Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Syndrome:
Regimens
M. TUNE*
of Pediatric Nephrologv,
and
Nephrologv,
STANLEY
Stanford
of Cal fornia,
School
Diego,
ofMedicine,
School
Stanford,
San
California;
Diego,
and
California.
the tDivision
Universits
ofMedicine,
nephrotic
syndrome
(NS). edema,
consisting and
of massive
hypoalbuminemia.
hyperlipidemia,
Edema The
NS allows creased renal
traditional
a decrease aldosterone salt and water serum extravasation
view
of and
has
been
that
resulting
massive
oncotic in hormone with above
albuminuria
pressure, hypovolemia, secretion, this 2.0 mechanism which
in
inand
causes
idiopathic disease
minimal-change
retention.
glomerulosclerosis
that,
albumin
in MCD
of childhood,
edema
g/dL
seldom
and the
Presenting outcomes
Etiology
The
system association
Evidence primary
in pediatric between
causes
evidence MCD
of idiopathic
pointing
( 1 ).
NS are
to MCD a role
not known.
of the
There
immune
patients
to intravenously
administered
albumin,
is circumstantial
fact an
of matic tions renin with genital
that
rise that and heavy
steroid-induced
in serum plasma aldosterone proteinuria volumes
often
occurs
and to increased in or
before
the and many no fraction. with edema.
Several
and
reports
have
described
Relapses
allergy
in children.
the syndrome
are triggered
commonly
by minor
infections
and
to bee stings or poison ivy. Abnorand cellular immunity have also been by corticosteprovides mdiof these observaimmunologically
patients
analbuminemia
described. Finally. the induction of remissions roid, alkylating agent, or cycbosporine therapy rect
tions,
alternative
a decreased
explanation
GFR, with
for retention
a decreased
of salt and
water
in NS
is
evidence
however,
for an immune
provides direct
etiology.
evidence
None
of
mediated
pathogenesis.
Natural
Before
40%
History
the availability
with NS
of
died etc.),
antibiotics
of infections
and failure, of
of
corticosteroids,
septice-
Pathophysiology
Proteinuria Children with have a generalized clearance than
This
of children
(bacterial
mia, MCD, although massively proteinuric, gbomerular leak to macromolecules macromolecules a range
other lines in the by which these
peritonitis.
cellulitis, (3,4).
agents increased
renal advent
the rate
or occasionally and
from
thromboembolism
antimicrobial
The
penicillin
survival
other
acute
in MCD radii.
suggest
is actually In contrast,
However, renal
sustained
massive failure
spontaneous
edema,
recurrent common.
septic If the
often
events, children
occurred
normal
and
of molecular
of evidence
macromolecules
is significantly
that wall has
increased.
protein-
remissions
from
negative
are
charges
lost
of anionic
(1). not The been
only after years of disease In the early 1950s, oral (hereafter ment
steroid disappearance therapy
with was
glycosaminoglycans mechanism
capillary
designated NS,
for the
as steroids) with
great
treatand
who
of idiopathic
(4).
defined. children
genic
A highly with
significance
protein recently
protein
and
urine
of
of proteinuria
4 weeks
of daily
MCD
of children.
responded, most of whom must have had and responded to retreatment. Alkylating
to Dr. Bruce M. Tune. Division of Pediatric Nephrology. University School of Medicine, Stanford. CA 94305-5119.
mechborethamine was successfully tried about the sone was introduced ( 1 ) but was quickly abandoned
its (7). acute toxicity. Better-tolerated oral alkylating
1046-6673/0805-0824$03.0()/0
Journal of the American Society of Nephrobogy Copyright 0 1997 by the American Society of Nephrology
introduced Although
later
with alkylating
steroid
toxicity
or resistance immuno-
agents
are both
Treatment
of NS
825
suppressive,
the
frequency
of
infectious
complications
was
logic
experience,
newly
diagnosed,
uncomplicated
pediatric
01
Study
. dI th I( 1i1i N .
Disease in
(. st s
biopsy. have
tf
renal
to are
Patients MCD.
of Kidney
of prospective,
Study
steroid-resistant
or present
lesions
the
in
early
studies Childhood
1970s,
by
a series
the
multicenter,
of Kidney Disclinico-
other
than
MCD
(Table
1).
cooperative
International established
(ISKDC)
definitions,
pathologic became
NS (5,6,8). proteinuria
and
NS mg/m2th
recommendations and
defined and
for therapy
as the combination of
that of
2.5
with but
complaint
MCD rarely
edema until In extreme
generally in the
is facial the to the urine parents cases,
present
edema or
during (12).
increased
early The
as Edema
childusual
being is typitolerated ascites present an caused
for diagnosis
was
management
hypoalbuminemia
of pediatric
(5,6)
neonatal
period
abdominal
edema, clinical
in a child or
and of a in
is examined. edema,
laboratory
concern
to cause identified
early
and
distress with
pleural
effusions,
peritonitis, site).
