Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
AND THE
The notes and recommendations in this report are based on the limited information presented. Any member choosing to act on the information included here must do so on that basis. No liability for loss occasioned to any business or the author or OATA LTD can accept person taking action or refraining from taking action, as a result of any material in this document. OATA 2006.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
2
CONTENTS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
CONTENTS
CONTENTS INTRODUCTION STRUCTURE OF THE REPORT AIMS OF THE REPORT QUESTIONNAIRES HOW TO USE THIS REPORT WHICH QUESTIONNAIRE TO USE RISK REDUCTION STRATEGIES WHAT THIS REPORT DOES NOT AIM TO DO 1.0 WHAT IS BIOSECURITY? 1.1 WHY DOES BIOSECURITY MATTER? 2.0 RISK ANALYSIS 2.1 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION 2.2 RISK ASSESSMENT UNCERTAINTY IS THE ONLY CERTAINTY! CONSEQUENCES!!! 2.3 RISK MANAGEMENT THREE TRUISMS A PRACTICAL APPROACH 3 STAGE DISEASE CONTROL SYSTEM MANAGEMENT OF PATHOGENS THAT ARE UBIQUITOUS 2.4 RISK COMMUNICATION
3
CONTENTS
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
4
CONTENTS
2.5 HACCP (HAZARD ANALYSIS AND CRITICAL POINT CONTROL) TAKING RISK ANALYSIS ONE
STEP FURTHER
DECIDING WHAT A CRITICAL CONTROL POINT IS EXAMPLES OF POTENTIAL CRITICAL CONTROL POINTS 3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL 3.1
ACCEPTABLE LEVEL OF RISK
TOLERANCE OF RISK REAL OR THEORETICAL RISKS 3.2 USING A RISK EVALUATION TABLE RISK TOLERANT OR RISK AVERSE A DECISION YOU MUST MAKE! ICH, KHV AND SVC EXAMPLES OF THE USE OF RISK EVALUATION TABLES REALITY TEST 3.3 DECISION TREE FOR DECIDING WHICH PATHOGENS AND DISEASES ARE OF CONCERN 3.4 TRAFFIC LIGHT SYSTEM 4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT!! CAN WE PROTECT OURSELVES? 4.1 CHOOSING YOUR FISH SUPPLIER THE EU APPROVED FARM MODEL THE LOGIC OF THE EU CONDITIONS 4.2 ACCEPTING RETURNS FROM CUSTOMERS 4.3 SIZE OF IMPORT CONSIGNMENTS OR DELIVERIES 4.4 RISK AND SUPPLY CHAIN CHARACTERISTICS WHY FISH DISEASES BREAK OUT MULTIPLY THE SOURCES - MULTIPLY THE RISK?
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
5
CONTENTS
5.0 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING!!! 5.1 ARE MY FISH DISEASE FREE? FREE OF DISEASE SPECIFIC PATHOGEN FREE 5.2
QUARANTINE AND ACCLIMATISATION
CAN FISH BE QUARANTINED? ACCLIMATISATION PREVENTATIVE ACCLIMATISATION 6.0 FUNDAMENTAL ISSUES 6.1 WHAT CAUSES DISEASES IN FISH POPULATIONS? 6.2 IDENTIFYING THE PATHOGEN CAUSING A DISEASE 6.3 DIFFERENT TYPES OF PATHOGEN FOUND EVERYWHERE OR NOWHERE ALWAYS A PATHOGEN? OR JUST ON SPECIAL OCCASIONS 6.4 HOW NEW OR EMERGING DISEASES APPEAR 6.5 CHARACTERISTICS OF NEW DISEASES 6.6 RATES OF PATHOGEN MULTIPLICATION 6.7 TYPES OF FISH DISEASE TRANSMISSION VERTICAL DISEASE TRANSMISSION (BETWEEN GENERATIONS) HORIZONTAL DISEASE TRANSMISSION (BETWEEN INDIVIDUAL FISH) 6.8 CHARACTERISTICS OF PATHOGENS THAT DETERMINE THE LIKELIHOOD OF DISEASE PRESENCE OR ABSENCE OF PATHOGEN HOW EASILY THE DISEASE IS TRANSMITTED POOR HUSBANDRY
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
6
CONTENTS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents
DEAD AND MORIBUND FISH DISEASE SPECIFICITY INFECTIVE DOSE OR VIRULENCE OF PATHOGEN AVOIDING AN INFECTIVE DOSE PATHOGEN PERSISTENCE 6.9 INFECTION ROUTES DIRECT CONTACT INHALATION INGESTION VECTORS AND FOMITES INTERMEDIATE HOSTS 6.10 DISEASE TRANSMISSION ROUTES WATERBORNE EXAMPLES OF VECTORS AND FOMITES FISH OTHER LIVING ORGANISMS PARASITES FOOD FAECES CLOTHES AND PERSONAL CONTACTS 7. SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT 7.1 BASIC WORKING PRACTICES 7.2 WATER MANAGEMENT
A. B.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
7
CONTENTS
E.
F. CALCULATION OF TURNOVER TIMES 7.3 STOCKING OF SYSTEMS DRAINING, DRYING AND TREATMENT FALLOWING (EMPTYING SYSTEMS) BETWEEN STOCKINGS CONTINUAL STOCKING 7.4
VENTILATION
DRY SURFACES VS WET SURFACES AS A HARBOUR FOR PATHOGENS 7.5 BIO FILTRATION AND DISEASE PREVENTION HOW BIO FILTERS CAN REDUCE PATHOGEN NUMBERS IN A SYSTEM OR INCREASE THEM!! 8.0 DISINFECTION 8.1 DEFINITIONS 8.2 DISINFECTION OF WET SURFACES DISINFECTANTS DONT DISINFECT DIRT THE EFFECTIVENESS OF DIPPING, WASHING AND SCRUBBING
DISINFECTANTS WITH
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
8
CONTENTS
8.4 CLOTHES
BACTERIA ON THE SKIN SKIN CLEANSING AND DISINFECTION BARRIERS FOR THE SKIN
DISINFECTION OF CLOTHES 8.5 FOOTWEAR 8.6 EQUIPMENT 8.7 DISCHARGE WATER 8.8 DISINFECTING SYSTEMS 9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES TECHNIQUES FOR DIAGNOSING AND SCREENING FOR SIMPLE ON-SITE INVESTIGATIONS 9.1 WATER QUALITY 9.2 PHYSICAL SIGNS IS THE PROBLEM INFECTIOUS? DISEASE CALLING CARDS CLINICAL SIGNS CLINICAL SIGNS CAN DECEIVE THE EYE MORE COMPLEX ON-SITE INVESTIGATIONS 9. 3 HAND LENS 9.4 AGGLUTINATION TESTS 9.5 MICROBIAL SAMPLING 9.6 BLOOD SAMPLING 9.7 TAKING SAMPLES FOR MICROSCOPY LABORATORY INVESTIGATIONS 9.8 SHOULD YOU HAVE AN ON-SITE LABORATORY?
DISEASES
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
9
IN FAVOUR AGAINST 9.9 MICROSCOPY 9.10 CULTURE OF PATHOGENS 9.11 IMMUNOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES A. ELISA - (ENZYME LINKED IMMUNO-SORBANT ASSAY) CAPTURE ELISA SCREENING ELISA
B. C.
CONTENTS
D. ISH (In-situ Hybridisation) and FISH (Fluorescent In-situ Hybridisation) 9.12 MOLECULAR TESTS PCR -POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION WHAT IS PCR? SINGLE AND NESTED PCR INTERPRETING RESULTS FROM PCR TESTS 9.13 CELL LINE ISOLATION OF VIRUSES 9.14 SUMMARY TABLE OF USES OF ON-SITE AND LABORATORY TESTS 10.0 TREATMENTS 10.1 THE FISHS IMMUNE SYSTEM - A NATURAL DEFENCE AGAINST DISEASES? FISHS BASIC RESPONSE TO PATHOGENS STRESS AND THE FISHS IMMUNE SYSTEM KEY FACTORS AFFECTING THE IMMUNE SYSTEM STRESS LOW
WATER TEMPERATURES
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
10
CONTENTS
10.6 IMMUNOSTIMULANTS 10.7 IMMUNISATION AND VACCINATION HISTORY PROTECTION BY VACCINES SPECIFIC IMMUNITY NON-SPECIFIC IMMUNITY TYPES OF IMMUNITY AND IMMUNISATION NATURAL OR INHERITED NATURAL EXPOSURE KILLED VACCINES LIVE ATTENUATED VACCINES METHODS OF VACCINATION IMMERSION INJECTIONS ORAL BOOSTER
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
QUESTIONNAIRES
QUESTIONNAIRE QUESTIONNAIRE QUESTIONNAIRE QUESTIONNAIRE 1 2 3 4 YOUR BUSINESS ATTITUDE TO RISK IDENTIFYING PATHOGENS OF CONCERN TO YOU ASSESSMENT OF PATHWAYS BY WHICH PATHOGENS SITE BIOSECURITY APPRAISAL
11
CONTENTS
MAY ENTER A SITE
APPENDICES
1 OATA WATER QUALITY CRITERIA 2 - EUTHANASIA 3 DISPOSAL OF CLINICAL WASTE 4 - LETHAL DOSE OF UV FOR VARIETY OF ORGANISMS 5 EFFICACY OF OZONE TYPICAL DOSAGE AND REACTION TIMES FOR A VARIETY OF ORGANISMS 6 - VETERINARY MEDICINES 7 - NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL LAW 8 - DEFRAS ADVICE ON AVOIDING SVC 9 - EMERGENCE OF INFECTIONS 10 - ZOONOSES 11 - FURTHER HELP BIBLIOGRAPHY (AVAILABLE ON THE OATA MEMBERS LOGIN SITE) WEBLIOGRAPHY (AVAILABLE ON THE OATA MEMBERS LOGIN SITE)
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
12
CONTENTS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
INTRODUCTION
The movement of fish, invertebrates and plants across international frontiers and within countries between fish farmers, collectors, wholesalers and retailers is essential for our industry. The fish and plants we move intentionally may also carry viruses, bacteria and larger organisms such as fungi, nematodes and crustacea. History has shown that most of these are apparently harmless. However, recent history has shown that some of these hitchhikers, albeit rarely, can cause serious diseases. The impact KHV has had on the market for Koi in the UK serves as a recent painful reminder of the problems that can arise when there is a loss of confidence among the buying public in the fish we sell. Governments take notice of these diseases, in particular the impact they have had (or might have) on native fish stocks or on food producing aquaculture industries. This document is intended to alert all interest groups to the responsible and pro-active stance that the industry is taking to safeguard both its future and the interests of the wider community. Many ornamental fish are kept in closed systems and so problems are contained and pose negligible risks outside of those systems. This document has been written primarily to help all contributors to the industry make informed decisions on where to buy fish and how their management of those purchases can minimise the chances of either receiving or passing on disease or health problems. Each individual business must decide to what extent, if at all, they apply the information provided. Even if every suggestion included in this document is fully implemented it cannot be guaranteed that problems will never be encountered, however the risks will be considerably reduced. The choice is not between a risky purchase and an absolutely risk free purchase (zero risk does not exist), rather it provides indications on how the risks may be reduced to a level acceptable to your business, consumers and to Government agencies. In December 2001 OATA wrote and distributed the document Koi Herpes Virus-KHV. A number of Governments specifically requested copies, at least one inter-Government agency posted the whole document on their website. It is hoped this document will demonstrate, and further, raise the credibility of the industry. We must reiterate that this document is what we believe to be, at the time of writing, sound information concerning risks and the management practices that may be employed to avoid or manage diseases. Since the information for aquatic animals is incomplete compared to terrestrial vertebrates, it is almost inevitable that advice about best practice will change with time. That said, universally accepted basic husbandry rules will always apply, and will always help prevent disease outbreaks.
13
INTRODUCTION
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
14
INTRODUCTION
Questionnaires
Detailed appendices and a webliography of Internet resources to be available via website Technical and Detailed
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
15
INTRODUCTION
QUESTIONNAIRES
The questionnaires can be used to assess how bio-secure your set up and those of your suppliers and customers are. They: Allow estimates of the risks associated with various scenarios to enable you to manage biosecurity issues now and take action, if wished, needed or required, to raise standards by establishing future targets and taking practical steps to achieve them. Establish a guide to good practice in some areas such as sourcing livestock and enable you identify how current practice might be improved. Provide outline background information on topics such as disease identification and vaccination that will help understanding of key issues.
By using the questionnaires, this report can be used to identify where you stand currently on biosecurity issues and if appropriate set future targets. The report is designed to consolidate in one place information that will enable each business to develop plans that might help decide buying policies, sales policies and work patterns to help prevent the introduction of unwanted organisms on to site or to detect them and prevent them spreading around once they are present.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
16
INTRODUCTION
R eview annually o r as required
Assess o r re-assess how these patho gens might get onto yo ur site
Unacceptable Risk
Unacceptable R isk
or
Change supplier
Acceptable
Unacceptable R isk
Accept able
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
17
INTRODUCTION
Questio nnaire 1
Questio nnaire 2
Questio nnaire 3
Questio nnaire 4
Questio nnaire 4
18
INTRODUCTION
RISK REDUCTION STRATEGIES
As an aide memoire and checklist a range of risk reduction strategies are listed. It is impossible to list all possible strategies in this document for all circumstances or confine such lists to those relevant to particular business types or situations. Thus not all will be relevant in al circumstances. The strategies can be used separately from or in conjunction with the rest of the report. Any risk reduction strategies will only be as good as the least effectively applied measure. Pathogens are likely to exploit any lapses or gaps.
THE FUTURE
This report will be revised as new information becomes available or gaps are identified. The most up to date information will be posted in the OATA members login area on our website.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
19
1.0 WHAT IS BIOSECURITY
Disease prevention
Biosecurity
Definitions of biosecurity
Biosecurity has no single definition but a working definition for our purposes could be The sum of all procedures in place to protect ornamental aquatic organisms (fish, invertebrate or plant) from contracting, carrying or spreading disease. The practical steps to achieve this will include: Deciding which diseases you want to control (Which bugs are bad?) then Deciding how to keep the bad bugs out!! Or if that fails Stopping the bad bugs spreading!!!
In this document OATA has tied together information that may help members make better informed decisions on a more formally structured basis. The level of biosecurity given by taking or omitting any of the actions or options mentioned is indicative only.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
20
WHAT IS BIOSECURITY
1.1
IN GENERAL
Biosecurity is attaining the status of the next buzzword and will have a long shelf life in the minds of politicians and the like. Fuelled by the costs associated with recent disease outbreaks they are very sensitised to the issues. For instance it is estimated that the foot and mouth disease outbreak in the UK during 2001 cost of 8 billion ($12 billion). A recent report from the Cabinet Office in the UK estimated that the potential cost of importing from Europe or Scandinavia of Gyrodactylus salaris, a disease of salmon, would be in the region of 1 billion ($1.8 billion) per annum. Increasingly non-native species of plant and animal are being viewed in much the same biosecurity terms as diseases. The information in this report will help address those issues also, though it is not its the primary aim.
COMMERCIALLY - DISEASES ALWAYS COST MONEY!!!! (EVEN IF YOU DONT GET THEM)
Whether in costs of prevention or in dealing with the problems of an outbreak, (direct economic loss, loss of consumer confidence or action taken by Governments) it is an inescapable fact that diseases cost money. Each business has to make a management decision, based on its appraisal of and policy towards risk, and choose where it meets those costs. The choices are to either avoid a disease or cope with its consequences. Inevitably there will be costs. Thus the ideas presented in this document are not and cannot be free of cost in either time or finance, but they are often cost effective compared to an outbreak of disease. An example of the impacts of disease on the industry can be seen by the records of ornamental fish exports from Israel where koi herpes virus came to prominence during the spring of 1998. (Israel exports koi, goldfish and some tropical fish though the precise breakdown between the categories is not known.) Compared to 1997 the quantity of ornamental fish exported (in terms of freight weight) to the UK reduced by 30%, 43% and almost 60% in 1999, 2000 and 2001 respectively. Indications of a recovery only became evident during 2002. This example also demonstrates that the market mechanism works very rapidly to avoid sources of fish that are identified by the industry as posing a risk.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
21
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Risk analysis is an everyday occupation for all businessmen. Will we make a profit if we stock fish from this or that supplier? What are the risks of fish losses if we buy from this or that source? In almost all cases decisions are made on the best information available: almost invariably there are gaps in that information about which judgements have to be made. Clearly the more definite and complete the information the more likely you are to be able to make a correct decision. Risk Analysis is usually broken into four interrelated parts which are described in the table below:
More practically and bluntly described in everyday English as: Deciding which diseases you want to control. (Which are the bad bugs?)
Hazard identification:
What organisms pose a risk? How can they be identified?
Risk assessment:
Under what conditions will they pose a risk? How great is the risk? What will be the consequences if a disease is:
-introduced on to your site or -is passed from your site to a clients or customers site What happens if they spread?
Risk management:
What can be done to limit the risks? What can be done to prevent the spread of pathogens? How do you keep the bad bugs out and stop them spreading if they get on site?
Risk communication:
Which this document hopes to achieve!
Telling all relevant people including suppliers, staff and customers about the results of the analysis and what is required of them and the benefits to be gained.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
22
2.1 HAZARD IDENTIFICATION 2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
The three main issues here are to decide: Which pathogens you are concerned about? The ways in which they might arrive or be transferred? How they can be identified practically?
2.2
RISK ASSESSMENT
CONSEQUENCES!!!
