Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Commissioner Urban Administration and Development Department, Palika Bhawan, Nr. 6 No. Stop, Shivaji Nagar, Bhopal Phone: +91-755-2552356 Project Co-ordination: Fax: +91-755-2552591
ii
PSC PWD ROB SADA SC/ST SFC SH SJSRY STP SWDS SWMS SWOT TCPD TFC UADD UDPFI UGD UIDSSMT ULB ULCRA
Public Sanitary Conveniences Public Works Department Road Over Bridge Special Area Development Authority Scheduled Caste/ Scheduled Tribe State Finance Commission State Highway Swarnjayanti Shahri Rojgaar Yojna Sewage Treatment Plant Storm Water Drainage System Solid Waste Management System Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats Town and Country Planning Department Twelfth Finance Commission Urban Administration and Development Department Urban Development and Plan Formulation and Implementation Under Ground Drainage Urban Infrastructure Development Scheme for Small and Medium Towns Urban Local Body Urban Land Ceiling and Regulation Act
iii
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Urban Administration and Development Department (UADD) of Government of Madhya Pradesh (GoMP) retained ICRA Management Consulting Services Limited (IMaCS) for assistance in the preparation of City Development Plan for Nasrullahganj town. The objectives of the exercise are three-fold: a) to assess existing demand-supply gaps in service delivery and derive a comprehensive infrastructure improvement plan (including a Capital Investment Plan) required, b) to identify revenue enhancement and financial improvement measures and c) to develop a Financial and Operating Plan to implement a sustainable infrastructure improvement plan.
Threats Lack of basic infrastructure, giving rise to poor living conditions, hampering socio-economic condition of the town.
As of 2011 (Provisional Data Census 2011), Nasrullahganj has a population of 23,738. Although the details for 2011 are not available, but referring to Census details of 2001, the work participation rate was 27% (2001) which was very low as compared to national rate of 39% and state rate of 42.7%. Currently, the sex ratio of the town is 964, which is far above than national level of sex ratio of 940 and higher than states sex ratio of 887. Literacy rate is 73 % which is very high as compared to National Literacy Rate of 64.84% and states literacy rate of 63.74%. Nasrullahganjs inhabitants are primarily agriculturalists. Soybean and pulse production is very high in the region. The total area of the town is 14.88 sq. Town has been delineated into 15 wards.
iv
Elevated Storage Capacity / Daily Supply (% of 57 amount of daily water supplied) Distribution Network / Road Length (%) 28
Sewerage, Sanitation and Storm Drains 6 7 8 9 Presence of UGD network (Yes / No) UG connections / assessed properties (%) Slum Pop/Public convenience (nos.) Storm Drain Length / road network (%) No No 102 197 No Coverage of UG network approximately 13% population resort to open defecation due to lack of individual or community sanitation facilities in their area
Roads and Street Lights 10 11 BT roads / Total (%) Road length per Street Light (m) 0 83 Municipal roads would require comprehensive upgradation following water supply and UGD implementation.
Solid Waste Management 11 12 14 15 16 Waste generation per capita (gms) Collection efficiency (% of waste generated) Landfill Area (Acres) Average vehicle trips Source Segregation and Composting (Yes/No) 250 42.1 4.3 1 No Need for a comprehensive program for SWM Presently, waste is thrown in an open ground near water tube wells Composing, Source segregation and Door-to-door collection needs implementation in a phased manner.
Actuals in Rs. Lakhs Items Surplus/ Deficit Overall Status incl. O.B. 2007-08 -32.15 2.12 2008-09 -47.50 29.15 2009-10 -67.02 29.94 2010-11 275.04 367.71 CAGR
Water Supply
1. Source Augmentation: Currently, the extraction of water is done through tube wells at various places with increasing population and economic development there would be more requirement of water. Thus, there is a need to encourage additional sources of water. This project needs to be developed completely by 2015. The additional water requirement can be met by adopting either of the following options: Drawing additional water from Narmada River. Sourcing water from the rain water harvesting vi
2. Water treatment facility: As there is no treatment facility available in the town, there is a need to install treatment infrastructure with a capacity of 5.6 MLD by 2035. By 2015 treatment infrastructure needs to be developed for 3.68 MLD water. 3. Distribution Network: The proposed water supply scheme includes the construction of additional 24.98 km of distribution network by 2015 and 39.63 km of distribution network by 2035. 4. Elevated Storage Capacity: In future with the increasing demand there would be need to increase the capacity of elevated reservoirs upto 1.23 MLD by 2015 and 2.19 MLD by 2035. 5. Metering System: 100% properties need to be assessed and water meters need to be installed in all the properties with water connection, so that revenue income of the Nagar Parishad can be increased.
Sewerage
DEWAT System: As the population of Nasrullahganj town lives in a very small area, and all areas are not contiguous and are fragmented, it would be very beneficial for the town (both financially and for operations & maintenance) to implement Decentralized Waste Water Treatment System (DEWATS) to dispose of its 5.26 MLD (by 2035) of generated sewage.
Sanitation
Public Convenience Systems: To provide safe and sufficient sanitation facilities to the citizens, mainly slum dwellers, around 37 more public toilet seats need to be added to the existing infrastructure in Nasrullahganj by 2035.
Secondary Collection: Secondary collection involves transportation of waste from collection points to the disposal site. At present, secondary collection is carried out by 2 tractors. These tractors are unable to collect the waste from the internal narrow streets. On a priority, secondary collection system should be strengthened to carry out waste transportation in an effective manner. All the waste transportation vehicles should be covered to avoid the spilling of waste. By 2015, 2 more tractors would be required if one tractor is making one trip a day and by 2035, total 6 tractors would be required. 2. Development and augmentation of the landfill site: The demand-gap assessment reveals the generation of 12.18 MT of waste in the town by 2035. The current available disposal site has 4.3 acres area which is sufficient till 2035. The collected waste is just dumped at the site without any treatment or segregation. The dumping site would have to be well-equipped to ensure proper waste segregation and composting facilities.
vii
3. Development of Vermi-Compost Plant: It is proposed to dispose the waste generated through Vermi composting which involves the stabilization of organic solid waste through earthworm consumption which converts the material into worm castings. The composting and segregation would help in some revenue generation for Nagar Parishad and it will also reduce waste amount to be dumped in the landfill site.
Drainage
1. Cleaning / Desilting of existing drains: As an immediate measure, Nagar Parishad should aim at timely cleaning and maintenance of existing drainage network. Under this project, major natural drains should be given proper attention as they are flowing in the Nagar Parishad area. 2. Construction of storm water drains: The Nagar Parishad should undertake the construction of Pucca Open and Pucca closed drains in phased manner. This construction may be done in tandem to the construction/up-gradation of roads. These construction activities would have to be carried out on an immediate basis to address the existing and future demand-supply gap. . In short-term, 3.20 km of new drains need to be developed and addition of 12 km of network needs to be done beyond 2035. 3. Upgradation of existing drains: The Nagar Parishad is also required to undertake drain upgradation works for the existing drains in town. In the short term, 24 km of existing Kutcha open drains should be upgraded to Pucca open or closed drains. 4. Development of Root Zone Treatment System (RZTS): It is observed that the sewage flowing through nallahs joins Rivers in untreated condition and creates heavy risk of river pollution. Storm water can be treated as well with RZTS after removal of settleable substances. It is a low-cost and maintenance free option that uses the capacity of plants (especially certain reeds hence also called reedbed technology) to absorb contaminants and structurally modify them for treating water.
viii
Health
1. Primary Health Centre: As per the UDPFI guidelines, the city need bed capacity of 54 by year 2015 and 75 by 2025 and 97 by 2035. At present, city has 50 beds. There are only five doctors. 2. Nursing Home: According to the estimates, a nursing home with bed capacity of 32 is required for the town in 2035. At present the town lacks a government or private Nursing Home. 3. Dispensary: Currently eight dispensaries are present in the town which is sufficient till 2035.
Education
1. Primary Schools: The overarching goal in this sector is to achieve 100% literacy rate in the city. Nasrullahganj requires one more number of schools by 2015; by 2035 it would require Nine primary schools. The infrastructure provision within the schools is in very poor condition and this has to be upgraded. 2. Senior Secondary Schools: Three Middle schools are present now and Three more would be required by 2035.
Socio-Cultural Facilities
Currently there is one community hall and one playground. By 2035 there will be requirement of two more community hall and playground each.
Urban Poor
Interventions needed have to be completed by 2015. These interventions are: 1. Prepare a Slum Free City plan 2. Comprehensive slum mapping and need for housing
Environment
1. Air Quality: Periodic monitoring and review is essential to check air quality. Suitable plantations or green cover should be provided on major routes to supplement better air quality. This would partially be addressed by the development of Parks in the town and a massive tree plantation drive. 2. Water Pollution: Efforts/schemes should be designed to check the diversion of sewage flow into Nevaj River through appropriately located sewage treatment plants. This aspect would be addressed by the development and upgradation of Sewerage & Sanitation facilities, Storm water drainage infrastructure and strengthening of solid waste collection/transportation system. 3. Water Bodies Conservation: For water body conservation and rejuvenation, proper attention should be given to the local pond. Also river front development needs to be brought in to improve the situation of the Navej River. City Development plan for Nasrullahganj ix
4. Green Spaces: A critical issue that needs to be addressed on the priority basis is the development of green spaces within the town limits to enhance the overall quality of the environment.
Economic Development
Development of Small scale industries: Focus should be on the agro-based industries. A land should be identified either within the municipal limits or near to the city boundary and proposal should be sent to the appropriate authorities for the same. This would thrust to the employment generation activities result into the overall up-liftmen of the society. Since, agricultural production of Soy Bean and Pulses is high in the town and these are exported from here to other towns and state for processing. Agro-Based Industries based on Pulses and Soya bean should be increased.
Urban Governance
1. Capacity Building: There is a need for training of the existing staff and new staff to increase the productivity of the work. Workshops and awareness programmes can be conducted. 2. Computerization: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad should initiate the process of computerization in its administration. Computerization will benefit most of its functions ranging from municipal accounting to tax management. The introduction of E-Governance will help in smoothening the processes and improvement in the efficiency. 3. GIS Mapping: A GIS mapping of the city properties will be very helpful in the provision of efficient services to the citizens. This would also help in keeping a tab on tax evaders.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Water Supply Sewerage & Sanitation Roads & Urban Transport Storm Water Drains Street Lights Solid Waste Management Urban Poor/ Slums Health Infrastructure Education Socio-Cultural Facilities Urban Environment Urban Governance Total Investment
the total investment identified for year 2015, which is about Rs. 1.74 crore at constant price and Rs. 2.08 crore at current price.
xii
CONTENTS
1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Background ........................................................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Objectives and Scope of Work .............................................................................................................. 1 1.3. Description of Tasks (as outlined in RFP) .............................................................................................. 2 1.3.1. Inception ........................................................................................................................................... 2 1.3.2. Development of strategies and priority actions ............................................................................... 4 1.3.3. Preparing a City Investment Plan (CIP) and a financing strategy ...................................................... 4 1.3.4. Draft CDP .......................................................................................................................................... 4 1.3.5. Final CDP document.......................................................................................................................... 5 1.4. Approach ............................................................................................................................................... 5 1.4.1. Guiding Principle ............................................................................................................................... 5 1.4.2. Approach and Methodology ............................................................................................................. 6 1.4.3. Module I: Inception and Kick off ....................................................................................................... 6 1.4.4. Module II: Consultations and Analysis .............................................................................................. 8 1.4.5. Module III: Finalisation ................................................................................................................... 10 1.5. Stakeholders Interaction ..................................................................................................................... 11 1.5.1. Interacting with Municipal Body..................................................................................................... 11 1.5.2. Interaction with other Stakeholders ............................................................................................... 11 1.5.3. Formation of Steering Group .......................................................................................................... 12 1.5.4. Workshops ...................................................................................................................................... 12 1.6. Report contents .................................................................................................................................. 13 1.7. Limitations and Caveats ...................................................................................................................... 13 2. Physical features of the Town ...................................................................................................................... 14 2.1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 14 2.2. District information ............................................................................................................................. 14 2.3. Location (Linkages and connectivity) .................................................................................................. 14 2.4. Physiography and landform ................................................................................................................ 14 2.4.1. Topography ..................................................................................................................................... 14 2.4.2. Drainage.......................................................................................................................................... 15 2.4.3. Climate ............................................................................................................................................ 15 2.5. Municipal area and planning area....................................................................................................... 15 2.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 15 3. Demographic Profile of the Town ................................................................................................................. 16 3.1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 16 3.2. Population growth and density ........................................................................................................... 16 3.3. Population projection ......................................................................................................................... 16 3.4. Ward-wise demographic details ......................................................................................................... 17 3.5. Issues ................................................................................................................................................... 18 3.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 18 4. Socio Economic Profile of the Town ............................................................................................................. 19 4.1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................ 19 4.2. Indicators ............................................................................................................................................ 19 4.2.1. Sex ratio and Literacy rate .............................................................................................................. 19 4.2.2. Average household size .................................................................................................................. 21 4.2.3. Workforce participation (Primary, Secondary and Tertiary occupation and income levels) .......... 22 4.3. Economic Base .................................................................................................................................... 22 4.3.1. Industrial activities .......................................................................................................................... 22 4.3.2. Trade and commerce ...................................................................................................................... 23 4.4. Issues ................................................................................................................................................... 23 5. Spatial Planning and Growth Management .................................................................................................. 24 5.1. Spatial growth trends .......................................................................................................................... 24 5.2. Spatial distribution of population ....................................................................................................... 24 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xiii
5.2.1. Municipal level mapping (to the scale) ........................................................................................... 25 5.2.2. Ward delineation map .................................................................................................................... 25 5.3. Land-use analysis ................................................................................................................................ 25 5.4. Housing scenario ................................................................................................................................. 25 5.4.1. Present and future Housing demand .............................................................................................. 25 5.4.2. Illegal colonies ................................................................................................................................ 26 5.4.3. Future growth possibilities ............................................................................................................. 26 5.5. Issues ................................................................................................................................................... 26 5.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 26 6. Citys Infrastructure Existing Status, Gaps, Issues, SWOT, Goals and Strategies ....................................... 27 6.1. Water supply ....................................................................................................................................... 27 6.1.1. Source, Supply, Distribution Systems and Treatment Facilities...................................................... 27 6.1.2. Connections and User Charges ....................................................................................................... 28 6.1.3. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 29 6.1.4. Water supply projects..................................................................................................................... 29 6.1.5. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 30 6.1.6. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 30 6.2. Sewerage ............................................................................................................................................. 31 6.2.1. Existing sewerage system ............................................................................................................... 31 6.2.2. Means of sewage disposal .............................................................................................................. 31 6.2.3. Household toilets (Dry Latrines and Flush latrines) ........................................................................ 31 6.2.4. Open defecation ............................................................................................................................. 31 6.2.5. Maintenance of septic tanks........................................................................................................... 31 6.2.6. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 32 6.2.7. Sewerage projects .......................................................................................................................... 32 6.2.8. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 32 6.2.9. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 33 6.3. Sanitation ............................................................................................................................................ 34 6.3.1. Private toilets .................................................................................................................................. 34 6.3.2. Community toilets .......................................................................................................................... 34 6.3.3. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 35 6.3.4. Sanitation projects .......................................................................................................................... 35 6.3.5. SWOT Analysis ................................................................................................................................ 35 6.3.6. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 35 6.4. Solid waste management .................................................................................................................... 36 6.4.1. Generation, Collection, Transportation and disposal of Solid Waste ............................................. 36 6.4.2. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 37 6.4.3. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 38 6.4.4. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 38 6.5. Drainage .............................................................................................................................................. 39 6.5.1. Existing drainage system................................................................................................................. 39 6.5.2. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 39 6.5.3. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 40 6.5.4. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 40 6.6. Traffic and transportation ................................................................................................................... 40 6.6.1. Existing traffic and transportation scenario ................................................................................... 40 6.6.2. Travel characteristics ...................................................................................................................... 41 6.6.3. Parking Current arrangements and requirements ....................................................................... 41 6.6.4. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 42 6.6.5. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 42 6.6.6. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 42 6.7. Street lighting and Fire fighting ........................................................................................................... 43 6.7.1. Existing situation of Street lights and Fire Services ........................................................................ 43 6.7.2. Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps ............................................................................... 43 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xiv
6.7.3. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 44 6.7.4. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 44 6.8. Urban poor and their accessibility to basic Services ........................................................................... 45 6.8.1. Poverty in the town ........................................................................................................................ 45 6.8.2. Slums in the town ........................................................................................................................... 45 6.8.3. Urban basic services in slums (In line with JNNURMs 7 point charter) ......................................... 46 6.8.4. Social security schemes and beneficiaries and other schemes ...................................................... 46 6.8.5. Present and future Housing demand .............................................................................................. 47 6.8.6. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 48 6.8.7. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 48 6.9. Social infrastructure ............................................................................................................................ 48 6.9.1. Health Infrastructure ...................................................................................................................... 48 6.9.2. Education ........................................................................................................................................ 49 6.9.3. Recreational facilities (Parks, Playgrounds etc) .............................................................................. 50 6.9.4. SWOT analysis ................................................................................................................................. 50 6.9.5. Issues .............................................................................................................................................. 50 6.10. Environment ........................................................................................................................................ 50 6.10.1. Pollution levels (Air, Water and Soil) .......................................................................................... 50 6.10.2. City green spaces (gardens and recreation total coverage ratio) ............................................ 51 6.10.3. Water front development and conservation.............................................................................. 51 6.10.4. Existing environmental regulations ............................................................................................ 51 6.10.5. SWOT analysis ............................................................................................................................ 52 6.10.6. Issues .......................................................................................................................................... 52 6.11. Heritage, Conservation and Tourism .................................................................................................. 52 6.11.1. Issues .......................................................................................................................................... 52 6.12. Existing Institutional Structure for development ................................................................................ 53 6.12.1. Urban Local body structure ........................................................................................................ 53 6.12.2. Town and Country planning department ................................................................................... 54 6.12.3. Public health engineering department....................................................................................... 54 6.12.4. Madhya Pradesh housing board ................................................................................................. 54 6.12.5. Madhya Pradesh pollution control board .................................................................................. 54 6.12.6. Issues .......................................................................................................................................... 55 7. Municipal Financial Assessment ................................................................................................................... 56 7.1. Financial Status at a Glance ................................................................................................................ 56 7.2. Revenue account ................................................................................................................................. 57 7.2.1. Revenue income ............................................................................................................................. 57 7.2.2. Own Sources ................................................................................................................................... 57 7.2.3. Revenue expenditure...................................................................................................................... 59 7.3. Capital account.................................................................................................................................... 59 7.4. Key financial indicators ....................................................................................................................... 61 7.5. Issues ................................................................................................................................................... 61 7.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 61 8. City Vision, Sector Goals, Strategies, Action Plan, Projects and Prioritization ............................................. 62 8.1. Formulation of City Vision ................................................................................................................... 62 8.1.1. Vision for the Town......................................................................................................................... 62 8.1.2. Mission Statements ........................................................................................................................ 63 8.2. Sector Goals, Strategies, Action Plan and Projects ............................................................................. 64 8.2.1. Water supply................................................................................................................................... 64 8.2.2. Sewerage and Sanitation ................................................................................................................ 66 8.2.3. Solid Waste Management............................................................................................................... 69 8.2.4. Storm Water Drainage .................................................................................................................... 71 8.2.5. Traffic and transportation............................................................................................................... 74 8.2.6. Street lighting and Fire fighting ...................................................................................................... 76 8.2.7. Urban poor and their accessibility to basic Services....................................................................... 77 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xv
