Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
By
Submitted To University Of Pune In partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree of Master of Business Administration (MBA)
Dhirubhai H. Ambani Founder Chairman Reliance Group December 28, 1932 - July 6, 2002 The Reliance Group, founded by Dhirubhai H. Ambani (1932-2002), is India's largest private sector enterprise, with businesses in the energy and materials value chain. Group's annual revenues are in excess of USD 22 billion. The flagship company, Reliance Industries Limited, is a Fortune Global 500 company and is the largest private sector company in India. Backward vertical integration has been the cornerstone of the evolution and growth of Reliance. Starting with textiles in the late seventies, Reliance pursued a strategy of backward vertical integration - in polyester, fibre intermediates, plastics, petrochemicals, petroleum refining and oil and gas exploration and production - to be fully integrated along the materials and energy value chain.
The Group's activities span exploration and production of oil and gas, petroleum refining and marketing, petrochemicals (polyester, fibre intermediates, plastics and chemicals), textiles and retail. Reliance enjoys global leadership in its businesses, being the largest polyester yarn and fibre producer in the world and among the top five to ten producers in the world in major petrochemical products. The Group exports products in excess of USD 7 billion to more than 100 countries in the world. There are more than 25,000 employees on the rolls of Group Companies. Major Group Companies are Reliance Industries Limited (including main subsidiaries Reliance Petroleum Limited and Reliance Retail Limited), Indian Petrochemicals Corporation Limited and Reliance Industrial Infrastructure Limited.
The company is targeting to open 100 more Reliance Fresh stores in New Delhi alone within four months, and a 1,000 new stores in 35 cities nationwide by the end of the year with a built-up area of over 4 million sq.ft. An investment of Rs.8,000 crore is envisaged for the NCR region alone.
Reliance Fresh stocks fresh fruits and vegetables, staples, fast moving consumer goods and dairy products. The stores are already selling over 1,000 tonnes of fresh produce daily and also 250 categories of commodities. The company is approaching farmers directly for the procurement of produce, seeking to reduce the 40% wastage that occurs through the traditional supply chain. The retail initiative of Reliance will be without a parallel in size and spread and make India proud. Ensuring better returns to Indian farmers and manufacturers and greater value for the Indian consumer, both in quality and quantity, will be an integral feature of this project. By creating value at all levels, we will actively endeavor to contribute to India's growth. The project will boast of a seamless supply chain infrastructure, unprecedented even by world standards. Through multiple formats and a wide range of categories, Reliance is aiming to touch almost every Indian customer and supplier.
and stock - outs". There are two major areas of profit leakage in retail. Firstly lost sales resulting from lack of stock and secondly forced margin reductions due to excessive stock.
Merchandise Planning needs to span the activities between setting long term , high level goals for sales, margin and investment for the business, right down to the allocation of space within an individual store for a defined S.K.U.. At each stage of the planning process the high level goals are tested and inputs from functional management enrich the detailed versions. Gaps are analysed and variances are explained or reconciled. The end result of the planning process should be a detailed set of targets (e.g. a purchase order budget) and instructions (e.g. a planogram) that can be reconciled with the original corporate targets, with any divergences being clearly explicable. These plans may be numeric (an Open to Buy) or graphical (the results of range creation collage software like that from Fashionyield, or space planning software like Spaceman) It is equally important to realise what they are NOT. Merchandise Planning is not a transactional process. Thus, setting a purchase order budget within an Open to Buy system IS merchandise planning. Creating a purchase order is not. Deciding how a certain line may be ranged and testing an allocation pattern is planning. Creating the actual allocation is not.
Merchandise planning is a strategic process. As such we need to create systems that lead us seamlessly and in an integrated way from top level strategy to tactical action. In creating a holistic system it is helpful to realise that we can split the planning process into five logical sections
Review The review process consists of two separate activities. Firstly we carry out a PreSeason Review of performance history to identify opportunities and problems. 10
Secondly we "normalise" it. Normalisation is the process of looking at history and ironing out the "bumps" to make it useful as a basis for planning. Merchandise Planning The first element in the merchandise plan is the Strategic Plan. This is normally high level, with perhaps a five year timescale. It is used to set the critical success factors for merchandising in terms of sales, margins & stocks. Next we would create a Channel Sales Budget. This would allow us to take into account the effect of new channels, new stores, closures and refits. Once complete we would create a Category Level Margin Plan. Here we are creating a weekly version of the strategic plan at category level for sales, margins and markdowns. We are now starting to get input from the individual merchandisers, and gap analysis between these plans and the strategic plan will ensure that we stay on course. At the same level we create a Category Level Weekly Sales, Stock & Intake Plan. It is here that we create our Open to Buy, normally the first significant win in the implementation of a planning system. These category level plans create the box within which the range plan will be created Range Planning We begin here with the Assortment Plan. In this plan we break down the goals of the merchandise plan into specific lines, or sometimes SKUs. The system should be capable of extending the results so that we can see the effect on overall margin mix, for example, of a change in cost price of an item. Once the assortment plan is underway we can start Distribution Planning. The lines that we plan are here given a distribution profile. From this we should be able to see both which stores a line is ranged to, and which lines a given store will receive. The link between available physical space and ranging done here is a key determinant of merchandise performance. In the ideal world we would now create a Line Level Weekly Sales, Stock & Intake Plan This would be the category level W.S.S.I., broken down by line to provide a detailed forecast of sales and stock requirements. However, volume & time constraints means that this may be for key items only. 11