can
produce
pain. septicemia, all
symptoms
with cellulitis infections
of
NS
respiratory
can are (without
in the course
MCD, tion
and tive category mesangiab
focal (DMP)
gbomerubosclerosis, characterized
area, membranoproliferative nephropathy hypocomplementemia and pediatric the
of idiopathic mesangiab of
(1 ,5). of of
or labial Almost
by the finding
(MN) rarity
cells/peripheral
Because of MN the in
apparent by
gbomerubonephritis, membranoproliferaidiopathic
pneumoniae
or an enteric with
When with However, be seen occurrence steroids.
bacterium. with
to of the (except not
membranous gbomerulonephritis
The
normalities
majority
or
of children
hematuria. resolve
MCD
present
little
these steroids
accompanying
hypertension
present a response
in MCD,
or no ab(6).
children, Focal
sence interstitial and which angial sometimes may far
these
of
two lesions
are now
NS.
typically
excluded
from in the
atrophy
The
features
combination
listed
of hypertension
MCD. 1 can their in Table
and
hematuria
any in MCD does
is particularly
unfavorable possibly preclude a
idiopathic
gbomerular
of segmental fibrosis, less ominous is generally hypercellularity seen
or focal
sclerosis was than identified (3 of greater as a focal
global
obsolescence,
tubular a pattern as
distinct hyalinosis
administered
( I 0).
mesangial in MCD
Mild
Approach Children
hospitalized senting initiation idiopathic massive with of
to the with
to rule the NS steroid (Table
New an
out
Patient episode
(Table now 2),
cells/peripheral in early
initial
of
NS
as well
were
traditionally
preor is simple biopsy if edema complication
complications However,
or other children
be predictive
management
but
not necessarily
an unfavorable
outcome.
hospitalized life-threatening
or if infection
or another
Minimal
Renal MCD,
patterns abnormality hypercellularity
Change
Biopsy overwhelmingly
in pediatric on light is electron seen
Disease
the
NS (5,6), microscopy; in some there
most
common
mild cases or
of
by focal
the
little
biopsy
or no
is characterized (nil-plus
Table
1. Probability
pediatric
of MCD NS
in early
biopsy
of idiopathic
mesangial disease).
Parameter
No negative correlates
Probability
90 to
(%)
Immunofluorescence
tive. On of
is negative
microscopy,
or occasionally
is epithelial
weakly
foot
posiprocess of
95
fusion
ities
in the
absence or epithelial
of immune
basement
complexes,
membranes, or
other
abnormal-
case yr old
alone
90 70 65
60
gbomerular
proliferation
endothelial The
with the age
cells
of the
(1). children
disease.
proportion
at the
of nephrotic
onset
who
The
have
great
MCD
majority
children (5,6).
between The
of 1 and of MCD
6 yr have is lower
alone months
resistant1
to 1 yr)
50 20 20
20
to 95%)
(65%) (6) and still lower in adults ( 20%) (1 1). the great majority of children with MCD respond to of oral
in the children
plus
hypertension
5, 6, 1 1, and or 40 mg/rn2 12. daily for I month,
10 0 to 5
then 3 of 7
1 to 2 months
steroid
to this with of MCD
therapy
course other and of
by
oral biopsy extensive
entering
steroids patterns
complete
alone are (5,6).
b
months)
responses frequency
of 2 mg/kg 1 month.
clinico-patho-
days
826
Journal
of the American
Society
of Nephrobogy
Table
2. Evaluation
of child
at the onset
Test
of the NS
Condition Considered
Diagnostic
Chemistry
Antistreptococcal
panel
titers
renal
failure
(rarely a simple NS)
PSAGN
Serum
complement
MPGN,
SLE.
ultrasound
Renal vein thrombosis (infants) Risk of activation by steroid therapy membranoproliferative gbomerubonephritis; SLE.
systemic lupus
PSAGN.
poststreptococcal
erythematosus.
is
suspected. and
studies, in MCD,
of NS, incidence
patients
were
more after
likely 1 yr was
in remisthe bong
testing. Although
in an outpatient
of relapse
proteinuria allows detection and treatment of most recurrences before gross edema develops. Most parents can be taught test other dren zoster
physicians
course, 6 1 % after short course. The steroids the compared therapy course the long The
sive NS years, courses
the standard treatment, improved outcome with for at least 2 yr. There when the different
the of in were
persisted
the
urine and
for
protein, the
therapy
in simple infection
duration
of remissions
relapses,
recognize
of bacterial
nonimmune administration
be avoided
of recurrences. Side effects in the standard-therapy of these the initial for studies, episode with
may
As a result to treat
relapses.
many of NS
globulin.
parents,
careful
coordination
between
hospitalization
great
majority
of cases.
long-term is very
commonly
prognosis
good. until However, puberty
children
relapses (15).
