08/10/2013

Supreme Court rejects citizens' request to change nationality from 'Jewish' to 'Israeli' - National Israel News | Haaretz
SUBSCRIBE T O HAARET Z DIGIT AL EDIT IONS

Haaretz.com

TheMarker

TheMarker Caf
Hel l o y t r You hav e v iewed 4 of 1 0 articles. Tuesday, October 08, 2013 Cheshvan 4, 5774 Search Haaretz.com

ISRAEL MINT
Pr ofile Log ou t
su bscri be n ow

Jewish World News

Do you think I'm sexy? Esquire does

NEWS

OPINION JEWISH WORLD

Rabbi Ov adia Y osef

BUSINESS

TRAVEL

CULTURE

WEEKEND BLOGS
Sy ria

ARCHAEOLOGY NEWS BROADCAST

Like 83k Follow

ISRAEL NEWS BREAKING NEWS

Home New s

World Bank report

Israel's brain drain

Word of the Day

1:06 PM Moroccan court releases youths arrested for Facebook kissing photo (DPA))

More Breaking News

National

Supreme Court rejects citizens' request to change nationality from 'Jewish' to 'Israeli'
Court rules against change in identity card registration, citing that there is no proof of the existence of a uniquely 'Israeli' people.
By Revital Hovel | Oct. 3, 2013 | 5:30 AM |
8 Tw eet 87

HAARETZ SELECT

11
Send Kenn Orphan and 864 others recommend this.

Recommend

T he Israel Air Force flyover at Auschwitz: A crass, superficial display

Why the Am ericans could not hav e bom bed the death cam p until July 1 9 4 4 , and why the 2 003 fly ov er there was a m istake. A response to Ari Shav it. By Yehuda Bauer | Magazine | 3

On T witter, nothing is sacred - not even Rabbi Ovadia Yosef

By Allison Kaplan Sommer | Routine Em ergencies | 2

Bibi, a modern-day Arafat, provides fodder for anti-Israel left

By Bradley Burston | A Special Place in Hell | 5

Ich bin ein sub-slime Israelische

By Asher Schechter | Features | 4

Uzzi Arnon holding his I.D.

Photo by Hagai Fried

The Supreme Court on Wednesday rejected a request by a group of Israelis to declare that they were members of the Israeli people and to allow them to change the ethnic registration on their identity cards from Jewish to Israeli. The court ruled that the issue was not one for the court to decide and that there was no proof of the existence of a uniquely Israeli people. The courts ruling echoed that in a similar case 40 years ago. The decision by court President Asher Grunis and Justices Uzi Vogelman and Hanan Melcer upheld the 2008 ruling by their colleague, Noam Sohlberg, who, as a Jerusalem District Court judge, had rejected the groups petition. Israel does not recognize Israeli as an ethnic group [in Hebrew leom.] The term can be translated into English as nationhood, but in the sense of ethnic affiliation, rather than citizenship. The leom attrribution - the main ones are Jewish and Arab - is assigned by the Interior Ministry, regardless of the card-bearers preference. The main appellant was Prof. Uzzi Ornan, a linguist who has long battled to separate religion and state. Ornan, 90, was born and raised in Jerusalem. He was expelled to Eritrea in 1944, when his underground activities were revealed to the British authorities.

Tex t size Comments (1 1 ) Print Page Send to friend Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share
THIS STORY IS BY

Reengaging American Jews, before they drift away

If Jews do not want to define them selv es by religion, let's m eet them where they are and recognize that they are in good com pany . By Arnold M. Eisen | Opinion | 3

Revital Hovel
RELATED TAGS Israel Suprem e Court Jewish law

Sophie's choice reality: T V storyteller has most shocking family tale of all
By Ayelett Shani | Magazine

T his day in Jewish history / T he sultan orders transfer of Safed Jews

By David B. Green | This Day in Jew ish History

NATI O NAL
African m igrant acquitted of sex ually assaulting teen
RELATED ARTICLES
By Nir Hasson | 07:13 PM