At a basic level this provides us with the means to monitor and react to consumer demand. At a more sophisticated level this provides us with the hard currency that can make efficient consumer response systems function effectively. The advent of ecommerce is going to increase the value and importance of line level forecasts shared with our suppliers. There is another sort of assortment plan emerging now. This is the Graphical Range Plan. This sort of plan moves out of the purely numeric type of planning that has been used up until now and starts to allow the range to be put together in a visual way. Typically digitally stored images are manipulated into collage type storyboards. Assortment planning Implementing an effective assortment planning process may be the key to offering the right products to the right customers. The old adage, the right product, the right place, at the right time, still holds true in today's retail marketplace, but with one important change. Retailers - whether traditional, e-commerce or bricks-and-clicks - must have a compelling selection of merchandise for the right customer as well. To determine the best course of action for reaching the right customers, it is important to examine one of the most important factors that impacts the merchandising process: Assortment planning. Assortment planning - which involves asking questions such as: Which product? How much of it? What colors? What sizes? Where to place it? Who is the target customer? and so forth - although it directly affects product selection, price, timing and micromerchandising, has traditionally been de-emphasized due to hectic retail schedules. Extinguishing delivery fires and meeting marketing and financial planning obligations use valuable time, forcing companies to take the easy approach to merchandising: repeating assortment breadth and depth from previous seasons, creating store assortments based on store volume and ranking items by sales volume alone.
12
Yet, to attract the right customer in today's increasingly competitive environment, assortment planning must focus on creating appropriate product breadth and depth based on the customer's desires and shopping patterns, taking into account lifestyles, climates and trends. Furthermore, assortment planning must present a compelling mix of products to illustrate the company's strategic vision. Benefits of Effective Assortment Planning The primary benefits of effective assortment planning fall into two categories: financial impact and personal impact. * The financial impact is a result of matching product assortment with market potential, while aligning inventory to sales. This leads to increased sales, fewer mark-downs and improved margins. In turn, these factors dramatically impact profit and shareholder value. * The personal impact of effective assortment planning is improved employee morale and overall efficiency. Increased store collaboration, buying and planning groups, more complete analytical information, clearly defined roles and responsibilities, and a detailed plan of action all work together proactively for this improvement. Assortment planning breaks the Merchandise Plan down into the components that enable the planner to address customer preference and need. These components are product attributes, styles, colors, and SKUs. By addressing these components, the assortment plan becomes the transition to the customer by way of the store. In developing a good assortment plan, the retailer hopes to: Manage inventory while addressing customer need and demand Develop a complete range of merchandise for presentation Enhance and maintain the company philosophy and image Support and execute the overall merchandising strategy Integrate with other planning processes, such as merchandise allocation
13
The assortment plan, then, provides the most effective way to balance the presentation of merchandise to the customer. The properly assorted presentation ensures enough selection without overstocking and strikes the right balance between breadth (e.g. number of styles) and depth (quantity of each style). In addition, the good assortment plan considers seasonality, to provide the right merchandise flow. Because assortment planning addresses the most detailed element of merchandising to the customer - the items for sale - the process is often very detailed and time consuming. Space Planning Space planning systems can be split into two types - numeric and visual. Numeric planning systems simply allow users to take account of space available and to calculate ratios like return on space. Visual systems allow users to create 3 dimensional walk-through models of the stores and to preview the look of a store once ranging decisions have been made. Factors to Consider in Product Selection Choosing a product for your retail store to sell may very well be the most difficult decision you will need to make when starting a retail business. The choices are limitless and the task may be overwhelming at first. Not only should there be a demand for your products, but it must be profitable and something you enjoy selling. Before you commit to a product or product line, consider the following factors while deciding what products to sell. Marketability Let's face it, it won't matter what products you sell if your customers aren't buying. Before considering what product to sell, determine what market you want to sell to. Once you know what kind of customer you want, then you'll be able to determine their needs.
