Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Pinto
[54] METHANOL DISTILLATION PROCESS 3,230,156 3,254,024 V1966 5/1966
[11]
[45]
4,210,495
Jul. 1, 1980
[75] Inventor:
3,391,064
4,013,521
7/1963
3/1977
Primary ExaminerWilbur L. Bascomb, Jr. Attorney, Agent, or Firm-Cushman, Darby & Cushman
[57]
Answer
Int. CLZ ....................... .. 301]) 3/14; C07C 29/26 US. Cl. ...................................... .. 203/22; 203/18;
Punt-ed meihaml _ 5 Pwduced by dlstlllmg a W? methanol mixture m (a) a ?rst column from wh1ch 1s taken a product methanol stream at an upper level, weakly aqueous methanol as a side stream and water as
bottoms and (b) a second column in which that weakly aqueous methanol is separated into an overhead product
stream and aqueous methanol bottoms. The ?rst column
203/21, 25, 26, 24, 22, 96, 97, 92, 93 75, 79, 831
85, 74, 771 81, DIG- 23; 563/913; 260/4495
[56]
2,115,401
2,152,164
3/1939
16
11,
L31 _ __
3L
3B
L0
55
51,
20
3B
5%
1.0
3
LB
-----
fl
52
32
,1_.&
21.
22 L2
1.1
LL
U.S. Patent
Jul. 1, 1980
Sheet 2 of3
4,210,495
1.31_.
15;.
2L
U.S. Patent
Jul. 1, 1980
Sheet 3 of 3
4,210,495
?\ a 2 :
iv $4 3
09
.a x. , S
L _ 4|!
U u
A:41% l
1
METHANOL DISTILLATION PROCEGSS
4,210,495
This invention relates to methanol and in particular to a distillation process and apparatus for producing puri ?ed methanol at high thermal ef?ciency. .
divide it and pass it to the reboilers of the preliminary and second columns in parallel. This form of the inven tion is especially useful in combination with a methanol
Crude methanol as produced by catalytic synthesis usually contains water and small quantities of organic compounds boiling below and above the boiling point
of methanol. Distillative separation of these constituents requires a large input of low grade heat, which is conve
In a form (see FIG. 1) affording very high thermal ef?ciency but requiring a source of higher grade heat, the columns are heated by passing fresh heat-carrying
fluid to the reboiler of the second column and passing methanol vapour from the top of that column in heat exchange in the reboilers of the ?rst and/or the prelimi nary columnl (if used). For the effective heating of the bottoms of the preliminary and/or ?rst column the
head; a ?rst column in which product methanol is sepa methanol vapour may be superheated or may be com rated overhead, water is separated as bottoms and an pressed before coming into heat exchange with these aqueous methanol side stream is taken off; and a second 20 bottoms liquids. Most conveniently, however, the sec column in which the aqueous methanol side stream is ond column is operated at a pressure high enough to separated into an overhead methanol stream that is ensure that its overhead vapour is not enough to cause recycled to the ?rst column and water bottoms that are boiling of those bottoms liquids. Suitably the column
discarded. Such a process involves column reboiler
pressure is higher by 70-120 psi than that of the column heating by warm crude synthesis gas and/or by a liquid 25 or columns'to be heated by its overhead vapour. If a (such as pressurised water) that has been heated by heat smaller difference is desirable, the preliminary and/or exchange with reacted synthesis gas. ?rst column can be in part heated from an external
We have now realised that the distillation sequence described in UK. No. 1280438 can be modi?ed to im
prove its thermal economy by taking from the ?rst 30 range l-20 psig, measured at the top. column an aqueous methanol side stream of higher In a third'form of the invention (see FIG. 3) employ
methanol content and by controlling the bottoms com
position of the second column at a lower water content. -
the ?rst and, second forms, the columns are heated by passing fresh heat-carrying ?uid to the reboiler of the puri?ed methanol by distillation comprises the steps of 35 second column and passing methanol vapour from the (a) feeding a water-methanol mixture to a ?rst distilla top of that column in heat exchange with water tion column, taking a product methanol stream from an methanol mixture fed to the ?rst column and/or (if one
predominantly water stream as bottoms; and (b) feeding the aqueous methanol side stream to a
This combination of steps can be put to use in a num 45 and circulating mixed plate liquid out to a heat ex
changer and then back on to the plate. Again the metha nol vapour may be superheated or may be compressed
