CC ON BUBER

CC ON BUBER: NOTEBOOK ESSAYS BY CID CORMAN ON MARTIN BUBER

by Cid Corman

BOOKGIRL PRESS

Copyright 2013 Scott Watson/Bookgirl Press All rights reserved Copyright 2013 Bob Arnold, Executor for the Literary Estate of Cid Corman

Published with permission of Bob Arnold, Executor of the Literary Estate of Cid Corman by Bookgirl Press swbotl@jcom.home.ne.jp

ISBN: 978-1-933175-07-2

Cid Corman I will not introduce because if you are reading this you likely already know who he is. Nor will I tell you how he and I rst met because that is already covered in an introduction to his early letters to me that appear in THE TOHOKU GAKUIN REVIEW ["Love Always--Letters From Cid Corman to and edited by Scott Watson", Sept. 1995] (in Japanese this academic journal is known as . ).[http:// iss.ndl.go.jp/books/R000000004-I3317593-00] Early in the 2000s when BONGOS OF THE LORD was still appearing as a printed mag, and after it had used a few short essays from Cid, he decided to hand over to me, for the purpose of future use, a thick binder notebook lled with essays typed on thick notebook paper. The notebook itself is sturdy and gray (IIH) and is made by Kokuho. The rst essays from the notebook appeared in The TGR in 2004 not long after Cid died in March. That collection is called "Surviving" [http:// www.abebooks.com/Surviving-Corman-Cid-Scott-Watson/770238821/bd]. The present collection is from towards the end of the notebook and all focus on Cid's readings of Martin Buber. Besides Buber, in these pieces are remarks about other persons of note such as Freud, Jung, and Charles Olson. Inside the front cover of this notebook, at the top left, is Cid's name written in ink and a date: October, 1965. The penmanship is his inimitable own, but one thing unmistakable is that he uses S for Sid--not C. Instead of typing the entire selection I made use of scanning technology. This is easier on my neck that aches from prolonged typing and also shares with readers how the pages actually appear, along with his hand written marginalia as and where it appears.

Scott Watson Sendai, Japan

from a rettdins oF Hartin 3

beris

iXttW&D

OF= f

U ss the], e o 3ntered ttn a ts ri y pote& ia Fe of o hers ttind y w 4 a uc settse into the

Of rFa Otte o tt e sell .the tthi OSOphy tts ty verbiase. mb th . o vo d ysses: o ust

T rttdtte ttust CW he atDyss it ttPans. The outtdest extt o o shortc is ttte fruit y _Fo attty. ratio , or s y sutterfic w Since tteFe y throwi y ttnto fe orle s ca o ust extel deS s pttdttty and OVe_r oarattce,

the perso
rrdista

hen ce st RSALE t4rOu & eXper

Ore Stt y & k d y his ow

ce ' eFttitS

ON (w LttZA ch tteatts odi ty. thout R c attac f r ts r mc t occurre c, w h ettc ou

ness to e r6 ht ome, IIcnter dr, o b ng

d t t o t s u s t

uman. . . matt that &y be Ca ed essent&

V

e e C t & z a t o )

Othin

V e = p s

tlIIay understa&d a stttuatioll, sayt at depth attd dettth rstanding onvincttng y exttose it tts und itt conversat & bttt um ess fttlldtt it way 3tlg h &o t6 o ettt tttter y,ithe understattd &&d, Ore thall that, =o y to Cratte pomDosity

ZA?10N st ttAr f r and ttndue pride anS se 6us rce of so f or sttch co can have no time
t lrotte 4t t 6 F r d h EALttZttS that th6 httaFt Of rO W ttto n ttrcceSS that o . (d o )is

n trttst, nbt on y t 'F t ttust ve itsettf

ser: '' aCh OtheF but to trust the process as a va lle bey3nd va tle f Bu or & had a s
t

se oF OF,
eS for a r

o& d ttave
th teFm ies . ll lf

s clivisive re ated frre a ytt and hiS n

c o

n sStte. Ar For the isste is that there where need rises ottt of need ttnt6 that sittati

1 :: : :: :3.: 8 8 3 3 : :p
hte ove a oe s otteratttve, s settce t
contrasts the llotion of the F

r,aS a
11. tttat Gthe r'perso
e o ent o

The _FOr r ttere itt an

r th Lat F

ndttvidu fr wttth

se fOr rves t S nsofaF a l& uslless has o

Lte Ss, wh

att es6r each otherc

2/

Llat ettse 6f es of /_3 its ttrh , h we what eF ttrStts cru6 a : the ttedd 6f o di _

c. Z e oys t, but es o EArJ=E ttt, 6rder t co e to a ythi . A d the A of tta ui

s di& o lca St aS h Ser 0&S Were, t nO o IP are f G x A Las the gracS,

Ettther att attpa_ratus or via ati b6dded. oes o RUStt wilat it is &d thus pre6 lldes the RU of olhers at any rea zttb e depth. oday & ese ttett addicts, 3 en the native ones,

he power, to carry ttts c6 teXt & ottst _for tS lr C teX s 0VER 0 E& S O APttoACrinS IT That ttea : ets t o other be. = laves t o 'possib LttZA O e to each Other he We kness of lost ar , ost poetry, ts oveF c6 txtua iztttio .

are each proLEd 6f htts cwn en t it. T e shtOme oott by ttatt ea, e tose of tterF 0t et a .
aFe terr bllt f61Ar of those b ndictttents of ZeFl vo ved ISea e f y. Attd thc critics, ke Xoest er, dont l .ce the roott of th usion. c o ll oemttca y to crttsh the Facadc y.

the ot t itt hettrtty ttettts t s ' P ettati 6& abi ity'I

or Sh erseris attt er40tSh Ore c ett thn hl its 71p6sitiv &capactttylt ot t &t a thrOWS

CT: he ab ty to pRC ve the 5ther t6 sotte &uthentit ext trhich tts 0 the t & b

hitts f awa'1, but rather that h meets to other in the f t os ay, at e ry p nttt without
d eSSeS hi h se f VULlERABL so 9 er SEtt th i'vLl& era tytF th o oan be tttro s ttroR ttd, as &OY As Lo d to6, c& nerGus e 9s ) =), uber RArOu d dd, RT (F ( etteritt tha& o t is neveF ttt be r' e is at y =
t e, but to tte il

that O CSe
otheF ttBM

ist whatev xt s o

and b
o cttts

6 ercis
for th

F so,

it IleC e SSar y
: F eLAr uSe

NttS extettsi5

f what o e is Att ways frnew ati y tl sttttlaton17 OeS ttev o el t becone poss . ! f So O llls itsft I e, on! eXte for he mere Grth s s and a s y ttnd ts reached reFe Se fdir cted & d h & d u On
perSO VttII br & pride. all atie o h t t s att=C 6t FO Vih i for its ol V y

re evance is as a tto

F the o 4

of &I1 0 elt

son
y IDS

ts ack OF c f tteetttng tthe other

G u ss3 S E 3 Si

y aid ttecottes uttfortunat tes f e eFO ty, v a arlq f Ot or Irf L he ttV o6 eS to gr

/
e dttfficu ty concttrtted tb be
0 &3 9 er a

of ttost or cs S 'lri&t'i rat r thall

ep n aC

that ttt s t bO of use

&ze vnat

p rea

he S a thuS m .

y ttove Frottore. y ettters as the S

IIe ass ss a Stttuat

ayst inevit&b
p ty t & y dia ogue.