8.2.8. Health ............................................................................................................................................. 77 8.2.9. Education ........................................................................................................................................ 79 8.2.10. Other Social Infrastructure Recreation.................................................................................... 80 8.2.11. Environment ............................................................................................................................... 81 8.2.12. Economic Development ............................................................................................................. 82 8.2.13. Urban Governance ..................................................................................................................... 83 8.3. Prioritisation of Projects based on Questionnaire Survey Result ....................................................... 84 8.3.1. Methodology for Questionnaire Survey ......................................................................................... 84 8.3.2. Ranking of the town requirement .................................................................................................. 85 8.4. Conclusion ........................................................................................................................................... 87 9. City Investment Plan ..................................................................................................................................... 88 9.1. City Investment Plan (CIP) ................................................................................................................... 88 9.2. Institutionalizing the CIP Process ........................................................................................................ 88 9.3. Summary of Investments .................................................................................................................... 89 9.4. Capital needs/ investments Physical Infrastructure......................................................................... 90 9.4.1. Water Supply .................................................................................................................................. 90 9.4.2. Sewerage and Sanitation ................................................................................................................ 92 9.4.3. Solid Waste Management System .................................................................................................. 93 9.4.4. Drainage.......................................................................................................................................... 95 9.4.5. Traffic and Transportation .............................................................................................................. 97 9.4.6. Street Lighting and Fire Fighting ..................................................................................................... 98 9.5. Capital needs/ investments Social Infrastructure ............................................................................ 99 9.5.1. Health Infrastructure ...................................................................................................................... 99 9.5.2. Education Infrastructure ............................................................................................................... 101 9.5.3. Other Social Infrastructure Recreational ................................................................................... 102 9.6. Capital needs/ investments Environment and Tourism ................................................................. 103 9.6.1. Urban Environment ...................................................................................................................... 103 9.7. Capital needs/ investments Urban Poor and their accessibility to Basic Services ......................... 104 9.8. Capital needs/ investments Urban Governance ............................................................................ 105 9.9. Summary of the Capital Investment Plan.......................................................................................... 106 10. Financial and Operating Plan ................................................................................................................. 107 10.1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 107 10.2. Financing Strategies for the CIP ........................................................................................................ 107 10.3. Finance Projections ........................................................................................................................... 108 10.3.1. Municipal Account Growth Projections and Assumptions .................................................... 108 10.3.2. Investment Capacity / Sustenance ........................................................................................... 109 10.4. Fund Requirement ............................................................................................................................ 111 10.5. Financial Operating plan ................................................................................................................... 111 10.6. Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 112 11. Urban Reforms ...................................................................................................................................... 113 11.1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 113 11.2. Mandatory Reforms at the level of the State Government .............................................................. 113 11.2.1. Implementation of the 74th Constitutional Amendment Act .................................................. 113 11.2.2. Public Disclosure Law ............................................................................................................... 114 11.2.3. Rationalization of Stamp Duty .................................................................................................. 114 11.2.4. Repeal of Urban Land Ceiling and Regulation Act .................................................................... 114 11.2.5. Rent Control ............................................................................................................................. 115 11.2.6. Community Participation Law .................................................................................................. 115 11.2.7. City Planning Functions ............................................................................................................ 116 11.3. Mandatory Reforms at the level of the Urban Local Body ................................................................ 116 11.3.1. Municipal Accounting ............................................................................................................... 116 11.3.2. E-Governance ........................................................................................................................... 117 11.3.3. User Charges............................................................................................................................. 117 11.3.4. Basic Services to the Urban Poor.............................................................................................. 118 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xvi
11.3.5. Internal earmarking for basic services for poor ....................................................................... 119 11.3.6. Property Tax ............................................................................................................................. 120 11.4. Optional Reforms at level of the State Government/Urban Local Body ........................................... 120 11.5. Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 121 Annexures 1: Workshop Proceedings ................................................................................................................. 122 Annexure 2: Questionnaire................................................................................................................................. 131 Annexure 3: Financial Projections ...................................................................................................................... 138 Annexure 4: Maps............................................................................................................................................... 142 Annexure 5: Presentation Of Final Workshop .................................................................................................... 143
xvii
LIST OF MAPS
Map 1 - Location map with respect to country/ state/ district Map 2 - District map showing Railway and road network Map 3 - Base Map of the town Map 4A) - Ward Map 4B) - Population Density Map 5 - Existing Land-use map Map 6 - Existing Road network map Map 7 - Drainage system map Map 8A - Water supply Map 8B - Solid Waste Map 9A - Solid waste (garbage dumping areas, existing location of landfill site) Map 9B - Physical Infrastructure Map 10 - Social infrastructure Map 11 - Slum location map Map 12 - Proposed land-use map (Broad overview) Map 13 - Proposed Road network map Map 14 - Proposed Drainage system map Map 15 - Proposed Sewerage system map Map 16 - Proposed Water supply map Map 17 - Proposed Solid waste management
xviii
EXHIBITS
Exhibit 1-1 Approach and Methodology ................................................................................................................. 7 Exhibit 1-2 Developing a City Vision (Source: JnNURM Toolkit) ............................................................................. 9 Exhibit 1-3 List of Members of Steering Group .................................................................................................... 12 Exhibit 3-1 Population & Decadal Growth ............................................................................................................ 16 Exhibit 3-2 Population Projection ......................................................................................................................... 16 Exhibit 3-3 Projected Population .......................................................................................................................... 17 Exhibit 3-4 Ward wise Demographic details ......................................................................................................... 17 Exhibit 4-1 Total quantity of commodities exported in 2010-11 .......................................................................... 19 Exhibit 4-2 Literacy rate and Sex ratio .................................................................................................................. 20 Exhibit 4-3 Demographically Critical Wards ......................................................................................................... 20 Exhibit 4-4 Classification of Wards as per their Literacy Rate .............................................................................. 20 Exhibit 4-5 Ward Level Gendered Analysis of Literacy Rate ................................................................................. 21 Exhibit 4-6 Average Household Size ..................................................................................................................... 21 Exhibit 4-7 Workforce details ............................................................................................................................... 22 Exhibit 5-1 Population Density ............................................................................................................................. 24 Exhibit 5-2 Land Use pattern ................................................................................................................................ 25 Exhibit 5-3 Present and future demand for housing ............................................................................................ 25 Exhibit 6-1 Location of Hand pumps, Tube wells and Well .................................................................................. 27 Exhibit 6-2 Present Water Tariff Structure ........................................................................................................... 28 Exhibit 6-3 Water Supply - Service Level Indicators ............................................................................................. 29 Exhibit 6-4 Present and Future demand and Supply Gaps: Water Supply............................................................ 29 Exhibit 6-5 Present and Future demand and Supply Gaps: Sewerage.................................................................. 32 Exhibit 6-6 Percentage of HH having individual toilet .......................................................................................... 34 Exhibit 6-7 Present and Future demand and Supply Gaps ................................................................................... 35 Exhibit 6-8 Solid Waste Management - Service Level Indicators .......................................................................... 36 Exhibit 6-9 Solid Waste Management - Service Level Indicators .......................................................................... 37 Exhibit 6-10 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Solid Waste Management ..................................... 37 Exhibit 6-11 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Drainage ................................................................ 39 Exhibit 6-12 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Traffic and Transportation ..................................... 42 Exhibit 6-13 Details of Street Lighting .................................................................................................................. 43 Exhibit 6-14 Present and Future Demand and Supply gaps: Street Lights and Fire Services................................ 44 Exhibit 6-15 SWOT Analysis: Street lighting and fire services .............................................................................. 44 Exhibit 6-16 Ward wise slum population of Nasrullahganj................................................................................... 45 Exhibit 6-17 Percentage coverage of existing infrastructure in Slums ................................................................. 46 Exhibit 6-18 Project Construction Components: IHSDP........................................................................................ 47 Exhibit 6-19 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Health .................................................................... 49 Exhibit 6-20 Details of government educational institutions ............................................................................... 49 Exhibit 6-21 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Education ............................................................... 49 Exhibit 6-22 SWOT Analysis: Social Infrastructure................................................................................................ 50 Exhibit 6-23 SWOT Analysis: Environment ........................................................................................................... 52 Exhibit 6-24 Institutional Structure of Nasrullahganj nagar Parishad .................................................................. 53 Exhibit 7-1 Financial status at a glance ................................................................................................................. 56 Exhibit 7-2 Source wise Revenue Income ............................................................................................................. 57 Exhibit 7-3 Tax Revenue ....................................................................................................................................... 57 Exhibit 7-4 Non-tax revenue ................................................................................................................................. 58 Exhibit 7-5 Assigned Revenue ............................................................................................................................... 58 Exhibit 7-6 Revenue from Grants/ Contributions ................................................................................................. 59 Exhibit 7-7 Capital Account................................................................................................................................... 60 Exhibit 7-8 Performance Indicators ...................................................................................................................... 61 Exhibit 8-1 Water Supply: Achievement Targets .................................................................................................. 64 Exhibit 8-2 Water Supply Long Term and Short Term Interventions .................................................................... 65 Exhibit 8-3 Projects Identified by ULB and Consultant for Water Sector ............................................................. 65 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xix
Exhibit 8-4 Water Supply Projects in a phased manner ....................................................................................... 66 Exhibit 8-5 Water Supply Projects: Responsible Agencies .................................................................................... 66 Exhibit 8-6 Sewerage and Sanitation: Achievement Targets ................................................................................ 66 Exhibit 8-7 Sewerage & Sanitation Long Term and Short Term Interventions ..................................................... 67 Exhibit 8-8 Projects identified by ULB and Consultant for Sewerage & Sanitation Sector ................................... 68 Exhibit 8-9 Sewerage and Sanitation Projects in a phased manner ..................................................................... 68 Exhibit 8-10 Sewerage and Sanitation Projects: Responsible Agencies ............................................................... 69 Exhibit 8-11 SWM: Achievement Targets ............................................................................................................. 69 Exhibit 8-12 Solid Waste Management Long Term and Short Term Interventions .............................................. 70 Exhibit 8-13 Projects Identified by ULB and Consultant for SWM Sector ............................................................. 70 Exhibit 8-14 Solid Waste Management Projects in a phased manner .................................................................. 70 Exhibit 8-15 SWM Projects: Responsible Agencies ............................................................................................... 71 Exhibit 8-16 Storm Water Drainage: Achievement Targets .................................................................................. 71 Exhibit 8-17 Storm Water Drainage Long Term and Short Term Interventions ................................................... 72 Exhibit 8-18 Projects identified by ULB and Consultant for Storm Water Drainage ............................................ 73 Exhibit 8-19 Storm Water Drainage Projects in a phased manner ....................................................................... 73 Exhibit 8-20 Storm Water Drainage Projects: Responsible Agencies ................................................................... 73 Exhibit 8-21 Traffic and Transportation: Achievement Targets ............................................................................ 74 Exhibit 8-22 Traffic and Transportation Long Term and Short Term Interventions ............................................. 75 Exhibit 8-23 Projects identified by ULB and Consultant for Traffic & Transportation Section ............................. 75 Exhibit 8-24 Traffic & Transportation Sector Projects .......................................................................................... 75 Exhibit 8-25 Project Development Initiatives to be taken up by Nagar Parishad ................................................. 76 Exhibit 8-26 Street Light and Fire fighting Projects .............................................................................................. 76 Exhibit 8-27 Street Light and Fire Fighting Projects: Responsible Agencies ......................................................... 77 Exhibit 8-28 Projects for Urban Poor .................................................................................................................... 77 Exhibit 8-29 Health: Achievement Targets ........................................................................................................... 78 Exhibit 8-30 Health Sector Long Term and Short Term Interventions .................................................................. 78 Exhibit 8-31 Health Sector Projects ...................................................................................................................... 79 Exhibit 8-32 Health Sector Projects: Responsible Agencies.................................................................................. 79 Exhibit 8-33 Education Sector: Achievement Targets........................................................................................... 79 Exhibit 8-34 Education Sector Long Term and Short Term Interventions ............................................................ 80 Exhibit 8-35 Education Sector Projects ................................................................................................................. 80 Exhibit 8-36 Education Sector: Responsible Agencies .......................................................................................... 80 Exhibit 8-37 Other Social Infrastructures: Achievement Targets ......................................................................... 80 Exhibit 8-38 Other Social Infrastructure Long Term and Short Term Interventions............................................. 81 Exhibit 8-39 Other Social Infrastructure: Responsible Agencies .......................................................................... 81 Exhibit 8-40 Economic Development Long Term and Short Term Interventions ................................................. 83 Exhibit 8-41 Economic Development: Implementation Agencies ........................................................................ 83 Exhibit 8-42 Urban Governance: Achievement Targets ....................................................................................... 84 Exhibit 8-43 Sector Priorities of Nasrullahganj ..................................................................................................... 85 Exhibit 8-44 Rank-wise Issues in Water Supply .................................................................................................... 85 Exhibit 8-45 Rank-wise Issues in Storm Water Drainage ...................................................................................... 86 Exhibit 8-46 Rank-wise Issues in Transportation .................................................................................................. 86 Exhibit 8-47 Rank-wise Issues in Solid Waste Management................................................................................. 86 Exhibit 8-48 Rank-wise Issues in Educational Facilities ........................................................................................ 86 Exhibit 8-49 Rank-wise Issues in Health Facilities................................................................................................. 86 Exhibit 8-50 Rank-wise Issues in Social Infrastructure.......................................................................................... 87 Exhibit 9-1 Summary of Investments required ..................................................................................................... 89 Exhibit 9-2 Investment Snapshot: Water Supply .................................................................................................. 90 Exhibit 9-3 Action Plan for Implementation: Water Supply ................................................................................. 91 Exhibit 9-4 Investment Snapshot: Sewerage & Sanitation ................................................................................... 92 Exhibit 9-5 Action Plan for Implementation: Sewerage and Sanitation ............................................................... 93 Exhibit 9-6 Investment Snapshot: Solid Waste Management .............................................................................. 93 Exhibit 9-7 Action Plan for Implementation: Solid Waste Management .............................................................. 94 City Development plan for Nasrullahganj xx
Exhibit 9-8 Investment Snapshot: Storm Water Drainage .................................................................................... 95 Exhibit 9-9 Action Plan for Implementation: Storm Water Drainage ................................................................... 96 Exhibit 9-10 Investment Snapshot: Traffic & Transportation ............................................................................... 97 Exhibit 9-11 Action Plan for Implementation: Traffic & Transportation .............................................................. 98 Exhibit 9-12 Investment Snapshot: Street Lighting & Fire Fighting ...................................................................... 98 Exhibit 9-13 Action Plan for Implementation: Street Lighting & Fire Fighting ..................................................... 99 Exhibit 9-14 Investment Snapshot: Health Infrastructure .................................................................................. 100 Exhibit 9-15 Action Plan for Implementation: Health Infrastructure ................................................................. 100 Exhibit 9-16 Investment Snapshot: Education Infrastructure ............................................................................ 101 Exhibit 9-17 Action Plan for Implementation: Education Infrastructure ............................................................ 102 Exhibit 9-18 Investment Snapshot: Other Social Infrastructure ......................................................................... 102 Exhibit 9-19 Action Plan for Implementation: Socio-Cultural Infrastructure ..................................................... 103 Exhibit 9-20 Investment Snapshot: Urban Environment .................................................................................... 103 Exhibit 9-21 Action Plan for Implementation: Urban Environment ................................................................... 104 Exhibit 9-22 Investment Snapshot: Urban Poor ................................................................................................. 104 Exhibit 9-23 Action Plan for Implementation: Urban Poor ................................................................................. 105 Exhibit 9-24 Investment Snapshot: Urban Governance ..................................................................................... 105 Exhibit 9-25 Action Plan for Implementation: Urban Governance ..................................................................... 106 Exhibit 10-1 Important assumptions made in the projections ........................................................................... 108 Exhibit 10-2 Different scenarios to assess investment sustainability ................................................................ 110 Exhibit 10-3 Impact of reforms and grants on investment capacity................................................................... 111 Exhibit 10-4 CIP Funding Pattern ........................................................................................................................ 111 Exhibit 10-5 Financial Operating Plan ................................................................................................................. 112 Exhibit 11-1 Municipal Accounting: Reform Action Plan .................................................................................... 116 Exhibit 11-2 E-Governance: Reform Action Plan ................................................................................................ 117 Exhibit 11-3 User Charges: Reform Action Plan.................................................................................................. 118 Exhibit 11-4 Internal Earmarking for Poor: Reform Action Plan ......................................................................... 119 Exhibit 11-5 Property Tax: Reform Action Plan .................................................................................................. 120 Exhibit 11-6 Optional Reforms: Status................................................................................................................ 120
xxi
FIGURES
Figure 4-1 Krishi Upaj Mandi ................................................................................................................................ 19 Figure 6-1 Sewage from the households .............................................................................................................. 31 Figure 6-2 Nallah carrying waste-water................................................................................................................ 39 Figure 6-3 State Highway ...................................................................................................................................... 41 Figure 6-4 Bus Stand ............................................................................................................................................. 41 Figure 6-5 General Health Centre ......................................................................................................................... 48
xxii
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1. Background
Madhya Pradesh is urbanizing at a fast rate and the Urban Local Bodies (ULBs) in the state are facing the challenge of meeting the requirements of the growing population with limited technical and financial resources. The Government of India (GoI) and Government of Madhya Pradesh (GoMP) have initiated a number of programmes to meet the growing demands of infrastructure and service delivery. These include both GoI schemes [including Urban Infrastructure Development Scheme for Small and Medium Towns (UIDSSMT) and Integrated Housing and Slum Development Programme (IHSDP)] and GoMP initiated schemes; such as the Madhya Pradesh Urban Services for the Poor (MPUSP), a DFID assisted program, which links reform with investment in infrastructure for the poor. After the assessment of the performance of the ULBs and their capacity for exploiting the above said resources it was felt that such a plan is essential, not only for accessing GoI/GoMP funding but also for providing a strategic framework for converging and co-ordinating various development inputs towards positioning the city on a development path. Therefore, the Urban Administration and Development Department (UADD) of Government of Madhya Pradesh (GoMP) has launched an initiative to support 5 Municipal councils, 245 Nagar Parishads and 30 urban centres in the state in preparing City Development Plans (CDPs). This initiative aims to provide a comprehensive Medium Term Strategy (25 years) and a City Investment Plan (CIP) for each Urban Local Body, based on which the concerned ULB will be able to access funds under schemes of Government of India (GoI) and GoMP as well as from its own sources for implementation of priority actions and projects, identified from this exercise. The document was also envisaged to provide a Financial Operating Plan (FOP) to direct the ULBs for mobilising various financial resources to implement the identified projects, adhering to the JNNURMs CDP preparation toolkit and keeping in view the Master Plan (wherever exists) provisions as prepared by Town and Country Planning Department. The preparation of the CDP will take advantage of the Revised CDP preparation toolkit/Heritage cities toolkit prepared under JNNURM and UADD/CMAMP guidelines. It is also expected that the CDP would provide Urban Reform Action Plan for the ULBs as envisaged under JNNURM. In this regard, MPUADD retained ICRA Management Consulting Services Limited (IMaCS) for assistance in preparation of City Development Plan for Nasrullahganj town.
1.2.
This exercise is centred on the following broad objectives: The CDP will scale up existing urban development and poverty alleviation schemes within a comprehensive and coherent strategic planning framework in order to ensure optimal benefit from available resources for the citizens of the ULBs. The CDP should aim to catalyse new thinking and provoke debate through a consultative stakeholder driven process. The vision and strategic thrusts of the CDP will be built around the lessons and findings of a comprehensive and rigorous stakeholder consultation and documentation process. The CDP will generate specific priority actions and projects that can be the basis for mobilizing funding from diverse sources. 1
1.3.