14
If your products only appeal greatly to some people, it may not be enough to sustain a business. Your product selection doesn't have to appeal to all of the population but it should be something you can convince a large percentage of shoppers they need. Profit Margin Selling big ticket items is generally more profitable, but can require more credibility to sell. When you look at the price of the product, don't forget to calculate direct and indirect costs (like overhead) of selling your goods. If you think you can sell 50 widgets a day for $1.00 each and the widget cost you $.50 each, it may look like you have a profit of $25 per day. But when you learn your overhead expenses average $20 per day, you may find your profit isn't sufficient even though sales are good. The best selling products won't ever earn any real money if your margin is too small. Consumable Choose a product with recurring sales value. A consumable item that needs to be replaced on a regular basis is one way a retailer can establish long term sales. By establishing a customer base with recurring products, customers will continue to come back to you to buy more as they use up the products. Additionally, satisfied customers are more open to recommendations for related products. What's Popular? When it comes to selecting products to sell based on what's popular, timing is extremely important. New trends and products can be a great boost to your business but you'll need to be at the beginning of the product lifecycle in order to be successful. Learning to pick a hot product before it becomes hot is a valuable skill that comes from knowing your market. Competition Competition is healthy and there are ways other than volume and price a smaller store can compete with larger retailers. On the other hand, the more unique the product, the less chance of competition. 15
Private Label One way to guarantee having a truly unique product line is to make the item yourself. Another way is to partner with a small business that makes a product you would enjoy selling. Also consider private label products which will allow you to brand an item made by another person. Quality When deciding which products to sell in your store, ask yourself the following question. Is this product something I would give my dearest friend? If not, you may want to keep looking. Product quality is extremely important when your reputation is on the line. Diversity Keep your product offering simple in the beginning. If your product line is narrow and focused, then your marketing efforts can be just as tightly focused, which will bring you the best results for your marketing dollars. As your business grows, so can your product line as long as you keep new products compatible with the type of business, your location and your market. The key to having a successful business is to know your products and to believe in the merchandise that you are selling. If you do not believe in the product yourself, then you probably won't be successful at selling it. Keep brainstorming and you'll find a product or product line that meets both the needs of your target market and your own ability to locate it, purchase it and resell it.
16
The data for this study was obtained through Primary & Secondary sources. Primary sources include: o Direct interaction with the customers:For knowing the purchasing habits and preferences. o Direct interaction with shopkeepers To find out the product assortment at their stores & the effect of the entry of organized retail outlets in their respective catchments on their business.
17
RESEARCH DESIGN
Data collection Data for this study is obtained from Primary & Secondary sources. Primary sources include observation, market surveys and interviews. Secondary data has been collected through company records. Research Design The research conducted was both observatory and descriptive in nature. The data was collected basically through a field survey using observation. The research design employed was descriptive research, as it was most suitable. Sampling size 40-50 stores were surveyed in each catchment area. Data source Primary data
The primary data was collected through observation and survey in competitor retailer stores in the segmented area prescribed by our leading manager, we carried with us the 3,500 SKU list which reliance fresh stocks along with informal interviews with the company personnel. Much of the information was collected this way.
18
The main aim of selecting the primary source is that it is necessary to know the current relevant data and information of retailers and consumers and also to know about the changing preferences and expectations of the consumers.
Secondary data
The secondary data was collected from Reliance Industries documents especially the 3,500 SKU list and other internet resources. The secondary data was also collected with the help of News paper and Journals.
19
20
consumers.
named '6 to 11'. Customer feedback for kirana stores 1. They feel that the kirana stores are fulfilling their needs and have an
edge over the retail stores as they extend credit facilities, home delivery and the customers have a long standing relationship with the consumers. 2. Kirana stores are experiencing a slight decrease in sales due to entry of the organized retail outlets. 21
For Reliance Fresh 1. They like the ambience and the service provided by the personnel while
shopping; in addition they were happy as they were provided the facilities of drinking water and washrooms not matched by any of the small retail stores. 2. Some people feel that most of the schemes are not very beneficial as they get almost the same amount of discount in the kirana and provisional stores.
Summary of SKUs for Business Units after a survey of 42 retail shops in vicinity of Reliance Fresh, Faridabad, Delhi Not in any S.No. Business Unit 1 Non Food 2 Food Total No. of SKUs 225 2025 2240 Reliance SKUs list 30 307 337
2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Non-Food Food No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
22
List of SKUs preferred in Faridabad, but not present in the original list of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd. Food Shri Sai Bhog Atta Ajanta Baking Powder Jindal Blended oil Coca Cola 300ml Pepsi 300ml Thumsup Ducks Waffy biscuits strawberry Ducks Waffy choco biscuits Ducks waffy vanilla Doaba Ghee 5kg Paras 1 ltr, mineral water Non-Food V-John Shaving Cream Hari Darshan Aggarbatti Madhusudan Ghee Joe Aggarbatti Axe Deo Cobra Deo Nippo AA size battery Shakti AA size Battery Wills classic ultra mild cigarettes Wills classic Mild cigarettes Drainex Pipe Unblocker Super Max Shaving Blade
Competitor Analysis The following stores have the largest stocking of different SKUs in foods category which present a serious competition to Reliance Retail in Faridabad Area. S.No. 1 2 3 4 5 Store Name Mangla Provision Store Bajrang Kirana Kataria Gen. Store Jindal Store Bhagat Gen. Store No. Of SKUs 470 347 334 330 309
23
Jindal Store
`
Bajrang Kirana Kataria General Store
Bajrang Kirana
Jindal Store
24
For Reliance Fresh 1. 2. 3. Presence of essential commodities is appreciated, The ambience gives them a wholesome shopping experience. More schemes should be introduced.
25
Summary of SKUs for Business Units after a survey of 42 retail shops in vicinity of Reliance Fresh, Uttam Nagar, Delhi Not in any S.No. Business Unit 1 Non Food 2 Food Total No. of SKUs Reliance SKUs list 319 46 1942 335 2261 381
2000 1500 1000 500 0 Non-Food Food No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List of SKUs preferred in Uttam Nagar, but not present in the original list of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd.
