Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 1 of 9

r
.

i! k ; ' . .y

C Ll V EN D B UN DY 3315 Gnl d But t e Road Bunker vl l l e ,Nv 9 8:9 7 PH ( 7 0 2 )2 46 .5564

' ' ''

' '' ) '

'
. '

. . Ib l7 . )3 :1' k f j i ' l: , 1
.

.!

I N THE UNI TED STATES D I STRI CT CO URT DI STRI CT 0 F N EVADA .

UN I TED STA TES 0 F A M ERI CA,
PI ai nt l f f ,

'

Cas e N0.CV 2: 12c v008 04LDGGW F

v.
C LI V EN BU ND Y
De f endant .

ANSW ER T0 C0 M PLAI NT

Thi sAns weri st i mel yf i l e d: Com e : N 0 W .Ct i ven D.Bundy,Pr o, $ T,a nd r es m ndst ot he a l l e ga t i ons s df or t hi nt he
ma t t e rn n med he r ei na i m e asf ol l ows :

1 . Wh hr e s wc tt o! 1i nt h e Co mp l s i n tI c a n ci t h e rn mr mn o rd e n ya tt hi st i me t h e
as s e r t i onst I X' t ' ei I L

2. Wi t hr e s mc tt o! 2i nt h e Co mp l n i n tld on d nu ' tt be r ewu s u c ha e q q ewi t l lt h ea l l e g M

l eg alc a pt i on Uni t e d &a/ 8 # K Cl i v e n #&pJp ,No.CVS98 531 J BR ( RJ . I I( Bt mdvh i n ora I mI Z t
t h e ye ara l l e ged. Howe ve r ,Ido he r e by de ny a ny a r v lal lal l ega t i o nsofvi ol a t i n g an ys uch Or de r
c om l ng outoft ha tp r oce edi ng orY i ng i n Tr es pas sa nm he r e by t he i l l e galnmm' ng ofc a t t l ef or

t l l ef ol l ow i ng r e as ons ;Thet hen e nt ke a ut er hy cl m' me db y Pl nl n t i Fa tt ba tt i me waspm s l mntt o

t l l e Endange r e dS#: ; / : , At tt #1 973( ESA 1 6U. S. C.j 1 531e ts e , q. le s t a bl i s hi ng t l xs o ca l l ed

O es er t Tor t oi s e' ' of Seut he m Ne w dn % i t l l r ea t en ed nnd enda nge r ed' ' pur s un nt t os a i d Act .

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 2 of 9

Howe ve r ,t he pa r t i c ul a rY es e r tTor t oi s e ' 't hey us e d wasne verpr ove nt o me e tt h ec r i t e r i aoft he

Ac twh e r e i nt h ec r i t t e rl h a dt ol xe n g a g e di nG f o r e l ' g nc o mme r c e ' 'p u r ml n n tt ot h eo r ki n a t ' mg

Tr e a t i e s ,s eet h- x di onsoft heActwhi c hs t a t ei n pa r t&sf onows :

( a )F/ ? ) # / J ? : :
T he t l t wgr 8 rI l t l dsa nd Jp c/ ar : ,t hat-

( 1 )p a ' r / p t ? . ' p e c i e sp // / #,wl l dl l l e , a n dpl an t s/ ? l t h et / / #/ : #S t a t e nh av e' Opr e n d e r e d

p x/ / ' / x/asa ' t ) / ? > 4&, J Y, otO t / pt l m/ cgr oyh and #,- / / ##? : ? # unt e mpnr e d: # ade ql l at e

c t wc 4 ' r pa n d: q z ? >r # !l / t ) p , '

az :i ' n #:4 :: / . olt ) rt hr e at e ne d w#/ ? xt l ct l Yn;

( 2 )ot h e r. J ) : t n p :o t/ / : / ? ,wl l d l l l n , a n dpl a n t s' ap :b ' e e ns o*:/ : *#l t 1 J ? p / l ? : : ? zt h at t h e y ( 3 )/ / ? : J :s pe c i e sp / f i s h ,F / / J / # : ,a n d#/ a p / :a r eo l : J / ? 2/ 2,e c o l o gi c a: #& ' a l / 5 p J4

hi n t cr i n a l ,r n c r e t i o n a l , an d, : / : / 7 / #/ :v a l u et ot h eSal / bpa n d/ 1 . : qe o pl e ; ( 4 )? / ? :Un i t e dS l al eh a sJ #, J #L . #l b8 I l a sas ov e r e i gns t a t ei nt hemt e r n a t i o n a l

