9 10 13 NVD 13CV446 484 IFP Motion, Proposed Complaint NVD Action Re Summary Eviction Lockout Burglaries by RPD, WCSO, Hill, Northwind, Et Al 56 Pages Doc 8

__________ District of __________
AO 240 (Rev. 01/09) Application to Proceed in District Court Without Prepaying Fees or Costs (Short Form)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff
v. Civil Action No.
Defendant
APPLICATION TO PROCEED IN DISTRICT COURT WITHOUT PREPAYING FEES OR COSTS
(Short Form)
I am a plaintiff or petitioner in this case and declare that I am unable to pay the costs of these proceedings and
that I am entitled to the relief requested.
In support of this application, I answer the following questions under penalty of perjury:
1. If incarcerated. I am being held at: .
If employed there, or have an account in the institution, I have attached to this document a statement certified by the
appropriate institutional officer showing all receipts, expenditures, and balances during the last six months for any
institutional account in my name. I am also submitting a similar statement from any other institution where I was
incarcerated during the last six months.
2. If not incarcerated. If I am employed, my employers name and address are:
My take-home pay or wages are: $ per (specify pay period) .
3. Other Income. In the past 12 months, I have received income from the following sources (check all that apply):
(a) Business, profession, or other self-employment u u Yes No
(b) Rent payments, interest, or dividends u u Yes No
(c) Pension, annuity, or life insurance payments u u Yes No
(d) Disability, or workers compensation payments u u Yes No
(e) Gifts, or inheritances u u Yes No
(f) Any other sources u Yes u No
If you answered Yes to any question above, describe below or on separate pages each source of money and
state the amount that you received and what you expect to receive in the future.
District of Nevada
Zachary Barker Coughlin
I have been incarcer. twenty times since 8/20/11, but not currently
I am arguably self employed. Nearly every waking hour is spent in the defense of either my formal disciplinary
matter or the various criminal prosecutions against me. My license to practice law in Nevada is temporarily
suspended, license before the USPTO is not suspended, but I have never filed anything therein, focusing on 62337.
0.00 week.
My mother has been paying my rent since approximately November 2012..it was $75 a months for three months, then
increased to $150 a month. She has paid my car insurance as well. My father has filled up my gas tank on numerous
occasions. Both have given me nominal amounts of spending money once in awhile ($20-60 here and there,
approximately one a month or so, my mother since November 2012, my father since about April 2012), besides that I
have been eating food from local food pantries, and just generally hardly have more than $5.00 to my name, my bank
account is overdrawn. I have applied for foodstamps a couple times but missed both appointments, but am pursuing
reapplying.
Coughlin was awarded $200 a month in food stamps for the next six months as of 8/28/13.
wAL=MART; RENO SPARKS INDIAN COLONY ET AL..
Case 3:13-cv-00446-RCJ-WGC Document 8 Filed 09/10/13 Page 1 of 56
AO 240 (Rev. 01/09) Application to Proceed in District Court Without Prepaying Fees or Costs (Short Form)
4. Amount of money that I have in cash or in a checking or savings account: $ .
5. Any automobile, real estate, stock, bond, security, trust, jewelry, art work, or other financial instrument or
thing of value that I own, including any item of value held in someone elses name (describe the property and its approximate
value):
6. Any housing, transportation, utilities, or loan payments, or other regular monthly expenses (describe and provide
the amount of the monthly expense):
7. Names (or, if under 18, initials only) of all persons who are dependent on me for support, my relationship
with each person, and how much I contribute to their support:
8. Any debts or financial obligations (describe the amounts owed and to whom they are payable):
Declaration: I declare under penalty of perjury that the above information is true and understand that a false
statement may result in a dismissal of my claims.
Date:
Applicants signature
Printed name
0.00
1996 Honda Accord with 120,000 miles on it, in very poor condition, appears as though someone might have have
been living out of it at various points over the last ten or so years. Worth probably $500, if that. I do not own any real
estate, stocks, bond, security.
Car insurance through USAA, but my mother has been paying that.
none.
student loans of approximately $70K, just went to the ER for a kidney stone, probably have been sent to collections for
that...no longer have cell phone, T-Mobile probably feels I owe them some money, I owe at least one friend some
money for bailing me out of jail on one or more of the twenty occasions since the initial arrest of 8/20/11.
08/20/2013 /s/ Zach Coughlin
Zachary Barker Coughlin
and again on 9/6/13.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
1471 E. 9th St.
Reno, NV 89512
NV Ba !947" #te$%oail& sus%en'e'(
)S*+, -tt& Regist !5",9.5 not sus%en'e'
/a0 an' tele is sa$e1 949 227 74.2
ZachCoughlin3hot$ail.co$
)N4+E5 S+-+ES 54S+R4C+ C,)R+
54S+R4C+ ,6 NEV-5-
Z-C7-R8 B-R9ER C,):7;4N
*lainti//
<.
C-SE8 5. B-9ER, in'i<i'uall& an' in his
ca%acit& as an e$%lo&ee o/ +7E ;-=
,664CES ,6 R4C7-R5 :. 74;;, ES>.,
R4C7-R5 :. 74;;, in'i<i'uall& an' in
his ca%acit& as a %inci%al in +7E ;-=
,664CES ,6 R4C7-R5 :. 74;;, ES>,
+7E ;-= ,664CES ,6 R4C7-R5 :.
74;;, ES>., ?-++7E= @,E;
?ER;4SSA ?-++7E= @,E; ?ER;4SS
;4V4N: +R)S+A =-S7,E C,)N+8
S7ER466BS ,664CE #=CS,(, @,7N
?-C7EN, in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit&
as a 'e%ut& /o the the =CS,, ;iC Stuchell,
in'i<i'uall& an' in he ca%acit& as a Ci<il
5i<ision Su%e<iso /o the =CS,A REN,
@)S+4CE C,)R+ #R@C(A 7,N. *E+ER @.
S6ERR-ZZ-, %esonall& an' in his
ca%acit& as a @ustice o/ the *eace Dith the
R@CA 7,N. @-C9 SC7R,E5ER,
%esonall& an' in his ca%acit& as a @ustice o/
the *eace Dith the R@CA 7,N. SC,++
*E-RS,N, %esonall& an' in his ca%acit&
C-SE N,.1
V-R4,)S +,R+S -N5 C4V4; R4:7+S
C,?*;-4N+ *)RS)-N+ +,
42 ).S.C. E 198"
@)R8 +R4-; 5E?-N5E5
>)4 +-?FC;-SS
-C+4,NF=74S+;EB;,=ER
42 ).S.C. SEC 1988
@)R8 +R4-; 5E?-N5E5
R,,9ER 6E;5?-N 7-4; ?-R8
- 1F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
as a @ustice o/ the *eace Dith the R@CA
REN, *,;4CE 5E*-R+?EN+ #R*5(A
R*5 S-R:EN+ ?-RC4- ;,*EZ,
in'i<i'uall& an' in he ca%acit& as an
e$%lo&ee o/ the R*5A R*5 ,664CER
C7R4S C-R+ER, @R., in'i<i'uall& an in
his ca%acit& as an e$%lo&ee o/ the R*5A
*-R9 +ERR-CE +,=N 7,?ES 7,?E
,=NERBS -SS,C4-+4,N #*++7,-(A
:-8;E 9ERN, ES>., in'i<i'uall& an in
he ca%acit& as the attone& /o *++7,-A
:-8;E 9ERN, ES>., ;+5.A S)S-N
94N:, in'i<i'uall& an' in he ca%acit& as
an e$%lo&e o %inci%al o/ =ES+ERN
NEV-5- ?-N-:?EN+A =ES+ERN
NEV-5- ?-N-:E?EN+A =CS,
5E*)+8 V4NCEN+ C-NN4Z-R,,
in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as a 'e%ut&
/o the the =CS,A @,E 5)RB4N,
in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as a 'e%ut&
/o the the =CS,A N,R+7=4N5S
-*-R+?EN+S -SS,C4-+ES, ;;CA
5)-NE @-9,BA in'i<i'uall& an' in his
ca%acit& as ?anage o/ N,R+7=4N5S
-*-R+?EN+S, ;;CA NEV-5- C,)R+
SERV4CESA @E66 C7-N5;ER,
in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as
oDneFo%eato o/ NEV-5- C,)R+
SERV4CESA R8-N =R-8A in'i<i'uall&
an' in his ca%acit& as a ;icense' *ocess
Se<e /o Ne<a'a Cout Se<icesA @,E;
5)R5ENA in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit&
as a ;icense' *ocess Se<e /o Ne<a'a
Cout Se<icesA 9E4+7 ;,,?4S, ES>.A
in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as a Cout
-%%ointe' 5e/ense Counsel /o the REN,
?)N4C4*-; C,)R+A S+EVE +)++;EA
in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as Cout
-'$inistato /o the REN, @)S+4CE
C,)R+A R@C B-4;466 @,7N 7,;:)4N
RE8ESA R@C C74E6 B-4;466 ?4C7-E;
SEG+,NA R*5 ,664CER -;-N
=E-VERA R*5 ,664CER BR4-N 58EA
- 2F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
?4;-N 9REBS, in'i<i'uall& an' in his
ca%acit& as an e$%lo&ee o/
N,R+7=4N5S -*-R+?EN+SA
EC,??A =-S7,E C,)N+8
C,??)N4C-+4,N CEN+ERA
C7R4S+,*7ER 7-Z;E++HS+EVENS,
ES>., in'i<i'uall& an' in his ca%acit& as a
%osecuto /o the R?CA *-+R4C9 ,.
94N:, ES>.A in'i<i'uall& an' in his
ca%acit& as -sst. Ba Counsel /o the State
Ba o/ Ne<a'aA ;-)R- *E+ERSA
in'i<i'uall& an' in he ca%acit& as an
4n<estigato Dith the S+-+E B-R ,6
NEV-5-
COMPLAINT FOR PERSONAL INJURY
NATURE OF CASE
Coughlin es%ect/ull& suI$its this *o%ose' Co$%laint Dith the ca<eat that
it nee's DoJ. Coughlin taJes seiousl& the nee', o e<en 'ut& to $aJes
$eitoious clai$s an' %esent the$ in a co$%etent /ashion, though Coughlin has
ne<e %e<iousl& DoJe' in a 198" o tot setting. Coughlin has 'iligentl& sought
to %osecute this action since the 9F9F11 Dong/ul aest, Iut has encountee' a
$ultitu'e o/ oIstacles, $an& in<ol<ing Ku'icial, %osecutoial an' laD en/oce$ent
$iscon'uct as 'etaile' $oe /ull& at the /olloDing1
http://www.s!i"#.om/#o/$%%&%''%(/()()$*)It+!ation)$,)$-)$,)','-)%,**.)
/o!#pa#)0+!sion)1+2in)1oo3ma!3in2)an#)En#not+s)FOFCOL)
Int+!lin+attin2)J4st)Cit+#)P!otions)an#)&),*)$,)Complaints
Coughlin seeJs to a%%oint$ent o/ coHcounsel at %uIlic e0%ense 'o to the
natue o/ this $atte an' the constant attacJs Coughlin has Ieen suIKect to /o
- "F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
e0%osing the e0tent to Dhich lanl'o' tenant $attes in Reno an' =ashoe Count&
ae i/e Dith o//icial $iscon'uct. Coughlin suI$its this Co$%laint in this /o$
un'e the 'uess o/ the constant theat o/ aest an' e0te$e in'igenc& in
conKunction Dith the %essing natue o/ the a%%eal o/ the eco$$en'ation to
%e$anentl& 'isIa hi$ in 22""7 an' 'e/en'ing against nu$eous e$aining
Dong/ul, <in'icti<e %osecutions o/ Coughlin in the R?C an' R@C. Coughlin
ai$s to %o<i'e a Co$%laint that co$%lies Dith all 'uties %lace' on hi$, Dhethe as
a sus%en'e' attone& a%%aentl& still suIKect to an a%%lication o/ at least so$e o/
the Rules o/ *o/essional Con'uct, o $eel& as a litigant.
-. @)R4S54C+4,N
1. +his Co$%laint alleges a <iolation o/ CoughlinBs ci<il ights, /au',
cons%iac&, 'e/a$ation o/ chaacte, negligence /alse aest, /alse i$%ison$ent,
$alicious %osecution, Iugla&, tes%ass, con<esion, /au', intentional in/liction o/
e$otional 'istess, Dong/ul e<iction, etaliato& e<iction, Iatte&, assault, Ieach
o/ contact, etc.
2. Coughlin cuentl& esi'es at 1471 E. 9
th
St., Reno, NV 89512.
"F -ll 'e/en'ants na$e' aIo<e ae Ielie<e to esi'e in =ashoe Count&
Ne<a'a, othe than Case& 5. BaJe, Esq., Dho$ is noD %acticing in :eogie, an'
?attheD @oel ?eliss, Dho$ li<es in Chico, Cali/onia, an' NothDin's
-%at$ents, ;;C, Dhich is inco%oate' an' Iase' in Belle<ue =ashington.
- 4F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
7( @uis'iction is in<oJe' %usuant to 1""1 'i<esit& an' 28 ).S.C. E 1"4"
#a(#"( an' 42 ).S.C. E 198", 1988 though the 6e'eal >uestion %esente' I& the
6outh -$en'$ent <iolations atten'ant to these state s%onsoe' Iuglaies 'esse'
u% as su$$a& e<iction locJouts an' the Sol'al <. CooJ Count& o<etones ae a
consi'eation.
+his is an action /o elie/ in 'a$ages, inKuncti<e elie/, an' /o attone&sL
/ees an' costs Dhich is Iought on Iehal/ o/ the *lainti// i'enti/ie' heeinaIo<e
Dho Das assaulte', Iattee', an' suIKecte' to e0cessi<e /oce un'e the colo o/
go<en$ental authoit& esulting in 42 ).S.C. E 198" Violation o/ *lainti//Ls
constitutional ights guaantee' to hi$ I& the )nite' States o/ -$eica an' the
State o/ Ne<a'a to Dit1 <iolation o/ 6outh -$en'$ent ights an' totious act o/
Iatte& on *lainti//.
Coughlin ealiCes this Co$%laint nee's a geat 'eal o/ DoJ. +he esult o/
Ieing Dong/ull& aeste' nineteen $oe ti$es since the 8F2.F11 aest at issue in
this Co$%laint has i$%e'e' CoughlinBs aIilit& to secue a%%o%iate counsel an'
%usue this $atte1
". Venue is %o%e in this, the nothen 5istict o/ Ne<a'a Iecause the
'e/en'ant is suIKect to %esonal Kuis'iction hee an' the clai$s aose hee C,?ES
N,=, *lainti// aIo<e na$e', /o the ti$e Ieing sel/ e%esenting, Z-C7-R8
B-R9ER C,):7;4N, Esq., an' /o cause o/ action against 5e/en'ants, an' each
o/ the$, alleges, a<es, an' co$%lains as /olloDs1
- 5F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
CAUSES OF ACTION
Since %lainti// 'i' not a%%eal /o$ the Ku'g$ent un'el&ing the Daant e0ecute'
I& the $ashal, %lainti// cannot noD collateall& attacJ the Daant. -n', noDhee
in his %a%es 'oes %lainti// 'e$onstate I& e<i'entia& /acts that the Daant Das
iegula, unauthoiCe' o <oi', o, that eithe 'e/en'ant %atici%ate' in the e<iction
o 'i' an&thing to cause 'a$age to an& %o%et& o/ %lainti// in the couse o/ o as a
consequence o/ the e<iction. #5a&s < 7all, 27 N8S2' 2"8.( M
4oio <. Cit& o/ NeD 8oJ et al., 92 ?isc.25 955, 41. N.8.S.25 195 #1978(.
Cetain& CoughlinBs 2F11F12 e$ail to =CS, Su%e<iso ;iC Stuchell in es%onse to
StuchellBs 2F7F12 e$ail to Coughlin, Dhich eithe the R?C an' 9ing o Ioth
e0cise' /o$ the 4F12F12 ME0hiIit 9N %esentation o/ an altered e%o'uction
theeo/ #Dhile the %age 12 o/ 4. $issing /o$ the /ist a%%eaance o/ such "F5F12
?otion 'i' a%%ea...the /a0 hea'e /o all %ages Das e0cise', $aJing less
noticeaIle the e0cision o/ StuchellBs 2F7F12 e$ail #ie, not %ae "8 o/ 4....he&, DheeBs
%age "9 o/ 4. as %aginate' in the /a0 hea'e $o$ent /o the Sceening *anel, I&
'esign...$aJing @u'ge =. :a'neBs "F2.F12 M,'e !1N at E0hiIit 1. in such 2"
E0hiIit *esentation quite 'uIious #es%eciall& Dhee the %age 12 #in te$s o/ the
%agination on CoughlnBs "F5F12 ?otion at the Iotto$ cente o/ each %age( an'
M%age "9 o/ 4.N #in te$s o/ the /a0 hea'e theein( s%eaJ <olu$es to eIut @u'ge
=. :a'neBs contention that CoughlinBs $otion MlacJs $eit( negates the /olloDing
authoit&, as 'oes his 2F22F12 e$ail to the R@C an' Stuchell as Dell1 O...- %at& at
Dhose instance a Daant is 'ul& issue' is not es%onsiIle /o the $anne in Dhich a
Shei// o $ashal e0ecutes the Daant. +he Shei// o $ashal onl& Ieco$es an
agent i/ the Daant is iegula, unauthoiCe' o <oi'. #4'e < 6inn, 192 -%% 5i<
".4A +eiIe < ?ouiocout, 14" ?isc 741, 742.(
+he %at& %ocuing issuance o/ the Daant con/es onl& an i$%lie'
authoit& consistent Dith that con/ee' theeI&, an', is not liaIle /o a trespass
committed by the officer unless he authoiCe' it. #4'e < 6inn, su%a, % "14, citing
=elsh < Cochan, 2" N8 181A see 5inJhouse < *aJa, " N82' 82, 91A 6ults <
?uno, 2.2 N8 "4, 42A Schie < Sha//e, 12" -%% 5i< 54"A Bach < NeD, 2" -%%
5i< 548A 9o$an < ?ac& P Co., 142 N8S2' 455A ;iIet& 4n'. *aJ < *otecti<e
*acJaging Co%., 71 ?isc 2' 112, 119A *ollacJ < ?aco$Is 4nDoo' Co%., 52 ?isc
2' 52".(
Since %lainti// 'i' not a%%eal /o$ the Ku'g$ent un'el&ing the Daant
e0ecute' I& the $ashal, %lainti// cannot noD collateall& attacJ the Daant. -n',
noDhee in his %a%es 'oes %lainti// 'e$onstate I& e<i'entia& /acts that the
Daant Das iegula, unauthoiCe' o <oi', o, that eithe 'e/en'ant %atici%ate' in
the e<iction o 'i' an&thing to cause 'a$age to an& %o%et& o/ %lainti// in the
couse o/ o as a consequence o/ the e<iction. #5a&s < 7all, 27 N8S2' 2"8.( ...O -
co$$ecial tenant /aile' to o<eco$e the %esu$%tion o/ egulait&, as equie' to
su%%ot a clai$ against the $ashal Dho e//ectuate' an e<iction Dith a <acate'
- 2F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Daant, aIsent a shoDing that the $ashal ha' JnoDingl& o negligentl& e0ecute'
an in<ali' Daant. Ro'igueC <. 1414H1422 ,g'en -<enue Realt& Co%., ".4
-.5.25 4.., 758 N.8.S.25 4" #1st 5e%Bt 2.."(. 57 -$ @u 2', ?unici%al, School,
an' State +ot ;iaIilit& E 89A 7. -$ @u 2', Shei//s, *olice, an' ConstaIles E 29,
=hee the con'ition o/ a $ashalBs Ion' is that the $ashal hi$sel/ o
hesel/, an' his o he 'e%uties, $ust /aith/ull& %e/o$ all the 'uties o/ the o//ice, a
$ashal is liaIle in 'a$ages on his o he Ion' /o an assault co$$itte' I& his o
he 'e%ut& in e0ecuting a Dit o/ e%le<in. *al$e <. 9ing, 41 -%%. 5.C. 419,
;.R.-. 19125, 278, -$. -nn. Cas. 1915C, 11"9 #-%%. 5.C. 1914(.
As to th+ /CSO 5ailin2 to s+!6i+ p!o+ss tim+l7 on /LS in %'*',:
N+2l+t o! 5ail4!+ to +8+4t+ !+24la! l+2al p!o+ss is an o55iial #+5a4lt 5o!
whih th+ s4!+ti+s o5 a sh+!i55 o! onsta"l+ a!+ lia"l+. *a%%e <. ;aD, 19"4 ,9
427, 129 ,Jla. 15, "5 *.25 941, 95 -.;.R. 9"9 #19"4(. - laD en/oce$ent o//ice
Dho le<ies e0ecution on %o%et& oDne' I& a %eson othe than the Ku'g$ent
'eIto na$e' in the Dit $a& Ie hel' es%onsiIle /o the 'a$ages su//ee' I& that
innocent thi' %eson as a consequence o/ the Dong/ul le<&. Bethel <. 5uni%ace,
57 ,hio -%%. "5 89, 522 N.E.25 1252 #"' 5ist. 7ancocJ Count& 1988(. -s to
%esons liaIle on Ion's in'e$ni/&ing those liaIle /o Dong/ul e0ecutions,
geneall&, see -$. @u. 25, E0ecutions an' En/oce$ent o/ @u'g$ents E 2.8. -$.
@u. 25 Shei//Bs E 24. @usti/ication un'e DitA Dit egula on /ace - shei//,
constaIle, o othe such o//ice $a& Kusti/& his o he acts I& shoDing that in
%e/o$ing the$ he o she acte' %usuant to the co$$an' o/ a Dit egula u%on its
/ace an' issue' I& a cout o/ co$%etent Kuis'iction,Q6N1R e<en i/ the Ku'g$ent o
o'e Das eoneousl& issue'Q6N2R o otheDise <oi'.Q6N"R +he co$$onHlaD ule
