Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Harald Schwarz
eff * s = k
p = A * exp B E/ p
From
( )
and
eff
Ed =
follows
B* p A* p * s ln + s * A
Calculated breakdown field strength Ed as function of the sparking distance d for different gases under normal pressure (p = 1 bar) and normal temperature (T = 293 K).
- Ed depends on the sparking distance s. - Volume effect: tests at scaled-down models are not suitable for the assessment of high-voltage devices. - High-voltage tests of the real device (actual physical dimensions) are necessary.
Page 63
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Ud = Ed * s Ud = f (p * s)
U = d
B* p*s ln Aps k + s A
Calculated breakdown voltages as function of pd (Paschen curve) for different gases: (1) Helium and (2) air; (3) Air and (4) Sulfur hexafluoride; (5) Sulfur hexafluoride
- for large values of ps: fan out into several curves - for very small values of ps mechanism of vacuum breakdown
Page 64
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Paschens law as analytical approximation formula (thin curve) and as real curve (broad curve)
eff d = 14 ... 18 .
Page 65
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Avalanche in homogeneous field and field distribution E along the central axis of the avalanche for the critical number of electrons at the avalanche head: Eg is the field distribution of the base field.
- The highest alteration of field strength can be found at the avalanche head. - If the avalanche reaches a critical length of
L
eff dx = 18 ... 20
0
(determined experimentally) photon radiation is emitted. - The photons can generate secondary avalanches.
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 66
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Streamer mechanism:
Fusion of independent avalanches into a conductive channel during the avalanche transit time
Model for discharge reactions with space charges or channels discharge according to Raether respectively (Streamer mechanism)
Page 67
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Page 68
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The phase diagram for pure SF6 is given as an example for b1).
The typical gas pressure in gas insulated switchgear is 2 4 bar. For temperatures below -40 C the insulating gas becomes liquid. By adding N2 the temperature for liquefaction can be lowered considerably.
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 69
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Leakiness can also result in a mixture of SF6 and N2. The following picture shows the breakdown characteristic of this mixed gas.
AC breakdown voltage for a mixture of SF6 and N2 depending on the volume percentage VSF6 of SF6 for constant striking distance s = 15 mm and varying pressure
Page 70
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The increased field strength can exceed the dielectric strength of the insulating gas.
Field distribution E/p, effective ionization coefficient and number of electrons Ne in an avalanche near the rough surface for air, SF6 and SF6 with increased pressure
eff
Page 71
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
In weakly inhomogeneous fields reaching the ignition condition results in a breakdown immediately. In strongly inhomogeneous fields partial discharges occur at the electrode with the stronger curvature. In electronegative gases (SF6, air) these discharges are stabilized by absorption of charge carriers in regions of lower field strength.
Difference between the voltage for initiation of corona and the breakdown voltage in a strongly inhomogeneous field for constant sparking distance
Page 72
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Polarity Effect
Polarity effect in a strongly inhomogeneous field for positive point electrode (left) and negative point electrode (right) Above: Formation of streamers in regions of high electric field strength and positive effective ionization coefficient. Middle: Formation of a positive space charge by left-over positive ions (left and right) and formation of a negative space charge by trapping of electrons in the region of lower field strength (right). Field strength E(x) along the x-axis for an electric field without space charge (thin lines) and the resulting electric field with space charges (broad lines) with shifting of ionization boundaries.
Bottom:
Page 73
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Positive point electrode: - Positive ions in front of the electrode decrease the field strength; - Electrons start in the field space; - After formation of the first avalanche a stable glow discharge is generated by photo ionization (dim bluish glowing); - Field strength in the gas space is increased; - Remaining sparking distance is shortened; - Breakdown processes are favoured Negative point electrode: - Strong increase of field strength in the vicinity of the point electrode; - Large statistical time variation until an initiating electron is available; emission of charge carriers from the point electrode; - Single statistically varying corona impulses; - Field strength in the gas space gets lower and more uniform.
In general:
Page 74
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
- Avalanches form in the gas space and travel towards the anode (analogous to chapter 5.3.). A positive space charge is left over. - If the field distortion is sufficient photons are emitted (similar to chapter 4.5.).
Formation of positive streamer discharge: 1 Streamer head, old; 2 Streamer channel; 3 Photon path; 4 Initiating electron; 5 Avalanche; 6 Streamer head, new
- These photons generate secondary electron avalanches, which are moving towards the positive space charge and get neutralized. - The electrode avalanches leave a new positive space charge, which is situated closer to the opposite electrode. - A passive, weakly conducting zone develops between the anode and the positive space charge. - The streamer growth needs a voltage gradient of about 4-5 kV/cm. - The propagation velocity is about several 10 cm/s.
Page 75
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
5.4.2.
