Sei sulla pagina 1di 10

Simons, J. S., Gaher, R. M., Jacobs, G. A., Meyer, D.

, & Keywords: disaster mental health, humanitarian assistance,


Johnson-Jimenez, E. (2005). Associations between alcohol international psychology, psychological support, psycholog-
use and PTSD symptoms among Red Cross disaster relief ical first aid
workers responding to the 9/11/2001 attacks. American
Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, 31, 285–304. The Flight 232 aviation disaster in Sioux City, Iowa, on
July 19, 1989, was the first of a series of events that led to
the development of a national plan for disaster mental
health services (Jacobs, 1995). As a result of our work in
The Development and Maturation of that disaster relief operation, Randy Quevillon and I pro-
Humanitarian Psychology posed to both the American Psychological Association
(APA) and the American Red Cross the development of a
Gerard A. Jacobs national plan for providing psychological support in the
University of South Dakota aftermath of disasters. Similar ideas were fielded from
other psychologists in the months that followed as a conse-
quence of Hurricane Hugo in the Southeast United States
and the Loma Prieta earthquake in Northern California.
After two years of preparation, APA and the Red Cross
Humanitarian psychological support as an organized field announced in October 1991 that they had reached an agree-
is relatively young. Pioneers in the field were involved ment to have APA support the Red Cross in routinely pro-
primarily in providing psychological support to refugees viding psychological support in disaster relief operations
and internally displaced persons in conflict and nonconflict both for those directly affected by the event and for the
situations. This article describes basic principles for the humanitarian relief workers who respond.
design of psychological support programs and In 1992, I visited the International Red Cross and Red
interventions. The International Federation of Red Cross Crescent Museum in Geneva. I was very impressed with
and Red Crescent Societies (IFRC) began a psychological the Wall of Time, a display listing each of the disasters
support program in 1991. The IFRC chose psychological and conflicts that had resulted in more than 1,000 deaths
first aid as its model for implementation in developing since the founding of the Red Cross in 1859, all of which
countries. Psychological first aid fits all the principles for were arrayed around the circular outer wall of the museum.
psychological support program design and is adapted to It was striking that out of the many hundreds of events
individual communities. The first generation of chronicled on the wall, only a few had occurred in the
psychological support programs differed dramatically United States. It became clear to me that as disaster psy-
depending on the countries in which they were developed. chology developed, it would need to look beyond the bor-
A second generation of psychological support programs ders of the United States to include an international hu-
evolved in response to the earthquake/tsunami of December manitarian perspective and to serve a much broader world
26, 2004. The Inter-Agency Standing Committee audience.
international guidelines consolidated the advances of Essentially, the term psychological support refers to
second-generation programs and provided a clear strategies for helping meet the psychological needs of ordi-
indication of the wide acceptance of the importance of nary people who have experienced extraordinary events. It
psychological support. A glimpse is provided of the third focuses on helping people deal with the emotional, cogni-
generation of psychological support programs, and an tive, physiological, and behavioral reactions to traumatic
admonition is made for a more empirical evaluation of the events. Traditional mental health services, in contrast, fo-
effectiveness of interventions. cus on responding to psychopathology or on long-term
self-improvement. Over the past 15 years, concepts of psy-
chological support have evolved and matured. Terminology
Editor’s Note in the field can still be somewhat confusing, and terms are
Gerard A. Jacobs received the International Humanitarian often used with contradicting definitions. In many cases,
Award. Award winners are invited to deliver an award ad- however, psychological support has been categorized into
dress at the APA’s annual convention. A version of this (a) disaster mental health or disaster psychology, which
award address was delivered at the 115th annual meeting, involves services provided by mental health professionals,
held August 17–20, 2007, in San Francisco, California. and (b) psychological first aid, which involves support pro-
Articles based on award addresses are reviewed, but they vided by family, friends, and neighbors but not by mental
differ from unsolicited articles in that they are expressions health professionals (Jacobs & Meyer, 2005).
of the winners’ reflections on their work and their views of I have served as an American Red Cross Disaster Ser-
the field. vices volunteer since the crash of Flight 232. I was one of