Any assessment of risk is incomplete without a review of the consequences. It is pointless putting time, effort and money in to protecting your business from an organism that causes no problems ( to the fish, you or the wider environment). Each business will need to balance the risks and outcomes associated with presence of particular pathogens in their stocks before deciding how or if they try to manage them or the disease(s) they may cause. Each business must ultimately make a choice of strategy based on its particular circumstances and attitude to risk and of course what is required by law.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
2.3
RISK MANAGEMENT
23
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
A PRACTICAL APPROACH
Pathogens are invaders. Just as with any invaders a three stage approach is best adopted : Approach Prevention Where to apply it at source or upon arrival Detection of newly arrived unwanted pathogens As soon after arrival as possible Techniques to apply Exclusion from the supply chain by vaccination/health screening, prophylaxis etc. Isolation/quarantine. Screening using appropriate method to ensure early detection. Rapid action, including treatment and/or euthanasia to eliminate problem before it spreads. As for prevention and detection of newly arrived unwanted pathogens.
On site continual
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
24
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
25
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Isolation, preventative acclimatization, treatment and management to eliminate or reduce pathogen loading at each "import" along the supply chain. Treatment on an "as needed" basis on in-coming stocks
Exclusion of pathogen. Closed systems eg. using principles of EU approved farm model to prevent pathogen entering supply chain.
Elimination or reduction by treatment or management prior to "export" from each site along the supply chain.
H igher biosecurity
Lower biosecurity
Some organisms that can cause disease such as Ich and Aeromonas hyrophilia are ubiquitous that is they are found everywhere. Others have a more restricted distribution and can potentially be more easily avoided.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
26
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
2.4
RISK COMMUNICATION
A risk analysis is of no use at all if it remains in your head or on a piece of paper in the desk. It is vital that you communicate to others: what you think the risks are the risks you are not prepared to accept how you will exclude those risks that you are not prepared to accept the risks you are prepared to accept how you will manage those risks you are prepared to accept (even if that includes doing nothing)
Who should you be telling? fish suppliers and their staff and in turn the producer or collector if possible your staff customers and other visitors to your site
This might be achieved by briefly stating your position on paper and possibly even in contracts of supply. This document is designed to help you reach your own conclusions on a range of issues. The questionnaires may help in crystallising your views.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
2.5
27
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
HACCP is the acronym for Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Point. This approach, which first arose in the food industry, seeks to identify hazards. It then identifies critical stages at which controls can most effectively be applied, to minimise or eliminate a risk. These are known as CCPs Critical Control Points. CCPs might include which fish you allow on to your site species, their origin, the supply chain used and the like. On your site critical control points might include isolation of new arrivals, preventative treatments, mixing (or not) of fish from different sources, movement of stock or equipment between different systems. All of these matters you have or could have control over and the controls you put in place and how they are managed can dramatically alter how secure your site and business is from problems caused by fish diseases. To identify CCPs you need to clearly layout all the livestock procedures on your site.
HACCP OVERVIEW
Consider all the potential biosecurity hazards that could occur on your site. Identify and rank significant hazards or critical concerns. Consider how to limit, avoid or eliminate the identified hazards. List the methods used and confirm preventative measures are in place. Consider appropriate action, corrective action or alternative plans. Enable and ensure record keeping is in place to facilitate monitoring of activities and outcomes. Put in place a system to check all the actions are actually taking place.
Of course none of this will work unless the outcomes of any review are communicated effectively to staff and they are trained to put recommendations into action. It may be very valuable to get them involved in the whole process, as they are actively involved in what really happens on a daily basis.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
28
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Hazard
Modify the step, process or product
Yes
No
Is control necessary?
No
No No
Could hazards reach unacceptable levels?
Yes
Yes
No
NOT A CCP
CCP
* Flow chart taken from "Code of Practice for Bio-security in the Egg Industry" RIRDE Publication No. 01/102 Project No>MS001-02
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
29
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Staff training in and knowledge of fish health, animal transport and phyto-sanitary legislation
2. Movements of live animals, plants and equipment on site o o which may be influenced by o o o o o o Acclimatisation/quarantine/isolation of new arrivals Staff knowledge and training Policy on the use and movement of equipment e.g. buckets, hoses, nets etc and water between different systems Fish health maintenance and monitoring programmes Water quality management and monitoring programmes Proper maintenance of UV or ozone systems if installed Isolation of any on-site disease investigation area Ventilation
3. What you do when your system fails and you have a disease problem o o o o o Be aware of any local legislation concerning requirements to notify disease Be aware of local legislation on movement of animals or plants after a disease outbreak. Ensure staff are trained to detect and react to disease outbreaks including legal or ethical requirements concerning euthanasia and disposal of mortalities Be aware of diagnosis techniques and treatment (including the rules governing these) Build up a relationship with a local veterinary surgeon.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
30
2.0 RISK ANALYSIS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
CHAPTER 3 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL. (Which are the bad bugs!)
31
3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL
3.1
First you must decide what level of risk or threat you will tolerate? Remember some organisms found on fish can causes disease in humans these are known as zoonoses. (See Appendix 10). Almost inevitably cost and personal attitude will be a driver in deciding what level of risk your business will tolerate (unless of course legislation decides the matter for you). Massive costs controlling a problem that has no impact are unlikely to be acceptable.
Tolerance of risks
Each business must make its own decision on what is an Acceptable Level Of Protection (you will often see this reduced to the acronym - ALOP), for itself and its customers based on experience and their own attitude to risk.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
32
3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL
3.2
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
33
In the risk evaluation table (a blank copy of which can be found for your use at questionnaire 2) below an attempt has been made to give an indicative value for the risk of the scenarios of probability and consequences that might be encountered. The higher the score the greater risk is associated with a particular set of circumstances.
Probability
of introduction Negligible or very low Score Minimal or Negligible Very low Low High Very High 1 3 5 7 9 1 1 3 5 7 9
Consequences of introduction
Low Medium High Very High Catastrophic 3 3 9 15 21 27 5 5 15 25 35 45 7 7 21 35 49 63 9 9 27 45 63 81
Using your own experience and the information contained in this report, you may be able to make an informed estimate of the probability of entry, on to your site, for each pathogen. Past experience and reports from others will enable you to predict the most likely consequences of the introduction of a pathogen on to your site, based on site-specific information such as temperature, stocking density, water quality and food used etc. To an extent both the probability of the entry of a pathogen and the consequences of its introduction are in your own hands. By implementing controls and appropriate management to: suppliers on-site activities(eg acclimatisation, isolation and treatment etc)
you can reduce (to zero in some cases)the probability of a pathogen entering your site, an outbreak of disease and in turn the consequences including disruption and cost can be reduced. It must be your decision about the level of risk you are happy for your business to tolerate. In making a decision loss of reputation and business caused by disease outbreaks are maybe just as valid as biological considerations such as the number of fish dying in a disease outbreak.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
34
3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL
Probability
of introduction Negligible or very low Score Minimal or Negligible Very low Low High Very High 1 3 5 7 9 1
Consequences of introduction
Low Medium High Very High Catastrophic 3 5 7 9
Spring Viraemia of Carp (SVC) and Koi Herpes Virus (KHV) SVC has been rarely encountered in the ornamental fish industry in the UK, but as a notifiable disease it must be reported to the relevant authorities. The consequences are that when found all the susceptible species on a site must be slaughtered and the site disinfected appropriately. In countries where SVC is not notifiable the consequences of the disease may be less extreme, the mortalities caused by the disease are rarely 100%, but the option of exporting to countries like the UK is lost. The mere presence of the virus causing SVC can be catastrophic in countries operating stringent controls, whether or not it is causing disease at the time it is found Measures can be put in place to exclude KHV. The success of excluding KHV will depend on the testing undertaken and the quality of the exclusion and isolation techniques used by suppliers. Once on a site when the temperature is in the correct range it is almost inevitable that catastrophic mortalities of koi will follow.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
35
Very high probability variable consequences Ich Icthyophthirius multifilis Risk evaluation table
Probability
of introduction Negligible or very low Score Minimal or Negligible Very low Low High Very High 1 3 5 7 9 1
Consequences of introduction
Low Medium High Very High Catastrophic 3 5 7 9
Ich Icthyophthirius multifilis Ich is found a round the globe. Thus there is a chance of it being present in any group of fish. Its population can grow very rapidly and it can cause serious mortalities, particularly among young fish. However, if properly treated it can be controlled and be of very little problems or consequences.
Reality test?
Past performance, though not 100% reliable, acts as a useful indicator of the effectiveness of your current practice. If your style of trading has meant that no problems have occurred either on your premises or those of customers in the onward supply chain or in the local environment, then that practical prior experience indicates that the operation is of low risk. Even so, we would encourage all businesses to review their operations using the concepts in this document. You could have just been lucky so far!!
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
3.3 DECISION TREE FOR DECIDING WHICH PATHOGENS AND DISEASES ARE OF CONCERN
36
Review and list the range of pathogens that the fish you sell might came into contact with
Determine the potential costs and consequences of the introduction of each pathogen on your
Tolerate
Interact actively with your suppliers to ensure management practices to exclude pathogen
Manage
Ignore as inconsequential
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
3.4
37
3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL
You might adopt a traffic light system of prioritisation for action. A green light or low risk - no or little action required - would be given to Ubiquitous organisms, or strains of them, that cause no problems. On the risk evaluation matrix (section 3.2) the arrival of these on site would be regarded as highly probable, but whose impact would be negligible. It may not be cost effective to try to exclude these organisms (but bear in mind there may be pathogenic strains of otherwise benign species which you might want to exclude). Good general husbandry can be used to ensure they do not become a problem. For instance some internal parasites where the life cycle cannot be completed in captivity (eg Diphylopbothrium). An amber light or medium risk - would be given to species or pathogens That are widely distributed or ubiquitous and that while they can cause serious problems you can tolerate them, cant avoid them or exclude them from the supply chain and because management by effective treatments are available e.g. Trichodina, Ich. A red light or high risk - would be given to. Notifiable diseases. In the UK the main disease of relevance for goldfish and carp is SVC. Very infectious diseases causing high mortalities for which treatment is inappropriate, difficult, expensive or not available. Efforts should be taken to exclude the pathogens causing these diseases (which might include strains of otherwise harmless bacteria) from the supply chain.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
38
3.0 DECIDING WHICH DISEASES YOU WANT TO CONTROL
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
39
CHAPTER 4 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT!
CAN WE PROTECT OURSELVES?
As pointed out earlier a truism is that if a pathogen is not present in a country or region or on an individual fish producers site it cannot be spread to your site. Many countries require that imports are free of specific pathogens. To achieve this, different standards are incorporated in their import laws. There are lessons to be learnt from some of the model conditions established in these laws. The EU specifies the conditions that must be met for a farm to be approved free of a disease. This model and the issues it raises can be used to establish a qualitative idea of the risks of trading with a particular supplier, whether that be an exporter, importer or wholesaler. You may choose to vary the model, for instance by adding more pathogens you want to exclude from the supply chain, or disregard bits of the model that you regard as irrelevant in your particular circumstance. It is likely that as more Governments, become more nervous about biosecurity issues, that they have already introduced or will introduce changes to their import controls with the aim of keeping fish diseases out. In a few instances there might be a relaxation of excessively tight regulation to avoid international action for imposing unfair controls through bodies like the WTO. However, rules on the national and international transfer of live aquatic (or indeed any) animals and plants are more likely to be gradually tightened than relaxed.
Buy from sites that can prove they have not got the pathogen or pathogens about which you are concerned. Or
Buy from sites that have treated the fish for the pathogens of concern prior to export Or
Treat the fish for the pathogens of concern during the isolation/acclimatisation period on your own site.
Some treatments may kill many more species of parasite than is intended. This may have positive health benefits and be very useful in reducing not only the pathogen of concern but also in reducing total pathogen loading. Some treatments should not be repeated too frequently eg formalin based remedies so it is best to gather as much information as possible about those used on the fish you purchased in the recent past.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
40
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
4.1
* you and your supplier would have to agree what abnormal and significant means. For instance you may think it should include only problems for which no explanation can be given or diseases that fish can be treated though they remain carriers or it could mean any problems explained or not of an infectious nature or not.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
41
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
Routine checks and reports No fish allowed to swim in from rivers or lakes
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
42
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
.. ARE OF SIGNIFICANCE
The logic behind these standards used in the EU could be applied to any transfer in the world to identify those that might be viewed as potentially risky. Such as: Moving temperate species to temperate zones whether the fish come from another temperate zone or from tropical areas (e.g. goldfish which though temperate in origin are produced in the far east). It is the characteristics of the fish species that counts in this assessment, not the point of origin. Moving tropical species to tropical zones. Already NACA (Network of Aquaculture Centres in Asia) a network including the Governments of many far eastern countries has identified the transfer of ornamental (particularly wild caught) specimens as requiring additional attention.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
4.2
43
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
No fish or plants should be accepted from any unknown source, including retail customers, and returned to your holding systems, unless full and effective biosecurity measures are in place to prevent any disease infecting the new fish or your stock. You cannot be sure of where these fish have been or what they have been mixed with.
Beware of hitchhikers on any fish entering your site. These might be present as sub-clinical infections of any pathogen e.g. Ich or even latent infections such as KHV.
4.3
The risk of losses may be reduced by importing smaller consignments more frequently than perhaps has been the custom in the past. However to be effective this strategy will require investment in effective isolation facilities.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
44
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
Retailer
Wholesalers (2) Exporters (5) Farmer/ Collector (9) Farmer/ Collector (13) Exporter (6) Farmer/ Collector (10) Farmer/ collector (14)
The number of sites that are involved in a chain can rise dramatically as is illustrated by the examples used in the table below. In exemplar supply chains A, B and C the same doubling principle used in the flow chart above is applied. Supply chain Retailer Importer/Wholesaler Exporters Farmers or collectors Total number of sites in supply chain to retailer A 1 2 4 8 14 B 1 4 16 64 84 C 1 8 64 512 584 30 30 D 1
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
45
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
If a retailer only wants fish that originate from or carry the risk from a certain number of sites (30 sites is used as an example in the tables below), this could be achieved either by: buying directly from farmers or collectors or by rigorous separation of stocks and on-site biosecurity at each step in the chain of supply. The other fish handled by exporters and importers should then be irrelevant to the retailer and the risks may be cut substantially, but they may still be significant if the pathogens are of concern present are found commonly on sites.
Even if very few producers are infected the other businesses in the chain to the retailer may have a significant probability of picking up pathogens from the stock originating on infected producers or sites infected as fish from these sites pass through the supply chain. The latter is particularly likely to happen if there are many stages in the supply chain at which co-mingling of stocks from different sources can or does occur. The risk of the retailer at the end of a supply chain receiving fish with a given pathogen present on or in the fish will depend on at least the: prevalence or infection rate of fish at the production or collection sites number of businesses involved in the supply chain the amount of co-mingling and cross-infection of fish from different producers or other businesses as they move along the supply chain efficiency of screening, treatment, monitoring, isolation and quarantine at the sites along the supply chain
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
46
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
With screening and 66.67% effective regime of treatments, monitoring and quarantine
Infection rate with pathogen of concern at the production or collection sites 0.1% 1% 10% 1 in 1,000 1 in 100 1 in 10 Probability of a retailers stock becoming infected in various supply chains (refer to table 1 above) A 0.0% 0.3% 2.9% B 0.2% 2.3% 19.5% C 1.9% 16.8% 75.4% D 0.11% 1.1% 10.5%
Measures such as quarantine that screen out infection can also greatly reduce the risks of infection passing on to a site and contaminating the supply chain. Illustrated is a model in which using disease screening and control techniques which gives a 2/3rd chance of stopping infection at each step. Even then, with many supplier scenarios, there is still a substantial risk of the retailer becoming infected. Rigorous separation of stocks reduces transmission so that combining quarantine and separation of stocks reduces transmission and greatly reduces risks. Different levels of investment in screening reduce disease risks to different degrees. If there is a 5% risk of producers (not 10% as in the scenarios outlined in the tables above) being infected then, without screening, in the 4 supplier scenario (B above) the retailer has 96% chance of picking up infection.
Chance retailer infected % 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0 10 25 50 66 Efficiency of screening and treatment %
If stocks are screened for disease, the risk can be significantly reduced. The more efficient the screening and treatment of fish the greater the reduction of risk passing along the supply chain. However, minimal screening and treatment has minimal effect, so the process must be taken seriously to be effective. The risk of infection may be magnified through the supply chain so that, uncontrolled, small risks at the producer level can be become greater risks as the fish move towards the retailer. By reducing the mixing of stock from different sources and by applying screening for disease, these risks may be contained or reduced.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
SUPPLY CHAINS AND DISEASE RISK (see also Appendix 9) WHY DISEASE BREAKS OUT
The likelihood of a disease breaking out is summed up by the following equation:
47
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT
The rate of removal of the pathogen
The ease with which the disease or pathogen spreads between individual fish or sites
X
o o
o o o o o
Example of factors influencing each part of the equation are listed below with links/reference to more details coverage elsewhere in the report. o o Number of infected consignments arriving on a site Presence or absence of quarantine/preventative acclimatisation Isolation or separation of batches The number of other carriers e.g. birds, vehicles, staff etc. entering the site Inadequate husbandry which stresses the fish and disables their immune system eg poor water quality, rough handling Lower or higher temperatures than are optimum for the fish Conditions that are optimum for pathogen e.g. temperature Emerging or new diseases High stocking density Number or fish present which are susceptible to the disease Some strains or species resistant (naturally or via vaccination) to some diseases Number of sources of fish that are used The number of occasions that fish are co-mingled with those from other sources in the supply chain Removal of dying or dead fish Single use flow of water through system removes pathogen Efficient UV and/or ozone Effective treatment with medicines Good husbandry (especially maintenance of water quality)
o o
o o
o o o o
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Relatively Biosecure
48
4.0 KEEPING THE BAD BUGS OUT Bioinsecure insecure Bio
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents
Multiply the sources multiply the risk (unless on each site biosecurity is managed effectively)
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
CHAPTER 5 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING 5.1 ARE MY FISH DISEASE FREE?
