162 scra 753 Francia vs IAC 8 scra 443 Domingo vs Garlitos 294 scra 687 Philex Mining vs CIR

151 scra 208 Tio vs Videogram 25 scra 935 NAPOCOR vs Arca 149 scra 395 CIR vs BOAC 524 scra 731 69 scra 460 Pepsi-Cola vs Municipality of Tanawan 438 scra 290 CIR vs Toda 155650; July 20, 2006 Manila International Airport 163072 Manila International Airport vs City of Pasay 120082; September 11, 1996 68252; May 26, 1995 CIR vs Tokyo Shipping 99886; March 31, 1993 Osmena vs Orbos

164 scra 320 PAL vs Edu 28508-9; July 7, 1989 ESSO vs CIR 110 Phil 331 Pascual vs Secretary of Public Works 103379; November 23, 1993 San Carlos Mining vs CIR 96541; August 24, 1993 Joya vs PCGG 101 Phil 386 American Bible vs City of Manila 60126; September 25, 1985 Cepalco vs CIR 25 scra 938 City of Baguio vs de Leon American Embassy 51 scra 352 Bishop of Nueva vs Provincial Board 235 scra 630 Tolentino vs Secretary of Finance 14 Phil 292 Lladoc vs CIR 78780; July 23, 1987 Nitafan vs. CIR 172087; March 15, 2011 PAGCOR vs BIR 213 scra 83 CONWI vs CTA 199 scra 824 CIR vs Javier

25043; April 26, 1968 Roxas vs CIA 17 scra 703 Limpan vs CIR 11952; August 18, 1997 CIR vs Santos 172231; February 12, 2007 CIR vs Isabela 293 scra 77 Davao Gulf vs CIR 56 scra 147 El Oriente vs Posadas 273 scra 47 Marcos II vs CA 190 scra 851 Zialcita 25 scra 827 Gome vs Palomar 181 scra 214 Mitsubishi 81311; June 30, 1998 Kapatiran vs Tan 191 scra 214 Chavez vs Appellate Court 53961; June 30, 1987 NDC vs CIR 1 scra 649 Henderson vs Collector 74 scra 306 Bagatsing vs Ramirez 316 scra 480 Pilipinas Synthetic Fiber

54 O.G. 6274 108576; January 20 CIR vs CTA 614 scra 605 157 scra 648 CIR vs Air India 108607; January 20, 2007 202 scra 450 CIR vs JAL 102 scra 246 38 scra 414 Madrigal vs Rafferty 172231; February 12, 2007 504 scra 19 158 scra 9 CIR vs Algue 21 scra 105 CIR vs Pineda 89 scra 199 Vera vs Fernandez 22356; July 21, 1967 Republic vs Patanao 13 scra 775 Phil Guaranty vs CIR 302 scra 250 PBCom vs CIR 298 scra 83 YMCA vs CIR 95 Phil 46 Punzalan vs Municipal Board of Manila 98 Phil 148 Lut vs CIR 25 scra 827 Gomez vs Palomar 456 scra 414 CIR vs Central Luzon Drug Co. 109 scra 511 196 scra 322 Reyes vs Almanzar 102 Phil 140 2 Phil 509 45 scra 74 166 scra 560 139 scra 446