932 November 2007 ● American Psychologist


two psychologists who represented both APA and the Pioneers: The Care of Refugees and Internally
American Red Cross on the committee that developed the Displaced Persons
Disaster Mental Health Services model, providing com-
mentary from South Dakota on each generation of propos- Mary Petevi had worked for years within the Office of the
als. I served for eight years as a national consultant for United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and the
World Health Organization. (She recently retired after
Disaster Mental Health Services in the American Red
more than 30 years in the field.) Much of her time was
Cross and as one of the initial members of the APA Advi-
spent in the field in difficult circumstances, trying to pro-
sory Board for the Disaster Response Network, APA’s na-
tect and support those affected by conflict and disaster. Her
tional network of disaster response volunteers. Within my
focus on the protection of refugees and internally displaced
first few years in those various roles, I met a number of
persons included an understanding of the psychological and
Red Cross paid or volunteer staff who had served as inter-
social impact of being a refugee and an understanding of
national humanitarian delegates with the American Red
the need for basic psychological and psychosocial support.
Cross, the International Federation of Red Cross and Red
She also understood the problems of applying Western de-
Crescent Societies (IFRC; the part of the Red Cross move-
veloped-nation concepts of diagnoses, treatment, and psy-
ment that deals with nonconflict situations), or the Interna- chopharmacology to persons in severe distress in develop-
tional Committee of the Red Cross (the part of the Red ing countries. She brought to this work her own experience
Cross movement that deals with conflict and acts of war). of being a refugee since 1974. She empowered local pro-
The delegates told harrowing tales of their experiences fessionals, associations, and the refugees and displaced per-
serving refugees and internally displaced persons in conflict sons themselves in the development of policies and prac-
and nonconflict situations. I was surprised to learn that tices. She supported their efforts toward improved
these delegates had not been offered any assistance in cop- individual and collective psychosocial functioning and re-
ing with the experiences they had directly experienced, covery. She spearheaded the development of the World
with the scenes they had witnessed, with re-entering their Health Organization’s Tool for the Rapid Assessment of
comparatively plush Western lives after working for Mental Health Needs of Refugees, Displaced and Other
months or even years in portions of the world experiencing Populations Affected by Conflict and Post-Conflict Situa-
intense hardship, or with rejoining a family constellation tions: A Community-Oriented Assessment (Jacobs, Revel,
that had continued to grow and develop despite the dele- Reyes, & Quevillon, 2006; Petevi, Revel, & Jacobs, 2001),
gate’s absence. and their Declaration of Cooperation: Mental Health of
In 1994, I began to advocate for better care for interna- Refugees, Displaced, and Other Populations Affected by
tional humanitarian workers within the IFRC. In 1991, the Conflict and Post-Conflict Situations (Petevi, 2001).
IFRC had begun to explore the idea of developing a world- Jean-Pierre Revel had served for many years as a physi-
wide Psychological Support Program. I wanted to ensure cian field delegate with various nongovernmental organiza-
that the IFRC was considering the needs of the interna- tions before joining the IFRC. He assisted those who found
tional humanitarian delegates, not simply the needs of themselves in some of the most difficult circumstances and
those directly affected. I had an emerging vision even then locations in the world. He was chosen to be the first coor-
of developing psychological support programs that could dinator of the IFRC Psychological Support Program. Al-
improve the resilience and coping capacity of people though not a mental health professional, he had a sense,
throughout the world, in different continents, cultures, and firmly rooted in years of fieldwork, of the need for effec-
circumstances. However, I felt that the first step was to tive basic psychological support. He developed a model
take care of the humanitarian relief workers who were vol- that explained that individuals affected by traumatic events
untarily putting themselves on the front lines to try to were most likely to seek psychological support from their
serve those in need. I did not see myself participating in friends and family, and he suggested that the community
the development of those models, but rather saw myself was the best level for intervention (International Federation
encouraging the experts in the field to move in that direc- of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies, 1998).
tion. Michael Wessells has spent much of his career protect-
I don’t think I could have imagined then the way my ing children and families in conflict and postconflict situa-
career would develop. To my dismay, I learned that there tions, working both with the Christian Children’s Fund and
were relatively few experts in the field at that time. Many as a professor teaching a new generation about these is-
of these early pioneers had made their marks in related sues. He received an APA Presidential Citation for his hu-
fields and routinely put themselves at significant risk for manitarian work at the annual APA convention in Hawaii
the sake of serving those in need. They were and continue in 2004. His development of effective community-based
to be an inspiration to me. models and his development of theory have touched count-

