Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
By Dr N Dr. N. Ramani
At the end of this Training, the participant should be able to: 1. Master basic Tolerance Types & Tolerance Concepts 2. To do basic Stack-up Analysis Techniques for 100% & 99.7% Interchangeability 3. Do a formal Tolerance stack-up analysis for Documenting d i C design Conditions diti 4. Determine if statistical Interchangeability will give a lower cost product 5. Determine if larger tolerance zones can meet Design requirements 6. Understand the Principle of Robust Design
Case of 100% infallible interchangeability no matter the cost : Safety is of paramount importance
Why do we require to do Tolerance Analysis? 1. To determine whether the parts will assemble 100% of the time or only 99.7% of the time statistically? 2. To determine if the parts will function properly at t worst t condition diti 3. To determine if the drawing tolerances could be larger 4. To complete p the design g p process 5. To provide a record of the dimensional design requirements that can be reviewed at a later date in case of a product problem 5
Assumptions while doing Tolerance Analysis: 1.All dimensions apply at 20oC 2.All 2 All manufactured f t d parts t meet t dimensional requirements of drawing 3.All parts are rigid in free state & in asse b y assembly 4.For , parts are manufactured ST with ith th the mean di dimension i as T Target t
What are the Types of Tolerance Analysis? 1. Radial Stack 2 Linear Stack 2. 3. Assembly Stack What do they do?
What are the Types of Tolerance Analysis? 1. Radial Stack Involves diameters or radial directions 2. Linear Stack Involves dimensions that are in X,Y , or Z direction 3. Assembly Stack Involves radial or linear directions of several parts Give a pictorial example for each type
Find the Dimension & Tolerance of X for +/-3 +/100% 3 Sigma I Interchangeability t conformance h bilit Example of a Linear Stack
11
Assembly y Stack
12
100 $ 100 $
?$
COST
100% Interchangeability
99.7% Interchangeability
Estimate E ti t the th cost t for f 99.7% 99 7% interchangeability i t h bilit Please write down your answer
13
100 $ 100 $
?$
COST
100% Interchangeability
99.7% Interchangeability
14
1. Let us say that there is a possibility to reduce cost substantially, if you are prepared to accept 99.7% Interchangeability, in place of 100% 2. Let us say that cost saving will more than offset the loss of 0.3% Interchangeability (3 out of 1000 assemblies) ) 3. Please answer the question, at what reduced cost, you will accept 99.7% Interchangeability
15
100 $ 100 $
Cost Saving
?$
COST
100% Interchangeability
99.7% Interchangeability
16
100 $
COST
< 20 $
100% Interchangeability
99.7% Interchangeability
17
100% Interchangeability
18
100% Interchangeability
19
Effect of component tolerances upon the assembly Assumption Extreme assembly conditions can and will be met in practice
100% Interchangeability
20
100% Interchangeability
21
Highest
Si of Size f B P Part t
Lowest
B
Lowest
A
Highest
Size of A Part
22
C min
C max
B max
A max
23
24
Effect on Assembly
26
27
Assembly tolerance = Sum of all tolerances of the individual parts (OK for 2 or 3 parts)
One One method is to provide the widest practical component tolerances based upon the statistical fact that it is unlikely that all maximum-tolerance parts or all minimum-tolerance parts would ever be brought together in the same assembly.
28
?*
31
32
Find the Dimension & Tolerance of X for +/-3 Sigma conformance 100% Interchangeability
33
Stage 1. Covert all Dimensions to be Median values & Tolerances into Bilateral ones 34
Start
End 2 4 1 3
35
Plus Minus Direction Direction +/Distance Distance Tolerance A# 'B' 'C' 'D' 1 0.2175 2.62 0.42 1.8985 2.62 0.084 2.536 0.0025 0.01 0.01 0.0025 0.025
36
2 3 4
0.025
37
38
X ?
39
40
6
100% Success 6 (? )
41
2.63 / 2.61
42
43
44
45
46
B
48
Calculate the Dimension & Tolerance for the Circlip Groove @ 100% & 99.7% 99 7% Interchangeability
49
50
#
1 2
Determine the relationship between Assembly (resultant) tolerance of +/-0.025 & four tolerances of part viz.0.0125
52
(Assembly Tolerance)2 { Number of Parts * (Part Tolerance)2 } Part Tolerance = Assembly Tolerance / Sq.Rt of N, where N is the number of parts or dimensions involved Very Important to note: Assembly Variance = Arithmetic sum of Variances of Parts 2 Assembly A bl Assembly Tol = (n ( 1 * 12) of f Parts P vide id CLT = Part Tolerance *n
53
#
1 2
54
55
TSA Vs STA
56
ST?
