Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Printing Productivity
What is everyone saying?
Why are the test results different?
The following exchange addresses the buzz around network office productivity, exploring the elements that
impact network office printing performance and providing testing recommendations.
Q: Rated Speed; Vendor Claims; Q: What do the consultants say? Q: What impacts productivity?
Consultant Test Reports – all with A: There are a number of independent A: Two key areas that impact productivity are
different results! Confusing? consulting companies that perform printing as follows:
testing and analysis of multifunctional
A: If you look at product brochures, systems. They all test systems with their own 1. What documents are primarily printed?
advertising claims, and third party test results,
test methodology. Each firm ends up with a) Are documents primarily stapled,
you are probably confused as to why there is a
different test results for the same products. The unstapled, or a mixture or
large difference in the productivity results for
test results are accurate for what is tested, but stapled/unstapled output?
the same product. Historically, the rated speed
vary because each company uses a different b) Are the documents primarily small (e.g.,
for a copier was close to the actual output of
test suite. In lieu of commenting on each 1, 2, or 3 pages) or larger documents?
the copier. When you are printing documents
company’s test suite and methodology, we will c) Is printing done in a production
in a busy office environment, you will see
discuss the factors affecting any test results environment (long run lengths, multiple
significantly different results between the rated
that should be considered when analyzing the sets) or office environment (typically
speed of the device and actual throughput.
data and overall report conclusions. small documents with very short run
In all cases, vendors claim a rated speed for lengths)?
their product. Industry standard rated speed d) Are documents simple or complex
can be determined by placing an original on documents (i.e., containing embedded
the device platen. Select 100 pages and press graphics)?
start. After the first page is out of the system e) What are the primary printed applications
and into the output tray, a certain number of (e.g., Microsoft® Word, PowerPoint, Excel,
pages will be produced in the next sixty seconds. email notes, PDF files, etc.)?
For example, a device with a rated speed of 50 f) In the case of color capable multifunction
pages per minute (PPM) will produce 50 pages systems, what type of engine is used (i.e.
in the next sixty seconds after the first copy is four pass vs. single pass), and is there a
produced. However, when printing documents, significant difference between the color
a system with a rated speed of 50 PPM may speed and the monochrome speed?
have print at speeds that are less than 50% of g) Does the color device pause often to
the rated speed. calibrate, replenish toner, or other system
checks?
1
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
Q: What is the impact of stapled You may see more than a 50% reduction in Q: Why is the size of a document
productivity when doing this simple test
and unstapled output? depending on the system that is being tested.
important?
A: A critical factor in determining the A: Productivity is impacted with many
effectiveness of the system is to see how it We tested the Xerox WorkCentre® Pro 245 systems when you are printing a large number
behaves when handling a mix of stapled and vs. a competitive 45-PPM system. The of small documents. Some systems will have a
unstapled output. Some systems can effectively results of the testing for the Xerox and noticeable delay between print jobs. When you
print documents that are all unstapled or all competitive systems are posted below. have a large number of these jobs, as is often
stapled documents. In the office environment, You may be surprised to know how much times found in the office environment, many
however, the job mix probably contains a mix the productivity can be impacted when your competitive systems may have a significant
of stapled and unstapled output. For example, jobs are mixed staple and unstapled jobs! impact on the productivity of the system.
you may have a one page mail note followed
by a stapled attachment. As the finisher is the Xerox WorkCentre Pro 245
most commonly ordered accessory for
Q: Why will there be a difference in
multifunction systems, it is important to Rated Speed of 45 PPM productivity between an office
understand the impact on productivity when environment and a production
you have this type of environment. environment?
A simple test using six documents
A: In a production environment, you generally
that are three pages each will
have longer run lengths than in the office
illustrate the impact of stapling.
environment, resulting in the printing of
multiple sets. As the number of sets increases,
1. Pause the print queue. At the PC that you the productivity of all systems will also
will use for the job submission, select increase.