$a& Ie co'i/ie' I& statute.Q 6N4R - %eace o//ice is si$ilal& %otecte' an'
Kusti/ie' in e0ecuting %ocess /ai on its /ace, Dhee he o she is suIsequentl&
- 7F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
chage' Dith /alse aest o i$%ison$ent. #N,+E1 the thing is, es%eciall& in
Re<2.12H..1.48 an' Re<2.12H..."74, the =CS, tansgesse' the e0%esss
'ictates on such stan'a' locJout o'es /o$ the R@C Dhich $eel& co%& an' %ast
the language /o$ NRS 4..25"#5(#a( theein, an' Dhile the =CS, $a& ha<e so$e
agu$ent that 7illBs associate BaJe $isle' the$ in his cae/ull& e0cising the
MDithin 24 hous o/ ecei%tN language /o$ the 1.F27F11 6,6C,;,SE he Das aIle
to get @u'ge S/eaCCa to sign, aguaIl&, the =CS, Ci<il 5i<ision 'oes such DoJ
'a& in 'a& out, an' JneD, o shoul' JnoD that it Das <iolating Ne<a'a laD in
ca&ing out su$$a& e<iction o'es in the $anne in Dhich it has Ieen.
Cetainl&, =CS, Ci<il 5i<ision Su%e<iso ;iC Stuchell Das a%%ise' o/ such
equie$ent that a tenant ha<e M24 housN /o$ the tenantBs ecei%t o/ such a
locJout o'e Ie/oe an& such locJout $a& occu I& Da& o/ CoughlinBs 2F11F12
Ditten coes%on'ence to Stuchell an' othes, an' Ie&on' that, CoughlinsB 2F22F12
lette to Stuchell cetainl& $aJes the aest o/ Coughlin I& =CS, 5e%ut& ?achen
on 2F28F12 es%eciall& cul%aIle(. Q6N5R Q6N1R ?aJs <. Shou%, 181 ).S. 522, 21 S.
Ct. 724, 45 ;. E'. 1..2, 1 -lasJa 6e'. 7.2 #19.1(A @e//es <. Count&si'e 7o$es o/
;incoln, 4nc., 214 NeI. 1.4, """ N.=.25 754 #198"(. Q6N2R +e''&Bs 5i<e 4n, 4nc.
V. Cohen, 47 N.8.25 79, 412 N.8.S.25 782, "9. N.E.25 29. #1979(. Q6N"R
ReinecJe <. Sheeh&, 47 ?ich. -%%. 25., 2.9 N.=.25 42. #197"(. Q6N4R BotheBs
5istiIuting Co., 4nc. V. 7ei't$an, "54 6. Su%%. 2." #S.5. 6la. 197"(, -//B', 48.
6.25 922 #5th Ci. 197"( #Statute setting /oth the 'ut& o/ a shei// to le<& u%on
%o%et& 'esciIe' in a Dit $a& s%eci/icall& gant i$$unit& /o$ suit to shei//s
- 8F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
le<&ing attach$ent on the %o%et&(. Q6N5R See, geneall&, -$. @u. 25, 6alse
4$%ison$ent. 7oDe<e, %aticulal& Dhee the locJout o'es o/ "F15F12 an'
2F27F12 in'icate 24 hous /o$ the tenantBs ecei%t o/ such o'es $ust %ass #an'
the locJout o/ 11F1F11 aguaIl& is suIKect to constucti<e notice o/ such
equie$ent gi<en the uIiquit& o/ NRS 4..25" +o Dhat the Ci<il 5i<ision o/ the
=CS, 'oes 'a& in 'a& out(, the aIo<e authoit& is una<ailing
4nteestingl&, that sa$e Oecei%tO conce%t Ieca$e e0cee'ingl& ele<ant
inci'ent to the =ashoe Count& Shei//Bs ,//ice nu$eous Iuglaies o/ CoughlinBs
/o$e ho$e laD o//ices an' entals #see Re<2.11H..17.8, Re<2.12H..."74,
Re<2.12H ..1.48, RCR2.12H.2798., R?C 12 CR 1242., etc( gi<en the ODithin
24 hous o/ ecei%t o/ the o'eO language in NRS 4..25"#5(#a( Dith es%ect to hoD
su$$a& e<iction locJouts ae to Ie caie' out in the conte0t o/ a su$$a&
e$o<al o'e Dithin a su$$a& e<iction case. *eha%s not so su%isingl&, 2@5C
@u'ge ;. :a'neBs Iothe R?C @u'ge =. :a'ne, 'i' not /in' CoughlinBs
agu$ents co$%elling in the ci$inal tes%ass case against Coughlin #see 219.1
SCR 111#4( *etition in N. S. Ct( inci'ent to o%%osing counsel in CV11H."228
IuglaiCing Coughlin /o$e ho$e laD o//ice Dith the =CS, in toD on 11F1F11,
an' again, Iut Dith the R*5 along /o the /un, on 11F1"F11 #not to $ention the
si$ila Iuglaies I& the =CS,, liJe that o/ "F15F12 #Kust an hou Ie/oe the <e&
21". %.$., heaing Ie/oe NVB @u'ge Beesle& in NVBH1.H.51.4, Ca'le Co. <.
9elle that @u'ge Beesle& testi/ie' Dith ega' to 'uing the 11F14F12 /o$al
- 9F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
'isci%lina& $atte /o$ Dhich the %o%osal to %e$anentl& 'isIa Coughlin is noD
on a%%eal in 22""7 Ie/oe the Ne<a'a Su%e$e Cout(, an' that o/ 2F28F12 inci'ent
to the /au'ulentl& oItaine' an' %atentl& in<ali' su$$a& e<iction o'e in R@C
Re<2.12H..1.48, at Dhich ti$e the =CS, /uthe <iolate' Sol'al <. CooJ Count&,
5.2 )S 52 #1992(, in Dong/ull& aesting Coughlin in RCR2.12S.2798.(
Russell <. 9alian, 414 -.25 422A 4oio < Cit& o/ NeD 8oJ, 92 ?isc.25 955.
?a&es <. )V4 7ol'ings, 72" N.8.S.2' 151, 28. -.5.2' 15" #2..1(. n' the R@CBs
/ailue to e<en $o<e to >uash CoughlinBs suI%oenaing eco's elate' to the /a0
logs an' con/i$ation o/ tans$ission o ecei%t inci'ent to the R@CBs Ousual
custo$ an' %acticeO o/ /a0ing e<iction ,'es to the =CS, /o se<ice #liJe those
in the Richa' 7illFCase& BaJe Su$$a& E<iction O+ialO in<ol<ing CoughlinBs
/o$e ho$e laD o//ice, an' the ODithin 24 hous o/ ecei%tO language /oun' Dithin
NRS 4..25" #the ,'e is <oi' o in<ali' a/te that %oint, in Dhich case, it Doul'
$ean 7ill an' o BaJe Dee the tes%asses, not Coughlin, ega'less, its
ina%%o%iate /o R?C cout a%%ointe' 'e/en'e ;oo$is to categoicall& e/use to
asset an& clai$ o/ ight 'e/ense that such a ci$inal tes%ass 'e/en'ant $a& Dish
to asset /o, sa&, Richa' 7ill a'$its to chaging the sa$e ent un'e a Ostoage o/
%esonal %o%et&O that Das %e<iousl& chage' /o O/ull use an' occu%anc&O.
Nonetheless, %osting an E<iction ,'e that 'oes not contain sta& aDa& language
#$uch less the /act that is 'oes not ha<e the equie' ODithin 24 housO language
calle' /o I& the statute( is not tanta$ount to %osting a no tes%assing sign, /uthe,
- 1.F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
7aClettHSte<ens $aJing agu$ents in his closing as to $attes not in e<i'ence
#allegations o/ li<ing in the esi'ence( i
/ailue to a%%l& the e0clusiona& ule to Me<i'enceN #'es%ite Coughlin ha<ing
a ecei%t #Dhich Das Ieing Dithhel' I& o%%osing counsel 7illBs /i$ in the
su$$a& e<iction an' a%%eal theeo/ in Re<2.11H..17.8 an' CV11H."228
inci'ent to 7ill, his associate Case& 5. BaJe, Esq., an' the =CS,Bs 5e%ut&
?achen, an' R*5 ,//ice Chis Cate, @. an' Sagent ?acia ;o%eC all
IuglaiCing CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice in No<e$Ie 2.11, along Dith the
e0cu%lato& still i$ages an' <i'eo /o$ =alH?at %o<ing that Coughlin %o<i'e'
his 'i<eBs license to the RS4C tiIal %olice o//ices, an' theeI& <itiating the
/au'ulent clai$s $a'e I& Reno Cit& -ttone& *a$ela :. RoIets, Esq., that so$e
a%%lication o/ NRS 171.1771, Dhich, ega'less, ha'l& o%eates to 'e/eat the
%ohiIition against such 9F9F11 aest %esente' in NRS 171.1"2 an' es%eciall&
NRS 171.1255 an&Da&s... ( %o<ing he %uchase' the <e& 5uact Cough ?elts
/oun' in his %ocJet, theeI& $aJing an 'esignation o/ a such as M/uitN o/ a
%oisonous tee athe ina%t( Dhee Ioth NRS 171.1255 an' NRS 171.1"2 Dee
<iolate', thee/oe $aJing such aests an' seaches inci'ent theeto illegal aests
equiing a%%lication o/ the e0clusiona& ule(, %osecutoial $ison#4t # 5e%ut&
Reno Cit& -ttone& *a$ela RoIets, Esq., %ut on testi$on& she JneD to Ie lies
gi<en the <e& <i'eo %o<i'e' to he I& =al$at an' o RS4C *olice cleal& shoD
Coughlin %o<i'ing his 'i<eBs license to ,//ice CaD/o'(, Ditness $ison#4t
- 11F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
#nu$eous instances o/ %eKu& I& Ioth =al$atBs 6ontino an' ,//ice 9a$eon
CaD/o'(, an' a to %e se in'igent un'e 2..8 4n'igent 5e/ense ,'e, aIuse o/
ont+mpt %oDe, <iolation o/ *engill& an' ?cCo$acJ, /ailue to gant a
continuance Dhee e0cu%lato& e<i'ence Das Ieing Dong/ull& Dithhel' I& an'
o%%osing counsel Dho$ ha' IuglaiCe' CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice Dith
Ioth the =CS, an' R*5 #NRS 4..25"#5(, Russell <. 9alian, 414 -.25 422A 4oio
< Cit& o/ NeD 8oJ, 92 ?isc.25 955. ?a&es <. )V4 7ol'ings, 72" N.8.S.2' 151,
28. -.5.2' 15" #2..1(., an' 'enial o/ a continuance to Coughlin #'es%ite one
Ieing agee' to in Diting I& RC- RoIets( is %aticulal& sus%ect gi<en the /ailue,
then, to acco' CoughlinBs ight to a s%ee'& tial #Dhich he 'i' not Dai<e( Dhee
Coughlin, Dho$ Iaile' out on 9F1.F11 Das not a//o'e' a tial Dithin 45 'a&s as an
out o/ custo'& 'e/enant, an' Dhee the RS4C e/use' to elease to Coughlin e<en
the -est Re%ot an' *oIaIle Cause Sheet until a/te the 1.F1.F11 aaign$ent,
Dheein R?C @u'ge =. :a'ne e/use' to e<eal to Coughlin, then a license'
%acticing attone&, the na$es o/ the /ou %ossiIle cout a%%ointe' 'e/ense counsel
su//icient /o Coughlin to %e/o$ a con/lict checJ %io to ageeing to such
con/i'ential in/o$ation Ieing elease' to Dhiche<e allege'l& an'o$l& assigne'
cout a%%ointe' counsel Doul' get such #an' it $a& Ie laD o/ the case that
CoughlinBs ight to such counsel Das ecogniCe' at such ti$e, $aJing @u'ge
7oDa'Bs suIsequent ,ctoIe 27
th
, 2.11 'enial o/ -igesinge an' the Si0th
-$en'$ent e<en $oe sus%ect(.
- 12F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
#M+his action Das Iought against all thee 'e/en'ants, alleging
negligence HH against Cit& ?ashal Richa' ?. SchDatC, /o 'a$age to
%lainti// tenantLs %esonal %o%et& in the couse o/ an e<ictionA against
+uscan& 7ol'ing Co%., Iecause as lan'lo' it hie' the $ashal to %e/o$
the e<ictionA an', against the Cit& o/ NeD 8oJ, on the theo& that the
$ashal acte' as agent, se<ant an'Fo e$%lo&ee o/ the Cit& o/ NeD 8oJ.
B& an ealie o'e o/ this cout, the co$%laint against the $ashal Das
'is$isse' /o lacJ o/ Kuis'iction.
M- %at& at Dhose instance a Daant is 'ul& issue' is not es%onsiIle /o the
$anne in Dhich a Shei// o $ashal e0ecutes the Daant. +he Shei// o $ashal
onl& Ieco$es an agent i/ the Daant is iegula, unauthoiCe' o <oi'. #4'e < 6inn,
192 -%% 5i< ".4A +eiIe < ?ouiocout, 14" ?isc 741, 742.( +he %at& %ocuing
issuance o/ the Daant con/es onl& an i$%lie' authoit& consistent Dith that
con/ee' theeI&, an', is not liaIle /o a tes%ass co$$itte' I& the o//ice unless
he authoiCe' it. #4'e < 6inn, su%a, % "14, citing =elsh < Cochan, 2" N8 181A see
5inJhouse < *aJa, " N82' 82, 91A 6ults < ?uno, 2.2 N8 "4, 42A Schie <
Sha//e, 12" -%% 5i< 54"A Bach < NeD, 2" -%% 5i< 548A 9o$an < ?ac& P Co.,
142 N8S2' 455A ;iIet& 4n'. *aJ < *otecti<e *acJaging Co%., 71 ?isc 2' 112,
119A *ollacJ < ?aco$Is 4nDoo' Co%., 52 ?isc 2' 52".(
#7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*age 2"518 to 2"5117( sustaine' the oIKection. ?R.
C,):7;4N1 4B' liJe to %la& a co%& o/ a <i'eo 4 tooJ o/ Segeant ;o%eC a'$itting
cetain things Dith es%ect to the ci$inal tes%ass. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 ?.
9ingT ?R. 94N:1 4 Doul' oIKect to the e0tent that ?. Coughlin is t&ing to
suggest in an& Da& that he DasnBt guilt& o/ the ci$inal tes%ass, Iecause he Das
con<icte' an' e0hauste' his a%%eal ights. -n' to et& that 4 thinJ shoul'nBt occu
- 1"F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
hee....7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*ages 2215 to 24121( B8 ?R. C,):7;4N1 > =ho
se<e' the e<iction notice HH no. 7oD 'i' the e<iction notice get /o$ the Kustice
cout to the shei//BsT ?R. 94N:1 ,IKection. Be&on' the sco%e o/ 'iect, an'
iele<ant. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 ?. Coughlin, 4B$ going to sustain. ;etBs a''ess
the issues HH ?R. C,):7;4N1 Can 4 $aJe an o//e o/ %oo/T ?R.
EC7EVERR4-1 HH this %anel has Ieen asJe' to looJ at. +he issue as to Dhethe o
not &ou Dee %o%el& in that esi'ence Iuil'ing, the issue as to Dhethe &ou Dee
tes%assing has all Ieen litigate'. +hatBs not the /unction o/ this %anel. +his %anel is
to 'ete$ine, I& su%e$e cout o'e, Dhat, i/ an&, %unish$ent &ou shoul' Ie
suIKect to. 4B' liJe &ou to /ocus on that issue. *lease %ocee'. ?R. C,):7;4N1
=hethe the %unish$ent un'e ClaiIone is Iin'ing authoit& u%on &ou entails
$oe than a cuso&, ecei<ing a ceti/ie' con<iction in the $ail /o$ a cleJ o/
cout, an' not un'etaJing an& 'iligent inqui& in that ega'. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1
8ouBe /ocusing on so$e <e& $ino 'etails as to Dho sai' Dhat at the ti$e HH 'o
&ou a'$it &ou Dee Iehin' the Iaica'e' 'ooT ?R. C,):7;4N1 4 Doul' liJe to
$aJe an o//e o/ %oo/, &ou 7ono. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 *lease 'o so. 4Bll gi<e
&ou tDo $inutes. ?R. C,):7;4N1 7a<e &ou ea' an&thing 4 /ile' in this caseT
?R. EC7EVERR4-1 4B<e ea' quite a Iit o/ it. 4B$ not sue it hel%s &ou. ?R.
C,):7;4N1 4/ that o'e Das stale, itBs ?. 7ill HH ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 =hatBs
the o//e o/ %oo/T ?R. C,):7;4N1 4tBs that i/ 4 can 'e$onstate that that o'e
Das stale, it Doul' Ie ?. 7ill Dho Das tes%assing, not $e. -n' that entails
/in'ing out HH an' the shei// has Ieen <e& unhel%/ul in this ega'. -n' ?. 7ill
- 14F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an' his associate testi/ie', %eha%s to thei 'eti$ent, that the tes%ass tial as to
Dhen that locJout o'e Das HH ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 =hatBs the o//e o/ %oo/T
8ouBe testi/&ing. +ell $e Dhat the %oo/ is. ?R. C,):7;4N1 +he i$%otant
thing is the laD in Ne<a'a sa&s Dithin 24 hous o/ the shei// ecei<ing that e<iction
o'e the&B<e got to 'o the locJout. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 +hatBs all Ieen litigate',
hasnBt itT 5i'nBt &ou aise these issues IeloDT ?R. C,):7;4N1 4n Dhich
conte0tT ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 4n the tes%ass con<iction. ?R. C,):7;4N1 8es.
?R. EC7EVERR4-1 ,Ja&. ;etBs /ocus on the issues hee, Dhich, as 4 un'estan'
it, ae to /ocus on Dhat, i/ an&, %unish$ent &ou shoul' Ie suIKect to Dith es%ect to
HH ?R. C,):7;4N1 =hatBs all this li<ing in the Iase$ent stu// ha<e to 'o Dith
thatT @esus. +his is Richa' 7ill in a nutshell. *eKu'icial nonsense. 7easa&.
Chaacte assassination. -n' then &ou t& to eIut it, an' this is not the issue, itBs
not ele<ant. Nothing he sa&s is ele<ant. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 4 'i'nBt sa& that. 4t
is ele<ant. 8ou con<iction is ele<ant. 8ouBe t&ing to elitigate HH ?R.
C,):7;4N1 7eBs talJing aIout sli%%es HHN(
#N,+E1 Dhile Ioth the RC- %osecuto 7aClettHSte<ens an' 7ill
continuousl& allege' Coughlin Das aeste' on 11F1"F11 /o ci$inal tes%ass at his
/o$e ho$e laD o//ice in his M%aKa$asN Deaing Msli%%esN the <e& <i'eos o/ such
aest /il$e' I& 7ill an' his lan'lo' neuologist client, ?eliss, e<eal such
allegations to Ie co$%lete an' utte lies. Coughlin is seen in such Deaing sDeat
%ants an' a teeHshit. Vi'eos taJen o/ Coughlin at scene an' ti$e o/ 11F1"F11
- 15F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
custo'ial aest /o tes%assing in R?C 11 CR 224.5 I& 7ill an' his client ?eliss
'e$onstating 7ill an' 7aClettHSte<ens l&ing aIout M%aKa$asN an' Msli%%esN #note
to $ention hoD iele<ant an' %eKucial allusions to such ae, in <iolatino o/ R*C
".5 an' 4.4( htt%1FFDDD.&outuIe.co$FDatchT<UEh20&cH9cg. (
4t is ionic, that 7ill an' BaJeBs oDn Diting in thei No<e$Ie 21st, 2.11
,%%osition to CoughlinBs No<e$Ie 12th, 2.11 ?otion to Contest *esonal
*o%et& lien $a& noD Ie use' against the$, in light o/ the staleness, <oi'ness, an'
in<ali'it& o/ the ,ctoIe 25th, 2.11 an' ,ctoIe 27th, 2.11 E<iction 5ecision an'
,'e an' 6in'ings o/ 6act, Conclusions o/ ;aD an' ,'e /o Su$$a& E<iction
in R@C Re<2.11H..17.8. See =illia$s < Nagel, 24" N.E. 2' 812 an' =ol/H;illie,
5.4 6. Su%% 1. BaJe Dote on 7illBs Iehal/1
O7ee, Coughlin /ile' his /ist $otion %usuant to NRS 118-H
42. on No<e$Ie 12,2.11. +hat $otion Das ti$el&. 7oDe<e,
Dhen the cout atte$%te' to set the heaing, Coughlin e/use' to
coo%eate o co$$unicate Dith the cout to get the heaing on
calen'a, 'es%ite e%eate' equests /o$ ?elissB counsel that he
'o so. -s a sole an' 'iect esult o/ ?. CoughlinBs e/usal to
coo%eate Dith the cout to set his oDn heaing, that heaing
ne<e ha%%ene'. +he 1. 'a&s in Dhich to hol' the heaing un'e
NRS 4..25"#8( ha<e noD e0%ie'. ?. CoughlinBs $otion is
stale, an' the elie/ he seeJs is noD ti$eHIae'. Because he
aIan'one' that $otion, it Das, e//ecti<el&, 'enie'.O
+o BaJeBs No<e$Ie 21st, 2.11 ,%%osition #hoD cle<e, BaJe Dites it so he
can $aJe ecJless allegations that aenBt tue in it that 7ill Doul' not Ie so /ee to
$aJe, gi<en he Das thee 'uing the No<e$Ie 12th, 2.11 aest(, is attache' the
signe', sDon, No<e$Ie 21st, 2.11 5eclaation o/ Richa' 7ill, Dhich e<eals at
the least an intent to $islea' the tiIunal I& 7ill, an' also e<eals 7ill an' ?eliss
contiIute' to a /alse aest to a $ateial e0tent. +hat 5eclaation ea's1
O4. ,n ,ctoIe 27, 2.11, this cout signe' a su$$a& e<iction o'e, an' on
No<e$Ie 1, 2.11, the =ashoe Count& Shei//s 5e%at$ent se<e' that o'e. +he
- 12F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
notice Das %oste' on the 'oo o/ the ho$e I& the =ashoe Count& Shei//s
5e%at$ent in the $anne custo$a& in =ashoe Count& /o e<ictions. +he locJs on
the /ont 'oo an' IacJ 'oo Dee change', an' De etaine' all Je&s to the ho$e.
5. -/te that 'ate, 4 Iegan to notice that it looJe' liJe so$eIo'& ha' Ieen
getting into the ho$e. ,n a%%o0i$atel& No<e$Ie 4,2.11, 4 Ieca$e concene'
aIout the
ho$e an' its contents. 4 entee' it an' Das aIle to con/i$ that Oso$eIo'&O ha'
Ieen getting in. 4 thought 4 ha' secue' the $eans o/ ent& Ieing use' I& Dhoe<e it
Das that
Das getting in. 7oDe<e, on late <isits to the ho$e, it Das clea that the ho$e Das
still
Ieing sue%titiousl& accesse'.
2. ,n No<e$Ie 1", 2.11, 5. ?eliss ca$e to Reno Iecause he Dante' to
ins%ect the ho$e. )%on ent&, it Das clea that so$eIo'& ha' again accesse' the
ho$e.
7. =e tie' to ente the Iase$ent an' /oun' the 'oo Das Iaica'e', not locJe',
/o$ the insi'e. =e Dee concene' that Dhoe<e ha' Ieen accessing the ho$e Das
insi'e, so De calle' the %olice.
8. =hen the %olice ai<e', the& agee' Dith us that it Das <e& liJel& that
