Medical Teachers

FO u r t h E d i t i o
A Pra
t ic a l G u id e f o
M E D ICA L T EA C H E R S
E d it e d b y
J Ohn A
Fo
re w o rd
De
re e r
n a
ld M
Ha rde
b y B r ia n D H o d g e s
.
de v elop m
SU p p O R T
Ca
Ro
ba
s e
. n
ta
| X
ip
Pr o f e s s io
E D U C A T I O N A L S T R A T E G IE S
d D is t a n
c e e
du
ca
t io
x %
x &H
s c ie n c e s
n a
lis m
A t ti tu de M
'
' " '" P+r '

r e v Ie w
"
i =g
a S C
l e a r n i n g In t e g r a t e d M e n t o r i n g T e a m b a s e d l e a r n i n g
I n s p i r e p l a n n i n g a n d D Ev E L o p M EN T p r a c t i c a l r e s e a r c h
le
de r sh ip
Ev i d e n
c e
ba se d
a ss e s s m e n
W r it t e n
m e
dic in
a s se s s m e n
WO&HP. ACE$ SSESs M EHT
P r o b l e m b a s e d le a r n in g
t s im u la t e d / s t a n d a r d is e d p a t ie n t s
Un de rgra du
Pa t ie n t
sa
te
d ic in e
E t h i c s S HT
A m bu l a t o r y c a r e t e a c h i n
g
E D U C A T IO N A L S T R A T E G I E S D i s t a n c e e d u c a t i o n
fe t y
te
a ch
m a
ll g r o
p t e a c h i n g SU p p O RTI V E
p I E R A S S IS T E D L E A R N I N G O u t c o m e b a s e d c u r r i c u l u m
C H U RCI JI L L
L I V I N G ST O N E
U STN U T
Scanned by CamScanner
Cc1r e e r b a s e d
A Pra
t ic a l G u id e f o r
M E D ICA L T EA C H E R S
C o n t e n t St r a t e gi s t : L a n ma 1a 11u n l 1' >

C o n t e n t Devel opm
ent Sw c j j j j j s t : A l ln
Pr o j = c t M a n a ge r 1 [ r c 1r 1 1' dr ez
D e s i gn e r C l l r i s r i u r i l l i lbo w
I ll u s t r a t i o n M a n a ge r : l er1ni j Ro s e
'
1 A iw
A Pra
t ic
l G u id e f o
M E D I CA L T EA C H E R S
Fo
u r
t h E d it io
E d i t e d by
-
A D
IM e m
H_
t M M E D M D F H EA F R C S (E d )
l R e l a t i o n s Of f i c e r A s s o c ia t io n f o r M e d i f E
ca
d u c a t io n in E u r o e
,
p
R e a d e r i n M e d +c a Ed u c a t i o n a n d O r t h
o p a e d ic S u r e r
g y , U n iv e r s it y
Uk
en
a t io n a
du ndee
f Du n de e
d M HO E M D F R C P (G l a s ) F R C P C F R C S Ed
G e n e r a l S e c r e t a ry A s s o c i a t io n f o r M e d i l E d
ca
u c a t io n m E u r o e Fo r m e r p
r o fe s s o r o
p ;
M e d , c a l E d u c a t i o n D i r e c t o r o l th e C e n t
r e f o r M e d . c a Ed u c a t i o n
a n d Te a c h i n
g De m
U n iv e r s i t y o f D u n d e e U K P r o f e s s o r o f M d i
e
c a l Ed u c a ti o n A H m a m U
n i v e r s it
y
R iy a d h S a u d i A r a b i a
,
Fb r e
w o rd
b/
D H o d g e s P HD M D F R C PC
R ic h a r d a n d E l , z a b e t h C u m e C h a i r m H lt h P
ea
r o f e s s ia n s E d u c a t i
o n Re s e a r a
Wi ls o n
Ce n t r e fo r R e s e a r c h i n Ed u c a ti o n P r o f e s s o F
:
r,
a c u l ty o f M e d i c i n e
a n d Fa c u lv o f Ed u
c a ti o
( O l s u u T) U n i v e r s i t y o f To r o n t o : V i c e P r e s i d e n t E d
u c a h o n U n iv e r s i t
y H e a l th N e w
To r o n t o O n t a r , o C a n a d a
,
LO n d o n
N e w Yo r k
O x fo r d
P h i la d e ]p h la
S t L o u 1s
Sy d n e y
To r o
n to
2 0 13
CH U R C H I L L
L 1V . N G ST O N E
E L 5E
a n
t 1n
Fo
pn
u r
f Els c
t o
L 1m
1c r
h Ed l t t o n
i t c \l
20 13 E1 e \ t
Lim
N o p J r t o t t h i s p u b l l t 1t m n m a y b B
m \ 1u d i n g phnt { UP! 1n g r L L F n h n
g
h t p u hl l s h l
a rr rn
fo
gc m e n t s m
u n
at
bc
a n
n o t
: d l
1t c
d t hc
1n
M hc
hw
o n
to
m za t io n b
b\
\ w
0rv t d u a l
l 5c
re
p r o du
u r
an
c e
tn
ht s
r ig
fo
sc r
d
d
o r t r an sm ittc
1n
a n
s t o r a gt
m l a t 1o n
an
fo r n i
it ho
l sys t e m
a b o u t t hc P u b li s h e r
w
ter an d
]c c t r o n i c
o r
t p u n n is s io n
1n
rn c an s
per mi ssi ons
h c C o p y r i g ht L i c e
n sin
m ( d 1a n
ic a l
w r 1t i n
lr o
p o l ic
ies an
g A ge n c h
c a n
m
o u r
bF
sin n s
t l o ri s c o n t u n e c l i n
bu
co n t n
"c 1 1
a n
r e t r ie v a
l u r t F1c r 1n f o r m a t i o n
s e e k p c r m i ss l o n
Cen
s u c h a s t h e C o p y r g t1 t C l e a r i n c c
rc r c o i n
by
o r
prot
1t J r c
ect ed u n
de
r co
p y r ig ht b y t
he P u b l is h e r
(o t h e r t ha n
as
r c ln
20 0 ]
o u r w
T hu o k
Fi r
D e t a t l\
d A ll
it e
C, r . J 1dl t 10n 2 0 0 5
Ti
Jr t
* Ed r t r 1J n Z L Q
Tt h = d u o n 2 0 13
R T
i 211 4
tr
n n
I SB N 9 7 8 0 T { 7 0 45 5 1 6
B r i L i b r a r
m t a io
t a 1 g u
Ca
r c i
u e
t v.
l i b r a r y o f C o n g m Ca t d 1 r
tx v .
A c a Ta l o g r e o T d : J .
cl ue
T hc
N
eTu t
1e d Sr r Y F
l 3 5 1t t r o
P = !: : ; r a t i o
1 11
H 9
D a ta
Tt l r5 n
3 \ J
I nl
ro m
h ( B r i t 1s h L t b r a r y
1n
ta
h c b br a r y
f C o n gr e s s
bli c do
t l Be p u
r n a 1n
o tices
Kn
u n
l o dg r -
dcT1-
m m
d hd
&
rcs
1-
do
f u 1r
* n
Br
o r
a r
o r
d t ht
re
Bc t y
ly
o n
he i r
dr
1m c n t $
l r
t h n
o #
gi n g A
c x
w r 1b c
1n
s n t w
1c N T d
p(T
J hc r c
\ u t <1n
r 1t m
t B 1
d
l
da
u
an
r >j ) 1n u
1:d .
r cl
t o p 1T t i
mr t f \
t hr
f
) n
&
t }l r
tm m
Trm
t l w la w
ru
ie r he a lt h
an
In
ln
r \\
t
1 w
l r
B,
c Bw r 1
t \ : wr Bef 1. c
]
I B, 1b t n }Bc
pn ) J r t )
l u 1l
B\
r t i
lm
t l u
J \ J
i
a r, t
l l \ Bd u a ] N
r n u r t
h,
l 1u t t e r
Tl u n 7
1t
< l. n
B u t 1t
o
. )
t 1c n t
r \
B p d
r Bd > d \
te
C lu n
ho
t t 1 Bt 1 h A I t B
1
\Iw
1i 1 v h
t bo n
lm l
\ , \
n t n
a n
l e d ge
h tn fo
t
c x
be c o
c \ a u a
br o a d e n
c n c n c e
r m J t 1o n
he ) h a l
t J 1n
: =A l l B 1
u a*
m * ir k
tw
t5
t 1n g
o u r
m e
n c c -
u s 1n
a n
an
h o d s t h e y s h o u ld b
i o n J l r e s p o n s i b i l 1
o r m et
p r o fc m
ln
l t h e i r ut \ ent
Le
111
1t , ) n
l 1J l , i h t y
u 1t\
\ u n
<t u
co m
t r e atm e n t m ay
o w
su
an \
11q
Pn
d kn
u si n
fo
a r t 1c s
: 1/ -
V V l(
rese are
d ic a l
o r m e
r a c t l c 5
c u t 1 a l p r o d u t s l d c n t l %c d r c a d c r \ J r c a i \ l s c d t o c h e c k t h c n 1 o s t c u r r e n t
i d T Li $ o r F \ z d c d ( 1) o n } t d u r e ) f m t u r c d t ) r (1Bj b y t h c r 1nu: act ur cr o f c a c h p r m t u c t t o t w a nu ni c r c d t o
r f 1 r d w ( r f o r m l1 t
m e t h o d a n i l t t u r i t 1o n u f a . l T\ 1m \ t r J t 1o n B n d L \ n t r 1 1n d i c m o n s l t i s t h e
B t Bo n
fc t
d.
c lu
&
:w u r
t t;
u o n J
L o n st J n
arc
h o d s F r o fc
m u r t a <H a y
c om
u
%c l d
m ct
y * Or
pc
r e Lo n
Tu t i
u sc
to
Fr
r n Tu n r
1n
m. n
br
r r $ p o m s r in
dn
l r
io a
f}
d r
an
r ar ch
Ln
r r = h
LTI t Bu s
c e
c hes
f-
\n
1n
bl i c
in g i n P u
hc
ll
ap
\rr e
\\ t \! n
negl \ en_c
m a
to
p r u p r 1a t c
\r n al
hr
am
o t o t
r c \n
m J
m
kt J d i agn
fc t y p r c
in \e an
hc n
To
o se s
c J t 1t m n s
h B b Bh t
o r
\ mm
fo r
an
Cont en
Fo r e w o r d
Pr e f a c e
C o n bu t o
ix
x
r s
SE C T I O N 1 C U R R I C U L U M D EV E L O P M E N T
1
N e w ho r iz o
J A
Den
Cu
R M
T he
u n
S L e in
R M
lu
r r ic u
in
n s
> a
p la n
dic a l
m e
du c a t io n
r d en
r 1i n
d de v e lo p m
an
en t
a r d e +1
d e r gr a du
t e c u r r i c u lu m
a n
li n i c a l
t eac
gr a du a t e t r a in i n g
D wml l N G R 1 l
Po
Co
hi n g i n
the e a r
ly y e a r s
16
ste r
st
23
n t
D A
in
in g pr
a tris
G o td t 1a
Pr e p a r in g f o
fe s sio
ge
n a
n e r a
l d e v e lo p m
Pe r r i e r I
,
e nt
32
siluer
l p r a c t ic e
42
T G i bb s
T he hi dde n
c u r r ic u
H j er t y
E w
lu
52
Gt 1t t berg
SE C T I O N 2 L EA RN I N G S IT U AT I O N S
8
Le ct u
G
Br o u tn
Sm
S 0 tl u
l l gr o
.)
S j
10
r e s
p te
BB1
ac
hin g
Ic M
u r 11i Br H,
ds
s k ills c ( n t r c
C lin i c a j
69
o m Bn
teac
hin g
75
J 5 Ker
t t acbi ng
id
1]
B(
12
A m bu la t o r y
d s
in
he
c o m m u n it
R S Wo r l e y ,
]4
Ru
ra
4 ca
15
t L :l c
hin g
93
D ell :
j A
a Br c
84
t t r Ae
D ist a n
J G
a n
c e
m B1t
t=
Bco t l r l
du
103
1) C ( n Bp t
r c m o
c a
lo
c a t io n s
112
t io n
A Z c1 c h d r i a l t
12 1
1G Pe e r
17
C.
l D
A f T 1. o s s ,
e n t o r in
d le a r n i n g
a s s is t e
m m '"
13 4
S EC T I O N 3 1 D U C AT I O N A L ST I AT EGI ES
b a b c 9l
1S
Ou
19
In de pe n de n
20
Pr o b l e m
,
t = o r w
E S,
le a r n in g
f , o Jl
+ I
'
T a n b a h v d <c
22
In
23
I n t e r p r o :e s s io
"
(r y
stu
dy
' '
"
a i n
Si m
\ 1'
1 1.
k i ll s
16 6
n er
in g
IA H
1 r c
'
"
l P D
Y F
M o b 1l e l e
c a t io n
19 9
oer
,ec
k..
20 7
a . .
2 15
du
c a t io n
22 1
i n g (m l e a r n i n g )
G S Fr i l l \
ar n
Ba r s
"
du
G . p ha , d t
m e d ic a l e
E [ Ea x
J E S.
' 83
d s t a n d a r d iz e d p a t ie n t s
u at e
D igi t a l
n a
4 0 0 L S A N D A I D S
28
gr a t e d l e a r n i n g
" . . I n t l , r 1 K . 1s 1:
\$ Ca
27
1.
te
26
a n
b a s e d le a r n in g
21
du c a t io
23 1
S E C . 0 N 5 C U . ( I C U I t j h I I I I I s
29
30
Ba s i c
sc ic n c = s a n
W n-
..
c u r r i c u lu m
Et h i c s
an
a t t it u
246
de s
.
33
239
A V C a r n i ' b, Bl j C B\ r r 1 1: C V"
32
o u tvm llc s
L mh n u u
C l i n i c a l c ommuni c at i on
J i ( SA. l t .
31
Pr o l e s s i o n a l i u
P M G l i t 1H o ! )
C H
"
2 62
Ev i d e n c e b a s e d
2 53
: Sl t
m e
Tn
d ic in e
2 70
Co
34
Pa t i e n
! Dro
t s a fe t y
2 76
S EC T I O N 6 A S SE S S N
35
Co
n c e
J N
o r c
36
p t s in
in
285
a sse ssm e n t
< r i c h B1Bl \ i l e n D a
id
St a n d a r d
j
37
se t t in g
i
o r c i +1
D W M c K in l e y
W r it t e n
L
a s s e s s iTt e n
Pc r f o
r r r a n c e
1 t i l e r i t l ge
Po
r t
39
fo l io
E W D
40
a n
I' M
w o r
1<o t +r s 1c o
S }
tla l l
d e r
kplac e
V l e t Bt e B\
a sse ssm e n
307
3 14
a sse s sm e n
n es sen
2 99
W 1 Sc Bl t Bw i n .1 C
,
38
29 2
e e n e 1m 1 t \
P M
1ra B\ d e r
V le
G i v i n g fe e db a c k
S K
41
Ev a l u
S G
Bc k o
&
m sbur
323
'
g p r o fe
tin
1Bt e n
ss io n a
lis m
333
S E C T I O N 7 ST A F F A N D ST U D E N T S
42
M
j
43
44
dic al
c K i m
St u d e
t su
pp
St a f f d e v e lo p m
A
c a
3 62
D
e n
369
e n t
ic
st a n
da r ds
a n
ho la r s h ip
sc
377
e 1i n t 1
Pu b l i s hi n g
Ed u
343
353
o r t
J A
1t 1 \ e r
J Bl i gh j
48
le c t io n
St u d e n
S M
47
se
N t Ls
r 1e
l e a d e r s hi p
c a t io n
S J L i e .l
C M cM
Ste
46
du
n t
R J D t B1
45
3 85
.. r o
c a t io n a
1e
e n v
ir
o n m e n
392
5 M c A le e r S lc u j j
49
d ic a l
C {r l t B l d
50
o w
to
du
c i 1t i n
I : l
m
a n a
re searc
400
I co / t e r Bs
ge
m td
ic n l
c o
lle ge
40 7
BB j f f Bl BBd y
In de
4 15
Fo
I t is
r e w o r
ho n
an
o w
he :o
to pc n t
o u r
fo
11 s
in
u r t
d 1 t 1o
rc w o r
pm
h i s %n c h o o k
i
c r c t r 1 c r1 i l t Jo r
+n o r c
l t hc a r e d e l i v e r y i t s e l f b e c o m e s m o r e a n
ad
t
l
h
t
t
r
t
F
c
i
s
a
a
e
t
d
d
in t c rp ro e ss o n
an
t c a rn ba s e
:
h
T
th
u
r
o
l
b
l
c
i
l
e
t i e n s t o t tn tx ) o k a r c p a r t l c u a r y v a u a
h
h
i
l
t
t
c
w
o
s
e
r
a
r
c c t 0u n I s d c s R n c d t o h e l p c d u c i l t
g pp
i
h
n
h
[
d
c
s
s
a
o
l
l
tc c n o
an
c v c R w i dc m n g s c o p e o : t o o
p g
$
w h i l c t h e %f t h s e c t i o n t a k e s u p
c d n i ] p d u c a t io n
I n t h is
t o p i c s t ha t rl o rn c dic a l ho o t c a n n e gle c t
u
m
c
a t io n s
s e c t io n
c o n s t d c r a t i o n s Fo r t e a c h i n g c o m m
h
h
d
n c w
w 1t
( n
a n c c
c t h l c s a n d p r o f e $ s 1o n a ] 1s n 1 a H
w i lt be
w r i t i n g a b o u t p J t 1c n t s a f e t y
s o m e t hi n g t ha t
ht
to t
B( [ B1 7i a r l l e r s h a s b e t o r n c t h
t
g o t o s o u r c e fo r
h e a l t h pr o%
ssi onal c ] u c a t o r s Hl o r c t h a n e v e r t n j s t e d
s o \ 1r c c s a r
r t wnr cd J t 3 t \ m c w h c H s i g n i %c a n t changes
r
s h a p t w h a t 1t 1 111 a n s t o b
e a ]c a r n c r
\n e d u c a t o r o r
i n d e e d t o n 1n
\ mi c a l
x c hm } l
T h c r i s t o r 1n t c r
t 1 a m b a se d
pr o te s sro n a l
c d u c a t 1o n
a n d
p r a c t tc e
A e d
gr e
cc r
at te n t io n
1u d d c n
d
t
nt \ \
lu
c u r n cu
e rs a n
teac
c c
hn
he
n \
rs
c v tT
+n
lu
st a
ra
p id ly
1w
c o n te x ts
an
b i l it y
o f le a r n
ld n d t hc n sc o r
f t hc f o r c e s = ha n gl n g
co m
dr
pa m
u c a l ly
a m a
o n
T he
t w o
1n
w a
hc
idc
u
n
n e w
f\
t l
Thc de
e du
o r
t x
p
o
s Ji n
ca t o r s
t o
t o
p 1c S
c r
t s
a n
f t h e bo
ke e p
co n
lt
m a
ke s
c lo s e
bt
On
so u r c e s
r e
,u
1t
r ea c
st
fu
ldc a
a n
pra
1n
t ic e s o r
he r lc a r m
he
%c e
1g n c
se c u o n
a c r o ss
de
it h
1s
ga n iz
o r
f-
tu aw s
hc
ho ol
per
se
pr a
d 1c J
rn c
rr u
( o n t 1n u u r n
i n
du
t
c t i ca
l t bt r nt ,
c a t 1u n
ht
%m
h
%r s t
e a c
sec t io n s,
se l e n
in
T hc
m
Iu
d5 > b
n \c
dr=J l
hr o
ts
tn t
r o
du
: he
e c I n
t .l l r
w
s> t
o 11 t
t lu n
tl
b l . l ld
t pH
1l r
u ri
t ht
.. e ( t ) r n
r t Bl
ru uc
a r m n
t>
Rt
r \
l l L 1 r l 11 K
l 1l r l # I l t
1\
LI 1
o
u l u p p
R
w e l l > t J b l l \ 1\ 1x < ] p p r o 1 L I r t \ h \ l L j j
a l4) n = u d c
]e m b J w t l l c a r m n H u u t c ( t f r l t \ t 1 r l t r i t t t l > L I I AL
l n d I l l > 1t t p l \ u \ 1\
\\ t
e l t l i r c c t t d It u r n l n
b a s e d r n t r g r a c c d a n d 1n t c r l B r u l t \ \ l o 11 1 l t t <u \
r J ne
he r
g dem
du
c a
h p r o fo u n d
t hi s
a n d
h e l p fu l r e s o u r c e
su c
ha
o n
ll
su r e
t ht r c
to
l pro
ha t
t 1o n
t0 0
Is r
m an
du
in
o
st r at e thc
T he s ix t h
a ss e ss i n
c x
pc
he
t o o ls
a n
pp r o a c he
d b u r ge o
n in
in
t s
n e
as se
c r < a ce
hc lm
o \ c n v
t 1o n
den
se n se
an
c hap
T he s e
up- t ac c
t
a s
ha s
tc
n d t r =a
e a r s
r As
li n i c a l
se c
st u
ha s
c at io n
r e c e n
c e
p le x
c o m
ig hl
du
re
fo
r o
co n
ca to r
c e s se s
r e n ce
s c l c e t 1o n
t he
lu
he e d u
de m o n
d tc a \
m c
ly he lp
a r c
ds
fe
r e
cv o
m t n t
ter s m
a n
t ro n J
fic
ter n
a rc a
t r o \ e r s 1c s
I B r t
u g } 1 t o l e a r n l n p 1n d t m L a l p r a L t 1 L t
d i s c u s s c u r r 1c u l u r n dcsl n i n t l i n t l 1 1s n c \ v
( i 1uon t h c cr ner } t nt n o t i o n o : 1 BuddLn L u r r 1L 1 l l u 1[11
t h a t 1s t h u u h t t u b a i c a t l t i s t a s m u l i 1 Bn 1p j l t o n
h c s c L o n t l s c L t l u n
st u d e n t s a \ t h c o \ c r t c u r n c u lu r n
b o o k a d d r c w \ t h c r r 1 1 r 1> t t m w \ t \ 1 n \ \ Iu L h
o f t hc
l l \ c L h 1p t e r h t n t l \ 1\
n Be d a J c d u 9 a t i o n t J k c
pb \ e
l \ 1m
s w t i o n r > r r 1 l n d u s t Fl a t o r 1 > \ 1/ 1 t l o t s n t Bt h t J l l
u u r A J m 1n l u m
w u n R m M r u Br wr aphn m n t c h
h J RM H R u n t e h m J l A m u H
m u n HH a n d n l c m
1u t l t u r
d a s s r w Jr n s h d \ . d > ) t i i t
p r t n 1t l L \ t t u t e Ht > \ t t 1
1
t
I
\
o
r
d
t
x
u
>
r t r \ l u n H u b l > Tl \ t \
u
e
l
d
o
t
t
t
n
a
n
9
a
a
sc
e )
to
o m e
g l 1c e
ra tu r e
a s s t s s mc n t
d %r u l s e c t i o n 15 t h c c a p s t o n e o f t h e
s e c t i o n d e J l s w r t h t h e e s s e n c e o f w h a t 1t
t o
111 0 3 n 5 t o b < a m e d i c a l c t t u L J t o r \ \ ' a t d o w e w w t
)
Fl o w d o h e c h o o s e t h e n e x t
a c h 1c \ e J \ c d u c a t o r
'
H o n m u w c s u p po r t o u r s t u d e n t s a n d
ge n e r a m n
I
o u r r< ea rc h
t 1L , o t h t t \ \ h 1l c a d v i n L l n R a o d t m i 1 a l l
'
p u b l i . T i o n s a n t i lv a , l r s h Jp I n t h 1s p 4 r t o f t h c b o o k
t h e r r Rd c r i s 1nv7t 1 t L \ l o i n u r r c i n f o r e c t h t t r p J r t 1 c 1
p a t w n 1n t 1w L o r n m u m t y o t p r a c u L t t h a t I s m . \ ht al
w lu l a t . i n
1 h e I L n 1r t h t t l 1t t . \ n o TA r r Tc f l c J G u t 1r l o r A 11 B d
h %Bt r r r \ \ u n t a i n \ \ r \ . H \ L lt > t \ o n b ) t h c w u r l d b
t u
l l \ u \ t t \ l s T t 6 u n 11 \ A d l L J l cdu. Jt 1L\ n l t \ \ J n t Cnt ul
1 c , C>nt h
a n
b o o k T h 1s
u i
w
ds
1n 1c
v ]
lc
w e
i n c rc a sl n
tc o m cs
lo
r e so u r c e
o
o u
to
a ssr o o m
The
de
t o
ic u la r ly
i t }1
pr o
1n
1s s u c s
bo
part
ys
1t s c n t r r c t y a s a c o m p c n d i t i m o F
f a c i n g h e a lt h p r o f e s s i o n s e d u c a t i o n t o d a y
T h e o \ e r a r c hl n g d e s r g n o F t hc bo o k f a c i lit a t e s s u c h a
c o m p r e h c n s l \ c r e a d i n g A 1t c r n a t n e l y t h c r e a d e r ( a n
d l p 1 n a n d o u t o c D n c l s e w e l l e d i t e d c h a p t e r s t o le a r n
t he
w o r
an
h c l p fu [
asln
g lo b a l u j n g
d rc Y l
G u 1t 1 15 t h c r c l o r c
F i r s t +c c a n b c r e a d
in cm
l o g 1c s a r
c du c an o n
m c
1n s t i t l 1t 1o n a
to
1w
1t 1o l l
\ r 11
B1n
1e \
hn
l l
u r\ >
n r n
>
h hu
lu
e t
1t o r
a t
tw
11 M. \ e\
n wn h e m
t \ l\ c
t
\ r J r c er .
a n
to
Bt
gr w
h h e h J Hc n e N
n wh L J l c d u c a m n c a r w
b L u l \ \ r t t c n t \w r , t \ 1mn. u p o n t h c b e s t
m n l\ , i r r t [
p r I L t 1L t \ \ \ B L U >l l L t l l u n \ 0 W1 1 1 C 1 1 t o r t c L h n o l L 6 \ o r
\ t r y e \ t \ l l t n L c L I e \ l u c \ t u r x t > e l 1n g J n r e d t L \ r cl At
I t [ > + 1 L I \ 1l l enex u \ m i r h e l l t T \u \ t n i r e l Lm b
o 11 t l w
I n BL r k i > 1m 1t t l \ L1\ t h I t i n t l w h e 5 l t l \ pmt css1on Lv c
1n
\ l l t > 1L h t 1\ i n t l w
1t r a l l h a n u n g
u
t t 1111
1t B[ t l \
I l r 1r Bt 1 D
l io
Ue s
M D p ho 1 RC PC
1b r
o rtt o
2 0 13
Pr e f a c
T he
Si n
c e
h o r i z o n s o f n i c d i c a + e d u c a t Io N a r c w i d e n i n
g
t h c F ir s t
Ed i t i o n o F A P r cBc t i c t t 1 G u i d e J r
t g lo b a l i n t
k i l ls
so n i c
du
t in
d ic a l
du
d in
h u r c fo
ls
re
t c r l n ati o n
j ourna s
ca t io n
Jo u r n a
a n
a n
n e e
a n
o t
he r
to
h c fu
n e \e
r o \1
o n
de
r t
ht
li n
iv e
a c
d e v l lo p m c n t
T he r e
r eso u r c es
su
ppo
r t
in
1s
tn c
f o r a la r ge r i n t e r n a t i o n a l gr o u p o f c o l
l e a g u e s 1n a l l h e a l t h c a r e p r o f e s s i o n s a n d a t a l l s t a g e s
o f t h e i r p e T So n a l p r o h s s i o n a l d c v t lo p m c n t
I f w e L e r e t o f o r m u l a t e a s t a t c m n t o f i n t e n t t o
e x p la i n t h e p u r p o s e o f t hi s f o u r t h e d i t i o n
w e m i g ht
s i m p l!
s ay t ha t o u r a lm
1s t o h e l p c l m ] c a l c o l l i a g u e s
In ge n e r a l
t o t e a c h a n d t o h e l p s t t d c n t
1o l e a r n
h e a h Hc a r e p r o : e w t o n a l s l i k t t o t e a c h a n d u u r d e s 1r c
t h r o u g h t h t / b o o k 1s t o p r o \ 1 0 c a p r a c t i c a l g u l d c t o
h e l p a c h f u l %l t h a t r o l t A p r a t t 1t a l h a n \ o n a p p r o a t h
v e r ) m u c h w f l e c t s o u r p h l l u / u p h ) 1\ i 1 l u ( h t u t t J L h i n g
Or
o p m m
a n d k a r n 1n g a s t o 1 n n o v H m n a n d d > CB
J1 l J )
J p p r L j c h
t h a t b u r +1t
a c k n o w l c dg c
w c
c o u r se
h \ 1t
J d 1 1 r t n t p c r s p > L \ 1 \ t
m e d 1c i l e d \ J c a t 1o n l r u n
}
l
b
a
r
l
u
n
t
l
t
u
>
t
L
1
n
e
1
r
n
l
l
l
e
v
e
t
r
n
r
o
W e st
n g )
R o ut
p
l
l
}
i
B
e
t
(
B
lt h t
h
l
h
h
r
o
t
n
1J
(
t
i
r
t
e
1.
n
e
a A
to
c r s in
e p o t
H
H
J
h
H
f
t
>
l
o
e
h
u
w
mn i n +
w r
c n t
m
m
1n
m n do t
w
N
n v t Rr n r r J n
a n d p r o > w m n a l d >wwnwn t
t
o f s t u J c n L \ u n d t r Bi n > c s w \ u L\ 1l l b e \ ( B 1\ t t l t > }\ r a t t \
e
du
c a t 1o n
c a r e
he n
pr
t
lw
Uf
u n
1l r
d All t
tu n n
lo n
n n n v
W'
I 11r l l t
w = H
r 1( r l t
h n l N
( ; i t + 1e
by
lo r
nBmT1t n, l >\ l
t lw
d l ( i I / r eudBer . v 1\ BI l } 1l )
B n t h M b d A m m n m n 1n 2 0 1n h m Nnual
M t c Br c a l I l u u k A w a r d \ 1r i 1 M 1[ l u n
A n c w m n d m m h M t t hn J \ lu n H H H HH W t o
l l t l 1t W h l \ h
w c b a v c \ p o t l t B<l r t > 4 l \ BT t l l t h r \
c m t r ge
l
t
.
b
t
r
=
r
}
r
a
t
a
f
t
\e
in
a r u cl i s c u s s L (
p
M
im
lu
by bo t h
po r tan
ce
ga g c
c n
t e a c he r s
an
r n a l l o n a l a c c n d i t a t io
d
ic a l e du c a t io n
e
T he
e
c o n tin u u m
p o s t g r a du
to
du
c d t1 c a t t o
m e
a n
a n
d ho
c u rr i
ts
sta n
du c a t io n f r o
d
i t h t he
de n
st u
t r a in i n g
a te
m c n
a n
d a r di z
u n
c o n t
in
in
de r gr a du
at e
at
io
m e
dic a l
fo r
m e
dic a l
u in
c a t io n
A d m i s s io
d ic a l
T hc
a c o n fe r e n e e s a r c a t t r a c t
1n g i n c r c a \ 1n g n u n l h c r s o r d c l c a t c
f r o m d c v c lo p c d
g
c o u n t n t s a s w e l l a s fr o m t ho s e w i t h e m e r in
g g t r ono
m ies
w ho
p r \ [ m s l y m a y 1a v e b e e n u n d e r r e p r e
s c n t e d a t r n t c m a t i o n a l n i c e t 1n s W c a r c s e c r n
g
g a rise
1n t h e u p t a k e o p l a c e s o n
d
t
t
o
s
r
a
u
a
e
c
i
o
t
r s c s in
p
g
m c drc a l c d u c a t l o n
m o r e ti c q u t i l t 1 s s u e s o f m e d i c a l
a t ro n a
lu
r r ic u
In t c
c a t ro n
d e v c l o p m c n t a n d s t r a t e gi e s
p r e v i o u s l y o v e r lo o k e d Ic a r n i n g o u t c o m e s
Cu
'
c d t 1c a t i o n
a n I n e r t a s c i
h
n e e t sstt y
r c x p c n c n e c i n e d u c a t io n
fo r a l l h e lt h c a r c r o := s s r o n a ls a n d t hc n t c d fo r
p
f o r m a l r e c o g m l 1o n o r s c h o l a r s h1 i n m e d ic a l
p
e re s
r t hc
a w a r c n (. s s o
s
de
r s
a n
s c le c t t o n
proc
sc
ho la r s hi p
a n
du
res
ht p
d ic a l
du
ma n a g c r n e n t
in
c a tio n
an d
c d t t Bo n h a s b e e n s i g n i f i c a n t l y r c v r s e d
l
d
h
h
d
d
v e n
s
b
b
l
e
t
t
t
i
t
e
a
s
e
s
a
a
i
a
o
o
e
e
n
s
s
e
p
p
t o tal
c h a p t e r s w t h o u t u n du ly c c p a n d in g t h e
n e w
l e n g t h o f t h e b o o k I n a d d i t i o n a f L1r t h e r 2 1 n c w
C o n t r i b u t o r s h a v e b r o u g h t a n e w p e T S Pe C t n e t o e x 1
A t o t a l o f 7 7 c o l l e a g u e s f r o m 14
1n g c h a p t e r s
c o
k
t n c s h a v e k 1n d l y c o n t r 1b u t c d t o t h l 5 e d i t i o n
a
rn g
m
t h c 6 4) o k t n 1l y r c p r c s e n t a t t v e o f i n t e m a t i o r u l o p 1n 1o n
o n ke
t o p c s 1n m e d i c a l e d u c a t i o n T h i s 1n t e m a t o n a l
l
h
a p & a
a s b e e n h r g h hg h t e d b ) t r a n s la t r o n s o f r e c e n t
d
C h m e s c ( f o r t h e Pe o p l e s R c p u b h c o f
e
1t 1u n s i n t o
c h i n a ) Ja p a n e s e v i e t n a m e s e K o r e a n a n d
h ab
\ \ \ a r A g r 1 t e lu l t o a l l c o n t n b u t o r s f o r s ha D n g t he i r
c p c r wn t e a n d e x p w t 1 s c a n d w o u ld c s p c e r JHy h k e t o
t h J n l I ) r B n 1 n Bl o d g e s f r o m
t h c W ts o n C e n t r e fo r
Re l e \ r L h i n Ed u c a t t o n a t Ah e L i n n e r s 1t v o F T o m n t o f o r
}\ 1\ e n \ T L \ u \ o mm t n [ S m t h c F r m ) r d D r H o d g e s
h h t n n u \ a t n c t ht \\ r1t ' . o 11 t 1l l n y t o p i c s 1n +n c d i c a l
> d \ t a mn a n d n
Br w u e n t s p c r k c r a t n wma u o n a l
T h is
w
n e w
a rt
tw
c n L r s
> 1n Ti l e
n o w
M Bn
\
>n
[u l
to
p IH \ r t
v
hN
BLw
u H mn
l n
Wr a
l
\ \ 1l v n = e
\t \L ll\ t
w m
an
L\x l
h c s t a n o f E l s e v ie r
h e c m n e 1ncr cmngy
l B\ m t e r a n i l h i s t c a n \ : o r t h e i r
d h t L u \ ) g u \ t l a n c c d \ 1r j n g t h e
w
it
ha
h c h mn
,
Ro
n a
f o An A D
e n t
ld At Hr d e n
D u n d e e 2 0 13
,
Co
Ju l ie
K A
Li
ct u rc r
SC h o
j a1
o r s
h Phn eMAS Bsc (Hon s)

