Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Vet John Penrod, with his wife Carol Giardina, carries on the spirit of the Lincoln Brigade at the New York reunion. Page 13.
Photo by Richard Bermack.
NYU ALBA Archives Open for Business, page 2 VALB Reunions from Coast to Coast , page 12
Middle School Poster Project, page 4 Spanish Culture Behind Barbed Wire: 1939-1945 by
Three Wars Couldn't Stop Fred Stix, page 7 Francie Cate-Arries, book review, page 16
I
To a grief as old as the ages.
n January 2003, while Bush and and Latin America in the ‘30s, Pablo
Blair were strapping on their hol- Neruda, Federico Garcia Lorca, and Always—in the eyes of the un-
sters, Sam Hamill, a peaceful poet Antonio Machado. bearable Bush or with this small
in Port Townsend, Washington, let Hamill had lived quietly on the child—it is the eyes. Many of Hamill’s
some poets know that their response Olympic Peninsula beside Port heroes—Homer, Milton, Borges—have
to the mounting war talk would be Townsend for 30 years without any been blind. What he sees is what he
welcome. Right away, quicker on previous invitation to read at the hears. At the end of “Eyes Wide
the draw than Bush and his side- University of Washington. It was Open,” we are told to listen.
kick, 11,000 poems shot through the about time. The invitation coincides But
internet. The Nation, in conjunction with his charming self-description: Listen. And you will hear her
small, soft, plaintive voice
with Thunder’s Mouth Press, quickly “thrust on an international stage with
it’s already there within you
published a sampling—263 pages Poets Against the War after living 30 a heartbeat, a whisper,
of poems. Since then the original years in the woods with my nose in a a promise broken
submission has doubled to 20,000. Chinese dictionary.” if only you listen
I’ll leave you to check in at http:// Not exactly. Poetry has its activists with your eyes wide open.
www.poetsagainstthewar.org/. Feel as surely as politics do. From his post The soft-spoken poet insists on be-
free to submit your own poems. on the Olympic Peninsula—Chinese ing heard, and as Abe Osheroff
On March 3, 2006, just about three dictionary notwithstanding—Hamill pointed out in remarks that followed
years after Bush declared his “mission has been as active in his domain as Sam Hamill’s reading, poetry, the
accomplished,” Sam Hamill, the ge- Reed and Osheroff have been in theirs. kind you hear and sing, has always
nius behind Poets Against the War, He is a translator and an editor, for figured in popular movements. In
was invited to deliver the first annual years he was the publisher at the Spain in 1937 and in Nicaragua in
Bob Reed-Abe Osheroff-ALBA lecture Copper Canyon Press, and he is con- 1985, literacy rates were low and rever-
at the University of Washington in stantly a working poet. That’s activism. ence for the poets was high. In both
Seattle. Sam Hamill, a Zen Buddhist Above all, it is the poetry itself cases, poetry was more frequently
and a pacifist, explained that “what that gives definition to his activism. heard than seen, more frequently sung
the Lincoln Brigade stood for we must “What you read,” says Hamill, “is than read. This has been a constant
stand for.” There is no contradiction what you feed your soul.” His audi- theme for Osheroff. In an exhibition of
between the willingness of men like ence was particularly well-fed at the Spanish Civil War posters called
Bob Reed (who died in Seattle a year University of Washington on March 3. “Shouts From the Wall” and in his re-
ago) and Abe Osheroff (who was very In “State of the Union, 2003” cent documentary film, Art in the
much alive at the speaker’s right hand Hamill is bitter: Struggle for Freedom, poetry and picto-
that night) to go to Spain together in Soon, the President will speak. rial images speak to the hearts and
1937 and vigorously oppose Bush’s He will have something to say minds of a people engaged in struggle.
about bombs
war 70 years later. There is no question: Sam Hamill,
and freedom and our way of life.
The selection of Hamill by the or- I will turn the tv off. I always do. his 20,000 friends, along with the stu-
ganizers of the lecture, including Abe Because I can’t bear to look dents, faculty and citizen-activists of
Osheroff, Tony Geist, and Peter Carroll at the monuments in his eyes. Seattle, are fine companions for Bob
of ALBA, was entirely appropriate. In a poem called “Eyes Wide Reed and Abe Osheroff at the begin-
Sam Hamill ascribes his lineage as an Open” he is tender as he regards a ning of this new series of lectures.
“engaged poet” to Euripides in ancient photograph of a small girl, probably Joe Butwin teaches English at the
Greece, John Milton in 17th century Middle Eastern: University of Washington.
England, his friend Tom McGrath in With her eyes wide open,
Deep brown beautiful eyes
THE VOLUNTEER June 2006 1
NYU Archive Open and Accessible
By Michael Nash
T
he three-year project to preserve
and catalog the entire Abraham
Lincoln Brigade archive at New
York University’s Tamiment Library
has been successfully completed.
