Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
&
Brand Reorganisation Strategy
BACKGROUND
This segment represents the low end users and the rural market. Basic
characteristic of this market is low margin and high volume.
HMT brands in this price range: Lalit, Chetan , Chetak, Rajat, Kedar, Ravi,
Kohinoor and shakti
Titan is with: Basics, Aqura, and Sonata
This segment is slightly above the mass market segment. Somya and Tennax
from HMT targets college going men and women who see themselves as
fashionable people. A similar offering, Timex's Mariner addresses the same
profile as HMT’s Sowmya but a slightly older age group. It is difficult to categorize
Titan's Royale, Regalia and Classique as premium or popular. Though they have a
premium image they are available at prices less than Rs.1000.
Vista from Timex and Chandan, and Sangam from HMT falls in this segment.
Royal , Regalia etc of Titan can also be considerd under this range.
Titan’s Insignia, Slimline, and Bandhan; HMT's Elegance range, and Misuni;
Timex's Indiglo and Datalink are main brand offered in this market segment.
Titan's Tanishq and HMT's Gem range fall into this category. So do most of the
Swiss watches like Omega, Piaget, Longines, etc. These are bought more as
status symbols and jewelry rather than watches.
Segmentation based on user category:
Ø Women's Watches:
Fashion and style are most visible feature of this segment
Ø Men's Watches:
HMT's Roman is probably the only watch that addresses the men's segment.
Market research indicated that HMT wasseen as a masculine brand while Titan
was seen as a feminine brand. In keeping with its masculine image HMT
introduced the Roman range.
Ø.Youth Watches:
Age group between 15 and 20 is treated as youth segment. Ruggedness and
durability at low price is basic feature of this segment.
Ø Kid's Watches: Target group is children aged between 7 and 10. Mainly digital
watches fall in this category. Grey market is most dominant player of this
segment. HMT’s Zap TIMEX’s Gimmix and Titan’s Dash are branded watches
offered in category.
Ø Sports Watches: Stress of this segment is on trendy designs for casual wear
with advanced features for the techno-savvy consumer.
TITAN INDUSTRIES
Since its inception, Titan decided that it would be the shaper of the watch
industry and not an adapter. They created competitive advantage through
differentiation. They first concentrated on technological leadership.
The Tatas took two decisions they will manufacture only quartz (analog and
digital) and not mechanicals, and they would set up state-of-the-art plant to
manufacture watches in a wide variety of designs and prices. HMT and local
players had always looked at the functional utility of the watch. Titan was first in
India to introduce the style concept. They projected the watch as a fashion
accessory.
They clearly identified that their main competitor was not HMT, but the gray
market. A firm differentiates itself from its competitors if it can be unique at
something that is valuable to the buyer beyond simply offering low price.
Differentiation allows a firm to command a premium price, to sell more of its
products at the same price, or to gain equivalent benefits such as greater buyer
loyalty. Differentiation leads to a superior performance if the price premium
achieved exceeds any added costs of being unique.
At Titan, the products were developed in such a way so as to enhance quality
and features to increase buyer value. This was the perfect example of
differentiation through technological leadership and product technological
change. In the initial years Titan chose to concentrate on the higher end of the
market which was responsive to the style element of the watch. Also this
segment of the market was relatively price inelastic. This was done so as to build
the brand image of Titan as manufacturer of good quality stylish watches.
Over the years the Titan brand and its signature tune Mozzart’s Fifth Symphony
has become one of the most recognised in Indian consumer durable goods
segment. Company has shifted its growth strategy from adding to equipment and
manpower to one of obtaining increased production through innovative ideas and
greater operating efficiency by adopting global best practices. It has come up
with two priorities
Ø The first priority has been to resolutely drive down unit costs through product
and process modifications and aggressive sourcing.
Ø The second priority has been to boost asset productivity - producing more with
less: less of men, materials, machines and time - and thereby securing the twin
benefits of higher output and lower costs.
Company sold 4.76 million watches in the domestic market as against 3.97
million in the previous year.
Growth came mainly from improved market penetration and from the newly
introduced Sonata brand (now Under TATA name), which now includes over 400
models at prices which start from Rs350.
Company has recently developed a new focus on several market segments with
large potential: women, youth, children, sportsmen, the budget-conscious and, of
course, the big spenders. A systematic programme of launching these has
already commenced and highlights of the year included the relaunch of Fastrack
and Raga.