The statements from chapter 4.5 are valid. A voltage gradient of about 10 kV/cm is needed. The propagation velocity of the negative streamer discharge is smaller than the velocity of the positive streamer.
5.4.3.
Leader Discharge
- For large striking distances only. - The positive leader discharge is discussed, because it is the most critical case.
Formation of a leader discharge: 1 Leader channel; 2 Leader head; 3 Leader corona; 4 Streamer head of corona; 5 Ionization boundary
- Up to now the physical mechanism of the leader discharge is not completely clear. - The heating-up of the leader channel up to 5000 C is important for the formation of a leader discharge. - The density of charge carriers is strongly increased by thermoionization and the voltage demand decreases from 5 kV/cm auf 1.5 kV/cm, resulting in a growing of the leader. - The heating-up is caused by collision processes of the numerous streamer avalanches in the leader head.
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 76
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Existence of different discharge types in an air insulated point-plate-arrangement: Inception voltage Ue and breakdown voltage Ud as function of the sparking distance d for positive and negative point electrodes (left). Discharge types and the accompanying relative voltage demand (right).
Page 77
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
For slowly varying voltages the breakdown occurs after slightly exceeding the permissible voltage Uo.
Ignition delay time for a voltage step (a) and a voltage impulse (b)
Page 78
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
For fast varying voltages the voltage can rise considerably in the time t = ts + ta after exceeding the value Uo. Therefore the impulse volt-time characteristic of a high-voltage device is very important, giving the limiting curve of the additional voltage increase in dependence on the impulse slope.
Voltage-time area - Determination of the static breakdown voltage Ud - Measurement of breakdown voltages for impulse voltages Lower value = build-up time characteristic Upper value = variance zone - Determination of area A - For a given arrangement the area A is constant (independent of the chosen voltage curve). - Drawing of volt-time characteristic based on a few measurements.
Page 79
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
5.6.1.
Spark Discharge
The charge carrier multiplication (dn) caused by collision ionization along the path (dx) is given by:
dn = eff * n * dx
eff
By taking into account the drift velocity
v=
dx dt
it follows
dn = eff * n *v dt
By assuming that the total current density equals the electron current density one gets:
I = I e = n *v *e
or
dn I = eff dt e
respectively.
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 80
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
n= = =
With:
eff
e
I dt
0 t 0
eff eff
i dt A* e QF ( (t )
during time t
A* e
LF Length of spark
= b * n * e Conductivity
one gets the spark resistance
RF (t )
RF (t ) =
RF (t ) =
LF LF LF = = * A b * n * e * A b * eff * QF (t )
QF (t ) =
T * LF T * LF
i dt
0
T
Air Nitrogen Argon SF6
= Toepler constant
T = 0.5 0.6 * 10-4 Vs/cm T = 0.4 * 10-4 Vs/cm T = 0.85 * 10-4 Vs/cm T = 0.4 ... 0.8 * 10-4 Vs/cm
Page 81
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The spark build-up time is estimated using the discharge of a capacitor as analogy.
Spark resistance, build-up time, voltage and current for the discharge of a capacitance (schematic)
It holds:
u (t ) = RF (t )* i (t ) =
T LF
i (t ) dt
0
i (t )
and
du i (t ) = C dt
Because the sum of the residual charge Cu (t) of the capacitor and the quantity of charge flown through the spark equals the initial charge CUd of the capacitor it holds:
C U d = i (t ) dt + C u (t )
0
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 82
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
u (t ) =
Ud U 1 + exp d T LF
t F = 4,4 *
T LF
Ud
= 4,4
T
Ed
t F 7 ...8 ns t F 2 ...3 ns
Page 83
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
5.6.2.
Arc Discharge
If the current density in a spark discharge increases sufficiently, thermoionization starts. In this case we talk about an arc discharge.
Possible operation points at the intersection points of gas-discharge characteristic and resistance line: (1) stable; (2) instable and (3) stable operating point
Page 84
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
For a stable arc it is necessary that the supplied electric power Pzu equals the dissipated thermal power Pab:
U * I = Pzu = Pab.
The voltage demand of the arc can be determined empirically
U=
lB n
lB
= arc length
n = 0,5 0,25
i.e. the voltage demand increases with the arc length and decreases for higher currents.
The quenching of the arc can be accomplished according to the A.C. voltage principle: At the zero transition of the current the arc is shortly interrupted. If the discharge gap is deionised during this phase, no reignition is possible. D.C. voltage principle: If the voltage demand is increased beyond the feeding voltage (e.g. by lengthening the arc) there is no stable operation point and the arc is interrupted.
