Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Id
1 The m a i n a i m o f this chapter is to explore active filters. T h e passive filters are made up o f passive elements l i k e resistors, inductors and capacitors and have been discussed i n C h a p t e r 20. T h e active filters e m p l o y transistors o r op-amps and resistors, inductors and capacitors. T h e active filters are single-ended. O n e l i m b is earthed and so the active filters are unbalanced. T h e y provide excellent isolation between circuits o f high input impedance and l o w output impedance. S i n c e they have a unity gain, b a n d w i d t h o f 100 M H z , they can be used at h i g h frequencies capability o f 10 V and current-carrying capacity o f a f e w m i l l i a m p s . up to I M H z . Frequencies as l o w as 10"^ H z are also possible. B u t they have a l i m i t e d input and output
23.1
ALL-PASS FILTER
All-pass filter.
= 0 = V i - V2
= V2
<21
622
N e t w o r k T h e o r y : Analysis and
Synthesis
Active
Filters
623
W v -
' R +
j(0C jCOC:
1 1+ j(0RC
changed as s h o w n in F i g u r e 23.3, a phase lead c i r c u i t w i l l be obtained w i t h m a g n i tude r e m a i n i n g equal to 1. Hijco) = 1- j(oRC 1+ jcoRC
R 2V,:
V,- + v
or and
= V2
or
2 2v 1 ' 1+ j w R C
2
vs. log /.
V
V: +
e{co)
1+ j a R C
-1
(23.1)
2iiRC
Figure 23.4 Plot of 0((u) vs. log /.
(23.2)
23.2
(23.3) 1 so that H ( j c o ) continues to be
LOW-PASS FILTER
A low-pass filter passes a l l frequencies f r o m 0 to CO, (cut-off frequency) and attenuates sharply the frequencies b e y o n d CO,. B a s i c a l l y , the frequency sensitive components L or C have to be used for filters Since L i s b u l k y and difficult to fabricate i n I C s , therefore, C i s the preferred component. There are two types o f R C circuits used as filters as s h o w n i n F i g u r e 23.5.
unity (-1). H e n c e , this is an all-pass filter. There w i l l be a phase shift p r o p o r t i o n a l to frequency. //(a))= - ^ M
V;{JC0)
= i ^ _ 2 t a n - ' (U/?C
1 sC
sCR + \ s C
-A/\/VTherefore, any value o f /? and C can be chosen theoretically t o m a k e the c i r c u i t an a l l pass filter. H o w e v e r , a fixed value of C is chosen and R is varied to obtain the desired phase shift. T h i s type o f c i r c u i t is also c a l l e d phase shifter as any desired phase shift can be m a n i p u lated without c h a n g i n g the magnitude. F i g u r e 23.2 shows the plots o f H ( j Q ) ) lag. and 6 { c o ) vs. l o g / . T h i s type o f c i r c u i t gives a phase
-180' Figure 23.2 Plots of H(/(u) and e{o)) vs. log I. log/ -log/
Hl
(a)
\HUa))\
R -VvV Z{s) =
sCR + \
These t w o basic circuits are introduced into an inverting or n o n i n v e r t i n g o p - a m p for one of the impedances and/or as s h o w n F i g u r e 23.6.
624
A c t i v e Filters
625
So an ideal low-pass filter has one pole at break frequency function G{s) = +
1 4-
s/CO^ filtering
(23.6) requirement. T h e
co,=
(a) Inverting Figure 23.6 (b) N o n i n v e r t i n g
(23.7)
Let
Z2 =
SC2R2+I
and
^ 1 = 2,.
-l/Cj/J,
= (SC2R2 +1)/?,
1 C2R2
(23.4)
In B o d e f o r m . Act
0.01
" O.ltu^
(o,
Figure 23.7
\ 0 Q ) , \00(0,
Plot of gain vs. co,.