The current year has seen the launch of the children's range, Dash.
A new, attractively priced, solid gold line, Nebula, is also being rolled out. The
Company now has 112 exclusive Titan Showrooms called 'The World of Titan'
across 69 towns and a chain of 101 Time Zone outlets covering 59 towns in
addition to being present in over 5545 dealer outlets in 1470 towns across the
country.
Titan launched totally a new product, quartz analog watch was an entirely new
product for India in 1987. Titan’s marketing strategy was initially built around 5
features:
It was not a program, therefore, that would place Titan watches in direct
competition with, say, mechanical watches from HMT. The marketing program
would introduce to India the type of promotional effort familiar in most developed
countries.
Sonata from Titan (Now sold under TATA) aims at the mass market and
advertises itself as "a Titan watch at low price". Sonata sold an estimated 0.8
million pieces (1998-99) within four years of its launch. It is probably the largest
selling sub brand from Titan. Titan entered the watch market as a premium
watch but competition from the unorganized sector and low priced options from
HMT forced Titan to introduce Sonata. Sonata was so successful that it
cannibalized the brand from the extension’s low price connotation.
Titan's Exacta, a rugged steel watch starts at the low end of the price spectrum
but offers high price versions as well. It is reportedly selling 1.0 million pieces per
year because of the constant upgradation in its models.
It is difficult to categorize Titan's Royale, Regalia and Classique as premium
or popular. Though they have a premium image they are available at prices less
than Rs.1000. Regalia (estimated sales - 0.2 million units) is at the higher end
with dress watches for special occasions. The Royale range (estimated sales - 0.6
million watches) caters to the gift segment. There is also Royale Crown in the
upper end of the Royale range. Classique is an office wears accessory that is
gold-plated and leather strapped (estimated sales - 1 million units). Classique
watches are targeted at the older, male segment of the market, and profess
timeless elegance through a combination of fine leather straps, clean classic
dials and sleek cases, thus making it, " A perfect fit for formal wear." Classique is
the embodiment of everything that is everlasting yet contemporary. These
watches tend to be generic in their simplicity, and find no real competitors,
except HMT. These watches are priced between Rs 550 to Rs 3000. Though
there are very high priced watches in the above three ranges it is the relatively
low-priced ones that sell. They all target the upper middle class men and women
in their thirties. Royale, Classique and Regalia are the watches that gave Titan
the popularity and the prestige it enjoys.
The Spectra range in this price band is a well-designed bimetal watch
("stylishness of gold and ruggedness of steel"). It sold just 70,000 units in 1997-
98. Titan Industries launched (September, 2001) its range of watches in steel,
targeted at urban men and women in the age group of 25-35 years. The Titan
Steel collection has a range of bracelet and leather strap watches for both men
and women priced between Rs 1,250 and Rs 6,000. The range will be retailed
through World of Titan, Time Zone and other retail outlets. The launch of the
steel watches, available in 90 designs, will be followed by an aggressive
marketing campaign.
Titan's Tanishq range initially targeted the European market with limited
success. In India also Tanishq faced resistance because Indian women do not
treat watches as jewelry.
The company is exploring the possibility of filling up the gap in the super
premium segment. At present only Swiss brands have a presence in this niche.
TIL, however, has its Nebula range for both men and women priced between Rs
6,000 and Rs 32,000. The new range is expected to higher price than the Nebula
range. In fact the company's focus would be on niche segments to grow the
market. By planning to launch a brand in the super premium category, Titan
perhaps hopes to be present across all categories.
Titan's Raga is an interesting product concept that offered to give dials that
match with designs on saris. This promise was unrealistic and Raga flopped
(estimated sales - 20,000 units). Raga is now being launched in more mellow
colors and its positioning changed. Raga silver watch range also did not fare well
because Indian dials.
Titan Industries launched its Fastrack range of watches for women (For Men It is
already present). The ladies watches are available in different finishes frosted,
polished and satin and come in varied geometric shapes with trendy leather
straps and classy metal bracelets. The watches retail from Rs 995 to Rs 1,950
and are attractively priced. The watches which have been designed at Titan's
creative studio is the outcome of research that has highlighted the need for a
watch that is fashionable, bold, unconventional and designed to accessories
western wear. A collection of watches with contemporary styles those are young
and distinctive. Designs that go from the relaxed and informal to the definitely
sporty. The woman's collection presents the all-new international 'Frosted' look,
which is trendy and chic. The Fastrack collection has elements like cool mesh
straps and features that include backlight and dual time. Also presenting a range
of fashion digitals in contemporary wrist hugging cases with oversized displays
and features that include countdown timers, chronographs, lap timers, hourly
chime, alarm and Hi-light glow.