The collection is now fully open for
research. This extensive work was
funded by the federal government’s
National Endowment for Humanities.
The ALBA collection is the largest
and most important group of histori-
cal materials documenting American
participation in the Spanish Civil War.
It contains more than 400 boxes of cor-
respondence, papers, and
memorabilia; 100 reels of microfilm;
nearly 200 oral histories; 5,000 photo-
graphs; more than 250 posters; and unteers’ experiences after they came to try to locate and identify collections
several dozen artifacts documenting home, their activities during World of Lincoln Brigade materials that re-
the life stories of the veterans and the War II, the McCarthy period witch main with the families of the veterans.
history of the Lincoln Brigade from hunts, and political activism in the We recently acquired the photographs
the 1930s to the present. 1950s, 60s, and 70s. that Benjamin Katine took in Spain
The most valuable and unique The other major portion of the ar- when he was working as a photogra-
portion of the archive consists of more chive is the so-called “Moscow pher for the Lincoln Brigade. If you
than 240 collections of papers acquired microfilm.” At the end of the Spanish know about additional Lincoln
from the veterans and their families. Civil War, the official archives of the Brigade collections that are still in pri-
These materials are extraordinarily di- international brigades were taken to vate hands, please contact ALBA’s
verse in content. A large number focus Moscow for safekeeping. In the 1990s, executive director, Julia Newman: ex-
on the experiences of individual vol- ALBA microfilmed the portion relat- emplaryone@aol.com; (212) 674-5398.
unteers in Spain, while others describe ing to the Lincoln Brigade. This film For further information about the
administrative issues, recruitment of contains the records of the Military Lincoln Brigade archive and access to
the volunteers, organization of the Commission and Communist Party the collection’s finding aids, visit the
medical corps, and battlefield strate- organizations, correspondence with Tamiment Library’s website at http://
gies and tactics. These files contain the Comintern, personnel files, and www.nyu.edu/library/bobst/re-
rich descriptions of the volunteers’ re- files relating to command, transport, search/tam/collections.html#alba.
lationships with the Spanish people, finance, training, prisoners, and mili- More than 1,500 photographs tak-
their impressions of the political situa- tary medicine. It also contains a en by Harry Randall during the
tion in Spain, and the ways in which photographic collection and records of Spanish Civil War are now available
they connected the Spanish Civil War the concentration camps established in on-line through the library’s website.
to the larger antifascist struggle. Many Spain at the end of the Spanish Civil The Tamiment Library is located
of these collections document the vol- War, where many International at 70 Washington Square South on the
Brigaders and Spanish soldiers were 10th floor of NYU’s Bobst Library in
Michael Nash, an ALBA board member, is
incarcerated. Greenwich Village.
head of the Tamiment Library.
The Tamiment Library continues
T
his spring, students at Middle
School 331 in the South Bronx
got a taste of history that is
not typically covered in their 7th
grade textbooks. Thanks to a grant
from the Puffin Foundation, ALBA
arranged with the arts-in-educa-
tion non-profit Marquis Studios to
provide a poster design residency
that centered on studying propa-
ganda posters created by Spanish
Republicans during the Civil War.
Students focused on the messages
and ideas that defined that turbulent
period in Spanish history. They then
used their observations to create post- ry of the war and an introduction to better able to understand the power of
ers dealing with pressing the basics of graphic design and the art in times of war. Throughout the
contemporary issues. Mixing basics of purpose of propaganda. After the in- creative process, students repeatedly
design and visual arts with history troductory lessons, Mr. Hudnall spent revisited the posters introduced by
and politics, teaching artist Clayton four lessons working with the school’s Mr. Hudnall so they could create au-
Hudnall led an unconventional but arts specialist, Ms. Jaar, teaching stu- thentic, convincing drawings and
enriching series of history lessons. dents about artistic choices such as designs. Using pastels, the class
brought its own posters to life. The
finished products warned against
drug use and promoted cancer re-
By studying the persuasive techniques employed search and clean air policies, all topics
in the government propaganda posters, that resonate with urban youth today.
Marquis Studios chose MS 331 to
participants were better able to understand the receive the ALBA funding because
power of art in times of war. the students were of an age at which
they could grasp the complexities be-
hind both the Spanish Civil War and
the very idea of propaganda and its
Over the course of 13 weeks, stu- hue, value, chroma, scaling, line quali- purposes. This understanding was
dents worked on crafting targeted ty and roughing out. For the last four vital to the success of the residency,
messages and paired them with classes, the class worked on producing as much of the class centered on dis-
graphic designs inspired by elements the posters while reviewing the causes cussion of historical events, motives,
seen in the Spanish Civil War posters and ramifications of the Civil War. and outcomes.
they viewed from the ALBA website By studying the persuasive tech-
archives {www.alba-valb.org}. The niques employed in the government Keija Parssinen has worked with the
first five classes centered on the histo- propaganda posters, participants were Marquis Studio team since 2004.
