Sei sulla pagina 1di 17

Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on April 8, 2009 at 12:32 from IEEE Xplore.

Restrictions apply.
MARCH 2009 — VOLUME 3 NUMBER 1

ON THE COVER: © DIGITAL VISION & EYEWIRE


Features

20 Digital Current-Control Schemes EDITOR-IN-CHIEF


Comparing the Performance of Digital Signal Processor-Based Dr. Marco Liserre, Politecnico di Bari, Italy
liserre@ieee.org
Current Controllers for Three-Phase Active Power Filters
Leonardo Rodrigues Limongi, Radu Bojoi, Giovanni Griva, and Alberto Tenconi EDITORIAL BOARD
Prof. Kamal Al-Haddad
Ecole de Technologie Superieur, Canada
Prof. Seta Bogosyan — Educational/Chapter News
32 Fuel Cell High-Power Applications University of Alaska Fairbanks, USA
An Overview of Power Converters for a Prof. Bimal K. Bose
University of Tennessee, USA
Clean Energy Conversion Technology Dr. Chandan Chakraborty
Phatiphat Thounthong, Bernard Davat, Stéphane Raël, and Panarit Sethakul Indian Institute of Technology, India
Dr. Michael W. Condry — Industry Forum
Intel, USA
Prof. Hiroshi Fujimoto — New Products
Yokohama National University, Japan
Prof. Okyay Kaynak
Bogazici University, Turkey
Departments and Columns Prof. Marian Kazmierkowski — Book News
Warsaw University of Technology, Poland
Dr. Mariusz Malinowski — Society News
Warsaw University of Technology, Poland
2 EDITOR’S COLUMN
Prof. Kouhei Ohnishi
3 MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT Keio University, Japan
4 INDUSTRY FORUM Dr. Alberto Pigazo
University of Cantabria, Spain
8 PAST AND PRESENT
Dr. Thilo Sauter
47 SOCIETY NEWS Austrian Academy of Sciences, Austria
62 CHAPTER NEWS Prof. Bogdan M. (Dan) Wilamowski
Auburn University, USA
64 EDUCATION NEWS
Dr. Richard Zurawski
66 BOOK NEWS Atut Technology, USA
68 NEW PRODUCTS
IEEE PERIODICALS/MAGAZINES
69 CALENDAR DEPARTMENT
Geri Krolin-Taylor
Senior Managing Editor
Janet Dudar
SCOPE—IEEE Industrial Electronics Magazine (IEM) publishes peer-reviewed articles that present emerging trends Senior Art Director
and practices in industrial electronics product research and development, key insights, and tutorial surveys in the Gail A. Schnitzer
field of interest to the membership of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society (IEEE/IES). IEM will be limited to the Assistant Art Director
scope of the IES, which is given as theory and applications of electronics, controls, communications, instrumenta-
tion, and computational intelligence to industrial and manufacturing systems and processes.-
Theresa L. Smith
Production Coordinator
IEEE Industrial Electronics Magazine (ISSN 1932-4529) is published quarterly by The Institute of Electrical and Elec- Susan Schneiderman
tronics Engineers, Inc. Headquarters: 3 Park Avenue, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10016-5997, USA +1 212 419 7900. Business Development Manager
Responsibility for the contents rests upon the authors and not upon the IEEE, the Society, or its members. The +1 732 562 3946
magazine is a membership benefit of the IEEE Industrial Electronics Society, and subscriptions are included in
Society fee. Replacement copies for members are available for $20 (one copy only). Nonmembers can purchase Felicia Spagnoli
individual copies for $53.00. Nonmember subscription prices are available on request. Copyright and Reprint Advertising Production Manager
Permissions: Abstracting is permitted with credit to the source. Libraries are permitted to photocopy beyond Peter M. Tuohy
the limits of the U.S. Copyright law for private use of patrons: 1) those post-1977 articles that carry a code at the
bottom of the first page, provided the per-copy fee indicated in the code is paid through the Copyright Clearance Production Director
Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01970, USA; and 2) pre-1978 articles without fee. For other copying, Dawn Melley
reprint, or republication permission, write to: Copyrights and Permissions Department, IEEE Service Center, 445 Editorial Director
Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 08854 U.S.A. Copyright © 2009 by The Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers,
Inc. All rights reserved. Periodicals postage paid at New York, NY and at additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Fran Zappulla
Send address changes to IEEE Industrial Electronics Magazine, IEEE, 445 Hoes Lane, Piscataway, NJ 08854 USA. Staff Director, Publishing Operations
Canadian GST #125634188 Printed in USA Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/MIE.2009.931893

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 1

Authorized licensed use limited to: IEEE Xplore. Downloaded on April 8, 2009 at 12:32 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
An Overview
of Power
Converters
for a Clean
Energy
Conversion
Technology

PHATIPHAT THOUNTHONG,
BERNARD DAVAT, STÉPHANE RAËL,
and PANARIT SETHAKUL

© ARTVILLE

32 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009 Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/MIE.2008.930365 1932-4529/09/$25.00©2009IEEE

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
E
nergy consumption plays FC power plant to the U.S. Department posed approximately 170 years ago
an important role in our of Energy (DOE) and the Ford Mo- when William Robert Grove conceived
modern civilization and tor Company. In 1998, UTC Fuel Cells the first FC in 1839, which produced
daily life, which is heavily delivered a 100-kW methanol power water and electricity by supplying
dependent on burning fos- plant, with 40% efficiency, to Nova Bus hydrogen and oxygen into a sulfuric
sil fuels. The increasing for installation in a 40-ft, hybrid drive acid bath in the presence of porous
threat of the fast deple- electric bus under a DOE/Georgetown platinum electrodes [1]. The process
tion of resources such as petroleum, University contract [7], [8]. by which this is done is very similar
coal, and natural gas forces people General Motors is involved in the to the electrochemical process by
to seek regenerative energy sources, development of FCs for stationary pow- which a battery generates power; at
such as solar, wind, geothermal, and er as well as the more obvious automo- one electrode, a fuel such as hydrogen
hydroelectric energies. Another way of tive markets [9]–[11]. In February 2004, is oxidized, and at the other electrode
saving valuable natural resources and they began the first phase of installa- an oxidant such as oxygen is reduced.
solving the environmental problem is tion operations in Texas at Dow Chemi- The reactions exchange ions through
to develop cleaner and more efficient cal Company, the largest facility in the a solid or liquid electrolyte and elec-
energy conversion devices. In recent world. These FC systems are used to trons through an external circuit, as
years, fuel cell (FC) research and devel- generate 35 MW of electricity [12]. shown in Figure 1 [15], [16].
opment have received much attention
for their higher energy conversion ef-
ficiency and lower or nongreenhouse- Fuel cells produce dc voltage outputs, and they
gas emissions than thermal engines in
the processes of converting fuel into are always connected to electric power networks
usable energies [1]–[3]. The power and
energy efficiency of an FC is highly de-
through power conditioning units such as dc/dc
pendent on thermodynamics, electrode and dc/ac converters.
kinetics, and reactant mass transfer,
as well as materials and components Axane (France) is also working on The theoretical value of a single
for assembling the FC. These factors FC technology. Three markets that are cell voltage of FC is 1.23 V. It is never
have been addressed throughout the likely to provide large commercial out- reached even at no load. At the rated
FC history and are now still the major lets [13], [14] are: current, the voltage of an elementary
challenges for FC research and devel- ■ portable multiapplication genera- cell is about 0.6–0.7 V [17]–[19]. There-
opment [4]–[6]. tors (500 W–10 kW) fore, an FC is always an assembly of el-
In industry, United Technologies ■ stationary applications (more than ementary cells that constitute a stack,
Corporation (UTC) Fuel Cells is in- 10 kW) as Figure 2 depicts.
volved in FC systems for space and ■ mobile applications for small hy- There are many different types of
defense applications. UTC Fuel Cells brid vehicles (5–20 kW). FCs, with the principal differences be-
activity began in 1958 and led to the FCs produce dc voltage outputs, and tween them being the type of electro-
development of the first practical FC they are always connected to electric lyte and/or the type of fuel that they
application used to generate electrical power networks through power condi- use. For instance, both the phosphoric
power and potable water for the Apol- tioning units such as dc/dc and dc/ac acid FC (PAFC) and the molten carbon-
lo space missions. Since 1966, all of converters. Power conversion and con- ate FC (MCFC) have a liquid electro-
the more than 100 manned U.S. space trol functions form the basis of what has lyte, whereas a solid oxide FC (SOFC)
flights, including the Space Shuttle, come to be known as the field of power has a solid, ceramic electrolyte [20]–
have operated with FCs supplied by electronics. In recent years, power elec- [22]. A proton exchange or polymer
UTC companies. In 1991, UTC Fuel tronics technology has been spurred electrolyte membrane FC (PEMFC)
Cells manufactured its first PureCell by needs for efficient control of indus- and a direct methanol FC (DMFC) may
200 power plant, the world’s first and trial applications and the development have the same solid polymer electro-
only commercial FC power. The Pure- of more reliable lightweight switching lyte, but the DMFC uses liquid metha-
Cell 200 FC produces 200-kW of elec- power supplies for a sophisticated sys- nol for fuel whereas the PEMFC uses
tricity and 700,000 BTUs of heat. The tem. This article reviews the current re- gaseous hydrogen [23], [24].
unit can be powered by natural gas, search of power electronic converters Currently, there are three general
propane, butane, hydrogen, naphtha, for FC high-power applications. areas of application for FC technol-
or gases from waste. Since their first ogy: portable power, distributed pow-
flight in 1981, UTC Fuel Cells power FC Technology er, and transportation. For each appli-
plants have provided electric power An FC is a device that converts the cation, it is generally found that one
for more than 100 shuttle missions. chemical energy of a fuel directly to type of FC is better suited than the
They shipped a 50-kW hydrogen-air electrical energy. Its concept was pro- others to satisfy the requirements of

