Student Loans: A NYPIRG Student Empowerment Workshop
I. Intro NYPIRG [NYPIRG is an exceptional resource for students]
A. A place to learn new skills while working on important issues B. PC(s) - fulltime staff person(s) trained in student development C. Issue experts and staff attorneys working for and with students D. Student oard of !irectors to choose issues and identify programming needs E. "orkshops addressing issues# organi$ing# communications# leadership# civic action# financial literacy# student housing%tenants rights and now student loans II. Intro Workshop: College students are &orrowing a lot of money# student loan de&t has passed credit card de&t# topping '( trillion) Students are finding it difficult to pay loans &ack# recent headlines may have left students unsure# and direct marketing companies# working for lenders# use many advertising tactics- some even illegal- to promote their loans to students# regardless of the &est interest of the student) *he A+ found that companies were using deceptive offers# fraudulent solicitations or illegal incentives) !"e#t$%e: ,-PI.+ prepared this workshop to help students sort through the marketing and to give them the information they need to manage and payoff their de&t) It will help students who will soon graduate with student loan de&t to understand the choices they will soon face regarding payment plans# deferments and for&earances# and loan consolidation) This workshop is not a one-on-one financial planning session, so if ou ha!e specific "uestions on the right plan for ou, reach out to the ca#pus$s financial aid office [or insert other ca#pus depart#ent, or co##unit group]) In this workshop we will/ () .eview student loan de&t history 0) .eview the various types of student loans 1) *alk a&out managing your de&t - including choosing a payment plan and deciding whether to consolidate 2) !iscuss what to do if you have trou&le making payments 3) Identify various loan forgiveness programs availa&le to you 4) !iscuss recent federal student loan legislation 5) 6nd with a list of great online and real world resources you can use A. Student Loans Br$e& '$stor( () College students are &orrowing a lot of money7 Student loan de&t has passed credit card de&t# topping '( trillion) 15 million Americans hold outstanding student loan de&t# and 0)5 million of those de&t holders are ,ew -orkers) ,ew -ork graduates carrying student loan de&t had an average de&t of '05#1(8) 9n this campus the average student graduating with de&t owes [see econo#icdi!ersit%org for a#ount]) ( 0) Among all &achelor:s degree recipients# median de&t was7 '5#;48 at pu&lic four-year institutions '(5#828 at private not-for-profit four-year institutions 1(#(;8 at for-profit institutions) 1) Pell +rant recipients# who generally have family income under '38#888# are much more likely to &orrow and to &orrow higher sums 2) Students are finding it difficult to pay loans &ack 1 See www)economicdiversity)org for a campus-&y-campus list of average student de&t load) 02#<88 ,-S &orrowers defaulted on their student loans or were more than nine months delin=uent on their payments &etween 088; and 08(0) In 08(0# 2<> of 03-12 year-olds say they are unemployed or under-employed) 3) .ecent headlines may have left students unsure7 In 0885# Congress passed the College Cost .eduction and Access Act) "hen it expired# Congress made the &i-partisan decision to extend the 1)2> rate on the su&sidi$ed Stafford loan for one year# until ?uly ( st # 08(1) @nfortunately# Congress failed to meet this yearAs deadline of ?uly ( st and the rates instantly dou&led to 4)<>) And a less-student friendly &i-partisan solution passed that set interest rates to that of (8-year *reasury yields plus a Congressional add-on percentage) B. 'ow the Cred$t Cr$s$s $s a&&e#t$n) student *oans C. 