W
hen Madison, Wisconsin,
voted by a better than
2-1 margin April 4
New York
to call for the immediate with-
drawal of U.S. troops from Iraq, Vets Cheer
it was another reminder of the
wisdom of Clarence Kailin.
Now well into his ninth decade,
Peace and
this native Madisonian has always
had faith in Madison’s progressive
Justice
potential. So it came as no surprise
that he gathered more signatures than Parade
just about anyone else to get the anti-
war referendum to the ballot. As has
been the case in every progressive
struggle of the past 70 years–from the
fight against Franco’s fascism in 1936
Spain to the fight against George W.
Bush’s high crimes and misdemean-
ors in 2006 America–Clarence Kailin
has been in the lead.
Tonight, his life and legacy will
be recognized at the Socialist Potluck
dinner at the Wil-Mar Center on
Jenifer Street, beginning at 5:30 p.m.
The event is open to all who bring a
dish to pass and who want to cele-
brate a life that has, for the majority
of Madison’s 150 years, enriched and
emboldened this city. Moe Fishman greets peace marchers outside the VALB office on Broadway. Matti
— From The Capital Times, Mattson and George Sossenko hold banner, below. Photos by George Cohen.
Madison, Wisconsin, April 8, 2006.
A
fter a lifetime of drifting farm. By the time he was 17, he ran off
from place to place, Fred Stix to join the circus in search of a more
doesn’t have a lot of personal adventurous life. “I liked that life-
possessions. As a matter of fact, he style. I was making 50 cents a day
doesn’t have much more than he left and I only had to work 18-hour days,”
home with more than 70 years ago. he jokes. “I’m a drifter by nature and
He doesn’t ask for much. A self de- so it suited me.”
scribed “hobo” (don’t call him a bum, While working in New York, an
a hobo is willing to work for his keep), even more exciting opportunity en-
Stix says he’s living the good life. He ticed Stix. Recruiters were looking for
has three meals a day--a luxury he volunteers for the Spanish Army. He
couldn’t always count on--and he’s enlisted in 1937 at the age of 23. “It
pleased to have a war bed to sleep on. was a chance to get out and see the
In a weathered antique footlocker, world, you know, see Europe and all
Stix keeps three wars’ worth of memo- of that. I guess it was foolish at the
ries. The locker holds two Bronze Stars time. We were radical. We never
and a Purple Heart--the only one he thought of the danger part. And be-
received out of the many that he could sides, I was always a believer in
have earned. It holds prisoner of war democracy,” he says. U.S. Army uniform. He was sent to a
dog tags stamped “Stalag 11.” There is During combat in the Spanish base near London and was thrilled to
lead that was taken out of his hand Civil War, Stix sustained injuries to spend his liberty in the capital city, de-
and shrapnel from a Chinese grenade his chest and thumb, where he still spite occasional air raids.
that was removed from his hip. There has copper from a bullet. He was “I had a pretty enjoyable life,” he
are telegrams written to his mother eventually captured and held as a says. “But then we found out we were
declaring him missing in action. prisoner of war for two years. For her- going to be part of an invasion in
The only gold in the case is from oism and service, he was awarded a North Africa. The pleasant times
Stix’s time as a ’59er. He’d traveled to box of chocolates. “We were supposed were over.” Stix was part of an ill-
Alaska the year it was granted state- to be fighting for an ideal, not awards. equipped, out-numbered Allied force
hood and collected a few small I liked the chocolates. You know, you near Tunis. His unit was attacked by
chunks as a prospector. To Stix, the get them and hand them around and Erwin Rommel’s German Panzers.
items in the locker remind him that he they’re gone,” Stix says, laughing. “He hit us very hard at night with
is fortunate to have survived. He returned to the United States tanks. We had nothing but rifles.
Stix has returned to his hometown and continued the life of a drifter until They chopped us up. There was noth-
of Suring, Wisconsin, for his final bat- World War II broke out. Impatient for ing we could do. You could shoot at
tle. This time, it’s with cancer. “I’m the United States to join the war, he them if they were at their turrets--
amazed I’ve lasted this long,” he says volunteered in the Canadian infantry and I did. But you can’t do anything
with a chuckle. “And these people in 1939 and was sent to Europe to fight against a tank,” Stix says.
