P2Pvalue Techno-social platform for sustainable models and value generation in commons-based peer production in the Future Internet

Programme: FP7-ICT-2013-10 Project: 610961

Start date: 201 -10-01 !uration: " months

!eliverable ! #1 $or%shop on platform: &eport of a 'or%shop to discuss the P2P(alue platform 'ith sister pro)ects
Submission date: 2014-02-14 *rganisation name of lead contractor for this deliverable: +,!issemination Status Public Restricte to ot!er "rogramme "artici"a#ts $i#clu i#g t!e Commissio# %er&ices' Restricte to a grou" s"eci(e b) t!e co#sortium $i#clu i#g t!e Commissio# %er&ices' Co#( e#tial* o#l) +or members o+ t!e co#sortium $i#clu i#g t!e Commissio# %er&ices'

P+ PP &/ ,*

P2P&alue ,eli&erable 3-1

!ocument information
1-1
.ut!ors *rganisation 0C1 0C1 /-mail "abloja#2ucm-es samer2+ i-ucm-es

0uthor Pablo /ja#gure# %amer 3assa# 1-2 /t!er co#tributors 1ame ,a&i Ro4as C!ris Pi#c!e# 5e&i# Fla#aga# 7ua# Pa&8# .#to#io Ta"ia or 1-3,ocume#t !istor) (ersion2 90-1 91-0 1-4,ocume#t ata 3e4'ords

*rganisation 0#i&ersit) o+ %urre) P2P Fou# atio# P2P Fou# atio# 0C1 0C1

/-mail a&i -ro4as2gmail-com c!ris2catas"a#glis!-com 6e&i#2"2"&alue-eu j"a&o#2+ i-ucm-es ata"ia or2ucm-es

!ate Februar) 14* 2014

,hange
%tarti#g &ersio#* tem"late .""ro&e &ersio# to be submitte to :0

/ditor address data !eliver4 date 1-=,istributio# list !ate

;or6s!o"* F</%%* istribute "lat+orms* C.P%* "eer "ro uctio#* o"e# source* so+t;are "lat+orms* collaboratio# samer2+ i-ucm-es Februar) 14* 2014

Issue Co#sortium members Project o>cer :C arc!i&e

/-mail members2lists-"2"&alue-eu <oretta-.#a#ia2ec-euro"a-eu C?:CT-ICT-6109612ec-euro"a -eu

II

@or6s!o" o# "lat+orm

P2Pvalue ,onsortium

0#i&ersit) /+ %urre) $Coor i#ator' Ce#tre ?atio#al ,e <a Rec!erc!e %cie#ti(Aue %tic!tu#g Peer To Peer .lter#ati&es $P2P Fou# atio#'

0#i&ersitat .utB#oma ,e Carcelo#a

0#i&ersi a Com"lute#se ,e 1a ri

0#i&ersitD ,egli %tu i ,i 1ila#o

III

P2P&alue ,eli&erable 3-1

Pro)ect ob)ectives
T!e "rojectEs objecti&es are: ,e&elo"me#t o+ a so+t;are "lat+orm o 0# ersta# * eF"erime#t ;it!* esig# a# buil a collecti&e i#tellige#ce tec!#o-social +e erate collaborati&e "lat+orm t!at ;ill +oster t!e sustai#abilit) o+ commu#ities o+ collaborati&e "ro uctio#o ,e"lo) se&eral customise #o es o+ t!e +e erate "lat+orm i# ;!ic! real-;orl commu#ities ;ill i#teract* "artici"ate* a# collaborati&el) create co#te#t T!eor) a# Polic) o ,e&elo" CCPP t!eor)* base o# multi isci"li#ar) a# multi-met!o researc! o# CCPP* a# etermi#e t!e +actors +or success* "ro ucti&it)* a# resilie#ce i# commu#ities $Gbest "racticesH'o ,e&elo" a set o+ &alue metrics a# re;ar mec!a#isms t!at i#ce#ti&ise t!e "artici"atio# o+ citi4e#s i# CCPPo %imulate t!e #e; sustai#abilit) mo els "ro"ose * s!o;i#g !o; robust t!e) are i# t!e +ace o+ i&erse commu#it) co# itio#so 9eri+) t!e com"atibilit) o+ t!e "ro"ose mo els ;it! i##o&atio# "olicies a# "ro&i e a series o+ "olic) recomme# atio#s +or "ublic a mi#istratio#s to e#courage CCPP- ri&e# social i##o&atio#,ata a# Resources o Pro&i e a irector) o+ eFisti#g CCPP commu#ities* toget!er ;it! t!eir mai# c!aracteristicso 1ai#tai# a# o"e# ;eb-base CCPP arc!i&e* ;it! t!e collecte ata-sets* sur&e)s* re"orts* /"e# : ucatio#al Resources a# o"e#-access "ublicatio#s* +reel) a&ailable to ot!er researc!ers a# t!ir -"arties u# er a# o"e# co")le+t lice#se- T!is i#clu es a "roject "ublic re"ositor) ;it! all co e a&ailable as +reeIo"e# source-

I9

@or6s!o" o# "lat+orm

/.ecutive Summar4
T!is eli&erable re"orts t!e results o+ t!e ;or6s!o" GFreeI/"e# %ource ,istribute Plat+orms +or Peer Pro uctio#H* ;!ic! ;as !el i# 1a ri o# 9 a# 10 ,ecember 2013- T!e "ur"ose o+ t!e ;or6s!o" ;as to iscuss t!e so+t;are "lat+orms t!at t!e C.P% "rojects are usi#g* a# eF"lore "oi#ts o+ collaboratio#T!e ;or6s!o" accom"lis!e its mai# goals o+ s!ari#g i#+ormatio# co#cer#i#g t!e C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms* iscussi#g a ;i e &ariet) o+ issues* a# (# i#g se&eral ;a)s o+ collaboratio# amo#g t!e "rojectsT!e ;or6s!o" e#gage 16 "eo"le +rom 9 cou#tries a# 6 C.P% "rojects $1 IP* 4 %TR:P* 1 C%.'* +rom bot! tec!#ical a# i#ter isci"li#ar) "ro(les- T!e ;or6s!o" "ro&i e s"ace +or t!e "rojectsE re"rese#tati&es to "rese#t t!eir "lat+orms a# recei&e +ee bac6- I# a itio#* se&eral "artici"ator) )#amics too6 "lace i# or er to eF"lore t!e "rojectsE "ote#tial a# e#courage collaboratio#- . G5#o;le ge Ca+JH* uri#g ;!ic! "artici"a#ts ;ere i&i e i#to grou"s* o#e "er table* iscusse se&eral to"ics i# a gi&e# timi#g* s;itc!e tables "erio icall) a# got i#tro uce to t!e "re&ious iscussio# at t!eir #e; table b) a Ktable !ostK- Crai#stormi#gs a# tas6-orie#te iscussio#s also too6 "lace* +acilitate b) a "ro+essio#alT!e "rojects iscusse a# agree o# a ;i e &ariet) o+ to"ics* mostl) relate to t!e C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms- %ome "oi#ts o+ collaboratio# ;ere +ou# : assessme#t o+ tec!#ologies $e-g- ."ac!e @a&e'* met!o ologies $e-g- 0L <ea# ,esig#' a# t!eoretical results $e-g- CCPP researc! (# i#gs'- Commu#icatio# co#cer#i#g o"e# "rotocols a# sta# ar s $/"e#%ocial* @a&e' ;as stre#gt!e#e a# +ee bac6 ;as "ro&i e to t!e C%. o# !o; to ai t!e ot!er C.P% "rojects .lso iscusse ;ere issues co#cer#i#g "lat+orm i#tero"erabilit) or at least "lat+orm lig!t i#tegratio#- Cest "ractices co#cer#i#g to"ics suc! as t!e e#gageme#t o+ users* !a# li#g ;it! commu#ities* e&e#ts* a# et!ical issues ;ere eFc!a#ge -

P2P&alue ,eli&erable 3-1

,ontents
1 Introduction################################################################################1 2 5eneral 6 7ogistic Info################################################################ 0genda#######################################################################################8 8 ,0PS soft'are platforms#############################################################9 ,ecarbo?et--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- = Ia4%i-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6 ,-C:?T---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 7 @i6irate--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- M P2P&alue------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 9 C3:%T--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 10 9 Finding points of collaboration among the ,0PS pro)ects############11 1et!o olog)----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 11 5#o;le ge Ca+J------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 14 Crai#stormi#g a# tas6-orie#te iscussio#s----------------------------------------------17

