Executing SQL over Encrypted Data in the

Database-Service-Provider Model
Hakan Hacgum
us




Bala Iyer

Chen Li

Sharad Mehrotra

Department of Information and Computer Science, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697, USA
hakanh@acm.org,  chenli,sharad  @ics.uci.edu


IBM Silicon Valley Lab., San Jose, CA 95141, USA, balaiyer@us.ibm.com

$m"$U% lD\= 4 > ("$

ABSTRACT


    !"$#% &' ()+*%$,"$-$/.0& 1.) 23

45 026$.789"$&! 4 $.;:<= 4 > ("$? (@ ?="$% AB89%0 4 "

%$,"$"$ =689 5 $ &DC?E 5 = 45 0F,G (890' 4

8989"$  00IH

%  J07= 4 <! ("$7="$% F 0 5 K"$L=M (MN="$ =.2O20="$ 

8P ( 0
="$% O'&,"/ 0BQ$("/ &R=,"$D O? $ Q$"SD"$$$ 
=,"$D C:<T U/ J =7 1 'E%"$% A'89%0"$U%  5 =
 "$V2!"
$W"$2 U$O%Q$"$O89%D 4 HLO% ()X"$="$ 3
 U/

4 "$8Y (LHD'."$? 

$.9!"$0-OZ (;0&R [$.H\.) 23S =;$]$.P*%$,"$2C^*N

L="$% 5 7=3"/ (0/.) 00&O 9 89V("=/ L_ = 5 
JV &W (/
D"$  (HLCK*Z ! P$. Z%$,GD7$.) UZ!
=V I`) 00IHS %"$=Z$.
= 5 W 4  U/ ;"$  HLC
a!."$] U"$b!R8P  c"$  (Hd = 5 Cfe1 I"$Q2O_$.bU'"9 4
$.g (/ h[$RJVb = 5 "$c$. (;$.g (/ hQ$"$2cd$.
=,"$D ,MD"$UD D"P= I$^ PD"$$$f &  Qg U/ R$. 4 $

4 "$8

5 $= ,"$CiE%)O> (/ R9$jJV^D"$$$k3

4 "$8

$.="$% 6"$U% lD"$O 4 $."$U% "$!$.89=03'2 ((?JV

=" 5 Q$2Cc*d$. X) (V"2O_!

4 L 5 9m$.b=m/.) (00&C

E%V I`) 00IHLOK!PGD0"$X$,. n 5 $^GD 5 $SEo+pqn 5 "$ 

U3,"B"=HD$2b U/ DC?r

5 "
Q="/ U$&Hg ?$9D"$L=+ (
8

5 /.g 4

$.Wn 5 "=Hb ?V== J0[ (?$.6="$% 6"$U% "$s= $O)' I$. 5 
. 2D &P$PD"=HD'$.; (/ DC?T+"=HD$ ^ ()g$.6"$8P  )D"
4 $.'n 5 ,"=H[D"$L== &6 U"$'V" 4 ("$892X (@$.>0 %_= I$C_a!.
 V"bGD0("$g (t 0&J"/ ( 

4 "/ (89!("$#k$u=0 S$.hn 5 "=H

$g89  89 v[$.;89 5 / ($ u (6$.X0 L[= I$CP? 5 0$6 4

,GV,"$ 89%$> 0  U$ &X 5 "
"$3 (,.] ("$6 0=9D"$=L$2C

5 $ &jU3"b$.R*<L$"$2O+ ()t.) (g02

$^ S~2 U$&("=Hj 4

J 5 = ==62 002:< 0 2 ($ d=,"$D 

"$U% "$=A("!BEz@C@+EDz__"$U% !Z"$0D' ? 5 Q$89"$@$.

"$ % 0&?$

5 =
= 4 > ("$B("7$.
*L$"$2C1+EDz_Z ("$?Q/ (-2

JLHPGDV"=$! P$.+ U"=' 4  5 =$ &W$&$."'= 4 <> U"$=0 5 $ O
5 = &j R U"$ ,<Hd 4

= 4 <! ("$^"$% 5 $O

4 ("

4 (89 0  ("PJ 5 = =

="$% X 5 ,.c (X) H%"$00O_L$"$"$ =P"$= 5 "$g0  &O7 ()
 5 Q$89"=M"$0 ($ =. u8P U"$#3$ &DC9BEz@-"$. I"[=,"$D 
U3"|$.@*<L$"$|$?=8P 00L ()+0 ("$&Z!("$0D' 7"$&3 ( v2 U$ C
ED >`GD2[Q$7 ("$
89"=$ v;U3"7 +0 ("$&? 5 8[JV"@ 4-5 ="$O
$.,"$9 $.9V$L$  0_$g"$2 5 X$.;="$% SQW3u 4 $,"
V== J0Hb "$ =2g$0898

5  2 U$ >U3"$.2 -C

*7 7V== J0

$D"$(% 'Q$("/ &B ;`)0? => _="$% C
a!.B) ( 5 "/ 0|n 5 Q$ S >$.

4 2 = J 0 I<Hb 4 D"$UD D &[$.B,GD

 0 5 M +0 HL"K W U/ ?8P () &89L2C|e"$8$.@J 5 = =1V,"=M
=V$ 3OD (/ (J) (=+ ! 6=,"$D 
.,"$ $Z 00V$.? D (L/ &! 4
$.6BEzm89%0O) 2b3]89("$O)& 3g$. (
X0 ("$&W 5 8XM
JV"S 4

("$&3  v2 ($ g. U]$. I"bU'fTx>y^EDCia!.h89%0

002'6"$&3 ( v2 U$ 6$b0"/ &9.) ("/%> U"$X R= 4 > ("$9=(M
0 5 $ P"$U% lD2kJLHc$.g="$% ^"$U% lD"$O>' I$. 5 S.) 2% &
$]D30\$.8R$. I"62'|CSz1"$. 89"$X 89V"=/ (L$0HLO
4 ("P"$&  v2 U$ P$R=.) ("$b$.g,GV,"=$ =

IP"$U% 9 h> H

4

 (/ (J) (=^"$ 4 ==  0O'$."$JLHc 5 =$ &\$.gV0^Q
4 8P ) (& &; ;890GP  4 "$8P ($ ]  4 "/ (Q=" 5  5 "$OD'. ,.b 

89V"=/ (%PJV($.

4 "S ) 5 Q="$  0

)k 2 89 ]("$&3 ( v2 ($ 

IU2 C
e"$8{$.$,.0& 2 (07 (&0OV$.689%0|V=
8P LHb= &(M
 I`2 L_,. 00&

4 "$89Q! 4 '. ,.9 @$.> = 5 ? 4_N

)/

4 ("] (00B89 5 $,"$P$

3 )d D/ C9*<h$.; U/ J) (=MN="$% MN"$U% "689%D0O

5 =,"] (/ j"$= gq$.h"$89 =P 4 $.\ (/ (J) =,M=,"$D 

JV6$2]$9W ($."2C

a!.W Dw 5 6 4 ="/ ($ ,$ M

"$U% "2C7ygQ?"$V("/ ($ 

% t$. "
 (/ ; (? [3"=HP 0 5 M

1.

INTRODUCTION

a!.^*<L$"$P.) (b8P ] ISV== J0

D"$L== &\QHDQ$89; ()u$.S*<L$"$

5 =.,"$2d d$.S,"/ R 4

,MJ 5 = =Cta!.b*<L$"$9.) (P 0=u. m \"$ 4

\$.;= 4 <! ("$9 ) 5 Q="=HLC6*+.) 

5 )c 89) (

4  0 I/ ($u \V("= 5  H

J0
(==2C7a!.'="$% '"$U% "@! 5 0X2;$"$U% > 5
 U/ (MN"$  Hc/.) (00&b U"$ =Cta!.g`"$QP/.) (00&] ^.2
R="$% gD"$UD D"$X"$($X$.89=03

E 5 V"=$2W 9) ("=7JLHX (9*Qx>y{z@.|C T;CLe002'=. C7a!. 7Z"$#

 ?V" 4 ("$892S'. 0$. 5 $."'! ? (?*Qx!y\C
!

 L?= 5 "$ Hg89  5 "$!$X& 5 ("/] (/ ;D"$  ,HLC_>'02 (Q

!

$89,"' U/

4 "$8$. 4 X 4

 5 QM

4 "$8Y.) (,#"$!$.) U>J"$2 (#9 %$W$. I"'= I$ ()P=2 

 =#%/d_"=HD$ ^ 4

Q$("$2h U/ X 
$.6Q="/  &.L 4 "=> U"/R=(M

0 5 $ O!J 5 X[' $. 5 9,. 00&Cfa|"/ DMN-X2d$\JV

8P D"$&3 U"/ &S,"=HD$ ]$/. ln 5 + ()g$.[ U/ 9&"/  5 M
0 ("$ I<H

Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for
personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are
not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies
bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to
republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific
permission and/or a fee.
ACM SIGMOD 2002 June 4-6, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Copyright 2002 ACM 1-58113-497-5/02/06 ... } 5.00.

4 "+"=HDD$ |C

a!. B`"$QB/.) (00&W> (+G 89 ]J%H

W (0C
+ (&V5 8\|
5 W

U CP*> (
4

5 )h$.) (6. ("/%> ("$9"=HDM

$ ^ B 5 V"$ "

$9= 4 > U"$;"=HD$ C'_"=HD$ &X (/ 9 
J 5 0#b"$2 5 2g$.6V"=MNJ%H%$"=HD$ ^Q+= & I`)2 (L$0HLO)G%M
V= &P$9Q/ U"= 5 ^U3"$.2 DC?_"=HD$ &;J%HS"$2! 
"$ 4 "/ (J0!$+"=HD$ &?JLH`)0
JV,.8P ("$#

I( C

5 )

4 "7n 5 "$  4 "$8i$.>a>zZ7MN

a!.Z=)6/.) 00&Z F$. (F 4

:N$/ (0AB U/ ?D"$  ,HLO2'. ,.

|89"$@890GB= 7 I| 0 5 D"$$$ 

4 "$8$.@ (/ (J) (=

D"$UD D"2C+a!.W"$n 5 I"$89L? 

$.) (B,"=HD$2] (/ 98P H](
JVhD"=HD$k US$.^"$U% "P= I$C

Q="/ ( &.L 4 ("=> ("/

(M

D"$3 (,.X 1$B="/ (=89 I1$.Z"$2n 5 = I$!"=HD$2/ J0 4 "$8i$.

=,"$3"

(_$.!D"$UD D"_= $1$+$.!0 L2O%"=HDK$.!/ (J0O

()XGD 5 $!$.?n 5 ,"=H; U7$.'0 %2CKx

5 _$. 7 D"$3 (,.989 I$ IM

& ($' (089Q>"=H9  L/ &B 4 $.?="$% MN"$U% "!89%0O
= ]2{D"$ 8P U"=Hm U/ \"$L== &u. X$jL 5 "Pk0 L
8P (,. CB*B' 00@JV89[02 U"0 ($"2O 4 "6 P0 ("$&; 5 8;JV"? 4
n 5 "$ 9 5 /.f (9=0$ OQ O' 

5  O!8

5 /.m 4

$.

 (/ XD"$L== &P2 (]JVW6 (?$.="$"2OV ()b$.6 QZ"$

 ]JV89 5 $2P' I$.]0 I=$0-"=?JLHP$.+0 L2C
r

5 "+D"$V=RQHDQ$8]OV'.=XJ = 9 ("$/. I$, 5 "$X ()^M

O1 689D"$ =2\ 4

="$0_w2~ ("$9=.2'\ ue1 & 5 "$

 89L/ (0BL$ I$ C

$."$

V=g$.Rn 5 "=Hf$d$.R0 L2C

 9.Q$2dJ%Hj$.S="$% ]"$U% "['.RQ$"$X$.

"=HD$] U/ J) (=C?a!.6"=HD$2b U/ J) (=[ 
5 &89L$2

' I$.P  I$  0  4 ("$8P ($ 

"=/  m 89 5 L; 4

n 5 "=H\"$L== &R$hL 5 "9 U;$.P="$"

5 ="?n 5 "$ >$[$.+ D"$D"$ l U$+"$"$=L/ ($ ]b$.

=,"$3"2O )6V" 4 "$89KVQ=MND"$L== &

W="$3"_n 5 ,"=H+"$ 5 0I$C
xZ =2SP$.
5 GD 0  ("=HP  4 "$8P ($ bQ$("$2O%!B0P$,.DM
 n 5 >$;=0 I
g"$ & ) (0Kn 5 "=HPU3,"
L$

g"=HDD$2P"$0l U$ |

0I
JKMLON'P9J   I    I      I 

'. ,.;Z'2 00$.> ),G1 (002'

 
Q$("$
$.W (/
' I$. 5 Q) U"/ v &S U/ 9"$  (HLC'
3N^4 "P="/ (QM
UP$.]="$"2C
Z0 %  (0=d8P ( %/ (  P N
0 U$ &

!#"%$'&)(+*-,.0/21*43 *5(76)"98:*<;>=?(7@A6"9B)*A(DCE(F8+1?"%G*E8FG&(7*'H

45 M

5 "=HD$2X"$0 U$ 

'.,"$S$.g U=="$ J 5 $

"$=V)!$W$.+ G

4 "/ 89,!"$#

0&J"/  

JUVN

"$0 ($ 

()6-$ 3=K 4
4

4 2 = J 0 I<H

5 "@ "$ /.;JLH+$Q$ &?$.7V" 4 ("$8P 

5 "FQ="/ ($&(H6("1 5 89,"$ 5 n 5 ,"$ C@r

D"$  (H

5 "|"$ 5 0I$|=.2u$.) U

4 "$8Y="$% +"$U% "$Z2 bJV+ /. 2P' I$.P"$2 =M

(J0U3"$.2 gQ/ J0 =. &X$.

I( .) 23
JVgQ 5  2S S$.+0 I=M

,"/ ( 5 "$C7
2!3,"

45 $  0 I$ 

D"$(% SJLH9$.= ("$"=H

0 89 I$2c c  5

 L; mGD 5 $ &h890GcEo+pn 5 "$ 

U3,"
"=HD$b (/ DC
a!.9"$QW 4
D"$=L$P.2

$.9 V"[ [("$&3 ( v2d (

4 00U'C\E%$ 

 U/ \ P"=HDD$2f ()kQ$("$2fk$.g="$3"2C

E%$  ; = 5 =='.2

ZW="$ JVW.2

 %  5 (0|"$0 U$ ) (0KV"/ U$"$B 5 ,.

(P=0$ O< |O'=,gD I-"$O' f&"$ 5 kJ%Hk U"$^ 890M
89%$C@E%$ 

=.2'Z.Um$+"$>"$ I$? n 5 "=H[JLH[=0 =$ &

I> L$[ W="$"'n 5 "=HX b 60 L'n 5 "=HLOL 5 ,.9$. (Z$.B8XM
 5 / U$ g U>$.
0 %' !"$2 5 C_E%$ 
89L/ (0)"$ 5 0I$>gn 5 "$ 

4 "$8

& > 5 "'GDV"=M

$.+a>z77MNJV,.8P ("$#VCj

0 5 +$.+) (V"? ^ED$ %C

WY\O] ^0W
g'h ^
lm] bdc
r hs \
r7Wxbdbdc

_M] `a] bdc

i jk
q jk
tjk
ttk

RELATION ENCRYPTION AND STORAGE MODEL

x7 4 ("$?Z' = 5 =@$/. ln 5  4 ("!n 5 ,"=H[D"$L== &6U3"@M

,"=HD$2^ U/ DOV0

5 '`"$QB = 5 =B.U

Q$("$2] U?$.+="$3,"2C
e"|2 /."$0 ($ 
 r

$. (>' 00|JV

5 =2

] ZOZOb
lm] nO`[W
lm] X[\
uvX w7WYb
y h n5W>zWx`[`

ZOX[Z
o7j
p j
tj
{{Yj

/ (J0B >8P (V2X$X 6("="$=V &;/ (J0+ U>$.