[staff at the nursing home] take care of on the front lines. With no commander and no other
me real good.” In 1942, Britain agreed to transfer alternatives, Stix fled into the desert
Stix’s early decisions were not un- U.S.-born soldiers back to their coun- and hid in a cave for two or three
common among his generation. Born try’s military. It was the first time in days. Scavenging Arabs finally found
in 1914, he dropped out of school at an his fighting career that Stix wore a Continued on page 8
C
onceptual artist Francesc Torres fought in the war or witnessed it are cavate the mass graves and remains of
began a project to excavate the very old. The worst part is that they the unburied victims, but his project
remains of Spanish Civil War may be condemned to not seeing the was blocked, first by a conservative
dead as a citizen activist. “I wanted to process come full circle. They may die nationalist government and then by a
reduce to zero the distance between without seeing some closure.” Torres leftist government. “Both sides fear
artist and activist. I was outraged. worries that if they get no closure, the the political upheaval that might result
Thirty-thousand people are buried nation may never have legitimate clo- from bringing out the past,” he states.
like dogs on the side of roads or un- sure, and the ancestors of those who To carry the project forward, he joined
der shopping malls in unmarked experienced the war will live forever up with the Association for the
graves … If you know where to look, with “corpses in their cupboards.” Recuperation of Historical Memory.
you can find artillery shells mixed in Torres was born in 1948. His “They had a team and no money, and I
with bones right on the earth’s sur- grandfather, a former politician, was had money but no team.” The
face, just left there to rot.” And not arrested during the war and put on tri- Association is a grassroots organization
only the bodies have rotted, according al with 60 other defendants. In a trial of relatives trying to find the remains of
to Torres, but with them the histori- lasting 20 minutes, he was sentenced to their ancestors. Torres had intended a
cal psyche of Spain, with wounds that die. Later, he was retried and the death project based on historical context and
may never heal. “Time is running sentence changed to life in prison. The exhuming military sites, but he ended
out,” he warns. “There is a narrow grandfather was eventually released up working with the relatives.
window before the people who lived after spending 10 years in prison. Why did the progressive govern-
A photographic mosaic taken during the excavation of a Spanish Civil War common grave, July 2004. The grave contained the
remains of 47 male civilians killed by a paramilitary fascist group in September 1936. The photo on the next page shows a hand
holding an empty rifle bullet casing.
10 THE VOLUNTEER June 2006
the people who fought and died to de-
fend the legitimate government have
been removed from the historical con-
science.” The left has to pay the price
of living with “a sequestered history,
and if you don’t own your own history
then you can’t deal with it properly.”
And without reconciliation, the
Spanish people may never have a uni-
fying historical narrative. They will
live like two nations, tranquil on the
surface but ready to explode emotion-
ally at the drop of a word.
“We need to dig,” Torres states. By
that he means uncovering the history
of the war through documentaries and
Continued on page 15
ment block his project, and why does
it continue to put up obstacles? The
one thing that unifies the left and the
Barcelona Artist Francesc Torres
right is their shame and their mutual
desire not to upset a delicate balance,
Presents ALBA-Susman Lecture
Torres explains. “The right was moral- Francesc Torres, one of Spain’s hibition based on the holdings of
ly and ethically bankrupt when most important conceptual artists ALBA, focusing on the participation
Franco died, and the left had to watch and the current holder of the King of African Americans in the Spanish
an enemy die [without ever being able Juan Carlos I of Spain Chair at New Civil War.
to hold him acountable]. When the na- York University, presented the Torres has recently been involved
tion transitioned from dictatorship to eighth annual ALBA-Bill Susman in several of the projects in Spain that
democracy and held its first election lecture, “The Retrieval of Memory in aim to recover the country’s histori-
after the death of Franco, there was an Contemporary Spain,” at the cal memory by exhuming the
unwritten pact between politicians of Cervantes Institute in New York on unmarked mass graves from the
both sides that neither would remind May 16. time of the Spanish Civil War. His
the other of what was done. Everyone Torres, a pioneering figure in talk focused on one such project.
could now be a good democrat, no the field of installation art, has a The lecture was introduced by
matter what their history. They are long-standing interest in the James D. Fernández, Director of
waiting for generations that fought the Spanish Civil War. One of his best NYU’s King Juan Carlos I of Spain
war to be gone, and then the civil war known works, currently part of the Center, and Antonio Muñoz Molina,
will be just like the Spanish American permanent collection of the Reina Director of the Instituto Cervantes
War.” Sofía Museum in Madrid, Spain, is a in New York.
But before the war passes into an- vast installation titled “Belchite/ Previous lecturers in the series
cient history, Torres continues, “We South Bronx.” The installation juxta- have included Bernard Knox,
need to surgically open the wounds or poses images of a Spanish city Gabriel Jackson, Baltasar Garzón, E.
the patient will never heal. The right devastated during the Civil War L. Doctorow, Philip Levine, Grace
had 40 years to take care of their vic- with images of urban blight in the Paley, and Antonio Muñoz Molina.
tims and to preserve their history, but South Bronx. Like much of Torres’s The lecture is co-sponsored by
work, it is a profound meditation on ALBA, Tamiment Library, the
Richard Bermack is the art director of The history, violence, and modern ruins. Cervantes Institute, and the King
Volunteer and the author of The Frontlines While at NYU, Torres has been Juan Carlos I of Spain Center.
of Social Change: Veterans of the Abraham developing a proposal for a new ex-
Lincoln Brigade.
THE VOLUNTEER June 2006 11
Lincoln Vets and V
Deliver Anti-W
from Coas
I remember back, before we
whacked Iraq,
I was watching the news.