November 2007 ● American Psychologist 933


less lives (e.g., Wessells, 1998, 2006; Wessells & Mon- ism. Anderson (1999) cautioned those involved in humani-
teiro, 2004). tarian assistance to think about these issues in depth, to
Jon Hubbard has served for many years as a psychother- explore the possible hidden ways that well-intentioned ef-
apist and field-based researcher for the Center for Victims forts may produce significant harm. Beware of those who
of Torture in Minneapolis. He has served in many conflict advocate that something is better than nothing and who
situations. Among other psychosocial projects, Hubbard wish to forge ahead with interventions that have not been
has worked to develop culturally appropriate community- well planned and prepared with the local community. The
based research models that can be implemented quickly in potential for harm is real. It is sobering to realize that in
diverse communities (e.g., Hubbard & Miller, 2004). He some cultural settings, psychologists may put an individu-
continues to remind psychologists that even in complex al’s life at risk even by talking to them without appropriate
crisis situations, intervention decisions are best based on permissions. This dramatically underlines the importance of
valid empirical data and on program evaluation that is sup- Principles 2 and 5 described here. The first principle also
ported by and actively involves the target communities speaks to the importance of incorporating effective assess-
themselves. He is part of the Center for Victims of Torture ment, monitoring, and evaluation in psychological support
team that received the APA International Humanitarian programs, to ensure that humanitarian interventions do not
Award in 2006 (Stepakoff et al., 2006). have iatrogenic effects. Second, programs need to be com-
munity based. My work in India gave me a new perspec-
Foundation Principles in Humanitarian Psychological tive on this principle. In India, the concept of community
Support is used to refer to groups of people who share a common
In participating in the development of models for interna- interest rather than to a geographically determined group.
tional disaster psychology and psychological support, I Thus, a single town or village can have multiple communi-
consulted with colleagues in community psychology, com- ties, grouped by religion, ethnicity, socioeconomic status,
munity theory, and cognitive– behavioral psychology. I ex- politics, or any number of other possibilities. Therefore, to
pected to find dramatic differences in the ways different be truly community based, a program needs to be adapted
cultures experience traumatic stress, but as I worked in for each interest group, to build on their strengths and meet
more and more countries and on various continents, I was their needs in a culturally responsive manner. This virtually
struck much more by the similarities of traumatic stress necessitates the involvement of the community itself in the
reactions than by the differences. Spielberger (1966) pre- design and implementation of the program (see Principle
sented a model of individual reactions to stress. Although 5). Third, programs need to be sustainable. They must be
the key to his model was the individual’s cognitive ap- capable of being maintained (e.g., affordable), but they also
praisal of the stressor, he also suggested that individuals must have sufficiently obvious merit to engage communi-
have a limited supply of coping resources, and once those ties in maintaining them. Fourth, programs need to build
resources are expended, the individual will experience a on the strengths of the community being served. Every cul-
stress reaction. Hobfoll (1989) has extensively elaborated ture has unique practices and coping strategies that can be
these concepts in his conservation of resources theory. integrated into the program and that build the sense of
I have come to define traumatic stress as stress that is of ownership of the program in the community. Fifth, use
such magnitude that it can overwhelm anyone’s coping local expertise. This is in part related to both Principles 1
resources, no matter how strong they are, how well-pre- and 2. Local residents will be there to serve the community
pared, or how extensive their coping skills. I have devel- for the long term and can help to design a program that is
oped a hypothesis over the years that it is the overwhelm- truly appropriate for that specific community. Sixth, pro-
ing nature of the stress that leads to the similarity of grams need to primarily address ordinary reactions to ex-
reactions in such disparate cultures. Nevertheless, with traordinary events. Psychological support is focused on
Spielberger as a mentor, I was strongly aware of the im- helping people through particularly difficult events in life,
portance of culture in helping people prepare for and re- not on addressing traditional psychopathology. This focus
spond to stress in their lives (see, e.g., Spielberger & Diaz- helps psychological support bypass some of the cultural
Guerrero, 1976). That is, culture in all its aspects has the roadblocks that may exist in the conceptualization of psy-
potential to influence both resilience and the ability to re- chopathology. Seventh, the final principle is one that is not
cover from traumatic stress—to affect them positively or universally endorsed in the field. I suggest that every resi-
negatively. dent of the affected area needs to be offered psychological
The seven basic principles that I teach for designing an support. Some colleagues prefer models that serve only a
appropriate psychological support program have essentially certain percentage of the target population, suggesting that
been the same from the beginning, but my understanding they are more realistic. I do not think it is profitable to set
of those principles has matured over time. First, do no minimalist goals when there are viable program models,
harm. That cautionary statement is not merely a trite tru- such as psychological first aid, that can serve all those in

934 November 2007 ● American Psychologist


need. The Inter-Agency Standing Committee’s (2007) crisis intervention services by licensed mental health pro-
guidelines share this point of view repeatedly throughout fessionals. This model has seemed to be an effective sup-
the document. port strategy in disasters ranging from house fires to the
Similarly, I have endorsed principles to guide the actual terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, but it remains to
interventions of providers. Again, these have remained be effectively empirically tested. Disaster mental health’s
much the same from very early in the development of di- reliance on mental health professionals, however, makes it
saster psychology (Quevillon & Jacobs, 1992), but my un- impractical for most of the world (and for potential cata-
derstanding of them has matured. First, providers need to strophic events in the United States). The World Health
be flexible. Whether in disaster psychology or psychologi- Organization (2005) reported that wealthy nations have
cal first aid, situations in crises change rapidly, and the 770.5 mental health professionals per million residents,
needs of those affected change quickly as well. Meeting whereas impoverished nations have only 3.2 mental health
people’s needs in such situations requires frequent changes professionals per million residents. Thus, in impoverished
in strategies and may mean that, at times, the provider will nations, reliance on mental health professionals is simply
most effectively offer psychological support by helping impractical. It may also be unrealistic in very large-scale
meet primary needs (e.g., distributing food, water, and events in wealthy nations. There is always a finite number
blankets). Second, be supportive. Third, be soothing. of mental health professionals. However, if psychologists
Fourth, use some direct guidance. Fifth, be an advocate. teach members of the general population how to more ef-
Although therapists may need to be cautious and concerned fectively support one another, there is almost always a pro-
about these issues in a therapeutic alliance, psychological vider nearby.
support is not therapy, but is short-term crisis intervention. When the IFRC chose a model to use in helping nations
The focus is to help the client work through this difficult develop psychological support programs, it settled on psy-
experience in life. It is important to understand traumatic chological first aid. This approach was developed primarily
stress reactions and their potential to affect cognitive pro-
in Scandinavia (Jacobs & Meyer, 2005). When I first vis-
cessing, memory, and problem solving. It is often particu-
ited Denmark in 1994, Vinni Smed, who was then the di-
larly helpful, for example, to help clients understand their
rector of the IFRC Reference Centre for Psychological
range of options in choosing a strategy to cope with an
immediate decision. Sixth, educate. Recent research sup- Support, told me that the Danish Red Cross had already
ports historic clinical intuition that understanding the over- trained more than 10,000 residents to provide psychologi-
whelming nature of traumatic stress may be the most im- cal first aid, and she felt that it had become well-integrated
portant protection against long-term traumatic stress into their culture.
reactions (Ehlers & Clark, 2006). Seventh, make referrals Psychological first aid refers to the provision of basic
as needed. Neither disaster psychology nor psychological psychological support by members of the general popula-
first aid are intended to deal with psychopathology. Clients tion, not by mental health professionals. It is community
with psychopathology need to be referred to the traditional based and is adapted to the culture and practices of what-
mental health system. In some developing countries, it may ever community the program is developed by and for. Be-
be necessary to help build or augment a mental health in- cause the program is developed with the community and
frastructure to serve these needs. Eighth, be present to cli- the support is provided by members of the community, the
ents! I have come to believe over the years that this is one support is likely to be culturally responsive. Psychological
of the most important roles a provider can have in psycho- first aid is low cost, having few expenses other than devel-
logical support. Essentially, this concept proposes that pro- oping the training and public education materials for the
viders need to be ready to serve those affected by trau- targeted communities. Psychological first aid is community
matic events when they are ready to be served, not based and low cost, which significantly contributed to its
according to the schedule of the providers. Sharing the ex- being a sustainable strategy. Additionally, the core skill in
perience of those in crisis can be a significant source of psychological first aid is active listening, which is at the
support to them. In Thailand, one of the most traditional heart of many therapeutic techniques. Participants report
interventions is to simply sit in silence with those who that active listening is useful not only in their psychologi-
have experienced a traumatic event. I have found the same cal first aid support, but also in their personal and profes-
strategy very useful in many mass-casualty events in the sional communications and relationships. This versatility
United States. contributes to its popularity and therefore to its sustainabil-
ity. Psychological first aid also incorporates the traditional
Planning for Humanitarian Psychological Support coping strategies of the society, building on the strengths
The disaster mental health model developed collaboratively of the culture. Furthermore, it builds the response capacity
by APA, the American Red Cross, and other mental health of families and friends, and these are the people to whom
professions (Jacobs, 1995) relies on the direct provision of individuals most often turn for psychological support.