The list of tasks followed for the preparation of the CDP of Nasrullahganj (as outlined by MPUADD) are detailed below:
1.3.1. Inception
This stage includes a preliminary analysis of the town including strengths and weaknesses of the city and finalization of the approach and methodology for the preparation of CDP for the town. This stage also gives an understanding of what impedes service delivery and management within the existing set-up and what contributes to better service provision. This stage consists of the following tasks:
Reconnaissance
During the first week of the assignment a reconnaissance exercise has been conducted, which included the following activities: 1. Introductory meetings with the Mayor/President, Municipal Commissioner/Chief Municipal Officer, Heads of Departments, Councillors, representatives of on-going urban programmes, etc. 2. Determination of the feasibility and composition of a city level Steering Group (comprising of Citizen forum) for the CDP 3. Formation of Citizen Forum comprising of 15 eminent persons from different walks of life. 4. Obtain base maps, and available secondary data on the citys demographics, master plan, reports prepared under past and current urban development programmes, ULBs annual budget reports, other reports giving status of service delivery, and other relevant documents on heritage listing, data on slums and urban poor, government policy documents, etc. 5. Identification of the line departments and key stakeholders for urban service delivery and development such as PHED, Town and Country Planning Department, Development Authority, SADA, local chamber of commerce, NGOs, CBOs, religious organizations, financial institutions, commerce and industry etc. 6. Field reconnaissance to determine growth patterns of the city, characteristics of slums and environmentally sensitive areas etc. 7. Identification of economic opportunities and blocks in tapping these (eg. Tourism, industry etc.) 8. Mapping: Preparation of City level base maps using Auto-CAD/GIS.
Line Departments of the state government such as pollution control board, health department, tourism department, PHED, PWD, Traffic and Transportation etc Private sector agencies such as chambers of commerce and industry, Non-governmental and community based organizations Representatives of the poor communities Representatives of on-going urban development programmes Representatives of media, academic institutions, etc.
Inception report
At the completion of this phase, an inception report consisting of a preliminary analysis of the town and final approach and methodology for CDP preparation has been submitted to the ULB. Further to which a presentation on the same report has been undertaken with the stakeholders to seek their inputs on the approach and methodology suggested in the inception report.
Sector analysis
Based on the interactions with various stakeholder groups (meetings, workshops, focus group discussions, etc.) and review of relevant documents (publications, reports, GOs, resolutions, procedures, laws etc.) an analysis of the current situation in all the identified sectors has been undertaken. This sector analysis has been carried out in the consultation with local counterparts and further a methodology for the sector analysis has been developed, which includes the following: Study of economic opportunity and potential for Local/regional economic development, with special reference to the poor Physical infrastructure demand and gap assessment (considering service level benchmarking) Transport study with emphasis on low cost public transport and livelihoods Heritage conservation and tourism Environmental sustainability Access to housing, employment and social and environmental services by the poor Health and Education services gap in the town Sectoral Issues addressed under the Master Plan (as prepared by the TCPD)
City profile
The findings from the sector analysis are used to prepare the City Profile consisting of the assessment of the existing situation in all identified sectors, emerging issues, SWOT analysis and projection of the present gaps and future requirements. Development of city vision and sector goals and strategies Discussion on strategies, priorities and major actions that may be required in the next five years to move towards the vision 2035 have been discussed to develop city vision, sector strategies and strategies.
Sector strategies
After reviewing relevant cases from national and international best practices, learning are identified to explore if the same can be applied in relevant sectors to bring in improved and efficient ways of working.
This stages also includes consultations with the local counterparts to develop sector strategies in consonance with the city vision and sector goals.
1.3.3. Preparing a City Investment Plan (CIP) and a financing strategy Project costing and determination of funding sources
Consultations with the different stakeholders has determined the types and sources of financing to be adopted for priority projects from internal resources, state and central governments, local financial institutions, donors, and through public-private partnerships.
Performance Monitoring
Performance- monitoring/sustainability indicators have been identified to assist ULB in review the progress and outcomes of the CDP on an annual basis and to enable them in setting the agenda for the future.
1.4.
Approach
The City Development Plan (CDP) is the Nagar Parishads strategy that presents both a vision of a desired future perspective for the town and the Parishads organization, and mission statements on how the Nagar Parishad, together with other stakeholders, intends to work towards achieving the short term and long-term vision. CDP should be very comprehensive and should cover all the aspects where town needs intervention. To achieve a comprehensive CDP, we have adopted few guiding principles as discussed below.
5.
6. 7. 8.
other reports giving status of service delivery, and other relevant documents on heritage listing, data on slums and urban poor, government policy documents, etc. Identify the line departments and key stakeholders for urban service delivery and development such as PHED, Town and Country Planning Department, Development Authority, SADA, local chamber of commerce, NGOs, CBOs, religious organizations, financial institutions, commerce and industry etc. Field reconnaissance to determine growth patterns of the city, characteristics of slums and environmentally sensitive areas etc. Identify economic opportunities and blocks in tapping these (eg. Tourism, industry etc.) Mapping : Preparation of City level base maps using Auto-CAD/GIS
This module has culminated in conduct of a one-day kick off workshop with stakeholders. The purpose of the kick-off workshop was to build participative energy and commitment of stakeholders for the study through articulation of the purpose, process, and expected outcomes of the CDP, and achieving a shared understanding of the same. The kick off workshop has helped in deriving a consensus along with the stakeholders firming the process and agreeing upon a structured programme to take the CDP forward. Further the institutional structures including the Steering Group for the consultative process has also been spelt out during this workshop. Following the workshop, we had submitted an Inception Report, which was followed with a presentation to MPUADD and the ULB. Exhibit 1-1 Approach and Methodology
In addition, we had a significant on-the-ground interaction effort through our research and support staff to compile data and information from the cities. From our experience in handling such studies, very often it is critical to spend substantial time with ULB staff/do sample based field visits given the data and information availability related limitations. Such interactions enabled us capture qualitative insights and served in providing surrogate inputs to validate and overcome the generally faced limitations of data availability. For instance, we have collected budget documents at the beginning at the study and do the analysis of financials in parallel. A time period wise analysis of revenue and costs along with their drivers enabled us to spot data discrepancies in the initial stages and helped us to identify areas where greater time is required for data collection/scrutiny. Similarly in the area of service levels benchmarking, we have done a physical reconnaissance of municipal assets to validate reports made available to us. We concurred the activities and steps identified by MPUADD in the Terms of Reference in moving from a Situation Assessment to formulate the City Vision and translating that to Sector strategies and priority projects. Some specifics of our approach along each of these steps are described below:
Sector Analysis
We have chosen the specific sectors/issues for preparing detailed sectoral papers, based on the criticality of the sector (as viewed by the stakeholders) and the baseline status of the prevailing service levels in that city. While the exact list of sectors has been finalized during consultations, an indicative list of sectors that came out as critical areas include the following: a. b. c. d. e. f. Water Supply Sanitation and Sewerage Solid Waste Management Urban Housing Public Transportation Social amenities and infrastructure including Schools, Hospitals, Markets 8
g. Heritage & Tourism The sector level analysis covered the following steps. a. Review the baseline status of the sector in terms of operational service level and financial indicators vis-a-vis benchmarks/norms and desired levels of service to arrive at the normative gaps. b. Identification of the possible alternatives for improving service levels, policy changes/implications and the magnitude of investment required to improve service levels in a time-bound manner. c. Developing a sector strategy, targets for service level improvement and a list of potential priority projects to be undertaken along with an expected level of improvement in service levels through implementation of these projects. These steps has been undertaken in consultation with local counterparts. While carrying out the sector level analysis, aspects relating to the need for provisioning for urban poor, broad review of cost-benefits including social and environmental impacts were factored.
City Profile
In profiling the City and crystallizing its SWOT (Strength, Weakness, Opportunity, Threat), we looked at slightly wider issues beyond sectoral dimensions to cover the following: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Spatial growth patterns and drivers Economic growth drivers - intrinsic and potential Infrastructure - Physical and Social Issues relating to Environment sustainability Extent of Urban Poor and their requirements Institutional Capacity gaps and requirements.
The city profiles has been drawn from the Sector analysis and assessment of the existing situation in all the sectors identified, emerging issues, analysis and projection of the present gaps and future requirements.
City Vision
Exhibit 1-2 presents an extract from the JNNURM Toolkit considered for developing a Citys Vision which we believed summarizes the key contours of a City level Vision formulation quite succinctly. The City Profile has been presented to the stakeholders and Steering Group followed with a discussion on city perspective and city priorities as perceived by the stakeholders. With the background of city profile, perspective and priorities, the participants contributed to the development a collective and shared vision for the city. Discussion were initiated on strategies, priorities and major actions that may be required in the next fifteen years to move towards the vision. Exhibit 1-2 Developing a City Vision (Source: JnNURM Toolkit)
Developing a vision for the city is central to the preparation of a CDP. A vision is a statement of where the city wishes to go, within a given timeframe, and is often expressed in terms of clear expectations. It defines the potential of the city and reflects its unique attributes in terms of comparative and competitive advantages, values and preferences of the citys residents, relationship of the city to the state, national and global economies, and of course, the history and physical characteristics of the city. A vision aligns stakeholders energies to work cohesively for the development of the city. Citie s need to systematically consider the future, and design strategies to accordingly shape the future. All objectives, strategies, programmes and projects must be aligned with the vision of the city.
Developing a common vision requires a significant effort of consensus building in order to balance the competing demands arising from different economic infrastructure sectors, as also from different interest groups within the city. In order to achieve an understanding on a common vision, it is useful to choose milestones and targets such as provision of a minimum level of services to all; public disclosure and transparency in the formulation of budget proposals; introduction of a single window in matters of service delivery and management and the like. In developing the vision, cities must choose a set of criteria that are directly relevant to the JNNURM components. It is important that when cities define outcomes and milestones on the vision, they ensure that these are measurable and have a time frame.
10
Developing a realistic and actionable Investment Plan and a Financial and Operating Plan within borrowing capacity limitations with a 5-year action plan and 15-20 year financial projections.
Developing 5 year action plan is an iterative process and factored inputs from consultations with stakeholders on priority projects to be taken up in consonance with the City Vision, Sector wise strategy and service level targets.
1.5.
Stakeholders Interaction
The CDP process involved several stakeholder consultations during the course of the project to make the process inclusive and CDP comprehensive. The team visited Nasrullahganj in the month of November and December and had interactions and discussions with the city officials and the political representatives to get information on the city strengths, existing scenario of infrastructure services, on-going projects, ULB setup, area of concerns, lacunas etc. And also the demand, gaps, vision, goals, strategies, priorities, financial situation etc. Apart from individual consultations, three stakeholder workshops were conducted at different stages of the study with the objectives of apprising stakeholders with the status of the study and obtaining feedbacks on CDP process and intermediate findings. The feedbacks from stakeholders were carefully evaluated and incorporated in the process.
11
Apart from meeting the ULB officials the team has also interacted with other stakeholders mainly Adhyaksha and the elected ward members and other eminent personalities of the town. Team has also met with revenue departments representative (Patvari), sub-engineer etc.
1.5.4. Workshops
The objectives and outcomes of various stakeholders are: 1. Kick-off Workshop Inception Workshop A workshop was organized to familiarize the stakeholders with the purpose, process, and expected outcomes of the CDP, and build enthusiasm, understanding and commitment to the CDP. The kick off workshop helped in deriving a consensus along with the stakeholders firming the process and agreeing upon a structured programme to take the CDP forward. It happened during first workshop i.e. Kick-off Stakeholder Consultation Workshop, on November 2nd, 2011. Presentation was followed by a participative session on discussion & suggestions. Outcomes of this workshop were; familiarization of stakeholders with the purpose, methodology & expected outcomes of the study, improvisation in our understanding of city & its problems, innovative approaches to counter existing problems and building of enthusiasm, understanding and commitment for the successful completion of a comprehensive and ambitious but implementable, City Development Plan. 2. Second Workshop City Vision, Sector Goals, Strategies and Prioritization Second formal meeting addressing all stakeholders happened during second workshop on December 3rd, 2011. Presentation was followed by a participative session and questionnaire round, which helped in finalizing the city vision, sector goals, strategies and priority actions for the development of the town. This workshop culminated in the consolidation of strategies, priority actions and projects. 3. Third Workshop Draft CDP Workshop The third workshop was conducted on 27th August, 2012 at Nasrullahganj.
12
In this workshop, findings and recommendations to achieve the vision has been presented to the city. Detailed list of proposed projects with broad cost estimates have been shared along with the sustenance capacity of ULB. This workshop also discussed about the reform process to make ULB more efficient. This workshop culminated in the consolidation of draft CDP, comments to improve sectoral issues have been suggested by stakeholders. The detailed proceedings of various stakeholder workshops are provided as Annexure 1. The second workshop also included a questionnaire survey to elicit stakeholders responses on key issues faced by city and extent of their severity. The details pertaining to questionnaire survey, viz. objective, methodology, questionnaire, analysis and findings, are provided in chapter 8 and questionnaire is attached as Annexure 2.
1.6.
Report contents
This report covers City Vision & Goals along with Strategies & Priority Actions required for the study and is organized as follows: Section 1: Introduction (this section) provides the background to the study and outlines the study progress till date along with proceedings of 1st and 2nd Workshops. Section 2: Physical Features of the Town covers location, physiography and landform of the town. Section 3: Demographic Profile of the Town provides various demographic indicators of the town like population growth, population projection etc. Section 4: Socio-Economic Profile of the Town provides information on socio-economic indicators of the town like workforce details etc. Section 5:Spatial Planning and Growth Management gives the details about the growth pattern of the town along with information on housing scenario present in the town. Section 6: Citys Infrastructure Existing Status, Gaps, Issues, SWOT, Goals and Strategies covers physical and social infrastructure sectors of the town. Section 7: Municipal Financial Assessment provides the financial status of the town. Section 8: City Vision, Sector Goals, Strategies, Action Plan, Projects and Prioritization describes the vision of the town. This section also covers the strategies to be made, action to be taken for achieving sector goals. Section 9: City Investment Plan Section 10: Financial Operating Plan Section 11: Urban Reforms outlines the reforms that should to be undertaken by ULB.
1.7.
The limitation faced during the preparation of the city development plan is the unavailability of complete data, as IMaCS did not conduct any field survey for the data collection, only secondary data was used which was provided by Nagar Parishad. Since To the Scale Ward boundary maps are not available with the town, the digitized maps prepared by IMaCS show the tentative ward and town boundaries which are marked by the officials of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and Revenue Department.
13
2.2.
District information
Nasrullahganj town is located in the Southern part of the Sehore District. Sehore is surrounded by seven districts i.e. Bhopal, Raisen, Hoshangabad, Dewas, Shajapur, Raigarh and Harda. Lying between the north latitude 2231' to 2340' and east longitude 7622' to 7808', the district's headquarters is situated at the Sehore city (Refer Map-1 in Annexure 4). The lacquer bangles of the district are coveted adornment of the Gond and Bhialaand Korku tribes of the region. Bhavai, the traditional dance of these tribes is an excellent example of their artistic proclivities. In tribal area of Sehore the Bagoria dance, with its vigorous drum beating, is still performed around the Holi Festival. Sehore stands in the foothills of Vindhyachal range in the middle of Malwa Region. After formation of Madhya Pradesh, the state capital Bhopal was a part of the Sehore District. It was bifurcated in 1972 and a new district Bhopal was formed. Big and small rivers abound the landscape of Sehore District. Narmada, Parwati, Dudhi, Newaj, Kolar, Papnas, Kulans, Seewan, Lotia and other rivers are found passing through the district.
2.3.
Geographically Nasrullahganj lies at 2320 N latitude and 7620 E Longitude and located in Sehore district, the town is surrounded by Vindhyachal range of mountains and Narmada River which flows just 8 kms from the town (Refer Map-2 in Annexure 4). Nasrullahganjs connectivity with other towns of State and Country through various mode of transportation is given below. Road: Nasrullahganj is a major town and is connected to Bhopal with SH 22 in the east at a distance of 92 kms and to Indore with NH 58A in the west at a distance of 164 kms. It is connected to the district headquarters Sehore with SH 22 in the north at a distance of 73 kms. Railway: Nearest railway station to Nasrullahganj is located in Budni which is at a distance of 50 kms from Nasrullahganj. Air: Nearest airport is at Bhopal which is at distance of 92 Km from Nasrullahganj.
2.4.
2.4.1. Topography
Nasrullahganj stands in the foothills of Vindhyachal Range in the middle of Malwa region. The most of the area is made of undulating plateau surface and is covered with black soils of different grades. Due to this it has got good productive soil.
14
2.4.2. Drainage
Babbar River flows in the northern part of the town and Narmada River flows in the southern side of the city. The town falls under Narmada Basin and its catchment area. A nallah flowing in North-South direction bisects the town.
2.4.3. Climate
Nasrullahganj is placed at 440 m above mean sea level. The climate of the town is relatively temperate with an average maximum and minimum temperatures at 32.30C and 18.40C respectively. The average rainfall reported in the town is about 1100 mm.
2.5.
Total municipal area under Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is 8.08 sq. Km, which consists of developed and undeveloped land. The existing municipal area includes both built-up area and agricultural area, which has been discussed in detail in fifth chapter. The master plan for the town has not been prepared, thus the town does not have any planning area for future growth. It has been observed that a large component of the existing municipal area is undeveloped, thus it creates space for the spatial development of the town.
2.6.
Conclusion
This chapter dealt with the physical features of the town which included topography, natural drainage, climate, and rainfall. It also provided information on its location and connectivity. The next chapter discusses the demographic profile of the town.
15
3.2.
As per the Census of 2011, the population of the town is 23,738 and town is categorized as Class IV towns. Exhibit 3-1 provides a snapshot of the population growth over the last few decades. The town has experienced very high population growth rate during 1981-91 at 104%, which was reduced to decadal growth rate of 17% during 1991-2001 then again increased to 38% in last decade (2001-11). Exhibit 3-1 Population & Decadal Growth
S. No 1 2 3 4 Year 1981 1991 2001 2011* Total Population 7,212 14,688 17,240 23,738 Decadal Population Growth rate (%) 104 17 38
Population density (P.D.) is calculated as population of the city divided by the municipal area of the town. It is generally represented in terms of No. per square km (No. /sq. km). The current density of Nasrullahganj is 2,938.
3.3.
Population projection
With a precedence of past and current trends of population growth in Nasrullahganj, an analysis has been carried out with an objective of estimating population for the next three decades using various methods which includes Arithmetic increase method, Incremental increase method, Geometric progression method exponential methods. Result of this analysis is presented in Exhibit 3-2. Exhibit 3-2 Population Projection
S. No 1 Method Arithmetic Increase Method 2011 23,738 Population Projections 2021 2031 29,247 34,755 2041 40,264
16
S. No 2 3 4
2011
Population Projections 2021 2031 28,758 33,422 36,698 33,288 47,055 53,310
Given the fact that decadal population growth rate of the Nasrullahganj town is highly irregular, taking any of the above method for projection will not yield correct projections, so to project future population last decades growth rate has been considered for population growth during 2011-21 at a CAGR of 3.25%, then factoring the increase in population density the CAGR of 3% and 2% has been assumed for 2021-31 and 2031-41 respectively. Exhibit 3-3 Projected Population
2015 Projected Population
Source: IMaCS Analysis
2025 37,687
2035 48,710
27,240
3.4.