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 33

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
and absorbed by a load (converter).
Electric Load Suitable alarms must shut down the
e− i FC process if unsafe operating conditions
M occur, and a cell voltage monitoring
system must monitor FC stack per-
formance. These functions are per-
Hydrogen and formed by electrical control systems.
Vapor Water As an example, Figure 3 shows a sim-
plified diagram of the PEMFC system.
Air and When an FC operates, its fuel (hydro-
Vapor Water
gen and air) flows are controlled by an
FC controller, which receives current
H2 O2
demand. This current demand is the

Cathode
2H + FC current reference iFCREF (see Figure
Anode

H2 O H2O
3) coming from the energy manage-
H2O y
ment controller. The fuel flows must
2e− 2e− z be adjusted to match the reactant de-
x livery rate to the usage rate by the FC
Channel

Channel
Membrane
Bipolar Plate

Bipolar Plate
Catalyst Layer

Catalyst Layer
Diffusion Layer

Diffusion Layer

controller [36], [37].

FC Characteristics
As mentioned earlier, an FC power
source is always connected to the dc
Overall Fuel Cell Reactions:
bus by a step-up converter. Switching
H2 + 1 O2 → H2O + Heat + Electrical Energy characteristics of the PEMFC (500 W,
2
40 A) at steady-state when connecting
FIGURE 1 – Different layers of an elementary cell of PEMFC.
with a boost converter are presented
in Figure 4. It can be seen that the
the application. The DMFCs are attrac- operate. The composition, pressure, PEMFC contains a complex impedance
tive for several applications in view of and flow rate of each of these streams component, which it is not purely re-
their lower weight and volume. The must be regulated. In addition, the gas- sistive at a high switching frequency
DMFCs are increasingly being devel- es must be humidified and the coolant of 25 kHz [36].
oped to replace or support batteries, temperature must be controlled. To Thounthong et al. [38] (who worked
mainly for the high energy density of achieve this, the FC stack must be sur- with a 500-W PEMFC system by ZSW
methanol. The DMFCs are promising rounded by a fuel system, fuel deliv- Company), Corrêa et al. [39], [40] (who
candidates as portable power sources ery system, air system, stack cooling worked with a 500-W Ballard and 500-
because they do not require any fuel system, and humidification system. W Avista PEMFC system), and Zhu
processing and operate at low tem- Once operating, the output power gen- et al. [41] (who worked with a 500-W
peratures (30–60 °C) [25]–[27]. The erated by the FCs must be conditioned PEMFC system) have demonstrated
SOFC, because of its high pow- that the electrical response
er density a nd high grade time of an FC is generally fast,
waste heat that may be used being mainly associated with
in cogeneration applications, the speed at which the chemi-
is a front-runner in distributed cal reaction is capable of re-
power applications at the storing the charge that has
industrial level [28]–[31]. The been drained by the load. On
PEMFC has many of the quali- the other hand, because an FC
ties required of an automotive system is composed of many
power system including rela- mechanical devices, the whole
tively low operating tem- FC system has slow transient
perature, high power density, response and slow output pow-
and rapid startup [32]–[34]. In er ramping [42], [43].
addition, PEMFC may also be For clarity about the FC dy-
used in residential and com- namics, Figure 5 illustrates a
mercial power systems [35]. FIGURE 2 – An PEMFC (16 cells, 500 W, 50 A, and around 11 V) Nexa PEMFC system (1.2 kW, 46
manufactured by the Centre for Solar Energy and Hydrogen
An FC stack requires fuel, Research Baden-Württemberg (ZSW) Company. It is being A), and Figure 6 depicts the FC
oxidant, and coolant in order to functioned at the GREEN laboratory. voltage response to a current

34 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
demand of the Nexa PEMFC stack. The needs of the application. FC operates converter (dc/dc converter, named
tests operate in two different ways: cur- giving direct current and at a low here FC converter) is always selected
rent step and controlled current slope voltage; thereby, the step-up (boost) to adapt the low dc voltage delivered
of 2 A # s 21. One can scrutinize the volt-
age drop in Figure 6(a), compared to
Figure 6(b), because fuel flows (par- − v FC + iFCREF
ticularly the delay of air flow) have dif- Fuel Cell
ficulties following the current step. This i FC Controller Air
characteristic is called fuel starvation Hydrogen
Compressor
Tank Fuel Cell Stack
phenomenon [1], [44]–[47]. The same
kind of FC dynamic responses can be
seen in [48]. This condition of operation M
is evidently dangerous for the FC stack, Hydrogen
as already demonstrated by Taniguchi Heat Exchanger Purge
et al. [49]. To utilize the FC in dynamic
applications, its current or power slope Air
must be limited, for example, 4 A # s 21 Exhaust
M Water Pump
for a PEMFC (0.5 kW, 12.5 V) [50]; a 2.5
kW # s 21 for a PEMFC (40 kW, 70 V) [51]; FIGURE 3 – Simplified diagram of the PEMFC system. vFC , iFC , and iFCREF are the FC voltage,
and 500 W # s 21 for a PEMFC (2.5 kW, current, and current demand, respectively.
22 V) [52].
Therefore, the constraints to oper-
ate an FC are as follows:
Ch1: FC Ripple Voltage
1) The FC power or current must be [200 mV/Div]
kept within an interval (rated val-
ue, minimum value or zero). 1
2) The FC current must be controlled
as a unidirectional current.
3) The FC current slope must be lim-
ited to a maximum absolute value
(for example, 4 A # s 21 [53]), to pre- Ch2: FC Current
vent an FC stack from the fuel star- [10 A/Div]
vation phenomenon.
4) Switching frequency of the FC cur-
rent must be greater than 1.25 kHz, 2
and the FC ripple current must be Time: 10 µ s/Div
lower than around 5% of rated val-
(a)
ue, to ensure minor impact to the
FC conditions [54], [55].
Ch1: FC Ripple Voltage
FC Power Conditioning [200 mV/Div]
The power conditioning system pro-
1
vides regulated dc or ac power ap-
propriate for the application. It is the
major component of an FC distributed Ch2: FC Current
system. The output of the FC is an un- [10 A/Div]
regulated dc voltage (see Figure 6),
and it needs to be conditioned in or-
der to be of practical use. The power
conditioner section converts the FC
power to usable power for different
2
applications. The power condition-
ing unit also controls electricity’s fre- Time: 10 µ s/Div
quency and maintains harmonics to (b)
an acceptable level. The purpose of
conditioners is to adapt the electrical FIGURE 4– Switching characteristics of a 500 W PEMFC of 25 kHz at the FC current supply of (a)
current from FC to suit the electrical 10 A and (b) 40 A (rated current).