Were we gonna attack?
A man named Richard Pearl
Veteran anti-war folk singer Barbara Dane with Bruce Barthol. came on and talked.
Photos by Richard Bermack.
B
ruce Barthol’s song Cakewalk of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade on from Cakewalk to Baghdad,
to Baghdad delivered a load March 12. The program paid tribute
written and perfomed by
of irony, while other songs to Veterans for Peace for their work on
carried more truths about war, in a the front lines against the U.S. inva- Bruce Barthol
remarkable musical performance, Continued on page 14
Bay Area vets (l-r) Coleman Persily, Clifton Amsbury, Ted Veltfort, Milt Wolff, Hilda Roberts, Virginia Malbin, Nate
Thornton, and Dave Smith at the podium. Associate Heather Bridger holds the mike.
O
n the gloriously bright
Sunday afternoon of April
30, one day after hundreds
of thousands of peace demonstra-
tors marched through the streets
of Manhattan, the Veterans of the
Abraham Lincoln Brigade gathered
for their 70th annual reunion to
Veterans for Peace president David Cline speaks at the New York event.
honor Veterans for Peace and other
antiwar activists. To thunderous ap- meaningful. On that same stage, be- president of the United States.
plause, our Lincolns were honored hind the same podium, Abraham The eight heroic veterans pres-
and praised by friends, family and Lincoln delivered a masterful rebuttal ent—Moe Fishman, Al Koslow, Jack
loyal supporters at this celebration, to the claims of his opponents, insist- Shafran, Matti Mattson, John Penrod,
held at the Cooper Union audito- ing that slavery was unconstitutional. Abe Smorodin, George Sossenko, and
rium in downtown New York City. This historic speech made Lincoln his Hy Tabb—remind us of the great sac-
The venue of the event was quite party’s candidate and then, of course, rifices over 3,000 young men and
women made to fight fascism. Moe
Fishman and Henry Foner, as always,
energized the 800-plus members of
the audience. The guest speakers, all
major voices for peace and democracy
in the 21st century, paid their respects
to the Lincoln veterans, each adding
his or her personal touch. Spanish
Magistrate Baltasar Garzón, Veterans
for Peace President David Cline, and
anti-war activist Cindy Sheehan kept
the audience focused on the issues of
peace today. Songs Against War: Voices of
Anti-Warriors, a musical performance
passionately presented by Barbara
Dane and Bruce Barthol, completed an-
other successful celebration paying
tribute to the American fighters whose
legacy will protect freedom and de-
New York vets (l-r) George Sossenko, Abe Smorodin, Jack Shafran, John Penrod, Al mocracy until the end of time.
Koslow, Matti Mattson, Hy Tabb, and Moe Fishman (on stage).
sion and occupation of Iraq. Many of Brigade. Bay Area Post Commander
the Lincoln Brigade vets who took to Dave Smith introduced the vets in at-
the stage connected the fight against tendance, including Clifton Amsbury,
fascism in Spain 70 years ago to the Virginia Malbin, Coleman Persily,
current opposition to the war in Iraq. Hilda Roberts, David Smith, Nate
This year’s event was held at the Thornton, Ted Veltfort, and Milt Wolff.
Florence Schwimley Little Theater at ALBA’s Peter Carrol served as master
Berkeley High School in Berkeley, of ceremonies.
California, drawing an audience of ap- Three representatives of Veterans Vet Milt Wolff with Wanda Henig.
proximately 500. As in recent years, for Peace spoke: Paul Cox, a Marine
the Abraham Lincoln Brigade who returned from the war in beyond. Singer Barbara Dane, who
Archives (ALBA) co-sponsored the Vietnam to organize active-duty GIs worked with the GI resistance move-
event with the Bay Area Veterans and against the war at Camp Lejeune; ment during the Vietnam war years,
Friends of the Abraham Lincoln Mike Wong, who twice refused army delivered a performance that careened
orders for Vietnam, landing first in from laughter to grief. She was accom-
the stockade and later in Canada; and panied by Barthol and musicians from
Steve Morse, an army veteran of the San Francisco Mime Troupe in a
Vietnam who was inspired to speak spirited performance that had the au-
out against war when he heard about dience on its feet.
the ambulances that Veterans of the Funds raised at the event will sup-
Abraham Lincoln Brigade were send- port ALBA, Veterans for Peace, and the
ing to Nicaragua. monument to the Lincoln veterans on
The musical program, written by the Embarcadero in San Francisco, as
Bruce Barthol and directed by Peter well as the Pablo Solare Pediatric
Glazer, linked the anti-war sentiment Hospital in Havana, the Center for
Liberty Ellman, one of the musicians in of earlier wars, from the French and Constitutional Law, Global Exchange,
Songs Against War: Voices of Anti-Warriors, Indian War (Johnnie I Hardly Knew and the San Francisco Mime Troupe.
with his grandmother, the sister of Ye) to Vietnam (Fixin’ To Die Rag) and
Lincoln vet Wilfred Mendelson.
