^^i.

m30m m5m 2012pio^

http://wvw.hxkqyxzz.net

West China Journal of Stomatology Vol.30 No.5 Oct.2012

505

1000-1182(2012)05-0505-04

610041)

, 7

R782

[doi]

10.3969/j.issn.l000-1182.2012.05.013

Quality assessment on reports of randomized controlled trials of oral and maxillofacial surgery in China Dong Wenhang''\ Li Chunjie', Xiang Chenyang', Shi Zongdao', Tian Weidong'"'^. (1. Dept. of Trauma and Plastic Surgery, West China School of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China; 2. State Key Laboratory of Oral Diseases, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China; 3. Dept. of Conservative Dentistry and Endodontics, West China School of Stomatology, Sichuan University, Chengdu 610041, China) [Abstract] Objective To evaluate the report quality of randomized controlled trials (RCT) of oral and maxilloA comprehensive electronic search was carried out through facial surgery in China during 20002009. Methods

Chinese Biomdical Literature Database (CBM), VIP Database for Chinese Technical Periodicals (VIP) and China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI), and 19 kinds of journals of stomatology in China were also hand-searched. We identified RCT published between 2000 and 2009, and classified into oral and maxillofacial surgery and labeled "random" and assessed the quality of these reports using the consolidated standards of reporting trials (CONSORT) statement. Results 53 RCT articles were included. Reporting quality of the 53 articles was not high and the CONSORT score was 8.22.5. Conclusion [Key words] lity stomatology; The reporting quality of RCT of oral and maxillofacial surgery in China is poor. The consolidated standards of reporting trials; randomized controlled trials; reporting quaCONSORT statement should be used to standardize the reporting of RCT.

l/L M M i ^ (randomized controlled trials.

2011-05-18; (101061162)

] 2011-11-05

. m
, Tel: 13608053216

(consolidated standards of reporting trials, CONSORT)

506

^^k^ m30m ^s West China Journal of Stomatology Vol.30 No.5 Oet.2012

http://OTVw.hxkqyxzz.net

1.2.3

1.2.4

1.1 1.2.5 nese Biomdical Literature Database, CBM). i ^ 4 ' 3tf4^^lJi[^](VIP Database for Chinese Technical Periodicals, VIP)P4'H^y^3tSi(China National Knowledge Infrastructure, CNKI),
2

2.1 2010^1^11^5 0 1.2 1.2.1

2.2

<(/|iIE P 1.2.2

4" CONSORTS B S ;|t

m 1 J
Tab 1 The results of RCT assessment by CONSORT statement =53

35/66.0 29/54.7 13/24.5 49/92.5

aw

29/54.7 47/88.7

0/0 5/9.4 0/0

10

0/0

^ 3 0 ^ m 5m 2012 ip West China Journal of Stomatology Vol.30 No.5 Oet.2012 http;//www.hxkqyxzz.net

507

:1

2/3.8

12

39/73.6

13

6/11.3

14 15 16

20/37.3 27/50.9 23/43.4

17 18

33/62.3 13/24.5

19
20

11/20.8 11/20.8

21 22

24/45.3 16/30.2

cl. -
2)?IW: 29

-^a,

r54.7%o 201:

^50-92.5%, 54.7%, 88.7%, 73.6%; .5%, 9.4%, 3.8%;

23Ji (43.4%

; 27;^ (50.9%)

a
lu

508

m3o# m5m 2012pio.^

West China Journal of Stomatology Vol.30 No.5 Oct.2012 http://mv.hxkqyxzz.net ment: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised

CONSORT^ H J i S i t M ^ o i

trials(Chinese version)[J]. J Chin Intergr Med, 2010, 8(7):604-612. i., 2004,4(6): 410-413. Wei Maoling, Gu Rui, Zhang Mingming, et al. A brief study on the quality of clinical trials in 11 medical journals of traditional Chinese medicine from 1995 to 2000[J]. Chinese J Evidence-based Medicine, 2004, 4(6) :410-413. [5] ^ ^ ^ , 2006, 6(4):297-304. Mao Bing, Wang Gang, Chen Xiaodong, et al. Assessment of reporting quality of randomized controlled trials published in the Chinese Journal of Integrated Traditional and Western Medicine [J]. Chinese J Evidence-based Medicine, 2006, 6 (4) : 297-304. 2006, 22 (6): 49-52. Zeng Li, Li Yingkun. The induction of evidence-based medicine and assessment of acupuncture effect[J]. J Clinical Acupuncture Moxibustion, 2006, 22 (6): 49-52.

i.mm. iEPEE^[M]. 2)is. iip.: A^Ji^tami,

20, 311.

2010:

Shi Zongdao. Evidence-based stomatology[M]. 2nd ed Beijing: People's Medical Publishing House, 2010:20, 3 n . [8] ^M, 2001, 11 ( 0 : 1 - 3 . Zhou Zhengyan. Evidence-based medicinethe new medical mode in 21st century[J]. J Oral Maxillofac Surg, 2001, 11(1): 1-3. [9] u, 2007,9(4):379-38i. Jia Chiyu, Chai Jiake. Analysis of the insufficiencies and advances of improvement of measures in wound repair hy point of view of evidence-based medicine[Jl. J Trauma Surg, 2007, 9(4):379-381. [10] Plint AC, Moher D, Morrison A, et al. Does the CONSORT checklist improve the quality of reports of randomised controlled trials? A systematic review[J]. Med J Aust, 2006, 185(5) : 263-267. [11] Al-Namankany AA, Ashley P, Moles DR, et al. Assessment of the quality of reporting of randomized clinical trials in paediatric dentistry journa]s[J]. Int J Paediatr Dent, 2009, 19(5) : 318-324. [12] Cioffi I, Farella M. Quality of randomised controlled trials in dentistry[J]. Int Dent J, 2011, 61(0:37-42. [13] [1] Moher D, Schulz KF, Altman DG, et al. The CONSORT statement: Revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials[J]. Ann Intern Med, 2001, 134(8): 657-662. [2] Begg C, Cho M, Eastwood S, et al. Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statement [J]. JAiVIA, 1996, 276 (8): 637-639. [3] Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D, ^ . CONSORT 2010^BJ:S [14] ., 2007, 28(2):84-86. Zhang Zuohu, Zhang Chunjun, Ma Bo. The effect of evidence-based medicine on the quality of the medical journals[J]. J Mudanjiang Medical College, 2007, 28 (2): 84-86. [15] Rowe BH, Strome TL, Spooner C, et al. Reviewer agreement trends from four years of electronic submissions of conference abstract[J]. BMC Med Res Methodol, 2006, 6:14. Harrison JE. Clinical trials in orthodontics 11 : Assessment of the quality of reporting of clinical trials published in three orthodontic jouriials between 1989 and 1998[J]. J Orthod, 2003, 30 (4): 309315; discussion 297-298.

^f5!i(SEmi|ffi*TA^fflitWHSf[J]. 4'HEg^f^R, 2010,

8 (7): 604-612. Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D, et al. CONSORT 2010 state-

Copyright of West China Journal of Stomatology is the property of Sichuan University, West China College of Stomatology and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.