so$eIo'& Das Iaica'e' in the Iase$ent. +he %olice tie' to coa0 the %eson to
co$e out, Iut Dithout success.
9. =hen the %olice 'ecline' to IeaJ 'oDn the 'oo, 5. ?eliss 'i' so. +he %olice
looJe' insi'e an' 'isco<ee' the 'e/en'ant, Zacha& Coughlin, an' his 'og.
1.. Coughlin ca$e out %eace/ull&, Dent u%stais an' Das %lace' un'e aest
I& the %olice /o tes%assing.
11. -/te Coughlin Das taJen to Kail, 5. ?e7ss an' 4 tie' to <i'eota%e the
contents o/ the Iase$ent Dhee Coughlin ha' Ieen hi'ing. 4t Das too 'aJ to
e//ecti<el& <i'eota%e, Iut De Dee aIle to ascetain that Coughlin an' his 'og ha<e
Ieen li<ing in th
Iase$ent o/the ho$e /o quite so$e ti$e, liJel& e<en Ie/oe the locJout. 4
oIse<e' that Coughlin ha' a Ie' set u%. 7e ha' se<eal co$%ute $onitos. 7e
ha' a stoe o/hoth /oo'
an' Date. 7e ha' electic s%ace heates.
12. Since the e<iction o'e Das se<e', $& associate, ?. BaJe, an' 4 ha' sent
nu$eous e$ails to Coughlin, in Dhich De Ioth e%eate'l& $a'e it clea to hi$ that
he Das not to Ie at the Ione Dithout ou %io %e$ission. No such %e$ission Das
gi<en.
?. Coughlin ha' no eason to %ossiIl& thinJ he Das %e$itte' on the %o%et&. =e
ha'
tie' to coa0 hi$ to coo%eate on getting his %ossessions >ut, Dithout success, o
e<en a es%onse.
1". -s a esult o/?. CoughlinBs IeaJHins, 5. ?eliss has incue' a Iill o/ V1,.2.
Dith a license' contacto to secue the %e$ises. +hat 'oes not inclu'e the cost o/
- 17F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the 'oo that Das IoJen in o'e to get Coughlin out. +hat 'oes not inclu'e the
nu$eous hous o/ $e an' $& sta// to 'eal DitI ?. CoughlinBs e%eate' IeaJHins
at the ho$e.
14. 4 a$ no e0%et, Iut 4 Ielie<e ?. Coughlin is DIat is calle' a Ohoa'e.O
7e has $an& ca seats thoughout the house. 7e has $an& 'ea' tele<isions. 7e has
a Io0 o/ ca Din'oD se<o $otos. +he attic, Dhich can onl& Ie accesse' though a
<e& naoD
o%ening, is /ull o/ ite$s, inclu'ing 'ea' electonic 'e<ices.
15. =e ha<e /oun' 'ugs at the ho$e. =e /oun' a Iag o/ Dhat looJs liJe
$aiKuana on the Jitchen counte. 4 /oun' a cacJ %i%e. +he contacto /oun' Dhat
he sai'
Das a lage quantit& o/ %ills.
12. ?. Coughlin has Ieen haassing an' stalJing $e, an' %ossiIl&, $& sta//.
,n No&e$Ie 15, 2.11, he Iust into $& o//ice an' ceate' a scene. +hen, he Das
%aa'ing u% an' 'oDn the si'eDalJ acoss the steet Dith a <i'eo ca$ea scea$ing
oIscenities at
$e an' $& sta//.O
NoD, i/ one ea's that 5eclaation I& 7ill, then Datches the <i'eos 7ill tooJ
o/ the $o$ents Ie/oe, 'uing, an' a/te CoughlinBs aest /o ci$inal tes%ass on
No<e$Ie 1"th, 2.11...Dell, one $ust conclu'e 7ill an' ?eliss lie', an' IoJe
the laD, esulting in %o/oun' e%utational 'a$age to Coughlin an' <ast 'a$age to
his /a$il& an' caee. +he& shoul' 'o ti$e /o this, %eio'. =hee, in that
5eclaation, so soon a/te the aest it is al$ost an Oe0cite' utteanceO is Susich o
9ings allegation o/ OIeaJing an' enteingO an' the OlocJs Ieing IoJenOT =h&
Doul'nBt 7ill Kust sa& that in the 5eclaation i/ it Das tueT =hee is the <i'eo o/
the Iase$ent that 7ill $entions atte$%ting to taJe. +hee DasnBt one %o<i'e' in
the $ateials 7ill ga<e to the cit& attone&, Dhich Dee 'isco<ee' to Coughlin.
=h& 'oesnBt 7ill coect his client Dhen he lies, in /ont o/ the %olice, Kust Ie/oe
the han'cu//ing $o$ent, in es%onse to CoughlinBs que& as to Dho e0actl&, in
an&one, ha' tol' Coughlin to lea<e, o issue' a ODaningO. +hat Iase$ent Das
/i0e' u% to Ie, Iasicall&, a stu'io a%at$ent a''ition to the $ain /loo /o o<e a
&ea Ie/oe the e<iction, an' 7ill a'$its this a%%eas to Ie the case in anothe
/iling. 7ill $islea's the cout aIo<e Dhee he /ails to $ention the nu$eous ti$es
Coughlin in'icate' he ha' a''e' 74ll to his OIlocJe' sen'es listO an' o in'icate'
he 'i' not consent to an& /o$ o/ electonic se<ice o notice o/ an&thing, an'
Dhee BaJe Das on <acation in eal& No<e$Ie. +he <i'eoBs 7ill tooJ title ZachBs
aest ...7H..14, /oun' at the aIo<e linJ, shoD %aticulal& Dell the /au' an'
ci$inal con'uct I& ?eliss an' 74ll inclu'ing l&ing to e//ectuate a /alse aest an'
ci$inal tes%ass an' in<asion o/ %i<ac&.
=hat is actuall& stali', in<ali', <oi', null, e0%ie', o otheDise ine//ecti<e is
the ,ctoIe 25th an' 27th Su$$a& E<iction ,'es I& @u'ge S/eaCCa in light o/
- 18F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the =CS,Bs a'$ission that on No<e$Ie 1st, 2.11 #allege'l& at 41". %$(, 5e%ut&
?achen IoJe into CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice Dith 7ill o BaJe in toD
#an' %oIaIl& one o/ those laD&es legal assistantF<i'eoga%hes Dho$ 'i<e a neD
?ece'es S;H2.. con<etiIle cou%....the Jin' Dith a VH12 engine...thatBs ight, a VH
12, V1".,... neD, thee ti$es the engine /oun' in CoughlinBs /ou Iange 1992
7on'a -cco' ;G #at least its not a 5G, ightT( Dith 11.,... $iles on it(1
-ll the case cite' IeloD ae ele<ant, an' $ost ae teiIle, /o 7ill, BaJe an'
?eliss, in a''ition to $aJing the ci$inal tes%ass con<iction e0te$el& sus%ect1
4oio, 41. N8S 2' 195
Russell < 9alian, 414 -.2' 422
Buha$s, 89 *."' 229
RosDicJ, 2"1 BR 841
7a$$on', 515 SE 2' 182
-lIet, 49. N8S 2' 951
224.5 an' ."228 tes%ass case1
actually exposes the Nev. Const. Art. 4 Sec 21 violations that the judiciary
in Washoe County and eno have been countenancin! in doin! much more than
turnin! a blind eye to the state sponsored bur!laries by the Washoe County
Sheriff"s #ffice in failin! to accord tenants the $24 hours from% the tenant"s
$receipt of the% &summary removal' $order% prior to the WCS# conductin! a
loc(out incident to a summary eviction) *here pa!e 1+ thereof &*hich) a!ain)
*as excised by either the ,C in providin! such to the S-N) or by the S-N) but
clearly not by Cou!hlin in faxin! such to the ,C as the fax headers and
pa!ination therein tell the tale and loc( the S-N and ,C in a fin!er pointin!
contest *here such excised pa!e 1+ reads1
M+his Dhole Iusiness aIout M+he cout $a& theeu%on issue an o'e
'iecting the shei// o constaIle o/ the count& to e$o<e the tenant Dithin
24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the o'e...N 4s ina%%licaIle to this situation, Dhee
- 19F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an ,'e :anting Su$$a& E<iction Das signe' I& ,ctoIe 27th, 2.11.
+hat language is onl& /oun' in situations ina%%licaIle to the cuent one.
NRS 4..25"#"(#B(#2(, an' NRS 4..25"#5(#-( ae the onl& sections o/ NRS
4. Dhee this MDithin 24 housN language occus, an' those situations onl&
a%%l& Dhee, in1 4..25"#"(#B(#2(1 M ". - notice se<e' %usuant to
suIsection 1 o 2 $ust1 ...#B( -'<ise the tenant1 W. #2( +hat i/ the cout
'ete$ines that the tenant is guilt& o/ an unlaD/ul 'etaine, the cout $a&
issue a su$$a& o'e /o e$o<al o/ the tenant o an o'e %o<i'ing /o
the nona'$ittance o/ the tenant, 'iecting the shei// o constaIle o/ the
count& to e$o<e the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the o'eN an'
4..25"#5(#-(1 M5. )%on nonco$%liance Dith the notice1 #a( +he lan'lo' o
the lan'lo'Ls agent $a& a%%l& I& a//i'a<it o/ co$%laint /o e<iction to the
Kustice cout o/ the toDnshi% in Dhich the 'Delling, a%at$ent, $oIile ho$e
o co$$ecial %e$ises ae locate' o to the 'istict cout o/ the count& in
Dhich the 'Delling, a%at$ent, $oIile ho$e o co$$ecial %e$ises ae
locate', Dhiche<e has Kuis'iction o<e the $atte. +he cout $a&
theeu%on issue an o'e 'iecting the shei// o constaIle o/ the count& to
e$o<e the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the o'e.N +he Da& these
su$$a& e<iction %ocee'ings ae Ieing caie' out in Reno @ustice Cout
%esentl& shocJs the conscience an' <iolates Ne<a'a laD. +hee is not Iasis
/o e//ectuating a locJout the Da& =CS,Bs 5e%ut& ?ache$ 'i' in this
case. +he aIo<e tDo sections containing the MDithin 24 hous o/ ecei%tN
language ae ina%%licaIle, as those situations 'o not in<oJe the %esent
cicu$stances, Dhee the +enant 'i' /ile an -//i'a<it an' 'i' contest this
$atte to a 'egee not o/ten seen. +o equie Ne<a'aBs tenants to get u% an'
get out MDithin 24 housN o/ Mecei%t o/ the o'eN #Dhat 'oes that e<en
$eanT +he use o/ te$s liJe Men'itionN, Men'ee'N, Mnotice o/ ent&N,
M%onounce'N, is aIsent hee, an' this Mecei%t o/ the o'eN language is
so$ething ael& /oun' elseDhee in Ne<a'a laDHsee attache' 5?V
statuto& citations, an' in e$%lo&$ent laD litigations Dhee one $ust /ile a
Co$%laint Dithin 9. 'a&s o/ Mecei%tN o/ a Right +o Sue ;ette, a situation
Dhich /olloDs NRC* 5#I(, an' NRC* 2#e( in i$%uting ecei%t o/ such a
lette, Dhen actual ecei%t is not shoDn, I& a%%l&ing a Mconstucti<e noticeN
stan'a' that elies u%on the 'a&s /o $ailing e0tension o/ ti$e /o ite$s
se<e' in the $ailing, etc.(. 4n -Iaha$ <. =oo's 7ole ,ceanoga%hic
4nstitute, 55" 6."5 114 #1st Ci. 2..9(, +he eco' 'i' not e/lect Dhen the
%lainti// ecei<e' his ightHtoHsue lette. +he lette Das issue' on No<e$Ie
24, 2..2. +he cout calculate' that the 9.H'a& %eio' co$$ence' on
No<e$Ie "., 2..2, Iase' on thee 'a&s /o $ailing a/te e0clu'ing
Satu'a&s an' Sun'a&s.N
?eanDhile, at Iates 7." *age 17 o/ CoughlinBs "F5F12 ?otion to 5is$iss in
224.5 an' at Iates 724 an illegiIle e%o'uction o/ %age "9 o/ 4. %age /a0 to R?C
- 2.F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
/o$ Coughlin Dith =CS, StuchellBs a'$ission that 5e%ut& ?achenBs -//i'a<it o/
Se<ice is incoect Dhee it alleges Coughlin Das M%esonall& se<e'N Dhee
<esion inclu'e' I& 9ing in 4F12F12 2" E0hiIit %esentation to NN5B Sceening
*anel e0cise' such %age.
,%-'9 an# '*%,& t!+spass as+1
Un4s+#: 4ntim+l7 +6ition wa!!ant n++#s to "+ !+iss4+#1 :een, "44 SE
2' 5.7, =oo's 19 N8S 2' 28", Regan 425 N8S 2' 725, 4oio, 41. N8S 2' 195,
Russell < 9alian, 414 -.2' 4221
+8pi!+# wa!!ant 5o! +6ition no 2oo#1 ;eese < 7one, 47 *.2' "12,
Buha$s, 89 *."' 229, RosDicJ, 2"1 BR 841, 7a$$on', 515 SE 2' 182, -lIet,
49. N8S 2' 951, ,BBien <. ).S., 444 -.2' 942, State <. ?Ena, 782 -.2' 141
#.1(, Cana<an <. State "8 So. "' 885, @o'an V. State, 8.2 So. 2' 118. #.1(, State
<. -sh, 12 S= "' 8.. #+N B99(. @o'an <. State 11. *."' at 47, =illia$s <. Nagel
24" NE 2' 812, 9oenig, 742 *.2' 249,Nelson, 9.9 NE 2 242, clai$ o/ ight
,BIanion 519 SE 2' 819, Bean 425 *.2' 1441
*lease in'icate in Diting Dhat &ou ha<e 'one to in<estigate Richa' :.
7illBs allegations, as set /oth in his @anua& 14th, 2.12 gie<ance against $e, in
Diting, inclu'ing, Iut not li$ite' to 7illBs allegations <is a <is the ci$inal tes%ass
aest o/ $e in on No<e$Ie 1"th, 2.11, lea'ing to a custo'ial aest, an' thee
ta//ic citations I& R*5 Sagent +ate /olloDing $& elease on No<e$Ie 15th,
2.11 Dhen 4 <entue' to 7illBs o//ice to etie<e $& state issue' 'i<eBs license,
Dallet #ce'its ca', $one&(, an' $& clientBs /iles an' $& oDn /iles an' ha' 'i<es
an' othe $ateials. +his is a /o$al, Ditten gie<ance against Richa' 7ill an'
Case& BaJe, in co$%liance Dith $& R*C 8." oIligations es%ecting thei /ailue to
tun o<e $& ha' 'i<es, 'i<eBs license, clientBs /iles an' $& oDn /iles, thei
i$%e$issiIl& in/luencing the R@C to /ail to gi<e $e a heaing on $& No<e$Ie
12th, 2.11 /iling o/ a ?otion to Contest *esonal *o%et& lien Dithin the 1. 'a&s
equie' I& NRS 4..25"#7(H#8( #heaing onl& tooJ %lace a/te Richa'Bs si0 DeeJ
<acation, on 5ece$Ie 2.th, 2.11, in acco' Dith Richa'Bs Ditten in'ication to
$e that he Doul' Ie aIle to get the R@C to Dait that long on his account..., an
i$%e$issiIle suggestion I& Richa' that he coul' i$%o%el& in/luence a tiIunal,
as Das Richa' theats that he Doul' ha<e $e gi<en the @o'an <. State O<e0atious
litigantO teat$ent i/ 4 Je%t u% $& o%%osition to his ne/aious ai$s.
OSuIKect1 RE1 =CS, 5e%ut& ?ache$Bs O%esonall& se<e'O -//i'a<it o/ 11F1F2.11
- 21F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
5ate1 +ue, 7 6eI 2.12 1114.1"9 H.8..
6o$1 ;Stuchell3Dashoecount&.us
+o1 Cachcoughlin3hot$ail.co$
CC1 $Jan'aas3'a.Dashoecount&.us
?. Coughlin,
,u eco's in'icate that the e<iction con'ucte' on that 'a& Das %esonall& se<e'
I& 5e%ut& ?achen I& %osting a co%& o/ the ,'e to the esi'ence. +he esi'ence
Das unoccu%ie' at the ti$e.
;iC Stuchell, Su%e<iso, =CS, Ci<il SectionO #N,+E1 this is the e$ail /o$
=CS, Ci<il 5i<ision Su%e<iso ;iC Stuchell that Ioth 9ing #in his 4F12F12
%esentation o/ a 2" E0hiIit %acJage to the Sceening *anel( an' NN5B Chai
Susich #in his 5F"1F12 SCR 117 *etition in 2.975( e0cise' /o$ the co%ies o/
CoughlinBs "F5F12 /iling o/ a ?otion to 5is$iss in R?C 11 CR 224.5, the ci$inal
tes%ass %osecuti
-''itionall&, this is a gie<ance against 7ill an' BaJe concening thei l&ing
un'e oath at the @une 18th, 2.11 ci$inal tes%ass /o$ $& /o$e laD o//ice tial
in R?C 11 CR 224.5. *lease e<ieD the ClaiIone 'ecision /o su%%ot /o the
contention that neithe Ba Counsel 9ing, SBN 4n<estigato *etes, o the SBN Dill
/in' a<ailing an& agu$ent that no in<estigation Das equie' on thei %at
es%ecting those allegations #%aticulal& 'uing the 5 $onths %eio' IetDeen 7illBs
@anua& 14th, 2.12 Ditten, Iut unsigne', gie<ance to *at 9ing an' the con<iction
on @une 18th, 2.12...cetainl&, the SBN has taJen an inteest in $& %en'ing
ci$inal $attes...(. 4n ClaiIone, the SBN Das taJen to tasJ /o $aJing such a
suggestion that no 'ut& to in<estigate on thei %at Das %esent, Dhee the Cout
ule' it cleal& Das...
*lease e<ieD the sDon 5eclaation I& 7ill attache' to his No<e$Ie 2.th,
2.11 ,%%osition to CoughlinBs ?otion to Contest *esonal *o%et& ;ien an' that
,%%osition itsel/, es%eciall& the Iit in 7illBs 5eclaation Dhee he /ails to allege the
R*5 i'enti/ie' the$sel<es as laD en/oce$ent o issue' an OlaD/ul o'eO /o
Coughlin to Oe$ege /o$ theO OIase$entO #Dhich ne<e ha' an outsi'e locJ to
Iegin Dith( %io to lan'lo' ?eliss JicJing the 'oo 'oDn #an' isnBt is inteesting
that the R*5 'i' not /eel it ha' authoit& to JicJ a 'oo 'oDn...suggesting the& also
/elt the& 'i' not ha<e authoit& to issue a OlaD/ul o'eO o Daning, %usuant to
R?C 8.1...1. to Coughlin to lea<e the %e$ises. 4 a$ co$%laining o/ an unlaD/ul
tes%ass an' in<asion I& 7ill, BaJe, an' ?eliss, es%eciall& Dhee in the othe
<i'eos %o<i'e' to Reno Cit& -ttone& Chis 7aClettHSte<ens #an' this is a /o$al
gie<ance against 7aClettHSte<enBs as Dell, es%eciall& consi'eing the e0tent to
Dhich he %ut on %eKue' testi$on&, /aile' to hol' 7ill to a suI%oena, in <iolation
o/ CoughlinBs ight to a s%ee'& tial #'uing the sa$e 2 DeeJ <acation I& 7ill that
esulte' in the R@C /ailing to gi<e Coughlin a ti$el& 7eaing on his No<e$Ie
12th, 2.11 /iling o/ a ?otion to Contest *esonal *o%et& ;ien in the e<iction
- 22F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
$atte /o$ CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice in the R@C, REV2.11H..17.8...a
?otion /o Continuance Das /ile' I& cit& attone&s 7aClett, Dhich CoughlinBs then
R?C a%%ointe' 'e/ense Counsel ;eD +aitel /aile' to ti$el& in/o$ Coughlin o/
an' agee to #'es%ite Coughlin, at that ti$e, ha<ing /ile' a laDsuit against Ne<a'a
Cout Se<ices, on ,ctoIe 19th, 2.11 in CVH.".51, CV11H.".51 Z-C7
C,):7;4N VS. ?-++ ?ER;4SS E+ -; #51(. 19H,C+H2.11.
6uthe, an& Ditings o /ilings I& Ba Counsel 9ing an' o Chai$an
Susich that suggest o in'icate Coughlin co$$itte' a OIeaJing an' enteingO o/
his /o$e laD o//ice, o that the OlocJs Dee IoJenO is totall& unsu%%ote' an'
ecJless an' conta'icte' e0%licitl& I& the <i'eos 7ill hi$sel/ /il$e' an' his
state$ents theein. *lease coect an& such /ilings an' alet the Cout to &ou
tansgessions.
BaJe lie' an' <iolate' NRC* 11 in his N,<e$Ie 21st, 2.11 ,%%osition
Dhee he allege' the R*5 i'enti/ie' the$sel<es as laD en/oce$ent an' issue' a
laD/ul o'e /o Coughlin to e$ege /o$ the OIase$entO o lea<e the %o%et&1
OE<en though he ha' a DeeJ to 'o so, Coughlin 'i' not e$o<e his %esonal
Ielongings /o$ the %o%et& %io to the locJout. 4n /act, he 'i' not e<en e$o<e
hi$sel/ /o$ the %o%et&. )nIeJnoDnst to ?eliss o his counsel, Coughlin
continue' to li<e in the Iase$ent o/ the %o%et& until he Das 'isco<ee' squatting
thee on No<e$Ie 1". 2.11 H Neal& tDo DeeJs a/te he Das legall& locJe' out.
Coughlin ha' Iaica'e' hi$sel/, his 'og, an' so$e o/ his %esu$aIl& $oe
cheishe' %ossessions in the Iase$ent. =hen Coughlin e/use' to e$ege /o$ the
Iase$ent a/te Ieing o'ee' to 'o so I& the %olice, ?eliss Das /oce' to JicJ
'oDn the 'oo to gain access to his oDn %o%et&. Coughlin Das aeste' an'
chage' Dith tes%assing. 5ue to CoughlinBs ci$inal acti<ities, the secuit& o/ the
house Das co$%o$ise'. -s a esult, ?eliss Das /oce' to incu costs in the
a$ount o/ V1,.2.... +o secue the %o%et& in o'e to %otect it an' CoughlinBs
Ielongings. - tue an' coect co%& o/ the Iill /o$ the contacto is attache'
heeto as EG74B4+ 2.O
BaJes NRC* 11 <iolation in his /iling o/ No<e$Ie 2.th, 2.11 in R@C
Re<2.11H..17.8 occus at %ages 1H", Dhee he atte$%ts to $islea' the tiIunal in
suggesting that Coughin /aile' to coo%eate in setting a 7eaing on the ?otion to
Contest *esonal *o%et& ;ien, e<en Dhee Coughlin es%on'e' to 7illBs then
e$ail in/o$ing hi$ o/ such a heaing, I& Coughlin e$ailing 7ill ORich, &ou ae
aDae the /iles can Ie on ha' 'i<eBs, ightTO in es%onse to 74llBs e$ail o/ a
7eaing #Coughlin suIsequentl& e<oJe' #an' ha' $a'e e0%ess %e<iousl& Ditten
in'ication that no such acce%tance o/ such electonic se<ice o notice Doul' Ie
a<ailing es%ecting co$$unications Dith Coughlin, an' 74ll Das a''e' to
CoughlinBs OIlocJe' sen'e listO on CoughlinBs 7ot$ail account, as such, Coughlin