November 2007 ● American Psychologist 935


There is a saying that seems to be understood through- I would be unable to do more than write empty theoretical
out the world: “When you have a hammer, everything treatises if my colleagues around the world did not invite
looks like a nail.” If you have only one tool for providing me to consult with them and provide training for their pro-
psychological support, you may tend to do the same thing grams. In many ways, it is genuinely their work that this
for everyone, everywhere, every time. Given the breadth of International Humanitarian Award honors.
individual differences, this is unlikely to be effective. The
saving grace of psychological first aid is that it is adapted The First Generation of Psychological Support
and shaped for each community in which it is imple- Programs
mented, so that the tool takes on many different shapes in In 2004, I was invited to organize a symposium at the 28th
different cultures. The IFRC’s model called for an initial International Congress of Psychology in Beijing. I chose to
assessment of the needs of the country. This was to be fol- highlight four programs in countries in different parts of
lowed by months of adaptation of the model through the the world with whom I had been privileged to consult,
collaboration of the IFRC consultants assigned to assist the sometimes as an IFRC representative and other times rep-
country and the organizing committee within the Red resenting the Disaster Mental Health Institute.
Cross or Red Crescent national society that had requested Sirry Thormar gave a presentation on her pioneering
assistance in developing a program. I was asked to partici- work in Iceland. She directed the development of one of
pate in the first implementation of the model in Bulgaria in the first national psychological support programs in the
1996, and it has been developed in various forms in coun- world, integrating disaster mental health and psychological
tries throughout Europe, much of Asia, and portions of first aid models in a program that has become part of the
Africa and South America. culture of that small island nation. From its inception,
The Inter-Agency Standing Committee’s (2007) recently Thormar has been a member of the IFRC’s International
released guidelines, developed by United Nations agencies Roster for Psychological Support, a team of international
and most major international humanitarian organizations, consultants who contribute their knowledge and expertise
reiterate the long-standing recommendation that expatriate to Red Cross and Red Crescent national societies around
providers (those who are residents of another country) the world. The Icelandic Red Cross maintains an active
should not provide direct services. Rather, they should con- continuing education program for professionals, bringing
sult with and train local providers to enhance their skills in world leaders in the field to Reykjavik to provide training.
serving their people (Inter-Agency Standing Committee, Burcu Aydin described the Turkish Red Crescent psy-
2007, pp. 48 – 49). This is because providing psychological chological support program, undertaken with the collabora-
support in a community in which one does not know the tion of the Turkish Psychological Association. She helped
culture, the language, the history, the religious beliefs, or develop the program following the 1999 earthquake that
the worldview is likely to cause problems and may cause resulted in widespread devastation and loss of life in west-
harm. The first principle of providing psychological sup- ern Turkey. The program evolved into a model in which
port, of course, is to do no harm. psychological support is based in community centers.
Therefore, psychological support programs are generally These traditional Turkish centers include mental health pro-
the product of consultants familiar with such programs fessionals among their staff. They host wedding receptions
(consultants who may be expatriates), leaders of the psy- and similar events, give courses on sewing and cooking,
chological support program in the country or community and generally serve as community gathering sites. Psycho-
developing the program (including representatives of the logical first aid has been added to that traditional mix of
community who are not professionals), and frontline pro- courses and activities, and in some centers, more traditional
viders. This is an amazingly rich mixture of human experi- mental health services have been made available. The
ence. One of the most powerful and rewarding features of Turkish Psychological Association has also worked with
this work is the incredible group of colleagues with whom the Turkish Red Crescent Society to implement a disaster
I have the opportunity and privilege to work. mental health program.
Many outstanding psychological support programs now Rose Kasina was instrumental in the development of a
serve those in need in many parts of the world, and many psychological support program to serve Kenyan residents
impressive colleagues direct and manage those programs affected by the 1998 bombing of the U.S. embassy in
and serve as frontline providers. I spend much of the rest Nairobi. She described the adaptation of that program to
of this article highlighting a few of these colleagues and serve HIV/AIDS patients, after the disaster-caused needs of
their programs to illustrate the development of the field. those affected by the bombing had been largely met.
The limitations of space prohibit paying individual tribute Jun Maeda, an associate professor of psychology at the
to everyone who has made a significant contribution. How- Muroran Institute of Technology in Hokkaido, was a core
ever, I feel that it is critically important to highlight a few member of the team that developed the psychological sup-
of the works of these colleagues, because as an expatriate, port program in the Japan Red Cross Society. The Japanese

