Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Q1
a.
Market price per share of the company at the end of the year (i.e P1)
i.
When dividend not paid
ii.
b.
P0
150
P1
P1
=
=
150( 1.12) - 0
168
150
P1
P1
=
=
150( 1.12) - 8
160
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
=
ii.
1,19,047.619047 shares
=
=
=
c.
1,75,000 shares
=
=
=
ii.
Rs 1500 lakh
=
=
=
Rs 1500 lakh
Thus market value of the Firm is same (Rs 1500 lakh) whether dividend is paid or not
Q2
a.
Market price per share of the company at the end of the year (i.e P1)
I
When dividend not paid
ii
b.
P0
125
P1
P1
=
=
125( 1.08) - 0
135
125
P1
P1
=
=
125( 1.08) - 6
129
=
=
=
ii.
2962.962962 shares
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
=
=
c.
4961.240310 shares
=
=
=
ii.
Rs 50 lakh
=
=
=
Rs 50 lakh
Thus market value of the Firm is same (Rs 50 lakh) whether dividend is paid or not
Q3
a.
ii.
b.
15
P1
P1
=
=
15
P1
P1
=
=
15( 1.14) - 0
17.10
ii.
If dividend paid
Dividend Received
Dividend after ordinary tax
=
=
=
Rs 1.35
1.35 ( 1 0.3 )
0.945
Capital gains
=
=
15.75 15
0.75
=
=
0.75( 1 0.26)
0.555
=
=
0.945 + 0.555
1.5
Investment
Rs 15
Rate of Return
x 100
10%
Capital gains
=
=
17.10 15
2.1
=
=
2.1( 1 0.26)
1.554
Investment
Rs 15
Rate of Return
If dividend paid
x 100
10.36%
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q4
If r = 10% ( i.e r = ke )
If r = 8% ( i.e r < ke )
P0 =
P0 =
P0 =
= Rs 180
= Rs 100
= Rs 84
P0 =
P0 =
P0 =
= Rs 160
= Rs 100
= Rs 88
P0 =
P0 =
P0 =
= Rs 120
= Rs 100
= Rs 96
P0 =
P0 =
P0 =
= Rs 100
= Rs 100
= Rs 100
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q5
P0
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
= Rs 102
According to Walter model, if r > KE , optimum DP ratio is 0% i.e Retention ratio should be 100%.
In given question DP is 30%, so it is not optimum ratio
Q6
Earnings of company
No. of shares
EPS
DP ratio
Dividend per share
i.
=
=
=
=
=
Rs 10,00,000
2,00,000
Rs 5
60%
Rs 3 per share
=
=
ii.
Rs 34.26
According to Walter model, if r > KE , optimum DP ratio is 0% i.e Retention ratio should
be 100%. If DP ratio is 0% then MP will be
P0
=
=
Rs 52.083
Q7
Statement of EPS
Earnings
Less Preference dividend
12 % of 100 lakhs
Earnings for equity share holders
No. of shares
EPS
r
KE
PE
KE
30,00,000
12,00,000
18,00,000
3,00,000
Rs 6 per share
20%
x 100
14.285714%
P0
42
42 x 0.14285714
DP ratio
d +
d + 8.4 - d
6 8.4 =
d(1 -
- 2.4
- d ( 0.40)
=
=
=
6
x 100
100 %
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q8
Earnings
No. of shares
EPS
Rs 2,00,000
20,000
Rs 10 per share
Total dividend
Dividend per share
Rs 1,50,000
Rs 7.5
KE
=
=
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
x 100
=
=
0.08 or 8%
x 100
10%
=
=
Rs 132.81
According to Walter model if r > KE , then optimal dividend policy would be to pay Zero dividend.
Thus DP ratio 75% is not an optimum dividend policy. If no dividend is paid MP will be
P0
=
=
Rs 156.25
So, MP can be increased by adopting a Zero dividend policy
ii.