Dash is Titan’s reply to Gimmix and Zap. Dash is available in 3 new collections
for kids - Popeye, Digital and Lumibrite. Titan is the sole licensee of Popeye in
India and this range is priced between Rs 350 and Rs 395. Giving Popeye of the
spinach-eating fame the additional responsibility of keeping time, the Popeye
brand of watches come in 6 different designs. The Digital range in a collection of
10 digital watches has features like El-light compass and Velcro straps for the
sporty and is priced between Rs 425 and Rs 495. And Lumibrite, is a glow watch
that comes at Rs 325. The company has also brought out a collection of five
watches for the girls, priced at Rs 295.
PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION
Titan entered the watch market as a premium watch. But the unorganized sector
and low priced options from HMT gave Titan serious competition. The
unorganized sector grew very fast — almost 55% of the demand in the total
market size of 20 million watches was being met by the unorganised sector. With
the import duty reduced to 25% (earlier 50%) and with the import license for
watch movement being easy to obtain, many smalltime players cropped up.
These small players offered competition to Titan on the price front. Thus Titan
launched low priced segment Sonata. Sonata was so successful that it
cannibalized the sales of all Titan watches across the board. Titan consequently
is wary of Sonata diluting its premium image. Even if we consider sonata as
separate from Titan then it was second to titan in terms of turnover, leaving
behind Timex and HMT. Therefore Titan planed to drop its name and leave the
brand as Sonata under TATA thereby distancing the parent brand from the
extension’s low price association.
Another problem for Titan can be reflected in terms of VP marketing’s concern:
"For us, the main concern was: Does the sum of all our communication for Raga,
Classique and Regalia add up to Titan? We felt it didn't besides; building each of
them as separate brands is a very expensive proposition. So, instead of a multi -
brand strategy here, we're going to unveil a single-brand one.
Titan has been facing a dilemma that whether it should market these brands as
independent sub-brands or not, but it because of the high costs carried on with
status quo but with more emphasis on segments.
It is also putting in place a strategy to tap the rural market rigorously. Titan is
currently in test market in rural Andhra Pradesh. While has the product and the
brand for this market in the form of 'Sonata', and reach in terms of distribution,
but in terms of Titan they don't have the communication. Mistake companies
generally make in approaching the rural market is to see as one large lump,
while in reality the market is very segmented and distinct.
Titan has been the first one to build upon style, but in terms of marketing if we
consider Classique or any other brand it was not targeting any particular
segment initially with a focus, whether it was the youngsters or the Children.
Thus there was a need to foray into these already present segments.
TATA
TITAN
SONATA
The price differential between the two ranges -- Sonata and Titan -- was not very
significant. If Sonata was priced at Rs 845, a similar-looking Titan would be
priced at Rs 1,200. What's more, the look of the two watches was not very
different either. They sold through the same distribution outlets.
As a result, very often, a value-conscious Titan buyer would end up settling for a
Sonata. Cannibalization between Titan and Sonata rose from 15-20% in the first
year to almost 30% by the end of the second year. Titan's initial reaction was to
cap Sonata's volumes at 2 million watches so that it did not cut into the mother
brand's volumes. But that meant that Sonata was unable to stem the onslaught
of the unorganised competition. Now in a change of tactic Titan has decided to
take the grey market head on. Says vice-president, sales and marketing, Bijou
Kurien: "Earlier, the pricing and positioning of Sonata vis-a-vis the grey market
was tentative." As a part of the new strategy, Sonata, with an ad budget of Rs 5
crore which is double than last year’s is being positioned as an aspirational watch
for the grey market consumer.
In 1998-99 if we consider Sonata as different from Titan then this 2-year-old
brand managed to clock sales of nearly 2.4 million units, marginally less than
numero uno Titan. To prevent cannibalization and drive distribution penetration,
Titan is creating a dedicated distribution infrastructure for Sonata.
Now Sonata will be sold as under the banner of TATA. For instance, earlier the
same distributor salesman would go to sell both Titan and Sonata to a retailer.
Now that system has been changed. Two different salesmen go on different days
to the same retailer to sell Titan and Sonata as separate brands. That way,
instead of competing with each other for space, Titan and Sonata can hope to
grab market share away from other brands.