' t =/ p&/ l J ? y ' l Jc o nn er v et o/ / *e xt e ntpr act i c a bl e/ / ? :v ar l i w. @ : c / p 4o tl l b h /? ' wi l dl l Y eand . :/ 4p2 f ac l hg e xt i nc t i on ,pl y,p aplt o-

@) ( A )t mi hg r a t o r y: / J #t r e a t i e s#/ / ? c a n a l aa n d#: , w ' t ) , . . e#/ # J ' a l / ( #a n dE n d a n g e r e d#/ #T r e a t yv # / ? J a p a l b ' ( S C ) t ? e &p p : ' p / / t w t m #: 1 & / ' : P r o t e di o n a p J F/ / # / / / : P r e s e r v a t i o ni n/ / ; pWe s t e r n d J ? ? / < p? ? : r 8 , '
( D)/ / ? :I nt n r n at i o n a lD pp : p/ / k ) pt o r/ / ? :No r t h- s t At l a nt i cF/ . / ? : r / ' , J , '

( E F )t / / h ? : I n t e r n a t i o n a l 6 ' t wp p / l l / / ? l t o rt h e / / , 4 / ? S e a sl > ) / ? : r / , . o l / / ? ,W o r t h ' a b # / :o c e a n ; e co nv e nt i on ( ? nI nt e r nat i t malTr adem J' pla/ gv : #S pec i e sotWi l d Fau na and
FI or a, ' and

( ( 9o t he ri n t e r n a t i o na l a g z ' : : me p/ J z ' an d
/ W Pur po s e s
7 / ) :pur pos e s( #t hi s ' / ; Z A J #: J ' ar et oJ l / ' t v/ #: a me ans e :r e gt hnd< * #4 ' / : / ? >u F n e 2/ ?
.

e ndange r e dJ J MJ / , J and / ? ? z ' : al : / ; Y s pe ci n s*J Mr ? # ma y be O p, er p e t ' o pr dpld a J e x a? pt ort he c t ) / ) . z ' &4/ / p? ?0tJ t / O' nda ng r e ds pec i e sa/ ? #t hr e at e ne ds pe c i e s ,and t o t ake , t / t Wn t e ps a, ma y& a ppr o pr i at et o ac hi ev et he pur pos e st #t he / J ' : a/ 24 and

c o nv e n t i o n s>/t o r t h/ ' / ? s u b s e di o n( a )5 /t h i s>: l / t w.

M dt he naf i nn ld ef mi on ofwha tt he c r ht e rne e dst ol xe nga ge 1 1 1 ;

( 9 )T / l et e r m' f o r e i g nc o mme r c e' ' i n c l u de s , t wl op ;ot he rl / # p J # , a n yl r a p . a : l / / / ? . . ( A): : / e: ? ? pe r s o n sF/ / / N ? ? o ne/ 4 e/ :/ 7 t o l mt r y; ( B ): : l e, z ? pn r s o n si n/ * o rm/ J :t ' o r e i g nOl z / ? l r / , . ; ( c ):: / l -: J ) al . J : t ww i t h l ht h eUn i t e dS / al : . a n da#p ? ' mT ? i naf or e i gnc / f / p / z y ; ' o r ( D) , / e, ppe r s o n swi t h i n1 / / ,Un i t e dSt a t e s ,e p r :t h e#: / ? an dF ## / / / :l h4 p p 4 / / 4 pa r e
mov i n gi n an y ' t wp/ z y orc t wnl i / : ,out e l te 1 / 1 : Uni t e d & al : 4 . .
2

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 3 of 9

Mor o ve r ,I% veope r a t pdun de rt hea ut hor i t yi n NRS 321 . 5965 99 ets e q( e fe c t i v eJ ul y