CO,
G{co) =
-R2/R, I + SC2R2
-/?2//?i i + y CO
(23.5) Figure 23.8 shows the low-pass shows the n o n i n v e r t i n g low-pass filter filter.
where CO, =
^ C2R2
is c a l l e d the corner
or break
frequency. W h e n a) = CO,
72
O.lco,
0.5CO,
\ACL\
e
-6 -27 -45 -63 -84 The gain o f the a m p l i f i e r i s unity (since A C L = 1 + ; absence o f R i means that R i = )
Figure 23.8 Low-pass filter (inverting). Figure 23.9 Noninverting low-pass filter.
At
626
Active
Filters
627
jl_
ButterwortI)
sC T h i s is same as E q . (23.5) without phase i n v e r s i o n . Therefore, the roll o f f o f - 2 0 dB/decade in magnitude and - 4 5 7 d e c a d e in phase is same for both circuits.
T h i s gives the flattest possible pass band and is mostly used. Ctiebysliev 1 2 3 fitters dB dB dB Chebyshev Chebyshev Chebyshev '= '= a ' = 1.045 0.895 0.767
23.3
BUHERWORTH FILTER
C h e b y s h e v filters have the least d a m p i n g . D u e to light d a m p i n g , there is p e a k i n g near the corner The single-pole low-pass filter has a loss o f 3 d B at the corner frequency. If we further want to reduce the loss, the slope o f the r o l l - o f f must be made steeper T h i s can be realized by adding a second pole. S u c h types o f filters are c a l l e d m a x i m a l l y flat filters. I f a second pole is added, the system becomes o f s e c o n d order, i.e. ,
/ / ( 5 ) = ^ = ^
frequency w h i c h gives rise to r i n g i n g to transients. F i g u r e 23.10 shows the response curves for different d a m p i n g coefficients.
(s + (0,)(,s + 0 ) 2 )
+ ( 0 ) , + 0 ) 2 ) 5 + (0ia2
dB
T h e generalized form o f the second-order filter is g i v e n b e l o w : G(s) = where ci} = resonance frequency A
1.414 Butterworth
-30
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 \
0.1
0.2 0.3
CO (0.
10
I9l
(0
Figure 23.10
'jco^'
+ j a
CO
+ \
I A/ U = 20 log
I + j a ' ( c o '
A 1.414 (0
CO,,
(23.11)
+
(23.10)
a'CO CO.,
co^
= 20 log
first-order
1 1
1+
filter. (23.12)
Different nomenclature filters are obtained as below for different values o f a ' (damping coefficient). Besset fitter M(0)) = a ' = 1.732 or ^/3 T h i s is a very h e a v i l y damped filter and gives stable response. l-F
( 1 [fj
628
A c t i v e Filters
629
I.e.
Miu
= 20 l o g 1+
(23.14)
or
{I +
SC2R2)
+ R , )
1 R. "2 + SC2R1R2 1 R.
R2 + R , ~ Rj R,R2 1 C|C2/?,/?2
23.4
s ' + s
C,/?, -fC2i?2
+^2^1
C,C2/?,/?2
C,C2/?2
S i n c e the gain o f the op-amp is unity, v = V^, Rf is not a feedback resistor but a resistor for bias c o m p e n s a t i o n . Therefore, qR, + C2R2 + C2Ri ^ ] 'J 1 1^ 1 (23.17)
C,C2/?,/;2
C,C2/?,/J2j
or
Figure 23.11 B y K C L at node A , Second-order low-pass filter.