Food
Hathi Brand Atta Gokul flour mills Sai brand Gowardhan flour mills Parle Poppins Satmola Coffee Bite Vicks Fun Flips Nat-Khat Crax Coca Cola 300 ml bottle Harvest Gold bread Perfect bread Uttam Sugar 1 kg Modi Sugar 1 kg
Non-Food
Cycle agarbatti 20 stick Haridarshan 20 sticks aggarbati Nippo Alkaline AA Battery Sony AA size pack of 4 Wills classic regular cigarettes Wills classic mild Wills classic ultra Milds Ship matches Home matches Vi-John Navy Cut regular Red and White Vicco toothpaste 100gm Ghadi detergent
26
Raj Hans brand atta Rose Brand Chlormint Hajmola Candy Competitor Analysis:
Pepsi 300 ml bottle Thums Up 300 ml bottle Anmol Yummy 75 gm Jindal oil 1 litre
Following stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in foods category which present a serious competition to Reliance retail in Uttam Nagar catchment area. S.no 1 2 3 4 5 6 Store name Big Apple Subhiksha Saraswati Arora Gen. Store Khandelwal Store Aggarwal Traders No. of SKU's 1543 1347 1297 1285 1230 969
Big Apple
Subhiksha
Aggarw al Traders
Sarasw ati
Khandelw al Store
Subhiksha
Saraswati
Khandelwal Store
Aggarwal Traders
Big Apple
1. Consumers range from lower middle to price conscious consumers. 2. Stores predominantly provide food FMCG items. They however lack proper infrastructure, and exhibit haphazard display. 3. There is a sabzi mandi closeby, which suffices the FNV demands of customers, resulting in less people coming to retail stores for food items 4. Popularity of local brands in the category of food FMCG. 5. Lack of variety in non-food FMCG products 6. Lower price brands more popular. 7. Market dominated by kirana stores. 8. Organized retail outlets scarce. Customer feedback for kirana stores Kirana stores should stock more non-food FMCG products.
For Reliance Fresh 1. 2. 3. More variety in food & non-food items is appreciated. The ambience gives them a total shopping experience. Customer loyalty programmes are very popular.
Summary of SKUs for Business Units after a survey of 48 retail shops in vicinity of Reliance Fresh, Welcome, Delhi Not in any Reliance S.No. Business Unit 1 Non Food No. of SKUs 326 SKUs list 51
28
2 Food Total
2006 2332
435 486
2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 Non-Food Food No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List Of SKUs preferred in Seelampur but not present in the original list of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd.
Food
Mango sip 200 ml juice Ashoka loose atta Postman 1 litre edible Oil Chloromint Candy Nat-Khat Snacks Crax Snacks Amul Chocolates Jindal Oil 1Ltr
Non-Food
Cycle agarbatti 20 stick Haridarshan 20 sticks aggarbati Nippo Alkaline AA Battery Sony AA size pack of 4 Wills classic regular Wills classic mild Wills classic ultra Milds Ship matches Home matches Vi-John Navy Cut regular Red and White Vicco toothpaste 100gm Ghadi detergent
Satmola Candy Baba Mustard Oil Nilons mango pickle Baba Mustard Oil 300 gm Fun Flips Snacks Baba mustard oil 500ml Competitor Analysis 500ml Shahji mixture
Following Stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in Foods category, which pose a serious competition to Reliance Fresh in Subash Nagar catchment Area.
29
S.No 1 2 3 4 5
Store Name Man Moti Store Prem General store Singh General Store Mahesh Store Satya Prakash & Sons
Mahesh Store
`
Prem General Store Singh General Store
Mahesh Store
30
Customer feedback for kirana stores 1. 2. Kirana stores should stock more variety in non-food FMCG products. Long standing relationships with customers relevant and valued.
Customer feedback for Reliance Fresh 1. 2. Variety in popular branded food items appreciated. The ambience gives them a wholesome shopping experience.
Summary of SKUs for business Units after survey of 38 Retail Shops in the vicinity of Reliance Fresh Store, Subhash Nagar, New Delhi Not in any Reliance S.No. Business Unit 1 Apparel and Luggage 2 Non Food 3 Food TOTAL No. of SKUs 83 225 391 699 SKUs list 63 22 26 111
400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 Apparel & Luggage Non-Food Food
List of major SKUs preferred in Subash Nagar but not present in the original lists of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd.