14 THE VOLUNTEER June 2006
Torres
Continued from page 11
One of the excavation project's volunteers wears a Another man with a backpack passes him
T-shirt that says "Anti-fascist Always."
There needs to be a process of reconciliation. on the way to the platform,
According to Torres, Spain needs a truth and
a man who doesn’t smile, even as they almost collide.
reconciliation commission similar to that in South
Africa, eastern Europe, and South America. In He makes a mental note to find a more likely partner
those countries, those responsible just need to ac-
knowledge publicly what they did to their victims for the slight meal he had planned to share.
and that is enough for them to be given amnesty
and to return their dignity. The process is not The train arrives, one that will offer a comfortable seat
about vengeance; it is about catharsis, and that
benefits both sides. ”If they can do it in Bosnia, for him to dream in, arms to hold him,
we can do it,” he states.
The International Center for Photography is
peace in this world and the next.
considering including Torres’s photos of the civil
war remains and excavation in an exhibit of from The Long Night of Flying,
Sixteen Rivers Press, 2006
Robert Capa’s photos. “Capa photographed the
war and I photographed the aftermath, 70 years
later,” Torres states.
A
t the close of Spain’s Civil War, amines the literature and art produced Bartra; essays by Joaquín Xirau; the vi-
when the embattled Republic through the mid 1940s by former sual arts of Josep Bartolí and
finally fell to Francoist forces, camp inmates who eventually immi- Remedios Varo; oral histories collected
nearly 500,000 Republican refugees grated to Mexico. Focusing on works by Margarita Nelken; and the poetry
flooded across Spain’s borders into
exile. More than half of these exiles Instead of honoring those Republicans who had valiantly
found themselves rounded up into
fought against Franco, the French state fashioned the exiles
improvised French refugee camps,
where they faced horrific condi-
as “red hordes,” "vermin,” and social undesirables, thus
tions including insufficient or absent constructing the Republicans as criminal prisoners instead of
shelter, starvation, forced labor, and political refugees.
physical and psychological abuse at
the hands of the French gendarme.
Francie Cate-Arries’s book about published in Mexico, this volume com- of Celso Amieva, particularly his
the cultural artifacts produced by plements Sebastiaan Faber’s Exile and beautiful and unjustly overlooked La
Spanish exiles in response to the Cultural Hegemony: Spanish Intellectuals almohada de arena (1960).
French concentration camp experience in Mexico, 1939-1975. Spanish Culture One senses that Cate-Arries must
speaks to and arouses a sense of out- Behind Barbed Wire is a prelude to the have felt an ethical injunction to in-
rage at how the French state treated Faber book in that it sets out to explore clude every piece of French
the men and women who had resisted the complex, constitutive function of concentration camp literature pro-
the fascist onslaught that would only the camps in exile literature as either a duced in the 1940s. The extent of the
too soon swoop murderously down on key commemorative place of remem- production, and indeed Cate-Arries’s
the French themselves. Instead of hon- brance; as grounds for moral authority collection of it, invites our admiration
oring those Republicans who had and political legitimacy as the site of while simultaneously proving a bit
valiantly fought against Franco, the creative resistance and cultural renew- overwhelming at moments.
French state fashioned the exiles as al; or as an arena for a polarized, The book opens with a consider-
“red hordes,” "vermin,” and social un- embattled struggle for emigration to ation of how many Spanish exiles
desirables, thus constructing the America. oriented their own narratives of mem-
Republicans as criminal prisoners in- The close readings of a wide range ory and loss through recollections
of artistic and literary genres are one (many of them historically inaccurate)
Gina Herrmann teaches Spanish of the major strengths of this work. of the highly charged symbolic death
literature at the University of Oregon. Positing that the exile community in Continued on page 17
in Collioure of the great canonical poet the deleterious and the strength-giv- tions of life in the camps and in
Antonio Machado. All the remaining ing effects of what Amieva and other pre-World War II France make graphic
sections of the work recuperate far less- prisoners wittily called “arenosis,” both the depravity of the French in the
er known works of the Spanish and Cate-Arries remarks: “Amieva’s lyrical face of the Spanish tragedy and the ab-
Catalan literary exiles. imagery of the sand as weapon, the solute terror experienced by the
The central thesis operative in sand as subterfuge, is not just another refugees as they confronted the dan-
Spanish Culture Behind Barbed Wire is metaphor. . . .Inmate-memoirists have gers of camp life and the threat of
the notion that the camps were not described their internment as being repatriation to Franco’s Spain.
merely life-sapping, barren, prison buried alive [. . . but] the refugees use There is little to criticize in this
landscapes, but also communal me- this same sand to transgress the limi- book. I felt the lack of a historical sum-
morial sites that served to help tations of their captivity. . . .Perhaps mary of the particulars of the
inmates reconstitute self and nation.