Companys Dividend policy will have no effect on the market value of share if r = K E ,
i.e KE = 10%, And since PE =
So, PE at which dividend policy has no effect on market value of firm is
iii.
such a situation KE > r and Market price as per Walter model would be
P0
=
=
= 10 times
Rs 76
) and in
Q9
Walter model
P0
=
=
Gordon Model
P0
Rs 55
=
=
=
Q10
Rs 60
=
=
=
=
Rs 137.80
15%
15% x 137.80
Rs 20.67
DP Ratio
=
=
1 - 0.6
0.4 or 40%
P0
=
=
=
Rs 91.87
=
=
Rs 103.35
=
=
=
Rs 91.89
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q11
a.
b.
MP of share
EPS
DP ratio
b
r
=
=
=
=
=
P0
40
Rs 40
Rs 12 per share
45%
1 0.45 =
0.55
14%
+ 0.077
0.212 or 21.2%
=
=
=
=
Value of share
P0
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
10 Lakh x 10 x 0.20
Rs 20 lakh
Rs 20 per share
=
=
=
Q12
Rs 156.923
b. If Adjustment is 20%
Current year dividend
Q13
=
=
Q14
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
= ( 1 0.5) 5 + 10 x 0.7 x 0.5
=
Rs 6
Q15
a.
According to residual approach, current years profits or earnings can be used for
financing capital expenditure and after financing capital expenditure, balance is
distributed as dividend
Current year profit
x 20
=
Rs 600,00,000
So, capital expenditure of Rs 600,00,000 can be incurred without raising additional equity
b. i.
Equity Funds
ESC
Reserves
300,00,000
1500,00,000
1800,00,000
Debt
12% debt
15% debt
Debt equity ratio
Capital expenditure
Raised from equity
1000,00,000
200,00,000
1200,00,000
=
12 : 18
=
2:3
=
550 lakh
reserves
550 lakh x
=
=
Rs 330 lakh
Rs 220 lakh
=
=
Dividend distribution
ii.
c.
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
2: 3
ii.
Dividend distribution
=
=
= Rs 480 lakh
600 lakh 480 lakh
120 lakh
= Rs 4 per share
Q16
i.
Statement of Dividend per share and external financing under residual approach
Particulars
40
10
45
50
50
20
35
50
30
30
3.75
-
3.75
-
15
ii
Statement of Dividend per share and external financing if Debt equity ratio
of 7:3 is to be maintained
Particulars
40
10
45
50
50
20
35
50
=3
37
50 x
= 15
30
= 4.625
10 3 = 7
20 x
=6
44
50 x
= 15
20
= 3.75
= 5.5
50 15 = 35
20 6 = 14
= 2.5
50 15 = 35
iii.
40
10
45
50
50
20
35
50
16
18
20
14
=2
24
-
= 2.25
27
23
= 5.5
30
-
= 2.5
21
29
Particulars
Profit after tax
Capital expenditure
1
40
10
2
45
50
3
50
20
4
35
50
12
12
12
12
Total dividend if
DP ratio is 30%
12
13.5
15
10.5
Dividend payable
Dividend per share
12
1.5
13.5
1.6875
15
1.875
12
1.5
28
31.5
35
23
External financing
18.5
27
v.
II
III
IV
3.75
60 cr
20 cr
16.375
131 cr
91 cr
8.5
68 cr
52 cr
6.5625
52.5 cr
45.5 cr
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q17
B
600
q
600 q
60 0.10q
(600 q) (60 q)
= Rs 540 0.90q
Dividend receivable
Less tax on dividend 15%
Rs 40
Rs 6
40 6 = Rs 34
Rs 576 0.90p
540 0.90q + 34
Return on investment
16%
16%
Current MP
0.16 =
0.16 =
p
Q18
= 543.40
p = 541.51
( 60 x 2crore)
x 12,000
Rs 200
Rs 60
2 crore
12000 lakh
1655.17 lakh
Rs 10344.83 Lakh
Rs 10344.83 lakh
9%
2.25%
6.75%
10344.83 x (1.0675)
Rs 12,584.49 lakh
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
rs 200
Rs 60
2 crore
Rs 12000 lakh
Rs 12000 lakh
11%
3.74%
7.265
14,808 lakh
2042.48 lakh
12,765.52 lakh
It is better for company to retain the dividend payout and invest the same in Bank and
distribute after 3 years, as it yields higher return to investors
Q19
d0
g
KE
=
=
=
Q20
Rs 2
5%
10( 1 0.3) = 7%
P0
= Rs 42
= rs 94.50
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
=
=
=
8%
36.75%
8(1-0.3675)
5.06%
=
=
1000(1.0506)
Rs 1279.93
Dividend payable
Rs 1279.93
Rs 142.21
Rs 1137.72
12.5%
1279.93 x
Rs 1000
1000 x
Rs111.11
Rs 888.89
Rs 888.89
Rate of Interest
Income tax rate for shareholders
Effective ROI
8%
30
8 ( 1 0.3)
5.6%
888.89(1.056)
Rs 1167.26
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Company should distribute dividend today and shareholder should invest in bank, as it will
increase yield of shareholders
Q21
i.