“start”, select “Printers/Faxes”, right click
on the desired printer, and select “Pause Several years ago, you may have created
Printing.” (This process is for Microsoft® Note that the Xerox WorkCentre Pro 245 print multiple sets of documents for a meeting.
Windows XP users. Other operating systems speed did not vary significantly when printing Today you may send out the document
may vary on how you pause the print queue). the unstapled, stapled, or mixed output. electronically with each user printing a single
set of the document to take to the meeting.
2. Send three stapled documents to the paused Also, when you print a mail note, memo, or
printer followed by three unstapled jobs. Competitive System
report in the office environment, you generally
3. Release the paused printer and record only print a single set of the document. In
Rated Speed of 45 PPM
the amount of time it takes to print the many cases, we have gone from print and
six documents. distribute to distribute and print. Instead of
multiple sets we are producing individual sets.
4. Pause the printer again. In the office, where there are a lot of jobs
being printed with one or only a few sets
5. Using the same documents, send the stapled made, the system may achieve only a fraction
job to the paused printer followed by a three of the rated speed of the system.
page unstapled job. Repeat the process until
you have the six jobs in the queue, with
every other job stapled followed by an
unstapled job.
6. Release the paused printer and record the The competitive vendor produced the jobs at a
amount of time it takes to print the six low of 8.7 PPM to a maximum of 30.2 PPM.
documents. Although you may assume that Simply mixing the output reduced the productivity
the productivity of the systems would be the by more than 2/3. A busy office environment,
same for either all unstapled documents or printing documents that have both stapled and
in the mixed staple/unstapled environment, unstapled output will be significantly impacted
you will likely see significantly different when job output is mixed.
results than you expected.
2
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
Q: How does the document Q. With color MFP’s, why does the Q: Why are job types important?
complexity impact productivity? engine type make a difference? A: Job types will often vary as to the length
A: All documents must be prepared for A: There are three types of engines that are and complexity of the job. For example,
printing. This starts at the PC where a Page used in most of the color MFP and printer PowerPoint documents will tend to be longer
Description Language is created and then sent devices manufactured today. A four-pass color documents than an email note or short memo.
to the device. At the device, the print controller engine’s productivity (capable of printing, for If you have a majority of short jobs, the
creates a raster image (RIP) with the appropriate example, 20 pages per minute (PPM) for black performance may be affected in two ways.
commands such as stapling, duplex, assigning text but slowing to 5 PPM when layering There may be reduced productivity because
appropriate fonts, and document data. The black, cyan, magenta and yellow for color the system does not effectively handle a larger
raster image can now be processed and printed jobs) will be greatly affected if a document has network queue created by the series of smaller
by the device. As the jobs become more color and monochrome pages mixed jobs. Longer jobs will also allow the system to
complex, for example a PowerPoint® document throughout the job. focus on printing the job rather than managing
with embedded graphics, the process takes the job queue, resulting in increased productivity.
longer because there is more data that must be The second type, a single pass engine (lays the The complexity of the jobs may also vary by
analyzed and prepared for printing. color and black toner down in one pass) will job type, which can affect productivity.
handle a mixed color and monochrome
Generally, systems with more powerful print document better than a four pass because it is On a color system, the job type is important
processors and memory will create the raster not having to pass the pages through the as a gauge to how much color is on the pages.
image faster than if you have a slow processor. system multiple times. Many competitive color devices have to pause
Some systems will also allow the print controller to calibrate, adjust the fuser temperature, or
to RIP one job while another job is being The third type of engine is one that is a hybrid replenish the toner if the job contains a lot of
printed. When the previous job finishes printing, of single pass and four pass. These engines have color. These pauses can take up to two minutes
the next job is already prepared for printing, the black toner separate from the color toners. to complete, and often happen in the middle
reducing time between jobs to print. Systems When a monochrome only page passes through of the job.
that do not allow you to RIP documents while the system the color toners are “disengaged”
printing other documents will have reduced from the print path. However, if a document
productivity as the system may have to wait has color pages mixed in it, the color toners
for the next job to be RIP’d before printing it. have to be “re-engaged” into the print path so
the color can be added to the page. Often this
process of engaging and disengaging the toners
can take anywhere from 30 seconds to a
minute to occur. Now imagine this having to
happen multiple times in one job.