Treatment
A small
of NS was defined by the (proteinuria of 4 mg/m2h in within 1 week) within mg) of daily prednisone 4
with NS relapses
may continue to have recurrences as adults. are usually not severe and can be treated with Even though steroid throughout childhood, are not common. steroid-responsive children eioral or side therapy serious
sequelbae Alkylating
therapy. to obtain
Because in ratio
the
reliably children,
timed proteinuria
urine is
specimens generally
ther relapse frequently or require high daily doses of steroids to maintain remission. These frequently relapsing steroid-dependent children may develop significant steroid effects, including growth lenticubar cataracts, and with roids bucib
NS
of urine Proteinuria
urine
significant
steroid
proteinlcreatinine
and within
the who
ratio respond
is therapy.
( 13).
Of
the most
95%
of
children Until
to prednisone, regarding
do so
is some
2 to 3 weeks
of daily
of the information
the optimal
agent of 2.0
or 0.15
therapy, with suggested ranges to 2.5 mg/kg cycbophosphamide maximum total cumulative mg/kg chborambucil (maxtotal cumulative dose, I2
agents cases. The may be used in of effectiveness
MCD was anecthree protocols this issue the drug they then
single
mg/kg)
dose, 6 mg;
courses
100 mg;
to 0.20 maximum
of alkylating
for the administration of oral prednisone has clarified (14). Patients receiving the short course received daily until their urine was protein-free for 3 days; received alternate-day levels became normal 4 weeks of daily
single
dose,
Second
or previously
responsive
prednisone until their serum albumin (mean, 16 days). Standard therapy was followed by 4 weeks of alternateof prednisone involved 6 by 6 weeks of alternate-day was used to treat the initial
alkylating
tration
agent
therapy
is enhanced
prednisone.
by concomitant
adminis-
of alternate-day
prednisone
day therapy. The long course weeks of daily therapy followed treatment. When the long course
these doses, oral alkylating children (5 to 10%) develop blood cell counts agent are measured the alkylating
agents are well tolerated. mild leukopenia. Therefore, weekly withheld during treatment or its dosage
is temporarily
Treatment
of NS
827
with count
a white of amounts
blood of hair
cell
count
of families
its
pediatric
Hypertension
and
acute
renal adults
failure with
2000/mm3.
Some
at the onset
particularly
more
(20).
commonly
Although
than
most
in children, appears
in appears children to be
on the childs
of treatment is uncommon.
acute limit patients
MCD
be less (20,22).
respond
therapy.
slower but steroid
the response
to develop dependency
rate
than
to
lower
that
fluid
this
medication
be given
in the morning
chlorambucil
with
urinary
a large
may
daily
common azathioprine
producing
in adults. (22),
more ( 5.5
Alkylating have
prolonged daily
agents
(20,22), effect
12 months)
bladder. develop
even
roids,
an additive
for or adult patients
Occasionally,
remissions
Cyclosporine
effective
mg/kg
steroid-resistant
in adult
steroid-dependent
with
nosis the
limited
mortality
risk
rate
of nephrotoxicity
treated in older
(25).
MCD with
The
NS
bong-term
good, exceeds
progbut actuarial
in successfully
is generally
or repeated as 15 to 20%
appear doses to be have
expectations
for age
(20).
much been
affected.
in recent
The
years
risk of sterility
is dose-dependent
and may
be less
lim-
Focal
Renal sion
Segmental
Biopsy
Glomerulosclerosis
of children
with prednisone. FSGS reveals
ited. been
A small
when halfofthese
percentage
treated children
with
The (5,6).
NS do not enter
biopsy Although in more
remisthan
Although
lignancies regimens
no data
NS, the
demonstrating
who possibility
secondary
discussed
uncommon
in children
compared
gbomerular
with
disease
MCD, among
FSGS
is the
and
most
frequent
only
progressive
to congen-
in childhood
is second
the
families
and
the causes
of pediatric
ESRD
(26).
cases may
daily), but the
of MCD respond
responses
to cycbosporine
often
on cycbosporine
prefer
is common
limited
( I 8).
However,
gbomerubar
cycbosporine
ment
membrane, features
degeneration of FSGS,
or necrosis. recently
Other reviewed
pathologic
of an alkylating
in Adults
MCD
with
antibiotic
Comparison
those definitions, pediatrics
of the major
in children criteria and internal for may biopsy,
patterns
be and
of idiopathic
by treatment The prevailing regimens
NS in adults
differences between often dogma, in
developed
agnosis sion
tern
fatal
of the
acute
NS, FSGS generally
infections,
absent > 1 yr
mostly who
after
within
seen
di-
complicated
or was
in some more
juxtamedubbary
or uremia,
Children
died
diagnosis,
medicine.
only
by discussions
between
colleagues,
has
been to
widespread
study. conclusions. the
gbomerubar from
source
obliteration. MCD
of the
a patby this
firm
in children is more frequent, more often complicated edema and bacterial infections, more responsive
and more likely to relapse than that in adults.