Brick Atta
NON-FOOD Brick Air fresheners/deodorisers (non powered) Agarbatti Article Description Garden fresh 200ml spray Shubhmangalam (20 sticks 31
Basmati rice Besan Blended oil Bubble gums Candies Ghee Core biscuits Dates Egg Maida Mouth fresheners
Lal quila loose Aashirwad 10 kg Anmol 5 kg Amanat basmati 10kg Hatthi besan 1 kg Sweekar 5l Sweekar 1l Big bubble Cloro mint 50 ps. Coffee bite Local/ unbranded Anmol ghee 500 ml Anmol 50gm Loose unbranded Regular white shell eggs Local/Unbranded Paas-Paas
Baby feeding bottles Battery Cigarettes Shaving accessories Household disinfectants Laundry detergents Oral care aids (0n powered) Matches Pipe unblockers Shaving blades
box) Haridarshan(10 sticks box) Johnson & johnson 250ml Nippo(aa size) Wills (10 pcs) large Gold flake (10 pcs) large Classic (10 pcs) Godrej shaving brush Rocky phenol (local) 500ml Trishul 500ml Genda phenol 500ml 555 bar Classic soft (med.size) Home lite rs.5 box Haathi (Rs.0.50 box) Smart Lite(Local)(Re.0.50 box) Kiwi Drainex 50gm pp Vijay (10 pcs)
Competitor Analysis Following Stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in Foods category, which pose a serious competition to Reliance Fresh in Subash Nagar catchment Area. S.No 1 2 3 4 5 Store Name Subhiksha Goel store Vishal store Manocha store Om Prakash & Sons No. of SKU's 363 366 363 361 239
32
Subhiksha
Manocha Store
`
Goel Store Vishal Store
Subhiksha
Goel Store
Vishal Store
Manocha Store
33
1.
draws customers towards the organized retail outlets. Customer feedback for Reliance Fresh 1. 2. 3. More variety in food & non-food items is appreciated. The ambience gives them a total shopping experience. Some people feel that most of the schemes are not very beneficial as they
get almost the same amount of discount in the kirana and provisional stores.
Summary of SKUs for business Units after survey of 32 Retail Shops in the vicinity of Reliance Fresh Store, Gandhi Nagar, Delhi
No. of SKUs S.No. 1 2 3 4 Business Unit Equipment FMCG-Non Food Food Pharma Total present in the list 6 391 825 51 1273
1000 800 600 400 200 0 Equipm ent Non-Food Food Pharm a No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List of major SKUs preferred in Gandhi Nagar but not present in the original lists of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd. FOOD 34
Brick Noodles
Article Description Mayos Himalya Snacks Local Frugo apple Frugo mix apple Tuk 3 Apna bhog (unbranded) Green Soy atta Ahaar 500gm Aahar 1kg Jindal oil 1litre Amul chocolate Nutune gulkand box Pan pasand box Milk Man Amul Milk Chocolate Renia Maini Gopal Jee Ghee 1 kg Unbranded Dahi Jodhpuri moong dal halwa Awadhi badam halwa Bombay halwa mix local Basundi mix Gits rabri mix Gits phirni mix Gits kaleva Gopal elaichi Gopal soft kesar elaichi Gopal pista badam Gopal butterscotch Perfect Vasudev 500ml Origano Grade group kaju Grade group pista Grade group acrot Smith & Jones Corn flours Chings green chilli
Brick
Article Description Anmol Golmol Funfill orange Funfill cream Funfill strawberry Coconutty Smackles Anmol-g Choco bite Don Cheese cracker Spigadora crackers Wheat man cookies Wheatman milk suji toast Notty Eaton Energiser Power horse Mehsons honey Weikfeild orange Weikfeild strawberry Post man 500gm Post man 1kg Unbranded maida Volga Chaudhary cheese Local brand Moti mustard oil Hardil mustard oil Golden sabut 500gm Golden moong sabut1 kg Organic dals unbranded Kanodia brand mustard oil 1 litre,2 litre,20 litre Ricela 1litre Veer jee rusk 100 gm skimed milk powder poly pouch Godrej-sofit 35
Core biscuits
100 % juice
Atta Besan Blended oil Block chocolates Candies and bubble gum Cheese spread Chocolates Chutneys Cooked ghee Dahi
Core Biscuits
Flavoured milk
Moong dal
Ready to serve (RTS) Rusks & baked biscuits SMP Soya milk
Pacranga Carrot Pickles Pickle Achar Pachranga Doon Mini Dubar 5 kg Doon Mini Dubar 10 kg Unbranded Rice Raw Rice Type1 Unbranded Hyderabadi Pulao Unbranded Standard Rice Veetee rice Sugar Tea packed leaf Shagun 5 kg. CTC Leaf Tea Spices - others Dabur garlic ginger Home made masala Smith jones fish curry Whole Wheat Bread paste Harvest Gold Soy day Ahaar soya granules Soya nuggets Nutrela Savour nutri Dabur garlic Dabur ginger
EQUIPMENTS Sphygmomameter Chi Swing IBP J&J forehead hot & cold pad Digital thermometer Mt 301-IBP
NON-FOOD Brick Baby diapers (disposable) Article Description Teddy SML 5 pcs Wills Navy Cut Light 10pcs. Large Gold Flake 10 pcs. Large Hawda bidis 10pcs. Large Flake 10pcs. Large Four square 10pcs. Large India Kings 10pcs. Large Wills Classic 10pcs. Large Vicco 100gm
Cigarettes
Dental cleansing
36
Neha mehendi 100gm Ghadi detergent powder 200gm Home lite Vi-john
Competitor Analysis Following Stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in Foods category, which pose a serious competition to Reliance Fresh in the Gandhi Nagar catchment Area
S.No 1 2 3 4 5
Store Name Venus Store Mahaveer General Store Uttam General Store Ramesh Store Bhola Shanker Namkeen Bhandar
Venus Store
`
Ram esh Store Mahaveer General Store Uttam General Store
37
38
Customer feedback for Reliance Fresh 1. 2. More variety in food & non-food items is appreciated. The ambience gives them a total shopping experience.