tile than methanol. This two-column system is expected before coming into the heat exchange, but most conve to ?nd application chie?y in the production of fuel niently the second column pressure is high enough to grade methanol. 50 ensure that its vapour is hot enough, suitably higher by In a form of more general application the two col 20-70 psi than the pressure of the ?rst column. The umns are, preceded by a preliminary column (topping temperature of the methanol vapour is chosen in rela
or extraction) from which components more volatile tion to the pressure and composition of the ?rst column than methanol are taken overhead and aqueous metha feed preferably such that the feed is partly vaporised nol bottoms is fed to the ?rst column of the process of 55 before entering the ?rst column. This decreases the
In a form (see FIG. 2) capable of using very low the feed were to be maintained in the liquid state. grade heat, such column is operated at a relatively low 60 ~ The crude methanol feed to the process, whether or pressure, suitably in the range l-20 psig, measured at not it includes a preliminary column, may include water the top. It will be appreciated that the heat consumption at for example 8-30% w/w and there may be, altema will be signi?cantly lower at locations substantially tively or additionally, a feed of water at a level above above sea level. Since the water content and thus also crude methanol feed level, sufficient to produce a bot the boiling point of the bottoms in the ?rst column is 65 toms liquid containing over 40, for example 40-60 or higher than in the second column, it is convenient to even 80-95% w/w of water. The effect of water is to pass fresh heat-carrying ?uid, whether process gas or increase the relative volatility of impurities such as low pressure steam or a liquid, to the ?rst column re ketones and higher alcohols to such an extent that they
4,210,495
pass out overhead with the impurities (such as dimethyl ether) that are of lower boiling point than methanol. Usually such a withdrawal of volatiles, especially if
there is a separate water feed, vis effected in a prelimi nary column.
The ?rst column effects the bulk of the water methanol and separation. The side stream suitably con tains more than 98% w/w methanol, preferably over 99% w/w. The methanol flow rate of the side stream is suitably 30 to 70% by mols of the methanol in the crude or topped or water-extracted methanol fed to this col umn. There can be a feed of recycled bottoms from the second column and/or recycled pure or near-pure methanol from that column, but thisv is not counted when calculating the rate of ?ow of the side stream. The second column separates the side stream aqueous methanol into an overhead stream of substantially pure methanol and a bottoms stream containing methanol, water and ethanol. The water content of the bottoms
the range 10-60, for example 10-30 atm. abs., a tempera ture in the range_l30170 C. and preferably containing
30-70% v/v of steam.
Crude synthetic methanol normally contains small quantities of ethanol, ketones and higher alcohols. Such
of these compounds (especially ethanol) as are not re
second column, especially when the whole of the bot toms liquid from the. second column is recycled to the 20% w/w. The composition of the bottoms stream is ?rst column, since that liquid contains substantially all typically similar to that of the feed to the ?rst column the ethanol in the feed to the second column. In order to and accordingly that stream can be recycled to the ?rst maximise the ethanol content and minimise the metha column at an appropriate level: part of it can be purged in order to avoid returning too much ethanol. Although 25 nol content of the ?rst column purge stream, the feed to the ?rst column can be misplaced upwards, that is, at a the methanol content of this bottoms stream is relatively level at which, when the column is in equilibrium opera high, its ?ow rate can be and preferably is controlled to contain only 0.1 to 1.0% of the methanol fed to the tion, the water content is lower than in the feed, so as to produce over a region of the column below the feed process. If desired, a proportion of overhead methanol
condensate can be recycled to an upper level of the ?rst column in order to increase the reflux ratio therein.
level a substantially constant methanol to water ratio; the purge stream enriched in ethanol is taken near, espe
It will be appreciated that the nature of the heat-car rying ?uids used is usually a matter of detailed design, depending on the design of the methanol synthesis and
cially just below, the end of the region remote from the
feed level. Such a process using a misplaced feed is the subject of our UK. Pat. No. 1,373,159.
The combination of the two or three columns as
ple.