JUVN I
J KQLONP9J  J|} I  J~5UJ I  EPA+ I  5}<}< I  }<|} I'

*! Z0IHP=$ U"=HS$["$2 U$+ S )DG

4 ("? (=="$ J 5 $! %303

j=2 U"$,.j D< u"$ 2 ($CX*<h$.X JVU3;,G (890O| 4

!

#%$.) (
$."$W! 5 0RJV[bn 5 "=H]$. (B %303 U=="$ J 5 $

5}<}<

\ I$."W S=0$ j"W < |O|$.h$.; GhR$. 

(=="$ J 5 $Pj(;JVP"$2 U$2Cq $. 5 [0=; 4

&"/ (0 HLO

!b = 5 89X$.) UX (d Gj ["$ ($2dU3"[2 /.c (=="$ J 5 $P 4
$.
"$0 ($ C

2.1 Partition Functions

uBGD0  b'. (? 'Q$"$2S g (=="$ J 5 $  TI 4  I 4 "?2 (,.
 T 4 [
 C@e"Z$. ! 5 "$V=OLZ
' 00V2X$[0
=89g/ U$ Cj
 g`"$QP8P (m$.^8P  m 4  0 5 
T 
4 U=="$ J 5 $  
T L$X ("=$ I$   N      N  O) 5 ,.g$. ( Q

$.=>) ("=$ I$ 7/ (#3[$&$."7U3"@$.!'.0?8P ( )%
()

 
LH^<Zg) U"=$ I$ 6DbU3"$0 (|C;e"$8P (00IHLO-!;`
45 ,$  N57KQ|KQ|+~ ( 4 002'
(=="$ J 5 $

N57KQ|KQ|+~v
   T v

2.

 T

[)D $ ] ] ;n 5 "=HP '="/ (=0 ($

$P 9)D $ ^]$."=HD$] U/ 9 (?$.6="$3"2C!*<hE%M

$ 

JUVN

a!.

4 2 = J 0 I<Hg 4 $.B89%0C

2
 O('.,"$70IH#3H%Z"/+=2 U"$,.6 F 5 V"=$O( 6 &
U"$ I$.M
89,$ B("',"=HD$2S (/

4 ">$.+ (=="$ J 5 $

="$3,"2

a!."$] 9"$D  5 X!("$#d q I-"$%;"$=2 ("$/.q U"$2 P=89
4 '. /.] U"$+"$0 ($2b$[ 5 ">!"$#VCZED ("$/.gb,"=HD$2S (/



JV02u$.) U1Q$("$1  4 "$8P ($ ; (JV 5 F8902HLC

WYX[Z
ef
pq j
fe j
p i t

4 "]n 5 "=Hm"$>"$ I$ &m("

"=HD$9"$"$=L/ U$ |C7e1 ) (00IHLO%!BGD0"$?$.

JKMLON'P9J

4 ("n 5 ,"=HgD"$L== &S (?$.6="$"2C?e"

G 890O)= ,"+

Q 6 b"="$=V)D &hn 5 "=HhU3"W"=HD$2^"$0 ($ [$

 Z 60 L>n 5 "=H 4 "!VQ=MN"$L== &
0I$] 4 $.R="$3,"^n 5 "=HLCj
 j (,. 3R$. g& 0JLHtDM

0 &k (

J KQLON'P%JR
jS' 00>GD0  c.2

C C;
 Q$("$? S,"=HD$2PQ="$ &[$. (>("=M
"$=V)?$g X 5 0[ ]"$0 U$ S[C  _ /.j U=="$ J 5 $  I ("=M

" 5 PP$.?="$3"2O 

"$ 5

,`)S gED$ 

   

4 $S$.+0 L
b$.

$.6"=HD$2] (/ X 

       ,O!_Q$"$_+$.@="$"

5 ="?89 &.L'JVB$.B$ 89L$ I<HLC

NF 
N      N

1 WG 890O= "K$.! U=="$ J 5 $

J7|}


4 $.

JUVN

/ J0

JVU3C7E 5 V=B$.+ 0 5 > 4 8P  S 4 $. ' U=="$ J 5 $B0  
$.
"/ &

  ::U

C!?= 5 89
$. (>$.
'.0+"/ & ' % lD2

 $'$.) UZ!? 5 0P 0I$"$) U$ 30IH9.) 23'/.=9$W"=HD7 U

$.? U=="$ J 5 $?030) Q$2 X 4 $.'"$2f030C_7 (,.S (0$,"$) ($ 3
.) (F I$12'6"$1 Cu_V L$._ L$"$Q$2+"$2 D"$|$
( 4 "Z / ( 0X=,"$ D$ |C_a!.>"$Q_ 4 $. @) (V"! (= 5 89
"=HD$ b ?D6 U'$.B"$2030C

 ("=$ I$ 


L$

 :  
:F(

()

  FF(

+:  O
:U
O

CZa!.) (? 

::  :
:U
O

F:  :U

u

N5+KM|KM|F~v
JUVN  
J |} 

 +:(


FF ::(
OF F




 :( 
F:  :( 
 :  :F(

TB -,"$L1 U=="$ J 5 $8P HBJV@ ("=$ I$ 

 T

="$ J 5 $

$h"$ ($S) ("=$ I$  &R 4

p i t
o

45 "=$."?0 == 4 Hb<Z;<HDV> 4 8P  &

45 $ 

U OB 5 0JV

5 =2

(=="$ J 5 $CR*<u$.S,G (890

5 =2

7N  
@  ,C

$X8P ( m L$\

 B
C ^

=,
4 J 5 ,#3,$C_
LHS. Q$&("/ 8XMNQ=" 5 $ g$/. n 5 O 5 ,.
(hy] (GDT+ IKOB2n 5 IM' l%$.|O
"^n 5 IM<D$.

fe j
i

7N   
= ^ ,
U
45 $ V?

8P ( &
2 002XW Q
 ,
UW 4K4 "B LHb!9 0 5 B@ T ()Y@ 
R$.;8P ( \ 4  T O| 4 @ T[Z
@  O|$.O? 7N  
@ T ]\

5 = &? I-"$% ("=M

"="$=V)D;$\ \=0 I=$ &R 4

pq j
o

CTS

45 $ CZ*?=. 5 0gJV02 U"

$. ('$. ("=$ I$ ^ 4 (=M

$ I$ 

ef
e

w ] `JIOWLK
FG H 
   TDQ KR
MONP 
O

WF[!8P  &

45 $ ^ '2 002

WF

4 I? 

'("/"?D"$="$% &C

"/ ()D8

45 $ iD"$UD Dh 5 V"$ "RD"$  ,H

8P  &

$RGD0 ( c 5 "XQ="/ U$&HLO 4 "9= 890  I<HLOKZb' 00' = 5 89S$.

89) ("$t$m I$^"="$=V)D &m"/,"=MD"$="$% &m8P  &DC

n 5 IMN' %$.]) U"=$ $  &DC?@G%$= ^ 4

B2Z3"2OF BZ;' 007=;0l U$"2O'.$."6 b8P ( &

5 "?Q="/ ($&(H]$9$."

45 $ 

 ("=$ I$  &89$.%D@ @"$0 ($ 30H[Q="/  &.% 4 "=! ("/O%$. 5 &.X I

+"/D"D"$="$% &S"6( U-$.2iZ[="/ (=0 ($9 Sn 5 "=H

' 00"$2n 5 "$>/.) (&_$B=89> 4 $.>(/ ($ ZD30VC@e("

L$^n 5 "$ 6\$.X0 L[ j="$3"2Cgo

,G (890O 5 0 #3?2n 5 IM' l%$.92 =?'."$B  (0 5 

8P (_$W0IH

= 890 I`)2

J |O) h2n 5 MD$.] I

8P H]8P b$S8

9= &0;. Q$&"/ 8

0J 5 /#3$C@r

5 0I$ IM

5 ">/ ($ ^ = 5 89!$.) U'2 /.g 0 5 B8P !$

S= &0XJ 5 /#32C6*h$.;GDV"$ 89L/ (0K=$ OFJV= D

$.2n 5 IM' D$.gZ6' 00K (0=P 0 5 ($ 5 "BQ="/ U$&H

u

5 = &

5 ">$.

*S$.+ (JV(+G 890OD gn 5 IMN' %$.b. Q$&"/ (8Y> > 00 5 QM

($X$.) (W'.j$.PD8P  u 4

d U=="$ J 5 $9"="$M

=V)DW$h ]`)0l\("['. ,.d("/"$ &^ W!00>D`)2

J7|}

$.

(=="$ J 5 $7,OK!P' 00' (= 5 899$.) UX ^ ("=$ I$ 

L$  5

u

5 ?"/ (&C

N T  P

5 =

()

N T  
| 

N T

45 "=$.">`>$."$
89"$?8P  &

45 $ Z$. (Z' 00

45 ,$ d,`)R.06U3"W (%H\ U=M

="$ J 5 $OL$.?0 (=$"!!6.0

4 "!$.B U=="$ J 5 $_'.=+8P  

 0 5 _GD. J @$(/ 0)("/"2C@?0 2 U$ 9 4 $.>8P  &
$ W$
 0 5 ;@)O&("$2 ($"@$. [$.!8P (GD 8

;

8P  O0@ ;_a` O"$ 5 "$[?

$P$+$.

8P M

5 + R="/ =0 U$ &^n 5 "$ U3,"$.;"=HD$h"$D"$=DM

C &DCO

5 8

45 ,M

 (0 5 ! [$.>(M

7N  
@ b_a` ,C'E% 89 0 ("$0IHLO 0 2 ($ 

45 ,$ ;$+

 (0 5 c@)O30=K$. [$.!89  8

4 $.!8P ( &

 0 5  b$.8P  |Od@ 

5 V"'JV 5  ("=HS 4 $. ("=$ I$ |OD"$=V,$ 0IHLC

02!,"+ ()

.0

45 ,$ |CRu

4 "bJV$.m<HDV9 4

45 $ C

/ ($ |Cmt. 0X$.;`"$Q

n 5 IM<D$.S) U"=$ I$  &DC

="/ U$2C

' 00+30m="/ =0 U$ tQ="/ ($& 

 &

5 "=Hh="/ =0 U$ d 

5 = &\ h("/"=MND"$="$% &h8P  &

T

O"$ 5 "$e?

5 8

+N 6  
@  T  ,C

 T

p|,Ef\JVB 6 5 J=Z 4  (0 5 ! 9$.

8P  9 4 (=="$ J 5 $

2.2 Identification Functions

e 5 "=$.,"$89"$O@!]`] (k DL$ `2 ($ 

|}5J~'K

N 

$9 == &\ (] L$ I`),"

(=="$ J 5 $

$b$.

 T

 ("=$ I$ [ 4

|}5J~'K  T
=   FF( 

#


JU2N  7
J |} CPe"W Q/ O
|}5J~'K  T 
>
 F
   ::U  C

$.9 U=="$ J 5 $

O% 

#$"

%!!

!#"%$&(7*+*.-, CE(+G "%G"%@/.

JU2N  J7|} H

&""

C0.B

P00 = DM 4 "$9.) (=.

' "

 !"

"9B*1.G"32v8FC G"%@0.54d&6.?8FG"%@/.?3

@04

45 $ h$.) (

5 =29 Z 

|}5J~K

5 $ 0 v"$V"=$ + 4

$.

45 $ |C_e"7G 890O3 

45 $ ]8P H

5 =+$.Q/ ("=B )=<(("Bg 0 5 ' 4

"/ (&C

> 3X$.' JVU3' ("=$ I$ P ; L$ I`) ($  45 ,$ O3Z
7N    $.) U?8P ' [ (0 5 A@P 
45 $ 8?

D`) X8P  &

$.68P  g 4

(=="$ J 5 $

$9'. /.8@SJV0&B?

 T

$;$.+ DL$ `"? 4 $.+) U"=$ $ 

+N 6 C
@A

|}5J~K   
[N  ,O'."$ N 

'$.+ ("=$ I$ g$. ('L/  B@)C

4 002' &q/ (J0u=.2'^=89

*$.jG (890u (JV(O+$.

 0 5 6 4

$.98P ( &

+N    TD
 O

7N/  TD
  
 C

Q/ OB?

45 ,$ 

 E
O ?

J U2N  J|}
7
 N   TD
 : 
7

4 ("X U=="$ J 5 $

Cbe("
O! )

$
$.) (? I' 
'=$ U"=Hb$X,"$2 ($W 00 4 $.+) U"=$ $ 
P$.gJV&  &Ca!.Hm2 kJV]"$2 U$2q X$.] 0 5 P U"$
U
="=$2g L$;$.+ (/ (J) (=C

 T

@


|}5J~'K
  
[N hg N  

|  \p@


lDL$ I`)"$+ 4

) U"=$ IM

$ +'.=["/ &8P H]U3"$0 (\' I$.R$.[ 0 5  OfZCWa!.

7N 
l   
@A- |$.@=K

"$ 5 0F 4 ?

4 DL$ `"$F"="$=V) &?$

) U"=$ I$ @'.=?"/ (&78P HWL/ ( P

 (0 5 '_0=@$.) (r@)C

+N 6
o   
@AZ !$.+=?

4 DL$ `"$>("="$=V &

$9) U"=$ I$ ?'.=6"/ &?8P HgL/  h X 0 5 6(B&("$2 ($,"

$.) (Y@)C

2.4 Storing Encrypted Data

ub2{.) 23b

5 &.f(/ ($ 9$\=V 4 Hf.2

$.^"=HD$k"$0 ($ 

K ts 

 

'.,"$

     0u

s J~v++NEK

2.3 Mapping Functions

|}5J~'K
  
[N hg N  P%m+n



7N    
v
f 
+$.[=6

@==L$ l (00HLOq?

p| #3,' =O?

$.62 =6'."$[ 9) U"=$ $ R"="$=V)?$P 9 5 89"$ +"/ &O
$..) (=.

7N 
o  
@Av

|}5J~K   
[N  hg N ci f-k

7 j


7N 
l  
@A
?

?
%

a!. |}5J~'K 45 $ P 0 5  4 "' ) U"=$ I$ P  5  ln 5 O3$.) UZ O
|}5J~'K   
[N  8
 7 |}5J~'K   
[N/9 ,O@ 4;: 7 P C\e(";$. [ 5 "$V=O
 ("=$ I$ P8P H;JV

7N   
fvv

?

=.2'W$.X L$ I`),"$[ (== &

4 00U' &

45 $ 'g$.+) U"=$ $ ? ==L  U$2]' $.