Summary of SKUs for business Units after survey of 38 Retail Shops in the vicinity of Reliance Fresh Store, 422/18, Khandsa Road (Near Anaaj Mandi), Gurgaon. No. of SKUs 429 828 50 59 31 1397 SKUs not found in any list 70 36 43 15 3 167
S.No. 4 5 9 10 11
1000 800 600 400 200 0 Non-Food Food Hom e Lifestyle Pharm a No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List of major SKUs preferred in Khandsa Road but not present in the original list of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd. FOOD Article Description Real Twist Haldiram Fresh gold Mishrambu Gagan Loose Anmol Vita Loose Kissan bisleri mountain water
Brick 100 % juice Cow Milk Dahi Ghee Jaggery Jellies Mineral water
39
Mouth fresheners
Passpass Harvest Burger Bread Buns 225 gm Harvest Bread Healthy Whole Wheat Bread 400 gm Harvest Bread Soften French Bread 250 gm
Whole
NON-FOOD Article Brick After Shave Care Description Vi-john Haridarshan agarbatti Haridarshan dhoop Air fresheners/Deodorisers Lotus Mysore sandal (non powered) Premium Taj Goodlook Cycle Antiperspirants/deodorants Axe 100ml Playboy 125 ml MTV 125 ml Baby feeding bottles Bonny Nippo Battery Bpl Energizer Bleach Ala bleach Laundry detergents Ghadi 1kg pwd Classic tooth Oral care/aids (non brush Aquafresh tooth powered) Pipe unblockers Shaving blades brush Drainex 555 blades Vijaya blade Cigarettes Brick Article Description Wills Gold flake Scissors Benson & hedges 555 pataka Four square Kartoos Fair & lovely 75
Cleansing/Washing/Personal gm. Joy 75 gm. J & J Ear buds Cotton wool products 75pcs. Dental cleansing Vicco Powder Biotique Facial tissue/handkerchiefs Beeta Jolly (disposable) All day wipes General/Personal Daffodils hygiene/Other S R foils Colormate Moon star Black rose Sunny 100 ml. Simco Lomani
Hair colour
40
Vidut blade Shaving Razors Disposable (non powered) Vidyut Vi-john shaving cream Emami shaving Shaving preparations cream Nivea shaving cream Cobra shaving cream Sun protection products Garnier Chand toilet cleaner Sun toilet cleaner Taj toilet cleaner S R Toilet Roll Beeta HOME Brick Fridge bottle Jug Facial tissue (wet & dry) Brick Article Description Fridge bottle - Pearlpet Milton Beeta tissue box 100 sheet LIFESTYLE Article Description Cello Montex Reynolds Pentek Pierre Cardin Parker 6 water col CK/5 Wax crayon-pencil, notepad Unbranded Faber-castle Apsara Fa Variants -175ml Vaseline Lipguard Apsara Nataraj Skin drying powder Household cleaning/care aids Hair care products other
Rahat rooh Cantheridin Local Fabler bright Household disinfectants Local Boroft talcum powder Vaseline talcum powder Liril talcum powder Z talcum powder Nivea Home Classic lite
Toilet paper
Matches
Ball pens
Combi kit Elastic bands Erasers Fragrances Lip balm Lip gloss Sharpners
41
Competitor Analysis Following stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in foods category, which pose a serious competition to Reliance Fresh in Khandsa Road catchment Area. S.No 1 2 3 4 5 Store Name Today Store Tapodhani Store Jagdamba Store Hemant Store Needs Store No. of SKU's 646 633 562 560 513
Needs Store
Today Store
Hemant Store
`
Tapodhani Store Jagdam ba Store
Today Store
Tapodhani Store
Jagdamba Store
Hemant Store
Needs Store
42
43
Summary of SKUs for business Units after survey of 32 Retail Shops in the vicinity of Reliance Fresh Store, Zamroodpur, GK-1, New Delhi - 48 (Near Lady Sriram College) Not in any S.No. 1 2 3 Business Unit Equipment Non Food Food TOTAL No. of SKUs 8 353 487 848 Reliance SKUs list 4 53 127 174
500 400 300 200 100 0 Equipm ent Non-Food Food No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List of major SKUs preferred in Zamroodpur but not present in the original lists of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd. FOOD Article Brick Atta Blended oil Block chocolates Candies Candies Candies Chips Description Ashoka Loose Jindal Oil 1 litre Amul chocolate 50 gm. Hajmola candy re. 0.50 per pcs Chloromint Vijeta orange Re. 0.50 per pcs. Haldiram classic chips 15g pp (rs.3) Lays masala chips Brick Egg Fruit based (mango) Health supplements others Jams Maida Namkeens Mustard oil Article Description Loose: regular white shell eggs Slice 300 ml btl Glucon-D orange 200 gm Kissan mixed fruit jam Rs.2 pouch Loose maida Murmurre 50gm (local) Baba oil 1litre pet Baba oil 500ml pet