IO
o

'' fFott the start. r ! oF b n the rig utte

y RIn eSs he dea LAr so 604e Who

Actua

s phys ca &red d ne s muctt nore y FttR10 ) ess:? &nd B 0 (11 lke y to be l'at a Fe to the other aticn ttELLS or the otherrs sit

r t3 83 3 r 3 3S so as tc &ve bee un&b e tc wttthdra

. =f the a yst teaches witharara
stancefof sus

dr atic& , tr&gttca i the cO&sq.lttnces of

his o 5 tuat s tsua cntiy ttte y

itadB&St t at that ieve
& the

, as he is attt to, since

pattte ay we

ha &ber ttcautif l y
o was

re ates htts story of a tAFOttan fFttslld w

so savecl ror socety

Omse In short, t trtte res

fo_r a4a yst is ke y to bc ttEJ_ lhe ppOSttte fr6m that uSLLa h f d atty y Provttd dtt A4d rO onse r fportr&it &tab 3 Every ReFalbrattdt se
pttese&ts & sltF & n lle and bttV Ous y Rttmbrattdt

a ways
Act

oarer eac

f us as we &re hts_ma
iS pattt tts

y the dged of & _Te ercRII Icep S ttte & it l ar e & d 4

stttuat o oc OttrF _4 d _for the =f exhu SA OF ttEtt A t iS Atte 6ss, Dtta oue ust comttc&ce ati nc operate ctlt oF h6 v etts of rttSk, s Sitttat 6 h fu r at o . U ess tttere s huttan be , there is essentia othing For ttan, any ttaII y t ref AS Te are thrown ac ve ctio b& Ourse occurst 6s :' ntttFva s ar !itim Tr(t e out). to the F b6 y are vit yth o u a6 s attd ttett a m to c nate ssuch reF ectiventtss ut theF o sttch l OS ty= ou de oF stch

3 8 3 : 8 e 3:: 8: t : :
sittp y For f exttcer atictt that dttvttde ,Gr 64 ! from a Others O es a Others si y os4ese . ' er is a te rea z s the vttta of r GOsttiZintti attd re zttntt tle thOr. t is boundi of course, i&extr cab y to s settse of bo cve atl fa t &d Fatts the .

BLlb

_T is so lll or ntt Freus,s fa cttz tr to dr6attil'he int6r _rets _Wo& ze sou that the

IS l ttnter ret o fr6 he start, o n$ ssity. his ate rret ,s use o sul e o v teri
ut h aS ttuber pretation as pieS, 1lowever. must be _fu tsho iZed. And a so d y Fea 9_Te adetuate ws, nd s Sed than Ju a y se co tess fo orers, that a the archetytta it tends to der e rttat tts aays stteciFttc in y
a 'S ttrO Cti St rOttnds for be
Ll rs

Rvery drea a te ctta w ch tty no tteans, of GOurSe,

Ca44 o dttvorced f FOtt the 6 6tional:

of the rtaFClr etvtta !

6 ore than

tiOn Catt be di

orced frOm what he o '1 o 8 or was:) co13sciollsri ca 6 y be t dy funct=`o Of itse f h hout ment& arttre es A e s6 s itco ls c snessi:. (SO = d6nt have awarettess of food e ccl & b d i 1 e, ct, 6_T the cttrcu atio o_f b od i& s ttu s er& y t y t&oush there are tes when th6se issueS do rise to ph ca
consc 1 stteSS t BLL here s enta thcO ls c ouS

ltess as suc 1.) =n dream t e bra is funtt ng o & sulD a ve . And th is' oy pFOper mat or br psyc 9$y,etc, A use _f F,st
otiom are r art as sub ati oF sexua p SeS ca . s eaa wh6 they ttre not o ens

he rete&

f ttenory is shoLTf

on tt vLa &ge , of extter

rettrrls,

er.cc attd th
t o sest

f r, but occurs natur& a_P st y & v the ocono y Of a &usio ty as tte .

&d G de eF r vattc e. A th s, attd h & b6 &s ttatttra y oo, wi

oF nocessttty" istribttttt a b o: s is a Funda ta F i' atLle ri. re at s p ysi6s & d sych . I s & r. Ache vttbr&tes .., sue or ttet
t t s tO ext nd he aS tO liSperse the wotL St O o f x aCt S0 ttt to n ze the efFoct

by ilbre in t ott f in as g it uptt attd ttIED&rce any directttotts and as far f_r Om c nter tts pOSsi ee do av to kttow the SCS Of FaS or ttV to
now th th s St e ce r to acottst rt. A& la ttteory. a

But it tts suSt a

it tl

t is oSse4

to a rLumatt rettat R at th s be r &itted o A ' boB4f de ve_Fed ca& ot o retrac d, t htts an effect, b )& g 4 s St( 38 a 8 tt &3 38 ch
it OCCuFs attd i8t1 04o LAFay Or attother ttradua

t S rs8 & 3 8 38 8 L ea ] the act las simttered dorn is y to be

y affect

lA" ?

'

One fo_Ttt oF ttaste o g pa n to disperse ttttent f_W v pr vttd & a ore abe ach e sowh re.
t stt for the I tt e 6 6 be de , rbvttdes uat Gwed, d ed, e First cttted. T y swa

bor of &h&
sffect yet tt A

er on stotte ttatt seem 6t to h&ve AFY

Decottd attd t ItS hav6 &ot de thl

rs tr: :: : :: :: :: : :: 8: ::
And it tts vita to REALttZtt tl is. he d66 or con frO e paranoiac fOr the first ti 1 s sceins tl someo e vF has underttOne tttc batt g at the satte po& t, Ie ttus , it seetts to _rl , iF grasp
`& s, hb S SO th c ci where antt what t4at pO t

bre ctt occttrS f & OnttFf: the reased a &Ve r Sy inf ctedt So pa bu d pressure & upon tta destr ctttve y. t occll s the satte & ve y p oe, re 4ops wettring t un ke raitt d a o e itt roc over 6 g pe_Tttods of o 6,etl.

t6 batter
OVed OF SO_ft

e ettents ttay tterhaps ettthe_r be re

eS otte LAray sI & Other, and tO

heLp aoorb th at,erittg or ttuate llfr ttt ad scoe for d ot ratiOna cPs z6 th cattl
att r

of & y he e nttst nt OF ache in e the o

a s I A r a y s s u

LlsttoFl

6r iFde

uSio

'r and be

t6nds to put it tter of 'acc tin !i t o a Ft(wl lhe F 6 f tpttd t e_rance) or faR_se doctora csi tht4 & never e her Gd, he ache st be rtet as ach qLlesti . ut c rity LS rettu red= B_are h a you& delltist
extr& t t Rf_Tolatt tOOth frorl m

e s t e d

Or is it, a

ogeFs

, I F that t e doctbr cttnt SE c 6ftett an , ote4 _40utth too)ne heF eXaCt y can t patttent. . Bubea u&dttr &s the need of rfobed sfi, & & g gh & 8e a c and ttut stem ollt

6 c d

& Oss ty.