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 35

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
by the FC to the utility dc bus followed
Nexa PEMFC System by an inverter (Figure 7) [56]. In gen-
eral, the load for the boost stage is a
DC Servomotor as Hydrogen filter and the inverter system.
a Load at DC Bus Tank The inverter is used for the interfac-
ing of the FC system to the power grid
to provide the grid with voltage/current
with proper frequency phase and mag-
nitude where the input for the inverter
comes from the boost converter stage
and the inverter (with the filter) be-
comes the load for the boost converter.
−VFC The power conditioner is also used for
the grid connection of the FC. An electri-
cal power-generating system that uses
+VFC FC as the primary source of electricity
generation and is intended to operate
FC Controller Air synchronously, and in parallel with
Board Compressor the electric utility network is a grid-
connected FC system [57], [58]. Such
FIGURE 5 – A Nexa PEMFC (1.2 kW, 46 A). It is being functioned at the TFII laboratory. systems may also include storage de-
vices and other generating sources and
may operate on site loads independent of
38 V Fuel Starvation the utility network during outages.
CH1: FC Voltage
3V
Phenomenon To employ the FC as a main power
27 V [10 V/Div]
source in dynamic applications (such
CH2: FC Current Demand as an electric vehicle [59]–[61] and
0.8 s
46 A [20 A/Div] railway vehicle [62]–[64]), the electri-
CH3: FC Current cal system must have at least an auxil-
46 A [20 A/Div] iary power source (storage device) to
1 CH4: Oxygen Flow improve the dynamic performances
6A 98 slpm [30 slpm/Div]
of the whole system, when electrical
2 loads at a dc bus demand high power
6A
in a short time (for example, vehicle
3
acceleration and deceleration), as por-
trayed in Figure 8. Moreover, one can
26 slpm
take advantage of this auxiliary power
Time: 250 ms/Div source to achieve an actual hybrid
4
(a) source to disassociate mean power
sizing from peak transient power siz-
38 V CH1: FC Voltage ing, the aim being a reduction in vol-
28 V [10 V/Div] ume and weight, and in the case of FCs
used as main energy source, the pos-
CH2: FC Current Demand
[20 A/Div]
sibility of regenerative braking [38],
46 A [65]. For example, some authors have
2 A.s−1
CH3: FC Current
described the study of the FC/battery
46 A [20 A/Div]
hybrid power source [66]–[70] and
1 CH4: Oxygen Flow
6A 98 slpm [30 slpm/Div] the FC/supercapacitor hybrid power
2 source [71]–[73].
6A For the past ten years, much
3 research has been conducted on the
utilizations of FCs in high power appli-
26 slpm cations. Today, the required FC power
Time: 5 s/Div is in the range of 1 kW to 2 MW:
4 ■ 1–2 kW for unmanned aircrafts [74]
(b)
and 40–700 kW for manned aircraft
FIGURE 6 – FC dynamic characteristics to (a) current step and (b) controlled current slope of 2 A ? s21. [75]–[78]

36 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
■ 50–100 kW for urban cars [9], [33],
[79]–[85]
A large research effort is underway to develop the
■ 100–200 kW for buses and light
trams [7], [86]–[88] FC for applications ranging from small portable
■ 600 kW–1 MW for tramways and
locomotives [62]–[64], [89]–[92]
electronic devices to automotive transport, as well
(for example four motors of 180-kW as residential combined heat and power supplies.
peak are installed on a tramway,
two motors per boggy. The total
power installed is 800 kW)
■ 480 kW–2 MW for distributed gen- dc/dc Converter dc/ac Converter
eration systems (grid parallel con- Fuel Cell Modules i (FC Converter) (Inverter) Utility Grid
FC dc Bus
nection) [8], [93]. + +
To increase the power and volt- vFC v Bus
age levels, several configurations for −

the FC association can be envisaged
p FC p Load
as depicted in Figure 9 [93]–[98]. For
association of the converter inputs,
FIGURE 7 – FC power system.
we can connect several FC in series
and then connect them to a con-
verter or each FC to a converter. The
FC parallel connection is currently
complicated because of complexity dc/dc Converter dc/ac Converter
(FC Converter) (Inverter)
of controlling the output power dis- Fuel Cell Modules i dc Bus Traction Motor
FC
tribution in each FC. For association + +
of converter outputs, the output of a vFC v Bus

converter can be connected in series −
for a high output voltage or in paral- p FC p Load
lel for a low output voltage. Storage Devices dc/dc Converter
+
FC Power Converter
Different power converter topolo- −
gies can be used for the power elec- p Aux
tronic interface between the FC and
the utility dc bus. For the dc link FIGURE 8 – Fuel cell powered vehicle.

dc Bus dc Bus
n FC + n FC +
in Series in Series

Electric Electric
g Groups g Groups Network
Network

- -

(a) (b)

FIGURE 9 – Modular stack FC architectures connected to the dc bus: (a) output connected in series and (b) output connected parallel.
n: number of FC in series in each group, g: number of FC-converter groups.

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 37

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
Fuel Cell Sytem
dc Bus
+ Hydrogen Water
Fuel Cell
Fuel Cell Control Air
System L1 − + Heat
i FC Filter vFC
C Bus i FC
+
v Bus dc Bus
FC Current
vFC Controller PWM +
S1 i FCREF
v Bus


− Fuel Cell Converter

(a) (b)

FIGURE 10 – Classical fuel cell boost converter: (a) power circuit and (b) FC current regulation loop.

voltage level, it is depending on ■ 270–540 V for electric (FC) vehicles [105]–[107], because it can be oper-
its applications: [60], [65], [82] ated in the current control mode in a
■ 270 V or 350 V for the standard on ■ 350 V (transit bus systems) to 750 V continuous condition mode, as por-
the all-electric aircraft [78] (tramway and locomotive systems) trayed in Figure 10. Then, one does
■ 48 V [99], 120 V [100], or 400–480 V [7], [63], [64], [87], [89]–[92], [104]. not need a blocking diode and passive
[30], [93], [101] for stand-alone or Basically, low-voltage, high-current filter between an FC and a converter.
parallel grid connections structures are needed because of the Based on the load conditions, the
■ 42 V (PowerNet) a new standard FC electrical characteristics. A classi- boost converter can be commanded
voltage for automobile systems cal boost converter is often selected as to draw a specific amount of current
[34], [102], [103] an FC converter [38], [93], [99]–[101], from the FC with a ripple well defined
by the frequency, size of the inductor,
and duty ratio. The FC boost converter
Module 1 D1 i Load sizes of 0.5 kW [38]; 1 kW [100], [101],
Fuel Cell + [105]; 5 kW [99]; 27 kW [106]; and 50
L1 i D1
i FC i L1 i C Bus kW [93] have been studied. However,
+
i S1 a classical boost converter will be lim-
v Bus
vFC C Bus ited when the power increases or for
S1
vGS1 higher step-up ratios. In that way, the
use of paralleling power converters
_ _
with interleaved technique may offer
Module 2 D
2 some better performances.
L2 i D2
i L2
Parallel Power Converter with
i S2 Interleaved Switching Algorithm
S2 The subject of paralleling power con-
vGS2
verters was on the sideline of design
engineering tasks for decades. Latest
efforts in standardization, miniatur-
ization, and the proliferation of high
Module N D current, low voltage power supplies
N
have directed additional attention
LN i DN
i LN to various techniques to parallel
power modules. The fundamental
i SN
difficulty using parallel power pro-
SN cessing circuits is to ensure that
vGSN
the load current is properly distrib-
uted among the parallel connected
power modules. Only then can the
FIGURE 11 – Multiphase paralleled step-up converters for FC high-power applications. design be optimized for the highest

38 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
reliability and lowest cost by ensur-
ing equal temperature rise and by
Current Duty Cycle to
minimizing the power rating of the
Controller Inductor Current
individual components. ~ ~ PWM ~ ~
iFCREF ~ ~ iL1 iFC
1 i LREF vC1 d1
The major problems of using a — GP1(s) Gid 1(s)
N Ci 1(s) +
single dc/dc converter connected − +
with FC in high power applications are Current Filter and
as follows: Measurement Gain
~
■ difficulty of the design of magnetic iL
1Mea
component: ferrite core and Litz- Hi 1(s)
wire size
Current Duty Cycle to
■ high FC ripple current, which may
Controller Inductor Current
lead to reduce its stack lifetime. PWM ~
~ ~
vC 2 d2 iL
Therefore, by paralleling convert- GP2(s) Gid 2(s)
2
Ci 2(s) +
ers with interleaving technique, these − +
problems can be avoided [108]–[111]. Current Filter and
A high-power dc distributed power Measurement Gain
~
system supplied by FC invokes the iL2Mea
need to parallel power modules with Hi 2(s)
interleaving technique. Active ripple
cancellation methods can yield even
higher performance. Today, the ac-
tive method of interleaving is well Current Duty Cycle to
Controller Inductor Current
known [94], [96], [98]. In the interleav- PWM ~
~ ~
vCN dN iL
ing method, the modules operate at GPN (s) GidN (s)
N
CiN (s)
the same switching frequency. Their −
switching waveforms are displaced Current Filter and
in phase over a switching period with Measurement Gain
~
respect to one another by 2p/N radians, iL
N Mea
with N being the number of converters HiN (s)
in parallel. It is important to note here
that, according to [54] and [55], a high
FC current ripple plays an important FIGURE 12 – Current sharing technique of N-phase parallel modules
role in its catalyst lifetime. Especially, (here, boost converters).

1 A/Div 10 A/Div

Fuel Cell Current ΔIFC = 1.5 A Fuel Cell Current

i L1 i L2
ΔIL = 3 A
i L1 i L2

TS = 40 μ s

REF TS = 40 μ s REF
Time: 10 μ s/Div Time: 10 μ s/Div
(a) (b)

FIGURE 13 – Steady-state waveforms of the two-cell interleaved converter system at an FC current command of (a) 4 A (vFC = 35.8 V) and
(b) 46 A rated current (vFC = 26.3 V).

