Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Preface
This report was completed by a mixture of full and part time students of Leeds Metropolitan Universitys MA Town and Regional Planning course. The group was made up of Nicholas Hirst, Alicia Hunston and Lee Greenwood. This report is part of a larger series of three, each taking a section of the grander Leeds Edible Campus area. Responsibilities for the report were split between the members to complete the research, audit and assessment of Woodhouse Moor. The initial audit was undertaken by all 3 members of the group, in which many of the photos seen throughout this report were taken. Todmorden, the home of the Incredible Edible ethos was visited and acts a as key source of inspiration and practical experience for the project. During the Incredible Edible Leeds Workshop, members of this group were put into two separate workforces. This gave a greater perspective when it came to new ideas. Following on, each member of the group worked on each page of the report equally.
Contents
Page 1: Page 3: Page 5: Page 7: Page 9: Page 11: Page 15: Page 19: Page 21: Introduction Maps and Site context Initial Land Audit Planning Implications and Policy Incredible Edible Leeds Workshop Event Quick Win Planting Locations Future Sites The Local Community; Learning and Opportunities with LEC Conclusion
Introduction
The premise of Leeds Edible Campus (LEC) in simple, you learn; you grow, you eat, you sustain. The project is about taking direct action, handing power to communities to shape their own future and reclaim the relationship with good quality, locally sourced food. The benets of the project are much wider reaching than simply providing food however. It is a positive, inclusive and educational process, which speaks to the fundamental principles in people, to not only look after themselves, but also each other. People have become disenchanted with the world and feel disconnected from political and economic bureaucracy. What LEC will do is enable communities to reconnect, to feel a sense of place and purpose. It has been shown in Todmorden, the genesis of Incredible Edible (IE), that it is achievable with the correct mind set and willingness to change the currently accepted patterns of day to day life. The key components to this are taking action, creating a sense of place and providing something which people relate to. Food is the starting point from which IE has taken huge steps forward, as it includes all members of the community regardless of age, religion, sex, or income. This report will focus of the transfer of these principles to a larger scale. The designated study area in this case is Woodhouse Moor, which lies to the north of the city centre and has a constantly changing and transient community due to the high levels of student accommodation. The main park is also a much valued, accessible and widely used commodity for local people and as well as those from much further aeld. The sense of openness and greenery, on a size such as this, is rare in Leeds. With this in mind, the aim of this report is to identify, discuss and prioritise possible food planting sites within the Woodhouse Moor area, which can be used to implement the IE ethos. To maintain the IE ethos, these sites need to be easily adaptable, relevant to the community and accessible for anyone wishing to engage. The sites will, in time, bring different aspects of the community together and help create an active and involved neighbourhood. It is acknowledged that there are challenges in achieving this; the city location is very different to a place such as Todmorden, where the project has thrived in the town environment. However, Woodhouse Moor in itself bears all the hallmarks of a community, with shops, restaurants, mixed ages, action groups and other facilities quite separate to the city. To this end, following the initial audit of nearly a dozen sites, three locations have been chosen as the starting point for the area. These, along with other medium and long term possibilities, will be discussed in this report. IE Todmorden began from small and humble beginnings, utilising any spare land possible to grow sustainable produce. The Woodhouse Moor opportunities in this report reect this and will be the catalyst for IEL.
Woodhouse Moor is located approximately 1.6 km from Leeds City Centre, as can be seen in Figure 1. Woodhouse Moor is a large park on the edge of Leeds City Centre. The park is currently spans at approximately 26 hectares and is multi-functional with various different facilities available for the visitors such as: tennis courts; playground; bowling green; basketball court; skate park and private allotments.
Known by many names to date, Figure 2 shows the Incredible Edible Leeds Campus Corridor carrot area, as it was known at one point. The project has suffered from many names, nally settling upon Leeds Edible Campus. Roughly 800m in length and 350m at its thickets, the campus corridor represents a large area, just outside a major British city.