When the second column is operated at a pressure in the range 1-20 psig the source of heat for its reboiler is
possibly also the synthesis gas generation section de scribed below, constitute the apparatus according to the
preferably saturated or slightly superheated stream at a 40 invention. The columns may be of the tray type or packed type or a combination. pressure under 50 psig, especially in the range 15 to 40 The process of the invention is especially suitable for psig. Alternatively it is a liquid such as pressurised purifying crude methanol made by catalytic synthesis water at a temperature in the range 125 to 160 C. If it from carbon oxides and hydrogen. If the synthesis is of is process gas it is preferably at a pressure in the range the older type, at pressures above 200 atm. abs., and 10 to 30 atm. abs and a temperature in the range 125 to temperatures in the range 300-400 C., over a zinc 160 C.; preferably also it contains 30-70% v/v of chrome catalyst, the process preferably includes water steam, and is crude synthesis gas. extraction in the preliminary or ?rst column, owing to When the second column is operated at a pressure the relatively high content of impurities of low solubil 70-120 psig higher than that of the column or columns ity in water. If the synthesis is of the recently developed to be heated by its overhead vapour, the source of heat type at under 300 C., at pressures usually in the range for its reboiler is preferably saturated or slightly super 30-120 atm. abs. but possibly up to 400 atm. abs., and heated steam at a pressure over 30 psig, especially in the using a copper-containing catalyst, the preliminary col range 40 to 60 psig. If it is a liquid, the liquid tempera umn need not provide water-extraction. If the intended ture is over 140 C. and suitably in the range 160 to product purity speci?cation is not too stringent, the first 200 C. If it is process gas, its pressure is preferably in column can provide the topping function. Since synthe the range 10 to 30 atm. abs., its temperature 140 to 200 sis over a copper-containing catalyst preferably uses a C. and again it preferably contains 30-70% v/v of
steam.
gas containing more carbon dioxide (l-20, especially 3l2% v/v) than the gas used in the older process (pref 20-70 psi higher than that of the ?rst column, the .source 60 erably under 1%), the crude methanol produced by it typically contains a substantial proportion of water, of heat for its reboiler is preferably saturated or slightly
When the second column is operated at a pressure
superheated steam at a pressure over 5 psig, especially in the range 15-30 psig. If the source of heat is a liquid,
content is usually sufficient for a simple topping col umn, especially since the content of impurities of low water solubility in the crude methanol is much lower than in that produced by the older process.
4,210,495
6 .
zinc-chrome catalyst) and 1,159,035 (copper-zinc Group II-IV oxide, especially copper-zinc-aluminium, catalyst). Processes using catalysts containing oxides of
manganese, vanadium and boron have also been pro posed and can be used.
. .Referring toFIG.-1, preliminary topping column 10 receives its main feed of aqueous methanol at 12 and may, if desired, receive ,a.feediof water at 13 if it is to
operate in water-extractive conditions. Vapours of methanol and high-volatility impurities pass overhead
at 14 and are cooled- in condenser 16 to a temperature
In any methanol synthesis process the reacted synthe sis gas is cooled to the dewpoint of methanol and the methanol is condensed and separated. Heat is usually exchanged between reacted synthesis gas and cool unre
such that volatiles, pass out at 18 but methanol is lique ?ed and ?ows back into the column at 20. The bottoms liquid passes out at22 and is in part returned via reboiler 24 in heat exchange with pressurised methanol vapour fromncolumn 50 to bedescribed and in part fed to col
umn 30. v .