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 39

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
1 A/Div Fuel Cell Current 5 A/Div

Fuel Cell Current

i L1 i L2 i L3

i L2 i L3 i L4

REF TS = 40 μ s TS = 40 μ s

REF

Time: 10 μ s/Div Time: 10 μ s/Div


(a) (b)

FIGURE 14 – Steady-state waveforms of the four-cell interleaved converter system at an FC current command of (a) 4 A (vFC = 35.8 V) and
(b) 30 A (vFC = 28.9 V).

sharp current rise/fall and large magni- the output voltage of a power supply, tor currents of the modules and the
tude of current ripple should be avoid- as portrayed in Figure 12 [112], [113]. other is the desired amount of FC cur-
ed. The multiphase parallel converters To make this approach work, two piec- rent reference iFCREF. Since the goal is
for FC high-power to evenly distribute
applications are de- the FC current, the
picted in Figure 11. desired FC current
The most sophis-
There are three general areas of application for is the FC current di-
ticated and most ac- FC technology: portable power, distributed power, vided by the number
curate current shar- of parallel modules.
ing implementations and transportation. Therefore the task
rely on a closed loop is two fold; measure
negative feedback system, very similar es of information must be available in the inductor currents and generate the
to those control loops used to regulate the system. One is the actual induc- average inductor current set-points.

L1 D1
iFC dc Bus
FC Generator and Power Converter Specifications + +
+
Rated Power of FC Modules 100 kW
S1 CBus v Bus
Rated Current of FC Modules 600 A

Rated Voltage of FC Modules 214 V (460 V at No-Load)
− L2 D2
v FC
FC Ripple Current 6 A (1%) +

Converter Rated Power 100 kW S2

Converter Efficiency > 94%



− L3 D3
dc Bus Voltage 540 V

S3

FIGURE 15 – 100-kW FC converter of three-phase interleaved boost converters with two FC modules in series [98].

40 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
According to Thounthong et al.
[114], [115], who worked with a Ballard
Nexa PEMFC unit (1.2-kW, 46-A, see
The PEMFC is well suited to automotive power
Figure 5), they have already demon- applications and may be used in residential and
strated the experimental results of the
two- and four-phase paralleled boost commercial power systems.
converters for FC applications. The
oscilloscope waveforms in Figures 13 the four-cell interleaved converter is VFC 5 250–450 V, VBus 5 548 V, weigh
and 14 portray the steady-state char- nearly zero. It means that the FC mean 50 kg) with two-phase interleaved
acteristics of the interleaved convert- current is close to the FC rms current. boost converters had been fabricated
ers at different FC current demands, In addition, it can be seen the FC rip- and tested [117]. Its volume and weight
the load at dc bus being adjusted in ple frequency is N-times the switching is less than one third of a single phase
order to obtain a constant dc bus volt- frequency of 25 kHz. boost converter, the FC ripple current
age of 60 V (here rated value). Figure According to Hwang et al. [116], an is less than 10%, and its efficiency is
13 illustrates the FC current, and the FC converter size of 1 kW with four- over 97%. According to Vulturescu
first and the second inductor currents phase interleaved boost cells had been et al. [98], the design of an FC con-
of the two-phase parallel converter at also presented. For an FC converter verter size of 100 kW with three-phase
the average FC current reference of 4 A size of 150 kW (technical specification: interleaved boost converters with two
and 46 A (rated current), respectively
[114]. Figure 14(a) presents the FC cur-
rent and the first, second, and third
inductor currents of the four-phase L1a D1a
parallel converters at the average FC +
L2a D2a
current reference of 4 A. For the last
test, Figure 14(b) shows the FC cur-
Ca +
rent and the second, third, and fourth i FC S1a S2a VBus + VFC
va Va = Vb = —————
inductor currents of the 4-phase par- + − 2
Electric VFC VFC
allel converters at the average FC cur-
vBus D = 1− —— = 1 − ——
vFC Network Va Vb
rent reference of 30 A [115].
One can observe again that the FC VBus − VFC
− S1b S2b Cb + D = —————
current is the sum of the inductor cur- VBus + VFC
vb
rents and that the FC ripple current is L1b D1b − D is the duty cycle.
1/N the individual inductor ripple cur-
rents. Absolutely, the FC ripple current L2b D2b

of the four-cell interleaved converter
is lower than the two-cell interleaved
converter. So, the FC ripple current of FIGURE 16 – 120-kW two-blanches interleaved double dual boost converters [96].

Low-Voltage, High-Current Section High-Voltage, Low-Current Section


L1a D1a L1b D1b
+
L2a D2a

C1b
L3a D3a S1b

L4a D4a
Electric
vBus Network
Fuel Cell iFC
Modules + C1a C2b
S1a S2a S3a S4a S2b
vFC

− D2b

FIGURE 17 – 200-kW cascade-parallel boost converter for the FC power converter.

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 41

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
proposed the two-blanches interleaved
double dual (IDD) boost converters for
FCs hold great promise as a clean energy an FC converter: 20–120 kW, as shown
conversion technology. in Figure 16. One summarizes that this
scheme can boost the FC input voltage
FC modules in series has been studied of 750 V has been proposed in [118]. from 60–700 V utility dc bus at the FC
for French urban transportation net- For the FC urban car, the 94-kW FC con- current of 333 A (20 kW).
works, as depicted in Figure 15. In ad- verter with the multiphase interleaved Another possibility to increase
dition, a three-phase interleaved boost boost converters at the dc link voltage the voltage conversion ratio of the FC
modules based on the commercial of 320 V had been designed and used high-power converter is cascade-par-
standard Lopak5 of insulated gate in the HydroGen3 FC vehicle of Gen- allel boost converter, as Figure 17 illus-
bipolar transistors (IGBTs) by Asea eral Motors (GM) Company [119]. trates. This similar concept has been
Brown Boveri Ltd. (ABB) for 250–1,000- To increase the higher voltage proposed in [120]–[122]. One might
kW FC converter at the dc link voltage conversion ratio, Viet et al. [96] have suppose that this power converter can

Module 1
L1 iL1

dc Bus
iFC Fuel Cell +
Modules
+ 1:n

vFC

TR1

Module 2
L2 iL2

1:n

Electric
vBus Network
TR2

Module N
LN iLN

1:n

TRN

FIGURE 18 – Interleaved current-fed full bridge converters with a parallel input and a series output for FC high power applications.

42 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
operate up to 200 kW with the voltage
conversion ratio of eight.
For ground isolation and high voltage
The power and energy efficency of an FC is highly
step-up ratio (but more complicated), dependent on the thermodynamics, electrode
interleaved boost/flyback [123], [124],
push-pull [125]–[127], and half bridge kinectics, and reactant mass transfer, as well as
and full bridge [128]–[132] can be con- materials and components for assembling the FC.
sidered as candidate topologies for the
FC converter. Advantages and disadvan-
tages of these converters are discussed rating by paralleling phases, not for high-power applications, inductor
in [127], [128], and [132]. The most by paralleling multiple devices. size (ferrite core and Litzwire) are sim-
popular ground isolation circuit today 5) Thermal management is simple. ple to design and fabricate, and the FC
for high-power applications is the full- The primary driver in all paral- ripple current can be virtually reduced
bridge dc/dc converter, because of rea- leling schemes for lower power to zero. As a result, the FC mean current
sonable device voltage ratings and soft applications is the decentralized is nearly equal to the FC rms current.
switching possibility [133], [134]. heat dissipation of the parallel The main drawback of the multiphase
Considering the ripple and direct power converters. approach is added circuit complexity,
current control requirement, an isolated 6) Current ratings of power elec- requiring measurement and balancing
current-fed full bridge converter topol- tronic components are reduced, of each phase current as the larger num-
ogy shows some promise [134]–[136]. because current ratings are pro- ber of control components illustrates.
It has small current ripple and high effi- portional to the continuous power
ciency. To reduce the size of the magnet- rating of the circuit. Acknowledgments
ic components and further improve the Based on research carried out over
converter efficiency, a multiphase inter- Conclusions several years, some work in the re-
leaved current-fed full-bridge converter FCs hold great promise as a clean viewed article were supported in
is proposed in [113], as shown in Figure energy conversion technology. A part by the French National Center
18. By paralleling input of the converter large research effort is underway to for Scientific Research (CNRS), the
system, input current, and hence the develop the FC for applications rang- Nancy Research Group in Electrical
power, can be equally shared between ing from small portable electronic Engineering (GREEN: UMR 7037),
the modules of the converter system. devices to automotive transport, as Thai-French Innovation Institute
Therefore, current stress on the semi- well as residential combined heat and ( TFII ), King Mongkut’s Univer-
conductor devices on the input side is power supplies. These applications sity of Technology North Bangkok
reduced. On the other hand, the series have a large emerging market and (KMUTNB), and the Thailand Re-
connection on the output side results in widespread adoption should lead to a search Fund (TRF) under Grant
lower voltage ratings for output capaci- reduced dependence on fossil fuels as MRG5180348.
tors and diodes. Furthermore, phase well as encourage the development of
shifted pulse-width modulation (PWM) a hydrogen economy. Biographies
is used for the interleaved full-bridge FCs produce low dc voltage, so that Phatiphat Thounthong received
converter. So, the input current ripple it is most often connected to electric the B.S. and M.E. degrees in electri-
frequency and the output voltage ripple networks through a step-up dc/dc cal engineering from King Mongkut’s
frequency increase. Hence, for the same converter. This article first introduc- Institute of Technology North Bang-
input current and output voltage ripple es electrical characteristics, power kok, Thailand, in 1996 and 2001, re-
requirement, smaller input inductors electronic requirements, and differ- spectively, and the Ph.D. degree in
and output capacitors can be used. ent types of FCs and is then followed electrical engineering from Institut
The advantages of the parallel con- by a discussion of the various topolo- National Polytechnique de Lorraine
verter with interleaving technique are gies of step-up dc/dc converters used (INPL), Nancy, France, in 2005. From
as follows: for FCs’ power-conditioning system. 1998 to 2002, he was an assistant lec-
1) Size and volume of passive de- The examinations of several differ- turer at King Mongkut’s University of
vices (inductor and capacitor) are ent approaches to power- conditioning Technology North Bangkok, where he
reduced. systems for single and multiple FC is currently a lecturer. He has pub-
2) Ripple of the input and output combinations have been reviewed. lished more than 30 papers in interna-
waveforms are reduced. High-power dc distributed power tional journals, refereed conferences,
3) Ripple frequency of the input and systems supplied by FC invokes the and two book chapters. His current
output waveforms are increased need to parallel power modules with in- research interests include power
4) Power converter is modular. It en- terleaving technique. By method of the electronics, electric drives, and elec-
hances reliability of the system, parallel converter modules with inter- trical devices (fuel cells, batteries,
and increases converter power leaving algorithm for an FC generator and supercapacitor).