Nasrullahganj Municipality has 15 wards and the ward-wise population has been shown in Exhibit 3-4. It is clearly visible that ward number 15 has the highest proportion of population. Literacy rate of ward number 10 and ward number 15 are highest, whereas of ward no. one and four is amongst the lowest. Sex ratio of Ward Eight and Nine are amongst the least, whereas of Ward Ten has highest. Exhibit 3-4 Ward wise Demographic details
Total Household Sex Ratio Ward No. Population Female Others Total Male Literates Female Others 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Male Literacy rate 63 71 69 64 77 74 74 79 76 81 80 76 65 73 80 73
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Total
445 266 144 448 117 168 176 149 253 150 323 212 555 335 911 4652
2245 1281 807 2466 623 971 916 761 1272 759 1480 1131 2852 1728 4491 23783
1179 669 422 1300 320 512 465 415 699 402 788 598 1514 912 2404 12599
1066 612 385 1166 303 459 448 346 573 357 692 533 1338 816 2087 11181
0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3
904 915 912 897 947 896 963 834 820 888 878 891 884 895 868 887
1409 912 559 1584 482 717 682 601 972 616 1182 861 1853 1264 3573 17267
814 529 327 923 266 410 366 338 571 342 666 490 1084 698 2024 9848
595 383 232 661 216 307 316 263 401 274 516 371 769 566 1549 7419
17
3.5.
Issues
1. A high population growth rate has caused several problems in the recent times as existing physical infrastructure and level of service has been restrained by several factors such as lack of funds, lack of proper planning, etc. 2. Sex ratio is alarmingly low 3. A higher proportion of female among the illiterates indicate lower attention paid to female education.
3.6.
Conclusion
This chapter discussed population growth trend and population density of the town. It was followed by ward-wise population details and includes population projections for next 25 years. The next chapter deals with the socio-economic profile of the town.
18
4.2.
Indicators
19
Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad has an over-all sex ratio of 887 and literacy rate of 73%. Exhibit 4-2 shows Nasrullahganjs literacy rate is comparatively higher than that of the state. Turning our attention to sex ratio, Nasrullahganjs overall sex ratio is lower than that of State and National. Sex-ratio and the literacy rate has been reorganized Exhibit 4-3 to identify the wards having sex-ratio and Literacy-rate less than town average and more than town average. Parameter
Sex-Ratio Literacy Rate
Source: IMaCS Analysis
Exhibit 4-3 Demographically Critical Wards Wards with Less than Town Average Wards with More than Town Average
8,9,10,11,12,13 and 15 1,2,3,4,13 and 14 1,2,3,4,5,6,7 and 14 5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12 and 15
Madhya Pradeshs sex ratio has increased from 920 in 2001 to 930 in 2011. It is still lower than the national levels. Indias sex ratio was 933 in 2001 and has increased to 940 in 2011. If we look at the sex ratio at district level in last two decades, the encouraging figures are noticeable. The sex ratio has increased from 898 to 908 and then to 918 in 1991, 2001 and 2011 respectively in Sehore District. Government of Madhya Pradesh had started some effective schemes and interventions for the welfare of women which is improving the situation in the state. The schemes that focus on sex-ratio sensitivity is Ladli Laxmi Scheme, which is handled by Department of Women and Child Development, Madhya Pradesh for betterment of sex ratio, education and health status of girl child. It is a very effective scheme which has been playing important role in improving declining sex ratio in the state. Literacy rate is one of the most important demographic indicators which sum up the existing literacy level and capacity to actualize the developmental potential. All the wards are classified in three different categories as per their existing level of literacy. This Classification is given in Exhibit 4-4. Exhibit 4-4 Classification of Wards as per their Literacy Rate Status Criteria (Literacy Rate) Ward Numbers
80 and above 75-80 Less than 75 Average Poor Very Poor 15, 11 and 10 12, 9, 5 and 8 1, 4, 13, 3, 2, 14, 6 and 7
Category
I II III
Exhibit 4-5 shows the ward-wise literacy rates in the town. It can be seen that most of the peripheral wards have lower literacy rate whereas the wards in the central area (ward no. 5, 6, 8,9,10 and 11) of the town have high literacy rates. It can also be seen that the wards having low literacy rate are mostly the slum wards. In addition, a detailed gendered analysis of literacy has also been carried out for all the wards of Nasrullahganj town.
20
Female Literacy Rate Status Very Poor Poor Poor Very Poor Average Average Poor Average Average Average Average Average Very Poor Poor Average Percentage 56 63 60 57 71 67 71 76 70 77 75 70 57 69 74 Status Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Poor Very Poor Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor Very Poor
Percentage 69 79 77 71 83 80 79 81 82 85 85 82 72 77 84
The total literate population is 73%. With the initiation of centrally sponsored schemes in Education such as District Primary Education Programme, Sarv Shiksha Abhiyaan and Education Guarantee Scheme at school level had contributed in the increased level of literacy in the state in last two decades; but the most effective scheme had been Padhana-Badhana Movement for literacy by Government of Madhya Pradesh, started in 1996-97. As per 53rd round of National Sample Survey (NSS), it was established that there was nearly 11.8% increase in the rate of literacy of the state from 1991 to 1997, which to some extent was due to Padhana-Badhana Movement. According to provisional Figures of census 2001 the rate of Literacy had increased 44.20% to 64.11% which reflected 19.19% increase in literacy rate within a decade. Other schemes which attributed to increasing literacy rate in last two decades includes upgradation of Madarsas scheme, Free of cost Distribution scheme of text books, Book Bank Scheme, Free of Cost School Uniform Scheme, etc.
Source: Provisional Population, Census of India, 2011 (3) and Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
The Average Household Size in Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad was 5.6 in the year 2001 and has decreased to 5.1 in 2011.
21
4.2.3. Workforce participation (Primary, Secondary and Tertiary occupation and income levels)
Work is defined as participation in any economically productive activity with or without compensation, wages or profit. Such participation may be physical and/or mental in nature. Work involves not only actual work but also includes effective supervision and direction of work. It even includes part time help or unpaid work on farm, family enterprise or in any other economic activity. All persons engaged in 'work' as defined above are workers. As per Census of India, Workers have been classified as Main workers, Marginal workers and Non workers depending on duration of their work months. Main Workers: Those workers who had worked for the major part of the reference period (i.e. 6 months or more). Marginal Workers: Those workers who had not worked for the major point of the reference period (i.e. less than 6 months) are termed as Marginal Workers. As a sub-classification, Main and Marginal Workers are again classified on the basis of nature of work performed; Cultivators, Agricultural Labours, Household Industry Labours and Other Workers. Cultivators: A person is classified as cultivator if he or she is engaged in cultivation of land owned or held from Government or held from private persons or institutions for payment in money, kind or share. Cultivation includes effective supervision or direction in cultivation. Agricultural Labours: A person who works on another person's land for wages in money or kind or share is regarded as an agricultural labourer. (S)he has no risk in the cultivation, but merely works on another person's land for wages. An agricultural labourer has no right of lease or contract on land on which (s) he works. Household Industry: Household Industry is defined as an industry conducted by one or more members of the household at home or within the village in rural areas and only within the precincts of the house where the household lives in urban areas. Other Workers: This includes all government servants, municipal employees, teachers, factory workers, plantation workers, those engaged in trade, commerce, business, transport banking, mining, construction, political or social work, priests, entertainment artists, etc. The details of the workforce for 2001 have been shown in Exhibit below. The details of the workforce for 2011 are in the process of conduction in the towns. Particulars
Main Worker Marginal Worker Non Worker Workforce Participation Rate (WFPR)
Source Census of India, 2001
The workforce participation rate of the town is very low (27%). There is a need to provide employment opportunities and reduce dependent population in the town.
4.3.
Economic Base
22
The population of the town is not involved in industrial activities. It does not have any big industry to boost the economy of the town.
4.4.
Issues
A significant number of male and female illiterates are a serious issue which impedes the overall development of the city. This can be attributed to less awareness, poverty and lack of sufficient accessible education. A high percentage of non-workers suggest that a significant proportion of population remains unemployed for a substantial part of the year. This needs to be address for realise economic upliftment of the society at large. Nasrullahganjs economy is highly depending on agriculture. Whereas this potential can further be actualized, this dependence is also a possible threat to the Nasrullahganjs economy. To achieve a sustainable growth rate, a more diversified economic base is of utmost importance.
23
5.2.
The towns old areas (i.e. in Ward four and three) are more dense and populated. A close look at the Nasrullahganjs map reveals (Refer Map-4B enclosed in Annexure 4) that the central region has comparatively higher population densities. Detail of population density is given in Exhibit 5-1 central areas have high density (above 200 PPH), whereas other parts of the town has density lesser than 50 pph. Exhibit 5-1 Population Density
Ward No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 Total Population 2245 1281 807 2466 623 971 916 761 1272 759 1480 1131 2852 1728 4491 23783 Area (Sq. Km) 1.36 0.18 0.04 1.02 0.03 0.23 0.46 0.13 0.13 0.30 0.12 0.14 1.07 0.14 2.74 8.08 Density (P/Sq.Km) 1653 7176 21463 2417 21190 4222 1991 5955 9891 2516 12364 8160 2670 12343 1638 Density (PPh) 17 72 215 24 212 42 20 60 99 25 124 82 27 123 16
In the map population density has been categorized into four types. Ward no. five and three have higher density and are shown in the dark brown colour. Wards 11 and 14, are in the density range of 50-100 PPH and are shown in the light brown colour. The wards 1,4,6,7,10,13 and 15 are the ones with least density and shown in the light yellow colour. Rest of the wards have medium density in the range 100-150 PPH and are shown in the dark yellow colour.
24
5.3.
Land-use analysis
Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is spread over about 8.08 sq. km. In absence of the Master Plan for the towns, it is difficult to estimate the exact land use breakup but from the preliminary visit it is clear that major part of the town is under agriculture use. Exhibit below shows the land-use pattern of the town based on the information provided by Land records and revenue department, 2011. Exhibit 5-2 Land Use pattern
S. No 1 2 3 4 5 6 Land use category Residential (Abadi) Amenities (Public-Semi Public) Roads Water Bodies Agriculture/ Green Space Commercial Total Area (Ha) 113.12 32.32 24.24 20.2 589.84 28.28 808.00 Percentage 14 4 3 2.5 73 3.5 100
As discussed above Agriculture accounts for 73% of the total land in town and the developed land is only 24.5%, which consists of 14% of residential use, while institutional, commercial and roads accounts for 4, 3.5 and 3% respectively. The broad tentative land use of the town has been represented in Map-5 enclosed in Annexure 4. The broad land use pattern shows that, institutional area is located along state highway. Residential area is divided in the two parts, one in North Western part and other in the south-eastern part of the town.
5.4.
Housing scenario
Housing is a very critical component of citys development. Some of critical aspects of Housing in any city consists of the number of households, average household size, type of building and provision of basic services e.g. water supply, electricity, sewerage, drainage, solid waste disposal etc. To analyse the housing scenario of the city, factors such as density of residential areas, household size, nature of built form and housing shortage have been considered.
2011 23,738 -
25
5.5.
Issues
1. The population densities in internal wards, which are in the core area are substantially high and are near to the permissible limits as prescribed in the UDPFI guidelines as compared to other wards. Initiatives should be taken to decongest these wards in order to reduce infrastructural pressure from the overcrowded wards. 2. The haphazard development and formulation of illegal colonies in the town has increased and leads to degraded quality of life. There is a need to prepare a master plan for regulated land development and proper management and development of the town.
5.6.
Conclusion
This chapter dealt with the spatial growth trend and how did Nasrullahganj expanded into the town it is now. The ward maps and land use pattern and housing scenario have also been discussed in detail. The chapter ended with a brief note about the growth possibilities and city specific strategies and action plan.
26
6. CITYS INFRASTRUCTURE EXISTING STATUS, GAPS, ISSUES, SWOT, GOALS AND STRATEGIES
The chapter deals with the current status of various components of city infrastructure and services provided by the Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. Various sectors/services have been analysed in accordance with the methodology mentioned earlier. Sectors / Services identified for the analysis include: Water Supply, Sewerage & Sanitation, Solid Waste Management, Drainage, Traffic & Transportation, Street Lighting & Fire Fighting, Urban Poor and their Accessibility to Basic Services, Social Infrastructure, Environment and Existing Institutional Framework for Development. Sector-wise analysis is presented in subsequent sub-sections. Demand-Supply Gap Analysis for various sectors has been done for short, medium and long term, i.e. 5 years, 15 years and 25 years.
6.1.
Water supply
Water Supply facility in the town is provided by Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad which undertakes sourcing, establishing networks, maintenance and collection of user charges for domestic as well as commercial purposes.
27
Hand Pump 2 2 1 0 11
Tube Wells 1 1 1 3 14
Wells 0 1 0 0 4
Water Supply from tube wells in longer time may become a problem in this area, as the ground water level has gone down up-to 300 ft below the ground and the water supply at present is much below the prescribed standards and with the increase in population would result into increase in demand for water. The quality of ground water in the district has been assessed by central ground water board by analyzing ground water samples in the district. From the samples it is observed that PH values of all water samples ranges from 7.27 to 8.07, which shows alkaline nature of the water in the district. Nitrate level in Sehore district varies from 5.6 to 358 mg/l. The excessive concentration of nitrate levels may be due to localized pollution or percolation of fertilizers used for agriculture. The hardness of ground water in the district has been found safe. No arsenic content has been detected in the ground water of the district. But as the Sehore districts ground water has iron and fluorine, usage of ground water needs to be reassessed for safe drinking (Water Aid, 2005, Water and Sanitation in Madhya Pradesh). In India, water supply projects are usually designed keeping 20 Hours per day pumping & treatment infrastructures live availability; however, the efficacy of the entire system is disadvantaged when continuous power is not available at various stages of pumping/treatment. Another statistics on power availability reveal that average per day power availability is for about 8 hours. A perspective look into the above available information would reveal that power cut acts as a major impediment in the provision of ample amount of per capita water availability in the town vis-a-vis existing infrastructure available. Thus, in the proposed strategy, in order to utilize the designed infrastructure at its optimum efficiency, and while tackling the power availability impediment, it would be worthwhile to have a direct power feeder for the proposed treatment plant and pump house.
Type of Consumer Domestic Commercial/ Industrial New Connections Domestic Commercial/ Industrial
For new connections Rs 705 includes connection fee, Rs 5 as application fee, road cutting charges is at the rate Rs 100/ft, Rs 105 as tap connection fee.
28
Indicator
Unit
Gap
Gap
Daily Supply
Per-capita supply
Lpcd
60
135
2.26
5.09
1.41 6.58
1.49
Treatment capacity against % supply Percentage of % Road Length Elevated Storage capacity % w.r.t Supply
100
MLD -
3.68
3.68
5.09
1.41 6.58
1.49
28
85
Km
10
57
33
ML
.82
1.23
0.41
1.70
0.47 2.19
0.50
It is evident from the Exhibit 6-4 that Nasrullahganj needs a major revamping in Water Supply sector as current level of service, 60 lpcd, is substantially lower than the prescribed norm of 135 lpcd. The huge gap in the water supply area at the end of year 2015 well underscores the above point. By the end of year 2035, Nasrullahganj city would require 6.58 MLD of water for daily consumption. No treatment of water happens in the town. In the area of Elevated Storage Capacity, Nasrullahganj city, at present, as per the UDPFI standards there is a gap of 0.41 ML in short term and additional 0.50 ML in long term will have to be addressed. An additional of 24.98 kms, 31.7 and 39.63 kms will be required in the area of distribution network by the year 2015, 2025 and 2035 respectively.
Gap
Unit
29
mains, 2 new overhead reservoirs and distribution system in the town. The new scheme is approved and the works are under construction.
Weaknesses Current Service levels of water supply are lower than level desired under the UDPFI guidelines. Lack of adequate water treatment capacity. Unmetered water connections. Poor collection efficiency of water tariffs.
6.1.6. Issues
1. A substantial part of population receives untreated water as the treatment facility does not exist for the supplied water; 2. Critical shortage of water during summer season due to lowering of water level in the Nasrullahganj; 3. Dependence on Hand-pumps and wells for daily water supply; 4. Complete absence of metering system and 5. Upstream pollution of River.
30
6.2.
Sewerage
As envisaged in the 12th schedule of 74th Amendment to the Constitution of India, responsibility of providing services pertaining to sewerage within the city limits lie with the ULBs. The same responsibility is with Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad.
2-3% of the septic tanks are cleaned per year as per the baseline survey. This indicates that many of the households do not clean their septic tanks on annual basis but may be on bi-annual or tri-annual basis.
Gap
Gap
% Population covered by Under Ground UGD Drainage % Sewer to (UGD) Road Length % Treatment Capacity
Source: IMaCS Analysis
100
Persons
0 0
90 100
Km ML
0 0
7.21 1.13
8.31 1.19
As shown in above Exhibit Nasrullahganj would require a sewerage system to cater the population of year 2035. According to norms mentioned under the UDPFI, the sewerage system would need to cover 90% of the road length during year 2035. A comprehensive sewerage system needs an integrated treatment plant which can be developed in a phased manner. A treatment plant with an initial capacity of 2.94 MLD should be developed to cater to the requirements of 2035 at 5.26 MLD.
Gap
32
Weaknesses Lack of maintenance and absence of timely cleaning of free public conveniences renders them unusable for significant amount of time.
Threats Improper usage of public conveniences would leave these facilities unusable and would require more maintenance. Wastewater from Houses and overflow from the individual septic tanks mix with storm water drainage system resulting in water pollution.
6.2.9. Issues
Many of the households do not clean their septic tanks on annual basis but on bi-annual or triannual basis because of high cost Lack of space availability, affordability, dense housing structures, and rental accommodation affects the construction of toilets and septic tanks. Absence of UGD system: All the wards are to be covered with UGD system. The disposal of sewage through either open drainage or septic tanks is leading to the pollution of ground water and surface water. An integrated UG system covering the entire town is critical, given the expected growth of the town. Treatment: Sewage water flowing through open drains without any treatment is the major cause of concern regarding surface water pollution. Thus, it poses a potential health hazard for the citizens. Uncovered Population: While the absence of UGD itself exposes the entire town population to the hazards of unsanitary conditions, almost complete population of the town remains uncovered by safe sanitary disposal systems. Need for greater coverage and better maintenance of Public conveniences: Absence of UGD itself exposes the entire town to the hazards of unsanitary conditions. Poor coverage, overflows and blockages of Storm water drains: With the growth in population of the town, the poor coverage of road networks by storm water drains without adequate linkages to main channels requires immediate attention. The drains also face the overflow and blockage problems due to the plastic waste thrown in the drains.
33
6.3.
Sanitation
Like sewerage, in the 12th schedule of 74th Amendment to the Constitution of India the responsibility of providing services pertaining to sanitation within the city limits lie with the ULBs.
As per the survey 82% households have individual toilets. Amongst all the wards ward 1, 13, 3 and 2 has low percentage of households having individual toilet.
34
102
60
Seat
22
37
15
37
Weaknesses The use of public toilets is considerably low probably due to the user charges.
6.3.6. Issues
The public toilets with pay and use model exists and are being run with the private sector involvement. However, the use of these toilets is considerably low probably due to the user charges. Further, such public toilets are not generally accessed by children on account of user fees as well as non-child friendly designs of such toilets. 35
Non-availability of municipal water supply in the vicinity has also affected the use of individual toilets. Overall availability of public toilets in the city is inadequate as the crowded areas like market place like Royal market and JP market and commercial establishments mainly observed in ward no. 10 and 12 are still lacking such facilities. The existing market place brings in considerable floating population from the surrounding region which does not have any kind of sanitation facility. Women, especially, get suffered severely due to absence of such facilities. Such public places, in turn being heavily crowded, showcase filthy and unhygienic environment, especially on the days when weekly bazzars are conducted on Thursday. The city does not have sufficient facilities of sanitation at the public places. There is need to provide sanitation facilities at the market places (Royal market, J.P.market and Chhota bazzar and major commercial establishment along Indore road. (SH-22). Public level sanitation facilities for women are grossly lacking in the city. approximately 13% population resort to open defecation due to lack of individual or community sanitation facilities in their area
6.4.