ii.
x 100
10.50%
iii.
x 100
Rs 132.25
32.25
Rs 9.675
Rs 22.575
22.575 5 for 2 years i.e 11.2875% p.a
x 100
13.50%
Statement of Post tax return on share of B (if tax on capital gains 15%)
Amount invested
Rs 100
Appreciation in value of share
15% p.a ( assumed compounded)
MP of share after 2 years
100(1.15)
Capital gain
Tax on capital gain
15% x 32.25
Capital gain after tax
Return after tax
Q22
x 100
=
=
Rs 144.44
=
=
Q24
Rs 132.25
32.25
Rs 4.8375
Rs 27.4125
Current market price of share is present value of all future dividends. Co is paying Rs 13 per
share indefinitely
Current market price
Q23
Rs 30
=
=
x 0.149
Rs 44.70
=
Rs 50 per share
Thus if MDs dividend policy is adopted Value of share is reduced by Rs 5.30 per share
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
Q25
a.
=
=
i.
Rs 30
Rs 32.786
P0
=
=
According to PE model
PE
=
=
Q26
a.
9.524 times
=
=
=
PE x EPS
9.524 x 2.25
Rs 21.429
d5
d1 ( 1 + g)
14.03
10.7 ( 1 + g )
( 1 + g) =
g
b.
=
=
1.0700 1
0.07 or 7%
+ g
=
=
+ 0.07
19%
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
c.
+ g
+ 0.07
=
Q27
d0
g
Ke
=
=
=
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
19.38 %
Rs 2
5%
15.5%
a. MP If g is 5%
P0
=
=
Rs 20
Rs 28.8
Rs 16.48
b. MP if g is 8%
P0
=
=
c.
MP if g is 3%
P0
=
=
Q28
Growth rate
1 2 year
3 4 year
th
From 5 year
d0
=
=
=
12%
10%
8%
Rs 1.50
r = 16%
Current Market price or intrinsic value of share is Present value of all future dividends
Current market price
= Present value of d1 to d4
=
=
=
+ Present value of P4
x 0.552
st
Year
nd
rd
th
th
, 3 , 4 , 5 year
P0
22.36
P1
P1
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
24.257
24.257 =
Year 3
P2
P2
26.25812
Year 4
P3
P3
28.3914
Year 5
Q29
d0
g
r
=
=
=
26.25812
28.3914
=
P4
P4
30.66
P5
P0
30.66
33.10
3.50
6%
15%
Rs 41.222
=
50
7.5 - 50g
=
53.5 g =
g
3.5 + 3.5g
4
=
0.0748 or 7.48%
Q30
Growth rate
1 2 years
3 5 years
67
Above 7
10%
12%
12.50%
11%
d0
r
=
=
Rs 5
17.5%
Dividend / outflow
5.50
6.05
6.776
7.589
8.5
9.5625
10.758
Q31
earnings
Shares
KE
i.
= 183.714
factor
0.851
0.724
0.616
0.525
0.446
0.380
0.323
0.323
59.340
87.459
2.4 lacs
1 lac
12%
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
=
or
CMP
= 8.333 times
=
= Rs 20
ii.