1 ,1 9 7 9 )wh e r e i nt h eSo v e r e i g nS t a t eof Ne v n d nbya n dt h r o l ehi t sLe g i s l a t u r el a i dc l a i mt ot h e

l n ndqi n ques t i on i nt he Bu ndv lma t t e ra nd t he I MI L Sns med i nt bi sm ndi ng mat t e r .' f he St a t eof
Ne va da l ai dc l ai mt oa l lI a ndswi t hi ni t sM r de r sr e t r oa ct i ve l yt o hsc omi ng i n t ot he Uni on. Thi s s ove r ei g na c toft he Pe opl e oft he St a t e ofNe va da t hr oug hi t sl e gi s l a t i ve a nd N BC Z m we r si ms

n e v e rI xe np r oN r l ya d j u di c a t e di n aCou r to fp r o pe r j u r i li di o l z sme a n i ngt h a tama t t e rofs uc h

mag ni t udede a l i ng wi t ht wo Sov e r e i gnl t l x Unhe d St a t e sa ndt be St a t e ofNeva dawoul d1 l a vet o

l xl l e a r d asa ma t t ert mde rt he Or i gi nalJ ur i s di c t i on Doc t l i ne N f or et he Uni t ed St at e s Supr e me

Cour t Th e onl ya t t e mpt soft r yi ng t ol odg e ahol di ng on t heowne r s hi p oft hepubl i cd oma i n ba s

%e n by wr ongf uls t i pul a t i on oft he Neva da At t or ney Gene r all xf or et hi s ve r yc our ti n Unl l e d Sl a/ g , M Wv e f/&/ l l z Thi s ve r y Cour twi s el yr ec ogmz 'ed i nt he di c t a ofi t s Or dert ba tt l u,a d

p r e v e n t e dt l x me r i t sof t h a t c a s ep r o c e e d i n go nf o rp r o m ra d j u di c a t i o a
Th e Ne vndnLa w,NRS 32l . 596599 et, : 4,i ss t i l la di v e1 aw wi t hi nt i t e St a t e ofNe vn dn
a nd hasne ve rY n r e pe al e db yt h e St a t e ofNev ada. n e r ef or esIha ve om r a t e d ove rt he ye a r s
um n t he r el i an ce oft hi sNew da La wa nd t he doc t r i ne ofne ce s s i t yt o pr ot ed my c omnmn l a w r i ght sofmy l i ve l i hood. I t1 x1 1 1 g we l ls et t l e dt b att he r ei s no gene r alf ede m lc ommnn l a w,J ' u s t

l x' cn n- aSt a t eAt t or ne y Gene r ale l edsnott oe nf om ea l a w oft u ts t a t e doe sno tf or cemet o not o mr a t et o pr ot ec tmy pr om r t y unde rt ha ts t at ea ut ho r i t ya nd r el y um n t ha tu me l a w i n good f ahhunt i lm y s t a t er i t .

I na ddhi ow i ft he c r i t t e r ,t he Tor t oi s e,di d notmee tt he c r i t e r i e ts e tf or t hi nt he ESA t hen

t heen t i r epr oce e di ngst ot a ke my pr ope r t y orde ny me a c ce s st o my edn hl i s he d wa t e rng *bt sa nd

v o c a t i o n wa sd o ne wi t h o u ta n yj mi s d i c t i o nf r o mt h el xg i n ni ng a n de v e r y t hi n ga n da c t so f

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 4 of 9

e nf o r c e mentt ba tf l owed om t bos edeci s i onswe r e wi t hol z taut hor i t ya ndw e r ef r u i toft he m i s on t r e ef r om t heG gi nni ng.

3. W hhr es pe dt o !3i nt h eCompl ai n tIde nyt hea l l ega t i onsf ort l xq n mer ea s onsx. tf or t h

1 1 .1 na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAn s we r .
4. W i t hr e s p e dt o! . . 4i nt he Co mphl n t Ic a nn e i t h e rn mr mn o rd e n ya tt hi st i me t h e
as s e r t i onst he r ei n.

5 .W k hr e s p e c tt o5 5i nt he Co mp l a i n tlc a nn e i t e rn mr mn o rde n ya tt i t t st i = t h e
as s e r t i onst he r ei n.