Waste is the unwanted material left over from places of human and animal habitation. Solid waste comprises unwanted and discarded materials from houses, street sweeping, and commercial and industrial operations. Increase in urban population and changing life styles lead to the generation of solid waste. Generally, solid waste is heterogeneous in nature and a mixture of vegetables, food items, paper, plastics, rags, glass etc. If solid waste is disposed-off in open areas without any treatment, it will cause a negative impact on the environment and ground water.
36
Service Level Indicator Waste Generated per capita (2011) % Waste Collected as per LBs Estimate % Waste Collected as per available capacity % Households covered by Door-to-Door Collection Road length per Conservancy Staff Total Rated Capacity of Vehicles No. of Trips per Vehicle/day Average Spacing Between Dustbins Mode of Disposal
The current practices of the solid waste management shows that there is no primary collection of the waste, but there is primary level and secondary level storage of waste. There is no segregation of wastes at source or at the disposal point. There is no processing or reusing or recycling of this waste at present in the town.
Waste Waste Generated Generated in gms/person Primary collection Push Trolleys Carts/
Community Bins
37
6.4.4. Issues
No Segregation Practice at Source; Lack of proper Primary Collection System There is no door-to-door collection system established in the city; Secondary Storage of waste is unorganized: Mostly open dumps are available for secondary storage of solid waste; Transportation of solid waste to the Trenching ground in open vehicles; No Separate collection and disposal of construction waste; Lack of proper management of biomedical waste; Manual handling of solid waste: Lack of safety measures and Lack of awareness among the town residents.
38
6.5.
Drainage
Currently, there is no separate storm water management system in Nasrullahganj but the storm water is carried away in drains constructed for sullage water.
99
130
Km
35.00
38.20
3.20
48.62
10.42
60.62
12.00
NA
Km
24.50
NA NA
33 67
Km Km Km Km
10.50
2.11 25.59
3.44 6.98
3.96 8.04
39
6.5.4. Issues
Lack of drainage network system in the city which would collect convey and dispose the storm water efficiently. City is vulnerable to stagnation of water due to lack of an integrated drainage system and proper disposal mechanism of storm water. Lack of design considerations and absence topographical analysis results in choking of existing drains and frequent incidences of water logging. Clogging of existing drains due to negligent practices of some of the citizens related to the dumping of waste in the drains. Field surveys and public consultations have revealed that that the silting of natural drains is a major problem and leads to the improper disposal of storm water which often leads to the overflowing of storm water. Encroachment on the open drains is a major cause of concern.
6.6.
This section reviews the existing situation in terms of their current level of service, coverage and key issues towards services provided by Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is the primary agency responsible for the construction of new roads within the municipal limits. Its role with regard to road infrastructure in the town includes the construction and maintenance of all roads in its jurisdiction, except the roads belonging to the Public Works Department (State Highway) or National highways. The construction of internal roads, in the case of a private colony development is the responsibility of the developer or individuals who are selling the land after sub-divisions of their plots. However it has to verify the adequacy of proposals in these areas, at the time of sanction.
main road for all institutional and commercial activities. The length of the state highway in the Nagar Parishad is almost around 4 kms. There are also few roads under PWD which connects other villages to the town. Total road length under PWD is about 1.5 Kms. Due to rapid development in economic and commercial activities, there has been an increase in traffic plying on the state highway. Also, due to absence of the bypass road, the state highway remains busy in the day time and the area around Figure 6-3 State Highway Mandi and Bus Stand gets congested some times (Refer Map-6 enclosed in annexure 4). As this traffic is just related to state highway, it does not affect the roads under Nagar Parishad but as town is growing the increasing traffic flowing through the town will create many problems in future. So, there would be a need for an alternative to reduce through traffic from the town after 25 years.
41
Weaknesses Huge gap in the existing level of service of roads. Several incidences of encroachments have reduced the effective width of town internal roads. Severe traffic jams due to narrow roads. Parallel parking on the internal roads causing problems.
Threats
6.6.6. Issues
Road Infrastructure: Internal town roads are very narrow, thus are very inconvenient for vehicular movement. With the demand estimations it is evident that there is a high requirement of the concrete and black top roads in the town for proper movement of vehicles and people. Encroachments along the roads: Presence of informal activities along the road margins illegal encroachments of pedestrian areas and internal roads are the other causes for traffic 42
congestion in the town. There is considerable commercial activity on the main centre road in the town. State Highway as a barrier or as a source of economic development: It is anticipated that the traffic flow will increase on this road as it connects to Bhopal to Industrial city Indore. Also town has regional Mandi, Bus Stand etc, thus it may as a stoppage place for traffic. This will help the town to raise the economic activities along the highway, acting as a boon for the town. But it has been observed that the schools and few other institutional buildings are present on the western part of the state highway. So, state highway will act as a barrier for children and working people who need to cross the road from residential areas to their work areas. So there would be a need to have foot over bridges or grade separators or by-pass as a long term strategy.
6.7.
43
Exhibit 6-14 Present and Future Demand and Supply gaps: Street Lights and Fire Services
Service head Existing/ desired level Indicator Spacing between lamp poles (m) Tube (%) High (%) lights Power Service Levels, Demand and Gaps By Year 2025 Demand Gap By Year 2035 Demand Gap Current Desired Existing By Year 2015 Unit level level (2011) Demand Gap
83
30
No.
430
980
550
1,247
232
1,554
302
Street lighting
35 64 1
75 25 -
150 275 5
735 245 -
585 -
935 312 -
200 37 -
1,166 389 -
231 77 -
High Mast lamps (%) Tube lights New Installation High Power Under Ground Cabling (Replacement and New)
585.00 16.50
77
Km
The present condition of street lights is not very good in the town as the average spacing between lamp poles is more than the desired as visible in exhibit above. Also, by replacing 150 existing tube lights with T-5 (28 W) and 275 High Power lamps with CFL (4X36) ULB can save energy of 61228.75 KWh and energy cost saving of Rs 2.6 lakhs per year
Weaknesses Lack of vigilance resulting illegal domestic and commercial connections from street lights.
6.7.4. Issues
At present a proportion of the street lights comprise of tube lights and halogen lamps which consumes lot of electricity, there is a need to replace these lamps with CFLs. This would help cut down on expenses on longer term.
44
Presently, the cabling for lampposts is not underground. Due to this the cases of illegal connections and theft are observed. Thus, there is a need to have underground cabling to avoid such cases.
6.8.
Pakka Kua Kshetra and Jin colony Muslim Mohalla Sabji Mandi Mohalla Ayodhya Basti, Bajranj colony and Sarvahra colony
296
45
6.8.3. Urban basic services in slums (In line with JNNURMs 7 point charter)
Access to basic services is now deemed as a criterion for identification of the poor and poor areas in a city (essentially slums). The responsibility for service provision in an adequate manner lies with the local body, which becomes a difficult job for increasing urban poor population. The basic services which are needed to be provided under seven point charter includes security of tenure at affordable prices, improved housing, water supply, sanitation and ensuring convergence of existing universal services for education, health and social security. Slums within the town do not have adequate infrastructure facilities. Exhibit 6-17 gives the coverage of existing infrastructure in the slums. Exhibit 6-17 Percentage coverage of existing infrastructure in Slums
Water supply Open spaces 30 25 35 35 25 Sanitation Electricity 55 60 75 75 65 Sewerage Housing 25 25 35 40 20 Roads 20 25 40 35 25
Ward No.
Name of Slum
Subhash colony and Idgaha Pakka Kua Kshetra and Jin colony Muslim Mohalla Sabji Mandi Mohalla Ayodhya Basti, Bajranj colony and Sarvahra colony
20 15 40 40 20
0 0 0 0 0
20 20 35 40 15
Source: Detailed Project Report, Integrated Housing and Slum Development Programme (2008)
The detailed study under IHSDP shows that majority of slum dwellers live in temporary shelters and most of the houses are entirely made of make shift materials such as wood, bamboo and plastic/tarpaulin sheets. Most of the slum residents obtain their water from well or bore well, or from Nagar Parishads piped supply system. Some bore wells are fitted with individual hand pumps for local supply, others are fitted with electrically operated submersible pump which pumps water to an overhead tank from which it is distributed through distribution pipes to a number of stand posts. The current sanitation alternatives in some of the slum areas of Nasrullahganj comprise an individual pourflush latrine. If residents do not have access to one of these sanitation facilities, then the common practice is defecation in an open space or along a drainage nallah. Solid waste management in the slums is handled in the same manner as in the rest of the areas by the local body. As a result of open defecation, lack of drainage system along the roads and improper sanitation facilities, unhygienic conditions prevails over there. Other facilities are also lacking in the slums in the town.
improvement/ provision of basic urban services. The Integrated Housing and Slum Development Programme, is a step towards strengthening of housing and infrastructure projects in the interests of the urban poor. This programme is also under implementation in the town. The detailed project report for understanding the existing conditions and suggesting strategies was put forward in 2008. The project cost is equivalent to Rs. 3.79 crores. The proposed components under IHSDP are:
Housing
Looking at the scarcity of pucca housing in the slum pockets, it has been proposed to construct 228 dwelling units. It was suggested that the land, if obtained after the proper planning of houses, will be used for commercial use and the revenue generated from this would be used for operation and maintenance.
Water
It is proposed to improve the water supply system in slums by laying water supply pipe lines.
Sanitation
Need of proper sanitation system and construction of drains as per need.
Roads
The new roads and existing kutcha roads will require entirely new construction.
Social Amenities
It has been proposed to provide Anganwadi for the slums. Other than this, the town has sufficient educational and health facilities which cater to the slums also.
Financial Arrangement
The town of Nasrullahganj has been included in the IHSDP scheme under the JnNURM. The sharing of funds would be in the ratio of 80:20 between central government and state Government/ULB. Exhibit 6-18 shows the components of project under IHSDP. Exhibit 6-18 Project Construction Components: IHSDP
S.No. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Total Name of Work C.C. Road Storm Water Drains Sewerage line EWS houses 228 units Playground development Community Hall Livelihood center Street Lighting Septic tank Quantity 931 mts 931 mts 870 mts 228 9390 Sq m 1 1 28 1 Project Cost (in Lacs) 25.37 19.23 5.73 291.87 1.41 14.63 8.19 9.38 3.67 379.47
Source: Detailed Project Report, Integrated Housing and Slum Development Programme (2008)
47
6.8.7. Issues
Higher proportion of Slum Population: The town has 5 slums, one slum in each ward. The slum population is about 16 per cent of the total population. These slums are spread all over the town. This dense concentration of slum dwellers along such environmentally and developmentally sensitive locations has only resulted in the complete lack of access to basic services, causing unhygienic living conditions. Land ownership: Slums have encroached private or government land and reside over these areas. Many slum dwellers do not have tenure security for their land and house. Lack of awareness on slum development programs: There is a general paucity of awareness of the various slum development schemes and programs announced from time to time by the central and state governments. This leads to long delays in the implementation of the programmes and overall dissatisfying results, apart from the factor of the benefits of the programs not reaching the intended beneficiaries.
6.9.
Social infrastructure
The social infrastructure has been classified into Health, Education and Recreational infrastructure. The geographical locations of various components of Social Infrastructure are shown in Map-9 enclosed in annexure 4. The facilities shown in figure include schools, colleges, administrative office, railway station, bus stand/terminal, police station, hospital, religious buildings, and military ground. It can be easily seen that most of these services are present either on the state highway or on the main connecting road inside the core area. The concentration of these facilities along the major roads improves their connectivity.
Figure 6-5 General Health Centre City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 48
Exhibit 6-19 summarizes the current status and Demand-Supply Gap analysis for Health Sector present in Nasrullahganj town. It also provides a snapshot of comparative analysis of existing level of service with level of service desired under the Urban Development Plans Formulation & Implementation (UDPFI) guidelines. Exhibit 6-19 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Health
Existing/ desired level Service head Indicator Government Hospital Nursing Home Dispensary No. of Beds/ 25000 pop. No. of Beds/ 4500 pop. Number/ 15000 pop. Service Levels, Demand and Gaps By Year 2025 By Year 2035 Demand Gap Demand Gap 75 25 3 21 7 1 97 32 3 22 7 -
Current Desired Existing By Year 2015 Unit level level (2011) Demand Gap 50 0 8 50 3 1 No. No. No. 50 0 8 54 18 2 54 18 -
The present condition of Health sector in Nasrullahganj town shows that there is an immediate need of Nursing Home in the town. There are total six doctors in the town.
6.9.2. Education
The town has two colleges one in ward-11 and another in ward-15. The town has three higher secondary schools 10 primary schools The town has 14 nursery schools and 11 Anganwadi schools. The details of the education facility are visible in Exhibit 6-20. Exhibit 6-20 Details of government educational institutions
Institution College Higher Secondary Schools Primary Schools
Source: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
Numbers 2 3 10
Students NA NA NA
Teacher NA NA NA
Exhibit 6-21 summarizes the current status and Demand-Supply Gap analysis for Education Sector present in Nasrullahganj town. It also provides a snapshot of comparative analysis of existing level of service with level of service desired under the Urban Development Plans Formulation & Implementation (UDPFI) guidelines. Exhibit 6-21 Present and Future Demand and Supply Gaps: Education
Existing/ desired level Service head Indicator Primary School Middle School College Per population Per population Per population Service Levels, Demand and Gaps Current Desired Existing By Year 2015 By Year 2025 By Year 2035 Unit level level (2011) Demand Gap Demand Gap Demand Gap 1826 5934 11869 2500 5000 100000 No. No. No. 10 3 2 11 4 1 1 15 5 4 1 19 6 4 1 -
49
The existing service levels in education sector show a good status. Existing schools are sufficient in number. The existing schools taken into consideration are just government schools. The problem faced in the education sector is the lack of basic facilities in the schools.
Weaknesses Lack of boundaries to the schools. Lack of Intermediate hospitals and PolyClinics. Lack of integrated schools and schools for handicapped. Quality of physical infrastructure of this Sector demands major revamping.
Threats Lack of maintenance can degrade the existing infrastructure. Lack of boundaries to the schools could result in encroachments. Poor connectivity to the schools could result of accidents.
6.9.5. Issues
Existing level of service in the health infrastructure demands a major revamping as these fall among factors which would guide future development of the area. Government Hospital which receives maximum number of patients from the town and nearby areas suffers from lack of infrastructure and poor maintenance of buildings and other assets; also it requires the permanent doctors, at present the doctors travel from other towns to Nasrullahganj. A continuous flow of funds needs to be ensured for development of new infrastructure and upgradation of existing infrastructure. Most of the schools of the town lack necessary infrastructure and hence, initiatives should be taken in equipping existing educational institutions with necessary infrastructure.
6.10. Environment
A towns environment is dependent on several factors which impact air quality, water quality, land quality, noise levels, etc. Each of these aspects gets affected by individual factors or a combination of two or more factors. Some of these factors are: Shortcomings in Solid Waste Collection, Underdeveloped Storm Water Drainage system, Undeveloped Waste water disposal system, Dust and particulate matters from vehicular traffic and industries, etc.
disposal of harmful waste, ground water pollution by leachate and surface water pollution by mixing of waste with water. In addition to these, solid waste clogging the drains leads to stagnation of water which ultimately leads to the unhygienic milieu. Under-developed drainage network and undeveloped waste water conveyance system leads to the stagnation of storm water and waste water in various parts of the city leading to unhygienic conditions which poses severe threat to the health of the citizens. It is anticipated that vehicular traffic on state highway will increase over the up-coming years, it will become a constant source of dust and other particulate matters which pollutes urban space and causes various kinds of respiratory problems to the citizens.
6.10.2. City green spaces (gardens and recreation total coverage ratio)
The city has no dedicated Green Spaces. Tree Plantation could be found along the few roads. As per UDPFI guidelines the recreational area should be around 8 to 10 per cent of the towns developed area, which is not there at present. As per the guidelines there should be 10 to 12 sq.m of green space per person. 31.5 ha of the green space requirement has been estimated to be added by 2036, as per the guidelines.
Policies
1. The National Water Policy, 1990 2. Indian National Policy Statement for Abatement of Pollution, 1992 3. National Conservation Strategy and Statement on Environment and Development, 1992
Legal
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. The Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, amended in 1988 The M P Public Health Act, 1949 The M P Control of Music & Noise Act, 1951 The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, amended in 1988 The M P Slum Area (Improvement & Clearance) Act, 1976 The Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Cess Act, 1977, amended in 1991 The Air (Conservation) Act, 1980, amended in 1988 The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, amended in 1987 The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991, amended in 1992 National Environmental Tribunal Act, 1995.
51
Weaknesses Less land for green areas and other environment improvement works. Almost extinct pond and sole dependence on ground water leading to depletion of ground water table
Conservation of Ground water. Threats Failure to integrate the issue of urban environment with infrastructure development projects. Failure to conserve pond and ground water table can have severe impact on the towns environment.
6.10.6. Issues
1. Leakages in Solid Waste Collection System leading to water and land pollution. 2. Clogging of drains and poor waste water handling system leading to threatening environmental situation. 3. Lack of adequate green cover in the city. 4. Open defecation.
6.11.1. Issues
Neglect faced by this area leading to underdeveloped infrastructure.
52
53
MPPCB is also responsible for implementation of the Municipal Solid Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000 of CPCB, which spell out responsibilities of the state pollution control boards and the urban local bodies. MPPCB is the monitoring authority with respect to ground water, ambient air, and compost quality in urban areas. The Board is also required to monitor processing and disposal facilities for municipal waste, with the approval of the State Urban Development Department, Town and Country Planning Department, and Ground Water Board. According to the Rules, the ULB City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 54
is responsible for implementation of the provisions and infrastructure development for collection, storage, segregation, transport and processing of solid waste in the town. The major areas of concern of MPPCB with regards to ULB functions are: Management of solid and liquid waste disposal; Waste water management; Improvement of roads and plantation of trees; Traffic management to control vehicular pollution; and Proper planning of the city.
6.12.6. Issues
Though roles of different organizations in the provisioning of urban services are clearly defined, plans formulated by different organizations suffer because of lack of coordination among various organizations. Since Nasrullahganj is in transition phase and the large proportion of area under its jurisdiction is agriculture, various departments who involved in provision of services to rural areas are still in the process of transferring the roles and responsibilities to respective departments. In case of street lighting, responsibility of installation of electricity poles and their electrification lies with MPSEB. Any failure in the coordination between Nagar Parishad and MPSEB results in poor urban governance. MPPCB should be regularly contacted to keep a check on urban environment and curb pollution. Nagar Parishad should maintain a healthy interaction for effective and comprehensive city planning. Meetings at regular intervals should be organized between various governing organizations for effective urban governance.
55
56
7.2.
Revenue account
The following section provides an in-depth review of the revenue account, in order to assess the municipal fiscal status. The revenue account comprises of two components - revenue income and revenue expenditure.
Tax Revenue
Tax revenue comprises of property tax, integrated tax, education cess, export tax, advertisement tax and other taxes. We can see that property tax and integrated tax constitute more than 50% of the Tax Revenue except for 2010-11 where export tax has contributed about 40% of the tax revenue (Exhibit 7-3). Exhibit 7-3 Tax Revenue
S.No 1 2 3 4 6 7 Property Tax Integrated tax Education cess Export tax Advertisement Tax Other Taxes Items 2007-08 Actuals in Rs. Lakhs 2.71 2.86 0.00 0.37 1.25 0.40 7.58 1.98 1.80 0.00 2.28 0.12 0.90 7.09 2.79 2.86 0.02 3.80 0.02 0.85 10.33 2.25 3.04 0.50 4.44 0.00 0.91 11.14 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
57
Key Observation:
The share of export tax has increased considerably over the last 4 years from around 5% in FY 200708 to approx. 40% in FY 2010-11. If this trend continues then we can expect the share of tax revenue to total revenue to increase from 6 % to double figures in the coming years and dependence on external funds would be reduced.
