Sei sulla pagina 1di 13

ABSTRACT drug dosage calculations, and intravenous flow rate when

grouped according to gender and the results are as follows. The


computed value for basic math operations is -1.932 with a level
Predicaments concerning drug dosage calculations of significance of 0.054; for conversion of units, the computed
have been an existing issue for nursing students exposed in value is -1.007 with a level of significance of 0.314; for drug
clinical areas. Based on the researchers’ experience, nursing dosage calculations, the computed value is -0.280 with a level of
students have difficulty on the conversion of units of significance of 0.780 and for IV flow rates, the computed value is
measurement, computation of pediatric and adult doses and IV -0.255 with a level of significance of 0.799. The overall
flow rate. According to Johnson and Johnson (2002), the computed value was -0.542 with a level of significance of 0.588.
learning process for medication calculations has been Since the absolute computed value, 0.542 was not greater than
problematic for years. The problem that occur were the critical value, 1.960 at alpha 0.05, then there is no significant
multifaceted and attributed to an array of factors that included difference on the participant’s overall level of competency when
students' limited basic mathematic skills and inconsistencies in grouped according to gender. With the results and findings
terms of teaching strategies for medication calculations. This according to the test utilized, it reveals that the Level of
underlying thought has motivated the researchers to look into Competency on Drug Calculations among Level IV Nursing
this problem in the assessment of the level of competency on Students of Far Eastern University based from their mean scores
drug dosage calculations among level IV nursing students of Far was categorized in Level II with a description of “Conditional
Eastern University. By knowing the competency of these Pass”. It also reveals that the level of competency of male and
students, the researchers will be able to identify their strengths female participants does not differ significantly; making the study
and weaknesses on drug dosage calculations. accepts the null hypothesis.

The focus of the study was to assess the level of


competency of level IV Far Eastern University nursing students
on drug dosage calculations. The researchers will utilize a non-
experimental research, specifically a descriptive design. Using
the Slovin’s formula, the researchers have come up with a
sample of 340 level IV Nursing Students of Far Eastern
University. The respondent can either be male or female ranging
from 18-23 years old. In the data collection there were 131
males and 209 females. Participants must at least finish and
pass 3 units on the following subjects: College Algebra and
Pharmacology. In addition to these, participants were asked to
sign a consent form to serve as a basis of their willingness to
participate in this research study. Researchers will use a drug
calculation test as their medium or instrument in weighing the Chapter 1
level of competency of the subjects in terms of drug dosage INTRODUCTION
calculation. The drug calculation test will constitute the
following elements: I. Basic Math Operations (25 items), II. The Problem and its Background
Conversion of Units (25 items), III. Drug Dosage Calculations
(25 items), IV. IV Flow Rate Calculations (25 items) with a total
Predicaments concerning drug dosage calculations have
of 100 items.
been an existing issue for nursing students exposed in clinical
areas. Based on the researchers’ experience, nursing students
The study determined the Level of Competency of
have difficulty on the conversion of units of measurement,
level IV Far Eastern University nursing students on drug dosage
computation of pediatric and adult doses and IV flow rate.
calculations. Among the 340 respondents which comprises of
Despite the formulas and techniques integrated on the matter,
131 male and 209 female, the computed mean score on the four
some students still find it confusing and may end up committing
areas are as follows. The male participant’s mean score on basic
a mistake, if not properly guided by the right principles on drug
math operations, conversion of units of measurement, drug
dosage computations.
dosage calculations, and intravenous flow rate are 14.9, 15.39,
13.8, and 12.85 respectively with an overall mean score of
57.95 while the female participant’s mean score are 16.1, 16.02,
According to Johnson and Johnson (2002), the learning
14, and 13.03 with an overall mean score of 59.16. With the
process for medication calculations has been problematic for
value presented on the table, it shows that the females mean
years. The problem that occur were multifaceted and attributed to
score on basic math operations, conversion of units of
an array of factors that included students' limited basic
measurement, drug dosage calculations, and intravenous flow
mathematic skills and inconsistencies in terms of teaching
rate is higher than that of the male. On the other hand,
strategies for medication calculations.
independent t-test was used to determine the existence of
significant difference on the participant’s level of competency
on basic math operations, conversion of units of measurement,
1
Rice and Bell (2005) have cited problems in practice number of untoward events that can range from mild discomfort
with substandard abilities for nurses to calculate medication and even possible death of patients. Along these lines, nurses
dosages. Calculation of medications is an essential step in safe could render a safe and quality nursing care for their patients thus
medication administration, and necessary to safeguard patients. improving nursing practice.
The authors referenced the American Society of Health-Systems
Pharmacist system which identified nine categories of
medication errors. They have also discussed nursing students Statement of the problem
classified as poor performers in mathematics since anxiety
attack takes place when dealing with calculations for the reason The study was intended to determine the level of
that they are concerned on arriving at a wrong answer and when competency on drug dosage calculations among level IV nursing
exposed to inconsistent teaching strategies in medication students of Far Eastern University.
calculations. Mathematical formulas have been identified as
problematic due to misapplication of formulas or Specifically, it aims to answer the following questions:
miscalculations.
1. What is the participant’s level of competency on the
following area:
Manno (2006) has stated that medication errors has A. Basic Math Operation
been a problem for many years and has killed thousands of B. Conversion of Units of Measurement
people and one of the causes of these errors is drug C. Drug Dosage Calculation
miscalculations that causes drug over dose. Across health care D. Intravenous Flow Rate Calculation
and home care, patients face the risk of medical error.
According to his landmark study entitled: To Err is Human: 2. Is there a significant difference on The level of
Building a Safer Health care System (2006) at the Institute of competency of participants when grouped according to
Medicine, ,estimated that as many as 98,000 Americans die gender?
each year due to a variety of medical errors; 7,000 of these
deaths are due to errors involving medications. Medication Significance of the Study
errors have become an increasing problem in the hospital
setting. It is estimated that medication errors also known as The purpose of this study was to assess the level of
"adverse drug events (ADE) increase the cost of hospitalization competency on drug dosage calculations of level IV nursing
by $ 2,200 to $ 3,200 per stay and prolong stays by 2 days on students of Far Eastern University. This was important because
average". Causes of medication errors are varied, ranging from accurate calculation of drugs is critical in nursing practice. Thus,
inappropriate orders to failure of the nurse to follow the five nurses must be competent on drug dosage calculations and
rights of medication administration. Many people believe that student nurses must be well developed on these skills to become
medication errors are a direct result of poor nursing. efficient nurses. The research aimed to promote the enhancement
of calculation skills in undergraduate nursing students by
utilizing an assessment test that exhibited their level of
competency on drug dosage calculations which will serve as
Dosage calculations should be double-checked by two basis for further improvement of their skills on medication
nurses or another pharmacist, Verification of a dose, rate or calculation, thus preventing medication calculation errors.
amount does not mean to question the abilities or competencies
of the dispensing or administering individual. It is simply a way It is hoped that the findings of this study will enhance
to further verify and protect the patient and staff involved. the knowledge of concerned individuals and parties. Particularly,
Medication errors are the eighth leading cause of death in the this study will benefit the student nurses on the following:
US. (Banning, 2006). To help decrease the incidence of Nursing Practice
medication errors, nurses need to step up to the plate, and Student nurses through this study will be able to
realize the importance of this issue. Following the five rights of practice and provide effective and safe care in the real clinical
medication administration is simply not enough. setting. Drug dosage calculation and administration, being an
essential skill and knowledge in nursing care will be focused and
enhanced to trigger the shaping of competent and efficient
nursing students. When the undergraduates become members of
In the Philippines, there are no statistics that can show the academe, they would be able to teach their students the
the number of deaths due to medication dosage errors. This importance and correct techniques of medication calculation and
underlying thought has motivated the researchers to look into its administration.
this problem in assessment of the level of competency on drug
dosage calculations among level IV Nursing Students of Far Nursing Education
Eastern University. By knowing the competency of these The academe will be able to look beyond the finite skill
students, the researchers were able to identify the students’ of medication calculation and acknowledge system issues that
strengths and weaknesses on drug dosage calculations. As a plague most medication errors. Through this study, they will be
result, it served as a motivator for nursing students to improve able to recognize the value of knowing the fundamentals of
their skills on medication calculation thereby reducing the mathematics in relation to nursing.
2
I. Basic Math Operations………………. (25 items)
Nursing Administration II. Conversion of Units………………… .(25 items)
As the students will become administrators in III. Drug Dosage Calculations…………. (25 items)
hospitals, they would be able to use medication proficiency IV. IV Flow Rate Calculations…………. (25 items)
exams for their staff members. This can be used in continuous Total: 100 items
screening and improvement of their personnel's knowledge and
skill on drug calculations. Thus, they will be able to give safer
The limitations encountered during data collection were as
and effective quality nursing care to their clients.
follows:
1. The researchers were not able to consider the stress and
Nursing Research
anxiety level that the participants may experience can
With its direct relation to nursing practice, student
affect the results of the test.
nurses will be able to improve the patient care management they
2. The Different IQ of the participants and their
are delivering in the clinical area by means of the facts and
motivation to take and finish the exam.
evidences nursing research is going to provide. This field could
3. The possibility of the participants to pick out any answer
also help in determining certain ways on how to enhance the
they like even without solving due to the number of
level of competency of student nurses by means of other studies
items which is a 100 item test.
and researches that could be made in relation to this study.