49
5.0 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING
There are various definitions of disease free. It would be wise to ensure that you are aware of the difference between them. It would be wise to confirm in writing what you expect of your supplier.
FREE OF DISEASE
Pathogens that can cause disease may be present even if the fish do not show any signs of disease. However, if they are not showing clinical signs they are often regarded as disease free. Such specimens can act as carriers of disease even if they themselves are not affected. Fish may not show any of the clinical signs of ulcer disease or KHV but could still be carriers for either those diseases.
Absence of a particular disease does not mean the absence of the pathogen causing that disease.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
50
5.0 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING
5.2
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
ACCLIMATISATION
51
5.0 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING
For fish acclimatisation may be a more accurate description of what is usually described as quarantine. Basically fish are rested and kept in optimal conditions that are as stress free as possible. It could be argued that these are the conditions least likely to precipitate full-blown disease in fish. Thus acclimatisation may achieve the complete opposite of quarantine as used for mammals.
PREVENTATIVE ACCLIMATISATION
However an acclimatisation period may be used to try to determine if the fish are carrying a particular disease. Each batch of fish must be isolated; this is a normal requirement of any good husbandry or stock system. Clearly there are costs associated with meeting this requirement, but these may prove to be less than those incurred during outbreaks of this disease at your establishment and/or that of your customers. No transfer of water between batches must be permitted including that on hands, nets, aerosols (eg the droplets formed by working air stones), wellingtons or buckets. Ideally each batch of fish should be isolated completely. No transfer of fish, water, waste products, gametes or equipment should be permitted. If you require exporters to give assurances as part of the contract of supply, they may require that you provide evidence of an effective isolation policy of new stocks, and its effective practical application. Basic records of water quality, mortalities and observations of fish stocks should be maintained and held for reference. Fish should be subject to a period of preventative acclimatisation/isolation for a suitable period at a temperature, or in conditions in which the pathogen of concern would normally cause disease or otherwise become detectable. The development of many diseases in fish are dependent on temperature, and any period of preventative acclimatization should take account of that fact. For instance in the case of a KHV this period should last at least 14 days, ideally longer at 23 to 28C. Any batch of fish in which signs of illness or disease, should be subject to tests. If these prove positive for a disease of concern, then that source of supply may be considered unsuitable until adequate remedial action has been undertaken. The growth of parasite populations is also at least in part attributable to how quickly they can complete their lifecycle, which is closely linked to water temperature. Batches from major sources of supply might usefully be screened prior to the start of the season. Given the apparent infectious nature of some diseases in closed systems, no chances of cross-contamination should be tolerated if any amount of confidence is to be placed in the results. All water should be discharged via the foul sewerage system never to open or natural waters.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
52
5.0 STOPPING THE BAD BUGS SPREADING
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
53
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Almost anything! Fish in aquariums and ponds are entirely dependent on our management of their environment to maintain their health. Health or disease is a complex balance between pathogens, the fish or other organisms and the environment. It is beyond the scope of this report to look into this balance in detail. Mismanaged environments stressed fish and opportunist organisms may lead to disease. It has been estimated that over 90% of diseases reported by hobby keepers are caused by poor environment, particularly poor water quality. To know what causes a particular disease at a particular time, the more information the better. Disease, per se, is not an entity or an end in itself. Disease is the end product of an interaction between a noxious stimulus and a biological system, and to understand disease is to understand all aspects of the biology of the species. (Mawdesley-Thomas 1972) Many diseases can be eradicated or kept to minimal levels by careful management and a good knowledge of the basic biology and natural history of the species (both the fish and the pathogen) concerned.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
54
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
6.2
Are we sure that scientists have identified the guilty organism correctly? To decide what causes a disease, scientists use a set of four rules known as Kochs postulates. These are: 1. The organism suspected of causing the disease must be present in all cases of the disease. 2. The organism can then be isolated and grown in the laboratory. 3. The organism isolated can infect animals that then show the same signs of disease. 4. The organism must then be isolated from those animals experimentally infected. Just being present when a disease occurs does not mean that a particular organism is the cause of a disease. Kochs postulates help avoid innocent bystanders being blamed for diseases they didnt cause.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
55
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
56
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
6.3
FOUND EVERYWHERE OR (ALMOST) NOWHERE Fish pathogens can have geographical distributions that range from the: Ubiquitous - found everywhere or very widely on a wide range of fish species e.g. Aeromonas hydrophilia (a bacteria associated with some ulcers on fish), or Ich (white spot)
to those Confined to particular areas of the world or particular species only e.g. KHV, neon tetra disease.
Some organisms found on fish can cause disease in man. These diseases are known as zoonoses. They can generally be avoided by good personal hygiene (Appendix 10).
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
57
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Obligate Pathogen Faculative pathogen may always be present
Host
Morbid
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
58
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
6.4
The organisms causing new and emerging diseases are probably not new, but have always been around. Viruses, bacteria and parasites, are opportunistic; normally they are present in small numbers and cause little or no problem. However if conditions change they may take advantage of the situation, for instance: Viruses and bacteria have been known to jump from one species to another, even from a saltwater fish to a freshwater species, if for example, the potential pathogen is brought into close association with a new host, by practices such as feeding raw diets containing marine fish to freshwater fish. Virtually harmless in their original host species, they may become very virulent in the new one. Geographically separate species carry different bacteria, viruses and parasites. The organisms carried harmlessly by one species may be pathogenic to another species if the two are mixed together. Geographically separate strains of fish of the same species may evolve resistance to different pathogens. When distinctive strains of fish of the same species are mixed organisms that cause no problem to one strain may cause serious disease in the other. Changes in husbandry conditions such as rapid rises or falls in temperature, or increased stocking density will change the type and level of stress the fish are subjected to, and may promote susceptibility to diseases caused by organisms that had previously been benign.
6.5
Cross-species transmission is inherently unlikely but if species are mixed in large numbers and in close proximity this unlikely step has many chances to occur. The more chances that are given for such an event to occur the more probable it is. Thus the more species that are mixed, on more occasions in bigger numbers the more likely it is that a pathogen will jump from one target species to another. Pathogens that jump from one species to another may, at first, be very inefficient at transmitting themselves within the new host species. If the new hosts are held at high density, or are stressed, then the pathogen is more likely to survive this period of inefficient transmission, allowing a new disease to emerge. Once the pathogen has successfully jumped from one fish species to another it may: cause a dead end infection. It kills all its new hosts and dies out. Killing all or most of your hosts is not a good strategy for a pathogen, if its host dies it dies too. Often over time these diseases may become less virulent, as that permits their hosts and thus themselves to survive. It kills its new host species, but does not spread to further fish species. Far more seriously it may be able to adapt and transmit to others of the new species; this adaptation may be a slow process with the pathogen improving its ability to transmit with each successful transmission.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
59
6.6 RATES OF PATHOGEN MULTIPLICATION
In 7 days at 200C one Ich growing on a fish can multiply to 500-1000 At 70C this same growth in population could take 5 weeks or more. In ideal conditions some bacteria can double their population every 20 minutes. At that rate after 24 hours one bacteria can divide and create: 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 or in words one million billion billion Viruses takeover the cells of the animals they infect. A single cell infected by a virus can expand to 50,000 to 100,000 times its original size because of the new viral particles being produced. The numbers of virus particles produced by each cell are astronomic and each of those viral particles can infect another cell.
The closer to the optimum temperature of the pathogen and/or the lower the fishs immunity the faster the pathogens population will grow and the quicker a disease may become apparent.
Optimum temperature
Sub-optimum temperatures
Number of pathogens
Time
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
60
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
6.7
Vertical transmission can be avoided by taking great care in selecting, or treating broodstock so they are free of a particular pathogen before they breed. This can be achieved by: testing the parents gametes (eggs, ovarian fluid and milt or sperm) for pathogens and the eggs/ offspring destroyed if they are positive for these pathogens or by treating the brood stock prophylactically with antibiotics or immuno-stimulants to reduce the risk of infection or by only breeding from certified pathogen or disease free offspring
There is also the potential that non-destructive tests (that is not requiring the fish to be killed) will, for some diseases become available shortly so potentially an individual fish can be tested for disease on an annual basis Some parasites match their reproductive cycle to that of the host so there are plenty of young infective stages available to infect the newly hatched fish or re-infect their parents. This strategy is common in parasites where the animals live solitary lives and only come together for reproduction.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
61
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Intermediate hosts
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
62
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
6.8
Listed below are some of the characteristics of disease that it would be useful to be aware of when working out a management strategy.
PRESENCE OR ABSENCE OF THE PATHOGEN If the pathogen isnt present it cant cause a disease.
POOR HUSBANDRY
Failure to maintain good water quality and hygienic conditions can directly eg via dead and dying fish or indirectly e.g. by causing stress and thus loss of immune response, create conditions in which pathogens may cause disease.
DISEASE SPECIFICITY
Some pathogens cause disease in only one species, for example KHV apparently affects only the common carp Cyprinus carpio. Others are found on many species globally and affect many species eg Icthyophthirius multifilis.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
63
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
The numbers of a particular pathogen that are required to cause disease is known as the infective dose. The more virulent the smaller the infective dose of pathogen is. Different pathogens and strains of pathogens will have different virulence and different infective doses will be required to cause disease. The exact infective dose is variable and dependant on the pathogen, the species of fish, the environment and the fishs general state of health. Aeromonas species can cause disease when there are 10,000 bacteria per ml of water for a short time. That sounds a lot, but one medium sized moribund goldfish can potentially infect 150 litres (approximately 35 gallons) of water to that level between 5pm and 8am the next morning in a closed system with no UV or ozonization. Just 100 bacteria per ml is required to cause disease over an extended period of three weeks exposure. The moribund goldfish could infect a system of 1000 litres to that level in just one hour.
PATHOGEN PERSISTENCE
Some pathogens cannot exist away from their hosts. In a system with no fish present Ich will die out in days as apparently will the KHV virus. In the latter case sterilisation may still be a better option for control. On the other hand other viruses e.g. IPN in salmonids will still be infective weeks or months after the fish are removed from a system.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
64
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Inhalation
Infective particles can lodge in the gills of a fish and the pathogens can enter the blood stream directly, infect the cells of the gill, or remain in the gills and live there (e.g. the parasite which causes Amoebic gill disease in Salmon in Australia)
Ingestion
Infective particles may be taken into the digestive tract and can either enter the blood stream directly, infect the cells of the gut lining, or lodge in gut lumen and live there (e.g. the parasite Ligula oceanica or some bacteria such as that causing Enteric red mouth disease). Infected food can introduce pathogens to the gut. Feeding wild caught food eg Daphnia, or animals that have died (of either disease or natural causes) should be avoided as this carries a high risk of introducing infective agents to the gut.
Intermediate hosts
Some parasites cannot complete their life cycle unless a secondary host (a snail for instance) is present. The continuous prevention of the vector/disease/host life cycle will keep the stock disease free. For instance, as is the case in a number of diseases, if a snail is the intermediate host then removal of the snail breaks the infection cycle and prevents the outbreak of disease.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
65
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION 6.10 DISEASE TRANSMISSION ROUTES
WATERBORNE
Water can transmit pathogens. The water can be flowing, it can be stagnant, it can be a thin film, on clothes or in splashes and aerosols. Transfer of water (in the aquarium or pond, on nets, plants, vehicles, hands, clothes, puddles on the floor, in fish body tissues or excretions - or even on the fur, feathers or skin of mammals, birds or amphibians) is a way that fish diseases are frequently transmitted.
PATHOGENS CAN BE TRANSMITTED IN FILMS OF WATER ON FLOORS, WORK SURFACES, NETS, HANDS, VEHICLES ETC.
Viruses can be stored as crystals but require a host and water to reproduce. Some bacteria can be dried and stored. Some cannot stand drying out (desiccation). All bacteria need the presence of water to reproduce. Many parasites are killed by drying them out. Others can form cysts that can resist desiccation for varying periods.
All parasites require the presence of water to grow and reproduce! Pathogens can be transmitted in water including films, droplets and fluids!
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
66
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
PARASITES
Parasites can cause disease in their own right. Trichodina, Ich, Dactylogyrus, and Gyrodactylus, Argulus and Lernea are a few of the parasites that might be found on fish. They all either puncture the body and draw off fluids, graze off layers of the skin, or feed on the mucus on the skin, gills or gut. They may ingest infected materials and carry them to their next host. The wounds they cause also open up a perfect entry point for some bacteria and viruses. Several scientific papers have suggested that parasites physically carry pathogens. SVC and ulcer disease are cited as examples of diseases carried by parasites while the anchor worm, Lernea is capable of transferring bacteria.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
67
FOOD
If fresh minced or chopped fish is fed it can be a continual source of infection unless it has been treated by pasteurisation, UV, irradiation or the like. Plankton samples collected from the wild can carry diseases or parasites. Artemia cysts can carry bacteria such as Vibrio. The capsule can be removed or disinfected. Heat treatment, irradiation and the effects of freezing can eliminate pathogens. Badly stored food can become a source of illness and disease. Food inappropriate to the species can promote disease. Diets consisting of material derived from the wild, such as fish fillets or wild caught Daphnia culex are often perceived as having great nutritional benefits as they are believed to contain many macro nutrients essential to the good health of the animal. However, there is an inherent risk in using wet diets as they may introduce pathogens to the stockfish. These many take the form of parasites that use an intermediate host to enter their final host (e.g. Diphylobothrium), or simply be concentrated by the feeding of the prey item to form an infectious particle which when ingested can establish the infection. Potentially the highest risk here is the use of wet fish in diets which can, under appropriate conditions, be a very high risk factor allowing large amount of pathogen to enter the diet if the source material was infected. This is believed to be how VHSV entered the Gigha turbot farm in Scotland in 1994 that led to the compulsory slaughter of the stock and fallowing of the farm. The requirement to use wet feed for Koi and other cold water species is limited as there are very good commercial diets available, and if it is deemed necessary for other species or for wild caught animals unused to a captive diet, then pasteurised or irradiated feeds should be used if possible. Good quality food will promote a healthy immune system and enable fish to resist pathogens.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
68
6.0 FUNDAMENTALS OF DISEASE TRANSMISSION
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
69
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
Isolate and acclimatise newly arrived fish whenever possible. If the fish you buy are carrying any pathogens then this will help, along with appropriate treatments, prevent them transferring them to your existing stock.
Work clean to dirty; work routines should start with the species and groups that are cleanest i.e. those groups likely to have the least pathogen load, such as newly treated fish, and the most vulnerable, young or stressed fish. Newly arrived fish may need to be treated with caution and care should be taken to ensure diseases are not transferred to or from them. Deal with fish requiring disease treatment last. Working in this way reduces the potential for pathogen transfer to clean fish.
Clean
Dirty!
Each aquarium, pond or system should as far as is possible be allocated separate equipment. This should be strictly adhered to especially in any isolation or acclimatisation area Sterilising and disinfecting equipment: nets and other equipment can carry pathogens between tanks, ponds or holding systems. Either equipment should be allocated and separated for use in a specific area, or else it should be disinfected as it is moved around a site. Hands are bits of equipment that can carry diseases, and so should be at least thoroughly washed between systems. Sterilising and disinfection filters ( see UV or ozone see sections D and E below) should be maintained and managed according to the manufacturers instruction to be as effective as possible barrier to the transfer of pathogens in centralised systems.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
70
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
7.2 A.
Single use: in these systems water is used just once and then discarded. Any pathogens it picks up are continually diluted and removed from the system. To that extent such a system resembles ventilation. In Channel Catfish culture systems in the US increasing the flow of water through such systems eliminated or greatly reduced the presence of Ich on the fish. This was because the infective stages were washed out of the system before they could find a new host. Multiple use flow through: in these systems the water flows from one pond to one or more others before being discarded. Any problems in a pond are passed on with the water flow to every subsequent pond. On an individual site it is best practise to allow the youngest fish first use of the clean water, as they tend to be carrying fewest, if any, pathogens. They also tend to be most easily affected by pathogens and become diseased by a smaller infective dose. If you are purchasing the older fish from such a site you may buy the accumulated problems from all the ponds in which the water has been previously used.
B.
RECIRCULATION SYSTEMS:
Without treatment: such systems just recirculate the pathogens released by the fish. Each time the water is recirculated, it picks up more released pathogens. Thus the pathogen load builds up with each passage. In this sort of system the likelihood of transmission is greater as is the likelihood that an infective dose of a pathogen will be reached. Using sterilising filters (see sections D and E below) UV or ozone: carefully managed sterilising filters can reduce or eliminate the build up of pathogens shed by fish in a holding system.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
WATER MANAGEMENT
Spring Borehole or treated water
71
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
Water recycled
Water recycled
No treatment
Holding system
Preventative treatments e.g. Preventative low level copper treatments e.g. low anti paraciticides in level copper anti marine systems may paraciticides in marine reduce infective load of systems may reduce narrower range ineffective load of of potential pathogens narrower range of
potential pathogens. Bio-secure dependant on careful maintenance of UV lamp, ozone doser etc.
Bio-secure
But if water is reused with no treatment it becomes increasingly bio insecure with number of times it is used
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
72
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
C.