1 : a we ness Of O 0 of o ers wa tO OneFs Ow the ther s r4d as a s6 rr or irdev o F but e must & t ho d back un ess that its s rettuired o e'S V era ity 4aust sh6 ts f nev rthe ess sccure lffic &t y .e.. S . t ust as a stLld ot Fee ess cOn fid ce 4 a teacher tto c say f!F dont ttl1614rrr th h 0 e Who a wayS the SrF ht 4SVeri!(C . Frost's
lS O&'S tRettse of Ltts Father o & who tteeps say& he efe oF sLliCttde). fFr dOnt k lrJ:' to ttost

It &ot a ttr Of

5/

_T es & ate y put t6

ish his o e 6od oF se

i So 0&s tO
y ______

re ation ffFttth ttyone e .

so.

ea is pOSSib e so o& s the phys ca &c ne has t proceeded beyond a cc_rta n ttbttnt Of o rettu_r . v There s pottnt say: L JIOttter cou d have over e Or Cancer w Il phFsictt and tte & ittatio were suffi itt nt ent to ttaintattn a bttLttn de
presstto of CattCeF Se Wttth a its co o tants ce bee ersib r6 her ott . here teF and recOFery has s S as yet ttot to be rd poss .

is, I f a p6 erftl psych COaF y ctto here is a prld we eFh S ost of us.
If yOtt can save

6ush stteCt t it i os io it as
e

, save illet OthttrrttsS,

quick.
The tteeS oF aFtt is Sttm y t h a t o f & 4 e t t d u r i n g f O r

tS dtta o "_f3rithe person of cttpacity tts rarett is precise

u Ost dtta

ca

y the aFtist, ancl he s thtls sharedt av ab 1 n thC fu os 6 htts dia o6a se F, for s &erttt os of others. s onttta .
ust hear thrOt ctors attd th6 h 6tio di

.
.

hat is actu&
The &nd

ct r ( theatre) ords the other

s ech oF si .

ettce vFhiCh a

s gestures address.

eF iS ttb ettcape Fr F6 theF 6re t A frott deat s of being tta& s . ut th

iVe hrtt ex&cer ated oo &rettess, w ls o LOeSS ers lo ct r w &

ese, ust e ttet utter t x ytt who ror Stence is trea e

y.

, d

nvarttab y he &tict h oth g c6u d tts a aborat6ry.

b6 ore extract or d .

vl sivett de et 3 britt .

e vG at a astt is t24e ty f ShttSsttcareFs ha ar o_f t& t tittc and ace: ts FLdex of vita tytt A p66m that stays a d r = iel freshes ttust fttnd the tteall of ettch ttorS anew e 6nd ttG& S and revent de_fintttic . s SaFtretS e ySi a y rat iS that he sa ll h r z6S us y and h 4S e ca o ho e to hitt t/f

it.

l ntic d & tepary itt fro &ut i e e F

GVe h oSl e t e _ 4 1 & p S t u r s,

But a]_so ered t seetts t6 have effectiv y ha

C ne must so out of cr_es d into ope _f as e o . v yl day ttust t ng ttrhere otheFS ttay fee

VA

7/

76

ttp_3

O ti

thtt ne

ativ

'1 o rlaYl i

a samcl u Littse ffF ttuS e th as ttos ive thFtSt th&t a is &nd

rea zAtio &re ttrashed

T by se o & sdes, d recs ve l ht _f above o F nS onese f as a Larbor ror others

whsIL tthey e Sh re ed here is ttea 6r

a sand. o rov de ettch a ter a of cett but R equir 8tltt httm to o ab o atte as Crusoe d rtt capac ty out o_f s pL the st of ttat rimorer' s ttrovideS even fr the brG ber. e c ffttP_ that routtht us Iia lshtta 's niF ta that wa eFt ot e
to t o F = ut every tids f s h O r e .

Y aFe attytt yu a_Te w ng to t

b& Ilot

to ses t&t your icie 9uttht ttay fittd stl speech to s .

Christ was latuFe and his sco e .Rd quat .

he attthor of , Fr &stattce, u61 o e rr tte aturen Such a wortt was &ot I a y 4S_er age 50. C istis histto_Ty, e o uch as
IAre httve ttttt rev s a lot d nct have

exceeded & f th . ust as S6cr e at age uld ttOt ha d th he 6ck: accep h6 w ud e def r d to e e tt ApaFt fr6 &yth & else er c s attd eave us ttte s&yi battd. s of A sctte nce tract o icatio h Fu d tteta ca y o etaphysics that

Bttpe s.
The dttff 1 ty of & it lrr story is t e_ra Fe lcurs in tt r, Fe ti 3 . ah

And eVe t tts not a o ra ty. t tts ony th_P6 art that ay d6ve o h al bei
frott rea z&tion to rca _fOr art eps zat o

t 0 ve at ttts ttaX e dl ue a a tch sep the des t fu est e Firos bLlr& & t pro
of departuFett Stays AS o AS SUCtt does it have tteanttn be wrtttes: f'AFt tts nettt
natuFatt ObttectiVttty &oF th

A 0 y . 3r the
oXgFettS

r o of
6 oF

sprit su_b ty, ut is the wortt and tetttattent of tll a dtion tt 6 the Stb ru tlle rea &d the sub t 0 ? whttc has beco e & formti' of tttte betwe9 It tts, atl sLL , the substantia F
a WayS iotettti '1 h&

ationtts sf
y . It s,
e

oc cttrS, COmes to

hett the ot

r Fee s ftl y attdFeSSed

8/

iladeed, that re31

aw n lts,

s if o ch 6f us Fe s eepttHtt be ut es ired u_st s&ch ttr na o arm

ot to lettove us fFO Tta C ttty"

but t6 open ts f es p Essettti& tttey est

our t e

y to t a d a that

lte&ch ss:r and y Bttberts works are sh the f o eda osy eSt approal
as k w , ! d sttre to ence

the cther CS ttOt tteap_ the ,ffort to ChaIItte the

3 ::: : ai : : :e: :]:

other, to ttEISeCt One's ow 'rishtnesst into h
,

roush otte s fettce t e seed nd ttrow in w&tever y educes the ttlldivttdu . BB_ber has the ttrace a so to re that he

thers i 1 o the mOst St SO fu a ray is ta secure ttd furx onfttrned one y to be

se f ttn a olle rs authentttcityt : tt s ronica tty, theni those whott we ca thy &ve th are often those who rttatest hea

