steel in cut width. Figure: Finished surface after gas cutting
DRILLING OF HOLES Prior to welding the plates into the girders required number of holes of prescribed dimensions has been done at the site in the plates with the help of drilling machines. These driven holes will be use for connecting adjacent girder with help of steel plates, bracing and gusset plate. At the site drilling of has been done by two types of drilling machine: Portable drilling machine. Fixed drilling machine.
Portable type drilling machine have electromagnetic base. Easy to move. Generally Use for the drilling in web plate and splice plate.
Figure: Portable drilling machine use by a person for drilling holes in web plate PORTABLE TYPE DRILLING MACHINE Figure: Steel plate showing holes driven by portable drilling machine FIXED TYPE DRILLING MACHINE Use for drilling of holes into flange plate and splice plate which is use for connecting of adjacent girder. Bottom part of the machine is fixed over the base The upper assembly can rotate over the base and drilling part of the machine can move with the help of track attached to the upper part of the machine.
Figure: Steel plates and girder WELDING PROCEDURE During the fabrication, welding of the girder has been done in the different phase. Fillet welding of 8mm unless specify. Procedure is described in the following photographs shown below. Placing of web plate over platform
Figure: Flange plate is being placed by the side of web plate
Welding of U-shaped plate to the web and flange plate to keep flange perpendicular to web
Tack welding
Welding of inclined road to keep web & flange at perpendicular to each other Hammering to remove the U- shaped plate
Placing of temporary welded girder over inclined platform for welding with the help of SAW tractor STIFFENERS Stiffeners are required where factored concentrated loads or reactions exceed the factored compressive (vertical) resistance of the plate girder web. Failure due to concentrated loads can be as local buckling of the web in the region where it joins the flange, or overall buckling of the web throughout its depth
TRANSVERSE STIFFENERS If a girder has insufficient strength (web local yielding or web crippling) to support concentrated point loads then a pair of transverse stiffeners can be added to the web to transfer the concentrated force to the web.
Transverse stiffeners
BEARING STIFFENERS Bearing stiffeners are placed over the end bearings of welded plate girders and over the intermediate bearings of continuous welded plate girders. They consist of two or more plates placed on both sides of the web.
Bearing stiffners SPLICE PLATE OR COVER PLATE Splice plate or cover plates are used to join the web and flanges of plate girder bridge. These are connected to the steel girders through bolts or fasteners. Bolts or fasteners are used because bolted joint is more flexible than welded one. If any bolt fails it can be easily replaced by another one without giving any support. If any girder fails then it can be replaced easily in bolted connection as compared to the welded one.
Splice plate temporary welded to the flanges before drilling of holes
Heat Transfer and Pressure Drop Characteristics of Finned Tube Banks in Forced Convection (Comparison of The Heat Transfer Characteristics Between Spiral Fin and Serrated Fin)