nol recycled from the bottoms of column 50. Methanol vapour passes overheadat 34 and is condensed at 36. Liquid methanol is divided'into a product stream 38 and a re?ux stream fed back into column 30 at 40. Column
toms liquid passing out at 42 consists substantially of
'water. It is in part heateduin reboiler 44 by heat ex- _
also a synthesis gas generation section in which a carbo 20 30 may, if desired, receive at 41 a feed of methanol from naceous feedstock such as natural gas, re?neryoff-gas, column 50 in order to increase its re?ux ratio. The bot
change with pressurized methanol vapour from column oxygen. Depending on the hydrogen-to-carbon ratio of 25 50 to be described and in part discarded or, when col the feedstock and the extent'to which reaction with umn 10 is water-extractive, recycled to point 13. C01 oxygen is used, the generation section may involve a umn 30 includes also purge off-take 46, which is at the CO-shift and COz-removal stage. If carbon monoxide is lower end of a region of the column in which, owing to available as a starting material, as in metallurgical off mislocation of feed 32, the methanol to water ratio is
substantially constant; The main off-take from column thesis gas generation gas streams are produced having 30 is at 48, to provide the weakly aqueous methanol temperatures over400 C. and up to 1100 C. Heat feed for column 50. ' recovery from such steam-containing raw synthesis Column 50, the second column, separates the gases by superheaters, boilers, boiler feed water heaters weakly aqueous methanol taken off at 48 from column and preheaters for gas and air is widely practised. Low 35 30 and now fed at 52. Methanol vapour passes overhead pressure steam from such recoveries or from the ex at 54 and is passed to the hot side of reboilers 44 and 24, haust of steam let-down engines, 'or gas streams follow where it, condenses and provides (owing to its high ing one or more such heat recoveries are suitable for pressure) the heat to maintain boiling in columns 30 and heating the column reboilers of the process of the inven 10 respectively. The resulting liquid methanol is divided
gases, generation can begin with the shift stage. In syn
tion, either by passing them through the hot side of the 40 into a re?ux stream fed to column 50 at 56 and a product reboiler or (in the case of such gas streams) by exchang stream 58 that is united with product stream 38 of col
ing them with a heating ?uid such as pressurised water, with or without boiling, and passing such a ?uid
umn 30. The bottoms liquid of column 50 is taken out at
carded at 62 or, if -desired,~-recycled tocolumn 30 at 33. The process of the invention is especially suitable in 45 Reboiler 64 is heated by hot ?uid from an external combination with a synthesis gas generation section in source, for example, by steam at 50 psig or process gas which CO2 removal is incomplete or comprises cata at 170 C. from elsewhere in the methanol production lytic reaction ,of gaseous or volatilisable hydrocarbon process or by a liquid heated by heat exchange with
with steam without oxygen. Such a section produces a such a hot process gas.v COz-containing gas from which a crude methanol (con 50 Referring to FIG. 2, preliminary topping column taining 830%. w/w of watery-results in methanol syn 10 functions in the same way as in FIG. 1, except that in reboiler 24 the source of heat is process gas 43 that has Three preferred forms of the invention are repre been partly cooled in reboiler 44 of column 30 to be sented in the accompanying drawings, in which described. Column 30 also functions in the same way as FIG. 1 represents a three-column process in which 55 in FIG. 1, except that in its reboiler 44 the source of heat , the last column-is operated at high pressure and pro is process gas at 150 C.; in reboiler 44 this gas is cooled vides the heating ?uid for theother two columns; to 125 C. and passed out to reboiler 24 and reboiler 64 FIG. 2 represents a process in which all three~col to be described. Column 50 is at a lower pressure than in umns are operated at low pressure; and J -. . FIG. 1. It performs the same distillation operation as in FIG. 3 represents a process in which the last column FIG. 1, but differs inithat (a) methanol vapour passing is operated ata moderately increased pressure and. its overhead is cooled and condensed by air-cooling or overhead vapour is heat exchanged with the feedto the water-cooling at 55 to give..the re?ux stream fed back at
thesis. a . , ' I
has been partly-cooled in reboiler 44. ' It will'be appreciated that minor features such as feed 65 ' Referring to FIG. 3, this represents a process resem
pumps, feed preheaters, vents and control valves arenot shown. In the-?gures optional features are shown by pecked lines and alternativepaths by dotted lines.
4,210, 495
No. of
theo-
8
TABLE 3
.
(b) the vapour of methanol from the top 54 of column 50 is condensed not in reboiler44 but in heat exchanger 45 and in the reboiler 24 of column 10. Heat exchanger 45 can be used in one of three ways. Following path B
Col-
retical
umn
10
plates
23
(FIG. 3) 110
30 50' (FIG. 1) 450 (FIG. 2) 300
and column liquid on the feed plate is withdrawn, heated in exchanger 45 and fed back to the plate. Fol lowing paths B and C, the liquid on the plate is with drawn, mixed with the feed and the mixture is fed to the
(FIG. 3) 350
220
50
50+ 45
plate.
Table 1 sets out pressures, temperatures, composi
tions and ?ow rates that are common to the three pro
cesses speci?cally described.
(external heat at 170') (external reboiler 44 at 85 C.) (external heat at 122" C.)
In view of the very low ethanol content of the product (0.1 ppm), much less than
TABLE 1
Theoretical Pres
Posi tion
l2
Composition,
2O ture could be lower, thus affording better reboiler transfer from the overhead
methanol va +Lr'ke column at from column 50. . Ihi: column could operate using fewer 11/1712: and still produce methanol meeting the
Plate
, No. \
sure
psig
Temp.