Scope and Limitation

The focus of the study was to assess the level of


competency of level IV Far Eastern University nursing students
on drug dosage calculations.

The research was conducted at Far Eastern University,


Manila. The researchers selected it as the setting primarily on
the grounds that the study may advance Far Eastern University Chapter 2
level IV nursing students into a paramount dexterity on medical THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
dosage calculation which is a fundamental aspect of exceptional
nursing care. The researchers desired to measure the Review of Related Literature and Studies
effectiveness of the skill in drug dosage calculation of the level
IV nursing students to further enhance and revamp their Level of Competency
potentials to evade medication errors that may jeopardize
patients’ lives, thus, producing globally competitive nurses. Based on Commission on Higher Education
Memorandum Order (CMO) No. Series of 2009 Policies and
The respondents for this study were selected fourth standards on Bachelor of Science in Nursing program, Article IV,
year nursing students in Far Eastern University, within the age Section 5 “Competency Standards”, under Safe and quality
bracket of 18-23, either male or female, and had their nursing care, a Bachelor of Science Nursing student must be able
willingness to participate in the research study. College Algebra to administer medications and other health therapeutics which
and Nursing Pharmacology were prerequisites for all the conform to the 10 golden rules in medication administration and
respondents. The researchers preferred students under the health therapeutics. One of the rules is the right dose, that is why
Institute of Nursing due to their desire to straighten out the each nursing student who graduate in Bachelor of Science in
capabilities of these future nurses in encompassing quality Nursing course must be competent in knowing the right dose
nursing care through equipped drug dosage calculation. through correct drug dosage calculation.
Participants came from different sections. The study is limited
on assessing only their level of competency, specifically their Burkhalter and Cooper (2001) had suggested in their
knowledge, skills and abilities on basic math operations, study, the “Measurement of Competence of Health Care
conversion of units, drug dosage calculation, and IV flow rate Providers,” that competence encompasses knowledge, skills,
calculation which are integral part of medication administration. abilities, and traits. It is gained by the healthcare professions
The traits of the respondents were excluded from the study. through pre-service education, in-service training, and work
experience. Competence is a major determinant of provider
The tools to be utilized were standardized, authorized, performance as represented by conformance with various clinical,
and approved by qualified and licensed experts. Researchers non-clinical, and interpersonal standards. Measuring competence
used a drug calculation test as their medium or instrument in is essential for determining the ability and readiness of health
weighing the level of competency of the subjects in terms of workers to provide quality services. Although competence is a
drug dosage calculation. The drug calculation test constituted precursor to doing the job right, measuring performance
the elements below in this blueprint: periodically is also crucial to determine whether providers are
using their competence on the job. A provider can have the
Drug Calculation Test: knowledge and skill, but use it poorly because of individual
3
factors (abilities, traits, goals, values, inertia, etc.) or external score was 75% and these students demonstrated that they were
factors (unavailability of drugs, equipment, organizational under-prepared in skills essential to medication calculation
support, etc.). mathematics, such as fractions, decimals and percentages
(Brown, 2002). Brown’s (2002) conclusions echo the
Competency can be assessed by using tests or inferred recommendations provided previously by Starkings (n.d) and
from performance that has been assessed using simulations or Pozehl (1996): that pre-testing upon admission is critical; that
work samples. The major advantage of tests is that single remedial mathematics courses should be mandatory if the pre-test
competencies can be distinguished and targeted for results indicate deficiencies; and finally that testing should be
improvement. The major advantage of simulated patients and ongoing throughout the program.
job samples is that they are more predictive of job performance.
Competency is not performance. Although it can predict
performance, a competent healthcare provider may not Medication Calculation
necessarily use effective procedures on the job. Both internal
factors (motivation, agreement with a standard, self-efficacy, Medication calculation is a dosage calculation to
inertia, etc.) and external factors (supervision, feedback, determine what quantity of medication is to be administered to
availability of resources, community, peer expectations, and the patient. Medication administration is a critical skill of the
incentives) affect whether a healthcare provider will apply his professional nurse, who must understand and follow various steps
or her competency. Detailed and immediate feedback to the in the drug administration process to assure patient safety. The
healthcare provider about his or her competence is useful for nurse must be proficient in medication dosage calculation to
both learning and improving performance. safely administer drugs. However, many medical-surgical nurses
experience difficulty when calculating drug dosages. One study
The use of pre-testing of mathematics skills such as revealed that 56% of nurses could not calculate medication
basic arithmetic and algebraic calculations, and the use of the dosages to a 90% proficiency rate. In addition, nurses made
results as a predictor of success in university based nursing significantly more errors in calculating intravenous drug dosages
courses, are not new. Van Lanen, Lockie and McGannon (2000) as compared to oral, intramuscular, or subcutaneous drug dosages
examined a university mathematics placement test and other (Ashby, 1997).
variables that predicted performance in an organic and
biochemistry course in an undergraduate nursing program. They For the nurse to compute the correct dosage of a
sampled 308 undergraduate nursing students. The variables that medication, first the prescriber must write out the order legibly.
showed significance in that study were the mathematics Poor handwriting has been cited as the primary cause in 15% of
placement test score, the grade in the previous principles of medication error incidents (Springhouse Corporation, 2001). It is
chemistry course, the number of supplemental instruction advisable for prescribers to always clearly print medication
sessions attended and the score on the Nelson–Denny test orders in capital letters. Many clinical settings have established
(which measures reading and comprehension skills and age). computerized prescription systems which have eliminated the
Although they acknowledged that these data were dependent on problem of illegible handwriting.
the individual student population, these authors concluded that
using predictive values in this way provides a useful profile of At times, verbal prescription orders are given to a nurse,
students who are at risk. by word of mouth or per telephone. Because these orders may be
transcribed inaccurately, dosage errors can occur. In clinical
Similarly, Hutton (1998) pre-tested 231 nursing settings, verbal orders should be discouraged due to this risk. If
students with a 50 item test. Results showed 80% (n: 184) of the prescriber has no choice but to give a verbal order, he or she
students scored less than 75%. Pozehl (1996) examined the should sign the order as soon as possible.
mathematics skills of 112 undergraduate students enrolled in an
introductory statistics course; exactly half of these participants A misinterpreted decimal point is also a common
were students majoring in nursing. Pozehl’s findings indicated problem which can cause medication dosage errors. If a dosage
that the nursing students were deficient in mathematics skills, of a drug is less than zero and documented as a decimal, a zero
particularly algebra, compared to the non-nursing cohort. should precede the decimal point for clarity. Conversely, the
Pozehl made a number of recommendations, including selective prescriber should not place a decimal point and zero after a whole
admission requirements that valued pre-existing mathematics number. If the decimal point goes unnoticed by the transcriber or
skills, early pre-testing of the mathematics skills of nursing nurse, the zero then acts to mistakenly multiply the dose ten times
students to identify students at risk, ensuring the availability of (Karch & Karch, 2001).
early and prompt educational opportunities to the students with
a deficiency in these skills and finally the evaluation of Abbreviations in medication orders can easily be