8P  &

45 ,$ f2 (00

|}5J~'K
  
[N !$9 /.]) U"=$ $ 

CSe1 & 5 "$

jgD`)S$.

X@uJVg h 0 5 S c$.gD8P ( C

   

J~v+7N K

 I

q$.^="$"2C

[O%$.+"$0 ($ 

    ? 7
 N  xw:

     E
   y
  
? 7N
   ?

9$.

45 $ 

"$0 ($ 

Q$("$2gb$.+="$"2

a!.'`"$QZ0 5 89

{

JKMLON'P9J

$b$.;"=HD$2^ 5 0+ 

 
 N   z
   u
7

4 002' &d X$.g"=HDD$2

e"X Q/ O!$.

{|$}m~a{
a
a









a
a




Q$"$
[ 5 0

5 =2k$u"=HDb \ 5 0^ 4

$.b"$0 ($ C

J7U2N I

$jQ$"$

e("g /.q 5 0

{1aA{

a

h3
h


aha


L/ ( 7$.
Q="$ &W("="$=V &

JUVN

C;e"6 Q/ (O|$.W`"$Q 5 M

0 ',"=HD$29$u: :% :D:% CLCC=AR$. (? '2n 5 0V$

J~v+7N K
  
+U

    ?

7N'P9J  O ,C_a!.?=)9 Z"=HD$2

J
~ v+7N K
 :  ? 5+  :
  

$P: :F:F::F:FD% C%CC=A]n 5 0$

5|~   ,Cvu'="$2 U!$.

"=HDD$ 

45 $ b > WJ0 /#XJV2G

.2

 I$ ; U"$P="/ (=0 ($O1ZP' 00!JVX"$2 DHR$h = 5 =

.2

"$0 ($  0KV,"/ ($"$+ ("$="/ =0l U$2^U3"B$.="$3"=MN= 

I, O!+ED

I7U O>T+ZE

 O'xZ02>`)=.

e(">2 /.b"$0l U$ |OD$.

="$3"'= D+Q$"$!$.B"=HD$29 5 M

5 =2c$

$COZ2 mJV

n 5 ,"=HS="$? ("$+="/ =0 ($2-C

89089L/ U$ |O b.U

^ 5 "B = 5 == |C?

LHbJ0L/#g ."'$/. n 5  5 ,.h (B
ZE

0OZ 0&h' $.c$.b (=="$ J 5 $S  ;$,"$89 2uJLHu$. "

"=HD>$.B 5 0C

45 $ Chyg2 (%'. 0O_$.90 L;Q$("$W$.989/

8P  &

a!.;=)h0 5 89^"="$=V)D+$9$.; Ggh$.W8XM

 U/ > JV 5 F$.K=V I`)_ )D O( 5 /. $.@  4 ("$8P ($ 6 (JV 5 

4 ("6 (=="$ J 5 $ J7|} ]$.W`"$Q

 DO S I$!("="$=V &[) U"=$ $ g    +:( C!ED 
$. X) U"=$ $ k X %$ I`2u$  O7ZgQ$"$b$.S (0 5 k:  Aj 
$.P lDL$ I`)"[ 4 $. J|} 4 "[$. W 5 0C\E% 89 0 ("$0IHLO1ZbQ$("$
$.g %$ I`"c: A 4 ("9$.]=m890UH3g   : Cq*m$.
0UH3[ DCe("+G 890OV 0 5 

$.S) U"=$ I$  &h 4

 5 0B 

a!.70 L 5 $ 0 v1$. |  4 ("$8P ($ 6$'="/ =0 U$! >& 3[n 5 "=H

5 =? I-"$L_8P  &

/ (J0
JVU3O3Z

U=="$ J 5 $CPa!.X8P ( &

5}<}<

}<|}

O> ()

45 $ 

45 $ 

EPA+


O

:
A


          ,O3"$0 U$ 
0K   I
J KMLON'P9J   I  

 I      I ,CP*<\$.P JVU3X,G (890O
JU2N 
$.;/ (J0
JU2N I C

2.5 Decryption Functions

> 3$.uV"/ ($("

$. (h8P h f"$0 ($ 

8P (!$.B"=HD$29"$"$=L/ ($ S$X I$>"="$=V)D &

"=HD$^"$"$=L/ U$ |C6a!. ( O
(890> (JV(O
JU2N I v

J7U2N

 I #

4
8

?b Ib' 00JVh02 U"^0 ($"2O?$.h&"/ (0=,.8P u 4

TI



;`2d kED,$ 

q.$.7"=HD$ V"/ ($("  K 0 2+$  TI O( FQ="$ 

 I   I    I   I     I   I    I   I    




()D"=HD$
 I  J KQL:N'P9J   I  J KMLON'P9J    )
 $>$. I" 5 "=HDD$2


U=="$ J 5 $ 0 5 C

?Z (9G 890OL = 5 89>$.) (7 ($."_/ J0

`2;  U 5

U |}  }<|} b> (j (0=tQ$"$2 $.d U/ J =Ca!.u"="$M
=V)D &]"=HD$2h"$"$=%/ U$ 
U 5 ?
 ' 00ZJVP b/ (J0
U 5 I
J KQL:N'P9J  U |} I  }<|} I , CRE 5 V=9!9!"$P$^89 5 $
Q
  JV,<!t/ J0 J7U2N I  U 5 I  $. I" }<|} I (=M
="$ J 5 $C;a!.;"$ 5 0I$ &b"$0l U$  KQJ7U2N I ' 00_L/ ( R$.; (=M
="$ J 5 $s JUVN I  J KQL:N'P9J  J|} I  J~5U J I 7 AP%5+ I  5}<}< I  JU2N I 
}<|} I  U 5 I  J KQLONP9J  U |} I  U 5 I  }<|} I u C* 4 Zc ("$u$qDM
,"=HDB$. KQJUVN I "$0 ($  5 = &P$.
V"/ U$"$P89 5 $

9KQJUVN I ,
 O2$.K"="$=V)D &'/ J0K' 00LL/  +$.7 U=="$ J 5 $

9KQJUVN I )' 00L,"=HD :

9

$. ) C

MAPPING CONDITIONS

*u$. W=$ c!SQ 5 %Hj.U

 5 ,.

7N  

$^="/ =0 U$b=V `gn 5 "=H

(g=0$ ] ()

< YS$

"="$=V) &

)D $ FU3,"F$.@="$"=MN= lD_"$"$=L/ U$ |C
a!. '="/ (=0 ($ 

8P 

J7U2N

@\$h$.
@)CPe("

/ J06 JVU3OD!. U

 F 
O

?8P Vb$

J|} ID

45 ,$ ^ 4

JLHb$.8P  &

45 $ ] '2 (002

7N  

L0CN9&)*.bE 5 /.d ^ I$ c U"$ =; d=0$ 

C7rBBZ#%2

5 Q6. U9 g!00Z`2R"/,"=M

&
("K'. /.[$.[: Z A
V"/ U$"_ @`2-C1T+V) & 5 V
 
7N/ 4 $.Z U=="$ J 5 $
'.,$."K("K(F$.78P ( & 45 $ T?
K"/D"=MN"$="$% &
"K"/ ()8]O I-"$L1="/ (=0 ($ _ ("$!VQM
= J0C P

 r
"/,"FD"$="$% &*+$. | =OU$.K="/ (=0 ($ 6 FQ="/ ( &.L=M

4 ("=> U"/

+N3  
 T Z
?

@AO

 TI \

+N  
@A
?


8]Ka!.+="/ =0 ($ ^ ? ;0 I=$0890G-Cj+,./#
$.g U=="$ J 5 $S 0 5 P"$"$=L/ ($ 

 I
T

0 X k (LHd 4

) U"=$ I$ $.) U68P H\L/  u b (0 5 r@+Q7'."$

@+Q Z

8P 00IHLO%$.+="/ (=0 ($ g 

+N   
 T Z

?

e("
Q/ O$.

@AO

  +:(



 T
I R ?

$.

@)CSe("=M

o 
@A
+N C

4 002' &S) I$ g >="/ (=0 ($2-

7N  
J|} Z

   SO

= m (00[8902HLj lDh0=R$. 

 :

G G (+"IH?&G *

4 $.K"=HD$2
0 5 89

()hD"$^$.[ 5 GD 0  ("=Hh0 5 89?"="$=V)D &b$

)D I$ b tV"/ ($ 

J|}

7N/
?

45 $ 

7N  
J|}
?

= 

 CD
 O

+N0C
@A

s 6) U"=$ I$ j$.) UWL/  6' I$.\ (0 5 

Q/ (O= "'$.

J|}  J~5U J x AP%5F  A}<}<  JUVN  }<|}  U|}  U 5  }<|} 

3.

4 00U'

 TI -?

@AO

V,"/ ($ C^a!.P U=="$ J 5 $98

(g$.? G; (0 5 

K>JUVN I

 T

L$ I`),"6 4

 I   I    I   I      I   I    I   I    u



Z) I$ hZDM

$. ? (=="$ J 5 $C

s I  JKMLON'P9J   I  JKMLON'P9J   

a!. (| O

5 /.u ])D $ d ("$ =W u=0$ 

+N3  
 T
?

tM

,"=HD$2B"$0 ($ ;"|$.@"$ 5 0IF 4 "$0 ($  0%V"/ U$"$@ (89&Q
"=HD$S"$0 ($ O'

G G (+"IH?&G *KJML0CN9&*'.SE
G

V,"/ ($ C!a!.8P  &W 

,`)b (

CFa!. iV"/ ($("78P HW (0=BJV

$:

$&%(')
$+*-,/.$0(12%3$.5416178/.1-,,7/.9,(*:,/.;'<*-,<=

%<>7/)?%*-,/.9,(*-,.%(0(1#%<$<=
'+7A@BC)!'<*-,/.'0A1#%3$.9,(*:,/.;DE+,>+$F3=

[C+*<^$.WG%M

5 0$ 0[/ J0"$0 U$2uJLHj U"$J I="/ ("=HR"$0 ($ ) 07V"/ U$"$

C &DCO:Q O)=0$ O)$C

N 0 5 :
N !=="$ J 5

00 5 Q="/ ($$.

="/ =0 U$ |C

5 DM

(0 2udn 5 "=HRGDD"$== CgYn 5 ,"=H\,GD"$== d= Q$

!=="$ J 5 $

002!2bV"/ U$ 

$q I$RM

,"=HD$2"$"$=%/ U$ |O(!!`Z I$K %3"$=7V"/ U$"
$.) U

!=="$ J 5 $

Z) I$ 

4 (" YN 0 5 

 Z #"0 \  n C


*<X$.BD = 5 == SJV02q!?' 00 5 =
 ?$. 4 002' &;/ J07$

:Q@,"=HD$A<Z$P8P 

;"$0l U$ 4$9 I$

"=HD$S"$D"$=L/ ($ C>a!. (? OV& 3
"$0l U$ 

Z) I$ 

Z I$ ^Z)D I$ ';g

 Z)D I$ 
 I$ Ag
! Z I$ C

 5 892S$;&"/ ($+$.+ L$ I`)"$'0 Q$2g g$.B/ J0C

5 =$.6(/ ($ 

O@'. /.c ;$.d,G,M

4 002' &P&"/ (898P (">" 5 0

$"$ v2bJ%HP$.

U=="$ J 5 $P ("$^(P=.2'|O!J 5 ;$.Hm U"$h QM

*^&"/ 0OVZ

$h I$;="$"=MN= lDS"$"$=L/ U$ 

45 $ O7,$C

 5 $2RJLH^$.;="$3,"2C2j;= "Wn 5 "=H^) I$ ,. ("/ (M

4 ("!D I-"$L

J7~5U J

4 "6$.

U=="$ J 5 $O@$.b8P ( &

FF  O
F(

J|} I R
  

  


.) 23\<!t ("=$ I$ 

O'.=6 L$ I`),"$' ("$



  


P $ $.) UmZ  { 0I! 2HD 5 = $.t8P  & D`)2
$.\"/ )D8
2 (=d$k="/ =0 ($c I$ R %30% &f"/,"=M
"$="$% &
(=="$ J 5 $C
ucD I-"$L$  ($mJV<Zi$.u!
2 (=
= B$.
="/ =0 U$ 
>Z001 !$.n 5 "=HPD"$L== O
& 
'2 = " 4 ("
$. 4 ("$89"?2 =C

GG (+"IH&G *
G

 T

L0CN%&*'.>a!. !)D I$ b >QHD8989="$ >' I$.S$.

"

D"$%  5 'C7

>JV 4 "$Z6 I-"$L$  ($+'.$."?("
>$.

7N  
 T " @AO  I n ? 7N/
@A

T




 C
 l 
@A,
T " @AO  TI R ? 7N 


 r
"/D""$="$% &Dq?
 B ()8]? +N3 

4 00U' &S)D I$ ] >="/ =0 U$2

e"? Q/ OD$.

7N   
J|} "

?

F S
 O

J7|} I R
3+

=  00-8902HLB !&("$2 ($,">$.) 

$ I`"$


#"m_$&% T % T  +'D,)

U"$+8P V2X$[ M

4 "$8

J0O%"

-d 

! Q/ (Z 4 $.>$ 89>/ J0C@a!.')D $ 

7N  
 T
?

u 

a!.) UP O!!]= D"S 00?V== J0^) ( I"$S 4

 T

;

()

|}5J~'K
[N S

 I

$.=9<ZR ("=$ I$ 

|}5J7~'K
<
[N 9 ,Cue1  00IHd!P/ #3P$.b QM

5 $ g 4 $.=+) I$ C7a!.B L 5 I$ b !$.) (!2 /.b  I"

 T

4 ) U"=$ $ _8P 2HWD"$(% >=89> (0 5 @ 4

 T

$ U$  4 Hg$.+) I$ 

 ] b MX dX h \O_
 j[{Yjj
{Q Yjj e jj
Q e jj f jj
Q f jj o7jj

;

o
f

7N 
[N  P L\

Y?

  O




7N 
[N/9  

|  

7N/

("$+"/ ()8]?u

.) 23?$.

4 0IM

TI

|}5J~K<
[N 9 

|}5J~'K
[N    I

0 ($2S$

$. (_2 

JUVN

JUVN

JUVN

JUVN

JUVN

JUVN


 HF  T



 ] bdX MX h \:_
 j e jj
eQ jj o7jj

 HF  T

;

()

 T

4 002'

N57KQ|KQ|+~
 T   N 9 R N5+KM|KM|F~v
c
    N 9  
|  n
'.,"$!\  N
R
N  P C_a!.) UZ OL!'= ,"> 00)  I"$Z 4 ) ("=$ I$ Z 4  T ()
c $.) U@ 5 0l[$ ($  4 HW$.!)D I$ |C_e("@2 /.X  I"2OZ>.) 23>
) I$ h("="$=V &9$9$.6  I"+ 4 $. I"B DL$ `"$C#u
 
/ #+$.D 9 5 $ ] 4 $.=)D I$ C
U 5  }<|} B="/ QM
e("+G 890OV) I$ .  J7U2N  }<|} Z

 ("=$ I$ P 4

[N'  N 9 ,OK!P.) 23X

 I
T

$.) U;U3,"$0l (|C]e"[2 /.u  I"

)D I$ cu$.P %$ I`"$; 4

+N3  
 T Z
?

|}5J~'K<
[N 9 

|}5J~K
[N     I

c O




7N/

x7$.8?