H c a l t h Pr o f e s s t o n a 1 E d u
Au
ephil O&rII(Ol on)

A s s i s t a n t pr o $ ss o r C c n t r e fo r B io m e d ic a l
E t h i c s Yo n g L o o L i n Sc h o o l o f M e d i c i n e
N a i r o n a [ U n i v e r s i t y o l Si n g a p o r e S n g a p o r c
Ja
f l c d r c 1n
A d c l a 1d c
Ra
ibu t
C B
F l i n d e r s U n iv e
qu
lin
C h in
r s i t y,
lia
st r a
a n
ca t io n
a r a n a
Mees PHO
Je
if e
n n
C l e la
d BSc(Bfo os ) HSc Pb0
MSED FRACS
OClinPsychol 1FBPs S FHU
Co
Jo h r 1 Si m p s o n C ha i r o f M e d i c a l Ed u c a t i o n ,
Sc h o o l o f b f c d i c 1n e a n d D e n t 1s t w C h a i r ,
A s s o c i a t i o n f o r t he S t u d y o f M e d i c a l E d u c a
lt a
a n
1n h l e d i c a l Ed u c a t i o n : f o r m e r l
y
f A n a t o m y C o 1[c g e o : h I c d i c i n e
d h c d +c a l S c i e n c e s A r a b i a n G u l l
n su
Pr o f e s s o
n t
r o
iv
y M
( r st
a n am a
B a hr a i n
Re s e a r c h G
D
J o h n B l i g h Bsc MA MMED MU f RCp Hon FAca dMEd

p r o f e s s o r o F c l i n 1c a l E d u c a t i o n a n d D e a n o f
M e d i c a l E d u c a t i o n C a r d i f : Sc h o o l o r
M e d 1c 1n e C a r d i f f U K
K
th a
in
d Ce
e a
E du
e o r
Fo
rm e r
No
d l c a l Ed u
U n iv
ir V C
a n
E c s D i r m
g Lo
t t +n
n 1t
Hl t a
y C
a r
t 1
Ex
c c u t iv =
a n
d Si n
A r ka n
i u
sa s
fo
n tc n n m
r n M
lo u
c to r
do
a r
r a n
1t l o n
ss o r
pe
o u
o
f Ru
W it w
a t c r s r 1n
A l la
)r
l H e alt h U
ra
d Jo h a
n n e s
n +v e r s t t
b u r g So
h A fn
ca
i n g Bsc MaCha II 0 FRCPE

B hl cduJl E t t u a t o n a n d D e a n
D C
Pr t \ [ c w
B1 l l Ch MFan Me d
u m
St u d e n
\ e rblty o
D C
Pr u
h l e d lc
W 1l e
Dt
irt
i n t'r
y,
C u l le g e
ts
1n c
n n c r h 1t y o
a v
Ce
u e e n s
l Ed
t h l c d 1= l n c a n l \ t cnnar y
e { t \ c a l R e s e a r c h 1n s t i t u t e
bu r gh
in
Ed
d t t l r 1t
Sh w n p u
n tt r
n
n Lt
U SA
n \\ r
b u r gh L I K
in
i s B1 MD CCFP t c FP f acpc(Hon)
Co
1r t \ t o r
l rn p m \ c m
M e t l t L L\ l (
N \ \ io n i l l
,
ru r C l i n i c a l Sk i ll s
U n i v r n w or
'
id A D a
n t n m in
l > m h w m m h t> J k n l
h n Hn n n n h U M n m
M e d i c a l Sc i t
sa s ,
Sr
lr f t c K
l l MA ll D Tho
l Mt
=du c a m
L i t t l e I. o c k A r k a n
,
f Lo
t r e l l M*
D ire
la
1a
UK
tn
f W rlt
pb
a m
I i n Sd
a n
Um
i n , 1= r ,
U n iv e r s i t y or Si n ga p m
d M
aA(Hoiu ) PCCT f Aca dM[ d
Cr
o r
n 1v c r s 1t
M e d l c J l I Du
y 1 Bo s p j \ a I
C h e n SU I
n
tio n
c a
l +1c l a t r t J n
R ic h
UK
BSc OPhl l HonDro ool
r o w n e
r r stt
A la s t
Yo
ro w
t t i n g ha m
d i c a l Ed u c a t i o n a n d D e p u t y
r e l o r M e di c a l a n d H e a lt hc a r e
CD&
t BSL Maes
pl
t io n
t io n
l y Pr o f e s s o r
c r r 1a
ic
o u rs
St G e o r ge
UK
Ju lie B
Ex
ca tio n
do
Lo
c a
Abe r de e
Pr o f e s s o
I 1&PE MT
Re a d e r i n M
ro u
l Ed u
ta
l v 1s l o n o f h i c d i c a ] a n d
U n iv e r s i t y o f A b e r d e e n
C o n r a n MO Ph0 JO
a Se c o n d Y e a r h e d 1c a l S t u d e n
P r o g r a m C o u r s e D Br e c t o r Depar t mt nt o f
p a t h o l o g y U m f o r m c d Se r i c e s U n i v e r s i t y
B e t h e s d a h l a r y ]a n d U SA
e n
bnn
,
c n t
\1
w o c 1 i i to n
l lc g c h W
u n
Me h in c
.
/r
tm n
Hm
Jo h
[n \ t
r n u t rt t n a
J I t e ah h
o n
a n t i 1 \ Rl u
L I n iy
n m m
A D
o n
Mc h c a l = d u
o
a n
DC
d Co
>Nny h
c r stt
a t to n
a n
U SA
n u n u n
n a
F To r o
gc
m c n
n to
'
C a n a da
t MMEDMO FHEA FRCS(Ed)
l I. c l a t i o
cm
i n M c d i c a t 1 d \ 1c
U n iv c r s it )
ik
t A n \ c r i c ;1 n
h\ n g t u
t7
P mh v m >
g Ed u
o n
a
fo r
Eu m p c H o n o r a r r R e a d e r
a n c < O r t h o p a = l i c S u r g e r y
n s
t io n
o Fli c e
A s so c ia t io
r D u n de e D
,
u n
de e
UK
te
D ie
1n i s l 1
In
Ph0 0ip Psych

f
M( di cal S i m u l a t i o n
o
f D e n m a r k, dc t lc v
C a p i t a l ce g i o n
H o s pit a l C o e
p
E r ik W
D rie
s s e n
A s su
Pr o fe
s so r
c 1a t c
D e part n
w n t
D t v c lo p m
h la a st n
l\ t
n n rar
c a
]t y
n c e
MB BS MpH
e r
E l iz
c a
t io
"
h AuB
1.
b e t h G a u f b e r g MlMPH
SOC+ a t > P r o f e s s o
F M c d i9
tn c
a n
d ps
yc
h*u
d M c d K a l Sc ho o l D w c t o r C
e nte
r
Pr o e s i o n a l D c v c ] o p m c n t T h e C a b
m
rid
ge
I Jc a l Ah A 1t i a n c c ; D i r t c t o r A r n o l d P G
o ld
I o u n d a t i o n l Bc s = a r c h I n s t i t u t e C a m b
r d
ge
M a s s a c h u s e t t s U SA
M Ru
n
sm rc h an d
r l e a l t h h c cj i c i n e
M ) a b t r i= h t U n iv c r s i t
s
N c t }u r ] 1 n d s
u
o m
n c t ' ro:tssor, C h a i r a n d / u
\ o u at
e
d
Sy n t r y M t l i c a t P r o v a m Sc h x ) j o
pu
f c a ] t l t U n i v e r s i t y o l Sydn" S d n
h I c d i c a l Ed u
in
l Fr
a e
A dj u
Ph0
Fl c
r va r
T he
Dc
d L i f e Sc i e
an
ha g e n
O: Ed u
c n t
M ic h
a n n
st l t u t c
lt ie l D
n s t in
D
pa rt
Fhn
r o r
1t e o
m e
f C o gm t rv c N c u
n t o f Ps c h o t o
y
g)
C o l l i g c t r n d o
Lo
to
r o sc tc n c e
E liz
,
n iv e r s i t
D jr = c
th A
l o r,
dla t n
p h a r d t MEd
U n dc r s t a n dl n a d
g n Le
E d u c a t i o n (P U L S
t hr o u gh Si m u l a t ] o n
C e n t e r A r k a n s a s C h t [d r e n
UK
e v e n
Pr u : c s s o
Co
tl r
L Tn \ f o
B\ t he s da
Ro c k
i n g MOpMMCp
f X * A L I l c r n c a n d I' a t h o l o
gy
u m
a r
S=
m l c
Un
lc c s
iv c r
an
it)
y l a n d U SA
,
ka
ju
Tre
v o r
Edu
c atio n
bb
e r
St u d e n
T h= N
S
Un
MD ph0
ht u
iv
c r s it
l a ast n
u n
BSc FhD CPsycho l
Dt par t r n=nt
t m
]n
st c r
Ps y c h o l o
UK
n do n
o
o
w a
y,
in J
( l
* +u
n w
n
i d g e mbc nb u r cpc h : hu
H I J L I I i H 1 * !, w
B
y . J t d tJ t r l L b p > c
n y C u l l >R > I u n
UK
>ric d
Ea
(l
Ba ed)
G a
r o
arm
l n o
e r
n r r a r
Un
Lu
e th
th s
dc c
u n
1 r l t \ c l( t
Mu h
B: 1\ t r I r
a
l h h Lw l
( n
Bv
id
hn o hw y L n hu m d I 1 u n u h M
m
w
L ( > d s I r n t 1t u t > l l b +> d l \ i t I t l u \ Bt l \ t 1i
U m v t r stt y u l I tT d \ I > t d \ I I K
Re, t Jr ch
ca t io n
Eu r o
+n
pe
l G a
a u
Pr o i
D Br c L
t Lt r
\ o r
Sc i c
To
h l e t l rc
in c
im
Un
te
I) t
\\
d M
t r e fo r
: \ +e d i c i n
c
o u n t
C a n ada
to
o
E\ 1 d ,
t Pn
m a
fo r d o
n c e
an
Ba
sed
Ht h
fo r d u k
FI CP
L Tn d c r g r a d u
c .
B\ L
In c
a t
MM
tc
T
a n
rcz
d M Cd m
o u n t
\ b r k L i SA
n e
,
Jo
a n n o
Go ld
h Aw
l .' t u l l
hlt t llL In
I n >
l [
d m
1 1 1 o 1
,
\ In
s in ai
B J b c d \ l e d 1c 1n e
n t r c
m t n t
1n
Cen
lt }
Nd S t u d e n t A t t a m
H X h Jl = d u h m o n
m n
w w
t a r 1o
n L c
wl o
n c rsm
an
On
ls o
Fa c
H eeS n O FRAeSp
Dt p5rt
HL C .
G lia H
\ \a
r o n t o
t E \ 1d c
\l
t rst
c at io n
n t o
io
s z
b u r g l l D HU F&CPC
Edu
in
Uni \ cr s1t y o
Nt
G in
r a
F r i t h eA
>r u le
D
d A d o lw e n t
O f f ic e r
a n
Devci opmt nt
Uk
(R e s p i r o l o g y ) ;
,
Care
h t e d r c a l Ed u
da
l u c
fo
H o s p i t a l 1b r o
y Bsc pm
. S1St an1 Dt a n C u r n c u 1u m 1n ( i I ' l a n m
a f d A s s o L 1a t A . ' r o h . M o r
N o r t hA r n O n t
Sc h o o l o f M c d t c i n t S u d b u r ( n t
c ht
ar
dee
so c ta t io n
S h ip h
l H E l la
)h
U SA
l'r im
H e a lt h D u
d s
h F( l l o w
r s 1t ! o F W
iv ie
aa st r i c
h c r la n
m
u v
ar c
n c
Ra
c t
bl
at
h Ed
a r a
Re s e
t J D
n sas
G i b b s MO SFHU l
A F k u 1 * H tk
n t1,
H o spit a l l i
t tl e
St
E)
1* sc
a n
$nt 1nung
t w l up n \ c n t
l\ L r h H
t 1br o
Ed u
c at io n
Fa c u h y o f
To r o n t o ,
n to
,
Con t r i b um
Ja
t G
n e
t MSc mo MRCG(Hon) 18Ps s
ra n
Je
FRCP(Hon) MRCR(lfon )
Pr o f e s s o
Em
T hc O p e
Pr o f t
r ita
f Edu
c a t io n
in
S Ke
a n
s so r
U n i v e r s i t y H o n o r a r y Pr o f s s o r
1v c r s 1t y C o tl t
g c L o n d o n M e d i c a l Sc h o o l
D i r e c t o r C e n t r e o r h l t d r c a l Ed u c a t io n i n
C o n t \ x t [C e n h l E D i a n d FA [ H I E R C e n t r e
f o r D i s t a n c e Lcar ni ng u K
n
ca
Sh
p p e n PHD
d C ha i r , D c p a n m ( n t o f M e d ic a l
U n i v c r s l l y o f M i c hi ga n b l e d i c a l
Pr
Sc h o o t A n
A r bo
ht t chrgan
u sA
Pr o fc
ic W
e r
sso r o
&
e r
a m
Pr o : t
i n
h +a y o C l i n
ic
so c ia
lis m
s s i c n a
n su
EDO
o v
lta
n t
c d
i c a l Ed u
c at io n
A lh a n y
f b l c d ic a l Ed u c a t r o n
i a
te
C o 1[c g c
c h m a n PHO
fe s s o r o f l u t a t o m y C o n s u lt a n t
f M e d i c i n e M a y o C l i n ic Ro c h e s t e r
La
Pr
U SA
n e so t a
n e s ; t a
Le in
a m
te
sc l*
) f nes([ din &f n* )
SFHU l Bua dMEd

Em
H
o s s a m
Pr o l c j
5 o r
a n
a m
d V
fo
rm e r
fo
u s a n
lc c
Chan
ce
ll o
h S c Bc n c t s C o l l e g e s U n i
S h a r Ja h U m t c d A r a b E n n r a t e s
,
c r s it
ic a l &
Pr o f e s s o
c n tu s
d y li ache MCH: RCS FACS pia (l du)
e a lt
ra c
Co
u s
M in
te
U SA
H
a n
a n
h f in
Ro c h e s t e r
ir e c t o r,
e l ls I l o s p j j a l
l c Y l C o tl c g c , A lb a n y N c w Yo r k , U SA
c d
N ir
t y Pb0
f \ +c d i c a l E d t 1c a t 1o
Pr o g r
rr e c t o r
Et h i c s
K K
den
sso r o
A sso c
Fr
d D
a n
a ro n
a n
c a t io n
I n de p c
Ed u
i c a I E c h r c a t 1o
r u
c d
l Sk i l l s C e n t r e N i m w
M e d i c a l Sc h o o l U m v c r s i t y o f D u n d e e ,
D u n d e e ; C l i r l i c a l Sk i ll s a d f o r Sc o t t i s h
M a n a g e d Ed u c a t i o n N c t wo r k U K
C ]i m
M edic in e ,
Un
La rr y G
Pr o f e s s o r
Bsc M0 ltncm FRC$P FRCPE FHEA
iv
e r s it
e a n
M e d ic a l Ed u
o n v
c a t to n
a n
i c h h Ic
r e a st a
d i c a l Sc h o o l
n o n v ic h U k
gli a
f
e f f MD * Ed MMan rncpc
f
A c a de m ic
P
sso r o
s y c h i a t r y a n d D ir e c t o r
L e a d t r s h l p D e v e l o p m e n t C e n t r e f o r Fa c u l t y
D c e c t p m c n t Fa c u l t y o r M t d i c l n c U n i v e r s i t y
V c c C h a t r Ed u o t i o n D e p a r t r n c n t
o f To r o n t o
O nt1n o
o f P s y t h l a t r y U n 1v t r s l t y o f T o r o n t o
C a n ada
J U
Pr o f r
o n a
ld M
d e
a r
Of MOf &CR(El as)
FRCPC F&CSU
G
t n c
Ed u
r a l S e c r e t a r y A s o c 1a t i o
c a t Bo n
Eu
1n
ro
lo
fe \
Fo r r mr P r o
pe
M t d lc a ]
so r
D i r e c t o r o f t hc C e n t w
1c a t E d u c a t i o n
c
f o r M c d t c a l E< l u t a t 1o n a n d l i a c h i n g D e a n
U n 1\ c r s t t y o f D u n d e e U K ' r o h s s o r o l
M t c a E d u c t 10 n r n a m U n 1 j t )
R i y a d h Sa u d J A r a b i a
s so c ta
ht U n
] \ t r b 1t
hb
Co
u rw
I d
u catio n
A 1e
D ire
r\ c r s rt
Ce n
o
f d
8Sc OFHI;
e r
cto r
an t
t r
i Se
fo
u n
Le c t
u r er
h l c d i c 1l E d
dee
m o r
i 1n u
u c a
e d
tro n
ic a l
Uk
Phk
Pml essor D e p a r t 11c n
Ac
aa st n c
a n
e e n e m
e a rl
Un
S y lv ia H
a \
I ' a t l r o l o gy
T he
t r i d 1t
J u d y M c B( l m
aA(Hn s ) k 1([d) MB* 01pHsw Ca tf
Sf =[ l IAt adMEd
N e t he r la n d s
Ca rl H
e n e
ry
M t dlc
in c
Care
gh
a n
ir e ct o r
Ce
D c part
i\
t r s tt
l o r v l d r m t {i w
f
P r l 1n Br y I t > a l t l 1
o
u r c B O x f u r d t 1K
n tre
r 1w n
f O
C u l lt c o t h t > d
V l \ i t i n . : 1' r u l c w
MA MRCGP
d
ir e c t o r
Un
n c r s it
D ayto
ac u
e s
\e d l t t r t l\ h i r r
D rr e
l t y D e v t 1o p 1n t n \ UV r Bg h t S t BBt c
s h o { t S c tm o [ o : M t d j c l m ,
Sn
1l t
Um
\n \ c a
lth
vc r u r
lt l u
L a
t \o n
UK
MN
y 0o o n
O h i o , U SA
in
1 e J d r r h w t Jni Vs l t y O<
D a n o \to W
p a t r ic ia H
t L 1n t
o r
t u n t
e d
ic
l \ t 1o
Bt l
K Bn l o y Ph
h a n d D dt J
R> w w
r\ lh r A l l i
l( d
l I\ o
a n c c n \t n
t 1o l 1 a n i
1* h t l a d e l p h l a , Pt
n n s
l lBt
se arc
o u r em
r n
te r n a tio
n a
h ( FA TH E R)
y l v a n l a , U SA
Co
x v l
hu
tn
to
1 C h r is M
MOPHD FRCF{Lim D Edin )
a n u s
La
I n fo
E d \ 1c n t
f p s y c h o l o g y a n d Mc di c
D n 1s 1o n o r Ps y c b o ] o g y a n d
1o n
L a n g u a g e Sc l c n
L o n do n Lo n do
S te
Em
e r
hlcx
M
itu
1c
iv
c r
PHO
A d e l a id e
[t ] n g & A
In
s s o c 1 1t c b
\ \ brr cnbL1r g H l l w
a\ B\ j t B. l t 71l Li c
u c
Pe n
\ n 1a
is
As-
l\
rb\
o r
J f A L;
T 1o n
&
\ e rg
pr o l c
l s 1m
Rwn
f D
a n
o u n
am s
h In
le v h
J r k
C o p c n ha
1o n
e n m
e r
it u
st
o s
te o
p it
c n
l c a p it a l
n m c r s it
g ht
y C l 1n
u m r
Fa (
h Ju x
In
a n
t )
n m
a t +m
a t Hj n
u e
atio n
iv e
r sit
} Pr o f e \
\ o r
Sc
d Ed u
fo
u n
to r
Bo
Unwr si t y Boston
st o n
t s aSc MB CHB PHD FRCP I HEA
e r
st lt u tc
ds l
ee
f M e d i c a l Ed u c a t i
o
ds
ee
Ce
c a t ro n a
de e
u k
su
c a t 1o n
fo r M e d i c a l Ed u c a t i o
n
l t a n t f o r m e r ly C e n t r e
,
m v e r si
f Du
a e
l T Ro
c
e
,
pr
ac t it i o n e r
tv
t o r
rr Ac
fo
f Ed i n b u
n t re
h s c c l i n ic a l
h t e d i c a l Ed u
c a t 1o n
g h E d I n b u r gh G e
n h s f i fe U k
e s
o u r
n era
0 CCn (EM) MCl inSc i FCFp m

A n d Pr o fe s s o r
n a U n i v c r s 1t
!
d St J o h n b C a n a d a
e
F a m l t y \ \ : h l t dr r ne
l l ! h t e t l r L 1m
h tc m o
f Fa m
r N t w fo u
n l
l l. i n
l 1a
Ro
C u
h p
in c
l l o n g Ko
m H
A
u
U
1J t e
rr
Pr o f L
Facul t y
iln
hM
m \ c r s tt
r 1a
t n m
u r
l Nt
L \
l* k CCFP * CliFSd FCFP
\ \ Ll r o
t h \e LIt \
h\ u
1n c
9l l a n
t Fa n
\ te m
St I u
y l e d i c i n
hn
n 1l
s
U n iv c
Can
c
rs
a L Ia
H0
l A
m t t 1t t 1y i n d
t n nun t t t d )
1
h 1+ 1i D
Ah ht
hw
I h hw
n
n
> t
llc a l
A mt a n t
in d
ui l m
hn
E S
a n
da
Mk MSc MRCp n cp
r s
F1t a dH Ed : HM cen Ed
An
>
L1h
H
Pr t c
n w 1ee h hu
,
de e ,
BSc MECHB oacoG MRCEP m
s s
Ce
n n
c J n
u k
e r sl
n tr e
l Co n
h t c d l c a l E l u
A d\ Iw
m o r
: l
Le e ds I n
e n
f M e d ic i n e a n d D i r e c
tor
t i n C l in ic a l T r a i n i
n g
R o f f BA(Hsn s ) MA
d J' r f l >
a n
f \ l e d tt
Kn n
7 l*
C lta r
Dea
lt y
! tu n#
rc a
U SA
E Ro b
n lv c r s i
J a1 m
f S u r c r y a n d l 1s t t t l 1 t e o
d ] i t a ] t h SLB(' nLt ' , L 1 K J S}\ l n g
De 1ar t ment
( d 1t
rs
f u l t M * ! l er ) )
m
F B1n d e
v c
se tts
pr o gr a m m
E d c 1c a t t o n
t i l I BE S I RCSED
M ic h
a rk
an
N il rD t t i G P
H
d i c a l Ed t 1c
i M8BS MMED MPH
a n
fe s s o
lo p m
r M cm
hu
assac
a n
d HSc
lt y D t
Ex1r na] T u
l e e I k F1pA FM CAp
f o r A c a d c m c A ff a i r s W
e rslF
b o o n s h o ft s c ho o l o f
D a y t o n O h i o U SA
De
a m
pr
rn a (io n a
,
t o r
e m n
s s o c ta t c
l 1
D ir e c t o
J a t ] t l n fo
a rm e
1J t e
Sl i t e u r u
l i e d) c i n e
t t
l ia
u st r a
L JSA
l hl edi cal
ar ch
Ph l l a d e l p h 1a
a a r
lat
COFnhagen
De
L SA
ate
i ln tv
ii
bh
T >u d l e
J Ct o
l l\
sc ho o .
Fa
PT. bl JL' 1\ t
Eu
tm n
Fa t
Jo h
Br a z i l
u n
s so r
F Vic d ic l n
Phk MED em ons)
e a u x
Pr o ft
tu s
t n
Sc h o o l
y K M i c h a e l s e n PHj
D 1\ t d R o s s B o y d P m f c s s u r t m i r 1 t u s
u n i v c r b n y n f o U t ho m
> M m o r or
l
i a n r g L m e n t U n n t r 1t \ o l C t n t r a l
Ll
id P r id
a v
Co
r r
hhn
Em
S a o P 1 A1 l o
o n a
Pr o f e s s u r U n i t r s 1r y o f N c \ \
S= h o o l o F h l c n t ; I ' r i n c l p a l
n su
Sp c e i a li s t
to n
in
e n n
MED Mu s
C o lle ge
ity
r n 1 i
d P r o FCs n
a n
LJK
t n n 1n
La
t P M
w a r
ce s,
ie
r r
C o n t i n u i n g Ed u c
a t io
n
l D e v c l o p m c n t Fa c u k
o
y f
h l c d l c l n c U m v c r s l t y o : To r o n t o L i K a S
hi n
g
K n o w l e d g e I n s t i t u t e S t ' \ i c h a e l s +d o
sp ita l
f o r o n t o O n ca n o C a n a d a
FMedSci
Pr oe s mr
Pe
u re
Mu n
t\tu tc
n e
L e a d :o r
O h h h c a
ih
n,
La
e r
Pr o f e s s o
In
T S
c h u w i r t h Mk Pho
f M e d i c a B E d u c a t i o n Fl i n d e r s
i n C li n i c a l E u c a t io n l e a lt h
r o
t io
n o v a
t W
Ce
p r o fe sso r
Em
E S
F Sy d n
Iv
a n
MaeS BSc Phn OSc
o n
Pr o f e s s o
e r it u s
Fa c u l t i e s
ft
Fo
F b 1c d i c i n
Je
A s s o c ia t i D e a n
rm e r
L S ilv
a n c
MO MEDFRCP(C)
e r
r o e n
J G
p r o fe s s o r
B D e n t is t r y U n iv e r s it
y
S
d
A
e
t
n
u
s
r
a lia
y
y
)
o
d i n st
e v e o
Te
k Ch
r o n t o
Re s e a
an
i n b
c n
h,
a r c
a a s t r ic
r sit
y1 M
a ast r
io n
Re
d G
Edu
r a
se a r c
F E l u
t o
a n
PhD
o e r
ru ct
en
l pm e n t a n
S c h o o l o f H e a l t h Pr o f e s s i o n
D
an
e r r
D e pa r tm
r
d Re s e a r c h
To
F Ps y c h i a t r y
f L ea r n in g
pr o g r a m D i r e c t
T hc
D epartm
p m e n t a n d Re s t
i
r s t ) M a a s t r i c ht ,
v a n
d V i c e P r e s id e n t
E d u c a t i o n C e n t r e fo r A d d i c t i o n a n d M e n t a l
H e a l t h Fa c u l t 5 o f M e d i c i n e U n i v e r s i t o f
y
r
c a t io n
Ph0
e v = lo
h t U n +v e
N e t he r la n ds
Pr o f e s s o
te
T hc N e t h e r l a n d s
n n
V le
f M e d i c a l E du
M a a s t r ic ht U n iv
de
v a n
f Ed \ 1c a t i o n a l D
Pr o f e s s i o i 15 E d u c a t i o n S c h o o l o F M e d i c i n
F l i n d e r s U n i v e r s i w A cl ( l a i d c A u s t r a l i a
A
P M
e s
c at o n a
du
a te
c a t io n
i c ht ,
To
r o n t o
t a r io
C an a da
E t hi c s
o
R Sk
lt o
eA MA RSA MNCGP
r C l i n i c a l C o m m u n i c a t i o n C o ll c g (
l
M
d
i
f
e
c
a
a n d D e n t a l Sc i e n c e s
o
U n iv e r sity o F
B i l l 1l i n g ha m U K
Pr o f e s s o
a t
u a n
rc h A
ss o c
Vo
ia t
MA BA
Cen
fo
tre
Bio
m e
dic a l
Yo n g L o o L i n S c h o o l o f M e d i c i n e
Si n g a p o
a l U n i e r s it y o f Si n g a p o r e
,
io n
r e
Da
id W
FCE F&CP FRCP
l l MBCHB MMED 0
D e p u t y R e g i o n a l Po s t g r a d u a t e D e a n
Pr o f e s s o r o F h I c d i c a l E d u c a t i o n U n i v
,
s t
v o n n e
Pr o f e s s o
Ce
n t r e
in
e r
t phil
f Fa m i l y M e d ic i n
fo
M e d i c a l Ed u
an
c a t io n
d D in
a n
o r
d Sy l v i a C T u c s s C h a i r i n M e c l i c a l E d c 1 c a t i o
Fa c u l t y o f M e d i c i n e M c G i l l U n i v c r s il y
M o n t r e a l C a n a da
a n
i d T S t e r n MD pm
V i c e C h a i r f o r a c u l t y A {h i r h Pm c s s o r o :
I n t e r n a t M e d i c i n e a n d M t d i t l l i d \ 1t a t i \ m
D
a v
i c a h n S c h o o o f Mt d1( i m'
N e w Yo r k , U SA
l
Jill E Th s u
th
w a
at
Mo
Si n a i ,
u n t
l t e BSc Mees Ph0 MMM
FRCGP FRACGP
P r u f c n n r N M> d h u h h n n m n M m m O>
t h e C e n t r e b r M>hc nl h h n u t h n Rt w n t h
h ho u l N M > i w
a n d Sc hM r s h h
U n r s i tY N r u > > 1 u J u Hr i h a
q u w n n d , A u $ r a hn
,
b i r m in gha m
er s
iq
Uk
d Ric ha r d
f b im r i n gh a m
P
n
a u
l S W
o r le
y MBBS 0
0ipobst al l N1C06
FACM F
Cp MBA
D
e a n
U n iv
A
Sc h o o l
r s it
f M e d ic i n
A d e l a id e , A
Fl i n d e r s
u sl r a
l iJ
d Z a c h a r i a h * DHB
f
Pr o e s s o r h \ Hl i c i n e U n i t
a n d I nf et i ous
D . s v a s e C h r i s t i a n h l = d i c a \ C o ll e g e V e l l o r e
l i n n i l Ni NH I n d i a
n a n
Se c t i o n
Cu
r r
i c u lu
de v e lo p m
en
C ha p t e r
ho r iz o n
ew
dic a l
m e
J A
Ev
a r s n e w id e a s a n d n c w t r e n d
s i n m e d ic a l
b e c o +n c a p p a r e n t T h i s i s n o t t o s a t h a t
y
p r e v io u s i de a s a n d t r e n ds ha v e be e n a ba n do n e d bu t
t ha t
ra the r
c ha n ge s
in c u r r c n t c ir c u m s t an c e s o r
e x pa n d i n g u n d e r s t a n d i n
g c a l l f o r t h e fb r t h c r d e v e l o
e
e r
du
ye
c a t io n
m e n t
n e \ e
Re
e
o
a
r co
ppro
c at
L1u
t o
io
In p r e v io u s
m e dica l e du
s ix
d pro
c e
du
r es
t hc
o r
c m c r
he s
ac
c e n t
g n in
p ic
in
m e
n ce
gc
d ic a l
c a
n s
f t l 1i s b o o k
t i o n w e r e cl i s c u s s e
e m e r
g in g
p ic s i n
to
d In t hc la s t
d it i o
i d e n t i fi e d
e r e
T h c g l o b a l iz
a t i o n o : h e a l t hc a r e d c l v c r
y
0nt er nat i onal d i r e n s i o n s o f r r i e d i c a l e d u
an
ca t
io n
p t u a [i z a t i o n o f ( h c r o l e o f t b t d o c t o r
d
a n
r e c o g n i t io n o f t h e i n l p o r t a n c e o f It a r n i n g
o u t c o m e s ] n d e fi n i n g t h c c u r r i c u ] u n 1 f o r 1 r l : n i n g
a n a p p r o p r ia t e w o r kfo r c e
hc a ] t h c a r c
p hy s i c i a n
u r ba n
r c co n cc
e ie s
ga
"
i As
b
:,
l v j 1#
1n
= o r 1c e
v d ic a l
l tt l
tn
]h
t d t 1( u
io
a l
i sse ssm t m
t1
: n i t 0( l r 1 u f p r u l t \ i o l l a ] i s m
ar) l i p j n r n c d i c a l t d u > n t t o n
%e
u rc
uw c h n > o mn n > Bl
a 1]
m Bn : r 1t !i c a r l
ir 1
( O1l : t Hnw p n
o W
b>
m Jd t
tn
a n i
o r l v il l
Bn \ ,
bc
co m
po
u n
d e d by
west cmi zed