Court rules Judaism, not place of birt h, is grounds for Israeli cit izenship By Revital Hovel | May 15, 2012 | 7:05 PM | 44 Once a Jew, alway s a Jew

Jerusalem Central Bus Station ordered to clean up its act

By Nir Hasson | 05:33 PM

www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.550241

1/4

08/10/2013

Supreme Court rejects citizens' request to change nationality from 'Jewish' to 'Israeli' - National Israel News | Haaretz
By Benny Ziffer | Oct. 14, 2011 | 11:39 AM | Court reject ion of Israeli nat ionalit y highlight s flaws of Jewish democracy By Aeyal Gross | Oct. 3, 2013 | 4:05 PM | 1
16

When he returned to Israel in 1948, he was registered in the states first census and insisted that he not be listed as Jewish. Instead, he wrote that he was of no religion and gave his ethnic designation as Hebrew. The newly-formed Interior Ministry accepted this without question.

Secret liv es of Israel's wolv es and hy enas, caught on tape

By Zafrir Rinat | 09:27 AM | 3

In 2000, Ornan petitioned the Interior Ministry to be registered as an ethnic Israeli, but his request was rejected and none of his subsequent legal actions were successful. In 2007, he submitted another appeal to the Jerusalem District Court, together with Uri Avnery, Shulamit Aloni, Prof. Itamar Even-Zohar, Prof. Yosef Agassi, singer Alon Olearchik, playwright Joshua Sobol and others. In his ruling rejecting the appeal, Sohlberg stated, the requested declaration has a public, ideological, social, historic and political character but not a legal one. This isnt a technical issue of registration in the Population Registry, but a request that the court determine that in the State of Israel a new peoplehood has been formed, common to all its residents and citizens, called Israeli. This issue is a national-politicalsocial question and it is not the courts place to decide it. The group argued in its appeal that an Israeli people was formed with the establishment of the State of Israel and that rejecting the existence of such a people is like rejecting the existence of the State of Israel as a democratic, sovereign state. They added that this was indeed a legal question that the courts could not avoid. In their response, the Interior Ministry and the attorney-general supported the district court decision, saying the issue was not justiciable. The primary precedent on which the justices based themselves in their ruling Wednesday was the case of Dr. Georges Tamarin, who immigrated to Israel in 1949 from Yugoslavia. He was registered as being of Jewish ethnicity, but in the religion section was listed as having no religion. In 1970, after a change in the law that forbade listing someone as being Jewish in either the ethnicity or religion section if he didnt meet the description of a Jew in the Law of Return, Tamarin went to court to change his ethnic designation to Israeli. Both the Tel Aviv District Court and the Supreme Court rejected his request, stating that for a person to declare that he belongs to a given ethnic group, there had to be proof that the group exists. Court President Shimon Agranat stated that there is no significance to the persons subjective feeling of belonging to a given ethnic group, without being able to establish via any criteria that such a group exists. Ornan expressed his disappointment with the ruling. In its ruling the court, in effect, agrees to totally ignore the obligations included in the Declaration of Independence, which promises full equality among all the states citizens, regardless of religion, race or gender, he said. The government consensus that has developed ignores the existence of an Israeli people that was created with the Declaration of Independence, Ornan continued. This consensus enables the Jewish majority to have full control over the country and to operate not for the benefit of Israeli citizens but for the benefit of the current political majority among the Jews.

