Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ff *
e. :l {'' & $. if{ i { !! a.d, ii
aperceived (orpotential) problem. In their model, Rossiter and pti-c}t€Ter to lrand attitude
strategies when motives are positive as transformational (transforming your mood) and
when motives are negative as informational.
Others in the past have attempted to deal with criteria they feei are important to
communication strategy by proposing various grids to help identify types of marketing
communication. Perhaps the best-known example is the so-cailed FCB grid introduced
back in the 1960s.12 Unfortunately, while many texts and even some practitioners continue
to refer to it, the FCB grid has a number of problems.13
The Rossiter-Percy grid begins with the distinction between recall and recognition
, it must be
associated with the correct brand awareness T3 of the
Rossiter-Percy grid in planning is th s1 ns about a
uct or service in terms of th e tarset audience s inv-olyement with the choice decision and the
*-:-**%
motivation that drives its behaviour. This in turn alerts the manager to speciflc tactical
requiremenls for creative execution (see Fig. 8.3).
3
o
o
E
:
a
c
.o)
I
message should be concerned with beneflt claim support and how it is resolved.
The obvi-
ous format to accomplish this i{_tg p-!9lg-tlrlrgplgb-19.*.qiit,'li9lv9Ql_by rlre-trranq.
This is
virtually every Procter & Gambie advert you have-ever seen!'How oio
dirty!'(the problem). 'Tide
irt.i. ir.tr*s
cleans even the dirtiest clothes'(the brand solves the problem).
get so et*f/"
Interestingly, it is not necessary to 'like'low-involvement informational advertising. The
important thing is that the benefit is clearly communicated, even in the extreme. In one of
the most successful campaigns ever, Procter & Gamble's Charmin toilet tissue for years
fea-
tured an obnoxious store clerk named'Mr wipple'. He was alwaylg&kj{rgaround
corners,
while shoppers tried to avoid him so they could 'squeeze f,@g1-p because it was
so
W.flt'Buteverytimetheytried,hewouldstickhisheadaroundtheaisleand
call out: 'Ladies, please don't squeeze the Charmin.,la
Everyone hated the commetcials, but the brand soon became the category leader. Why?
The benefit of 'softness' was being clearly and dramatically demonstrated. When people
were
shopping in the toilet tissue aisle and saw the Charmin package (the recognition reminding
them of the need), they did not think: 'Oh, Charniin. They have that awful TV commercial,
I'm not buying thatl'No, they were wondering if it really was that soft. Because it is a low-
involvement decision, one with little or no risk, they gave it a try. This does not mean that you
should 8o out of your way to produce advertising people do not like, only that liking the
advertising, at least when dealing with negative motivations, is not required.rs
The Charmin example, in fact, illustrates each of the important considerations involved
in implementing low-involvement informational brand attitude strategies. First of all, it
uses a problem-solution format. The problem here is imptied: toilet tissue that is not soft.
Charmin is the solution; it is'squeezably soft'. Secondly, you do not need to like the execu-
tion, and the target audience did not. Thirdly, keep it simple, using a single benef,t or a
group of benefits that reinforce each other. For Charmin, the benef,t is clear: softness.
And,
finally, the benefit claim is stated in the extreme.
gmotio4al portrayal of the benef,.t in order to arouse the correct emotionai response; not in
providing information. The advertising must 'ring true'. Beyond anything else, low-
involvement transformational advertising must suggest emotional authenticity. The target
audience must simply look at it and see it as'real'. We put this in inverted commas because
we do not mean it must be literally real. What must happen is the target audience must see
itself emotionally in the role of uslng the products: 'That ice cream bar iooks so good I want
one right nowl'You can just feel how good it tastes by looking at the execution.
A good example of what we are talking about may be seen in two very similar outdoor
poster campaigns that ran in Sweden, one for milk and one for ice cream. Two examples from
each campaign are shown ln Adverts 8.2 and 8.3. Which of these iooks most appetizing
to you? Overall recognition for the milk campaign was 55 per cent versus only 20 per cent
for the ice cream campaign.16 The images used in the milk campaign are clearly more ,real,
in the sense of exciting interest in 'drinking one now'. They are simpty more attractive.