3
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
Q: Why does the workgroup size Q: Why are separator or banner Q: Will using a separator or banner
make a difference? sheets important? sheet to identify print jobs affect
A: An effective multifunctional system can A: A banner or separator sheet is a piece of productivity?
reduce or eliminate expensive personal or paper that is placed between print jobs. The A: Xerox WorkCentre systems provide
small shared printers. The system becomes banner makes it very easy to identify the user virtually the same performance with or
even more cost effective as the size of the who printed the job. We believe that a without a banner sheet. Competitive systems’
workgroup increases. As the workgroup size separator sheet is critical to support a large performance will improve when not using
increases, the number of jobs that are printed workgroup. If you cannot easily find your job, banners. In all the systems that were tested,
during the day also increases. many people reprint the job, resulting in Xerox WorkCentre systems were significantly
wasted productivity, increased costs and waste faster without banners, ranging from 1.4 to 1.9
You will probably encounter peaks and valleys at the end of the day.
in your workload. For example, when you times faster than the respective competitors.
arrive at your desk first thing in the morning, If the end user community is unhappy with the For example, the following chart compares
what do you do? Many people open their email system implementation because they cannot the Xerox WorkCentre Pro 245, with a rated
and either read documents on line or print easily find their job or the system is too slow for speed of 45 PPM, versus two competitors who
email notes and attachments. It is estimated their environment, you may end up purchasing also had a rated speed of 45 PPM. All three
that it is 30% faster to read a hard copy more systems than you originally planned. systems used a test suite that represents a
document versus an electronic document. mix of jobs that are typically printed in an
Many users also take the hard copy to office environment.
meetings and review during the meetings. Some systems do not have a system generated
Performance testing should replicate the busy banner page, so they rely on separator sheets
office environment where multiple people are created by the driver. This impacts productivity
printing documents at the same time. When in that a separator sheet is processed by the
this happens, the system uses a print queue. device as a separate job.
The effectiveness of the network controller and
system’s ability to manage the print queue
should be tested. That is, how quickly can the
system RIP the next document in queue while
printing the current job? Does the system
minimize the time between jobs or does it
cycle down between print jobs?
4
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
Q: What test suite should I use for Q: Are there other productivity Office Printing Productivity
my office? considerations? Summary
A: We would encourage you to use documents A: Although printing accounts for about 2/3 Not all systems are created equally!
that you print daily within your organization. of the output of many organizations, there are The Xerox WorkCentre is optimized for the
This will give you the best data to understand other factors that will affect your system’s busy office environment. Xerox has been
how the product will behave in your performance. If you are using a multifunctional producing printing systems since the 1970’s.
organization. We also suggest that you system that can copy, print, scan and fax, there The experience with our printing systems and
replicate the environment that you will be are other factors that will affect the overall DocuTech® solutions taught us how to maximize
using the system, as the productivity of tested productivity of the system. Attached is a white the system’s productivity. Multiple jobs
systems will vary widely depending on the paper that addresses these factors. continue to print with little or not hesitation
job mix. For instance, if you have a large between jobs. We strive to keep the paper path
workgroup, insure that you have multiple full at all times, resulting in output speed that
jobs in the queue, representing the busy approaches the rated speed of the device.