of evolution
of FSGS
was
cases
suggested
precluded
postmortem
In a large
series
White
of early
ci a!. (6)
biopsies
found
from
MCD
children
in 88%
with
idio-
Churg
and
White
and
associates
(5,6)
reported
that
children of NS resisto of
of unselected
and 64% of referral cases; the difference was probably influenced by the practice of pediatricians not to refer uncomplicated, ment
24)
with FSGS in biopsies obtained at the time of diagnosis showed a clinical pattern of initial or rapidly developing tance renal
cases years Because
steroid-responsive NS (presumed MCD) to renal treatcenters. Because NS in adults is not easily treated (20and because MCD is less frequent as a cause of NS in than
been the and
to steroid therapy, commonly followed by progression failure. Other investigators (15,27) described a number
with evolution FSGS whether can to resistant NS be these missed FSGS and/or in a needle and ESRD biopsy, after many MCD. particularly of steroid-responsive biopsy-diagnosed
adults
long as regarding 20%
in children
the standard frequency apparently
( 1 1,20),
practice of MCD decreasing
early
renal
biopsy
medicine. adults,
in NS
The reported
has
data more
in internal in nephrotic as
when
uncertain
glomerubi
patterns
are
of
not
early
sampled,
and
it remains
late FSGS
FSGS
becomes
common In certain
( I I ,20), respects,
probably is more
represent specific
this
More before
question
828
Journal
of the
American
Society
of Nephrobogy
Treatment
Table
3.
Intravenous
M-P M-P
pulse
Steroids
found Gubler
diatric
and
reported
In
alkylating
agents.
responsive
studies of
Although
to prednisone.
the
FSGS (28)
FSGS.
to be poorly
further
Habib
of intermittent
Week
20 to 25% agent.
steroid-responsiveness
the effects
I to 2
3 to 1 1 to
30 mg/kg 30 mg/kg
30 mg/kg I8
3 times/wk every
every
10
1 wk
2 wk
6 8
4 with
prednisone
plus
a cytotoxic
compared
with
prednisone
alone, the ISKDC reported no added benefit from azathioprine (60 mg/m2-day for 90 days) (8) or cycbophosphamide ( 2.5 mg/kg body weight daily for 90 days) (29,30) in the treatment of steroid-resistant phosphamide had the renal already using early treatment with with noted them, FSGS. The ISKDC no robe in the treatment of this abandoned of success, concluded of FSGS (29,3 that cycbo(29). After 1 ), many therapy others and and late continued forms of had
19 to 50 5 1 to 82
a
I)
30 mg/kg 30 mg/kg
dose,
every every
1,000 mg.
4 wk 8 wk
8 4
slow slow
taper taper
Maximum
Maximum
dose,
other
day.
for children
steroid-resistant
courses slowly.
were cell
used counts
in patients were
who measured
responded weekly,
more and
alkylating
in the early
the
alkylating
agent
was
temporarily
withheld
or
its dosage
the disease (28,32-34). Cycbosporine. Because pressive agent in solid-organ cycbosporine has been widely
reduced
of leukopenia.
as an immunosup-
agent protocol,
was started at the end of the first 2 pulses were given weekly until the
nobogicalby mediated diseases. In pediatric NS, a consensus has emerged that cycbosporine is more effective in steroid-dependent than steroid-resistant disease, that the efficacy of corticosteroids is a more cyclosporine than important determinant is the renal biopsy. of responsiveness to and that there is a high (35,36). in steroid-
end of the alkylating therapy and then continued as in Table 3. If the alkylating agent was needed later, six pulses were repeated over 2 weeks and then the alkylating agent was given
with weekly pulses. When a patient showed a partial or com-
plete
response
M-P/tripbe-therapy
protocol
(M-P
pulse
rate of relapse after discontinuation of cycbosporine Moreover, cycbosporine may be more nephrotoxic resistant than with bow-dose ness in steroid-responsive or alternate-day in producing disease (35). steroids increases sustained
plus alternate-day prednisone) and then the protocol or failed to achieve a urine
of In
1 .0, a second
most cases, protocol,
course
the were
of alkylating
second course
produced
occurring
a more
after
complete
completion
and
of
stable
the
Late
relapses,
as if
of cycbosporine
reductions
treated
teinuria in steroid-resistant disease, including FSGS (36), this effect has not been seen in all studies (37). The French Society of Pediatric Nephrobogy (36) treated
cases of steroid-resistant cycbosporine FSGS combined with 6 to with 12 months of mg/m2-day
they nisone
were
new
cases and
of NS, advancing
daily
predtherapy protein-
therapy
only as needed. The numbers uria and decreased (38) examination complete patients
and on
30 mg/m2 day.
prednisone 3 yr of com-
function
for
1 month results
and were
then
every
other complete
After or nearly
in Table
4. Two-thirds
follow-up,
as follows:
(proteinuria of < 10 mglkgday), 35%; mod5%; nephrotic-range proteinuria without ESRD, 30%.
remission and receiving no therapy. Four had relapsed after completing the protocol
Methylprednisobone/triple-therapy
est rates of remission in steroid-resistant been achieved prednisobone an alkylating
is detailed
protocol.