Page 85
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Breakdown:
Flash-over:
There are two cases a) Field lines parallel to surface b) Field lines nearly perpendicular to surface
Flash-over at boundary surfaces: a Field lines parallel to open boundary surface; b Field lines nearly perpendicular to open boundary surface
Case a): A gas discharge occurs. The insulator surface has a limited influence on the discharge process (trapping and releasing of electrons). Very often the breakdown field strength at the boundary surface is lower than in the solid insulating material and in the gas space due to pollution layers at the boundary surface (see next section). Case b): Sliding discharge (see section 5.7.3)
Page 86
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
5.7.2.
Conductive layer at the insulator surface caused by - atmospheric humidification and - pollution. As a result leakage currents of about 10 mA 100 mA occur.
Phases of pollution layer flashover: a) Displacement of leakage current by dry zone with local temperature rise. b) Growing of dry zone caused by Joule heat, accelerated drying. c) Interruption of current after drying of complete insulator periphery. d) Flash-over bridging the dry zone, formation of an arc. e) Growing of dry zone and arc length by further drying.
Page 87
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Insulator for open-air application with sheds for increasing the creeping distance
The creeping distance depends on the pollution. There are several classes of pollution defined for transmission networks. Ub is the operating voltage.
Page 88
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Pollution class a
According to Glyer and Vogelsang [9.9] Agriculture and forestry, no industry, clean atmosphere
Degree of pollution
No significant pollution
Areas without industry and low density of buildings with house heating. Areas with few industrial companies but with frequent wind and rain. All areas have to be distant from sea shore or at high altitudes (no sea winds in any case). Areas with industrial companies without special dust and exhaust gas pollution or areas with average density of buildings. Areas with high density of buildings and heavy industry, but with cleaning wind and rain. Distance to the sea shore has to be at least 1 km. Areas with many industrial companies and periphery of large cities (high density of house heating). Areas close to the sea shore or with strong sea winds. Smaller areas with heavy industrial pollution, causing thick conductive layers at the insulators. Areas close to the sea shore with strong salt winds (salt mist).
Light pollution (periphery of large industrial areas), frequently strong fog (river valleys)
Light pollution
Heavy industrial pollution (e.g. Ruhr area, industrial area around Kln and Mannheim)
Heavy pollution
Very heavy 3,8 cm/kV conductive pollution (vicinity of large power stations, chemical plants, iron and steel industry)
Page 89
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
5.7.3.
Sliding Discharge
Sliding discharges along surfaces are critical at cable ends and bushings.
Typical electrode arrangement for sliding discharges with equipotential lines (without taking into account the refraction of field lines)
The following equivalent networks can be used for determination of the field distribution:
Equivalent networks for determination of the initial tangential field distribution for different voltages: Left: Impulse voltage and A.C. voltage (dielectric displacement field only). Middle: Taking into account conductive pollution layers for A.C. voltage. Right: D.C. voltage (steady-state electric field).
Page 90
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
After exceeding the inception voltage Ue first partial discharges occur at the electrode corners.
Ue =k
p*s
r
k=8 k = 21 k = 30 discharge in air discharge in SF6 discharge in oil
After first partial discharges initiation of glow discharge of formation of streamers Because of high transverse capacitances high currents are flowing in the streamers possibility of thermo-ionization even for short streamer lengths Formation of leader discharges and bridging of large sparking distances Formation of leaders for
0 , 44
pF / cm 2 U g = 25,8 kV C / A
Page 91
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
6. Breakdown Reactions in Solid and Fluid Insulating Materials 6.1. Purely Electrical Breakdown
The purely electrical breakdown occurs in solid insulating materials at very high field strength. High-polymer plastics consist of macromolecules and show semicrystalline behaviour.
Structure of semi-crystalline high-polymers with crystal lamellas: 1 Crystal lamellas, 2 amorphous regions with a) Interconnection chains, b) Chain ends, c) Folding back of chains
Page 92
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The energy band model for crystals, giving an energetic description of the mobility of electrons, can be used.
Anode and cathode are metallic electrodes with free electrodes, symbolised by the Fermi level of anode and cathode respectively (FNK / FNA). The difference between FNK or FNA and the valence band of the insulating material is the work function, which is necessary for releasing electrons from the metal surface. In the valence band of the insulating material all electrons are fixed, in the conduction band the electrons can move freely. There are no electrons in the forbidden zone. The energy bands of the insulating material shift if a voltage is applied to the electrodes.
Page 93
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
In order to initiate a breakdown electrons have to be elevated into the conduction band of the insulating material. This can be accomplished by:
Thermo-ionization For high cathode temperature electrons can get over the potential wall. Outer field emission For high field strength at the cathode electrons can get over the potential wall. Inner field emission Electrons can be elevated from a trap level (defect of insulating material) to the conduction band with lower energy.