office environment. If you have stapling
requirements, insure that you have a mix of To understand how products perform in
both stapled and unstapled jobs. this environment, Xerox Corporation hired
BLI who determined test methodology and
If you are testing a color MFP device, be sure developed a test suite that includes banners
to use a document that requires the system to with a mix of jobs that are typically printed in
switch between color and monochrome pages an office environment. The results of the testing
to see how the engine handles it. Also add for the BLI test suite are displayed on the
pages that are heavy in color to see if the next page. Note that as the rated speed of
system can keep up with the demand without the Xerox system increases, so does the
having to pause. corresponding performance. In the case of the
competitive systems, the tested performance
If you would like to use a test suite of jobs
leveled off and did not increase with the
that has already been prepared, your Xerox
corresponding rated speed.
representative can also provide the suite to you.
It is designed to represent the busy office
environment with a variety of different job types.
5
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
*Note: Print productivity was conducted by Buyers Laboratory Inc. (BLI), with each product operating in default mode and resolution set at
600 dpi. Multiple jobs from a BLI test suite were sent in series to each device with output consisting of a mix of single and multiple stapled sets
with a banner page for each job. The order in which jobs were sent was randomly selected and was the same for each model.
6
Network Office Productivity –
MFP Performance
Xerox WorkCentre Systems Versus competitive products
7
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
8
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
System Intelligence
SMart Controller Intelligent Print Drivers
In a networked, digital multifunction Additionally, printing of multiple page Our goal is to minimize the steps to get basic
environment, throughput of devices is a much documents begins as soon as the first page is device information. Our print drivers allow
more accurate indicator of productivity and RIP’d, not after the entire file is processed. users to see the device status, current print
performance than traditional copier “page-per- This greatly improves overall output speed. queue, printed document queue, and supply
minute” (PPM) ratings. The fastest rated-speed status, all from within the print driver. The
system in the marketplace can be dramatically Competitive Observations: There is print drivers are for the WorkCentre series,
slower in the office, depending on the type of significant variance in the controller design ranging from 32 to 75 page per minute
job and workflow. architectures of competitive systems. Most systems, are designed to provide more
competitors use a processor that is shared flexibility for the user. For example, exception
The Xerox systems use the SMart Controller, between functions, for example print and page selection allows the user to print inserts,
an intelligent controller that is dedicated to copying functions. The controller is not tabs, or combine simplex and duplex output,
the printing task. It is not shared with other dedicated to the task, potentially reducing all from within the print driver.
functions such as copying. The intelligent productivity. Additionally, the controller may
controller is a high-performance computer that be optimized for production printing (e.g., long Competitive Observations: Device status, job
uses a state-of-the-art processor that effectively run lengths, complex jobs), and may not manage queue, and paper/toner status are not
manages multiple tasks and simple or complex the common office jobs effectively, resulting in generally available from within the print
documents. While jobs are printing, other jobs significant delays between print jobs. driver. Rather, the user must go to a separate
are being ripped. When multiple jobs are in the utility or even multiple utilities to find this type
print queue, the controller manages five concurrent Resource Management of information. Additionally, advanced features
printing tasks including processing, formatting, such as exception page selection for printing
When working in a shared environment, it is
scheduling, waiting for print, and printing. tabs and inserts, if available from the vendor,
important to make sure that the system is
are found on high end (>50 page per minute
Banner/separator sheets can be printed at the available to print the jobs sent to it. But what
systems) and may require the purchase of an
device with the job and without hesitation happens if the system is not configured for a
EFI controller to support the application,
between jobs. Combined with the ability to required paper stock? The Xerox WorkCentre
which means increased costs and training
keep the paper path full at all times, this means systems are intelligent enough to set aside jobs
requirements.
that multiple users in larger workgroups can that require a specific resource. For example, if
successfully send their work to the device and the paper tray has not been configured for
11x17 inch paper, and the user sends a job Systems Warm-Up time
most likely have their printed output waiting
for them at the system. requiring 11x17 paper, the system will “Hold Xerox systems are manufactured to warm up
for Resources.” It places the job in a held job quickly from off or from low power mode.