If a disease causing organism is present in a population of fish, that population can be described as infected. Many organisms present in fish populations, that can cause disease, do so only rarely. Fish can shed infectious materials even when a disease is not apparent. The fishs immune system has evolved to be able to deal with some organisms by either eliminating or controlling them. In the wild, or in farms where water is used only once and then discharged, those infective materials may rapidly become diluted and dispersed in the river, lake or sea. Thus no other fish is exposed to an infective dose nor is the fish discharging infective materials subject to re-infection so there is no outbreak of disease. In recirculation systems little such dilution or dispersion can occur. Thus not only is infection passed to clean fish, but the infected fish are subject to re-infection. While a fish may be able to deal with a small dose of a pathogen, if subjected to continual re-infection a disease may be caused. This is especially so as in an untreated re-circulation or under gravel system, the amount of the disease causing organism in the water rises and often the water quality falls, both of which make the fish more susceptible to infection and disease. Some organisms are killed when they pass through the UV filters. This action can only take place as the water passes through the filter and thus has no direct impact on biological material at any other point in the system. Ozone can be used to make the water in the whole system a hostile environment , in which many pathogens cannot survive.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
73
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT D. ULTRA VIOLET-UV (including sunlight) See also appendix 5
SUNLIGHT
Strong sunlight has high levels of UV that can disinfect water. However the degree of disinfection achieved will vary considerably and be dependant on, among other things, water clarity and cloud conditions. As the outcome in ponds may be highly variable leaving water in sunlight to help disinfect it should be regarded with caution.
Conversion factors
You may come across a number of different units being used to describe the lethal dose of UV. Different forms are used. 1,000W/cm2 = 1mW/cm2 = 1mJ/cm2 = one millionth All of the values below are the same: 20,000 Watts/cm2, 20,000 W/cm2 or 20,000 microW/cm2 20 mWatts/cm2, 20 mJoules/cm2, 20 mW/cm2 20 mJ/cm2 or 20 milliWatts/cm2 or 20 milliJ/cm2
Effective dose of UV
UV kills by disrupting the genetic material in the nucleus of cells; generally the larger the organism the greater protection the genetic material has from the cellular material surrounding it (which absorbs UV) and hence the greater the dose of UV required to be effective. Different organisms have different tolerances to exposure to UV (See Appendix 5). The OIE recommends 10mJ/cm2 UV as the minimum lethal dose for bacteria. Generally it is acknowledged few bacteria can survive 25mJ/cm2. To kill some viruses requires 125 200mJ/cm2, while small parasites may require 1,000 mJ/cm2. UV is an effective killer of pathogens in clear water. It is ineffective if the water is heavily contaminated with suspended material or some dissolved minerals which prevent light penetration, or if the bulbs have exceeded their recommended working life. UV systems must be maintained according to manufacturers instructions to achieve best results. UV light is harmful to the eyes. One should never look at an illuminated UV source.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
74
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
E.
Ozone is a very effective oxidising agent rapidly degrading cell membranes, organelles, and the nucleus of pathogens. It is highly reactive with organic material and can penetrate particulate matter very rapidly. To achieve disinfection a residual ozone level of 0.4g/m3 per hour (equivalent to 0.4mg/l source http://www.unep.or.jp/ietc/Publications/TechPublications/TechPub-8f/B/Disinfection2.asp) with a contact time with the pathogen of around 4 minutes is required. This level of disinfection is very easy to achieve in a re-circulation system by injecting ozone into a foam fractionator column (protein skimmer or similar) and allowing the reaction and contact time to complete there. It is possible to automate this process by means of an ozone dosing computer which will measure the redox potential in the reaction vessel and add more or less ozone as required to ensure effective sterilisation. However it should not be assumed that ozone is the answer in all situations, to every disinfection problem and the advantages and disadvantages must be considered.
ADVANTAGES
The advantages of this technology are as follows: it has a high efficiency of disinfection that virtually guarantees the elimination of infectious microbes from the water; it is a clean technology that does not impart taste or other traits to the water; the disinfecting process is not affected by different water pH values.
DISADVANTAGES
The disadvantages of this technology are as follows: it is relatively expensive for instance the electric arc generation poles required to oxidize the air and convert it to ozone are expensive operation of the ozone-generating equipment requires skilled technicians, as escaping ozone is a hazardous to staff and other livestock; it requires a continuous and constant source of electricity; inspite of its complete disinfecting power, the residual presence of ozone in the water is limited, it has a negative impact on silicone glues.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
F.
75
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
There are at least two considerations in calculating turnover times. Most frequently the calculation used is simply: Volume of system in litres Rate of pumping litres per min = turnover time in minutes
Thus in a system with a volume of 1000 litres and a pump producing 100 litres/min 1000 100 = 10 minutes
That does not mean that in 10 minutes all the water has passed through the pump and any UV filter attached to it. It takes much longer to ensure that all the water to pass through the pump. The explanation is that in the first minute 100 litres (10% of the total volume) of water passes through the pump. At the end of that minute the system contains 100 litres that has been through the pump and 900 litres which has not. Assuming there is good mixing in the next minute 100 litres passes through the pump but 10% of this will already have passed through the pump and UV. Thus at the end of two minutes 190 litres not 200 has been treated. This explanation is illustrated in the table below. Time minutes Volume pumped lts Volume litres treated for first time if mixing of water perfect 100 90 81 74 67 60 54 47 43 38 Volume treated
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
100 190 271 345 412 472 526 573 616 654
The formula to use to work out the time taken for all the water in a system to pass through the pump or UV is: Volume of system in litres Rate of pumping litres per min Thus in the example above 1000 100 x9 = 90 minutes x9 = time in minutes for all the water to pass through the pump
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
76
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
7.3
STOCKING OF SYSTEMS
The stocking policy of systems, particularly fishponds, can have a significant impact on the pathogens carried by fish that are produced in them.
Sterile ponds are free of pathogens so cant transmit them to fish stocked in the pond or system subsequently.
CONTINUAL STOCKING
Continual stocking of ponds may mean the continual availability of hosts so pathogens dont die but continue to multiply. The use of an all in, all out policy may slightly reduce the risks of disease transfer from one batch of fish to the next. Co-mingling of batches in a continually stocked pond (especially if the fish stocked come from a number of sources) multiplies the risk. The fish you buy could come from source A, but may have pathogens originating at many farms. After all is said and done, if the pathogen you were concerned about was never present, no amount of management can reduce further the risk. However, it would be wise to instigate a system of checks to make sure the situation remains the same.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
7.4
VENTILATION
77
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
Aeration and splashing creates small water droplets than can become suspended in the air as an aerosol. Aerosols can contain small pathogens such as bacteria and viruses. Particularly in humid environments aerosols can be long lived and thus act as a transmission agent for diseases between holding systems. Some pathogens found on fish may cause diseases in humans (see appendix 12). In damp environments mould and fungal growth are encouraged. These may damage the fabric of a building. The spores from moulds and fungi may pose a risk to humans, either by direct inhalation or by sensitising the skin or lungs and potentially triggering dermatitis or asthma. Good ventilation of a fish room can help prevent the transmission of diseases between fish holding system in at least two ways: Dilution: for instance by replacing 50% of the air in a room, 50% of the aerosols formed and hence 50% of the pathogens carried by them may be removed. The chances of an infective dose being transmitted are, all other things being equal, reduced by 50%. Drying: by continually replacing humid air, any water present on surfaces will tend to evaporate. Many pathogens find it easier to survive in damp atmospheres or damp surfaces than dry ones. Puddles and damp surfaces may permit fish pathogens to survive for a long period thus increasing the pathogen population present in the room, increasing the places an infective dose can be found in the room thus increasing the chances and outbreak of disease. Infective spores of the marine protozoan parasite Amyloodinium ocellatum can be transported at least 4 metres in an aerosol droplet. Whitespot Ichthyophthirius multifilis and the bacteria Aeromonas salmonicida have also been shown to be transported by aerosols. Ventilation can help by drying water droplets present in the air as an aerosol. Aerosol droplets persist longer in damp air. Pathogens by Air Aemononas sps bacteria have been known to spread at least 7m in aerosols. That was the size of the room in which the experiment took place and may not represent the distance could travel in ideal conditions. Remember viruses are smaller and maybe carried further still. At its simplest, ventilation may be just allowing air to blow through the fish area. Normal outside air usually carries very few organisms let alone fish pathogens. Heat lost (or more rarely gained) can make this simple solution expensive. Most sophisticated ventilation systems reclaim heat from the air discharged so reducing costs. It may be a wise precaution to ensure the inlet to your ventilation system is not placed close to the outlet from the system so that contaminated aerosols are not pumped straight back into your fish house.
VS
It is an unfortunate fact in our industry that most surfaces will come into contact with water at some time and become damp. This causes problems as damp surfaces provide a much better environment for the survival of pathogens than dry ones. Desiccation or drying is a very effective method for killing pathogens that need a small amount of water to survive. If a surface is perpetually wet or wetted regularly, then there is the potential for any pathogen to survive for long periods, as there is no opportunity to dry out and kill the pathogen. If the surface is very wet numerous bacteria, algae and protozoans may begin to grow on that surface and form a biofilm. This can trap undesirable pathogens and allow even longer survival times as they can provide an ideal habitat for bacterial growth and nutrition or provide an environment where natural
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
78
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
oxidation, desiccation etc are limited. The build up of a bio-film may hinder disinfection of that surface by either preventing penetration of the active ingredient into the film, or exhausting the active ingredients due to its high organic content.
7.5
It is not the aim of this report to explain how filters work to improve water quality. However, it is worth reiterating the point that the stress caused by poor water quality does create the conditions in which pathogens are likely to cause disease. Fish kept in good quality water are better able to resist pathogen invasion because it is more likely that their immune system is in better condition. That said, bio-filters can act as a means of reducing pathogen loads but care is required as they can also harbour pathogens.
They also have two other minor roles acting as a: Reservoir for bacteriophages (a type of virus) that can kill pathogenic strains of bacteria Mechanical filter trapping bacteria, viruses and parasites either in the media or on the biofilm.
The bio-film is a very hostile environment to new bacteria, each bacterial species that has already colonised the filter is competing for nutrients with each other; less aggressive species starve to death and, in turn their organic components are recycled. In addition to this the protozoa are consuming microbes continuously and again their waste and any dead protozoa will be recycled. All of these defence mechanisms used by the established bacteria can make it a slow process for a new species of microbe to become established in a filter. An obvious example of this is the long period of time it takes for a biological filter to mature from the ineffective filters colonised initially by Pseudomonas sp and Vibrio sp to a bacterial flora dominated by Nitromonas, Asetobacter & Nitrosomas species. In an established system a mature biological filter can significantly reduce the level of circulating pathogens.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Research has indicated that well established biological filters could reduce the levels of circulating Aeromonas salmonicida from 1 million CFU*/ml to 700,000 CFUs/ml (or a 30% reduction). If combined with an ozone tower prior to the bio-filter then they become more effective acting as a final sink for any pathogens that escape the ozonation process before the water is re-circulated around the system.
79
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
OR INCREASE THEM!!!!!
As always there has to be a word of warning with this approach to reducing pathogen load. The pathogen may become established in the filter and ultimately act as a reservoir of pathogen continually shedding pathogen into the environment. This can happen when the load of pathogenic bacteria is so high that it out competes the established bacteria in the filter. The pathogen will have its own suite of aggressins that it uses to survive in the filter biofilm. If present in sufficient numbers it can out compete established bacteria populations. Should this happen then there is little option but to sterilise the bio-filter with hypochlorite or similar to remove the pathogen before restocking occurs. Some may argue that this should be done after any serious disease outbreak as part of the control regime. It is worth remembering that pathogenic viruses will need their host (the fish or invertebrate), to replicate in. They cannot replicate in the biofilm although they may become trapped in the filter. *CFU means colony forming unit. This gives an idea of how live pathogens are present.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
80
7.0 SYSTEM OR FARM MANAGEMENT
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
CHAPTER 8 DISINFECTION
81
8.0 DISINFECTION
By the very nature of the trade (especially at retail level) many disinfection routines, such as footbaths at entrances, are just not possible. The information below may help to establish what is possible and practicable in different situations.
8.1
DEFINITIONS
Disinfection Killing 99.99% of bacteria present only 1 in 10,000 pathogens survive Sterilisation Killing 99.999999% of bacteria present only 1 in 10,000,000 pathogens survive
8.2
Normally good quality disinfectants are very effective in treating wet or damp surfaces, in particular halogens (chlorine based bleaches or iodophores) are very reactive and have a short half life which means that used properly there is little risk to animals that may come into contact with the surfaces subsequently. If the area has substantial biofilm build up then pre-cleaning with detergents followed by disinfection should be considered. It is best to prevent wet surfaces becoming contaminated in the first place. This could be achieved by instigating a regular maintenance schedule, which could be as simple as drying after use and wiping down with disinfectant. In areas such as packing stations where many fish and lots of water from different aquariums may come into contact with surfaces, a formalised Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) should be developed that requires daily (or as frequently as the use of the area necessitates) stripping down of the area followed by a standardised disinfection.
DISINFECTANTS DONT DISINFECT DIRT Disinfectants, including UV and ozone, are inactivated by dirt Mud, biofilms, mucus and blood absorb and inactivate disinfectants Suspended particles, whether inorganic (soil and clay particles) or organic (faeces and algae) inactivate disinfectants Effective disinfection can only be achieved when surfaces have been thoroughly cleaned and rinsed or as much suspended materials and dissolved organic material as possible has been removed from the water.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
82
8.0 DISINFECTION
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
8.3
HUMAN SKIN
83
8.0 DISINFECTION
Bacteria on the skin 10 trillion bacteria (10,000,000,000,000) live on the skin of an average human. 10 billion (10,000,000,000) will be left after 99.99% are removed by disinfection. However those bacteria remaining tend to be those that are deeply embedded in the skin Recently deposited bacteria such as those picked up from immersing hands in an aquaria or pond are the most likely to be killed by disinfection.
Use of bactericidal soap (such as a coal tar soap or one containing triclosan or tricloban) Washing hands in 40-60% alcohol after washing with soap and water Adding iodine or chlorhexadine gluconate
99.99%
* 60C is the hottest temperature that can be tolerated without blistering. Great care is required to avoid injury at these temperatures. (To achieve complete sterilisation 137 deg C for 1 hour is regarded as incompatible with life)
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
84
8.0 DISINFECTION
8.4
CLOTHES
Clothes, like skin, can be the source of cross infections so care must be exercised in preventing transmission of a pathogen from a disease outbreak or high biosecurity unit to the rest of the facility. The easiest way of achieving this is to have dedicated clothes for use in the disease or high biosecurity areas and make sure that all people entering high risk area change from their outside clothes into suitable personal protective clothing for that unit e.g. lab coats or other overalls. Often this is achieved by having a changing area or ideally changing room adjacent to the high risk area.
DISINFECTION OF CLOTHES
Normally a boil wash with a bio-cidal washing powder is sufficient to achieve good disinfection of clothing. It should be remembered that a minimum temperate of 60C must be reached for at least 20 minutes for this to be effective. Ideally there should be regular washing of work clothes scheduled in to the working regime and clothes should be washed centrally rather than relying on staff to take them home, risking the spread of disease to home aquarium and hence the wider environment. In cases of severe disease outbreak or where the operator wants to be extremely bio secure then it is prudent to arrange for the personal protective clothing (PPC) supplied by the company to be soaked in strong hypochlorite (minimum of 10ppt free chlorine) overnight prior to laundering. New PPC should be issued on request.
8.5
FOOTWEAR
Ideally all footwear should be scrubbed clean and dipped into a strong disinfectant (such as hypochlorite or iodophores) to prevent transmission of disease between unit and the external environment. The use of shallow foot baths or sponge mats is the easiest way to achieve this. However, some staff and visitors are concerned with disinfectants damaging their footwear (halogens are aggressive chemicals) so it may be worth considering providing Wellington boots, or similar, for staff and visitors to areas about which you are particularly concerned. While disinfection of clothes or footwear may be regarded as impractical in many situations the fact that if contaminated they can transmit disease should not be forgotten.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
8.6
EQUIPMENT
85
8.0 DISINFECTION
Like skin and clothes disease can be spread on the surface of contaminated equipment such as nets, vehicles etc.. Ideally all equipment that comes into contact with stock (diseased or healthy) should be immersed into a strong biocide regularly (such as hypochlorite or iodophores), ideally after each use, to achieve sterilisation (killing 99.999999% of all the bacteria present). As a minimum nets, buckets, hoses etc should be sterilised on a daily basis and never used on a different aquarium or moved around the site without sterilisation.
8.7
DISCHARGE WATER
Most wastewater from wholesalers and retailers is discharged to foul sewers. Foul sewers are hostile environments to many pathogens and massively dilute any pathogens that are present. UV or ozone can be used as required to sterilise water discharged from a site. Alternatively, chlorine based bleaches can be used but these usually have to be neutralised by the addition of chemicals e.g. thiosulphates. If required to undertake discharge sterilisation further advice and approval may be required from Government agencies.