" Stud4 on soft'are platforms######################################################22 : Summar4 and conclusions#########################################################2 ; &eferences###############################################################################28

9I

1 Introduction
T!is eli&erable re"orts t!e results o+ t!e ;or6s!o" GFreeI/"e# %ource ,istribute Plat+orms +or Peer Pro uctio#H* ;!ic! ;as !el i# 1a ri o# 9 a# 10 ,ecember 2013T!e "ur"ose o+ t!e ;or6s!o" ;as to iscuss t!e so+t;are "lat+orms t!e C.P% 1 "rojects are usi#g* a# eF"lore "oi#ts o+ collaboratio#.ll C.P% "rojects ;ere i#&ite to "artici"ate- /+ t!ose* %iF acce"te t!e i#&itatio#: C3:%T $alt!oug! because o+ last mi#ute issues t!e) coul #ot come* t!e) !a a# o#li#e "artici"atio#' ,-C:?T ,ecarbo?et Ia4%i P2P&alue $4 "art#ers joi#e ' @i6irate Fi&e ecli#e : Catal)st C.P4.CC:%% $t!e "roject !a #ot )et starte ' C.P%2020 0%:1P $#ot i#tereste o# t!e subject o+ t!e ;or6s!o"' @eb-C/%I $t!e "roject !a #ot )et starte ' T;o i #ot a#s;er: ,igital %ocial I##o&atio# %tu ) %ciCa+e 2-0 %ome (gures: 2 a)s 14 "eo"le N 1 o#li#e N 1 +acilitator 6 C.P% "rojects: 1 IP* 4 %TR:P* 1 C%. Partici"a#ts +rom 9 cou#tries

CAPS projects are considered those funded by the Objectives 5.5 and 1.7b of the call FP7- C!-"#1$-1#. CAPS stands for %Collective A&areness Platfor's for Sustainability and Social nnovation(. !hey are listed in http)**ec.europa.eu*di+ital-a+enda*en*caps-projects

T!is re"ort is orga#i4e as +ollo;s- T!e #eFt t;o c!a"ters "rese#t t!e basic i#+ormatio# t!at ;as "ro&i e to a##ou#ce t!e ;or6s!o" a# its age# a- T!e +ollo;i#g c!a"ters "ro&i e a escri"tio# o+ t!e to"ics t!at ;ere co&ere uri#g t!e ;or6s!o"- C!a"ter 4 escribes t!e C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms t!at ;ere "rese#te uri#g t!e (rst "art o+ t!e ;or6s!o" $i#clu i#g C3:%T* ;!ic! ;as "rese#te i# t!e seco# a)* a# a iscussio# o# P2P&alueI5u#e ga gets also o# t!e seco# a)'C!a"ter = escribes t!e met!o olog) a# t!e "artici"ator) )#amics t!at ;ere a""lie i# or er to (# ;a)s o+ collaboratio# amo#g t!e C.P% "rojects- C!a"ter 6 outli#es some t!eoretical iscussio#s arou# a taFo#om) o+ C.P% so+t;are "lat+ormsT!e (#al c!a"ter* 7* "ro&i es some co#clu i#g remar6s* +ollo;e b) t!e re+ere#ces?ote t!at t!e ;or6s!o" also i#clu e i#+ormal tal6s* small si e meeti#gs a# iscussio# time uri#g brea6s* i# sum muc! more t!a# t!is re"ort ca# ca"ture-

2 5eneral 6 7ogistic Info

T!e ;or6s!o" ;as orga#i4e ;it! t!e +ollo;i#g i#+ormatio#-

Audience expected
@eOll !a&e bot! ge#eral a# tec!#ical iscussio#s- I#itiall) more ge#eral* iscussi#g t!e "lat+orms broa l)* or "ossible ;a)s to collaborate amo#g iPere#t "lat+orms--- but t!is ;ill i#e&itabl) s"ar6 more tec!#ical iscussio#s getti#g i#to t!e etails- @e ;ill cou#t ;it! bot! "ro(les i# t!e ;or6s!o": e&sItec!ies a# i#ter isci"li#ar) bac6grou# s-

Program
T!e "rogram is o"e# a# it e"e# s o# t!e "artici"a#tsO co#tributio#s @e eF"ect all "rojects atte# i#g to "re"are at least a s!ort "rese#tatio# eF"lai#i#g t!e so+t;areItoolsI"rotocols t!e) are ;illi#g to use or !a&e u# er co#si eratio# @e e#courage "ro"osals o+ lig!t#i#g tal6s $2-=mi#'* s!ort tutorials* a# to"ics +or iscussio# i# rou# tables s"eci(c

Topics
FreeI/"e# %ource ,istribute Plat+orms +or Peer Pro uctio# @!ic! so+t;are "lat+ormItec!#olog) ;ill* eac! C.P% "roject* use as base +or e&elo"me#tQ Plat+orms +or commu#icatio#: e-g- social-#et;or6i#g* microbloggi#g Plat+orms +or collaboratio#: e-g- ;i6is* "a s* ;a&e For iscussio#: ,ias"ora* 5u#eI@a&e* <oreaI:lgg* etc Tutorials* e-g- Ra gets S Cots i# 5u#eI@a&e

Location
Faculta e I#+ormTtica $Facult) o+ Com"uter %cie#ce' 0#i&ersi a Com"lute#se e 1a ri $0C1' CI Pro+- 7osJ RarcUa %a#tesmases* sI#* 2M040* 1a ri $%"ai#' !tt"s:II"lus-google-comI11=MM3M7994M462MM1=11IaboutQ!lVe# !tt":IIi#+ormatica-ucm-es

Logistics
/"e# to "artici"atio#: ?o registratio# +ees It is eF"ecte t!at t!e "artici"a#ts "a) +or t!eir o;# tri"s* !osti#g a# meals <u#c! o+ bot! a)s ;ill be i# t!e same 0C1 buil i#g- @e ;ill "ro"ose a commo# "lace +or i##er o# t!e 9t!

0genda
Monday 9th December Room: First Floor* 2Sala de &euniones 09:00 09:30 11:1= 11:4= 13:00 .rri&al S Registratio# Prese#tatio#s o+ C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms $,ecarbo?et* Ia4%i* ,-C:?T' CoPee Crea6 Prese#tatio#s o+ C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms $@i6irate* P2P&alue' <u#c! 2Rrou# Floor

Room: First Floor* 2Sala de &euniones 14:00 Partici"ator) ;or6s"ace to (# out ;a)s o+ collaboratio# 17:00 %ummi#g u" 20:00 GCaWas S Ta"asH 21erca o e %a# 1iguel 21:30 ,i##er 2Xerai# Restaura#t

Tuesday 10th December Room: First Floor* 2Sala de <untas 10:00 10:30 11:00 11:30 12:00 13:00 %tu ) o# %o+t;are Plat+orms I#tro uctio# to 5u#eI@a&e Ra gets Prese#tatio# o+ C.P% "roject C3:%T CoPee Crea6 Rou# table S ,iscussio# <u#c! 2Rrou# Floor

Room: First Floor* 2Sala de &euniones 14:00 Rou# table S ,iscussio# 1=:00 Closi#g 16:00 %"ace +or small meeti#gs S c!atti#g

8 ,0PS soft'are platforms

T!e ;or6s!o" "ro&i e s"ace +or all atte# i#g C.P% "rojects to "rese#t t!eir "roject* +ocusi#g o# t!e so+t;are "lat+orm* tools a# "rotocols t!e) are usi#gI e&elo"i#gT!us* eac! "roject re"rese#tati&e ma e a sli e-base "rese#tatio# ;it! its subseAue#t iscussio#- . summar) o+ t!e "rese#tatio#s a# iscussio#s +ollo;s-

DecarboNet: A Decarbonisation Platform for Citizen Empowerment and Translating Collective Awareness into e!avioural C!ange
T!e ,ecarbo?et "roject $,ecarbo#et* 2013' aims to create citi=en empo'erment and to translate collective a'areness into behavioural change * s"eci(call) loo6i#g +or: Raisi#g I# i&i ual a# Collecti&e .;are#ess $Perso#al :>cac)' Triggeri#g Ce!a&ioral C!a#ge a# Foster %ocial I##o&atio# .#al)si#g Ce!a&ioral Patter#s a# I#+ormatio# ,iPusio# Processes