'ow the Cred$t Cr$s$s $s not a&&e#t$n) student *oans III. +(pes o& Student Loans , (ou ma( a*read( ha%e: Perk$ns- Sta&&ord- P*us are &edera**( $ssued *oans. +here are a*so pr$%ate *oans. According to the CBP# roughly '<42 &illion is outstanding federal student loan de&t while the remaining '(38 &illion is in private student loans A. Perk$ns Loans7 *he Bederal Perkins Coan Program provides low interest loans for graduate and undergraduate students with exceptional financial need) the &est student loan terms) 1. Bor undergrad and grad students with most financial need) *he college acts as the lender (they determine the amount) using funds provided &y the federal government) -ou make payments to &ack to the college or its agent) ,ot all schools participate in the program) 0) *he amount you can &orrow depends on your financial need# the amount of other aid you receive# and the availa&ility of funds at your college or career school) 1) Students must file a Bree Application for Bederal Student Aid (BABSA) and Perkins promissory note as part of the application process for a Perkins Coan) 2) Su&sidi$ed loan 3) Coan program with the most opportunities for loan forgiveness7 loan cancellation for teacher service at low-income schools and under certain other circumstances specified in the law (D6A)) Students may defer repayment of the loan while enrolled (at least half-time) at a postsecondary school) 4) Can &orrow up to '3#338 per year for undergraduates and '05#388 totalE up to '<#888 per year for graduate or professional students and '48#888 total) Average ,ew Award as of 08((7 '(#;4< 5) @p to (8 years to pay off) ,o alternate payment plans unless you consolidate it together with Stafford loans) <) Interest .ate is set at 3> and there are no fees except for late payment ;) ; month grace period B. Sta&&ord Loans7 the largest source of federal student aid 0
() -ou &orrow from the Bederal +overnment Stafford Coans carry a fixed interest rate# and are typically the most afforda&le type of student loans At this school we [&heck with the financial aid office] 2 www)finaid)org 0) Su&sidi$ed7 for students with demonstrated financial need-- the federal government pays the interest while you:re in college and during grace and deferment 1) @nsu&sidi$ed7 all students are eligi&le--you pay all the interest on the loan# and it gets added to your total (capitali$ed) while you:re in college 2) Interest .ates F Bees Bederal law sets the maximum interest rates and fees charged Stafford loans &orrowed after ?uly (# 0884 have a fixed interest rate of 4)<> In 0885# a Bederal law passed that cut interest rates in half &y 08(() Birst reduction (from 4)<> to 4>) Coans in 088< have 4> interest rate# 088; saw decrease to 3)4># 08(8 saw decrease to 2)3># and 08(( saw decrease t8 1)2> which was extended in 08(0) "hen this law (and the one year extension) expired in ?uly 08(1# unfortunately# Congress let rates dou&led to 4)<>) And a less-student friendly &i-partisan solution passed that set interest rates to that of (8-year *reasury yields plus a Congressional add-on percentage) *he rates will vary year-to-year with the market &ut will stay fixed throughout the repayment life of the loan and will &e capped at <)03> for all undergraduate loans) Students taking out loans for this year should expect to pay 1)<4> (rates are higher for parent and graduate loans)) -ou pay a (> origination fee Stafford Loan Interest Rates Academic Year Subsidized Rates Unsubsidized Rates Graduate Rates 2011-12 3.40% 6.80% 6.80% 2012-13 3.40% 6.80% 6.80% 2013-14* 3!"# 3!"# $41# Current Stafford Loan interest rates in effect from 07/01/2013 to 06/30/2014 *Tese rates a!e "een u#dated to ref$ect te ne% student $oan interest rate $e&is$ation tat %ent into effect on 'u&ust () 2013. 3) Choice of payment plans7 standard ((8 years)# extended# graduated and income &ased 4) +race Period and Gaximum Amounts 4 Gonth grace period - time &etween graduation % leaving school and when you have to start paying Coan limits vary &y year# type of degree# and type of loan (su&sidi$ed or unsu&sidi$ed)) Stafford Loan Limits %e&endent Students Annua' Loan Limits *irst +ear ,-)-00 .,3)-00 su"sidi/ed/,2)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Second +ear ,6)-00 .,4)-00 su"sidi/ed/,2)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Tird +ear and 1e2ond ,7)-00 .,-)-00 su"sidi/ed/,2)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Inde&endent Students Annua' Loan Limits *irst +ear ,()-00 .,3)-00 su"sidi/ed/,6)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Second +ear ,10)-00 .,4)-00 su"sidi/ed/,6)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Tird +ear and 1e2ond ,12)-00 .,-)-00 su"sidi/ed/,7)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 