Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Himachal Pradesh
Punjab
Uttaranchal
Haryana
Arunachal Pradesh
Delhi
Sikkim
Meghalaya
Bihar
Manipur
Tripura
West Bengal
India
Gujarat
Chhattisgarh
India
Daman and Diu
Orissa
Maharashtra
India
Andhra Pradesh
Goa
Karnataka
Pondicherry
2007-08
Kerala
Tamil Nadu
SUMMARY REPORT
India
2007-08
SUMMARY REPORT
Principal Investigators
Professor Ariela Keysar and Professor Barry A. Kosmin
Research Analyst
Steven Schmidt
Contents
Introduction
T
he Worldviews and Opinions of Scientists in India Summary Report gives the highlights of an
international, academic web survey conducted by the nonpartisan Institute for the Study of Secularism
in Society and Culture (ISSSC) of Trinity College in Hartford, Connecticut. The survey was conducted
between August 2007 and January 2008 in cooperation with the Center for Inquiry India. The large national
sample of Indian scientists, the first of its kind, included 1,100 participants from 130 universities and research
institutes. The intent is to conduct a series of surveys in various countries with differing cultures, in order to
learn who today’s scientists are and what they think about contemporary moral and ethical issues.
The criteria for inclusion in the survey were possession of a personal e-mail address at a scientific institution that
was in the public domain and having a doctorate or equivalent qualification. The scientists were approached
individually to participate via an e-mail contact letter, which was followed up by an electronic web-based survey
questionnaire. The survey was administered directly from ISSSC in Connecticut and replies were transmitted
directly to a dedicated website. The Center for Inquiry India helped design the questionnaire. All the respondents
were assured that participation was completely voluntary. No incentives of any kind were offered and no
support or encouragement was sought from the scientists’ own institutions. The 130 institutions with which the
participants are affiliated are listed in Part I-G. The institutions with the largest number of respondents were the
Indian Institutes of Technology in Kanpur (58), Kharagpur (53), Madras (51) and Bombay, Powai (50). Other
institutions with large numbers of participating scientists were the Indian Institute of Science (41), the Indian
Statistical Institute (33), the Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (24) and the National
Institute of Mental Health & Neuro Science (21).
The median average time spent online completing the questionnaire, including answering questions and adding
comments, was 21 minutes. The survey instrument invited the respondents to participate “in an international
research project designed to explore the beliefs and values of scientific professionals.” The self-identified “scientific
professionals” were assured in the instructions:
The information gathered in this study will be kept confidential, of course. The data will be reported only in the
aggregate and you will not be identified in any way in any reports. Many of the questions deal with personal beliefs
and worldviews. If you find any questions intrusive or insensitive, feel free to skip them. You have the right to change
your mind about participation in this study at any point. At the end of the questionnaire you can offer additional
comments and express your feelings.
In fact, many hundreds of respondents took the opportunity to offer a rich array of comments, explanations and
expansions upon their answers to the questionnaire. This rich material will be reported separately on the ISSSC
website, along with detailed multivariate analyses, a full description of the methodology and the text of the
questionnaire. In this report, the exact wording of the survey question appears in the heading of each figure.
This summary report contains three sections. The first is a profile of the respondents. The second describes their
opinions on political, economic and scientific issues. The third delves into their worldviews and religious beliefs
and attitudes.
1A pioneering study of 800 Indian scientists limited to five institutions (India Institute of Science, Bangalore; Delhi University; Indian
Institute of Technology, Delhi; American College, Madurai; and C.M.S. College, Kottayam) was carried out in the early 1970s (David
Gosling, Science and Religion in India, The Christian Literature Society, Madras, 1976).
2 Part I The Profile of the Scientists
Part I
The Profile of the Scientists
Physics 40
Life Science 34
Engineering 16
Earth Science 15
Medicine/Veterinary/ 15
Health
Mathematics 12.5
Behavioral/
4
Social Science
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45
Part II
Opinions on Political, Economic
and Scientific Issues
Most of the scientists chose this What was the main reason that led you to become
career path because of personal a scientist?
interest and curiosity. Some followed
a teacher or a role model and others Personal interest, curiosity 55%
thought of doing good in the world.
