Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
com
Economics - I
Mapping to Curriculum
Reading 13: Demand and Supply Analysis: Introduction Reading 14: Demand and Supply Analysis: Consumer Demand Reading 15: Demand and Supply Analysis: The Firm Reading 16: The Firm and Market Structures
This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 Expect around 12 questions in the exam from todays lecture
www.edupristine.com
Key Concepts
Shift in Demand and Supply Curve Price Ceiling Elasticity Subsidies Substitution and Income Effect Total, Average and Marginal Revenue Profit Maximization under Imperfect Competition Economic Profit This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 Kinked Demand Curve Oligopoly Games
www.edupristine.com
Types Of Markets
Types of markets are broadly classified into :
Markets for factors of production, eg : labor Markets for services and finished goods, eg : Clothes Firms are buyers in factors of production and sellers in services and finished goods Intermediate goods are used in production of finished goods and services Capital markets is place where savings are converted into investments. Firms raise capital through these markets in the form of debt or equity
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Why is the supply curve upward sloping?
Increasing marginal costs Marginal Cost = Minimum Price
Demand Curve
P=Marginal Benefit
Supply Curve
P=Marginal Cost
Quantity
MB = WTP = Pmax Maximum Price Buyer is willing to pay MC = Pmin
Quantity
www.edupristine.com
Imp
With the change in price, quantity demanded and supplied can be represented by movement along the demand or supply curve Other than price, changes in independent variables will cause shift in demand and supply curves Example : Change in income causes a shift in demand curve Increase in input will lead to decrease in supply
www.edupristine.com
Q1
Q0
Quantity
Q0
Q1
Quantity
www.edupristine.com
Price
Decrease in supply
Decrease in demand
Quantity
Quantity
www.edupristine.com
Price
MB>MC p*
This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 equivalent to the marginal utility that they get
MC>MB Demand (MB)
q* Quantity
www.edupristine.com
p1
p* Falling price Demand (MB) p* p2 Demand (MB) Rising price
Quantity, q (kg)
The price is always set by the demand curve & not by the supply curve. Thus, in figure: a) The price will be p1 & quantity will be qd b) The price will be p2 & quantity will be qd
10 www.edupristine.com
Price
Excess demand
D Quantity
11
www.edupristine.com
S
Excess demand
Unstable equilibrium
Excess supply
Stable equilibrium
S
Quantity
D
Quantity
12
www.edupristine.com
Solution: We solve the equilibrium price(P) by equating the function equal to each other So,
This -1600+280P=8640-360P
13
www.edupristine.com
14
www.edupristine.com
Auctions
Auction is a way of determining equilibrium price. Categorized in two types : A) Common value auction B) Private value auction In common value auction the value of a item is same for any bidder, but bidders do not know the value at the time of the auction In a private value auction every bidder places a subjective bid on the item and the value to each bidder differs
15
www.edupristine.com
Auctions
Auctioning treasury bills with a single price auction : In US Treasury securities, a single price auction is held but bidders can also submit a non-competitive bid indicating that those bidders will accept the amount of treasuries indicated at the price determined by the auction, rather than specifying a maximum price in their bids. The amount of securities specified in the noncompetitive bid is subtracted from the total amount to be sold. Example: Suppose there is $60 billion face value of Treasury bill to be auctioned and there is Noncompetitive bids application of $5 billion face value of bills.