N R N A7KQ|KM|+~v
 T   N 9 R N5+KM|KM|F~v
c   N' i N 9 7

'."$

j%C

  
 O
 I
T




("$X("/"D"$="$% &DB*h$. 

02' &X="/ =0l U$ |

4 00U' &b >$.B="/ (=0 ($ |

$.B$ 89+/ J0C_a!.

N R N5+KM|KQ|F~v
 T   N/9 R N A7KQ|KM|+~v
  ,C

'.,"$

 \ 0=g U"$ =X \ P=0$ |O| ^$.W!b (=="$ J 5 $B RJV
4 "$8

7N/
?

+N0C
[N   $|  
?

5 "!,. B >J =2PP$.

=V I`)
) ("=$ I$  &; 4

+N3  
 TZ

?

GG (+"IH&G *',J G G G(F" H&G *d*.[E 5 /.\ 9)D $ \89 &.L+ ("$ =
R 0Q
  Ca!.6<Zg U=="$ J 5 $B2 (RJV 4 "$8 !S I-"$L
/ (M

()

; 
C uB2 ^D;$.
="/ =0 U$ h 



C


7N/
?

xZ$.

c O
 
 I |}5J~K<
[N   TI \

2 (=+!+. U+ [/. + 415 = &[ I$."> 4 $.B JVU3B![8P M

 &C7r

4 002'

"$3,"$=2C_a!.8P  &[' 00FJV+ 

+N3  
 TZ

?

45 $ ] 
("/"?"$="$% &C!a!.+="/ =0 ($ ^ 


8P ( &
4 002'

 









I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}

  U 5

  U 5
 U 5
 U 5
  U 5
 U 5

I
I
I
I
I
I

I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}

 

 

 

 
I  
I  ,C

JUVN I  }<|} I  U 5 I  }<|} I  ; 0 5 2-O

:  F
Q
 :U 4 "7 (=="$ J 5 $ JUVN  }<|} ()[ ("=$ I$ 

FF  ::( 4 "W (=="$ J 5 $ U 5  }<|}  h"$U% ;  I"$+ 4  0 5 
U 5  }<|} C
$.) U'$ ($  4 H JUVN  }<|} Z
| /LEK>3
J "  KdKQ+| /L K>J+ O$.b? +N    8P M
e("F)D $  #KMKMF*
| /L KQJF Z #KMKMF*| /LEK>J3 OD (
 &; '$ 89+ (>$.B8P ( &[ 4  KdKQ+*
Z I$ 

e"1 Q/ OU$.K/ J07 JVU3@=.U'|$.@) U"=$ $ [ ()+ M

45 $ + 4

$ I`2 ($ 

a!.^) I$ 



02' &9)D $ 




GG (+"IH&G *',

U 5  <
} |}

JU2N

JU2N

JU2N

J7U2N


JUVN  <
} |}

!S (=="$ J 5 $

JUVN  <
} |}

} |}
I <
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}

I
I

I
I

  U 5

 U 5
  U 5
 U 5

} |}
I <
I  }<|}
I  }<|}
I  }<|}

GG (+"IH&G *d*.

?&3  ]

 T Z

 

!
C

U 5  <
} |}

 

I
I

 
 C
 ,

4 0IM

="$ JV2] JVU3+' I$.S$.+"$0? 4 $. U=="$ J 5 $>"$"$=2C

 

45 $ 6 4

DV)D

 T



;

7N 

4 "?2 (,.g b 5 "$|C

_"/D"7"$="$% &DK*<; 5 /.9 +2 =>Z?0 Q7 5 Z 00

$.>) U"=$ $ _ 4

 T

+N   

 
; L$ 4 H; 00D$.>) U"=$ I$ _ 4 ;

+N3  

$.) U

4 002'

#"h_$&% T % T  ('D*)


7N/



; 
 O
|}5J~'K
[N     I n
TI

Z("/"Z"$=,"$D &K* 4

 T

@/.?B"%G"%@/.6*.

+~}<|KM|F~K 3
  +~}<|KM|+~) SO
+3
N   
 +
~}<|KM|F~K CY? +N3  

+~}<|KM|F~) 

+~}<|KM|F~K 3
  +~}<|KM|+~) SO
+3
N   
 +
~}<|KM|F~K CY? +N3  

+~}<|KM|F~) 

a|"/ (=0 ($ h 4

7N  
 TZ

?

@/.B?"%G"%@0.,

$ U$  4 HR$.;("/"$ &g) I$ C9E%V I`) 00IHLO|$.;8P  &P 
(

U"$X"/D"W"$="$% &

("'"/ )D8]Cj+=V 4 Hb$.B="/ (=0 ($ 

@/.?B"%G"%@/.6*21

5 6 = 5 89[$.) U

5 Q (+ h="/ (=0 ($ &b)D $ 

5 Vf'.$."S"b(S$.^8P  &

$.; (=="$ J 5 $

0


4 002'

' I$. 2n 5 (0 HtV,"/ ($"]="$%  5 =0HLO?$.\8P  &d 4
$.^ I$ 

@/.B?"%G"%@0.,

a!.="/ (=0 ($ ^ 4 $.+!989V= I$6 I$ ? 

& 3^ (

5 ,.g ;) I$ g89 &.L

U"$ =9 \ I$."W Q j"6 u S=0$ CPp|

$.[)D I$ h 




="/ (=0 ($^$X$.

= > ("=$ I$ 

7N  
!

F~}<|KQ|+~ !="$2 U$89L' ?89"$ DM

302m= ^& ($2kn 5 "$ 9 U"$^(P89($ g m$. "

7N/<
[N  %P  

7"/,"!"$="$% &O3Z

 ]D[$.B="/ =0l U$ ] ] WQHD8989="$ ?! 2HP' I$.b$.B"$0' 4

("="$+="/ (=0 ($ h"$2n 5 I"$B89"$6(/ ($ C6a!. D = 5 == 
2 (]JV

5 g 

rBV"/ U$"A\

U C
4 002'?$.+$ (89+8P  &[ 

4 002'+$.6$ 8968P ( &9 

"

bV"/ ($("

C
Z)D I$ ?$.) (
%303

89"$
$.) b6 (=="$ J 5 $6 )SV"/ U$"B ("$? = 5 ==2C

4.

IMPLEMENTING RELATIONAL OPERATORS OVER ENCRYPTED RELATIONS

*;$. _=$ 9Z

D="$ JV?.2f  % l 5 (0"$0 ($ ) 0VV"=M
U$"$

 5 /.^ ?=0$ OOQ OV=B I-"$O) g&"$ 5  &

V"/ ($("$Y@ XJV! 89089L$2W W$.!D"$V=X U/ J) (=? ("=M
/. I$, 5 "$CBr

5 "
Q="/ ($&H^ 
$9 ("=$ I$ ^$.689 5 / ($ ^ 4

$.;V"/ ($("$ "$=$.W0 % )]$.[="$"2CWEDV I`)2 (00IHLO
Z^' 00B (=$89DX$u89 5 $] j 5 V"$=,b 4

Q!"$S&"=M

5 = &^$.g U=="$ J 5 $P )D ;Q$("$2k U

U$2dJLHj$.PV"/ ($("

$.="$3"2C!a!.=W (Q!,"$?' 00F$.]JV+`)0I$"$2g (?$.+0 L

4 $"SD"=HD$ c$R&"/ U$b$.P=" 5 S"$ 5 0I$C-jS' 00? (=M
$89B$b89  89 vW$.[Z"$#h; ($.W0 LW 8

5 /.h 

V== J0C~e 5 "=$."$89("$O!!^' 00B="=Hc$d 5 "$h b8

5 /.k 

V== J0W$. ('V"/ ($("$BGD 5 $2bg$.0 L?= W ("$ 5 ,.
$. (>$.HS2 bJV 0 2S$;$.
 5 0? ("="$ % &;U3,">$. (M
QZ"?Q="$2 8{ ('=L^ ('$.HS ("="$ 3

,C@a!.

$.8

,"/ ($"$72 9JV'

4

' $. 5 B WS$;Q$("$

5 "$V= '$;& 5 U"/ L$+$. ('$.+0 L=MN= M

 L$0H; 89089L$2-C1a!.? 89089L/ ($ 
5 =2c k$.

V,"/ ($"$SD30Vk m$. 9=$ f' 00?JV

4 002' &P=$ O'."$B!+30] (] 0&J"/ ( 

4 "9"$>"$ I$ &uEo+pn 5 "$ 

4 "9$.g 5 "$V=b 4

*<]$.W JVU36(/ ($ OV![ ("$^$.?0

$.

4 R$.) Uh$.d=0\V,"/ ($"jGD 5 $R (h$.d="$"2C

00?M D"$mV"/ ($("$g U"$^ = 5 892m$u,G 5 $g (P$.
0 L2Cta!.^,"=HD$ mV"/ U$"; ' 00
0Hc#c$.^ U=M

J KMLON'P9J 4  I O- ()^D"$R 00F$.W$."  I (=="$ J 5 $C

T
ud,G0  i$.m JVU3d 89089L/ ($  5 = & G 890

J7U2N , C|x! =6+$._,`) I$  4 ? 7N   
0
0  TD
o A@CBAD TD>E  PAF
="$ J 5 $

 = 5 ==2P 9$.?D"$%  5 7=$ O%$.

JVU3?=0$ SV"/ UM

e"X,G0   &]$.P 89089L/ ($ d 4

) I$ 

Q b$.+="$"? 

$.=^ 

$&%('/)
$A*-,/.9,A*-,3= .

J
5

JUVN  }<|}
? +N 45

'JV 4 "$OV$.
= v$.

7N

}<|} I

J
9 _:&; z$< ' 5

0I

I =

'.,"$'$.' I$ 

hED$ %C

J7U2N I

/1*NM (7@'&)=" .$

  





 
 

C=.?B

  



'.,"$WV

C=.?B

"!#  &

'



"9B)*d.G"328:C G"@/.

VYX/Z[V  \
C VYX"$

4 "$;$\ R0 Q9 4



4M&6.8:G"%@/.3

4@(

u=b 4

(&&"$&3 ($ 

V"/ ($ C

U=="$ J 5 $;
"="$=V)DS$

b fG 890O>$.^DM

5
5R^`_ acb e' d g) f?h
09892 S$. (S!\"$2 ($R&"$ 5 

5 = &u (=="$ J 5 $3
4 "$0l U$ 
 O! () 4 "P /.k&("$ 5 k8XM
W
 5 $B$. vFL ~K
i  45 ,$ |CZa!.) U
OjVYXS
 OV ()WV 


Ik?lm
i cnpo CKa!.@"$ 5 0I$ &?"$0 ($ 6'
00%L/  W!


(=="$ J 5 $ 
q;
o C@f 5 0? X$.'"$ 5 0I7' 00V. UB (S%="=H
"/ U$ ]P

4 ("!2 (,.SD Q$ Z 0 5 ? 4 [O% ;$.' 5 8;JV,"@ 4  5 0_ X$.

&"$ 5 ]"$V("=$2h B (=="$ J 5 $"o;C'* 4

V 

jDOV0IH]&("$ 5  &P 

V" 4 "$892-C

/1*+**<N*E8FG"%@/.-, =v*5(7C G @ (/.10327.WZ= "? W=0$ ]V"=M

U$ 4035
0Z
 h W"$0 ($ R[OD'."$ i B X)D I$ ^=V IM
4 [
`2X9?"789"$' 4 $.
U=="$ J 5 $         
 C@
Q="/ ( &.L 4 ("=> ("/u 89089L/ ($ h 4

D% I"$89L? '$9="/ =89 '$.6"$0l U$ 

 I

4 "$8{$.6="$"
5 = &9$.

V"/ ($("2O> ()c 89089L$W$.g=0,$ |Cfa!. XQ="/ U$&HLO

.2!3,"2OV 5 =.'$.6L$ I"$!"$#g 4

89089L$ &W$.6=0M

$ b$[$.B0 L2C@*<b  I$ O$.BL$ I"$B"=HD$29"$0 ($ 

4 "$8

$.9="$3"6$g$.90 %2C]


(0I$"$) U$ W89,.  =8Y '$X) U"=$  00IH]89 5 $

$.=0$ 
V"/ ($("+ U'$.="$3,"
U=="$ J 5 $1 

[O 

5 = &X$.+ ) 

(==L  ($2]' I$.g$.
5 =.$.7"$ 5 0$|$?$.70 L2C@a!.70 L

D"=HD$K$.!"$ 5 0I$7 )6`)0I$"$_ 5 _ 5 0K$.) U7(_$ ($  4 H

[CZE%V I`)2 (00HLOD$.BV"/ U$"

2 ]JV
"$>"$ I=$^ 
6 5
0v

*<89089L/ ($ c 4

/. 2g (

6 587
6 9 I _ :&; z< ' 5

)

0I>=

4 002'

0[2 (fJV

$.g&"$ 5  &\V"/ U$"qPUT

4 00U'

PUT
 -PUT 7

 PT I

 5 /.j (\V"/ ($("6 j 5 "

$9$.[0 L2CBa!.^$.60 LD"=HD$'$.6"$ 5 0

2D6$^JVX="/ (=89 I=$2

D`)2


$$ (+*5$CEG"%@/.O,V=*5(7C G@(.QPR27.

V"/ U$ q P$2mJLHSPUT
 ,
 O

'. /.f$.^&("$ 5  &d SV" 4 ("$892O? ()-V

 


"!$# %&





  


!#"%$&(7*)(. , CE(+G "%G"%@/.

C GG (+"IH&G *A3:H

U 5 I( =

QVX$.>="$3"7 Z)D $ 

&"$ 5  &d k (&&("$&3 U$ 

4@'&(

J
5 G

5 =X$.XV"/ ($(";/ ($ W 

( C

Q \ +$bJV;GD 5 $2R (+$.;="$"2C

J
JUVN
 TDE   TD
U 5 

035?7&

O| 

$]$X<Zg"$0 ($ O_ 

  

fk "$89L']$. Q ^V"/ ($("+89.) (M

4 ($.) U+$.

45 $ Z 4

U 5  <
} |} C;e"= 890  I<HLO-Z9 = 5 89
$. (W$.
,$ c 4 U 5  U |} W$.P$ 89S W$.) U; 4
JU2N  J7|} O% (!=.2'P ge1 & 5 "$ D
 C@*<S  I$ OL! 5 =  ()

L035 7

="/ =0 ($2b$D

%<>7/)?%*-,.9,(*-,3=

*X$.'"$D  5 Z=$ 7!'.) 23'& 3P$.e?

O

e("P Q/ O< fV"/ ($ 

$."$%  5 >=$ 

JU2N  7
J |}

I R

J
/1*IH@'" .4,V=v*5(+CEG @(%.AJK27.ZZ= lD"K < 6V"/ U$  5 f!C
a!.Q
  S) I$ 3 5 0PJV
 $.">2n 5 0 I<H9)D $ 

'. /.q2 (=]$.V<
  q("="$=V9$d k2n 5 Q ',O'"P 5 0
JVP89"$9&"/ (0Z)D $ 
"$ 5 0I$ &^ j$.,/ (MaQ
  Y, Cha!.
JVU3 <
  ]V"/ ($ ^ ]JV+ 89089L$2b ( 4 002'

4 "/ 89Z"$#

V"/ U$"$O_!9' 00

 J7|}

+N3  
0
 v

Q ?