'i' not ecei<e 7illBs e$ails /o$ ,ctoIe an& i$%licit authoit& 7ill $a& asset to
%o<i'e Coughlin notice <ia electonic $eans, an' theein is <itiate' an& o/ 7illBs
testi$on& at the tes%ass tial that the ODaningO against tes%ass Das ela&e' in
7illBs <aious atte$%ts at e$ailing Coughlin 'uing the /ist /eD DeeJs o/
- 2"F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
No<e$Ie, inclu'ing the %eio' Dhee BaJe Das on <acation an' so$ethings
a%%ea to ha<e sli%%e' though the cacJs at the 7ill laD /i$ es%ecting noti/&ing
Coughlin in an acce%te' $eans o/ se<ice(. Coughlin 'i' not ecei<e an& e$ails
/o$ 7illBs hill3icha'hillaD.co$ a''ess IetDeen 7illBs e$ail o/ -ugust 12th,
2.11 an' No<e$Ie 18th, 2.11, this Coughlin sDeas %usuant to NRS 5"..45
un'e %enalt& o/ %eKu&1
6o$1 Zach Coughlin Q$ailto1Cachcoughlin3hot$ail.co$R
Sent1 ?on'a&, No<e$Ie 21, 2.11 "115 *?
+o1 hill3icha'hillaD.co$
SuIKect1 RE1 Ri<e ocJ
Rich, &ou ae aDae that O/ilesO can inclu'e things on ha' 'i<es, ightT
Zach Coughlin, Esq.
121 Ri<e RocJ St.
Reno, NV 895.1
775 ""8 8118
;icense' in Ne<a'a
6o$1 hill3icha'hillaD.co$
+o1 Cachcoughlin3hot$ail.co$
SuIKect1 Ri<e ocJ
5ate1 ?on, 21 No< 2.11 1415"1." H.8..
? coughlin Hthis con/i$s a <oice$ail le/t /o &ou
4 noD ha<e &ou 'i<es license P Dhat 4 thinJ ae &ou client /iles.
5onBt JnoD, 'i'nBt looJ that closel& H &ou %i<ac& P all.
=ill elease the$ to &ou at the heaing to$ooD.
*lease con/i$ that the heaing is on calen'a
RghO
Coughlin a%%eae' at the R@C /o the 7eaing he Das notice' on /o
No<e$Ie 22n', 2.11 %usuant to the No<e$Ie 12th, 2.11 /iling I& Coughlin o/
the ?otion to Contest *esonal *o%et& lien in R@C REV2.11H..17.8. 7ill /aile'
to a%%eae'. 6uthe, 7ill continue' to lie aIout his Oo//eing to %o<i'e CoughlinO
his client /iles, inclu'ing those /iles on CoughlinBs ha' 'i<es. 6uthe, at least one
o/ CoughlinBs ha' 'i<es, u%on thei /inall& Ieing etune' to Coughlin on
5ece$Ie 22n', 2.11 #Dith one o/ the e0%ensi<e la%to% sceens co$%letel&
cacJe'...( in'icate' a <i'eo ca' 'i<e Das loa'e' to the ha' 'i<e, inclu'ing one
on 5ece$Ie 2th, 2.11, 'uing the %eio' /o$ CoughlinBs aest o/ No<e$Ie
1"th, 2.11 to 7illBs an' BaJeBs /inall& etuning CoughlinBs clientBs /iles an' ha'
'i<es to hi$ on 5ece$Ie 22n', 2.11 #unless &ou count the instance Dhee 7ill
%la&/ull& set 'oDn a Iag o/ tash an' in'icate' to Coughlin Ohee is &ou clientBs
- 24F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
/ilesO at the ti$e Dhen 7ill /inall& etune' CoughlinBs state issue' 'i<eBs license
one /ull DeeJ a/te Coughlin ha' 'e$an'e' it, on No<e$Ie 22n', 2.11,
so$ething that 7ill lie' to the couts an' the %olice aIout his Dillingness to 'o so
u% to that ti$e aIsent a coeci<e 'e$an' that Coughlin sign aDa& his ights,
inclu'ing those to his 'a$age 'e%osit. 6uthe 7ill <iolate' Ne<a'a laD in %lacing
'e$an's u%on Coughlin that Coughlin e$o<e his %o%et& in the e0act $anne an'
o'e that 74ll 'e$an'e' #7ill equie' Coughlin to a%%ea Dith cetain <ehicles
an' a OceDO o/ $o<es, an' insiste' Coughlin $ust e$o<e all the %o%et& on the
/o$e ho$e laD o//iceBs e0teio %io to Coughlin Ieing alloDe' to Oche& %icJO
the ite$s Dithin that Dee o/ the $ost <alue, equie$ents /o Dhich thee e0ists no
su%%ot in Ne<a'a laD /o 7ill to $aJe, inclu'ing Dithin NRS 118-.42., all to the
'eti$ent o/ CoughlinBs clientBs concens an' the e%utation o/ the Ba in Ne<a'a
an' Ie&on'. +he R@C ne<e nee'e' CoughlinBs %e$ission %e<iousl& to set
7eaings, inclu'ing the one on No<e$Ie 7th, 2.11 that Coughlin Das se<e' an
i$%o$%tu notice o/ Dhile he Das at the /iling o//ice on No<e$Ie "', 2.11, no
'i' the R@C nee' CoughlinBs %e$ission to to set the ,ctoIe 1"th, 2.11 su$$a&
e<iction %ocee'ing 'ate, the ,ctoIe 25th, 2.11 O+ialO, o the 5ece$Ie 2.th,
2.11 7eaing 'ate.
6uthe ecJless an' lacJing in /oun'ation $entions o/ OIeaJing intoO the
/o$e laD o//ice an' OIoJen locJsO 'es%ite the /act that no /actual su%%ot e0ists
/o such an allegation, thee Dee no OIoJen locJsO e<e $entione' I& an&one
#an' i/ 7ill is Dilling to $aJe u% /in'ing a OIag o/ Dee' an' cacJ %i%eO along Dith
'esciIing Dhat 7illBs oDn <i'eos shoD to Ie <ita$ins as a Olage quantit& o/ %illsO,
then &ou JnoD Richa' :. 7ill, Esq. Doul' ha<e Ieen all o<e an& OIoJen locJsO
at the /o$e ho$e laD o//ice, &et, thee si$%l& Dee none, not that that Doul' sto%
*at 9ing o @. +ho$as Susich /o$ coIIling togethe such an allegation in the SCR
117 *etition in 2.975( along Dith so$ething aIout Coughlin Ieing suIKect to a
custo'ial aest /o OKa&DalJingO I& the Reno *olice 5e%at$ent Dhile Coughlin
Das /il$ing Richa' :. 7ill, Esq.Bs contactoBs ceD loa'ing u% a 'u$% tucJ Dith
ite$s o/ %esonal %o%et& then locate' in CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice #the
aest occue' shotl& a/te Coughlin 'isco<ee' that 7illBs contacto, *hil
SteDat, ha' use' CoughlinBs oDn 'istincti<e %l&Doo' to OsecueO o OIoa' u% the
%o%et&O in 5ece$Ie 2.11, /o Dhich the lan'lo' Das ulti$atel& aDa'e' costs,
V1,.2. o/ Dhich Dee Iase' u%on SteDatBs in<oice /o Osecuing the %o%et&O,
Dhich inclu'e' the cost o/ %l&Doo', an' O/i0ing a leaJ in the Iase$entO 'es%ite
NRS 118-.42. onl& alloDing costs /o O$o<ing, stoing, an' in<ento&ingO a
tenantBs %esonal %o%et&(, Dhich Coughlin Das unaIle to e$o<e 'uing the scant
1" hous he Das a//o'e' to 'o so I& the Reno @ustice CoutBs ,'e /olloDing a
7eaing on CoughlinBs No<e$Ie 12th, 2.11 ?otion to Contest *esonal *o%et&
;ien #the 7eaing Das not set o con'ucte' Dith the O1. 'a&sO equie' I& NRS
4..25"#7(H#8( Iecause Richa' :. 7ill, Esq. nee'e' to go on a si0HDeeJ <acation
shotl& a/te CoughlinBs No<e$Ie 12th, 2.11 /iling #in a $atte noD on a%%eal in
SCR 2.""1 an' 218"8, Dheein, so$ehoD, a co$$ecial tenant, Coughlin #Dho$
- 25F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Das Ioth unning a laD %actice an' Coughlin ?e$o& 6oa$, a /oa$ $attess
Iusiness /o$ his ho$e, Dhich Das %e<iousl& utiliCe' /o co$$ecial %u%oses I&
a 'ug an' alcohol ehaIilitation counseling Iusiness an' is Cone /o $i0e' use
%u%oses( Das su$$ail& e<icte' Iase' u%on a No Cause E<iction Notice onl& #ie,
the nonH%a&$ent o/ ent Das neithe notice', %le', no ague' I& the lan'lo'(
'es%ite the clea 'ictate against the use o/ su$$a& e<iction %ocee'ings against
co$$ecial tenants not Iase' u%on the nonH%a&$ent o/ ent #Bench BooJ stu//( set
/oth in NRS 4..25".
+he 5ece$Ie 21st, 2.11 ,'e OResol<ingO CoughlinBs ?otion to Contest
*esonal *o%et& ;ien actuall& equie' Coughlin to %a& the e0act sa$e a$ount o/
ent /o 17 'a&s #No<e$Ie 1 to No<e$Ie 17th, 2.11(, V48. #ie, %oHate' /o$
the V9.. %e $onth ental agee$ent( as Coughlin Doul' ha<e un'e a O/ai ental
<alueO, /o the O/ull use an' occu%anc& o/ the %e$isesO 'es%ite the /act that 7ill
so$ehoD signe' a Ci$inal Co$%laint /o +es%ass -gainst Coughlin, on
No<e$Ie 1"th, 2.11 'es%ite an& Su$$a& E<iction ,'e not Ieing se<e' in
acco'ance Dith NRS 4..4.. #an' thee/oe NRC* 5 an' 2#e( <is a <is the ODithin
24 housO o/ Oecei%tO o/ the locJout o'e, an', thee/oe, an& such locJout that
ha' occue' Ieing en'ee' a nullit& o %usuant to a <oi' ,'e( an' Dhee the
=ashoe Count& Shei//Bs ,//ice Ci<il *ocess Se<ice Su%e<iso ;iC Stuchell has
a'$itte' in Diting that the -//i'a<it o/ Se<ice /ile' No<e$Ie 7th, 2.11 I&
5e%ut& ?achen, attesting to ha<ing O%esonall& se<e'O the Su$$a& E<iction
,'e on No<e$Ie 1st, 2.11, Das, in /act, %u%ote'l& $eel& %oste' to the 'oo
o/ CoughlinBs /o$e laD o//ice Dhile Coughlin Das not ho$e, at Dhich %oint a
Sol'al <. CooJ Count& <iolating illegal locJout occue'. 4n a 6eIua& 7th, 2.12
Ditten coes%on'ence to Coughlin, Stuchell Dote1 O?. Coughlin, ,u eco's
in'icate that the e<iction con'ucte' on that 'a& Das %esonall& se<e' I& 5e%ut&
?achen I& %osting a co%& o/ the ,'e to the esi'ence. +he esi'ence Das
unoccu%ie' at the ti$e. ;iC Stuchell, Su%e<iso =CS, Ci<il SectionO.
+he te0t o/ NRS 4..25" s%eaJs to se<ice o/ ;ocJout ,'es1 M+he cout
$a& theeu%on issue an o'e 'iecting the shei// o constaIle o/ the count& to
e$o<e the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the o'e...N is ina%%licaIle to this
situation, Dhee an ,'e :anting Su$$a& E<iction Das signe' I& ,ctoIe 27th,
2.11 #though not $aile' to Coughlin until a/te the No<e$Ie 1, 2.11 locJout ha'
allege'l& alea'& occue'(. +hat language is onl& /oun' in situations ina%%licaIle to
the one inci'ent that in the su$$a& e<iction /o$ CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD
o//ice. NRS 4..25"#"(#I(#2(, an' NRS 4..25"#5(#a( ae the onl& sections o/ NRS
4. Dhee this MDithin 24 housN language occus, an' those situations onl& a%%l&
Dhee, in1 4..25"#"(#I(#2(1 M ". - notice se<e' %usuant to suIsection 1 o 2
$ust1 ...#I( -'<ise the tenant1 W. #2( +hat i/ the cout 'ete$ines that the tenant is
guilt& o/ an unlaD/ul 'etaine, the cout $a& issue a su$$a& o'e /o e$o<al o/
the tenant o an o'e %o<i'ing /o the nona'$ittance o/ the tenant, 'iecting the
shei// o constaIle o/ the count& to e$o<e the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t
o/ the o'eN an', 4..25"#5(#a(1 M5. )%on nonco$%liance Dith the notice1 #a( +he
- 22F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
lan'lo' o the lan'lo'Ls agent $a& a%%l& I& a//i'a<it o/ co$%laint /o e<iction to
the Kustice cout o/ the toDnshi% in Dhich the 'Delling, a%at$ent, $oIile ho$e o
co$$ecial %e$ises ae locate' o to the 'istict cout o/ the count& in Dhich the
'Delling, a%at$ent, $oIile ho$e o co$$ecial %e$ises ae locate', Dhiche<e
has Kuis'iction o<e the $atte. +he cout $a& theeu%on issue an o'e 'iecting
the shei// o constaIle e$o<e the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the
o'e.N
+he Da& these su$$a& e<iction %ocee'ings ae Ieing caie' out in Reno
@ustice Cout %esentl& shocJs the conscience an' <iolates Ne<a'a laD. +hee is not
Iasis /o e//ectuating a locJout the Da& =CS,Bs 5e%ut& ?ache$ 'i' in this case.
+he equie$ents atten'ant to se<ing Su$$a& E<iction ,'es an' con'ucting
locJouts ae /oun' in NRS 4..25" in tDo sections containing the MDithin 24 hous
o/ ecei%tN language ae ina%%licaIle, as those situations 'o not in<oJe the %esent
cicu$stances, Dhee the +enant 'i' /ile an -//i'a<it an' 'i' contest this $atte to
a 'egee not o/ten seen. +o equie Ne<a'aBs tenants to get u% an' get out MDithin
24 housN o/ Mecei%t o/ the o'eN #Dhat 'oes that e<en $eanT +he use o/ te$s
liJe Men'itionN, Men'ee'N, Mnotice o/ ent&N, M%onounce'N, is aIsent hee, an'
this Mecei%t o/ the o'eN language is so$ething ael& /oun' elseDhee in Ne<a'a
laDHsee attache' 5?V statuto& citations, an' in e$%lo&$ent laD litigations Dhee
one $ust /ile a Co$%laint Dithin 9. 'a&s o/ Mecei%tN o/ a Right +o Sue ;ette, a
situation Dhich /olloDs NRC* 5#I(, an' NRC* 2#e( in i$%uting ecei%t o/ such a
lette, Dhen actual ecei%t is not shoDn, I& a%%l&ing a Mconstucti<e noticeN
stan'a' that elies u%on the 'a&s /o $ailing e0tension o/ ti$e /o ite$s se<e' in
the $ailing, etc.(. 4n -Iaha$ <. =oo's 7ole ,ceanoga%hic 4nstitute, 55" 6."'
114 #1st Ci. 2..9(, the eco' 'i' not e/lect Dhen the %lainti// ecei<e' his ightH
toHsue lette. +he lette Das issue' on No<e$Ie 24, 2..2.
+he cout calculate' that the 9.H'a& %eio' co$$ence' on No<e$Ie ".,
2..2, Iase' on thee 'a&s /o $ailing a/te e0clu'ing Satu'a&s an' Sun'a&s. 4n
o'e to Iing a clai$ un'e eithe +itle V44 o the -5-, a %lainti// $ust e0haust
a'$inistati<e e$e'ies an' sue Dithin 9. 'a&s o/ ecei%t o/ a ight to sue lette.
See 42 ).S.C. E 2...eH5#/(#1(. See Bal'Din Count& =elco$e Cente <. BoDn,
422 ).S. 147, 148 n.1, 1.4 S.Ct. 172", 8. ;.E'.2' 192 #1984( #ganting %lainti// an
a''itional thee 'a&s /o $ailing %usuant to Rule 2(....N 6uthe, as seen in the
-n<ui case, thee is so$e agu$ent es%ecting not e//ecting a locJout /o at least 5
'a&s Dhee a lease has not e0%ie' I& its te$s, as CoughlinBs aguaIl& ha' not.
7oDe<e, in his @anua& 2.th, 2.12 Secon' ?otion /o ,'e to ShoD
Cause, Richa' :. 7ill, Esq. 'i' not get all Iogge' 'oDn in legal eseach an'
stu//, instea' he Kust %ointe' out1 O6-C+S S7,=4N: C,N+E?*+ ,6 C,)R+
2. EG74B4+ 1 #the Su$$a& E<iction ;ocJout ,'e( Das se<e' on Coughlin on
No<e$Ie 1, 2.11 I& the =ashoe Count& Shei//s 5e%at$ent in its custo$a&
$anne, I& %osting sa$e on the /ont 'oo o/ the %o%et& in the $anne custo$a&
/o e<ictions in =ashoe Count&. +he locJs to the %e$ises Dee change' at that
ti$e, theeI& eKecting an' 'is%ossessing Coughlin o/ %ossession o/ the *o%et&.O
- 27F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
7ill Dent on to lie again in that @anua& 2.th, 2.12 ?otion Dhen he equate' his
o//e to let Coughlin get so$e o/ the %esonalt& Coughlin Das unaIle to e$o<e,
'ue lagel& to 7ill /ailing to e$o<e the chain linJ %a'locJ /o$ the IacJ&a' gate
that 7ill ha' onl& Kust installe' in ti$e /o the 1" hous Coughlin ha' to e$o<e his
%o%et& in e0change /o Coughlin Dai<ing his ights to the V7.. 'a$age 'e%osit
Coughlin %o<i'e' u%on $o<ing in, Dhee 7ill s%ins it1 O12. ,n 6i'a&, 5ece$Ie
2", 2.11, Coughlin ha' a ceD o/ hel%es, an' $a'e %ogess. Nonetheless,
Coughlin /aile' to e$o<e all o/ his Ielongings /o$ the *o%et&. Coughlin /aile'
to e$o<e his things 'es%ite ha<ing Ieen gi<en a''itional ti$e to 'o so a/te X the
ti$e set I& the Reno @ustice Cout in its o'e o/ 5ece$Ie 21, 2.11 #EG74B4+ 2(
ha' e0%ie'.O
-%%aentl&, to 7ill, at least one has O /aile' to e$o<e all o/ his Ielongings
/o$ the *o%et&. Coughlin /aile' to e$o<e his things 'es%ite ha<ing Ieen gi<en
a''itional ti$e to 'o soO Dhee 7ill theatens to ha<e one aeste' /o ci$inal
tes%ass o lacen& #o/ thei oDn stu//, aguaIl&( i/ one is on the %o%et& one
$inute %ast 5 %.$., unless one Dai<es an& ight to thei 'a$age 'e%osit #Dhich
neithe 7ill no the ;an'lo' e<e 'i' etun, no 'i' the& co$%l& Dith the
equie$ent that the& %o<i'e an ite$iCe' state$ent in'icating an a%%lication
theeo/ Kusti/&ing such a /ailue to etun such 'e%osit Dithin ". 'a&s....an' 7ill
'oes not Dant to get into Dhethe his con'uct is <iolati<e o/ the 65C*- o Dhethe
he is license' a as 'eIt collecto(. 4n that ?otion, 7ill continue' on1 O1". ,n
5ece$Ie "., 2.11, Coughlin $o<e' this Cout /o a te$%oa& estaining o'e
to %e<ent ?eliss /o$ 'is%osing o/ the ite$s he #Coughlin( ha' aIan'one' on the
*o%et&. CoughlinBs $otion Das /ull& Iie/e', an' the Cout entee' its o'e
'en&ing the $otion on @anua& 11, 2.12. - tue an' coect co%& o/ this CoutBs
@anua& 11,2.12 o'e is attache' heeto as EG74B4+ ". 14. ,n +hus'a&, @anua&
12, 2.12, in acco'ance Dith EG74B4+ 2 an' EG74B4+ ", a license' contacto
hie' I& ?eliss Iegan cleaning u% the *o%et& an' 'is%osing o/ the aIan'one'
ite$s still e$aining thee. 15. Eal& that a/tenoon, Dhile the contacto Das
hauling the /ist o/ se<eal loa's o/ aIan'one' %o%et& to the tans/e station
#'u$%( /o 'is%osal, Coughlin sto%%e' the contacto in ta//ic an' atte$%te' to
%e<ent hi$ /o$ ca&ing out his tasJ. 12. S%eci/icall&, Coughlin stoo' in /ont o/
the contactoBs <ehicle in an e//ot to %e<ent hi$ /o$ %ocee'ing to the tans/e
station. Coughlin theatene' to sue the contacto. Coughlin cli$Ie' u% on the
contactoBs <ehicle. Coughlin then calle' the %olice an' /alsel& tol' the$ that the
contacto ha' stolen his %ossessions, an' that the contacto ha' tie' to un hi$
o<e. CoughlinBs acts Dee s%eci/icall& calculate' to %e<ent the contacto /o$
'is%osing o/ the aIan'one' %o%et&, an' to /ustate an' inte/ee Dith ?elissB
co$%liance Dith this CoutBs @anua& 11, 2.12 o'e. 17. =hen ?. 7ill o/ the
un'esigne'Bs o//ice Das noti/ie' o/ the /oegoing, he Dent to the tans/e station
an' %esente' EG74B4+ 2 an' EG74B4+ " to the %olice. +he contacto Das then
alloDe' to %ocee'. 18. 7oDe<e, Ie/oe the contacto coul' etun to the Ri<e
RocJ *o%et&, Coughlin Das thee. 7e ha' his <i'eo ca$ea an' Das DalJing u%
- 28F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an' 'oDn the steet scea$ing an' &elling at the %olice, the contacto, an' ?.
7ill, once ?. 7ill ai<e'. -t the instuction o/ the %olice, ?. 7ill then oItaine' a
te$%oa& %otecti<e o'e #O+*,O( against Coughlin /o$ the Reno @ustice Cout.
Coughlin en'e' u% Ieing aeste' an' taJen to Kail that 'a& as a esult o/ his antics
at the tans/e station an' the *o%et&.O
+he thing is, an' Coughlin Doul' sue liJe to get the 911 ta%es #o, $oe
liJel&, Dith 7ill, an& eco'ings that $a& e0ist o/ 7ill calling so$eIo'& in
%aticula he $a& ha<e ha' in $in' Dith the R*5( o/ calls I& Coughlin #an' i/
=alH?at can call 911 o<e a can'& Ia, o a sJate Ioa' o<e an i*hone he see$s
to ha<e set 'oDn on the concete goun' in 'oDntoDn Reno, then sJateIoa'e' o//
so$e 1.. &a's aDa& /o su//icientl& long %eio' o/ ti$e to see$ to ha<e Ieen
%ett& $uch the onl& %eson not to ha<e hea' so$eIo'& Dho %icJe' it u% theaten
to thoD it is in the i<e i/ it Dent unclai$e' can call 911 #an' $aJe u% a Iunch o/
lies on the s%ot /o the %u%ose o/ $ani%ulating the %olice into assuages the
sJateIoa'es oDn negligence <is a <is the i*hone( is it uneasonaIle /o Coughlin
to call 911 u%on ha%%ening, totall& I& chance, to coss %aths Dith 7illBs contacto
Dhile 'i<ing, catching site o/ a huge 'u$% tucJ /ull o/ CoughlinBs %esonal
%o%et& hea'e' toDa's the toDn 'u$%T 7ill a'$its the ,'e 'en&ing CoughlinBs
?otion /o a +*, #an' he&, /a$il& heiloo$s ae %ett& /ungiIle, ightT =ho nee's
a +*, /o thatT