58
7.3.
Capital account
The Capital account comprises of capital income and capital expenditure. What distinguishes a capital income from revenue income is the purpose for which it is used. Capital expenditures are those expenditures which will accrue benefits to Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad over many years.
59
Capital account of the Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad was in deficit in 3 years except for 2010-11. Their capital expenditure exceeded their income in 3 of the 4 years . This is a good thing to notice since capital expenditure will generate returns in terms of better standard of living for the residents. In general the Capital Income of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad comprises of grants and contributions from centre and state governments. Major source of income is Capital grants from GoI and GoMP . Exhibit 7-7 displays the capital income and expenditure during last 4 years i.e. from 2007-08 to 2010-11 . We can observe from Exhibit 7-7 that approximately 98% of the capital expenditure went into capital WIP, 2% were spend on purchasing assets. Exhibit 7-7 Capital Account
S.No. Capital Income 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Share Actuals in Rs. Lakhs a b c i ii iii iv v vi vii viii Sale of asset Loans Grants & Contributions Special Projects Basic services UIDSSMT IHSDP Flood relief & NRCP State finance commission (S.F.C) T.F.C Other Grants Total Grants & Contributions d e Public Contribution Other Capital income Total Capital Income Capital Expenditure Capital Work in Progress Purchase of fixed assets Other Capital Expenditure Reserve Fund Total Capital Expenditure
Source: Annual Accounts, Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
9.71 0.83
2.73 2.42
3.02 1.00
4.09 0.96
3.88 0.97
0.00 71.79 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 10.99 82.78 0.00 0.30 93.62 2007-08 125.02 0.74 0.00 0.00 125.76
0.00 85.68 0.00 0.00 5.77 13.28 10.99 0.00 102.44 0.00 0.45 108.05 2008-09 155.55 0.00 0.00 0.00 155.55
90 0.02 0.00 0.00 0.00 12.74 10.99 79.78 180.79 0.00 10.02 194.82 2009-10 256.84 0.00 0.00 5.00 261.84
301.61 9.07 21.00 2.00 0.00 27.95 0.00 41.73 375.41 0.00 0.13 380.58 2010-11 98.30 7.25 0.00 0.00 105.55
31.36 39.59 1.38 0.13 1.34 6.54 3.95 15.91 93.67 0.00 1.48 100.00 Share 97.66 1.86 0.00 0.48 100
60
7.4.
S. No I Ii Iii Iv
Observations
Operating Ratio: The average operating ratio of the Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is 0.64 which is less than 1, indicating that Nasrullahganj revenue expenditure levels are lower than the revenue income generated. This might also indicate that the revenue income is being utilized for paying off capital expenditure since capital utilization ratio is more than one in 3 years . Capital Utilization ratio: Average Capital utilization ratio of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is 1.10 which is more than 1, indicating that Nasrullagunjs capital expenditure is more than its income . It also means that they are utilizing their revenue income for capital purposes . This kind of capital expenditure is good for the Nagar Parishad in the long term and will accrue benefits to the people residing in the village . Salaries expenditure to revenue income: approximately 34% of the revenue income is utilized for paying the staff employed by Nagar Parishad.
7.5.
Issues
Capital Utilization ratio is more than one, indicating that expenditure is more than the capital income. This indicates shortage of capital funds under various schemes. Tax revenue accounts for only 6.16 % of the total income, which is very less. There seems to be a need for rationalization of different types of taxes.
7.6.
Conclusion
This chapter dealt with the analysis of municipal finance and the financial health of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. The next chapter deals with City Vision, Sector Goals, Strategies, Action Plan, Projects and Prioritization.
61
8. CITY VISION, SECTOR GOALS, STRATEGIES, ACTION PLAN, PROJECTS AND PRIORITIZATION
The vision for Nasrullahganj was formulated by stakeholders and IMaCS through a consensus approach and continued consultations with the community. The consultations revolved around the citys strengths, current issues, concerns, problems and the areas that need to be focused on to achieve the desired results.
8.1.
After completing a rapid assessment of the citys infrastructure, physical and environmental aspects, and institutional and financial status, a consultative process was started with Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. The City Vision and Sector Goals workshop was held to explain the purpose of the CDP, the ownership of the plan, and the need for establishing or strengthening partnerships to leverage Nagar Parishads role in facilitating economic growth and improving quality of life. The officials of other government departments such as Health, Education, etc who have a stake in the development of the city were also involved in this workshop. This workshop focused on highlighting the current status of all the services provided by various Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad departments and the key issues confronting each department. The consultations held so far were concluded with a visioning workshop with stakeholders. Nagar Parishad officials and other stakeholders together carried out the visioning exercise at this workshop. The workshop started with a plenary session in which the current status and gaps in various services were presented to the stakeholders. It was followed by the mission statements and the perceived needs of the stakeholders. The comparison also served to identify additional priorities not mentioned by the Nagar Parishad officials as well as discrepancies between the services provided by Nagar Parishad and the stakeholders perception of such services. The Presentation by IMaCS team was followed by a questionnaire survey which aimed at eliciting stakeholders perception of city, citys infrastructure, major issues and where they want their city to be in the future. This was followed by the ward-wise detailing of ward-specific problems and potentials that can be harnessed for the development of ward and city.
2. City should be clean and beautiful with employment opportunity for everyone including women. 3. Industries both small and large scale should be encouraged in town so that employment opportunity can be developed. 4. Promote education, health institutions and a safe environment for the citizens. There should be good supply of water in the town.
63
Development of new areas should be undertaken through implementation of Town Planning Schemes. Detailed development plan has to be prepared for the selected new areas with the guidance of master plan /land use plan for the city. 8. Conserve Nasrullahganj Environment Conservation of major Nallah and the natural environment of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. These Mission Statements would serve the purposes of aligning/initiating development works with the formulated vision, guidance during the policy formulations to achieve the goal and framework for the coordination among the various stakeholder agencies.
8.2.
Per capita supply as per norms 24/7 water supply WATER SUPPLY Quality of water Non-revenue water Consumer metering Roof water harvesting Private sector participation
64
Project Rationale Water Supply in the town not adequate to meet the existing and future demand. Current treatments were restricted only to chlorination. Revenues from water charges are not adequate, and the installation of water meters becomes important both from the perspective raising revenues and checking water consumption.
Sub- Projects Water Supply source augmentation to 6.58 MLD by 2035. Development of water treatment facility of 6.58 MLD by 2035 which can be taken up in a phased manner. Increasing distribution network to 72.46 km by year 2035 which can be taken up in a phased manner.
The projects identified to meet the Gaps (Demand-Supply) in this sector are listed in Exhibit 8-4. The list of identified projects recommended under CDP, is preceded by a list of on-going Projects. In addition to the estimated Gaps (Demand-Supply), the contribution of on-going Projects in addressing
65
the expected demand has also been considered while identifying the projects for Horizon-1 (Short term) and Horizon-2 (Long term). Exhibit 8-4 Water Supply Projects in a phased manner
A On-going Projects (as of 2011) Nasrullahganj Water Supply Project (Under UIDSSMT) Status: Under Construction Implementing Agency: Nasrullahganj Nagar parishad Being designed for year 2040. Aimed at increasing the daily water supply to 5.6 MLD Project Components: Construction of an Intake Well to draw water from Narmada River B Treatment Plant of 5.6 MLD Capacit0y Distribution Network: 5 Km Elevated Water Storage Tanks (2 numbers): Capacity of 350 KL each. Components Source Augmentation (MLD) Distribution Network (km) Treatment Capacity (MLD) OHT Capacity (ML)
Source: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and IMaCS Analysis
Sewage reuse
Recycling
and
66
Sector
In addition to above area, a constant effort should be devoted towards Community participation and awareness campaign for the proper maintenance of Public Toilets and Cost Recovery through collecting the user charges.
Table given below shows broad action plan needed in sewerage and sanitation sector.
67
The projects identified to meet the Gaps (Demand-Supply) in this sector are listed in Exhibit 8-9. The list of identified projects recommended under CDP, is preceded by a list of on-going Projects. In addition to the estimated Gaps (Demand-Supply), the contribution of on-going Projects in addressing the expected demand has also been considered while identifying the projects for Horizon-1 (Short term) and Horizon-2 (Long term). Exhibit 8-9 Sewerage and Sanitation Projects in a phased manner
A Ongoing Projects (as of 2011) Sanitation Project: City Sanitation Plan for Nasrullahganj Status: Under preparation Initiative of Government of Madhya Pradesh to implement the National Urban Sanitation Policy in the State. A joint effort of Government of Madhya Pradesh, UN-Habitat, Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and AIILSG. Funding support has been provided by UN-Habitat for preparation of this plan. Aims at achieving sanitation infrastructure development along with developing awareness in the community and encourages public private partnerships in the sector.
68
Sewerage Project: Providing and laying of sewer network of Nasrullahganj Status: Under Construction Design period of 30 years, till 2038, it will enable municipal Parishad to collect the sewerage and storm water and carry it other suitable place for providing desired treatment before the waste water being finally disposed off to river or rushed for any other purposes. Providing and laying of sewer network within town . Total network length will be 20.28 Km. Two stabilisation ponds for 4 MLD capacities will be constructed. Components Underground Drainage Network (km) Sewage Treatment Plant Capacity (MLD) Public Convenience Seats (Nos.)
Source: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and IMaCS Analysis
The projects identified to meet the Gaps (Demand-Supply) in this sector are listed in Exhibit 8-14. The list of identified projects recommended under CDP, is preceded by a list of on-going Projects. In addition to the estimated Gaps (Demand-Supply), the contribution of on-going Projects in addressing the expected demand has also been considered while identifying the projects for Horizon-1 (Short term), and Horizon-2 (Long term). Exhibit 8-14 Solid Waste Management Projects in a phased manner
A Ongoing Projects (as of 2011) On-going project: clean-Green and healthy journey towards vision 2020 Components of project are followings: B Awareness programme for the people of Nasrullahganj; Workshops for the municipal employee; Compost Production Centre; Buying of new Instruments Components Wheel Barrow/ Hand Carts (Nos.) Community Bins/ Dustbins (Nos.) Collection Points (Nos.) Vehicle Carrying Capacity (Tonnes) Tractor Trolley (Nos.) Land Fill Infrastructure (Tonnes/day) Composting Plant (Tonnes/day)
Source: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and IMaCS Analysis
70
71
Sector
2015
2025 New Formations: Pucca Open 3.44 km, Pucca closed 6.38 km 100% None
2035 New Formations: Pucca Open 3.96 km, Pucca Closed 8.04 km 100% None
Pucca drains
New Formations: Pucca Open 3.20 km Desilting of drains to increase their capacity None
Rehabilitation of existing primary nallahs and water bodies Flood prone areas
72
Exhibit 8-18 Projects identified by ULB and Consultant for Storm Water Drainage
ULBs Suggestion Scheme for augmenting storm water drainage network for the town Project Rationale According to normative standards, the length of the drains are assumed at 130% of road length considering all divided roads to have drains on either side and undivided roads on at least one side. Further the drains in the initial phase shall be open and subsequently be made closed; hence the investment is towards up-gradation annually and for construction of new closed drains. All existing open drains shall be first upgraded to closed drains and subsequently new drains shall be constructed. Prominently, all the road and storm water projects are to be taken up simultaneously to match the levels of the roads with the drains and allow draining of rain water from the city. Projects Proposed Storm Water Drainage network for the town of Nasrullahganj Sub- Projects Cleaning/Desilting of natural drains such as nallah flowing from west to east part of the city. Construction of 8.04 km of Pucca closed drains and 3.96 km of Pucca open drains by 2035
The projects identified to meet the Gaps (Demand-Supply) in this sector are listed in Exhibit 8-19. The list of identified projects recommended under CDP, is preceded by a list of on-going Projects. In addition to the estimated Gaps (Demand-Supply), the contribution of on-going Projects in addressing the expected demand has also been considered while identifying the projects for Horizon-1 (Short term) and Horizon-2 (Long term). Exhibit 8-19 Storm Water Drainage Projects in a phased manner
A Ongoing Projects (as of 2011) There is no project ongoing in this sector. B Components Desilting and strengthening of primary drains (km) Upgradation from Kutcha to Pucca Open (km) Upgradation from Kutcha to Pucca Closed (km) Upgradation from Pucca open to Pucca closed (km) Construction of new Pucca open drains (km) Construction of New Pucca closed drains (km)
Source: Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and IMaCS Analysis
Projects Under Horizon-1 Projects Under Horizon-2 35 2.11 22.39 3.20 3.20 35 3.96 8.04
73
Parking facilities
The broad sector interventions to address both the short and long term requirements have been enlisted below:
74
Exhibit 8-22 Traffic and Transportation Long Term and Short Term Interventions
Sector Interventions Required Construction of new roads in areas which are at present earthen. New roads to cater to missing links and developing areas Development of Parking Spaces Improved bus stand and related amenities
Outcome
The projects identified to meet the Gaps (Demand-Supply) in this sector are listed in Exhibit 8-24. The list of identified projects recommended under CDP, is preceded by a list of on-going Projects. In addition to the estimated Gaps (Demand-Supply), the contribution of on-going Projects in addressing the expected demand has also been considered while identifying the projects for Horizon-1 (Short term) and Horizon-2 (Long term). Exhibit 8-24 Traffic & Transportation Sector Projects
A Ongoing Projects (as of 2011) Ongoing project is Upgradation of Existing Road Network of Nasrullahganj. Total project cost 120.68 lakhs. Components of projects are following
Site clearance and Dismantling; Granular-base course and Sub-base; Excavation and earthworks; Bituminous Course and Traffic sign board.
Components Upgradation of Roads (km) Construction of New CC Roads (km) Construction of New BT Roads (km) Widening/ Strengthening of Roads (km) Development of Parking Areas (LS) Development of Bus or Truck Terminus (LS) Projects Under Horizon-1 Projects Under Horizon-2 15 8.51 1.58 1.21 2.42 1.23 8 0.65 1.92 3.84
75
Action Plan following the Strategies Action Plan for Street Lighting:
To install new street lights Shifting to energy efficient lights in a phased manner
There is no project ongoing in this sector. B Components New Installation of Tube lights (Nos.) Underground Cabling (km) Projects Under Horizon-1 585 16.50 Projects Under Horizon-2 231 9.06
76
Exhibit 8-27 Street Light and Fire Fighting Projects: Responsible Agencies
Immediate measures to be taken Finalising the sub projects to be undertaken Preparation of DPR for finalised projects Submission of DPR to funding agency Authorities/Agencies responsible Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad in consultation with Councillors and other stakeholders Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
8.2.7. Urban poor and their accessibility to basic Services Sector Goals
To achieve hygienic environment in slums, access to basic services and quality housing for all slum households with the ultimate aim of a slum-free city
77
Key areas which would be addressed by detailed strategies and action plan to meet the sector goal are provided in Exhibit 8-29. Exhibit 8-29 Health: Achievement Targets
Sector Components Doctors per 1000 population Effective implementation of health programmes and related services in the slum areas of the city Regular checks for water contamination in all water bodies of the city 2015 2 To be carried in coordination of Dept. of Health, GoMP Yes (Provision to be made for necessary infrastructure) 2025 2 To be carried in coordination of Dept. of Health, GoMP 2035 3 To be carried in coordination of Dept. of Health, GoMP
Health
Yes
Yes
78
Ongoing Projects (as of 2011) Projects Under Horizon-1 54 2 Projects Under Horizon-2 97 3
Education
Exhibit 8-34 Education Sector Long Term and Short Term Interventions
Sector Interventions Required Expected Outcome Development of necessary infrastructure Awareness generation Enforcement of regulations on private schools 100% enrolment in primary schools Achievement of prescribed teacher-student ratio 100 % literacy rate
There is no project ongoing in this sector. Projects Under Horizon-1 11 4 Projects Under Horizon-2 19 6 -
As discussed earlier, Nagar Parishads role in this sector is limited to the provision of providing basic services and catalysing involvement of other departments. Availability of land is a necessity in this sector for which Tehsil office should be consulted. Exhibit 8-36 Education Sector: Responsible Agencies
Immediate measures to be taken Finalising the sub projects to be undertaken Preparation of DPR for finalised projects Submission of DPR to funding agency Authorities/Agencies responsible Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and Dept of Education, GoMP Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and Dept of Education, GoMP Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad and Dept of Education, GoMP
80
Considering the stakeholders view and standard guidelines, following projects have been proposed in the town: 1. Community Rooms: At present Nasrullahganj has one community hall but the infrastructure provision of the same has to be revamped. 2. Parks: The vacant land in the city should be identified and developed as parks to serve the dual purpose of increasing the green cover in the city and provide citizens with open spaces for recreation. Exhibit 8-39 Other Social Infrastructure: Responsible Agencies
Immediate measures to be taken Finalising the sub projects to be undertaken Preparation of DPR for finalised projects Submission of DPR to funding agency Authorities/Agencies responsible Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
consciously. There should be a clear-cut strategy to conserve and protect the physical environment, including rivers and natural drains in and around Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. It is important to weigh the environmental impact of the new programs or development schemes. Lately, a large number of unauthorized layouts have come up in the city, near to the citys fringes or in fringe areas. It is important to devise a plan, which can check the growth of these unauthorized developments, especially within the citys precincts. Lake and River conservation should also be explored with the possibilities of reviving lakes as water sources or points of interest in the city.
Strengthening the markets, Improving transportation infrastructure, Bringing Nasrullahganj on Railways Map of India, Promoting small & medium scale industries.
Projects Envisaged
For promoting economic development of the town, following projects have been envisaged for Nasrullahganj. 1. Development of Commercial Areas: This can further be achieved by development of new commercial areas and up gradation of existing commercial areas. New commercial areas can include dedicated markets for important commodities or general markets. In addition to the development of new markets, existing markets can be upgraded to increase their capacity and provide better services to the users and customers. 2. Development of Industrial Area for Small & Medium scale industries: With the objective of diversifying the economic base of Nasrullahganj Town, an industrial park for small & medium scale industries should be developed. A land should be identified either within the municipal limits or near to the city boundary and proposal should be sent to the appropriate authorities for the same. This would thrust to the employment generation activities result into the overall upliftment of the society. 3. Redevelopment of Hawkers Zone: The hawkers zone in city is not organized. The Hawkers zone would dedicate space to the hawkers and hence reducing congestion on the city roads, making waste collection easier and making it easier for customers to shop. Exhibit 8-41 Economic Development: Implementation Agencies Immediate measures to be taken Authorities/Agencies responsible Finalising the sub projects to be undertaken Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Preparation of DPR for finalised projects Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Submission of DPR to funding agency Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad
83
8.3.
In the second workshop conducted on December 23rd, 2011, questionnaire survey was carried out for the formulation of city vision and sector strategies. The discussion took place with around 25 stakeholders who included, CMO, Adshyakha and other eminent people of the city. The questionnaire consisted questions pertaining to the level of city infrastructure such as water supply, road, sewerage, college, hospitals, mode for economic development, overall quality of life in city, vision in their opinion for the city. Each sector status was discussed in detail and their view on sector development was taken.
8.3.1. Methodology for Questionnaire Survey Sample Set for the Interview
Around 25 stakeholders participated in the workshop and care was taken that representation from various sector be present during the survey. Stakeholders consisted of senior Government officials like CMO of Nagar Parishad, Elected Body head Adhyaksha and Parshads (Ward Councilors), citizens, reporters, Nagar Parishad staffs. During the town survey, verbal survey of questionnaire was already carried out from Schools and Hospitals.
disposal, schools, health facility, and economic development options. Similarly 14 questions were given ward specific. Detailed questionnaire is attached in Annexure II.