=0 I=$ &\$.

4 002' &c<Zu= 890 I`)2c"$0 ($ b 4

I G  J UVN I >=KO'."$$.
6 587
6 5

$ g' 001JV+="/ (=0 ($2] L$

n 5 "=HS89 5 / ($ ] ,"$='$.+0 L

b$.+=,"$3"2C
= D"b$.

V"/ U$"+$. (

G%M

f 5 V"$="$ :fKAk$q. &.0 &.L

 5 $R (h$.j="$3"^' I$.

G
0I >=    JFJ V Q



 TI g  T R V X


a!.) U? O$.="$3,"?' 001&("$ 5 b$."=HD$2P 5 0'J =2

R$.9 U=="$ J 5 $W 4

V X

CSa!.X="$3,"WLm
/W

V," 4 "$8

(LH

&&"$& ($ b"="$=V)D &$8V

 0 5 

 L
O = 
IZL7(Z. U
(LH
4 "P$.=h (=="$ J 5 $9 -V  Cta!.]"$ 5 0$P 4 P T I G ("$

"$ 5 "$2]$9$.W0 L2O'. ,.hV" 4 "$89

$.[&("$ 5  &SV"/ UM
$ rP

C@a!. _V,"/ ($ P2 (9JV> 89089L$2["=H;

= ;3"=H^ 5 0XJV0& &b$] b= &0X&"$ 5 \ 4

j P= &0"P

I G
Ts

&("$ 5 R89 5 $]J%Hg$.W="$3"2CW? P"$ 5 0I2O

$.'0 L70IH;2D7$= ,"Z 5 07 P = &0KP

'.X89 5 $ &'$.>&("$ 5 @"="$=V)D &B$P
$.W (&&"$&3 ($ 

 L$0IHLO

PUTj' 007JV

45 ,$ ?=V I`)] 4V 

C_r

TI G

&"$ 5 

4  5 "$=O

' 001JV689 5 $2

(@$.>0 %2O= !$. I"789 5 / ($ W"$2n 5 I"$K$.) U@ 5 0@JV

`"$Q
D"=HD$2-C

jBGD0l ( S$.B 89089L/ U$ 

5 = &W$.B,G (890?JV0UC

f h
JU2N 
P T
5 ^c_ja b 'D T  ) 8
a!. (W O1!X! L6$g`)R$.X 5 8;JV,"+ 4

}<|}  I
 k?lm

D) U"=$89L2Cp8Vt$\:

V"/ ($ ^ >="/ (=0 ($2S$

 PI

PUTK7&

a!. (' OD!B`"$Q'; [&"$ 5  &;S$.

J|}  n

o;C Aa!.

}<|}

}<|} I

(=="$ J 5 $+S$.

(=="$ J 5 $C_a!. !Q$P2 (PJVBD?

$.B 5 0!' I$.g$.

$ 89

}<|}

$.; (&&("$&3 U$ 

$; 5 %>$. 5 8;JV,"! 4 8902HLB D

/1*]*@(7G" .$

 %$0IHLO%= + 00

.) 23+ 0I"$2 %HgJVg&("$ 5 VbJLH

$.;="$"2C[e1  00IHLO-!XV" 4 "$8

,V=v*5(+CEG @(].

27.R

 

}<|}

4 "
2 /.

v+L~'K
J|} 
C

="=$ &RV"/ U$ 

T

0Z ? 

4 002'

T

T

0
 I
T

'."$?V
Q)i0 Q+ 4
4

(=="$ J 5 $C

4 00U' &hZP = 5 89;$.) U"$0 ($ VY ()

0 L2CP*<R$.

("$?=Z I-"$?89 ($ J0? 9 ("$?`2[("! U=="$ J 5 $

          (
i  "$=V$ 30IHLC@a!. 4 002>M
) i  i
   
&>" 5 0@2 (WJV 5 =
 2B$' 89089LV$.@=1 I-"$@V"/ U$"2



0

 Q

jb

  xw
  
  z?
 Q 

 PT I

0I

VQ
4

$.g U=="$ J 5 $; 

P TI G

V'C

* 4

P TI G

 T

]$.0 Q3V

9$.?"=HD$2
45 $ b 4

$.h8P  &

T I G CK

4 $"F$._"$ 5 0I$K ("$_"$ 5 "$2B$>$._0 L2O(Z

gO ()+V" 4 "$8

45 ,$ 

 003$._"=HD$ 

JLHS="=$ &X$.B 5 0>] (=="$ J 5 $

$.

V'C

T[V"/ ($ 

$+$. ('$.6 (89 5 L' 4 !"$#bW ('$.0 %'$98XM

 5 $

Tg bVQ$"$L== &9V)

5 VS'.$."!">!$.

U=="$ J 5 $K0 Q$2[ %VR. 23Z("/"=MN"$="$% &B8P ( &C1* 4 $.

U=="$ J 5 $>.) 23+("/"=MN"$="$% &;8P ( &O%$.P$.
"$ 5 0I$
"$, 5 "$mJLHd$.g="$3"S U"$]"$=("=$2

5 $R' $. q \ ("=$ IM

$ |C\a!. 5 O_="=$ &^$.P"$ 5 0I$; X ^= 890P0L2 0>V"/ ($ 
U3,"; b= &0P) U"=$ $ |Cb
0I$"$ ($ 30IHLO13j 4

$.98P  &

5 = 45 0!$R89 5 $qP

99("/"9D"$="$% &DOZ I9 

(X$.

=,"$3"Z$"$2 5 '$.
89 5 L7 4 0 L!!("$#-C@ED '$.' 5 0
. 23bJVk&("$ 5 V2mJLH\$.g=,"$3"2O


 L$0IH

T

e"+,G (890OV$.W=("=$ &SV"/ U$ 

089L$2S 

4 002'

 T
'."$rV
,"/ ($ 

2 cJVb 89089L$2

5 = &9 ;89"$&MN="=? (0&"$ I$.8]C

P  DT 

7&

 P I TD

 T

JUVN >2 (RJVW 8XM

JUVN I   =

 C
/1* &=/N9"98FC G *<; N9" " .)C G"%@0.S,V=v*A(7CEG @(r.  27._a!.Z 5 0 2 U$M
0 89 ) U$ 6V"/ U$"
! F 89089L$2?= 89 0 U"$0H
$>$.K&"$ 5 DM
&XV"/ U$"2

 PUT

'."$8VS0 Q? 4 00F U=="$ J 5 $

WC

CK

z '    E b  d/ )

I

i I  i I     i  I


C

(] u 5 V"$="$ b 4

$.^0 4 =M

Z$.) (>$.+V,"/ ($"

' 8XM

$

U 5

JUVN

OL$.) U> OZB> (L>$W`)S 00V$.+890UH3Z'.X ("$B

8P  &"$C7a!.6n 5 "=HP '="/ =0l U$2b$;$.



  TD
 TD
 Q 

 

TD


4 002' &Sn 5 ,"=H


 TD

 Q

 P I

I 
5I G U 5
   TD
JU2N I
T
  TD
 DT 


a!.S) I$ 

 Q> Y? 7N    
JUVN  J|} U 5  U | }    O
'.,"$   SD`)2k tE%$ 
 C
EDh>=="$ J 5 $ >=M
D
="$ J 5 $  2 (=7

 Q

4 cJ="$ ($ @ JV 5 1$.Z (JVU3Z 89089%/ U$  4 $.

==M I-"$[V"/ U$"W ("$;$,!"=$.LHLCWe1 I"$Q2O$.;&("$ 5  &



$.X"$ 5 0I$6J) (=2jd G\ U=="$ J 5 $6 WW=$ U"=H

$.) UW OK$.X="/ =0l U$ d! 5 0uJV9"="$;3j' I$. 5 W$.
&"$ 5  &hV"/ U$"2C\a!.9"$2 (=

4 ("X 0 5  &]$.S&("$ 5  &

V,"/ ($"? >$.) U' ' ]= & I`)2 (%$0IHP"$2 5 B$.+89 5 / U$ 
\$.90 L2C]e"WG 890O1 5 X$g$.9&"$ 5  &gV"/ U$"2O
00B$.] 5 0S$. (b.) 23h



pFp 0 5 

4 "

U=="$ J 5 $

' 00KJVW&("$ 5 V2]$&,$."2C#t.]$."$ 5 0$ &P 5 0

4 $.
=6D I-"$XV"/ U$"W U"="$ X (B$.;0 L2O| 5 /.^ 5 0B2 
JV!D"=HD$W ()$.7"="$=V)D &

c

5 07 8989  ($0IH+"$,M

 TI

0I =
'."$

$. (7 5 0P 5 =?$.?V$L$  00 89  ($ S 4

=7 I-"$! 89089L$2[$.!0 L@= >8P H60HWJVZ"$,M

Q="$ $2X$6$.=' 5 0
'



4 "!'. /.9$.'("="$=V &

 0 5 

pFp@C

e 5 "=$."$89("$O2 89 5 $ &7$.@"$7Q,$ $!$._ (=="$ J 5 $

4 c
 ]fb ()B$.@ 5 J=2n 5 %=1 I-"$@JV<Z+$.@!

"$7Q$ 
!W0IHg2g$9= D" 9= &0W&"$ 5 
JLH

P TI

 5 0

V"/ ($(" (B X$ 89C'a!.) U+ O-

L7&"$ 5 X' 00V70 89  ($

Dq 5 0

4 "$8

4 ("$892

4 "$8 9D -,"=M

$.,"Z&("$ 5 C

a!. 5 OV" 4 ("$89 &[$.+&"$ 5  &X U?$.+="$3,"'= lDOD'. 0
=$ ("=HLO% 5 09= & `2 L$0IHX"$2 5 '$.?89 5 / U$ P (7$.

 T

0 L2C
' g (=="$ J 5 $

a!. (' O%!B`"$Q>&"$ 5 P$.

"=HDD$2X 5 0>S$.B="$"
5 = &6 00D$.' (=="$ J 5 $@ m



089%$h\$.;="$3,"= C2u; 00 5 Q="/ U$X$.X (JVU3[" 5 0

& 5 0Z 4

D"=HD$_$.?"$ 5 "$2; 5 0O ()P 0 !$.?="=$ &[V"/ (M

$.=' 5 0_ 4 [
 CK
O3$.'D"$+<$ S ;$.' 5 J=2n 5 L

$ 

0v




 5 "$2; (Z (P Q!"2C@a!.>"$2 =9 @$.) U@$."$' U"$?+8P ($/.M

J|} C6a!. ( O-!W`"$QBV" 4 ("$8 9&"$ 5  &bM


]$. JUVN I "$0 U$ h]$.6="$"2C'a!.60 L

 dxw
  
b  d/z?
 Q 

$."$ 5 &.j (\G (890C;E 5 V=W!;! L+$S89 5 $

("$b 00>"/D"XD"$="$% &O@$. [&"$ 5  &

V"/ U$ q2 (kJVb"$0 2kJLHm h"="$=V)D &u="=$ &

V"/ ($ 

 

5 $"vQ g89. = v

"="$=V)D &9$;$.

$.=h 

I _ :&; z<

9

I   I     I 

rBh &3 ( |OB$.^QHD8;JV0[f

G
0I =

a!. (> OLZ+W 6&"$ 5  &WV"/ ($ 

U=="$ J 5 $





5 =[$+892 ( & 45 00IHW"$2 5 Z$.' (89 5 %1 4 !("$#;D' (@$.

'.,"$8V-

 PT I

 DT 
T
JU2N I  =

f!CBB2!3"2OV$.6 )D +Q$("$2h (+$.W=,"$3"+ RQ$ 00KJV



O)Z`"$Q
="=
^) U"=$ I$ ^ 
(?$.="$3,"2C>a!.6Q="/ U$&H

T

JUVN ' 

/1*/**5G " *5(+*1.?8F*S,V=v*5(+CEG @(S. 27. *<89089L/ ($ b 4


(_$.>="$"Z 7  5 0IZ= O
' I$. 5 ?`"$Q
,"=HD$ &;$.+"$0 ($  
()
O) I? 
89VQM
= J06$P$00|'.$."B("+B P& 3] 5 0W 4 ~
 (0=g (V2 U"$

 6JV@ 89089L$2

= 89 0 ("$0IHB$!$.@&"$ 5  &'V"/ ($("2C@a!.) U
$; 89089L

P

7&

$.'D I-"$?V"/ ($ 

Z',"=HDK$.> (/ %OL [V" 4 "$8i$.!&"$ 5  &+V"/ U$ 9
$.

8902HL u2 (,.

4 $"?$.6&"$ 5 V2g 5 0

("$"$ 5 "$2b$9$.0 L2O

=,"$3"2C?

%C9e"6G 890O|$.XV,"/ ($ 

="/ =0 ($2b$D

JU2N I   =

TD

gD"=HD$2S ('$.+0 L2OZV" 4 ("$8Y$. 5 0 2 U$+0 8XM
) U$ uV,"/ ($ 

4 $,"_$.!"$ 5 0I$7 ("$>"$ 5 "$2

EDO%3X' $.P$.
JVU3?D$ 89 v ($ OD$.
89089M
/ ($ ^ 4 $.6==MD -,"$V"/ ($("
$.6="$"B=. 5 0l]JV

5 = &;$.6 5 $"=MaQ ^

5 =g' $.^ ("$C

i) ( 36Q="/ ($&(H^ ?$

="/ =89 I7$.?%$ I"$>"$0 ($ 

 I



$$.?0 L2OL'. /.

8P LH689VL$ $.>*<rq 9!z

()^89 5 $'$.6=D -,"$C+a!. 

) ( 

D"=HD$'$.8

Q_ 4  (0 5 ($ &B$.

Q="/ U$&H]89 &.L

JV6/.2 (V"B$. ]$."$%  5 BQ="/ ($&H]= 

n 5 "=Hb U?$.="$3"2OD$.<Z"$#P="/ =89 == ]Q2O) b$.

$.>= v> 4 $.> 5 $"Q ;89 &.L@JV>n 5 %"/ ($ !"$ 5 0$ &+ X. &.

*<rq X!z

="/ (=89 == R ^,"=HD$ ]Q+89) U"$2b$9$.Q="/ U$&H

Q2C7e">,G (890O%= ,">$.

="/ (=89 I=$ &9$.W<!P"$0 ($  )D %  5 00IHR R89 5 =M

&b$.W=6D I-"$X (B$.;0 L2C0t. ,.hQ="/ ($&HR 

5 =2

5 V^ %$&"/ ($ &S 5 "

}<|}




$. ? V"2C

Y."%@/.

/1*

,V=*5(7C G@(S.AZc27.
a!.,"$; U"$W==L$ l (00Hg<!PD 4
M

5  SV"/ U$"$'J) (=2SS$.BJ &X ()9$.

='=8P DM
4 "$89"KL1F0 89  ($! 5 0 2 U$O('. 07$.70 (=M

$ CKa!.

$,"6LC[a!.; 89089L/ U$ h 4

5  RV,"/ ($"6J =2

$.