-n' its not liJe the lan'lo' coul' Kust acce%t ent in the $eanti$e, o that
the %o%et& still e$ains unente' to this 'a&, so$e 11 $onths a/te the locJout,
an' a%%aentl&, so$e V2.,... Doth o/ attone&Bs /ees %ai' to 7ill /o a tDo
Ie'oo$ ho$e that a%%aises at aoun' V9.,... cuentl&, i/ that. -n' 7illBs
/antastic legal DoJ #ODong site suge&O an' all( Das suel& Doth the isJ o/ a
Dong/ul e<iction laDsuit #an' checJ out those %otential 'a$ages un'e =inchell
<. Schi//, 124 Ne<. 9"8, 19" *."' 942 #2..8(, not that the loss o/ a %atent attone&Bs
caee coul' a$ount to all that $uch(. Rega'less, its not all that coloaIle /o 7ill
to allege Coughlin Das <iolating so$e ,'e entee' on @anua& 11th, 2.12 I&
CoughlinBs con'uct o/ @anua& 12th, 2.12 Dhen NRC* 2#e( %o<i'es that " 'a&s /o
$ailing is to Ie acco'e' to account /o the se<ice o/ /ilings, e<en /ilings
electonicall& se<e' on egistee' e/iles liJe Coughlin. 4ts si$ila to 7ill Danting
a ci$inal tes%ass aest Dhee NRC* 2#e(Bs thee 'a&s /o $ailing Dhee no
%esonal se<ice Das acco$%lishe' #I& Da& o/ NRS 4..4..( an' 7illBs et al 'i' not
e<en co$%l& Dith the constucti<e se<ice equie$ents o/ $ailing the su$$a&
e<iction locJout o'e %io to 7illBs IeaJing into CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD
o//ice on No<e$Ie 1st, 2.11, Dith the hel% o/ the =CS,, in <iolation o/ Sol'al <.
CooJ Count& Dhee Coughlin Das not acco'e' the O24 housO cushion a/te
CoughlinBs Oecei%tO o/ the locJout o'e $entione' in this CoutBs oDn %acJets on
the se<ice o/ ;ocJout ,'es, Dhich 7ill hi$sel/ attache' as a suIsequent e0hiIit
ecentl&...4t gets /unnie.
+he ci<il 'i<ision o/ the @ustice Cout an' the Shei//Bs ,//ice thinJ that
Dhole ODithin 24 housO language in NRS 4..25" $eans ODithin 24 housO o/ the
- 29F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Shei//Bs Oecei%tO o/ the ,'e /o$ the @ustice Cout...=hile otheBs thinJ it is
ODithin 24 housO o/ the tenantBs ecei%t o/ the ,'e /o$ the Shei//...an' this
CoutBs o//icial /o$s an' instuctions see$ to i$%l& that Oat least 24 housO /o$
Oecei%tO o/ the locJout ,'e $ust Ie acco'e' to a tenant. =ho JnoDsT But, it is
not clea, as 7ill suggests, that the Ousual custo$ an' %actice o/ the =ashoe
Count& Shei//Bs ,//iceO is IlacJ lette laD u%on Dhich Ba gie<ances, custo'ial
ci$inal tes%ass aests, $ulti%le ?otion /o ,'e +o ShoD Cause, tens o/
thousan's o/ 'ollas in attone&Bs /ees sanctions against a %o se a%%ellant, etc. ae
Daante'. So$ehoD the 5istict Cout /oun' a Da& to sanction Coughlin Dith
V4.,.5. Doth o/ attone&Bs /ee in that a%%eal o/ the su$$a& e<iction Dithout
hol'ing a single heaing, Dell, othe than the 7eaing on 7ills ,'e to ShoD
Cause, Dhich Das 'enie' Dhen Coughlin 'esto&e' 7illBs contacto *hil SteDat
on cossHe0a$ination. #Reall&, *hilT Reall&T 8ou coul' /ell Oa 'e%essionO in &ou
2 ton loa'e' to ca%acit& 'u$% tucJ u%on Coughlin allege'l& Ocli$Iing u% on itO,
though &ou in'icate' &ou ha' alea'& Oalighte' /o$ the <ehicleO, Iut, Dait, &ou
coul' see CoughlinBs hea' aIo<e the tailgate Dalls in &ou ea <ieD $io #Dhich
'oesnBt see$ to Ie thee on an& the $an& <i'eos o/ the e<ents o/ that 'a&.
-n' e<en i/ such a $io Dhee %esent on SteDatBs tucJ, that 'oesnBt
eall& e0%lain hoD all the %esonalt& stacJe' u% so high in the tucJ Ie' #e%lete
Dith s%ecialiCe' a''Hon high stacJ etaining Dalls( Doul'nBt oIscue an& %u%ote'
<ieD o/ CoughlinBs hea' high aIo<e the aea aIo<e the s%ecialiCe h&'aulic 'u$%
tucJBs tailgate, con/i$ing SteDatBs $ee sus%icion that Coughlin cli$Ie' on his
tucJ. Coughlin sDeas un'e oath he 'i' not cli$I on SteDatBs tucJ. 7ill nee'e'
a little O/actO to s%ice u% his ?otion to ShoD Cause Kust enough, an' OCoughlin
cli$Ie' u% on the tucJO Das OKust the ticJetO, an' SteDat 'i' not $in' going
along /o the i'e, so long as... -n' none o/ the $an& <i'eos /o$ that 'a& actuall&
shoD an& o/ the 8ose$ite Sa$ catoon <illian t&%e Ieha<io 7ill attiIutes to
Coughlin in his Don'e/ull& i$aginati<e ?otion /o ,'e to ShoD Cause an' o
-%%lication /o ,'e o/ *otection concening the e<ents in<ol<e' in the
Ka&DalJing custo'ial aest 7ill ha' Coughlin suIKecte' to on @anua& 12th, 2.12.
?uch liJe 7illBs contacto, *hil SteDat, /lat out l&ing in an a//i'a<it Dhen
he sDoe Coughlin Ocli$Ie' u% onO his tucJ, 7ill si$ilal& lie' in an a//i'a<it
aIout Coughlin, a%%aentl& Dhile Oengage'O $aJing O%h&sical contactO Dith 7ill.
,n *age 2 o/ 7illBs -//i'a<it attach to his ?otion /o ,'e to ShoD Cause,
@anua& 2.th, 2.12, 7ills attests1 O5. ,n 6i'a&, 5ece$Ie 2", 2.11, De unlocJe'
the house at 91.. a.$. as o'ee'. =e o<elooJe' the chain on the IacJ gate. +hee
Das noIo'& at the house Dhen De Dee thee. -t a%%o0i$atel& noon, $& sta//
in/o$e' $e that an enage' ?. Coughlin ha' calle' the o//ice scea$ing that he
coul' not get in the IacJ &a'. =hen 4 /inishe' the $eeting 4 Das in, 4 i$$e'iatel&
Dent o<e an' unlocJe' the IacJ gate. Coughlin ha' a s$all ceD. 7e chage' at
$e an' $a'e %h&sical contact. 7e Das enage'. =e le/t. =hen De etune' at 51..
%.$., ?. Coughlin Das scea$ing an' &elling oIscenities. 7e 'o<e o// in a s$all
) H7aul. 7is ceD e$aine'. =e DalJe' the %o%et& Dith the$. +he insi'e
- ".F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
.goun' /loo Das $ostl& cleae' o/ all Iut a Iig +V. +he Iase$ent ha' Ieen
cleae' so$eDhat, Iut thee Das still a lot o/ OKunJ. O =e coul' not access the attic.
=e Dent outsi'e. 4 tol' CoughlinBs ceD the& coul' e$o<e an&thing an'
e<e&thing outsi'e, i/ the& Doul' onl& t& to ehang the gate that ?. Coughlin ha'
taJen o// the hinges Ie/oe De coul' get o<e to unlocJ it. 4 tol' the$ 4 Doul' locJ
the gates in the $oning.
+hat is eall& inteesting. Co$%ae the aIo<e to the /olloDing e0ce%t /o$
%age " o/ 7ills @anua& "', 2.12 ,%%osition in CV11H."228, the a%%eal o/ the
su$$a& e<iction ,'e1 O12. =hile at the %o%et& to e$o<e the %a'locJ,
Coughlin, on $oe than one occasion, scea$e' %o/anities at ?elissB counsel,
an', at one %oint, chage' ?. 7ill an' atte$%te' to %h&sicall& inti$i'ate hi$. -t
least the au'io o/ this inci'ent Das ca%tue' on ta%e. 1". Ne<etheless, at 51.. %.$.
on 6i'a&, 5ece$Ie 2",2.11, counsel gante' Coughlin an' his agents a''itional,
un/ettee', an' unli$ite' access to the outsi'e o/ the %o%et& to e$o<e an&
e$aining ite$s.O =heeas in his @anua& 2.th, 2.12 sDon 5eclaation 7ill goes
so /a as to in'icate Coughlin O$a'e %h&sical contactO #Dhich is a 'a$n lie
an&Da&s(, in 7illBs then associate Case& BaJe, Esq.Bs NRC* 11 signe' @anua&
"', 2.12 ,%%osition, 74llBs associate BaJe Dill onl& go so /a as to sa& that
Coughlin, Oat one %oint, chage' ?. 7ill an' atte$%te' to %h&sicall& inti$i'ate
hi$.O BaJe Das stan'ing 'iectl& ne0t to 7ill 'uing the inteacation Dhein 7ill
sDoe, un'e %enalt& o/ %eKu&, that Couglhin O$a'e %h&sical contactO Dith 7ill(.
Soun's liJe Case& BaJe, Esq. Das not quite Dilling to Os%ice u%O the sto& line as
7ill hi$sel/ Das. Case& %oIaIl& 'i' not ha<e enough eason to sign on to the lies
aIout Coughlin Ocli$Iing onO the contactoBs tucJ. 4n 7illBs -%%lication /o a
*otection ,'e against Coughlin 7ill sli%s u% an' clai$s that Coughlin Das
Ocli$Iing on the contactoBs tucJ, %icJing though the contentsO IacJ at CouglinBs
/o$e ho$e laD a/te the inteaction at the Otans/e stationO #toDn 'u$%(,
Dheeas 7illBs contacto in'icate' in his -//i'a<it that the allege' Ocli$IingO on
his tucJ occue' at the Otans/e stationO. 7oDe<e, Ioth 7ill an' his contacto,
*hil SteDat in'icate that the Reno *olice 5e%at$ent Oequeste'O that 7ill /ile' a
*otection ,'e -%%lication against Coughlin. 4/ that is tue, its i$%o%e.
+he R*5 can %o<i'e in'i<i'uals in/o$ation aIout seeJing one, Iut Dhen
the R*5 goes a ste% /uthe an' stats uging in'i<i'uals to /ile %otection o'e
a%%lications, o, as has ecentl& Ieen the case Dith R*5 ,//ice -lan =ea<e an'
Sagent ,li<e ?ille, Dho$, u%on in/o$ation an' Ielie/, uge' NothDin'Bs
a%at$ent $aintenance $an ?ilan 9eIs to sign a /au'ulent ci$inal co$%laint
against Coughlin /o O'istuIing the %eaceO on @ul& "', 2.11, an' again uge'
Su%eio ?ini StoageBs ?att :ant to sign a si$ila Iaseless O'istuIing the %eaceO
ci$inal Co$%laint against Coughlin on a%%o0i$atel& Se%te$Ie 21st, 2.12 then
thee is $oe than a little in'ication that the R*5 is out o/ contol an' atte$%ting to
incite $e$Ies o/ the %uIlic to sign /au'ulent ci$inal co$%laints Iase' u%on a
etaliato& ani$us I& the R*5 toDa's Coughlin. ,//ice =ea<e an' Sagent 5&e
shoDe' u% to an unnotice' @ul& 5th, 2.12 Iail heaing /o Coughlin, %esi'e' o<e
- "1F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
I& @u'ge ;in'a :a'neBs Iothe R?C @u'ge =illia$ :a'ne #Dho$ ecei<e'
CoughlinBs ti$el& Notice o/ -%%eal o/ the ci$inal tes%ass con<iction, un'e NRS
189..1., &et /aile' to /oDa' it on to the 5istict Cout, Dhich so$eDhat ecentl&
'is$isse' CoughlinBs a%%eal in that $atte, Dheein Sagent 5&e an' ,//ice
=ea<e testi/ie' un'e oath, Dith Cit& -ttone& @ill 5aJe singing IacJu%, the the
e//ect' that, 'es%ite Iail onl& Ieing <ali' Iase' u%on one eason in Ne<a'a #to
secue the 'e/en'antBs atten'ance at tial( the O%uIlic health an' sa/et&O 'ictate'
inceasing the cash equie' to Iail out Couglin +EN6,;5, /o$ a Ion'aIle
V1,415 to a C-S7 ,N;8 V",....
Consequentl&, u%on @u'ge :a'ne so i$%e$issiIl& aising CoughlinBs Iail,
alleging a O%uIlic health an' sa/et&O ationale /o so 'oing, Couglin Das /oce' to
s%en' 18 'a&s in Kail, Dheein the o%%otunit& to ti$el& contest the V4.,.5.
attone& /ees aDa' to Richa' 7ill inci'ent to the su$$a& e<iction a%%eal an, all
Dhile Coughlin Das 'enie' an& o%%otunit& to access Kustice o /ile 'ocu$ents
/o$ Kail, an' Dhee Coughlin sustaine' sign/icant 'a$ages, /inancial an'
otheDise, an' Dhee the Kail e/use' to tans%ot Coughlin to a heaing on a
lan'lo' tenant $atte Dheein he Das a na$e' %at&.
6uthe 7ill Kust /lat out lies in his @anua& "', 2.12 ,%%osition to
-$en'e' ?otion /o E$egenc& Restaining ,'e. =ell, he 'i' tell the tuth
Dhen he Dote, on %age "1 O11. ,n 6i'a&, 5ece$Ie 2",2.11, counsel /o ?eliss
neglecte' to e$o<e the %a'locJ to the IacJ gate o/ the %o%et&.O +hat is tue, he
'i' 'o that, an' it 'i' %e<ent Coughlin /o$ e$o<ing all his %o%et& 'uing the
scant 1" hous Coughlin ha' to $o<e it. But, Dhen 7ill sDeas, on %age ", that1
OCoughlinBs access to the house itsel/ Das ne<e hin'ee'.1O he is Kust Osi%%inB
'anJO o so$ething, as, oI<iousl& /ailing to e$o<e a locJ on a gate gonna ten' to
ha<e that e//ect, noD...an' Dhen 7ill sDeas1 O 1". Ne<etheless, at 51.. %.$. on
- "2F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
6i'a&, 5ece$Ie 2",2.11, counsel gante' Coughlin an' his agents a''itional,
un/ettee', an' unli$ite' access to the outsi'e o/ the %o%et& to e$o<e an&
e$aining ite$s. +he onl& con'ition %lace' on that access Das that CoughlinBs
hel%es agee' to e%lace the gate on its hinges as Iest the& coul'. Coughlin an' his
agents /aile' to e$o<e the e$ain'e o/ CoughinBs %o%et& /o$ the &a' that
night, an' /aile' to %ut the gate IacJ on the hinges.O Coughlin Das ne<e $a'e
aDae o/ an& such Oo//eO I& 7ill, an', e<en i/ he ha' Ieen, he&, itBs the Ooutsi'e o/
the %o%et&O, Rich, %eo%le geneall& %ut thei <aluaIles insi'e, &ou JnoDT
+hen the 7ill %e<aication an' oI/uscation e0%ess JicJs into o<e'i<e, Dhen,
in his @anua& "', 2.12 ,%%osition he continues on1 OC. Coughlin is Not Entitle'
to - Sta& Coughlin clai$s to ha<e 'e%osite' V25. Dith the KusticeBs cout %usuant
to NRS 4.."85, although he has not %o<i'e' an& %oo/ in su%%ot o/ his clai$.
-ttache' heeto as EG74B4+ 1. is a tue an' coect co%& o/ the KusticeBs coutBs
'ocJet as o/ 5ece$Ie 19, 2.11. +hat 'ocJet shoDs that Coughlin %ai' a /iling /ee
/o his a%%eal on 5ece$Ie 12, 2.11, in the a$ount o/ V212....O =ell, actuall&,
@u'ge S/eaCCa Dai<e' the @ustice CoutBs V24... /iling /ee, an' the V212...
e%esents the 5istict CoutBs /iling /ee, an' its not eall& clea Dhethe that 'ate is
Dhen the checJ Das cashe' I& the 5istict Cout, o Dhethe the @ustice Cout hel'
on to the checJ /o quit4e aDhile Ie/oe shi%%ing it along Dith the R,- to the
5istict Cout, etc., etc. 7ill continues1 O4t is entiel& unclea /o$ the /olloDing
enties o/ that 'ocJet Dhethe o Dhen Coughlin e<e %ai' an a''itional V25....
un'e NRS 4.."85.O +hat $ight, technicall& Ie tue, Rich, to the e0tent that &ou
Dote it on @anua& "', 2.12, an' ae sneaJil& in'icating that &ou ae looJing at an
ol' 'ocJet /o$ the @ustice Cout /o$ 5ece$Ie 19th, 2.12, e<en though
Coughlin $a'e a Iig 'eal to &ou an' the @ustice Cout, in Diting, that he Das
'e%ositing the V25.... su%ese'eas Ion' $entione' in NRS 4.."85, on 5ece$Ie
22n', 2.11, a /act Dhich 7ill hi$sel/ $entions in his oDn /ilings...So, Jin' o/ a
lacJ o/ can'o to the tiIunal thee to $aJe all this agu$ent Iase' u%on so$e ol'
'ocJet an' the e0tent to Dhich it /ails to e<eal o O$aJe cleaO $attes to Dhich
7ill ha' ea'& Ditten notice o/ <ia his oDn eH6le0 account an' se<ice o/ /ilings
u%on hi$ connecte' theeto, in a''ition to CoughlinBs /a0es, e$ails, an' thee
$ight ha<e e<en Ieen a se<ice o/ a Notice o/ *osting Su%ese'eas Bon' #nee' to
checJ on that $oe(, etc. in connection Dith the 'e%ositing on 5ece$Ie 22n'
2.12, the V25. equie' /o a sta& 'uing a%%eal o/ a su$$a& e<iction in NRS
- ""F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4.."85. -n', actuall&, 7ill sli%%e' u% a Iit thee, in light o/ the /olloDing1 -n',
actuall&, 7ill, in his @anua& 2.th, 2.12 /iling, a'$itte' that Coughlin sent hi$ that
5ece$Ie 22n', 2.11 e$ail noti/&ing hi$ o/ the %osting o/ the V25. su%ese'eas
Ion' seeJing a sta&, Dhen he a'$its, on %age "1 O11. *usuant to EG74B4+ 2,
Coughlin Das %o<i'e' access to the *o%et& on +hus'a&, 5ece$Ie 22, 2.11.
+hat 'a&, Coughlin sent an e$ail to the un'esigne' an' @u'ge S/eaCCa, in Dhich
he essentiall& announce' that he Das entitle' to a sta&, an' to etun to an' continue
in %ossession o/ the *o%et&. @u'ge S/eaCCa quicJl& es%on'e' I& e$ail, an'
e$in'e' ?. Coughlin that the sta& ha' Ieen 'enie'.O 6oun' in E0hiIit 1 is the
5ece$Ie 22n' e$ail to 7illBs ,//ice that alets the$ to the %osting o/ V25. ,
s%eci/ie' as a Osu%ese'eas Ion'O, Dith a citation to NRS 4.."851
7illBs @anua& "', 2.12 ,%%osition continues, on %age 81 OE<en i/ Coughlin
e<entuall& %ai' so$e a$ount toDa' an a%%eal Ion', it Das not in ti$e to sta& the
e<iction 'uing this a%%eal. +o 'o that, a %o%e $otion $ust Ie $a'e an' gante',
an' the Ion' %oste', %io to the locJout. +he locJout hee occue' on No<e$Ie
1, 2.11. B& the ti$e Coughlin $anage' to /in' that statute an' %a& an& $one& to
the cout, he ha' Ieen locJe' out o/ the %o%et& /o si0 DeeJs. -s such, an&
equest /o a sta& Das, an' is, $oot. -t this %oint, Coughlin 'oes not ha<e an&
ights in eithe the eal o %esonalO. ,''l&, -n<ui saD a sta& gante' a/te a
locJout Das con'ucte', an' 7ill #R*C ".1 O$eitoious contentionO issues( cites to
no legal authoit& /o his contention that Oto sta& the e<iction 'uing this a%%eal...a
%o%e $otion $ust Ie $a'e an' gante', an' the Ion' %ose', %io to the locJout.O
CitationT None.
5es%ite 7illBs stange a%%oach o/ not actuall& in'icating that his o//ice 'i'
not get an 5ece$Ie 22n', 2.11 e$ail noti/&ing the$ o/ the %osting o/ V25. /o a
su%ese'eas Ion' seeJing a sta& un'e NRS 118-."85 #Iut athe, 7ill /ocuses on
Dhat one cannot glean /o$ looJing at a 'ate' 'ocJet...(, 7illBs ,//ice Das $a'e
aDae o/ such $attes, in Diting, in the /olloDing 5ece$Ie 22n' e$ail to 7illBs
,//iee1 O...6uthe, this is all $oot at this %oint as 4 ha<e /ile' a Su%ese'eas Bon'
o/ V25., an' acco'ing to NRS 4.."85, 4 auto$aticall& get a sta& o/ e<iction an'
a$ entitle' to etun to the %o%et& an' continue in %ossession. +he statute sets the
Su%ese'eas Bon' #Dhich &iel's a sta&( at V25. i/ ent is un'e V1..., unless the
Cout Dishes to ule that 4 a$ a co$$ecial tenant. 7oDe<e, i/ the cout 'oes ule
that 4 a$ a co$$ecial tenant, the No Cause E<iction Notice in this case, un'e
NRS 4..25" $aJes a Su$$a& E<iction *ocee'ing i$%e$issiIle, as Su$$a&
E<iction *ocee'ings ae not alloDe' against co$$ecial tenants Dhee onl& a No
Cause E<iction Notice is /ile'. 4ts one o the othe, Iut ?. 7ill an' BaJe cannot
ha<e it Ioth Da&s. 6uthe, the Couts ,'e o/ 5ece$Ie 21, 2.11 is Kust that, an'
,'e, its not an agee$ent, its not a settle$ent, etc, etc. an' the au'io eco'
cleal& e/lects that. NRS 4.."85 Sta& o/ e0ecution u%on a%%ealA 'ut& o/ tenant Dho
etains %ossession o/ %e$ises to %a& ent 'uing sta&. )%on an a%%eal /o$ an
o'e entee' %usuant to NRS 4..25"1 1. E0ce%t as otheDise %o<i'e' in this
suIsection, a sta& o/ e0ecution $a& Ie oItaine' I& /iling Dith the tial cout a Ion'
- "4F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
in the a$ount o/ V25. to co<e the e0%ecte' costs on a%%eal. 4n an action
concening a lease o/ co$$ecial %o%et& o an& othe %o%et& /o Dhich the
$onthl& ent e0cee's V1,..., the cout $a&, u%on its oDn $otion o that o/ a %at&,
an' u%on a shoDing o/ goo' cause, o'e an a''itional Ion' to Ie %oste' to co<e
the e0%ecte' costs on a%%eal. - suet& u%on the Ion' suI$its to the Kuis'iction o/
the a%%ellate cout an' ie<ocaIl& a%%oints the cleJ o/ that cout as the suet&Bs
agent u%on Dho$ %a%es a//ecting the suet&Bs liaIilit& u%on the Ion' $a& Ie
se<e'. ;iaIilit& o/ a suet& $a& Ie en/oce', o the Ion' $a& Ie elease', on
$otion in the a%%ellate cout Dithout in'e%en'ent action. 2. - tenant Dho etains