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 43

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
with a PWM dc/dc converter,” IEEE Trans.
Energy Conversion, vol. 23, pp. 669–680, June
There are many different types of FCs, 2008.
[17] I. Sadli, P. Thounthong, J. P. Martin, S. Raël, and
with the principal differences between them being B. Davat, “Behaviour of a PEMFC supplying a
low voltage static converter,” J. Power Sources,
the type of electrolyte and/or the type of fuel vol. 156, pp. 119–125, May 2006.
[18] S. C. Page, A. H. Anbuky, S. P. Krumdieck, and
J. Brouwer, “Test method and equivalent cir-
that they use. cuit modeling of a PEM fuel cell in a passive
state,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 22,
pp. 764–773, Sept. 2007.
[19] S. Pasricha, M. Keppler, S. R. Shaw, and M. H.
Bernard Davat received the en- Bangkok, Thailand. His research inter- Nehrir, “Comparison and identification of stat-
gineering degree from Ecole Nation- ests are electrical machine drives and ic electrical terminal fuel cell models,” IEEE
Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 22, pp. 746–754,
ale Supérieure d’Electrotechnique, power electronics. Sept. 2007.
d’Electronique, d’Informatique, [20] S. R. Choudhury and R. Rengaswamy, “Charac-
terization and fault diagnosis of PAFC cathode
d’Hydraulique et des Telecommunica-
by EIS technique and a novel mathematical
tions (ENSEEIHT), Toulouse, France, References model approach,” J. Power Sources, vol. 161,
in 1975, and the Ph.D. and Docteur [1] P. Thounthong, B. Davat, and S. Raël, “Drive pp. 971–986, Oct. 2006.
friendly,” IEEE Power Energy Mag., vol. 6, no. 1, [21] C. Wang and M. H. Nehrir, “A physically based
d’Etat degrees in electrical engineer- pp. 69–76, 2008. dynamic model for solid oxide fuel cells,” IEEE
ing from Institut National Polytech- [2] M. C. Péra, D. Candusso, D. Hissel, and J. M. Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 22, pp. 887–897,
Kauffmann, “Power generation by fuel cells,” Dec. 2007.
nique de Toulouse (INPT), Toulouse, IEEE Ind. Electron. Mag., vol. 1, no. 3, pp. 28–37, [22] M. Suzuki, N. Shikazono, K. Fukagata, and N.
in 1978 and 1984, respectively. Since 2007. Kasagi, “Numerical analysis of coupled trans-
[3] M. Tekin, D. Hissel, M. C. Péra, and J. M. Kauff- port and reaction phenomena in an anode-
1988, he has been a professor INPL.
mann, “Energy-management strategy for em- supported flat-tube solid oxide fuel cell,” J.
He is the author of Power Semicon- bedded fuel-cell systems using fuzzy logic,” Power Sources, vol. 180, pp. 29–40, May 2008.
ductor Converters and has published IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 54, pp. 595–603, [23] D. H. Ko, M. J. Lee, W. H. Jang, and U. Krewer,
Feb. 2007. “Non-isothermal dynamic modelling and op-
more than 50 papers in international [4] W. Schmittinger and A. Vahidi, “A review of the timization of a direct methanol fuel cell,” J.
journals and refereed conferences. main parameters influencing long-term per- Power Sources, vol. 180, pp. 71–83, May 2008.
formance and durability of PEM fuel cells,” J. [24] M. Paquin and L. G. Fréchette, “Understand-
His research interests include power Power Sources, vol. 180, pp. 1–4, May 2008. ing cathode flooding and dry-out for water
electronics, drives, and new electri- [5] C. Casati, P. Longhi, L. Zanderighi, and F. Bianchi, management in air breathing PEM fuel cells,”
cal devices (fuel cells, batteries, and “Some fundamental aspects in electrochemical J. Power Sources, vol. 180, pp. 440–451, May
hydrogen purification/compression,” J. Power 2008.
supercapacitor). He is a Member of Sources, vol. 180, pp. 103–113, May 2008. [25] U. A. Icardi, S. Specchia, G. J. R. Fontana, G.
the IEEE. [6] C. Kim, K. J. Kim, and M. Y. Ha, “Performance Saracco, and V. Specchia, “Compact direct
enhancement of a direct borohydride fuel methanol fuel cells for portable application,” J.
Stéphane Raël received the M.E. cell in practical running conditions,” J. Power Power Sources, vol. 176, pp. 460–467, Feb. 2008.
degree in electrical engineering Sources, vol. 180, pp. 154–161, May 2008. [26] J. Y. Park, J. H. Lee, J. Kim, S. Han, and I. Song,
from the Ecole Nationale Supérieure [7] S. Varigonda and M. Kamat, “Control of sta- “Stable operation of air-blowing direct metha-
tionary and transportation fuel cell systems: nol fuel cells with high performance,” J. Power
des Ingénieurs Electriciens de Progress and opportunities,” Comput. Chem. Sources, vol. 179, pp. 1–8, Apr. 2008.
Grenoble, Grenoble, France, in 1992 Eng., vol. 30, pp. 1735–1748, Sept. 2006. [27] S. K. Kamarudin, W. R. W. Daud, S. L. Ho, and U.
[8] Y. Kishinevsky and S. Zelingher, “Coming clean A. Hasran, “Overview on the challenges and de-
and the Ph.D. degree in electrical en- with fuel cells,” IEEE Power Energy Mag., vol. 1, velopments of micro-direct methanol fuel cells
gineering from the Institut National pp. 20–25, Nov./Dec. 2003. (DMFC),” J. Power Sources, vol. 163, pp. 743–754,
Polytechnique de Grenoble (INPG), [9] R. von Helmolt and U. Eberle, “Fuel cell ve- Jan. 2007.
hicles: Status 2007,” J. Power Sources, vol. 165, [28] P. C. Buddingh, V. Scaini, and L. F. Casey, “Uti-
Grenoble, France, in 1996. He is a pp. 833–843, Mar. 2007. lizing waste hydrogen for energy recovery
professor at the Institut National [10] V. P. McConnell, “Downsized footprint and ma- using fuel cells and associated technologies,”
terial changes for GM’s fourth-generation fuel IEEE Trans. Ind. Applicat., vol. 42, pp. 186–194,
Polytechnique de Lorraine (INPL), cell technology,” Fuel Cells Bull., vol. 2007, pp. Jan./Feb. 2006.
Nancy, France. His research inter- 12–15, Jan. 2007. [29] K. Sedghisigarchi and A. Feliachi, “Impact of
ests include power electronic com- [11] K. Bonhoff, “The clean energy partnership fuel cells on load-frequency control in power
Berlin-CEP,” J. Power Sources, vol. 181, pp. 350– distribution systems,” IEEE Trans. Energy Con-
ponents, supercapacitor, batteries, 352, July 2008. version, vol. 21, pp. 250–256, Mar. 2006.
and fuel cells. [12] General Motors Corporation. Dow—GM Make [30] J. Lee, J. Jo, S. Choi, and S. B. Han, “A 10-kW
World’s First Significant Fuel Cell Applica- SOFC low-voltage battery hybrid power condi-
Panarit Sethakul received the tion a Reality [Online]. Available: http://www. tioning system for residential use,” IEEE Trans.
B.S. and M.S. degrees in electrical gm.com/company/gmability/adv_tech/500_ Energy Conversion, vol. 21, pp. 575–585, June
engineering from King Mongkut’s Uni- stationary 2006.
[13] D. Lecocq, “Tomorrow’s energy today with Ax- [31] Y. H. Li, S. S. Choi, and S. Rajakaruna, “An
versity of Technology North Bangkok, ane,” Fuel Cells Bull., vol. 2004, pp. 13–15, Mar. analysis of the control and operation of a solid
Thailand, in 1979 and 1982, respective- 2004. oxide fuel-cell power plant in an isolated sys-
[14] Axane Company. Axane: Products [On- tem,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 20,
ly, and the Dipl.-Ing. from the Univer- line]. Available: http://www.axane.fr/axane/ pp. 381–387, June 2005.
sity of Wuppertal, Germany in 1986. gb/produits/evopac/concept.html [32] P. Corbo, F. Migliardini, and O. Veneri, “An ex-
Since 2005, he has been an assistant [15] R. J. Wai, C. Y. Lin, R.Y. Duan, and Y. R. Chang, perimental study of a PEM fuel cell power train
“High-efficiency dc-dc converter with high for urban bus application,” J. Power Sources,
professor at King Mongkut’s Univer- voltage gain and reduced switch stress,” IEEE vol. 181, pp. 363–370, July 2008.
sity of Technology North Bangkok. Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 54, pp. 354–364, Feb. [33] W. Mitchell, B. J. Bowers, C. Garnier, and F.
2007. Boudjemaa, “Dynamic behavior of gasoline fuel
He is currently a director of the Thai- [16] S. Y. Choe, J. W. Ahn, J. G. Lee, and S. H. Baek, cell electric vehicles,” J. Power Sources, vol. 154,
French Innovation Institute (TFII), “Dynamic simulator for a PEM fuel cell system pp. 489–496, Mar. 2006.