Super Structure
ST ?
Foundation
57
ST
Assembly Tolerance = RMS value of Individual Tolerances Foundation
58
Process Control: 1. Must be maintained on any statistical tolerance vide ASME Y14.5 standard 2. Symbol drawn next to dimension 3 Not shown in our drawings 3. 4. Operations / QC will maintain Statistical control t l of f process
59
60
Benefits of ST: 1. Reduced costs 2. Closer average Fits 3. Improved Quality / Performance of Product Sony USA Vs Sony Japan Story
61
62
When should we apply ST? 1. Limited Space requires a close assembly tolerance 2. Fits with a narrow range of Clearance required 3 100% Interchangeability not possible 3. 4. Means of reducing manufacturing cost 5. To reduce Tolerance Accumulation Selective assembly required Adjustments / complex designs required Tighter tolerances on components required
63
When should we apply ST? What if Analysis? You want to know what will be the condition for 99.7% of parts if manufactured around the mean of dimensions
TSA Vs STA
64
65
When will ST succeed? 1. Manufacturing is done to the middle of the dimension 2. Use of proper controls to produce parts to a near normal distribution within drawing specification
66
Responsibility for achieving ST: 1. Engineers understand that parts are to be produced with the Target on the mean 2. Tools are designed & produced to achieve the above target* 3. Necessary inspection equipment are available ( (In process p gauging..) g g g ) to determine Cp & Cpk *Reamer Design Example
67
Normal Distribution: 1. Formed where manufacturing processes produce in a random manner about the mean with a majority of the dimensions close to the mean & a decreasing number occurring away from the mean 2. If dimensions from a stable process are measured & recorded according to size, a plot of resulting frequency distribution will approximate the Gaussian curve
68
CLT?
69
Conclusion?
70
Four tolerance zones can be increased & still meet original design requirements of 0.084+/-0.025 using g 99.7% p probability y
71
1 Four tolerance zones can be increased & still 1. meet original design requirements of 0.084+/-0.025 using g 99.7% p probability y 2. How did we get to suggest +/-0.0125 tolerance?
72
1 Four tolerance zones can be increased & still 1. meet original design requirements of 0.084+/-0.025 using g 99.7% p probability y 2. How did we get to suggest +/-0.0125 tolerance? 3. From CLT formula: 4. Tol of p parts / features = Tol of Assy y/( (Sq.rt q of number of parts or features)
73
74
75
100%
99 7% 99.7%
76
Is it possible to relax manufacturing tolerances on all 5 di dimensions* i * & still till achieve hi assembly bl t target t of f 0.034 +/-0.022, thereby reducing cost * +/- 2,3,4,5 & 8 thous
77
1. We have relaxed original tolerances of +/- 2,3,4,5 & 8 thous to +/ +/- 0.010 0 010 2. Check correctness of Calculations 3. How did we get proposed tolerance of 0.010?
78
Very Important
79
Part 3
P t1 Part Part 2
You are the designer of this assembly The top surface of part 1 is to be proud of the top surface of part 3 by 0.0005 0.018 Determine the Unknown Length & fix tolerances of the di dimensions i of f parts t 2&3t to achieve hi th the objective bj ti f for 100% interchangeability 80
1. Average Axial Clearance = (0.0005+0.018) / 2 = 0.00925 Nominal 2. Total Tolerance = (0.018 - 0.0005) = 0.0175 = +/- 0.00875 3. Target Clearance = 0.00925 +/- 0.00875 (Check max & min values) 4. Nominal Unknown Length = (0.250+0.125+0.00925) = 0.384(approx) 5. Tolerance of Dimensions 0.384, 0.250 & 0.125 = +/- 0.00875 / 3 = +/- 0.0029
81
Part 3
P t1 Part Part 2
You are the designer of this assembly The top surface of part 1 is to be proud of the top surface of part 3 by 0.0005 0.018 Determine the Unknown Length & fix tolerances of the di dimensions i of f parts t 2&3t to achieve hi th the objective bj ti f for 99 99.7% 7% interchangeability 82
Part Tolerance = Assembly tolerance / n = 0.0175 / 3 = 0.010 0 010 = +/- 0.005 Rechecking:
83
84
85
86
87
89
90
91
Thank You
92