%ossession o/ the %e$ises that ae the suIKect o/ the a%%eal 'uing the %en'enc& o/
the a%%eal shall %a& to the lan'lo' ent in the a$ount %o<i'e' in the un'el&ing
contact IetDeen the tenant an' the lan'lo' as it Ieco$es 'ue. 4/ the tenant /ails to
%a& such ent, the lan'lo' $a& initiate neD %ocee'ings /o a su$$a& e<iction I&
se<ing the tenant Dith a neD notice %usuant to NRS 4..25". Sinceel&, Zach
Coughlin, Esq.O. ,h, an' 7ill an' SteDat a'$it to this in a <i'eo. Richa' 7illBs
contacto, /o so$e stange eason, e$o<e' a la''e Coughlin oDns /o$ the
%o%et&, %e<enting CoughlinBs access to the attic u%on his Ieing alloDe' that scant
1" hous to e$o<e his %o%et& #an' the attic ha' Ieen eno<ate' to alloD /o
stoage o/ a consi'eaIle a$ount o/ %o%et&. 4/ Coughlin Das 7ill he Doul' ha<e
calle' the R*5 to e%ot the Olacen&O o/ his la''e I& 7ill, in a R4C, thing Dith
his contacto. But 7ill esca%e' %osecution that ti$e, o<e the& Dhole la''e 'eal.
4t ne<e Das $a'e clea Dh& the contacto e$o<e' the la''e /o$ the %o%et&,
othe than, %eha%s, liJe the a%%l&ing o/ a locJ to the IacJ&a' gate, $aJe it e<en
$oe unliJel& that Coughlin Doul' Ie aIle to e$o<e all he nee'e' to, es%eciall&
gi<en the li$ite' /un's /o $o<ing <ehicles an' hie' hel%, in the scant 1" hous
alloDe' un'e the 5ece$Ie 21st, 2.12 ,'e.
-lso, this is a co$%laint against 7ill an' his contacto /o %ett& lacen& o/ the
la''e /o$ CoughlinBs /o$e laD o//ice, a'$itte' to on ta%e on 5ece$Ie 22n',
2.11 I& 7ill #though the issue o/ Dhethe the& inten'e' to O%e$anentl& 'e%i<eO
Coughlin o/ the use an' enKo&$ent theeo/ $a& Ie goun's /o 'eIate, 7ill shoul'
get to s%en' the ne0t 12 $onths 'e/en'ing hi$sel/ as Coughlin has /o$ the
onslaught o/ SBN, =C5-, an' Cit& o/ Reno %osecuto
in<estigation...otheDise...gee, 'oesnBt it Jin'a Ieing to $in' CoughlinBs question to
R*5 ,//ice Chis Cate, @. Dhile Coughlin Das in cu//s 'uing the custo'ial
aest o/ No<e$Ie 1"th, 2.11 Dhen Coughlin asJe' ,//ice Cate1 Oae &ou on
Richa' 7illBs %a&oll tooTO. Coughlin has /aith/ull& e%ote' on e0actl& Dhat
,//ice CateBs es%onse Das, hoDe<e illHa'<ise' a sacastic es%onse he $a&
clai$ it to ha<e Ieen. 7ill has /aile' to /aith/ull& e%ot on Kust Dhat he $eant
Dhee he /ile' 'ocu$ents attesting to ha<e /oun' Oa cacJ %i%e an' a Iag o/ Dee'O,
a O<ial o/ so$e sotO, an' Oa lage quantit& o/ %illsO an' O'ugsO in CoughlinBs
/o$e ho$e laD o//ice.
- "5F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Res%ecting CoughlinBs Ditten co$$unications to 74llBs o//ice concening
CoughlinBs e0%ess e/usal to acce%t electonic notice o se<ice o/ an&thing /o$
74llBs ,//ice, inclu'es the /olloDing1
6o$1 Zach Coughlin Q$ailto1Cachcoughlin3hot$ail.co$R
Sent1 ?on'a&, No<e$Ie 21, 2.11 411. *?
+o1 c'IaJe3icha'hillaD.co$
SuIKect1 RE1 ?eliss <. Coughlin
Case&, coul'nBt o%en the$, an' e<en i/ 4 coul', 4 'onBt consent to
se<ice I& e$ail o/ %lea'ings, no I& /a0. 4 ha<e tol' &ou that $an& ti$es. 4 Dill
/ile a ?otion /o Sanctions i/ &ou 'o not cease atte$%ting to cicu$<ent the
%oce'ual %otections acco'e' tenants. +he onl& $atte /o Dhich 4 consent to
ha<ing &ou o &ou o//ice contact $e I& e$ail, is to tell $e i/ an' Dhen 4 can get
$& e0igent clientFlaD %actice $ateialsFstate issue' i'enti/ication, etc. 4 e/use to
acce%t se<ice o/ %lea'ings an' $otions &ou Dish to sling though the couts at
Da% s%ee' Dhile Dithhol'ing $& $ail an' Dallet. Co$e onY 8ou Iette than
thisY
Zach Coughlin, Esq.HHHHHHHHHHHH
6o$1 Cachcoughlin3hot$ail.co$
+o1 %aticJJ3n<Ia.ogA 'a<i'c3n<Ia.ogA n<sccleJ3n<couts.n<.go<
SuIKect1 ;4+4:-+4,N 7,;5 N,+4CE e<2.11H..17.8 c<11H."228, 2.""1
21"8"
5ate1 ?on, 15 ,ct 2.12 171."1"4 H.7..
?. 9ing,
+his Diting $e$oialiCes, in %at, ou con<esation aIout &ou /ailue to
in<estigate, in an& eal Da&, the ci$inal tes%ass allegations, in <iolation o/ the
ClaiIone 'ecision. )%on $& asJing &ou %ointe' questions, &ou huie'l& /ile' a
SCR 111 *etition in an atte$%t to e0cuse &ou /ailue to asJ an& o/ the %ointe'
questions 4 ha<e %e<iousl& %ut /oth to &ou ega'ing that ci$inal tes%ass $atte,
/uthe &ou a'$itte' to Ieing unaDae #allege'l&( o/ the /a$ilial elation IetDeen
@u'ge =illia$ :a'ne an' @u'ge ;in'a :a'ne #'es%ite that Ieing quite clea in
$& ecent /ilings to &ou(.
8ou $ight Dant to looJ at -B222 an' the Co$$ittee on the @u'icia& notes
/o$ ?ach "1, 2.11.
+his coes%on'ence e$in's &ou o/ an' /uthe %laces &ou on notice o/ that
the /act that &ou ha<e Ieen %lace' on a ;4+4:-+4,N 7,;5 N,+4CE. +7E
V45E, 64;?E5 B8 R4C7-R5 74;; ,6 +7E REN, *,;4CE
5E*-R+?EN+BS C7R4S C-R+ER -N5 S-R:EN+ ;,*EZ 4N +7E +4?E
*R4,R +, +7E ;-N5;,R5, ?ER;4SS -;;E:E5;8 94C94N: 5,=N +7E
5,,R, 4S ,6 ?-+ER4-;;8 RE;EV-NCE +, SEVER-; C4V4; ;-=S)4+S
-N5 CR4?4N-; *R,CEE54N:S. R4C7-R5 ;4E5 4N C,)R+, )N5ER
,-+7 =7EN 7E +ES+464E5 +7-+ +7E R*5 -NN,)NCE5 +7E?SE;VES
- "2F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-S ;-= EN6,RCE?EN+ -N5 ,R5ERE5 C,):7;4N +, C,?E ,)+ ,6
+7E B-SE?EN+ *R4,R +, +7E 5,,R BE4N: 94C9E5 4N. R4C7-R5
SEN5S +7E S+-+E B-R ,6 NEV-5- ;E++ERS ,N
6)R+7ER, ,664CER C-R+ERBS *,;4CE RE*,R+ 4S
5E?,NS+R-+E5 +, BE 6);; ,6 ;4ES B8 +7E VER8 V45E,S +7-+
74;; *R,*,)N5E5 +, +7E C4+8 ,6 REN, *R,SEC)+,RS,
*-R+4C);-R;8 =4+7 RES*EC+ +, =7E+7ER C,):7;4N RE6)SE5 +,
;E-VE -6+ER BE4N: =-RNE5 ,R +,;5 +, 5, S, -N5 +7E EG+EN+
+, =74C7 C-R+ER =-S )N-B;E +, 4SS)E - C4+-+4,N ,R RE;8 ,N
- S4?*;E =-RN4N: 4N ;4:7+ +7ERE,6. C,):7;4N -C+)-;;8 -S9S
C-R+ER 4N +7E V45E, 74;; 64;?E5 =78 7E 5,ESNB+ @)S+ 4SS)E
S)C7 - =-RN4N: ,R C4+-+4,N. +hen, Cate goes on to atte$%t to o//e
his <ieDs on Ose<iceO, hoDe<e u'i$enta& the& $a& Ie. Ieing cae/ul to note to
Coughlin O&ouBe not the <icti$ hee.O +o the e0tent that 7ill an' ?eliss tes%ass
into CoughlinBs /o$e laD o//ice on this 'ate, Dith the hel% o/ the R*5, Sol'al <
CooJ Count& has Ieen <iolate', an' Cate an' ;o%eC ha<e <iolate' =heele <
Coss.
-n& E<iction ,'e signe' I& @u'ge S/eaCCa Das stale in light o/ the
/ailue to ha<e the locJout o'e se<e' u%on Coughlin an' a locJout %e/o$e'
ODithin 24 housO o/ the Shei//Bs ecei%t o/ the ,'e o/ Ioth ,ct 25th, 2.11 #the
si$%le one %age ,'e signe' I& @u'ge S/eaCCa an' notate' in his oDn
han'Diting( an' o the ,ctoIe 27th, 2.11 6in'ings o/ 6act, Conclusions o/ ;aD,
an' ,'e /o Su$$a& E<iction( Ioth o/ Dhich Dee ecei<e' I& the =CS, Dell
o<e 24 hous /o$ Dhen the locJoutBs Dee con'ucte', an' thee/oe, Ioth such
,'es Dee stale, an' thee/oe, Richa' :. 7ill, Esq. co$$itte' tes%ass u%on
CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//ice, theD aDa& a geat 'eal o/ CoughlinBs
%esonalt& #so$e o/ it <e& senti$ental(, an' Ioth 7ill an' BaJe ha<e lie'
e%eate'l& in cout /ilings in in'icating that Coughlin Das se<e' the Su$$a&
E<iction ,'e on No<e$Ie 1st, 2.11 Dee the& also a'$it that Coughlin Das not
at his /o$e ho$e laD o//ice at the ti$e =CS, 5e%ut& ?achen %oste' it on the
'oo theeo/ an' e//ectuate' a locJout #an' ?achen lie' un'e oath in his
No<e$Ie 7th, 2.11 /ile' -//i'a<it o/ Se<ice attesting to ha<e O%esonall& se<e'O
Coughlin the Su$$a& E<iction ,'e on No<e$Ie 1st, 2.11 #=CS, Ci<il
5i<ision Su%e<iso a'$itte' as $uch to Coughlin in Diting1
NRS 4..25"1 5. )%on nonco$%liance Dith the notice1 #a( ...+he cout $a&
theeu%on issue an o'e 'iecting the shei// o constaIle o/ the count& to e$o<e
the tenant Dithin 24 hous a/te ecei%t o/ the o'e. +he a//i'a<it $ust state o
contain1
6uthe Dhee is $& 'a$age 'e%osit #eithe V5.., o, aguaIl& V7.. gi<en
the e0tent to Dhich the Stan'a' Rental -gee$ent a//o'e' $e the choice Dith
es%ect to hoD cleaning Das to Ie 'one an' the e0tent to Dhich 7ill an' BaJe ha<e
/aile' to co$%l& Dith
- "7F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
?. BaJe, &ou ha<e co$$itte' %o/essional $iscon'uct #an' 7ill /ile' a
gie<ance against $e in a lette to the SBN 'ate' @anua& 14th, 2.12 %u%oting to
Ie sent on &ou Iehal/ in O/ul/illing &ou R*C ".8 oIligationO...si$%& %ut, ?.
BaJe, in &ou ,%%osition to ?,tion to constest *esonal *o%et& ;ien in
Re<2.11H..17.8, on %age 5, &ou lie Dhee &ou Dite ODhen Coughlin e/use' to
e$ege /o$ the Iase$ent a/te Ieing o'ee' to 'o so I& the %olice, ?eliss Das
/oce' to JicJ 'oDn the 'oo to gain access to his oDn %o%et&O. 8ou JnoD that
that is not tue. +he Reno *olice 5e%at$ent 'i' not i'enti/& the$sel<es as laD
en/oce$ent o otheDise issue an laD/ul ,'es 'iecting Coughlin to Oe$ege
/o$ the Iase$entO. 8ou ha<e 'e$onstate' a lacJ o/ can'o to the tiIunal in that
ega' in cons%iac& Dith Richa' 7ill. 4n a <i'eota%e' inte<ieD, R*5 Sagent
;o%eC a'$its that neithe she no ,//ice Cate, no an&one else that 'a&,
i'enti/ie' the$sel<es in an& Da& to Coughlin in the OIase$entO o otheDise issue'
hi$ an& sot o/ ODaning to lea<eO o Oo'e to e$egeO o/ an& sot, Dhatsoe<e.
?. BaJe, &ou Dee not e<en thee. 8et, &ou <ieDe' the <i'eo taJen I& Richa'
7ill o/ the $o$ents in question Dhee the R*5 Dee at the Iase$ent 'oo %io to
5. ?eliss JicJing it 'oDn, inclu'ing those $o$ents Dhee 5. ?eliss is seen in
one <i'eo Dhis%eing to Richa' 7ill. 4/ thee eall& Das all this i'enti/&ing
the$sel<es as laD en/oce$ent an' issuing Coughlin an o'e to e$ege Dhich
Dent unhee'e', then Dh& the Dhis%eingT =h& 'i' Richa' /ail to inclu'e the he
tooJ o/ the $o$ents Dhee the R*5 Dee at the OIase$entO 'oo an /aile' to
i'enti/& the$sel<es o issue an& laD/ul ,'esT 7oD Doul' Coughlin JnoD that
an& <oices that $a& ha<e Ieen au'iIle 'i' not si$%l& Ielong to $oe o/ the goons
7ill an' BaJe outinel& hie /o$ Ne<a'a Cout Se<ices to tes%ass Iehin'
CoughlinBs /o$e ho$e laD o//iceBs IacJ&a' gate, <isiting in %ais, thees ti$es a
'a&, one inging the 'oo Iell e%eate'l& /o ". $inutes at a ti$e, Dhile the othe
#R. =a&, @oel 5u'en, an' othe license' %ocess se<es( tes%asses Iehin' a a
latche' IacJ&a' gate an' Iangs on Din'oDs an' %ees though close' Ilin's Dhile
issuing theats inten'e' to in'icate the& ae Ieing $a'e I& so$eone Dith colo o/
laD Iehin' thei Do's, Dhile 'esse' u% in an out/it s%eci/icall& inten'e' to
con/use the %uIlic into thinJing these %ocess se<es ae Shei//Bs 5e%utiesT
Rega'less, the eal /l& in the oint$ent is the /act that R*5 Sagent ;o%eC
a'$itte' that neithe she, no Cate, no an&one else i'enti/ie' the$sel<es as laD
en/oce$ent an' o issue' Coughlin an o'e to e$ege /o$ the OIase$entO.
4n'ee', in 7illBs 5eclaation in RE<2.11H..17.8, /ile' a scant 7 'a&s a/te the
aest, 7ill cetainl& /ails to $ention an& such allege' $o$ent Dhee the R*5
i'enti/& the$sel<es as laD en/oce$ent an' issue Coughlin an o'e to e$ege
%io to ?eliss JicJing the 'oo in. 7ill Dites lettes to the SBN accusing
Coughlin o/ ha<ing a OcacJ %i%e an' Iag o/ Dee'O an' Olage quantit& o/ %illsO
#the <i'eos 7ill tooJ that 'a& e<eal those O%illsO ae <ita$ins, so$ething 7ill /ails
to clai/& Dith the SBN, an' 7ill ne<e has %o<i'e' an& sot o/ in'ication o/ Dhat
the OcacJ %i%e an' Iag o/ Dee'O looJe' liJe e0actl&, no has he es%on'e' to
- "8F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
equests /o %hotoga%hs theeo/, o $a'e in'ication Dh& he 'i' not call the %olice,
gi<en the /act that he has in<ol<e' laD en/oce$ent at e<e& othe %ossiIle tun.
7ill an' BaJe ha<e continue' to /ail to 'eli<e CoughlinBs secuit& 'e%osit, an' in
'oing so, Dhee the& /aile' to %o<i'e the equisite coes%on'ence Dithin ". 'a&s
o/ an& such e<iction, ha<e <iolate' Ne<a'a laD1
NRS 118-.242 Secuit&1 ;i$itation on a$ount o <alueA suet& Ion' in lieu
o/ secuit&A 'uties an' liaIilit& o/ lan'lo'A 'a$agesA 'is%uting ite$iCe' accounting
o/ secuit&A %ohiIite' %o<isions.$$
?Bs. BaJe an' 7ill, Doul' &ou not sa& it $oe accuate to chaacteiCe the
situation in e<2.11H..17.8 as one /itting un'e the NRS 118-."55 hea'ing,
%aticula& Dhee the R@C, at the ti$e o/ that su$$a& e<iction O+ialO ha',
acco'ing to @u'ge S/eaCCa, no Olocal uleO o O$echanis$ I& Dhich tenants $a&
'e%osit ent Dithhel' un'e %aaga%h...O an' the/oe acJnoDle'ging the Iilliance
in CoughlinBs @CR;V Rule 44 coolla& in the R@C agu$entT Cetainl&, un'e the
NRS 118-."55 anal&sis, a/te one sti%s aDa& the agee' to V"5. /o Dee's
$aintenance #Dhich Jin' o/ a$ounts to a Dai<e o/ te$ in the Stan'a' Rental
-gee$ent that @u'ge S/eaCCa inte%ets to equie such OcaeO o/ the OlaDn an'
suoun'ing goun'sO #Dhich, to the Cout, a%%aentl&, inclu'e' ODee'sO(, 'oesnBt
itT(, an' the agee' u%on ce'it /o /i0ing the stais, Dell, then, an' othe a$ounts
/it quite nicel& into the O/i0 an' 'e'uctO a%%oach set /oth in NRS 118-."2..
But, ega'less, &ou %ocee'e' un'e a No Cause E<iction Iasis, Iut against a
co$$ecial tenant, a /act &ou ae stucJ Dith, as the +enantBs -nsDe, nu$eous
%hone calls to BaJe, an' $an&, $an& instances thoughout the /ilings in that
$atte $aJe clea thta this Das CoughlinBs ho$e laD o//ice, a co$$ecial lease
Dhich the Stan'a' Rental -gee$ent s%eci/icall& alloDs /o. -n' taJe a looJ at
that 2..8 =inchell < Schi// sea/oo' Iusiness goes un'e Iecause o/ Dong/ul
e<iction case Dheein 'a$ages accounting /o the loss o/ oneBs entie Iusiness #an'
Dhat is a %atent attone&Bs Iusiness Doth, 'o &ou thinJ, 5. ?elissT( ae alloDaIle
un'e Ne<a'a laD. *lease e$it V45.,... to $e Dithin 7 'a&s o/ this e$ail Ieing
sent to &ou in satis/action o/ this 'is%ute against &ou, 5. ?eliss. Richa' an'
Case&, 4 Dill 'eal Dith &ou late, Iut &ou liaIilit& is on %a Dith 5. ?elissBs, no
'ouIt, an' that is Ie/oe the 65C*- stu// an' the /act that &ou o//ice is not
license' as a Iill collecto. HZach CoughlinO
22. 1as+# on M!. ;ill<s +8p+!i+n+ an# "a32!o4n#: his revie* of the
pleadin!s in th+ liti2ation "+tw++n =!. M+!liss an# Co42hlin and his revie* of
the pleadin!s in Cou!hlin"s liti!ation *ith Washoe .e!al Services, ?. 7ill is o/
the o%inion that Coughlin is not competent to practice la*. See +ansci%t o/
7eaing =e'nes'a&, No<e$Ie 14, 2.12, * "9, ; 1H12.
#7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*age "911 to "9112( > -n' as a esult o/ &ou
'ealings Dith ?. Coughlin, 'i' &ou /o$ an o%inion as to his competency to be a
la*yerT ?R. C,):7;4N1 O">+tion. Calls for a le!al conclusion. /xpert
- "9F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
testimony. I #on<t "+li+6+ M!. ;ill is ?4ali5i+#. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 ,<eule'.
+7E =4+NESS1 8es, 4 'i'. B8 ?R. 94N:1 > -n' letBs stat Dith &ou
conclusion, an' then DoJ IacJDa's. 4s ?. Coughlin co$%etent to Ie a laD&eT
- No, he is not.N(
#N,+E1 =hile the 5F"1F12 SCR 117 *etition that NN5B Chai$an Susich
/ile' #Dhich lagel& co%ie' an' %aste', liJe 9ingBs 8F2"F12 Co$%laint, the
%u%ote' 1F14F12 unsigne', unsDon gie<ance 7ill %u%ote'l& e$aile' #onl&( to
9ing( $ight %lea' such, 9ingBs 8F2"F1" Co$%laint neithe alleges, no is this
/o$al 'isci%lina& heaing the setting /o, an e0a$ination o/ Dhethe Coughlin is
Mco$%etent to %actice laDN o Mco$%etent to Ie a laD&eN. +he *anel an' 9ing
consistentl& <iolate' R*C ".1, ".", an' ".4, in a''ition to R*C 8.1 in /ailing to
a%%oach the R*C 1.1 #'ut& to %o<i'e co$%etent e%esentation to clients, Dhee,
unliJe, sa&, a Ia e0a$ination, the inqui& is not a geneal one equiing a
%actitione to 'e$onstate Ioa' scale co$%etenc& at the %actice o/ laD, Iut,
athe, tagete' an' /ocuse' on 'ete$ining Dhethe in so$e %aticula, s%eci/ic
instance, an attone& /aile' to %o<i'e a client e%esentation that $et the
equie$ent to 'o so un'e R*C 1.1. +he SBN o//ee' aIsolutel& no e<i'ence that
Coughlin e<e %o<i'e' an& such e%esentation to an& client #N,+E1 67E"Bs #an'
all othe e0hiIits such M/in'ings o/ /actN( ae not Me<i'enceN an' the *anel
co$$itte' e<esiIle eo in so chaacteiCing o teating such as Me<i'enceN in the
Iu'en o/ %oo/ calculus. 4n Re Santosuosso, 4n e =eiss.(.
2". Based on Mr. Hill's experience in litigating #N,+E1 7ill actuall&
Das /oce' to a'$it that his associate, BaJe, han'le' the su$$a& e<iction in
17.8 in the Kustice cout as Dell as the a%%eal theeo/ to the 'istict cout, Dith 7ill
altenating IetDeen allegeing in his 5eclaations in the a%%eal in su%%ot o/ a /ee
aDa' that he ha' onl& e<ieDe' BaJeBs /ilings, onl& to then allege' at the
'isci%lina& heaing o/ 11F14F12 that he ha' ea' M<ituall& e<e&thingN Coughlin
/ile', onl& to to late #u%on Ieing caught in a lie he has tol' again an' again, ie, that
Coughlin M/aile' to aise the issue in the tial coutN es%ecting the i$%e$issiIilit&
o/ utiliCing su$$a& e<iction %oce'ues un'e NRS 4..254 against a co$$ecial
tenant Dhee such su$$a& action Das not Iought u%on an allegation o/ nonH
%a&$ent o/ ent( allege that he MDasnBt theeN in the tial cout an' ha' not ea' o
listene' to the tansci%t #'es%ite Coughlin %o<i'ing his /i$ Dith co%ies o/ all the
au'io o/ e<e& heaing in the tial cout in 17.8...so...as /a as 7illBs si$%l&
ansDeing MnoN to 9ingBs o<eti$e questions ega'ing Dhethe Coughlin Das
Mtuth/ulN Dith the cout o o%%osing counsel, Dith nothing in the Da& o/ s%eci/ics,
Ieing so$ehoD su//icient to su%%ot a M/in'ing o/ /actN $uch less a Mconclusion o/
laDN that Coughlin <iolate' an& %aticula R*C...Dell, such sa&s $oe aIout the
*anel than an&thing, eall&( Dith Coughlin, Coughlin Das not truthful with +ith+!
counsel o! th+ court. See +ansci%t o/ 7eaing =e'nes'a&, No<e$Ie 14, 2.12, *
5", ; 2H12.
#7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*age 5"15 to 5"112( B8 ?R. 94N:1 > ;et $e estate
the question. +he question is1 -s an attone&, ha<ing a es%onsiIilit& to Ie tuth/ul