Around 26 hectors in area, the land of Woodhouse Moor is owned by Leeds City Council, and is managed by the Parks and Recreation department at Leeds City Council. There is however also a heavily involved steering group for the preservation of Woodhouse Moor: Friends of Woodhouse Moor. The park is visited by 3 million people annually. The land was bought by Leeds Corporation for 3,000 in 1857. Quickly following its purchase, the park was opened as a Victorian era public park, within the year of 1857. The park currently consists of three parts, the rst been the main parkland commonly known as Hyde Park Field and two further sites on the other side of Woodhouse Lane, which are known as Monument and Lower. The park however was once much larger, with land now occupied by The University of Leeds being part of the original public park in 1857. In 1858, Queen Victoria visited the park during her visit to open Leeds Town Hall, leading to the building of the Victoria Memorial which was moved into Woodhouse Moor from the centre of Leeds in 1937. In addition to the statue of Queen Victoria, other statues found within Woodhouse Moor include; Robert Peel Statue; Duke of Wellington Statue; and the Henry Rowland Marsden Statue. Due to a rise in popularity of Leeds as a student city, and Woodhouse Moor as a leisure location for the growing student population, over the last few decades the area has had tension rise between the transient student population and long term residents. The development of the greater Hyde Park area as a student housing mini village led many families to leave, and over periods of student withdrawal, such as summer holidays, the area become much emptier. These changes have led to a rise in many social issues, such as crime and litter. It is hoped that the LEC project will remedy and galvanise the roles of these groups, creating a distinctive sense of place and relationship between all occupants.
Source: woodhousemoor.org.uk
Whilst this information provides a clinical and bureaucratic approach to the need for planning permission, we must not forget the origins of Incredible Edible. IE Todmorden sought to do, rather than sit and wait. Guerrilla planting was undertaken when and where possible with any spare land within the town being used and adapted to accommodate growing. It took actions such as this to show people what can be achieved and to turn heads. Should the founding members of IE have sought to undertake extensive consultation, permissions and involvement with any number of stakeholders, it would be likely that the scheme would now still be bound in red tape and nowhere near as widespread and successful as it has been. We must also provide some context. What is the actual harm caused by the planting of some areas in Woodhouse Moor? In a worst case scenario, the land is simply returned to its former condition. No aspects of this project are irreversible, but the benets are endless. It is hoped that the relevant authorities and community groups would see this perspective and embrace the change that can be made and the betterment of the lives of locals. Role of the Leeds City Council and the Planning Authority The land is owned and managed by Leeds City Council. Therefore the role of the landowners is of a bureaucratic and statutory nature. Leeds City Council see the importance of open space and Victorian parks within the city but do they necessarily want to move away from the traditional planting for the second biggest public park in Leeds? The park is managed by Leeds City Council Parks and Recreation Department. Long term, it will be important for LEC members to develop a partnership with in order to make Woodhouse Moor a key part of the scheme, as the park has the size and potential to become a vegetable hub for the Incredible Edible Leeds scheme. As well as Leeds City Council there are private allotment renters within the park and these people would be a helpful asset to volunteers of the scheme because of the allotment owner knowledge, some of the renters maybe willing to educate volunteers or even help manage the sites within Woodhouse Moor.
A number of positives were also identied in the discussions. A large number of the sites are easily adaptable and require very little work to make them suitable for planting. It was felt, whilst walking around the site in our workshop groups, that the project would also add interest to the more mundane areas of the park and if anything, improve its appeal and attraction to the public. Should it be felt that the chosen sites are unsuitable after a period of time, the short and medium terms sites can be quickly and easily returned to their former condition. The area as a whole is easily accessible for all parties, being predominantly at with a number of paths covering the park. This could form the basis of a green route leading between this and other sites within the identied corridor. It was felt in the workshop discussions that the LEC elements in Woodhouse Moor had the real possibility of being a agship for the project as a whole, because of the amount and variety of opportunities within the landscape. If the initial sites identied in this report are successful, the expansion of the project could be wide ranging for the local community. There are a number of residents, schools and businesses who could be heavily involved in changing the mind-set and perception of locally grown produce. The scope for educational opportunities within the sites is discussed elsewhere in this report, but as seen with IE Todmorden, the knock on effect of an engaged community will pay dividends and may even result in new careers and opportunities for the next generation. As an example, there are a number of restaurants, cafes and takeaways along Woodhouse Lane who could sponsor planting beds and utilise some of the resulting produce to promote the scheme. The workshop provided a number of points for further consideration and aided clarication on choosing the best methods for the phasing of our sites . One major concern regarding the nature of the workshop was the potential over thinking of the process. From our time spent with the founders of IE Todmorden, the clarity of their conviction came from actions rather than prolonged procrastination. As we were told at the outset, in many cases it is better to seek forgiveness, than ask for permission. With that in mind, our following recommendations seek to reect that spirit, in creating a sustainable future for the area.
10
1
The following locations are those chosen as quick win sites for Leeds Edible Campus, following the initial audit, research of planning policy and the feedback provided by the Incredible Edible Leeds Workshop Event.