44 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[34] A. Emadi, Y. J. Lee, and K. Rajashekara, “Power an experimental fuel cell/supercapacitor- [70] K. S. Jeong, W. Y. Lee, and C. S. Kim,
electronics and motor drives in electric, hybrid powered hybrid vehicle,” Control Eng. Prac- “Energy management strategies of a fuel
electric, and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles,” tice, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 41–53, Jan. 2005. cell/battery hybrid system using fuzzy log-
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 55, pp. 2237–2245, [52] P. Corbo, F. E. Corcione, F. Migliardini, and O. ics,” J. Power Sources, vol. 145, pp. 319–326,
June 2008. Veneri, “Experimental study of a fuel cell power Aug. 2005.
[35] M. H. Nehrir, C. Wang, and S. R. Shaw, “Fuel train for road transport application,” J. Power [71] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Control
cells: promising devices for distributed gen- Sources, vol. 145, pp. 610–619, Aug. 2005. strategy of fuel cell/supercapacitors hybrid
eration,” IEEE Power Energy Mag., vol. 4, pp. [53] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Super- power sources for electric vehicle,” J. Power
47–53, Jan./Feb. 2006. capacitors as an energy storage for fuel cell Sources, vol. 158, no. 1, pp. 806–814, July
[36] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Test of automotive hybrid electrical system,” J. Elect. 2006.
a PEM fuel cell with low voltage static convert- Eng. Transport., vol. 1, pp. 21–25, no. 1, 2005. [72] R. Kötz, J. C. Sauter, P. Ruch, P. Dietrich, F. N.
er,” J. Power Sources, vol. 153, pp. 145–150, Jan. [54] R. S. Gemmen, “Analysis for the effect of inverter Büchi, P. A. Magne, and P. Varenne, “Voltage
2006. ripple current on fuel cell operating condition,” balancing: Long-term experience with the
[37] P. T. Krein, R. S. Balog, and X. Geng, “High- Trans. ASME, J. Fluids Eng., vol. 125, pp. 576–585, 250 V supercapacitor module of the hybrid
frequency link inverter for fuel cells based on May 2003. fuel cell vehicle HY-LIGHT,” J. Power Sources,
multiple-carrier PWM,” IEEE Trans. Power Elec- [55] W. Choi, G. Joung, P. N. Enjeti, and J. W. Howze, vol. 174, pp. 264–271, Nov. 2007.
tron., vol. 19, pp. 1279–1288, Sept. 2004. “An experimental evaluation of the effects of [73] M. Uzunoglu and M. S. Alam, “Dynamic mod-
ripple current generated by the power condi- eling, design, and simulation of a combined
[38] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Control
tioning stage on a proton exchange membrane PEM fuel cell and ultracapacitor system for
strategy of fuel cell and supercapacitors as-
fuel cell stack,” Trans. ASME, J. Mater. Eng. Per- standalone residential applications,” IEEE
sociation for distributed generation system,”
form., vol. 13, pp. 257–264, June 2004. Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 21, pp. 767–775,
IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 54, pp. 3225–
[56] A. Sakhare, A. Davari, and A. Feliachi, “Fuzzy Sept. 2006.
3233, Dec. 2007.
logic control of fuel cell for stand-alone and
[39] J. M. Corrêa, F. A. Farret, L. N. Canha, and M. [74] T. H. Bradley, B. A. Moffitt, D. N. Mavris, and
grid connection,” J. Power Sources, vol. 135,
G. Simões, “An electrochemical-based fuel-cell D. E. Parekh, “Development and experimental
pp. 165–176, Sept. 2004.
model suitable for electrical engineering auto- characterization of a fuel cell powered air-
[57] K. Sedghisigarchi and A. Feliachi, “Dynamic
mation approach,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., craft,” J. Power Sources, vol. 171, pp. 793–801,
and transient analysis of power distribution
vol. 51, pp. 1103–1112, Oct. 2004. Sept. 2007.
systems with fuel cells-Part II: control and sta-
[40] J. M. Corrêa, F. A. Farret, V. A. Popov, and [75] N. Lapena-Rey, J. Mosquera, E. Bataller, F. Ortı,
bility enhancement,” IEEE Trans. Energy Con-
M. G. Simões, “Sensitivity analysis of the C. Dudfield, and A. Orsillo, “Environmentally
version, vol. 19, pp. 429–434, June 2004.
modeling s used in simulation of proton ex- friendly power sources for aerospace applica-
[58] D. B. Nelson, M. H. Nehrir, and V. Gerez, “Eco-
change membrane fuel cells,” IEEE Trans. tions,” J. Power Sources, vol. 181, pp. 353–362,
nomic evaluation of grid-connected fuel-cell
Energy Conversion, vol. 20, pp. 211–218, Jan./ July 2008.
systems,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol.
Mar. 2005. 20, pp. 452–458, June 2005. [76] T. L. Cable and S. W. Sofie, “A symmetrical, pla-
[41] T. Zhu, S. R. Shaw, and S. B. Leeb, “Transient [59] P. Thounthong and B. Davat, “A PEM fuel cell nar SOFC design for NASA’s high specific pow-
recognition control for hybrid fuel cell sys- power source for electric vehicle applications er density requirements,” J. Power Sources, vol.
tems,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 21, with supercapacitor or battery as auxiliary,” in 174, pp. 221–227, Nov. 2007.
pp. 195–201, Mar. 2006. Progress in Fuel Cell Research, P. V. Alemo, Ed. [77] A. K. Sehra and W. Whitlow, Jr., “Propulsion
[42] F. Jurado, “Novel fuzzy flux control for fuel-cell Commack, NY: Nova, 2007, ch. 8. and power for 21st century aviation,” Progress
inverters,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 52, [60] S. M. Lukic, J. Cao, R. C. Bansal, F. Rodriguez, Aerosp. Sciences, vol. 40, pp. 199–235, May–
no. 6, pp. 1707–1710, Dec. 2005. and A. Emadi, “Energy storage systems for July 2004.
[43] C. Wang and M. H. Nehrir, “Load transient miti- automotive applications,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Elec- [78] J. Dollmayer, N. Bundschuh, and U. B. Carl,
gation for stand-alone fuel cell power generation tron., vol. 55, pp. 2258–2267, June 2008. “Fuel mass penalty due to generators and
systems,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 22, [61] M. J. Kim and H. Peng, “Power management fuel cells as energy source of the all-electric
pp. 864–872, Dec. 2007. and design optimization of fuel cell/battery aircraft,” Aerosp. Sci. Technol., vol. 10, pp. 686–
[44] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “DC hybrid vehicles,” J. Power Sources, vol. 165, 694, Dec. 2006.
bus voltage regulation supplied by fuel cell/ pp. 819–832, Mar. 2007. [79] M. Granovskii, I. Dincer, and M. A. Rosen, “Eco-
supercapacitor hybrid source,” ECTI Trans. [62] R. Lallemand, A. De Bernardinis, G. Coquery, nomic and environmental comparison of con-
Electrical Eng., Electron., and Commun., vol. 4, J. P. Ousten, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Active load ventional, hybrid, electric and hydrogen fuel
pp. 90–95, Aug. 2006. for fuel cell system dedicated to transporta- cell vehicles,” J. Power Sources, vol. 159, pp.
[45] R. Gaynor, F. Mueller, F. Jabbari, and J. Brouwer, tion applications,” in Proc. EPE’03, Toulouse, 1186–1193, Sept. 2006.
“On control concepts to prevent fuel starva- France, Oct. 2003. [80] W. Kempton and T. Kubo, “Electric-drive ve-
tion in solid oxide fuel cells,” J. Power Sources, [63] T. Furuya, K. Kondo, and T. Yamamoto, “Exper- hicles for peak power in Japan,” Energy Policy,
vol. 180, pp. 330–342, May 2008. imental study on a PEMFC fed railway vehicle vol. 28, pp. 9–18, Jan. 2000.
[46] M. Meiler, O. Schmid, M. Schudy, and E. P. motor drive system,” in Proc. 41st IEEE-IAS, [81] T. Aicher, B. Lenz, F. Gschnell, U. Groos, F.
Hofer, “Dynamic fuel cell stack model for real- 8–12 Oct. 2006, pp. 1249–1252. Federici, L. Caprile, and L. Parodi, “Fuel pro-
time simulation based on system identifica- [64] T. Montani, “Electric energy storage evalua- cessors for fuel cell APU applications,” J. Pow-
tion,” J. Power Sources, vol. 176, pp. 523–528, tion for urban rail vehicles,” in Proc. EPE’03, er Sources, vol. 154, pp. 503–508, Mar. 2006.
Feb. 2008. Toulouse, France, Oct. 2003. [82] O. Bitsche and G. Gutmann, “Systems for hy-
[65] L. U. Gökdere, K. Benlyazid, R. A. Dougal, E. brid cars,” J. Power Sources, vol. 127, pp. 8–15,
[47] J. T. Pukrushpan, A. G. Stefanopoulou, and H.
Santi, and C. W. Brice, “A virtual prototype for Mar. 2004.
Peng, “Controlling fuel cell breathing,” IEEE
a hybrid electric vehicle,” Mechatronics, vol.
Control Syst. Mag., vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 30–46, Apr. [83] R. M. Moore, K.H. Hauer, S. Ramaswamy, and
12, pp. 575–593, May 2002.
2004. J. M. Cunningham, “Energy utilization and ef-
[66] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Control
[48] P. Thounthong, S. Raël, and B. Davat, “Fuel ficiency analysis for hydrogen fuel cell vehi-
algorithm of fuel cell and batteries for distrib-
cell and supercapacitors for automotive hy- cles,” J. Power Sources, vol. 159, pp. 1214–1230,
uted generation system,” IEEE Trans. Energy
brid electrical system,” ECTI Trans. Elect. Sept. 2006.
Conversion, vol. 23, pp. 148–155, Mar. 2008.
Eng., Electron. Commun., vol. 3, pp. 20–30, [67] J. Gonzales and G. Tamizhmani, “High effi- [84] P. Fontela, A. Soria, J. Mielgo, J. F. Sierra, J. de
Feb. 2005. ciency fuel cell based uninterruptible power Blas, L. Gauchia, and J. M. Martinez, “Airport
[49] A. Taniguchi, T. Akita, K. Yasuda, and Y. Miyazaki, supply for digital equipment,” J. Power Sources, electric vehicle powered by fuel cell,” J. Power
“Analysis of electrocatalyst degradation in vol. 153, pp. 151–156, Jan. 2006. Sources, vol. 169, pp. 184–193, June 2007.
PEMFC caused by cell reversal during fuel [68] P. Corbo, F. E. Corcione, F. Migliardini, and O. [85] B. J. Bowers, J. L. Zhao, M. Ruffo, R. Khan, D.
starvation,” J. Power Sources, vol. 130, pp. 42– Veneri, “Experimental assessment of energy- Dattatraya, N. Dushman, J. C. Beziat, and F.
49, May 2004. management strategies in fuel-cell propulsion Boudjemaa, “Onboard fuel processor for PEM
[50] P. Thounthong, “Control of fuel cell/battery hy- systems,” J. Power Sources, vol. 157, pp. 799– fuel cell vehicles,” Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, vol.
brid source for electric vehicle applications,” 808, July 2006. 32, pp. 1437–1442, July–Aug. 2007.
ECTI Trans. Elect. Eng., Electron. Commun., vol. [69] A. Folkesson, C. Andersson, P. Alvfors, M. [86] J. Ally and T. Pryor, “Life-cycle assessment of
5, pp. 192–198, Aug. 2007. Alaküla, and L. Overgaard, “Real life testing of diesel, natural gas and hydrogen fuel cell bus
[51] P. Rodatz, G. Paganelli, A. Sciarretta, and L. a hybrid PEM fuel cell bus,” J. Power Sources, transportation systems,” J. Power Sources,
Guzzella, “Optimal power management of vol. 118, no. 1–2, pp. 349–357, May 2003. vol. 170, pp. 401–411, July 2007.