Already, Sonata has also added 500 outlets in the last one year, thereby pushing
up the total coverage to 6,000 outlets. Sonata's next big opportunity is to open
up new markets. The company now plans to set up about 10 Sonata showrooms
—exclusive franchised outlets—this fiscal. The strategy, however, will be to go
into smaller towns, such as Bhopal, where it is opening its first Sonata
showroom.. Within these towns, Sonata showrooms will be located in ‘watch
localities’ rather than ‘hot and happening places’. ‘‘We now have to get into
smaller towns and make it an economic proposition,’’ Mr Kurien said.
The debate is whether to launch this new line under the ‘FasTrack’ umbrella or as
a new brand altogether. So while keeping to the FasTrack brand field and
imagery, Titan may launch a “different look” one that would be more feminine
and colourful in comparison to the men’s line which is more instrumental, sporty
and macho. Once the product is with a ‘fashion’ tag, then the realisation of its
fickleness and thereby, constant change is the only way to survive. Titan
Industries, which forayed into fashion watches in 1998 with Fastrack, has
recognised the greater need for upgradation in this segment more than any
other, and will come out with a new collection for men and women by the year-
end.
Fastrack, though positioned for the 15-25 years age group, has a lot of older
customers in its net as well. In the Titan portfolio, Fastrack contributes to 4 per
cent in value and the company has decided to establish it as an independent
brand because of its high penetration potential.
Titan earlier launched into several sub-brands, but it cared little to communicate
their meaning to consumers. Now Titan is changing the position with Titan as
umbrella link brand with clear differentiation of the sub-brands. Coming up with
Fastrack Titan is using smart new designs (for men and women) to counter
Swatch and Esprit, which have won the admiration of the style – conscious Indian
youngster. There is a fine example of this strategy in form of advertising
campaign for DASH As a marketing experiment at the showrooms, Titan decided
to have the Dash display at the height of 3.5 feet to make it more accessible to
the child. It also kept colorful stools for the children to stand on to have a better
look at the watches. Inspired by nightlife and urban lifestyle, a multimedia
campaign will herald the launch of this dramatic product-line. This includes
television commercial, print ads, billboards, in-store display material and web-
based promotions.
THE TATA BUSINESS EXCELLENCE MODEL (TBEM):
Titan Industries has signed up to implement the compliance plan laid out by the
TBEM.Beginning July 2000, it will be evaluated on 7 parameters that constitute
the TBEM: leadership, strategic planning, customer and market focus,
information and analysis, process management, human resources focus, and
business results. The goal is to reach a score of 600 in next five years. Titan
currently stands second in the Tata group, with a score of 450, after Tata Steel.
The objectives of TBEM are:
Ø To provide a framework for the group to become competitive.
Ø To work as a competition to ensure participation.
Ø To acquire competitiveness using quality as the route.
Ø To monitor the progress through ratings.
Ø To become a transformational tool for every company.
The TBEM drives excellence across functions in the following manner:
1. The Leadership criterion checks how senior leaders create leadership
system based on
Group values. With the able leader in form of Mr. Xerxes Desai at the helm of
affairs, Titan has become a dynamic, vibrant and pro-active organization.
2. The Customer and Market Focus checks how the company determines
customer groups, key
Customer needs, and complaint-management issues. Titan has always been a
customer centric organisation and always has focused on satisfying the customer
demands.
3. The Strategic Planning criterion examines how the company develops
strategic objectives,
Action plans, and resource-allocation. Since its inception, Titan has been the
shaper of the watch industry. It has identified the future trends well in advance
and taken appropriate steps in the right direction to emerge as the leader in the
industry.
4. The Information and Analysis criteria check whether the organisation
has key metrics in place
To measure and analyse performance. Being market-driven, Titan has its
information systems in place and has its hand on the pulse of the watch market.
5. The Human Resources Focus checks the appraisal system, the work
environment, and the
Training and development of the employees.
6. Process management examines the product design, production
and delivery process, and
Supply chain management. Titan has pioneered the style concept in the watch
industry and is the undoubted leader in design.
Strategy Evaluation
Titan banks on Cutting edge technology that has helped Titan create value-for-
money price and the result is extraordinary marketing presence in about 40
countries, with a network of some 3,500 retailers abroad and high volume of
domestic presence.