11
This site is in the middle of the main park in Woodhouse Moor and is a perfect location to start the Leeds Edible Campus scheme. As a central location in the park, joining several paths from various directions and acting as a central link, this site has the highest of all footfall of all the sites originally audited in the park, with hundreds of students and other residents passing everyday, heading towards Leeds University, Leeds Metropolitan University or towards town, and back home again. Prior to future developments, this will be the rst or last LEC site in the carrot, depending on direction of travel. As it stands, this site has numerous wildowers growing free and some larger planted bushes, with a light tree canopy coverage. Suggested Ideas for this Site The central circle offers much opportunity to bring nature, planting and food close to a important thoroughfare, relaxing and meeting point, if done correctly. Remembering that this location is initially to be a quick win site, this report makes the following suggestions for this site; Planting in the pre-existing beds, which shows the soil is at a capable level of nutrition to grow. This site has ample pre-existing soil beds, and as such the addition of new planters is not required. Planting of vegetables which require low levels of sunlight, such as Lettuce, Peas, Beans or Radishes. This is due to the areas fairly high amount of tree canopy coverage. Ensure seeds and soil is protected through sign fronts, as this is a busy walking area.
12
This site is adjacent to the Memorial of Queen Victoria and as such is home to a large ower bed. Presently, and traditionally, this bed is lled with spring/summer bloom owers, and acts as a impressive front to the park. Of the three Quick Win locations chosen from the initial audit, this site is closest to local businesses in the surrounding area to Woodhouse Moor, being close to several fast food shops and a large pub. As such, this site is a pioneer in getting local business involved, a key aspect to community growing, as learnt from Incredible Edible Todmorden. Suggested Ideas for this Site Coming into Woodhouse Moor from the main street, Woodhouse Lane, this entrance offers a beautiful set piece of many summer/spring blooming owers set in place by Leeds Council. While it is not the desire of this report to destroy beautiful areas of Woodhouse Moor, the Incredible Edible ethos dislikes the placement of blooming owers over the placement of practical vegetables. This leads to this site being a tentative location, that must be handled appropriately. This report advises the following at this site; A mixture of both blooming owers and vegetables, to maintain the current character of the area. The current entrance will be kept similar, while further back vegetables will take precedence. Seen as this site has such an abundance of ground soil, no constructed planters are necessary. Clear signs and labelling to ensure that owers are not mistaken and picked as vegetables.
13
Located on the boundary of Leeds University, this site is home to Woodhouse Moors Duke of Wellington Statue. Currently at a level of slight disrepair and damage, the area is in need of slight infrastructure management, which would perfectly t into turning this site into a valuable LEC corridor location. Currently the statue is surrounded by multiple show owers in a planting bed and numerous ad hoc dirt paths, trodden in by students. Suggested Ideas for this Site As a main entrance to the park, this site offers a great opportunity to get people moving through the park invested into the idea, and welcome them to a newly edible Woodhouse Moor. Once again remembering that this site is currently thought of as a quick win site, this report suggests several developments for this site; Planting around the statue, inside the circular area, with stone steps to make the large inner area accessible to planters and pickers. While this area does have abundant green space, the addition of constructed green planters at this site would help educate and capture the attention of the passing foot trafc. As a primary entrance to Woodhouse Moor, being the main entrance for both Leeds Metropolitan University students and University of Leeds students heading into town or Headingly, this site sees large footfall of people quickly moving. As such the planted vegetables at this site need to be ideally both perennial and attractive to not become damaged and to make people stop and appreciate them. Below is an example of an attractive perennial garden.
14
Future Sites
In addition to the initial sites outlined previously, the scope and magnitude of Woodhouse More provides further exiting opportunities to expand upon, if given greater time and funding. It is important to consider future expansion sites at this early level, so as to ensure expansion is possible and smooth in the future. This section of the report explores two of the most viable examples of future expansion of the Incredible Edible ethos in the Woodhouse Moor area.
15
1
Potential Future Developments to the Site As has been stressed to this point, it is hoped that future development at this site will lead to a spreading of the campus corridor northwards, towards Headingly. By placing LEC plants and signs around this busy area, it is hoped the ideology of Incredible Edible will spread. Several key suggestions by this report follow; By turning the current bus stop near the north end of the park into a Incredible Edible bus stop (both seen below), many people who access this vital service will learn and benet from LEC. By networking and gaining partnerships with local shops, it is hoped that shop fronts in the immediate area could become covered in planting beds with free vegetables in. Planting beds already exist on some shops near the site, yet many are poorly maintained with only blooming owers in. To carry on the approach taken of getting the project out there, as well as ground planting sites around the statue of Peel, constructed planting beds around the bus stop and streets to continue to rise awareness.
16
17
How the large circle planter could possibly be positioned. The paths bisecting each section are clearly visible, separating and making accessible the vegetables within.