3raduate or 4rofessiona$ ,20)-00 .,8)-00 su"sidi/ed/,12)000 unsu"sidi/ed0 Lifetime Limits 5nder&raduate 6e#endent ,31)000 .5# to ,23)000 ma2 "e su"sidi/ed0 5nder&raduate 7nde#endent ,-7)-00 3raduate or 4rofessiona$ ,138)-00 .5# to ,6-)000 ma2 "e su"sidi/ed0 or ,224)000 .for 8ea$t 4rofessiona$s0 *or $oans first dis"ursed on or after 9u$2 1) 2008. C. P*us Loans () Bederal loans that graduate or professional degree students or parents of dependent undergrads can &orrow to help you pay for college) 0) @)S) !ept of 6ducation makes the loan through !irect Coan Program 1) Su&Hect to credit approval 2) @nsu&sidi$ed loan 3) Interest .ates and Bees Bederal law sets the maximum interest rates and fees PC@S loans have a fixed 4)2(> interest rate Pay a 2)082> origination fee# deducted from each dis&ursement 4) +race Period# Gaximum Amount# 9ther !etails *here is no grace period) .epayments &egin 48 days after dis&ursement while you:re in school) Gust sign a Gaster Promissory ,ote (GP,) and graduate or professional students need to complete entrance counseling &efore receiving a PC@S loan Gax loan amount is cost of attendance minus other financial aid) D. Pr$%ate Edu#at$on Loans .A*ternat$%e Loans/: "as the fastest growing segment of loan Industry 1 () Coans that are not secured &y the federal government) 9ffered &y &anks# credit unions and other lenders) 2. ecoming increasingly prevalent as cost of higher education rises 2 1) Garketed aggressively - lots of commercials# direct mail etc 2) Su&Hect to credit approval and &etter interest rates for &etter scores 3) *erms of private%alternative loans are typically worse than federally &acked loans Digher interest rates o ,ot capped &y the federal law o 9ften varia&le rates (prime interest rate plus some percentage)# while federally &acked loans have fixed rates o Sketchy marketing7 may advertise the lowest interest rate they offer (to the most credit worthy &orrowers) rather than the entire range of rates they offer) ,o real loan forgiveness options o ,o death%permanent disa&ility forgiveness - heirs would have to pay de&t out of your estate o ,o forgiveness for going into high-needs fields Cess flexi&le payments o !on:t have to offer the four (Standard# 6xtended# +raduated# and Income ased) payment plans o Gy offer some flexi&ility - like interest only payments for a time Bewer%less flexi&le deferment options o Gost offer deferment for student enrollment (though interest is capitali$ed) o Gay not offer or may limit hardship for&earances 4) Should only &e used as a last resort Gake dou&ly sure you:ve exhausted every federally &acked option (Stafford# @nsu&sidi$ed Stafford# PC@S loans etc)) &efore turning to private loans .ead and reread the fine print in the offer A,! on the promissory note &efore signing Students typically have lower credit scores (they have short credit histories) so if you have to take out a private loan# getting a parent to cosign will save you money (assuming they have &etter credit than you) ,ever &orrow more than you need to pay your cost of attendance - extra has to &e counted as an asset in the federal financial aid formulas Shop around# &ut &e careful &ecause terms%rates may &e descri&ed differently from lender to lender) E. 0nsure a!out wh$#h *oan (ou ha%e 1 wh$#h terms2 () !ig up the papers and keep them all in one file 0) Iisit ,ational Student Coan !ata System (www)nslds)ed)gov) Dave to enter some personal information and apply for a PI, num&er 1) Ask the financial aid office *hey have it all on file 3 ProHect 9n Student !e&t# Pri!ate 'tudent (oan Polic )genda# see at http7%%proHectonstudentde&t)org%initiativeJview)phpKinitiativeJidxL5 4 *en years ago# only five percent of total education loan volume was in private loans) *oday they represent an estimated 08 percent of what all undergraduate# graduate# and professional students and their families &orrow to pay for school) Bederal regulations re=uire you to have an exit interview with them &efore graduation I3. 4ana)$n) Student Loan De!t A. Cons$der Conso*$dat$on () .efinancing two or more student loans into one larger loan) -ou can consolidate federal student loans) Bederal law sets the length of these loans and caps the interest rates) 2. !ifferent types of Bederal loans can &e consolidated together (e)g) Su&sidi$ed with unsu&sidi$ed or Stafford with Perkins)) 3