8.8
DISINFECTING SYSTEMS
It is wise to regularly empty and disinfect systems to try to ensure that pathogens cannot build up in a system. You may choose to do this at the end of a season to ensure any pathogens are not lying in wait to infect new animals. When disinfecting a system remember to clean all parts including the pipework and dont restock it with fish held in it prior to disinfection they may carry all last seasons pathogens with them, this may put you back to where you started rather than give you a fresh start.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
86
8.0 DISINFECTION
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
87
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
The identification of disease is a very important, and skilled, procedure in fish keeping and aquaculture. It is the cornerstone of good disease management as it allows the correct intervention, use of the correct and most effective therapeutics and husbandry. There are legal implications as some diseases are notifiable, such as Spring Viraemia of Carp (SVC) in the UK, and failure to report the presence or suspicion of the presence of these diseases may leave the responsible person open to prosecution by the appropriate authorities. There are a bewildering array of identification techniques available ranging from simple observation to scientific techniques requiring expertise or equipment that is only available in a very few Government or university laboratories. The techniques available often have long names that are rarely used, instead acronyms are substituted, a guide to these is included in the descriptions below. Below are brief descriptions of some of the more common techniques you might already be aware of or hear discussed as time passes. Note of caution! A technique is only as effective as the skill and care of the person carrying it out. Purchasing tests from centres of excellence that are quality assured (ISO 9000, UKAS accredited etc) should give a guarantee of quality
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
88
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
89
9.1 WATER QUALITY 9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
Whether by high tech filter systems or simply regular water changes good water quality should be maintained. This will promote the immune system function and general health of the fish being kept. It has been said that the greatest step forwards in human health has been the introduction of municipal sewerage works. It is also estimated that 90% or more of fish disease is caused directly or indirectly by poor water quality. The OATA Water Quality criteria should be used as a minimum standard (Appendix 1).
9.2
PHYSICAL SIGNS
CLINICAL SIGNS
The clinical signs, that is what can be directly observed by eye, associated with fish disease are generally quite indicative of the disease group. For example large sores often indicate a bacterial infection, spinning may indicate a neurological disorder or flicking off surface a parasite infestation.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
90
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
The gross pathology of a disease can often give a good indication as to the cause, for example, the presence of the open furuncles (abcesses) in goldfish is indicative of Aeromonas infection. However, it is not possible to tell the species of bacteria causing the infection, which may be A. salmonicida, A. sobria or A. hydrophila. In some instances gross signs are all one needs to accurately diagnose disease, for example if a fish with a distended abdomen is euthanased and found to contain a huge parasitic worm, then there may be no need to proceed further. Secondary invasions of bacteria and parasites might be the most obvious problem on an individual fish, but these signs may obscure the presence of the primary pathogen. For instance the clinical and physical signs of KHV include: Bleeding from the gills White patches (where excess mucus has been produced or tissue has died) which may be small to very extensive on the gills Pale patches and blistering on the skin Sunken eyes Occasionally fish have shown signs of nervous problems (that is periods of inactivity followed by hyperactive behaviour triggered by a very small stimulant)
But in the years following the disease becoming a problem it was often misdiagnosed because of the obvious presence of secondary infection with bacteria and parasites which were judged the culprits. The presence of the majority of fish diseases especially those caused by bacteria or viruses cannot be definitively determined purely by observing the fishes appearance or clinical signs alone. With few exceptions it is very difficult to identify parasites by observation by eye.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
91
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
92
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
9.3
HAND LENS
Examining the skin, lesions or internal organs using a simple x10 hand lens may show up small parasites or damage to the tissues that are not seen with the naked eye.
9.4
AGGLUTINATION TEST
There is the potential to use this diagnostic test for the rapid identification of pathogens in the field. It relies on antibody tests where the antibody is bound to a latex bead. These are then mixed with a suitable sample of the fish tissue. If the pathogen is present the antibodies cross link with the pathogens, and the latex beads precipitate to form a solid, and this indicate the presence of the pathogen. If the solution stays milky (because the latex balls have remained in suspension) , then there is no evidence for the pathogens presence given. These agglutination tests are very useful for rapid diagnosis, but they are not as sensitive as laboratory based immunological (see 9.11) tests and a negative result is a good indication of the absence of the pathogen, but these tests may fail to detect a low level infection.
SAMPLING
When samples are taken for laboratory examination, great care must be taken to prevent cross contamination between: organs within an individual animal individual animals if several are sampled the animal and the investigator.
The most common errors associated with each procedure can be listed thus:
9.5
Samples are usually taken by sterile swab. o Swab contaminated by the user i.e. the sterile swab touched the users skin and contaminates it with human microbes and microbes from other samples if the operator dont clean their hands adequately. Swab contaminated by the faeces or gut contents of the animal i.e. the sterile swab is swamped with the bacteria from a naturally rich microbial flora masking pathogens Swab contaminated by the environment (eg dropped on the floor!) again the sterile swab is swamped with the bacterial from a naturally rich microbial flora masking pathogens
9.6
BLOOD SAMPLING
Samples are usually taken by needle and syringe. o Not using a clean syringe between fish, thus there is carry over from one sample to the other, making it impossible to tell which fish is infected or has antibodies.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
9.7
93
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
Samples are taken following dissection. The commonest error here is sampling the wrong organ! Remember the kidney of fish runs below the spine (many people think this is the main blood vessel, the aorta) while the spleen sits where you would expect the kidney to be if a fish was a mammal. It is not unknown for very experienced investigators used to working on mammals to sample the spleen rather than the kidney thus, missing the most important fish organ for diagnosing infectious disease.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
94
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
LABORATORY INVESTIGATIONS
(Individual farmers, wholesalers or retailers are unlikely to have the facilities to undertake these tests. They are likely to be undertaken on samples sent to specialised laboratories. The cost of tests may vary considerably both between diseases and the laboratory chose.)
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
95
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES 9.8 SHOULD YOU HAVE AN ON SITE LABORATORY?
There are points both in favour of and against having a laboratory (or an area in which sick fish are examined on a site). Some of the key points to consider are:
IN FAVOUR
Accurate identification of pathogens may permit selection of appropriate effective treatment Earlier detection allows earlier treatment, which is usually most effective. Sending samples off site may lead to significant delays in diagnosis.
AGAINST
Good quality equipment is required and that may be expensive. Accurate diagnosis requires experienced and/or trained staff. Inaccurate diagnosis can be costly. Potentially all the pathogens entering your site will enter the examination area. Unless hygiene is carefully managed diseases could also spread from it to other parts of the site.
9.9 MICROSCOPY
A microscope can be used to see and accurately identify many of the common fish parasites by using wet preparations or skin scrapes. Similarly damage to the gills can be seen, but it may not be possible to establish the cause of the damage using a microscope alone. You may also just be aware of large numbers of bacteria in the mucus though you cannot identify them. This is the limit of the investigations possible in even those retail outlets possessing and using a light microscope, a diagnosis cannot always be made on this information alone.
HISTOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES
In heavily infected fish, scientific laboratories are able to prepare and stain very thin sections of tissue (this is known as histology) in which using microscopes they may be able to see signs characteristic of various diseases. Under extremely powerful electron microscopes individual virus particles can be seen, however this does not identify the strain of virus, just the presence of virus like particles. Examination of the tissues by histology is often desirable as this can indicate which organs have been infected, and can detect the physical presence of pathogens, (not the species of bacteria or virus although fungi and parasites can be accurately identified based on their morphology). Often this technique can be
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
96
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
used to eliminate a pathogen, e.g. by identifying a neoplasm (tumour or cancer) or toxin induced cellular changes. However, when combined with culture (9.10), immunological (see 9.11 ) or molecular techniques (see 9.12) identification of pathogens can be very accurate.
A.
If any of you have been unfortunate enough to be involved in an investigation of a possible SVC outbreak, you may well have seen samples for ELISA testing being taken. These tests very rapidly (often within 4 hours) give an indication of the presence or absence of a disease. The results are only regarded as, at the moment, presumptive and require confirmation by cell line isolation testing before confirmation of the presence of a disease. Samples from, preferably clearly diseased fish are returned to the laboratory for the cell isolation test. It is interesting to note that ELISA tests are used to confirm outbreaks of swine fever and foot and mouth disease, and it is possible, as testing techniques are developed that confirmed recognition of fish diseases by these tests will be accepted at some point in the future. ELISA tests rely on a level of knowledge of the antibodies produced by the fishes immune system to a particular pathogen which is not yet available for all fish diseases. Latent or dormant infections may not produce very large amounts of antibodies making them difficult to detect. There are two types of ELISA test: Capture ELISA: in this test antibodies are used to capture and detect the presence of the pathogen. In effect this test will tell you that the pathogen, or at least the parts attacked by the antibodies are present. The test is set up in such a way that a colour change occurs and is used as a measure of the presence of a particular pathogen.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
97
Screening ELISA: In this test the process is reversed in that the known pathogen or pathogens are used to detect the presence of antibodies. Antibodies are the chemicals fish naturally release to attack the pathogen. The test allows the recognition of the antibodies, if present, by a colour change. Any colour shows evidence of the animal having been exposed to the pathogen at some time in its life, and the intensity of the colour (which is proportional to the degree of binding of the fishs antibodies to the pathogen) can give an indication of how recent this was. The advantages of this method is that it allows many pathogens to be screened for at once and will give an indication of the diseases the fish or population of fish have been exposed to during their lives. Thus, this can be a very useful tool in assessing disease risk when importing fish from abroad as exposure to pathogens of concern can be assessed.
B.
IHC Immuno-Histo-Chemistry
Thin sections are cut from potentially diseased animals and instead of being stained with a series of dyes, antibodies are used to bind to specific pathogens. The slides are then stained so that any of the specific pathogens present can be seen under a microscope.
C.
A very similar technique to IHC except the detecting antibody has been tagged with a fluorescent dye such as fluorescein. The staining principle is identical for IHC but the slide is examined under a special microscope to enable the fluorescence to be seen. The technique is more versatile than IHC as different coloured dyes can be used to identify different antibodies and hence pathogens or strains of pathogens in a section. However, the high cost of the specialised microscope (around 40k) restricts this to dedicated diagnostic laboratories.
D.
In many ways ISH and FISH can be considered the molecular equivalents of IHC and IFAT. However, instead of relying on antibodies to detect proteins, DNA or RNA probes are used which are tagged with either a dye (ISH) or a fluorescent pigment. Treated slides are examined under the microscope for the presence of the dye or fluorescence, which demonstrates the location of the pathogens genome within the tissues. These techniques can be used to look at material preserved for long periods. It can be used to take a fresh look at materials from old disease episodes using new tests to try to determine what caused them. For instance these sorts of techniques are being used to re-examine disease outbreaks of disease in carp to see if they were caused by KHV.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
98
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
A.
WHAT IS PCR?
PCR is a technique used to produce a large number of copies of a specific region or sequence of an organisms DNA or RNA, its genetic code. The DNA or RNA code or sequence is unique to the organism of interest, and by amplifying this specific sequence using the PCR, a very small quantity of material from the pathogen can be detected. In PCR the DNA or RNA from a sample in which it is suspected is the pathogen is extracted and placed into a PCR machine (sometimes called a thermocycler) with a genetic template (primers) from the pathogen of interest and bases - chemicals that are the building blocks of DNA and RNA. The mix is then repeatedly heated and cooled, which allows the primers to bind with the target sequence in the pathogen of interests gene fragment, and produces a replica set. Each time the thermocycler runs a heating/cooling sequence the number of copies of the template doubles until either the operator finishes the process after a known series of replication sets, or until the bases are exhausted. The initial copies of the genes are significantly amplified (each cycle doubles the number of copies of the gene fragment in the mix). Once the cycling has finished, the mix is taken out and the gene fragments are visualised on an agarose gel and the presence or absence of the known gene template indicates the presence or absence of the pathogen. If the pathogen is not present then nothing will be found on the agarose gel. PCR becomes even more sensitive as scientists are able to increase the number of the segments they can detect in a sample making detection easier. If not one, but two sequences of unique genetic code are used for detection. The results may be more accurate and are known as nested PCRs. It has been said that this technique can potentially detect a single viral particle in a sample.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
99
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
It must be remembered that molecular tests are limited by technical constraints and they are not usually considered as definitive tests for the detection of a pathogen, instead they should be considered along with other more traditional tests such as culture (9.10) and cell line isolations (9.13) The method doesnt necessarily detect the whole disease organism. PCRs may be described as proxy tests, that is they detect the presence of small chains of genetic material not necessarily a whole organism. Thus a PCR can detect the debris of organisms long since gone, or certainly no longer capable of producing disease. Because PCR amplifies the signal from a single fragment of a gene, there is the potential to detect levels of the pathogen that are not sufficient to give an infective dose to the host. However, this sensitivity is very useful for detecting the presence of an organism on a site and thus is very useful in ascertaining risk due to the presence of a pathogen. If only a small genetic probe, that is one that only looks for a small sequence of DNA or RNA has been developed, there is the potential for it to cross-react with related genes in non-target organisms. This is equally true of antibody based tests too, although their sensitivity is less as the signal is not amplified in the same way as a PCR test. Thus a full understanding of the genome of the organism is required to be fully confident of the test (again this is also true of antibody based tests too). Certain PCR test require RNA rather than DNA to be collected. Unfortunately RNA is less stable than DNA, so unless appropriate storage has been carried out (e.g. during in transport) then it is possible for the sample to degrade and any signal to be lost.
FALSE RESULTS
The standard method can show false positives and negatives if the methods are not very carefully controlled in other diseases. Vaccination, with live attenuated vaccines might cause false positives due to the introduction of the pathogens.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Cells can be grown in thin layers in shallow dishes. A whole range of types of cell are now grown in labs routinely, for instance Fat Head Minnow (FHM) and Koi Fin (KF) cells. Some viruses such as the SVC virus grow in a wide range of cell lines, but others can be very specific and only grow in cells derived from the original host. Currently KHV can only be cultured in koi fin cells. Viruses, or samples thought to contain viruses, can be inoculated on to these cells. Cells that become infected will show definite signs of infections, these signs may be specific to a particular virus. A PCR can be used as a tool, to confirm the presence of a virus, this does require the PCR to be sensitive enough to detect viruses at the level at which it can cause signs of infection in the cells.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Test Pathogen group Bacteria Viruses Parasites Fungi Poisons (weedkillers etc) ELISA ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ ++++ PCR +++ ++++ ++ + IFAT +++ +++ ++ + ISH (FISH) +++ +++ ++ + Histology ++ ++ +++++ ++++ +++ Culture +++++ +++++ + +++++ Gross pathology ++ ++ ++++ ++ ++ Anatomical features +++++ ++++ Toxicology screening +++++
101
9.0 IDENTIFYING DISEASES
++++ -
+++ ++++
+++
+++++ -
++++
++++
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
102
10.0 TREATMENTS
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
103
10.0 TREATMENTS CHAPTER 10 TREATMENTS
Some treatments can be used as prophylactics, to deal with a pathogen before it causes a disease, or when a disease breaks out, to hopefully cure it. Treatments are to a greater or lesser extent regarded as veterinary medicines by Governments around the world. The use of veterinary medicines are governed by a variety of laws, it would be impossible to summarise these rules as they differ from one country to the next. In Appendix 7 is a dated note of some of the points, concerning the situation in the UK. It is axiomatic that intensive farming of animals goes hand in hand with culture of their pathogens. The culture of fish has had severe problems from time to time as a consequence of infectious diseases. In Atlantic salmon farming, Norway was initially plagued with vibriosis disease and Scotland and Norway suffered badly from furunculosis in the late 1980s. There is little doubt that these bacterial diseases have been very successfully brought under control by vaccines. However, there are still many diseases for which vaccines are not available and this includes the vast majority of diseases that affect ornamental fish. Think how useful a white spot, SVC or KHV vaccine might be. However, the costs are often considered prohibitive as the licensing of a single vaccine costs in the region of 10,000 and this does not include the cost of the research programme, which may run into hundreds or thousands of pounds, that is required to ensure safety and efficacy as part of the licence application. All treatments should be used in accordance with the manufacturers instructions and according to the law in any given country. Great care should be taken to avoid misuse of treatments as they might cause harm to the staff using them, the fish being treated or the environment.
Temperatures outside the optimum range for the particular fish species Stress
TERMINOLOGY
In any discussion of the fishs immune system it is useful to be aware of the meanings of some some key words ANTIGENS ANTIBODIES c hemicals, pathogens or foreign bodies entering a fish c hemicals produced by the body in response to the presence of an antigen.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Continued on page 98
Antigens Pathogen
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
105
STRESS AND THE FISHS IMMUNE SYSTEM
The immune systems of fish have evolved over millions of years to protect them against pathogens. This system should be regarded as an integral part of any biosecurity management scheme. Mucus Mainly physical barriers to pathogens Skin (including gut lining)
10.0 TREATMENTS
Avoid physical damage to either or both. Damage permits pathogens access to the body as well as causing osmoregulation problems which will stress the fish
The INNATE (non specific) immune system Consists of chemical released into body fluids by various and system defends cells. This against any antigen entering the body. Various body cells
ACTIVITY OF BOTH IMMUNE SYSTEMS SEVERELY DEPRESSED BY STRESS AND TEMPERATURES OUTSIDE (PARTICULARLY LOWER THAN) THE FISHS OPTIMAL RANGE AND PROMOTED BY GOOD HUSBANDRY AND NUTRITION
The specific immune systems Reacts to individual antigens. This system relies on chemicals know as antibodies and cells which engulf and digest invading pathogens. White blood cells
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
106
10.0 TREATMENTS
INNATE IMMUNITY
consists of chemicals released into body fluids by various cells. This system defends against any antigen entering the body. It does not react specifically to any one antigen. Reacts to individual antigens. This system relies on chemicals known as antibodies and cells which engulf and digest invading pathogens. This system has a memory and can react more powerfully to an antigen if the fish is subsequently exposed again to the same antigen (see 10.7). The mechanism of protection is dependent upon a population of white blood cells called the lymphocytes. These cells carry receptors on their surface which can recognise chemicals (known as antigens) present on any material foreign to the fishs body (including pathogens). In a fish not previously exposed to a particular disease and its characteristic antigens only a small subpopulation of lymphocytes can recognise the antigen and react to it immediately. These lymphocytes react by dividing rapidly to produce identical copies of themselves. The number of cells that can recognise the antigen on the invading pathogen therefore increases rapidly.