6. W hhr es w dt o !6i nt heCompl ai n tldo not t q e r ta nopi ni ona tt hi st i met hea s s e r t i ons
t h er ei n.

7. W i t hr es pe c tt o 7i nt h eCompl ai n tIde ny t hea l l e ga t i onsf ort hem q mer nss e tf 0%

h e r e i na hwe1 1 1 : 2i nt h i sAr k s we r . 8. W h hr e s pe dt o!8i nt h eComp l mn 'tId e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o nsf o rt h e>mer -q n nss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na l m e1 1 1 2i nt hi sAn R we r . 9. W k hr e m tt o1 9i nt h e Co mpl a i n tIc a nn e i t e ra mr mn o rd e n ya tt h i st i me t e
at eN n nst h er eh x

1 0. W khr es wc tt o!1 0i nt heCompl ai ntla f f l r mt hen- r t ml nmt I wX I G

11 . Wi t hr e s mc t t o! 1 1i nt h eCompl a i n t1a t r l r mt h ea xe r t a i nst h e r e i n. 1 2. Wh hr e s - t t o! 1 2i nt h eCo mphi n tId e nyt h ea l l e g a t i o nsf o rt h emmer e a s o n ss e t f o r t h h e r e i na l m e1 5 2i nt h i sAns we r . 1 3 . Wi t hr e s - t t o! 1 3i nt b eCompl a i n tla f l l r mt h ea %e r t a l nqt l er e i

1 4. Wi t hr e s p e c t t o! 1 4i nt h eCo mpl a i n tId e nyt l xa l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h es a mer e a mn ss e t :) r t . h

h e r e i na hwe1 5 2i nt l l i sAn s we r .
4

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 5 of 9

1 5 . Wk hr e s - t o1 1 5i nt h eCo mp l a i n t Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o l k qf o rt h es a mer e a s o nss e tf 0 z 1 h

he r ei na l m ei n52i nt hi sAnn we r .

1 6 . Wi t hr e s pe dt o! 1 6i nt heCo mp l a i n t Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt b eK n mer e a xl k ss e tf o r t b h e r e i na l m ei n5 2i nt h i sAr swe r .

1 7 . Wi t hr e s wc t t o! 1 7i nt h eCo mpl a i n t Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i on sf o rt h e= mer e a s o n ss e tf o r t h

her e i na hwei n!2i nt l t i sAn s we r .

1 : . Wi t hr e s - t t o1 1 8i nt h eCo mpl a i n t1d e nyt h ea l l e g a t i om f o rt h es a mer e a s o n ss e tf 0 1 11 h e r e i na b o v ei n5 2i nt h i sAn s we r . 1 9 . Wi t hr e s pe c t t o! 1 9i nt h eCompl a i nt Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i on sf o rt h eumer e a mnss e tf o r t h h e r e i na ev ei n5 2i nt h t sAnq we r .
: I

20 . Wk hr e s mc t t o! 20i nt l l eCompl a i n tId e nyt l xa l l e g a t i on sf o rt h eK a mer e m xnss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na hwe1 ! 2i nt h i sAn s we r . 21 W h hr e s pe c t t o! 21i nt h eCompl a i n tIa t r l r mc e r f a i nm %e r t s i nqt h e r e i ni np a r ta n dd e n y c e r t a i na l l e g a t i o a si np a r t f o rt h eK n r n er e a xr l ss e t f o r t hh e r e i na ev ei n! 2i nt h i sM s we r .

;
1

i i I i

2 2. Wh hr e s mc t t o! 22i nt l x Compl n l n tld e nyt h ea l l e g a t i on sf o rt h es a mer e a %nss e t f o hh

h e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt l z i sAn s we r . 2 3. Wh hr e s wc t t o! 23i nt h eCompl a i n t1d e n yt h ea l l e ga t i on sf o rt h es a mer e a s o n ss e t f o r t h h e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt hi sAn s we r . 2 4Wi t hr e s p e c t t o! 2 4i nt h eCompl a i n tld e n yt h ea l l e ga t i om f o rt h er w q mer e a xnss e tf o r t h h e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt hi sAn s we r . 25 . Wh hr e s p e c t t o5 25i nt h eCo mpl a i n tI( l e n yt h ea l l e g a t i on sf o rt h ep -mer e m s o n ss df o r t h h e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt hi sAn s we r .