This files expired at 30-Jun-13 Discount Rate (In%) Face Valuehas Cumulative FV
0.1082 0.1088 0.1094 0.1098 0.1106 0.1118 0.1125 9 16 11 12 10 5 5 9 25 36 48 58 63 63
16
www.edupristine.com
Solution
The total face value of bills offered is $60 billion, and there are non- competitive bids for $5 billion So we must select the maximum price, that is the minimum yield for $55 billion($60-$5) face value of bills that can be sold to make bids competitive. So at a discount rate of 0.1098%, $48 billion face value bills can be sold to make bids competitive. The pending $7 billion should be sold at higher rate of 0.1106% The single price for the auction is 0.1106%
17
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Price, p (Rs/kg)
CS
Supply (MC)
CS = V - P
p*
18
www.edupristine.com
Price what is actually paid Value what one is willing to pay p* - Price what the consumer pays (equilibrium Price)
19
www.edupristine.com
Price, p (Rs/kg)
Supply (MC)
20
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Price, p (Rs/kg) CS
Supply (MC)
p*
PS
Quantity, q (kg)
21
www.edupristine.com
Causes Of DWL
Monopoly: e.g. OPEC, Indian Railways
Government restrictions in the form of taxes, subsidies, quotas, price ceiling, price floor all cause This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 a imbalance in the quantity demanded and quantity supplied. These restriction create a dead weight loss. Inefficiency occurs because of : Price Ceiling : Eg- Rent control Price floor : Eg- Minimum wage Taxes and trade restrictions : In the form of subsidies and quotas Public goods and common resources External Costs External benefits
22
www.edupristine.com
marginal benefit are higher than marginal cost OR buy goods when marginal cost is higher than marginal benefit Causes reduction in consumer surplus OR
pq p*
DWL
Supply (MC)
pc
PS
qc q*
Quantity, q (kg)
23
www.edupristine.com
Price Ceiling
Price Impact of Price Ceiling Price Impact of Price Floor
Demand
Pw
s
Supply
Floor Price
Pc
Quantity
Qd Qe Qs
A price floor is a minimum price that a buyer can offer for a good, service, or resource. PF < EP = No effect PF > EP = Supply will exceed demand at the floor price Causes loss of efficiency (deadweight loss) because the quantity actually transacted at PF is less than the efficient equilibrium quantity.
24
www.edupristine.com
Incidence Of Tax
Imp
Tax: Difference between what buyers pay and what sellers gets per unit Hence a tax on a good or service
Increases its equilibrium price and decrease its equilibrium quantity because of the deadweight loss created
Tax Revenue = Tax * Equilibrium Quantity Actual and statutory incidence of tax:
Actual: Who actually bears tax buyer in the form of high prices paid or seller in the form of less prices received Statutory: Who is legally responsible to pay tax
25
www.edupristine.com
DWL
Tax revenue from sellers
Qtax
QE
Quantity
Qtax
26
QE
Quantity
www.edupristine.com
Stax
Price D
Stax
S Ptax PE PS
Tax revenue from buyers
DWL
Tax revenue from sellers
DWL
Tax revenue from sellers
27
www.edupristine.com
Subsidies
Through subsidiaries, governments compensates producers for difference between actual price of the goods and price at which goods sold. A subsidy raises marginal cost (supply costs curve) above marginal benefits (demand curve) This leads to a deadweight loss from overproduction.
Price, p (Rs/kg) CS Supply (MC)
Price Subsidy Price ($ per ton) S
105 90
S - Subsidy
A
p*
Demand (MB) PS
45 30
$30subsidy
D
Quantity increases Quantity (million of tons (per year)
Quantity, q (kg)
15 30
60
90
120
150
180
28
www.edupristine.com
Production Quotas
Govt. imposes an upper limit on the produced quantity of a good over a specified time period.
Causes reduction in the quantity produced leading to an inefficient allocation of resources and a deadweight loss to the economy Increases the market price and lowers the marginal cost of producing the quota quantity
Production Quotas Price ($ per ton) 105 90
75
60 45 30 15
MC Quota
30
29
www.edupristine.com
Elasticity
Elasticity
Imp
EP %Demand %Price
Price Elasticity
Income Elasticity
Note: Price Elasticity for substitutes & complements is known as cross-price elasticity
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 30 www.edupristine.com
Price Elasticity
Price Elasticity
Price
Imp
Price Elasticity of Demand is affected by :
Availability of Substitutes
Implication
Ed = 0
1 <Ed < 0 Ed = 1
Perfectly inelastic.
Relatively inelastic. Unit (or unitary) elastic.
Relatively Elastic
Quantity/Time
31
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Measure of the responsiveness of the quantity supplied to changes in price Price Elasticity of Supply
Affected by:
Availability of resource substitutes E.g. Gold vs. rice
Momentary (immediate)
32
www.edupristine.com
Imp
EA to B = (0 5) / (0+5)/2 = - 5/2.5 = -5 (15 10)/(15+10)/2 5/12.5
Price 15 A
From point A to C, it is the elastic region. Here a price increase will decrease the total revenue because the %decrease in quantity demanded will be greater then the %increase in This price files has expired
B
at 30-Jun-13
10
Unitary elastic
From point C onwards, it is the inelastic region. Here, a price increase will result in increase in the total revenue because the %decrease in quantity demanded will be lesser then the %increase in price
10
Quantity/Time
33
www.edupristine.com
34
www.edupristine.com
Questions
1. Adam notices that the percentage change in demand for the shoes that his company produces is smaller than the percent change in price that caused the change in demand. If the company reduces the price of shoes the total revenue for the company will most likely Revenue A B C Increases Reduces Demand Elasticity Inelastic Inelastic
Increases
2. The demand for home dcor increases when the average family income of Saunderland increases from $15,000 per annum to $20,000 p.a. The income elasticity for home dcor is
A. Greater than 1
B. Less than 1 C. Between 0 to 1
35
www.edupristine.com
Questions (Cont..)