CiR^
+ C2R2
+ C2Ri
(-1
1 C1C2R1R2
C,C2/?i^2
The denominator can be recognized as the characteristic equation o f a second-order system i n which
C| C2 /?i ^2 (23.16) \lsC, R2+{l/sC2) and Substituting the value o f VA = (1 -t- S C 2 R 2 ) V B i n E q . (23.16), we obtain ^" V2;rC,/f a ' = 1.414, C,, C2 are taken as (23.20) (23.21) ^ Taking 1 2n^[c^C^R^2 = / ? 2 = /? and C, = 2C2 and Ay = 2 R , w e get f r o m E q . (23.18) (23.19) (23.18)
F o r a B u t t e r w o r t h filter w i t h d a m p i n g coefficient
a or (1 + SC2R2)VB 1) R, 2 y and C, = ^ F
630
A c o m p a r i s o n o f tlie magnitude and pliase angle for a first-order low-pass filter and a secondorder low-pass filter is g i v e n b e l o w :
Third-order filter o-
ff> First-order Second-order -6 -27 -45 -63 -84 -8 -43 -90 -137 -172
Fifth-order filter o filter r 3 ^
Second-order filter
Second-order filter ( i - ^ - H . 6 I 8 i + 1)
Here the magnitude has a 3 d B fall when co = co,. B u t the loss is 0.26 d B f o r the secondorder system c o m p a r e d to 1 d B for the first-order system at cu = 0.5cy, m a k i n g the second-order system m a x i m a l l y flat. A n o p - a m p w i t h unity g a i n is taken into account. O t h e r w i s e , w e c a n introduce the voltage d i v i d e r c i r c u i t o f Rj and R i n the feedback l o o p o f a n o n i n v e r t i n g a m p l i f i e r . I n that case the transfer function is g i v e n b y
Damping (a)
coefficient
Third-order
Therefore, the gain o f the first stage is 1 w h i l e the gain o f the second stage is 2. (b) Fourth-order filter, o:'(first stage) = 3 - 0.765 = 2.235
= - 2 ^ ~ 2
'
a ' ( s e c o n d stage) = 3 - 1.848 = 1.152 T h e gain o f the t w o stages are 2.235 and 1.152. Rf w d R are chosen.
The gains are 1, 2.382 and 1.382 for o b t a i n i n g B u t t e r w o r t h response. ^""^ '^^ d a m p i n g coefficient filter, a ' = 3 - AQ. ^ The corner frequency for both o p - a m p filters remains the same, v i z .
CO,, = CO, =
1 RC
'
Ao = 1.414 Ao = 3 - 1.414 = 1.586 (23.23) /Jy and R, For Since the values o f C , ,
higher-order filters, the phase angle at w = o) w i l l be 45 x ; i , where n is the order o f filter and C 3 w i l l be different, therefore, the higher order filters are = R-
not a cascade o f B u t t e r w o r t h filters. F o r instance, the n o r m a l i z e d values o f C,, C2 , C3 w i l l be 3.456 F, 0.2024 F, and 1.392 F at the n o r m a l i z e d frequency o f 1 rad/s and /?, = / ? 2 =
23.6
filter
HIGH-PASS FILTER
^ with the transformation, where s/co, at coj.^ at h i g h pass. It passes all the
23.5
frequencies above the corner frequency w i t h out attenuation. F i g u r e 23.13 shows a h i g h pass filter (inverting).
Figure 23.13 High-pass filter.
632
A c t i v e Filters
633
In our general c i r c u i t o f Figure 23.6(a), /?, and C , , are introduced in place o f Z , and introduced in place o f Z j . -sC,R. Z| (1 + JC |/?|)/ JC| l + sCfRt
is
Noninverting
tiigli-pass
filter
Interchanging the positions of R and C in F i g u r e 23.9 o f the noninverting low-pass, a noninverting high-pass filter can be obtained as s h o w n in Figure 23.14(a). T h e g a i n o f the a m p l i f i e r can be unity o r 1 + (Rf/R).
(23.25)
where
Vf)
where A =
-(Rj/Ri).
For the th-order filter. For a second-order filter as s h o w n i n F i g u r e 23.14(b), the transfer f u n c t i o n is g i v e n b y
M{0}) = 2n
(23.28)
H{s) =
^0
(0
(23.30)
1+
or
M(co)
d B = 2 0 In 1+
For
2n
where = - 1 0 In + 20 In A
(23.29)
= 0.586/?