44
Clear
15g pp (Rs.5) 7 Up 300 ml bottle Sprite 300 ml bottle Mountain Dew 300 Limca 300 ml bottle Coca-cola 300 ml bottle Namkeens
Baba oil 15litre tin Baba oil 5litre Hardil mustard oil Duggar mikture Shahji mixture Magic: Fry Noodles noodles, ready to eat 10gm pack
Colas
Pepsi 300 ml bottle Thums Up 300 ml bottle Krown gold cookies 100 gm pp Krown gold premium biscuits 250 gm pp Anmol yummy
Cookies
Malka red 500gm Royal blue 500 ml Packaged water pet Royal blue 1 lt pet
Core Biscuits
75gm Anmol-G 75gm pp Britania Tiger cream biscuits 165gm pp P goldMarie Lite
Poha Loose poha Rava / sooji Loose unbranded Loose rice type 1-4 Loose sona masoori Loose parmal regular Loose standard rice Royal blue soda 500 Nutrela Dabur garlic ginger paste Bikaneer mix namkeen 400 gm Bikaneer pouch Crax-Mast mattar 45
Biscuit 16 gm pp Loose urad dal Mango sip 200ml Safal 200ml Good health 5 litre
Raw rice Raw rice Soda / mixers Soya nuggets Spices - others Namkeens
Blended oil Candies Nafed 5 litre Coffee bite Loose candies Nancy Solano re.0.50 per pcs Vicks
10 gm pack Haldiram Taka-Tak Chut kut Fun flips Golmaal Chips Krackkur Krishna Lip chip Yellow's diamond Glucon-D Bru instant coffee 13gm sachet Kingfisher 1litre Rajdarbar Mouth fresheners Rajnigandha Balaji Mustard oil Ashirwad 1lt Rusks & baked Golden OK meat Masala 100gm MDH Garam Spices masala Masala 100gm OK Garam Masala 100 gm pack Satmola Jaljira pow. Re.1 sachet Local turmeric Competitor Analysis Salt Tea packed leaf Ketchups biscuits Wah taj 350 gm Britania rusk 350 gm pack Shaktimaan toast Surya 1kg Nova tea 100 gm pack Hilltop 500ml Packaged water Packaged 15gm pack Pooja all in one 150g pack Pooja aloo bhujia 400g pack Pooja chana chor 150 gm Pooja falhari chiwda 150g pp Pooja kashmiri mix 200g pack Pooja panchratan Other dry fruits mix 150g pack Batashe loose Amrit Taaza bread Golden bite bun Farmer's city fresh max 400 gm bread Lord's bite bread 200gm Oxyizer 1ltr
46
Following Stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in Foods category, but none of them pose much competition to Reliance Fresh in the Zamroodpur catchment area as almost all of them are small retail shops having limited number of SKUs. S.No 1 2 3 4 5 Store Name Brij Lal Senjay Kumar Shiv Store Dinesh Store Sukda Store Vijay Store No. of SKU's 299 276 263 256 249
Vijay Store
`
Sukda Store Shiv Store Dinesh Store
Shiv Store
Dinesh Store
Sukda Store
Vijay Store
Market Overview:
47
1. Mix Population ranging from lower income group to higher middle income group 2. HLL has an efficient distribution network in the area because of regular and frequent visits of their sales men and Supervalue Stores 3. Presence of Retailors like Subhiksha and 6 Ten in the vicinity. Big Bazar and Big Apple are in negotiations with many people regarding site for opening their outlets 4. Majority of the stores had large number of SKUs 5. Almost whole population in the area feel that big organised retailers like Reliance, Subiksha, Big Apple etc. are operating in loss, as they aim at eliminating small unorganised retailers 6. Nearby there is Azadpur Mandi which results in less people coming to Retail Stores for Food items.
Summary of SKUs for business Units after survey of 35 Retail Shops in the vicinity of Reliance Fresh Store, Majlis Park, Adarsh Nagar, New Delhi-33 (Near NDPL office) Not in any S.No. 2 4 5 Business Unit Equipment Non Food Food Total No. of SKUs 15 353 734 1102 Reliance SKUs list 4 32 119 155
800 600 400 200 0 Non-Food Food Equipm ent No. Of SKUs Not in any Reliance SKUs List
List of major SKUs preferred in Adarsh Nagar but not present in the original lists of 3,500 SKUs prepared by Reliance Retail Ltd.