It is e&elo"e arou# a co#teFt-s"eci(c re"ositor) o+ carbo# re uctio# strategiesFrom a tec!#ical "oi#t o+ &ie;* t!is is a set commu#icatio# a# 6#o;le ge co-creatio# tools- T!e) are t!e base o+ a GCollecti&e .;are#ess Plat+ormH e"icte i# t!e +ollo;i#g ;or6Yo;* ;!ic! collects* a#al)ses a# is"la)s i#+ormatio# +rom a ;i e ra#ge o+ sources regar i#g social be!a&iour i# climate change issues:

T!e Collaboratio# Plat+orm is t!e re"ositor) o+ collecti&e 6#o;le ge* trac6i#g usage "atter#s a# be!a&iours +rom iPere#t ecological resources $!tt":II;;;-ecoresearc!-#etIclimate* a-6-a- 1e ia @atc!' $%c!arl et al* 2007'Its core is a# a -!oc so+t;are create 10 )ears ago- It is a large searc! i# eF t!at uses ?atural <a#guage Processi#g $?<P' a# 6e);or Io#tolog) associatio#s as mai# tec!#iAues +or ata "rocessi#g- ,ata is collecte b) a ;eb cra;ler +rom t!e o"e# sources a# "art#ers: e#&iro#me#tal ?R/s* #e;s me ia* Fortu#e 1000 com"a#ies* a# social me ia users $T;itter* Faceboo6* ZouTube* RoogleN'T!e @eb user i#ter+ace is s!o;# as a ,as!boar * "ro&i i#g ata &isuali4atio#* tre# s a# collaboratio# +eatures- ItEs im"leme#te b) t!e @ebl)4ar tec!#olog) a# actuall) it re"rese#ts t!e most c!alle#gi#g "art o+ t!e "roject +rom a tec!#ical "oi#t o+ &ie;- It i#tegrates "rett) #e; +rame;or6s* suc! as F</%% 3-js +or ata &isuali4atio# a# .lo!a 3T1<= : itor a# "ro"rietar) so+t;are @i6i ocs +or real-time collaborati&e e itio#- /t!er so+t;are tools i# t!e "roject are t!e social me ia a""licatio#s* o#-li#e games ;it! a "ur"ose a# e#erg) co#trol e&ices ;!ic! "ro&i e a itio#al be!a&iour i#+ormatio# to t!e searc! i# eF.+ter reAuesti#g more i#+ormatio# t!roug!out t!e iscussio#s* a Auic6 emo#stratio# o+ t!e a#al)sis a# mo#itori#g so+t;are "lat+orm* 1e ia @atc!* ;as s!o;#- It s!o;e ?<P-base se#time#t a#al)sis $1a)#ar et al* 2013' a# e#tit)-base tag clou s aggregati#g +rom t!e multi"le sources me#tio#e - T!e) claime t!at o#e o+ t!eir aims is to i#tegrate t!is tool ;it! "o;er+ul real-time collaborati&e ca"abilities* so t!e tool ca# use commu#it)-create ocume#ts a# #ot just eFter#al sources- T!e) are curre#tl) eF"lori#g se&eral F</%%2 tec!#ologies +or collaboratio#* suc! as Toget!er7% +rom 1o4illa-

"a#$i: "mpact assessment for $ocial "nnovation

I.4%I $I.4%I* 2013' is a su""ort actio# aimi#g at e&elo"i#g a structure met!o olog) able to e&aluate t!e "ote#tial socio-"olitical* eco#omic a# e#&iro#me#tal im"acts o+ collecti&e a;are#ess "lat+orms +or sustai#abilit) a# social i##o&atio#- T!e met!o olog) ;ill also ma" 6e) c!aracteristics able to etermi#e a broa er u"ta6e o+ t!e Collecti&e .;are#ess Plat+orms $C.P%' i#itiati&es- T!e I.4%I met!o olog) ;ill re"rese#t a combi#atio# o+ Aualitati&e a# Aua#titati&e a""roac!es a# ;ill co#si er bot! ta#gible a# i#ta#gible im"acts- I.4%I ;ill su""ort a# oPer o""ortu#ities +or 6#o;le ge eFc!a#ge a# s)#ergies e&elo"me#t to C.P% "rojects- It ;ill o so b): ,e&elo"i#g a socio-economic impact assessment methodolog4 +or t!e s"eci(c (el o+ social i##o&atio#

/Peri#g t!ree online tools for impact self-assessment * e#abli#g "rojects to u# ersta# a# im"ro&e t!eir im"acts- T!e t!ree tools ;ill be targete to: t!e

"

Free*,ibre*Open Source Soft&are

"rojects* t!eir users a# :uro"ea# citi4e#s t!at ;ill be e#gage e&aluatio# o+ t!e "rojects b) &oti#g[

i# t!e

I e#ti+)i#g best practices a# su""orti#g t!em i# reac!i#g t!e "la##e im"act o# commu#ities[ Creati#g s)#ergies a# i##o&atio#[ coordination among funded pro)ects o# social

/ngaging /uropean citi=ens i# t!e e&aluatio# o+ social i##o&atio# "rojectsE out"uts a# i# becomi#g a;are o+ t!e "ote#tialities o+ t!e social i##o&atio# a""roac![ ,e&elo"i#g polic4 recommendations a# a researc! roa ma" +or i#tegrati#g iPere#t i#itiati&es ;it! t!e (#al aim o+ i#creasi#g t!eir im"act o# commu#ities a# t!eir ca"abilit) to a ress societal c!alle#ges-

T!e C.P% "rojects re"rese#tati&es ;ere i#tereste o# t!e met!o olog) +or e&aluati#g t!e C.P% "lat+orms* a# it ;as clari(e t!e "artici"ator) "rocess i# ;!ic! t!e met!o olog) ;ill be e&elo"e * see6i#g i#&ol&eme#t o+ t!e C.P% "rojects i# t!e e(#itio# a# &ali atio#- Cesi es* t!ere ;as "le#t) o+ i#terest o# !o; I.4%I coul +acilitate citi4e#s to use t!e C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms a# !el" t!em i#crease t!eir use a# im"act- Citi4e#s ;ill also be reAueste to &ote about t!e "lat+orms a# t!e "rojects out"uts-

D%CENT: Decentralised Citizens ENgagement Tec!nologies for direct democrac& and economic empowerment
,-C:?T $,-C:?T* 2013' aim is to "ro&i e ci&il societ) ;it! imme iatel) usable igital tools +or irect emocrac) a# eco#omic em"o;erme#t- Cesi es* it also aims to gro; lo#g-term alter#ati&es to to a)Es !ig!l) ce#tralise "lat+orms a# "o;er structuresT!e major outcome ;ill be a# o"e#* +e erate a# ece#tralise social #et;or6i#g "lat+orm +or large scale collaboratio# base o# i#tegrati#g success+ul o"e#-source tools a# ser&ices t!at e#able to s!are i# real-time o"e# ata* emocratic ecisio# ma6i#g* a# igital curre#c) +or t!e social goo - T!e "lat+orm ;ill su""ort use cases i# t!ree areas su""orte b) t!ree mo ules i# t!e "lat+orm: ,igital social curre#c) Cro; sourci#g /"e# ,ata ,irect emocrac) T!e tec!#ical esig# o+ t!e "lat+orm ;ill be i# c!arge o+ t!e %ocial @eb @or6i#g Rrou" C!arter o+ t!e @orl @i e @eb Co#sortium $@3C'- 3e#ce* t!e "lat+orm ;ill be alig#e ;it! t!e @3C recomme# atio#s $@3C* 2013' i# t!e +ollo;i#g to"ics: /"e# +ormats +or social ata base o# .cti&it)%treams $!tt":IIacti&it)strea-ms' $:sc!e#auer* 2010'