- 4.F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an' to ha<e can'o Dith o%%osing counsel, Das ?. Coughlin tuth/ul, an' 'i' he
use can'o Dith &ouT - #Richa' :. 7ill, Esq.( No. ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 M!.
@in2: w!ap it 4p: pl+as+. Yo4<!+ limit+# to $9 min4t+s. B8 ?R. 94N:1 >
S%eci/icall& elating to ?. CoughlinBs can'o to the cout, 'i' he shoD can'o to
the coutsT - No.N(
?. 7ill /elt that CoughlinBs /ilings Dee aIusi<e, at one %oint calling ?.
7illBs associate a lichen. #N,+E1 actuall&, CoughlinBs e$ail to 7ill utiliCe' the
te$ MlycanN, as in so$e t&%e o/ DeeDol/ to 'esciIe 7ill an' BaJeBs Ra$Io
;itigato a%%oach an' the 'a$aging, in a%%o%iate natue theeo/...Dhich is /a
'i//eent than calling one a MlichenN( Coughlin has accused ,r. 0ill of bribin! the
eno 1olice 2epartment to ha<e Coughlin aeste'. ?. 7illBs sta// is teoiCe' I&
Coughlin. See =e'nes'a&, No<e$Ie 14, 2.12, * 54, ; 4H15.
#7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*age 541" to 54115( B8 ?R. 94N:1 > =ith ega'
to a %eson %eha%s HH to the e0tent that ?. Coughlin $a& ha<e e0hiIite' these Ia'
Ieha<ios, Das he otheDise Jin' in his 'ealings Dith &ou an' 5. ?elissT Coul'
&ou e0%lain, Kust Iie/l&, to the %anel his actual 'e$eano Dith ega' to his
'ealings Dith &ou an' &ou clientT - 7is eH$ails, his /ilings Dee aIusi<e, to sa&
the least. Calling $& HH he calle' $& associate a lichen. 4Bll a'$it De all ha' to
eteat to the 'ictiona& on that one. Name callin!. 7eBs accuse' $e o/ IiIing the
Reno *olice 5e%at$ent to ha<e hi$ aeste'. ?& sta// is aIsolutel& teoiCe' I&
this $an.N(
7illBs e/eing to Coughlin as M=acJ& ZacJ& on CacJ&N 'uing a
con<esation Dith Coughlin $aJes 7illBs oIKection to the chaacteiCation o/ his
st&le o/ litigation as l&canHesque athe %uCCling, though, cetainl&, the %u%ote'
1F14F12 e$ail /o$ 7ill to the SBN contains so$e tul& 'uIious lies I& 7ill #M2.
=hen the house Das secue' a/te CoughlinBs aest, De /oun' a cacJ %i%e an' a
Iag o/ Dhat a%%eae' to Ie $aiKuana. +he contacto also e%ote' /in'ing a Io0 o/
%ills an' a <ial o/ so$e sot. We understand Cou!hlin has unsuccessfully tried
the .a*yers Concerned for .a*yers pro!ram) and that he has a history of
substance problems.N *age 4 o/ 5 o/ such 1F14F12 M;ette to *aticJ 9ing, Esq.1,
that 9ing Das too e$Iaasse' I& to seeJ to ente into e<i'ence(. #consi'e the
<i'eos that 7ill an' his lan'lo' client /il$e' 'uing thei Iugla& o/ CoughlinBs
/o$e ho$e laD o//ice #at Dhich ti$e the& also lie' to an' Dith R*5 ,//ices to
e//ectuate a /alse aest( on 11F1"F11, %aticulal& in the /olloDing Ieginning at the
se<en $inute $aJ, Dheein the allege' Mlage quantit& o/ %illsN ae e<eale' to Ie
<ita$ins1 htt%1FFDDD.&outuIe.co$FDatchT<U82ZCt2E,i4 . 6uthe, 7ill ne<e
has es%on'e' to CoughlinBs $utlti%le equests to %o<i'e so$ething, an&thing, in
the Da& o/ su%%ot #a %ictue, the ite$s the$sel<es, etc.( to su%%ot his assetion
that MDe /oun' a cacJ %i%e an' a Iag o/ Dhat a%%eae' to Ie
$aiKuanaN...4nteestingl&, a Iag Ma%%eaingN to Ie $aiKuana 'i' not esult in 7ill
$aJing an& assetion as to Dhethe an& such allege' MIagN hel' the ao$a o/
$aiKuana theein o an& othe s%eci/ics o su%%oting /acts(.
- 41F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
- e<ieD o/ the 1F14F12 M;ette to *aticJ 9ing, Esq.N that 7ill %u%ote'l&
e$aile' onl& to the SBN #so$ehoD /a0ing a signe', sDon @u'icial 5isci%line
Co$$ission Co$%laint to ?. SanoDsJi $et Dith no action #MDe 'onBt acce%t
/a0esN(, &et an e$aile', unsigne', unsDon MletteN /o$ 7ill is gi<en the -ct o/
Congess teat$ent( e<eals an inteesting thea' unning thoughout the $atte
noD on a%%eal in 22""71 ?c:eoge School o/ ;aD 1977 class$ates =;SBs *aul
Elcano, NVB @u'ge Beesle&, an' R?C @u'ge Nash 7ol$es.
+hee is Kust so $an& easons Dh& 9ing Das /oce' to /ogo seeJing to ente
into e<i'ence the %u%ote' 1F14F12 unsigne', unsDon, e$aile' onl&, /i<e %age
gie<ance lette I& 7ill to 9ing1 the un'eniaIle i$%ession that a Dhole lot o/
i$%e$issiIle e0taHKu'icial co$$unications $a& Dell Ie going on, 7illBs
i$%loing the Ba to contact <aious cout sta// in'i<i'uals #I& na$e e<en(
cetainl& len's an i$%ession that 7ill has, o is i$%l&ing, an i$%o%e aIilit& to
in/luence a tiIunal, 7illBs allusion to ;aD&es Concene' /o ;aD&es is not onl&
$oe than a Iit tacJ&...it $aJes NVB @u'ge Beesle&Bs testi$on& in that ega' e<en
$oe cuious #SCR 1.5.5 con/i'entialit& touting an' all, so sa& nothing o/ SCR
12"#"(, in a''ition to the %atent /act that 7illBs %u%ote' /i<e %age gie<ance is
%lainl& /ull o/ lies an' o atte$%ts to $islea', e<incing the highest le<el o/ a lacJ o/
can'o to the tiIunal #Dhee, %e =ates, the SBN is an Ma$ o/ the coutN(, lacJ o/
Mcan'o to o%%osing counselN #the ule elates to M/ainess to o%%osing counselN, Iut
that 'i' not sto% 9ing o Eche<eia /o$ 'el<ing into such...(, $uch less /ainess
to o%%osing counsel, to sa& nothing o/ es%ect /o the ights o/ thi' %aties #/o$e
R@C Chie/ Ci<il CleJ e0%esse' signi/icant 'issatis/action to Coughlin #aIout
7illBs so 'oing( as to 7illBs in<oJing so$e %u%ote' o//eings 7illBs lette in'icate'
she Doul' %o<i'e the SBN as to Coughlin u%on Coughlin in/o$ing Stancil o/
such %u%ote' Ditings I& 7ill to the SBN.( -''itionall&, such /i<e %age gie<ance
also $anages to $ise%esent Dhethe an' Dhen CoughlinBs lease Me0%ie'N #see the
e0te$e signi/icance o/ such chaacteiCation in the conte0t o/ the hol'o<e
%ocee'ing o no cause su$$a& e<iction #7illBs lette consistentl& /ails to i'enti/&
such as Msu$$a&N in natue, an' e<inces co$%lete an' utte /au' as to the its
assetions es%ecting CoughlinBs 12F".F11 ?otion /o +R,, ...., o, in the
altenati<e, ?otion /o Sta&, an' the associate' MenclosuesN 7illBs lette %u%ots to
ha<e Ieen attache' theeto #though, inteestingl&, noDhee in the ",.94 %age
%o'uction I& the SBN on 11F7F12 to Coughlin %u%oting to so$ehoD $aJe u% /o
the egegious <iolations o/ SCR 1.5#2(#c(, is to Ie /oun' such MenclosuesN...
htt%1FFDDD.sciI'.co$F'ocF12"291."2F11H7H12H.2.4H22""7HBatesH1HtoH"H.94H
StateHBaHo/HNe<a'aHE0cuseH/oH6ailingHtoH,Ie&HSCRH1.5H2Hc
So, /o all Coughlin JnoDs, 7ill %o<i'e' inco$%lete 'ocu$ents theein
#Dhethe he %o<i'e' the SBN the ele<en e0hiIits to his 1F"F12 ,%%osition to
CoughlinBs ?otion /o +R, o Sta& #7ill consistentl& chaacteiCes such as onl& a
?otion /o +R, as to the 'u$%ing o/ CoughlinBs %esonalt&, Dhich 7ill alleges
Coughlin MaIan'one'N #/unn&, /iling a ?otion /o +R, to sto% the 'u$%ing, an' o
a ?otion /o Sta& o/ the e<iction itsel/ #es%eciall& Dhee such 12F".F11 ?otion,
- 42F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
an', e<en $oe so, the 1F5F12 Re%l& to the ,%%osition Hill's associate Baker /ile'
thooughl& sets out in cogent legal anal&sis #es%eciall& consi'eing the
cicu$stances un'e Dhich such Das %e/o$e'( the teiIl& sus%ect as%ects o/ the
%ositions that 7illBs associate $aintaine'N...o/ couse 9ing 'oes not Dant to Ie #o
ha<e M4n<estigatoN *etes Ie( suI%oenae' /o /oce' to testi/&, es%eciall& as to the
NRS 4.."85 su%ese'eas Ion'Fsta& o/ a su$$a& e<iction against a co$$ecial
tenant #the use o/ the su$$a& %oce'ues in NRS 4..25" un'e such
cicu$stances is Iae' #a Kuis'ictional Ia %e Vol%et, 5a<i'sohn, -iJins, etc.(
I& NRS 4..254.
#+hee ae a nu$Ie o/, uh, inteesting a%%eaances o/ 'ocu$ents that
in<ol<e 7ill in the Iates sta$%e' ",.94 %age %o'uction to Coughlin I& the SBN on
11F7F12 #/ou Ku'icial 'a&s Ie/oe the /o$al heaing in this $atte #so, *anel Chai
Eche<eia cetainl& 'i' not see$ to ha<e an& %oIle$ Dith such untimely
disclosures, e<en Dhee he /aile' to consi'e CoughlinBs #o e<en alloD such to Ie
a'$itte' into e<i'ence, a%%aentl&( 11F1"F12 o 11F14F12 /ilings #7E-R4N: H Vol.
4, #*ages 1.2115 to 1."11"( +7E =4+NESS1 SCR 1.5Bs Ieen thoDn out the
Din'oD. 8ouB<e ule' on $otions Ie/oe 4B<e e<en ha' a chance to o%%ose the$ o
/ile a e%l& to an o%%osition. 8ou clai$ that NRC* is a%%licaIle hee. 8et un'e
NRC* Dhen 4 /ile a $otion to Ii/ucate, an' he /ile' an o%%osition, an' 4 get thee
'a&s /o $ailing un'e 2HC, an' he %u%ots to /ile it on the 24th, an' &ou ule on it
DhenT ,n the ".thT 5onBt 4 get /i<e 'a&s, %lus thee /o $ailing to /ile $&
o%%osition to %ese<e /o a%%ealT MR. EC;E0ERRIA: So should *e disre!ard
the motions you filed *ithout !ivin! the State -ar the opportunity to respond
timelyA I ha# two motions sho6+# 4n#+! m7 #oo! last ni2ht. Sho4l# thos+ "+
#is!+2a!#+# 4n#+! 7o4! l+2al !+asonin2A -ecause you did not offer the State
-ar the opportunity to respond. ?R. C,):7;4N1 =ell, that HH ?R.
EC7EVERR4-1 8es o no, ?. CoughlinT ?R. C,):7;4N1 4tBs not a &es o no.
?R. EC7EVERR4-1 8es, it is. ?R. C,):7;4N1 That would entail figuring out
whether or not 30 days prior to the hearing HH ?R. EC7EVERR4-1 ;etBs /ocus on
the issues IacJ. 8ouB<e $a'e a $otion noD to equie $e to ecuse $&sel/.N(.
-$ongst the Iates sta$%e' enties in<ol<ing 7ill #see 4n'e0 theeto
Coughlin ha' to ceate, an', o''l&, though the SBN an' R?C $anage' to co%& the
sa$e /ilings I& Coughlin o<e an' o<e, an' o<e #ne<e 'igitall& o/ couse, though
the R?C Dill c& MesoucesN, all Dhilst e/using e/iling #e0ce%t Dhee R?C
5onna Balla' lies aIout that, natuall&( the SBN /aile' to inclu'e in such ",.94
%o'uction to Coughlin an& in'ication #$uch less actual co%ies theeo/( o/ Kust
Dhat such MenclosuesN %u%ote'l& %o<i'e' I& 7ill to 9ing entaile' #gi<en such
Das %u%ote'l& e$aile' to 9ing, it Doul' ha<e Ieen <e& eas& an' econo$ical /o
9ing to /oDa' such e$ail on to Coughlin, hoDe<e, /o the $ost %at, the SBN
an' 9ing ha<e stea'/astl& e/use' to utiliCe e$ail in an& $eaning/ul Da&,
es%eciall& Dhee 'oing so Doul' 'e%i<e 9ing o the SBN o/ the un/ai a'<antage
it consistentl& ganes in the ti$e is o/ the essence a%%oach it taJes to cheating
Res%on'ents out o/ thei SCR 1.5#2(#c( ights....#see BolesB Bie/ an' Re%l& Bie/(
- 4"F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
in the 11F7F12 ",.94 %o'uction to Coughlin I& the SBN o/ 11F7F121 1277H1279 /a0
/o$ Reno Cit& -ttone& to Richa' :. 7ill, Esq., that 7ill %o<i'e' to SBN
consisting o/ 2@5C @u'ge ElliottBs ,'e 'is$issing CoughlinBs a%%eal o/ ci$inal
tes%ass con<iction in R?C 11 CR 224.5 #219.1( " %ages /o$ 9F1.F12 containing
8F27F12 ,'e in CR12H1222
H1785H1789 RC- 7aClettBs ?otion to Continue tes%ass tail in R?C 224.5
Iecause Richa' :. 7ill, Esq., Ditness, Dill Ie on <acation.
H2...H2..2 -est Re%ot an' 5eclaation o/ *oIaIle Cause Sheet I& R*5 ,//ice
Chis Cate @. /ile' Dith Ci$inal Co$%laint /o tes%ass I& Richa' :. 7ill in
R?C 11 CR 224.5 on 11F1"F11 listing Coughlin as an attone&, /uthe <itiating
SBN an' R?CBs /au'ulent assetion that Coughlin /aile' to 'isclose /act he is an
attone&.
H27""H27"4 "F27F12 ,'e in CV11H."228 2@5C @u'ge 6lanagan a%%eal o/
su$$a& e<iction Dith 7ill an' BaJe as o%%osing counsel 5en&ing 7illBs BaJeBs
1F21F12 ?otion /o ,'e to ShoD Cause a/te heaing on "F2"F12 an' "F22F12
H27"8H27"9 4F12F12 /a0 /o$ R?C 5e%t. 2 #@u'ge =. :a'ne( 1 an' 2 o/ 2 -est
Re%ot an' *oIaIle Cause Sheet /o 11F1"F12 custo'ial ci$inal tes%ass aest
Dith *C Sheet I& R*5 Cate an' 7illBs Ci$inal Co$%laint
H272.H ;ots o/ e$ails IetDeen Coughlin an' the SBN quite coo%eati<e an'
es%onsi<e to an& an all SBN equests /o in/o$ation o coo%eation in an&
in<estigations
2772 CoughlinBs e$ail to =CS, 'etailing 5e%ut& ?achenBs Iugla& Dith 7illBs
associate BaJe o/ 11F1F11, ?achenBs /alse a//i'a<it ega'ing M%esonall& se<ingN
Coughlin 24 hou locJout o'e on 11F1F11
279. CoughlinBs "F12F12 e$ail to 9ing in'icating he has &et to /inish sen'ing
e<e&thing in es%onse to 7illBs gie<ance.
H272.H ;ots o/ e$ails IetDeen Coughlin an' the SBN quite coo%eati<e an'
es%onsi<e to an& an all SBN equests /o in/o$ation o coo%eation in an&
in<estigations Dhethe elating to 7ill, :a'ne, o Nash 7ol$es, etc.
2772 CoughlinBs e$ail to =CS, 'etailing 5e%ut& ?achenBs Iugla& Dith 7illBs
associate BaJe o/ 11F1F11, ?achenBs /alse a//i'a<it ega'ing M%esonall& se<ingN
Coughlin 24 hou locJout o'e on 11F1F11 Iugla& I& 7illBs associate BaJe o/
that 'ate
279. CoughlinBs "F12F12 e$ail to 9ing in'icating he has &et to /inish sen'ing
e<e&thing in es%onse to 7illBs gie<ance.
H2712 +ahoe =o$enBs Se<ices #see CV11H.1955, 2."17( attone& Bian
:onsal<es, Esq.Bs e$ail e/eing to othe attone& /ee aDa's $aJes cuious 9ingBs
onl& equesting Coughlin %a& 7illBs lan'lo' clientBs aDa' in 9ingBs closing
agu$ent. #eall& 'isgusting hoD ol' /o$e stooge /o the IanJs /oeclosue
$e'iato 9ing #:iles sue' hi$ in that ole, Iut a%%aentl& the Iie/s /o such Dee
taJen 'oDn( see$s onl& inteeste' in getting 7ill an' o 7illBs neuologist lan'lo'
Dho can a//o' to IloD V2.9 #at least( %usuing a s%ite su$$a& e<iction( athe
- 44F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
than %usuing a''essing so$e attone& /ee aDa' to an shelte /o aIuse'
Do$enFchil'en1
7E-R4N: H Vol. 4, #*age ""111H2( M?R. 94N:1 ...-n' 4 Ielie<e it Doul'
Ie a%%o%iate since &ou hea' e<i'ence on the issue o/ the cout o'e that he %a&
5. ?elissBs /ees. +hat an& einstate$ent, i/ &ou 'onBt 'isIa hi$ %e$anentl&,
Doul' Ie he Doul' Ie equie' to /olloD that cout o'e to %a& those /ees. +hanJ
&ou.N
+o Ie /ai, 9ing $a& ha<e Kust Dishe' to a<oi' the Canon 2, Rule 2.15, etc.
issues associate' Dith 2@5C @u'ge Elliott #see the a%%eaance o/ @u'ge ElliottBs
,'e in all o/ the Mo'esN a//i$ing CoughlinsB ci$inal con<ictions...( /ailing to
ecuse hi$sel/, $uch less 'i<ulge the /act that he Das the *esi'ent o/ C--=Bs
E0ecuti<e Boa' Dhee =;S, C--=, an' +ahoe =o$enBs Se<ices Dee all coH
'e/en'ants in CoughlinBs Dong/ul te$ination suit %esi'e' o<e I& inteeste'
%at& 2@5C @u'ge Elliott #/o sha$e( in CV11H.1955, Iinging the legiti$ac& o/
an& ulings on an& cases in<ol<ing Coughlin I& @u'ge Elliott into seious 'ouIt
#an' $aJing the 11F22F12 ,'e I& @ustice Che& 'is$issing CoughlinBs a%%eal in
theeo/ in 2."17 Doth& o/ econsi'eation o/ so$e sot, %aticulal& Dhee goo'
cause /o an& allege' /ailue to ti$el& /ile a *etition /o Reheaing is $ani/est /o$
the sche'uling associate' Dith the 11F14F12 /o$al 'isci%lina& heaing an' the
11F19F12 an' 11F2.F12 tial 'ates R@C @u'ge S/eaCCa insiste' on /o the i*hone
case in RCR2.11H.2""41(.
6uthe, the 'ictates o/ SCR 1.5#2(#c( <is a <is ti$el& 'isclosing antici%ate'
Ditnesses an' the /acts to Dhich the SBN inten's to ha<e the$ testi/&, an' the
e<i'ence su%%oting such testi$on& %o<i'e' anothe eall& goo' eason /o 9ing
to a<oi' seeJing to a'$it it the %u%ote' 1F14F12 e$aile' gie<ance I& Richa' :.
7ill, Esq., to 9ing Dhee such 'e$onstates quite cleal& that 9ing an' the SBN
JneD /o quite so$e ti$e #11 $onths, at least( o/ Ioth the $attes to Dhich NVB
@u'ge Beesle& $ight testi/&, in a''ition to those to Dhich =;SBs Elcano $ight
Deigh in, Dhee such 1F14F12 lette ea's #see /o$ the 11F7F12 %o'uction to
Coughlin I& the SBN o/ ",.94 Iates sta$%e' %ages at Iates ".1"H".17 7illBs
1F14F12 e$ail to 9ing, /i<e %age gie<ance, unsigne', unsDon #intestingl&, eithe
7ill /aile' to eall& inclu'e such M'isclosuesN o 9ing e0cise' such,
ina%%o%iatel&, /o$ this ",.94 SCR 1.5#2(#c( %o'uction o/ 11F7F12, causing
$uch %eKu'ice to CoughlinBs 'e/ense htt%1FFDDD.sciI'.co$F'ocF12"291."2F11H
7H12H.2.4H22""7HBatesH1HtoH"H.94HStateHBaHo/HNe<a'aHE0cuseH/oH6ailingHtoH
,Ie&HSCRH1.5H2Hc (1
@anua& 14, 2.12 V4- E?-4; ,N;8 %aticJJ3n<Ia.og
*aticJ 9ing, Esq. -ssistant Ba Counsel Re1 Zacha& B. Coughlin,
Esq. Ne<a'a Ba No. 947"
?. 9ing1
8ou an' 4 have previously discussed ?. Coughlin. ?.
Coughlin, 'ue to his $ental instaIilit&, lacJ o/ integit&, an' co$%lete
inco$%etence, constitutes a 'ange to the %uIlic i/ he is alloDe' to
- 45F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
continue to %actice laD. +his lette is Ditten to 'ischage $& and my
associate"s reportin! obli!ations under 1C 3.4. *lease consi'e the
/olloDing1
1. Rissone <. :essin, CV1.H.1"41. Altho42h not
amon2 M!. Co42hlin<s most si2ni5iant +thial 6iolations: it
p!+s+nts a 2oo# mi!oosm o5 his #+!+litions. M!. B+ssin was a
li+nt of our office. 7e 'e/au'e' the %lainti//, as is his modus
operandi in dealin! *ith *omen. -%%o0i$atel& one &ea a/te
Ku'g$ent Das entee' an' the case conclu'e', ?. Coughlin inteKecte'
hi$sel/ in the case on Iehal/ o/ :essin, t&ing to collect on a sanction
aDa' against o%%osing counsel. 4t tuns out that Iecause he ha' /ile'
IanJu%tc&, :essin no longe oDns this clai$. 4/ &ou looJ at the /ile,
&ou Dill see that Co42hlin app+a!+# an# th+n 5il+# a "iCa!!+
Dpa!tial with#!awalD #o4m+nt on 5ece$Ie 8, 2.11.
SuIsequent to that ti$e, Co42hlin has "++n !host*ritin!
#o4m+nts that purport to be from 5essin) individually) and e6filin!
them for 5essin. 0e is usin! the 78s87 for 5essin"s si!nature. Th+s+
a!+ l+a!l7 not documents that are si!ned or prepared by ,r. 5essin)
and the fact that somebody &Cou!hlin' e6files them on5i!ms h+ is
!host*ritin! witho4t th+ !+?4i!+# #islos4!+. 4n a''ition, it appears
that Coughlin has /acilitate' the /iling of *hat may be a /au'ulent
IanJu%tc& on Iehal/ o/ :essin. CoughlinBs lacJ is 'e$onstate' in the
:essin case I& the /act that he 'oes not un'estan' the e//ect on the
oDneshi% o/ :essinBs %otential clai$s /o$ :essin ha<ing /ile' a
ban(ruptcy, #i.e., the clai$s noD Ielong to the IanJu%tc& tustee, not
:essin.(