B y cascading the first and second-order filters, higher-order high-pass filters can be obtained. T h e slope is the same 20 dB/decade f o r two poles and { n x 20) d B for n poles. Phase 9 from E q . (23.26) c a n be written as and F o r n o r m a l i z e d frequency o f 1 rad/s, the values o f C i and C 2 are 1 F a n d the values o f R i R 2 are adjusted. R i is R 2 / 2 for a second-order filter.
e{j(o)
=
1 +
0)
23.7
' (0
BAND-PASS FILTER
G)i and CO2, the pass-band b e i n g between W i and C02> coi. Its transfer function is g i v e n b y
K2S
JO)
So at oi = CO,, there is a phase advance o f 45 for a s i m p l e pole, 90 for a second-order h i g h pass filter and n x 45 f o r the /ith-order filter.
(23.33)
1-F
1 + ^ to.
co 2 J
634
A c t i v e Filters
635
It has one zero and two poles. T a k i n g Z , = Z^ and Z j = Zg, F i g u r e 23,15 can be obtained from Figure 23.6(a).
order filters w i l l make the band-pass filter a fourth-order filter but w i t h r o l l - o f f o f - 4 0 d B / decade. In general, a second-order band-pass filter w i l l have one pole, a fourth-order band-pass filter w i l l two poles, and so o n .
1+SC2R2
sC -sC, R^ (23.34)
rAVv
1 \
R '2'-2 yC
and S2 =
-1
R,
andG,=
Figure 23.15
Band-pass filter.
Ro = Q
There are two types o f band-pass filters, narrow band and w i d e band. T h e narrow bandpass filter has Q > 10, whereas the wide band-pass filter has Q < 10. A g a i n , the narrow band has B W < O.I, and the w i d e b a n d has B W > O.I.
(23.42)
Figure 23.16 Ivlultiple feedback narrow-band filter.
F o r w i d e band, the centre f r e q u e n c y / Q is the geometric mean of / a n d / L , and for narrow band the centre frequency / Q i s the arithmetic mean o f and / L .-. F o r w i d e band,
and the gain must satisfy the c o n d i t i o n A Q < 2 Q ^ . A n advantage o f multiple-feedback narrow-band filter is that the corner f r e q u e n c y c a n be changed to a n e w frequency without changing the gain o r b a n d w i d t h b y c h a n g i n g R2 to R 2 where R 2 is g i v e n b y R'2 - R2 (23.43)
(23^.36)
/ H + / I .
(23.37)
[fc)
23.10
T h i s type o f filter requires a pole at s = COQ t o p r o v i d e the first - 6 dB/octave asymptote. H e r e Wo < 0), where i = co, is the first zero that occurs. A second zero occurs at s = - W 2 and is
1 -F-
a pole at s = -(0 gives a flat asymptote at the h i g h frequency end. S o the transfer function
(23.38)
ft) 2 J
(23.44)
ft),, Therefore, the m u l t i p l i c a t i o n o f two first-order filters makes the band-pass filter a secondorder filter. B u t the r o l l - o f f is h a l f o f second order, i.e. - 2 0 dB/decade. C a s c a d i n g two secondTaking Z , = Z j = Z , F i g u r e 23.6(a) w i l l g i v e one zero and one pole. C a s c a d i n g two such circuits, a band-reject filter w i l l be obtained as s h o w n i n F i g u r e 23.17.
^^l-i:!!5!r2I!lfiyiA^^
Synthesis
Active
Filters
637
23.11
F e e d i n g the input to a low-pass and a high-pass filter o p - a m p s i m u l t a n e o u s l y and s u m m i n g the outputs o f the t w o op-amps, a noninverting w i d e - b a n d reject filter can be obtained as s h o w n in F i g u r e 23.18.
To voltage divider -I-
Figure23.17
For op-amp A ,
0
(23.45)
To voltage divider
Figure 23.18
T h e cut-off frequency o f the high-pass filter (fi) s h o u l d be greater than the cut-off quency o f the low-pass filter (/ H ). See F i g u r e 23.19. R1O Overall, + SC2R2) +s q R ^ sC2R2) (23.47) (23.46)
dB Pass band .