t o e m p l o y m e n t n
a g
y b c h c l p e cl by i n ce r n a t i o n a l
f a c i l it a t i n g l o c a l
to
r c es
c o m m it t e d
d i c a l e d u c a t i o n T h c Fo u n d a t i o n
f I n t c r l n at i o n a M e d i c a l E d u c a t i o n
a n d Re s e a r c h
( f A LM ER ) a n d i t s r e g i o n a l i n s t i t u t e s
f e i to \ e s t i p
su p p o rt
m e d ic a l t e a c h e r s t hr o u gh t h e i r
t r a i n i n g s c h e m e T h e W o r l d Fe d e r a t i o n f o r M e d i c a l
m e
o
r 1oc i at i ons
o f M e d i c a l S c h o o l s ( PA F A 1 15 ) e x e r t
l n nu e n c e in n e e dy a r e a s a n d t hc 0
e l a t i o n f o r h [ cx l i c a l E d u c a t i o n i n E u r o p e (A I E E )
p
v id s a w e a lt h o f p r in t c tl r e so u r c e s a n d a n
an n u a l
i n t e r n a t io n a l c o n fc t e n c e a t t r a c t in g m o r t t h a n 3 0 00
d c ] e g a t e s f r o m o v e r 10 0 c o u n t r i e s A t t h e A H LE E
2 0 0 9 c o n f e r e n c e i n M a l a g a , at t h c w G w e e l c d a
i n g t he i n t e m a t io n a . r o l e o : m e d ic a l
s y m p o s i u cn d i s e d u c a t i o n i n s e e k i n g t o i n c u lc a t e a n d r l u r t u n
t he hi
l
c r i o o e c r l m k c d p r o f c s s i\ m a l
i
i
f
t
o
t s
c o m pa s sio n
qu a
d
h
e m p a t hy a n d i n t \ w it
i
b
t e r c o n t r i u t io n t o
a n
d e v
an
in t
a u o n a
e m
p in g
n sc
i.
s c ss
r
J
so c
ial
re s
n s
po
i b i l it y
Ne
A X [ E E z o l l in V ie
m o
Jt
n n a
de ls
r e 5-
n tlm
: t l 1t
be r
hF
o
e f m
'
J.
\)
'
,
J m +,
:\
\ ?
il
V p
LLTuC. f o n a /
?\
J 1 s
n \
i n n w d U: r nmnmh nn l n w n w t m n he
Co u n
i d e n t i fi e d b y t i l t i r p o b l t i u n 0 11 t l t e \ p c ( t r \ l l 11 u f s l o
e c o n o m i c d e v c l o p n w n t i n r c l n h n t o t h e h c hM i H o r
t aht y * n r u y s i z e a n d c c o n o n c g r o w h T h = a s w c h n c d
i c t t / 1t 1Bt d e t 1e / o p n
w B
\ i c h s t e k s t o p r o m o t e t hi s i s t h e n < w l
y r e la u n c h e d
w c b \ i t c h t c d E u i \ b r l LI w h i c h p r u > i d c
a t r a n sn at io n al
l e a r n i n g a p p r w 1c h w i t h a c w s s t o a n
c o ]b h o r l t l e
l
b
l
t ra w
c
s y n c t r \ \ n o u s u n l in t w c b i n t r s a n d
as y nch
B
n o t i s t i l c u s s i \ n gT \ u p s
a n il
hu J i wu v e d n
Jc > e d
c a n
u r r
m a
p p o r t u n i t i e s fo r
fo r A d v a n c e m e n t
p l-
t io n
rec u
chol
lt e r a l
l> n
r n
J1) >
A S t hc
c o
1n c u
r e so u
o r
(w h i c h
T h c c o n t i n u : n = d v e . o p m c n t s o f n c w I cami nB
t c c h n o j o g i e s a n d t t 1c i r j n f ] u e n c e o 11 t e a c h i n g a 1Bt l
*e a r m n g
/ n
<
H a r de n
p r o bl e m s
m i g r a t io n
ce n tres
io n
c at
D en t , R M
dit io
du
in
c Kwnr 1r
el t w1
hHm
1 /I , 1 .
H H r 3 u 1
1141 14
I n
t m
1i v
lc
c Bi
1r
m o
, ,
!l n
>
I
T I 1I K
f.
RB
1e 1 t
S E C T IO N
H H m s
j k 1h
A<
r ln B
x H
<n H m H N =H
H t H :u t
n w hu c( e\ \
l c :i n 1n R a n
l Bn 1B Be l e t o / J 1} Bc l Bt
C ll r
1t
I : H
KKI
n H
M N
m u o n m c n r
m
N
1
v n n r
Ccw
c o m m u n
Yunc
hs l
Me
s u c
h Mam
d en h
d hn g
0 t
d u c a t i o n (O B E ) i n
u
]
Vb c r 7 t b c l / n o t m t j c b y o t / C i r n d o t b l 1s
a t t l 1c
(
cl o
\ \ b l l o n go n R \ > d l i d e s e r r h c d by E l i z a b e t h
v r 1 1t )
o l
s o r 1? c t h l n g y o u c a n
Fa n 11 c r t t h t A T E I 20 11) \ t m t e r e n ( c i n G l a s g o w A t
r e B J ) i [ r \ 1Bul \ / l n 1 b u t { 1t { r y \ h 11r 1B T c U ( t n n u
t hc s a m t c o n f c r c n c e
S t e f \ 1\ L 1n l g m n P r e s i d e n t o f
1 O 1( 1 o 1) B r ! l / l r
A l tf / t h
t B t 1/ B
W F M E d e w n he d h m
> H = Jl w r p n 5 v 1d e s n n w c h a
w
e
r
c
c
1
2
m
J
f o r { l 1 r e c t 1n g t h e t r J t t r n K \ \ r { t h c r h c n l t h c a r e
M sm
qt t i
& o k s i t n a l \ a n d Bt ) r n\ cet t n t l 1 > e A i m a t l t m a l r t
m m ts
l \ \ r t h > f l 1t t i r g l o b a l
n c ( e ) s 1&
lw r c n M
d o c t o r C o r m v t c n \ e t\ \ \ r , I e t l m 1t l \ i n w J S t h c t h e m t
T h t p o p u l a r i t y a n d a v a i l a b i l i t y o f e l e a r n i n g t 1s i n g b o 1h
o f t h c A u u s \ 2 0 10 1s \ u c \ f \ l e l l l r d l l r Be / w r
s t a t i c a n d m o b i l e d e v i c e s h a s b r o u g h t w i t h 1t c o n c e r
n
a bo u t t h e q u a l i t y o f t h e s t u d e n t s l e a r n i n g e x p e n e n c
e
Ti t m a x i m i z e l eam1ng t h e r e i s a n e e d f o r a n i n f o n r Be d
D x o r s m ? y n o r n e c i n t i e t u u l e r o u n d e a B e
f a c u l t y t o g u Bd c s t u d e n t s t o t h e m o s t p r o fi t a b l e s i t a
1W
t r a d 1t w a l { o }c s
h i l o o t h e r n e w l o te s
J
n e r
\
E ] t a m i n g w a s t h c t h e m e o f t h e A p r i l 2 0 11 I s s u e o f
m il
y c m c gc n s fe F . !
M e d i c 1 Tac her
S Wr r h 1 u J l t J p i T e I U r Bt g B t hr
Pa t l c n 1 f o c u s e d s i m u l a t i o n b y t h e m e o f h ! b n ds
u 1
U I . E J1 l O ( m jr r T r r
a
r
p t s i m u )a t o r s a p p r o p D a t e l y J t t a c h e d t o a s 1m u l a t d
p a t i e n t t o c r e a t e a r e a l i s t i c c l i n 1c a l s r u J t 1o n
b
e e n r epr t ed b ! R
r K n e e n c Y t A LI EE 20 09 1n
U
n c y b a g e d m e d c a 1 c o u c B t ro & o Bi e 1 s
l
h
A
M
t
t
a
a
e
a
m
c o n f p r e n c e t h e r o l e o f d 1s t n 7
s
a
e
g
r e J i r o r p L s e a 3 Ba c l e a n s G 1 a d d r e s s H t h e
M
1m
ubt
l
{
n
h
w
t
u
e r e bv
n s e
p o r t J b l e l i g h t \ e e 1g h t a n d
r n i n
5 u
\n e x p e n 7n t
e q u 1p n 1e n t i s u s r d t o
r c e a t e ke
e s
3
e
Es j l 1 3 t f e a c g u n c t h =
y ele
m e n t s \ \ : a d 1 mJ l
T I J C $ a n d
BJ . , g e a n d
dmu w J
et t 1ng \ n J c o s t a c l i v e \ Ll ! a $
t n c r o p J5> f W
111\ 1\ t r J t 1 d b l
t h c v i c a t i o n o f J 5 1 m u h c d o e n t 1n
p
g
t h e a t t e 1n t h e c o n e r n c v e n u e
o
\\
o u
m c
ha s d
h
sc o o l c
t c t m (
d i\ a l
u r r i c u t 1 n
L T
r0
o 1n
q
H A X
C LI N l l
ll
(t
>
L * r e
> Jl
lld m
l ? o r ] 1)
l eJ t
1) X J
p l H ILX { 1 I
t B\ i 1 W
) 1>
Bm
ij
I n
l Bl >
\lr r > n
ll r r l n
\\
. .
il ir
/u
h m o tu
Hs
r 1 l Bl r
'"
H f
( /
), / ) 1 C d
Hm
Ti l t
'
dm
1l p
Hn
p /)
" Ci
'
tt T) e b
tr e
J. J I I
Jh
W W HH H
br i N
\ T
ih
en
C d
J1 t J
v 1a f
cJ
ge
'
s e n
to
: CV }
b t e B1 d i * u s s d
1 t t n b e r t Se l u rw i r t h Tn d C t v s v +\ n d c r V l e u t r n
W n 1 1n A HW = G u i N F 5 7 >hct c u d nn
( \ \ r t nt
I\ \
4LI H
( \ f r wu g J
l <t u ( >
n n a
te
h 1r 1/ : p 1 { +y A I H r l j r W 1 \ p l t \ > n t t 1 l l r \ \ n \ \ l w
B ( P\ d * t B k B w B' 11bn\ l BB\ 1l l : 1 0 1 l \ n
,
( J A I:
,X ?
IX H H K H
i r B1p r n 1 > l 1t l t Bu l 1 o
1J1BiVtr\l ty u
V ie
J XH W
fl
Wbl
Ol
l \ e \ \ r 1e ? i n
,
lm
vc
:U
a M e s\ m c n
h le
IV
a e
mn w n u h
p r o lt
s s t o n n ts m
p>r
to
tM c nw nh
pc
f i, f n
L h w
a Tr \ e
A
:o
r
1k eha
n w Ht
1\ M v s 1 i n v n
\tc
w n eq
h n cJ\ TO
d e v e l o p e d a t t h c 14 t h O t t a w a C o n f c r c n c c i t 1 2 0 ] 0 i n
a m i a n d r c f; n e
+n 2 0 \ 2 a t t l 1c 5 t h O t t a w a C o n
b r c n e c i n K u a la L u m p u r
t l <J n
; 1c n e
o n
c o n
i n
s c ; c rd
du d
Bn f c n
cw
9 / ,c a n t p
he a th s c ie n
ttc
s Ix r e
l\
o 1l t r
c e
t f ?e d c l c o p m
du
f ?t s
gcd
tm
re s
a r 1g c
p !1 c
o n
m c
1/ a n
d ic a l
du
c at
L(
d s s c s s n t n t
A S S A S S me n
K &
s e
CJ
n J
c1p f
c o n }p A fc n c o
n o
ln
1r
\ /
a n
t u 1t 1o
1n
a n
a n
BK n s N
in t o
d 1s cu
a s
s c
G u ide X o
6 1 ( 2 0 12 ) D
b c h a 1 mr
a n
o m
es
sc u
c e
1s
d
r e
u a
]u
c u r r n u
d b v H e lc
c m u n \
u n
1n
0 Su l . n
tr
t 1n
fo
r ta n t
l t eacht r b A d e t 1 l A d w
l a t e d t o pru: t ' S}OnJ] 1\ l n
J n
du
J1h
t w
%s t L n J
c o n
pts
H t} i 1 c
t h
1 1
ht
L1 c a
tl
tu
Jy
n m c s
o v e r lu o
hu
k e J lc a n
n n
i cs
t io
c o n t
in u
d e r gr a d u a t
in g
e d ic a l
pro
ce
d u r e s fo
a n a ge m e n
m e
d ic a l
a n
in
st ra t e
to
gie s
e v o
lv e
bo
as e m
a n
ie
r e v
ar e
ie
he SPI C ES
d fu r t h e r by
t
i n
\ ee
in
da
m c n t a
l pn
lu
c u rr ic u
te n ce
'
v :
ph=
n cl
an
d t heo
r Y c o n u n u e
ho u ld bt lik e
c o t 1r s e
1\
1Nl
k E[ r L ! W Y I\
BI H
I'
h s
L3
TH t 1
'
he
to
uw s
hr
o u tm
J wc 2 e
n 1e
1 b L 1 me s
C hapt e
> Hc n t
M
> 1e h n
n
\n
le
( h 111 Lt
..
r
65
hv
m o re
4 1 0 f t hi s
wh h h ha s
w hv n M > > G u M c M
J
1 m Nh > T w n t 5 k t v
w h h n w NJ u n n n ! m M
tr
at t m c t c t
Z01 F
a n
c r r o r s o c eu r
o r n i c d s t r a t c gic s
h e c n p n n o wd h t h c
o t
F pe n w
I, k n a r v d t h c A M E E
m w n v a n d a w dcs cDt c d b y h i m
34
hn
haw
1 I WN I S
m t h m Gw c e
r e d h'
d
k
L
l
2 0 i n G u gm
a t t hc s t u d e n t
o o
e
In t hh n i o M
i n hnr ni n H h h e t c h w
hc
d hm
 :
t\\ r
\n
\m o
u n u m
he lp
"
Jt t \ t u. l t \
h s h n 1 Gn h u E
HH I
o u tc o n w s on
. \
r l 1\ c n t
at cg
ho l a r s hip
i n t > r J W. l
I Lu
N1
l CA
\ t uut nt
nn d
a n
u n
u t
Wt ct t i on
u r L u n dc v d o p n w n
pre
t io n
h > l u l lu
C
H H
de
in
'
L n
l e c t io
se
sc
in u e
ha t
t x l s
BnJ h u
t r
in g
w hi c h
f t h c h i d d e n c u r r 1n 1l u m
f
s t u d e n t c a L t u a l l y f o l l o w a n d w h 1c h I s d s c r ib e d u r t h e r
b \ F r t d t a t f e& a n d E h m b c t h Ga u r g +n C h a p t e r
o n e o f 1hv n c w
c h 5 p t c m \ n t h i s t in J o k
IC
'
a r
D1 1 l 0 u wn r h t B n 1
u r r t n t
r a in
fr o
c a t io n
c a
>
f h
J UJ t
t ilt
> e du
an
c a t io n a
ld H
n a
t t
:B I
s s 1O N
in
(C M E )
r 11 u r t
da r d iz a t io
te t
sta n
ts
E L
l t i r nl n
\ u hl> L
1\
r u At u rt
1n
i pr
u u m
d e r s h p
dic a l l du
e r au o n o
'
m c lu
undt r gr aduat e
in e
pTOah
io
an
de n
tu
d e s s h o \ Ln n g c a r e a n d
b
c ha\ 1 n g
w it h
1n t e g n t !
r e s p e t o F 5 t 1c n t s a n
b
i l t
t o a ll S u c h p r o f e t
a n d a c c o u n t a b l lm
r e p o n s
S: o l b e h v i o u r n e e d s t o b c c x p l l c t t l ! 1n t c g r 5 t e d
o u r
d i t a t io n
ac c r e
a d
C ha p t e r Z Ex a m p le s a r e a n
l
ea
b
l
b
a se d
r
n
r
o
c
t i v e o r p e r s o n a l i z e d c u r n c u [u m
p
1n t e r p r o f c s s i o n a l
i n g e n ha n c e d t hr o u gh t e c h n o lo
e d u c a t i o n a n d c o m m u m t y ba s e d e d u c a t i o n
c o ns
C h a n g i n g s o c i a l c 1r c u m s t a n c e s a n d c a r e f u l
Ro
1s
in
d( l
m o
o 11
Tr T1
c 1sY
b ) t r d :, 0
t N
b c ha \ i
Pr of ess ar l
! f pt dl c J /
io
c a
A H
The
c o n t
p o s t gr a du
du
m (
cr j 1 I
n a
a n d
io
i t h t hc
t w
e c u c a t io n
t o to
r n at
te
A d rr \ is s io
th e
to
d [c
t f Bb
c o n
In
d 1l t c d
c u r r
to
c us
a re
1n o
i to
a n t
1 1l t g
ke d
d /o
n n
o f c n ga gc m
bo t h t e a c he r s
a n c e
u iu m b y
ic
T he
kl bt
b r 1 ry
TBr o y
to
w o u
do
b
re
l c
c 1t i c n
v l
s s c s s r T 1e n
h /l c
bc
o r ts
t lo p o
n tp
re s s u r e s
:>
lsv
th e
1n
Is s u c s
to
l/
1rn c
T hc i m p o r t
'
F'
l pohnn ch a i
at
AM E
p M ncr
tw t h
hc
S E C T IO N
C BBr r i 1 Bi 1m
l pn l t
1 t e B1 e o
n r
p o s iu m
tu
de n t
a n
stu
de n t
c n
ga gc
den
de n
1d c
st u
e n
i o n t r a
"
m e n t
..
20 1 1
(. "
\n
'
pm ' "
"
C h J Pt c
cw
c n
t hc
n :
11c ld
'
nce
in i
st r a t e
gie s
c l lc
To r o n
..
'
n c es
e d u Tt
r ap
id
h a n ge
hc p r a c t i c e o Fm c d l c i n c
f r e g i o n a ll y a p p r o p r i a t e
J c J p r o l l fc r a t \ u n o f
Nt 1
f w h ic h
so m e o
s m
e n
an
h e i [ c 1 n: d e \ c l o : ? m e n ( o
a n d t hc . . . .
h m lt h
s (
l
h
o o s 1n s o n t e c o u n t n e
m = di al K
5 a
l
h
5
r a c t c r ) t he r e B
c
a
i
e
r
c
o
m
m
fi . c a s t r o n c
m a\
t
f
i
n er
c n t , J dej r ee o
so m e m c c h5 n .sm t o
n e e d fo
t o
.c c aj
n c n ca r:
c a l t in
p 1r 1 ) : i r . a t
O r >p
tl
n iu
s . a n b r
Lt
t io n
co n
m
d\
u B
B a DJ P t
\\ n
Ly m
W r
I hn
Ul u m
n r] h
he
t .W1
r 3
t{u
B %BM
I Bn
>
a t l p t t d
Pu p u BA 1
tu
i nd
Br r
Br i ) } 11 u R 1n t r
H1e i t
u n
t1
R1 o
l> c t
\
u rr
r n J t l 1 1B1a
w in
t t 1d c
t jy
l llr
D mh h H J 1H
In
i n B> > \ t
lu
nt\
ht' 1n > \ J l t u
P
[i\ e
t lw
n t ry
ted
W Bt t l t
eu 1 hr
n r t
t h>
g ht
t au
hy i s
as
an
e n t
ha t
l e a de r s hi p
T h e se
a b 1 1 s h me n t
0o c a l n t L &
the
In r e s p o n
to
i n \l
a ll
l t\
c r
a e
t ) O p t o \ 1d e B b v c in t O bt J w J
\ A \ t [ E c o n ec r c n e m Eu r o p
J H u e s A n a J n i n w c sc n
thJn
l\ e
n e\e
i n n u 5
3 MI
11 t n
n n
J H.
'
1 V\ \
hn
u He h c
Th e
1\ Ac
bm
<e J L t e h h s
1nwnJh
u
hn C
o r
t
n \ i \ n a s = m e r1
ou H c3
Mna
in
h\ x l \
l 1\ Bx l 1\ a
d a UJ p W t I
1n
/e
e lo p m
1l l Bt
n rn
to
afB
u rces
1 1 1 c
>i n T l l y
7 1t e r e h J 1 l x T
du c a t io
rew
HU$ HN
: w
1 I
li n \
Bt t : 1T1n:
B ll \
r r *d s 5 u
d e s i gn e d
su c
t io n s
has
c a t io n
ff de v
st a
pr o m o t e
to
du
d
l
e du
c h o l a r s h i p 1n m e i c a
h a n c e d p r o %l e 13 : s
f
1nt
er
nat
i
onal
i
o
l
t
a
r
o
u
he p p
i s n d m c e d by t
d
t
a
t
1]
e
o
u
r se s
f
t
c
o r p o s gr
t h e Bc m ) n d
c es
: r \ \ u l'
e s
qu
at
d in
le a d e r s hip
can
ht
n t c
d ic a l
m e
i . . ?nf t rcn9cs a r e J t t r 1t l ng a u & e n e ) t o m

u t 1L l n 1 +
e
l
h c T \t h L J T C p r u f > b1 \ \ n s I n t e t m i u o n .J c o a e r e m e s
&\
* t m
ho \ e
fe r e n
m c c J l
n ew
:
( pA ILO ) I A I \ 1I R
tl
dc r r c p r e sc
ttn
, "
pa n }
in
f Ic a d c r s h i p
/= % . i
i
Fl
d
ha v e lo o k e
:H
45)
n
a l iy b e e
lc rc
in
to
he q u e s t r o n
u su
l t he
su ll c c t o
a
u ss e s
J l 1B A X = )
( +I u L / \ 1B , :
tc \ l l +l S
, . A1
t
g a gc m c n
Nc w
du c a t \o n
hl n F a p p r o a c h e s
..
i n t hc
ll c n e c
c x =e
stu
A s p IR E t o
t r t r eso u rc e s
i li e d
n t
"
"
t su p
dc
ra
m e
h e i r 1n \ o w e m e n t 1 n
s c h o o l c u r r 1c u l a a n d s u
he r
h a s tv
d is c u s s e d i n o s y
h i M c M a n u s d i sc
o r 8c s C r s
i
c o ic B
N
b
d
y
c hai r e
i C ha p t e r 43
ro c e sse s n
c lt c t i o n p
n e o f s
ib i l i t y
d Bc a l s c l \ o o l m i gh t i n c l u d e
i l
t h c <c v e \ o p n e n t o l m c d c a
l
x t racu r r 1
d
pp o r t t o e v t o p c
in
m c n t
o t
a s ha r e d r e sp o n s
he r ha v e
t eac
V ie n n
A M EE 2 0 1l i n
a t
p l\ , \
IA
Bur on
t 1111 11 14 I T
O v e r t l \ e yt or s
t
Ju
( 1t lo n
h il v e \ \c \
XO w
l\
t
\t
l u p e t l i n t el
eJ"
1\ t w
w c Fc
l re J
tn
l " ,
Rn w
"
to H u
'
"
w
' Bc
tv
'
1L
t Bl n e
d
.n
* 4 $ PT EF l
w bl 1c a t
a n
t re n
ha s
t mp
+n
dica l
he
ca
1o im
t a t c mp t s
n t
1 1 t hc a
st u c n t s
n a n
w1
ed u c
of
da r d l m t io n i n
f ro m
Un d e r gr
d
CM E
g an
i on
sel et i on pr
oc e d
ur
es
or
ch
du
s h i p an
ma
n a g em e
ad
c a
tio n
e nd
fe r e n
a t i on s
c o n s c n su
ce
i ca 1 ' B
Bch
v an c
e me
Sc h o l a r s h i p p u bl Bc a t o n
a] t h pr o f cs s l on s c t
a n
ca r e er
on
Bca t i
1n h
nt
M ale y M
l y : , D e n t J : U s in g r u r Bl a n d r e m o t e
hc u n d e r g r a d u a t e m e d i c a l c u r r ic u l u m
SCt t ngn
ME E Gu B de No . 7 ,
ld ca 1 Tea c 1 br 31 96 9 - 8 3 ,
M
r e
ua t
e A
0 ca l O
'
u ] i\a n
H,
Mo
a n
o k
W Fe MT
I n t c g r a t m g p r o f e s s i o n a [ 1s m i n
M E E Gu i de No 6 1 , f ed B c d
r el
l R,
to
t he
Tt a (
SS
cu m
Co o k S H
V
c u
lu
4- 7
2 0 12
p lo
e x
a to n
du
200 9
m(
n t
d ic a l
20 0 9
ca t io n
a\ c b e w
g c 11a p t e r s
1n t c r c s 1 t o
o l ar
2 0 12 C o
re c o m m
an d
1n
a t
m e
A M E E G u i d e N o 4 3 M e d i c a l Te a c h e r 3 1 5 7 4 5 9 0
stan
in
3 3 18 1 18 2 2 0 1 1
d ho w
o u t c o m e s an
te achers an
d J t a t Bo
.1c c r c
an d
i p,
dic a l
m e
h on
ea en
i es
et lu ca u o n
on
du
en g J g c m c
of
b y bo t h
gr a d u a t e t r a 1n 1n
r at eg
M c G a gh] e w c
Co n t i nu u m
p o st
st
l o o k c l l e a r n t n g
lnv c
l t t r n a t 1o n a
m e
an
nt
he m
sJ r t
lu
cu
op mc
el
c r
t o a s se s s t
c u m
er
T h c s p ] c Es m o d e l , der 1i al E d u r a i o t + 18
2 8 4 29 7 19 84
I s e n bc r = SB O t t a w
um
r nc u l
he
f k e y p r e s e n t o t i u n s a t 1nt cmat i onal

gg e a t c d t h e f o l l a \ r i n g c u r r e n t j . s u c \
su
ds
Pr e \ i o u
1o n s a n
o ) n f cT c n c e s
N e w h o r iz o n
re
LAi t
ll pr ac t i si n g
so m e
: t h e se i n t h e fo l
fa m ilta r t o p i c s o f
Pa r m
h +i c h a c l s e n U
c ec
Te a m h ) s c
h m ore
d i c a l t e a c he r s
G u i de N o
m e
d e s PD
d lc a m l n g a p r a c u c a l gu l d E E
6 5 M t i Bi c i B1 Te a c 1w r 3 4 : C 2 7 S
2 0 12
Re f e r e
s'
n c e s
l e e 20 0 9 c
o n
I EE 2 0 ] 0 C o
fc r e
n e c
r lf c r c n
i e e 20 1 ) C o
lc
r e n ec
a s i e e 2 0 12 c
fe
re n c >
A SP I
\w
A:e a 1 ? /
c t r n cu
ar
Tr
i l d
i.
T
FJ r
a t
J
t
lB
Th c
lu rn
'
he r
L lr
lu
> Bi n 1n
a r n ln
ht t p //
r (
Bs t
11 >
in
o rg
ht t p / /
w l n r j 11l < c o t g
h +v t
htt i1 i /
lin w
deJ
u nd e r
Jn
o rg
11 i y c
rn
l il l 1v j rn (
T1 t t p / / wn Ma me c
t o- ( x( e1j >r , Lc
L r1r n c u
u rr1 u r
y1r er \ u rn t u
7
3
5
1w r 3 i 5 4
4
2fj l 2
y R
a c
asp lrc
hB
r c
Ar c h n c
rx
t t 1e i u
5n
In
d l 1J t e
tu
r e
a m cc o t
t hr
t w
d lL
A f e Bh (
t b e Bf t
ft ]1 l ' r f ) f>
WVWf mul Ay l h
1r n
m )lt\
W. m
i
r du c a t to n
]u
[ 1u n
o \ > r
Sd
H 1
} 1t t 1l / /
h t t 1Jl
w n
r u
t l1
\ u \+rr
IMT
c w
o i c m
S n e l l LS
t Tw
BB1
an d
A f r 1Bt eB1
l ft d lr
v a n
+i
l tt
,h
a e r 3 3 i 6 5 2 67
d c r V le u t e n C PHI : G
f t he t h e o
1= E G u \ . B1J N o 5
S\ >
Fr a n k J R
t } l c nd
m s
u so
1n
e n era
a_
t e n t
; f r J1a1 Ti n ; A e r 33 : 7 8 3 7 9 7
n r n
1n > r t
N
H n
\ ) :
Con\ &i ' nL1\

t 1m t
A ( H(
Bl
Thc
t ea
1 f } . B Ar
bu s
m mn
lcl
32 : t i1 L t i 30
t\
Y N a l\ m
\ l \ \ t \ a t 1\ >
>
= i
20 11
r( 1u
20 1 1
3 3 2 6j 7 3 0 2 2 U I l
1mr r namnJl
rs .
H w n
h t
U1\l g11t.\
Ue M >
\ 11 n
t L 1 11 n
M
l y \ l e l 1B , Bt 1, B u
L\
: 1n
1t
tm
r
l 11o t t
Fau t n
Jc\ t l 0pm*nt
l t a. l c&hl p i n m n l i c a l
B E H G u i d e
r e n e n
m
3 4 4 3 SL L3 20 12
K t h n Y HVnh c l D
C a mm J
Sc
p Bns
C ha p t e r
Cu
Z
C t Br r i c t Bl u
+ 1
dt
In
R M
el o&nctt t
du
t r o
io
ct
plan
d de v e lo p m
an
Se c t i o t 1 .
lu
ic u
r r
a r
r r
m u c
a n
a n
d e BB
p a t h o l o gy
o r g a n ic
pla
n n in
hc
he
pr
1n
1s
d lc a
rr
u n
C.
p
du
c ed
hm
du ca t io n
p r o du c ed
e
bc
bh it
ra
o u T
r e m
s v er
p o s t gr a du a t
at e
1t
tio n
m
n
&
he p r o gr a rl r m
fu l
t a 9
t l
in
ju
s o j u l 1o
>
a r
c o w
rrJ k $ l r
, f L J
lra g
! c j
o n
ly
g Jf
o n a
ss
c l
gs
Pe a
e CL
c e
hi n g
n Bu
ne
1w f 1n o
on
! \
ra n
lu
9 u r r
it
tr
l BT j
\ t n \ Lr t
hr m 7
ge
11 n c e u b
7 ht
u r1, i
: t 1e m
c r e a s in
r e sp o n
10
T1U
fo
pl
r 1r
n w n
he
a s
ke
s e
5 3
a = L J
r c
D3 c 3
p c E
c
L u r r H u
J m
{ r l
lu
j r l
: d
( V l l\ 1 l
) J 1f
lll\U
Jl H n
rt
v h n houn B
lt
hr
'
pp r o
r 1\ t \ t l o
c a n
a
be
u sr
h c r p Mc w n
t o
ide
11
1 1r
lu l
rH
kl
Wa n
rt
t n 1t \
C o o kp
r c o
Hn u
e t
ro
o r
c m
p ha s m
pn
ltt n t M
n o A
ony
te Jc
n t
hc
kn e s s
tm
u c
F TB 2 1 A n
e x te n d e
Ts
an
MA g w
i fy
5FJa\ t y
i l f u lu r n
t d
n t
l \ 9S5)
e , 1l I t r s T h e \ m i o :
\
p u l l p 4 t 1L n t $ 8 o \ e n n n c n t
l t l\ t
he s
Br r n?B /1 ; e m o r
d t t c r c
n v r7 tm m
i t l t 1 } 1 w Bt
r\
ac
( 11nn
r J 1e r 1
h t
hat
> .
e s
t pr u
pp
h a b b t c n ( Bt l r t l uncd b y : r t n k e t a l ( 2 1) 10 ) ,
al 12 0 H 4 a n d n t h e n T h e n c M h m h w n
m t
! e
As s o s s m o n l
le v
hic h it m e e t s a n d
e e d s o f t he
p o pu
rn c n t
at t
g
s ib il i t y
Wh a t h
!e
tn e s e c
m e e t
a so
t o w
ex te n t
es t o
he a l t h
In
es
t he
d ic i n
so c i al
he
to
bu
ca re
m e
SU C ( c s s
se r
is is
c r
t a t iv e
1s
q u l p s 1t 5 g r a d u a t
T he da y s a r c n o w
l r kc a
a c u r n c u lu m
t he
w hen
o : a ha t
an
an
d pr ev e
be in g pa id
e di c a l s c ho o i a n d
tio n
! {
ain
d c n t s c l l m c a l t r a i n 1n g w J s l 1m i t e d
ho hap pe n e d t o p re se n t du n n g a
1t 1s n o w a ( c e p t M t h J t c a r e f u l
t
n e c e w
1s
d e r g r a du
u n
t c a c 1e r
stu
a t t a c
he
o
fo
devel opment
a n
m c lc a
1c n t s
p at
1c a
ge
he n
L.
pl-
1J n
t h
o n
gl c
to
a n
lu
c o n t i n u in
p a st
m a
ic
e n
m o t io n
Cu
in g
v l s lo n
a c u t n c u lu m
an
Cu
sr ut 1 y ( } l ,
CUT1nJ uni
'
r ur \
l i tr '
1 J P
1 d(
d > ht
\ wh
t '
Hc n
c nrc
w n
t bt
'
'
>l t e
j'
1h1
om r
pe r l
m.
)u c
L 1 kc n
a a
o r c lin t
pe\
n i i re
t or s r t ' o .
dn x l
n u
n rc
n n m
l q u a ht im
pe c ia
un d r
>
to
d as
hd
WL I I U s
nt > : r i l t >d
hc
.w
H n
) l
h lc
c l n it a
B J
thu
bv ( \\
lh
c o nc e
th o
1)
id e a
On o
bu
o o u tc o n l o
p:
t.
du
lt
h o u l cJ
c a t 1o n
du
c a t 1o n
tco n
o u
fo
1n
Iu
pe
ex
here
Fro j
do n
in a l
\ \
ht
e t }
r e
t l 1c
18
c r
PCt l f i ed
l
c \ r n L 1 B u m
rtL e s/
he
} d s
m att er s arr
ht
te
tt
m a
J (
hl rli
tu
e r
he le u r m
de l
rr i o
]t
T h 1\ r c p r c
o f L u r n cu
lt
i n d
ro
a r m n
o l 1 t L o mt s
du
1s
d> a
l r c e
rl
u t( t
f I> .
Fm r,
t r d j 11 l r Bi :
J JI i
f r Bf
)1 i \
n n
Jt +n P d u mHn
u n
k l HA
il n
lo
Bl n
u n
ht
\t
o r k
fo
en t
r m
t l l t'
lr
N n
ph
r sp c
t iv
n w
g t lr e
cu l ur n)
p m h
t ; 1r
d io
h Hd h o o d
va w u
l 1r
d u h h o o d 0 1d
,
a t
ge
h .N c d
rn u t u a
n a
(u n
syst t i n
lly
he
c x d
gr i d s
t 1s m
L o n t e n t
bJ s e
cJ N
a cu rr ic u
lu
fr o
o r m o re o
C hJ p t t
re n l
r
fr o m
ha t
tJ U
( F1
2 2
Bn
7)
ie l
d t itt
ec / r e d
TT
B/
r o t
l 11 1
l> w
B1
l t 1L t
1 < 4 1 r l 1 1{ > \
<
Bl \
.n
in
ht
h>
] 1i > c n l > n t
.n t t \
Bh u
M H ;
r\t l ,
1r r . \ u
in
1l
hw
l
n
t t
h> H h
I
lu
: \
HN v
r> n
wn
\ l r r lt t 1 \ 1n 1 w
n n r
a n
J Hn
w n
h n
h1uht
he h rt u l e
B c h 1n 1t n a
1r r l \ t l ] t 1 n
n w e
B t B1
aunH t B H n d 1 t HUn h
Ju \
w nt
cur r1cul uni