PE
8.333
Price
Rs 20
=
=
iii.
8.333 x 2.4
Rs 32.40
Dividend
factor
Present value
0.893
0.797
2.358
2.314
= 37.752 0.797
Market price
30.088
34.76
Q32
E0
DPS
0.6
0.72
0.864
1.0368
1.858
2.081
2.331
2.6104
3.459
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
b.
6.039 + 20.640
Rs 26.68
=
0.6 x 0.909 + 0.72 x 0.826 +
0.864 x 0.753 + 1.0368 x 0.683 + 1.858
x 0.620 + 2.081 x 0.564 + 2.331 x 0.513
2.6104 x 0.467 + 58.803 x 0.467
=
Rs 34.70
14
12.344%
x4
26.68
14%------------26.68
? ------------- 30
10%------------34.70
For diff of IRR of 4%, change in price is
8.02, for diff in rate of 3.32 Change in
price is 14 -
x4
Q33
PE ratio = 7.5
Retained earnings
Rs 3 (37.5%)
Total earnings
i.
= Rs 8 per share
MP
=
=
=
KE
PE x EPS
7.5 x 8
Rs 60
ii.
P0
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
+ g
=
=
Div per sh = 8 3 = 5
+ 0.12
21.33%
=
=
=
iii.
P0
Rs 67.80
=
=
=
Q34
Rs 191.67
Statement of profit after Tax
Operating Profit
Less Interest on secured loan
Interest on unsecured loan
Profit before tax
Tax
Profit after tax
Number of equity shares
2,50,000
EPS
PE ratio (given)
Value of share
Q35
EPS0
DPS0
Current PE
i.
25,00,000
3,75,000
1,25,000
20,00,000
10,00,000
10,00,000
=
=
=
Current MP
P0
12.5
Rs 50
4 x 12.5
Rs 5
Rs 2
7 times
Growth rate
Past 4 years
Future
= 14%
=
=
Estimated PE ratio
( 25 lac x 0.15)
(10,00,000 x 0.125)
= Rs 17
=
3.4 times
4%
2%
ii.
Current PE ratio
Current EPS
Actual price in the market
P0
35
35 (0.14 - g)
4.9 - 35g
37 g
g
Q36
d1
g
RF
r
=
=
=
=
=
=
=
7 times
5
7x5 =
Rs 35
2 ( 1 + g)
2 + 2g
2.9
0.0784 or 7.84%
Rs 2 per share
7%
9%
13%
1.5 , likely to increase to 1.75
KE
=
=
=
P0
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
R F + ( R M - R F)
9 + 1.5 (13 9)
15%
Rs 26.75
If increased to 1.75
KE
=
=
=
P0
R F + ( R M - R F)
9 + 1.75 (13 9)
16%
=
Q37
RF
=
RM - RF =
10%
5%
1.6
Growth rate
Rs 23.778
d (2002) = d7
d (1996) = d1
=
=
Rs3
Rs 2.115
d7
3
=
=
d1 ( 1 + g )
6
2.115 ( 1 + g)
- 1
0.06 or 6%
Cost of Equity
P0
=
=
=
R F + ( R M - R F)
10 + 1.6 (5 )
18%
PRAVINN
MAHAJAN
CA CLASESS
=
Q38
i.
ii.
d1
DP ratio
=
=
=
EPS
Rs 7
(1 0.3)
0.7
= Rs 10
g = b.r
0.06 = 0.3 x r
r
iii.
Rs 26.5
= 0.2 or 20%
Value of share
(along with growth
Opportunities)
=
175
Vg
Q39
KE
P0
Value of growth opportunities
Value of share without growth
Value of share
(along with growth
Opportunities)
=
=
=
100 + Vg
175 - 100
Rs 75
=
=
=
=
15%
Rs 80 ( after growth)
Rs 20
Rs 80 Rs 20 =
60
EPS
=
=
60 x 0.15
Rs 9
Growth
opportunities
Vg
Growth
opportunities
Vg
Vg
Rs 60
=
80
20
0.1125