Only a very small minority were A teacher/role model 20%
attracted to science for its financial Doing good in the world 11%
rewards or social status. Job opportunities 6%
Vocation/calling 6%
Social status, international contact, financial reward 2%
n = 1,100 100%
On the scale of 1 to 7, a majority In your opinion, how well respected are scientists
of respondents answered four or in India?
more, indicating that in their
opinion scientists are generally 100
well respected in India.
90
80
70
60
percent
50
40
30
20
27 29
10
14 16
1 5 8
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Very badly Very well
6 Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues
In Indian usage, “scientific To what extent do you think that India today is fulfilling its
temper” refers to free inquiry, constitutional duty “to develop the scientific temper,
the application of logic and humanism and the spirit of inquiry and reform?” (Article 51Ah)
the avoidance of bias and
preconceived notions. (On a scale from 1 to 7)
100
Overall, the majority of
90
responses to this question
on the constitutional duty 80
to develop “scientific temper” 70
are negative and critical.
60
percent
50
40
30
20
29
10 24 23
14 4
6 1
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Not at all Very much
Most respondents believe that To what extent should government and public funding
public funding of science should of science be based on its technological benefits to
be based on its technological the nation?
benefits. Furthermore, most
approve of private-sector To what extent do you approve of private sector
involvement in basic science. commercial involvement in basic science?
100
90
80
70
60
percent
50
40
30
20
10 25 21 21 24 21 22
2 16 14
6 6 10 9
0 5
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Very little Very much
Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues 7
The preference for a mixed economy Which is your preferred economic model?
is consistent with the respondents’ support
for both government and private funding
of science. 56% Mixed economy
9% Socialism
6% Village based/autarchic
8% Unsure
Three out of four of the scientists believe In your opinion, is the under-representation
that the current under-representation of of women in the sciences due to nature
women in the sciences (see Part I-A) is (biological, genetic, inheritance) or nurture
due to nurture, that is, to culture influence (learning, cultural influence)?
and learning, rather than nature, i.e.,
biological and genetic reasons.
75% Nurture
9% Nature
6% Unsure
1
Overall the Indian scientists think that How would you rate the scientific literacy today
scientific literacy in the country is low. of the following groups in India?
They rank school teachers as having the (Mean scores)
highest rate of scientific literacy while School teachers 3.6
ranking politicians lowest. Interestingly,
the media score the third highest, just Young men 3.4
below young men and above young women. Media people 3.1
Government officials and business people
Young women 3.1
are also perceived as more scientifically
literate than the Indian population as Government officials 2.7
a whole. Business people 2.6
The population as a whole 2.3
Politicians 1.9
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Very low Very high
8 Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues
The vast majority of the Do you think that the process of biological evolution
scientists endorse the theory is a fact?
of evolution (88% “definitely”
or “probably”) but there is a Do you think that human beings, as we know them,
slight tendency towards “human developed from earlier species of animals?
exceptionalism” with a lower
degree of definite commitment 100
to the concept that “human 90
beings developed from earlier
80
species of animals.”
70
60
percent
50
40
30 66
54
20
30
10 22
3 2 3 8 9
0 5
Definitely not Probably not Unsure Probably Definitely
12
Yes
10
22
Unsure
26
66
No
64
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
percent
Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues 9
The levels of opposition to Would you refuse to work on any of the following because
personal engagement in of your moral or religious beliefs?
potentially controversial areas
of scientific research range widely Designing Biological Weapons 64
by issue. Of course, depending
Designing Nuclear Weapons 54
on the scientific discipline of the
respondent, the individual ethical Chemical Pollution 34
issue can be either “theoretical” Human Cloning 29
or “practical.” Detailed findings
Animal Vivisection 21
according to scientific fields can
be viewed on the survey website. Voluntary Euthanasia 16
Population Control 11
Genetic Engineering 8
Stem Cell Research 8
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent responding “Yes”
Among traditional or alternative Do you think that there is any efficacy in the following?
curative and diagnostic techniques,
two clearly stand out. About half Homeopathy 50
of these scientists think homeopathy 49
Prayer
(50%) and prayer (49%) are efficacious.