3. Can only consolidate during the grace period or repayment) 4
2) -ou can:t consolidate private loans together with federal loans) ut you can consolidate private loans with other private loans) 3) Interest .ates and Bees Interest .ate L the weighted average of the interest rates on the loans &eing consolidated# rounded up to the nearest (%< of a percent and capped at <)03> -- doesn:t really change the cost of the loan 5 *here are no fees to consolidate federal loans Private consolidation loans have interest rate informed &y your credit score and will likely have fees 4) enefits Single monthly payment 9ften reduces si$e of monthly payments Bor older loans (&efore ?uly 0884)# trade varia&le interest for a fixed rate Access to alternate repayment plans for PC@S and Perkins &orrowers .esets the 1-year clock to apply for deferments%for&earances (if you:ve used up your allowed deferments%for&earances) PC@S &orrowers (from private lenders) can reduce interest from <)3> to <)03> Private lenders may offer timely payment discounts and other incentives Bor private loans# if your credit score has improved you may get lower interest 5) !raw&acks -ou pay more over the life of the loan Can cut short you grace period Cose &enefits of the Perkins loan (expanded forgiveness options# no default fees) Gay lose (or have to repay) discounts related to current BB6C loans B. Pa(ment p*ans *here are 2 types of repayment plans that Stafford loan &orrowers and consolidation loan &orrowers can choose from or switch &etween7 standard# extended# graduated and income &ased) Plus loan &orrowers can use all &ut the income &ased plans) *his flexi&ility helps# &ut remem&er that changes that decrease your monthly payment increase your time to pay off the loan and the total amount you pay) 5 Parents and students can not consolidate their loans together) 6 Coans that are in default &ut with satisfactory repayment arrangements may also &e consolidated) Bor example to consolidate a defaulted loan with the !irect Coan program the &orrower must agree to use the Income Contingent payment plan) 7 Bormula7 de&t ( M interest rate ( N de&t 0 M interest rate 0 N de&t 1 M interest rate 1 / L interest rate de&t ( N de&t 0 N de&t 1 / () Standard -ou to pay a fixed amount# at least '38# each month @p to (8 years to pay off the loan Digher payments &ut fastest way out of de&t and least interest paid 0) +raduated Start with small payments# which go up every two years (st payments are interest only or half the standard plan payment# whichever is greater Cast payments are much larger--up to ()3 times the standard plan payment Dave (8 years to pay off the loan# depending on amount 1) 6xtended -ou pay a fixed amount each month Dave up to 03 years to pay off the loan# depending on amount < Cower payments &ut you pay more in interest 2) Payments &ased on income a) Income Contingent (for !irect Coan orrowers) your monthly payments are adHusted to an afforda&le level each year# *he amount calculated using your tax return# your family si$e# your interest rate and the total amount you owe) ;
After 03 years any remaining &alance is forgiven &) Income Sensitive (Bor BB6C orrowers) Payments are a fixed percentage of gross monthly income Dave to reapply every year and provide proof of income Cength of loan is (8 years c) Income ased (,ew for &oth BB6C and !irect Coan orrowers) Part of College Cost .eduction and Access Act of 0885 @ses a more generous formula that assumes less availa&le income to calculate monthly payments (8 After 03 years any remaining &alance is forgiven 3) Comparing the cost [*rite this ta+le on the chalk+oard Pa(ment pt$ons &or a 567-888 Loan at 9: ;; Comparing Payment Plan Costs for a $35,000 Loan at 6.0% Plan Term Initial Monthly Payment Total Cost of Loan (Interest Payments! Standard 10 years $ 388.57 $ 46,628.40 8 Cess than '(8#888 (0 years# '(8#888-'(;#;;; the term is (3 years# '08#888-'1;#;;; the term is 08 years# '28#888- '3;#;;; the term is 03 years# and for de&ts of '48#888 or more the term is 18 years) 9 Caps monthly payments at 08> of the difference &etween AdHusted +ross Income and (88> of the federal poverty line 10 Caps monthly payments at (3># of the difference &etween AdHusted +ross Income and (38> of the poverty line 11 Chart made using calculators availa&le at finaid)org) Interest paid under the Income Contingent Plan would vary &ased upon the si$e and changes in a &orrower:s income over time) Graduated 10 years $ 263.25 $ 48,882.37 Extended Fixed 30 years Graduated -30 years $ 225.51 $ 175.00 $ 67,653.00 $ 73,601.05 In!"e #!ntin$ent %Initia& sa&ary !' $25,000( 18 years) $ 243.33 $ 57,*03.45 3. Re#ent <edera* Loans 0pdates A. !ama=s Student Loan De!t,Re*$e& P*an a) A new e=uation for Income-ased .epayment (I.)) I. is a repayment plan for the maHor types of federal student loans that caps your re=uired monthly payment at an amount intended to &e afforda&le &ased on your income and family si$e) &) Implemented &y executive order since taxpayer su&sidies to private &anks for student loans was outlawed (govAt &acked private loans nixed)) Saves govAt '48 &illion over the next (8 years- can now ta&&ed for direct govt loans and repayment programs) "ill not cost taxpayers anything) c) "ho does this affectK i) (from !ept of 6d) ()4 million students graduating starting in 08(0) And an additional estimated 3)< million people who took out different kinds of federal loans no earlier than 088< and take out an additional loan after 08(0 who will &e a&le to consolidate them into one loan) d) *he Os7 caps loan payments at (8> of their discretionary income starting in 08(0 (as opposed to (3> &y 08(2) e) Borgives &alances after 08 years (from 03 years) f) *he @S !epartment of 6ducation# which now administers all federal education loans# is giving &orrowers the option of consolidating federal and private loans (Bederal Bamily 6ducation Coan (BB6C) Program) at reduced rates) B. Bene&$ts a) Pay as you earn7 monthly payment amount will &e less than the amount you would &e re=uired to pay under a (8-year standard repayment plan# and may &e less than under other repayment plans) Although lower monthly payments may &e of great &enefit to a &orrower# these lower payments may result in a longer repayment period and additional accrued interest) &) Interest payment &enefit7 if your monthly I. payment amount does not cover the interest that accrues on your loans each month# the government will pay your unpaid accrued interest on your Su&sidi$ed Stafford Coans (either !irect Coan or BB6C) for up to three consecutive years from the date you &egan repaying your loans under I.) c) 08--ear &alance forgiveness7 if you repay under the I. plan for 08 years and meet certain other re=uirements# any remaining &alance will &e canceled) d) (8--ear pu&lic service forgiveness7 if you work in pu&lic service# on-time# full monthly payments you make under I. (or certain other repayment plans) while employed full-time in a pu&lic service Ho& will count toward the (08 monthly payments that are re=uired to receive loan forgiveness through the Pu&lic Service Coan Borgiveness Program) *hrough this program# you may &e eligi&le to have the remaining &alance of your !irect Coans forgiven after you have made the (08 =ualifying monthly payments as descri&ed a&ove) *he Pu&lic Service Coan Borgiveness Program is availa&le only for !irect Coans) C. D$sad%anta)es a) !oesnAt cover anyone who took out loans &efore 088< (that wonAt &e taking out more loans starting now)) &) !oesnAt cover purely private loans7 typically taken out# though# when students exhaust their federal loan amounts c) !oesnAt cover defaulted loans d) -ou may pay more interest7 the faster you repay your loans# the less interest you pay) e) So I. isnAt focused on assisting with the overall &urden of student loans of the average student) Instead# it intends to help those with lots of student loans who either have a low income after school during their early years or have a relatively low income throughout their career) 3. When Student Loan De!t Seems 0nmana)ea!