1
G ( s ) = -^l(lliW
Band reject
Pass band
^f(i + sC2R2)(l +
t
3dB down Low-pass filter
1 1
I \ i / / High-pass filter
F o r op-amp A , Gain,
\ 1 \
77-
= /f,C. '2'-2
(23.48)
Figure 23.19
/H
fc
/L
C-f
0)-
=. < T h ,e
gain is made 1)
23.12
NOTCH FILTER
A notch filter is one w h i c h attenuates at one particular frequency, creating a notch in the b a n d pass. T h i s i s a special case o f the band-reject filter where the two zeros at coj and CO2 merge. W h e n w e make tUj = (O2 i n E q . (23.48), i.e.
= 0)2 = 1
RiC,
o f op-amp A =
I RiCi
of op-amp B
638
A c t i v e Filters
639
23.13
F i g u r e 23.21 shows a n o n i n v e r t i n g narrow, band-stop f i l t e r F o r analysis, each T ( Y ) is transformed into n ( A ) and reduced to a single For null c o n d i t i o n (/?, + R 2 ) R i = X,X2 = RiR2 (23.51) (23.52)
Figure 23.21 3 Noninverting narrow band-stop filter.
F i g u r e 23.20 sliows a l a g - l e a d and l e a d - l a g network. T h i s network is used as c o m p e n s a tion network in control systems. The transfer function o f such a network is
7t -network.
F r o m E q . (23.46), TF = A y =
Figure 23.20 Lag-lead and lead-lag network.
V2wF
where fflb is c a l l e d the reject frequency or notch frequency. to
/o = 1 .
(23.54)
sR,R2+f
Similarly, C 3 is made equal to I C ^ .
(23.55)
InRC
C,
1+ l 2 \ sR^R.q) R, , SR,R2C2)
1 + -
(23.50) I +ST
23.15
It is a versatile filter from w h i c h w e can realize at the same time all the four types, i.e. low-pass, 2) high-pass, band-pass and reject filters. The state variable formulations are obtained b y secondorder filters (two poles) because they are less liable to parameter variations. T h e c i r c u i t consists of t w o op-amp integrators and one s u m m e r op-amp as s h o w n i n F i g u r e 2 3 . 2 2 .
where
If
^ 1
If >
^ ^ 2
it is a l a g - l e a d network.
F i n a l l y , C ) is made equal to C2. T o achieve a positive transfer function, a n inverter is introduced either before o r after the network. W h e n C , = C2, R\ R2 gives a l e a d - l a g network R i < R2 g i v e s a l a g - l e a d network
640
Band-pass
filter
B y L a p l a c e transformation,
, a ^
(22.56) (22.57)
s
VoA
= V ,
+a(os
R KRJ
+ voB
R. [R1+R2
( R ,
+ 1 RllR'^')
[ R J
C o m p a r i n g w i t h the standard f o r m , AoaJa = 1 and <a = I, a = fiib the centre frequency o f band pass
(23.58) where
filter
vB the output o f the first integrator is band-pass filter. S o integrating a high-pass filter gives the output o f the second integrator is a low-pass filter. S o integrating a band-pass gives a low-pass filter. filter
^oA =
- V , .
- a
I.e.
VoA,
sj
(23.59)
23.16
or
J H-to-f-I
B y i n t r o d u c i n g a fourth o p - a m p as a s u m m e r w i t h the outputs o f high-pass and low-pass (23.60) op-amps as inputs, w e can obtain a notch In the c i r c u i t , a l l resistances are made equal, except
and chosen in such a manner so as to make /?C = 1. A s w e k n o w a for different types o f filters ( a = 1.414 for Butterworth), w e can determine the value o f
= -I,
CO,.
= I =
U L
filter.
EXERCISES
23.1 versus l o g /. 23.2 D i s c u s s the general characteristics o f a low-pass O b t a i n the third-, fourth- and second-order 23 .4 filters. fifth-order filter.
filter
=
D r a w the schematic d i a g r a m o f an all-pass filter and plot its magnitude and phase angle
s\^,
filter
- -I,
(o= a , = a n = I