 /"e#

.PI +or @eb a""licatio#s i#tero"erabilit) base o# /"e#%ocial $!tt":IIo"e#social-orgI' $1itc!ell-@o#g et al* 2007' @eb "rotocol to allo; t!e +e eratio# o+ status u" ates a# ot!er ata base o# L1PP "rotocol $!tt":IIFm""-org' $%ai#t-.# re* 2011' T!ere is a clear alig#me#t o+ ,-C:?T a# P2P&alue aims* a# t!us t!is triggere a &i&i iscussio# tr)i#g to clari+) a# ee"e# t!e 6#o;le ge o+ eac! ot!ersE tec!#ical aims- T!ere ;as i#terest o+ ,-C:?T UX Lean Design met!o olog) $Rot!el+ S %ei e#* 2013'* a# agile met!o olog) +or e#gagi#g citi4e#s i# t!e "lat+orm esig# t!roug! user eF"erie#ce "rotot)"es- T!e so+t;are "lat+orm "la#s to be e&elo"e a+ter t!e) 6#o; G;!at t!e user ;a#tsH* a# ;ill be e&elo"e i# Rub) o# Rails b) ?:/ so+t;are e&elo"me#t com"a#)- T!e) still o#Et 6#o; i+ t!e) ;ill reuse eFisti#g F</%% or be "rogramme +rom scratc!,-C:?T eF"lai#e multi"le issues co#cer#i#g t!eir areas o+ researc!: +rustratio# o+ %"a#is! 1=1I,RZ ;it! :lgg-base social #et;or6 <orea $Cabello et al* 2012'[ multi"le issues ;it! t!e liAui emocrac) so+t;are $use b) t!e Pirate Part) i# Rerma#)'[ or t!e #o#-social #ature o+ bitcoi# as a igital curre#c)1ore tec!#ical iscussio#s +ollo;e * a# it ;as clari(e !o; t!e @3CI,-C:?T aims to em"o;er t!e /"e#%ocial o"e# sta# ar * ;it! a #e; 3-0 &ersio#* +rom a more securit)- ri&e# a""roac!- T!is sta# ar is also +ollo;e b) t!e P2P&alue so+t;are "lat+orm ga gets- .+ter;ar s* t!ere ;as a re&ie; o+ t!e curre#t +e eratio# "rotocols $/%tatus* L1PP* @a&e* etc'* a# !o; #o#e o+ t!em !as bee# trul) success+ul- T!e @3CI,-C:?T ;ill u" ate t!e sur&e) o#e o# 2010 $@3C* 2010' uri#g 2013 a# 2014T!e grou" also iscusse #e; sta# ar co#cer#i#g 7%/? acti&it) streams* a# se&eral issues co#cer#i#g cr)"togra"!)- T!e iscussio# e# e reac!i#g agreeme#t o# t!e #ee +or real i#tero"erabilit)* a# @3CI-,C:?T agree t!at i eall) t!e) s!oul see6 a sta# ar t!at ca# i#tero"erate ;it! 5u#e- . "ossibilit) ;oul be to buil a Rub) &ersio# o+ a @a&e-com"lia#t clie#t-

'i(irate: Crowdsource

etter Companies

@i6irate $@i6irate* 2013' is a C.P% "roject ;it! t!e aim to a#s;er t!e Auestio# G3o; com"a#ies aPect t!e "eo"leQH- It is base o# a# o"e# so+t;are "lat+orm o+ s!are i#+ormatio# about com"a#ies i# t;o Ya&ours: a#al)sis o+ subjects a# claims- First t)"e are a#al)sis stateme#ts +or a s"eci(c com"a#) a# to"ic- %eco# re+er to claims relate ;it! a# s"eci(c subject a#al)sis ;!ic! cites a s"eci(c i#+ormatio# source $?R/* ?e;s\' @i6irate ser&ice is base o# @ag#* a Rub)-base F</%% "lat+orm +or team- ri&e# ;ebsites i#itiall) release i# 2009- It "ro&i es structure ata com"o#e#ts to su""ort

@i6irate co#ce"ts $com"a#ies* to"ics* claims\' a# collaborati&e e iti#g o+ t!e co#te#ts- T!ere is a 6i# o+ @i6i* ;!ere t!ere are iPere#t roles: rea ers* ;!o "artici"ate co#sumi#g t!e co#te#t- : itors* ;!o ca# e it t!e co#te#t i#-"lace ;it! a @Z%I@ZR e itor- @ag#eers ca# orga#i4e a# arra#ge ata i# Gcar sH* creati#g t)"es o+ car s* co##ecti#g t)"es a# ;riti#g Aueries +or retrie&i#g car s- I# ge#eral* t!e be#e(ts "ro&i e are: Combi#es C1%* @i6i a# atabase ca"abilities-

@eb users are em"o;ere to create li6e co ers Re uce co#teFts or areas o+ ;or i-e- t!ere is #o a mi# area .ll c!a#ges are trac6e a# re&ersible It "ro&i es a YeFible a# !ig!-le&el mo s s)stem to a more +eatures-

I#itiall) t!e iscussio# +ocuse o# t!e moti&atio#s be!i# @i6irate $9isser* 2014'* ;!ic! is co#cer#e t!at Cor"orate %ocial Res"o#sibilit) is #ot ;or6i#g ;ell e#oug!* a# com"a#ies s!oul be rate b) users* alt!oug! usi#g t!e rigour o+ claims ;it! sources a# #ot just i#+ormal rati#g as ma#) Gcor"orate ;atc!H ;ebsites- It ;as reAueste s"eci(c etails a# a li&e emo#stratio# o+ t!e @ag# "lat+orm* s!o;i#g !o; t!eir ata is structure a# t!e ;i6i as)#c!ro#ous e itio#-

P)Pvalue: Tec!no%social platform for sustainable models and value generation in commons%based peer production in t!e *uture "nternet
T!e P2P&alue "roject $P2P&alue* 2013' ;as i#tro uce i# (rst a)Es mor#i#g* ;!ile t!e P2P&alue "lat+orm ga gets ;ere i#tro uce uri#g t!e seco# a)- I# t!e +ollo;i#g summar) ;e merge bot! iscussio#sP2P&alue is a# :uro"ea# "roject t!at aims to stu ) t!e commo#s-base "eer "ro uctio# o#li#e commu#ities $suc! as @i6i"e ia* F</%%* /"e#%treet1a"* etc'[ u# ersta# ;!ic! are t!e mai# +actors t!at aPect t!eir e&olutio# a# "ro ucti&it)[ "ro"ose metrics a# re;ar s +rom t!e i# i&i ual le&el +or t!e "romotio# o+ "artici"atio#[ buil a ece#tralise so+t;are "lat+orm t!at ;ill i#tegrate recomme# atio#s to boost sustai#abilit) bot! i# t!e macro $commu#ities' a# micro le&els $"artici"a#ts'[ test t!e "lat+orm a# !)"ot!eses i# real commu#itiesIt ;as #ote t!at t!e "roject +ollo;e /bjecti&e 1-7b $FIR:: Future I#ter#et Researc! :F"erime#tatio#' a# #ot =-= as most C.P% "rojects- T!e "roject "art#ers a# ;or6 "la# ;ere outli#e * i# or er to later +ocus o# t!e so+t;are "lat+orm* ;!ic! is base o#

t!e collaborati&e so+t;are 5u#e- 5u#e is a F</%% +e erate collaborati&e social #et;or6* e&elo"e si#ce 2007 a# u# er t!e umbrella o+ t!e Comu#es ?o#"ro(t- It is com"lia#t ;it! ."ac!e @a&e $@eis S @ac6er* 2011'* L1PP* /"e#%ocial a# @ebsoc6ets $all o"e# "rotocols a# o"e# sta# ar s' a# "la#s to "er+orm testi#g o&er t!e commu#it) #et;or6s o+ t!e FIR: C/?FI?: "roject- ,ue to t!e commo# sta# ar s use b) P2P&alue a# ,-C:?T* some tec!#ical iscussio#s +ollo;e * "ro&i i#g a# i#sig!t o# t!e structure o+ t!e "lat+orm* a# es"eciall) o# ."ac!e @a&e- @a&eEs !istor) ;as summarise * +or "artici"a#ts to +ull) u# ersta# its origi#s a# tec!#ological "ote#tials* es"eciall) co#cer#i#g t!e @a&e Fe eratio# Protocol i#itiall) e&elo"e b) Roogle a# to a) +rom t!e ."ac!e Fou# atio#- .+ter t!e @a&e Ra get tutorial* t!ere ;ere i#te#se tec!#ical iscussio#s o# t!e @a&e Ra getIRobot structureRa gets a# Robots are /"e#%ocial-com"lia#t t!ir -"art) a""licatio#s $similar to Faceboo6 a""s' t!at ru# o# to" o+ @a&eI5u#e- ,-C:?T ;as &er) i#tereste o# P2P&alueEs use o+ t!em* i# or er to ta6e it i#to accou#t +or t!e 3-0 &ersio# o+ /"e#%ocial-