MARCH 2009 ■ IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE 45

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.
[87] M. Kim, Y. J. Sohn, W. Y. Lee, and C. S. Kim, [104] L. Nicod, “Energy strategy and optimization lated dc-dc converter for fuel cell applications,”
“Fuzzy control based engine sizing optimization on hybrid light rail vehicle,” in Proc. EPE’03, in Proc. IEEE-VPPC’06, 6–8 Sept. 2006, pp. 1–6.
for a fuel cell/battery hybrid mini-bus,” J. Power 2003. [121] B. Huang, J. P. Martin, S. Pierfederici, and B.
Sources, vol. 178, pp. 706–710, Apr. 2008. [105] J. M. Andujar, F. Segura, and M. J. Vasallo, Davat, “High voltage ratio non-isolated dc-dc
[88] M. Saxe, A. Folkesson, and P. Alvfors, “Energy “A suitable model plant for control of the set Converter for fuel cell power source applica-
system analysis of the fuel cell buses operated fuel cell-DC/DC converter,” Renewable En- tions,” in Proc. 39th IEEE-PESC, 15–19 June 2008,
in the project: Clean urban transport for Eu- ergy, vol. 33, pp. 813–826, Apr. 2008. Island of Rhodes, Greece, pp. 1277–1283.
rope,” Energy, vol. 33, pp. 689–711, May 2008. [106] M. Mohr and F. W. Fuchs, “Comparison of [122] L. Palma, M. H. Todorovic, and P. Enjeti, “A
[89] A. R. Miller, K. S. Hess, D. L. Barnes, and T. L. three phase current source inverters and volt- high gain transformer-less dc-dc converter for
Erickson, “System design of a large fuel cell hy- age source inverters linked with dc to dc boost fuel-cell applications,” in Proc. IEEE-PESC’05,
brid locomotive,” J. Power Sources, vol. 173, pp. converters for fuel cell generation systems,” in pp. 2514–2520.
935–942, Nov. 2007. Proc. EPE’05, 11–14 Sept. 2005, pp. 1–10. [123] R. Attanasio, M. Cacciato, A. Consoli, G. Scar-
[90] A. R. Miller, J. Peters, B. E. Smith, and O. A. [107] J. J. Brey, C. R. Bordallo, J. M. Carrasco, E. cella, A. Testa, and F. Gennaro, “A novel
Velev, “Analysis of fuel cell hybrid locomo- Galvan, A. Jimenez, and E. Moreno, “Power converter system for fuel cell distributed en-
tives,” J. Power Sources, vol. 157, pp. 855–861, conditioning of fuel cell systems in portable ergy generation,” in Proc. IEEE-PESC’05, pp.
July 2006. applications,” Int. J. Hydrogen Energy, vol. 32, 1621–1627.
[91] T. Yoneyama, T. Yamamoto, K. Kondo, T. Furuya, pp 1559–1566, July–Aug. 2007. [124] S. de Caro, A. Testa, D. Triolo, M. Cacciato, and
and K. Ogawa, “Fuel cell powered railway vehicle [108] J. J. Lee and B. H. Kwon, “DC-DC converter A. Consoli, “Low input current ripple convert-
and experimental test results,” in Proc. EPE’07, using a multiple-coupled inductor for low ers for fuel cell power units,” in Proc. EPE’05,
2–5 Sept. 2007, pp. 1–10. output voltages,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., 2005.
[92] T. Ogawa, H. Yoshihara, S. Wakao, K. Kondo, vol. 54, pp. 467–478, Feb. 2007. [125] G. Wang, P. Pant, H. Mohammad, P. Famouri,
and M. Kondo, “Energy consumption analysis [109] Y. K. Lo, T. S. Kao, and J. Y. Lin, “Analysis and O. Demirci, “High efficiency low cost in-
of FC-EDLC hybrid railway vehicle by dynamic and design of an interleaved active-clamping verter system for fuel cell application,” in Proc.
programming,” in Proc. EPE’07, 2–5 Sept. 2007, forward converter,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., 2003 Fuel Cell Seminar: Special Session on Fuel
pp. 1–10. vol. 54, pp. 2323–2332, Aug. 2007. Cell Power Conditioning, 3 Nov. 2003, Miami,
[93] C. Wang, M. H. Nehrir, and H. Gao, “Control of [110] H. Mao, L. Yao, C. Wang, and I. Batarseh, “Anal- Florida, pp. 16–20.
PEM fuel cell distributed generation systems,” ysis of inductor current sharing in nonisolated [126] M. H. Todorovic, L. Palma, W. Choi, C.
IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 21, pp. 586– and isolated multiphase dc-dc converters,” Dowling, D. Humphrey, D. Tarbell, P. Enjeti,
595, June 2006. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 54, pp. 3379– and J. Howze, “Development of a low cost fuel
[94] A. de Bernardinis, M. C. Péra, J. Garnier, D. 3388, Dec. 2007. cell inverter system with DSP control for resi-
Hissel, G. Coquery, and J. M. Kauffmann, “Fuel [111] M. Baumann and J.W. Kolar, “Parallel connec- dential use,” in Proc. 2003 Fuel Cell Seminar:
cells multi-stack power architectures and ex- tion of two three-phase three-switch buck- Special Session on Fuel Cell Power Condition-
perimental validation of 1 kW parallel twin type unity-power-factor rectifier systems with ing, 3 Nov. 2003, Miami, Florida, pp. 27–32.
stack PEFC generator based on high frequency DC-link current balancing,” IEEE Trans. Ind. [127] H. Wetzel, N. Fröhleke, J. Böcker, P. Ide, and
magnetic coupling dedicated to on board pow- Electron., vol. 54, pp. 3042–3053, Dec. 2007. J. Kunze, “Fuel cell inverter system with inte-
er unit,” Energy Conversion Manage., vol. 49,
[112] A. Lidozzi, V. Serrao, L. Solero, and F. grated auxiliary supply,” in Proc. EPE’05.
pp. 2367–2383, Aug. 2008.
Crescimbini, “Power electronic converters [128] T. P. Bohn and R. D. Lorenz, “A low-cost in-
[95] B. Ozpineci, L. M. Tolbert, and Z. Du, “Multiple distribution in HOST hybrid propulsion sys- verter for domestic fuel cell applications,” in