FSGS
The
highhave
Table
4.
M-P
protocol: function
effects
on
in children
proteinuria pediatric
in steroid-resistant
with a regimen combining a series of methyl(M-P) pulses with alternate-day prednisone and agent ( I 3,38). The M-P pulse/prednisone regimen in Table 3. An alkylating proteinuria using had agent not been was fully added in 78% by proby 2 (1)
No.
normal protein!creatinine
Cr Cl ratio ratio
> >
21/32
0.2 0.5 to 0.5 to 2.0 1 .9 3/32 2/32 6/32
66
9 6 19
in which prednisone,
controlled pulses
response
the following
indications:
or partial
not significantly improved over 2 weeks; (2) a complete with a subsequent significant
adminat
urine protein!creatinine nephrotic protein/creatinine Renal function normal Cr Cl proteinuria, decreased ESRD
a
ratio
of proteinuria
any time during the M-P regimen; and (3) a urine protein! creatinine concentration ratio of 2 at week 10 or later. The alkylating agent, chosen at the discretion of the individual nephrobogist, was either cycbophosphamide (2.0 to 2.5 mg/ kgday) or chborambucib (0. 1 8 to 0.22 mg/kg-day) (based on lean nonedematous body weight) for 8 to 1 2 weeks. The longer
Cr Cl
9 16 9
Cr Cl, creatinine
80 38.
clearance,
m2).
from
methods
serum
creatinine
(normal, reference
mL/rnirnl.73
are from
Treatment
of
NS
829
sponded
to retreatment
(three
with
M-P
plus
prednisone
and
experience therapy
in the (13).
prepubertal
children
treated
with
one had
serum all most 0.02
with normal
triple blood
therapy).
therapy
Although
during the
several
protocol,
children
all
required
responders
antihypertensive
pressures,
concentrations,
without
were
antihypertensive
clearances. 80 ratios was estimated mL/min-l.73
agents,
from m2 in
in Adults
a higher
has adults. than children prolonged
monitoring.
Creatinine
Although
frequency
been The for
of nephrotic-range
reported in children
proteinuria
with FSGS
without
urine
SE),
abnormal
serum was albumin 1 22
proteinuria.
4. 1
In these
averaged 0.2 g/dL,
2 1 the
0.06 and
(2 1 ), the prognosis
in children nephrotic both both age adults
and response
outcome
to therapy
is poorer
of FSGS
for nephrotic
are similar
unresponsive disease FSGS potential of therapy in in for
protein!creatinine
creatinine
clearance
1 .73 normal
m2.
ratios
Three
re-
(2 1 ,38,44).
children
clearance.
persistent
six patients
proteinuria
whose
creatinine as did
responding
2.0
developed
chronic
or ESRD,
(38,45).
The FSGS
correlate 8 months steroid-induced
a urine a ratio
of 0.4 (after
few and mild,
1 2 yr) and
as were in a
recent treated
with
increase with
increased
remissions (to 30
of treatment,
in adults appears
with were appeared often
with to
S to less to studies
5.3 yr).
were effects
to 60%) patients
relapses
Complications
of children
given
more
(39).
aggressive
Side
M-P
of the
pulse
steroids
therapy
for
no
of daily in adults
or the number
therapy
remissions
(45).
in
Among
one study,
who
achieved of cycbo-
rheumatobogic
seen with prednisone MCD, and alkylating cases toxicity of mild is limited
pulses.
or was (40).
frequent
phosphamide increase
than
in children
of responses
(2 1 ). The
regimens (45), has but
addition
not controlled
chborambucil
and
transient
in the M-P
because the
have
studies
not
in
been
this
done
analysis in adults with
and
with than FSGS racial
the
were
steroid
not nephrotic
regimens
standardized. FSGS of (25). has efficacy
in the
The proved and
several
use a much of to be
of daily
between
cycbosporine
Other
M-P Table between and
therapy response gland completed. agents. (42)
M-P
5 shows
protocols. for
a direct
used
reported
modified ( 13,41,42).
series,
a lower
pulse the
regimens percentage
requires
steroid-resistant
relationship,
of toxicity
The
ness adults in than
influence
to therapy than adults
of race
of
on the natural
history
with NS FSGS
and
in greater are (46).
of children of successful
the addition or recurrent rapidly both two with cases, less
given outcomes.
heavy before failure
an alkylating The
agent
agent One child
studied to have
the
percentage
protocol to persistent died Except which also
M-P/triple-
in children. in other
black
overall larly
patients
prognosis resistant
with
and
FSGS
(24), progressive
do
not
variant
necessarily
gbomerulopathy, of FSGS,
have
a poorer
a particumore
in Birmingham
one
to use
in New
could alkylating M-P
Enbe
collapsing
treatment
is much
aggressive
therapy,
of to ste-
from
Because
roid-resistant
the
major
nephrotic
pediatric may be
studies
(by
have
ISKDC
been cases
limited with
several 6. The
Although more
criteria),
pediatric
and
adult
series histories
composed levels
of
different to therapy
has
been groups
to be more
treatment
(30,36,38).
and different
of resistance
resistant of
to therapy
Diffuse
DMP
Table 5.