mathematics skills throughout the course. Pozehl also tested the misinterpreted. Abbreviations vary in different institutions and
level of mathematics anxiety, finding that the nursing students cause confusion. Whenever possible, the words in a medication
reported higher levels than non-nursing students. order should be clearly written out. For example, words such as
units, micrograms, milligrams, every day, or every other day are
Brown (2002) administered a computational preferable to abbreviations for these words (Springhouse
mathematics test to 868 undergraduate associate degree nursing Corporation, 2001b). Abbreviation of terms within the metric
students from across the United States of America. The mean
4
system can be difficult to decipher if handwritten. Whenever over time, the pass rate for medication calculation tests should
possible, metric units should be written out as words. also become more difficult. Hence, the authors suggested
building medication calculation mastery over a period of time to
Medication Calculation Errors in Nursing Practice successfully reach medication calculation proficiency. The
results of their research with 130 students not only supported the
No one really knows how many the exact number of concept of on-going assessment of medication calculation skills,
miscalculation errors since by some estimates as little as one in but additionally, the role of faculty to develop medication skills
ten errors are reported (Pepper, 2002). Of reported errors, one over a four-year curriculum. Nursing students would then
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) study found that 7% were advance from simple medication problems to highly technical
due to "miscalculation of dosage or infusion rate." Combining and complex medication calculations. Elliott and Joyce
this estimate with the estimate for total deaths, as many as 3,000 recognized mathematical skills, may not necessarily be as simple
to 6,800 deaths are caused annually by medication math errors as a review process, but suggested these skills be developed
(Thomas, et. al., 2001). This would mean that in the average overtime in nursing curriculum.
hospital one patient dies every year or two because someone
makes a miscalculation and one or two patients are sub-lethally Burke (2005) described the nursing profession's need to
harmed each month. As future nurses then, there is a distinct broaden horizons for medication administration processes. Under
possibility that we will harm, or even cause the death of, a education, barriers to successful and safe medication
patient over the course of our career. administration included lack of best practice to teach students the
fundamentals of medication administration. More importantly,
In 2001, the academic pressure significantly increased Burke identified nursing curriculum did not focus on the entire
in nursing, after the Institute of Medicine released a report medication administration process. Instead, nursing schools
documenting over seven thousand deaths/year from medication primarily focus on administering, and often disregarded
errors and reform efforts were flawed given the convoluted prescribing and dispensing processes. He also identified seven
systems (Institute of Medicine, 2005). The public and significant barriers to safe medication administration. Lack of
professional outcry from this report pressured most nursing interdisciplinary teamwork and efforts, fluctuation in staffing
programs to revamp teaching strategies and revise standards for patterns, and use of abbreviations were identified within the
medication administration. Many nursing schools adopted seven barriers. Delays in responding to safety concerns and
strategies to assess medication calculation proficiency every systems flaws within healthcare environments also influenced
semester. Increased assessments created the need for nursing safe medication administration practice. Burke also identified
programs to initiate or revamp existing policies. recent research that has examined the negative impact of nursing
staff working over 12 hour shifts or 40 hours per week and the
Studies by Johnson and Johnson (2002), suggest that increase risk of medication errors.
the learning process for medication calculations has been
problematic for nursing faculty and students for years. The Medication administration requires nurses to
problems that occur were multi-faceted and attributed to an demonstrate successfully a range of mathematical concepts,
array of factors that included students' limited basic mathematic including ratios, proportions, fractions, percentages and
skills, to disagreement among the faculty as to best teaching. measurement conversion (Brown, 2002; Hoyles, Noss & Pozzi,
2001; Pozehl, 1996). Errors in medication mathematics may have
Rice and Bell (2005) also discussed nursing students as serious consequences that include harm to the patient, potentially
classified poor performers in mathematics, expended high even death, not to mention disciplinary and possible legal
anxiety levels when dealing with calculations, and exposed to consequences for the nurse and the organization in which he or
inconsistent teaching strategies in medication calculations. she is employed (Brown, 2002; Grandell-Niemi, Hulpi, Leino-
Mathematical formulas have been identified as problematic due Kilpi & Puukka, 2003; Hoyles, Noss & Pozzi, 2001; Shore &
to misapplication of formulas or miscalculations. Best teaching Shore, 2003). A review of the literature shows that getting
practices have been elusive and results for nursing students undergraduate nursing students to demonstrate a proficient level
were dismal. They studied the application of dimensional of medication calculation accuracy remains one of the strongest
analysis as an alternative learning strategy for medication instructional challenges for nursing academics (Kelly & Colby,
calculations. Working from the assumption that students 2003).
successfully completed science courses, the authors studied a
total of 30 nursing students over two semesters. The authors The findings of Hoyles, Noss and Pozzi’s (2001)
concluded the learning strategy, dimensional analysis, was ethnographic study into the practices of pediatric nurses strongly
successful in improving conceptual skills, thereby reducing the suggest that the mathematics utilized in undergraduate nurse
number of incorrect responses to test items. education is not visible in practice. Instead, they found that the
participant nurses, who had practiced longer than three years,
Elliott and Joyce (2005) discussed the need to develop employed a more holistic approach. Their success in medication
calculation skills over time, and not assume the mathematical calculation was related to “situated abstraction” (Hoyles, Noss &
skills have been previously taught to students. The development Pozzi, 2001). This notion is based upon the assumption that
of these essential skills were not captured in one semester, context is an inseparable component of medication mathematics,
instead these skills were built across all nursing courses. Elliott as nurses will choose actions that seem relevant to them in their
and Joyce suggested as content material became more complex situation (Hershkowitz, Schwarz & Dreyfus, 2001). The three
5
factors that were situational were: the packaging of the drugs; thinking process: thought, reasoning, the way information is
the specific social routines (such as checking with two nurses); encountered and stored and memory functioning (Gagne, 1985;
and the clinical effects of the drug itself. Stenberg, 2006). The researchers, as stated in the methodology of
the study, did not include to seek the factors that affect the
Kelly and Colby (2003) identified a similar processing of information of the selected level IV Nursing
phenomenon with their students and argued that a constructivist Students in Far Eastern University but only to inquire about what
approach to teaching medication mathematics was the key. No happened with the information that was given to the students by
formulas were provided to their students; instead the students their mentors, since then up to now, and that prior knowledge
were encouraged to answer the following questions: “What are plays an important role in learning and in nursing practice. The
the givens? What are you looking for? What information must researchers supposed that how the information was incorporated
be transformed in some way?” At the end of this process, one and retrieved was useful for health professionals as well as for
important step was performed and the students were asked to nursing students to know, specifically on drug dosage calculation
justify their answers. This process allowed the students to when it comes to hospital practice.
identify irregularities in dose rate, volume or concentration
(Kelly & Colby, 2003). Although the constructivist approach
may enhance students’ ability to learn medication calculations,
we argue that students still require basic understanding of
mathematical concepts.