936 November 2007 ● American Psychologist


program has been based in medical teams, because the his extensive experience in Hurricane Mitch in Central
medical setting is one place in which cultural restrictions America, and he began the implementation of a program in
on emotional expression and asking for help do not seem the earthquake-affected area in Bhuj and the riot-torn
so strong. In addition, the Japanese Red Cross Society has camps in Gujarat. The program began with a core psycho-
92 hospitals in Japan and fields medical teams in disaster logical first aid program and then moved to community
response. They hope to move toward adding a psychologi- mapping and collective problem solving. It was truly a
cal first aid component as Japanese society becomes more community-based program. Part of Prewitt Diaz’s adapta-
accepting of psychological support concepts. tion was to build a detailed career ladder of advanced
These four programs were designed and implemented by training, enabling paid and volunteer local staff to build
some of the best and brightest in the field of psychological their knowledge and expertise over time in a well-struc-
support. I would consider these, together with the Ameri- tured process. This program has been incorporated by the
can Red Cross disaster mental health program and the Dan- Indian Red Cross Society and currently operates in Orissa
ish Red Cross psychological first aid program, to be first- and Gujarat, as well as in Kumbakonam, Tamil Nadu,
generation programs, which continue to evolve and change without outside funding.
based on changes in the profession and in the cultures they Prewitt Diaz’s design was genuinely psychosocial. I had
serve. the opportunity to consult with the program in 2005, and it
was amazing to see how accepted it was in the communi-
Developments in Asia: A Second Generation of ties in which it had been implemented. The program began
Psychological Support Programs with community committees to decide the priorities of the
The tsunami of December 26, 2004, was among the largest community and to decide how best to meet those needs
disasters in recorded history, particularly with regard to the with technical assistance from the program staff. One of
loss of human life. The state of Aceh in Indonesia was the priorities identified by the communities was finding a
rocked by the second most powerful earthquake ever re- way for the large number of widows to support themselves
corded (United States Geological Survey, 2007). Minutes and their children. The program invested small amounts of
later, the coast was struck by a wall of water that reached money in community groups. The loans were sufficient to
nearly 100 feet in height in areas of Aceh and wreaked buy needed tools and were to be repaid through volunteer
havoc more than two miles inland (Canadian Association work with the program, rather than in currency. One group
for Earthquake Engineering, 2005). The shock wave from of women said they were good at sewing. The program
the earthquake also raised tsunami waves 65 to 100 feet in bought them sewing machines and arranged for a place for
height that caused extensive destruction and loss of life in them to work. Their group now produces school uniforms
India, Sri Lanka, and Thailand and caused less devastating for much of the region. Another group said they were
damage in a number of other countries, most notably the skilled in embroidery and traditional artwork. They were
islands nation of the Maldives. Many populated islands given the necessary tools to produce high-quality artwork
there were swept completely underwater by the tsunami. for the tourist industry. These widows now support their
This event also triggered a need for psychological support families.
of historic proportions. Fortunately, a new generation of Volunteers with the IFRC Psychological Support Pro-
professionals was ready to support those countries in devel- gram organize many community-wide activities, building
oping a new generation of programs, building on the psy- the cohesion of the community. Schools had local artists
chological support program in India developed jointly by paint large murals representing the cycle of psychological
the Indian Red Cross Society and the American Red Cross. support on the end walls of their buildings. One group of
In January 2001, the state of Gujarat in India was struck school children asked to develop a response team to sup-
by an earthquake centered in the Kutch district near the port children whose families were involved in disaster,
city of Bhuj. It was the second most deadly earthquake in playing with them and talking with them while their par-
India’s history, a country with a very active seismic history ents were occupied with the recovery. Teenagers who vol-
(Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sci- unteer with the program are seen as community heroes and
ences, n.d.). I was asked by the American Red Cross to are literally cheered by the community when they earn the
serve as a humanitarian delegate, implementing a psycho- right to advance to the next level of training.
logical support program that could serve the people af- The Asian Disaster Preparedness Center (ADPC) in
fected by the earthquake. Working together with local col- 2002 invited the Disaster Mental Health Institute to work
leagues and the local Red Cross branches and national with them in developing psychological support programs in
staff, we developed a program specific to the Gujarati cul- Asia. The ADPC and the Disaster Mental Health Institute
ture. developed a statement of understanding, with the Disaster
Joseph O. Prewitt Diaz, a psychologist and psychiatrist, Mental Health Institute serving as ADPC’s partner for psy-
made significant adaptations to the program on the basis of chological support. The Disaster Mental Health Institute