As a result, they were more likely to have been fu111' processed and stored in the memory,
available to be remembered later on a shopping trip.
,1ll
il
ilt
ilt
til
ill
**s*g-*$g&g{3 e **e!w#sl*{&?t*tr $Yffie?csv 151
Of course, to be effective, these images must be available at the point of purchase so that
the interest generated by the poster is activated as the shopper thinks again about how
good the drinks iook and (should) taste. Remember, this is a low-involvement decision so it
is not necessary actually to believe it will taste as good as it looks, only that it might; and the
,taste' that was experienced from the execution is enough to encourage purchase, even if
there is no actual intent to try and create the drinks shown. The images make the milk itself
more desirable.
This is really important, because in effect thebenef,t is in the execution. For this reason'
when dealing with positively motivated behaviour the target audience must like the advert-
ising, because it is the execution itself that elicits the emotion, not the information in the
message. This is often difficult for advertisers to accept. There is a strong temptation to
include a more tangible benefit when advertising a low-involvement product purchased
from positive motives, a kind of benefit that would be more appropriate when dealing with
negative motivations.
An example of what we are talking about is illustrated in a test conducted in Sweden of
two Toblerone commercials using Ake Wissing & Co.'s Ad Box technique, a procedure for
152 i;L';:.tir::rl''r .: ',.,,
Advert 8'4 The same commercial, but with two different endjngs,
the first reflect ng a positjve emotronal
experience, the second a specific product attribute. The
first verstn signi{icantly outperformed the
second' as we would expect for a low-involvement product where purchase
is iriven by positrve motives.
Source: Ake Wissing & Co. TOBLERONE rs a req stered
trademark of Kratt toods
100
90
80
rt
70
L
xs c 60
b
50
.o
le 40
t)
30
st
I. 20
10
x
ic
Message Advertiser lmage Buyer Interest
is Receives any ldentification Positivelyinfluenced lnterestedin
message Ihinks the advertiser towards the buying/trying
t- comes through very advertiser
clear and evident
rf
le
Fig,8.4 Communication Pre-test Results from the Two Versions of the Toblerone Commercial
ri
Source: Ake Wissing & Co.
154 ii r l.i & 1" {:i 1lr i tr; i; I kt l] 1;'f !t,iL; { { !{ t: i,,q }!,1
consciousness, whete emotional memory is stored), which over time becomes linked to the
brand (more about how this works is discussed in Chapter 10).
To illustrate what we mean, let us consider a campaign developed for Lipton's line of
I dehydrated side dishes. These are those noodle- and rice-based products that you just add
gXahp,( WateItoinordertoreconstitute,thenffithecategoryposi-
tioned themselves along either a &s!-e' or a 'qtrick-qd-easy' benefit. while _taste is
.an
appjepdate benCflt for_alow-involvement food product, q'{€lg rgy.ls not. This is a caf-
tgorybeneflt, addressing the negative motivation driving the decision to purchase this type
of product. loo often marketers conluse what motivates cateqory decisions with what
@i-Unfortunately,thishadbeenLipton'sStIate8y.
But in repositioning the brand, it got things right. The benefit selected was the positive
emotion that goes with a nurturing family meal. Advertising was created that presented
warm famiiy mealtime situations, of which serving Lipton side dishes were a part. This
meant that when shoppers were in the aisle and confronted with many, many alternative
dehydrated products, recognlzing the Lipton package triggered the need and elicited mem-
ories of that warm feeling they had experienced watching the advertising. This positive
emotional response, linked to the brand, was the reason to buy the brand.
As the Charmin case did for low-involvement informational advertising, this example
illustrates all the important points to be considered for implementing low-involvement
transformaLionaladvertisingstrategies.First*'t*asemotional tic.Whilemothers
rarely experience warm family meal situations because of the rush of family life (one reason
they are in the category), it is nevertheless their idea of an 'ideal' meal. In this sense the
emotion was'real'and desired. Secondly, the_[alggLaudiencqliked the executions, the pos-
itiveemotiona1messageIeSonatingw1ththem.@onwaS
BecauseLiptonwaSthefirsttocapitalizeonthis
strong emotional beneflt,' iV6Gn@ it. Any other brand that tried to copy it would prob-
\__---'/
ably onty reinforce the associa-tion rvith Lipton. llpally, the beneflt delivery was implied.