This review of related literature has shown that a large


proportion of undergraduate nursing students are unable to
demonstrate an appropriate level of mathematical knowledge on
entry into the program. This study had sought to determine the
level of mathematical knowledge of the Level IV nursing
students of Far Eastern University.

Cognitive Learning Theory

The researchers had come up to employ the Cognitive


Leaning Theory as the researchers’ guide in the study. This
theory emphasizes unobservable mental processes that people
use to learn and remember new information or skills. In other
words, it stresses the importance of what goes on inside the
learner. It is widely used in education and counseling. The key
to learning and changing is the individual’s cognition
(perception, thought, memory, and ways of processing and Applying this model to the researchers’ study, the first
structuring information). Cognitive learning, a highly active stage in the memory process involves paying attention to
process largely directed by the individual, involves perceiving environmental stimuli; attention, then, is the key to learning. The
information, interpreting it based on what is already known, and drug calculation test that the researchers had conducted to the
then recognizing the information into new insights or respondents of the study served as the stimulus. This test got the
understanding (Bandura, 2001; Hunt, Ellis, & Ellis, 2004). attention of the respondents. The researchers verbally explained
the instructions aside from the written instructions on the test. It
Cognitive Learning Theory includes several well- was also the researchers’ responsibility to know if the
known perspectives, such as gestalt, information processing, respondents are weary or distracted prior in taking the test, so that
human development, social constructivism, and social cognition the explanation and test will be moved at another time when they
theory. With these perspectives, students or learners are are more receptive and attentive. In the second stage, the
encouraged to think of their potential applications in the researchers prepared a visual drug calculation test that was
healthcare setting, by keeping with cognitive principles of processed by the senses of the respondents. Another
learning and being mentally active with information to responsibility of the researchers’ in this stage was to ascertain
encourage memory and retention. whether there are sensory deficits among respondents. In the third
stage, the researchers did not take concern on short-term memory
The researchers had seen many concepts of this theory but more on long-term memory, because this served as aid in
that the researchers can apply to their study, primarily because it assessing the level of competency in drug dosage calculation of
talks about the mind and processing of information that is the respondents. In short term-memory, the researchers are
relative in undertaking the study on assessment of the concerned if the respondents are keeping their knowledge in drug
respondents’ level of competency on drug dosage calculation. dosage calculation activated every now and then, so that it will
That learning is merely unobservable and can be measured be then stored in their long-term memory, since short term
through an exam or aptitude test. Of the several perspectives or memory is not limited in its capacity but in the duration with
concepts of Cognitive Learning Theory, the researchers opted to which it can actively retain information. This stage further
apply the Information Processing Model which emphasizes assessed the long-term memory of the respondents since by