Mesangial
is an uncommon
there predominantly
Proliferation
biopsy
is mesangial for 1gM,
pattern
in pediatric is either
NS negative
no
(5,6). or
pediatric agent
FSGS therapy
with
Pathologically,
on light
positive
microscopy, on
sections, classified may be was more
complexes characterized
2-j.tm mesangial otherwise disease) has (5,6),
electron by >3
has
proliferation, stalk
or
Study
nuclei
on
I- to
diffuse
Los
New
Angeles
England
(13)
(38) (42) (41)
100
78 53 20 failure.
18
25 47 100
hypercellubarity
in biopsies
Stanford/UCSD Birmingham
a h
( 1 ). The
to control therapy. resistant
latter
than As
pattern MCD
difficult to
a favorable DMP
originally steroids
to oral studies
CRF.
chronic
renal
UCSD,
University
of California,
San Diego.
but
been
usually
significant
resolved
whether
among
treated
or not
(6).
There
NS
have
in the
of pediatric
830
Journal
of the American
Society
of Nephrobogy
Table
6. Treatment
prednisone,
of pediatric
and the
steroid-resistant
M-P/tripbe-therapy
FSGS:
protocola
natural
history
and
the effects
of cyclophosphamide,
cycbosporine/
No. of Patients
(%)h
Failure
prednisone ci al. (ISKDC) et a!. (6) 1 year (5) (30) 21 32 20 32 persistent after 1 month of daily, followed 28 25 35 66 by I month 28 25 5 9 of intermittent (3 of 7 days 43 50 60 25
or
10 10
0 0
100
100
(ISKDC) of prednisonec
+
prednisoned (36)
therapy defined
(38)e as proteinuria
Steroid
resistance
alternate-day), oral prednisone or prednisobone, except in the cycbosporine study, which used I month of daily prednisone followed by iv M-P (3 X I g/rn2 over 1 wk). Follow-up: ISKDC cycbophosphamide study, 3 to 102 months (average. 42 to 45 months); M-P/triple therapy, 9 to 150 months (average, 76 months); cycbosporine, 28 to 58 months (average, 38 months). b Complete response proteinuria: ISKDC and White et a!., 4 mg/m2h; M-P/tripbe therapy. urine protein/creatinine ratio 0.2; cycbosporine. < 10 mglkgday. Partial response: ISKDC, abnormal but a decrease of at least one of four categories of proteinuria (<4, 4 to 40, 41 to 100, and >100 mg/rn2th); M-P/tripbe therapy. urine protein/creatinine ratio > 0.2 to 0.5; cyclosporine. proteinuria of 10 to 50
mg/kgday. Failure: persistent NS or ESRD. C One year of alternate-day prednisone (40 mg/rn2). d One year of alternate-day prednisone (40 mg/rn2) plus 90 days C Complete plus partial responses (75%) with M-P/triple therapy
(35%)
with
cycbosporine.
reported
possibly
frequency
because
and
of the
resistance
criteria used
to therapy
to establish
of DMP
the
of treatment-resistant
rotic report suggests disease of and lowering A a potentially of
NS
deterioration
may
contribute
of renal lipids inhibitor approach by in
to later
function.
atheroscle-
diagnosis.
A preliminary NS long-term
The
authors NS.
have The
not that
seen
many that
cases have
DMP
plasma valuable
a hydroxymethylglusteroid-resistant to this
impressed
resolving
form
taryl-coenzyme
reductase
suggest
of NS resulting
complication
(50).
Summary Other
The effective
Therapies
angiotensin-converting antihypertensive enzyme agents for inhibitors (ACEI) patients with NS are
who
review and
the first
biopsy
patterns, outcomes
to therapy,
long-term
examination,
develop blood pressure elevation either from renal disease or from steroid therapy. Moreover, FSGS therapy slower ACEI of these
namic
tween than
cence,
and
adult
diseases growth,
seem
more
However,
present very
underlying
different
determinants maturity,
for challenges
that
responsive
to immunosuppressive
including and
immunocompetence,
proteinuria and benefit from function when treated with an when is begun,
by
pediatricians
internists. major biopsy patterns in pediatric and DMP. MCD is overwhelmingly steroid-responsive
of massive
be used agents
renal
administration to avoid
vigorous
of one hemodyACEI or
function
most multiple
of the
edema.
three
serious
preof 1
combined ACEI/diuretic therapy. Thromboembobic disease is a relatively dangerous, not been complication systematically
problems
bacterial
uncommon,
but very
and
relapses.