input converters for fuel cells,” in Proc. IEEE- tem,” in Proc. EPE’07, 2007. Proc. 2003 Fuel Cell Seminar: Special Session
IAS 2004, 3–7 Oct. 2004, vol. 2, pp. 791–797.
[113] X. Kong and A. M. Khambadkone, “Analysis on Fuel Cell Power Conditioning, 3 Nov. 2003,
[96] D. B. Viet, Y. Lembeye, J. P. Ferriux, J. Barba- and implementation of a high efficiency, in- Miami, Florida, pp. 41–48.
roux, and Y. Avenas, “New high power—High terleaved current-fed full bridge converter for [129] D. Georgakis, S. Papathanassiou, and S. Manias,
ratio non isolated DC-DC boost converter for fuel cell system,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., “Modeling and control of a small scale grid-
fuel cell applications,” in Proc. IEEE-PESC’06, vol. 22, pp. 543–550, Mar. 2007. connected PEM fuel cell system,” in Proc. IEEE-
Jeju, Korea, pp. 1148–1154.
[114] P. Thounthong, P. Sethakul, S. Raël, and PESC’05, 2005, pp. 1614–1620.
[97] L. Palma and P. Enjeti, “A modular fuel cell, B. Davat, “Design and Implementation of [130] H. Tao, J. L. Duarte, and M. A. M. Hendrix,
modular DC-DC converter concept for high 2-Phase Interleaved Boost Converter for Fuel “High-resolution phase shift and digital imple-
performance and enhanced reliability,” in Cell Power Source,” in Proc. IET-PEMD 2008, mentation of a fuel cell powered UPS system,”
Proc. IEEE-PESC 2007, 17–21 June 2007, pp. 2–4 Apr. 2008, York, U.K., pp. 91–95. in Proc. EPE’07, 2007.
2633–2638.
[115] P. Thounthong, P. Sethakul, S. Raël, and B. [131] A. Avergerg and A. Mertens, “Design con-
[98] B. Vulturescu, A. De Bernardinis, R. Lallemand,
Davat, “Modeling and control of a fuel cell siderations of a voltage-fed full bridge dc-dc
and G. Coquery, “Traction power converter for
current control loop of a 4-phase interleaved converter with high voltage gain for fuel cell
PEM fuel cell multi-stack generator used in ur-
step-up converter for dc distributed system,” applications,” in Proc. EPE’07, 2007, pp. 1–11.
ban transportation,” in Proc. EPE’07, 2–5 Sept.
in Proc. 39th IEEE-PESC, 15–19 June 2008, Is- [132] D. K. Choi, B. K. Lee, S. W. Choi, C. Y. Won, and
2007, pp. 1–10.
land of Rhodes, Greece, pp. 230–236. D. W. Yoo, “A novel power conversion circuit for
[99] K. Agbossou, M. Kolhe, J. Hamelin, and T. K.
Bose, “Performance of a stand-alone renew- [116] J. C. Hwang, L. H. Chen, and S. N. Yeh, “Com- cost-effective battery-fuel cell hybrid systems,”
able energy system based on energy storage prehensive analysis and design of multi-leg J. Power Sources, vol. 152, pp. 245–255, Dec.
as hydrogen,” IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, fuel cell boost converter,” Appl. Energy, vol. 84, 2005.
vol. 19, pp. 633–640, Sept. 2004. pp. 1274–1288, Dec. 2007. [133] R. Bojoi, G. Griva, G. Kovačević, and A. Tenconi,
[100] R. J. Wai, R. Y. Duan, J. D. Lee, and L. W. Liu, [117] H. Xu, E. Qiao, X. Guo, X. Wen, and L. Kong, “ZVS-ZCS full-bridge dc-dc converter for volt-
“High-efficiency fuel-cell power inverter with “Analysis and design of high power interleaved age step-up in fuel cell distributed generation
soft-switching resonant technique,” IEEE boost converters for fuel cell distributed gen- systems,” in Proc. EPE’07, 2007, pp. 1–8.
Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 20, pp. 485–492, eration system,” in Proc. PESC’05, 11–14 Sept. [134] X. Zhu, D. Xu, G. Shen, D. Xi, K. Mino, and H.
June 2005. 2005, pp. 140–145. Umida, “Current-fed dc/dc converter with
[101] W. Choi, J. W. Howze, and P. Enjeti, “Fuel-cell [118] S. Ponnaluri, G. O. Linhofer, J. K. Steinke, reverse block IGBT for fuel cell distributing
powered uninterruptible power supply sys- and P. K. Steimer, “Comparison of single and power system,” in Proc. IEEE-IAS’05, 2005, pp.
tems: Design considerations,” J. Power Sourc- two stage topologies for interface of BESS 2043–2048.
es, vol. 157, pp. 311–317, June 2006. or fuel cell system using the ABB standard [135] H. Mehlich, S. Jaehnert, J. Mehlich, B.
[102] B. Fahimi, A. Emadi, and R. B. Sepe, Jr., power electronics building blocks,” in Proc. Veit, and S. König, “A current-controlled
“Switched reluctance machine-based starter/ EPE’05, 2005, pp. 1–9. fuel cell system with short-time stor-
alternator for more electric cars,” IEEE Trans. [119] H. Hinz, “A simulation model for the analysis age for grid feeding application,” in Proc.
Energy Conversion, vol. 19, pp. 116–124, Mar. and design of the electric power conversion EPE’07, 2007.
2004. system in fuel cell vehicles,” in Proc. EPE’03, [136] M. Mohr and F. W. Fuchs, “Clamping for cur-
[103] T. A. Keim, “Systems for 42 V mass-market pp. 1–9. rent-fed dc/dc converters with recovery of
automobiles,” J. Power Sources, vol. 127, pp. [120] B. Huang, I. Sadli, J. P. Martin, and B. Davat, clamping energy in fuel cell inverter systems,”
16–26, Mar. 2004. “Design of a high power, high step-up non-iso- in Proc. EPE’07, 2007.

46 IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS MAGAZINE ■ MARCH 2009

Authorized licensed use limited to: King Monkuts Institute of Technology. Downloaded on April 7, 2009 at 05:38 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.

Potrebbero piacerti anche