6
experience and verity that also the researchers who were in the
same level of the respondents, were done with their The Main Variables of the Study
mathematics subjects, as well as pharmacology course last
semester. So it is where, the knowledge of the respondents on The two main variables of the study were the drug
basic math operations which is supposed to be taught since calculation and level of competency. The independent variable
grade school and the formulas in drug dosage calculations last was the drug calculation while the dependent variable was the
semester were applied and this was shown on their solutions level of competency which was measured by a validated
upon answering the test as well as their score. It is also where questionnaire on conversion of units, drug dosage and IV flow
the researchers as well as the respondents were able to assess if rate calculation.
they remember or had forgotten their knowledge regarding
these matters. The researchers also considered that while long-
term memories are enduring, a central problem is retrieving the Definition of Terms:
stored information at later time that affected the test results of Drug Calculation
the respondents in the study. In the last stage, it entails the
action or response of the respondents upon answering the test. It It is the determination of drug dosage and Intravenous
is where the researchers assessed how the respondents attended flow rate through computation, and usage of formulas, unit
to, processed and stored the information that was presented as conversion and basic mathematical operations. It is the act of
well as finding ways on how to solve the problem. properly calculating the exact amount of medication to be
administered in a particular client.
Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development
Level of Competency
The respondents are under the formal operational stage
and had the ability to answer questions which included problem It is the measure of the quality of being competent or
solving, analysis and rationalization. During this time, people having a possession of required skill, knowledge, qualification, or
develop the ability to think about abstract concepts. Skills such capacity. It is the knowledge of the respondent or ability to
as logical thought, deductive reasoning, and systematic planning perform correct calculations or conversion of units, drug dosage
also emerge during this stage (Pilliteri, 2003). Ergo, the study and Intravenous flow rate calculation. It is the extent of the
was appropriate for these subjects because their cognitive aspect ability of the client to properly calculate for the medications to be
has reached this level based from Piaget’s theory of cognitive administered based on his/her own knowledge.
development.
Based from a research in University of Malaya for
Conceptual Framework health workers (2004), the level of competency can be measured
using Competency Level Evaluation (PTK). The scores of the
Equipped with knowledge on drug dosage calculation, respondents from the drug calculation test will be classified using
the respondents were tested by the researchers to know their this tool. After all the scores are taken, the researchers will get the
level of competency. The researchers gave a test about the basic average (mean) of the entire sample and also be classified using
mathematical operations, conversion of units, drug dosage and PTK. The structure for grading PTK is as follows:
IV flow rate calculation. This determined the level of
competency of the Level IV Institute of Nursing students Level of Competency
regarding drug dosage calculation. Description
Level IV Pass/Achieved the
Research Paradigm Competency Level
with excellence
The research paradigm was divided into input, process (80% and above
and output. The research process was focused on assessing level percentage score
of competency on drug calculations of level IV nursing students from the test)
of Far Eastern University. The research had undergone a process Level III Pass/Achieved the
in which the following statements above had been their channel competency Level
in answering the problem statements. Definitely, if these steps (60% to 79%
were achieved, they will be aiming an output, that will percentage score
contribute on the improvement and development of the skill on from the test)
drug calculations of nursing students of Far Eastern University. Level II Conditional Pass
(50% to 59%
Hypothesis percentage score
from the test)
o The Level IV Nursing Students of Far Eastern Level I Failed to achieve the Competency
University has achieved the competency in drug (50% and bellow
calculation. percentage score
o The level of competency of male and female from the test)
participants does not differ significantly.
7
of the time.
Chapter 3
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research Instrument

This chapter contains all the information on how the The primary tool of the research was a drug calculation
study was conducted, the locale of the study and the target test which measured the respondent’s competency on basic
population. This chapter would further discuss the specific mathematical operations such as addition, subtraction,
interventions and research design that the researchers’ used in multiplication and addition along with conversion of units that all
order to collect and obtain the needed information. came with critical thinking and analysis. The remaining part of
the test included questions regarding drug dosage and IV flow
Research Design rate calculation. The test consisted of a hundred items divided
into four major parts 25 items each. The entire questions were
The researchers utilized a non-experimental research, constructed using words or sentences requiring the respondents to
specifically a descriptive design. The objective of this design evaluate and analyze each item according to their mathematical
was the accurate depiction of the level of competency among skill and capabilities. The tool was lifted mainly from
level IV nursing students of Far Eastern University. It involved mathematics and pharmacology books. It was answered manually
collection of numerical data to test the hypothesis and to answer with the use of pen or pencil. Respondent’s profile came prior to
the questions concerning their status. They haved described the the series of questions. A sheet for computations was provided by
phenomena on the subject’s level of competency on drug the researchers and the use of calculator was allowed. The
calculation.Through this, the researchers can describe the instrument had undergone validations from two mathematicians
dimensions and importance of the inclined number of students and a pharmacology professor. A pilot study was done to 20
who experienced drug calculation errors. students to test its reliability.