There was no 'selling' as such, only an association of the brand with
time experience.
Before we leave this example, there is an important point to be made. The target audience
did not believe that by serving Lipton side dishes it would actually have a warm family
meai. There was no implied causality involved. What happens, and this is true for most
effective transformational advertising, is that the target audience transfers the positive
emotional feelings linked to the situation to the brand that is a part of that situation.
Because this is a low-involvement decision, this positive association is enough to occasion
purchase.
The considerations for implementing low-involvement brand attitude strategies are
summarized in Table 8.3.
Hir
{t*sl:**$i}r**i s i:*&4*{lifi}{&Ti#l* $?*A?f6Y 155
lnformationa . Information should be provided that solves a problem as the result of usrng the brand
' KeeP rt simPle
' Use an extreme presentation of the benefit
' The advertising does not have to be llked
Transformational ' Elicit the conecl emotional response
. Be certain the advertising 'rings true', providing emotional authentrclty
. Link the emotional response to the execution
. As a result, the advertising must be liked
Why? Again, it is because the message must be accepted as true. Because it is a high-
involvement decision, much more cognitive activity will be involved in processing the
message. Assuming the target audience pays attention, it will take the information pro-
vided in the message and integrate it with its existing knowledge base in the conscious or
declarative memory. These associations in memory will create new thoughts about the
brand in relatlon to the links formed in memory between existing beliefs, and the new
information.18 These new thoughts will be favourable or unfavourabie towards the brand
relative to the information already in memory. This is why understanding the target audi-
ence's existing attitudes towards the product and category are so important. Without this
understanding, it will be difficult if not impossible effectively to develop advertising that is
likely to build or reinforce a positive brand attitude.
Since understanding the tarSet audience's attitude is so important to pitching the mes-
sage at an acceptable level, does this mean we can talk only about things the target audi-
ence already believes? Can we not 'stretch' those attltudes to make them more favourable?
The answer is yes, we can, but n e must be very careful not to go too far. That, of course, begs
the question, how far can lve go before the target audience witi simply reject what we are
saying. The answer comes fiom ear11' work in attitude change theory that addressed this
very issue. In Sherif and Hovland's assimilation-contrast theory, they identifled an area of
'indifference'that falls between those things we can readily accept and those we reiect out-
right.le The key to impiementing high-lnvolvement transformational brand attitude strat-
egy successfully is to know where the 'latitude of rejection' begins beyond the latitude of
indifference, and not to cross the line. This answer will come from good research into the
target audience's attitude ton-ards the category, product, and brand.
While the target audience must believe the message, as was the case with low-involvement
informational brand attitude strategies, it does not need to like the advertising itself.
Learning is simply not dependent upon liking the advertising, even in the high-involvement
case.20 If the benefits presented ln the message are convincing, how they are presented wiil
not matter-assuming, of course, that it is the 'style'of the advertising that is not liked, not
the fact that the audience cannot understand it. As mentioned earlier, however, this does
not mean that you should go out of your way to create advertising the target audience does
not like, only that its 'liking' it need not be a concern.
will even
:@t-Th"t i-"hy..-.quire a high-involvement transform4tional brand attitude
strategy. Yet somewhere in the campaiSn believable intormat (remember, this is
high involvement and the message must be accepted) will need to be provided in order to
satisfy the secondary motivation that is involved in the evaluation of the models the target
audience 'likes'.