RANK 1 2 3 4 5 6 6 8 9
RANK 1 2 3 4 5
85
RANK 1 2 3 4 5
RANK 1 2 3 4 5
RANK 1 2 3 4 5
RANK 1 2 3 4 5
86
RANK 3 4
RANK 1 2 3 4 5 6
8.4.
Conclusion
This chapter dealt with the city vision, sector goals and sector strategies to achieve sector goals. The discussion on sector strategies was followed by the identification of interventions required in every sector. This was followed by the identification of projects and project implementation agencies.
87
9.1.
The City Investment Plan is a multi-year scheduling of identified and prioritized investments. The scheduling or phasing of the plan is based on the assessment of fiscal resources availability (for new investments and O&M), technical capacity for construction and O&M, and the choice of specific improvements to be carried out by 2015. The need for the CIP is on account of: City growth and infrastructure needs (to be carried out once every five years); Scheduling of investments of ongoing projects due to cost and/ or time overruns; Assigning of priorities within the constraints of available financial resources.
9.2.
The City Investment Plan is an important element and is significant in terms of the citys management process and sustainability with regard to the delivery of basic services. The CIP will also provide a framework for the annual budget cycle of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad for the next five years. As a part of Nasrullahganj CDP, CIP includes the following: The desired service levels/ standards for infrastructure provision; Identified the roles and responsibilities of various stakeholders in the implementation of identified projects; Project phasing and strategies for implementation.
In Nasrullahganj, Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad has the primary responsibility of delivering municipal services. So the CDP proposals will have to be implemented by the Nagar Parishad. The projects, prioritization, investment phasing, strategies and action plan are framed accordingly. The CIP involved the identification of public facilities to cater demand of the city populace in the years 2015, 2025 and 2035. The projects have been identified through a demand-gap analysis for various urban services. Identification of projects was followed by their prioritization based on the stakeholders consultation. The projects identified are aimed at ensuring the optimal and efficient utilization of existing infrastructure systems and enhancing the capacity of the systems/services to cater to the demands of future population. In addition to the projects which are related to major urban services, CIP also includes developmental projects like greenery development, parking spaces, system modernization etc. City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 88
The CIP and forecasted future needs for provision of capital facilities under each identified sector is presented below. These assets will help Nasrullahganj in improving the quality and coverage of service for the current population as well as accommodate the expected increase in population. In some of the sectors like source augmentation for water supply, development of landfill site etc, a planning horizon of 25 years has been considered.
9.3.
Summary of Investments
The total estimated capital investment required for providing efficient services to the present population and future population of Nasrullahganj by the year 2035 is Rs. 76.24 crores at constant prices. Of the total identified investment a total of Rs. 32.74 crores of investment has been proposed till year 2015. The planning horizon for the projects has been considered on the basis of demand generation in various decades and degree of initial capital investment. Hence, some of the sectors have been planned for the short term as well as the long term whereas some sectors have been divided into various sub-parts in which some of the sub-parts have been planned for the long term only whereas rest of the sub-parts have been planned for short term and long term. The phasing of the identified projects and investments is based on the following principles. Priority needs, with developed areas receiving priority over future development area; Inter and intra-service linkages, viz. water supply investments shall be complemented by corresponding sewerage/ sanitation improvements; Size and duration of the requirements, including preparation and implementation period.
Exhibit 9-1 presents the summary of sector-wise total investment need, investments up to 2015-16, proportions of investments required in various sectors w.r.t total investments in different horizons. Exhibit 9-1 Summary of Investments required
Investment by 2015 Sectors (Rs. lakhs) 987.29 400.71 560.17 481.91 99.75 37.98 621.25 244.00 195.00 22 35.00 12 3,697.06 % w.r.t. total till 2015 26.70% 10.84% 15.15% 13.03% 2.70% 1.03% 16.80% 6.60% 5.27% 0.60% 0.95% 0.32% 100.00% Total Investment (Rs. lakhs) 1,227.96 501.62 1,495.16 1,164.42 192.2 199.60 621.25 1,079.50 975.00 88 60.00 20 7,624.71 % w.r.t. total till 2035 16.11% 6.58% 19.61% 15.27% 2.52% 2.62% 8.15% 14.16% 12.79% 1.15% 0.79% 0.26% 100.00% % of Investment till 2015 w.r.t 2035 80% 80% 37% 41% 52% 19% 100% 23% 20% 25% 58% 60% 48%
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Water Supply Sewerage & Sanitation Roads & Urban Transport Storm Water Drains Street Lights Solid Waste Management Urban Poor/ Slums Health Infrastructure Education Socio-Cultural Facilities Urban Environment Urban Governance Total Investment
89
As can be observed from Exhibit 9-1, a total 48% of the total identified investment need is proposed for funding by 2015 Within the total investment proposed by 2015 for Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad, maximum share has been taken by the Water Supply at more than 26 % . Roads and Transport and storm water drains at 15% and 13% respectively. Health sector envisaged the investment at 6.6 %. Housing for Urban Poor accounts for 16.8 % of the total investment, while Sewerage and sanitation accounts for 10.84 % of the investment. Subsequent sections provide an investment snapshot for each of the sectors followed by the detailing for Priority needs and Long Term needs. Discussion on Investment is followed by an Action plan for the implementation of projects in the short term i.e. for a period of five years from year 2011 to 2015 Investments in different time-periods for various sectors are provided in subsequent sections. The investments have been estimated for three terms, namely: 1. Short Term (Year 2011 to Year 2015) 2. Medium Term (Year 2016 to Year 2025) 3. Long Term (Year 2026 to Year 2035)
9.4.
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Water Supply considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The short term is being defined as a planning horizon of 5 years from year 2011 to 2015 whereas medium term and long term are being considered as 10 years from year 2015 to 2025 and year 2025 to 2035 respectively. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-2. Exhibit 9-2 Investment Snapshot: Water Supply
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs Water Supply 1 2 3 4 5 Source Augmentation Treatment capacity Distribution Network Elevated Storage capacity w.r.t Supply Refurbishment of Old Distribution Network 987.31 180.46 487.37 217.90 61.60 39.98 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 240.67 111.61 78.44 34.72 15.90 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 1,227.96 180.46 598.97 296.34 96.32 55.87 14.70% 48.78% 24.13% 7.84% 4.55% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Water sector needs a total investment of Rs 1227.96 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 987.31 Lakhs whereas in the long term, investments of Rs 240.67 Lakhs would be required.
90
The Nagar Parishad would have to develop a comprehensive watershed management plan for the city including details of groundwater availability, use, potential for increasing the water drawn from the available ground water source of the town. Identify the areas hitherto not covered by water distribution network and develop a comprehensive plan for providing water supply to these areas. Increase the number of domestic connections Reserve land for zones that are good for water recharge and water conservation Capital investments on system refurbishment and replacement shall happen only after conducting water audit and identification of Non-Revenue Water (NRW) sources Improvement of collection efficiency is applicable to both arrears and current demand Daily per capita water supply (min of 135 lpcd) Elevated storage capacity w.r.t supply (33%) Distribution network reach as % of road length (min 85%)
91
Water Supply
12-13
13-14
14-15
15-16
System coverage % of PT assessments (min 85%) Cost recovery through user charges (100% O&M expenses)
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Sewerage & Sanitation considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-4. Exhibit 9-4 Investment Snapshot: Sewerage & Sanitation
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 400.7 336.60 61.05 3.05 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 100.92 83.06 17.86 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 501.62 419.66 78.91 3.05 83.66% 15.73% 0.61% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Sewerage and Sanitation 1 2 3 Under Ground Drainage Network Treatment Capacity Pub. Convenience for Floating Pop Sanitation Facilities
Source: IMaCS Analysis Sewerage & Sanitation sector needs a total investment of Rs 501.62 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 400.70 Lakhs whereas in the long term Rs 100.92 Lakhs would be required.
92
years. The Action Plan, as shown in Exhibit 9-5, also discusses about various Support & System Sustenance measures, Action Measures, Sector Notes and Performance Monitoring Indicators. Exhibit 9-5 Action Plan for Implementation: Sewerage and Sanitation
Sewerage System/ UGD Consolidated Yearly Investment (Rs Lakhs) Capital Facilities Support & System Sustenance Measures Action Measures UGD Network Treatment Capacity Public Convenience Seats Ensure every house tax assessment & water connection is also connected to the UGD Improve collections to reach 85% collection efficiency by 2015 12-13 13-14 140.25 14-15 140.25 15-16 120.21
Development of a DPR for laying of UGD system in the town Eradicate the conditions which give rise to conditions of malaria and other water borne diseases. Ensure access of sanitary facilities to the slum dwellers Isolate sewerage system from storm water and drinking water channels
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Solid Waste Management sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-6. Exhibit 9-6 Investment Snapshot: Solid Waste Management
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 37.98 0.50 1.97 10.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 91.72 0.31 10.00 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 69.90 0.38 10.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 199.60 1.19 1.97 30.00 0.60% 0.99% 15.03% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Solid Waste Management 1 Primary Collection 1 2 3 2 Wheel Barrow/Hand Carts Tricycles Community Bins (Dust bins) Tractor Trolley 3 4 5 Disposal Site Land Fill Infrastructure (as per CPHEEO Standards) Composting Plant
Vehicles
22.72 2.80
72.49 8.93
52.99 6.52
148.19 18.25
74.24% 9.14%
93
Solid Waste Management sector needs a total investment of Rs 199 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 37.98 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 91.72 Lakhs and Rs 69.90 Lakhs would be required respectively.
Increase the ambit of Solid Waste Management to include recycling and to facilitate and regulate the sector accordingly. Ensure optimum utilization of existing fleet I-E-C campaigns to be initiated for awareness among the urban poor and slum dwellers towards better SWM practices Initiate steps towards sharing the responsibility of primary collection of segregated garbage with citizens Develop transfer stations in a scientific, eco-friendly manner processing waste at these sites, for different types of material Develop decentralized waste processing sites at each zone- appropriate
94
12-13
13-14
14-15
15-16
technologies Improve and ensure access to sanitary facilities for the urban poor and slum dwellers. Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad shall be the prime implementing agency for the sector For establishment of Intermediate Transfer Stations to reduce cost of transportation, identify sites which are cost effective Identify localized/ decentralised locations for processing/ disposal/ reuse of biodegradable and plastic waste Source segregation reduction of waste to be collected (min 70 % of waste generated) Door-to-door collection as % of households covered (min 80%) Optimum fleet utilisation (No. of trips/ vehicle/ day - average minimum of 2.5) Vehicle capacity as % of rated capacity to waste generated (minimum 100%)
9.4.4. Drainage
To meet the formulated sector goal with satisfactory level of service indicators, the sector would require an investment of Rs1,164.2 Lakhs i.e. around 37% of total investment estimated under City Investment Plan as shown in Exhibit 9-1.
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Storm Water Drainage sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-8. Exhibit 9-8 Investment Snapshot: Storm Water Drainage
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 481.91 of 175.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 329.55 175.00 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 352.96 175.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 1,164.42 525.00 45.09 % Component w.r.t sector Investment
2 Upgradation i ii iii Kutcha to Pucca Open Kutcha to Pucca Closed Pucca Open to Pucca Closed Pucca Drains Pucca Drains Open Closed 18.96 237.10 10.17 18.96 237.10 10.17 1.63 % 20.36 % 0.87 %
3 New Constructions i ii 40.68 43.68 110.86 50.30 127.66 134.66 238.53 11.56 % 20.48 %
95
Storm Water Drainage sector needs a total investment of Rs 1,164.42 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 481.91 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 329.55 Lakhs and Rs 352.96 Lakhs would be required respectively.
Preparation of DPR for augmentation of storm water system in the town Isolate sewerage system from drinking water and storm water lines Identify, delineate, sanitize and protect the natural drainage system of the city Improve drainage network on a priority basis in flood prone areas All new roads to be designed shall have adequate provision for storm water drains. Constructing new drains shall be integrated with the new roads development Drainage network should 130% of road length All divided roads to have drains on either side and undivided roads on at least one side Drains to be cleaned before and after monsoon for better functioning
96
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Solid Waste Management sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-10. Exhibit 9-10 Investment Snapshot: Traffic & Transportation
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 560.17 195.00 170.17 90.00 25.00 80.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 448.64 16.03 192.34 58.77 16.50 165.00 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 486.34 18.46 221.49 37.40 19.00 190.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 1,495.16 229.49 584.00 186.17 60.50 435.00 15.35% 39.06% 12.45% 4.05% 29.09% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Urban Roads, Transport & Traffic 1 2 3 4 5 Upgradation (Kutcha to Pucca) New Formation (Pucca Roads) Widening/ Strengthening Development of Bus & Truck Terminus Land Acquisition
Traffic & Transportation sector needs a total investment of Rs 1,495 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 560 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 4,48 Lakhs and Rs 486 Lakhs would be required respectively.
97
The Action Plan, as shown in Exhibit 9-11, also discusses about various Support & System Sustenance measures, Action Measures, Sector Notes and Performance Monitoring Indicators. Exhibit 9-11 Action Plan for Implementation: Traffic & Transportation
Traffic and Transportation Consolidated Yearly Investment (Rs Lakhs) Capital Facilities Roads Upgradation Roads New Formation Development of Truck Terminus Action Measures Sector Notes Performance Monitoring Indicators Bus & 12-13 72.03 13-14 81.03 14-15 141.05 15-16 176.06
Identification of earthen roads which need to be upgraded to BT/CC Improve connectivity within the Municipal area Provide parking lots and introduce parking fee Provide for footpaths on the existing and yet to be developed roads Construction of flyovers at various locations in town Development of Parking space Development of Bus and Truck Terminals The design of the new roads should have provision for shoulder, foot paths, utility ducts and storm water drains under the foot paths. New roads development shall be integrated with the drain construction (i.e. for any new road drainage facility to be planned and constructed alongside) Road condition - % municipal roads surfaced (100% - CC/ BT surfacing)
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Street Lighting sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-12. Exhibit 9-12 Investment Snapshot: Street Lighting & Fire Fighting
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 99.75 58.50 41.25 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 40.42 20.00 3.02 17.40 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 52.04 23.10 6.29 22.65 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 192.21 101.60 9.31 81.30 52.86% 4.84% 42.30% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Street Lighting 1 i ii 2 New Installation Tube Light High Power Underground Cabling (Replacement and new)
98
Street Lighting & Fire Fighting sector needs a total investment of Rs 192.21 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 99.75 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term, investments totaling to Rs 40.42 Lakhs and Rs 52.04 Lakhs would be required.
Identification of roads uncovered with street lights Equipping new roads with Street lights Undergrounding of new and existing cables Procurement of new fire fighting equipment Cable should be laid underground New instalments should be energy efficient Utilization of Fire fighting equipments should be properly documented Street Lighting Average spacing between consecutive poles ( 30-35 m) Street Lighting Operations and Maintenance cost Fire Fighting Average Time taken to reach the affected site
9.5.
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Health Infrastructure sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-14. Exhibit 9-14 Investment Snapshot: Health Infrastructure
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 244.00 64.00 180.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 413.50 336.00 70.00 7.50 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 422.00 352.00 70.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 1,079.50 752.00 320.00 7.50 69.66% 29.64% 0.69% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Health Infrastructure sectors needs a total investment of Rs 1079.50 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 244 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 413.50 Lakhs and Rs 422 Lakhs would be required respectively.
Augmentation of Bed Capacity of the city by either developing new facilities or upgrading the existing ones Development of Nursing home and Dispensaries
100
13-14
14-15
15-16
Provisions should be made for the optimal utilization of health infrastructure by tackling obstacles like shortage of power, medical staff, etc Primary care should be given due importance Hospital waste should be properly disposed
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Education Infrastructure sector considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-16. Exhibit 9-16 Investment Snapshot: Education Infrastructure
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 195.00 65.00 130.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 390.00 260.00 130.00 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 390.00 260.00 130.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 975.00 585.00 390.00 60.00% 40.00% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Education Infrastructure sectors needs a total investment of Rs 975 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 195 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term, investments Rs 390 Lakhs and Rs 390 Lakhs would be required respectively.
101
Development of New Schools at all level Equipping Schools with necessary Infrastructure Complementing Education with employment opportunities Generating awareness about education Provisions should be made for the optimal utilization of education infrastructure by tackling obstacles like shortage of power, staff, etc Primary education should be given its due importance
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Socio-Cultural Infrastructure considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-18. Exhibit 9-18 Investment Snapshot: Other Social Infrastructure
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 22.00 10.00 12.00 Medium Term Rs. Lakhs 22.00 10.00 12.00 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 44.00 20.00 24.00 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 88.00 40.00 48.00 100.0% 54.55% 45.45% Component w.r.t sector Investment
Socio-Cultural Infrastructure needs a total investment of Rs 88 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 22 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 22 Lakhs and Rs 44 Lakhs would be required respectively.
components of Socio-Cultural infrastructure and its proportion with respect to the investment required in the sector is being presented in Exhibit 9-18.
Development of Community Rooms, Community hall and a Public Library Development of Green Spaces Development of a Recreational Club, a Sports Complex and a Swimming Pool Maintenance of these public facilities plays a crucial role in preserving the assets A healthy socio-cultural atmosphere fosters a healthy environment for growth Land for these facilities can be acquired under the Public Purpose
9.6.
Investment Snapshot
An investment plan was devised for the improvement of urban environment considering the future threats in the short, medium and long terms. The initiatives have been classified under various tasks as shown in Exhibit 9-20. Exhibit 9-20 Investment Snapshot: Urban Environment
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Rs. Lakhs 35.00 30.00 5.00 Medium Term) Rs. Lakhs 17.50 15.00 2.50 Long Term Rs. Lakhs 7.50 5.00 2.50 Total Term Rs. Lakhs 60.00 50.00 10.00 100.0% 83.33% 16.67% Component w.r.t sector Investment
103
This sector needs a total investment of Rs 60 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 35 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 17.50 Lakhs and Rs 7.50 Lakhs would be required respectively.
Strengthening of Waste Collection and Disposal Mechanism and Waste Water Conveyance System Development of green spaces and tree plantation Preservation of water bodies
9.7.
Capital needs/ investments Urban Poor and their accessibility to Basic Services
To meet the formulated sector goal, an investment of about Rs 621.25 Lakhs i.e. 8.15 % of total investment estimated under City Investment Plan as shown in Exhibit 9-1.
Investment Snapshot
An investment plan was devised in line with the IHSDP scheme for the provision of basic services to the urban poor. The investment anticipated for various tasks is shown in Exhibit 9-22. Exhibit 9-22 Investment Snapshot: Urban Poor
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term Long Term Rs. Lakhs 621.25 546.25 75.00 Rs. Lakhs Total Term Rs. Lakhs 621.25 546.25 75.00 Component w.r.t sector Investment 100.0% 87.93 % 12.07 %
Urban Poor/ Slums' Improvement 1 Slum Improvement - Rehabilitation/ Housing a Slum Improvement- Infrastructure
Source: IMaCS Analysis
104
Provision of basic services to the Urban Poor needs a total investment of Rs 621.25 Lakhs. It has been assumed that identified projects will be carried out in the short term with the aim of providing quick respite to the urban poor.
Construction of housing units and other infrastructure for urban poor Ensuring that new developmental schemes/projects have a city wide coverage with a special focus on urban poors
9.8.
To meet the formulated sector goal with satisfactory level of service indicators, the sector would require an investment of Rs 20 Lakhs i.e. around 0.26 % of total investment estimated under City Investment Plan as shown in Exhibit 9-1.