November 2007 ● American Psychologist 937


helped develop psychological support components for a restoring some degree of order and predictability to their
number of regular ADPC training programs, including lives. In addition, in the evenings the restored school build-
health/hospital courses and general disaster management ing served as a gathering place for the community to dis-
courses. Dozens of emergency managers throughout Asia cuss their difficulties and recovery efforts. Moreover, the
learned the basics of psychological support in the fall of committee saw that the psychological support program was
2004, only weeks before the tsunami struck. serious about listening to them and about making a differ-
By the time the 2004 earthquake/tsunami occurred, the ence. The program in Sri Lanka has progressed to the point
India Psychological Support Program had begun to spread that a Buddhist monastery has asked that their monks be
into other areas of the country, and the program had gener- trained in psychological first aid because they can see that
ated a team of highly trained young professionals under it is becoming a part of the Sri Lankan culture. In addition,
Prewitt Diaz’s guidance. Immediately after the earthquake/ the American Red Cross is assisting the government in
tsunami event, the American Red Cross offered some of developing a postgraduate diploma in disaster mental
those leaders to Sri Lanka, the Maldives, and Indonesia to health for social workers.
assist in developing programs. All three countries accepted In Aceh, Indonesia, the region doubly damaged (earth-
the offer, albeit some countries more quickly than others. quake and tsunami) by one of the worst disasters in world
These programs have become some of the most impressive history, the American Red Cross has teamed with the Indo-
I have seen, and two of them were led by young profes- nesian Red Cross society to develop the psychological sup-
sionals the age of most psychology doctoral students in the port program. Sujata Bordoloi, who had served as the se-
United States. nior national staff member in the program in India, was
In the Maldives, Satyabrata Dash, a psychiatrist, found tapped to be the expatriate program director of the Indone-
that the concepts espoused by psychological first aid were sian program. This program faced the daunting task of
little known in the culture but were quickly accepted by helping more than 120 communities across the most se-
the residents. One major complication there has been that verely impacted coastline to reconstitute themselves. In
the Maldivian language did not have words to describe many areas, 80% of the residents were killed in either the
many of the ideas, and the federal government closely reg- earthquake or the tsunami. This mortality level meant that
ulates the addition of new words to the language. There- many of the people with crucial roles in the functioning of
fore, to avoid having words the public would not under- the society were gone. In many cases, entire villages were
stand and to avoid the lengthy bureaucracy of adding new simply erased from the earth, and much of the key city of
words, concepts are described in phrases, sentences, or Banda was flattened by the combination of a major earth-
even paragraphs using the existing language, rather than quake and the 100-foot wall of water that arrived 15 min-
with a single new word. This is somewhat cumbersome but utes later. Social reconstruction and the rebuilding of com-
is more effective for the time being. Additionally, the munity networks through culturally responsive
Maldives was one of the few nations in the world without interventions have been a central feature of the psychologi-
a Red Cross or Red Crescent national society, so there was cal support program there. Additionally, the University of
no pre-existing structure within which the program could Indonesia and the American Red Cross will develop a mas-
naturally reside. ter’s degree in disaster psychology to develop leaders for
In Sri Lanka, the program was developed together with the future.
the Sri Lankan Red Cross Society. Anjana Dayal was the Both in Sri Lanka and in Indonesia, the psychological
expatriate program director there until recently and worked support programs have decided to develop their local staff
with a local counterpart. Local committees were formed even further, by having 20 of their key workers in each
throughout the American Red Cross’s area of assigned re- country complete the Disaster Mental Health Institute’s
sponsibility, which included most of the devastated south- Graduate Certificate in Disaster Psychology–Asia. This cer-
ern coast of the nation. An example of the program’s re- tificate program involves four advanced courses individu-
sponsiveness to the communities can be seen in one ally adapted to each country and taught by Disaster Mental
heavily impacted village. When the community committee Health Institute faculty, as well as additional readings and
was asked what their highest priority was for psychological projects based on the coursework.
support, they asked for help in rebuilding their school. The APA’s large donation to the American Red Cross in the
program staff replied that such work was not part of their immediate aftermath of the tsunami was not targeted spe-
mandate. The committee responded that the question asked cifically at psychological support, but was given with the
of them was how the psychological support program could explicit instruction that it be used wherever it was most
most help the community recover and that rebuilding the needed. Nevertheless, the APA membership can examine
school was their priority. So the psychological support pro- these programs with pride, both in the profession, and in
gram began by helping the community rebuild the school. APA’s role in financially supporting the American Red
Doing so gave the children a place to go during the day, Cross efforts.

