Project: 53 Benitez Subject: STP Specifications Submittal Evaluation Technical

Item No. Parameters Specifications Brahms Compliance Points AENSCHEM Compliance Points

Date: May 14, 2013

ALPINE Systems

Compliance

Points

Eco Systems

Compliance

Points

Type of Treatment Total Capacity Space Allocation Footprint

SBR 300 cubic meters 102.6 sq.m

SBR 300 cubic meters/ 230 cubic meters 94 sq.m

1 1

SBR 300 cubic meters/ 230 cubic meters no layout submitted

X 1

SBR 300 cubic meters 96 sq.m

1 1 1

SBR 300 cubic meters 160 sq.m

1 1

Influent Characteristics BOD5 Concentration COD Concentration TSS Concentration Oil and Grease pH Effluent Water Requirements BOD5 Concentration COD Concentration TSS Concentration Oil and Grease pH Total Coliform not >30 mg/L not >100 mg/L not >50 mg/L not >5 mg/L 6.0 - 9 up to 3000 MPN / 100 mL not >30 mg/L 100 mg/L not >50 mg/L not >5 mg/L 6.5 - 8 up to 3000 MPN / 100 mL 1 1 1 1 1 1 less than 50 mg/L less than 100 mg/L less than 70 mg/L less than 5 mg/L 6.78 not specified X X X 1 1 1 not >30 mg/L not >100 mg/L not >50 mg/L not >5 mg/L 6.0 - 9 up to 3000 MPN / 100 mL 1 1 1 1 1 1 not >30 mg/L not >70 mg/L not >30 mg/L not >5 mg/L 6.5 - 8.5 up to 3000 MPN / 100 mL 1 1 1 1 1 1 200 - 350 mg/L 250 - 800 mg/L 300 - 500 mg/L 150 mg/L 6.5 - 9 250 mg/L 750 mg/L 300 - 500 mg/L 150 mg/L 6.5 - 8.5 1 1 1 1 1 250 mg/L 750 mg/L 300 - 500 mg/L 150 mg/L 6.5 - 8 1 1 1 1 1 350 mg/L 700 mg/L 500 mg/L 150 mg/L 6.5 - 9 1 1 1 1 1 300 mg/L 500 mg/L 300 mg/L 25 mg/L 6.5 - 8.5 1 1 1 2 1

Equipment and Material Specification Collecting/ Equalization Tank Bar Screen Manual Bar Screen, Stainless Steel ANSI Manual Bar Screen, Stainless Steel ANSI 304 304 w/ 20 mm opening w/ 20 mm opening Influent Transfer Pump complete with accessories, submersible type, Non Clog Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood Porous Disk EPDM type submersible type 1 not specified X Manual Bar Screen, Stainless Steel ANSI 304 w/ 20 mm opening submersible type 1 Manual Bar Screen, Stainless Steel ANSI 304 w/ 6 mm opening Influent Transfer Pump complete with accessories, Positive Displacement Type, 3 lobe 1 cyclone type non clog 2

Pumps

not specified

Air Blowers Diffuser

Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood Porous Disk EPDM type

1 1

not specified not specified

X X

Alpine to specify what type Porous Disk EPDM type

1 1

SBR System Waste Sludge Pumps Air Blowers Diffuser Decanter c/w motorized valve Submersible, Non clog Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood Fine Tube Bubble Diffusers Float Submersible, Non clog Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood Fine Tube Bubble Diffusers Float 1 1 1 1 not specified not specified not specified not specified X X X X Submersible, Non clog Alpine to specify what type Fine Tube Bubble Diffusers Submersible, Non clog X X 1 1 Submersible, Non clog Positive Displacement Type, 3 lobe cyclone type non clog stationary type 1 1 1 1

Effluent Holding Tank Discharge pumps Chlorine Tank c/w pumps feeder Submersible, Non clog HDPE tank c/w variable speed displacement feed pump Submersible, Non clog HDPE with pump 1 1 not specified concrete tank X X Submersible, Non clog plastic tank with feeder 1 1 Submersible, Non clog HDPE tank 1 1

Sludge Holding Tank

sludge feed pump air blowers diffuser

Submersible, Non clog Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood coarse air bubble diffusers

Submersible, Non clog Rotary Piston Blower with silence hood coarse air bubble diffusers

1 1 1

not specified not specified not specified

X X X

air lift system Alpine to specify what type coarse air bubble diffusers PVC for underwater, BI for above water PLC butterfly valve

X X 1

Submersible, Non clog Positive Displacement Type, 3 lobe cyclone type non clog

1 1 1

7 8 9

Piping Control Panel Valves Other Items included in scope of Works Electrical power and water supply and tapping point for construction needs Detailed drawings that showing plan and section fitting to proposed location assistance in procuring permits mechanical ventilation of STP system warranty equipment warranty operations and maintenance completion date

HDPE/BI for waste; PVC for vent centralized PLC Non rising stem brass material @ 150 psig

BI for main header and PVC for branches centralized PLC Non rising stem brass material @ 150 psig

1 1 1

not specified not specified not specified

X X X

1 1 1

HDPE PLC ecosystem to specify

1 1

10

Must be provided

provided

not specified

not specified

provided but up to radius of 10m from STP

Must be provided

comply

not specified

detailed drawing will be awarded upon award of contract

provided

Must be provided Must be provided Must be provided Must be provided

provided provided 5 years 1 year

1 1 3 1

provided not specified 1 year 1 year

provided Alpine to clarify

provided provided

1 1 1 1

1 1

lifetime warranty 12 months from startup Alpine to clarify their proposal for operations and maintenance, (fees, duration, etc)

1 1

5 years 1 year from date of complete installation but not to exceed 18 months after shipment date of provided

Must be provided

1 year after startup

not specified

60 - 90 working days upon receipt of order Must be provided 1 year provided

2 1 1

150 working days not specified not specified

X X

Alpine to clarify completion of all works In site training and lecture provided

X 1 1

6 months 3 month hands on training provided

1 1 1

12 13

Training of Rockwell PMO/PMT Completed Projects

Total
Conclusion: Here is the ranking from most preferred to least preferred 1 2 3 4 Brahms Ecosystem Alpines AENS Chem

42

13

30

40

Note that this is a partial evaluation due to insufficient data from other suppliers Legend: none stated notable unacceptable Description of Points System: 0 1 2 or more for features not included or all brands having same features for features that complied for features that are highly valuable (subjective)