\ c n t t i o n \ o r t a l k s (a s c e n i r i o
o r L n k b N c d cur r nuh1m
] pw
a r t
u n
l pn
v e o
l r n jn
t rn
c n 1t c o n 1 r s i n
1n > a B\
}l l t h l o
d \f lc
Pil Bt
n n
l dt
C L
d
t hc
u n
3
3
11
i H
Tim
C hJ p t
1 1
a n
r ml n g
dt f i nt j
det s ons Jbj ut

r >
\ \ a > fr o m
1n i
ts
d r- -
a s
are
e s
at '
i rn
un t
phnes a t r a dMon a eurr i =ul un1
m \
t'
F t ht s c pe r s w c t l v t s
c
N o a c c o u n t o f c u r r c l 1 l u m c o n t i n t w o u l d he
t hc h i d d e n c u r n c u lu m
l
w r t h o t 1t r t $ r e n e e t o
t
c
e
p
T h t Dc c l a r 0 c u m c u l u m 1s t h r c u m c u l u m a s w t u u t
T %c t a u g h t
c um
1 n \ t l t u t 1o n s d o c u m n t s
1n t h t
d
h
T
c
5
t
e
m
u
r r i L11
h
h
c
t
c
s
i
n
r
a
c
t
Iu m i s w a t a p p v n
t
p
d
de n
h
h
d
T
i
b
h
t
t
n
e
s
u
e
t
e
l u m i s w h a t 1s l e5mcd v
f
l
\n o 1\
l earnl ng t h t
t he st u d e n t s
c u r n c u lu m
tw o
f t h e b t g 1d t a s i n r n a l l e a l t l c1 \ t 1o n o v [ T t h c
: l c a r n 1n x
h
p a s t d i a d e h a s BnBn t h t n 1 o \ e t o t t u c o
d r r \ c r o r c u m t u l u m p la n n i n g
t ht
a s
o u t c o m ts
( H a r d e n 2 0 0 ) I n a n o u t c ( 1 r r l t BJ w D r p p r o I A h t o
Onc
pare d
> pc
=u r r i
ha w d
T hc s e
1 yo
yr
M1 c
n in
h c c o n w t o h n 1l n w J w
o l t h e c \ 1r r c u l \ Bm
G \ n bt
p r( \ c
b> r
bo d y r y \ w
c n u m
H H H VHI N1
n u rn
p la n
c o n te n t
hj wt s or
t v
rn
s f Br
p c r o
st a r
wu
Ir o
o\
o r
h c on k h1r M in
h=
Uk m, B( y$.
i s s t u d 1t x l
n 1 or
pr aLMi n d o n
C r l r n A h B h 1e H t m n h t i (
T
en t
on t
r r it u l u r n
ht
rl n
t
h>
u n
l : Bn
v 1v m
v H
>
tv
h o m
I t h a s b e e n a d v o c a t e d t ha t t hc c u r l c u l u r s h o u l d
b c t ur ncd o n 1t s h e a d , w i t h s t u d e n t s s t a r t i n g t o t h i n k
l i k e a h c a t t h p r o f e s s i m a l l r o m t 1c d a y t h e y t n t c r
l
m e d t c a t s c h o o l S t u d e n t s a t I Bo f s t r a h t c d t c a ] Sc h o o
pa
N c w \ b r k s N n d [ h c l r %r s t S n e c k s w k r k l n g 0 5
stu d e n ts
m e d i c s I n a v e r t t c a l ly i n t c w a t e d c u r n c u l u m
d
ir e ba s i c
l
t
s
t
c
d
d
l
l
d
c
i
ar
to c im ca m c
1n t r o
u c c
c tn c a o n g
T hc
i
r
1=
s c e n c e s i n t he c J r ly y c a r s o r t h e p r o g r a m
l
d
t l 1c
o
ies
n r r d : o r s t u d e n t s t o c o n t i n u e t he i r s t u
b a s i c s c 1c n c e s a s a p p l i c a t o c l i n i c a l n t c d i c i n c i n t h c
l a t e r y e a r s 1s n o w r e c o g n i z c
I n a %n J p o r t : o l i o
a s se ss m e n t
s t u d e n t s a t D u n d e e h t d i c a ] Sc h o o l f o r
e x a m p le
a r t e x p c e t c d t o i n t e r pr e t t h c c l i m c a l c a s e s
t h e y d o c u m e n t i n Ah c c o n t e x t o r a n u n d e r s t a n d i n g o f
t h c b a s i c s c 1e n e c s
A s p i r a l c u r n c u l u r n (F t g 2 3 ) o f f e r s a u s e f u l
a pp n c h t o
t h c o r g a n 1z a t 1o n o f ( o n [ c n t ( H a r d e n &
St a m p c r 19 9 9 ) n a s p i r a t c u r n c u l u m
r l p "
4n n r n
c u r r \ c u l u rn
a=
w o u
ld
rl
hb 1 \o i
d
i c
h o r l h c l t h 1r k t n , / r c i 1i F1' A a
o n t i n u . m 1n l h u S P I C E S r r ' J l
t m
lo go
M u c h d j s c u s s l o n a n d c o n t r o v e r s y i n m e dc l
1 th
u o n ba s r e l a t e d t o e d u c a t i o n s t r a t c g i e $ Th
e sn c
B
rn o
e l (F r g 2 4 ) o f f e r s a u s e f u l t o o l f o r
p lw w 1 \
c u r r i c u lu m o r o 1 a l u a t i n g a n c x rs t i n g o n e
(
h e r e 1 s i t c r at t >c
t hc
op i
r c v 1 s1 t i ng
of
t op t
i hr o u g
es
h ou
It
t 9 84 )
ar e
at
r c l sr t c d
dt l
f er
I n-
cn t
c5 r
o v
c o m
v 1 s Bt
mn
pc
1$
t c n c r
t o a to
at
l
o
cd
to
ou s
f s t udmt s
s t r a t e gy
T-
l ea r n l nz
Br
m u nn
Ee c i n + e n
c
S L p d
or
er pof eson
com
as
In :e gr
Ha r 1
eac
P r o be -
s of
in t r c J \c 3 w n
ese n ts
pr
Sd e n n * e d
c o u r se
cs
a vo i
d I : Dc u I t )
n
(
Ont e:
d i n g t h e p o ]a n r J n g o l o p i n i o n z n d a c k n o ,
t ha t s c ho o ls m a y v a r y i n t he ir a p p r o a c h
SN
Ah \ c m
t m aw
p ic
F Be 2 4 S P I C ES
Stu de n t
m ode
l o t e d u c a o m 1 sa'
t r e d le a
ce n
r n in
} n \ t uLI mt
Co d
A MJ L
H 3
Y 9 an 4
\ t n t r r \ 1 l e Tr m
h t l 1t \ t u r t l t c t r
\ t ut l t nt l t Jm\ n j t t > r \
hn h h w u V h u t h e r
> 1n
hw n i n R h 1 n n
r \
cn
n \ \
g
} t \ t \ lc n t \
u h
r 1t
tl
m t
Hl H
nJ
M, m
i n t
B Hn n >
tH m
l>
h l u , It
1 t ,
l t l\> 1
1 +1\ h
hc r
hJ n
arc
t 1o n
w
hl
gn
cn
m
t \i
t! c
uuL
\ l t > 1\
i U1 1 t
u 1
lr
n >
u l
li \ w
n 1n
u m
hn n
<t t r t Bc
tr,
11 1 \ \ t r r y
mhni quc
1 t \ i 1\ t
nB
t h>
o n
hr
tu
"
ht
lu
b a s e d .e
\ us
hn
dc
r \ t t Bd
Wh e n t h m
ren \
o nw
l timc
o
m u u n ts
omt s
d
J
d 1c n
b e a r r a n g l e :
,
an
nc Lt
nt
Ve w 1
P t o b te
UC
w c w
l c a r n 1t r g t } u t t
h co u n c
e n JLU t c
t l 1e
huuhl ht mv v > J h e h r e t h e
lu
t x
m
hpt cr 19 o n uh. W J
h c m HCr
w p r m TdJ t hu t
P h a sq 2
p.i
SCS
l>
a l n rn
g (P B L )
ppm
n l l \
..
1 l\ l
.. .
'
h t a l edu
n
o t (
u \ L t n
11
Jt
st u
n t s
k in g i n
w o r
sm a
ll g r o
bu
ps
in
a so
h(
C r ,r1 d
f l a r g e g r o t l p s , i n i n d i v 1L I u a l i z e d l e a r n i n g
E le v e n s t e p s
o r n i c h s t u <c n t s w o t k i n g a t a d i s t a n c e
d
h
PB
L
i
i
o
i
n
t
b
be t w e e n
t
e
c
n
z
e
e
c
o
n
u
r
n
(
u
m
n
ca
F
J
d
b
l
b
d
a
t
t
a
o
c
n
n
r
o
c
r
1
n
c
r
a
l
t
sc
a s k ba st d
i nt bm 5t i un
p
t
c o i 1t c x
le a m
ln
(H a r d e n
& D
i s 19 9 8 1
:r e
o n
to
J rm n r
Co
t as
t Bf
'
1t
r 1H
tj
y l
11 r r ,
ABrT 1 \
Jn
ks hi p s a r e
r r ic u lu m
as a
d c r
cu
'
.l r
Bn n
il l 1
r d
ba s= d
m m u n i t y
n n
1( I H l l
i n t ( gr a t c d i n t o t hc
l d m
n o w
\ r :r 1
\ {) r t
:n
m u rt
p la n
n e
po n
e n t s
p c r iu n c e
e x
ab
it h
b h p pro
u u
h to
(H a r d e n
ks hi p s
c c r
i 1r J : /
r
l o 1 e ly
d le a r n i n g
E le c t i v e s
ac
TS L
69 3
c l e fs
1:
\ :: r \ ( t c c
11 d n J
b 1t 1t 10
c m
J c J fl y T\ : r
S LW RI
1S<'
t
C ?
In l e g r a t t o
a n
1S
i n
PO/
C 0 1 3 0 1 1, n (
ca f
1n
tn
e n
= BC c t 11 u
sn
t s
a w
h ( laj
se
d fu
he
b c t Lv c 1 n d n
h c bw n d c x
t r
t c h n
T1
1nt cdt ed
. Bm
teac
h th c u r r
l c 1o j
dn
Co m
fr u
Au
d f u r t l 1e r
ba
m u n .ty
'
n n
U l l
1n t r
at c
j w
1
tl \
in \
L u
a rm n
U
1
he
>
p r u B> \
t J < 2 0 137 ] T l 11 \
he
u 1
Ut l ed t u
lw t r
rt
l hi r
he r
in
i t ll
st u d t n (s
p r n t lln *
T hn
h n c m t h > c onununi t y
C h Br t c r s ) 3
l 14
a n e
lt\
a \
SJ
Jcn
tu
la s s r o o m
d m t hc
f c m 1s t h e i r l carni ng o n t h c
bc J \ n b b l e . "
Io n g e r
r\u c
pr
t L\ o
t
Tu
he T e
\n tc r
1n
to t
t he
hc n l
a n
\l
c n s\ l r e t
h5 t
M u d c n
hJ \
lc a r n t n g
h > wn x u r n u l u n 1 n d u d c n h c
h. a \ p r i c t u c
e n t \J l to r l m
hJ t
1 Te m
l o tA
t hv
,
r \ L \ Bl u m
J w
T h
rt
i n akin
l\
n o
5n
47r
w n
w 1l l \ t
h>
p
o
co n i
b\
\ (\
1 n u h o d c a n be
ha v e n h p a m n t s
tm nk
c u te [ u sc
r n tn
I I \
1n u L c a
n o
ge
t lt e
h\
l e mmg
1l l \ l
m u
c x
u g h t he
p\
L u r T 1c u
lu
rc n =c 7
Th c
t L o 111 0 5
tm
1n a g i t
c pu r n c m
n \ a t lt
11r o g r e w t h r
t \ l \ lt n t \
ran
t n t h e M U L hw t s
l l ll
A<
d e
h 11 t t L I L t u
It
n tl t l t lw
1N \
u sc
e n u Ht c n
\\ L
)\ >1
l 1o
h h
\ l i n t Ht h
Bl (
tm
lw
N > v
r J n BN
n A \\ r
I l r> u
1L
hr
h. p:h
c w
n \ e\
l im
n t i 1t e t
nJ
u r rc
\ ct t \ n
h
\ - 11V L C
HW
L\
ppm prm
M >
l
Br i t r 1 t \ J t 1 1
ch
teJ
lc n t
n Bn
p4 t
rc a
T 1\
n w
co m
n io rc
1m
rn
Se BC C t C O
ppr o a c h
r t u n 1) t 1c
p&
t ic
SI U a C n t
Hu n t
t l : i l B \ : \ 1i n r n \
T h t r t a r c s t r u r 1* t d u c i Bt i u n a l i nt l l o Hl \ \
J h 1w J p m
to r p L c i n l c v < c m p h a m n n a hm w
n r t y a \ 4l
o n t h> c u m n m
l
m 9) r u t l 1 p t i t r s
i t r r l r 11e a n d
c u m m t l l )i t
te J
he r \
u r n 1n
m
ttr
\ l n B: t } 1A t l t B
t
m a
An
h
Jr
o n
pru
an u
m c n t
gc
Sy s t e
l l aMr n 20 00
: e w l u n J l t e J l \l r1 \ : 1c r \
Yh
J
lc
m J n J
14 : H r s p ( L t B\
.
o . . ( Ja m r 11 l L
3
2
(
hil p t \ r
In
l d
d b5 s ic
hi n g
b I t 1s
t ea=
\ t e
\ c n
an
se s
c u r r 1c u
m o v e
1 i
r1 l
t he l r
. s
/ m i 1$ a 3 w .
p ]1 n
pr oh s wn
l , u t j 'j t c t
a t
d ](
a n
m an
2 2 El e
c bJ s d d
r l hed
1s a m o e t o i n t > r
rt
Bt
(
r e
C ha p t r
in
1r u u m
co T
en t
rt
d e c a de s
tw o
da r d e a t u
st a n
d-
r n Td 1 t )j C O u
i o
a r c n o w %r m l y e s t a b ]i s h e d a s a v a l u e d c o m p o n t n t o f
t h c c u r r c u l u m j n m a n y m e d i c a l s c h o l s T h e y h a v e
be in g a f r i n g e e v t n t t o a n i m p o r t a n t
m o v e d rr o m
e d u c a t i o n a l a c t i > i t y t ha t c o n t r j b u t ( s t o t h c c x w c t e d
e x i t le a r n i n g o u t c o m e s
I t i s n o l o n g e r p o s ti i b l c f o r st u d e n t s t o s t u y i n
d e a l l t o p i c s i n a c u r n c u l u m E[ c c t [ \ e s o r SSC s
p r o \ T d e s t u d e n t s w t h t h e o p p o r t u n 1t y t o s t u d y a r c a s
w h i l e a t t he s a m e t u n e d e e l o p i n g
o f in t e r e s t t o t hL m
a n d ti m e
s e lf a s se ss r n e n t
s k i l l s i n c r i t i c a l a p p r a Bu l
c t 1r f c n f
h e r e ha s n
a ro u
h
e c u r r ic u lu m
st r u c t u n n g t
o m
ay
d 1m p ] 1n e s I n t t w a t + d
e r c e s a n d m ( dica l
i
OW CC
l ear ni ng
n g
Bn
s s to n a
1r
1+t 1 l l 1 1
p B1c 1t
e.
t e r pr o fe
in
tB
1( +r T1 l
ur
vl
T BL is a
do n n a l p
i n t t g r 1t i o n a n d PB L i n c l i n i c a l
e t a l 2000)
Is
l C ( 1 r r 1r 1 1u n
1r \
k b a s e d l e a r n i n g (T B L ) t h t l c a r n i i s f o c u s e d
a s t r ie s o Ft a s k s w h i c h t h c d o c t o r m a y bc e x p e c t e d
s u c h a s t hc m a n a g A rn c n t o f a p a t ie n t
t 1n d t r t a k e
In
\ l l l l lu l
i\ n w
hm h
c r
to
a n t i / qr
t ea=l ut
11 hsnB r
A
uc
h o d ti ) r
C tu p t e r s i n
t \1 t t c a c b e r
h t u s r t u w h ic h i \ l s m m \ i 1 p r t w r l * t e
p
t h i s b m k d r w r h c \ h e t w l l s +Bv i 1i l B1 M 1 I n
3 t l ki t
m et
he
wh o l e-
l nR r r ma < n U
P o w c r tu l m o l s i f u e d p r o l w \y T h e y n 1 > t l I I u
b p a s h m
a n t i t l w t r r o l e i s n o r r t i a n u n > o l
m f m n a t 1n n t r a n Fc r
Sm
7t u
dc n
ur
U gr o
Hth
gr o
u
.M
L c n
W o r
L t
w or
bt u
an d
as s
k f a t 1h t a m
in
ch M t i : n
u \ u a
lly
r 1M
l +11 p t t r t \ n \
]n
> t n w n
ll
w d
k r rw
I
h 1w > r h
h n Mw
h B r Sm
m M$
t ca c h
d n L k u pnvnhe u n V
t 7 I r a r n 1n R f r o m t I L h
W
L1o11
111gt \
cn t r w
T u t o r u t*
Lo w
OW4 " 4 4
,
tl
1
{ in
mh en l l cl ty
I
nd t
e t
1 e. +
r n 1 nx
ca n
\ ak
l t : 1p\
\ 1l
un t
row.t l l f 1J Jl t ,J.l l (Br,J
F lg 2
h u t o n S t 1 1\ \ n b \ n J \ t e t l u J r > \ b > l r l R
d i e d \ \ h l l e a t t h c in 1 n \ t t . m c t h e t l t \ > l t t
y
p
t he a b i l t t
t o w o r k o n t hc \ r O W N a t Ll t u t a k>
r c j p v n ii b i l 1t
y fo r t he i r o w n l c a r n . n R
c o n tn
st u
p p L c a t 1o
C O tT : N
n. f i i nt
\
t
i c h
i/
dw
m a v
e s
R r 1l
1 b
( :3)
Be
d c h W\ !
t tr L n
l o p m = n t i n r c ( t n t y t u r \ l 1J \ w l n
h . M u n w c hn m
c u
m
I Uh w
e
be
u w
a r +f j
l \
t t Uf L A
t t BL. t h f
1
'
' a
\n
ti \ r t u
\n (
d B1
'"
( Xa t rl jt i l
11l nt t 1t 1
l i
BU i
h tu u
H ' h a t 1mu , 1 h
ilt
ld b >
u f
rH
l l {1n
T1a
l
Uc _
9 18
?W
4d r t
u t
l 1
aw
\ a
t\
l 1e
lx
}$ J t m n
e 1\ 1L
t **
1s
np
n 1
1I J
uf
Bl Nj
(R
71
wc MW>
1 1 8 3 1 l lt
n>
nu
t u \ Bl l 1 t i v t \ t
1r ] u r r r l t r t
. ' Hl t
ha i
ll
'
ru m
t 0: i t
l\ \ u e %
lu t l>
t lt\ n
t1
' "
'
v c
t At i
U1
r r r r
1 Bl l n
l >
vi
Bn
1r
g hb
ll L
se s
n o
4&c
st u d i n
" / b { : F :
ht
. IH
Vht
1
t e\ l
e m
1n J
Bu A
lw
l u L Iu
nt
t n1nh< t ul I eBl t ht
B Ht
'
>s N .
d u n n t hc
t hm
hw \
ac
o u t m
W
h o
A
+
n t
t ht
ln
hn g
m c c
>
hc
uL
st
1 ( L n \
1 l
tu
pc tc
dc n
m bp t t n \
n nt
i bill t y
n hM y
stu t t n
u r
u \ 1r J
m ac
c e n
In
h n [ n i M n
n \c
he y
c o m m u n lc a
t
r
u
wl
tn
R\
tu
u w t
+.
T lw
l \ t\ r t
ht
d ic a l
i n
du
stu
ct m n
ru w
h
t A1t
ht
J\
n lm
n in
ha n
c n su m
ha t
r?
V W
hc k
a rn
r + t 1 9 = b
r Bx
pn
rt
a ttc
pt
( 1\ \
l1
lw
n h
a t
>Jt
tr o n
c or
I p t ht r u a
n a
II
l t lr>
t J ): t
41
ke
hm
pr
.
m
f t>
lb h
u r
l\
me ( 1
(
t l r>
1n n \ u r
r 1t l \ e
l\ 1
t i
l> n
h tt J
l 1l
1 1l Bt
f \v
a
t t tt
II \\
\\ a y
a l
1o r
8 B
n u 1
\ l
l l B1
1
:
Bt r B\ 1B \ 1i H
I.
l 1w
Hn
n h 11
<l l l t . TBt l \ \ \ 1 l r e t I\ 1 11 l 11
h 1T d t l 1 l t l 1l t t +>
1 1 i BB
1l t B l
B
n e
UW X
u n
u w
Hk h
hn n
u 1h l u
nt h n
t I I
n u n 5
h h n t
hn
h w
Ph '
\ 1
Hn h
t .
nn h
t e nJ h
t un1
hk > h m
o l t tt
Nn I
H\
\t n n
\ B rtrt t
le \ e l
Mx I
n n
tu
n m n J
u w
h> rr
nu
y wB
g > t h= h
tnw
I 1l r
I 1H
1n1nh
te
l l 11t
1
11 ,
I\
H H 1 t rn t
h H
a
t l t t 1r
r 1
v 1 >
mn t
e x
to
n a l
!u
Lh '
+w
l t\h1Bi 11H
In
l i\ t
wl +n
1n
l\ H
u m es
e x
ht
1l u
1 1 1 1t w
u r lr n
>
\ Lu
B lh e
n w r
%t t
th
Bt x p 1r \ t
Gm
l\ I { )
ptw
1l
t l t l l * l B( 1 l BBt
m
i\n
t\
o n
rc spu n \ l
m be lm
tt
1 1TH
t 11 { r n t t r l f
l l b Bj 1 1 1
r\j r
lt In
Rr \
( fj 3
b ill t ) \ u
under anDng d
he
C
m
A H N
t1
l1
'
r l t
. e
t t r n t 1 11\ \ \ B1
t u dc nt
AI
I 1
T Ca c T S h a \ t
dr m h a c a c
p m bl t
I m H H.
1M
ncc
be th
ht
t\ c n(
l > n \ l 1 1 w 1 n l 1 1 1 1 l l l 1 i 1 t 1 1\ 1 l 1 \
l
Ut
h
t
ur
ht h1i n l t h 1t n I H H H h 1 l 1 <1 n 11
in H t
t t1
: tl t l l l l l l l d w L t l n l { ' 1 h l l l t l t e\ l , l t > \ 1' Lh l t t r B 1 t 1 l \ l t 1H l
[ t l \ 11B 1 11 1l w l t w B Bl B B t \ 1* l
U \ t d \ l t [n
> x t 1l l l l l r 1l l n n \
? B
I n t
l lM
T ht
1 h H
( o n l m o n
F rs 1 6 Fa
ln
h o u l d b L p 1t d
c o m m u m c i t 1o n
tt h
T-
hr i r
a w r v
t lt e L o n \ t x t
g a t t e n t io n
o m
1s
to
p c c c c d Bt L\ r
vn
1I H
Mr
he i r
rc
de n t
t t1 t
u i t h a n a t m n 1l o r i n t w
l i c a l . h( Wl Th c t L' aeht r ,
a stn
c r
A Y L TV T
FJ 1l u
e\
{ =\
a Mt b s me n t
c o u rac
'
u wn n wn t
vrs
f t he
MT N T
tt B
D t pc
n L
b m mh
n w
o\
sh
F u I
hl
>
uh
nh
h mu i n
nn
h> nH
1
n m
\ \ huH
hr n $ J m n m h n n s N n h h w h h h n e
h t M N u u n m n H ru h W > u H n > J w h $ h h
n t
WC T l O e q
C l l r r i c I J1m
l pm
en t
t e ue o
Su
im ple m
io
e n tat
n m l ar
T he de v e l o p m
in
lu
c u r Tic u
i m
e
r e
dc
pr o g
n t
a
e m e n t
de pc
t gr o
1n
aca
d e m i c s t a ndar
T he r e
p o s t gr adu
CY
a c r v
c c s
to
ea
i ng
c h
re s
d q u a lit y
qu ir c
r c
m c n
ib i lit y fo
assu r an c e
ts
it h
bc d
do
p p ro
ac
m ina n
in
yo
be r
n u m
F a pp r o
he s
ac
t he
to
i
pb
i t ec r
\ t h a
wp
a r cA
n s
oa c h
he
c le a r s t a t e m e n t
hin g
T hc
te ac
o n
he
n a
h in g
p teac
e t
hin g
ssess m e n t
m m u n i ca t io n
ke ho ld e r s
do pt ed
s a
gie
i n t e gr a t e d
hn
stu
de n
u *
lo gi e s
ts
r o
u t
he
c u rr
hc
s t u
bo
en v
d i n g t he
u s e d i n c l u di n g
l ar
ll g r o u p t e a c h i n g a n d t he
lu d in g
a t i on a l
c lu
in
c o v e te
p le
te c
i n c
o u tc o m es
c o n te n t
ho d s
U1h e
Co
uc
t rat
s m a
sta
ed
le a r n i n g
n e w
e x a m
a n
is
hic h it is
t io
e c u c a
teac
in
1n
c n c c
qu
gr o u
m e n t
pe ct ed
e x
to
lu de d
or gani t i on o f t h e
h as i s
e mp
i s i n t e n de d
le a r n in g
T he
ge
de n
tu
u r c u r r i c u lu m
m an a
pe c t e d
e x
co n t e n t
sc
19 8 6 )
n
no
add,
be
to
g p r o gr a -
T hc
to
pe ct
re s
c w r i c u lu m
he s to
t he t r a i n in
ds
n e e
S T he
f th c
n ( e
can
a f
n s
po
m e
ul fi l
2 T t 1c
i ll ha v
hin g p r o gr a m
f u ll y p l a n n e d T e n q u e s t i o n s
r e l a t e t o t he f o l lo w i n g
1 T he
l l be
wi
tea
T B1 e s e
ca tio n
a c s
y st a
an
t hc c u r r ic u l u m
a + nm e
a n
i lo r
du
te e
s im
a re
st a
a n
ma
1n
Fa
iz e d
gn
de v e l op m e
fo r
ir
qu
t w o rk o
bu t i on s
t ri
rec o
st a
co n
an l
il l b c
i n g, t e a c h i n g
t t o su pp o
asse ssm e n
t
pla n
ln
e t ho ds
en t
i ron m e
gr
e ss
ic u lu
den
a ll
t he
ts
n t
l earni ng
t Te n c e s
a n a
e n t
ge m
f t he
c u m
cu
lu
o u t c o m e s
7
lit
1 c
1an
hi n g
t m
1s
m o r e
lu
ra t
T h
ha n
m a
kl
o o
c x
ha
o v r a
ll
w
*
c a
an
he
d
re a
t 1r n
n t e x
rc .
po
l + 1(
d 1t
gr t
dn
>
lu
t (
h e go J l
a n
\ \ 11 l \ u
1>
rt
\ l 1t
l 1l e
BBJ \
t u ll l w
l ut
f t hc
t J t
Co
c \ 1r n c u
D
1\
L
l. n
?n
e IL
lm lt
\\
l LI w
u u
n m
r l 1l
lw lt t
1hh
art
>
p l Ba u\ \
a tn
v 1n
r 1y
r lB
t 1r \ U
1 l ; t j t 1r
ht ll B\
n 1\ t Bl n
u r r Bt u
L e
\ 1n
l llt
l \ 111w
dn L
C\
r t n L C
o n tn
[ u
n n
1l !
. .
1 1 +r
1i
n n
yw
r r
h d
\W
\ u
BW
n \lv
1BJ
c n c rL \
t in
lu
( a
e
(io
5 25
e , l t .
l How
"
A BE L IE
6 m
ca n
gs
r\lc n
n em
R t : hni ques
l n l b y d L c t o r s
19 8 5
K A N ET G u
e ( a
( i t 1 11 r u n l t v s e t t i n
E G u hl
h tc f
W m e n
ilc a l
m ex
c u
HAr
R M
n a
\n \
a n
W R t b n n 1 t n 11 0
t > v lu \\ i\
iL u
lu
l \ a n Be \
1' nnk l Lt \ cn l
hm
Htu
1l \
31
Le u
in g
i JD Bt h r 3 0 : 45 5 4 7 3
ZA
1u J
t u l:
H c a t h p r o f c s 1o a 1 7
7 \ l \ > n h e \ l t h W \ e 1n \ i n d n 1n t e r d c p c n d c n t
l \ 1 >I 1> BAB1l et 3 7 l i : 1 ) 2 3 \ 1) 5 8 2 0 10
\ \t e n
1n
\ eU t
n 1\
t o c \ r l\
Gt
n n u t h
[l]c
hm
bu
hl 1not s
[ t nBal
in
2ch l s
L t 11 [
\n
7 bt t l t ' WN 5
BL e t n \ t \ i n
h e 1\
p hu
rn J n
lB T lw
l r b v D ) t O B n e n B C E J w a t n g Ff\y s +o ke M
A G Bl l Jo r R o n ? o \ t J l d S m l s 1 1 R e s
S a n F r a n , 1c 9 o 20 10 J L \ w c ! & 1 H i
t m p h a \ <\
t h5 n o n t h
Bn B 1n e d l B BBt 4 l l 1t J t B\ \ n
In
t 11 n u d Bt
th c
rJ
p5r t
b lt
I u LI d L I T h \
l t 1c
I Bl r +r m
1tl
l( R
1\ I r 1 L
p n
u n ipo n r n n
t t o H> \ 1.
n v T tu
t l u1nun M
A fi n a .
do
H, l l >m\
in
Ah e
hJ n
r : r t Bt a
r 1 A a n s t o
dn tdu J l
in
& rw
f)n
n m
go
t h
t s on
l \ t r J t \ g \e \ T h e r e
t h e c u r r 1m l u m
\s
h
T
19l
uc.
Jt
l
(
nal
r
g
n a
( u r n t u
r r
lf b
1s
h as 0 s
( mp
cBpprc uch C o n t d c r a t t o n
t a l ls o l t ir
L i n l e n t a n d }m w
H u
hc
_ he
lt
rc
c o J 1p o n r n t o f I n
1s o n
1( A
d ( d u c a 1o
ho w
a bo u t
a n
ht
lt \ (
he r
he dt
to t
pr ot
h o ds
c o n c e rn
LAOr kl ng
st r at
ap
m e t
Jh \ A f l 1 e [ t i r
Bt r n t t f t Bi n i
Hanin
A M
1 E 1Bl u
c r l ir Br u pl 1l B> t B
>r w
h D
c B Br e
G t B1t l e
q l B Bl i F
Ko N , d H
l m a t 1o n : 11I h l E G u j \ l c
29 : 73 5 75 1 200 7
t t
Bt l o l 1
n u
9, U
t +
I IQ
t
23
B1 l B
A he st
1i c a l 1, 1c br r
d e n RM A p p r o 1( h c
h a l i M Ed u t
n Sh W
ar
E 1l 1
d t Bo 1l
co u rw
hn
Bo o k
n o
t o a sk w
he n p ] 1 n
A f n h c u l h 1u c u t m
m n
ar
d = n R H O
fu
tu r
M 1.
1s
h lu
H
ti 0
bal
ed
B y \ 1o B i r B t t 1 Tm
1s t t ) c a
1n
d 1e r
20 0 7
k Tu
a n d p m h
M w l l cu 1
3 4 : 3 9 1 39 7 2 0 0 {1
t t i o 11
d e n RM D a n s M 1
h t on u
h m c d mmn g M e i h m 1 T1w Ar r
ar
n u u m
. Am LJm
Z OW3 U
19 9 H
l [a r dc
RM
So w
\
ra tc
l r
t hr
m od e
l U
2 9 : (I Z S 6 2 9 ,
I b r d c n RM
cducaunn
t u I in
>
o n
y(
d e n R ' t T r c 1n t t g r a t 1o n ta d t i e r u t o o l l o r
c u r n c u ] u 111 p l a n m n R a n d c v 1l u l i t o n
A h d i c l Bl
E e1t 1c a t r o r 1 3 4 : 5 5 1 5 5 7 2 0 0 0
a r
ear ni ng t hc a n s w e r t o n w r
b a s e d : cJmt ng i n t l1> dl nl cl
2 03 56
3 6 5 . F s %b
H
h c H1
l l Bs a
cl u c s t t o n s
o r c u rn cu
H a r d c n MM C r o \ b y JR D J \
L u r n c t1
u o n
20 Bs 8 4 [ b
[ Ba r d c n RA t 1 n
lt H n p l, l n n i n g
s Eo
M t J tr
in
p i
d c n
t t Br n c
S D
t r hJm d
1j m l I el t m
St
n 1n
W +1 S o
u n n
e v(
r Bn 11
t dt 1
Bl t h}nJl
M I C 9S
t l r>
n t
'
18 1 i 44 2 9 7 I )H B
W ha t
pt r
t 1 1 Tdt h r 1 l ( 2 ) ] 4 I
ro p r l l
1\ J + p Br 5
14 3 j 9
,
9 11
c u r r t t 1B u m ?
1w
il r e
\ m
11 t
u t r l \ r 1n
c \ ti l r
p lil n
a n t
l\ a t
\l y w
r n u \ 1 spc c
n Br
tu
I( T1 ( l
h j d l \ k i ll s
h houl t < l w
eae
l p l ir y e t l
\ t*
Am 1 I H H H 1
I 1H W H
So f '"
%H
J l> m n i n H o u h u w
in A m n
i I t i \ >\lll.\ll I n \ p o r t 1l n t t o
h n s t h L U mh mn I n w h k h t h > t udr nt
i n he
> ) Pt L \ > \ I t u
p > r f o r 11 t h e t 1\ k S t m t t n t \ < l \ l l Bl : y l n #
t r o w 1 1t w t l t L n l \ L I I L1 u I I n t h t I 1K l m
r t t l u i r c t l by Iu w
(1
to
w r
h : 1t
>m
a r
t w
Bt
n w
n n
so m e
ta
ht d m
h,
'
hc
n \
d
J n
m o l t
w i
n L
}: t
T 1e
lt
}t u u
\ lx
n a
n r c J
1h
lt
m e n t
t l
lt
hr
part
hr
r c
r t
B1 a \ l l t
tr m n
hn
t su
l 1t
h>
rn J
i\ io
y bt
ro
a n
T hc
h i c h t hc
i h i ht y t o
h o \ p it a l
to
o r
q \ Bi r c
t udcnt
b i lit y
r n m u n 1t
v n
rc
t t 1 1n t \
u u
blL
ht
t t ln B
t
hc
B>t r
r J1 1n a
gc
\ L n ll n
p rc
d t r n c r Ac n L y
m in t
fu
m n
11 r J w
his
n J tu r>
h t , 1 Bl t j b (
in t
r 1d
In tt r
rd
1}
r 1r r t t
B t : 1t
t u
r u w
r \ 1t 1 l
t
t B
dn L
pe
H n in
lu
hc
ho
t hc
c
a n
m e
hc
f %c i c
>
l 11e n t \
rn c t
u u
a n
n o
a m ix t u r e
ha n
do
o
c
tr
ro u n
er m
d I n ge
t o bc
h o d s i s hk e l y
i n a i r e a d he r e n c e
t
m e
de t
t co m es
o u
e ra l
m o r e
sin
in
g le
Th
Eeur t f 1gct hods
de tc
rm
to t
e r / Yi ed
c s e d c : r T
d b ", t h o
:d b e
\ l c t.
te
fL1 t
h a t t he
t he o t he r w
tan t t
11 \
h>
w
pM
tt
ls
A W
t \.
in E
n o r m
ptm
lu
\\
l wl t
\m
t 1n \ t r \ \ a n d
r x
l b\
11t e n t
t Lr r 1n
ho ds
o
po
im
w w r
rJ( t l
u sc
I t i\
\ c n
\lw
3 + M l l (
lu
W A
F lo
c u r r c u
c
I n p a r i l l > l w i t h d e t c r m i n t n g t l 1e c o n t e n t o f t 11c
l
r i c \ 1l t 1n ] d e c B\ i o n s r n u \ t b e t a k e n a b o u t h o w 1t w i l b e
d ch v u r c d W h c t h e r e h d c h m o v e r w h i c h k a r n i n g
t he r e
c w n t
toh > t
n c t h o ds m
a rc
c fce u v e a n d c f %
h
l
d
a ke n
h
t
e
h
u
s
o
bh
d
t
t
a
o
m
n
N
s
a
1r c
pr i ncp
1n t ( J n c o u n t I t I S d e 1r t h a t k n o w i c c l g c i s a p p l i e d m o w
k a r n t n t h c c o n t e x t 1n w h i c h i t
c f :c t t i v d y w he n i t
i \ t o bt a p p l i e d I t i s a l s o a c ( P t c d t h a t a c t i v e l c a m l n g
> c t i v c t h a n p a s s i v e l e a r n i n g (S c h m i d t
i
rn o w
B! ) 8 3 ) I o w t v c r a w i d e r a n g e o r l e a r n i n g m e t h o d s
c a n r n e c t t h= w o n d o m
Hu t h t r J d M o n a l l e c t u r e b a s e d c o u r s e s a n d c o u r s e s
b a w d o n v n a H g m u p Pr obcm b a s e d h a r n i n g PBLJ
l
h
m e d ic a l
t f :c c t t \ c
p r a c t i t i o n e r s (Sc m i t
pro d u ct
k n o
e t a ] 2 0 0 6 ) T h c c v i e n c c f o r a n y d i f f c r c n c c 0n
p r ob l
t
ge o t i t c o m e s b c n v e c n t r a d i t i o n a l a n d
H ow ew
hJ < c d L o u r s e s s w e a k w a r t h n g c t a l 2 0
l i ba n es &
t h e r e a r c j i ri c r c n c e s j n o t h e r o u t c o m e s 0 e
X a k c l ] i s 0 0 1 0 N e 1]1 e t a l 2 0 0 3 W a t m o u g h c t a l
20 0 6 1 T h c c h o k e o f r n h o d s b r a g > e n c u m c u l u m
w j j j d e p e n d o n t hc r a n g e o o u t c o m e s [ h a t h a v e b e e n
t \ c
.\
# UUt u ) r n t \
n
t
h Lh
T h 1s
hm
pt
r
rc
u t L u rn t
l> J r
200 1
t
s t 1n t
a r n in
hn
u r \
he
. 1( LI dt nt
Ic
h
h 4
u
l l u l l 1l t l n
1u r 3
e s \ u L
o n
hl c t o h n
h> n h M t y t o
h e wt t t n 1n
NW
p w :o r m
f
]
= r rc r n c w
in
1T o m
h
t e c o
he
ht
l \
l t ii n
rc n c
to
In
r w1 r o n r n t n t a \
r t s u \ L i t ; H 1u n
iy
M=
i n
n t lc n t
1n L l \ l t t c
Lv +t
p>\ dy
1\ e d
l o> u p e n w o n
ps
l>
n tl l t o n
>
w t
thc
110
lw
t ltf lr
pu n
1T1 t n t
r o tu
.l
\ li
u u h o m>
( T +1t r
he u t
hn uhB
b>
L
t l t +r
de
1n d t
ly
lL t
t ll
d t rr
u n
t tt n t
pJ
\ >
1\
( T n > 1x ( n L
dt p5 r t
st u
m a
lo
M
h
n n w tt n t
m J y
1 1 1 L
a s
]n
u n u
h ou t d he
m an
o n
L Ar
tL
tM m n
I m
ir
[o
o r
,1 t
k\ tu
fu n n
\1n t ll t i o
\\ a r
In
he
&
m n
\t
t o n
t t l Al > n t
U t h u
fn
t }1e
f t he
N I1 H
D t liv e s
Tn t
\
a n
B\
L n
n l ; w
n \
h5 t
J UVM
Bu r t
t u lc
t hc
11u
\\
1\ c
L i
bt
tc
tc
\ o Hw
d hy
n
1s l m
a n
t a n t ur
d ho w
hc
iu b e
as se
h o +t h s h o u l d
l
u r n c u u n t p b m n in g
l
A e t o r b e g i n n in g t h e
n rc t
a \
kin *
he
tu
l c n
t t t\
S E C 1 O
20
T he
o
t ll e r
ha t
l\ a en
]n
du
c ted
u st n
b t e d pa t ie n t s
s im u
d o i n g b u t t he y d o
t m
ho \ e
n o t n l c a su re
de qu a t e bu t
p
l
t
u
i
n
t
t
u
a
a
n
c
o
n
n
t
s
r
a
c
a
i
n
i
n
i
u
o
r
g e du c a t i o n it
p
g
g
d
d
l
l
h
E
t
t
a i n c d m a st e r y
h
t
a
n
a t a n 1n
s ir
o
t n ec t
rv n u a
is n
w h i l e t h c h l g h c ?i t
h
}1i g h c st I c v c i t h a t i t i s
e
y ,
So m e a r g u e
1s
s ho w i n g ho \ e
a ss e s s
d r g r a h 1 t >
u n
fo
to
qu
m e a s t 1r e d
arc
rl l a s t c r
x a m t n a t 1u n s c o n
a rc e
s ki l ls
t o
c la s s1 c a t io n
is
o u tco ln c
p r a c t r c Tb l c
t
r c l a t in
o u tc o m e s
a ga i n s t
1el l opmm1
C l Br D c Bl BB111
g hn
t
t r u n in
\s
b Rb l y
ro
h a t h e o r s ht r A g u l a r l y d o c s t h r r e l e v a n t s k 1i l
s u c h t h 1n g s a s
c a n o n l Y b e r n l i r r e d 1n d r m c t l v l r o m
c l 1n 1( a l r c c o r c l
a n et a u d i t s ( s L c C h a p t e r 3 8 p e r f o r m
\ \ L ) r k l l l L t as, C
an ( t
a n
SSmt nt )
O u t c o m e s r c b t 1 n 1o a t t 1 t u d e s a r c e l e n n 1o r e d i f
%c u l t t u a s s e s s T h t u s e o s e l f r p o r t i n g q u e s t i o n
c o r re c t
n a 1r e s n l a v b e b ] a s e d b ) s t u d e n t s g m r r g t h e
h
\
a t t he y
h
n g \
c t d a n w
t r r a t ht r t h a n r c \ c a
o r c x
o r c v t n t
T hc c o m
t hc c a r ly
s k i ll s
in
t
m o n e s
c o u r se
co n tact
r e du c
an
#l e s
pr o p o
As
du
1n t r o
v o ve s
hc
fo r n
t im e
c t to n
go e s
an
i n c r ea ses
o n
he
f
o
v c r
hc
ba s i c
sc te n c e
an
t 1c a l
lm
In
t c t * t
q
. r Bl ( o
n
l ba s i c
as an
in v
l i! ft
l O bs c
de
this r
fo
r a t t it u
be
\ v r 1t
Fo
t c n
a ct
o u r ( a n
li n i c a l
bsc
g l
d Bn a l o u t c o m
d b< ha w o u r
as a n
A1 a
c ssc n
r a s s A s s m c n t a n t i +s d o / t 1\ l i n k e d t a
b
h
L o n g 1t u n 1] r e p o r t \ f r o m a
r
o
e
a n o u r s
l
o
s e n c r s a r c m o r e r c I l a bl c t h a n p o i n t o b s c n
r r it u
1 11c
: pb
par t
a n 1j J t l o n
ac cur hn
a \ r r
In
t tt
( j
t d
b>
, <t u
u r
rm
:r
r t
1t
L r
lt n
t l t Br i i r
v i n t
IW
sys t t r n s o r
a l
rt
rlt
1 m 1rn
\ r r
> B
lt i
i 11r l t
c o m
po
r J n
T r a d i t io r w l -
1u
t }r J
Pr
nc
F Bl} 3 2
Th e t r a i m
ru
l c U rn c u
t u re
1t
w L r L
R1 v t s * d
lt m
r\ ,
w 1t
lr
\ l > 111 l \
t 1u ) : B
1t
l\
l\
n n
it
u n
\ t 1t l A J
1t
k i l ls
]m
m e d l t 1l
h> m
r IL
t \
[t rt u
( I(
a w
d t s
c
r>
\n
l 1t t
hJ t
h
irr
I\
pr
c un
H n 1h
i 1m . 1l
t ltt
l t l tt
rn t
l\
F 1g 3 3 Tt \ t
in \ t 1
te d I n
u lu m
1l w
t)
ln
&c
n t T 1L
rt i n t n t
= 1n 1 L I
o r
t
t n
pr
ll
l>
c u r r l c u l m
Be h a w o u 1a l
/ b ro
1\
sc i e n c e s
Bi o l o gi c a l s c i e n c e s
i b t 1 LI >
ar r
c u r r ic u lu m
Po p u . n s e n c o s
)d \
Tl t a t r u n
g 1o s
I 1\ 1L
H m n
1n
In le g r l t1 d
11>
\w
Chn )c a J s l u d[e s
CBBr uc a l a n d
v r r t l t 11 t
l Bm
B: 1m / e d
\
uJ l l
rtJ n t
:w
tl rJn] 1l t Al
w H
h it
um
a t1
1t n
d n
\\ J \
Ih
h>
w n
l n i +1 I t >
o r
br
B1l r 1, :
1 1\
i n n >t l
b>
a r 1, I t l r
I\ 1
w n
tn
II
1l !
huun dJ n >
]c b r
l 111l r r t l Bl r ] 1B
l ll l \
S U C l 1L >
d j v t ch
l
( 1p 1111
t 1n
Ir dl t 1 N
1( ar nm l \
t u d en t
ro f
u m c a bo n s kr* s
C_
l
l
n 1
o
N rt \ t n i L J \ l O n
nQ
o n t
n
j L c\ i r L
cn
hLWhn J r
+u
) 11 t
A ll
n ru n
r 11J r
c o n s n it r t
\ L
l L 1r T1
1e
h r o u g h o u t t h c c o u r s e ( Fr g 3 4 )
W ha t e v e r t hc fo r m a l s t r u c t u r e o f t h c ( *
i n t e gr a t i o n c a n o n ly t a ke p la c e a t t he l m e l o f
o l e a r m n g D r ff e r c n t a p r o a c
i
s t u de n t s e x p e r e n c e
p
h
i
t
o n ha v e be e n u s e d h l t h l an
r
a
i
t
i
i
e
n
v
h
n
e
g
c
o
a
t
g
s
1 \ \ lo
Dc g r c s o f SU CC E S S T h c m o t ba s i c
f r a m e Jc c t u r & o n t h
s c h c d u ]c m t h m t h e s a m e t i m e
d
f
d
f
i
t
h
u c i p l 1n c s m i lt t in
n
e
f
r
e
t
c
ro m
sa m e sys t e m
i
t
t
l a n y n e gr a i o n l s b r gc l ! a 1u t k
1 5 r c l a t av c l y s i m p e
ess m e n t
n en t o
Cu
es m a
ga t e
su r r o
a s a
ttltu
1n c r e a s l n
o n
e a
te rm s
1n
is
s 1 o n a r s +n
d b e ha \ t
erted
re a
am u u n t
am o u n
T h i s h a s be e n d e w n b c d
s
3 3)
F
c u r n c u lu r n ( ig
r tio n s
F lo 3 4
h u o t d l
t ll
le u r a tio
m o
de l
m o
de l
T Bu
1 t h c Ic t
t 1n d > t
B r .l d u
1t e
bc
c u o r t lln a t r t l b
y ;i n
h
BH
At t nnpt a v e b e u n m N tp t u
h a w m Rh 1n h w r t c t l t u r c d e h w e d by t w n n r
n n v r i n hv uu Rh m n l d H f e r n t m L h h n m
T hu s c a n
w \ r } e { f L L t l \ L l t n 1 t h L 1e n t c l lh r t I S P U T i n t o l 1n
p
m n g 1n u p r c p J r a t 1o n T h L y d u n o l w ( r k i l c h t \ u a c t\ t r s
p r t p \ r A 1n J e p L n d L n t l y a n l r r l w t u p o n l y t u d c l n c r
cn n t r n
\)
m w
u w
u re \
l 1n \
ttw
u n l n n
h>
C tu
o n
In u
i c u la
n ir r
ttc m
pt
to
t t 1c
o v ( T t o I 1 LL
\ l rt \
l\
It
m s o
fb mu
11 1 t
n u
tr
bi n g
at
po r t a n t
im
f t he
5r t o
lu m p l a n n i n R is \ lc t t
r
w h i c h t h c lc a r m n
g m tco m c 7
B< n o a b s o l u t e l y c o r r c = t o r d e r
o r
dc l n
ll
_ 1 p
a ha
s n ia
b ec
a n a
d l c s s d u p l 1c 1
M
d
b
f
e
r
o
w
r
c
w
n
a
u t w
o
rn at
g n d m n fo K c
l t \ cl
d
d
t
a
J u m p lt
u c e
in t r o
1 T} Pi cs a r c D r
u o n
rT e n
ff e a
La
t e r 1n t
a n
d bn
he
w r u c tu r c
c o u r se t
ltt
rm i
w M 1u n \
llv c r in R
d t
t he i :
u n
i 1 L [ )n 1
hi n g
t he
ly t
W ha t e v
er
m an
tc
\ r 1t l v e
d l w i p li n
o w n
id l i n
in
e d ic a l
in
c r e ase
m h n
l r n d t Wo u r s h o u ld b c e \ a B u a t
D t \ 1Rn i n g t h t e \ a l u a t t u n s t r a t t 9 3 i s a n i m p o r t a n t p a r t
o l o \ r r 1 l l c u r r i c u l u m p l a n n i n g T h e e \ a l u J t 1 o n s h o u ld
11 w t I I 1 \ p r m t w
al t houh w a l u a t i o n
L o v e r o c 1t c o r n c
T he p r o c e s s
c va l
o f t l t c b t t c r i s t a s l c r t o a : h 1c \ c
Ev t r y
hA y
t d u c a t io n a
t i o n s h o u ld
t c a 9 hc m
p la c
w r
ll
a\ o 1
ll he
di > d
5 c l1 l \
st u
111 At r r
in
c o m m o n
ppro
to
s t Bc
t ht
u dm
f ta u lt s
i \ b)
c 7slt
t rn
be
to
n t
r \
ta
n t
m u t
lu
an
ta
can
d
thl
c w
tm $
hc
dc
stu
i n
ho
r 1 p 1d i n t l m e n t i o n
cc
u t c o m
he
ke
a n
lu
c v
ta
t s
Jd
a t
io
de r t J k \ n s T he r e i s
h 1p b e t h c e n t h e
as s E
s o w e r
rt
t 1v e s t a
ke T b
f t hc
v 1c w s
r \
r y t ha t
r t c t 1o n
n L
p a 7s t he
c n =o m
a n
1n
t 1o n \
u n
h t c \ a \u 5 t 1o n o : u u t c o n 1 c s I t L s
l Bn k T g c i s p r o s p c t t \ c a n . I 1 n c
r a l l d c w n Ot t h e u r r h Mu r n r n h c r
t
m c
pwat cd
t hJnt w1n*Jl \ Jl t er t t \ L\ uht
\ u p t 1
1BA n r n f y C o n 1 0 ahnor mal l t y Su b l e c t \ I 1J !