3. If the number of ice cream bars demanded increases from 10 to 17 when the price decreases from $1.50 to $1.00, the price elasticity of demand and type is: A. -1.49 and relatively inelastic B. -1.3 and relatively elastic C. -1.3 and relatively inelastic
36
www.edupristine.com
Solutions
1. B. Demand elasticity is inelastic when the quantity demanded changes less than the price change that caused that demand. When demand is inelastic the total revenue reduces when the price is reduced. 2. A. The income elasticity is greater than one when the percentage increase in quantity demanded is greater than the percentage increase in income. When the demand for the product increases with increase in the average income the income elasticity is always greater than one. 3. C. If the number of ice-creams demanded changes from 10 to 17 on the price changes from S1.50 io$1.00. the percentage change in quantity is ((10 -17)/(10+17)/2)) = -0.51change in price is (1.50- 1.00) / (1.5+1.00) / 2] =.40. Thus, price elasticity is -0.51/0.4 = -1.3. Since ED => 1 <Ed < 0 in this case hence it is relatively inelastic
37
www.edupristine.com
Agenda
Demand and Supply Analysis: Introduction Demand and Supply Analysis: Consumer Demand Demand and Supply Analysis: The Firm The Firm and Market Structures
38
www.edupristine.com
UQa, Qb Qc......Qn
Where the variables are quantities consumed of goods a through n files has expired at 30-Jun-13 Its is assumed that no This quantities are negative Holding all other quantities constant and increasing one will result in greater utility Utility is an ordinal measure
39
www.edupristine.com
5
C
A B
4
A
3
B
I2
1
C D I1
2 3
4 5 6
7 8
Good X
Indifference curves cannot cross Indifference curve for two goods slopes downwards The figure shows how two indifference curves Indifference curve are convex towards the origin cross each other In the figure when we move to consume more of Two indifference curves for a given individual good Y, we have to compensate by consuming cannot cross because the transitivity less of good X. assumption is violated Slope of the indifference curve is known as That is if U(B)= U(A), and U(B)= U(C), then marginal rate of substitution(MRS) U(A)= U(C)
40
www.edupristine.com
Units of X 14
Units of X 14 20
41
www.edupristine.com
Consumers Equilibrium
The graph shows consumers budget constraint line and some indifference curves of the consumer The indifference curve which is tangent to the budget line is the most preferred consumption bundle This tangent represents consumers equilibrium bundle of goods, the most preferred combination
Good Y 9
5 I2 I1 I0 6 8 Good X
42
www.edupristine.com
T0 T1
The substitution and income effect are both positive, so consumption of the good increases This files has expired The substitution effect is positive but the income effect is highly negative than the substitution effect, so consumption of the good decreases The substitution effect is positive and the income effect is negative but smaller than the substitution effect, so consumption of this good increases
T2 I1 I0
at 30-Jun-13
B0 Q0 Qs Q1
B1
B2 Good X
43
www.edupristine.com
Good Y
Good Y
T2
T2 T0 T1 I1 T1
T0
Q0
Q1 Qs
44
www.edupristine.com
Agenda
Demand and Supply Analysis: Introduction Demand and Supply Analysis: Consumer Demand Demand and Supply Analysis: The Firm The Firm and Market Structures
45
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Cost of passing up next best activity
Normal Profit
Forgone profit on alternative activity which could have taken up
Economic Profit = Revenue Explicit Costs Implicit Costs Accounting Profit: Firm revenue minus expenses over given time period (Does not take implicit costs into
account)
46
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Amount
$450,000
$15,000
$15,000 $5,000 $50,000 $85,000 $395,000 $55,000
47
www.edupristine.com
D
Quantity
Quantity
48
www.edupristine.com
TR P Q
where: TR= total revenue P= price Q= quantity Average revenue is total revenue divided by quantity sold
Price
AR TR/Q
Marginal revenue is increase in total revenue by selling one more unit of a good or service Firms operating in a perfect competitive market will sell all the products at the same price, so that price=AR=MR
49
www.edupristine.com
50
www.edupristine.com
Example
Imp
Calculate the total revenue, average revenue and marginal revenue given the quantity supplied at each price and the demand curve
Qty
2 65
3 55
4 50
5 45
6 40
7 40
Price
8 35
Total Revenue