Less than 20% endorse faith healing, Faith Healing 16
Vaastu and astrology. The least favored Vaastu 14
therapies, endorsed by only a few 14
Astrology
scientists, are amulets and dowsing.
Magnetic Therapy 13
Pranic Therapy 13
Electrotherapy 10
Reflexology 10
Palmistry 10
Reiki 8
Urine Therapy 7
Numerology 6
Power of Amulets 3
Dowsing 2
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent responding “Yes” to each item
10 Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues
The scientists are by far more Do you approve or disapprove of degree courses in
likely to approve of university Vedic Astrology?
degree courses in Ayurvedic
medicine (90% “strongly” Do you approve or disapprove of university degree
or “somewhat”) than degree courses in Ayurvedic medicine?
courses in Vedic Astrology
(44%). 100
90
80
70
60
percent
50
40
30 58
20
31 27 32
10 17
3 13 12 3
0 5
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent responding “Yes” to each item
Part II Opinions on Political, Economic and Scientific Issues 11
The Indian scientific community is In 2005 space scientists went to Tirupati to seek
split on the issue of seeking a religious the blessing of Lord Venkateswara before launching
endorsement of a space research project, the rocket and satellite.
which occurred in 2005. Approval of
this ritual has the support of 41% of Do you approve or disapprove of the action?
the scientists while 46% disapprove.
However, the level of disapproval is
more intense with a plurality (33%)
“disapproving strongly.” 14% Approve strongly
nsure
13% U
A plurality of the scientists (44%) Do you think that scientific organizations should
is willing to criticize and confront confront religious practices if they contradict
religions where they think they accepted scientific theories?
contradict accepted scientific
theories but a sizeable minority
(23%) is opposed.
44% Yes
33% Sometimes
23% No
12 Part III Worldviews and Beliefs
Part III
Worldviews and Beliefs
The majority of the Indian scientists What is your current religion, if any?
are Hindus and 10% self-identify
Hindu 66%
as atheists or having no religion.
Small minorities of the scientists are Christian 3%
Christians or Muslims or profess Muslim 3%
other religions.
Sikh, Buddhist & Other 4%
Atheist/ No religion/ Secular 10%
Did not report their religion 14%
n = 1,100 100%
III-B. Vegetarianism
The scientists are most likely to regard When it comes to your outlook, do you regard
their personal outlook as “secular” or yourself as...?
“somewhat secular” (75%). Note that
in India, secularism means tolerance
(see II-M). 59% Secular
7% Religious
3% Don’t know
Part III Worldviews and Beliefs 13
Most of the scientists reject Do you agree or disagree with the following statements?
the idea of divine or human
ability to perform miracles.
However the level of support God performs
38
for “supernatural” human miracles
agency (24%) is noteworthy.
Holy people 24
perform miracles
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent responding “Agree strongly” or “Agree somewhat”
Ghosts/Spirits 7
Caste system 6
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Percent responding “Yes” to each item
14 Part III Worldviews and Beliefs
III-G. Spirituality
70
60
percent
50
40
30
20
10 24
17 19
11 14
7 9
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Not at all Very much
The ISSSC research team would like to express their appreciation to all the
Indian scientists who agreed to participate in the survey and share their
worldviews and opinions. The Indian project is the first in a series of
international surveys of scientists in various countries representing a variety
of cultures.
This project is a work in progress. Further findings and additional statistics are available and
will be updated periodically at www.trincoll.edu/secularisminstitute.