Print jobs are stored on the WorkCentre’s queue and continues to print other jobs that do Xerox WorkCentre color MFPs use technology
dedicated hard drive, not held at the print not require the resource. The next job that is developed for our production color devices.
server until memory is available to move the sent that does not require the resource continues Emulsion Aggregate Toner (or EA toner) is
job to the device. The customer advantage is to print. This allows the system to continue to chemically grown toner that does not require
two-fold. First, the print server requirements produce output without interruption. fuser oil. This allows the fuser to warm up
are minimized as the jobs are quickly moved quicker, and therefore the system is ready to
to the device where the controller manages the Competitive Observations: Resource print in less than 2 minutes. Our newest
multiple states of the print queue. The ability management is a problem for most of the monochrome MFP systems require only 72
to see all jobs in queue, including jobs that competitive systems that we have tested. When seconds to warm up as a result of new fuser design.
have been printed, allows the user to see the you send a print job to a system that requires a
status of their job and avoid reprinting the job resource that has not been configured for the Competitive Observations: Warm up times
if the job is not at the device. Secondly, with system, all further printing stops. In the above on some competitive monochrome devices
the full job queue, all the print jobs are visible case when the 11x17 inch document is sent to can be as much as 6 minutes and up to 9 minutes
to the user. If the user needs to prioritize a the device, no further printing will occur until for color MFP systems. The fuser oil needs to
print job, (i.e., to attend a meeting or make a the problem is corrected. reach a hotter temperature. Even other competitive
flight), they can promote the job to the top systems that use a chemical toner require longer
of the queue. warm up times because their toner requires a
hotter temperature to adhere to paper.
9
Network Office Productivity –
What is the true office Productivity?
Summary
Whether it’s job queue management, intelligent systems design, Full job queue management allows the user to not only see
or superior feature design, including outstanding concurrency, their job in queue, but also to be able to promote or hold their
the Xerox WorkCentre systems provide exceptional productivity. job as required.
The Xerox SMart controller manages the print queue very And as seen with the BLI test results*, the Xerox WorkCentre
effectively, processing up to five different tasks at the same time, systems consistently maintain a two to three time printing
regardless of the type of job being sent to the system. We do not advantage when printing in the busy networked office environment.
clear out the paper path between jobs, have virtually no delays Unlike competitors whose performance leveled out as the rated
when printing banner sheets with the job, and control resource speed increased, the Xerox systems’ productivity increased
issues which makes the system consistently available to the user. significantly when the rated speed of the system increased.
Our color systems use the latest technology in engines so they can The Xerox systems will allow you to get your work produced
handle any environment without a hit on productivity - one that effectively in the busy office environment.
uses a lot of color and one that uses little. Xerox color systems use
SMart Kits that are quick to warm-up and ready to produce
output when needed.
*Note: Print productivity was conducted by Buyers Laboratory Inc. (BLI), with each product operating in default mode and resolution set at
600 dpi. Multiple jobs from a BLI test suite were sent in series to each device with output consisting of a mix of single and multiple stapled sets
with a banner page for each job. The order in which jobs were sent was randomly selected and was the same for each model.
Prepared by:
© 2006 by XEROX CORPORATION. All rights reserved. Copyright protection claimed includes all forms and matters of
copyrightable material and information now allowed by statutory judicial law or hereinafter granted, including without limitation,
material generated from the software programs which are displayed on the screen such as icons, screen displays, looks, etc.
XEROX®, CopyCentre®, WorkCentre®, DocuTech® and SMARTsend™ are trademarks of Xerox Corporation in the U.S. and/or
other countries. Microsoft® is a trademark of Microsoft Corporation. BLI is a trademark of Buyers Laboratory Inc. Changes are
periodically made to this document. Changes, technical inaccuracies, and typographic errors will be corrected in subsequent editions. 610P725080 NOPWP-01UB
10