C+E$T: Collective en+anced, Environment for $ocial Tas(s

T!e C3:%T "roject $C3:%T* 2013' ;as "rese#te i# t!e ;or6s!o" seco# a)* a# t!roug! o#li#e &i eo-co#+ere#ce* as ue to last mi#ute u#eF"ecte i>culties* #o C3:%T re"rese#tati&es coul "!)sicall) atte# t!e ;or6s!o"- C3:%T* o""osite to t!e rest o+ C.P% "rojects* is a# I#tegrate Project $IP'- It aims to +oster social i##o&atio# a# sustai#able coo"eratio# t!roug! t!e "ro&isio# o+ a# o"e# collecti&e eliberatio# "lat+orm to su""ort i##o&ati&e i eas a# i#itiati&es ;it! a see (#a#ce a# cro; -+u# i#g a""roac!- I# or er to o so* it ;ill: :#gage a large base o+ orga#i4atio#s* #et;or6s* a# "rograms t!at alrea ) o"erate success+ull) i# t!e areas o+ social i##o&atio#* e#tre"re#eurs!i"* earl) stage busi#ess i#cubatio#* ser&ice esig#* a# creati&it)Create a liAui i#+ormatio# a# social eliberatio# "lat+orm* base o# a coo"erati&e a;are#ess a""roac! a# im"leme#te o# to" o+ a broa s"ectrum o+ social me iaT!us* it ;ill gi&e &oice to commu#ities beari#g i#terests about !ar -to-sol&e* !ig!-im"act social "roblems* "romoti#g t!e emerge#ce o+ i##o&ati&e social i##o&atio# &e#tures t!at a ress t!ose "roblems* allo;i#g a tra#s"are#t a# collecti&e testi#g a# selectio# o+ social i##o&atio# "ro"osalsT!e "rese#tatio# ;as gui e b) t!e "artici"a#ts e#Auiries* co#cer#i#g t!e t;o rou# s o+ o"e# calls a# t!e structure o+ t!e cro; -base "rocess +acilitate b) t!eir so+t;are "lat+orm- .s "lat+orm t!e) ;ill reuse t!e Cubri6 cro; sourci#g "lat+orm $+rom t!e FP7 IP C0CRI5' a a"te to ma#age t!e o"e# calls $+or i eas* +or "art#ers a# +or a""licatio#s' a# user e#gageme#t- T!e iscussio#s e# e u" re&ol&i#g mai#l) arou# t!e etails o# t!e o"e# calls* ;!ose structure ;as "raise a# raise i#terest amo#g all "artici"a#ts-

10

9 Finding points of collaboration among the ,0PS pro)ects -et!odolog&

T!e ;or6s!o" mai# c!alle#ge ;as to (# "oi#ts o+ collaboratio# amo#g t!e "rese#t C.P% "rojects- T!e i ea ;as to (# ;a)s i# ;!ic!* ;it!out substa#tiall) i#creasi#g t!e ;or6loa * eac! "roject coul e#gage ;it! ot!er "roject$s' i# commo# tas6s* s!are resources* coor i#ate e&elo"me#ts* use commo# sta# ar sI"rotocolsItoolsI# or er to +acilitate t!is "rocess* t!e 0C1 orga#i4atio# !ire t!e a i#ter#atio#all) recog#ise social e#ter"rise* .lte6io $.lte6io* 2013'* s"ecialise i# +acilitati#g collecti&e "rocesses i# orga#i4atio#s a# e&e#ts- T!e) !a&e "ro+essio#al eF"ertise i# a large collectio# o+ grou" )#amics* "rocesses a# met!o ologies- I# t!is ;or6s!o"* t!e) use t;o met!o ologies +or e#gagi#g t!e "artici"a#ts-

A view of the

or!sho" during the start of the #now$edge %af&

First* t!e) use t!e met!o G5#o;le ge Ca+JH $5C'* also 6#o;# as G@orl Ca+JH $Cro;#* 200='- T!is is a structure co#&ersatio#al "rocess ;!ic! !as t!e +ollo;i#g ste"s: T!e room !as se&eral tables* c!airs* a# coPeeIjuice +or e&er)o#e* ;it! ambie#t c!ill-out music .ll "artici"a#ts sit ;!ile t!e +acilitator eF"lai#s t!e "ur"ose a# rules o+ t!e 5C-

11

T!e i ea be!i# is t!at most "ro ucti&e co#&ersatio#s !a""e# i# GcoPee brea6sH* so t!is met!o tries to em"o;er t!at i#+ormal set-u"- . +rame Auestio# is "ro"ose a# ;ritte# i# a blac6boar * ;!ic! ;ill be later bro6e# i# t!ree s"eci(c Auestio#s $;!ic! are i#itiall) ig#ore b) t!e "artici"a#ts' T!e grou" brea6s i#to small grou"s* ;it! about (&e "eo"le i# eac! grou"* eac! grou" i# a table- T!e +acilitator gi&es t!e (rst Auestio# $i# a Yi" c!art' a# a timi#g +or iscussi#g t!e Auestio# to"ic- T!e "artici"a#ts s!are i#+ormall) a#) t!oug!ts* i#sig!ts a# i eas o# t!e to"ic :ac! table !as a Gtable !ostH* a "erso# ;!o ;ill ta6e #otes a# "artici"a#ts are e#gage a# t!e to"ic is iscusse ma6e sure t!e

.+ter t!e time is u"* all "artici"a#ts c!a#ge table* eFce"t eac! table !ost* ;!o remai# i# t!eir table- T!e +acilitator "ro&i es t!e# t!e seco# s"eci(c Auestio#T!e table !osts eF"lai# to t!e #e;comers ;!at t!e) iscusse "re&iousl) i# t!at table a# later e#gage i# t!e #e; Auestio#- T!e i ea is t!at e&er) "artici"a#t bri#gs 6#o;le ge a# i eas +rom "re&ious iscussio#s* boosti#g i eas miF* +ee bac6 a# i#s"iratio# . t!ir rou# +ollo;s ;it! a#ot!er table c!a#ge a# s"eci(c Auestio# Fi#all)* t!e Gtable !ostsH summarise +or e&er)o#e t!e iscussio#s i# eac! table-

Diagram showing the #now$edge %af& a""roach %%'() *mage by htt"+,,www-thewor$dcafe-com

12

%eco# * a# base o# t!e i eas o+ t!e 5C* t!e "artici"a#ts sit i# a circle o+ c!airs- T!e) ;ere "ro&i e ;it! s!eets o+ "a"er a# e#courage to i# i&i uall) brai#storm im"orta#t to"ics t!at t!e) +eel t!e) ;oul li6e to tal6 ee"er- T!us* a+ter some mi#utes* t!ere is a collectio# o+ "ro"ose to"ics- :ac! "ro"oses eF"lai#s ;!) s!e (# s it rele&a#t a# ;!) s!e #ee s to ee"e# i#to it- .+ter;ar s* t!e grou" tries to (# relatio#s amo#g t!e "ro"ose to"ics* a# ;!e# "ossible tr)i#g to merge t!em- T!e aim is to !a&e* i eall)* 4 to"ics to be iscusse $.* C* C* ,'* ;it! a (rst rou# ;!ere . a# C are iscusse * a# a seco# rou# +or C a# ,- T!e grou" is s"litte t!e# i# t;o* ;it! "artici"a#ts c!oosi#g ;!ic! to"ic to iscuss- .+ter 1= mi#utes* t!e grou" gets u#ite a# s"lits agai# +reel) +or t!e last t;o to"ics- :ac! time* t!e grou" iscussio#s must be gui e b) a gi&e# table to (ll-i#* ;!ic! is stro#gl) tas6-orie#te : t!e grou" s!oul agree o# #eFt actio# to ta6e "lace* ;!o ;ill o it* ;!ic! resources ;ill be #ee e * ;it! ;!ic! aim* a# ;!e#- Fi#all)* co#clusio#s a# summi#g u" ta6e "lace* +ocusi#g o# #eFt actio#s-