-s Dith all o/ the $attes e/eence' IeloD, 4 stongl& suggest
that &ou contact the Second 9udicial 2istrict Court and !et e6filin!
access to the cases mentioned so &ou can looJ at the 'ocu$ents
&ousel/. :la'e 7all, Esq., is o%%osing counsel in that case an' $a& Ie
o/ hel% to &ou.
2. : am informed an# "+li+6+ that M!. Co42hlin was recently
convicted of a theft crime in eno ,unicipal Court. I am further
informed that the $atte aises out o/ sho%li/ting at =al$at. +hat case
is %esentl& on a%%eal to the 'istict cout in case nu$Ie CR11H2.24.
?. Coughlin is e%esenting hi$sel/.
". ?. Coughlin is %esentl& /acing ci$inal chages ega'ing
the the/t o/ an i*o'. +hat is %en'ing in Reno @ustice Cout as case
nu$Ie RCR2.11H.2""41. 4 ha<e e<ieDe' the /ile. ?. Coughlin got
into so$e sot o/ agu$ent Dith his %uIlic 'e/en'e. -s a esult, he
Das e/ee' out /o a co$%etenc& e<aluation.
- 42F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4. =e e%esent 5. ?attheD ?e4iss, a %h&sician /o$ Chico,
Cali/onia. 5. ?eliss oDns the %o%et& at 121 iver oc( Street,
Reno, Ne<a'a. Beginning in ?ach 2.1., the %o%et& Das lease' to
?. Coughlin an' his thenHgil/ien'. +he lease expired in e!ruary
"0##. +he gil/ien' le/t the co$$unit& in a%%o0i$atel& ?a& 2.11.
5. ?eliss contacte' us in a%%o0i$atel& -ugust 2.11 to assist in
e<icting ?. Coughlin. Coughlin ha' not %ai' ent o utilities since
?a&. 7e conten'e' that thee Dee haIitaIilit& issues Dith the %o%et&
that justified his *ithholdin! rent. -ll o/ his clai$s Dee 'eci'e'
a'<esel& to his %osition at the eviction hearin!. @ustice o/ the *eace
*ete $fera%%a ordered &oughlin evicted from the premises effective
'o(em!er #) "0##. #n that date, the /asho+ Co4nt7 Sh+!i55<s
=+pa!tm+nt performed their normal eviction procedure1 lo3s w+!+
han2+# an# the eviction notice *as posted on the front door. /+
6i#+otap+# th+ hom+ an# its ont+nts at that tim+. )%on ins%ection
o<e the ne0t /eD 'a&s, it Ieca$e a%%aent that Oso$eIo'&O Das
IeaJing into the ho$e on a egula Iasis.
,n Sun'a&, No<e$Ie 1", 2.11, 5. ?eliss ca$e to toDn, an'
4 $et hi$ at the ho$e on Ri<e RocJ Steet. -s De DalJe' though the
ho$e, it Das oI<ious that so$eone Ieen in thee since 4 ha' last Ieen
in se<eal 'a&s Ie/oe. 5. ?eliss 'isco<ee' that the Iase$ent 'oo
Das Iaica'e' #not locJe'( /o$ the insi'e. +he Reno *olice
5e%at$ent Das su$$one'. Th+7 t!i+# to coax *hoever *as in the
basement out, Dithout success. -/te 5. ?eliss ha' to JicJ the 'oo
'oDn, it was #iso6+!+# that M!. Co42hlin ha# bro(en in an# was
in th+ "as+m+nt. 7e Das aeste' an' is presently facin! criminal
trespass char!es in eno ,unicipal Court. See case no. $$ CR ,%-'9
21. 7e is also facing a contempt motion in front of *udge $fera%%a in
th+ +6ition as+. S/eaCCa has sta&e' that $atte %en'ing the
esolution o/ the ci$inal tial. +hat Das sche'ule' /o @anua& 1.,
2.12, Iut Das continue' at the equest o/ ?. CoughlinBs neD attone&.
5. +he e<iction o'e is noD on a%%eal to the Secon' @u'icial
5istict Cout. See case CVl1H."228, %en'ing in 5e%at$ent 7. -s %at
o/ the e<iction %ocess, a lien Das assete' against the %esonal
%o%et& that Coughlin le/t Iehin' at the ho$e. ,n November 1+)
2;11, Coughlin /ile' a $otion to contest the lan'lo'Bs lien in the R+no
J4sti+ Co4!t. Th+ o4!t tried to promptly set a hearin!: "4t
Co42hlin refused to cooperate in settin! the matter: an# th+ o4!t
too( it off calendar. Coughlin then einitiate' that %ocess an' a
heaing was held in +ecem!er, at *hich time the court heard evidence
of Cou!hlin"s lac( of cooperation in settin! the November hearin!.
<ou may also *ant to contact eno 9ustice Court staff) and in
particular) chief cler( =aren Stancil, aIout ?. CoughlinBs aIusi<e
- 47F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
teat$ent o/ he an' he sta//. -/te the heaing, the cout issue' an
,'e ganting Coughlin a tDoH'a& ti$e Din'oD to e$o<e his
%esonal %o%et&. +he /ist 'a& Das +hus'a&, 5ece$Ie 22, 2.11.
-/te Coughlin Das alloDe' into the ho$e that /ist 'a&, he sent out an
eH$ail to the e//ect that "+a4s+ h+ ha# appealed J4#2+ S5+!aCCa<s
o!#+!, he Das entitled to a stay of proceedin!s an# was 2oin2 to
!+s4m+ li6in2 in th+ hom+. -s a esult, he 'i' <e& little to e$o<e
an& o/ his %esonal %o%et& that 'a&. ,n 6i'a&, 5ece$Ie 2", 2.11,
a/te he leane', again, that his stay ha' Ieen 'enie', Coughlin
asse$Ile' a s$all ceD an' the& Dee aIle to e$o<e a suIstantial
a$ount o/ his %esonal %o%et&. #8ou nee' to un'estan' that Mr.
&oughlin is a hoarder. We have the photos and videos if you *ould
li(e to see them.(
7oDe<e, ?. Coughlin did not get all of his property out. 6o
e0a$%le, 4 counte' 1" ca seats that he ha' so$ehoD $anage' to get
'oDn into the Iase$ent. 0avin! failed to remove all of his
belon!in!s, ?. Coughlin th+n mo6+# "+5o!+ J4#2+ Flana2an 5o! a
t+mpo!a!7 !+st!ainin2 o!#+! to prevent the disposal of his
abandoned property in ao!#an+ with J4#2+ S5+!aCCa<s o!#+!.
-ttache' is ?. CoughlinBs motion, $& o//iceBs opposition, an' ?.
CoughlinBs reply. Th+s+ #o4m+nts #+monst!at+ M!. Co42hlin<s
ompl+t+ an# 4tt+! inomp+t+n+ as an atto!n+7.
,n 9anuary 11) 2;12, @u'ge 6lanagan 'enie' ?. CoughlinBs
equest /o a temporary restrainin! order. ,n 9anuary 12) 2;12, the
contacto hie' to clean the house co$$ence' DoJ. ?. Coughlin
/lagge' the contacto 'oDn in ta//ic Dhen he #the contacto( Das on
his Da& to the 'u$% Dith the abandoned property /o$ the house.
Coughlin calle' the %olice, Dho ai<e' at the tans/e station.
Coughlin Das /alsel& asseting that the contacto ha' tie' to un hi$
o<e. 7e also tol' the %olice
that the contacto had stolen his possessions. -/te 4 %esente' the
cout o'es to the police, the contacto Das alloDe' to %ocee'. ,t
their instruction, 4 ha<e noD ha' a +*, issue' against Coughlin I&
Reno @ustice Cout.
7oDe<e, Ie/oe the contacto coul' get IacJ to the Ri<e RocJ
house, Coughlin Das thee. 7e ha' his <i'eo ca$ea an' Das DalJing
u% an' 'oDn the steet scea$ing an' &elling at the %olice, at the
contacto, and at me) *hen : arrived. ?. Coughlin en'e' u% Ieing
arrested and ta(en to jail. +he %olice in/o$e' $e that "+a4s+ o5 th+
n4m"+! an# t7p+s o5 ontats th+7 ha6+ ha# with him, he is no
lon!er eli!ible for citations in the event of infractions.
Enclose' &ou Dill /in' a op7 o5 a supplemental document 5il+#
"7 M!.
- 48F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Co42hlin on Jan4a!7 $*: ,'$,, an' sent to $& sta// an' 4 I& e$ail
/o$ Coughlin that $oning. Pl+as+ not+ that the attorney
desi!nation on th+ 5i!st pa2+ in#iat+s that it is "+in2 5il+# "7
Co42hlin as appellant. 8ou Dill note that the caption is from a
different case. 4t is unclear in which case Mr. &oughlin intended to file
this document, although, Iecause o/ the case nu$Ie an' the ca%tion, it
a%%eas to ha<e ulti$atel& been routed to the Ca%entie case #CV.8H
.17.9( an' not the e<iction a%%eal case #CV11H."228(. 4 a$ told that
counsel in the captioned case may also be in the process of filin! a
bar complaint a!ainst Cou!hlin.
2. =hen the house Das secue' a/te CoughlinBs aest, we found
a crack pipe and a !ag of what appeared to !e mari-uana. The
contractor also e%ote' /in'ing a Io0 o/ %ills an' a <ial o/ so$e sot.
We understand Cou!hlin has unsuccessfully tried the .a*yers
Concerned for .a*yers pro!ram) and that he has a history of
substance problems.
7. ?. Coughlin has filed t*o la*suits a!ainst his former
employer) Washoe .e!al Services. 7e has sue' all of the !oard of
directors and the management of the company. Both cases ha<e noD
Ieen 'is$isse'. 1oth as+s #+monst!at+ his la3 o5 omp+t+n+. I
s422+st 7o4 ontat Jos+ph Ba!in: Es?., in ;as Vegas, as he Das
counsel /o the 'e/en'ants in that case. Yo4 ma7 want to ontat
1aul /lcano) /s>.) the director of Washoe .e!al Services.
8. ?. Coughlin has a haIit o/ initiating cases an' asJing to
%ocee' in
/o$a %au%eis. 7e has 'one so in cases against $e, $& o//ice, $&
client, an' =ashoe ;egal Se<ices. Yo4 will 5in# th+m i5 7o4 run a
search for Cou!hlin ? on the Second 9udicial 2istrict Court *ebsite.
+he couts that ha<e e<ieDe' the 'ocu$ents ha<e geneall& 'enie' his
equests. =hat is o/ note is that his !+p!+s+ntations in th+
appliations to p!o++# in 5o!ma pa4p+!is a!+ inonsist+nt with
an# ont!a!7 to th+ !+p!+s+ntations that h+ has ma#+ to J4#2+
Flana2an in th+ ont+8t o5 s++3in2 a t+mpo!a!7 !+st!ainin2 o!#+!.
,n the one han', h+ t+lls th+ o4!t h+ is "!o3+ an# has no p!op+!t7,
an' on the othe han', he is telling the court that he has a great deal of
(alua!le property at the home that needs to !e protected. +his
- 49F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
'e$onstates a goss lack of candor with the tri!unals Dith Dhich he
'eals.
9. Co42hlin has also t!i+# to 5il+ a as+ a2ainst m+: m7
assoiat+: m7 li+nt: an# oth+!s: inl4#in2 th+ R+no J4sti+ Co4!t.
4t is also to Ie 5o4n# on th+ w+"sit+. @u'ge Steinhei$e has ule' that
he 'i' not co$%l& Dith NRC* 8.
1.. CoughlinBs Ieha<io Das unusual to stat, an' has Ieco$e
$oe an' $oe IiCae 'uing the ti$e De ha<e Ieen 'ealing Dith hi$.
7e se<es %a%es he 'oes not /ile, an' /iles 'oes not se<e. 7e
consistentl& signs ceti/icates o/ se<ice that he has $aile' to us, Iut
De ha<e ne<e ecei<e' /o$ hi$ I& $ail. ;+ has post+# 6i#+os o5
th+ +6ition s+!6i+ att+mpts an# pa!ts o5 th+ t!ial on Yo4T4"+:
includin! some recordin!s he secretly made in court *ith his
cellphone.
11. -nothe +8ampl+ o5 his inomp+t+n+ is that h+ does not
understand *hat orders are) and are not) appealable. 7e #o+s not
4n#+!stan# that 5ilin2 a noti+ o5 app+al divests the lo*er court of
jurisdiction. 4 a$ con/i'ent that once &ou looJ into this $atte, &ou
Dill agee that ?. Coughlin shoul' not Ie %acticing laD. 7e is a
'ange to the co$$unit&.
Sin+!+l7: /s/ Riha!# B. ;ill R:71Jn Enclosues1 HCoughlin
-$en'e' E$egenc& ?otion /o Restaining ,'e H?eliss
,%%osition to ?otion /o +R, HCoughlin Re%l& to ,%%osition to
?otion /o +R, HSu%%leinental Re%l& to ,%%osition 'ate' 1F1"F12
#N,+E1 the hea'e to each o/ the /i<e %ages o/ this %u%ote' 1F14F12 lette
I& 7ill to the SBN ea's1 M;ette to *aticJ 9ing, Esq., @anua& 14, 2.12N(.
- 5.F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ho$, along Dith R*5 5ual'e %ulle' Coughlin o<e u%on his elease /o$
Kail on 1F1"F12 /o the 1F12F12 OKa&DalJingO aest $a'e u%on the /au'ulent
assetions o/ Richa' 74ll, R@C @u'ge @acJ Schoe'e #Dho$ e<icte' Coughlin
/o$ *aJ +eace an' gante' 7ill the %otection o'e inci'ent to the Ka&DalJing
aest an' Dho &elle' O'o &ou Dant to go to KailO at Coughlin at the e0tension
heaing Dhen Coughlin Ioache' the to%ic o/ 7illBs aIuse o/ %ocess, an' Dho$
Dong/ull& gante' the 2F27F12 E<iction ,'e in R@C Re<2.12H..1.48 'es%ite the
'e/icient 5 'a& notice listing the Dong cout to /ile a tenanBts a//i'a<it #a
equie$ent un'e NRS 4..25", an' 'es%ite CoughlinBs nu$eous calls an' 2F22F12
e$ail to the R@C, S@C, R*5 an' =CS,,
Coughlin 'iscusse' Dith Stancil the cicu$stances o/ the 2F28F12 e<iction in
Re<2.12H..1.48 an' conco$itant aest in RCR2.12H.2798. Dhee the R@C,
'es%ite at least tDo %hone calls IetDeen Stancil an' Coughlin an' one 2F22F12
e$ail /o$ Coughlin to Stancil an' R@C=eI3Dashoecount&.us #Dhich Das at one
%oint Dithin the /ile in 1.48, un'eneath the 'ocJet on the le/t han' si'e, Iut Dhich
u%on CoughlinBs e<ieDing such on 8F1F1" Das no longe to Ie /oun'( aleting the
R@C to the Kuis'ictional 'e/iciencies in the 2F14F12 5 5a& Notice o/ )nlaD/ul
5etaine allege'l& O%esonall& se<e'O on Coughlin I& Ne<a'a Cout Se<es, Dhich
liste', %usuant to NRS 4..25"#"(#I(#1(, the <e& S%aJs @ustice Cout Dith Dhich
Coughlin suI$itte' a +enantBs -nsDe #?otion to 5is$iss( /o /iling on 2F22F12 at
noon, Dhich the S@C /aile' to /ile, Dhee the R@CBs @u'ge Schoe'e then entee' a
;ocJout ,'e on 2F27F12 'es%ite the 'e/icien& in the Notice. )%on Coughlin, on
8F1F1", atte$%ting to /ile a Vei/ie' Co$%laint /o 4llegal ;ocJout as to a ental at
ONothDin's -%at$entsO Dith the sa$e 9aen Stancil, noD a counte cleJ at the
S%aJs @ustice Cout, Stancil e/use' such 'ocu$ent /o /iling, in a nonH$inisteial
eKection o/ such, I& noting that ONothDin's -%at$entsO is locate' Dithin the
con/ines o/ Reno, no S%aJs.
.2798. #a case the R@C an' =C5-Bs ,//ice 55- alDa&s inten'e' to 'is$iss in light
o/ the Ku'icial $iscon'uct inheent to the R@CBs @u'ge Schoe'e an' then R@C Chie/ Ci<il
CleJ 9aen Stancil JnoDingl& issuing a Dong/ul su$$a& e$o<al o'e #locJout o'e( on
2F27F12 inci'ent to a 2F14F12 5 5a& )nlaD/ul 5etaine Notice in Re<2.12H..1.48 that liste'
S%aJs @ustice Cout as the /ou$ in Dhich Coughlin $ust /ile a tenantBs a//i'a<it #Dhich
- 51F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin 'i', 'es%ite @u'ge *easonsB %atent $iscon'uct at the 7F"1F12 heaing in s$ugl&
asJing Coughlin /o the M/ile sta$%e'N co%& o/ such Dhee *eason an' the R@C Dee /ull&
a%%ise' o/ the S%aJs @ustice CoutBs /ailue to /ile in such +enantBs -//i'a<it Coughlin /ile'
#its /ile', Dhethe so$e cooJe' cleJ %uts a sta$% on it o not( inci'ent to Coughlin
suI$itting such /o /iling to the S%aJs @ustice Cout 11159 a.$., on 2F22F12
4nci'entall&, /o$e R@C Chie/ Ci<il CleJ Stancil, on 8F1F1" e/use' to /ile in
CoughlinBs Veti/ie' Co$%laint 6o Relie/ 6o$ 4llegal ;ocJout that Coughlin suI$itte' /o
/iling at the $parks *ustice Cout /o Ie&on' $inisteial easons that Stancil an' R@C @u'ge
Schoe'e cleal& /aile' to a%%l& to CoughlinBs Iene/it inci'ent to Ne<a'a Cout Se<ices
success/ull& seeJing a locJout o'e in the su$$a& e<iction in Re<2.12H..1.48 /o$ the
R@C #at the S@C on 8F1F1" Stancil tol' Coughlin she Das e/using to /ile in his suI$ission
Iecause she JneD that NothDin'Bs -%at$ents Das a MReno a''essN an' the MS%aJs @ustice
Cout 'oes not ha<e Kuis'ictionN ...Dhich, again, 'i' not sto% Stancil an' R@C @u'ge
Schoe'e /o$ issuing a su$$a& e$o<al o'e on 2F27F12 that esulte' in a custo'ial aest
o/ Coughlin on 2F28F12 in RCR2.12H.2798. Dhee the 2F14F12 5 5a& Notice the lan'lo' Das
equie' to suI$it Dith his 2F27F12 a%%lication /o such a su$$a& e$o<al o'e listing,
%usuant to NRS 4..25"#"(#I(#1(, the S%aJs @ustice Cout as the /ou$ in Dhich Coughlin
$ust /ile his tenantBs a//i'a<it(
+hen thee is the $atte o/ the R@C ci<il 'i<ision /ailing to /ile in CoughlinBs
12F22F12 Notice o/ -%%eal o/ the 12F21F12 ,'e .esol(ing CoughlinBs ?otion to Contest
*esonal *o%et& lien in e<2.11H..17.8, an', si$ilal&, /ailing to /ile Coughlin "F12F12
Notice o/ -%%eal in R@C e<2.12H..."74 #the su$$a& e<iction I& :a&le 9en, Esq. -n'
Sue 9ing o/ =esten Ne<a'a *o%et& ?anage$ent o/ Coughlin...@u'ge ;in'a :a'ne
#see 219.1 an' 54844( Das a /o$e associate o/ 9enBs1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_ZhEHsoj4o +he e<iction 'e%icte' in that <i'eo
occue' Kust $inutes Ie/oe the heaing Ie/oe Ne<a'a BanJu%tc& Cout @u'ge Buce +.
Beesle& #Dho Dent to ?c:eoge School o/ ;aD in 1977 Dith tDo othe Ditnesses at
CoguhlinBs 11F14F12 /o$al 'isci%lina& heaing, though onl& @u'ge Beesle& an' =ashoe
;egal Se<icesBs *aul ElcanoBs testi$on& Das i$%o%el& notice' Kust one 'a& %io to the
11F14F12 heaing, in <iolation o/ SCR 1.5#2(#c( #es%eciall& Dhee nothing unJnoDn to Ba
Counsel 9ing Das allege' 'isco<ee' o testi/ie' to(.
=7ERE6,RE, *lainti// es%ect/ull& %a&s /o Ku'g$ent against 5e/en'ants,
an' each o/ the$ as /olloDs1
a.:eneal 'a$ages in e0cess o/ V1.,...A
I. S%ecial 'a$ages /o $e'ical an' inci'ental e0%enses, %ast an' /utue,
acco'ing to %oo/ at tialA
- 52F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
c. S%ecial 'a$ages /o lost inco$e, %ast an' /utue, acco'ing to %oo/ at
tialA
'. 6o an aDa' o/ attone& /ees, costs, e0%enses an' inteest as alloDe' I&
laDA
e. 6o an aDa' o/ inKuncti<e elie/ to Ie s%eci/ie' in $oe 'etail in the nea
/utue.
/. 6o such othe an' /uthe elie/ as to the Cout see$s %o%e in the
%e$ises.
5-+E5 this 9F1.F1"
FsF Zacha& BaJe Coughlin
Z-C7-R8 B-R9ER C,):7;4N, Esq.
*o *e -ttone& /o *lainti//
- 5"F54 -
Complaint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
CERTIFICATE OF SER0ICE
*usuant to NRC* 5#I(, 4 heeI& ceti/& that 4 a$ an e$%lo&ee o/ the laD o//ices o/
Z-C7-R8 B-R9ER C,):7;4N, Esq., 1471 E. 9+7 S+, Reno, Ne<a'a 89512,
an' that on this 'ate, 4 se<e' a tue an' coect co%& o/ the /oegoing 'ocu$ent I&1
ZZZZZ 5e%ositing /o $ailing, in a seale' en<elo%e, ).S. *ostage %e%ai', at Reno,
Ne<a'a.
ZZZZZ RenoFCason ?essenge Se<ice.
ZZZZZ *esonal 5eli<e&.
ZZZZZ 6acsi$ile.
ZZ ZZ EH6iling
a''esse' as /olloDs1
7ill an' ?eliss1 252 6oest St.
=CS, 911 *a Bl<'
R*5. 211 E. 2
n'
St.
R@C 1 South Siea St.

FsFE$%lo&ee o/ Zacha& BaJe Coughlin, Esq.,
- 54F54 -
Complaint

9 10 13 NVD 13CV446 484 IFP Motion, Proposed Complaint NVD Action Re Summary Eviction Lockout Burglaries by RPD, WCSO, Hill, Northwind, Et Al 56 Pages Doc 8

Caricato da

Informazioni sul documento

Copyright

Formati disponibili

Condividi questo documento

Condividi o incorpora il documento

Opzioni di condivisione

Hai trovato utile questo documento?

Questo contenuto è inappropriato?

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

9 10 13 NVD 13CV446 484 IFP Motion, Proposed Complaint NVD Action Re Summary Eviction Lockout Burglaries by RPD, WCSO, Hill, Northwind, Et Al 56 Pages Doc 8

Caricato da

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

District of

Potrebbero piacerti anche