b e r r \ <j t t d o n (. c r a l o ( c a \ l t ) r 1\ 1i i r t l t n 5 n t l L u l
I eazut ri ( ] ' J' J7 ) l u w d e s ( n l H d t 1B\ u \ J \ p 1r J l L u r r h u
>u
A n y i n n { }v a t i o n w i t h i n t h c c u r r i c u l t t m w i l l r e q u i r e
1 mmn n f
t r u hm
p m a l ly w he n a n y b r m
pw
o f i n t t B: r u t l L 1n 1\ i n v o t v t d t B 1 n p u r t J n t t h a t t Bt a c h e r s
e du
t hc
n r > v u il i n to r r n e d
n h 1m t t h e \ \ r n c \ 1l u m
u u n n l r n n n l > Lw n a n d t h e i r m v n r o l e v khi n k
th
o t =
ha n d
r m
H Uu
c \
Tr
t r i( \
t t \
adt
hl7 to
2 1
ly y > a r \
>ar
h( t h > o r t t i c n l t o n \ i d r 1t l u n \ a n u m be r
H ho M
h a v e i n t r o d u u x l p m Vh h o u t W
An
hc
l l ke l )
+ +r . l . ' . .
}u \ t
d t \rl > d
in
cu r n cu
d e r 1n
d
T he r e
m
c rc
b u t t h e r e s h o u l d b e a t r a n s p i n n t l o Ri c b t h i n d t h t
T h i s \ Ln ll e n a b l e s t u d e n t s t o a p p r e c l a t t
a r r a n gt m e n t
t h e r e l Ln a n c e o f p a r t i c u l a r l e a r n i n g o u t c o m e s a n d
d i m i n i s h 1: h c t e n d e n c y t o 1c a m i n e Ffi c t t T1t l y b y r o t e
l t n t b c c a u w t h e t o p i c h a s b e e n p l a c e d 1n t h c c u r n c u
u m a n d m l l bc a ss _
d
ru t \ o n
l\ j n #
t e Bl \
H H wd
Ev a l u
A
t { T
lln iL k l
c wn s v >
O >M n M m
a n d
>v n rt tu h m
n h> d e p h H J v Bt h Bl enwr > %
t h n c
m I
i l r 1u
\\
he
n n
r e s o tl r
f i n t e g r a t i o n b y f t n u u n R l c a r n i n R a r o t 1n d u
Ch e s o f Ch n i c a l c a m
A t h e Mu d n t d v d
op an
u n d c r s t a n l l n g o t h c r Tn g c o r m u w r i a l r e l t v a n t t o t h t
t h e y a r c l e d t o i n t c g r t c t h i \ k n o w lt r d e f o r
c a e
g
t hcnnc hcs
p r u h lc
e t \ t n L u t 1: n
tJrl
\ \ <t
q to r t
Na n
A) L u
e r l\
J Bu
\ la
he
>
Bc
m a =
g F T u r d
he p n
ud eh Of
CUr r i cuun1 pannn1

u
t u r
an
r n
hJ n
tire
r vw
ll
d >
n r e
1t
a n
b r n f t u m r h . l
C j i n it a l p la c e . rt e
L u rr
t o pJ
u m
pm
p l 1n
l i 1 1i t , d r l d
ph n n d L o
l
T h > B wJ
t hc h a c
hM
L 1
it (
in n
tH
Vi
>
hu L l
al t i
. 1L
HH W
B}
\ r
n il n Bl io r \ n
h> r N >
n m n
a n
i nei t ohl y
r e mu r
PM
an
h>
m
d
ll(
t t
fn t m in t u n
Hw n h
hn
h r Bn
tm
.u
c o
w
o
r u n t
t he r
in m
h n aH h
hn e
o mp
w t
t
1
h>
pu
h uu h l
v
u
n h
hi n g
H hh
he
lw
u n
n n
t h>
h uu h l
n mh o ;
R\
pe \ t 1
he
l t u b e 1L I t
h h t > J 1n N h e
110 e t
n tl
n w n c 15
ha v s
h1Ch
boul t h
u l t ht
m c n t
. T1h h n n H
UB t ht p t v mn t
u M t
w
o
n v r
n wJ > Ot t h h
\ \ \\ \
1 he
a m n w
n n U H w
M1 \ t h >
1t ' \ \ l t 1l t t \
n u
hn M
iv
l t he > n w
e J
t r Ail l
A J>\ 1
r>
lh n H
w 1
l\ e
in
n m
t le M
Dn t
n rt
n m J >v
An h M
r c mu n
u w
c t
1t t
jll
1n H
h>
rn u n n
Hw
m n
in w
dw
u n u
u m
u n v
n u m
nn. t
St n
u la r n M u n
t u r m
to
to
he
d c w lu p c d
lu tn
u t r tL u
H h 1; h l dem
>h
c n r w ary
n g
Hd Hwd
h v
ht t l
1l h
ho
1nd
> r n J Ah
m n a c
1n i
ta tt
t h
n n ta
u I K N u m
c v u Au J t n 0
uh r n h ou h A h c p h n n r d 1 wv p e v c l y
,
S E C T IO N
2 2
Re f e r e n
A l ba n
E 1u
ppro
1\ n
B
a n
L\ m
a n
dc
c \
&
n n L c s
Tt
1 c 1w r
du
r a
Bu
m e
c x
\ r tr
e
tr o
l
>
ic \ w
te
a n
a n d
> n >
i r
}A
rd
hl n
lu
rn t u
lro m
st u dy
t 1o n
Co
bc t w
ro
a n t
ht u
Do
l:
0n i c a
plm
Af t d m 1
Pr i n c
go
a r
\ f t 1 11(
dc
n w
s t 1r
n su s
li s S
c t
1 Tr a [ /w
BB
dd
pr a c t
to
sc
y BM!
l H
o w
(\
cr \
&
tt
] 1m
cJ
\ r \
lm Jr
rrl
[ )u
ruL ttt t
ilt
bJ
l / n
M AI (
1 w
tn
] l Jr mni :
B d
t m m
S\ h m
Rs
In
hW
11dur4
IJr 4
lj
t t
11a n
y o : t he
l %c c r s U f t
St u
o
3 7 : 1 1m
a ly c $
: 1h e
(J f k
\ Bf x
c
n t 1L a
1 r )
1n
l r f)
\ . t +u n
a n
n !
2 l J3
S c *, r r p b l c r A JJA
tr
\
u
r Jm
iJ
,r
1 to
d e r r a d u a t c t r a t m n z r 1 a P b i R1 R t L
<d > n J1 e s 1n 11e e t h $ S r B I ( e J M u { d 1r r , n
ti n
r\ n
u r l u N
ht
1r 1r
7 L I S Tt )
t 1l J t )
> 1t
Ih
r 1B w
1t > r
du
JW \
m c
111
.lrt
hNH
l 1
HW
1 1l \ \ 1 l l l
1t l u e
fHB
BJe
WM
hd
lrL I I
P r b lc
\\
a c u
bJr e d
h e : 1 Ju
I cJr mn,
( o rn
a
o
ru
rn J L e
F m hl e
l M
lx t
c n
rn
bJ
de
] rl
n \
w
At t
~t n 4
k
r 1 1 n n i l#
1l
Qu
J n
i E 1u +
Jf
I h 3
MuBt n 1
f p r o b l e +n h J <+ d l r
ts u
} 1o
le n L
r r 11m
ft L1
1s o n
\ L
y fo
q aj
: f F 1Bc t t 1 i J l i c B B1 1n n 1
A t l 1n
\
JG
su n
u n d
l 11\ l r e
t l1 i n
WJ
' ":
> d
pat
n c
n m
a r r 1n
rr c
d b,
t ( Bn
\ > r 1 1u u
Bu 5 Bt 2 Sf 1 7
Bl t o r i
J t )t j ( \
t nt t Bl t 1n>
1r l
$ t f, t l u r \
ht t p / a
HG
/ Lg c
s \ 1r a n c c
( F m
1t h l l 1
It m
N 1r
i \ ) JR J l r >
jH l l>
hn c
S\ hm } d t H ( j
lu
in uit
Bi \ Bt m
\ )n
B>
te
pw
n n
BD
J C r L\ ) b \ J
1n
1\ } l t tl L I l 1 1\
\ \
m n Tl t
t\ [\t
n t n l l Hi n
1\ n l
2 B 11 t B 14 B
I B l l B1 1 l r l , 1 1B H q t 1
HM
Ha
tc
dc W n I M
\ an
ln
d e s L n p 1o
20 0 o
I F
hn H
ho o l
Jl 1
J4
t*
du
t 1 u r l o 11
l v c
10nt v r m
f >\ r nr t rn r u r r n J n
l n \ l c Bl B 1e r r l Bt A f e 1 l t (
o u n ( 1
t i l
a n el t
J J1 J
1 1' d
cl
tc e
q u J lt t )
c an
2 8 3 18
l ' a r ])
CH
n t s
n a rr J t l\ t \
r u tt
L >
hm
5n (
llta
M A AI
qu
n c n ec a
ct o r s
A 1. , b r
f t }1p
re o n t e n t o
A qu a llt a t m
r c g l s ( r a t o n h o t 1s c
and
h
1 7 ; } f J 5 17 1 l y i j 3
i t t 11t
n c
Rr J
u n d c r
st
po
b lc l n b a s e d
I y ) 7
e t
1\ l r r 1f r 1t #r j
5 : 10 5 ] 16 2 0 0 0
d S M
dt t . ( Ur r l LU1t . r B1
: 1 r u b 1r
c c n
c x a +n
el e r t
a \
A W 1i l i c SC , M c A r t l l . U b /
1 a
t e c u r n ( u lu n l , A ( i r n ., f
fe , rr 1
p r c p J r c h o u w o f fi c e r s b>t t l r . . r 1b 1 1
O N c j [ PA J o
200 7
+t t l 1L J (
d > n .U f
L l
c x
[ a l ls h
J t io n
t a n
t Ru h w
a r n
D t ]t b r
atc
1n t c
a t
r,
Mt d u B
12 4 ) 19 9 9
33 : 12 ]
n ew
l a r y A c a d m i ,
K 1 1 1> e f ( t
1at xt r
O N c j ll I A T he ( o
\i rn i n M
c u rn cu
D C 200 4
gt o n
lc n ct
d l a l
> w
r r 1u 1n t > n J n
rd
)o
h n ] c a ] a n d l o m m u n 1t y l t t t 1ngs
)
A 1Bi E
l r 1> m e d l t a l c d u L a t Bo n
Re \
r t( n ( \
n l
o o
to
1t
ashin
t 1o
L iv c r :x
19 9 5
t A A +C p r o j r c t o 11 f l 1
1 s 1r 1 t l r l i t s C / B1r t m t S; i l l s
v c r
du
bu
>
n i v t r s it
N c w blc D
l\ c
3 7 2 ( X )4
q u a l t t a t 1\ c
8 2 9 9 j hh
er
1n
J t B h r b o h m
de C
A
: ! )t ( mat 1L
D
u te
Th c
rn
l 1e r 1 7 3 8 3 3 9 0
b h IE I br
lu
c n
b n c n c e
c Bm t n
l l e g i a 1i t y
c o
; f c1i c e l = t l t m
L \ 1r n L u
c u r e
d bJ h l (
T L i t t le \ \
an
r1 o
at c
d t.
320 $ 34
Du
B u 1 ] n g
L i n k o p i n g Su
2 4 2 8 0 2 5 2 (X 12
l\
c a r
hc
h l l Lh
u n
\r n a n
m MC
mt \ l 1LI nc
in
1l c B Br t n
1r t o r l
D a hl c L O
Pm
f/
W hrt =o
m r c B 11 t
E , h 1t
y of c
70 ; 18 6 19 3 , 19 9 5
h \ f cl Bc, 1l 7
C O r be t t EC
d
l p1BBe 11 r
e eu e o
3 5 11 4 3 2 0 0 1
n tl
a c
t hc
X 4 k c l [ 1s G C
c Br 1o n
B l i gh J l d c
C t Br r i c Bt l m
c e s
MA
e se
'
t (
I\
L t
I Bf \ . " t l 1
t . \ t 1i JJt l
,n
:, )J
'
R, \ l 1> r
H l 1w
tn r
11
J 1B
M t t Bl
< 1 l
tt n
Brn
00
hu u
B\ 1hnv m
turn un HM n
( lu
t J
t hu
N hL r
H Ri n N
'
Rya n Rhl
u r
:n r
Bhal
u BBp i M
n
hn
C ha p t e r
Po s t g r a d u a t
ha p t e
bo l i t p o s t gr a d u a t e m e d i c a l t d u c a t i o n
t
a n
g o n c e t h e d o c t o r h a s a l w a d y q u a l i fi c l
f
a t e r a v a n a ble n u m hc r o f y e a r s a t n l c di = a l s c ho o l a n
p o s s e s s e s a b a s l e n i e d i c a l q u a t i fi c a t i o n n t t r a n y U K
t h i s +s a f i r t 3 c a r c o u r b e
m e d i c a l s c ho o l
a l Ah o t 1g h
m o r e r e c e n t l y s o m e m c d i c a I s c h o o l s ha v e d e v e l o
ped
a f o u r y e a r g r a d u a t e o n ly e n t r y m e d ic a l d c gr = c c o u r s e
a s l s ( o r l l m o n 1n N o r t h A m c n c a
c
1s a
RO a u c c 1o n
[ X I \ G L k \ i ) 1 \
ca
he U K d o c
l l e d Fo
Jo b t
r a l n 1n
r u
,n
]a r
PO
1n a
pro
T B1[
e n ter
to rs
dat i o
u n
1\
t e cte
%r s t
(1r 1t e r n )
T h1 ye a
a r
A1
a n c
p r Am d c
t r u t tu rc
st .
tm
c n \ lr o n m
is a l! a n d a s s ( s \ m c n t \
a c h o : 4 m o n t h\ d u r a t i o n
ppra
n o w
ea r
c n
n o l l
e n
T he
he
\ t
J r e
h o s p i t a l s p > c r a l t w s u ( h a \ TTl e L i l L i n t
l 5 a n t j y n j c ( t 1 1u v r h i s
d
t
i
n ( < Oht t t r
t
i
a
s u r gr F
p
2 w n h J t u n h r
d
F
n
d
a
u n h u
f
H
o
u
n
w
o
w
e
1s n o
o
hy
d
n
i
n
u
L hn h n R 1 w n tw
h
4
u
Uf
u
r
J
m
s
m u
o st s
t hr e e
st i
lt
u \ u a
l l!
1n
ra n
ge
l t Be
s p c ( 1a
l r 1L
rl t r J
gemr al pr a9t l t ( po\ t \ J\ t p1md

are
fr o
o
v e r
3 y > a r \ lo
an n u a
y p u p LBr
u
U WK
a n > w
h n
r n > ru
uu nB h n
l p r J L t rt
A v wH JM
a n d
m r n h
in
l Pr J {
yr t
I ht
L L > w
\ >
J n d
>
t l
H yt
hm
:t \ r
ir\
W
n
hw
Hm
H w n
pa w
r a
pre
r L
Hn t
r ; 1t l t ) n
ye
u r
l t ' l l ( T 1l p r t } t > v
hnt t o
: l Bt w
HH w
3 yt l r \
t 1
l t r a n n a n d s p > 1aht
t h t t r a i m n h w / 1t l e s w t r c t h t
r ct a c h c a r e l r g r a d e p t s
l l r t he w n w h n u u h t c r
p r c r c g m r M o n ho u w o
u u nJ
an
io r
se n
r r
ictd u
in t he
r e gist r a r
d e u e t o p n
?n
sp e c ia
list
h e 19 9 s S i r K c n r t e t h C o l m a n p r o p o s e d a
r c fo r n i o : p e c ia l i s t t r a i n i n g i n t he U K T h is i n i t i a t iv e
s p e c i a li s t t r a i n i n g l e a d i n g t o a
e s t a bl i s h e d s t r u c t u r e
C e r t i Dc a c c o f C o m p l e t i o n o f Sp e c 1a l i s t T r a i n t n g
(C C ST ) a rt e r a d e %n c d n u m b e r o f e a r s o f t r a i n i n g
(b e t w e e n 4 a n d 6 y e a r s ) a n n u a l a s s i s s m e n t s a n d a
%n a l a s s e s s m e n t S u c h d o c t o r s w e r e n o w t o b e c a l l e d
s p c ( 13 h s t r e g i s t r a r s
In 20 0 3 T hc D e p a r t n i c n t o f H e a lt h bega n t he
A 1o t l e r r 11s t 11g \ 1e i 1u e B1 C d r r s m o v e m e n t a n d v s t a b
l l s h t d F o u n d a t 1 o n \ a r l n d Fo u n a t i o n v a r 2 g r a d e s
o
f d LK
pp
a n
S, 1l r 1l e
r to N
t tw
ln t m e n t s
pec
lt y
( \ T A S)
t t he
h m hean o n e o
e t l l . 1i e L I \ 1L J c l L n
a n
.a
te t
MI u
re
L . l l
t t i l li n
kt
M d
\\
n l r
n m An
1\
LI 1t
ho le
ke
tr r5 n
y t ho
l i n
g t ht
tu
n e \ e
Hm
ds
\r r
a n
pl
h it
he
de
i
An
1n
L TK
k
f d1sr l l i oned
dld
p r e v wt r mmn FF
\ Ln
A$
t pl sodS
WS t t m
r LC\ nnmn\ w\
I I\
\ L1
9o
1 s t r l 1s
u 7 r n
I K
1 1 11r 1g
Pr
st J
t
u
n o
1 1 1 1 5 t l ebacl t
to rv
n Mu
1
1 Tr
n (B
u
l u l 1\
, t t
dk
ra rs
w a h
m o
1n \ r t e \
gist
\ d
T he
1n 1t s w a
l n 2 ( 10
Jo h n
r e
c hc
r o c e ss
w o r
fe s s o
po
appr opnat e
h a t , l mt or s
n d m o n k Yr
\ t r 1\ t
I n 19 m t h c noya $ n n n H w i n n n n m L I h H h h Bn n n n
(t h t T o d d I( e p u r t J t o l n . +\ t n w d t b ] t t h > \ 1r B: l r t u \ t l \ ) l \
Of p o w r u d u m e n nh t J l e J w D n n M Hh n u m u n i k t
lo
gl s t r a r
Cu
hLuh
h m
AhnB h >
n
Jt
t 1t t .
he
In
] l 1( i l n 1 t
Se c t i o Yt 1
Pa t i /
t r a in in g p o s t s
r a in i n
ln
an
r a n
W a ./ , N
T his
i in g
1neJ m c s +1 1n pcei ahst