While this is a special case, the manager must be alert to the fact that for some high-
involvement transformational brand attitude strategies a dual motivation could be
involved. Whether there is or not will be answered in the development of a behavioural
process'
Sequence model, oI some othel investigation of the target audience's decision
Regardless, the primarv positive motivation must be the flrst And, iust in the
as
9enrg.
lo*li6lrr"-ent transformational case, the critical concern is-emofrqral-auth@lity. At
the high-involvement level, however, the target audience mustPersonallyidentifywith the
brand as it is portrayed in the execution. Just as with low-involvement transformational
strategies, the benefit is in the execution. The target audience wants the product in order
to
pel the thrill of driving a new sports cal or the sense of glamour that goes with wearing high
fashion clothes. The execution must arouse those feelings'
Because of this, as with low-involvement transformational brand strategies, the target
,like' the advertising. But, in the high-involvement transformational case,
audience must
that liking must go beyond simply liking the execution itself. The likingmustbry@lggf
brandbased.Because it is a high-involvement decision, in processing the message the
target
*ai".r." must really believe that the brand, as portrayed in the advertising, is the one that
will satisfy the sensory gratification or social approval motivation underlying its need. The
brand must be portrayed in such a way that it elicits from non-declarative emotional mem-
ory the correct emotions, the the target audience wants to experience in using the
feelings
product. (How this happens will be discussed in Chapter 10')
What the manager must consider when implementing high-involvement brand attitude
strategies is summarized in Table 8.4.
Transformational ' Be alert to possible dual motivations and the need to provide information
a Elicit the correct emotional response and link it to the brand
The target audience must personally identify with the brand as portrayed in the execution
Liking must go beyond the execution and extend speciflcally to the product and brand
). Obviousl , cor ralron\ want their name to be r(,.ojlizecl,fuar.
re called for. In terms of&a4g_A*ilude, the pri_
mary obiective is ro build and su:tain overall nelrrrye
'.fr1
at(itude_[og41rdril.o-ounu. tu
otfo.r . ^-,,-^:^, ...^-r ,
orporate image
-.**" I
I
I
II
lI
lll
I
l:jr\i*Lryi:{xs* & {*stff iJFi}{&?***i 1T&sYH$Y 159
e
to specifically influence investors to buy or analysts to recommend a stock or bond issue; or
F
to specifically get a govelnment agency to look favourably on something the company
wishes to do. In such cases, the appropriate brand attitude strategy will be the one that
reflects the risk and motivation involved in the particular decision being addressed, just as
E
with any other brand advertising.
e
i-
t- ffi CHAPTER SUMMARY
e ln this chapter we have discussed the development of communication strategy, based on the four
!'- communication objectives of category need, brand awareness, brand attitude, and brand purchase
e intention. We have emphasized the important distinction between recognition brand awareness
- and recall brand awareness, and the implications for creative and media strategies. The critical
'mess-
importance of involvement and motivation was highlighted and related to the processing of
ages. We then looked at how these important considerations influence brand attitude strategy in
the context of the Rossiter-Percy grid, and outiined the principles involved in implementing brand
attitude strategy.
e
e
5
ffi QUESTIONS TO CONSIDER
c
8.1 Underwhat circumstances should the manager consider including category need as a
com mu nication oblective?
5 8.2 When should brand purchase intention be considered as a specific communication objective?
e
8.3 What are the important considerations the manager must use in setting the brand awareness
5
strategy?
5
s
8.4 Why is it important to think about brand attitude as a relative concept?
: 8.5 ln what ways are involvement and motivation involved in driving brand attitude strategy?
'- g.6 What are the key strategic differences between informational and transformational strategies?
L
g.7 How should the manager look at corporate advertising in terms of communication strategy?
I
S NOTES
T
5 1. The four communication effects discussed here, and their use as communication objectives, follow
a from the work ofJohn Rossiter and Larrl' Ps1qy, first introduced in Advertising and Promotion
Management (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1982). This book also talks about a fifth communication effect,
lj
something Rossiter and Percy call purchase facilitation, to account for situations where the adveltiser
may need to address issues arising from problems with other components of the marketlng mix.
F
2. This very important distinction was first made in Rossiter andPercy, Advertising and Promotion
c Management.
E
3. MeasuresofadvertisingrecallarenotvalidpredictorsofadvertisingefTectiveness.Themostthatcan
rt
be said of day-after recall (DAR) measures is that they rzrgftf provide some indication of attention to
an advert. What is important is that the lrrandisremembered. Even published studies by leading
DAR companies have never shown advertising recall to be a valid measure of effectiveness.