130 180 220 250 270 280 280
Price 70
Price 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 1 2 3
Quantity
Average Revenue
70 65 60 55 50 45 40 35
Marginal Revenue
70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
MR Quantity 8
7 8
51
www.edupristine.com
Q f ( K , L)
With a given capital an increase in amount of labor employed leads to an increase in total product The output with only one worker is considered the marginal product of the first unit of labor. With the addition of a second labor the total product will increase by the marginal product of the second worker, we can assume marginal product of second labor is likely to be greater than the marginal product of the first and the marginal product of labor is increasing at the lower end of labor input
Production Function
A
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 52
Quantity of labor B
www.edupristine.com
Operating Costs
Total Fixed Costs, TFC Sum of costs that do not vary with level of output. It also includes normal profit. Total Variable Costs, TVC Sum of costs that change with the level of output. Total Costs TFC + TVC Marginal Cost, MC: MC = TC/Q TC = TFC + TVC Change in total cost required to produce an additional unit of output. Average Costs This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 Average Fixed Cost: AFC = TFC/quantity produced Average Variable Cost: AVC = TVC/quantity produced Average Total Cost: ATC = AFC + AVC = TC/quantity produced Sunk Costs Costs that have already been incurred as the result of past decisions.
53
www.edupristine.com
Imp
TC TC=TFC+TVC TVC
120
100 80 60 40
TFC remain constant TVC increases as production increases This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 TC increases as TVC increases
54
www.edupristine.com
Cost Calculation
Imp
Output TFC TVC TC= TFC + TVC AFC= TFC/Q AVC=TVC/Q ATC=TC/Q MC=/\TC//\Q 0 3 5 9 12 200 200 200 200 200 0 100 200 200 300 400 0 67 40 0 33 40 0 100 80 0 33 50 25 33
14
15
200
200
500
600
700
800
14
13
36
40
50
53
50
100
55
www.edupristine.com
Imp
MC always cuts ATC and AVC at their minimum points!
MC = DTC Dq
The vertical distance between the ATC and AVC curves is equal to AFC MC declines initially, then increases
points
Quantity, q
When MC < ATC, ATC will fall. When it equals ATC, ATC will be its lowest point and starts to rise as MC rises.
56
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Cost
AP MP
MP Max MC Min
Output, Total
Labor Marginal and average Product Curves Q1 Q2 Cost curve
Marginal leads Average. When MP is falling and MC is rising after L1 it maxmizes AP and minimizes AVC at Q2. Post this point, both AP starts to fall and AVC starts to rise.
57
www.edupristine.com
Short-Run Loss
In short-run the capital is assumed to be fixed, but in long run all factors of production are variable Break-even output quantity happens: when the total sales cover both fixed and variable costs where P=AR=ATC In the short run a firm would continue operating : If the products are sold for more than its cost AR>AVC If the product is sold for less than its cost, a firm would suffer losses which can be minimized by shutting down the operations If the average revenue is less than the average variable cost the firm is operating at the short-run shutdown point
Price
A firm experiences economic losses when P < ATC When P = AVC, the firm is operating at a shutdown point
MR=P
Quantity A firm will minimize its losses in the short run by continuing to operate when AVC < P < ATC since it
is covering some of its fixed costs from the difference between P and AVC
58
www.edupristine.com
Perfect Competition
Imp
Under perfect competition the relation of shut down point and breakeven point can be explained by way of total revenue(TR) and total cost(TC)
TC=TR at the quantities of Q1 and Q2, which is the break-even point Profit is maximized at the Qmax, where the total revenue exceeds the total cost TC>TR leads to economic losses
59
www.edupristine.com
Short Run
At least one input is fixed
Long Run:
All the inputs are variable, known as planning curves LRAC curve is U-shaped
Economies of Scale: Quantity produced increases by one unit, costs increase by less than one unit Diseconomies of Scale: Quantity produced increases by one unit, costs increase by more than one unit
60
www.edupristine.com
Economies Of Scale
Long Run average total cost
Average Unit Costs
Downward slopping LRATC occurs due to economies of scale. Which eventually become
into play.