]J) (&X=8P (%$ ' 'Q="/  &.L 4 "=> U"/

0I?ZI

* 4 Z
' =.b$[89 5 $'$.
I?2 (]JV+89 5 $g 

5  

I

5 "Z$.B=,'=8P L$ O

4 00U'



I >=

TI
 I Z I
 I
T

'."$8VS0 Q? 4 00F U=="$ J 5 $

WC

 T

'."$

q. 0S$.b 89089%/ U$ u 4 $. 5

$.) Uh OrZ I g
 hQ="/  &.L 4

=,"$3"R= 

' g (=="$ J 5 $

 cV"/ ($("Xd$.

"=> U"/O[$."$u R

$,. 2 0_/.) 00&X$.) U6 ("$ =CbE%V I`) 00IHLOF= ; 5 0 

 I Z I
I

 I

 5 0lW"$ &  ($> I$.," 4 "$8

"

O($BJVZ J0!$

45 ,$ j U+$.[0 L2OF (+!00

(0H^$.["="$WD"=HD$ 

(W$g"="$,$0Hj %$,"$"$6$.; (0 5 W \$.X )DGj (=="$ J 5 $

4

$.9"$ 5 0I9 U;$.S=,"$3"2O@!P' 00>Q$("$] (c D I$ ) (0' (=M

="$ J 5 $] c$.g"$ 5 0IP 4

("$ & c 4

I ,C
D &P

("

$.X 5 0

$.

5  m$.) (;' 00

$,"$89 b$.
4 "$8

$.) U6 OK'.$."W ["$ &  ($

 I

5 /.\ (R (=="$ J 5 $; +" 5   0 4 ("+$.W("="$

89089L/ ($ O@J 5 W!P' 00? &"$S IX d$.b = 5 == m$
45 00_"$= j 4

#h$.9 (0&J"/ b= 890CXa!.

00 5 Q="/ U$>$.B2

$.X) (V"

4 ("'8P  L/   &6$.B  I$ ) (0 (=="$ J 5 $

()k$.]"$ 5 0I$ &c89%D `2 ($ 9$u$.^8P ( &

45 $ 

()]D30V2g (0&J"/ %C







e"? Q/ O!.) 23

5.

T
0v

 I 

 TD
JU2N 

 TD

JUVN I C

OL 5 "7 5 "$V=

X$. 7=$ P 7$WD30

]Q="/ U$&H\$]=0 IW$.989 5 / U$ j 4

()j$.S0 L2C\a!.S="$3,"[' 00

:

="$C

89

5 +' I$.W$.[:JVQ$A?n 5 "=HB0 

4 (" 

5 "1JA<$ 3! F$

$. (189  89 v$.

,G 5 $ ;Q2C@*; 5 "Z=,=$ &O3$.!QZ 4 n 5 "=HW= Q$7 4


0  &

M

"=HD$2P"$0 ($ C

 

T+ &


 

=0M

5 0I$ 0

L$"/ ($ 

JV<ZhZ0 L
]ED,"$3"2C

 
 @

 M 

!#"%$'&(7* .
&*5( =/N%C=.?3L4d@( *
=/N%@ '*5*E3 m1@
C * R@(7*
G1C=. C56'*5(+CE$*3 C3N%C (
@04 *
N@ '*5*A3
1 @SC (7*4" . ?

B "9BJ4,

J 9F

L' 9 H v~ 9

 vLJ
   
    
~< v
M=v v

v 
  9 %        ! 
     
9 L %' ~F F ~


~vLJ ; L L%F L % $ F%
 

5Fv
~
=  
L

:
?r
"$ &  0Fn

5 "=HP="$C

("$=W$.9="$"

5 /.; 4 $.?n 5 "=H; ZV== J0O%"$0&3 U$ &6$.>"$M

) 4161783=

%
L$ Laa@ J aaBLa
J L ta

 yLtaz JtvuawByLtaz
%
La =J v9BLa
n
= HJ
s+tvuaw5x yLtaz { |}tauawBy~t9z

o5pHqJr J9 a

v9a a= L 9 vaBL9
n

9
t
=

x
{
J

~= F=5 9 aL
y

o=pq r
=HJ



!#"%$'&(7*#".

5 =9$.P 89089%/ U$ u 4

8P ( ),"1 4 $._89 5 / U$ $?$.70 L2CKr

'
J 

n 5 "=H

r
"$ & ) (0

$.B"$0 ($ ) 0V,"/ ($"$?D = 5 ==2S S$.

"$%  5 >=$ g$
89 5 $? Z8

JUVN

@c dBe Y;f d
d fHjJk ]=Y$^%hFlmi Y$Z$[;]5Y'^
>@?BA /$C ?
S
X
Y;Z'[+\%]=Y$^ _a`bY;Z'[<]=Y$^
? CHGJI 45/'6LDFKME /;0$1;4=/$6
+
T
U
V
W
)+*-,
.
/$0$132%45/'6 798:/;0'1<4=/$6
NO$P%O'Q R
S
!"$#%"'& (
]g
T+U-VMW
)+*-,

ALGEBRAIC FRAMEWORK FOR QUERY

SPLITTING

> 3P Wn 5 "=H

$&%(' 0(1#%3$K$&%('

    $&%(' 416178 ) 

 $&%A'     ,(*-,= 

$ ^ (?="$3,"2C

/1*T, (+@ *A8:G"@/. ,V=v*A(7CEG @( . 27.ZED Z2 /.[ 5 0Z X '"$0 (M
k @"=HD$2+$&$.,"@ L$B
= &0>Q="$ &B [$. J KQLONP9J
U=="$ J 5 $6 4 "$0 ($ R I U
$.W=,"$3"2OV XD"$+<$  \ ?(
89089L$2g U
$.="$3"2C'?? ;"$ 5 0I2O)$X89 5 $ T
0,
 O
'."$ j
V _ +=Z 4 (=="$ J 5 $O$.>Q="/ ($&(HX @$B="/ =89 @$.
890$["$0 ($ - I $b$.;0 %2OF"=HD$.W"$0 ($ c U
$.0 L2O) ()S$.g89 5 $B$.B"$7Q$ |CZa!.) (? O
$ 

4 002' &Pn 5 "=HX("!$.

/ J0X$.) (B"$="$ 368902HLB'.=9$ 0 ("=H\ 6&"$2 U$"6$.) (

JLH

4 "/ (89!("$#] %$

9Q=MNJ) =Rn 5 "=Hg$ 89 v"2O)'. ,.^ BJV,HLb$.6=V[ 4

4 "$L

Q_ (@$.70 %2CKk ("$ <H6 4 V== J 0 I$ _G%M

$.' 23,"/ &?$ 0 U"=H9 4 890UH3@ X$.') ("=$89%@ DL$ `2

DV 5 V6$._L$LF 4 $._"$0l U$ C7E%0$ &?$._=VM

 `[Q="/ U$&H]V)


J F

4 $"K"$0l ( &B' I$.

"=HD$S"$0 ($ C

6EC3N9&CEG"%@/.

@04 C @'".%$)&)*A( H

a!.B"="$=V)D &9n 5 "=H9="$ S=89+ 4 $.B 0 5 ($ 
Q="/ ($& P ("$g 00 5 Q="/ U$2c ke1 & 5 "$
Q="/ ($&H

e1 & 5 "$

:
W$


 ,Cca!.b`"$Q
JUVN / UM

E
J'>X b$c= 890IHm="/ =89 IS$.

J0$;$.W0 L2O'. ,.^ (0 5 ($'$.6n 5 "=HLC7

^ (0$,"$) ($ 3

%J#I$&%('



   

SUT
VWOXZY [I\[]^W`_NaY [ \[



 

"!# $&%(')+*-,/.0213,/45.6'*
Q

c h3nIf&o(pq



702$/8:9+;<=<=>

r s/t

s/w=tUxp r-

d2u

f/z:{}|2~=~=
d

R
0

* ,/.-021,/4=.6' *-K

$=!3@BADCFEGH!3#I$%J'2)

$5!F@LADCFEMG02$/8:9+;<=</>

N

/=U :

4 $"? 5 00 &

&:}25/

/=U -

/:}2==

3
O=3BDF2 /-/+&v /-/
`N

3

g5FLDFF-M 3-/73=5 3-/

+g
5FBBH3I&(Z/

U 3
O=3BDF2 3-/73=5 3-/

5FLDF
/=U2 +g



< |C

4 $"'"$>"$ I$ &

7N  
}<|}

(7*

&*5(

(+"%G" .)$

$.

J7U2N

JU2N I

/ (J0OZ C CO

4 ("' W& 3Sn 5 "=HX="$

$6JVB=0 I> L$<Z[ ("=$



$R 0 5 U$S$.S"$8P  )D"X 4

 5 /.^$.) U+89QB 4

$.gn 5 ,"=HLC7; ($."XVQM

=,"$3"2C[a!.) U OF=0,$.6 5 0B"="$=V)D &b$P$.[8XM

0UH3$.) UWZ"$#R u) ("=$89%

}<|}

Cba!.X"$ 5 0I$[ U"$

"$ 4 "="$[$ 

|$.) (_GD

5 $@ U

5 "BJ5Q$ 3[' 00KJVW$b89  89 v$.W89 5 / U$ 

="$3,"2CWr

E
>+ W$^ 0 5 ($X$.9 "[n 5 "=Hj (6$.

5 $| (|$._="$3"

$.?0 L'J) (=29P$.

"$ 5 0I$! 4 $.Bn 5 "=H; (0 5 ($b U!$.

(0&[' $.b$.B"=HD$P"$D"$=L/ ($ ] 4 $.+=' 4  5 0

e1 & 5 "$

I V$. (1,G
5

"$ 4 "="$2+$?  

$. (
$ ($  4 Hg$. "+n 5 "=HLC!a!.60 %B"=HD$>$. 5 0

5 "=H9="$C

`"$Q2O3 W$.>0 L_) U"=

O

/:+=/(

1*A&(+"93 G"9884@( @'".%$)&)*A(+"%*A3

$.@="$"1 ("=

,
 Cga!.9="$3"W=$g$.



$.) U> (002

(Z8P LH[ _V== J0@ 5 07"=M

0 L9$.g"=HD$2d3"$= f 4

5FLDFM
/=- +g


 !a!.+`) 0|n

E
7>7 Z$;89 5 $') ("=! 4 $.

"'n 5 "=H

e1 & 5 "$

U7$.'="$3"2O3'. ,.X=0$
"$=V)D &]$

+O
=3BDFH3IJ2+/

/:+==(

N

! "$'&(7*.



7
 !

Q="/ U$&H

3/= -/Z 3 2 /-/+&v /-

N

JIJ

 -/73/= -

5 g=0,$ C

JI&(

3I&(

f&z:{}|2~5~/(y
d

VFWOX7b


J !



N 
3I&(

d f5hFiBjBklm
s/w5txpr-y c+eg

dvu

XaMNb

4 $,">"$>"$ I$ &9=0$ C

W`_Nab
R

c+eg
d f5hFiLjDkFlMmHh3nIf&o(pq+r-s/t
K

O7

:
>

US T
VWOXZY X\[]XaM Y X\[

= J 0 I<H

oJnIfoJp

C_a!. (7 OL!>! 5 09 (=$89D@$+"$>"$ I$?$.

n 5 "=H[="$O
$.W-"=B 4

 (0 5 ($ &9$.Xn 5 "=HgL 5 "$

('$.+="$3"2O b$.B0 %

DL'0 QB 89 5 L> 4 Z"$#VC

u_ 00

5 Q="/ ($7 5 "F 2 ( 5 = &'G (890CK?1 !`"$QFG 890O

= "@$.

4 002' &Wn 5 "=H6$. (@89 5 $1$.! 89K 4 $.

=. V2\$]$.90 L2OK'. ,.u"=HDD$6$.X 5 0; ()j8XM

8P  &"$@ 4 $.=>8902HL1!("$#D &+["$7QW:< =#DD"$ 3A

 5 $_ 23"/ (&>$ (0l U"=HLC_a!.> 23,"/ &'$ (0l U"=HX @,"=HD$26J%H6$.

'.=6$ 0 ("=Hb ?89("$+$.) (

 

0 L? ()b=. V2PJ) (,#X$W$.+="$"2O%'. ,.S$.S89 5 $

< R (
$.6="$3"2CBe1 ) (00IHLO)$.W"$

$.

5 0I$+ U"$;D"=HD$2^ U

$.0 L2C

FF

%(0(1#%<$

  $&%('.%(>7/.;'+7+@B

    '+7A@B '0(1#%3$ ,(*4 +,7(* +$
 '+7+@B !'<*:,  $&%(' '<*-,
 $&%A' 416
 $&%A' ,(*-, 
 %<>7 ,A*-, 

5.1 Heuristic Rules to Separate Queries

*N6=. 5 0R 89892D  ($0IHhJVXJD%  5 +$.) UW S"$ ,.\=6 4

= J 0 I$ 6GD Q+ \ (0 5 ($ &S Sn 5 "=H^ h 5 "
$. (S$.R = 

V,"2C

5 "S (=$899 P"$ 8P ("$ 0IHc$uQ/ (J0 =.f$.

$. 
 (M

4 2 = J 0 I<H

45  5 "$_Z"$#VC1*Q$2 O( W$. F=$ |O(!7' 00L"$Q="$ 

5 "$=03
$S X= 890"?/ =#

SZW' 001GD0("$[. 5

3 7

"$ Q$ " 5 0

&MF

M

4 "/ 89Z"$#VO| )

4 $.D"$V=]89%0O )bQ=MNJ) (=2g$ 89 v2 ($ ^ '"$0M
& ($2$

M

VQM

$.hG ,]n 5 ,"=Hq0 (t=. 5 0qJVRQ

J =2-C?a!. 
$ OV.2!3,"2OV B 5 $= $.6=V[ 4

&

M

a!.6`"$Q
Q$h 
$9%3"=?$.[ JVU3Wn 5 "=Hg L$P 9("="$M
=V &Rn 5 ,"=H\="$OZ ()u$h8P   5 0 ($9$.bn 5 "=Hj="$9$
&"/ U$
+&L%X0 

4 "$0 ($  0F 0&JD"/

5 = &B$.>Q/ ) ("/9n 5 ,"=HW"$,>"$ $'0 '

 , C7e1 &

5 "$

A
:Z=.2'>$.Bn 5 "=HX="$

g'. /.b$.B<ZX=0$ 

. 23+JVb 5 =.2b2'b$;"$0l UM
$ 

N+ :



J7U2N

CFED _"$0 U$ K U"$7"=HD$+ +Q$"$2

R$.6="$3"2O-!6`"$Q
"$0 (;2 (,.h"$0 ($ 
' I$.h"=HD$2b"$0l U$ 
A
J,C

e1 & 5 "$

 I

h$.;n 5 "=H
D

C?a!.6"$ 5 0$ &P="$W 

=.2'h 

><C(@ B
  

?9 IPQ/ )DO>$.b 5 "="$LSn 5 ,"=Hd="$]"$2n 5 I"$X$.]L$ I"$

N F : I

"$0l U$ 

J7U2N I

O7 ()

U 5 I

j

4"65 

($ >$.) (_ ;$.>"="$=V)D &+="$O

$.'="$3"Z 7) U"=$   ($ &6 9$.' 0 5 U$ P 4 $.>!6=0M
$ j) I$ C;ED ; 5 "+J5Q$ 3; 
$gV" 4 "$8

(8

0  _hc E G T
  T   G
J
  DT >E $  
   T 5 = &

5 $.@<!?0 L=MN= lDZ=0,$ ;)D $ 

() 0
E  FAF (JV(!$.Q 9V"/ ($("
$.[Q/ () ("/^"$>"$ I$[" 5 0B %30D &S=0$  ^"$0 ($ ) 0

_a9

(0&JD"/  
j+2 (]2

 
  "!# $ &% ('*) +-,
. ) /

 

"$>"$ I$$.n 5 ,"=H9="$6 &  

O
o

  

?GD 5 $g ('$.="$3"2C7e1 & 5 "$

TD

E
,O8

0 L=MN= 

V)D2S

L$6$.
="$3"=MN= 

Q ZJV &X (J0B$[

$.Bn 5 "=H[="$:D 

 @"$V ($2D0H["$>"$ I$ &6$.?. &."=MN030

5 = &W$.+V"/ ($("

89089L/ ($ !0 Q$b b$.