. potent

th s ore o14er has rea ed [

Last yeari o heF Fe ttrr the throe of 6 Cr tha & th reSt f f nd is 5_re g 7e& r to thatt She tta 6v r be . 11y fbF ther anl&ed d s tr Ook at the S 6 f6Sh, F fr th6 dis& e6 6 ettrntt i b = y my mother eye & d tt vo t isstsS forth d 6re bea l f th ever ib forO S rtha wa artter 6F s fll d more ttrao r 6er. She did ttot ttee o se e cottG, &br ven wattt tO sSe tte e very 0 And o

visittr a S hare o &ts of ort wttat at Fo oart was 1 e&'eed th mensch saysf
th 3 t b _4 b C fttrtt Gne a eans of tte

rattd it is ttr

ted
dtla

thtts ttced heL4, tO See is sra_4ted t &d

r ttndiv 6ther i A3Set C4 sst But beyo&d

'
e

the tr r s by ts strug , ch t e 6 a rs, a thers o t utt thc the br d eVttn so be cottFirmed. dfF rent way &

P ttt P& &instant 3 : t

r a a t e F a t r t S l f u e s t t t h a t i S t h e

ca w&th the cran

e F tt stor

_ i f . 1 r C AI t.
8]i IFS ! EIS
0 ' r i 1 F

Btti3 ke De ouve Re & this n t u ea izes that =st state is th the d e_r & thtt cottn & abandottRe S S t t 8s 3] && u gc ta. r e.
-1

Bu eF p ut that ttatt shou

meFO y aS ObtteCtti, foF t

d ever rega
&t ttre entS &

a nan
rrdia

Cttt W 'agS gethttt 8r 9 :

o e th ost oF us exist For othe_Tsi vo v e& this ittp the face of what se3 es tts, for The unin o t, a necess ty il ge s to be cottti&

ettt fttw rea ze is that can tten tru y & ve to theF

y 60 f_Totttation ssue s 4ot

But the
SpttGifiC. heFl lhO Aussie tenn

se & & ts difF lm uttty r6ug es to the

s a y t t r ( D a v t t d s O n )

le o her day de t g&ve tho

e ra tty abs$

= actt weak serves byhis hobbed opo nt (Cra s)

ere ttatte a
.

berate y ttaSe tto at pt to sma u it f vor otherwis

eWidcP_ce t

Attd there tts

at

suc res onses aF

NOT Com

ace`

OftC e attt tiC is hard for peop z o re ll ss tiley are tl ease 7eS ven to : There s no ttuarantes that ttt ytr e a rttcttated & d that 4 the cotttraFytt the chOhed" se respottse p a wi t rec ve mor or eQua honoF. As ttuber sa : re are tttmes whett a ttan, to satisIFy sotte sta e co nc t, fOrfe ts th great chance of

Trellce betttee a trus occi d ou occ&sion).'r

a s re es the v ous deceptS_o s thttt otte ila catt em osure. e Fl earing ex yy t lthttdel Yet there o Freedo wse. Roo or o o s hcpo eS sta a. h Other ttust a ttrays be ttcco
od&ted. 4ere tts a p t where o e bocottes stldd y th_ro hetttio beha 6 r thS e ssary, s ttt w r the h or a cause whOse bF othersi o y &ture is auth ity. 'It is onets bettng sht t be collFirmed i e_Tsr and seeEl tse f as y 6 decs tive y offer a he t6 thisi ytte a to sse iS man's essen_ t& co dice, t r6sttst it itt hi sse

cPur,se.: One t at tittss pay deartty for & fe

n b lt it tts tteveF tSC dOar.

ved frott be

att as

ar. can be redeetted.r

2/

Frott a seas of Sartr 's Fata ope 6ssness o 3

r! e w o ea y kIIoFS hOW far our
se

hertttic4 has

ost

the y of true freedo

& d st h f

tween = of f
y v e of the dettand

in, icttt in every sreat k_r.ow

v pttctise dttrccttessi ov

edtte oF this k
he WeFe tte O

a,
y

earth w

did it

and 4ot dettart fr6

ar, suttpressed L

t unti
ing.

scoffers ar, st vo o the voice of their ow

tl heaIB _4 iS

. ubeF Shares C

ar's aotio

0 he ri oy& adversaryil.

es that o4e ttust f nd otheFS in thettr who . e r6a 3neS , Wttthitt event, a d 6t abstract d frro . e rtt a&d dap. cF Of the ana vtica as SeeS the fa o&e se sectts to ow.

. wh& s ng at the eded tt s&ys): s o ot a

otther ut a bo

tettSttve stir ng O Or.e,S be & _fe o the of the 6.et a , o er. (A y reverse this and
ittvttte a ot ers to beco to e herAse Ves

d sw dandi o ost ing

Stwtrra 6wttd by stlru ed) is is th soc

turo f , 6& y here'the Fea tt of tty actttott is r40t the a be3 bttt pos tl e eci ersoFl tthO faces lrlet W o = c aotta a n t tttrety, unttty, n ue 3 o y tO re s, and wttth his dy &mic cs er rea iz s a 6s thi & &ys anew.

1' zes, =14at tty as e c a e

aFld ithe d
ty stttrs to tten

tl nSWered
llt ttf b ossoE14s tua

o6 ca
heIL ostte.T'

ed.
&

e interltLu

e dia

sees that he is &o

sees t at i,

it !ltea6h but r: Oet

and ; LAFhiCh

S ttOt a natter of prop

iS C04G6Fned with protta & Att a dea,et .l q ts he ttpecific p rs ntro ed "ThOre part fro re y try arttest persllasttGtt iS o cttpture the & o F adher nt , and the ttro m tts ction
s y statttstic& are everttw&ere.) . As St ett r i c& IPo ca eth S at their aittnS

eig 9& thtt eFfectiv fact9_F.

exte&ds tta y ttras

abo o& F the hutta

prOpeF

what hutta G! c y Vttta

ty tts c rec prooityti

OS o ers W . He se&sets that 6 st not e et each unf S h sf settso others= IL. Wthin Fe at

V .

and Pe

atts, ll htts c ar y, than any, O SpEAK IS BO NAtt Rtt A D OR , SO li EI]rG 1:AT AND SOH ING TttAtt FiD ]1 D , AND W R FA DIAL GIC LLy, IF A OF GRttAT LNESS, I O FULF W ANttV TEE EN 70F . c adds as & coro ary (as a caveat),

G FAI

3 3t 8 it
v scarrisd what tt hadfto sa t enterS the aottu6 as a Fa ure, alld the dtta o e s a Fa ol , os of COurset (A artt as tt re iS eSSe a ca ) y dtta o Attd he ttotes that s ce tts o _4 t ttte d a fOFe osttca t What s t9 btt s d Cam _4eVer be ttredeter ned and oB_y Occur, it is et. . &t Fe dt ber rhat r sa need o _Tettettber what is tto:_
0 e aceds o detttity

Why shou o ?