This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 minimum, that is the lowest point of LRATC, the point
is known as minimum efficient scale
Q* =optimal O/P (firm size) Output
61
www.edupristine.com
62
www.edupristine.com
Price
150 145 140 135 130 125 120 115
Total revenue
0 145 280 405
Total cost
100 180 305 400
Profits
-100 -35 -25 5
Marginal Revenue(MR)
Marginal Cost(MC)
8
9 10
110
105 100
880
945 1000
920
990 1050
-40
-45 -50
75
65 55
110
70 60
63
www.edupristine.com
O/P
Marginal Pro.
32 30 28
TP
20
decreasing marginal returns = 10 Marginal output/product This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 decrease 8 when additional unit of input is put
6 4
8 0 6 1 2 3 4
MP 2 1 0 6 1 2 3 4 5
Total Product
Marginal Product
64
www.edupristine.com
Marginal leads Average. Hence when MP>AP => AP will rise since MP pulls AP up when MP<AP => AP will fall
65
www.edupristine.com
MRP is the increase in firms total revenue by selling an additional output from employing one more unit of the factor. Profit maximization quantity of an input a is that quantity for which MRPa = Pricea By employing one more unit of an input the firm can increase profits as long as MRPa >Pricea as the revenue earned from this inputfiles is greater than the cost of the input This has expired at 30-Jun-13 If the MRP < Price the firm should decrease the quantity of input employed, even the firm loses revenue but the cost savings are greater MRP of a factor is: marginal product price
The cost minimization function can be defined as :
66
www.edupristine.com
Questions
1. TVs are taxable and recently there supply has became less elastic than demand, who will bear low taxes and what will be impact on deadweight loss
Party bearing low taxes A. Seller B. Buyer C. Buyer Impact on deadweight loss Increase Increase Decrease
2. Government has recently increased taxes on goods which has demand inelasticity. Such a action This files has expired at high 30-Jun-13 will result
A. No reduction in equilibrium quantity produced / sold B. Small reduction in equilibrium quantity produced / sold C. large reduction in equilibrium quantity produced / sold
67
www.edupristine.com
Solutions
1. 2. C. Party with high elasticity will pay low taxes and high inelasticity causes less deadweight loss B. High inelasticity causes less deadweight loss because there is a lack of substitutes causing less effect on equilibrium quantity.
68
www.edupristine.com
Agenda
Demand and Supply Analysis: Introduction Demand and Supply Analysis: Consumer Demand Demand and Supply Analysis: The Firm The Firm and Market Structures
69
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Price
Firms to become price takers with Demand curves taking shape of perfectly elastic Market price will equal to ATC in long term
Demand
Quantity
70
www.edupristine.com
Economic Profit
Economic profit = Total Revenues Opportunity Cost of Production (both explicit costs and implicit costs including cost of capital and normal profit)
Price Economic Profit P MR TR-TC is Maximum MC ATC Revenue (Costs) TC TR
Figure A illustrates that using marginal approach, economic profit is maximized at Quantity Q when MR = MC = P; Figure B shows that using total approach, profit maximization also occurs at Quantity Q when total revenue exceeds total cost by the maximum amount
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 71 www.edupristine.com
MC ATC
P*
P*
MR
Quantity
` MR=P
Quantity
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 73 www.edupristine.com
P1
Firm will shut down at a price below P1 as it will not even be able to realise AVC At P2 the firm is earning a normal profit (economic profit = 0) At prices above P2, firm is making supernormal profits
Will expand production along the MC line. Short-run supply curve for a firm is its MC line firm produces by moving up and down along the supply curve as MC = MR = P
SR market (industry) supply curve is horizontal sum of the MC curves for all firms
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 74 www.edupristine.com
P2 P1 D2
P1 P0
MR1 MR0
Market Firm Short run adjusted to an increase in demand under perfect competition
Figure A:
Demand price and quantity .