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The breakdown is governed by an avalanche mechanism, similar to gas discharge processes. A permanent damage of the insulating material occurs if the power density exceeds the value 10-5 w/mm3. The breakdown field strength Ed lies above 1000 kV/cm. That value can only be reached for:
- dielectric stress < 1 s - very thin insulating material < 1 mm - very pure insulating materials e. g. PE foil d = 100 m Ed 800 kV/mm at 20 C Ed 300 kV/mm at 100 C
Page 95
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Loss factor
J w = ( + j ) E tan =
tan
~ exp
( ( ))
u o
Page 96
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Stationary case:
Pzu = Pab
dPzu dPab d d
dPzu dPab = d d
(Point C)
At the stability limit any disturbance of the system (without further increase of the voltage) results in an increase of temperature destruction. The breakdown voltage is a parameter of the insulating material: about 0.1 ... 20 MV depending on type and purity of the material. The breakdown voltage is independent of the sparking distance, because the complete insulation is thermally overloaded.
High-Voltage Technique and Insulating Materials Page 97
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Page 98
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Pab
- After reaching the breakdown voltage self-maintained temperature rise (similar to global thermal breakdown); - Breakdown voltage Uk
- Especially critical for tangential field strength at boundary surfaces of laminated dielectrics. Example: Solid-type cable Belted insulation cable Radial-field cable
Page 99
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Formation of fibre bridges under the influence of an electric field (right) in insulating oil contaminated with dielectric fibres (left)
- Travelling of the fibres into regions of high field strength - Formation of a channel with higher conductivity - Special case of the local thermal breakdown - Remedy: Barriers for subdivision of free oil spaces
Page 100
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Page 101
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
PE: EP 1: EP 2: EP 3:
Life characteristics for different dielectrics (A.C. voltage): Polyethylene foil in air, SF6 and silicone oil Epoxy resin in model arrangement (d = 1mm) Insulation sample with local increase of field strength by corrugated metal foil inlays Same as EP 2 for large scale insulations
Life tests with insulation samples produced under real manufacturing conditions
t E d d = to E o
1 / k
k = Lifetime exponent
Page 102
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Orientation values for the short-time dielectric strength (1 minute), lifetime exponents and operating field strength (30 years) for several insulations at f = 50 Hz, T = 20 C Dielectric Application k
d E (1 minute) kV/mm
9 30 30 40 30 40 12 140 > 200 > 200 180 55 80 20 30 125 125
Page 103
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
There are three ranges for insulating materials with high tan (Pertinax, some cast resins, PVC): - Electric breakdown, - Thermal breakdown, - Erosion breakdown.
Page 104
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
For high-performance insulating materials with small tan (PE, PTFE, epoxy resin) one gets a lifetime line (double-logarithmic scaled diagram). The region of thermal breakdown is missing, because the dielectric losses in the insulating materials are not high enough. Therefore it is possible, to determine the permissible operating field strength for an expected lifetime of 25-40 years (= 200.000 ... 350.000 hours).
Page 105
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Ed(x)
Ed(x)
E(x)
E(x)
Page 106
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
In small gas voids and gaps the local electric field strength is higher than in the surrounding insulating material. Usually the breakdown field strength is lower than in the solid insulation too. Partial discharges can occur at the following exemplary locations:
5) 1) 2) 3) 4)
1) 2) 3) 4) 5)
Surface defect of insulation Gas void in insulating material local destruction caused by preceding stress inadequate electrode adhesion Gas gap at electrode edge
Besides these inner partial discharges outer PD can occur. For both types the following equivalent networks were developed:
Page 107
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
The current in both circuits is determined by the series impedance before the defect:
R2 >>
1 C1
for outer PD
C 2 << C1
for inner PD
Page 108
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Outer PD
i (t ) =
d U 1 (t ) U (t ) = C1 R2 dt
dU 1 (t ) U (t ) = dt R2C1
i(t ) = C2 dU 1 (t ) dU (t ) = C1 dt dt
Inner PD
dU 1 (t ) C2 dU (t ) = dt C1 dt
dU 1 (t ) dU (t ) dt dt
Page 109
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
It is possible to sketch the voltage at C1, which is temporarily shortcircuited by the spark gap.
The partial discharge is an extreme long-time mechanism. PD causes high-frequency field variations at the defect, resulting in high local dielectric losses and possibly a local thermal breakdown. Inside the defect ions are accelerated, which erode the insulation surface and cause needle-shaped cracks. Accelerated electrons penetrate into the insulating material and occupy trap levels (energy band model). Thereby the inner field emission is intensified. PD can cause an intesified generation of NOx at the defect. If there is residual humidity inside the void, nitric acid is generated, which corrodes the insulation.
Page 110
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Page 111
Chair of Energy Distribution and High-Voltage Engineering Prof. Dr.-Ing. Harald Schwarz
Page 112