Major Premise 1: Not prisoners of war

Minor premise 1: don't have a country protecting them(Under this Convention, civilians are
afforded the protections from inhumane treatment and attack afforded in the first Convention to
sick and wounded soldiers. Furthermore, additional regulations regarding the treatment of
civilians were introduced. Specifically, it prohibits attacks on civilian hospitals, medical
transports, etc. It also specifies the right of internees, and those who commit acts of sabotage.
Finally, it discusses how occupiers are to treat an occupied populace.)
Minor premise 2: Intelligence standards to datene prisoners at BLACK sites, and approval from
Headquarters
Minor premise 3: They themselves have violated the geneva convention
Major Premise 2: You can get valid information
Minor premise 1:Only 39 detainees at cobalt were subjected to the IE techniques only 5.6% of
the detainees that were subjected to IE techniques did not produce proper intelligence, all of
them were terrorists (US Senate committee on intelligence)
Minor premise 2: Minor premise 3: The information that lead to the death of Bin Laden was
originally gained at the CIA BLACK sites.
Minor Premise 3: Detainee information is a key tool for validating clandestine sources. In fact, in
one case, the detainee's information proved to be the accurate story, and the clandestine source
was confronted and subsequently admitted to embellishing or fabricating some or all of the
details in his report.
Major Premise 3: It's not actually torture
Minor premise 1: No permanent physical/mental damage torture causes long lasting and
psychological damage
Minor premise 2:
Minor premise 3:
rewbuttles
they had psychologists on site to determine if the psychological state was ok to continue IE
techniques
Based on these facts, we conclude that KSM's allegations of Saifullah Pai-acha's involvement in
a plan to smuggle explosives into the United States motivated the FBI to track down and arrest
Uzhair Paracha in New York just a few days later(so there is interdepartmental communication)
Doctors were on site to check the physical state of the datennes.
program ron for 4 years only 6 added in 3 years
conditions improved after a while at the sight

The Study asserts that the "CIA representation that the use of the CIA's enhanced interrogation
techniques produced otherwise unavailable tactical intelligence related to Shkai,
Pakistan(studies name is redacted in the Senate document)
back up2pt2 intelligence derived from the use of CIA's enhanced interrogation techniques
thwarted a plot against the U.S. military base, Camp Lemonier, in Djibouti
On March 25, 2003, while being subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques, KSM provided
U.S. domestic threat information concerning Saifullah Paracha and his son, Uzhair Paracha.
KSM stated that Saifullah Paracha was a Pakistani businessman in Karachi, who owned a
textile business with a branch in New York City. KSM alleged that his nephew, Ammar alBaluchi, and Majid Khan had discussed a plan with Saifullah to use his textile business to
smuggle explosives into the United States. SM was also aware that Ammar al-Baluchi and Majid
Khan had approached Saifullah and Uzhairto help resettle Majid Khan in the United States,
where Majid had plans to blow up several gas stations. KSM stated that Ammar was hoping that
Paracha could sponsor Majid's entry into the United States, if necessary. KSM alsotold his
interrogators that''Uzhair may have provided other logistical support for Majid's entry into the
United States Finally, KSM noted that Saifullah owned a media company in Pakistan and had
traveled to Kandahar, Afghanistan, in 1999 to meet with Usama Bin Ladin for the purpose of
offering al-Qa'ida the services of his media company. (Both were caught tried and convicted)
CIA, FBI, and Department of Justice documents show that information obtained from KSM after
he was waterboarded led directly to Faris's arrest and was key in his prosecution.
as a result of the lawful use of EITs,' KSM 'provided information that helped lead t the arrests of
terrorists including... Saleh Almari, a sleeper operative in New York
The CIA interrogation program played a key role in disrupting the "Second Wave" plot and led to
the capture of the 17- member al-Ghuraba group ("second wave suicide hijacking operations in
the Unites States and Europe.")
"second wave suicide hijacking operations in the Unites States and Europe."
CIA documents show that key intelligence collected through the CIA's Detention and
Interrogation Program, including information obtained after the use of enhanced interrogation
techniques, played a major role in disrupting the Karachi hotels bombing plot.
The chain of events leading to KSM's (one of the masterminds if sept 11)capture begins in
earnest with Zubaydah's interrogation on August 20, 2002, when, during his second period of
being subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques
CIA records clearly indicate that sleep deprivation played a significant role in Abu Zubaydah's
identification of JosePadilla as an al-Qa'ida operative