It was the selected design because the objective this Data Collection Procedure
research was to describe the level of competency of their
subjects and do not include correlations and other study groups. The researchers’ had collected quantitative data on the
Also, the researchers utilized a cross-sectional design in which level of competency on drug dosage calculation among level IV
they collected data at one point in time. nursing students. The initial step of the researchers was to select
potential respondents that participated in the study. After
identifying respondents, the researchers had personally
introduced themselves, established rapport and stated the
Population and Sample objectives of their study. If the respondents agreed to participate
in the study, they are given the consent form for them to sign
The subjects were selected using stratified random prior to answering the questionnaire.
sampling, in which the researchers make use of the fishbowl
technique in selecting the sections that took part in the study. The researchers used a drug calculation test for data
This sampling technique captured the characteristics of the collection to assess their competence on drug calculations. The
population that was proportional to the sample. Thus, the result respondents used a pen or pencil in answering the test and were
of assessing the level of competency on drug calculation among given 90 minutes to answer the corresponding questions.
selected level IV nursing students of Far Eastern University
attributed to the whole population. Using the Slovin’s formula, Statistical Treatment of the Data
the researchers came up with a sample of 340 level IV Nursing
Students of Far Eastern University. The respondent can either To answer the research question number 1 on what the
be male or female ranging from 18-23 years old. Participants level of competency of the participants was, the following
had finished and passed 3 units on the subject: College Algebra formula was used:
and Pharmacology. In the data collection there were 131 males Formula:
and 209 females. In addition to these, participants signed a
consent form to serve as a basis for their willingness to
participate in this research study.

Research locale

The study was conducted at Far Eastern University, Where:


Manila. The researchers had chosen FEU as their locale because
it will benefit their colleagues as they will able to know their
level of competency on drug calculation. It was also selected
because it was where the researchers had established their
observation and motivation in undertaking this study. The Xi= score
setting is mainly based on FEU, Manila specifically at Law
Building wherein potential respondents had their classes most To answer the research question number 2, on the
8
significant difference on the level of competency of the practicing nurses of the need for ongoing evaluation of student
participants when grouped by gender, the independent t-test was basic math skills and provide continuing education in math skills
used. for practicing nurses.
Formula:

b. Conversion of Units of Measurement

Table IV.2 Participants’ Level of Competency on


Where:
Conversion of Units of Measurement

This table indicates that majority of both gender


achieved the desired level of competency in terms of conversion
of units of measurement obtaining a total of 63.36% of males and
71.29% of females who were able to arrive at levels III and IV. In
X1 = Male participants line with this, barely 30% of both groups have failed to reach the
passing score of the test.
X 2 = Female participants
The females, having a higher mean score of 16.02
n = number of respondents compared to the 15.39 mean score of males may suggest that
females are more competent than males in this area.

c. Dosage Calculation
CHAPTER 4
Table IV.3 Participants’ Level of Competency on
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS
Dosage Calculation
This chapter has aimed to answer the research questions to
determine the level of competency on drug dosage calculations
among level IV nursing students of Far Eastern University.
The table above displays the corresponding number of
male and female participants in each particular level of
1. What is the participants’ level of competency on the
competency. 42.75% of the male’s population failed to achieve
following area:
competency level while 41. 63 % of the female’s population also
a. Basic Mathematical Operations failed to achieve competency with a mean score of 13.8 for males
and 14 for females. It denotes that a greater number of the
Table IV.1 Participants’ Level of Competency on Basic participants failed to achieve competency compared to those who
Mathematical Operations achieved competency.

The result of the test proves that most of undergraduate


The table above displays that 60.3 % of the male nurses have problems in terms of dosage calculation which could
population and 72.25% of the female population reached the contribute to the overall problem of nurses in drug
competency level III and IV in basic mathematical operation. administration. This could be evidence that not all nurses’
The overall mean percentage of both populations in basic especially undergraduate nurses have mastery in dosage
mathematical operations is 62%. It means that, on the average, calculation. It would support the previous studies made by
the nursing students of Far Eastern University have achieved different experts like Brown (2002), which concluded that
competency in basic mathematical operations. students majoring in nursing were under- prepared in skills in
calculation of medication which is a very critical part of the job.
Student nurses shall demonstrate the ability to solve
multiple step mathematical problems that require demonstration
of basic math operations including fractions, decimals and d. Intravenous Flow Rate Calculation
percentages and the use of algebraic equations. Nursing
students as well as practicing nurses continue to struggle with Table IV.4 Participants’ Level of Competency on
math competency as it relates to nursing. According to Blais Intravenous Flow Rate Calculation
and Bath (1992), the most frequent type of mathematical errors
was conceptual errors (setting up the problem) and arithmetic This table shows that majority of both groups has failed
errors (incorrect addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, to achieve the competency in Intravenous Flow Rate Calculation.
decimals, and fractions). According to 21 Flynn and Moore Only 50.38% (n=66) of the males and 49.76% (n=104) of
(1990), graduate nurses made errors at a rate of 1 in 12 when females has reached the level 3 and 4. Half of the participants
performing written calculations. have failed to reach the competency which signifies that this area
is a weakness of many level IV nursing students in Far Eastern
These statistics should alert nurse educators and University.
9
These observations can be associated on Johnson and
Johnson’s analysis that the learning process for medication
The mean score of females (12.85) was higher than calculations has been problematic for nursing faculty and
males (13.03) which may indicate that females are much students for years wherein the problems are attributed to an array
competent than males in this area. of factors that included students' limited basic mathematic skills.