Ch, Wtten otte

v v

ca

d into Fe atio . he 3in s ttn the tatt otty as tt a re be stracts S6es ttt resu tFld fOr ed a ttays divor a gro H an

o vent: 6r wttat tt rttcise y mufOd i4

F & yt

eters t sOe w dW that pro e t p r t t h e

ues are ofFeFeS tO attyone yet e 612

V
'

& 1 : vity 3 c3 8 e : 3 ta838 C ?t ' 8 38 .ute 8 .l

an ttnaS ssi e Ficti6 e 6de rn S i i4ed ua is lo tFast3

ra s t o s c e .

in era varittty of ittd=v

to llttderstattd he ndttvttdua sG fi FhttCh the I Ss tt its de th, S the s si nd as stress thc abso ute (cf C, 00,etc). Despite a oA & e 'outer 14For at or e ren a _71tOre

t a refrettc e ' attty, ses of cosEIttc s to the a sou &s the one that is rea y mea , w&at u st aby _r 3s hre s the t ndency

N9

D3E OF

1 NIF

eFaC eitus a ways remattned i_4 acco_rd h the tllloro& ving sPeech o is tittet y settsuous ...oos. dOes not ceas o oe For the
s su us ttea fu WOrdt the hu a w cL

cont& S the anintt of tl e trilet tted can be & th6 1FJFd beCattse t is be II ... t grows II( e sou )attd d ve o19s out of ttt to a voice which stte s to fe ow so s ..F . A setry that endl res nduFeS aS ivttIIg peech, hearrSt of s ec , as lhe poGt hinse f itt rROst suscept G to t o ving r 6f ttO_Tds and that is the rrtrtteiF RfOrds, & speec , attd tts Of cottrse, the ''meattittffr, the p wer that rettetfs ance. cont No ttatter hor ttucL tAre s ic t, however, the G ower oF ttrt is ts y uttusua enllanced b ity to carry r_ aII coAf dence and fe sttce, to others Oycnd a , ar exc er's fetttme. hese extensiotts oF huma
e g r e a 1 p a y s o & f O F 0 r l h y e t t t t h e r i c tO provttde ttround e s s 6 f b

or shou oetts w der

d at each rea

ttzattton.

uber caref x er's LAreak-4esses & ' y sco_Tes his ar ts faoRP 6f lntesca 4 Ot rirst,
__eaCh ttatt tO ne: retr at r s e ' the o her co os tOO nttch to l e with and str y a uts o et Su ucary
d GO fuSi . & ort, a co u s

oSt and the aut ear fg6F y _EtttOt rs ber 6a r iS st tcot s p ' o s tuatib stlch esapes 6r eva snsss'1
It ttaS rl at=on 6 h bei s Su_c , bllt

it tts e cli n c & dy as para_ in is w& dise, t is tture mas rbatiO . Che aSturbatio bttite u r a so seeS how o tO arl th ss S trtther ar t_Tttri S3 oF ar &terfeFeS, rt becotte ate.F, (This, of c6uF et wo &d be disp ted tty oll_T CurreL !or t ory. BIP_t thiS lh OttS OF itchancef a
p=osLi irfredd6 rF stt OF coursO o fr ed6ra at

ating to a is ttere se f ndu gencer r

&O Ctte e t Fef& Se exo t as fec us acttton perhapO. te the o o GtS F_3 Care =or others,

tti t 88. : : : :

2/

h se f intO the cond

eic i3 a 3w ;; ; y3 11ot take tttettse v s out of the co a ty, they

6tta ttII lht rOm titte c t& l out A d they st de ver up

ss t n thettso ves, the wh6 e vttntt pFSO &nd oe ttersorL fe, n order t with stand w & has t possessiott of t . Buber tts quttte accurate httre, he artttst

w r ar ttis etttrl ei sOFar s t , as he cant n t e occllrrenCe of tth tover

f'CO S tO h tries to re e the eve t

so substantttve
e4t

y as 10 rettd 's ttrottth ttay b hers.. e tr s,cret and

r e S t i t s a c t o w t t t h u t t t t s

r ttt aVai

to

fr is 3fLttab e ap_d ttts ttea & yottd the bear & Pc G f tt rt i he 6ns n iniO
lr OFe e ll, cotttttnuintt poss y.
s tS attd e tts the on y o 9 1 Ow to

that nen 4a 6 0 tier est th o os Fttwith the wordj that they attays ke .
t in th

do th s on inos o_f tty o

G44S Gf it

'1 e .ne 1 ne aiother ltrttc) y th

other. 1

r o ..I SeOs th

t those

ee y ta with one a .

e a frO ece : r ecl w Skr d l c rkOr =t y ke, IAror &s t the Wei do 6 Ow l otattity

'c osttOS, Por of th _4t tO to f t thett lhre ttxper 6 with o attOth ri h3 O tte attother xtter 6nce, and sttplD o t 6 e r40 6r xper e&o6t t Gther W6r g t wth the r iv d a the iv Ifr a the tlead '1

ber's t&rtt t der 3tX SOr assttstance tts natttra _ tOol Bttt we are s 34 so .

Authettticttty ead Oac a t ut hott to o tlte trucness of s bettn herl th

e rttChes oF hu are d ope&

to a&
3

widest,

,
& :s

beF SeeS

l and poetryt as

stpre & vett t attd 6o u b O y as ttanl e sees the peri WOrds of det oh from contexts asp the of fa to 8ess oF s eechtt A d can s too that it: re tthere o

osue, theF SO be no W 1 rrdia 8 g s8

F/

Buber a
ht

so rea

=zes that a matt GAN spedk to

1 snfaT an

F al

thAntf call_v

oes s 0 to others so he ttdea of lisur rttser LH er ch resu ts Vtab y from authentic con_frotttat oll s Vt& fOr eatr attd a s s someth oa had seYlsed &d rea zed o that it he a he ed ttpon llthe otherlt. c meet & . B r ttushes oyond W _ttttenstettnts llWOrd ttarlesFr rasp & tilat r,deF nf' is fttr &ess it ita

tha& s & attinea tOda zes that the e rea

very difFere es of ttea Ow ttore sco e t and Pic ess tO dia oue so tha 6verto 6siotc,, leattzes ttore than one, occur a And one
sense= ' nolArs A ttreto && c t statte of

o r zes ttnat S

ansttatte tts think es latt did ttot exttst efore hav ntt a fe ow be ved efore he d that tteans oward over a &&st him, & before he ,&gs ttith hi dea . heFe WaS a
v e r y

ways another.