This constructive, as opposed to de-
structive, valence permeates the study: The central thesis operative in Spanish Culture Behind Barbed
the camps are read as lived spaces “of Wire is the notion that the camps were not merely life-sapping,
subversion, resistance, and agency”
that become memorial sites and there-
barren, prison landscapes, but also communal memorial sites
fore discursive vehicles for creative that served to help inmates reconstitute self and nation.
expression.
Dividing her research into four
major sections, Cate-Arries explores even more significant than the sand’s “concentrationary universe” estab-
the camps as “lieux de memoir,” spac- capacity to externalize forms of artis- lished in France between 1939 and the
es of Spanish moral authority in a tic expression is its power to aid and end of World War II. The introduction
Europe (particularly France) still in abet the inmates’ efforts to cover up could have been strengthened by the
denial about the threat of Fascism, forms of political or cultural resis- inclusion of a list of the camps, their
universes of cultural resistance, and tance.” Through her complex reading geographical locations, descriptions of
sites that manifest the fractured rela- of sand, a single trope prevalent in the conditions in each camp, and sta-
tionships among the many Republican much of the exile literature, Cate- tistics on numbers of inmates released
groups in exile. Arries manages to connect her close throughout the camp’s duration, in-
Cate-Arries is a superb reader readings back to her overarching mate deaths, and their causes.
clearly invested in the affective quality agenda to reveal the concentration Given the obvious dominance of
of the texts she closely analyzes. camps as repositories of suffering and Catalan cultural production in this
Evidence of this is found in her re- death, but also as spaces of political particular body of exile texts, I would
markable discussion of sand in the continuity, ethical and artistic renew- have expected the author to give more
chapter on the poems of Celso al, and as demarcated locales of attention to the distinctions of Catalan
Amieva. fraternity and resistance. experience and expression. This is a
Many of the concentration camps In addition to the chapter on minor point given the ambitious scope
were located on the French shoreline, Amieva, perhaps the most remarkable of Cate-Arries’s project. She has done
where the inmates faced the devastat- section of the book is the chapter de- Peninsular Studies an important ser-
ing effects of blowing sand. Her voted to the stunning sui generis vice by inserting more than 50 works
treatment of the various ways the “memory album” Campos de concen- of exile literature and history—many
camp inmates narrate both their strug- tración, composed of 65 drawings by of them little known, if not utterly ne-
gles and their inventive, creative uses Josep Bartolí accompanied by the text glected by the criticism—into the
of sand echoes the very lyricism on of Narcís Molins i Fábrega. Bartolí’s frame of our discipline.
which she comments. Describing both grotesque and often humorous depic-
Louis H. Gordon
(1915-2006)
Louis H. Gordon, the popular
New York brigadista, passed away at
Max Shufer his home on March 25.
(1914-2006) Lou was born in Brooklyn, gradu-
ated from Boys’ High School, then
Lincoln vet Max Shufer, 91, a resi- went to work as a union organizer for
dent of Pawling, N.Y., died at home on the Pulp, Sulphite & Paper Mill
Friday, March 31. He was the husband Workers (today, part of the United
of Shirley (Aldor) Shufer. Steelworkers of America). It was while
Max sailed for Spain in June 1937. attending the Labor Relations School
He was captured by the Franco army of Cornell University in 1937 that he
in March 1938 and spent over a year as learned of the plight of the Spanish
a prisoner of war until he was ex- people and decided to go to Spain. He
changed in April 1939. served on the Cordoba and Aragon
Max was a physicist and electronic fronts and was wounded during the
engineer at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Ebro battle.
Institute in New York City for over 30 Lou was a regular attendee at re- delegation were amazed to learn that
years. Before that, his service in Spain unions of the Lincoln and Lou had participated in the liberation
earned him a place on the government International Brigades. During the of the Dachau concentration camp in
blacklist (see The Volunteer, Winter Homenaje in 1996, he surprised the April 1945 as a sergeant in the Combat
2001). Amigos who had organized the event Engineers of the Seventh US Army. At
Born in Manhattan on September in Madrid. At one point a group of the table was the daughter of an
7, 1914, he was the son of the late young madrileños accompanied Irish Austrian IB veteran who had survived
Solomon Shufer and Anna Katz and American brigadistas on a night years in the camp and had been liber-
Shufer. He attended the Morris School out. Little did they suspect that their ated by Lou’s unit. The daughter
in New York City and later attended Lincoln veteran was a noted harmoni- Continued on page 19
Fort Eustis, Virginia and I hope you’ll find time to contin- now. I’ll close—regards to all around.
Dec. 8, 1941 ue them. Take care of yourself. If you want to
Dear Moe [Fishman]— Should I be transferred to any know anything about anything to do
Possibly recent events and the new place I will notify you of my with me, my wife is secretary and
Declaration of War against Japan can new address. Also, remember how treasurer of the Paper Union Local
best answer the question of my atten- important packages are away from 107-54 E. 13th Street - Gr. 3- 1469. Pay
dance at the Xmas dance. I’ll try to home. After all someone has to feed her a visit—she’s a good lookin
have my wife attend for me. the censors! blonde. (That should do it.)