Analy sis || Rabbi Ov adia Y osef: Sectorial party leader or a social rev olutionary ?
By Yair Ettinger | 09:03 AM

MO RE FRO M THE WEB

Recommended by

FACEBO O K
ACTIV ITY
Recent Activity Noa Shaindlinger recommends Drafting the blueprint for Palestinian refugees' right of return Tw ilight Zone.
on Friday

RECOMMENDATIONS

Shaul Hanuka recommends Rand Paul: The single greatest danger to Israels standing in the U.S. Opinion.
about a month ago

Guy Butavia recommends West Bank w ater shortage forcing Palestinians to lease land from settlers - Diplomacy & Defense.
about a month ago

Facebook social plugin

MORE FROM HAARETZ.COM

Israel's secret weapon in 197 3: Diaspora Jews
(Haaretz | Jew ish World)

FROM AROUND THE WEB

Phot os from Space: Ghost ly Green Bubble
(redOrbit)

Al-Shabab leader believed killed by U.S. commandos

(Haaretz | New s)

The Real Problem In Working From Home (It 's Not What Y ou Think)
(Forbes.com)

Obama, Rohani, Abbas, and t he snub by Israel: News y ou may have

Mossad agent s married Palest inian women, lived double lives for 15

www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.550241

2/4

08/10/2013

Supreme Court rejects citizens' request to change nationality from 'Jewish' to 'Israeli' - National Israel News | Haaretz
(Haaretz | New s) (Your Jew ish New s)

Here comes t he bride, all dressed in leat her and t efillin

(Haaretz | Culture)

Hundreds t roop t o Ay ala for 'Million People March'

(ABS-CBN Philippines)

Recommended by

COMMENTS
Name Subject Comment
Your comment here

By adding a comment i agree to this sites Terms of use

LATEST

MOST VIEWED

HIGHEST RATED

Open All
1 16

10

The dream of t he emerging St at e of Israst ine by t he Left has suffered anot her blow...Condolences
By Darth Zaider ( Ed) 03 Oct 2013 03:38PM

My ID card say s ISRAELI CITIZEN 09 By Zionis t forever 03 Oct 2013 00:59PM

11

is et hnicit y and being Israeli is 08 Jewishness nat ionalit y

By logic rules 03 Oct 2013 07:47AM

26

07

Jewish Arabs
By Mariapales tina 03 Oct 2013 06:01AM

45

Every one wit h any connect ion t o t he land, any where in t he world, is an Arab.
By A hmet 03 Oct 2013 00:43PM

25

06

It is indeed a puzzle t hat people living in Israel and are cit izens oft his count ry are not considered Israeli.m
By Marlem 03 Oct 2013 03:24AM

40

Cit izenship 05 By Jeff 03 Oct 2013

40 03:15AM

So, one can change one's et hnicit y by conversion? 04 By Meliss a 03 Oct 2013 03:13AM

44

03

I part ially agree wit h t he ruling; wit h t hat in mind, it 's also not fort he court or t he st at e t o be concerned wit h an ID-bearer's et hnicit y
By Max Lury a 03 Oct 2013 02:54AM

18

Net any ahu's speech 02 By w jm 03 Oct 2013 02:25AM

36

17

01

Wow! Nat ionalit y based on et hnicit y ! Is t hat really a 21st cent ury concept or is Israel st uck in t he 7 t h cent ury ?
By Shimon 03 Oct 2013 02:22AM

67

16

www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.550241

3/4

08/10/2013

Supreme Court rejects citizens' request to change nationality from 'Jewish' to 'Israeli' - National Israel News | Haaretz

NEWS: Diplomacy and Defense | National | World | Middle East | Features | Opinion | Israel weather | Maccabiah 2013 JEWISH WORLD: News | Rabbis' Round Table | The Jewish Thinker CULTURE: Books | Food and Wine | Arts & Leisure HAARETZ.COM BLOGS: A Special Place in Hell | West of Eden | Diplomania | Routine Emergencies | Eyes Wide Open | Jerusalem Vivendi | Strenger than Fiction | Modern Manna | The Fifth Question HAARETZ.CO.IL: | | | | | 2013 | | | | FAQ | Contact us | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Management | Editorial | Employment Opportunities | Advertise on Haaretz.com | Haaretz News Widget

Design by Roni Arie | Accelerated by cotendo Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora. Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved

www.haaretz.com/news/national/.premium-1.550241

4/4