Note to Reader: I focused on introducing and providing follow up commentary to quotes. I also added my inquiry question to provide clarity as to what I want to talk about in the paper. Im satisfied with the tone of my paper and content. Im not sure at this point what, if anything, I would further revise. Ill never forget my freshman year at the University of Nebraska when I had my first drink of alcohol. It was a Budweiser. I recall thinking it was disgusting but everybody promised me it would get better so I continued. After my third, I was slurring my words and fell back in a chair and hit my head on a wall that briefly stopped the party. I immediately got up and continued my conversation which caused everybody to break out in laughter. Are you alright?! several people asked and I had no idea why. Apparently the noise of my head hitting the wall sounded as if I shouldve been concussed but I had no clue because I felt nothing. A series of epic tales involving alcohol would ensue, ruining all hopes I had of playing basketball for the University. After my dismissal from college my mom quickly drove across the country from Charlotte, North Carolina to Lincoln, Nebraska to retrieve me and bring me back. All was not lost however, because I quickly received scholarship offers to play basketball in North Carolina. I had had enough of college, after my previous run so the next step was the military. I met my soon to be wife at 21 and joined the Air Force at 22 bringing her along with me. What I thought would be a chance to leave alcohol alone and get a little more structure and discipline in my life didnt quite turn out to be the case. Twelve years later, I wonder what is the significance of the culture around alcohol and drinking in the U.S. Military?
Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
My first base I was assigned to was in Great Falls, Montana. You can imagine the culture shock I had going from relatively big city living to mountains, horses, and one stoplight towns. Another thing they had plenty of was alcohol. You could buy it at a cheaper price than anywhere off base and considering there wasnt much off base that is usually what your nights were spent doing. I was security forces at the time (military police) and our schedule consisted of being gone away from home (in the field) returning on the fifth day, followed by two and half days off, two training days then back out. My coworkers and I were together all the time on and off duty and the motto I quickly learned was work hard, play hard. With limited options available off base we usually drank and played video games or found one ran down club in town to go to which usually involved drinking and fights. Being in isolation for extended periods of time and boredom are not lost on people serving in the Navy who are stuck on a boat for relatively long periods of time. In a study titled Military Culture and Drinking Behavior Among U.S. Navy Careerist, a young female sailor spoke to this stating: Underway, while youre on a cruise, youre hitting ports that all there really is to do is drink. I mean, you can find other things to do, but when youre out to sea for 30, 40 days, you really just want to get of the ship and have a beer. Even people that dont normally drink are gonna be out there and may not know their limits. (Ames, Cunradi, Moore, Stern, 7) I dont see anything wrong with that. The only thing is most wont keep it to just a beer. It appeared to me that everyone drank. I recall being at an official military function and the chaplain, which is a military pastor, priest, reverend, etc., started drinking from the keg our leadership provided. This blew me away because how I was raised, I thought no member of the clergy drank. I ultimately chocked it up to my lack of knowledge of other denominations rules. We were all far away from home, overworked and Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
bored. Drink! At my going away party our boss showed up and brought me a case of beer and had a few himself before getting in his car and driving home. The next day, while still drunk, I gave an epic going away speech which involved me roasting multiple members of my flight (about 30 people) to which my leadership begged me to keep going. That was the environment, the job, and it was great. My next move landed me in England. England was great; however, the horrible work schedule didnt allow me to see much of it but again, the same work hard, play hard mentality applied here just as it did in Montana. It was here were I began to move up the ranks and started to see the implications of misusing alcohol. It is customary for an individual that is getting promoted to a higher rank to have a promotion party held in his/her honor. That individual proceeds to buy drinks for everyone because naturally with the new rank youll be acquiring new wealth. Typically, all coworkers from boss to peers to subordinates will show up to show their support for your success. However, make the wrong decision, better yet, get caught making the wrong decision and watch that support flee rapidly. I recall one of those very promotion parties taking place and the honoree left the function and proceeds to get a DUI on base. The new rank he was to acquire was taken and he was demoted two ranks back from his current and forfeited hundreds of dollars in pay. The contradictory nature of essentially promoting drinking at official functions and traditions then subsequently severely punishing someone that has an infraction upon leaving that function, never left me. I went on to see it happen in at least a dozen cases for the rest of my time in the military. The thing about it is that the punishment doled out was dictated on how well liked you were within that organization. There wasnt a standard punishment given to all violators. This was also noted by a female lieutenant in the Navy that Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