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 6 of 9

2 6 . Wi t hr e s p e c tt o1 2 6i nt h eCo mp l a i n tIn mr mo e r t a i na s c e r t n i n At he r e i ni nm r ta n dd e n y
c e r t a i na l l e g a t i o nsi np a r t f o rt h er u q n wr e m s o nss e tf o r t hh e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt h i sAns we r . 27 . Wi t hr e pe c tt o!2 7i nt h e Comp l a i n tIa f r mnc e r t a i nm q c e r t n i nRt h e r e i ni np a r ta l dd e n y c e r t a i na l l e g a t i o nsi np a r t f o rt h eR n r n er e a s o n ss e t f o r t hh e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAl uwe r . 2 8 . Wi t hr e s p e dt o! 28i nt h eCo mpl n i n tIs mr mc e r t s l nm q c e r t n i n Rt l rr e i ni np a r ta n dde n y c e r t a i na ne g a t i o r si np a r t f o rt l wm q r n er e a s o nss e tf o r t hh e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAns we r . 29 . Wi t hr e s p e dt o5 2 9i nt h eCo mp l a i n tIa Tl r mc e r t xi nn o r t xi n Rt h e r e i ni np a r ta n dde n y

c e r t a i na l l e g a t i o nsi np a r tf o rt h es a mer e a s o n ss e tf o r t hh e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt h i sAnm e r .

30.W i t hr e s w dt o530i nt heCompl ai ntls mrr nt . hea s c er t ai nRt I I e I ' eW

31 . Wi t hr e s pe c t t o: 31i nt h eComp l a i n tId e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt l l e>mer e a xn ss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na l m e1 5 2i nt h i sAn me r .

32 . Wi t hr e s pe c t t o! 3 2i nt h eComp l a i n tId e n yt h ea l l e g a t i on sf o rt h eR a mer e - r k ss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na l m ei n! 2i nt b i sAn s we r . 33 . Wh hr e s mdt o! 3 3i nt h eCompl a i n tla cl r mc e dx l ' na s c e r t a i nst h e r e i ni np a r t a n dd e n y
ce r t ni na l l e ga t i onsi nI mr tf ort he< % - I w' U S OnSs e tf o r t hbe r ei na l x) vei n!2i nt hi sAnq we r .

34 . Wi t hr e s mc t t o! 3 4i nt h eCo mpl a i n tIn mr mt h ee . e r t a i n st h e r e i n. 3 5 . Wh hr e s pe dt o! 3 5i nt b eCompl a i n tId e nyt l xa l l e g a t i ox k sf o rt h e*: ner e a s o nss e tf o r t h h e r e i na l m e1 1 1 ! 2i nt hi sAn s we r .
36. W hhr es mc tt o! 36i nt heCompl ni ntlde nyt hea l l e ga t i onsf ort l l eR n mer e ms onss etf or t h he r e i nal m ei n!2i nt hi sAns wer .

37 . Wh hr e s pe c t t o! 3 7i nt i e Compl s i n tIa t f l r mc e dn i na Ke r t a l nst l > e r e i ni np a r t a n dd e n y

c er t a i na l l e ga t i onsi npa r tf ort he=me= S OI I Sx' tf or t hhe r ei na l m ei n!2i nt hi sAns wer .

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 7 of 9

3 # . Wi t hr e m tt o! 3 8i nt l x Cor n p l a i n tI d e n yt l l ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h eumer e a xnss e tf or t h

h e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAn s we r .
3 9 . Wi t hr e s p e c tt o! 3 9i nt l x Co mp l a i n tId e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h eumer e a s on ss e tf or t b h e r e i na ev ei n! 2i nt h i sAn s we r .

40 . Wk hr e s mc tt o! 4 0i nt b eCo mp l a i n t ld e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h e=mer e ' m %l k ss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt h k sAn s we r . 41 . Wk hr e s pe dt o: 41i nt h eCo mp l a i n tIde n yt l l ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt hes mr n er e ms o n ss e tf o r t h h e r e i na l m ei n1 8 2i nt h i sAn n we r . 42 . Wi t hr e s wc tt o54 2i nt h eComp l n i n tId e n yt b ea l l e g a t i o mf o rt l l e>mer e a xr l ss e tf o r t h h e r e i na ev ei n! 2i nt h i sAn n we r . 43 . Wi t hr e s p e c t t o!43i nt h eCompl a i n tId e n yt hea l l e g a t i o mf o rt h e<mer e a s o n ss e t f o r t h h e r e i na ev e1 1 1 52i nt h i sAn s we r .

44 . Wh hr e s p e dt o! 4 4i nt heCompl a i n tId e n yt l xa l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h eq n mer e a s o l k ss e tf o r t h

h e r e i na hwe1 1 1 ! 2i nt h i sAn s we r .