SPECIFIC IMMUNITY
Antibody level
Time
Two types of lymphocytes produce different reactions to the presence of antigens: B lymphocytes are responsible for producing antibodies. These bind the antigen on the pathogen leading to the pathogen being killed by the body. T lymphocytes can kill cells that are infected by a pathogen. They can also produce chemicals known as cytokines which are important in activating special blood cells known as phagocytes which engulf and kill the pathogen.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
107
10.0 TREATMENTS
The immune response depends upon a great deal of cell division and the production of proteins. The two main factors which decrease the rate of cell division and protein production are: STRESS Stress shuts down those aspects of metabolism which facilitate cell division and the production of protein in favour of providing carbohydrate energy sources, which might be required for fight or flight reactions.
STRESS
LOW TEMPERATURE Reduces the rate of chemical reactions and thus slows cell metabolism. The optimal temperature for vaccination of a given species of fish is related to its preferred or normal temperature range. Thus for Atlantic salmon the optimal temperature for protein production and cellular activity is about 12C and is extremely slow at 4C, while for sea bass the optimum temperature is about 22C and at temperatures of about 10C the immune system of such warm water species is suppressed. The rate of induction of an immune response is faster in warm water species. At their optimum temperature, cold water Atlantic salmon will take about 6 weeks to start producing antibodies and the response will reach a peak at about 10 weeks post-vaccination, while warm water sea bass start producing antibodies within 1 week, reaching a peak in about 2 weeks. Thus, if fish are to be moved to a location where the risk of a particular disease is high, they need to be vaccinated at a certain minimum period of time prior to movement in order to ensure that they are protected. This minimum period depends upon the species and the temperature.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
108
10.2 CHEMICALS
A variety of chemicals are routinely used as treatments for fish. It is not appropriate to review the range of chemicals used either currently or historically. Many reference books are available that fulfil this purpose. In fish farming concerns over the safety and potential environmental impact of some chemicals has led to their withdrawal from the market or for bans on usage to be put in place.
10.0 TREATMENTS
10.3 ANTIBIOTICS
Since they were first discovered antibiotics have revolutionised the treatment of a whole range of previously deadly diseases in man and animals. That said the greatest step forward in reducing human disease was the introduction of municipal sewage systems and a ready supply of clean drinking water. Equally it is true that the greatest gains in fish health are to be made by careful husbandry; after all fish have spent hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of years evolving mechanisms to deal with the disease causing organisms in their environment. Despite this antibiotics have their place in treating fish diseases and fish farming. Antibiotics have received massive adverse publicity over the past couple of years. The reason, in the first instance, was the growth in prevalence of antibiotic resistant bacteria in hospitals. This was generally blamed on doctors for over-prescribing antibiotics. Blame was also put on the general public for insisting that they receive antibiotics for illnesses, like the common cold, which being viral in origin are not killed by them. Over the last couple of years the veterinary use of antibiotics has been the subject of media attention. In farming antibiotics can be used as growth promoters, to treat specific diseases or as prophylactics. In particular the use in the veterinary sphere of antibiotics either used in human medicine or closely related to those used in human medicine has given rise to public debate. The concern is that their use could: Or Remain in the meat of the treated animals and thus enter the human food chain. Promote the emergence of resistant strains of bacteria that can cause disease in humans.
An additional concern has been that bacteria that do not cause problems to humans could transmit their antibiotic resistance to other species of bacteria which might cause illness to humans. Already a report has appeared in the press implicating misuse of antibiotics on a fish farm (not in ornamental fish or on an ornamental site) for the resistance to treatment of an infection in a woman who died. The problem was apparently cause by a Vibrio spp. bacteria which infected a puncture wound cause by the spine in the dorsal fin of a gilthead bream. Twenty other people have been reported as being infected by similar bacteria following puncture wounds in the hands caused by handling Tilapia spp. This resulted in swelling and uncontrollable bleeding from the wound. In half the cases the hands were amputated to save the patient. Vibrio spp. bacteria are very common in water and the species involved in this in this incident usually cause no problems.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
109
10.0 TREATMENTS
Resistance to antibiotics is not a new phenomenon. Bacteria resistant to ampicillin, timethoprim, nalidixic acid, tetracycline, cefazimide, carbenicillin, cefazolin and cephamandole were found in 2000 year old ice from the Arctic. These same bacteria were not resistant to streptomycin, gentamycin, chloramphenicol or ciprofloxacin. That saidp resistance to most antibiotics is absent from bacteria collections from the early part of this century.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
MAGIC BULLETS? 110ANTIBIOTICS Some categories of antibiotics kill a wider spectrum of bacteria than others. 10.0 TREATMENTS
That said antibiotics do not specifically kill a single species or strain of bacteria. Indeed one of the problems associated with antibiotic use is that they kill both pathogenic and useful or harmless bacteria. Antibiotics are not well aimed magic bullets that hit a very specific target but more closely resemble shotgun pellets whose effects spread outside the intended target to a greater or lesser extent.
10.4 PROBIOTICS
Imagine adding bacteria to your fish holding system or transport. It goes against normal experience, but this may be one way forward in disease prevention particularly in young fish. Bacteria will take advantage of any opportunity to colonise an area where food is available for them. This could be the skin, gills or gastro-intestinal tract. The theory behind the use of probiotics is that if you can ensure every site where bacteria can grow is full of harmless bacteria, then pathogens will not get a chance to become established. The benign bacteria form what is in effect a protective sheath over the living fish tissue. There have also been a number of scientific papers published over the last twenty years that indicate bacteria isolated from the gut mucus produce substances which inhibit pathogens. Development of a pattern of use of probiotics in fish is some way off. That said, interest is being shown in the technology. The use of probiotics such as natural yoghurt have been used to help recolonise the guts of animals and humans following antibiotic treatment which killed the bacteria population normally present.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
111
10.5 PREBIOTICS
The bacteria in our guts is altered by the food we eat. Thus the gut bacteria in a person eating a diet high in fibre will be different to those in the gut of a person on a high fat diet. The same is true of the bacteria in fish intestines. Prebiotics are foods used to promote the growth of helpful bacteria. This technology is in the earliest stages of development for use with fish.
10.0 TREATMENTS
Effectiveness*
Excellent
Good
Range of activity
Limited
Wide Short
Duration of Short Short Long protection *assumes accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment used
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
112
10.6 IMMUNOSTIMULANTS
Immunostimulants can be defined as substances that improve a fishs protection from diseases by stimulating its non-specific immune responses. The non-specific immune system is a series of reactions to foreign material, such as bacteria, that do not involve the specific immune response e.g. antibody production. They react on first contact with a pathogen to slow or stop the establishment of an infection. These responses are short lived and can be overcome by aggressive pathogens. The level of protection induced by an immunostimulant can be directly measured by looking at the non-specific defence proteins such as the opsonising protein ORP, before and after treatment. The level of this and other proteins are elevated for a period after treatment with an immunostimulant and by inference the resistance of the host to infection is also enhanced during this period.
10.0 TREATMENTS
-glucans, levamisole, MDP CpG, ssRNA, LPS -glucans -glucans, MDP, FK-565, peptidoglycan -glucans, levamisole, MDP
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
BENEFITS OF IMMUNOSTIMULANTS
113
10.0 TREATMENTS
The perceived benefits of immunostimulants are many and varied. As most immunostimulants occur naturally the molecules that can be obtained from a natural source in large amounts., e.g. glucans from yeast or chitin from arthropods (such as shrimps shell meal) can make cost effective dietary supplements. The addition of immunostimulants as dietary supplements, can improve the non-specific defences of the fish providing resistance to pathogens during periods of high stress, such as grading or transport. Their use in vaccine formulations, experimentally at least, has given very good antibody responses without the adverse side effects that have been reported for some other types of chemicals (known as adjuvants) historically used to boost the bodys response to vaccination. Theoretically, larval fish can be bathed in a solution of an immunostimulant or it can be incorporated into their diet (e.g. in enriched rotifers or Artemia) to provide improved protection through crisis periods such as end of yolk sac/first feeding or metamorphosis. It should be stressed that the use of immunostimulants in larval fish must be approached with caution as there is evidence that feeding an immunostimulant to larval fish may be detrimental to the optimal development of the full immune system. However there is great potential to improve larval survival against bacterial and viral pathogens by the judicious use of immunostimulants.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
114
To overcome this, most immunostimulation use involves pulse feeding the immunostimulant for a short period, usually 4-6 weeks. The level of immunostimulation then falls back towards the resting level before another dose of immunostimulants is given. This tends to cause the host immune system to return to the stimulated level then to fall when the immunostimulant is withdrawn. The process can then be repeated. Such a strategy offers immense flexibility in disease management and risk reduction as the immunostimulant can be fed during periods of increased disease risk. Such periods of risk include: spring and autumn temperature changes; just prior to the breeding season; or prior to shipping.
10.0 TREATMENTS
SUMMARY
Immunostimulants offer the ability to protect valuable stock against short term threats from pathogens and can be administered a few days prior to stressful husbandry procedures. They have the potential to enable larval fish to protect themselves from infection providing the immune system is sufficiently developed to benefit from their administration. Since most immunostimulants are natural products, which have short, non-hazardous, breakdown routes, they may be easier to license for use. This may give the industry an effective method of providing animals with short-term protection at particular points in the production cycle. However, it is unknown how they may adversely affect the developing immune system of larval fish and inappropriate use may be detrimental to their survival in the long term.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
115
10.0 TREATMENTS
Vaccines are relatively recent additions to the medicines available to treat fish. The table below summarises the impact that the introduction of vaccines had on the use of antibiotics in the salmon farming industry in Norway. It may be that the whole of this change cannot be explained just by the introduction of vaccines, but may be partially explained by the development of generally better husbandry techniques. Production of salmon tonnes 60,000 342,000 % reduction in use of antibiotics Total weight of antibiotics used kg 50,000 679 Antibiotics used per tonne of production grams 830 1.2 99.85
The reasons for the salmon industry to move away from antibiotics included the: short period of protection they offer need for repeated doses to be administered particularly for recurrent diseases difficulties caused by resistant strains of bacteria increased concern about and control of residues present in the human food chain. increased concern about the impacts that antibiotics and other chemicals used for disease treatment could have on the environment
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
116
10.0 TREATMENTS
PROTECTION BY VACCINES SPECIFIC IMMUNITY
A vaccine is best regarded as inducing protection against a particular disease that is specific for that particular disease and does not protect against other diseases. Vaccines induce long-term protection and in aquaculture (fish are usually kept and grown for 2 or 3 years prior to sale) a single administration is usually sufficient to induce protection for the lifetime of the fish. This long term protection is because the body retains a memory for that specific disease and can react quickly and effectively when the causative pathogen arrives.
NON-SPECIFIC IMMUNITY
Vaccines may have more general immunostimulatory properties that can also activate the non-specific defence mechanisms. These can increase disease resistance levels but only for a short period of time. Due to their capacity to induce such responses they are also used in shellfish culture, especially of shrimps, but strictly speaking this function should be considered as that of an immunostimulant.
Strictly vaccines are used only as a prophylactic measure in vertebrates, including fish. They do not work generally very well, or at all, if administered while fish are affected by the pathogen the vaccine is intended to control.
NATURAL EXPOSURE
Animals and their pathogens regularly come into contact with one another and diseases occur naturally. Equally naturally some of the animals affected recover and become resistant to the disease. This may over time lead to naturally immune populations. However, the pathogen might keep changing so that it can continually infect its hosts and stay one step ahead of their immune system.
KILLED VACCINES
Killed pathogen are injected or introduced to an animal. Its immune response will react to the killed pathogen and remember it. When confronted with a live pathogen of the same species the immune system can react actively and attack and eliminate it. Animals tend to react less strongly to killed vaccines than live pathogens. Animals may need booster doses on a regular basis to ensure the immune system is primed for the disease the vaccine is designed to protect them from.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
117
LIVE ATTENUATED VACCINES
These vaccines use a live rather than killed pathogen to promote immunity. However rather than using the normal strains of pathogen they use attenuated or weakened pathogens. Because the vaccine is live a good response is promoted by the animal but because the pathogen is weakened it should not cause disease. A potential problem with this sort of vaccine is if the pathogen reverts to its original disease causing type. However, before vaccines are permitted to enter most markets in the world extensive tests have to carried out to prove that reversion does not happen.
10.0 TREATMENTS
METHODS OF VACCINATION
There are two main methods of administering vaccines to fish, immersion in a dilute suspension of the vaccine or by injection into the body cavity. For practical reasons the latter method require the fish to be over about 15 grams in weight and so it is not usually feasible for ornamental species due to their small size.
IMMERSION VACCINATION
This is effective for some, but not all vaccines. The vaccine against the bacterial disease vibriosis is highly effective when administered by immersion. It is used widely in marine fish aquaculture. However, with the exception of the vaccine against Enteric Red Mouth (a disease of trout), which is delivered by immersion to fish in freshwater hatcheries other vaccines are delivered by injection in order to achieve effective protection. Immersion vaccines are not formulated with any adjuvant and comprise a whole bacterial culture inactivated by addition of formalin. Small batches of fish held in a net are immersed for about 30 seconds in vaccine which is usually diluted about 1:10 with water. Each litre of undiluted vaccine is sufficient to immunise about 100kg of fish. The method is ideal for vaccinating large numbers of small fish.
INJECTION VACCINATION
This is the most effective route of vaccination as it allows the incorporation of adjuvants that induce longterm protection. However, it is obviously very labour intensive. Adjuvants are oils which prolong the duration of protection given by a vaccine and also act as immunostimulants. However the use of adjuvant has been associated with side effects which can result in the viscera adhering to the body wall of the fish.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
118
10.0 TREATMENTS
BOOSTER VACCINATION
Antibody levels may fall after vaccination. Eventually they will fall to a level where they do not offer adequate protection. At that point the fish may be vaccinated again with a booster. This vaccination, which may have been repeated at regular intervals returns antibodies to protective levels.
Antibody levels
Fish protected
Vaccination
Booster Time
Ideally the booster would be given before the antibody level fell below levels that protected against disease.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
119
QUESTIONNAIRES
QUESTIONNAIRES
1. Your business attitude to risk
2.
3.
4.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
120
YOUR BUSINESS ATTITUDE TO THE RISK OF PATHOGENS ENTERING (AND LEAVING) YOUR SITE.
High biosecurity 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Prepared to accept and fund the costs of any outbreak of disease Not prepared to fund any measures to prevent pathogens entering your site or the disease they may cause Prepared to invest in biosecurity measures to prevent the entry of specific pathogens Prepared to invest in comprehensive, effective biosecurity measures Prepared to fund prevention of pathogen entry and treatment of disease including the regular additional use of external professional advice, e.g. vets Prepared to invest in training staff, cost effective disease prevention and treatment
QUESTIONNAIRE 1
Low biosecurity
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
121
QUESTIONNAIRE 2
A risk evaluation table may be used to help make decisions. (3.2) Risk evaluation table
Probability
of introduction Negligible or very low Score Minimal or Negligible Very low Low High Very High 1 3 5 7 9 1
Consequences of introduction
Low Medium High Very High Catastrophic 3 5 7 9
Before a pathogen or potential pathogen can be allocated to these categories a range of information about each of them should be gathered. Answering the questions below may help you gather the required information for each pathogen or potential pathogen and place it in a category with more confidence. 1. Will the pathogen have an impact on your business: cause fish losses on your site? cause reduction of saleability of the fish while on your site? be passed to your customers, or subsequent customers sites and lead to loss of confidence in you as a supplier?
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
4. Is the pathogen (6.3) always going to cause disease (obligate pathogen)? only going to cause disease under certain circumstances (facultative pathogen)?
5. Are the pathogens of concern transmitted (6.9) horizontally? Vertically? Both? is a vector, intermediate host or fomite required?
6. Under what conditions will the presence of the pathogen cause disease? (4.4) 7. Could the pathogen of concern become established on your site (does the stocking density, temperature, host or vector availability, pathogen loading, dispersal or transport technique permit transfer)? (4.4, 6.0, 7.0, 8.0) Yes Uncertain No-if there is no risk of the disease becoming established on your site or being carried passively through your site then the assessment can be stopped at this point
8. Which techniques must be used to accurately identify the pathogens concerned? (9) Are these techniques available to your supplier either by employing an off-site consultant (including Government laboratory) or on-site? Are these techniques available to you either by off-site consultant (including Government laboratory) or on-site? The pathogen cant be accurately and reliably detected and hence risk is uncertain.
9. Are there treatments available for the pathogen? (10.0) What are those treatments? How effective are they? Are there legal constraints on their use eg requirement for veterinary prescription and supervision? What are the costs associated with treatment?