Things are happening very fast Being in Anti-aircraft will proba- Salud y Victoria
in these parts, as you might well bly mean plenty of action—of a new Lou
imagine. I believe the Army and type to me, but I’m used to loud nois- Btry B-6th Bn.
Navy are geared high enough to es—if that’s possible. Fort Eustis, Va. (spell it right now)
cope with this and any future situa- Manila is getting a taste of avion
tion. Most of us here believe war
with Germany and Italy will fol-
low—also war between the Soviet
Union and Japan. George & Ruth
There is a feeling of calm, quiet Songs and Letters of the Spanish Civil War
confidence in the air. No excitement,
no running around, no joking—just a An intimate view of the lives of George Watt, a
serious business which must be fin- Lincoln Brigade volunteer, and his bride, Ruth
ished in the quickest possible Rosenthal Watt, a peace and social justice activist
manner. supporting the anti-fascist struggle from New York
Everyone feels that we are doing City, brings the 1930s to life. This dramatic reading
the right and only thing—and since of letters exchanged between George and Ruth is
the camp sent an enormous amount interwoven with rousing songs of the era that pro-
of men to Pearl Harbor, Schofield vide a political and historical context to the anti-fascist struggle.
Barracks and other Near Eastern bas- Music is performed by Tony Saletan, accompanied by Sylvia
es it strikes close to home, it’s more Miskoe. Letters are read by Dan and Molly Lynn. Watt.
personalized.
To order the 2-CD set, go to:
I guess most of our guys will be
www.cdbaby.com/cd/georgeandru-
in the service pretty soon—those
th.
that can possibly make it. You’ll
probably have to hold up jobs for ten Or contact Dan Lynn Watt directly to
men yourself. You can do it, I’m sure. order CDs or to book a performance.
I appreciate greatly your letters 617-354-8242 or dwatt40@comcast.net
WWW.ALBA-VALB.ORG
BOOKS ABOUT THE LINCOLN BRIGADE Passing the Torch: The Abraham
Lincoln Brigade and its Legacy of Hope
The Spanish Civil War: A Very Short Introduction
by Anthony Geist and Jose Moreno
by Helen Graham
Another Hill
Member of the Working Class
by Milton Wolff
by Milton Wolff
Our Fight—Writings by Veterans of the
Fighting Fascism in Europe. The World War II Letters of
Abraham Lincoln Brigade: Spain 1936-1939
an American Veteran of the Spanish Civil War
edited by Alvah Bessie & Albert Prago
by Lawrence Cane, edited by David E. Cane, Judy
Barrett Litoff, and David C. Smith Spain’s Cause Was Mine
by Hank Rubin
Mercy in Madrid
by Mary Bingham de Urquidi Comrades
by Harry Fisher
The Front Lines of Social Change: Veterans of the
Abraham Lincoln Brigade The Odyssey of the Abraham
by Richard Bermack Lincoln Brigade
by Peter Carroll
Soldiers of Salamas
by Javier Cercas The Lincoln Brigade, a Picture History
by William Katz and Marc Crawford
Juan Carlos: Steering Spain from Dictatorship to
Democracy EXHIBIT CATALOGS
by Paul Preston
They Still Draw Pictures: Children’s Art in Wartime
British Volunteers in the Spanish Civil War by Anthony Geist and Peter Carroll
by Richard Baxell
The Aura of the Cause, a photo album
The Wound and the Dream: Sixty Years of American edited by Cary Nelson
Poems about the Spanish Civil War
by Cary Nelson VIDEOS
Into the Fire: American Women in the Spanish Civil
❑ Yes, I wish to become an ALBA War
Associate, and I enclose a check for Julia Newman
$30 made out to ALBA (includes a one Art in the Struggle for Freedom
year subscription to The Volunteer). Abe Osheroff
Name _ _________________________________ Dreams and Nightmares
Abe Osheroff
Address_________________________________ The Good Fight
Sills/Dore/Bruckner
City________________ State ___Zip_________ Forever Activists
Judith Montell
❑ I’ve enclosed an additional donation of ___
_________. I wish ❑ do not wish ❑ to have this You Are History, You Are Legend
Judith Montell
donation acknowledged in The Volunteer.
Professional Revolutionary: Life of Saul Wellman
Please mail to: ALBA, 799 Broadway, Room 227, Judith Montell
New York, NY 10003
Name _ _____________________________
Address ____________________________
The Volunteer
c/o Abraham Lincoln Brigade Archives NON PROFIT ORG
799 Broadway, Rm. 227 US POSTAGE
New York, NY 10003 PAID
SAN FRANCISCO, CA
PERMIT NO. 1577