Because
of
the
response
of the NS. Preventive strategies have studied, but the authors use the fobavoidance of aggressive diuretic ther-
pediatric MCD to corticosteroids, steroid has generally been defined as persistence month of daily followed by 1 month administration. steroid-resistant
therapy, steroid-resistant typically but
lowing precautions: (I) apy, particularly when soon produce remission intravenous albumin hemoconcentration (3) the use of
regimen
concomitant
may
use of
to prevent
and and NS
DMP It is not
of have globally
DMP
represent without
to
occurred obsolescent
Treatment
of NS
831
gial
hypercellularity
may
be
associated
with
greater
difficulty
7.
Coldbeck
IH: Experience
with alkylating
agents
in the treatment
evolution
of MCD
of patterns
of FSGS
to ESRD
in serial
and
suggest
biopsies.
van-
DMP,
and
progresfeatures
common
NS, FSGS is the most freby MN (which is rare in chilto its pediatric counterpart,
gbomeruboscle-
MCD with
likely
is less
and
regularly
elderly
more
slowly
commonly
responsive
associated
to
I 1.
mt 46:
1223-1241,
corticosteroids
in the
is more
and once
renal with
MCD edema
and
glomerubosclerosis
remission
is achieved.
with do
with
present
with
commonly
Although
study. Am J Kidney Dis 26: 740-750, 1995 Sibley RK, Mahan I, Mauer M, Vernier RL: A clinicopathobogic study of forty-eight infants with nephrotic syndrome. Kidney in!
1985
renal
biopsy
present renal
by
similar function,
of resistance aggressive
comparisons in adults.
and regimens
pediatric
loss
of
and
27: 544-552,
used a
with of
13.
Tune
BM,
Lieberman
E,
Mendoza
SA:
nedisease.
internists
phrotic focal segmental gbornerubosclerosis: Pediatr Nephro! 10: 772-778, 1996 14. Brodehl Lessons Siegel follow-up I: The treatment ofminimal learned from mubticentre 1991 NJ, change co-operative
adult
systematic
series.
There
analysis agents
is insufficient
cycbosponine and
information
have with been
to
support
used cases
syndrome:
Eur J PeLong-term
syndrome. in
adults
difficult
Goldberg
of children
B, Krassner
with 1972
LS, Hayslett
IP:
agent
increase can of
the also
steroid-resistant trial
nephrotic
and control
duration
Cycbosponine
J Pediatr 81: 251-258, Barratt Lancet 17. Grupe 746-749. 18. 19. Niaudet nephrosis. Gregory
RP.
in MCD, remission. has agent steroid sustained is more than not been
is often courses
TM,
Soothill
Significant achieved
especially
with Longer
limited courses
or cycbosponine. administration,
of either complete
IR: syndrome.
Chborambucib N Eng!
immunosuppressants,
when
combined
of frequently
relapsing 1976
295:
can
produce
more
and/or
P. Habib
J Am
MI.
Smoyer nephrotic
resistant
Johnson
K, Bunchrnan
Long-term
pattern. A protocol combining prednisone, and an alkylating nc mens. tocols FSGS has
with
of pediatric
ysis.
syndrome:
7: 543-549,
produced
normal
the
renal
percentage
of all
of
reported
sustained
regi-
20.
remissions
DO:
trials
of this
and and
other adults.
combined-drug
pro-
in children
21.
term follow-up. Pei Y, Cattran dence segmental istry suggesting study. A, segmental
in adults Regional
1987
with
idiopathic
gbomerulonephritis
References
I. Nash change and edited 2. 3. MA, focal by Edelmann gbornerular Edelmann CM syndrome, sclerosis. CM Jr. Jr. Bernstein diffuse In: Boston, I, Bamett mesangial Pediatric Little, HL: Kidney Brown, Minimal Disease, and Co., 23. 22. nephrotic hypercellularity,
of corticoresistant
Minimal Ads change Nephro! 17:
idiopathic
disease and 127-150, 0, Pontion the with
adult:
gbornerulosclerosis.
1992. pp 1267-1290 Dorhout Mees El: Edema Contrib Nephrol 43: Rich AR: A hitherto ullary gbornerubi 100: 173-186, 1957
formation
in the nephrotic
syndrome.
Banfi G, Moriggi M, Sabadini E, Fellin 0, DArnico celli C: The impact of prolonged immunosuppression outcome of idiopathic syndrome focal-segmental in adults: A 1991 36: 53-59, in adults: J Kidney L-H, Dis Auriche A treatment 1446-1456, Recurrence gbomeruboscberosis collaborative nephrotic
retrospective
in lipoid
Rydel
II, Korbet
sclerosis Am A, Noel Kidney A, Stablein
SM, Borok
RZ, Schwartz
Presentation, 25: 534-542, P, Cablard in adult
MM: Focal
course, 1995 and
segmental
response renal nephrotic glornerNorth
4.