Attd aS tt rea

izes

O s u e

e overhttard

soo&er o_T atert t6be tObe of

every sO

o u y t t i S t t e a t t t t O

e sees that ti o ystery oF the co of atttiuase d tttat of the comi&

matt are o&e.fl , t h e oe s spOtte&

eSs, sttOttenness to the

o, wtterever this ttartner htt b6r, Ad it F ows, as st&tes, that po try tts that tF tto oth6r f61rn && uatte so trued as tO a

rr B tlrlttt we ll of s e ut Grahce t3
herefore, cvery paratthr s it e of a ttoett r &S PO speatts: o may a so of ttts trttht.3 by say: he po t s eatts if otte d6es not ttea thctt the s&b 6 f tt b6sratthy alld tae uthOr
of & y wOrl s s u s t t h l i V s p e r o f

tttis v ry ttOe h stte is as ttoet the F spcakt3r of a trtth ber t's too &d trttth fa td & a o ttte woFd b&ctt t e=_ & rea tttyl y = for thett are futtdamettta v trF t t t he gets ati P of s be tr e F ovtttby: pea LlrSe:= ice s s 6f t s beyond c tua 6si 0'ltrh6 y q y tru6 6f ttcttec vers etc. he poet oerri SO suage

yt ? f 3c e

l tou accuracy le
e s o f u y s o

18uttcto. co_
e d y his so

But the

e of Roettng

d u :S:: ( : :38::
l is fttta H authentttc tolArards the y of a ch deetter poss provide taim as a ty t ttie 3 nduriVIs nerit othe_7 wiso. SO ost extrttoFdinary work of art, say, by a boy C

fet a urity, ness oF ich reOuttres a f& that th ttve at depth. cccasion stttys a

henti t such a ature pttrso , y tts Of

& OF t ever st911d up o a ttattare wor &A= by & & _f 50. Oycets PO s a re ma e WOr f art and few at anv age coll

, ut U 7SSES, Say, s Fttr produce such a tfo rollnd for the ore ttature, One provided cth r. uttt as FW "n t atttre of the ttarL had t o ore rlatLre atta _p4I y a so cut bactt a & t itse f in erb& en ties

but ts ttov fOPce of t is f a naturity that no y9 iant rtl j tto matter how br
co d accomttodate s eextterttnce arld

e r zat o8tl WO d be ttecessar possttb y

&osuatee Or a OhIIo says: I kno 1 0

Ou d ook atnd be _f ttt is to e y wOrk lllo t ato Aature ibttt l canttot attlrity
ust ttel tttere TttUG
thro h e eFy d y attd

Y tttIF, w ch means
, t h r 6 o co I I s

wo_Ttts,etc.

There are no short cuts.

A says h sf c 3 &o more. But 6 sG F to be sa e to t that t he ttst worth b that it ha theri others abo
can ven &ore for then tha Gr tSe

d is
f.

Pss y.
ubeFi etr 6 ' ( revF i' r !) aittst rtruth Ff(8 thei o ): fattth

i:de er'S ?

(diSCOVe y) s lfrtile. 4 _71st reve atlo e e & nes th tter deta d 6oracudes: t & he truth I s e h & truth of whic voucLsaFed f 3 iS o p_4eu la that pours itse Ottt 0 abOVO ( Ff uvttae ott a band of tten
OW SU_pertterso a : 6 S itSe = to e

c iv persOIl, s sln 6nets own oxist cet T fe & n the , aIIs orS W his fattth owed '1 V l ttess for tlle wora that is sPo 0 y ll

) (

.tf

Bl se t eep F th S his trtlth ut s &ot tr h that infortts fait t , but ts trtteness, its esse ia coherttnce to wh 66 LLle S wltlat is an. As srace, As ned ,tye WheF ces che and oy are
settaFab P . e attd the dist ct o II oses scIIse: it is

ess an ana fe ts ear y at al o any yst's tr t enter, o deve oG huttatt r &tion l n aco. 06cttr ffective ber ees such y tdke r re atiOtt as litrattscending his task as it trttnscend his ttethotl_.i UT, oth trttns6end 6n fe, un

&ess fe t ed be so conctti d anS so y 30 de a pretty tauto t is c ear osy. PrOV & most, an S ttive n F4uua servicet , . A co_rO ary, o re ver s r uttred he face of ev be se f O ti IL s re are sitttationtt where o&e ttust it6Fy Ottt'I, v ore s ervttc e s o mutua zed, w re otte ttere y y rea dr a o r for h sbOd, b nd t any other.
i erd FFre at o s cut off frott the ste_rt. Attd o_4 y acAe ttF ictecl pe&elrate es , oF s ence. Or sOttet oth n: 3 quiet aff ction wi al F.4yS prOve effi
cac ous

he doctorts FEE: & aysist diSturlDS re attto& so. It iS by _46 s ttFr ngs p_ow stana Attd tG ocastton mttst b otrred fr io. ABs Buber ' says t tt a Who rea hat is y tts One who do nt s t CttFry on th6 ob Of a itts bttt enters
6 t at tittes as a ttarttter d&res.11 rnhe ttdoctor of ttou s pttec se y otte lAF&o t po der6us sF, s a

but heFs s.

y a ne

c .

Btter is keett in setti

( t ria y)attd

Fe Of b th Ftteud the fa
ca y) ttin &

Syc

the ic character of r' u ti e e t th 6_Tux is 'tthe ttrrev r ved ti 3, a f Ct that y Of hows ,tse l by the starkest of & ista f L perSttectiVes, th c ottc er& .46&0 cl r& dettth

f, the . entiftted wih the erab6die G , he

eSCattab e tr trl eness as st
FP i s at

f e g attd Fr IL Fattth is e cited ness

o&st a reco o f rssp

whttch a re 11 Fed.
l y .

sib=

As suc

, t is a

& ever a
ust co stant

d perLaps
y _Fetttr

s the
0

F r611ttdtt to lArh_ich

w tever everatte we may attair2, f it artia ity & osd SCttSO

ut it ttl ou d _Tlot d tttat an y res oIIse

2/

to lteett reSponsibi
:,A_9enSe OF s e a ated in

ty a 0 y heFe does a
a positivS thrttst deSt V for it ew of h f of th

' tt&

G6Se f _48 ot e FS, '

= = ithtt that be t_rtle, ca t, u &ot, cttrcuttv or cuse nOrta `tys t &s abiSe & d draw f t even as a p &&t 66s F t e b t ess of sht, to

the fiery center as jo

ro.