Rice and Bell (2005) also discussed that nursing


students are classified as poor performers in mathematics,
The result might have been affected by the number of expended high anxiety levels when dealing with calculations, and
items given. It was in the last part of the test and some exposed to inconsistent teaching strategies in medication
respondents were complaining of a lengthy exam during the calculations. Mathematical formulas have been identified as
examination. The fact that this was not graded, there is a problematic due to misapplication of formulas or miscalculations.
tendency that they did not seriously answer questions that has
affected their scores.
The table above shows the summary of the Level of
Competency of the different sections of the test. At section I
(Basic Mathematical Operations), 25% of the students failed
e. Competency in all Areas while the remaining 75% passed. At section II (Conversion of
Units), 27.94% failed while the remaining 72.05% passed. At
Table IV.5 Participants’ Level of Competency on all section III (Drug Dosage Calculation), 42.06% failed and the
Areas remaining 57.94% passed. At section IV (IV Flow rate
Calculation), 41.47% failed while the remaining 58.53% passed.
As we can see, majority of the students failed at sections III and
The table above presents the participant’s level of IV compared to sections I and II. Generally, 27.65% of the
competency when grouped according to sex. It shows that the students failed the exam and 72.36% passed. Overall, the students
number of males who failed to achieve the competency level that reached the level of competency are 57.65%.
was 40 or 30.53% while the number in females is greater with The student nurses of the Far Eastern University has a
54 or 25.84%. Male participants with conditional pass score are higher percentage rate who passed the in the Basic Mathematical
16 or 12.21%, however, 34 are in females or 16.27%. There are Operations and Conversion of Units than the Drug Dosage
60 males or 45.80% who achieved the competency score while Calculation and IV Flow rate Calculation. This shows that
there are 93 or 44.50% in females. The number of participants although according to Blais and Bath (1992), the most frequent
who achieved the competency with excellence is 15 or 11.45% type of mathematical errors was conceptual errors (setting up the
in males and 28 or 13.40% in females. The mean or average problem) and arithmetic errors (incorrect addition, subtraction,
achieved by the females which is 59.16 shows greater percent multiplication, division, decimals, and fractions) the students was
than that of the males who got 57.95. skilled enough in answering the Basic Mathematical Operations
questions and Conversion of Units questions than answering the
It can be interpreted that females have greater Drug Dosage Calculation questions and IV Flow rate Calculation
competency on overall drug calculation than males. Several questions. It also shows that the student nurses are more
factors contributed to this examination result that was out of competent and experienced in Basic Math and conversion
control by the researchers. These factors were as follows: compared to the drug dosage and IV flow rate computation. This
environmental factors, physical factors of the respondent, result also demonstrate that most of the student nurses of the Far
cognitive factors of the respondent, and psychological factors of Eastern University have problems in terms of dosage calculation
the respondent. and IV flow rate calculation which is very essential in their
profession as a future nurses. Just like what Brown (2002)
Environmental factors that affected the results are the concluded that students majoring in nursing were under- prepared
place where they took the examination (noise, temperature, and in skills in calculation of medication.
other distractions). But this result could have happen due to the many
factors that have affected the students while answering the test.
Physical factors are factors coming directly from the These factors includes the number of items of the test, the
respondent such as the condition of the respondent before and environment where they have taken the test, the fact that it is not
while taking the exam. graded, the positioning of the section Iii and IV at the last part of
the exam and the anxiety the student feels knowing that the test
Cognitive factors that contributed to the result are includes math and computations.
mainly the previous knowledge of the respondent with regards Based on the result of the test, the majority of the level
to the subject matter. IV student nurse of the Far Eastern University can be classified
under the Level III of the Level of Competency.
Psychological factors are those factors coming from
the respondent examples are anxiety of the respondent with
regards to questions regarding the subject matter.
2. Is there a significant difference on the level of
competency of participants when grouped according to

10
gender?
Not Accept
-0.280 1.960 0.780
Table IV.7 Independent T-test for the Significant Difference Significant H0
of Participants’ Level of Competency on Basic Math
Operations when Grouped According to Gender
The table above shows the result of the Independent T-
Computed Critical Level of test used to determine the existence of significant difference on
Interpretation Decision the participant’s level of competency on dosage calculation when
Value Value Significance
grouped according to gender. The computed value was -0.280
with a level of significance of 0.780. Since the absolute
Not Accept computed value, 0.280, was not greater than the critical value,
-1.932 1.960 0.054
Significant H0 1.960, at alpha 0.05, then there is no significant difference on the
participant’s level of competency on dosage calculation when
grouped according to gender.
The table above shows the result of the Independent T-
test used to determine the existence of significant difference on The decision was to accept H0 that the level of
the participant’s level of competency on basic math operations competency of male and female participants on dosage
when grouped according to gender. The computed value was calculation does not differ significantly.
-1.932 with a level of significance of 0.054. Since the absolute
computed value, 1.932, was not greater than the critical value, Table IV.10 Independent T-test for the Significant
1.960, at alpha 0.05, then there is no significant difference on Difference of Participants’ Level of Competency on
the participant’s level of competency on basic math operations Intravenous Flow Rates Calculation when Grouped
when grouped according to gender. According to Gender
The decision was to accept H0 that the level of
competency of male and female participants on basic math Computed Critical Level of
operations does not differ significantly. Interpretation Decision
Value Value Significance

Table IV.8 Independent T-test for the Significant


Difference of Participants’ Level of Competency on Not Accept
-0.255 1.960 0.799
Conversion of Units of Measurement when Grouped Significant H0
According to Gender

Computed Critical Level of The table above shows the result of the Independent T-
Interpretation Decision test used to determine the existence of significant difference on
Value Value Significance
the participant’s level of competency on Intravenous Flow Rates
Calculation when grouped according to gender. The computed
Not Accept value was -0.255 with a level of significance of 0.799. Since the
-1.007 1.960 0.314
Significant H0 absolute computed value, 0.255, was not greater than the critical
value, 1.960, at alpha 0.05, then there is no significant difference
on the participant’s level of competency on Intravenous Flow
The table above shows the result of the Independent T- Rates Calculation when grouped according to gender.
test used to determine the existence of significant difference on
the participant’s level of competency on conversion of units of The decision was to accept H0 that the level of
measurement when grouped according to gender. The competency of male and female participants on Intravenous Flow
computed value was -1.007 with a level of significance of Rates Calculation does not differ significantly.
0.314. Since the absolute computed value, 1.007, was not
greater than the critical value, 1.960, at alpha 0.05, then there is Table IV.11 Independent T-test for the Significant
no significant difference on the participant’s level of Difference of Participants' Level of Competency when
competency on conversion of units of measurement when Grouped According to Gender
grouped according to gender.
The decision was to accept H0 that the level of Computed Critical Level of
competency of male and female participants on conversion of Interpretation Decision
Value Value Significance
units of measurement does not differ significantly.