938 November 2007 ● American Psychologist


Another path of the development of psychological sup- circumstances, to serve those in need and to build the ca-
port in Asia was APA’s direct support of psychologists and pacity of the host nations. The local staff have invested
other mental health professionals in the tsunami-affected their energy in serving their community’s recovery, in
countries. APA teamed with the International Union of many cases delaying their own families’ recovery for the
Psychological Science in inviting psychological associa- sake of the greater common good. They have done so with
tions or individual psychologists (there is no national psy- an impressive level of professional expertise.
chological association in Sri Lanka) in the four most af- Perhaps the most exciting development in this second
fected countries to nominate participants for one week of generation of international humanitarian psychological sup-
training held in Singapore. As APA’s consultant on the port is the release of the Inter-Agency Standing Commit-
tsunami, I was also charged with consulting with these par- tee’s (2007) IASC Guidelines on Mental Health and Psy-
ticipants and offering assistance where I could. In Tamil chosocial Support in Emergency Settings, which I alluded
Nadu, India, the most affected state in India, participants in to earlier. These detailed guidelines and practical field
the Singapore training organized one week of training in guides were developed through a lengthy process with rep-
psychological support together with the National Associa- resentatives of most United Nations agencies and interna-
tion of Psychologists and the Sri Ramachandra Medical tional nongovernmental organizations, led by the World
College. Psychologists and psychology graduate students Health Organization’s Mark Van Ommeren and the Chris-
from a number of programs in the region were participants. tian Children Fund’s Michael Wessells, and with the input
In Sri Lanka, the Singapore participants returned to their of hundreds of professionals around the world. These
disparate roles as academics and practitioners. Some con- guidelines reflect an acknowledgement of the importance of
sultation has been provided in Sri Lanka, but there has psychological support by the humanitarian community and
been no coordinated effort there by the Singapore partici- a commitment to meet the psychological support needs of
pants. In Thailand, some of the psychologists trained in those affected by conflict and disasters around the world.
Singapore have been developing models that expand be- They consolidate the advances made to date in the second-
yond the traditional Buddhist model of support. In both generation humanitarian psychological support programs.
academic and applied roles, these psychologists are finding
new culturally responsive strategies for providing assis- Third Generation: Looking to the Future
tance to enormous numbers of those directly affected by Even as these second-generation psychological support pro-
the event. The Indonesian Psychological Association has grams are maturing and evolving, a third generation is be-
undertaken some very creative programs, particularly fo- ing designed. New professionals and experienced psycholo-
cusing on the needs of youth in the most affected regions. gists new to the humanitarian assistance field are able to
These programs were then adapted for the Yogyakarta re- see with new eyes. Justin Curry, psychosocial advisor to
gion following the large earthquake there in May 2006. International Services for the American Red Cross, is one
Similar to the psychological support program in India men- of those trying to shape a new vision for the field, focusing
tioned earlier, psychologists in the Indonesian Psychologi- on long-term perspectives and developing new ways of
cal Association have identified financial concerns as a ma- integrating the community-based models of psychological
jor stressor in the affected areas, and they are exploring an support into other sectors of humanitarian relief. Profes-
emerging concept of psychoeconomics. They are currently sionals working on such components as water and sanita-
trying to begin a new professional society within the Indo- tion and health have recognized that the community psy-
nesian Psychological Association to build on these innova- chological first aid committees are a powerful resource for
tive efforts. activating and educating community residents. In addition,
These tsunami-related developments, both through the Curry has recognized the need for more systematic and
American Red Cross and through the nations’ psychologi- validated assessment, monitoring, and evaluation of psy-
cal associations, have been the foundation of a virtual chological support programs. Most of the existing IFRC
quantum leap in psychological support in the South Asia and American Red Cross programs have been evaluated
region and have produced a second generation of psycho- with moderately loose qualitative methods, which makes
logical support programs. Dedicated professionals, includ- comparison of different strategies in different events diffi-
ing Prewitt, Dash, Dayal, Bordoloi, and many others, have cult. Curry has encouraged an international dialogue on
literally given years of their lives in our stead to serve the strategies and techniques for effectively and scientifically
psychological support needs of those impacted by the tsu- evaluating programs that adapt uniquely to each culture
nami, as have many of their local paid and volunteer staff. and community. These are difficult issues in community-
These expatriates, and many national staff of the psycho- based programs, and they have been discussed for decades
logical support programs who moved from other parts of in the United States (e.g., Iscoe & Spielberger, 1970). The
their countries, have separated themselves from their fami- issues become even more complex within an international
lies and from their home cultures, often living in difficult context. Valid program evaluation is particularly important