MW:
Nephrosis:
corticosteroids.
study
507-515,
of
25.
5. 6.
Churg
syndrome White nephrotic
I. Habib
RHR,
R, White
Lancet
RHR:
Pathology
nephrotic
study 1970 of 26.
of cycbosporin DH:
I: 1299-1302, Ltincet
ira 45:
1994 of focal
Tejani
ubosclerosis
posttranspbantation:
A special
832
Journal
of the American
Society
of Nephrology
American 27.
Pediatric 2[Suppl of
Renal
Transplant
Cooperative 1992.
Study.
J Am
39. 40.
tal gbomerubosclerosis:
84-88, 1995 II: Prolonged diseases SA. Reznik with Miller rheumatic Mendoza
A bong-term
use VM, of large Griswold
follow-up.
intravenous WR,
C/in steroid
43: in
Soc Nephrol
3]: 258-263,
Hayslett
JP. Krassner
LS, Bensch
KG, Kashgarian
to renal
M, Epstein
insufficiency.
of children.
Pediatrics
Yorgin
des
8: 41.
PD,
agents.
Tune
BM:
Treatment
pulse
of steroid-resistant
methybprednisobone 1990 EC: 4: 303-307, Kohaut
focal
segmental
gbomerubosclerosis
Pediatr
FB, of patients
Nephrol
MR, with
29.
of Kidney
Waldo ment
Benfield
phamide
controlled
therapy
clinical
30.
Tarshish
phamide uboscberosis: ease
P. Tobin
does
segmental glomerubar sclerosis: A trial [Abstract]. EurJ Pediatr 140: 149, 1983. JM, Bernstein I, Edelman CM Jr: Cycbophospatients with focal segmental gbomerDisof the International Study of Kidney
in focal
steroid-resistant
Pe-
diatr Nephrol 42. Guilbot the 43. stract]. Ingulbi outcome 44. children. Cameron long-term loscberosis. 45. course
therapy
1993.
(pst)
does
not alter
lAbrenal in DO: The
(FSGS) and
J Am
of
31.
in Childhood. Pediatr Nephro! 10: 590-593, 1996 Spitzer A, Gordilbo-P 0, Houston IB, Travis LB: Prospective, controlled trial of cycbophosphamide therapy in children with the nephrotic syndrome. Lancet I : 423-427, 1974 Siegel NJ, Kashgarian M, Spargo BH, Haysbett JP:
E, Tejani
segmental
gbornerubosclerosis
32.
change
33. Mongeau
and focal
1974 J-Y,
sclerotic
lesions
L, Robitaille prognosis
in lipoid
nephrosis.
prognosis of patients with C/in Nephrol 10: 213-218, MM, Clinical RM,
13: 125-137,
Gorneille
5, Pelletier
Primary
sclerosis: 743-746, 34. Geary
nephrosis
1981 DF, Farine
in childhood
associated
Is long-term
J Kidney
SM,
Dis
Genchi
23: 773-783,
Borok lesions
RZ,
Schwartz
MM: adults.
The Am
of gbomerular
in nephrotic
J Kid-
M, Thorner
P. Baumal focal
R: Response segmental
in steroid-resistant a reappraisal.
gbomeruloscle-
47.
R. DAgati
1996
V: Idiopathic
A clinicopatho-
Cliri Nephrol 22: 109-1 13, 1984 Niaudet P. Broyer M, Habib R: Treatment of idiopathic nephrotic syndrome with cycbosporin A in children. Cliii Nephrol 35:
531-536, 1991.
mt
R, Girardin E, Gagnadoux M-F, Hinglais N, Levy M, M: Immunopathobogical findings in idiopathic nephrosis: significance
2: 402-408,
36.
Niaudet nephrosis
Mebocoton cycbosporine
of glornerular
1988
immune
deposits.
Pediatr antiprotein-
49.
Apperboo
Al, de Zeeuw
D, de Long
PE: Short-term
dent nephrotic
38. Tune BM,
ES, Cohen AH, Fine RN: Long-term of steroid-resistant and steroid-depensyndrome. Am J Kidney Dis 18: 583-588, 1991 R, Sibley RK, Reznik VM, pediatric Griswold focal WR, segmen50.
to antihypertensive treatment predicts long-term in patients with non-diabetic renal disease. Kidney 45]: 174-178, 1994
Coleman
therapy
JE. Watson
in steroid-resistant
AR: Hyperlipidemia.
nephrotic 1996
Mendoza
ing agent
SA: Intravenous
methylprednisobone
of prednisone-resistant
PediatrNephrol
10: 171-174,