Figure B:
As Price firm will earn an economic profit in the short run In the long run firms will increase production and/or new firms will enter Demand increases > Price increases > Profit increases
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 75 www.edupristine.com
Industry
S0
S1
Firm
MC ATC MR1 MR0
P1
P0
P1 P0
Q0
The initial equilibrium is at price P0 and quantity Q0 , earning normal profits With a permanent increase in demandThe demand curve shift to D1 The new market price will be P1 (increases as demand increases) output will increase to Q1 (to meet demand)
In short run since P1 > ATC earning an economic profit With positive economic profit new firms enter the industry which increases total industry supply causing the supply curve shift to S1 and decreasing the price back to P0 eliminating the economic profits
76
www.edupristine.com
Monopoly
A monopoly is characterized by Only 1 seller Price searchers and have imperfect information regarding market demand Specialized product with no substitutes High Barriers to entry (BTE): Following types Legal barriers: Patents, copyrights, government granted franchises Natural barriers: high capital costs and economies of scale or scope, e.g.: electric utility. Price setting strategies include Single price or Price Discrimination Monopoly has downward sloping demand curve Meaning demand will decrease if high prices are fixed or vice versa profit maximization involves a trade-off between price and quantity To maximize profit, monopolists will expand output until MR = MC Demand curve must lie above ATC to earn profits In LR economic profits can exist unlike pure competition markets
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 77 www.edupristine.com
Demand curve must lie above ATC at Q so that price > ATC and firm earn profit Optimal quantity will be in the elastic range of the demand curve.
78
www.edupristine.com
Price
$1200
MC=ATC
D MR files has expired at 30-Jun-13 This Quantity 80 Without Price Discrimination 50 110 190
D Quantity
Price discrimination Q , Economic Profit , Example assumes no fixed costs & constant variable costs so that MC=ATC Total profit is increased to $3,200 from $2400 and total Output is increased from 80 units to 110 units. In price discrimination, where total output remains same, some (shaded) part is converted from CS to monopoly profits Where total output increases (shown above), Some part of deadweight loss also converts into monopoly profits
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 79 www.edupristine.com
Imp
Price S=MC Consumer Surplus Perfect Competition D=MB Efficient Quantity Quantity S=MC Monopoly DWL
Reduction in output Sum of consumer and producer surplus in monopoly is less than that in Perfect competition High prices paid by consumers compared to perfect competition represented by deadweight loss
Difference between Monopoly profit and DWL Monopoly profit is additional which directly goes to the
producer / monopolist (earlier part ofhas Consumer Surplus at This files expired (CS) in Perfect competition) DWL is the loss due to restricted output (difference in quantities of perfect competition and monopoly) this comes from both CS and producers surplus Price discrimination reduces this inefficiency By increasing output and allocating more resources where MR = MC Firm gains from customers with inelastic demand while still providing goods to customers with more elastic demand
Neev Knowledge Management Pristine 80
30-Jun-13Q
Consumer Surplus PM
Monopolys Gain
PC Producer Surplus QM
MR D=MB Quantity
QC
www.edupristine.com
Natural Monopoly
Price Market Demand
Imp
PAC PMC
Natural monopoly occurs when a single supplier brings maximum efficiency of production (minimum ATC) and distribution due to economies of scale and benefits economy
A single-price monopolist will maximize profits by producing where MR = MC, producing quantity Qu & charging Pu. If two firms produced approximately one-half of output QAC
ATC for each firm would be much higher than for a single producer producing QAC Potential gains from monopoly (1) Incentive to innovation (mixed results) (2) Economies of scale and scope
81
www.edupristine.com
82
www.edupristine.com
Imp
MC
MC
ATC
ATC
P* ATC* D MR Quantity Q Short Run O/P decision for a firm Q MR P*, ATC*
Quantity
Firms maximize economic profits at quantity Q production where MR = MC Firm earns positive economic profit because price, P > ATC. Due to Low Barriers to entry competitors will enter the market in long run
New firms entry causes firms demand curve downwards to the point where price equals avg. total cost (P*=ATC*) such that economic profit becomes 0. At this point, there is no longer an incentive for new firms to enter the market creating a LR equilibrium
83 www.edupristine.com
Imp
MC ATC
ATC P D MR Quantity
MR Quantity
In short run, perfect competition firms do not earn economic profit as P=ATC but in monopolistic competition,
firm earns economic profit since P>ATC though optimum quantity occurs when MR = MC in both markets Inefficient allocation of resources : ATC is not at a minimum for the quantity produced Inefficient scale of production: Price is slightly higher than under perfect competition
Imp