Titan has segmented the market on the basis of the following variables:
Ø Demographic: The segmentation here is done on the basis of social class i.e.
working class, middle income group etc. since marketing is potentially and
intimately connected with the “ability to pay” this segmentation is meaningful in
analysing buying patterns of a particular class.Age, children, young, adults,
Social class: upper, middle and lower come in this category.
Ø Psycho graphic: In Psychographic segmentation buyers are divided into
different groups on the basis of lifestyle and personalities. People within the
same demographic group can exhibit very different Psychographic profiles.
Lifestyle : professionals, affluent Personality: adventurous, “cool”, traditional
Ø Behavioral: Benefits: functional, attractive, reliable, Occasions: gifts, special
occasions
Ø Geographical: Region: Europe, Middle-east
This was the major re-emphasise of the sub-brands. Titan’s first attempt at
emphasizing its sub-brands didn’t yield the desired results. Instead of targeting
different customer segments with different sub-brands (as is being done now),
the watchmaker focused on product differentiation as the selling platform With
product differentiation being replaced by segment-based focus, Titan’s sub-
brands building has got bright chances of creating an identity of their own.
Positioning Strategies
Since its introduction, Titan has been positioned as a premium brand, providing
high quality products. With its numerous sub-brands catering to different
segments, the challenge that Titan faces is to create a strong brand image. It
follows different positioning strategies, these strategies can also be analysed in
the present context of Sonata, Fastrack, dash and Raga, Classique and Regalia as
;
Ø Attribute positioning:
When the company launched its products, it was the first to bring quartz
watches to the Indian market. The company successfully leveraged this to
penetrate the market and gain a market share. Raga Classique and Regalia come
under this strategy. Classique has been positioned as elegant corporate wear
that leaves a quiet, but definite impression and fusion of function and
sophistication. Power dressing now has a new weapon! Regalia as Magic in gold
and unique futuristic material, finely crafted sleek cases and patterned dials with
special appliqué flowing into intricately designed bracelets. A unique combination
of an all-gold and bicolour look, the 'Regalia' range represents the essence of
dress-wear. Raga has been differentiated and positioned as Exclusive watches for
women. The Raga and Silver Raga collection is elegant, delicate and feminine
with each piece being truly unique. An exciting collection that includes
decorative motifs, 'kadas', studded bracelets and a first of its kind three-in-one
watch. The designs are inspired by traditional Indian as well as contemporary
motifs and are expressed in ropes, 'kadas' and ornamental bracelets. Crafted
exclusively for the sophisticated woman, who wears silver jewellery with elan,
the Silver Raga makes a perfect accessory that completes a woman's wardrobe.
Ø User positioning:
Titan caters to several user groups- children (the Dash), sportspersons and
adventurers (PSI4000 and Fastrack range). The Fastrack range is seen as being
contemporary, sturdy and reliable. The advertising, packaging and
merchandising of this range is young, vibrant and ‘cool’ (the ad line says “Cool
watches by Titan”)
Ø Benefit positioning:
The Fastrack Digital range offers the customer a functional watch that is also
attractive. The digital watch has a “techno-geek” image, but Titan seeks to
differentiate its offering on the basis of superior style and attractiveness.
Ø Competitor positioning:
With the entry of several foreign watchmakers into the market, Titan had to
counter the threat. Most of the entrants are catering to the upper end of the
market- Omega, Tissot, Cartier etc. Titan already had the Tanishq brand in this
segment. However, it has tried to reposition this brand by increasing the price
range to encourage more customers.
In order to truly gauge the extent to which Titan has built itself into a nationally
recognized brand, we need only refer to marketing guru Al Ries’ definition of the
word, which is “a brand is a proper noun that can be used in place of a common
word”. In the Indian context Titan can be taken as for the watches. This is what
marks the difference between a mere name of a product, and a brand.
Perhaps one of the most highly regarded works on brand building is the now
classic ‘22 Immutable Laws of Branding’ by the father and daughter team of Al
and Laura Ries. Using these laws we can see the Titans Brand building strategies.
In our view the disassociation of the Sonata brand from the parent Titan and its
further association with TATA was a well long term planned strategy, as the
association of Sonata built in quite strong with Titan and Titan in Indian context is
synonymous with Watches thus a strong association of Sonata with the watches
segment developed. But as we have seen that the sonata has been cannibalizing
the Titan sub-brands, whether this strategy is able to bring back the style image
of Titan back. This all exercise leads to the conclusion that Titan is on a path of
Fortification