.n the $eft/ A$te!io0s $ogo- .n the right/ 1avier 2ernande3/ the "rofessiona$ faci$itator that "artici"ated in the or!sho"/ whi$e o"ening the second round of the #now$edge %af&-

13

.nowledge Caf/
T!e 5#o;le ge Ca+J met!o ;as +ollo;e * usi#g t!e +rame Auestio# G3o; o ;e (# "oi#ts o+ collaboratio# amo#g usQH a# t!e +ollo;i#g t!ree s"eci(c Auestio#s: 1- G@!ic! i#teresti#g or i#s"iri#g i eas C.P% "lat+orms "rese#tatio#s' i )ou !ear t!is mor#i#gQH $i-e- i# t!e

2- G@!ic! ot!er i eas )ou !a&e to buil coo"eratio# bet;ee# usQH 3- G@!ic! +uture sce#arios o+ )our "art#ers!i"s "rojects e# i# 3 )ears time' o )ou e#&isageQH $i-e- ;!e# t!e

T!e met!o ;or6e "rett) ;ell a# t!e "artici"a#ts came u" ;it! a large amou#t o+ i eas- %ome issues iscusse i# t!e tables ;ere* co#cer#i#g t!e (rst Auestio#: Tec!#ical ."ac!e @a&e s"eci(catio# at P2P&alue coul ,-C:?T

be i#teresti#g +or t!e @3C a#

,iscussio# about i+ t!ere are a#) ri&i#g +orces +or istribute social #et;or6i#g%ome are outli#e * suc! as ata "rotectio#* s"eciall) rele&a#t i# :uro"e* a# busi#ess-orie#te cases* i#clu i#g istribute orga#i4atio#s- @e ac6#o;le ge t!at t!e :0 is "utti#g resources to e&elo" t!is 6i# o+ "lat+orms,esig# ,iscussio# o# iPere#t a""roac!es +or esig#: i#stea o+ creati#g a "lat+orm a# t!e# loo6 +or t!e commu#it)* liste#i#g to t!e commu#it) a# create a "lat+orm accor i#g to t!e +ee bac6 o+ t!e users Ro to commu#ities to (# users- T!e ,-C:?T "roject ;ill (# out ;!at t!e) are actuall) usi#g* ;!at t!e) ;oul li6e to use a# t!e# t!e) ;ill create moc6u"s to im"leme#t t!eir tools usi#g agile met!o ologies- T!e) (# &er) i#teresti#g bei#g i# t!e same s"ace as users o- T!eir results ca# be use to gui e a a"tatio#s +or t!e ot!er C.P% "lat+orms /ur "rojects are more user-orie#te ge#erall) "ositi&e t!a# tec!#icall)-orie#te * ;!ic! is +ou#

/t!er to"ics ,igital curre#cies i#tegrate t!e o#li#e commu#it)

i# so+t;are "lat+orms to i#ce#ti&ise "artici"atio# i#

I.4%I met!o olog) a# ;illi#g#ess to +acilitate t!e C.P% "rojects ;or6* e&e# !el"i#g t!e "lat+orms to attract users

14

Issues co#cer#i#g t!e seco# rou# : ,iscussio# o# !o; to e#gage users i# collaborati&e "ro uctio#- It ;as eF"lai#e a# !ig!lig!te t!e 90-9-1 "ri#ci"le: 90] o+ t!e users are &ie;ers* 9] e#gage occasio#all)* 1] belo#g to t!e core grou" $Cra# t4^g S 3eim 200M' 0si#g I.4%I "roject to gat!er "rojects loo6i#g +or commu#ities Per+ormi#g mar6eti#g stu ies i# or er to u# ersta# ;!atEs ;or6i#g +or attracti#g users- :-g- i e#ti+) ri&i#g +orces suc! as ata "rotectio# a;are#ess* istribute orga#i4atio#s or to be Roogle s6e"tical %tu ) suitable commu#ities a# "romoti#g t!e so+t;are t!ere C.P% e&e#t so all "lat+orms attract users toget!er %!are best "ractices amo#g C.P% "rojects o# ;!at ;or6e e#gage users a# mo&e +or;ar i# t!e 90-9-1 i# or er to

:Fc!a#ge o+ 6#o;le ge o# metrics a# user )#amics o+ t!e commu#ities amo#g t!e C.P% "rojects Plat+orm i#tegratio# ,iscussio# about usi#g eFisti#g so+t;are to buil #e; "rojects* suc! as I.4%I- T!ere are tec!#ical co#strai#ts* as t!e) are usi#g ,ru"al Tec!#ical iscussio# about t!e arc!itecture o+ 5u#e* to loo6 +or "ossible "oi#ts o+ i#tegratio# or collaboratio# ,iPere#t le&els o+ i#tegratio# bet;ee# "lat+orms: <i#6s to iPere#t "lat+orms* ;it! "ossible ee"er i#tegratio# ?e;s sectio# %ocial me ia ,issemi#atio#- It is "ro"ose to use commo# !as!tags +or bri#gs messages to a broa er au ie#ce- /t!er i eas are &otes +rom users a# usi#g P2P Fou# atio#Os blog Issues relate to t!e t!ir a# last rou# : :#gageme#t 3u#ti#g +or commu#ities- Put )our co#te#t ;!ere "eo"le are ,iscussio# o# co#cer#s o+ "ri&ac) a# ata' et!ical issues $e-g-: ;!ile scra"i#g issemi#atio#- T!is iscusse * suc! as

1=

Plat+orm i#tegratio# @e mig!t use tec!#ical "rotocols +or i#tero"erabilit) @atc! out +or "roject lice#se com"atibilit) issues Cuil i#g reusable a""licatio#s I.4%I "lat+orm as ce#tral #o e +or all C.P% "lat+orms* ;it! iPere#t le&els o+ i#tegratio# ;it! it- .#ot!er "ossibilit): a 5u#e #o e to eFc!a#ge i#+ormatio# amo#g all t!e C.P% "rojects 0si#g ,ecarbo#etEs 1e ia @atc! +or ge#eral mo#itori#g Im"leme#t ,-C:?TEs se&eral "rojects igital curre#c) +or "romoti#g "artici"atio# i#

,iscussio# o# a +uture ;or6s!o" o# !o; to get "eo"le +rom commu#ities* i#ter#al sco"i#g a# collaboratio# amo#g "rojects-

A view of the

or!sho" during the #now$edge %af&

16

*nforma$ notes and co4ee during the #now$edge %af&

rainstorming and tas(%oriented discussions

.+ter t!e 5C (#is!e * ;e e#gage o# t!e seco# met!o - I# a Auic6 brai#stormi#g* a# a+ter a iscussio# +or u#i+)i#g se&eral o+ t!e to"ics t!at arose* ;e e# e u" ;it! t!e +ollo;i#g +our to"ics t!at t!e "artici"a#ts ;a#te to eF"lore i# e"t!: .' 90-9-1 rule: u# ersta# i#g i#ter#al user commu#ities )#amics a# e#gageme#t i# o#li#e

C' /rga#ic &s ?o#-orga#ic commu#ities: a""roac! to;ar s so+t;are "lat+orm esig# C' Co#cer#s about "ri&ac) a# e#gage i# "ilots' et!ical issues $regar i#g +ocus commu#ities

,' Commo# so+t;are "lat+orm "rotocols: o""ortu#ities +or tec!#olog) reuse* i#tegratio# a# im"ro&eme#t across "rojects . summar) o+ t!e i eas a# actio#s iscusse +or eac! to"ic +ollo;s-

17

%irc$e of chairs and "$enty of "a"er sheets and "ens for the brainstorming to ta!e "$ace

0> ?0-?-1 rule: understanding internal user d4namics and engagement in online communities T!is ;as +ou# to be o#e o+ t!e most outsta# i#g issues* a# a# issue o+ co#cer# +or all "rojects- T!e 90-9-1 rule t!at ;as iscusse i# t!e 5C ;as +ou# i#teresti#g +or e&er)o#e* brea6i#g it i#to t!ree esirable )#amics: .ttract #e; users to be a;are o+ t!e so+t;are "lat+orm a# use it as &ie;ersIrea ers* t!at is* to become "art o+ t!e 90]- :-g- (rst users +or @i6irate Co#&i#ce &ie;ers to e#gage a# "artici"ate acti&el)* t!at is* to mo&e +rom t!e 90 to t!e 9] :#courage a# i#ce#ti&ise occasio#al "artici"a#ts to become more a# more i#&ol&e * t!at is* mo&i#g +rom t!e 9] to t!e 1]T!is grou" iscusse "re&ious success+ul a# u#success+ul eF"erie#ces* +or i#sta#ce: Rat!er t!a# limiti#g to o#li#e i#teractio#* "er+ormi#g +ace-to-+ace meeti#gs ;it! commu#ities a# i# i&i uals ;it!i# t!em uri#g "ublic e&e#ts ;!ere t!e) ca# be i#&ite is +ou# im"orta#t to establis! ties a# i#crease t!e "artici"atio# 3a&i#g t!e #otio# t!at K)our &oice is goi#g to be !ear K ;as Auite use+ul i# a# :0 "roject* i# ;!ic! t!e +ee bac6 o+ t!e users ;as se#t to t!e :C-