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
123
QUESTIONNAIRE 3
Examples of routes of entry Fish Plants Water Packaging material Wildlife Equipment Staff Customers
Indicative list of sources Wild fish swimming onto site, commercial supplies, customer returns Commercial supplies, customer returns River, tapwater, borehole, water used for transport Fish and plant transport boxes and bags. Any animals , reptiles, amphibians, rats , invertebrates etc. Nets, bags, vehicles Hands, clothes, protective gear Hands, clothes
Rate on a scale of
1 9
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
124
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
Likelihood of occurrence
Very likely Likely Possible Unlikely Very unikely Not known
Biosecurity score
1 3 5
Effective 9 If an estimate cannot be made then it may be best to assign a low score ie assume low biosecurity Highly effective Not known
As appropriate this assessment can be applied to your business, the businesses supplying you directly and in turn down the supply chain to the point of production or collection. The indicative score is based on the scoring system described above ie the higher the value given (between 1 and 9) the higher the biosecurity.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
125
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
The indicative score is given only as a guide. Individual circumstances might greatly vary the score given. For instance for question 1 the scores given indicate that if a member of your staff has visited a site then that is likely to promote biosecurity. However this will depend on several factors including: the knowledge and experience of the person making the visit, the quality, accuracy and thoroughness of the report they provide effective management action being taken on the basis of that report.
In the absence of any one of these conditions the value of the measure is reduced and thus reduces its value as a biosecurity safeguard. Many of the scores will in reality depend on the quality of management. A good site poorly managed may present a significant risk. No absolute reliance should be given to the indicative scores included in the table. The scores you give can be used to calculate an average biosecurity score for a site, either yours or those of your suppliers, this may prove useful in deciding whether to continue trading with a particular supplier or site, or to ask for improvements to be made or to change the procedures eg treatment on arrival, you use when accepting fish from that site so as to limit the biosecurity risk to your site.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
126
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
1.
Question
Text reference(s)
Comments
Your score
Supply chain
Do you know how many facilities the fish you buy enter en-route to your site?
4.4
4.1
Up to 9 Down to 1
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
3.
Livestock
Closed cycle production on site (applies to farms) Under what conditions and when were broodstock introduced to the site? Stock is bought in from how many other farms or sites? (Generally the higher the number the greater the biosecurity risks). Livestock from individual farms isolated Detailed information available on suppliers Up to 9 Up to 9 8-9 1-9 1-9 4.4
127
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
4.
Preventative acclimatization
Where appropriate are preventative acclimatisation methods used to prevent entry of pathogens? Are fish acclimatised on arrival? Are fish treated prophylactically for pathogens of concern on or after arrival? Is the acclimatisation area separate from fish already held ? Are newly arrived fish separated on a centralised system by use of either UV or ozone? Or Are newly arrived fish put in separate holding systems, such as single aquaria on UG filtration? Are newly arrived fish mixed with old stock? All 1-9 depending on the measures applied and how rigorously
5.2
6.8,6.9
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
128
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
6.0
7.2
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
7a
9 7 1-4
7.3
129
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
Down to 1
Pond management
Dried and limed between stocking? Dried between stockings? Treated with lime but not drained between stocking? Fallowed between stocking? How long for? Prior to fallowing were all fish removed? By what technique: Netting Poisoning Electro-fishing Other 2 9 1-4 ? 2 1 9 7-8 4-5 3-4 7.3
Stocked continuously using: All in all out policy for stocking ponds? Continual stocking and mixing of batches?
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
130
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
Health monitoring
No formal system On-site visual On-site microscope Vet visits as needed Vet visits at regular intervals Regular sampling programme (wet preparations, histology, bacteriology) 1 3 5 6 7-8 7-8 10.0
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Official services visit to assess health of stock as needed Official services visit to assess health of stock regularly Official services undertake regular sampling programme (wet preparations, histology, bacteriology, virology) Other techniques 10
6-9 6-9 9
131
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
Fish treatments
Are the fish stocks treated prophylactically for the pathogens of greatest concern to you? Are fish only treated for pathogens when they are visible to the naked eye or cause disease? Are the fish vaccinated against important pathogens? Nothing is known of the fish treatment regime at the supply site No treatments are undertaken Up to 9 4-7 Up to 9 1 1 9.0
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
132
QUESTIONNAIRE 4
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
133
SUMMARY OF RISK REDUCTION STRATEGIES
Below, as an aide memoire, are lists of some risk reduction strategies that might be applied as and where appropriate. Some such as those applying to moving fish or equipment around a site might apply to any business. Others such as those concerning hand disinfection may for practical reasons apply less widely. They can be used to inform management of a site or as a guide of what to look out for when evaluating a site (for instance that of a supplier). These are not a substitute to answering the questionnaires, nor are they comprehensive, but may add to the value of the evaluation process that should be undertaken preferably after the questionnaires have been completed. * A 5.2 C Q Appendix Chapter section Chapter (whole) Questionnaire Section* Q1 C2 Whole report, A1
Whole report
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
134
General husbandry
Ensure the appropriate staff know the biology of the fish species in which you trade and can, as appropriate, pass that knowledge on to other staff members and customers Ensure the appropriate staff members know enough of the biology and characteristics of fish diseases, especially those caused by the pathogens of greatest concern, to recognise, treat or call for additional assistance as appropriate Monitor stock health regularly (using appropriate techniques for detection of pathogen of concern) Be aware of the potential for new diseases to emerge or old diseases to re-emerge Know how and when the available disease treatments may be used. Be aware of the manufacturers recommendations concerning use, health and safety and disposal Maintain water quality appropriate for the species (remembering to maintain an appropriate temperature for the species) Maintain records of water quality, fish health, imports and the like Maintain the health of the fishs own immune system by appropriate husbandry including resting/acclimatization periods Avoid unnecessary stressing of fish eg over or under stocking depending on species, using correct transport and handling methods Be aware of how disinfectants work and how they may be used. Clean and disinfect surfaces, nets and equipment as required. Regularly sterilize systems (this could be between stockings at regular intervals or end of years) as appropriate. Always remember the pipework is part of the system and must also be sterilised. Keep holding areas well ventilated and surfaces as dry as possible. 10.1 10.1 C9, A9 8.0 C4, C5, C6, C7, A7 C9 6.4,6.5 C10 A2
Section
7.4
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
135
Avoid bringing disease on to a site
Identify the pathways by which pathogens could arrive on your site Establish a plan to minimize or eliminate where possible the risks identified with each pathway Wherever possible purchase from a source that matches the EU Approved Farm model and/or sites that are not infected, and not supplied by sites which are infected, with the pathogen of concern When possible visit the sites you buy fish from. Know your supplier! As far as possible know your supply chain. The more participants in a supply chain (especially if fish from different sources are mixed) the greater the potential for problems, especially if adequate management is not in place at each site When available buy fish which are free of the pathogens of concern to you (or, if appropriate or possible, which have been vaccinated against them but which do not act as carriers) Isolate newly purchased fish, especially those from different sources, acclimatize them and treat them either promptly upon the discovery of a pathogen as required or prophylactically as experience dictates Remove or prevent the entry of vectors and fomites (including equipment and organisms that carry diseases other than the livestock you intend to keep such as unwanted fish, snails, birds and amphibians) that could bring disease on to, or move disease around your site 5.2 4.4
Section
C4, 6.10 Whole report Q3 4.1
6.10
Section
6.8, A4 6.8, 7.2, A4, A5 7.1 8.0
C8, 7.5
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
136
SUMMARY OF RISK REDUCTION STRATEGIES
Section
C7, 8.7
8.4
8.2
Ensure that routine sterilisation of nets, transport buckets etc is carried out, preferably after each use (making sure they are used free of disinfectant prior to reuse).
8.6
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
137
Appendices
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
138
SUMMARY OF RISK REDUCTION STRATEGIES
Questionnaire 1 Questionnaire 3 Contents Questionnaire 2 Questionnaire 4 Risk reduction strategies
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
139
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
140
CONTENTS
1. AMMONIA
SOURCES MEASUREMENT OF AMMONIA SAFE LEVELS OF FREE AMMONIA
2.
NITRITE
SOURCES MEASUREMENT OF NITRITE SAFE LEVELS OF NITRITE
3.
NITRATE
SOURCES MEASUREMENT OF NITRATE SAFE LEVELS OF NITRATE
4. 5. 6.
PH
THE PH SCALE
BUFFERING
RISING PH
DISSOLVED OXYGEN
SATURATION SOLUBILITY OF OXYGEN WEATHER MEASUREMENT OF DISSOLVED OXYGEN OXYGEN CONSUMPTION
7. 8.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
141
1. AMMONIA
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
SOURCES
Table 1: Levels of TOTAL AMMONIA (mg.l or ppm) that maintain FREE AMMONIA at or below 0.02mg/l (ppm) at a range of pH and emperatures
PH/Temp C 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
6 250
154
105
74
50
35
25
6..5 77
50
34
23
16
11
8
7 24
16
11
7.5
5
3.5
2.5
7.5 7.7
5
3.4
2.3
1.6
1.1
0.8
8 2.4
1.6
1.1
0.75
0.52
0.37
0.27
8.5 0.78
0.52
0.36
0.25
0.18
0.13
0.1
9 0.1
0.07
0.05
0.04
0.04
0.03
0.03
These figures apply to freshwater. To meet criteria for marine fish these figures should be halved.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
142
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Levels can be reduced by: Improvement of stocking, feeding and general husbandry procedures Improvement of biological filtration Use of ion exchange materials Dilution by water changes
In aquaria and ponds the principal sources of ammonia are: Excretion by fish and other livestock as a normal part of their metabolism The breakdown of protein in uneaten food or dead livestock which remains undetected. It is therefore of great importance that careful cleaning is undertaken at suitable intervals.
As ammonia is released into the water by either of these processes it may take one of two forms: Free Ammonia (unionised ammonia, chemical symbol NH3 ). This form of ammonia is highly toxic to fish Ammonium (ionised ammonia, chemical symbol NH4). This form of ammonia is virtually non-toxic to fish
NH3 Ammonium
The balance between Free Ammonia and Ammonium is determined by the pH and temperature of the water and may be summarised :
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
143
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
MEASUREMENT OF AMMONIA
Test kits and electronic meters usually measure all ammonia present, this is TOTAL AMMONIA. Some test kits measure Ammonium-Nitrogen and apply a conversion factor to determine the ammonia. This will usually be explained in the instructions provided with the test kit.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
144
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
2.
NITRITE
SOURCES
Levels can be reduced by: Improvement of stocking, feeding and general husbandry procedures; Improvement of biological filtration Dilution by water change;
In aquaria and ponds nitrites are produced by Nitrosomonas bacteria when ammonia is broken down.
MEASUREMENT OF NITRITE
Test kits are available. Some of these measure Nitrite-Nitrogen a conversion factor being applied to the result to obtain a true Nitrite reading; full instructions should be available with the test kit used.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
3.
NITRATE
145
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
SOURCES
Levels can be reduced by: Dilution by water change, ensure water used for change has a lower nitrate level; Use of ion exchange materials; Increase plant density; Use of denitrifying biological filtration
Nitrates are: Produced as Nitrobacter breaks down nitrites; Introduced in tap water. In some areas of the country in tap water nitrate levels exceed 130mg/l
MEASUREMENT OF NITRATE
Test kits are available. Some measure Nitrate-Nitrogen a conversion factor then being applied to obtain a true Nitrate reading; full instructions should be available with the kits used.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
146
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
4.
PH
147
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
THE PH SCALE..
10 11
12
13 14
TAPWATER
...is logarithmic
This means that the ph of a pond or aquaria alters by one units its acidity or alkalinity alters by x 10; Thus ph6 is x 10 more acid than ph7, And ph5 is x 100 more acid than ph7
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
148
5. BUFFERING
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Hard water and seawater contain dissolved materials that prevent rapid change in pH they are BUFFERED. The buffering system in seawater is overcome at about pH 8.1. Once the buffering system runs out a very rapid fall in the pH may occur jeopardising livestock.
RISING PH
At low pHs the toxicity of ammonia is low. Low pHs may be bought about by carbon dioxide, produced by animals all the time and by plants at night, dissolving in water and forming carbonic acid. If water of a higher pH is added, particularly if buffered, then there may be a sudden increase in pH. Associated with this rise will be a rapid increase in the toxicity of any ammonia present. This situation may arise in the transport of livestock in either hard or seawater.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
6.
DISSOLVED OXYGEN
1 litre of oxygen weighs 1,428mg 1 litre of air contains 285mg oxygen I litre of freshwater contains 14.6mg oxygen at 0C
149
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Water is therefore an oxygen poor environment. It contains only 5% of the oxygen that the same volume of air does.
Plants at night
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
150
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
SATURATION
If a beaker of sterile freshwater is left to stand at 25C then the normal maximum amount of oxygen that it can dissolve is 8.2mg/l. At this point the water sample is said to SATURATED. If it contained only 4.1mg/l then it would be 50% saturated. A level of dissolved oxygen of 6mg;l as recommended in the OATA Water Quality Criteria is equivalent to 73% saturation.
SOLUBILITY OF OXYGEN
As the table below demonstrates, that as the water temperature rises the amount of oxygen it may dissolve before becoming saturated diminishes. Seawater dissolves less oxygen than freshwater before it becomes saturated. Table 2: Solubility of oxygen Temp C Mg/l oxygen freshwater 14. 612.8 11.3 10.1 9.1 8.2 7.5 OATA criteria in terms of % saturation 41 47 53 59 66 73 80 Mg/l oxygen saltwater 11.7 10.4 9.3 8.5 7.8 7.1 6.5 OATA criteria in terms of % saturation 47 52 58 65 71 77 85
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Altitude and atmospheric pressure play a small part in determining oxygen solubility. For practical purposes both may be ignored.
WEATHER
The weather may combine all of the factors to create problems (some of them may arise also in fish houses). Sunlight increases water temperature and hence decreases oxygen solubility. Freezing ice seals the surface preventing the entry of oxygen and the escape of toxic gases. Still periods when there is little wind such as before thunder storms, the rate of diffusion of oxygen is diminished by the reduction of the pond surface area (ripple in a light wind may increase the surface area of a pond by two or three times).
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
OXYGEN CONSUMPTION
151
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
Size of livestock small fish use relatively more oxygen than large fish. Total weight of livestock Oxygen consumption of livestock doubles for each 10C rise in temperature, but oxygen availability is reduced as its solubility is also reduced by the temperature rise. Biofilter activity ammonia production mirrors oxygen consumption.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
152
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
7.
BIOLOGICAL FILTRATION
Biological filtration is the process by which waste, principally ammonia, products in ponds and aquaria are broken down by bacteria.
BIOLOGICAL FILTRATION
AMMONIA
NH3 BACTERIA
NITRITE
NO2
} }
NITROSOMONAS
NITROBACTER
NITRATE
NO3
OR
NITROGEN GAS
N2
AMMONIA
NH3
} }
(REQUIRES THE ABSENCE OF OXYGEN TO PROCEED ie ANAEROBIC)
VARIOUS
DENITRIFICATION
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
153
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
A surface on which to grow (the larger the surface area, the greater the population which may grow) A good supply of dissolved oxygen and an active filter may use more oxygen that the livestock in the water it processes A supply of nutrients ammonia and nitrates
The bacteria responsible for denitrification require: A surface on which to grow; A supply of nutrients o Principally nitrates; o Secondarily, if methanol or similar chemical is present, nitrogen gas will be formed; o If other organic materials are present, ammonia may be formed.
Oxygen kills the bacteria responsible for this process. A filter may be said to mature when any ammonia entering a tank is instantaneously converted to nitrite and then in turn to nitrate. Biological filters are only mature for specific conditions; if the stocking density or feeding increases then the filter needs a further period of maturation.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
154
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
8.
APPENDIX A
TROPICAL SPECIES
*Dissolved Oxygen *Free Ammonia Nitrite Nitrate - min 6mg/litre - max 0.02mg/litre - max 0.2mg/litre - max 50mg/litre above ambient tap water
Factors marked * should be measured in the first instance, if they prove satisfactory, and the fish appear healthy, then further investigation may not be necessary.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
155
APPENDIX 1 WATER QUALITY CRITERIA
COLD FRESHWATER
8kg/1000 l
TROPICAL FRESHWATER
Fish up to 5cm (2) 1.5kg/1000 l Fish over 5cm (2) 2.5kg/1000 l
TROPICAL MARINE
Fish up to 5cm (5) 1kg/1000 l Fish over 5cm (2) 2kg/1000 l Guide stockings are ADVISORY only. They may be exceeded if the water quality standards are satisfied. When the water quality standards are exceeded at a lower stocking, this must be considered as the maximum stocking density permissible. The TOTAL volume of the system must be measured and taken into account in determining actual stocking densities.
TECHNICAL NOTE
The above figures should be read in the following manner: Free Ammonia as NH3 Nitrite as NO2 Nitrate as NO3
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
156
APPENDIX 2 FISH EUTHANASIA
FISH EUTHANASIA
It now is widely accepted that fish feel pain or something similar to it. Euthanasia must be carried out using a technique that brings about death quickly with as little pain as possible. A well-aimed blow to the head which kills fish rapidly by rendering the animal unconscious at the same time as destroying the brain is considered one of the most humane ways of euthanizing a fish. If faced with a large number of fish to destroy, a member may be best advised to seek help from his or her vet. A fish anaesthetic such as benzocaine which is highly effective may be considered. Fish are netted into a tub of benzocaine where they are allowed to become overdosed. Benzocaine is relatively insoluble in water. It must first be dissolved in alcohol at a rate of 40g to the litre. This is then dissolved in water at a rate of 20ml per 2 gallons (9 litres) which gives a benzocaine level of 100 ppm. This will rapidly anaesthetise the fish. Fish should be left in the solution for 2 hours to ensure that death has taken place. Dead fish should be disposed of with due consideration to health and safety, and in accordance with disposal of waste legislation that may be applicable. They should not be thrown in the bin or flushed down the loo!
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
157
APPENDIX 3 DISPOSAL OF CLINICAL WASTE
Two years ago in a BBC Watchdog program about the company Petsmart concerning their care of mammals, the issue of the disposal of dead animals was raised. The program alleged that dead animals that should have been treated as clinical waste were thrown in the rubbish skip rather than in yellow bags.