18
19
In time, we should seek to provide a denitive curriculum that incorporates messages about nutrition, food hygiene and sustainable and ethical food production. This curriculum is to be complemented and reinforced by practical hands-on food education like cooking and grown projects and farm links with in the local community. This will help develop an understanding of the relationship between a healthy diet and physical activity for their short and long-term wellbeing and health and create opportunities for people to eat and cook with vegetables that they have grown themselves. Local markets and food festivals in the area would be ideal for this. LEC could hold a Field to Plate day either within the centre of the park or on the Rampart Road sites, where local people, with the help of nearby cafs or restaurateurs can see the results of their labours and eat dishes made of the produce. This re-engagement with the origins of food, rather than the over reliance on mass produced convenience food, will give people the skills and information they need to take control of their lives, feed themselves well and prepare our younger generations for the future. There may be no better time in which to implement such a training and education programme, in light of recent national food related problems and the economic climate. Woodhouse Moor is the ideal location in which to provide educational events, due to the tourist footfall it receives throughout the year. The initial task however, will be to engage the public, either through an initial meeting or by way of guerrilla planting to generate interest. The IEL Workshop proved that there are already a number of willing parties with a background in this eld, who can assist in facilitating the launch of the project.
20
Conclusion
The sites identied in this report give a clear and structured approach to the implementation of LEC in Woodhouse Moor. The three quick win sites would be planted as a kick start to the project and the IEL Workshop proved that there are more than enough willing and able parties to make this happen. It is hoped that this will be the beginning of a phased and comprehensive integration of the project, with the medium and long terms sites coming in to action and leading on to wide ranging community involvement. Apathy is not an option and direct action is the way forward. The guerrilla planting of some small areas may initially cause an adverse reaction from some, but with the strength of the IE philosophy it is hoped that many will be convinced that the benets outweigh any small negatives or reservations. We have been wary not to compromise the use of the park as a whole and we are condent that the chosen sites achieve a respectful and appropriate balance. If anything, the chosen sites will add to the experience of visiting Woodhouse Moor and will bring people in to the area from further aeld. This can only help the area and create a sustainable local economy for people and businesses. It may in the longer term also be able to support related employment, as has been shown with IE Todmorden.
21
Initially, funding may be an issue. Generosity from local people and retailers will be required to make these modest ,initial sites feasible. As the project grows and becomes more successful, greater exposure will hopefully lead to greater investment from different sectors. As mentioned earlier in the report, sponsorship of planting areas from local restaurants and shops could be the key at this early stage. Whilst there are challenges, the long terms benets of the project must be kept at the forefront of this implementation stage. It would be remiss to ignore the constraints of the area, but through dialogue, learning and doing, these can be overcome. It is time to stop talking and start doing. LEC is truly a community led project, working from the bottom up, rather than simply waiting for change to happen. Recent scandals regarding food production and the over-reliance on multinational companies vin the UK mean that there is no better time for communities to take control of their futures.
22
Bibliography
Friends of Woodhouse Moor. (2009). Map and About. Available: http://woodhousemooronline.com/?page_id=2. Last accessed 19th May 2013. Leeds City Council. (2012). Local Development Framework. Available: http://www.leeds.gov.uk/counciPages/Introduction%20to%20Local-Development-Framework-(LDF)-.aspx. Last accessed 19th May 2013. Leeds City Council. (2006). Unitary Development Plan. Available: http://www.leeds.gov.uk/docs/FPI_UDP_001%20Volumen%201%20Written%20Statement.pdf. Last accessed 19th May 2013. Incredible Edible Todmorden Unlimited. (2013). Incredible Edible Todmorden . Available: http://www.incredible-edibletodmorden.co.uk/. Last accessed 19th May 2013.
Current Status
Existing ower beds around base of statue Open grassed land, no existing planting Open land Existing planting beds laid out Existing landscaping with raised beds Appears unused and covered with grafti. Predominantly unused, except for occasional events and concerts Grass verge, planted with daffodils. Divided areas of grassed land, unplanted Existing hard surfacing, pavement and bus shelters
Potential
Existing plants could be easily replaced with vegetables Hanging boxes could be added along fence and beds created on grass Possible raised beds and planters from tyres or railway sleepers Plant veg in existing beds, is in close proximity to bowling green however Use existing infrastructure as growing areas Possibility for climbing plants/vegetables High potential for hub area, raised beds and possible IE events Veg beds interspersed with existing planting Possible collaboration with nearby Church for planting areas Would require more extensive input, but shelters and surrounding area could be made edible Long term aim, close residences. Opportunity for large scale planting or IE events/markets
Equipped play area surrounded by open land, occasionally used for events or parking