Table IV.9 Independent T-test for the Significant Not Accept


-0.542 1.960 0.588
Difference of Participants’ Level of Competency on Dosage Significant H0
Calculation when Grouped According to Gender

Computed Critical Level of The table above shows the result of the Independent T-
Interpretation Decision test used to determine the existence of significant difference on
Value Value Significance
the participant’s overall level of competency when grouped
according to gender. The computed value was -0.542 with a level
11
of significance of 0.588. Since the absolute computed value, Some studies showed the same result. Among these
0.542, was not greater than the critical value, 1.960, at alpha were the studies of Hutton, Brown, and Lanen, Lockie and
0.05, then there is no significant difference on the participant’s McGannon. 231 nursing students were pre-tested by Hutton
overall level of competency when grouped according to gender. (1998) with a 50 item test with results of showing that 80% of
these students scored less than 75%.
The decision is to accept H0 that the level of
competency of male and female participants does not differ
significantly.
This has also been in congruent with the study by Brown
Discussion of Findings (2002), who administered to 868 undergraduate associate degree
nursing students from across the United States of America a
mathematics test. The conclusion of Brown to their results is that
This section reiterates how the data were put into pre- testing upon admission is critical and remedial of
understandable form and substantialized into its existing mathematics courses should be mandatory because the results of
literatures. The implications of the findings for nursing practice the study he has conducted was that the students had a mean
and research was also made. score of 75%. The result of the mathematics test further
implicated that students majoring in nursing were under-
prepared in skills in calculation of medication which is a very
critical part of the job.
When a medication order differs from the fixed amount
at which a drug is supplied, the dose needed must be calculated.
Calculation requires knowledge of the systems of dosage
measurements and the ability to solve arithmetic. Nursing In a mathematics placement test made by Lanen, Lockie
students invariably express anxiety that they will miscalculate a and McGannon (2000) to 308 undergraduate nursing students,
dose and cause harm. Although everyone is capable of error, no they concluded that the students are at a risk and they still lack
one has to cause one. The surest way to prevent a mistake was skills needed in nursing competence. Although they
to exercise care in performing basic arithmetic operations. acknowledged that the data they gathered were dependent on an
individual’s skills, it is better that they have more focus on the
mathematical aspects of their course because it affects the overall
performance.
The participants

This is consistent with the study conducted by Pozehl


(1996), Pozehl findings indicated that the nursing students were The implications of the study for future researchers
deficient in mathematics skills, particularly algebra, compared include opening the path for a bigger scope of application. This
to the non-nursing cohort. also raises the idea that it can be done in any clinical area.

Most of the students feel anxious when it comes to Discussion of Hypothesis


mathematical operations. Researchers observed that most of the
students were shocked when they first saw the questionnaire The researchers had used an independent T-test for the
because it deals with mathematics. significant difference of participant’s level of competency when
grouped according to gender. This method was designed to
examine the statistical difference of two means of the male and
female group. It was presented in table 9-11the result of the
The respondents’ were given a series of computational independent T-test, and it has clearly showed that all areas have
mathematics test focusing on Basic Math Operations, lesser absolute computed value than the computed value with a
Conversion of Units of Measurement, Drug Dosage level of significance ranging from 0.054-0.799. Ergo, there was
Computation, and IV Flow Rate Calculation. Their mean score no significance on the participant’s level of competency when
on these tests are 58%, passing but yet has not reached the level grouped according to gender. In addition, the null hypothesis was
of competency, which shows that most of the students are not so accepted since the test has proven no significant relationship
focused on mathematics which is one of the basic skills needed between means.
for a career in nursing, these further affects their level of
competence and more importantly their performance of the job
they will pursue.
CHAPTER 5

12
SUMMARYOF FINDINGS, CONCLUSION AND
RECOMMENDATION Recommendation

Summary The researchers recommend further enhancement of


drug dosage calculation skills of level IV nursing students in Far
The purpose of the study was to assess the level of Eastern University. Drug calculation concept in pharmacology
competency on drug calculations of level IV nursing students of must be further discussed in lectures; and if possible, there must
Far Eastern University. By knowing the competency of these be an increase in units in pharmacology so it will be given more
students, the researchers were able to identify their strengths emphasis. As early as level I, Algebra Course must be integrated
and weaknesses on this skill. The researchers had looked into with medication calculations. It is better if the institution will
the problems of mathematics in nursing that focuses on basic implement an annual assessment exam on this area to test the
mathematical operations, conversion of units, drug dosage and proficiency of their students.
IV flow rate calculation. They had also inferred the significance
of the participant’s level of competency when grouped Teaching and learning strategies must be implemented
according to gender. effectively and must be given focus in practice. In every clinical
exposure, clinical instructors must ask their students manual
computations of drug dosage or flow rate before administering
The researchers had used a descriptive design. The medications or setting up an IV infusion. They may also give
samples of 340 participants were based from the Slovin’s regular exercises on medication calculation to master this skill.
formula. They had used stratified random sampling and students
were selected from different section using fishbowl technique. The researchers would like to recommend the following
The primary tool of the research was a 100 item drug for the next researchers that would like to embark on a similar
calculation test which is composed of 4 areas: basic research. :
mathematical operations, conversion of units, drug dosage and 1. They can use this research as additional evidence that
IV flow rate calculation. will further study and determine the level of competency
on drug dosage calculations of nursing students.
Findings
1. What is the participant’s level of competency on the 2. The researchers also recommend that they also include
following area? the factors that affect the level of competency on drug
The participants had achieved a level 3 dosage calculations of nursing students. .
competency on basic mathematical operations and
3. The researchers should also measure the anxiety level
conversion of units; and level 2 competency on drug
of the nursing students when answering mathematical
dosage and IV flow rate calculation. Their overall
tests.
competency on drug dosage calculation is level 2.
4. The researchers are recommended to study the best
2. Is there a significant difference when participants are strategies in teaching Mathematics which should come
group according to gender to compare their level of along with enough time to learn the subject, which
competency? should not be in a comprehensive manner but in an
There exists no significant difference on the invasive manner. If these strategies be applied, the next
participant’s level of competency when grouped researchers should also check if there is an improvement
according to gender. The level of competency of male in the competency of the students.
and female respondents does not significantly differ.

Conclusion

The level of competency on drug calculation among


the 340 level IV nursing students of Far Eastern University was
in level 2. The level of competency between male and female
participants’ does not differ significantly. The male and female
participants’ were equally competent based on the results of the
test given by the researchers to measure their competency level
on the four major areas in medication calculations.

13

Potrebbero piacerti anche