1M

 Follo;i#g I.4%I eF"erie#ce* t!e) use mo#etar) i#ce#ti&es ;it! #o#-"ro(ts orga#isatio#s* i# or er +or t!em to e#gage t!eir members T!e) ;ere rat!er use+ul i# t!e mome#t* !o;e&er o#ce t!e "roject is o#e t!e le&el o+ acti&it) ro""e sig#i(ca#tl) Co#tests $gi&i#g IPa s as re;ar ' ;ere also use i# a#ot!er "roject- T!is "ro uce a similar result: a !ig! le&el o+ "artici"atio#* ;!ic! ro""e a+ter;ar s It ;as also iscusse t!e im"act o+ t!e arc!itecture im"leme#te to allo; collaboratio#- T!is ;as co#si ere im"orta#t to ta6e i#to accou#t o# t!e "relimi#ar) stages T!e grou" agree o# t!e i>cult) o+ t!e c!alle#ge* a# t!at i# a#) case se&eral "rojects $I.4%I* P2P&alue* ,-C:?T' are i#te# e to stu ) relate issues uri#g t!e "rojectPractical actio#s: %e# a# e-mail about t!e "re&ious eF"erie#ces o+ I.4%I i# t!ese issues I#&ite eac! ot!ers to ;or6s!o"s relate to t!e to"ic %!are success+ul e#gageme#t "ractices amo#g all C.P% "rojects I.4%I ;ill !el" to i e#ti+) "rojectEs #ee s regar i#g commu#itiesP2P&alue ;ill "ro&i e access to t!e CCPP commu#ities irector) t!at is bei#g built* i# case it ma) be use+ul as targets +or ot!er "lat+orms-

19

@> *rganic vs 1on-organic communities: approach to'ards soft'are platform design FreAue#tl) so+t;are "lat+orms are esig#e a# e&elo"e b) tec!#icia#s a# t!us t!e) o#Et ta6e i#to co#si eratio# t!e &isio# o+ target commu#ities- T!is issue ca# be +rame as a# orga#ic &s- #o#-orga#ic a""roac! to;ar s "lat+orm esig#- T!at is* eFisti#g orga#ic commu#ities #ee a# reAuest tools t!at are im"leme#te s"eci(call) +or t!em[ ;!ereas grou"s o+ e&elo"ers buil t!em ;it!out a "articular au ie#ce a# t!us ;it!out ta6i#g i#to accou#t t!e s"eci(cities o+ t!e commu#ities t!at e&e#tuall) use t!emT!ere are some au ie#ces t!at mig!t be rece"ti&e to certai# issues- I# t!e case o+ climate c!a#ge $,ecarbo#et': sc!ools* "ublic go&er#me#ts* gree# "arties- I# t!e case o+ P2P&alue: ;!at &alue oes t!e "lat+orm "ro&i eQ Probabl) it ;oul be suitable +or Roogle s6e"ticsIt is ac6#o;le ge t!at it ;oul certai#l) be use+ul to "ro&i e Auic6 ;a)s to get +ee bac6 +rom users a# commu#ities earl) i# t!e "rojects to re uce t!is commu#icatio# ga".mo#g t!e "rese#t C.P% "rojects ;e +ou# at least t;o i#itiati&es tr)i#g to a&oi t!is usi#g agile so+t;are met!o ologies- ,-C:?T ;ill use <ea# 0L* a miF o+ agile so+t;are e&elo"me#t a# G<ea# %tartu"H* i-e- a# agile met!o olog) +or "ro uct a# busi#ess e(#itio#- /# t!e ot!er !a# * P2P&alue ;ill +ollo; %crum* a# agile met!o olog) +ocuse o# so+t;are e&elo"me#t a# t!at ;ill e#gage social scie#tists uri#g t!e +eature e&elo"me#t "rocess- %i#ce 0L <ea# coul co#tribute to a better commu#icatio# bet;ee# tec!#ical a# #o#-tec!#ical "artici"a#ts more t!a# just !el" e&elo"me#t* P2P&alue is goi#g to asses t!e a o"tio# o+ t!is met!o olog)- I# a#) case* t!e co#clusio#s o+ ,-C:?T 0L <ea# ;ill be s!are ,> ,oncerns about privac4 and ethical issues Aregarding focus communities engaged in pilots> %e&eral C.P% "rojects ;ill #ee to collect ata +rom t!e commu#icatio#s amo#g users o+ t!e o#li#e commu#ities uri#g t!e testi#gI"iloti#g "!ases- 3e#ce* "lat+orms ;ill co#tai# so+t;are +eatures to ma#age t!is i#+ormatio# t!at coul im"l) et!ical a# Ior legal issues* "articularl) co#cer#i#g "ri&ateI"erso#al ata- T!e grou" s!are t!eir a""roac!es a# "re&ious "ractices* a# agree to "rioritise et!ical co#cer#s uri#g t!eir social researc!- T!e use o+ ata mi#i#g ;as also iscusse * attem"ti#g to ra; a li#e bet;ee# t!e Faceboo6-li6e ,1 a# t!e o#e "la##e to be "er+orme i# t!e "rojects- T!ese are com"leF Auestio#s i>cult to a#s;er uri#g a s!ort iscussio#* so t!e eFc!a#ge ;as re uce to s!ari#g a# "la##e eFc!a#ge o+ re+ere#ces!> ,ommon soft'are platform protocols: opportunities for technolog4 reuseB integration and improvement across pro)ects# ,uri#g t!e ;or6s!o" it i become clear t!at "rojects ;oul use iPere#t so+t;are "lat+orms tec!#ologies: Rub)* 7a&a* ,ru"al* @ag#- .s lo#g as t!e "rojects !a&e alrea ) committe resources $e-g- "art#er eF"ertise or "eo"le !ire ' accor i#g to t!ose

20

tec!#ical "re+ere#ces* it is +ou# u#+easible to reuse or s!are ;!ole "lat+orms amo#g "rojects- 3o;e&er* some commo# issues ;ere e"icte i# t!is area@!ic! "rotocols a# sta# ar s to use i# or er to +oster i#tegratio# a# o"e# "lat+ormsQ . com"re!e#si&e list o+ curre#t tec!#ologies use i# social "lat+orm ;as i#tro uce $@3C* 2010'- It ;as agree to !el" i# t!e #eFt issue o+ t!at sur&e) i#clu i#g some a itio#al tec!#ologies li6e ."ac!e @a&e* ;!ic! is a core "art o+ t!e P2P&alue "lat+ormI5u#e- 1ost o+ t!ese sta# ar s are curre#tl) su""orte b) t!e @3C a# it ;as ge#erall) acce"te to tr) to +ollo; t!ese sta# ar s ;!e# i#tero"erabilit) ;as #ee e - Cesi es* ,ecarbo#et agree to e&aluate @a&e as a "ossible real-time collaboratio# tec!#olog) to be i#tegrate i# t!eir "lat+orm- /# t!e ot!er !a# * t!e grou" iscusse about t!e tre# s i# so+t;are tec!#ologies to be a;are o+-