'C.
60
Grade AA speci?cation.
Ethanol
660 ppm
660 ppm
25
Although the total external heatload of the process of FIG. 2 is substantially higher than thatof FIG. 1, it
is the more economic process for use in combination
(13.4)
22 -
(261)
17.02
32 34 38
18
48
Isa:
l a.
86
82.98
86 70
(73.3)
100
(26.7)
0 0 100 0.1 ppm
0.1 ppm
100
42(13)
48 5 30
11a
74
(28.86)
400 ppm
(26.18)
54 99.7
44 0.3
(44-0)
l. A process for producing puri?ed methanol by distillation, comprising the steps of: (a) feeding. a .water~methanol mixture containing small quantities of ethanol, ketones and higher
alcohols to a ?rst distillation column, taking a prod uct methanol stream from an upper level, taking
Theo % w/w or ppm w/w Pres retical sure Temp. (Flow rates kg mol h-l) Plate No. psig C. Methanol Water Ethanol
. 45
S?ial to FIG. 1
129 99.7 0.3 469 ppm
(44.0)
54 58 128
133
100 100
0,.
0
(43.4) 60(33)
87.9
7.6
water containing less than 40% w/w of water. 2.. A process according to claim 1 in which the me
(0.5)
(0.08)
0.3
0 0
7.6
(0.02)
469 ppm
0.001 ppm
w
52
s4 58
60 '
30
'
73
70
99.7
(44.0)
48
100 1(1)
0.001 ppm 55
(43.4)
87.9
(0.5)
S ial to FIG. 3 52 10 44 79 99.27
(0.08)
0.6
(46.066)
54 32 35.6 10 100 100
, 84.93
(0.49 l)
0 15.00
thanol-water feed is the bottoms of a preliminary distil lation column in which components more volatile than 4.5 methanol are taken overhead. (0.02) 4. A process according to claim lin which each column is operated at a pressure in the range 1-20 psig, 1300 ppm 60 measured at the top and the columns are heated by (0.0423)
13 ppm 680 ppm
10
v94
(761x16)
(23.8916) (0.0424)
passing fresh heat-carrying ?uid to the ?rst column reboiler and then passing the partly cooled ?uid leaving
that reboiler to the reboiler of the second column. 5. A process according to claim 1 in which the col
Table 3 sets out the number of theoretical plates and 65 . umns are heated by passing fresh heat-carrying ?uid to the heat load for each of the three columns. (Notethat the reboiler of. the second column and passing methanol the number of plates actually required is about double vapour from the ,top of that column in heat exchange tha number of theoretical plates). with water-methanol mixture fed to the ?rst column
9
overhead vapour.
4,210,495
12. A process according to claim 3 in which (i) the second column is operated at a pressure 70 to
120 psi higher than that of the ?rst column and the preliminary column and (ii) the three columns are heated by passing fresh heat-carrying ?uid to the reboiler of the second column and passing vapour from the top of that
column in heat exchange in the reboiler of the ?rst column and the preliminary column. 13. In a process for producing puri?ed methanol from
a water and methanol mixture containing a small quan
psig, measured at the top and the columns are heated by and taking a bottoms stream containing methanol, passing fresh heat-carrying ?uid to the ?rst column ethanol and water: reboiler and then dividing the partly cooled ?uid leav -the improvement resulting in lowered heat consump ing said reboiler into two part-streams, passing one tion which comprises part-stream to the reboiler of the preliminary column 25 (i) taking said aqueous methanol side stream from a and passing the other part-stream to the reboiler of the level at which the liquid contains at least 95% w/w second column. of methanol; 11. A process according to claim 1 in which (ii) taking as said second column bottoms a stream (i) the second column is operated at a pressure 70 to containing less than 40% w/w of water; and 120 psi higher than that of the ?rst column and (iii) in said second distillation column taking a prod (ii) the two columns are heated by passing fresh heat uct methanol stream from an upper level. carrying ?uid to the reboiler of the second column 14. A process according to claim 13, wherein the and passing methanol vapour from the top of that water content of said side stream is about 0.3 to 0.6% column in heat exchange in the reboiler of the ?rst i i i column. 35
45
55
65
1977
[GB]
United Kindgom . . . .
. . . . . . .
10403/77"
add August
1977
[GB]
United Kingdom
32399/77.
SIDNEY A. DIAMOND
Arresting Of?cer