Efficiency of monopolistic competition is unclear Consumers benefit from advertising make better purchasing decisions But is it worth the additional cost of advertising is largely subjective Impact of Product innovation: it is necessary Firms that bring new and innovative products face less-elastic demand curves, enabling them to increase price and earn economic profits. However, close substitutes and imitations will cause initial economic profit to disappear in long run Advertising expenses: These are high Create or increase a This perception of differences between products files has expired at 30-Jun-13 Generally it increases ATC curve Due to being relatively fixed cost economies of scale Advertising may also reduce ATC When it causes substantial increase in output where economies of scale bring down overall ATC Demand Curve becomes more elastic, because every firm will advertise Overall, Price reduces, Quantity increases (due to more elastic demand curve) and markup reduces
85
www.edupristine.com
MR curve has a break Any movement of MC curve between the break points will not change output Conclusion Small changes in costs are not significant for Oligopoly Demand curve is more elastic above Pk Price This files has expired at 30-Jun-13
If firm increases price above PK it will lose market share
More Elastic
86
www.edupristine.com
Oligopoly Games
Two suspects, A and B. are believed to have committed a serious crime. However, the prosecutor does not feel that the police have sufficient evidence for a conviction. The prisoners are separated and offered the following deal:
If Prisoner A confesses and Prisoner B remains silent, Prisoner A goes free and Prisoner B receives a 10year prison sentence. If Prisoner B confesses and Prisoner A remains silent, Prisoner B goes free and Prisoner A receives a I0year prison sentence. If both prisoners remain silent, each will receive a 6-month sentence. If both prisoners confess, each will receive a 2-year sentence. has expired at 30-Jun-13 Prisoners' DilemmaThis What files should prisoners do in following case
Prisoner B is silent
Prisoner A is silent
Prison A confesses
Prison B confesses
A gets 10 years B goes free
A gets 2 years B gets 2 years
87
www.edupristine.com
Subsequently, Firm A and Firm B have entered into an collusive agreement to reduce output and earn increased profits. Possible 4 scenarios post this agreement
Firm A Honors
A has an economic loss B earns increased economic profit A earns zero economic profit B earns zero economic profit
Firm A cheats
88
www.edupristine.com
89
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Short run market supply curve is constructed by summing quantities supplied at each price across all firms in the market Supply function under perfect competition : Marginal cost curve above the average variable cost curve No well defined supply function under monopolistic competition, oligopoly and monopoly as all these markets face a downward sloping demand curve For every market the quantity supplied is derived by the intersection of marginal cost and marginal revenue The price charged is then derived by the demand curve the firm faces The quantity supplied depends not on the firms marginal cost also on demand and marginal This files has expired atbut 30-Jun-13 revenue
90
www.edupristine.com
Imp
Sum of squares of the market shares of largest firms Sale of four largest firm Total industry sales Monopolistic competition Large number of owning small market share Oligopoly Monopoly
Market Types: Criteria Market ..type Number of firms Perfect competition Large number of This files firms
Small number of
Single Seller
HHI
< 1000
1000-1800
>1800
10,000
91
www.edupristine.com
Number of Sellers
Many Many
Barriers to Entry
Very Low Low
Few
High
expired at
Very High
Monopoly
One
92
www.edupristine.com
Questions
1. The HHI for the silicon wafer industry in Saunderland is closest to , where rest of industry constitutes 8 firms each with 2.5% market share Company Market Share
A
B
50%
10%
C
D
10%
5% This files has expired at 30-Jun-13
E
RoI
5%
20%
93
www.edupristine.com
Questions (Cont.)
2. The four-firm concentration ratio for the silicon wafer industry in Saunderland is closest to
A. 52% B. 47% C. 75% 3. As a result of increasing labor from 80 to 90 workers, output increased from 800 to 1000 units per day. The marginal product of additional worker is closest to: A. 200 units /day B. 30 units/day C. 20 units/day This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 4. Which of following least accurately describes relationship between different cost curves (ATC= Average Total Cost, AVC = Average Variable Cost and AFC = Average Fixed Costs) A. AFC is downward sloping and ATC and AVC are U Shape B. AFC and ATC is downward slopping and AVC is U shaped C. AFC is downward slopping and ATC follows AVC 5. Marginal product of capital is equal to A. Inputs required for output of on an additional unit B. Additional units of output for one additional unit of capital and labour C. Additional units of output for one additional unit of capital keeping labor constant
94
www.edupristine.com
Question (Cont)
6. A natural monopoly will least likely to exist when A. ATC decreases as production increases B. Few firms are engaged in production C. Large economies of scale are present When regulators force monopolist to follow marginal price, which of the situation is most likely to occur A. Price is fixed where ATC curve intersects the demand curve. B. Price is fixed where MC curve intersects the demand curve. C. Price is fixed where MC = ATC This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 In Monopolistic market, consumer surplus is reduced due to A. High prices are charged and efficient quantity is not produced B. High prices are charged and efficient quantity is produced C. Inefficient resource allocation causing zero deadweight loss
7.