k etic and

S CIISe,

rta ffect, o
t is ttte fire th

e a t7rayS c
t ve

sttort

w 6 _re air tO .4 itt ur

n ati e, positive cetus r tttr&s. ucr pro3 ts Fts stttu

rt is &

nettativ d ttOra

Ex te rites: f a gu t occttr ifhett sotteb 0

uF S an Order of the ha4 wclr d whose foun dat os he olrrs and reco 26s &s those of
OWn _Stettce & d cl_f a i co o& hu ex st

o pe_rf y when he

s
ce.

octor (`hd is is 6=e thatt an lere

doctora atter))wtto c8 frOnts stl h a sRli t th v tL S ttatttent ttu t ettter 81 y 04 into tthttt situatio s h& d in , he St y to LArou of the order a& ear : Ltts concerns

y6 t !it A a friettd
fe is 6'S OW& lt ttHS that other for who t . OF hOW eVttryorl s. &tter sca St J te in s ovftt htrt ca o s holtr L t e on th resp6 of his fatlleF itt the face O a her's deatttj Attd r es to try ev3

o a8Pfdi tts he foP s m p yon6 ese

seift tthe pttthoS ltsh OurSe lle c10esttt kttw ittt that that refus br Osr to & blle doL rn than attTthing eise For ght ao 6 es it lo a ard r fbr hittse f to y with hi f ttnd it F Pcds tt sl r 6
0rdttr lvettts he divOrc6s _4o

fTO iS fa s is li G crSi! ytt btt F_Tott a f protect o fact s liOT S fdestrtlc t o antrl lAF thOut any p6s tive Facttor to redec .

r y

388 8: :: 3 38 ..d : gi 1 3
efFectttvo e tl rdO& f r a _s y

IS I wttre thore

atts l cb d J

e a sirab e to 0 e r o s r cr tttca &OLkt their havttor y t h the ca ty to respOttd fu ha e ha y y neve And so things st set Worse for them sttde.

On so poetry y presettce catt evoke ttresettce

call otty b effe6tive where it is t ttust be a e to e met, odio fo3rth.

Buber, & L sto_ry oF ttG an e, denonstrates how ana ysis etc., tend to te diff16 tie of re at Father than to e nd e nto Te issues Frarranse o that tholigh pos

that viab o s eff tld, the fu e oF a tterso&ts be s tttartsd.

ness

th r terms, attyone syC (dis c y tra ht)has the c city, as he wttry

dttffic u ty atesi, find a arser 6s o thatt is usua Fespon y t e
cr sitt attd tte tes the occas

Or

l o Ca oC &tes t ifhe& a ll or e y
&, 6 14ree tts

th erso & pOssttb ty v ed presutta y fell s ttuch to ttsave the blP_t it ke th0 rttsearc rs who pre o elistettces to s nett p thett meFe y aS s, or who fa

y a Crttey Acy way o_F sostroy ers6 Whl e g t fe attd t46 6ty. 01 pretens tO save the
1 o ore aid r vttta t n ex 611ons 6r ittf rttSo ent. A f 9syfi lfays h 1 are ev &y vas 6s oF the issu_es

nttth & tsit ga :1 3+ to to ze a ttersO G s o

o ed, wich have et tO be f y facedi)

t'= Bu er stresses the lleed For 'tobedtto4 iSten so con bttt it is i dettuate es there tts a lnFl co &ty, cattacio lS respo&se atever fbr

ay be rettu_hed of ttt nd the for uSt tte

llel sitatodl) Se iss os Of h & Fe

ation

are no

attettta ocessar ess

aFS theSe days'are

y, to art.
G ttraSstri ers

So ttaray scho

6att he& ' .

at a cettete_ry: on y t v uttsi nottto of the deaS d they t d to _4w o ere y CttV8 the ttFttlnd St theret teS t wouttd FO Otte ot r thatt he who tttl

a . 3 ! ? 1

Int ilit ttus betP s ttpt, o

0 u y

BttlDer WOu

d t t i 4 o c o m p e t e n c e o f t h

ana

ysttetc.

as f roser st the poLrrer of for the spec&& icor the dtta otticeatttG 3 SOttet & tradttctory here. And it settms to me that Ro ers is, at FOOttt try to 6, the Lartter p8Ssibi ity: g P the unfragttented ro hat tho m dosy v vcl litt pay situattton, cuts aga st th c attc; u r is apt in pottnting out anS upt Ferhatts, ndeed, t is on ythe artist
o&r ti le wtto can atte t L F hO eSSS a tegr ty,

be catts edic G ttatt the pr est, the tthi OSOpher,

tse F te ds o er obta l tt Ad the word ttartist'1 to s lttgest its tll t are y a d insofar as t ey
COnVeFse O & 6n 6F i cttrefF attd Fiauthenticity

f r ation and whose tas , OrCOVer, be16 6s ore ex city st that, or the arser ro es tllat once

attd 'lconfront

ont'

For the artist's woritt is a & ortt e r &t of any si_4 e Fe edi tha tho h ttts tteattintt is strict y coherent 6Yl y rc ati & to s e ves, ut is cf fe ttust ave the cattacity ev kttd cont ua f the arsest re at oa FeaC , openttess, order t at the work se f may hatre depth and rantte of earttns, A_71d O ete re o 6an a& artttst fttnd ttte y co Fu nestt of ressiottj For s wor ust IEE he ives of others opertttivo y4 ffective re s rea ati _Te On that pri zatiGtt ttt bsar wttsther c y br ttot. Oo vration that f s t e aF e F Zation o_f others vo vcd isttchatter ol y, per fage o for &ssi =i at' what one ttattts, but f it abr tes c Datttty r otte rtta 611 0r another, attd curr es se f ote ce accordi y. i
Jo otte L eVeF b vezH earttt w& kv o t wa hout G a _fitte Fider W I 4 , attd 43 0&e Ott & o a

hoFse.

practisc s ttever exttrc s e mere , thOu

6Od o l 6o at it that war

_V.ercise iS i

here s no 4HOttth t ut exttens on and one ntts F L t e extens 9. Buber r verts to &n o
accurate e o 4, bu

d adatte of htts 6w
&eeds exa

-1 h is

? it hera 8 3 3 : i 1 ,
e: ?ione caIInct dO

ris re vo s on the I10ed or s =ots CettteF

V

pr ncip e that r3sists m

_rta y & d that stays p

lt.

2/
Recottc
abs

`ato , foF
ute reso LrC e_re

catt on
o rse._

y ccctr be_fore axI

_ _____

ribu

where

x atio_L ttay be abso

ltio ay be

ute y de Vered,
ey6nd the

FheFe abSO

giVe

ower of s

o her tO resc y tto

d Or nesate.

oeVer! that r 6 ho tts nor erat o 9 oF SettuttIIG tteither etta su r treS thru gous ccllfess o ( nes t re sf u nation), serves. he in er fe re s bondase.