November 2007 ● American Psychologist 939


in humanitarian efforts, in which donors need to be shown Ehlers, A., & Clark, D. M. (2006). Predictors of chronic
the effectiveness of their investments. It is easier to dem- posttraumatic stress disorder: Trauma memories and ap-
onstrate the impact of a pound of food than a measure of praisals. In B. O. Rothbaum (Ed.), Pathological anxiety:
psychological support, but the latter may be no less impor- Emotional processing in etiology and treatment (pp. 39 –
tant to the recovery of an affected community. 55). New York: Guilford Press.
In a separate initiative, APA has been spearheading the
development of ethical guidelines and/or a code of conduct Hobfoll, S. E. (1989). Conservation of resources: A new
for American psychologists working internationally. Merry attempt at conceptualizing stress. American Psychologist,
Bullock in the Office of International Affairs and Stephen 44, 513–524.
Behnke in the Ethics Office teamed to host an international
gathering of some of the world leaders in the field in De- Hubbard, J., & Miller, K. (2004). Evaluating community-
cember 2006 to begin to frame the necessary concepts for based mental health and psychosocial interventions in refu-
subsequent amplification and review by other colleagues. gee communities. In K. Miller & L. Rasco (Eds.), The
In summary, international psychological support in the mental health of refugees: Ecological approaches to heal-
humanitarian community was founded by a group of pio- ing and adaptation (pp. 337–374). Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.
neering professionals. These programs developed and ma-
tured. By the time of the earthquake and tsunami of De-
cember 26, 2004, the field was poised to serve those Inter-Agency Standing Committee. (2007). IASC guidelines
affected by this unprecedented catastrophe with a series of on mental health and psychosocial support in emergency
psychological support programs that evolved from the first settings. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
generation and built on the foundation of the knowledge
constructed by the pioneers in the field. The establishment International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent
of the Inter-Agency Standing Committee’s (2007) interna- Societies. (1998). World disasters report: 1998. Oxford,
tionally agreed on guidelines is a clear sign that psycholog- England: Oxford University Press.
ical support has come of age in humanitarian service. Al-
though this second generation of programs thrives, leaders Iscoe, I., & Spielberger, C. D. (Eds.). (1970). Community
in the field look forward to and prepare for the next gener- psychology: Perspectives in training & research. New
ation of innovations, particularly with respect to the scien- York: Appleton Century Crofts.
tific evaluation of those programs. I sincerely hope that
you and I can contribute to that next generation. Jacobs, G. A. (1995). The development of a national plan
for disaster mental health. Professional Psychology: Re-
Author’s Note search and Practice, 26, 543–549.
I thank Jordan Pekevski for his assistance in the prepara-
tion of this article.
Jacobs, G. A., & Meyer, D. (2005). Psychological first aid:
Correspondence concerning this article should be ad-
Clarifying the concept. In L. Barbanel & R. J. Sternberg
dressed to Gerard A. Jacobs, Disaster Mental Health Insti-
(Eds.), Psychological interventions in times of crisis (pp.
tute, University of South Dakota SDU114, 414 East Clark
57–71). New York: Springer.
Street, Vermillion, SD 57069. E-mail: gerard.jacobs@
usd.edu
Jacobs, G. A., Revel, J. P., Reyes, G., & Quevillon, R. P.
References (2006). Development of the Rapid Assessment of Mental
Health: An international collaboration. In G. Reyes &
Anderson, M. (1999). Do no harm: How aid can support G. A. Jacobs (Eds.), Handbook of international disaster
peace— or war. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner. psychology: Meeting the psychosocial needs of people in
humanitarian emergencies (Vol. 3, pp. 129 –140). West-
Canadian Association for Earthquake Engineering. (2005). port, CT: Praeger.
Reconnaissance report on: The December 26, 2004
Sumatra earthquake and tsunami [Electronic version]. Ot-
tawa, Ontario, Canada: Canadian Association for Earth- Petevi, M. (Ed.). (2001). Declaration of cooperation: Men-
quake Engineering. tal health of refugees, displaced, and other populations
affected by conflict and post-conflict situations. Geneva,
Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sci- Switzerland: World Health Organization.
ences. (n.d.). 26 January 2001 Bhuj earthquake, Gujarat,
India. Retrieved March 24, 2007, from http://cires Petevi, M., Revel, J. P., & Jacobs, G. A. (2001). Tool
.colorado.edu/⬃bilham/Gujarat2001.html for the Rapid Assessment of Mental Health Needs of

940 November 2007 ● American Psychologist


Refugees, Displaced, and Other Populations Affected by United States geological survey. (2007). Retrieved March
Conflict and Post-Conflict Situations: A community-ori- 23, 2007, from http://earthquake.usgs.gov/regional/world/
ented assessment. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health 10_largest_world.php
Organization.
Wessells, M. G. (1998). The changing nature of armed
conflict and its implications for children: The Graça Ma-
Quevillon, R. P., & Jacobs, G. A. (1992). Treatment issues
chel/UN study. Peace and Conflict: Journal of Peace Psy-
in mental health responses to disaster. In L. VandeCreek, chology, 4(4), 321–334.
S. Knapp, & T. Jackson (Eds.), Innovations in clinical
practice: A source book (Vol. 11, pp. 403– 411). Sarasota, Wessells, M. G. (2006). Child soldiers: From violence to
FL: Professional Resource Press. protection. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Spielberger, C. D. (1966). Anxiety and behavior. New Wessells, M. G., & Monteiro, C. (2004). Healing the
York: Academic Press. wounds following protracted conflict in Angola: A commu-
nity-based approach to assisting war-affected children. In
U. P. Gielen, J. M. Fish, & J. G. Draguns (Eds.), Hand-
Spielberger, C. D., & Diaz-Guerrero, R. (Eds.). (1976).
book of culture, therapy, and healing (pp. 321–341). Mah-
Cross-cultural anxiety. Oxford, England: Hemisphere.
wah, NJ: Erlbaum.
Stepakoff, S., Hubbard, J., Katoh, M., Falk, E., Mikulu, World Health Organization. (2005). Mental health atlas:
J. B., Nkhoma, P., & Omagwa, Y. (2006). Trauma healing 2005. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
in refugee camps in Guinea: A psychosocial program for
Liberian and Sierra Leonean survivors of torture and war.
American Psychologist, 61, 921–932.

November 2007 ● American Psychologist 941

Potrebbero piacerti anche