48
Food Brick 100 % juice Atta Article description Tuk 3 (1litre) orange Ashoka loose Apna bhog loose Safal loose atta Jindal oil 1 lit Amul chocolate Hajmola candy re.0.50 each Mango mood re.0.50 each Pan pasand re.0.50 each Chana dal regular Channa dal Cheese spread Chocolates Core biscuits Cream biscuits 500gm Chana dal 2 kg Milk man Amul milk chocolate Golmol 100gm Funfill orange cream 100gm Gopaljee milkshake pwdr kulfi flavour 200gm Goaljee milkshake pwdr strawberry flavour 200gm Gopaljee badam shake powder 200gm Anmol yummy 75gm pp Gopaljee thandai powder 200gm Tea bags 100 % juice Spices - others Dabur garlic ginger paste 150gm Homemade masala 200gm tp Brooke bond Safal orange juice 250ml Other flours Pickles Salted biscuits Soya nuggets Brick Ghee Health supplements others Jaggery Maida Mustard oil Article description Madhusudan 5 litre jar Glucon-D orange 200 gm Jaggery (Gur) loose Loose Maida Tez mustard oil 500ml kanodia brand mustard oil 1ltr,2ltr Bombay Chana 200 gm pack (Local) Shahji Mixture 250 gm (Local) Sanskriti Mixture (Local) Gopaljee Dalia 500gm pack Mothers Madras Onion Pickle 400gm Time Pass 150 gm Nutrela 200 gm Loose Dabur garlic paste 50gm Dabur ginger paste 50 gm.
Candies
Namkeens
Instant powders
49
Anmol-g 75gm pp Paras cow ghee 1ltr Loose dahi Regular white shell fresh eggs loose Gopaljee elaichi flavour 200ml Gopaljee kesar
Shyam jeera pwd 100 gm cbd Divya salt 1kg pp Parle may fair mini butter cookies 20g pp Parle may fair butter cookies 70g pp Dip trix biscuit (free
Core biscuits
Flavoured milk
200ml Gopaljee pista badam 200ml Gopaljee butterscotch 200ml Nutune gulkand box 50 gm. Dabur homemade tomato puree 200g
Bubble gums
100pcs box Boomer jelly watermelon 100pcs Parle kaccha mango bite re.0.50 each Bonkers chews re.0.50 each Bonkers chews stick
Candies
Ketchups
Candies
Rs.5 each Cadbury's mr. Pop lollypop (55gx55pcs) box Anmol Lemon Maza
Chips Funflips 35g pp Chips Haldiram's Whoopies 11g pack Pansari Mustard oil Mustard oil Ghee Maida Pickles Mineral water 1 litre Pet Pansari mustard oil 1/2 litre Pet Madhusudan 15L tin Maida, Delhi Mill Stag Local: thakurjimango 500g H2G0 1 litre bottle Paras 1 litre bottle Spices - masala Chocolates Muffins Namkeen Cream biscuits
Cream Biscuits 250g pp Cadbury's Celebrations Lotto Choco Pie Local/Unbranded Kakaji Moong 35 gm. Harnarayan Amla Murabba 1kg Harnarayan gajar Murabba 1kg Chaman Achaar Masala 1/2 kg tp
Pickles
50
Top Ramen 100 gm Spicy Veg Cup Noodles noodles Top Ramen 100 gm Mast Masala Cup Noodles Canned food
Chaman achaar masala 1 kg jar Ching's Secret Sweet Corn kernels 500gm tin
Competitor Analysis Following Stores have the largest stocking of different SKU's in Foods category, which pose a serious competition to Reliance Fresh in Adarsh Nagar catchment Area. S.No 1 2 3 4 5 6 Store Name Subhiksha Randhir Store Barnala Store Mahadev Store Ahuja Store Gurunanak Store No. of SKU's 725 615 501 437 368 345
Subhiksha
Randhir Store
`
Gurunanak Store Ahuja Store Barnala Store
Mahadev Store
Randhir Store
Barnala Store
Mahadev Store
Ahuja Store
Gurunanak Store
Subhiksha
51
Suggestions
52
A. Reliance fresh should change their product assortment according to the catchment areas. B. The company should strive to stock local brands that are popular in a given area to boost their sales. C. In order to differentiate itself from other big retailers, the company should come up with newer and more effective customer loyalty schemes. D. Reliance can give the option of shopping on credit to its customers. E. Reliance fresh can benefit from starting a home delivery service in areas close to the shop. F. More aggressive advertising campaigns should be undertaken so as to make Reliance Fresh more popular and recognizable among common masses. G. The Company should try to explore new formats in retail operations where there is no competition to be the pioneer. H. Company and sales force should concentrate more on strengthening their retail and distribution relationship and communication. I. Better storage facility, timely supply of goods and an effective system to redress complaints. J. More attractive promotional offers should be devised to attain customer loyalty and retaining them for a longer time. K. The company should make all out efforts to retain the competitive edge in pricing over its competitors.
53
LIMITATIONS
54
1) The storekeepers were reluctant to give data regarding their shops and hence we had to continuously probe for information. 2) To wait patiently, as we were on the learning front. 3) Some of the respondents were sometimes too casual while giving interviews 4) Respondents sometimes had opposite views while having a discussion with us on the retail sector coming up in India.
55
BIBLIOGRAPHY
56
BIBLIOGRAPHY
REFERENCES
www.ril.com accessed on Friday 15th June, 2007 www.about.com accessed on 1st July, 2007 www.retailindia.com accessed on 8th July, 2007
57