:e does lte&

e& Ost6_r d attrettara, whose (Of attes l riOus te theiF sto ieS.
And wttt a tness in the llatte Spec .)

Bor ttrasps h w c ever mod rll ttan s hiS in vo o ard evasio s of authttnti OWS y, he a the alllswers and & often in ted cltrtt twists

as wo to var he forttu ae.

d ttafka to so s ttrv u tIPat s ttoi y ttGtte ettFe

Bttb6r uses DOstOevsk

IS, 4 d B A fF lk tt 8e satteF?

evo vese SO that ttte Ffher 1)can stattd :a_4t"oF

'1(now ttor6 art

lS y 6LAr.

eyo&S tlle fray

ise c3_ ed nd b ttte

Very ttage o
ab rclity diS

the oRe o s ays a th p y tp

in u y btt With 4o ore chottOe than

stticttde t a qua abst_rdity. Ber t F s ttU_ttttntt the wOrds es u

outh of f attd a 0 p et u si a . F6r= . o of t is 6rucia ro r to atty ttuttattrf be 6 FeSS f ttt tts

to X's
tuo sri or ths Bttt his e

!! rettu

prOfOuttd e&Se idtta o

ifferettt fFO dttr in

C fo

t bet_rttys the

&. A d ttvery ttu ty th & d06s 6an bef s reFerred ettact y tO tttupttdity. Attd 6f cburse
an n occur with6 B 1 u 1 s ttOt be

e o of

dunghi ( ke a b s excrem t) y that oaytt Wttth r to tte fre6d fro , t itt rathe o be rea zed 3 te. ihe brOuttht Pos ve &g and y =o t6 ope tc sense how deep y our cOndit o are sh9_red,etc.
A &fka say
s thtt o y

d o 6xa 6F ttRtL t that. t itt or tl On e a

!?. the sta_rt that each oF l s is FicOttaettined tO di t

ea& II o e call dra vita it frorl

ina y is what

6 ous to

fr6

FeSS cOttDAl' (so tttat evett at th s escatte into a darit b 6& stFedt rrovttdes a tr6 ndotaS feO g i) l o ''fro o doo e ra itte us.
But th$ is a Ot on that it is tiCOttdettnatiO an ettendttt o . Fbr it ot o ard this ird o Pr & & pos (da atiOn) y poss Tre t

t Satte tO r

/
Indec d, tho h We ca &t, the ttre oF thttnis

r6hins urpOseSr(which wot d e & 6iCa y be redundant attd tatto osica ) c o6 that wit the sitttat on death s the 3er a that we &Fe and ttay be, 4_nhat the fe= v is a f oweri&s. iro ttay f d ca er the d a the Festerir_ ve the nose pause, etc. y y ut is h3__Td ttstttnctive y 0 o ad re the co rat o re& ed ttnd to keep it rith utt f r aS ng as we ca&. L /d is tt rttyth. f ttctte &nd re ose` As breath as p se s, as earth revo ves a sungetc.

he horrortt then, or the ttettat ViStS is the ne

osary cor6 ary: cOnd eS to veF,. Antl this

is tteckett s espec & bay.

uber c10o settse the

i C& Onl v reatting &_ratlo Se sees that irre occur th 1 6st aCtive and te ifay ot as & Or & dob _ oFFerttng to a tttose bu_t as a who cottt F The weattness oF evevl lrith the

crux of Ll atintt h a ro_fou dest

srace of her ack&ow

doesIIt ttFaStt the ex

edGnent oF ttkl t is that she

stetttia root of it and as

restl & 6t i&ove beyo d her unittue= Ss tO Where she can oin Others. She wants to he p othttrs, ul
a way tliat 66me t her owtt r SGtte pri

She ist t s, 6srlsta&t y g the ground fro

Llnder own f et.

1lary.

lclr & satttsfact

r a is s$ l ra 2ed as to be os veS of a re_ onsibi ty a s sO tOc OF a

So th w6 css ttf a ttecltet

r a Br k r 0 s fi y_ is th W ss to t 3 on t e res onsi ty for thOse to w 1o ne is r ated or sho d . f either Becttett or BrO

r u y_ = 8sgi8 t 3 e ] Br 8 &8
p ayed E is se a & a yo an attd been o ess wou dve lDe & CuFbed. f r ttt3 _fFi teo

hav

Beri CO ture o art aFe as 1ry O basic and far It e o inS as atty = have e . he artis is t a S ave to n&turet b lt frec &s se _ftof it alld far as he may rettove y ho hse fFOtt it, he nay found httS ttsr y Via what occu_Ts to hi e s here of the bO d f f his sett es th f da ta evellts of percep ti , which is & eetitts wttth the wo_F d & eveF

II a

etttng ttit4 the wOr

t il

"7 )wh o 9o Go rad F ed er ( 8 d his risach he ttsp _Tituaflt? G haSis, 1 at is sPecifttca ,ve y sets marl y huma what dectts &art _f_rott a iOther v s &d p4 vttdSs bo the F ctua basiS fotr o r discu io 1 ot be rn ed y the concopt oF spttT &it . The tarh e ody sou erson s th ulllan & , s this ttho eness whttch s v d 4 is meeti& 14Fttth the wo_r d... o &er be & frott a ve, d c rtain y fr6 be o bttt frott evettyw re ti?

uber cottes c ose to iltte e catteFFlherS attd the vita rea z o of the cttbod d e notttst & isses the basttG lature of art t _To C b ocmes corpore& f one oVe to c 6S to owiedtte t. e t e otherl & d aFt Cttrtattn y sttpp t e two cottneCted o_rga3tS g rather th y are e the e ectrttc oes betlrFee_4 ch ttts
Sp S

rtThe ttew tte d uttt te y c s re s ttG at lh : the ?1 33 di 6 se th e ti6 4d t ttt very activity t t . SO that t6a & stract o ltrlu_st reti TII

e ses, o t 19th 6 uFytt that

to sctlrce sooner or
a co ter ttach

ateFitO ttO C&.

Or tta

& of tta 3

So t SIs ec ng are never ttere divttdtta s: they o tlnctive attd this pFOVides the seed of CO
& rewt or tts r&ther the e to & vttdtta seed ro s. e t whttc Fr e Se e wor d

is o httk are s y a stagell

V

1l p _rcept o draws out o_f the be the LArorttd that ife lleed: o n attd, its e3 y ttsi
art trattscends neeS a nto the ocessary d es ttte su eFf L S

4
&d thus has raore

try art uber sces p

an

erlc bec Is6 inates frott a par exce h aII rettSy ess la iS a 1 ly

&& dittens

on otte o .

81- g= s t , 8 16FSt 1 !=