Investment Snapshot
A sector wise investment plan was devised for the Urban Infrastructure considering the demand arising in the short, medium and long terms. The infrastructural requirements of a sector have been classified into various components for which cost estimates are provided in Exhibit 9-24. Exhibit 9-24 Investment Snapshot: Urban Governance
Costing Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad Short Term 12.00 3.00 3.00 6.00 Medium Term 4.00 1.00 1.00 2.00 Long Term 4.00 1.00 1.00 2.00 Total Term 20.00 5.00 5.00 10.00 Component w.r.t sector Investment 100.0% 25.00% 25.00% 50.00%
Urban Governance 1 Electronic Items for Computerization 2 Training Modules 3 GIS Mapping
Source: IMaCS Analysis
Urban Infrastructure needs a total investment of Rs 20 Lakhs in three phases by year 2035. In the short term, this sector would require an investment of Rs 12 Lakhs whereas in the medium term and long term Rs 4 Lakhs and Rs 4 Lakhs would be required respectively. City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 105
Computerization for improving accountability in the system GIS mapping for having a wide database which can be used for improving the revenue, better planning and implementation
9.9.
As mentioned that the total investment required for the next five years for the entire city is Rs. 36.97 crores, out of which about Rs. 4.39 crore towards Education and Health sector, which will not be required by the ULB as implementation agency for these services is state government. Following section details about the existing plan under which this investments can be considered.
106
107
b. Revision of Water charges at specific intervals. Though the revision in water tariff should be done on annual basis to recover 100% of the O&M cost. However, annual revision is not a general practice in all the ULBs across the state, so revision after every five years is envisaged for projections. c. Introduction of Sewerage Charges in 2014-15, after implementing the Sewerage Project d. Maintenance of the collection performance of taxes and charges at certain minimum levels for current and for arrears e. Borrowings from market or financial institutions
Old Outstanding loans Revenue Expenditure Growth in Expenditure Pay Commission Revision
108
Head
Assumptions
years Assumption for assessment of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishads sustainability Income Items Growth in revenue income Actual average growth with a minimum 8% and maximum of 12% (based on last five years trend) Property Tax: Propose to introduce from FY 2012-13 Annual growth in Assessment 2 % per annum Increase in Assessments due to Survey/ 888 properties PT Reforms Initial Revision in 2012-13 150% of the existing Revision of Tax 50% every five years Collection Performance 85% or current average whichever is higher by 2015 Income Items- Water Supply Annual growth in Water Connection Regularisation of unaccounted connections Coverage Initial revision in water tariffs Next Revisions in water tariffs Initial revision new Connection fee Future revision new Connection fee Collection Performance Income Items- Sewerage Coverage Sewerage Charge Initial revision - new Connection fee Future revision - new Connection fee Collection Performance
2% per annum 7,075 connections 85% of Assessed properties by 2015 by 150% in FY 20011 by 50 % every five years by 150% in FY 20011 by 25% every five years 85% by 2015-16 100% of water connections by 2015-16 50% of water charges from year 2014-15 Rs. 1000 per connections by 10% every five years 85% by 2015
109
the total investment identified for year 2015, which is about Rs. 1.74 crore at constant price and Rs. 2.08 crore at current price.
No No No No No No No No No No No No No Yes No
Scenario 1: With reforms in Property Tax, Water Charges and Sewerage charges
This case assumes the reforms in property tax, Water and Sewerage have been implemented and accordingly the investment capacity has increased by Rs. 0.79 crore above the base investment capacity. These reforms will increase the total sustainable capacity to 9.6%.
110
The impact of the different scenario on the investment sustainability of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad is shown below in Exhibit 10-3. Exhibit 10-3 Impact of reforms and grants on investment capacity
From the above analysis, it is very clear that ULB alone even with the grant support under UIDSSMT scheme and reforms will not be able to implement 100% of the projects identified under the City Investment Plan (CIP). But they can substantially increase their sustainable capacity with these reforms. So, it is recommended that ULB along the support from UADD, GoMP should try to develop few projects at PPP model and additional grant support from GoMP. It is also recommended that on the same lines of the National Urban Information System (NUIS) programme for strengthening of information system at Nagar Parishad level, GoMP should also provide support to all the local bodies in Madhya Pradesh, which are not covered in the mentioned programme.
111
Performance Indicators
10.6. Conclusion
This chapter discussed the Investment sustainability of Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad. The discussion on assumptions for various financial projections was followed by detailing of investment capacity of ULB. The investment capacity was analyzed for four scenarios; Base case, PT improvements & Sector Reforms, UIDSSMT Grants & Reforms and Debt Funding & Reforms. The investment capacity analysis was followed by a discussion on the funding requirement of the city. The next chapter deals with the urban reforms and includes the discussion on the objective and current status of various reforms mandated under UIDSSMT.
112
Current Status
1. The State Government has implemented 1) constitution of municipalities, 2) composition of municipal councils, 3) reservation of seats for women, SCs & STs, 4) constitution of district planning committees and, 5) incorporation of schedule 12 into the state municipal act. The Process for constitution of MPCs in Million Plus cities is in progress.
113
2. In addition to incorporation of schedule 12 in the state municipal act, all the functions that were required to be transferred to ULB has been transferred by MP state government to ULBs. 3. The SFC has been constituted and recommendations have been submitted by the same.
Current Status
GoMP has issued instructions to ULBs to disclose as much information as possible through different means such as web sites, notice board, etc.
Current Status
Earlier Stamp duty rates in Madhya Pradesh stood at 7.5% of the Market value. The rates have been reduced to 5%, and are in effect from 1st April 2011. The computerization of whole system is also in the progress.
11.2.4. Repeal of Urban Land Ceiling and Regulation Act Desired Objective
UIDSSMT requires certain reforms to be undertaken by states/ cities in the Repeal of ULCRA with the objective of increasing the supply of land in the market, removing the inefficiencies and in the establishment of an efficient land market.
114
Current Status
The ULCRA has been repealed in the year 2000.
Current Status
The MP Parisar Kirayedari Vidheyak, 2010 was passed by the State Assembly in March, 2010. Thus, the reform for rent control in the state has been partially achieved. Bill has been sent to GoI for Presidential Assent.
Current Status
Completed Mohalla samiti are formed as the third tier. Provisions have been made in Municipal Acts and Rules have been framed for prescribing procedure.
115
Current Status
In this area, all reforms have been achieved with the transfer of powers related to the provisioning of water supply & sewerage, public transport and solid waste management. This has been supported by the association of ULB with city planning functions. This has been achieved by the active participation of ULB in the preparation of city development plans.
Current Status
1. At present, Double Entry Cash Base system of accounting is being followed in NPP. 2. Double Entry Accrual Base accounting has not been adopted in the NPP. 3. State has drafted its own accounting manual which has been revised as per the provision of NMAM. 4. State has not modified its current laws and regulations to be in compliance with the double entry accrual based accounting. 5. A resolution has been passed by Government expressing commitment to establish modern municipal accounting system.
116
Current Status
Till now, none of the services has been covered by e-governance applications. The applications which were proposed to bring under e-governance are registration of births & deaths, public grievance redressal, payment of property tax and bills of other utilities, municipal accounting, works management system, etc.
Appointment of State-level Technology Consultant as State Technology Advisor Finalization of implementation action plan Work in Progress Appointment of Software consultant(s) / agency for Yes deployment/training Implementation of e-governance against the following modules Property tax Accounting Water supply and other utilities Birth and death registration Citizens grievance monitoring Personnel management system 20% 25% 25% 50% 50% 50% 40% 30% 70% 80% 75% 75% 100% 30% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
30%
117
Current Status
At present, Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad levies user charges only for Water supply. Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad charges Rs 2650 and Rs 3750 as connection fee for domestic and commercial new connection respectively. The tariff structure is based on flat rate. The tariff for domestic connection is Rs 50 per month and commercial connection is Rs. 100 per month.
Formulation and adoption of a policy on user charges by State/ULB The State should set up a body for recommending a To be sorted out by State and ULB user charge structure Recovery of O&M cost 70% 80% 90% 100% Establishment of proper accounting system for each service so as to determine the O&M cost separately Water Supply Sewerage NA Solid Waste Management Achievement of targeted service standards for the services Water Supply (lpcd) 75 Sewerage NA Solid Waste Management 70% Defining user charge structure for the services Water Supply Sewerage Solid Waste Management 20% 25% 75 70% Yes Yes Yes 50% 50% 75 80% 80% 75% 100 85% 100% 100% 100% 135 90%
Current Status
The Nagar Parishad attempts to universalize the coverage of services such as water supply, sanitation, solid waste management and other infrastructure facilities but has not achieved any break City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 118
through due to the location disadvantage of these areas and inadequacy of funds available. Nagar Parishad has also been coordinating with other agencies for the universalization of services like health and education.
11.3.5. Internal earmarking for basic services for poor Desired Objective
UIDSSMT requires certain reforms to be undertaken by states/ cities in the provision of basic services to the Urban Poor, with an objective of providing security of tenure at affordable prices, improved housing, water supply and sanitation. In addition, delivery of other existing universal services of the government for education, health and social security is to be ensured.
Current Status
State has identified all Urban Below-Poverty-Line families using financial and non-financial criteria. While financial criterion uses monthly income as the parameter, non-financial criterion attempts to cover social factors such as housing, water & hygiene, education, literacy, employment, etc.
2 3 4 5
119
Current Status
Currently, Nasrullahganj Nagar Parishad levies property tax on residential, commercial properties and its collection during the year 2010-11 was Rs. 111087. The property tax is being calculated on the basis of Unit Area method.
120
S.No. 7 8
Reform Bye-laws for reuse of recycled water. Administrative reforms i.e. reduction in establishment by bringing out voluntary retirement schemes, non-filling up of posts falling vacant due to retirement etc., and achieving specified milestones in this regard. Structural reforms Encouraging Public Private Partnership
9 10
To be completed To be completed
11.5. Conclusion
This chapter provided the objectives and status of various reforms mandated under UIDSSMT. The reforms were discussed under the headings of Mandatory Reforms at State level, Mandatory Reforms at ULB level and Optional Reforms at State and ULB level.
121
In addition to the above, eminent citizens, press and members from other associations were also present. Total headcount of the workshop was approximately seventy. A brief summary of proceedings of Kick-off Stakeholder Consultation Workshop is as follows: 1. ICRA Management Consulting Services Limited (IMaCS) made an inaugural address in which background to the study was explained which was followed by an overview of the firm. IMaCS showcased its capability in doing this kind of study by demonstrating successful completion of similar projects in the past. 2. IMaCS explained the need for a long-term plan for Nasrullahganj and role of IMaCS, with support from Stakeholders, in preparing the City Development Plan. IMaCS team also sensitised the stakeholders to start formulating a vision for the town. City Development plan for Nasrullahganj
3. Adhayksch and CMO, Nasrullahganj stressed on the need of primary focus on improving overall quality of life of the citizens in addition to the physical and social infrastructure of the town. The presentation by IMaCS familiarized the stakeholders with the purpose, process, and expected outcomes of the CDP study. Members were then requested for their views and suggestions in formulating the City Development Plan with key stress on following areas: 1. Vision for the town in the next 25 years; 2. Projects to be undertaken and 3. Ward specific issues that need immediate attention . A few sector wise suggestions that came out of the discussion are as under Water Supply: Water being an essential and a vital need, needs a proper conservation and a harvesting plan to provide the town with adequate water supply when required. During the time span when water sources get fully exhausted, the city needs are fulfilled by various sources like tankers etc. Drainage: Existing Drainage system needs a revamping as it is totally dilapidated. Unhygienic environment is mainly caused by open drains and sewerage getting accumulated at various junctions in front of the households, which in turn has caused a milieu for the residents and is a potential health hazard. Sewerage & Sanitation: The city in general is not equipped with a Sewerage system. A sewerage system should be developed at the earliest. Solid Waste Management: Major concern is disposal of solid waste. New disposal sites need to be identified and existing disposal sites should be properly maintained according to recognized norms in practice. Best practices from other places can be used to improve the efficiency, effectiveness and collection of solid waste collection. Land Utilization / Development: Due importance should be paid to beautification and the provision of Green spaces in any kind of city infrastructure.
123
124
Presentation started off with a brief introduction of the study i.e. Preparation of City Development Plan for Nasrullahganj, so as to bring all the stakeholders on the same platform. Based on the information collected by various sources, the representative from IMaCS presented city profile which included demographic and socio-economic profile of the town with spatial component. Demographic profile dealt with population growth trend and its probable reasons, it also showed the population projections and the methods used for these projections. The stakeholders agreed on this projected population. Socio-economic profile comprised of key socio-economic parameters, major economic base and major potentials and main issues. During this, stakeholders stated that few steps are needed to increase employment opportunities and improve quality of life in the town to reduce the flow of people moving out of the town. City profiling was followed by the findings of Sector Analysis which included Water Supply, Sewerage and Sanitation, Storm Water Drainage, Solid Waste Management, Transportation, Health, Education and other socio-cultural facilities for short, medium and long term, i.e. 5 years, 10 years and 25 years respectively. Analysis comprised of existing status of service level indicators, Demand-Supply Gaps for short , medium term and long term and key observations and major issues. City Development plan for Nasrullahganj 125
After covering these sections, IMaCS team turned the focus on formulation of a vision for Nasrullahganj. This part of the presentation included definition of vision, major concerns that need to be addressed while developing a vision and important aspects that define Nasrullahganj. It was then followed by few sample Vision Statements from IMaCS team. Formulation of City vision and Sectoral goals were supplemented by a Questionnaire survey. questionnaire with the aim of obtaining stakeholders priorities for the city. The Questionnaire survey was distributed in Hindi Second Workshop language. Questionnaire survey included stakeholders view of problems in the various sectors, evaluation of citys growth and infrastructure and ranking of major issues and problems of the town, as perceived by stakeholders. Further, the stakeholders discussed the Sectoral strategies and vision in detail and share their concerns and apprehensions on how should the city move forward towards a developmental path. Amongst the major concerns is-insufficient water supply to the entire town, and hence there is a dire need for augmentation of the system for which few potential sources were suggested by the stakeholders. Further, they highlighted the need of employment opportunities in the region , the lack of which leads to the youths moving out to other cities. One of the important suggestions which came up during consultations was - Since Nasrullahganj has a strong agricultural base and has a regional crop market (Mandi), there is a scope for a few small scale agro based industries e.g. Soya bean plants and Daal mills which can be thought upon to be established in the town. Stakeholders also had concerns regarding the transportation and traffic aspects in the town. During the discussion, it also came up that since a substantial percentage of population resides in slums in the town and there should be a focused strategy to improve the quality of life of all the slum dwellers by providing basic infrastructure to all of them. The stakeholders also had concerns on non-availability of parks, playgrounds, community halls and not properly maintained ponds and it was suggested by them that pond needs to be conserved with pond front development and thus creating a parks and other recreational infrastructure near them. The Stakeholders also appreciated IMaCS strategies and sector goals in various infrastructure sectors and helped prioritizing the needs and the actions required for the development of the town.
126
127
128
129
130
ANNEXURE 2: QUESTIONNAIRE
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
2006 -07
2007 -08
2009 -10
2010 -11
2012 -13
2013 -14
2015 -16
2016 -17
2017 -18
2018 -19
2019 -20
2020 -21
2021 -22
5 686 -
94 63 192 189
(681 ) -
31 2 2
68 27 29
62 1 30
69 338 368
57% 0
5.47 68%
1.98 74%
1.10 79%
1.50 85%
2.22 86%
2.40 86%
2.78 87%
3.20 87%
3.68 88%
Property Tax Integrated tax Other Taxes Rental Income from Municipal Properties Water Charges Sewerage Charges
0 0 0 0 5
3 3 2 3 0
2 2 3 3 5
3 3 5 3 6
2 3 6 4 6
3 2 4 4 6
7 2 4 4 17 0
9 3 4 4 22 0
10 3 5 4 25 3
11 3 6 5 28 6
11 3 6 5 32 11
15 4 7 6 47 17
16 4 8 6 50 19
17 4 9 7 52 20
17 5 10 7 55 21
18 5 11 8 57 21
139
2006 -07
2007 -08
2009 -10
2010 -11
0 0 5 0 0 0 0 0
1 5 17 60 0 11 0 71
2 31 48 58 0 12 0 70
1 32 53 78 0 4 0 82
2 30 53 109 0 4 0 114
2012 -13
2013 -14
2015 -16
2016 -17
2017 -18
2018 -19
2019 -20
2020 -21
2021 -22
2 31 67 76 0 7 0 84
2 34 78 86 0 8 0 94
2 38 91 96 0 9 0 104
II
II I
0 0 0 0 0 5
6 0 0 0 6 94
13 0 13 0 26 144
7 0 13 0 20 155
50 0 28 0 78 244
10 0 12 0 22 144
11 0 14 0 24 175
12 0 15 0 27 199
14 0 17 0 31 226
15 0 19 0 34 254
17 0 21 0 38 288
19 0 24 0 43 341
21 0 27 0 48 377
24 0 30 0 54 415
27 0 34 0 60 457
30 0 38 0 68 503
0 0
30 1
46 2
57 2
81 2
62 2
61 2
68 2
74 2
82 2
90 2
99 2
109 2
120 2
132 2
145 2
0 0 0
25 0 1
25 0 0
29 0 0
39 0 0
26 0 0 0
29 11 0 0
32 32 0 0
35 62 0 0
38 85 0 0
42 89 0 0
46 93 0 0
51 98 0 0
56 103 0 0
62 108 0 0
68 114 0 0
Existing Loans
140
2006 -07
2007 -08
2009 -10
2010 -11
2012 -13
2013 -14
2015 -16
2016 -17
2017 -18
2018 -19
2019 -20
2020 -21
2021 -22
3 16 121
9 17 159
17 19 209
25 21 252
28 23 274
34 25 300
37 28 325
37 30 349
37 33 374
37 37 402
0 0
5 63
2 75
4 92
54 175
0 0 0
10 1 0
3 2 0
3 1 0
4 1 0
0 0 0
0 38
0 73
0 101
0 69
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 Special Projects Basic services UIDSSMT IHSDP Flood relief & NRCP T.F.C Other Grants New Grants Sub Total Grants 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 72 0 0 0 0 11 83 0 93 0 86 0 0 6 11 0 102 0 106 90 0 0 0 0 11 80 181 10 194 302 9 21 2 0 0 42 375 0 380 0 36 0 0 1 5 29 71 2 73 219 0 0
4 0 0
10 0 0
12 0 0
15 0 0
9 0 0
4 0 0
4 0 0
4 0 0
4 0 0
0 5 0 175 180
0 6 0 340 345
0 6 0 471 477
0 6 0 324 330
0 7 0 0 7
0 8 0 0 8
0 8 0 0 8
0 9 0 0 9
0 9 0 0 9
0 10 0 0 10
423
589
411
22
17
12
13
14
15
126
156
262
106
130
213
413
572
393
17
12
13
14
15
141
ANNEXURE 4: MAPS
Map 1 - Location map with respect to country/ state/ district Map 2 - District map showing Railway and road network Map 3 - Base Map of the town Map 4A) - Ward Map 4B) - Population Density Map 5 - Existing Land-use map Map 6 - Existing Road network map Map 7 - Drainage system map Map 8A - Water supply Map 8B - Solid Waste Map 9A - Solid waste (garbage dumping areas, existing location of landfill site) Map 9B - Physical Infrastructure Map 10 - Social infrastructure Map 11 - Slum location map Map 12 - Proposed land-use map (Broad overview) Map 13 - Proposed Road network map Map 14 - Proposed Drainage system map Map 15 - Proposed Sewerage system map Map 16 - Proposed Water supply map Map 17 - Proposed Solid waste management
142
143