RISK ASSESSMENT
As with any operation in the work place, a risk assessment may be required for operations handling dead animals under the Health and Safety or COSHH legislation. This should include any risks to health from handling dead animals, including any precautions thought necessary (in the case of fish good personal hygiene and the provision of gloves may reduce any risks from zoonoses).
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
158 UV
APPENDIX 4 LETHAL DOSE OF UV FOR VARIETY OF ORGANISMS
The following list is not comprehensive but shows the great variety of dose required to kill different groups of potential pathogens BACTERIA Bacillus anthracis (Anthrax bacillus) B. megatherium species (veg) B. megatherium species (spores) B. pratyphosus B. subtilis (mixed) B. subtilis (spores) Clostridium tetani Corynebacterium, C. deptheriae Dysentery bacilli (Shigella sonni) Eberthela typhosa (Typhus bacillus) Micrococcus candidus M. piltonensis M. spaeroides Myxobacterium tuberculosis Neisseria catarrhalis Phytomonas tumefaciens Proteus vulgaris Pseudomonas aerugenosa P. fluorescens Salmonella species Salmonella enteritidis S. typhimurium (ave) Sarcina lutea Serratia marcescens Shigillia paradysenderiae Spirillum rubsum Staphylococcus albus S. aureus S. hemolyticus Streptococcus lactis S. viridans FUNGI Saccharomyces ellipsoideus Saccharomyces. species S. cerevisiae Brewers Yeast Killing dose ( W s/cm) 8,700 2,500 5,200 6,100 11,000 22,000 22,000 6,500 4,200 4,100 12,300 15,000 15,400 10,000 8,500 8,500 6,600 10,500 6,600 10,000 7,600 15,200 26,400 6,160 3,400 6,160 5,700 6,600 5,500 8,800 3,800 13,200 17,600 13,200 6,600
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Bakers Yeast Common Yeast Cake Penicillium roqueforti P. expansum P. digitatum Aspergillus glaucus A. flavus A. niger Rhisopus nigricans Mucor racemosus A M. racemosus B Oospora lactis VIRUSES Bacteriophage (escherichia coli) Tobacco mosaic Influenza PROTOZOA Paramecium PARASITES Nematode Eggs Algae Chlorella vulgaris
8,800 13,200 26,400 22,000 88,000 88,000 99,000 330,000 220,000 35,200 35,200 11,000 6,600 440,000 3,400 200,000
159
APPENDIX 4 LETHAL DOSE OF UV FOR VARIETY OF ORGANISMS
92,000 22,000
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
As can be seen from this data, the major groups of pathogens that will affect cultures of fish (psuedomonads, representing the Aeromonas and Vibrio group) Rhabdoviruses (to which SVC belongs) and the Herpes Viruses (to which KHV belongs) are rapidly destroyed by ozone, clearly demonstrating how effective this disinfectant can be.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
161
APPENDIX 6 - VETERINARY MEDICINE
Veterinary medicines legislation in the UK has been thoroughly overhauled and will now be covered by one piece of legislation, The Veterinary Medicines Regulations 2005, SI No 2745. Any amendments to the Regulations will be made annually. For the last decade mainstream fish treatments have been in a grey area. They technically required full authorisation which few or none had, but were well known to the authorities. This new regulatory framework will establish the Exemption Scheme for small pet animals which will resolve this problem. In accordance with the Scheme products will be clearly labelled and easy to recognise. This briefing note is just to give an outline of the changes coming over the next two years. Members are referred to more detailed sources of official information at the foot of this document. You may need to review the product ranges you stock and also ensure all stock not meeting the labelling requirements are sold by November 2007.
If a product is either presented as a medicine or has a medicinal function then it will be covered by this definition. Treatments for ectoparasites are normally regulated by veterinary medicines law rather than that covering pesticides. A few small exceptions exist for vaccines made and used on a single site and for veterinary medicines based on radioactive isotopes.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
illegal veterinary medicinal products, including herbal and homeopathic remedies that are covered by the definition above. Authorised products must be used for the species and purposes for which they were authorised. Vets may use treatments outside of this requirement subject to prescribing cascade rules. Vets are fully aware of these rules. Any use off label i.e. not for the purpose the medicine was authorised, automatically means that use is subject to a veterinary prescription. It is quite clear that importing products labelled only in Chinese, for example, is illegal.
More information is available from the web sources referenced at on page 164.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
The costs of completing the full authorisation process are considerable. These costs would mean that products for some species would never be financially viable and so would never be available. This could cause significant welfare problems.
163
APPENDIX 6 - VETERINARY MEDICINE
The Exemption Scheme relieves manufacturers of the necessity to undertake expensive testing. However it does not relieve manufacturers of the need to use Good Manufacturing Practice , which will include on site inspection of their facilities, and as appropriate other controls applied to fully authorised medicines.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
165
APPENDIX 7 - NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL LAWS
This is a rather dry subject but is included so that the background to how and why laws to prevent the entry of certain fish diseases to countries are made. International trade is governed by the rules of the World Trade Organisation (WTO). In a nutshell the WTO rules state that member countries may not protect industries in their own countries by putting in place tariffs, duties or other barriers to the import of products from other countries without justification. 49 countries are members of the WTO. The WTO permits barriers to trade that protect countries human, animal or plant health within what is known as the Sanitary and Pytosanitary agreement most commonly referred to as the SPS (see box below).
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
The OIE Aquatic Manual which includes lists of OIE 166 http://www.oie.int/eng/normes/fmanual/A_summry.htm notifiable diseases and diagnosis procedures.
Individual countries or trade blocs such as the EU can then decide what diseases they want to protect themselves against. The EU has in essence three different scenarios
Disease-free zone: where after exhaustive testing using procedures set out by the OIE a country or zone is found to be free of a pathogen then it may apply rigorous standards of fish health (including intensive testing) to any imports of species susceptible to the pathogen. Eradication zone; where the pathogen has occurred or occurs occasionally in a member state but the member state applies strict control measures when it is found. It may act as though it is disease-free as far as imports are concerned. Diseased or infected zone where the pathogen is present (or hasnt been proved by a variety of methods) in a member state and no action is being taken to control or eradicate the disease then no barriers are put in place to trade with other countries or zones within the EC in which the same disease occurs.
The EU also required the eradication of animals under some circumstances when the pathogen is found. Thus a notifiable disease in the EU has a different meaning to a disease notifiable to the OIE. Spring Viraemia of Carp can be used as an example*; Countries** Finland, Denmark, Sweden, Ireland and Northern Ireland United Kingdom Disease status Extensive testing allows these countries and areas to be deemed disease-free for SVC. Where imports are permitted from May only import susceptible species from countries or zones tested and found to be SVC free or which can prove that SVC has never occurred in their country Where they may export to Anywhere
Has had occasional outbreaks of SVC but eradication or control measure are enforced. Known as an eradication zone Either SVC is known to occur or they have not undergone the testing to prove absence of the disease
May only import susceptible species from countries or zones tested and found to be free of SVC or which can prove that SVC has never occurred in there country Anywhere. General health rules will apply but no requirement for SVC susceptibles to be tested for SVC.
As it is not regarded as disease-free can only export to areas of lesser health status, within the EU this means the other 20 member states. Cannot export SVC susceptible species to disease-free, eradication zones.
**Individual zones or farms may have a different status from the country as a whole
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
ADVICE TO DEALERS, TRADERS AND FARMERS ON STEPS TO PREVENT THE SPREAD OF SVC
167
APPENDIX 8 DEFRAS ADVICE ON AVOIDING SVC
Taken from: Spring Viraemia of Carp, produced by Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food Welsh Office Agriculture Department (now DEFRA) several years ago. Copies can be obtained from MAFF Fish Diseases Laboratory T: 01305 206600. Dealers, traders and farmers should report any knowledge or suspicions of SVC to the Fish Diseases Laboratory, Weymouth or to their local Water Authority. Carp, just like any other fish, have increased susceptibility to disease when they are stressed. Stress can be caused by a number of factors such as rapid changes in water temperature, movement from one site to another, poor handling or overstocking. The risk of disease and mortalities can be significantly reduced by keeping stress to a minimum wherever possible. Dealers should avoid collecting and mixing fish from different sites, especially when the fish are intended for immediate sale. If feasible, dealers should also consider a period of quarantine (preferably for two weeks) for recently acquired stocks. This may prevent the introduction of SVC to their own stocks and to those of customers. When netting stocks, dealers should ensure that nets and equipment are disinfected before use at another site. It will obviously benefit dealers, traders and farmers to ask appropriate questions of importing agents or wholesale suppliers as to the health of fish before accepting consignments. Importers of ornamental varieties should take all reasonable steps to determine whether overseas suppliers can give assurances that their fish stocks are free from infection with SVC virus, or other serious diseases. Importers should consider seeking satisfactory responses from suppliers on points such as: Are regular examinations for disease carried out on fish stocks held on the suppliers site/ premises? Are all new consignments of fish brought into the suppliers site/premises examined for disease? Who undertakes these examinations (e.g. own employee, private veterinarians, state veterinary service)? Are only sick fish examined, or are random samples of apparently healthy fish also examined routinely? Are samples taken for laboratory tests for bacteria, viruses, parasites? If yes, which laboratory carries out the test? Can the supplier provide a list of tests carried out on his site/premises and the results? What steps does the supplier take to ensure that the health status of his own suppliers fish stocks is acceptable?
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
168 DISINFECTION
Ideally, disinfection should involve the treatment of nets, sacks, footwear and other equipment such as boats, prior to moving to other waters. Equipment used in fishery remedial work, such as bank repairs and stock netting, might similarly be treated. Iodine-based preparations (iodophors) are recommended for disinfecting equipment: such preparations, by way of example, include Wescodyne (Ciba Geigy Ltd) and FAM-30 (Vanodine International). Advice on local sources of supply or suitable alternatives may be obtained from local veterinary surgeons, Water Authorities, or the Ministrys Fish Disease Laboratory at Weymouth (T: 01305 206600). As a broad guide Wescodyne should be diluted: 1 parts in 100 with water and FAM-30: 1 part in 100 with water. Other iodophores should be diluted to provide a final concentration of 250 parts per million active iodine. Suppliers, or scientists at the Fish Disease Laboratory, Weymouth can advise in cases of doubt. Disinfection is best achieved by first cleaning off all mud etc followed by immersion for 15 to 30 minutes; or by application to surfaces using a pad soaked with disinfectant. (Reference to specific disinfectant products should not be construed as any criticism of similar products). For regular disinfection of heavily soiled footwear, a bath of 1% caustic soda (sodium hydroxide) solution is more appropriate. The strength of the caustic soda should be checked daily and the disinfectant replaced if the pH is 11 or below, as shown by indicator papers. Protective clothing should be used when handling caustic soda to protect the skin and eyes. This disinfectant can corrode metals. Iodophors and many other disinfectants are extremely poisonous to fish. Footwear and all equipment, especially nets, should be thoroughly rinsed with tap water after disinfecting. Disinfectant and washings must be disposed of in a way, which does not harm the environment. They should never be tipped into water containing fish or other aquatic life.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
EMERGENCE OF INFECTION
For an epidemic to occur a pathogen must spread to new hosts faster than its current hosts recover or die. Formally: if the coefficient R>1 then an epidemic can occur if the pathogen is introduced (e.g. with new stock). Rs value depends on transmission coefficient, , initial population density of nave hosts, S, and the rate of removal of infection, . R = S > 1
169
APPENDIX 9 EMERGENCE OF INFECTIONS
This formula illustrates how the risk of epidemics can be reduced by preventing over-crowding or stress (to reduce S and ) and by removing sick fish (to increase ).
Pathogens that are normally rare may emerge as a serious disease problem under systems that produce and move large numbers of live fish at high density (increasing and S). Pathogens may also evolve increased virulence under such conditions, as high rates of missing of hosts select for rapidly spreading pathogens that can take advantage of the opportunities, even if damage to the existing host is increased. One potential source of new pathogens is the mixing of stocks from different sources. Some stocks may be resistant carriers that spread a pathogen to nave stocks of the same or similar species, resulting in disease. A more complex emergence can occur when pathogens jump to different species. Cross-species transmission may be inherently unlikely ( is small ) but if species are mixed in large numbers and in close proximity (S is large) the unlikely step has many chances to occur. Once the pathogen has jumped species it may cause a dead end infection. Perhaps killing its new host, but not spreading. Far more seriously it may be able to adapt and transmit to others of the new species; this adaptation may be a slow process with the pathogen improving its ability to transmit ( increasing) with each successful transmission. If the new hosts are held at high densities, or are stressed, then the pathogen is more likely to survive this period of inefficient transmission, allowing a new disease to emerge. The best way to reduce the risk of disease emergence is to adopt good husbandry: do not overcrowd or otherwise stress fish, avoid mixing stocks or species from different sources and remove sick fish as quickly as possible.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
MYCOBACTERIUM
Cause: Mycobacterium marinum, M fortuitum and other Mycobacterium species; common bacteria in all aquatic environments Comment: the most common chronic disease that affects aquarium fish, commonly called mycobacteriosis or fish tuberculosis (TB). It may take two or more years for the number of organisms to grow to detectable levels. Transmission: bacteria are shed from infected skin ulcers and the intestine into the water. Fish are infected by contact with organisms in water, cannibalism and eating uncooked infected fish. Signs in fish: most show few or no external signs of disease but advanced cases may exhibit poor growth, weight loss, colour change, lethargy, chronic non-healing ulcers, skeletal deformity, abdominal swelling, incoordination, sudden death.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Signs in humans: single or multiple (sporothricoid) non-healing ulcers on hands or arms, commonly called fish tank or swimming pool granuloma, aquarists nodule, aquarists finger, aquarists arm. Small lesions may heal spontaneously but others require courses of multiple antibiotics over several months. Control: there are no effective non-lethal tests to identify infected fish and no vaccine
171
APPENDIX 10 - ZOONOSES
VIBRIO
Cause: various Vibrio species; common bacteria in marine and brackish environments Transmission: infection by contact with bacteria in water Signs in fish: ulcers, lethargy, inflamed areas on skin, deaths Signs in humans: ingestion may cause vomiting and diarrhoea; wound infection produces local inflammation and severe tissue reaction
AEROMONAS
Cause: Aeromonas hydrophila and other Aeromonas species; common bacteria in freshwater environments Transmission: infection by contact with bacteria in water Signs in fish: ulcers, lethargy, inflamed areas on skin, deaths Signs in humans: ingestion may cause vomiting and diarrhoea; puncture wound infection produces local inflammation and severe tissue reaction.
OTHERS
Several other organisms of aquatic origin have been linked to human disease but in most cases these have been due to contamination of the environment rather than direct infection from fish. These include Salmonella, Leptospirosis (Weils disease, usually associated with surfaces or water infected by the waste products of rats), Streptococcus, Erysipelothrix (fish rose, erysipeloid), Cryptosporidium. Details of these and other rare cases can be found in the reference below.
REFERENCES
Nemetz, TG & Shotts, EB Jr (1993) Zoonotic diseases. In: Fish Medicine (ed. MK Stoskopf) WB Saunders Co., Philadelphia
FISH TUBERCULOSIS
Fish tuberculosis or mycobacteriosis is most commonly caused by Mycobacterium marinum or Mycobactenum fortuitum. The disease is spread by various methods; skin granulomas may release bacteria directly into the water, bacteria may be shed via the faeces from tuberculous granulomas in the liver or gut lining, or bacteria may be shed in the urine from the kidney. Another more direct route involves dead fish in the tank or pond being cannibalised. This is very common and usually the heavily infected abdominal organs are eaten first. Disease can also be spread by the aquarist who feeds live infected fish to his large specimen fish such as oscars (Astronotus ocellatus) or piranha (Serrasalmus spp). The disease is zoonotic and in man is often called aquarists arm; it is occasionally seen in people working in aquarium shops, the commonest site of infection are the hands and arms due to minor scratches becoming infected. As an infection of man it is difficult to treat, often taking months to resolve. In fish TB is in my experience impossible to eliminate once it has occurred in a tank or pond, affected collections offish
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
not have any new additions and when the collection becomes depleted it is better perhaps to 172 should sacrifice the remaining fish and disinfect the system before starting again.
APPENDIX 10 - ZOONOSES
Because of the possibility of human infection, hygiene is very important when dealing with fish tanks. Wash hands and arms well after doing any tank servicing and pay particular attention to dressing any cuts and scratches. Do not use siphons that involve you getting a mouthful of water! Do not wash out tank filters in the kitchen sink or pour wastewater down it, if you have to then make sure it is well washed afterwards. Simple, sensible hygiene practices should be more than enough to reduce greatly the already very low risk of infection.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
OTHER ORGANISMS
Cryptosporidiosis Cryptosporidium is a strange protozoan organism causing enteric problems in man, again although it has been found in fish it is actually frequently transmitted by water. The organism has been found to be present in tap water. Again this is the link with fish, there is no evidence of transmission from fish to man.
173
APPENDIX 10 - ZOONOSES
PREVENTION
Basic commonsense hygiene will prevent transmission of infections being transmitted to aquarists and pondkeepers. Hand sterilising preparations are useful in the shop situation, good thorough cleaning and disinfection of tanks, nets etc are important.
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org
Ornamental Aquatic Trade Association, Wessex House, 40 Station Road, Westbury, Wiltshire, BA13 3JN, UK Tel: 0870 0434013, Fax: 01373 301236 info@ornamentalfish.org, www.ornamentalfish.org