was asked Is there a standardized alcohol policy, and if so, is it enforced?: No, and its different for everyone, because if its a one-time occurrence, you say, Hey, dont let it happen again. If it happens on a continual basis, thats where you have to start documenting it, but it depends upon the leniency of the chain of command (Ames, Cunradi, Moore, Stern, 6). In England I also saw people finding significantly cheaper rent in off base homes/apartments if they bought their British landlord liquor. In every place in the world where there is military base/installation the alcohol will be priced significantly cheaper than anywhere off. The actual discount percentage is set by Department of Defense Instruction which states in part that alcohol will be: no more than 10 percent less than the best local shelf price in Alcohol Beverage Control (ABC) States and 5 percent less than the best local shelf price in non-ABC States. (Chu 5) The number is 10 percent for places overseas. (Chu 5) That is a perk afforded to those for serving in or working for the military. That is also the appeal of it and what allows most people to get drunk without breaking the bank in the process. While in England I was sent on my first deployment to Afghanistan and it was definitely tense to say the least. While on deployments to the Middle East you are required to abstain from alcohol because we dont want to offend members of the Islamic faith while occupying their country and punishments for violators range from reduction in rank (demotion) to being discharged from the military. This is expressed through a military document called General Order Number 1. General Order #1 states many things one of which is: This Order prohibits the actual or attempted importation, introduction, exportation, possession, purchase, sale, resale, distribution, transfer, manufacture, or consumption of any alcoholic beverage or alcohol- containing substance within the countries of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, and Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
Iraq (Commander, U.S. Naval Forces Central) I then went on to get stationed in Georgia where I deployed twice to Iraq among other places. It was in Iraq that I was schooled to the fact that there is just about always a way to circumvent rules/laws. I had a friend who worked in supply, which basically held all types of goods. He would then just really barter with members of coalition forces who apparently werent under as strict of rules as we were for alcohol in exchange for whatever they wanted that he had. People would also have family members pour out mouthwash and put alcohol in its place and have it sent over to them. This was all done to combat work related stress. Working twelve hour shifts, seven days a week for six months or more takes its toll on you. Add in seeing combat action and you bet people are coming back to their tents or whatever they are sleeping in and looking to pour something strong in a cup. Earlier, upon returning from my first deployment in Afghanistan to few years later coming back from Iraq, the Air Force and military in general started focusing more on different programs and reintegration was apart of that. Reintegration is the stage of the deployment cycle (pre-deployment, deployment, post-deployment or reintegration) characterized by the service members reentry into his or her daily life as experienced prior to deployment, or into a new civilian life, including the domains of work, family, and personal experiences. (Marek, Hollingsworth, DAniello, ORourke, Brock, Moore, Butler VI, and Zhang) During this time members are encouraged to ease back into normal activities and if having a drink was one of those activities then ease back into that too. My experiences were that nobody paid any attention to that. When we were on our way back everybody couldnt wait until we landed in Qatar where they had a three drink per day policy. They controlled this by assigning a card to you they would stamp each time you had a drink. Naturally, this could be circumvented by having your friends Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
that dont drink buy drinks for you using their card and yes this resulted in immediate intoxication, but hey work hard, play hard right?! Getting back to the states there were all sorts of programs that the Air Force had in place, like the 0-0-1-3 Drink responsibly program. What does 0-0-1-3- mean? The "first and second zeros" restate the law of zero underage alcohol use and zero driving while under the influence, or impaired by alcohol. The "one" indicates one drink per hour (one 12-ounce beer, four to five percent alcohol, or 1.5 ounce shot of 80-proof alcohol, or one five-ounce glass of wine at 11 percent alcohol). The "three" stands for no more than three drinks per evening of alcohol use. (McClendon) This is a great policy in theory but you would rarely see it in practice. That being said, I think the effort was there to try and put a stop to what was deemed a problem for troops returning from deployment and in general but perhaps the damage had been done for career airmen (those that reenlisted more than twice). I think the focus on new personnel entering would be a better target and have better results. This turned out to be the case at one base in San Antonio, Texas, where they wanted to combat Alcohol Related Incidents in technical training schools. Cindy McClendon, who writes for Goodfellow Air Force Bases official website, states the definition of an ARI as: (1) driving under the influence, incidents, and accidents; (2) underage drinking; (3) accidental injuries or death as the result of drinking (e.g., intoxicated and hurting oneself); (4) crimes against people when drinking (e.g., sexual assault, spouse/child abuse); and (5) crimes against property while drinking (e.g., intoxicated and damaging the neighbors property). (McClendon) In tech school, as we call it, the main problem was underage drinking and those that were busted for it would find themselves out of the military just as quick as they were in. The test program involved giving a Brief Alcohol Intervention (BAI)(short briefing about the dangers of alcohol) Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