4 5 . Wh hr e s mc tt o! . 45 i nt h eCompl a i n tId e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o mf o rt h eq n mer e m q o l x ss df o r t h h e r e i na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAn me r .

46.The Def el vl n nti x or po r a t esi t spr evi ousans we r sast hough f ul l ys df or t h he r ei n.

4 7 . W khr e s mc t t o! 4 7i nt h eCo mpl a i n t Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o x sf o rt l l e>mer e a s o r l ss e tf o r t h h e r e i na hwei n5 2i nt h i sAn q we r . 48 . Wi t hr e s pe c t t o! 4 8i nt h eCompl a i n t Id e n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n sf o rt h e<mer e a s o nss df o r t h

he r e i na i m ei n12i nt hi sAns we r .
49.TheDe f e nd an ti n cor por a t e si t spr e vi ot l sans we r sast hough f uny s e tf or t hh er e i a

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 8 of 9

5 0. Wi t hr es wc tt o!. 50i nt heCompl a i ntIde nyt l eV e ga t i onsf ort hes a mer e m xx k ss etf or t h

h e r e i na l m e1 1 : ! 2i nt h i sAn s we r . 51 . W hh r e s md t o! 5 1i nt l e Comp l n l n tt h e De f e n da n td e n i e st h a tPl a i n t i f fi se mi t l e dt o

s a i dr eq ue s t e dr e l i e fbe ca us et he y ha ve n otS M GIacl n i m um n whi ch r el i efc an l x gr a nt ed a nd l

de n yt h ea l l e g a t i o n st l xr e i nf o rt h eq n mer e mR n ! k ss e tf o r t hl xr e i na hwei n! 2i nt h i sAn n we r .

W H ER EF0 R E,De f e ndan tr e s m df ul l ys ubmkst hes e ams we r st o Pl a i nt i F s Compl ai ntan d
r e que s t st l l atPl ai nt i c sr e ques tf orr el i e fi ni t sPr a ye rf orRe l i efl x de ni ed 1 -. n : 1 * *t he y ha ve n ot

s t at e d adai m upon whi c hr el i efca nI x gr an t e d and De f e al nn the r eby r eq ue s t sf ors uch r e l i efa s

t h i sCo u r t d e e msj u s t a r dp r o mr .

D A T E D t h i sf d a y o f J u n a , 2 0 1 2
Re s pec t f ul l ys t l bm i t t e d,
.
. , , ' ,

. . *

. . .

s
'

.'
, .

. ..

'

1 ? z ? r ( . . ' . , . r . .
s z

-)
, / '
z ' , z
,
.

'

C LI V EN D.B

DY

g f
g '

'

321 5 G0I d Bt l t t eBoad Bunker vi l l e,NV 98007

/' ' ' ' , J

PROO F O F SERVI CE

PH ( 7 0 2) 3 46 . 5 5 64
1 ,Cl i ven D. Bundy,c er t l ' f yt ha tt bi s ANSW ER T0 C 0 M PLAI NT wa ss er v e d um n
Phi n t i l ont hi sda t eby t l l eY l ow i de nt lc a t i on me t l md ofxx r v i ce:

US M A 1 L

I gna ci a S.M nr eno A%i s t antAt t or ne y Gene f al Thom a s K.Snndgr a u, Se ni orAt t or ne y Uni t e d St a t e sDepar t mentofJus t i ce Envl r cnmentand Na t t l r alRe s our c e: Di vi s i on
999 18' hSt r e et h Terr ac e,Sui t e 370 , Sout De nverC 0 80202

Na t ur l lRe K ur c a :Se c t i o n

Case 2:12-cv-00804-LDG-GWF Document 9 Filed 06/04/12 Page 9 of 9

nani e lG.Bc gden Uni t e d st at e s At t cr ne y Nadi a Ama d spec i alAoi s t antUni t e d St a t e s At t nr ne y 333 l a s Ve gas Bl vd,Scut h,Sui t :5000 Lasve kas Nv 891 01

D a t e d t h i sf d a y c f J u n e , 2 0 1 2 .
'

;
' ' '

0i

e '

/
'

. .. ' '<

' '' 1'

, ,

/ /
'

Cl i ve n D.Bt l ndy