*e A. A%o$d De&au*t () In default after ; months of missed payments 0) Collection agencies will hound you 1) Cate fees and collections costs 2) Credit record%score damaged for 5 years 3) -ou might &e sued 4) Paychecks may &e garnished up to (8> 5) Income tax refunds sei$ed <) ecome ineligi&le for other state and federal student aid ;) *hese de&ts never go away# usually not even in &ankruptcy B. De&erment () A temporary &reak from loan payments for eing enrolled at least (%0 time in college# or in a graduate fellowship# or reha&ilitation program for a disa&ility @nemployment 6conomic hardship Peace Corps Active Gilitary !uty 0) Casts up to 1 years 1) Dave to apply with lender 2) Bor su&sidi$ed loans Bed government pays interest# for unsu&sidi$ed you have to pay it during deferment or have it added to your principle (capitali$ed) C. <or!earan#e () Shorter term &reak from loan payments 0) Bor &orrowers who don:t =ualify for a deferment &ut need a &reak AmeriCorps service Internships F residencies Binancial hardship 1) Casts up to (0 months at a time &ut can &e renewed for up to 1 years 2) have to apply with lender 3) -ou pay (or capitali$e) the interest regardless of su&-or unsu&sidi$ed loan D. Sw$t#h to In#ome Based Repa(ment P*an () Gonthly payments are adHusted to an afforda&le level (prior example under Bederal Coans update section) 0) Dow to apply for I.7 Bor more information a&out and to apply for I.# contact the servicer(s) of your student loans) If you are not sure who your loan servicer is or would like more information a&out your loans# you can look it up on www)nslds)ed)gov) 3I. Loan <or)$%eness Pro)rams State and federal government offer a num&er of programs to forgive all or part of your student loan) *hey:re for students who study and work in particular high need or pu&lic service fields) A) Bor details on high need or pu&lic service fields# go-to http7%%www)finaid)org%loans%pu&licservice)phtml ,% for exa#ple- Caw 6nforcement or Corrections officer - as an example of the many opportunities to forgive Perkins loans Pu&lic Sector 6mployees - far reaching example of forgiveness [look to the footnote for further explanation] *eacher level ( and 0 - the most commonly known program 3II. <ree 4one(2 *hink a&out Binancial Aid# +rants# or "ork Study first Bederal Student Aid# an office of the @)S) !epartment of 6ducation# ensures that all eligi&le individuals can &enefit from federally funded financial assistance for education &eyond high school) *oday# Bederal Student Aid performs a range of critical functions that include# among others7 o 6ducating students and families on the process of o&taining aidE o Processing millions of student financial aid applications each yearE o !is&ursing &illions of dollars in aid funds to students through schoolsE and o 6nforcing financial aid rules and regulations 3III. Resour#es A. <or In&ormat$on and Resear#h 11 www.studentde!ta*ert.or) ,, Student PI.+:s "e& site a&out student de&t activism) Includes a Student !e&t -ear&ook where you can post or view picture and profiles of students struggling with de&t) 11 www.pro"e#tonstudentde!t.or) ,, Cots of research and advocacy a&out student loan de&t# including state-&y-state data 11 www.e#onom$#d$%ers$t(.or) ,, Das average student loan de&t for almost every college in the country B. <or 'e*p w$th Your Loans () www.#o**e)e&$nan#e#enter.or) P creates a personali$ed college finance plan or repayment plan &ased on your individual information and situation www.studenta$d.ed.)o%,, *he !epart of 6ducation:s "e& site has rules and regulations re student loans 0) www.&$na$d.or) ,, 9ffers lots of information# calculators to help you compare loans# estimate payments and more 1) 4app$n),(our,&uture.or) ,, *ons on info on student loans# career planning# financial aid# etc) Some college financial aid offices use it for federally mandated student loan entrance and exit interviews for students 2) www.om!udsman.ed.)o% ,, *he Bederal Student Aid 9m&udsman of the !epartment of 6ducation helps resolve disputes and solve other pro&lems with federal student loans) Site offers lots of resources to educate and help yourself and# if that fails# they can help you individually) 3) NYS Attorne( Genera* ,, Bor unfair# anti consumer treatment# call the ,-S Attorney +eneral:s hotline7 (-<88-55(-5533) *heir investigations are ongoing) 4) www.ns*ds.ed.)o% ,, ,ational Student Coan !ata System "e& site allows you to look up your student loan information) 5) +he >(our s#hoo*? <$nan#$a* A$d &&$#e ,, Dave your information on file <) Are re=uired to give &orrowers an exit interview to help them plan to manage their student loan de&t# and learn their rights and responsi&ilities)