to the masses then conducting random alcohol Breathalyzers to underage airmen on weekends when they returned after being allowed to go leave the dorms. The test resulted in 19 fewer airmen getting kick out and $684K saved in training costs to replace them. (Klesges) In the eyes of the Air Force this test program was a huge success. Its great that they identified that there was a problem, but a one year trial doesnt seem to be doing enough. Perhaps the damage is done for service members prior to this trial, however, maybe going forward it will change the culture. I always wondered if this culture of drinking was specific to those of us in the Air Force or was it happening in other branches. According to a study titled: Alcohol Use and Preventing Alcohol-Related Problems Among Young Adults in the Military, which basically compared heavy alcohol use among young (18-24 years old) service members in all four branches as well as civilians in the same age range, it appears that no branch is exempt. For the males: Marines Corps 38.6%; Air Force 24.5%, Army: 32.8%, Navy: 31.8%. (Ames, Cunradi) For females the numbers are lower at: Marine Corps 12.9%, Navy 11.5%, Air Force and Army 6.3%. (Ames, Cunradi) In addition, more than half (53.8 percent) of all young military personnel reported at least one episode of binge drinking (defined here as having consumed five or more drinks on the same occasion at least once in the past 30 days) (Ames, Cunradi) Judging from those numbers, at a minimum, no less than 1in 4 of the males in any branch of service reported heavy alcohol use. Thats significant. Building on my curiosity, I thought, what if I had stayed in college. Would I have had the same drinking habits? As I mentioned, in the same study they compared these rates of military personnel with civilians of the same age enrolled in college and not enrolled. The study said: Of the young men in all branches of the military, 32.2 percent Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
engaged in heavy drinking, compared with 17.8 percent of civilian men. Women serving in the Navy and the Marine Corps had significantly higher rates (11.5 percent and 12.9 percent, respectively) than civilian women (5.5 percent); rates among women in the Army and Air Force (6.3 percent in each) did not differ significantly from those of their civilian counterparts. (Ames, Cunradi) If you look at the branches as jocks and geeks, the Air Force would be the only true geeks with the Navy getting an honorable mention. Stereotyping, jocks are athletic, not very intelligent, and love to party; geeks are the opposite. This is how its viewed within the culture as well which is why I dont find these numbers very surprising as far as which branches have the highest rates of heavy alcohol use. At the end of the day, I learned a lot, saw a lot, and drank a lot during my twelve years in the military. I definitely think that alcohol plays a significant role in the military culture through official ceremonies or as a means to cope with different variables such as stress, boredom, and loneliness. I cant say that those individuals that are abusing alcohol didnt join with those behaviors previously established. The military has also implemented policies to combat the problem regardless of fault; they recognize it is a problem. Ultimately, the onus is on the individual to decide if they want to be consumed by the culture or not because when it comes to rendering punishment for infractions the military is never at fault.
Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
WORKS CITED: Ames, Genevieve, and Carol Cunradi. " Alcohol Use and Preventing Alcohol-Related Problems Among Young Adults in the Military ." NIAAA Publications. N.p.. Web. 7 Apr 2014. <http://pubs.niaaa.nih.gov/publications/arh284/252-257.htm>. Ames, Genevieve M. et al. Military Culture and Drinking Behavior Among U.S. Navy Careerists. Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs 68.3 (2007): 336. Print. Chu, David. United States Government. Department of Defense. DoD Instruction 1330.9. 2005. Print. "Commander, U.S. Naval Forces Central/ U.S. 5th Fleet." Commander, U.S. Naval Forces Central/ U.S. 5th Fleet. N.p., n.d. Web. 09 Apr. 2014. Klesges, Robert C.Talcott, WayneEbbert, Jon O.Murphy, James G.McDevitt-Murphy, Meghan E.Thomas, FridtjofReese, Gregory J.Nicholas, Rena A. Effect of the Alcohol Misconduct Prevention Program (AMPP) in Air Force Technical Training. Military Medicine 178.4 (2013): 445451. EBSCOhost. Web. 1 Apr. 2014. Marek, Lydia, W. Glenn Hollingsworth, Carissa DAniello, Kathleen ORourke, Donna-Jean Brock, Lyn Moore, John Butler VI, and Jing Zhang. "Returning home: What we know about the reintegration of deployed service members into their families and communities | NCFR." Returning home: What we know about the reintegration of deployed service members into their families and communities | NCFR. N.p.. Web. 7 Apr 2014. Brent Ervin Ms. Hofmann Tales of A Drunk Airman English 1102-Sec-044 April 9, 2014
McClendon, Cindy. " 0-0-1-3 "Drink Responsibly" Program." goodfellow.af.mil. Goodfellow Air Force Base, 18 Dec 2012. Web. 7 Apr 2014. <http://www.goodfellow.af.mil/news/story.asp?id=123330353>. Whiteman, Shawn D, and Adam E Barry. A Comparative Analysis of Student Service Member/Veteran and Civilian Student Drinking Motives. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice 48.3 (2011): 297313. Print.
Mildred Aebisher and Muriel Gruff v. Bernard Ryan, Individually and in His Official Capacity as Principal, Oldfield Junior High School, Harborfields Central School District, 622 F.2d 651, 2d Cir. (1980)