h
t hc
in
c n n w n n
n w
n w u
1
J
d
k
N
u
u
s
1h an
m u n
m n a r a bb
h u L e Rr p u 1 h
q
h k e t h m e Ut h e e u k e r h J . B Re p o r t Ot 1
t j K H 1> J a M , k n t J l n h h M w n h n . He e n r e g a r d e d
N
H ni un
h H 1\ \ h
B: r > / 1\ > l
nt m
n w
n w
l 1l h ,
hh
NJ he
pv M
>
w
l t 1e \
nh
In
151u 6
n m v
hJ w
n w
gr c M
c r a n
t h e E n g l 1 h DLPdr t m
ent
m Tk e p l v
w m lu a w dm n s
N t l h >m
pl l wt ' e\ \ 1 l l t \ e St r Al t t g L l BL \ l t h A u t h l r i t l e h
h o k t R p t u t m
n n n n t t h. n
>hn ha >d
t h t 111 Bn 14 1 m t n t m d r l r v t r n u n i t 1i t t h t pwt gl t t l u a t t
Eu n c n o n i n E n g L 1n d i s c on ne t h ht l c
dm n w
en t
R= p o r
Cf u o kc
r e l a t i o n s hip t o
m c u l c a l s = l 1o o l s
l d
i
20 0 8 ) St r a t e gi c H e a l t h A u t h o r i t i e s v i l b c a b o l i s w
d n e r ic s
i n E n g l a n d i n 20 13 , l c . i n g t l, u p o s t g r a d u a t e c a
w it h a n u n c e r t a in hl t u r c
n is n r c
d u c a n o n ha s b e c o r n c a
d i r n . N s l o n s Whi l e
nppc . 1 a . d
p o s t g r . Du a t c m e d i c a l
c ance
o f gl o b a l s i g n i %
kin g
nce w or
Il y . g . r t o g. I n c l i . Ic a l c x p v r w
t=f
l 1c r c \ s a l s o i n c r e a s i n g i n
o u t s i d e t hc l r c o u n t n c b
k f . Rc e : o i l o , v i n g
l
, n . c a l w o r
n a t io n a l , z a u o n , i t t n
a gr c r m c n t s
. De
\ n t c m 11 1o . A l Fr e e t :
an d
, e gi . Al
Eu r o p e a n U n i o n
l
N t c d b y t lw
s u c h . . Th o s e n n p - .
r " o s r gr a du a t c
E U ) T hc N a t . A l A d . K c C c n t r r o
Eq. .
ar.
\n to n n a u o n
es
pro
o"
po st
Du a t c
g.
m c
q"
o' " scas
' "
e du c a t io n
d rc a l
l i %. d d o c t o r s
in
. d t r ain in g
lI K
d i . l Ed u c a
l . 2 0 0 3 T h , \ \ b r l d F. d c r a u o . Fo r M e c
d . c o m p r c lw n s l e c do c u rn = n t
t 1o n ( \ \ T h l E ) p u b l i s h e
\ \T M E
p . Tg r a d . A t c . c d i c a l e d u c a t i o n
u t le d
l
T
u s pu b
tm p r o c n , c n t
g l o b a l s u . Da r d s f o r qual i
d , r l . Fo r m . l a u n g t h c
h c a u o . pr o"dcs a t , m c l y ' ' "
acc ou"
Ta L . . g ' "
. l. .
d l
po st g r a d . a t . M . , c . ' ' " .
B
f
r c g\o n
t
c
l
l
,
o
a
3
.
c
J
S
l
t
n
c
.
n e e ds o : , n d m d . a CO. n
l
"
"
L
r
v
a
"
d
N
.
m
m
d t h c a a i l a b l . , u n l a n a .
t he
an
F u n a a m e n t a ls o
m e
d ic a l
du
Dm
or'
*o
o .
t.
1n
l K a , .
u :L PP r t
' "
u rH ,
h l m Ln m
P U b Lg ' "
'
' "
c a tio n
To
"
d,
H ,n
. r
. .
ho
T hc ,
"
,r:
t l, H '
lo p
I (,
1r p '
w , H ' "
r . . [\ . . Tn
"
In u .
' '
e'
l' "
H-
M .
\ l"
1 1, y t l 1,
u \,B
"
"
ol
1 t 1t H
l lm v c rn
Ac a dt
. .
XX : '
.
t r a i n i n g 1n
s , i . " l c o l e g . .
o s p e c ia l t i e s
n c a r lj 5
hin g
m en t s an
do
(w
f 6
to
&
f fe r s
Hw h
p e r v r s o n t he o r e u u l
h e x p e r ie n c e , s yst e m at ic
as
r e se a r c
i
i
. g p r o gr a m m es
a
n
t
h
r
f
e
t
o
n
lu a u o
cn ts,
"
ex
pert
su
c . a
T a n s i t i o
to
p e r io d
' "
] p la = '
p r a c t ic .
t eac
l a s t s fo r
i c a ll y
t r a i n i n g t }T
I Li r t h e r
fr o m
m e
d ic a l
st u
de n t
ct o r
Y e a r 1 h o u s e o &i c e r y ea r b
d i
I n t h e U K t h , Fo t J n a t o n
f cmp] Oyment . h i c h j u n i o r h o , p\ d
t h c %r s t y e a r o
t h e i r 5 y e a r s o f m e di d
d . . t o r s u n d e n a k e f Dl l o, l ng
n e c e s s a r y t o c o m p le t e
I
s
t
t
ra m in g
. . d c r g. du a t e
i
l ll r e g s r r a t 1o . . I t h t h e G e . En l
t his y e a r t o o bt a i n u
h . Di = . 1 C o . N e l l
Ho . . c r T h , s i r s t c a r a s a d o o r 1s s e e n by m m 5
e a r A n d p e o p l e 1u , t
a . d d i &i c u lt
h a . c b e e n t hr o . n
h
h
t
e
t
d
h
a
c i ea t
, rt c n v \ p r c c d r
d
l
i
h In i e
e a o w ha t t o e x p
1n a t r h c d e e p c n d . 1 t
un
a s a r e s u lt o r t he i r
" \ l , k , n g c n ' " o n me n t
, . Tl "
To t h 1. c n d t h e G e n e r a l h l e dK al
W h l . \ [ . . Tr J ' " n
( \ 1 u n . 1l h " , c 1u t r n l . n , l c r s r a d u a t c . Rd a l s t u d e n u
h a d j w in g \ . It h a P
J pe n o , 1 o f
. n , lv n kc
t.
to
a . t r c s s fu
b.
n n lm
t h e h > , lw
n c.
w rr
u ru n
tm .
w c rr
u u
n mr c
g h1n w
> x l'
dF c
" mHt n g t , m
h \ n q \ 1n
u v
ll "
[c
kom
\n
.c
XJ
m , IH ,r
t h II
l ' \ 1d t )
ho w
ll p r e p a r e d
w e
f e lt
he y
w e rt
lt
w e r e a s a r e su
rc
gist
ho t r s c
Ff i c e r s
cons1l t ant s l e l l t h e y
r a t ro n
l l t hc
d e r gr a du
u n
2 5
p r o gr e s s i o n t o
chc p r c
d ho w
f t he ir
a n
t r a in in
Po s t g r a d u a t e
l
s k ills
ate m e
1c a
e d u
B o t h g r o u p s r a n k e d c o m n l u m c a t 1o n
a rea s
( t h a t 1s b e s t p r e p a r e d ) a n d r a n k e d b a s i c
d
t o r i n g s h l l s (s u c h a s p r e s c r i b i n g t r c a t n l c n t d c c i s l o n
m a k i n g a n d e m e r ge n c i e s ) lo w e s t
H o u s e o l hc e r s r a t e d
ti o n
high e s t
he
et
su
lv
se
an t
e s
en
g n i %c a
1s o r s
l y hi g h r
n t
13
1n
o u
t o
h a n d id t hc
f t h c 17
ar e as t
lr
c on
est e d
"
su
la ll
l 20 0 6 )
Y
'
o rs
c on s le n :
J
EI Pe
Jt
c x
pc
o $
is
n o t
n c n e c
su r
pn
d 1l h t
s 1n
c o n s u ta n !
lt t e s
a n
he
r e
lo
m a
tr
ha
l o m e
1# l e
L o
l , 1,
Tu n
lw :
co
( )j
l>
n e n 9e
rn c
pr
drc a l
gr r
a n
hc
j 11)
d a r ci 0
trm n r c
lr
rc
c v c n l u a
t
i
hII
t lr>
N>
h>
\ > L
I 11 r J \
t \l l\t > \
hn
h> m
h > Br n 1 l w Mr
jl y ht s
lu
\ Bt t n \ >
bt
t 1l
1,
> H >
1xl wr l l w
t l Bi r
e d u t u
F l g 4 1 C hJ
H u ts
tlL
t e r 1s h c s o f F o s t g r a a
ua
te
du
c a bo n
n u u n i
fr o
= 4\ r e e r
gm tle
>he
u n nr
>
n m
g t he
o n
Nn vk
At l vaned hr wnnt t
i w >
d r 1wc n H u d n h T h p 1 I n w h U. ] r t h r h h w n l n
d u L in m n n l n n i n a r
a n d t h e p mL e m o r b t r u L t u r c d e
b o t h v n a l 1n p o w g r / l d \ 1J t t 1J \ > ( h t i \ i c A l l 1 l l L1 11 W i t t\
l t l i n i e I I Ai n d p r i r \ \ i c a l
r e s p e c t t o t hc d t v e lo p m t n \ o
l
o
n i r Rc r y i \ l u t l l s i t i o n o F
l
t
t
t
c
I n s p c c ia lt i t b n ir
s k i ils
an
ll
A n m hr
a n t
r 1c
n s u tt 1 n
> mh
pe r t
1 o
d w
w n t
tor
w t v t r
\t
(c o n s u
l\\ay
lta n t
o r
ke
gc
M t 11\ c
n r r
yc
i\ r s s a
11 p r a L t i t i o n c
prtn
p a \)
h i e v e r e a l m a s t e r y o F o n c s s u b j e c t Fe w m a y e v e r
le v e l a ft e r a li fe t i m e s e x p c r e n c e
r e a c h t he n e x t
h a v e p e r h a p s l i g h t h e a r t e dl y c a t I c d t h c
w l1j c h w c
Tt h d a n
to
'
ac
l i n i c a l p r a c t i c e T r a i n e e s a lso a
c t l\
el
i t h e t c a c h l n g o f m c i c a l s t u d c tt
p a r t ic ipa t e n
s a
n
]l
c s T h i s c o n t r i b u t e s s ] g n i %c a n t l
j u n I o r c o e a gu
y to a
f t h e i r c l in i c a l m a t u n t y
c n hn n c e rn c n t o
c l i n i c a l t r a i n i n g la s t s :o r 6 8 y e a r s w it h r o t at i
u
d r : : c r c n t d i s c i p l i n e e v e r y 4 6 m o n t hs T
a
to
h
e e t t h c s t i p u l a t i o n s o f I n di
u s u a l l y s u : fr c e s t o m
v ] du
d t o ade qu at e e x po su r e an ex
c o l le g e s w i t h r e g a r
p eT
d i s c l p [ 1n e s T h c t r a i n n g i s f r t h
l
e n c e i n p a r t ic u a r
di v r d c d i n t o b a s i c a n d h igh e r s p e c i a lt y t r a in i n a t t
ll
a re as
St
da r ds fo r
a n
in g
r a in
l M e dic a l C o t i n c il s e t s s t a n d
a r d s f o r t r a i n i n g p o s t s a n d h a s r c q u 1r c d t h a t t 1c r e
b e a n a p p r o v e d c u r n c u l u m f o r t h c Fo u n d a t t o n p r o
l uci c
d
g r a m i T1 c a n d o r a l s p c c r a l u c s Su c h s t a n a r s 1 m
w it h c n d p o i n t
a p p r o v e d t r T Lm n g l x t s t s
a c u r r ic u lu m
t hc
ln
t hc
u K
Ge
n e ra
m e n
ts
c o n t
in
]n
u it
asse ss m e n t s
t ect
r
pp r aisa ls
a s s c H im c n t
du
c s
an
n am t
hln g p r o gr am
tc ac
1 ar
to
a \ se
ls
an
d y lc
st u
a\ c
du
catio n a
l s u p TR 1s o
pr o
ro ta t io n
Pr o
hc p o s t
f a gr e e d
o
e
s m c n t s \ 1s I n g a r a n g
i
t
ba l a n c e o f a p p r o p r a e c li n i c a l
ac
fo
as
m e
in
a n
du
to t
c t io n
c o u r se s
po r ta
im
c u rn cu
te a
bo t h
Ft
dic a l
du
c a t io n
is t ha t t he
h o u l d m a t c h w h a t 1s t a u g h t a n d
c lo s e l y m a t c h
s ho u ld a l so
d l car ni ng a n d t h c t u r n c u l u m
an d
e ac
hi n g
ttm e
ha t
c a
a n
Hc d M u c p n
n u n
I>
po
st
gr a du
Fo
t r alm n
at 1
In c u
he
pr o gr e
fo
rm a
u 1\ (
m1
Jb (e
lt
l la b u
hJ t ha \ b J t h t \ \ r n
1a
&
t r ai
nt
t r a l mn un
an d
t l 1mL
ol
dt
al
Bt r e\
an 9 l
t l n 1
lu
t ,t
lu t
> x 1t
cj
t e ac
c a se
ks ho p s
ts
re
.n p r a c t ic e
a l
de by
u m e
t ru
f fo r ts
pre
ga r de
ko s
iv r t i e s
a ct
t ra in e r s
ly p r o
t be
L1 s
ci r e c t o r s t o
du cat ion
et
m ay
c o m m i t m e n t s u n l e ss c o
ca
hi n g day s
o r
o r
c a t io n
m a
st r u c t u r e
t ecte
an
d de pa
d e b f tm
r er
p r o te c te d
m a e
t r u ly p r o t e c t e d
an
t iv e a s s e s s m e n t
1
1v
l\
prm
dc d
\ a r et
1n
i n c lu di n g
B l l\ \ w w g
i t.
uL u t
t on a l
p li
to
M A tt
lt .u n
\\
r c \ \L W
u t ( o M > \
m o t
Ot h
pr J c t
J t
\n ( >
rm
h l LI \ t y
r t \c n t
an
\e c
\c a
d
\\
gr a n d r o u n d s
n t 0s I n d
r ou
wJ r d
n t a t r \ 11 15 a t
'
\t
p r c t e A t e d
ra m m
l 1m
s c $e n t r o u s e
o
e n
i n e e
du
ar e
su c
r m a t iv e
>h l \
m e n ts
ed
t ra
1I n d
a ( t 1v l t j >
>
ke
ll
by
r ts
I RT U H 1
1n
de l rn
su m m a
fo
g,
de dic a t e
as a
1 1t l l ( L 1 1 V
t A
r eL o g
1o
Co
rc \
vn n
rn c n t s
a ss e s s m e n t s
m t
o u tc o m e s s
jo
fo
in
fo
tt
gs
m e e t in
po
m a
T( k a n
pt
e n t to u s
an
rs w
Fe a t u
'
n t c o n c e
sc
r a
ac
t r a 1n ] n
r o t e ct e
t 1m e
he d
he
T h 1s
lu
m e
:. i c [ 1 : 1 7 l \ (
\ i [ L1
\ :
te
e n c ro a c
A\ [
as
da t o r y fo
r T\ a n
ro te c
r c se a rc 1
1o
to
t im e
su c
e n t a t io n s
'
ted
l v 1t ] c s
de v o t e d
15
te
p r o gr a m m e s a s e gm e n t
it h c lin ic a l a t t a c hm e n t s o r
m o st
su r
o r
m o r t a l 1t
d
g i c 1l p r o c
u rcs
: \ls
L
I A
by
h>
w B
" l
Ot
1 u 1 B n
rm
i n
u n w
i 1 1 l 1t n \
r1 u
\ B 11 1 i
h Bn h > 1J u m
n n
J H
1 i 1> 1 H
t \ lr >J
n n > r
1n
h1 h w
l> h m
B1 1\
: r H u n ut h n m u
hu t h n n
N u w a dw
r u hM
n n L o rc
t hu r w > hu t u n n J h hu u k
t h w H1nhh n
c u r r j c u t t m n n t . a u t \ \ l m n t L r 1w r l 1 t o r [ 1t t l \ u l a r p o l l
g r \ d u l t = s p e L I 1l t l t \ (A L l t l t r\ 1y o f M t ( i \ L i \ l l t m Bt l C o l
l t g c s I{ o y l C o l lt g t o l Ph y h i c i l n \ i m t l Su r . v t ) l \ s o f
C a n Jda j
C l t n i c a ] p ra c e l m n t s k n o w n a \ r c \ i c l t n t l t \ i n t h t ?
U n l t e d St t t s a m l s \ p t c i a l t y m g i h t r i r p o \ t s i n t h p
U K a n d m h c r p m g r a t h 1a t c t r M n 1n g p m g m m n w s
p m v i d e t r a i n w a h J m n w ch p n v c c x p Os u w t o
,
In
n u N
hm
he & V W m
me h J l
nueci u c h
In h u m
L a u
n t \
1n = e
rm
+\ n t l
n iu
t ie s l \ a
a
ppro
n ts n u
su
n v
ass
t WCa
abens
J c r t h c
n M
c o n u
ht i r
tn t
l\
( im
be
pc r v
tso r
[o
b
rcv
l ( W
l r
h 1t
n p n t
c o m l 1 1e n [ a r
u rn a
Rc
n 1p c r v 1s o r
de pa m
Th u
n m
o 11 t h e t r . Ut l L
h
m o [
d
i o \m l l
]
l
a
l tt t (
r t f 1 l i \ y 1111 c t 1n g s a n i l p r t t c e d u r c w
t m\ t \
)
r 1c t l c a l m c \ \ \ \ r c T n e
u s e :u l
v TT
T ht p r o v \ b \ o n
ro
>h i s i s
r At n
bu
to r n r M
hm
r l n w
Lo n su
u m m
t x t ra
a n
c u r r
c lo w
n N
m i Lm r
a n
t hc
s to
tc
u st
a c
t \\
hng
h 0M i n h o
n s ht s
u w
n i o c
ht
o f
tr\w c
he
e n n n in
unr
M ro
in
fr
c o n st r u c t iv e
He r e
n o n t
d ba c k
hr c a t c n i n g m a n
c a n d idat e s
he l p
u o n s a ls o
p c r :o
o n
n e r
T he se
t o pr
m o c
p a re fo
in
e x am
r t l 1c
ir
su m m a
c N a m i n a t 1o n s
t 1v t
'
hc r o le is e s s e n t ia l a n d t hes e t r a in i n g
f a c u lt y dc v e lo p m c n t c o u r s e s ha v e
o r
t hc t r a in e r
b e e n s h o w n t o b c n c %t t h c t r a i n e r s a n d t h e d o c t o r s i n
t r a i n i n g To p i c s s u c h a s g i v i n g c o n s t r u c t i v e : e c d b a c k
d
m
n d ]c a r n ] n g a s s s m c n t a p p r a i s a l a n
t e a c hin
Tr a i n i n g fo r
is giv e n
rm a n ce
In h o
u se
no c
e v a lu a ti n
g the
g r a m r rt e
ro
ffe
in
t io
e x a m in a
t ly
a re
f u l fo
u se
l th e t r a rn i n g
e n e ss o
d iv i d u a l d e p a r t m
n s
e rr ts
o r u n i ts
en e s a n
a
Ef r e c t r v
m o
d a li t i e s fo
fo r i n
a t rv t
nss h' nl cnt
l u d e t h c O bj e r t l l e S t r l l ( t u r e t 1 / 1Rs s i n 1i r
Un ] v
o T c h n Bc e1 l s A i ll T ( O SA = S ) d e v t i n p c d a t t h c
(, t c C h a p t e r 3 8 ) h l s c v a l u a t 1o n
s j t y o : To r o n t o
n i a k e s 1 1s c o f a n o p c r a t r u n s p c e i h c c h e c k l i s c t n v o l v i n g
d ir e i t o b s c n a t t o n o r t r a i n e e s p e r fo r m i n g v a r i o u s
A n o t h e r u s e f u l t o o l i s t h e 1r r t p e r i e t l
t a sks
st r u ct u rc
t r a in
in
t es
C o l l e g S l 1 r g 1c d 1 A s s i s n 1 } Bt D e i t c e ( I C SA D ) w l u c h
a t i c s s [ T1c n t
to
t e c hm q u e s
c o m p u t e r ba se d
u t t l iz e s
t r a c k t h e n u m b i r o t m o \ c r m n t s a n d t hc t o t a l t i m e
ta
ke
fo
t o
t r ain ee
20 0 3 ) L r k c
p le t e
c o m
se t
h e O S A T S T h c P r o c c 1u
tas
(Pa t i l
t t
8 41 s e el A :
1e
he
e l o w d by t h e Ro y a l C o l le g e s o f Su r g e o n s i n
1
L K h z s g o o d r e l 1a b i [ 1t v a n d v a l i d t t y a n d a s b s e s
kc y o p e r a t i o n s I n t h e i r
t r a ] n e c p e r f o r m 1n g v a r i o u
ho
se n
t he
m o st
po
im
1s s a
t ra ln = t
tr a
/e e n
)n e r a n
t r a in
Jn
f consut ant
la L t o
rt a n t
t 1s fu
v a r 1o u \
a r c
e r
an d
du
9 t 1t , n
d tr a in
ee
t B1(
or
o b ou
r ai
an d
Ub r
a wt
he c h c
\ \
Bu
1n
lw
t 1n n
r r J L
t \
t{\
p r 1o
t r a l ri u t
wp c R l
\ J'
\ [ . t r to r
\ 1 \ n
t \ l >w
t
fo
r c
ct u
dv
Jt nr
i ne t
n*
t> > d l t
>
Yl
t r t 1 B11r
Pe
d le t o
c J rn r
( l
1e
u >
im
1u
fl L d
J Bl l
ht l cr k
T hc t r m
e
u r
l j 1i r i )
B
PUt r ngb
=al M l e r
p
rl u n 1
l f l l 1r
v / 1l r 1
kt
J 1 r r Tn
r!
U n
f h 11
l r , mHr H] P ( 4
l lt 1
w 1n
ll
11 H
tm
n l H
an
hm
li
he
st
o r
Hy
i d es
i n
r e
a re
H a re
d T he
w e
r e a
e 1 . I l et o1s
J r c
T he
2 00 0 )
t r a in in
1n
\ h dl a n d s
hrc h
t o rs
a n
ABr r
1e B B1
ll
ht
ht
> H
hr
nn J
t
h pr J
l lu
w e \ t r
t t
ht
hw
ac t n r t
to
lln t s
rt
hc a t
i ht t hq
1o n
l hd
w e
o n
t!
hn
t he
ho u g h t
he y
\\ \
he v
h o \ 1g h t
h e y l i d
t he
ho u g h t
hc v d u n o t
a dv rc e
\t
hs
1n
n n
prln
n
m
w c s mn h mc t h c
>
m H
1Ul > N n t U l w
n n u v h n huJng
t he
B r m
u te
t e a c he
hj
t x
\w
t m
lJ\
n
h
r
t
u e
1n
h r$ C a n d
e \
+n
hm
t l t \ 1t r \
r l ll\ t
r Lo rt
t r 1l m
i\
1n
ll
t lw
hu
c t a
n
n
8 4
dc o
v e r e
nx o r dw
r l B\
tu n
tr
1t m n
I t t lv l t It h w i t 1 t
w o r
d u e \
In
t lw
i t \ l a t io
li n i
Th e
l\
w n n
d t 1t ,1 t Bt l n l l p r n w 1n 1111o \
\ t
lbo r \
l k n m v h tg r a n d J J H
o
h
k
r
m
n t t n dM
i r r t ihM .
v H m
h
c r M u t Hn na J L u
r Hs L t h n o n h wn l n n n J t n
u
n
wn t s
d
I t w M i nchn> t r u n w s m n u w n t s a n
t)
3
C
t
h
c
r
)
Jp
bu t l r tu
\ > 1m l s t 1m n 1 l T I v c ( s t t
r t 1u
d do c
ob
1n
a n
n e n t
sC t t l n g t he ke
e
O a l l & M c A te e
c o n s 1L1 t a n t s
\ \ \
c c r 3
'
> BT 1\ t l
m
1
t h e t o p t h e 1r i e
a s
n s r u le s
( lu
n M
TH 1 I
n mv uvh1l l
p o r t l Uh o
L t n \
w o r
l \
1\
rj
i v
I1 r HB
HH
n w
Tl l
tr
c n
hJ
lli
h nh
t
lt n}
t U
h \ v i p l t 1l
w
n b LBl l J r r l
Cu
gs
/
fc
t r a i n er s
p t he
to
s \ 1 lt a n
t +n
( ) I I4
b
t Bv
c o n s t r L Jc t 1 e
c7
U mr a n m h o b u t
p r t \ t nt ed h e l o \ e T h t e
hc
Le a s
hr> t
dba
g t h e k e jf o b , e c t n
fa c u t ) d e e : o
rs
che
c s
r o1 r \ u l
Un
\ t t
am
( u l 1n \ B
'
unJ e
he
t l t 1n
ro t
al
pt
Bn t c r v u
c o n \ t ru ct n >
(
h e r t r J 1 mn p \ r \ t T h A r t
u r
n r n t a t l ( 1f l o
u f d
rt
h hl s
'"
ch t r r n i n \ n
1n
r t u n 1t r t \
pp o
nt r c t l \ c
nt ,
su
s c t ri n
tea
g fe
1v
1n
1n
tra in r c
c a m r n n ( l n
r nJ t m
T hc q u a
T his
be h
In
c o u r ses
l y E n c o u r a g e m e n t a n d p o s r t 1v c c o m m e n t w o r k f a r
be t t e r t h a n t h t m e t h o d s o f b u l l y i n g h a r a s s m e n t a n d
t e a c h 1n g b y h u m t l 1a t t o n
ra c tio n
p ro
su c
e c r c d by t h e
d t he U n iv e
t tv c
lt
in t e
u m v c r s it ic s
ide
pro
r s it y o f
f D u n d e e i n Sc o t l a n d a n
y
M
C a r d i : : i n W a l e s r u n c c r t i Dc a t e s d i p l o m a s a n d
d
h
f
o c t o rs
t
o
s
e
l
d
o
r
t
i
o
d
u
c
a
n
c
a
e
r
d
I
m
c
n
tc r s
Lw c d s
h e i r k n o w l e d ge a n d
B
a n d dt nt l st s w h o w i s h t o d l v c o p t
s kM s fu r t he r s t N
G n t n g k c ba c k c o n s t r u c t i v e l y ] s o n c o f t h e ke y
ef f
t ra in e r t o u n de r st a n d a n d t o u se
s k l ] ]s : o r t h t
sit
c )a t !
pc
rn a n
n o w
de\
d cl \ t t o
l Ro y a l C o lle ge s
o ne
e
o n
in
t o n 1 i ni
t nt
t' t
:w
ha t
do you
t h
1\ g o i ng
her e
'
ha t
oh
]
\ t\
\1
pp
or
n c l l 1s i o u
t i ng
\ id
\ -
: wh
at
\ cd
y mB
r 1s
p r a c t ic
l 1a p p e
n s
do
Re in f o r c e
hat
w as
ight
p c c i :i c a l l y y o
: s
di d
o n
st a k e s
mi
r r ec t
e
tim
;n e x t
hi
s ha p p e n s
ry
t hi s
in s t e a d
d i n a c l i n i c a n d i n t h e s u r g e r y a n d i s a : a i r ]y q u i c k
a n d e f fe c t iv e w a y o f g e t t i n g t hc d o c t o r s i n t r a in in g t o
g i v e a v i e w a n d t h e n r e c e i v e c o n s t r u c t i v e f ec db" k
,
sio n al
b o d ie s
\ I 0 N
su c
l le g e s
as co
g Fo r t i l e R o y a l c
(c
e x a m
jn at i
o r1
in
\ : 1 I \ 1 E
l in i c a l
a n o bj e c t i v e
assessment o f t
Th e s e i n t h c f o r m a t o
r a c t ic a l m a n a e
t u n i c a t io n
T
l
m
r
c
o
p
i
l
a
i
c
n
g m ent a
c
nd
i
d
d
f
h
T
i
l
a
n
a
h
k
l
t
c
c
e
i
o
e
a
l
s
s
i s a c hi
d
s
a
r
u
proce
w
y o n u c t i ng t h e e x a m i na t i on i n a n OS CE s et t j
r ea
lin ic a l
ir
e n v
it
T h e Fo u n d a t io
in t he U K
T he r e i s
l e g e s o f v a r i o u s s p e c i a l t i e s i n t h e u K A u s t r a li a , N e w
Z e a l a n d c a n a d a a n d T h a i l a n d ) o r b o a r d s (e g Th e
s p e c i a l t y b o a r d s i n t h e U n i t e d St a t e s ) o r b y u n i v c r s i
M a l a y s i a a n d Pa p u a N e w G t ] i n e a ]
t i e s (e g i n I n d i a
l
i
t
c
o
e
o n o r t h e s t i p u la t e d p e r i o d o f c lin i
m
f ol l owng
p
c a l e x p e r i e n c e a n d t r a in i n g T h e a w a r d o f d i p lo m a o r
d e g r e e m a y b e a s a f e l l o w s h i p (e g F e l l o w s h i p o F t h e
R o y a l C o l l e g e o f Ph y s i c i a n s a n d Su r g e o n s o C a n a d a ) ,
a m e m b e r s h i p (e g H e m b c r s h i p o f t h c Ro y a l C o u c g c
,
Fo
u n
A u gu
Pr o f e s s i o
ba s e d
u r r
i c u lu
c u rr
ic u lu
20 11
st
Cu
o u t c o m e s
a n
da t i o
it
ds ,
w ar
u sin
am
c u r
T he
ar e
i c u lu
r r
D c u lu
14
b u a
or
checkl ist
te ste d
be
( m s t o
u n
1g
(e
o n m e n t
c ar e
r o u n
fo r
ll
w e
hi s
d t he l o gb o o k A
an
f o r t he U
K
o f th
e
o u t c o m es
he f o l l o w jn g
li s m
n a
f O b st
degr e
ic i a
c t r
(e
n s
Hl
a n
ter
d G yn
o
lo gi s t s )
a c c o
M e d ic i n e
as
o r
i n Sin ga p
ore
an
su m m a t il e
in
e n t
] R c > 1c w o r C o
j J] r e v i e w t h c
n n
T h is
a s se s sm
jx tc
tr a ln
he
n t
UK
T Pr o g r t
pru w
L c
a n
n o w
w
c \ s
n ea r
LJ
a n n
ll c d
hc
u al
in n
(A R C P )
t }\ e
ye
fa i l
f.
1o
a r n ir l a
t io
i t \ >n
= x
w n
fo
\ h;
ni at
r rTl a
an
m en t
an a
ge
r 1i n
g fo
f t he
ac u te
ly iu
it a t io
d p ta n
an
e l at i on
s k i ll s
Pa t i e n
p w ti h pa t i en t s
s hi
t s a :e t
H t hi n
c o n t ro
t r it io n a
H t a lt h p r o
E t u
x),
wnsni un wA u d n d
r a >x a mi n a t t n n v i vnq h
hr o
ic dis e a s e
an d
co m m
l in i c a l go v
n i
ca t i on
e r n a n c e
c a re
m o t
io
p a t ie n
\L
le ga l
iM
a n L
i in
ic \in
\ \ \ , r 1i
\
l1ulti B1i >\\oiLt' t Bu> M l t \ \ ( MC

h 1Bw w> ) \ r u n w hw 4 b h m
c a
h b im
a n wwr
o
sc
Nu
.\ r
t l\
u 1c a
E)
Re s u
c ar e
t e
du
c a t io n
an
d p u bl i c
ut al
c e
an
gn it i o
pa t ie
I n l LCt i on
It i\ p a u i
u r a l e x a 1 m n a \ l u l l a \ w > )l
l a c t o r y x . r l J r n 1 ;\ n t L \ i l l \ c U o
R t p e a t o f p a r t u l t h e p r d t \ n \ 11 1o u r
t a r g e t e d t r i 1i n i n /
r t t 1r u v i r l tBo . 11 t h e trti r1i n# p r u
r n w r i 9 u s c u sd
w cn
]
{
t
t
y
r
a
r
c
a
e
1(
n
n
g
gr
lac
o r
hc
l in i c a l
m a n a ge m e n t
D i s c h a r ge
m a st e r s
S u d a n o r h l a s t e r o r Su r g i F a s i n l n t l i a )
I n a d d i t i o n t o t h t s c e x a n 1 i n a t 1o n s a t o
a ll t r a i n t t s w i ll u n d \ r # o
c n d o f t r a in i n g
Re c
o o
in g gm
a 1\ L
l\ il w
i l ll
J 1h
u c s
m cx
t r a i n in
c o
\ le
\ ic a l p r a c t i c e
l l e a gu
es
\ r n \ t\ g
p p r 1i s a l s
an
a s s e ss m e n ts
n i 9 i ni eal t x a t ni na t i on ( M

i ni - E RT f (
h h w r y t aki n< nnt e x m n i n m n e a s c b a s e d hscusCns
N m N h > > e m r d k e e p i n g a n d d c e i s h n n1akn
w= t u hw .
o n N'
r ocedur a s k j u s f or p n cd CJI
'
Xl
u
r
c
v
m
D
m
l
t
E a n d 3 6 o d e g r e e assesnnco
h>
c M
'
bj t
c t iv e
0S
c Eq
tr
t . t :t u r e c
o g b oo
w r it t e n
EM
o st
s
an
In i t l l
in
x lIm
Bn
io
m i
\ lt s u n t l bt l\ a v io u r s
T A B 11 1t i l S U r C S c\ 1nnwni t Jt i l w
v k h p n n t s c o m m u n i c a u n v k h c ou c a g u m w am
n r n g a n d a c c e s s i bi ht y
r ni n< u p o n t hne
, ,
0 0 1 1 8 o t h t r . Bt t r i h u t e s )
I <= c a n s e o l t h c
rs a
p n o r p c r t ? p t i o n s h y t r a in e
b
t r a in e c s o r t h t M i n i c E x
c BD a m l D o l s a s n t e rc
i u onb
t i cck b o x e x c r d w w
s wn d A c I alw
20 1 F
h e u s e d a \ \ Bp \ r v i s t l d l e a r n i n w t n t s i \ n n ( 1c a s s t i m
tu
as s c wn wn t
d SA r
t t s t x a Te
s
se e
v
no w
C }r a p t c
pr=s>
r
37)
M C Qs
a d i ci n n n l lo n
g
a b a n d o m d a lt o
n
c d
as
Ii
y q u e s t i o n s n r c b e i n g r c d t 1c e d o r
T h > m a j o r y o l e x a n n i n g hod>si nchr

r
ge t
h de n n
o r a l c x u n \ i 11a t i o n
(v i v a v o c t ) o n t o p i c s r c a t t d t o
a p p l i t d b a s ic s c i e n c e s , c r i t i c a l c a m
e v i cl c n c e b n s e d
e ss a
'
m a t iv c
oxse s s n i n t s
in t
h c f \ Bt r \ 1 c
os t g r
Us
g 360
in
lr l
n 1a s ur c
d c
g rt
ln
e c b
c s s m f n \ w e
l\
111l t u
dc
1 n
d bFha
a ri
o ll a
vlu u r
b ly
a n
O ft
Ev i 9 c
n c c
b y t h c Fo
a ]l t he s e
d a t io
u n
do
il l b e ke p t
in
an
po
f o l io
rt
rn c n t s
ct o r
in t
o c t o r s
i n i n g i n d i f %c
ra
ac c o u n t
aw a r e
ge
ht
l pn
su c h
a s
hc N at
ties
I t has be
tr o
s lt \o n
gr a t
rn b
he
lu
re
\c
a n
rc =
c n
gn
dt c a l
to
go
d ro
so m e
stu
den
to
So
u n c
de r go
to u n
e n
tzc
d Ln l t
N w
d kn
r \ m e
o w ln
s o r +1c
k rt )r f u
c a n c r 1e b
l C l i n ic a l A s s e s s m
b d 1c
a n
1 2
o st
p r o blc
ro n T
fu l
st r
to
p lc
r ubt on'
hc
) s s l b le
n c ]
n e r t
he lp
t
rn c d
St
ic a l
he r
ha r i
o r t vc n
c (
t l m c t ha t t h e t r a n
f rr s t y e a r o c t o r ] s a
o : c hc s c d o c t o r s
l 1p
dl a l
train in
an
re
pe at
a lj o
p J r t o f t h e y e a r I n a d d t t 1o n d o c t o r s a t t h c c n d
o f : m s t gr a d u J t c t r a i n i n g s o m e t i m e s h J v = g r e a t : %
lo r a v a n e t )
c u l t y 1n p a s b 1n t h L l r e x i t c x a m l n a t i o n b
\ i o s t o f t h e s e d o c t o r I n d l f %c u l t y c a n b c
o f r e a so n s
h e l & d a n d c a n gc t b a c k o n t r a c k t o a c h r c v e a s u c c e s s
fu l
ca re e r
Ho
ld a d o c t
her s in
co u
\ \
f o t 1c e
o r
d J f %c u l t y
1n
hc
A u t ho
o t
sc n
cu m e
T ht
lc c
to
he
at io n a
The
d) mppt anng
L Dw
d > r
r1
J r n
r d
rJ j
L u
}j >
1ou
u w
t l l] a
i n s\\ t
n u t
> n
t
w
d 1L t J
t 1> r l t \
t '
u L
\ I>
J \ (
h > n J w n A 1w
t l r 1 l t t t L' r\
t l
\ t 1r \ t \ 1 1 r n t
1t
t B
m 1t
r r t n
1s o ri 1
Bpt u Rh n
( ) m
l t B\
. lr
np
a
'
en t
>
/ 1mt
bo u
t issu
acc
id e
i ly
su
iv
c rslt
ts
pp
o rt
h i n fo r m
su c
Hn
n a
ca n
co n
c lu
i n
Ta b le 4 1 M
h a n ge
a n d
d gi v e s
Dc
a h
in
Dc
1 h
du
ct
nL t '
ll h
w\
l >5
f jo b
o n
(r e l a t e d
issu e s
de
1n a
r ca
m o ve
list
d e t a ils
m
easu r e
to
be i n g
t re
s s o rs
n a te
r o
a n
d h e Br
s e ve r
B N
B1
40
at w
o
d w
35
ce
30
e n J
or
tDb
t t rl
'
H uv
s
h ,
>f Lt c nA
rrp
yn W
Cu
rit
tv n
n 9 k
n u r ul
Hn n c
>
Lb
Gc
it y
5o
6 e
s rl
e n
o
L1
a p J
. 1' t r \ t ) r
N Bw
t io
Rm u n
: } t ' l t } r m1
pr
so
b(
as
so m
D e 1! f \
h 1r 1 \ \ h
f Bi r m i n g h a m
s t r e s so r s a n
m ain
e s
br e a st
e x am i
p
pp
t 1o n s c l a 1m l n g q u a l l : i c a t i o n s t h e d o c t o r d o e s n o t h a v e
w it h
rc st a rc h
m 1s c o n d u c t
r e la t i o n ship s
i m pr o pe r
:
%
d
l
d
h
h
t
t
t
c
a
l
s
a
s
o
c
o
n
e
n
t
a
l
c n
n
r c a
c
y
p
C o m p t e n c e a n d pe r fo r m a n c e i ss u e s c a n i n c lu d e
s e r i o u s c lim c a l t r r o r s
p e r s 1s T e n t p o o r t 1m e k e e p t n g
p o o r c o m m u n ] c J t 1o n s k i l l s a n d r e p e a t e d f . ] 1u r e t o
Be h m o u r a l p r o b le m s m a y
a t t en d e du c a t io n a l c \ e n t s
i n c l u d e t h e m a c h o t y p e o F b e ha n o t 1r n o t r e c o g n i z i n g
c to r
Lus d
ht r p
t he U n
f t he s e
pr o fe s s to
do
>r u>wnuhH unhBt