8.
95
www.edupristine.com
Question (Cont)
9. In a Nash equilibrium, a player A will take the best possible action against the player B, given that player B will not make the most optimal choice. The statement is most likely A. Correct, since player A must always make the best possible action B. Incorrect, Both players act in their own self interest, and make a choice assuming that the other person will also make the most optimal decision C. Correct, player A and B must make differing decision to maintain an equilibrium 10. In monopolistic competition and in short run, A. Product innovation (PI) will lead to earn economic profits (EP) whereas advertising (AD) will cause ATC This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 to rise B. PI will have no impact on EP and AD will cause ATC to fall C. PI will decrease EP due to associated costs and AD will cause ATC to rise 11. The following statement best describes the situation when both firms default in above question A. Economic profit is shared equally by both B. Approach to No economic profit C. Economic profit will be higher to the firm which defaults first
96
www.edupristine.com
Question (Cont)
12. Given output of 500 units at total cost of $2,000, fixed cost of $1000 and marginal costs of $2 and market price of $2, to achieve optimum output, a firm operating in perfect competitive markets should
A. Not change its output level B. Reduce output and keep producing C. Increase output to earn high profits keeping price constant 13. Long-run equilibrium condition for a firm in long run can be explained as A. P = MC = ATC. This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 B. P = ATC = TR. C. MC = TR = TC.
97
www.edupristine.com
Solutions
1. B. Herfindahl-Hirschman Index is calculated for the industry as follows: HHI = 502 + 102 + 102 + 52 + 52 + 8 * (2.52) = 2,800 2. C. The four-firm concentration ratio is calculated by taking into consideration the market share for the top 4 firms in the industry. Four-firm concentration = 50 + 10 + 10 + 5 = 75% 3. C. Marginal product is change in output divided by change in input (labor). Here output changed by 200 units & labor changed by 10 workers. Thus, marginal product is 200/10 = 20 units per day 4. B. AFC is downward slopping as AFC decreases for each extra unit of output whereas ATC follows AVC as ATC increases with the changes in AVC. This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 5. C. The marginal product of capital is changes in output for one additional unit of capital, holding quantity of labor constant.
6. B. Natural monopoly occurs when a single supplier brings maximum efficiency of production (minimum ATC) and distribution due to economies of scale and benefits economy.
98
www.edupristine.com
Solutions
7. B. In marginal price policy, prices are fixed when marginal cost intersects demand curve hence monopolist is not able to recover average total costs 8. A. Monopolists produce less than the optimal quantity and charge high prices than what consumer is willing to pay which causes deadweight loss to occur. 9. B. In a Nash equilibrium the player A takes the best possible action given the action of player B and player B takes the best possible action given the action of player A. 10. A. product innovation enables to charge high prices and earn economic profits whereas advertising causes average total costs to rise This P files expired 30-Jun-13 11. B. when both firms default = MC = has ATC causing zeroat economic profits 12. A. Since MR = MC, increasing production will increase MC higher than MR causing losses and decreasing output will lower down overall profit hence keep output unchanged. 13. A. For a competitive firm, long-run equilibrium is where P = MC = ATC. For price-taker firms, P = MR. Competition eliminates economic profits in the long run so that P = ATC
99
www.edupristine.com
Supply (MC)
p *
MC> MB
Stable equilibrium
Quantity
pq p * pc DWL Suppl y (MC) Deman d (MB) PS qc 100 q * Quantity, q (kg) Pric e P
K
EP
%Demand %Price
%Q Supply %Price
MR
Qd
Quantity Implication
Qd Qe Qs
This files has expired at 30-Jun-13 MC always cuts ATC and AVC
Costs at their minimum points! MC = DTC Dq ATC = AFC + AVC Required subsidy (with marginal cost pricing) Price Market Demand
Perfectly inelastic. Relatively inelastic. Unit (or unitary) elastic. Perfectly elastic.
Pu
PAC MR PM
C
ATC D
MC
Qu
Quantity
Quantity
PN
...
MPN MRoutput
QAC QMC Natural Monopoly Average Cost & Marginal Cost Pricing
101
www.edupristine.com