V"/ ($ 

D"$%  5 '=,$ |C

JV_ 5 00

5 $.7n 5 "=HB="$Z (1 I1 1 00 5 Q="/ ($26 $. 4 002' &

n 5 "=H]$.) U+"$="$ 3+$.;=,6 4

8902HL?'.]DbZ"$#

4 "]$.\8P () (&"^ 892Y:<xZJC A

a!.\("="$=V &fEo+p

n 5 "=HS '=.U'gJV0U

l 3 63q T b

t

t
p

 !
 e1  0Fn

4 $"7 5 00 &6=0M

$ ^ b"$7Q$ |C

!#"%$'&(7*.

&*5( R(7*

8P   5 0 U$2

(+"%G".$

5 "=H9="$C



4d@(C

3 *5G;xB?" *5(7*d.8:* $)&)*A( H

5 = &'$.7V"/ U$"@ 89089L/ U$ 6 = 5 ==2[ 

$.>D"$%  5 @=,$ |O3"$ 5 0I$ & ;$.!`) (0D="$'=.U'; Xe1 &(M



 ,CSa!.X`)) (0_="$XV"

4 ("$8968

5 /.R 4

$.Xn 5 "=HR8XM

 5 / ($ k (;$.g=,"$3"2OZ )d$.P"$ 5 0$P U"$]D"=HD$2c ()

`)0I$"$O )P$.+`) 0 (Q!,"B ' 0 5 U$2g U?$.0 L2C

5 =X ]==M I-"$SV"/ U$"2CjZ= "X

,G (890OK'. /.

 
   

 7

l
t  3 "m 

t-

5 "$

a!."$P ("$P= I 5 U$ 6'.\$.9=0$ dV,"/ ($"[2 ((

v  3 "qm "

oqrt
p svuwxyzl{ h3| s d6h
}~ Tv~ l p

5 "

5 00V$.
=0M

l
rtsvuwxyzl{ h3e g"}dme g

t p

)

$ jV,"/ ($ [ (JVU3X$.""$0 ($ ) 0_V,"/ ($ W. &.,"6 

3 qm <
63 T

5 ,.W 4 $.!!("$#[ 4

$.'="$3,"! U"$
D"=HD$X ;`)0I$"$29 U7$.?0 L2C_r

 5 =' S=0 I=$ &[$.+n 5 "=H

-3 l m

n 5 "=HXD"$L== &W >

(Z$.'="$3"2C_a!.?"$ 5 0I$!JD/  2
4 "$8

-m

h3e g"}dme g

$."$%  5 '=$ O- g&'$.+`)) (01n 5 ,"=HS="$OV (

=.U'
$ !$. (_ ;$.Z="$> 4 1
e & 5 "$

i

c-dfe g

oh3e g}qdfe g"<h
| s dmh3}~ T~

0  _a; E G T   T
  G _h9 E 

() 0   TE      TD
D
J FAF
(JVU3]$.V<
  qV"/ ($("  TD>E  
 TD C a!.kZ]"$0 (
$. Q
  gV"/ U$"
J) =gS$.+ 89089%/ U$ ]D = 5 ==2b 
E
 ,
 C


J b
,>"$ $ &t I-"$
5 = &[ 5 $,"Q
  C

c-h3e glk dme g

A
7!=.2'

EGFHI

V"/ ($("

=0$ 

I L
MN O P"Q"R CS L ?TCU*V W-X3Y V Z

J K
I

^E9_ I

cih
e g

$.;n 5 "=Hb="$; 4 $"+$."$>"$ I$ &C+e1  00IHLOV!W 5 00|$.<Z

e1 & 5 "$

5 ,"=HR="$;' I$.Q 

089L/ ($ q = 5 ==f f$.^D"$%  5 P=$ |O? 5 /.f$.) U

  TD>E 



89 5 / ($ ] (BE%"$3"2C

A
J',
 C
< ] 8XM

5 = &W$.

=
[ \]
B U*?A@ 3
B Z
K9L
M N O P"Q R C@ 3

495 

n 5 ,"=H^="$9 [=.U'j je1 & 5 "$

C^a!.9

J:C@ B3U*?A@ B&abCS L ?TCU V W-X
Y V

^E9_ I

5 /.

$.989 5 / ($ d U6$.9="$3,"X (WV== J0O@!9G%[ 5 00

>:?T@ B

0 12
 ' %  3/
   "! #  3

$ S0 Q$29 X$.>D"$%  5 7=$ 9"$ 5 0$ &W X$.

n 5 "=H[="$
E
:,C

> C@ B

: 3' %  &;$ &% '<) +-,
. )

G%"$0 (9$.X=0,$ dV"/ U$ WJLH^$. I"W 89089L/ UM
=.2'9 Xe1 & 5 "$

C@ B3U*?A@ B

 % 

$\JVS=L[$h$.P0 L

$. (X' 00'"=HD;$.S"$0l U$ X$R 0 5 U$S$.]n 5 ,"=HLC

>:?A@ B

$0A1#%3$
$A*:,



uB.) 23B)

5 $bGDV"$ 89L$Z$[=.2

$.+ 0  I<Hb ()

$.,-$ 3=' 4 $.6 U"$,. I$ 5 "$D"$V=2] g$. ') (V"2C

$&%('
)
K$#%('.%<>7
%*-, FM $0(12%3$

 
 $A*-, 

    $A*-,
&

6. EXPERIMENTAL EVALUATION

*<S$. '=$ OZ"$=L' 5 "?GDV"$ 89L/ 0V"$ 5 0$C



A@-D+

= &u$.hQ="/ U$&Hq = 5 == (JVU3O'!h2 (t2 = 0IHtM

uu"/ ($.\$Q$\JLH

5 $ 0 v &

a>z77MN

JV/.8P U"$#

a>z77M~JV,.8P ("$#] (/ (J) =; B"$2 ($\ U=2 0



C O3'. /.X U"$> 0=B"$ 4 "="$26$+ (1$.

4 $("

y]xd 

:

 C

 C D
y]x

 U/ J =["$=V$ 30IHLC

a!.WGDV"$ 89L$?Z"$W 5 ,$2^

O
,C
* 4

O
,O
JU2N I OZ 
$.g="$"X' 00
 5 J89 I;$h$.b0 %;$.b"$0l U$ 
Z00! (6$.X"=HD$2R Q!"$W&"/ ($jJLH^$.qJ I V"/ (M
$("2C!a!."$7Q,$  4 002!2]JLHP$.=,=M<D I-"$V"/ U$"
' 00'JVb 89089L$2u (;$.S0 %2C $ S= S$.S=0M
$ q mD"$+<$ fV"/ U$"$92 ((PJVg 5 002k (JVU3b$.

<Zg*<x>y*<L$0IMNJ) (=2RV,"$=) (0789 5 $"$B' I$.uz1%$ 5 8

=,=M<D I-"$
V"/ ($("2O% Z !

$ 0
/ (J0OD 4 ) U"=$  5 0 ("> L$"$Q! S 5 ">GDV"$ 89L/ 0Q 5 DH

"=
$.;n 5 "=Hg L$9$.Wn 5 "=HS="$W=.2'h \e1 & 5 "$V

ZW ("$$9GD 5 $+$.6n 5 "=Hb0 (] 00 5 Q="/ ($2] he1 & 5 "$V

 5 0I7$W (0IH[$.' 89089DM

 F

ygBvZ"$L==("$K' $.

"$+V," 4 "$89R (B$.[="$3"2O ()h $.";V" 4 "$892h (

5 =dZ"$]*<x>y
Tx  E
 %C
t )2' FF: (?$.+V"/ U$ &9QHDQ$8]C
m*(N%C G"@/.?3:.Vq
 . 0;$.;a>zZ7MN JV/.8P ("$#g 0 5 D8

 LX= 4 > ("$^89VL$

("$P$.

$ 2b$.

0 

= &]$.9"$>"$ I$


J ,C uW2 R2

 5 00F$.

@7,+$7

5 0M

/ J0CuP) U"=$ IM

4 ("
$.=B/ J0

6-,(*4 @:E0+F/.56-E(1-0+F(*:F8

E<4:FF($8/.
@+4*<*&''+7(*@7A*-F8

9@@7,+$7,A1F+$.
@

E<4-FFA$8

zK ("=$ I$ K.) 23_JVW"$2 U$2WJ =266$.7) U"=$ $  &

"$ IM
$"$  XD="$ JV2bJV02CZaF;"=HDZ$.B"$2'' 4 $.B"$0 ($ O

=0$ B b"$7Q$ B JVU3+$.+ 5 $"vQ O"$ 5 0$ &9 

!

$.>n 5 "=HB="$!=.2'X [e1 & 5 "$




7
 ,CKe1  00IHLO$. 1="$Z2 [JV

4 002' &S (=="$ J 5 $

964*<*:'+,+1F+$.

4 "B=+D I-"$O)$.6("="$=V &9="$6 B89%D I`)2b$

$.Xn 5 ,"=Hg="$[=.2'\ Re1 & 5 "$D

6*:0A$A*-F$&% O E<4-FA@2%3$7 OZ 

 *:0A$A*:F+$&%
 7,+$7A4

E<4-FA@2%3$7

5 = &X$.60 4 =MN 5 $"

= 89 0 ("7$$.' 89089L/ ($ X 4 =Z I-"=M

S = 5 ==2u u$.9D"$%  5 W=$ ,C

()

yg "$= 4 

=$ X$+ 0 5 ($!$.>=,ZD I-"$' (@$.!=,"$3"2C@a!.!="$ /#

?$P"$,>"$ $6$.6==MD -,"$6V"/ ($("

*=*=*

y]xuBBy\CrB7 4 $.Z89 5 =M

$.;0 %[ ("/D &g$] 5 "60 L<(=,"$3"[ ("$/. I$ 5 "$CP?0IM

/ U$ W 4 $._==M I-"$@V"/ U$"@D = 5 ==26 +$._"$%  5 

< SV"/ U$"

(

5 =2$.ZxZ0U>`=.X"=HD$ [ 0&("$ I$.8

3 2 DC

I72 89089%$

, C (7G"%G "%@/.?" .)$

0l (==S 4

N$@(+"%G1

. u

5 =W2n 5 M' D$.W ()62n 5 IM

( $P ("=$ I$ ^$.W U/

D$.^. Q$&"/ (89

4 "
<ZbD I-"$L

n 5 "$ Ct7n 5 IM' D$.f )m2n 5 IMD$.c. Q$&("/ 89

5 =2P )X %3Q$ & ($29 9$.'L$G%7 4 =M

. 23'JV9' 0IH

0,$ % I<HXQ$ 8P ($ S b (/ (J) =

%
 O  C_T+/ ( 0SD="$ $ 
( C

$.'="$"!=0,$7$.

&*5(+"%*A3.jZ= ,"$2W!+D I-"$LKn

 5 I$6$;"$=L?$. 0 5 ($ ^ 4

5 ,"$  4 "$8ia>zZ7M

$.6 I-"$L
=V$B 4

$.j U"$,. I$ 5 "$C{a!.h`"$Q]n 5 "=HLOB g=.2'

n 5 "=H

b j=0$ 

4 "$8

e1 & 5 "$

=)c u$. I"/dJ) ("$[=.2Y$.gn 5 ,"=HDMNGD 5 $ j$ 89

 O- + X89%D `2g3,"$= h 4 a>zZ7MN~n 5 "=Hb 5 8[JV" DO-DM

$2

%CYa!. ]n

5 "=Hk %303b Q 

4 ("

GD 5 $2; 9 5 "! U"$,. I$ 5 "$C

a!.=?GDV"$ 89L$K=.2k$.) (

5 "! U"$,. I$ 5 "$?DL77 %="$% 5 >= & I`)2 (L!U3"$.2 X 5 
$+$.'D"$V=P898

5  2 U$ X"$($L0JV<Z90 L> ()

="$3,"2C

 O

j= &0^/ J0O? k IS S(P M

0322< hV"/ U$ C?a!.6=^n 5 "=HLO 

=.2'^ ^e1 &M
5 "$

0 5 89 4 "$8~$.',"=HD$2[/ UM

$.>=,"$3"_= ? ;0 LZ= !"$=V$ 30IH;'.;$.'n 5 "=HW 

4 Q=" 5 $ &X2n 5 IMD$.b. Q$&"/ (89' '& ] 

J KQL:N'P9J

J0O ()PV" 4 ("$89Z$.?"$2 0n 5 "=HXb$.

=0$2S"$2'C7a!.

V"/ ($ JV!

6.2 Experiment 2

*<S$.+=]=? 4 GDV"$ 89L$O%!Q 5  2]n 5 "$ >$.) (

0 5 Q 9V"/ ($ C7@GDV"$ 89L$@ U"$

J =2X;$.'89%DM
I`)2q"$= t 4

e1 & 5 "$  S
o 
 q$.Ra>z77MN JV/.8P U"$#-C

7
 @=.2f$.
0 L=MN= O%=,"$3"=MN= OD ()X$.

ju`"$Q\ 5 = 45 00IH

E<4-FA@#%<$7
@7,+$7(4 C
"$,>"$$>$.>& 9n 5 "$  5 = &B$.!"$,>"$ $ &+" 5 07="$ JV2

$/ (0Dn 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ +$ 89 4 ("@ "$2 (= &B 5 8[JV"| 4 J 5 /#3$

W$.Z V"2O W$.6GD 5 $6$.Z="/ =0l U$2;n 5 "$ K W$.

Q ] (=="$ J 5 $O 890IHLO

!q/ (J0O

()

0 L<U="$3"1 ("$/. I$ 5 "$_' I$.6 I-"$%|) U"=$ I$  &'=/.89C

e1 & 5 "$

:
O_$

E<4-F3($8



E<4-FFA$8

"$2 (=;3,"=H^=.) U"$0IH]' I$.^$.W "$2 (= &g 5 8[JV"? 4

m&)*A(&?3 *AB
 4d(7@  / , 0

!#"%$&(7*>=.
@/.