B
km
F fa
r un c l
Jl
sUr ?r \
t r.
Pre
'
n \ n
cv
25
H n
f u] uw
r t
ess
v o lu n t e e r su c
n o t
l h o w s e v e r e e a c h m a y b c (w w v A s Bh a m A c u k /
s t u d y l s u p p o r t l s s e s l c o u n s c l ll s t r e s s s h t m l ) A s c o r e o f
5 0 1n a 6 m o n t h p e r i o d i s c o n s t d = r e d t o b e s t r e s s f u l
e n o u g h t o c a u s e i l l n e s s Y o u m i g ht w a n t t o w o r k o u t
y o u r o w n s c o r e f . r t h c p a s t 6 m o n t h s i s e c Ta b)c 4 l )
p e r s o n a l c o n d u c t i s s u e s (n o t r e l a t e d t o b e i n g a
d o t [ o r ) c a n i n c ]u d c t h e ft rr a u d a s s a u l t v a n d a l i s m
c hi l d
r u d e n e s s b u ll y i n g r a c i a l a n d s e x u a l h a r a s s m e n t
p o r n o g r a p h y a n d s e r i o u s t r a f' c o ff , n c e s
FxI
Ju
I 1u
u >
mu W
u r B +r
Ru t r
a 9
: r e ( 1u
i l tn
la c k
se
Ev
s a p p e
ill
ke d
g
r 1n < b lc c p s
w
as
C l i n i c a l < c s s mc n t
n t )
( N C M 2 0 0 4 ) ht 1
:
d
l
o L t o r s i n d l t %L u l t \
l 1 : h t e d s e \ e r a carl y / l g n \ o
T he w
1n c l u d < . < t h e
e du c a t to n
t e r m s o t +1c i r
in
o l }o m
abo v e
be
can
se v ( r c
F ho u
so m e o
o f t h i s a m a 15 o u t s i t l c t h e s c o
pe an d
f
t h i s c h a p t e r H u w t v e r s o r +1c p o i n t e r s w i l l
c a p a c 1t y o
h t l p t h c c d u c a t 1o n a l s \ l p { T \ l s o r t n ci o t h e r s i n h c t n
A fu ll
f t hc
p r o d l r e c d by
lt y
p e o p le
e n
he y
5o
ll
o r a
a d ua
22
1m
15
A L LI
t bot
n hw
r t (. o
tv m n w
De ad
t p p o 1r J r i t u
ho
1pn t i o
h w hn p
sc
ho
14
no s
gh t
c o lle
ge
de n bt
13
11
l h u sh d h o
30
SE CT AO
li r n i t a t i o n s
o n c s
[ o r p r o bl e n
be h a v i o u r
H
a lt h
C { Br i w
n o
1ete1o1}eJ
l l i n g o r lw l p
tar iam sm
a n cl
c a
t l 1o
a u
tt tn }l
h e n he a d i n g
Lv
p r ia t e
ppro
in a
kn e ss is s u e s c a n I n c l u dc v il r i o u s
t1 N n c m e s = o g n M v c i n w u n r w n t
a n d a d v e r s e li h e v e n t s w h l L h t 1 n c a u w
p r
s c r i o c 1s
t e m s O n c c o m m o n p r o bl e m i n d o c t o r s 1n t r a n i n g i s
p o s t n a t a l d e p r s s l o n w h i c h i s t r c a t a bl t b u t s a d l y n o t
o rt e n d i a g n o e d u n t i t la t e
c
p hy s
an
an
gc n c r a
Ev a l u
A dc '
a n
be
e m
p e rfo
o r
p o s trl a ta l
n s ld ( r
to c o
l po
d c
ro s
lo n
il
rm a n c e
pu rta
1m
u n
m e
u rn w n
n t
1r c a \
h ],
pr o
n i ri tc s
(M o b a n n a
lt u
c u
tra
a c
b " u t
lp C c l o
e r ti e
Pr o b a b /
f v AJ
l }
r+
o 8
iy
yo u
&Bv
do
n< !
a sx
tr
n 1 n
f x Jt
f o ll u
11 1t
o u t c o rr 1 A 5
o
u u t c u rn \
du
t i J i n1n
1n
I u LL
l 1e
n bg
\ 1r
r wr
rw w
i t u
: rl j / r d
r} i
1u 7
qt
'
: ru d
u J t
nd
t )
e: wnvht
t r
l >'
ct
ht
lt '
1j
>> r
tr
I J9
u r(
ht H
r r
1r
Gr
n w
rt
h 1l w
ld H
ht
M
t
#is t (
IH
J rm
l,
u n n
H >,
n r [
S t 1L
HH 1
t he
du ca t to
t e a c hi n
f o llm
of t h e c r o s s
?
do c
to rs t
hi n k
i s
i st
n io r
n o
It
1o
i ke
or
sp
om
co u r s e
nt
to
pu
t t he
l e ss o n
an d
ng
t ra ln e esT
bo u
c a r ee r
It
1[ \
e \ 1
Jen
a n \
Q \
"
t r
g
w
as
t w
he
d t }H
n
h i n g e t ea i en k
l w r t a n t t o b r c L 1d e n a n l
t
he r
o t
tx
s o u r c es
dec
1s r o n
& 1 1 r :e
m u t rp c
e d
C v '
IL
ou
e n
c o m m en te
e \ a L 1J t 1o n
"
ea c
w i
in J
he
o f o tr
h a n t h i s T hc r e a n
at
>' 0 0 o )
Bt
o n c
i a n
\t
c =
i n
u u n o
ndi ng
m o m
Be r L
do m
1w
lu
e \ a
a 1m n
\s m u c
bo u
t r
1n
u be
gb
l!
m e r e
o r s
e \ 1u c n ;
H 1
> w
l tn
m
1L
n n
r=
hn
q hm
H 1
lily
n 1n
i n
: t xht n
>
u u n i
l t 1l
n ltn
Htt
HI \ t r 1 n l \
tn
N H
= C
o r
r
\
y
jc
n c
e S
th 3 l r
k iv
u n u n
\rd t d
1aht
w
;l \
hH
h h
w n
a n t
\ 1e>t w\ \ r
v
h>
um
t
.
TH i n
h>
u n
\t
uengt hs
t pew
Ot
r
d J s T t h r e e
N onc n
FOr
hm
t 1n
in
st u
c u
(
b o u ( e S
co n
thl
n n pk
de n t
rm
nd
Ht t H > n hl
t t
Sl m l h h m
I h 1 m Vh n d r > w m h
J rt
Vr u n b 8 1 B
hh n w
t r H1 HB 1
J h h J
r
l \> t L
H
es
\\
or
sh
d ia t n
ha t
USO
c o u r se
at
cl 1ma
ou r
fo
t t he
3 11
$t
pr o ach
ask a r e as
g t he at r
r a t +n
pc
wa
dm
to
rJ t ln
c s s 1o n )
irt
l >e p t
Lh n L e
w
>
a t io n
h c 1"
po \ t w
co
ig ht
w e
1ca t r on a l
hc
mt t h L H\
n
'
ec
h 1n g
hn g
ac
f in f o r
r*
n c e t u a li
p
sah
i li t y
a n
re m
a u
ed
iab l e
\ e r el
uc
atio n
u t
a y f ac u l t y de \ cl op me
d id p e o p l e g o o n
t i\ c
teac
lu
t hc
m ea su re s
in
t \o n n alr c s
f
d
ap
pr e t at io
E v a lu
W ha t d o ]u
a
in te r
an
i s t hc
In t e r
dn
an
a sp e c
in t o p r a c t ic e
Ex it
Evajuatto.
e ss
t h mk
in e e s
f fe t
m s
to f
s t he 6 -
ly s i s
t h c GP r e g i st r a r s
l c ommu ni c at r o n s k i l l s
ra
h at
E\
r
lt a n t
Hear n Se n
sy s t e m a t ic
1s
l proc
m t n ta t io n
In : i
co nsu
g t hc t e
m c a stt r in
dd
h at
is
c atio n a
l 20 10 )
q u e s t io n s
c t
E v l ] t 1a t ] o
lp
1n
a n
p lc
p r o gr a
n g t h e d o c t o r i n c u lt y i \ a n c x p t r t t a s k
l 4 m i a t i o n h e r e 1s 1 7 1 r t 1) t o r a l s e l w a r c n e s s o f
h o \ e a n d \ \ h ! t h c s e p r o b l t n l s m a y a r 1w a r 1d t h e n e e d
f o r r e f e r r a l T h a n k f u l l y t he p r \ r g n o s l s \ s $ o o d f o r t h e
\ a s t m a ] o n t y w h o g c t 1n t o dt : f Kul t
T hc
1r r i
d i o l p r a c t l i t .1a v c g r e a t l y i n c r e a s e d t e a m w r k
l o a d a l n r h o u r s L u l t t 1r c l a c k o r s l e e p a n d s h r t w o r k
c a u si
t r a in in g
du
an a
c t ro n
bo
d l c a t i o
t hc
c e s tg n
in
d ic a l
c o lle
t io n
tll c
c an
t o a p p ly f o r
in t he N a t io n a l
po st
e v a lu a t i o n
e c
t o t o n b l t l c r ] n L ] t 1d ( . c o g n 1
he a d
d
a fw
h
c t o r p o w
c
o
n
t
io n a l
i n ju q
t lw
o r
n t L1m l o g l c A L d i s u s E L )
o r a n 1J
k
t hc
h
k
h
w
o
r
n
t
t
c u k u r c a n d h mn >
c
o
v
h
n
h a
k
h
h
h
e d
l
t
r
s
w
o
r
o
d
L1
d
l
A
o
u
t
w u r
o 1
o r g a ma t o n ) a n
g
h
12
U
h
o
u
r
s
h a v e d n c d u n c c t h e 19 m
c n
n
pc r
i
]
d
t
c o rn p e x
Le e c k \ \ J s c o rn m o n
t hc I n t L n sl t y a n
) o f
O t he r
t hc
l ig i b l e
t io n
i t io
a s
t h=
c a u se
krc
t ic c
an
s ic
n w n
Re m
I prat
r i 1r n c
t u ll y
HH N M V
h n l 1 lt l h c i \ p n v l l > g t o w L) r k w i t h ( l o \ t o r 111 t (
1n R \ \ 11L l t o
b r i n g t i l L m i n t o w h a t l v v . 1n \ w
1W H h 1v c BeM n h c d u c o n n n u n i t w o t p a c u t e B1
n wn e / t J
dn apw
n u c m h l p t y e o : n mh l
w hw
p
lt
Ta b l e 4 2 T h i r t e
typ e
e n
s o
e v a lu a
t io
M e th o d
S t u d e n t ( Le
Pe e
a rn e r
r a tin
l n g s
r ra
Ex t e r n a l
Le a
m m
ine
in
e x
ho
s u m m a tw e
f te a c h i n g
Ra ti n g
s c a le
Se lf
Fo
rm a
trve
an
s u m m a t >l e
Ra b n g
s c a le
S tu d e n t s
Fo
r m a th e
an
s u m m a iv e
Ra t :n g
s c a le
G r a d u a te
R a tin g
s c a re
G r a d u a te
ti n g s
Ra t i n g
s c a le
A d m i n i s t r a to
sChoash p
R e v ie w
rv i e w
ra tin
gs
Jr c
tu t
hc
n s t r a to r
Su m
m a trl e
o u tc o m e m e a s u r e s
Ex
A dm
Jn l s
t r a to
Fo
A ll
T h 1& e
e n s t r a :e
to
e 5
bo
St u d e n t s p e e
ve
m e a s u re
ie n
ce d
Lav
t i m e rs an
fa ct
di 9] n
r n u st
be
n e x
u i
o L\
an
d de n t
la t io
t t
n s
he i r
lw
a c
[w
a n
ide
(l
u c
t a u * l\ t
be
n1 e
O
N
ftj l
e u r r J( u
t r a l m>
t w
n u t
i r 1c
lJ
l t . 1t
Io
tt
>
a \
\ >
t }u \
] 1t 1 i H
pt
in
ht
a w e
i n d
l l > r 1t > t
r \ 1\
\ \
1n e n
t r 1l l \ e r
l \l
.r
o n
bo x
1 u
\Jt
c A c
C o 11t t x t \
d M A n w H h A n hpy Ju u n t n k
ZU i l
AJ e 4h H d 7em Hr r 1 B f H r V
r L 1M
p
O r Kc l r l i ,
fl
r i l l 1m
1\
t i e j 2 11 7 7: 1 7 1) 2 2110 i
li e , l 1r A p r
n t 1n l u B
l\5
t 1
l XG
l l
i st w
m t n c
rt
19 9 1
o04
ho
si o
%i n g
1s
d 3
Lm1er s. Zi ng
n t
\n .
. 1 COr s
l i ni t-1B1rcs i 1B
XJ
u t
V C
c 1m i c a l . e s s mc n r
\ i, \ m
t\
1 G
L,\ n do
TT ( e
h,\ n
b u r s R S&
tn s
ru
v tl
l i.
t r ( $ t s t r a r c r d 1nt na
\ \ ns J
f S1Br et y
W
C he n s
\\ )r l 1
HI W
hn
I d l m i n g 1e g i r t m
l {o r
l c ]i m
1' J
"
vor kpl nv
t h P e r m t S s 1o
r 1 1l
u r
L\
#i c a
c \\ m
43 94
"
: v cc
L\ L
\ \h
cc
B1\ \
n r r au m
Br , 1
b r idge
B tu
lo m
R dp
HH
1 w
E : S i t ru
f 4 r d 20 10 R a d c l i f f e P u h t i s h i n g
t io m
ca rt
gc
vi
Ca m
d 1 p d r f i ip a r i o n
C a n b n d g c U m v c r s t t y Pr e s s
h l o ha n n a K C o t t r e l l E \ \ h u D , C ha m be r s k
n c w
A c n
t j \ Bt Bc s
d pr ac t lc =
i st r y h a s br e n
l c d ge
kn
c
r e
d a bo
p r i p $
} 1J S
t r ut t ur e
ho
c ru c i al
jd
li ke
er s
]i s m
1o n a
gsi
l e
2 0 0 6 St y lu s P u b i s h i n g L I C
t Ul e
Mmma l e
n 1s t r a t o r
dm
lle g e t e a c h i n g S l e r l l n g V
co
t i m e r s T h e o d t i +n c r s i n s t j j l c d
a t u t u dc s
t h e k n o w l e d ge
s kills
T h e y d t s n bc d
o f t he ir
c r a ft
td
rs
rm a
m e
t iv e
m a
m m a
d p ro gra m
m e
Su m
e an
tr a l o
a m s
tw
Pro gr a m
p :o y e 1s
e m
l n s
sN
W= t n
Fo r m
Adm
Y\ i
m
Adm
d pe e rs
Re v i e w
i sh
am
ti n g s
a n
a w a rd s
v o u n
t iD e s
Br it
rm a tw e
e r s a n
c o m
Fo
d p r o f_
a n
]c
pe
s u m m a tr v e
Pe e r s
Su
he
a n
s e e le
g d o c t o r s) w e r e i n t r o du c e d il l t o a p a r t i c u la r c o m
it v o f p r a c t i c e , w o r k i n g w i t h a n d l e a r n i n g fr o m
to
a (w e
Ra ti n g
e a n
a n
Se k m
u n
yo
s u mma t
rm a
tiv e
Te a c h : n g p a r t f o +l o
Aer
d
d
Fo
rm a
m i s t r a to r r a
ach r
a n
S t u d e n ts
Fo
E m p lo y e r
Te
s u mma
s c a le
S c [f
a tu m n r a
tiv e
t iv
R a tin g
s c a le
S t u d e n t in te
a c h :r
ffe c t
m e
Ra ti n g
ng o
o r e c o rd <
Te
O u tc o
d by
Fo r m
V id e
A dm
rm e
Ex p e r ts
gs
bn g s
p e rfo
s c a le
r a l [n
ra
an
Ra t i n g
pe rt
e x
S e lf
Ex l
gs
u s e
1h
t ndr wnn n h B n u n t o n n n n $ nS
M h k t nqm> 1 o n l h n Ht t p
h
N t he
h 1n N
H n H h M
Lh m w J
1u L u v
2o 0 E
X m
>t
3 B: 13 \ \ J H U 0 0
R m hn w
LOnuhant t mc h ws
C ha p t e r
C o n t in
in g
de v e lo p m
1:
t io n
se
. PBn
In t
du
ro
C o n s i de r
e n t at io n
t Jn h
m ar
Pn
re
c a r e
to
Jl gc
a n n u
c rsm
br o ad
t hc
o n
sc c n a n o s
rr t s h e r
st n t t d
; a r c 1o
pic
pn w
N o r fo lk
M gc
r c a lrn
fo
r m J t 1\ e
t f
r Y n d
'
ho
I p o s s i b l y 6 11
c an
o \e
u rs
n o
Bj
a n
ro u n
hu
fo
fM
r t
rm
pr
) 0J
1
hc
u n
zr e
an
im pr o \ in
pru
u n mn mu n
t]
co u ru
an
he p r t
he
fhx
t lv
>
w e
tal
li
p m pc
m an
M c n J n m
r i p r 1u A l \
1r (
c o
r 1l r u
r w n
n o \ t
lt > 1
Jl p > r H n
tw
rt' ' "}nl /Bl
111n =
u r
r c \ ld> n t
t n
hm
y ( f : 1111l n
: j
w t
l l > BK\ 1t
he
a u
d tc
Kn
o w
he
t o
p Ic
Kn
o w
h c Fo
Kn
o \e
ht
F,
lin e
ll e a g u
fo u
s a
s t e
p r o c e ss of
i t h t he i r o w n
e s w
r c cl t u r e m = n t s
p pro
i n t he
r t an ce
1n
an
n o rm
c e ss t o
n ec
rm a t
o u t c o r +1 c
A1 &t
K
Kn o
tn
th
. \ - ur 3 a
sh c
me mb e r s
u t i
? x 3
c e
Th o a u 0 e
o v
te ac he
CPD
IJ
lu p c
'
f o r r 1 11
1\ n
> R
[ 1k e
hn>
rhn11i
1
I m
l r lw
ll>
w w H1
\ \
11\ l \ e
tn
It h \ t r u
hnnr v
h
w t 1r
: B\ 1L
 r
\ }l t
t l
'
p \ 1t \ l 1\
t l 1 t lw
Hm
b y \ B1t
1Nyhl l Bwnt l nun

J (
an
ga ge d
t \ c r
y phy m
n tt
t \ t 1\
HH
w pu H
rm n
gr a du a t e t e
> n
ht m
t r
pe e r s : c o
po
r im
e d
h J l j e n z e ) l m J Yl n i : p r ( e n \ J t l o l\
i f
m o r J l a t 1d i t s r \ >
o t h e r )n a l t 1B p r 1 t
d
Kr
in t
o u
is e n
o n e
f e
yle
Kn o
q t . 1l l t !
t l n B:
a n w<
J n
w i t
st
p J TJ h h h
n t J t lu n \
Jf J
a n
w &
i n t o r x
be
m . gh t
o 9 u s
r e hu v
e se a r c n
t c a c l-
by
.w h i n d
1) n
fa r g r c a t t
su m e
1e
ds
cunc\ t t \ t
i n d
rn e n t
st
rn a n a
<e s sl o n s
o c r r (n t
'
hm
f a H Hgnant
r 1ap s
&
o
a st
as
u r c
ds
rm a t
tm
su c
a s
n e e
ha p t e r
t re as
t he y
ic a t
an
a m
o n
t h c t e a c h e r ( s c e n a n o 1)
f
C P D T l O r e c f c t +v c o r
( 5 c n a r i o 21
r a n 1z e r
d
ro e l e r o r u g
t he p r o gr a m m e p
t
s
e
j
n
v
k
\
n o
g
ps
as
T he a r c c a p t u r e d h e r e
l c n t c nc
d s sC n CS \ b u r dc p 5 r t n
d
t e t ha t r o u n s
o
D
n
:
c c u t lv c o f c t r
t h e h o s p t a > s c h 1e e x
t
l
n g
1
r
s
n
E
v
e
rs
hn d c d m c d i n r e c e n t y e a
a t e f idan ce
ll
a
\
m
s
ha v e dt s a p p o l n t l n g y
r c s e n t a t 1o n s
p r o fe ss s p
h
h
t
i u s w y
w h e n y o u a s k . our L o l e a g t
o n
p m } ] p t\
o \ c r b L m k t l
n
b
m
e
y c u
t h e y c la i m
p r a c t 1c
t s t hc c a se
d o t he r \ o m p c t rn g \ n t t r
a n d o fh9 c s a n
s u r g1 c z l s u i t e s
l u a l r t y c r n m 1t t c e
b u 2 l s o s rt o n t he ho s p i t a q
c s
i nd) at or s 1n , t \ ( r Jl
d o b sc n e t h a t \ t s p c r f o r r n a n c e
ta
ic e
l 19 9 5 )
pe
ha n ge
re c
W c ll p r e
pa r e d
. i n t c r v c n t 1o n i t s e l f
d a f f e c t h e a l t hc a
re
o r i i m m e clr a t e a
nd
I u r t hc r w h i le t he st e p s to
f s i o n l l d ( v c l o p m e n t (C PD)
u ln g pro c s
lf c v l de n t i n a n y t ea
s t v e n se
r ha
f p r a = t te c
T his
t ra in in
isc
c o m n u n
an
po rta
t x c rc
pra ct
n c
h i n g by
e a c
f c c t l v c d u c a t 1o n a
a v rs
c u n t ln
in g
in i
ar t
rn
Ic
in l p r u
t l\ c
f M c d \ c 1n c t o r n c
o g
' \sc d p r
B t u r c b
l
v e r y p o pu ar
T ht t r t l c o
a r t t c ip n n t s
o
5
3
r
p
e
v
h o u r s t o Bt x t u r c t o o
Ui s e a s e : Wh a t t h A
o n he a r t
\ l r s c o r ga n
k n o \ e \ b t 1 a x k t hc c o
e e ds t o
e n e r a l t sc n
s c ho o l
(I ]
si
u n i\ c r s l t y ,
Jn t h i s
d
t w o de L a t s
l ve 2
yo \ 1 l a
ra n i n c
; 1r l y
o u t e t )m t s
ran n w
by
n 1n
t o u r st
lo #y
hst
n c ra
h lo w
prc
t hcmsel vcs
l i r l l c 1a R S
r a L \ l l t y a n d t ht c
b ou t p r a c
i
c a n br n R
c t io n
hc
s i lv e r
L
pe r r i e n 1
llt
'
n 1 t et O
a u is
D A
e n
J G o ldu ia
fe ssio n a l
pr o
t he
\ u\ l B>n\ t m, 1\ h e
l> :
p r Bn
br n
t h>
\nr
c u rr
tw d
nr
h>
in ic
HW
t\?
l i\n s
kn
T au
pa r t
n o st \ tn
w v n am
I;
In
c an
o w
m
m n
:x
he
o ne s
n ce
ncd
) r t a n t st t
C a n a du$
i l n p ly
m Bn
types o
F p r a c t i t io n c r s fr o m
se n i
c ia n a s s is t a n t s o r n u r s e
to
a u
phy
n o m o t 1s
p r a c t it io n e r s t o
in de p e n
s c l F r e gu l a c i n g p hy s i c i a n s
d en
w h o m a y b c gcncm
l
p r ac
h
l
i
t
i
i
e r t r a n c
n f a +n i l y m e d i c i n e n
t i o n c r s (n e
o r
c er
fi cci b y t h e n a t i o n a l bo d y ) o r f a i n i l y p h y s i c i a n s o l t c n
w i t h n v o o r m o r e y e a r s o f s p c e ia h
y t r a i n i n g i n t hi s
I n t h c U n i t e d St a t e s r i m a r
c o m p l e x d i s c i p li n e
p
y c ar e
i s m o r e e c le c t ic in i t s m ix : p a c d ia t r ic i a n s
o bs t c t
c ia n s
g e n e r a l i n t e r n is t s p h y s i c i a n a s s i s t a n t s n u r s e
i
i
t
t
o n e r s a n d f a n 1 i l y p hy s i c i a n s ( e n e r a l
c
r
a
p
p r ac
g
c o m p r i s e t hc a u d i e n c e
t io n e r s) m a
Pr i m a r y c a r e
m i gh t
a ls o
c li n i c ia n s
c o m p D sc
t e a m 5i
g iv e n t hc
i
h
i
i n c r e a s n g e m p a s s o n i n t c r p r o f e s s i o n a l c o l ia b o r a t i o n
i m p r o v e l1 ( a \ t h c a r c a n d a t i e n t
a s a n l e a n s t o
o
p
a n d t h c r o l e o f i n t c r p r o f e s s i o n a l c l u c a t i o
c o m es
i
n
n
f o s t e D n g t h e s k i l l s a n d b e h a v i o u r s n e c e s s a r y fo r el f
t i v e c o l la b o r a t i o n
(H e a l t h C a n a d a I n t c r p r o f e s s i o n a l
C o l l a b o r a t i o n 2 0 ] 1) T h u s t h e p r i m a r y c a r e t e a m
c o n sist
o f a r a n ge o r he a l t h c a r e
m a
p r o fe s s i o n a ls
s u c h a s p hy s ic ia n s
n u rse s
s o c i a l Le o r k c r s
d ie t ic ia n s
a n d p ha r m a c i s t s
E a c h b r i n g i n g a p a r t i c u la r r o l e a n d
p e r s p e c t i v e t o t h c p r i m a r y c a r e s e t t i n g (G o l d m a n
e t a ] 20 10 M c u s c r c t a l 2 0 0 6)
,
e e
u w
Wic
s o
Ot ht r pi l rt i i par1t
a r c r n c t l 1t n l \ u f p a y m t
dc e h n i n g
m u n t
ncyi
c a =c n
t\
'
'
r n
d n g s
1y
B1 B 1y
<v
p>\
nnr y
l A
o rt B
1m
r it a n
t t
tln#
in
r l
t t l n
1> >
'
'
Ch n j M a u J , c a s e s t u t h m
G o v = r 11 1l 1t n t I ) t l p 1r t n 1 e n t
p r a L t ic
l l \ 1m
v hnh nuur ahan

St e r i c s 2 0 12 )
l n
q u ire m e n t s
th e o v a n t
re
in
n c e
c tp
c o
t th e
a m o n
m e a n s
li n
o th e r
thin gs
g p r a c t ic e
n ti n u i n g e d u c a t io n o r C P D
p h y s t c r a n le a r n e r i n v o l v e d
e
Tr a
i n in
t h e r e a r c c o u n t e r v a i li n g fo r c e s
fe s s i o n a l a n d r e gu la t o r y g u i d e l i n e s
t h a t m a y c o m p e l p hy s i c i a n s t o p a r t i c i p a t e i n s u c h
I n r e g a r ds t o lic c n s u r c t h e r e a r e g u id e l in
c c n ts
t h a t s u g g c s 1: a m i n i m u m n u m b e r o f h o \ 1r s o f f o r m a l
c o n t i m Bi n 9 e d u c a t i o n o r C PD f o r a w i d e v a r i e t y o f
p h y s i c i a n g r o u p s l t i s t 1s e f u l t o k n o w w h a t t h e s e a r e
fo r e a c h j u r i s d ic t io n a n d w h e r e p o s s i b le t o t a i lo r
Fo r e x a m p l e i n t h e c a s e
i n t e r v e n t i o n s t o r n c c 1 t he m
o f t h e Ro y a l C o l l e ge o P h y s i c i a n s a n d S u r g e o n s o f
C a n a d a a d d i t i o n a l C PD p o i n t s m a b e g a i n e d b y
a s k i n g p hy s i c ia n s
to
p e r fo r m
p r e w o r k s ho p c h a r t
d
i
l
d
au
ts
r e a d in g a n d r e fle c t i o n
p o s t e c t u r e s t r u c t. u r c
l
i
e x e r c se s o r p e r s o n a
l earni ng p r o j t s r e s u l t i n g f r o m
p a r t i c i p a t i o n i n a C P D a c t i v i t y ( Ro y a l C o ll e g e o f P h !
s i c i a n s a n d Su r g e o n s o f C a n a )
Si mil arl ! i n t h e
i
d
L n i t c St a t e s t h e r e a r c p r o g r a m m e s b a s e d O n
r e c
t i fi c a t i a n o r m a i n t e n a n c e o f c e r t i fi c a t i o n (e D c a n
B o a r d o f Fa m i l y h l c d i c i n e A m c D c a n B o a r d o f +nt er nal
h l e d 1c i n t A m e r i c a n B m n l o f \ [ c d i c a l S W a l t i e s )
ATr cdi t at i on C o u n c i l I o r
Fu r t h e r
C \ LE
t ht
I A C C I E ) i n c r v a s i n gl y rcqt 1i n s p n w r o t c o m . v t e n c e
s t B, h * t i p r c / N S T n m l t i p l c c h o i c e t e s t s
o r pe r f1
a n ( e
t 1c h a \ h o \ p t a l n \ e J s u r e s \ n a d d i t i o n t o
at t e
at
t \c h J u t n i t ie s
J r 1( e
IA c c r e \ h. a t io n C o u n c il fo r
COnt l nt \ l l \ \ \ t . h L 1 l E. LI UC. 1t 1n) o m s t J t e i n t h e
O n t hc
i n t )l e f o n
o t
h e r ha n d ,
pro
hcw
> & u c
he r e
p p r o p l ia w
an
d r el e
)1i t l B t l t n t n w n y l r n n \
h n w 1h n i 1t w l y
p r a e c wt t i ng h n M r > n n h u r w
u n ly
t l 1a t g r a n d r o t Bn l \ : l ( t i v i t 0t \ l BT t B\ 1> 1\ t l y ; 1t l d B> \
m
m
: r m w n h pr u j
t h e r e s h u n t c a s e o l t h e v eek w
n L1t > d
o m n n m
h i gh hg h t
v M n g spm r, a n d a w
In 80 11
t o t h c d 1i l y : 1t . t i v i l i e s u l [ n o \ t at t t ml 1T>,
i n c c n v c s fn r
v e
i n M a n e c s l p h l i Mn
rc
n w
C PI ) a t t i v i t i t S b r t X ; t m p l t , P h y s i c i a n
;l t t t n t lin g
Pr u g r n m
i
p r J L t i c l s t n m ll t t l n t b c Pr a L t i c t 1n ( t n t v c s
h1 A u n r a h a m a y r D v c p a y n w n l r o : p a 1 Uci pat i n
1n m n v c n c t i v M = h n i c h a s
in q u t
p r w . R n
N
i n g t h e d is
11 > v i n t
u r w
t h e a u d ie
ovl
kNo
e n v ir o n m e n t a n
B 1\
\ t B
j p r ; 1\ t i t
nt >
1t d
t t r 1b \ Bt >
n t J 1BB
>n
Kn
tt\r w
h he w
\ A'
p ic
At
> mc n h n
n e
hc
o r
s hc
kn o w
hc
s h o u l t l t l 1c t o p i c o r
v T hc a n w c r h c m
)\ \ w > v > l l i e \ n u A i u t i n k n o w l c d w o r t h c u b j c c t a r c a
hm k n o Wl c J jw N h m h l o r t hc i n b r i n m h n t o
n n v t n e c k n n d e x p c c t o n s a t h v o hvcl s t h e p r a c
t i = e n t t t l s = x p r c s A d h y t l 1 c l e a r n L r (t \ w mi t r o 1
spcet i vc a n d t hc n e e d s Of p a M s , p o p u l a t i o n s
ht a l t h L r L s y s t e 11 1s o r r i g i o n s (t l t c l a r ge r 11 l il c t u
p
T l \ i s t w o l b l d \ h e m > r > t l > e t ! a n i l b \ 1i l t l o n
, P e c \ iv c )
t ha N J s n h j c t i v c h h C t h > t h l r n u m T hi s u x m n
pr cmnt s t o o k UWf u i n h m h s c u n a r h n i n w h k h C P D
p r o v k b r hh c a e h c r s m n 1e l r n r t h c n n x l s N t h e i r
m h l i e n \ t \ a n t i t l w i r p a \ i u n t p o p \ Bl a t i o n $
t io
m
1H
T xr n
J v s v n wn t
l e
111 1u c
ev e n
,
? W ir y
be
r a iv x
ll e r m o d i %c a t i o n s m p r a c t t c t m i g h t be
i
o r ev
d
w i t h a b r i e f C PD p r t w n t a t o n
a c e o m p lrs ht
en
h
n
c
l
a
e
s
r
e
r
a
r
c
g
g
qu lre a
a t l i d i l c t i c ] t c t u r c ; h o L v A\ t ' r
c E
p e r ha ps t n c o m p a ss i n
m u c h n c b t r C p D c x p d RH N
g
f
a
t 1v c w w l o n s u c h a
t
b 1# h l y i n t
s a
a L o m bin a t to n o r a
p r ac
] 1a n l s O n w o r k * l 1o p a n d p o s s i b l y a n f r s h c r o r
k t t t 1n g
c a l ( x p t . r j > n c t i n t bt w o r
k w he n p r > pa r tn g a
prcs
u s e f u l q t 1t s t i o n t o i Bs
hc r \ kn o w o r he ltAv
d
n c e in t m
d
t
c
u
h
o
a
w
t
a
i
i
\
e
tat o n
T
A v a lu a lle m o d
ej
i n r c g a r d s t o t l 1l s p a r t 1c t 1 l a r I s s t 1c
s t 1o n 15 t h a t o f Pa t h m a n e t a
h
l
t o u s E t o uddr t ss t i s q u (
t hn e s a m n h n u
u rn
0 9 9 1n t h i s m o M Pm h m a n o u
ad h
:r o m a w a r > n ( s S t o a gr t c m ( n t t o a d o p t io n t o
l
n
o r c 1i n 1c a l
A
a
1o
n
o
r
r
t
w
n
l
u
n
k
t
o
n o
c
c n L c in r c ga r
h
i
a
t
t
t
n
o
r
n
m
c
I
s
t
t
a
e
c
t
a
s
s
e
n
p
t of
g
c d g ( . T J1 e a w t t m
l I n t he
u 1d t l l n c s : f o r x a r T 1p >
ado
c hm c il l p r a c t l c c g
j b p 1c k e d U P a n d ] m p l c m c n t ( d
t i o n \ t at ' a p r a L t 1( e
l a r l y a n d 1r l t h e
l
ad h
t h o u R h n o t u m l o 1T n y n r r t g u
l
d
k
s
I
l
C
o
w
o
t
n
n
ist e nt l
g
c l] m ( a
t he
\ t a =t
( n c t
y
W h l e h C PD
a p p r o p n a t e ly
an d
e l k c t l v ly
a p p ll e d
f o r m a t s u s e d a t w h r c h s t a g e d e p e n d s o n t h e p a r t 1
l a r s t a g t a l o n g t h t L o n t i n u u m t x i n g t a r g e t e d (D a v t s
Fo r e x a m p l e d Bd a c t r c l e c t u r e s m a y be
c t a ] 200 3 )
f a n I s s u T w h 1l c p e e r
h
r
o se n t o p o m o t t a w a r t n e ss o
c
i
o u ld b A m o r e
\
\
l
n
a
r
n
ll
o
e
r
g
appr
u t a n d sm a
g u p
i n
le r s)
t k
S u b l e c t i v c n e c a s a r c t h o s \ t h a t a r c i d c n l i fi t d a n d
c x p r c s c \ by t h= l t a r n u r
T h e s t n c c d s a r b a s c l o n
t h e l c J m\ r i 1 b i l l t i c b t o r c l l e ( t m d c x a m i n t t h e i r o Lv n
kn m hdw an d p m c u c e s
E\
a n 1 F ll _ s
s U
o r
l\
b)\
J t s t o n n .1 r L S
Fo
r \
A
c u s
In fo
gro
rm
l c
tlv c
v n n
n c cl
gq u
l s
l 1o
ils s e g s m c n
l to o ls
lo g s
ps
o m m t n
ts
d s a \ t s s m t n t \ r c ll t c t p h y \ l c 1a n s
d
& r e c p t t o n s o f p r o blt n s l n t l t ht i r t x pc r i c n e c s a n
i
h
l c a m 1n g s t 1 It \ a n 1 p r \ w i l c i n s l Rl 1 t i n t o t t 1r p r i o r t y
l t J m l n g . l r V J S T I 1c w J s c \ w1 1 e n t h c l n ) t l n n l ] a w p J r t l
'
l to
t
: u t 1o n n C I D n n L p h v s i c i a n \ m a y b c m o t l v a c
l
a c q t u m a t i o n 1l k n o \ \ l t d g c i n t h c %e t d t n t l fi c a r c a s
ry se t m
t
h
111
h
l
n
l
h
c
s
s
m
c
2
3
i
s
s
A
c
0
0
t
L
r
\
1
s
)
t mm
g
hav t
n r a l ] h t t o n i 1 r d e l i d c n c c s u gg e s t s t h a i p h y s i c i a n v
h
b
e m
t
a
s
c
s
s
mc
n
t
s
t
c
a
t
1
a
c
n
1r
y
d1l i l c 1es & r o m i n g
d
ata
b
r
t
l
s
L
1
a
i
o
n
d
b
w
n
t
a
n
o
\
e
r
u f 1n t o r m A
sc l\ e i
y c
?
b
h
a
c
t
t n
f
s
h
l
s
n
t
G
a
s
s
m
w
t
l
a
s
e
n e n t
( D J \ u e t 3 O i j
l
l
n
t
i
o
r
i
r
K
b
c
s
e
l
\
n
t
i
g
Ac
o
T B B le
th A
o r
p
c n t 1c u d
( Lt . ceT 19 ) S) o b ] c c l l \ c i n f o r m a t i o n l n d t a L 1n
SUbi t we
n e e
a l s o rt(B
u1rt' d
h
Fo x a n d
l b
( o l l e I , t 1t \
( 1 9 5 11) . .
T in t
J
'
h
C
(J n d w s s [ b l y h t m b l l n z ) t o t e : D p r \ }
( TJ . l i t e :
f
f
t p r l T1 e
t
t h + t r n u l t j p ] A f . } Lmr J
= a k
w i r T
)i r e
In
e \
I
f
IL u
L }1 J n
e
r
d
s
C
t
u
t
m
r
m
p
y
p
CF=T, ( 5
1s w 1L L r \ c s t u d ' o \ e r 3 0 11 N \ 1r t h A m L r i r l p h ! l
l 1J n t
V l 1J t d 1d ) u u i n \ r b t r t e n t l \
G a i s . e e / . t d
'
1
ht l
H
m
D
h
h
n
J
r
t
J
t
H
T
t
L
w
A
u
L
J
1
r
c
e
t
Jn ot 1r r t
k
l\ J t
t
l
\
)
1
L
1
r
r
1
t
t
t
r
1
r
i
t
t
r
?
l
r
n1n:
:
UU
X
\ b h
t o
bat e
.
J=
m e n t s a r c
Obl t Lt nt ' nt \ . Bh
J r e
l +n
pr
i L J
t 1
Rel l t \ l n 1'
t
he
m m
[] l t
Bt l
n \
t )l t n j
l Jr h
1' H > T HL HHH