A view of some "artici"ants whi$e e5"osing the to"ics found in the brainstorming

21

" Stud4 on soft'are platforms

,uri#g t!e seco# a) o+ t!e ;or6s!o"* t!e "artici"a#ts recei&e t;o #e; "eo"le: a#ot!er member o+ t!e 0C1IP2P&alue team a# a# i#&ite researc!er* Feli"e /rtega* eF"ert a#al)st o+ @i6i"e iaEs big ata $/rtega et al* 200M'- Cesi es* t!e "artici"a#ts mo&e to a #e; room $G%ala e 7u#tasH' ;!ere t!e) ;ere &er) i#tereste i# t!e 1930Es origi#al G:#igmaH cr)"togra"!ic mac!i#e eF"ose t!ere $5o4ac4u6* 19M4'- T!is triggere i#teresti#g iscussio#s o# ol a# #e; met!o s o+ cr)"togra"!).+ter "rese#tatio#s a# i#+ormal iscussio#s* t!e 0.CIP2P&alue team "rese#te t!eir "relimi#ar) stu ) o# so+t;are "lat+orms* ;!ere t!e) aim to classi+) commo#s-base "eer "ro uctio# $CCPP' commu#ities a# t!e so+t;are "lat+orms t!at sustai# t!emT!is classi(catio# ;ill be use +or t!e co#structio# o+ a large sur&e) o# CCPP t!at P2P&alue "la#s to lau#c! uri#g its (rst )ear- T!e iscussio#s ;ere stro#gl) t!eoretical* le b) t!e most i#ter isci"li#ar) "artici"a#ts* as it co#tai#e bot! tec!#ical eleme#ts a# a social scie#ces a""roac!- T!e grou" "ro&i e +ee bac6 o# t!e c!aracteristics t!at ma6e a CCPP commu#it) o#e $criteria o+ elimitatio#'* t!e tec!#ical +eatures a so+t;are "lat+orm ma) eci e to !a&e to !a# le t!e o#li#e commu#it)* a# t!e mai# +actors +or "ro ucti&it) o+ t!ese commu#ities-

A view of the origina$ 6nigma cry"togra"hic machine 719809 "$aced in the :nd day or!sho" room

22

: Summar4 and conclusions

%ummi#g u"* t!e ;or6s!o" accom"lis!e its mai# goals o+ s!ari#g i#+ormatio# co#cer#i#g t!e C.P% so+t;are "lat+orms* iscussi#g a ;i e &ariet) o+ issues* a# (# i#g se&eral ;a)s o+ collaboratio# amo#g t!e "rojectsT!e ;or6s!o" e#gage "artici"a#ts +rom siF C.P% "rojects* +rom bot! tec!#ical a# i#ter isci"li#ar) "ro(les- T!e "rojects "rese#te t!eir "lat+orms a# recei&e +ee bac6- Cesi es* se&eral "artici"ator) )#amics too6 "lace i# or er to eF"lore t!e "rojects "ote#tials a# e#courage collaboratio# amo#g t!e "rojects- %ome o+ t!e ;a)s t!e "rojects agree i# collaborati#g are: bot! ,ecarbo#et a# ,-C:?T ;ill assess t!e a o"tio# o+ ."ac!e @a&e i# t!eir o;# "rojects[ P2P&alue a# ,-C:?T ;ill commu#icate +urt!er co#cer#i#g o"e# "rotocols $/"e#%ocial* @a&e'[ P2P&alue assessme#t o+ t!e 0L <ea# ,esig# met!o o+ ,-C:?T[ I.4%I recei&e "le#t) o+ +ee bac6* tas6s a# i eas to be im"leme#te i# or er to ai C.P% "rojects[ P2P&alue ac6#o;le gi#g t!e i#terest o+ ot!er "rojects o# t!eir CCPP irector) a# CCPP t!eoretical results a# t!us ;ill s!are t!em ;!e# com"lete [ all "rojects agree o# issues co#cer#i#g "lat+orm i#tero"erabilit) or at least "lat+orm lig!t i#tegratio#[ all "rojects ;ill eFc!a#ge best "ractices co#cer#i#g multi"le to"ics $e#gageme#t o+ users* !a# li#g ;it! commu#ities* e&e#ts* et!ical issues'-

A "a"er ;ower during the #now$edge %af&/ re"resenting the "o$$ination dynamic of trave$$ing from tab$e to tab$e carrying the !now$edge of the "revious discussions

23

; &eferences
.lte6io $2013': !tt":IIalte6io-esI Cra# t4^g* P- C-* S 3eim* 7- $200M'- 0ser lo)alt) a# o#li#e commu#ities: ;!) members o+ o#li#e commu#ities are #ot +ait!+ul- I# <roceedings of the :nd internationa$ conference on *=te$$igent T6chno$ogies for interactive enterTA*=ment $"- 11'- IC%T $I#stitute +or Com"uter %cie#ces* %ocial-I#+ormatics a# Telecommu#icatio#s :#gi#eeri#g' Cro;#* 7- $200='- T!e ;orl ca+J: %!a"i#g our +utures t!roug! co#&ersatio#s t!at matter- Cerrett-5oe!ler %tore Cabello* F-* Fra#co* 1- R-* S 3ac!J* .- $2012'- 3acia u#a ;eb social libre ) +e era a: el caso e <orea- Te!no!u$tura- Revista de %u$tura Digita$ y Movimientos >ocia$es* 9$1'* 19-43 C3:%T $2013': !tt":II;;;-c!est-"roject-euI

,-C:?T $2013': !tt":II;;;- ece#t"roject-euI ,ecarbo#et $2013': !tt":II;;;- ecarbo#et-euI :sc!e#auer* <- $2010'- .cti&it) %tream o&er L1PP- /#e%ocial@eb-org
!tt":IIo#esocial;eb-orgIs"ecI1-0Ios;-acti&ities-!tml Rot!el+* 7-* S %ei e#* 7- $2013'- Lean UX+ A""$ying Lean <rinci"$es to *m"rove User 65"erience- /OReill) I.4%I $2013': !tt":IIia4si-euI 5o4ac4u6* @- $19M4'- 6nigma+ how the ?erman machine ci"her was bro!en/ and how it was read by the A$$ies in or$d ar Two - C- 5as"are6 $: -'- 0#i&ersit) Publicatio#s o+ .merica 1a)#ar * ,-* ,u""la;* ,-* S 3are* 7- $2013'- 1ultimo al %e#time#t .#al)sis o+ %ocial 1e ia- I# CC% %R.I @or6s!o" o# %ocial 1e ia .#al)sis* 1itc!ell-@o#g* 7-* 5o;alc4)6* R-* Ros!elo&a* .-* 7o)* C-* S Tsai* 3- $2007'/"e#social: From social #et;or6s to social ecos)stem- I# ,igital :co%)stems a# Tec!#ologies Co#+ere#ce* 2007- ,:%TO07- I#augural I:::-I:% $""- 361-366'I::: /rtega* F-* Ro#4ale4-Cara!o#a* 7- 1-* S Robles* R- $200M* 7a#uar)'- /# t!e i#eAualit) o+ co#tributio#s to @i6i"e ia- I# @awaii *nternationa$ %onference on >ystem >ciences/ <roceedings of the A1st Annua$ $""- 304-304'- I::: P2P&alue $2013': !tt":II;;;-"2"&alue-euI %ai#t-.# re* P- $2011'- :Fte#sible messagi#g a# "rese#ce "rotocol $L1PP': Core- I#ter#et :#gi#eeri#g Tas6 Force- RFC 6120 $base o# 2004 &ersio# RFC 3920' %c!arl* .-* @eic!selbrau#* .-* 3ubma##-3ai &ogel* .-* %ter#* 3-* @o!lge#a##t* R-* S Xibol * ,- $2007' G1e ia @atc! o# Climate C!a#ge: Cuil i#g a# 9isuali4i#g Co#teFtuali4e I#+ormatio# %"acesH- I# %ema#tic @eb C!alle#g e-

24

 9isser* @- $2014'- C%R 2-0: Tra#s+ormi#g Cor"orate %ustai#abilit) a# Res"o#sibilit)- %"ri#ger @3C $2010'* %ur&e) re"ort o# t!e o"e# a# +e erate %ocial @eb* @3C Fe erate %ocial @eb Commu#it) Rrou" !tt":II;;;-;3-orgI200=II#cubatorI+e erate social;ebI;i6iI%ur&e) @3C $2013'* %ocial @eb @or6i#g Rrou" C!arter $,ra+t' !tt":II;;;-;3-orgI2013Isocial;ebIsocial-;g-c!arter-!tml @eis* T-* S @ac6er* .- $2011'- Fe erati#g @ebsites ;it! t!e Roogle @a&e Protocol- *nternet %om"uting/ *666* 1B$3'* =1-=M @i6irate $2013': !tt":II;i6irate-euI

2=