"? >"$ 8P ("$ 0IHS= B' I$.b "$2 (= &X 5 8[JV"! 4 J 5 ,#3,$Z$.
="$3,"
?JV=$"
J06$;0 89  ($+ 5 0>'. ,.b! 5 0]$.,"=M
' =!.) 23@$?JV!"=HD$2 ()`)0I$"$26 (F$.Z0 L2C1a!.ZV,"=M
4 ("$8P ' 7= & I`2 L$0IHX 89"$U3



*1.G 31

4@(O2(+3 GS3 *5GR@04m*@?)=v*5(+"

;BA H*1?
. 8+1
CE( vH

 



*1.G 31

 5 $g$.=6$Q$
' I$.R "$2 (= &S 5 8;JV"? 4
E
:

'
J ?=.2$."$

5 0I$+ 4 $.6$Q$C
*
B=.2'^$.) U

5   ($ [QZ ;0 L=M= I$'n 5 ,"=HDMNGD 5 $ 

J 5 /#3$CWa!.W"$2 =j  5 [$P$.;,"$2 = &b 5 8;JV,"B 4

"$2'+"$ 5 "$2hJLH]$.[="$3"2Ct.^$.[ 5 8;JV"

4

J 5 ,#3,$

$. (Z) ("=$ I$ P$.? (/  "$2 (=OD$.'="$3"Z.) (> JV=$"! (M
 J 0 I<HR$]`)0I$"W 5 W89"$
$.6=0$ ^D"$2 2 U$C

4 0=P"$U'OK'. ,.dD](W$ ($  4 H

t. 06,<!("$#gQ+ ()g0 L=MN= I$

n 5 "=H%M,G 5 $ P$ 89+D"$2 (==.) ("$0IHLO% ' '(>$.

2 =

4 "

$.@="$3"=MN= I$Zn 5 "=H%M,G 5 $ ?$ 89C1*B$.@GDV"$ 89L$O$.

=0$ D IHd 4

$.bn 5 "=Hj [ "$2GD 8P U$0IH

'N

CRxZ2 5 =b 4

$.>V== J 0 I<H[ 4 D"$ 4 $/.;J ($/.;*<r[s O% &
/ (J0>=2 (;"$M
8P ( 26 |$._JVQ1/. 
VL$0IH

4 ("1$.7 U/ J =Z$ 89 v"2CFBO

4 "$8$.[ 5 8;JV,"+ 4

J 5 ,#3,$O|D"$2 2 U$X 0IM

5 ($ g >V," 4 "$89b%  X [=2n 5 L$ l (0/ (J0+=2 (|O2 5 = &;$.
Q$ DHbJV. U% "? g=,"$3"=MN= I$6n 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ S$ 89C
*B$.=7GDV"$ 89L$V!_ (0=?89) ("$
$._n 5 
 "=H%MNGD 5 $ 
$ 89[ k 5 "P U"$,. $ 5 "$P' I$.m$.b2 (=] 4
=,"$3"2O%'. /.SV," 4 "$89! 00V$.
/. I$, 5 "$C+a!.

.) 2% &\ R= &0

45 $ >=,"$ JVS P$.

("=M

4 "$89"
"$"$=L$
$/ (0@ U/ SD"$  ,HLO)'. 0

$.;0 (=$,"W"$"$=L$B"$2>MN030_ (/ b"=HD$ /<D"=HD$ |O
'."$Z$.Z="$3,"K 1=" 5 Q$2$+D"=HD|$.! (/ %C@e1 & 5 "$

$.9n 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ 
O


4 ("= &0,M=,"$3"6 ()

= Q$L'' $.b$.+D"$%  5 'C

=.2'Z$. Z89) U"$ =|CK

&3 ( PZ
D"$=LZ$.>"$ 5 0I$

7. CONCLUSIONS

0 2 ($ jE%"$% XzK"$UD D"

BEz'89%D0 4 ("L$"$D"$ =

89 5 $ &b. 689"$&2R' I$.\$.;"$ =9 4

*L$"$$,.0(M

& C_*X$.
+Ezu89%D0OD ="$% B"$U% "Z2 PD"$(% ?= 4 =M
> U"$> 1 ?="$% _$B '3"=H0 U"$&!0 L=MNJ) (=ZU3"|$._*<L$"$,2C

0 #X8P LH^($."W="$% OK.2!3,"2O1 (/ J =[ ("$9=V,M

  0C

T (/ u g u"$  5 b"$= 5 "$\ 4

"$ 5 02OF"$  HR ()\= 5 "$ I<HR 4

(

L$"$"$ =C~?g

 U/ g ($.X="$% MN"$U% "

= I$] P) ("/ (89 5 %2Cm*m$. 9 V"2O7!^ %"$==2f R=V I`)
 U/ (MN"$  Hg,. 00&

b'.) U+ 4

$.WU'"+ 4

$.; (/ (J) =

L+(B=" 5 Q
$.6="$% ;D"$UD D"B' I$.^$.[ U/ 3fr

5 "B=(M

0 5 $ \ +$bQ$("$;$.; (/ b (+$.;="$% XD"$UD D"6 4 $"6DM

"=HD$ &; I2O'. ,.] ]0IHSJV6"=HDD$2SJLHP$.BU'"2Cvu
.) 23?D30V9$,. n 5 
4

5 = &'. /.9$.?J 5 0#[ 4 $.>!("$#

,G 5 $ &R$.REo+pn 5 "$ P2 (qJVh^JLHd$.^=,"$D 

"$U% "?' I$. 5 B$.g$bD"=HD'$.WQ$("$2h U/ DC?a!.

$/. ln 5 
D02HDZ ^:3 U"$=+ ),GADO3'. /.S 00U'> ("=$  0G%M
 5 $ d 4

(cEo+pfn 5 "=HRj$.9"$U% "W= C]a!.X"$ 5 0I

4 $. 
n 5 "=Hb 
=%?$X$.60 L2C?a!.6("="$
"$ 5 0I
4 $.
n 5 "=HW  4

5 )WJLH;D"=HD$ &

$.! (/ %OL ()[,G 5 $ &+ B8XM

V$ ($ 9n 5 "=HW (K$.!0 L@= $C?u!D"$V=2W$/. n 5 7$

E
J

V,"/ ($!$.?Eo+pbn 5 "=HLO3 ()W=0 I7 I_ L$+ B="$"7n 5 "=HW ;

4 "'D 4 M

B a!.60 %=MN= I$6n 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ b$ 89 (0=9 0 5 D?$.+,=M

!("$#P898 5  2 U$ PQ'"$2n 5 "$P$W="/  4 "'=0$b"$2'
JLHP$.+="$"2C

4 "$L' 5 8[JV"$Z 4 J 5 ,#$C@a!.

`"$Q>J ("> b$.
`& 5 "$
=.2'
$.;n 5 "=H%M,G 5 $ ]$ 89

4 "$8

$ 89C

jgM

J 5 /#3$C
e1 &M

$ 896= & `2 L$0IHhD"$2 (=W' I$.]$.6 ,"$2 =[ ]$.6 5 8;JV"
4

= 'n 5 ,"=HDMNGD 5 $ $ 89Z' I$. 5 _"=HD$ O'. /.; @0(=M
$2RJ%Hh"$89U% &g"=HDD$ jQ

0 L=MN="$3"_ U"$,. $ 5 "$CKa!.7"$ 5 0I$K 4 $.=7$Q$@ ("$> (0=

$.]n 5 
 "=H%MNGD 5 $ d$ 89g k 5 "P U"$,. I$ 5 "$C

<Z"$#W898

O
J[=.2'X$.gn 5 "=Hu"$=V=b$ 89X 4

0 L=MN= lD+n 5 ,"=HDMNGD 5 $ X$ 89>' I$.gD"=HD$ S ()90 L=M

'> (+Q 5 D 2] R 5 "

`"$Q
=+GDV"$ 89L$O-e1 & 5 "$

*;$.7`"$Q_=7 4 GDV"$ 89L$O(!'Q 5 D [$.>89VL$

5 "$

D"=HD$ RV," 4 "$89\ U+$.[0 %+= $CXaFSGD"$=

4 2O>e1 & 5 "$

$. 

=.2'B$.W$(/ 0Kn 5 "=H%M,G 5 $ ]$ 89

6.1 Experiment 1
4

0=S=.2'+Q$\D"$2 (=O- I+ B&("$2 ($,"+$.) (]$.6="$3"=MN= 

n 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ j$ 89CRa!.P"$ =m ; 5 9$^$.S89 ) L

&?3 *ABO4d@ ( 3 *A8:@/.?B-3 *5G0@04*@?)=v*5(+"

/ , 0 ;BA 
H *1.?8+1
CE( vH

 

4 ("!JV($.90 %Z X="$3"

= [n 5 "$ C'?0I$. 5 &.]$.W0 L=MN= Wn 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ b$ 89

Q6 4

   
 !+C%D
)     8 $ E' 

64 D ' %



6F 8 .G 

F% 8 !%H %!+I3J!+C4 10
B2+2
 0 
( ) * 
K 
9 8  %!%%D
)   %  8 L9 8  %!+

! "%$&(7*5M.
#
&*5(
HC3 *AB @/. q( 4d(7@

J 5 ,#3,$C

[> ;GD0  m d$.b"$%  5 ;GDV"$ 89L2O@$. XJV. 2%M

 

    

 "
 !
#

$ %&'    
( ) *
)  '!+-, ./!%- 10 %232a 0 
8 !
!
)  '!%435!%4 60 %232a 0 7 
2 a !% ; 7 a
! 

:9' (  a ;
! <
!  8 3 

HC3 *AB

S$.

n 5 "=HLC+a!.W`)& 5 "$; 00 5 Q="/ ($+$.) (n 5 "=Hg"$=V=[$ 89+,M

4 ("$.6= &0,M=,"$3"6= 5 |O)'."$

Network cost
Server site

Query Execution Time

Query Execution Time

Client site

Single server
Server site (C/S)
Client site (C/S)

Number of Buckets

O


ZQ

4 $("$

Number of Buckets

4 "

n 5 "=H%M

$.

GD 5 $ g$ 89C

 

! "$'&(7*-,
).

O


Z0 L2O~="$3"2O~ ()

'
J \Z89) U"$ =

4 ("mZ0 %=M<E%"$3"

Q="/ ($&(H
Q="/ ($&(HLC

$.= &0MN="$3"

*A8:G2@04[.& Hv*A(m@=4 H&8 *5G3@/.

'
J 

$/ (0

n 5 "=H%MNGD 5 $ P$ 89C

K-Y 4

"=HDD$ 

 *A8:G

D"$  (HLOL ();$.>Q! 4 LV"/ U$ &6 Pn 5 "=H[GD 5 $ X' $.
 (/ 6V"$= Q$O%$. 5 ZL$  5 7$6JV`

U

>

4 "$8~$.?QHDQ$8XM

,

B7E-CBD (b@"=HDD$ ^EL/ ) ("/-C

2


T;C)ED&X ()gT[CAu &"

g6C)z1"="$ &DC-ED ("$/.]

 W+
:

 W
U 
 UO +:D
C

I,

!^">O FF: C
T7E-CT (/ ;_"=HD$ ]E%/  U"/C  #%$&(')
 Q: Y
*W   WF
# W ,$
U# N
= " , +  $ FW
O
a

:LC

[C >

(
2

2  008P (|O 3CAt 8]C.- N/+$

 FO C
2 %
 "&eWaW4(C)z@"$L$ B 00O F
3WF '

U"$  (M<yg0 ) %O C

;10

OT (/ (J) =B

= ("$/.

+:O

! (0 4 "$ l %OV*"$% O

I72

> "$ 5 ] U

+::

 O h C

 O h

 

W  W

 
O

 +/ UL-

%,DC

W (
4

4H

.%=$ <<U>>C $VC ("$&C

y\CEt =0,=B ()
=V2 #%' 5 'g$.

DCT;C

W $  

U$O h( C

"=$.|O ()^EVC)E 5  ("$=.) (|C

N/+$ ; E3WF

)

a>zZ7MN[C&B


 ("$  (J0MN0&($.]#3HLO

J02>`)=.,O 4 Q
= 4 <> U"$6"=HDD$ |C*<

WCED 0JV"$=/.) ($vO)[CeZC

B :;35<hO

/( WF
AW

GF= 

( WF
CVyg >

F:%

"/ >MNB 00

 IZ$ WF
C

008P C V"$HbT;C

008P 

45  5 "$+ 4 . &."?2 5 2 ($ |OQ/ ("= 5 O

 (/ (J) (=+$.("=HLO) ()b89("$CJ=><XS-

"$2GD 8P ($ b 4 =,=M 0 5 2bn 5 "=HS Q!"$C*<6

7.8-"&>O &

I(
IU2

W  W35-!O

x
CVE%,. "2CT+=,"$ D$ ] 4 ;,

 3,"$= H

C)z1L$ 0 DCV
Q$&"/ (8XMNJ) =

4 ("BJ/   &9 & / (0F= & ( 5 "$B ()S 5 J0 #H

xZL#gZ89 LHLO a %

 C

T U/ J) (=W ? 9ED,"$D C*

;C>C*3   ? 

 C

%O
 , 7F

O)x
C*HL"2O ]EVCVyg.D"$="/ %C)zK"$UD D &
[C+ (&V5 8\|
5 

 

J0L,#S ."

T U/ J) (=M<ED"$% MzK"$UD D"Byg%0CVa|,. 2 (0|?V"=

h

WV D @3WF )%N WF

OV) (& 2

W
3( WF


"=HD$QHDQ$89CA3WF2

KG 5 $ &9Eo+p\U3,"?_"=HD$2ST (/ ; 

O M :
 

a

89$.%

O)x
C*HL"2O)
Cp| O) ()^EVCyg."$(="/ DC
[C+ (&V5 8\|
5 

a!'MT+x7M

< 
S -O

WCp_C? Q2O)6CED.) (89 I"2O ()]p@CVy\CBD08P C

W  W

"=HD$2b (/ %C*

W":;35<?=>

WCp_C? Q2O)p@CVy\CBD08P O ()gy\CT+,"=$ 5 vC-rB

T (/ XxZ #%? gzK"$  (Hg
8989"$. =89C%*<

REFERENCES

W 

 I$ |C*<9

IU

C)z@  (/ ($,$=#%H%M<ED.  "$X )g

C-Z00C)
 5 "/ ($

Q$ 8P ($ ] 4 $. 5 8;JV"Z 4  5 0>$ ($  4 HD &P

8P () (&89L>=,"$D 6 4 $. (/ (J) =6="$% D"$(% ,"2C

% TW  

 @'".%$)&)*A(H

 [C  C3 & D =.O)WC  O)x

CV
CVrB O) () C Mp_Ca1 (|C
> 0J) (0FD$ 89 v ($ ] 4 . Q$&"/ 89C*<9 W 
 W:;35<
=>< S -O FFD C

$.P="$% bD"$(% ,"2CRa!.S0 %;L;(;2j$h8P  &

4 ("60 %=MN="$"

Q="/ ($&(Hh-C C= &0MN="$3"+Q="/ (=M

&H

@04B.& H*5(D@04 H&?8 *5G3V@/.

0 LBn 5 "=HLC7a!.=,"$D 6D"$(% ,"?"$,/  '$.+"$=V= J 0 I<H

$)&*5(+"%*A3:H

7
 +Z89 ("$ =

V"=M

, ,.

$[8P  &?$.
V"$= Q$B 4 $.+ (/ DC7a!.B0 L'&$!$(/ 0

Y




.@/. @'".

4 ("$892bg$.+0 L?= I$C

!#"%$&(7*

8.

VC C

^? W Q O A
O,O