Gyr beter
2.
8 July, 1992
The Honorable David N. Dinkins
Mayor of the City of New York
Dear Mr, Mayor,
Iam an MD/PAD student at the Columbia University College of Physicians &
Surgeons as well as a resident of Washington Heights. I am of course, very
concerned about recent events here in my neighborhood but like to view things
both in their global as well as positive context.
Last year, I wrote and published a philosophical guide to New York City
entitled: Prospectus Practico-Philosophicus. Tam sending you a copy of the
conclusion to that book which summarizes one view of New York and its greater
meaning and importance in the world. In light of the events in Washington
Heights, and indeed throughout the world, I thought you might find my
comments useful.
With admiration for your courage, strength and calmness, I wish you the best in
your efforts to resolve this crisis.
Yours sincerely,
Ogan Gurel
50 Haven Avenue, #210
‘New York, NY 10032
(212) 694-5690Prospects Praches- Phi loxaphicus
by Ogan Guret
PROSPECTIVE xr
Wittgenstein concluded his Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus with
single proposition which reads:
What we cannot speak about we must pass over
in silence.
ane statement sunmarizes the argument that ethical and aesthetic
Teeters Of the metaphysical sort are not appropriate elements of a
jogical philosophy. However, Wittgenstein once commented that the
dooryimPOrtant part of his Tractatus was the pare tree was
vwritten -- what he termed the ethical part.
Likewise, for this Prospectus about New York, it would seem proper
Howagave Unsaid any Further discussion of the worta in general.
However, New York's most important facet is thee it's a city of
fhe world. No other major metropolis, neither London, Paris,
Rome, Woscow, nor Tokyo compares to New York with its dynamic and
Cosmopolitan diversity. This fact is not meant to amuse
fourists...it is an ethical fact. And because of this, those who
are truly immersed in the New York ethic are humanists in their
fespect for the individual, are tolerant of diversity, and delight
in original thought. Living in New York City is, in the deepest
sense of the word, civilized,
Now there may be examples in your New York experience where you'll
doubt that. At times, you'll come acrese despairing instances of
racism, hatred, prejudice, and violence. But consider that these
emotions and responses have plagued human evolution since its most
primitive beginnings. Fortunately and unfortunately, New York is
poised on the edge of that evolution. People here are constantly,
coleuscut’ say relentlessly, being confronted with differing
qutures and ideals. “some of the responses are regressive in
morta inethezs are progressive. Thus, of all che places in the
norte where Progress in these challenging human Problems may be
achieved, New York, tronically stands best situated,
seth ey retake a visit to the United Nations on First Avenue and
doth street. Access: Take the 1 train te 42nd, transfer to the
63-7715) AZ Bus to 1st avenue and then walk up tonshe UN. Tel.
263]7713._ AS you tour through this stream ue idealism you might
feel a curious sense of deja vu That may be because the
fgueiments underlying international cooperarion are similar to the
ideals of progress, reason and compassion motivating many of us.
What we cannot do now, we must dream into action.