r ' r
1 ,
):
B1t
l t h l 1*
;1
n r w
l prJL
t lL
11
l d 1n H
\ ,
1r
(t
B r t r) :
tu
H w
I w
1 n 1r \ l w
\ l ed11nt ,
e n c 1
20 1 1
t
) 1n)
w L
w
ln t
u L
JM
'
A r
I n
"
h m $
o n
e w
c n
:w
N n
re
r t
i lt
la r g < 9 3 p
J m
1\ H 1
lo
re
n
a r c
nl
t % n M NC m n ic
1n t h e t l l m
W
an
ld
1n
n ian
n 1 5 n
hv
a su r c
L\ ! ob( wr \ ee. 1 dsc s m ' nt t d\
c $w
i l
\ t> i
\ u \
: n
R u T a n h h
1\ u t r l r A
<h n
; i t ro n
he r
u n M
t \ t 11
/ L1nosb
T he
h > H
l t > t 1l r t
ho
\ \
n n
l t w Rep
n t
,
a t m r Ba
o f
sa Fa
\ t lt u t e
C h
Hw
a
r
o
m
w h1c h
1
i
t
r
anl
aced
be c n rea 1 y
t )t
m to
3 1 r Dc u l oo
n i
J r e
b. 1 h
:a l\
1c e
p r aL1
ha s
n L e
ge
6 F w V E V L S x r
E. \ Jmpl A5
T he l n
h n Lt
%W
ed u
dt
t \
T
su
agr e e m e n t
x} TJR
hc
r t
r f
at e
pn
Sm
he w
C o n t in u in g p r o le s sio
E h n w i w c w n w n t m N w
c n h h
t h e o u et
o d i : tc 1L n t
t \ +" c\
u t
1n t \ t 1 M \ t m n
\ m l l \ 1\
an
h o d N ht w n u w n n u 1 h % a n d e Hd L m
c x t e n n
T h c p u r i " \ t \ 1 l t h e n e e \ l \ \ w t w r n > n \ \ l 1o u l l
n ss
t
d t W r n n n t t l w s t r J W e\ t l \ t \ l l L u m b 1n > \ 1 a
p p o It h
p r o e 1d c b J 111 0 r o umpr ct \ cn11\ t u n u r x t a n d \ n g o l t l w
M t u . i t l u n (G r a n t 2 0 0 2 )
T h u s t h t ( r t 1 t i o n u B \ n c l l e \ t l v t C PD i n t t n t i 1t t
o n
pr cscnt s r J t h e r t h a n 1 \ m p l e l n t l 7t r a\ ht l or w l
t i o n a c t rv l t
cn
t r uy
tl
C PD
e c t w c
Ih
lt
p nn
n m
n m
hanunR t he
w r
pn h
h r o u g h t h c c 1 m c r % t r a i m t w \ \ n d 6 e t \ 1n R\ I e
T mn R
\ 1n l M 1b l c \ t B\ > l v
s t y le s a n d e \ p e n t r l + C \
\ i 1d
u h lt \
t 1v e l y dt t cr1 1nt \ l p r \ L t 1\ t
\ n \ l p t r Bu m 1n L >
a s
t
g p
Fo" a l
P J { { )
n o
a sb
n w
LV
e e d b
1/
1(
J/ 1 f
v Bd u l t \ o
o l q
r r\
: /t
Jr
de
/ 11
b e. l dh
ss
5 S
Fc
te o /
e r 1h
35
y A
rt c e n t
: E l u
\r t m t n t o
( a t io n
'
e ( 9/s
5 b
A'
r 1
wst cmat i c r e v i e w h y t h c U S
(2o ] o 1 s h o w c d b e t t e r
o
L' oi nt s lo r B
c a r n c r s p a r t 1c \ p J t 1n g 1 n b l c n d e l l c a r n 1n
g
t o n n m g o n hn c
a n d fa c c o fa m
in st r u c u o n
It s
p o w h h t ha t t h c a d d m o n a l lc a r n n g t m c a n d i n s t r u c
t 1\ m a l t l c m t n t s
r a t ht r
t ha n m e r e ly t h e m o d e o f
l e a r n i n g p la
t hc
r o le
in
e n ha n c e d
o u t c o m w
( L I 5 D c p. " . . . . t o l Ed u c a t i o n 2 0 10 ) . n d t h e r e f o r e
p r o w a n u n e pl anner a w e n c o u r a g e d t o c o n s i d e r s t r a t
> #lt \
t u e x t e n d t hc l a r m n g b e y o n d t h c
p a r t i c u la r
t a L t Ta : a ( (
Adv a n c e
o r ga n z C r s
pr o w a m m c
wht r t hv i n : o r Tn t 1o n 1 s p r o v l d t d i n p r c p a r a t l o n f o r
t h c Bo r m a l p r o r a m r n c
I s o n e s t r a t e gy t h a i c a n a l s o
b t \ t v d t o t n a l c a r n c r s (A u s u b c l 19 6 0 K i c \ v r a
L
1l 1 ) 9 7 )
Su c h a n a d v a n c e o r g Y m T ( r ( a n t a k e t h e
t t
t o r m o t a n c m a l l m e s s a g e d 1r e c t 1 n g p a r t r c 1 p a n t s t o a
wht r c t h e y G n s i g n m a c c e s s m a t c T 1a l s a n d
w t bs m
b e gi n i n t c r a c c i n R w r t h e a c h o t h l r A n o t h e r s t r a t e gy i s
t o r v q u t s t t ha t p J r t l \ \ p a n t s L o m p l c t e l e a m \ n g t a s k s
m p le
1n S 1
p n L l r t o J t t e n d 1n g a conf cr t nct Fo D t t u n b i n w h l h C a w b m 1 :ht b e e m p l o y e d a t t he
C
t c r A n \ e It 4 m e T b m i g h t b c e n c o u r a g e d t o c o m p l e t e a
s h o r t p a l 1c n t a u d i t t o r m
o r %\ t s m 1l a r C e s
o f a
p
t c u l I T U t \ L\ r L e r
t0
br i n g t o t he
OT
J n l 1r 1e
& m
Dcp
l rt
hM
n n n
l de v e
he n c r = a wd h y n n p r o v i n g w a n d e h v e r
g
y m e t ho d s
a n i l h y p r o \ i d 1n
g t a l c t a s c d t T1a t c r i a l
N o t n r m n g t ak e p c i n t h e c l a
ss r o o m
o r
t 1 n t r r n t t
o l c o t 1r s (
t t n t rc
Ad v a n c e s in
In t e r n
b \ w t l t { d \ n o ]o g y h a v L r n n d t i t o s s i b l t o e n a
p
g ge w i t h
l u t n r r \ b c l o r u D\ Bn n g a n d a rt e r a f a c e t o f a c
e
e du
t 1o n
proc
n a
t ( 1s
r ?A
r c cl
It
1s
fu l
F e Sb
he
S an
sc o
to
1n t c n
Ix
e n c o u n t e r a n L
: Icc
n cr
1. in e
n c c
(?p a r t
B+
:w
J 11
f>
w a \ \
In
f L\ r m
tu re
hl\
J t
r
rL c n
\\
pdu
he
}\ t
( >H
t l t
1n
t\
1o n
I t BL J t 1L + n a ]
hi n k
l r A
Tt > \ c
Jn
:'
T\ \ \ e
rJ
tc
Bt
m u
t \
ll
H
t
n
In
1 n t L r \ t n t wn
t L1 r
tm
L
in *
p BT
nu >J N
1t
he h J r m
1> n
>
an
\ t H
1n
It
1n
t>J
t \
Sh
t l\
>
h h
tl
w
t l 1L
tn m
pr
1\ t h >
Nd
:t
t t \ \ >
HH 1
RH G
>f
i t t\ n
in d
t W h
h h u wh
tttn
t \\\n
t n \ t > wh w
Rt >
TJ
.
p I
Mh
1T H I =
5 h
m n n u u H
r L n
1 1 L r >c n
h >l p
l l 1\
hr ' ' JJt n.
l\e
n \
( r \ U l 1L j \ 1e
1 r u1 r l > H m
t hn1
u t in + m
,
>
r t
lm
I= J H
c a
c \ n
i n t
ln J
du
n e
J
Lt
J rn c r
t t
v Ic t ( [ [ >)
k Bu
h t It
1n
o r
r e \ c n t J t 1u n
n l a n n e r
h 1 h he
in
/ u1r 1L
l Bn: Buf rl Jt l ( J1B
J
ht
w n 1 T 1\ 1t B
: Tw
>
rj
le L
M n
An d m
n tm
hJ p t c r h J u h J h
n a
x JH a m m e
a s
tr
ir
b le p v r c c p t l \\ n
z k e \ t h > p r o u LI > r
h 1n 4 o
u t
11 B
bo
J \
c n t io n
u 1c o c s
dpom4
h 1n k
arid
Cr ct \ el
w io -
m n
C PD l e w
m o r t
th
chc
Knm
1w
H u w
tw l 0 e
u
u m
hc E
m n
ht
\t h
U L
g t
m L
he
to
w n
P Be h > +1 t l c w
1 n
T
l\
n c e
o r
pt
do
rc
i ncl udc
b e g\ m
C W t h>
the
1n
\ /\ t \
am
nc c h o
sugg s
> u
i l
v A c
n t c
is
st ar t in
fo c u s
o n
i t h t h,
..
a s l, c c t s
in t e r ested
bj c c t a . d c a n h e ll t l, c i . B t n t o r
l
f
t h c t o p i c t l , C u 1d i c n e c i b r . A l y
o
,n
m a t e r i a ls
le a r n in g
w ith
Ta k
l b o f t . . Pr i z e d b y l c a r n c r s a
cs an ,1
d
e
l
c
n
"
.
.
i
f
s
l
e
t
t
o
c
s
u
r
c
n
h
c
=
,
,
y
h o " " . r t l 1c l e c t u r e , i r i l s
m ' " a gc ' " c n t t , p b O f t e .
T h is i s a
t o . . . Tl , c m a c e , 1a l d " " g t l , c p , c s e . Ta t i . .
d e %. . t t h a t c m b c c . s i l : ' " . . t . d lb r e x a m p l e b y
b
CO
p r o . i d i n E , m u [t i p l . . 1, o i c c O r s i n \ i l a r q u . 10 c
1
, y , lc v c lu r
I
i
o
r
.
.
l
d
b
f
H
d
H
c
.
t
e
c
r
.
.
,
.
.
.
R
.
c
r
o
Rc
g
p
[ " " l i . R" " o r
' " g a n n . 1. p 5 p c r c a b e , n t h p , o m l ' "
H a n do u t
dc r s
"
" 00
'
"
p"
\h
"
'
..
Bu u "
a l 1h .
d , l l 0
, "
d.
"
"
'
"
"
"
TE, k 1" U l "
. .
"
. N l 1l "
"
"
M a d , 1o , y c B"
,l
1-
..
, n . t u r ia
rcnu n
A ' "
..
"
"
g ,n l u
..
"
r '" c "
"
D L b , U.
In t e r a c t i v it y
n a
M . I tv u d
L 1, C . 1"
s.
"
"
" I
'
"
pa n t
'
an
c.
Fo r
\n
in s u l in
st a r t
n ew
-
%ll
to
pJ
pE
a.
h , lp
pe
l,d '
AR " p
i, t m "
e c ee
1n t e r a c t / : v
on an
gi nni ng c, l
2 hu u r
br o k e n
c c t u r c
Ic . .
e do .
c 1u n
do \, n
an v h r r
t , t
H] / N
t l, e
e r/
h.
p , 1l w
'
" l
1n \ .
' "
ro . s
, c
r . o n 1m t r n , n t
f . Il m . 1 n
pr e s e n te
u n
k e \ p m' "
& (
a . .1 . . H . . t
h.
gc l
st '
hu
A ls o
s . a.
Or t
n,l ,ht
hc !
l pracI I.
, n ..c a
ih i h e s p e a
g I
( "
g :
gl c
ln
p,u
ca
o. o m m u tc
gc st r a t v
r . Nt .
thn , d
19 32 )
r c q u r n t ly
m o st
qu c m
"
f.
to . 1
peet
I Pc r b
a.
. T1
co n
Th c . : c o
Tu , e o r t o
g &r . p S
a co n
r c l\ m
"
'
t o c ha .
J N
l.
l bt o r ."
1
P , t l c n t c e n t r e , v id o ,
h i g h l i g h t t i w 1w : . 1n a l
h'
hn
n '"
' "
co m
.c , "
rt m c n t
Jl
t o c l u n gc a n
fr o m
r ]s
L .
2 00 4 )
l t . rc
co -
?3 & '
t o f o li o
] 9931
asb .
( ' ' "
m m u e
or
c.
w a
o r
\ n c lu
A t t he
h 1, m n \ . o : 1n To , y
t
o l l u , c l , n 1c a ll y r e l e " \ n
p lc
Rs
d li. . p J u c n t \ n t c .
il c d d i g i t 5] s t j n c s
(D H = n d r o
T'
d.
h ds
' ' "
1l )
'
'
pt.
1.
th e r le
a rn e rs
110 t H J .
y b.
1n t c f K t l v l t
\ n \ c J 6\ l r t h c n \ 11. C s u c in a , : :m l t )
B n = . " '
m cctm s
l
k
J . . r 1n J ll \ q u . t c o n t c r c n ( e o
m ' e. .
o C N J C n e 1g h
t l . . . n 1 t h . \ . B \ 11. . PJ n Kl 1 U' "
l w . R1 n . 1: . n . e m H n 1 w m . n w J t h \ n 5 bo u t a
1t r
Bi e ,
r.
, H
l,
1\
H . n
H: .
N\ et h\
T In
1. .
Bm
H.
n .
n \ n
. 1, 1r n
H ..:
l n .
\ n r n \ be t
>
. .
1> l
\\
'
Tl w n
Un h 1
1
' '
'
r,' n
li
t h>
l lpt 1 ,
'
,}
l 1
u r
1w
11 1.
h k l , PJ r t i , l p J H t \ J w n u n v u [u u
r , m l n l , \ r , 1\ \ 1u l
k
J ) r d Ln h . . U l l
h
[
p
h
n
n
i
l
\\
p
, 1 , tlr r . \
pn n , h t . . a
P 1r t r t u la r 1n m u r r l 1b 1n > t h 11LI w h i l e n o t u l l o
r hn R
t 1t J H u I ) n n t
y . 1 t h. . . M 1l m t > j / ' , I r y \ t m l h , \ l t r
n
,
d c , l l r 1 J Ju u m L l u , t n b
y i ner ni pr \ n n l n \ l r y Tb l >
by p a r t n i p a n h
,
1l , rx H .
nm
\ i
uh c n w
X r : BH 11 n 1.
I n > t lu u
' "' "

u n
l lu
. .
Bm ,
p l>
y>
l lrr
. 1t 1
1u
m n
\ 1"
he [ h
>
. >
. . ABBl n r
Ir
RRt
p l 1,
l\
Po l n t \
" r
h p ra( n m
t \ c : n .n t ::
m c
hc
to
pN
l 3ncr
hc pr m
u ite n
N\ e t
n t cr
\t n u
t t lw t
h M \ hu i la
h mu v mn
l c hi h \ :
Ui v e r : e
..t
n o ve
v 1e w
'
hnH
e>n 01
t c i c hu #
"
m \
S t , n 1n r n t
\ i'
a 1
Hn u
n e
a r t R u il
Y l m w ' ' 1n
i n t I k a t = LI > 1 \ L c u
t m e n
l\ > v > t
r \n .
h> Pr \ > n t c r
pr t.
h n wn mn N t h > l > m
t
\r
l \ 1tt 111! )
l l w 1n t t \ W
ul '
n n o rw
Nw n
11 m \ \
i l I 11n \ l y
"
'
!.
>' " 1
in w
'
E \n . M
Nh n m N
'
i n s t JM J n ' " \
.. c .
t.
o UR .
I 1l , 1t J I n By
bl o c k N +. . m . m . . . . u l , I h . . H . . m h
u p in to
l r n n ' " n 1' "
w i t 1> 1t t t .
' 1
,
u t
a n d Q& A (A I, w b r 1r 1. r 1)f J\ J ( h 1w l & A
!
d B
it h
I . a r . . r s h . . B= t n
\
d
t , du c m o n co1
.
l In r d . A a d > , l , y
. . l, o , M H
l t y d c . c lo p m e n \
f
u
.
a
l " " :
1. . Ru . . . . d n t h = g c. . I o
o i n t e r a c t w it
r
t
y
( l y . s o . 2 0 n u ) I, \ s y p
a c t n ,t r
t
a
r
i c . \a t c d a bo v ,
n
. Et l a
:
r
.
o
d
a
,
h
r
b u 1l c l . o n t >
f K n o . . 1c s a n d
c
t hc p r i . " p lc s . .
a n d m ld r c M C
F
. t a l 19 8 9 ) a h o . t t he
x
.
l
d
Rs
.
t
k
(
o
1 . g\ , c s ( 19 q ) a n
f t h = a u c n e t a n d t hp
a . cl c x p c r , c n . . o
, n t c ll , g "
d
l
c i n t o . s . f u l p r a c t , c a\
.
k
c
n m
l
. o r io n o 1 t r a . . . u n g
l a r ge
r . Ia t n c l !
a
d
.
B
aw
. Te ll , g c n e c
t. t
,,
i
S
,
0
9
&
\
c
1
2
0
Ra t h
l l t . r . t . r e ( Fo r s c t l u . . l c t a
i
f
i
b
t
2 0 0 2 St . N c , t & Sn . II 19 99 ) a n e o u : . = o s o m e
b. . c . n l. a m crs
. c t h o , i . [ . r p' " mot ' " ' " t cr J cl 1. 1t
: . I[o . .
T h. .
,n
'
tiv it y
ra c
\n
e
, J c, ' \
In t e
r o
s l
. h
/I
, [ [
tm
n w
,w
rk
\' "
n . n h , h: " MR
b ke r d u U >
t \ L\ \ \ n M e
'
( st r o
d e s ign
gly
gr e e
gr c
cx
d{
a n
ei
d i s a g r e e s t r o n g l y d i s a g r e e ) , 1n d a u d i e n c e m e m b e r s
t o s ca n d u p a n d p o s i t i o n t h c m s e lv c s
a s ke d
a rc
u n de r t hc
p o i n t i n t h e s L a l e t h a t 111o s t c l o s e l
'
pro s e
b le s t he i r p o s i t i o n w i t h
T hc m o de r a t o r t he n rn
[n e n t
(o f c e n
gr o
to
de t e r
hc
in
fo r
h e ir p e
rs
m o
se a t s a n
Dzc
s t
p e c t iv
he k e y
(T i b e D u s & S i l v e r
c u s si o n
o m
gr o
e s
ta
p to
dd
ta llo
o
la
ba s e d
c a so
m a l e r ii 1l t o
n s
U
d jo p r e
s e n ta
tjo
n S
S t a n d a r d iz e d p a t i e n t s fa m i l l e s
L rv e
d e c id e gr o u p
t o e x p l o r e t he
lu d e t h e s e s s i o n
p e r n t ln g
ro o m
tn k s
'
c an t
su m m a
tht
to
fr
o Yes
i l h t he
ga r
h e i r p o s i t i o n To c o n c
d e r a t o r a s ks p a r t ic i p a n t s t o
reaso n s
s t a r t in
r e
rl
Vi d {
rese m
y s to
r e tu r n
co n c e
to t
Case
m a
l o r i a [s
g X
ra
ys
EC G s
he i r
f t he
pts o
R e a l p a ti e n t s
l NAl Bt I N G C I l A N C; I : . 1R ( ) c G j *
2 0 0 1)
K N O \ > : I ) G I N S I . 1
T h e r e i s i n c r e a s i n g e m p h a s is o n t h e p r a c t i c a l r e s e a r c h
fi e l d a n d s t u d y i n g t h o s e m e t h o d s g e a r e d t o c l o s i n g
k n o v l c d g c t o p r a c t i c e ( St r a u s c t a l
t hc g a p s f r o m
2 0 0 9 j o f w hi c h C p D i s a n i m o r t a n t e v e n e s s e n t i a l ,
,
T he
r e
ll e c t
a c tu
Nst o r
t he r e l e v
r ac t
a n c e
io
s c e n a r io s
n t
fr e qu
case s
p a t ie n t p D\ a c y
d i a gn o s i s o r
pr o t e c
in te
f p a t ie
l
c lin ic a l
a
d dit i o n
to
a n a
ge
a n
m
f C PD by p r o
o r
e n
c x c m
o t
ttes
ha t
l y m o d i %c d t o
p li f/ de t a il s o f
m e n t
m
ign
M ay
in g
fle
re
e n
ha n
ce
c t o r1 a n
a r d i ze d p a t i en t s '
bou t
u h om
m u c h has
f
h
r
un d
i
v
t
t e a c hin g
e s o
b e e n wc t e n r o m t e p e r spe c
d
d
i e n t s an
a ss( s sin g c o m p e t e n c e
ar e
gr a d t e s a n d r e s
r e l a t i v e l y l e s s c o m m o n i n t h t C PD s e t t i n g b u t a r c o :
l 1 9 9 7 K a n t r o L i t z 1 9 9 1
l
D
p o t e n t ia l v a u e ( a \ s e r a
C ha p t e r 26
Si m u la t t d /
se e
Z a b a r e t a l 2 0 10
M o r e u b i q u i t o u s a n d le s s
& a n d a r d iz e d
pa t ie n t s)
c
mt
t
e
n
c
a
s
e i s r e l a t i v e l y s i m p le t o
h
i
e
t
e
s
\
r
1
ex pe
l
i
f
d
b
d
b
o
i
D
r
b
o
e
r
u
r
n
t
c
e
u
s
c
d
a
m
g a
a n
st r u c t
y
i
l
d
i
i
\
s
)
n
a
n l
i
t
t
w
u
s
1u
a
e
t
r
t
o
r
t
t
le c t u r e o r p r e s e n a o n
l
d=
l
\
d
r
o
l
a
t
a
s
a
a
u se
p
p r o b l e m , Ol \ ng o r c a n
L
d
[
IE
E
h
f
]
u
i
d
t
t
t
t
h
i
t
Pr nt at i on A f u r t e r a d i o n o
h
l
\
i
t
t
n
r
ran # n *
o : s l m u la [ l o n s
h a s b e e n t in e t
an d
M a n y t e r ms a r e t 1 s e d t o d e s c r i b e t h i s
C a n a da)
l i
p r o c = s s i n c lu d i n g k n o w l e d ge t r a n s a t o n (
d
St a t e s ) ,
i
j
c
t
i m p le m e n t a t i o n a n d d i s s e m i n a t i o n ( n e
d
K
i
an d
n g o m
s c ie n c e
(U n i t e d
a n d i m p l e m e r 1t a t i o n
E u r o p e ) v l c K i bb o n e t a l 2 0 10 1 T h e y s h a r e c o m m o n
k n o
e o l d d e fi n i t i o n o f
c le m e n t s w r ha p s t h e d e c a
f H e a lt h
e d g e t r a n s ia t +o n b y t h c C a n a d i a n I n s t i t u t e s o
t he e x c ha n ge
Re s e a r c h i s a s r c p r e s e n c a t i v = a s a n )
co m
po
n e n
sy n t
he s is
e d ge
d e t h i c a l l!
h n a c o m p l e x
a n
so t tn c
sy st e m
p p li c a t i o n o f
f i n t e r a c ti o n s
k n
a m o n
o
g
t o a c c e l e r a t e t h e c a p t t 1r e o f
r e se a r che r s an d u se r s
h
%
h
b
a
o
r e se rc
t c
c n e
if o r t hc p u b l ic ) t hr o u g h
p r
e
:
f
t i ye se n ic e s a n d
hal
t
h
m o r e
1m p r 0 1 e d
l
h
t
d
h
s
e
m
h
c a r e sy
ea t
( Ca
e n e
u c ts
A n d a s t r e n gt
de
I
i
h
h
Re s e a r c
n st t u t s
d i a n I n s t r t u t e s o f 1t t a h
'
R t c h t r c h t n S a n t t l u C a n a i a 0 0 S)
l v i d e o o r a u d i o c a % c b r t 1r \ Bl J t i o n t L )
p le p Dn t e c
t>t }1nt JIurl t\ r > p r t B1Bt >\ l b >
9 o 1n p ] ( v
m u c h m f )r e
l a t i { n \ (h l 1n B r t t l w
j
a n a e s t h c s t a r j r r c \ u w it a t t o n \ r 1 u
1
7
10
J
2
t
>
Mu
r
r
a
y
1
a
2
7
os e t
> w
w
m
n
h
r
w > m n t anl
L
u
r
r
r
c
n
J o Ho M n g a o n
in m
t
i n \ he
)
i
r
a
i
\
t
c
r
I
r
r
h
a
r
r
h
t
t e
l
in t e r a c t i v i t y w j t
: IH \
t
n
u
t
1
a
l
1
l
l
i
9
n
+
i
t
f
t
r
1
t
f o n n o c m ii r l x ) \ t 4 o r i r r l l (
t
(
l
l
l
1
)
l
\ ll \
1
B
(
r
J m u l tl B( t r u r t 19 r > r n m
k
sim
ca n ta
c t 1s s o n
la t t e r
bo
a c t
Jr
1c
a r c s
iv i t y
dat i
in v o l s t
a n d
ca n
\ o
l tu
h>
t B{ l r 1
( t l
l
t lt
n t r 1l
Bl 1l \ e t Bt 11l
\ t r 1l h
w h i c 11 p n r t 1\ i p Bn ( \
\
t
B) t i t t
l
t
d
I
k
w
o
i
w
n
h
:
}\ a v e
d t e r n t
l
t
l
i
t
i
n
i
t
n
l
}
(
(
t
t
1
1
;
t
n e x t 5 10 p a t i t n t h L v 1 1
n w BH n A hw r n n
1 hc u l l h n a t c o a M
e t Bn . :
t h a t a r c r \ l c v u n t t u t }\ e j r p r l L t l L t h \
au
di t f o
r rn
jn
; 1p p l i t
llJ
11l
t Bi 1K
tw
ll\
l l \ 1w
\ l\t )
1; <\ l t
1>
f r ht i
m
(1n t
H ll y
n \ T t\
j n g i 1 n d i l t t c T a r1 t d u \ a t i o n r v t n t i m
i n c l i n i c a l p r : t c t i c e a m l 1 a t i t t n t
c hu r t * c s
c n c o \ 1+ a g c
h
T i t e n e x t st =t i on o \ Bt l i n u s b o m t o > t t s t
o u t c o ln c
i
t h ; i t he l p t n a b l t ?
e v id e n c e b a s = d l e a r n i n g M r a t c g t ts
t hh p r o c e s s
be f o r e
c t 1r
h h w h n v n t h a t h a h h pr ohssi onas
h
: ewBe r n n t n n w n u n d k n m h H> t h n t a r c n e c e s s i b tc
h m n Hr a t c t l i n t o t h e i r H a c t i c e s a n d t h a t
aM
, nn
\ lm u l t l ht
\ 1p p l ) r t c LI b y a p p r o p r i n t t
\ l t s i r e t l >hl nBt \
l n or cl t r t o
i n c
r > i n >u r \ t \ w11t ( D t v i s t t a l 2 0 0 3 )
h
or
h
h
M
t
umr
nt
s
u
r
r
o
r
e
s
s
e
s
e
a
c
r
n
>
t
hnhngs
w
[T t r 1\ t l 1= [ i e l t l o l k n o w l \ d g c t r a n s n c i o n t u t t a c h e r
o r t o u r s e o r g n n i l u r c a n d r a w t Bp o n t h e r i c h l i t t r a t u r e
o n r o 11 i n d c r s
p r c \ t o c o l s tl n w s h u t ( s Bt n t l n l g o r i t l \ l \ 1s
Re
Bn
l l o p BN l t n t
C ri r r i c u l 1n BB r r [
S t c >i L}N
38
20 0 3
c t al
la t c d
h 1t r
k l \t e 1 \ m r v \ h \ n t
+ i n
)
J l 2 00
L) l i n n e t
J l ( w\
rn
b t\
\\
nn
J
umnh1 W
C RD b h t w n ( h ,
l .
I D c \ i \l B
l . \
C RD
p
m .
CD
t e=
J w
35
a lt c m
o de l
MJ
pr c s e
dc m
A 1J
w u
u u
u w
fu l
tn
(A
ic
tc r
it
w s w
Adv a
s ta n
d a r d ri
n c*
A'
l s
bc dl l
(o r
t' l t t
x a n l
s l BL
es ,
p lc
Sc
n s t
e n a r io
Fu
u t ( o m =s
t'
St
])
r f or
y.
Sc e n a
c n a r o
rl )
pCr
h ke
c n t 1o n \
1n t c n
r at c
u t
l upt t r
in
re n L e
un nt \
t MJ E
ts
(9 )
c in a n
Qe
C L t
OC C
(Mll l tr
In
I u d e n u u mr
N uJ
se n e
t 1H
Su
m m
hn
J>
t n > 1n
u L t 1n \
\ u L a \
i n il t i
o ns
u u [ T1 \ *
i t le
P.
r 1
k 1 l 13 J h , i 5 m t u J = , Th c J J w c w u r n m H > M
h
J
Ur
wr 1l n t \ mr J t m t h t le J r n c r I \ t \ l u r e J 4 l 1
A ,
J rt
n 1 : t i ! a \ J l b hl = i n t l m a
u i ti .\ t
y i m l u d e (H a y \
S. h u w r t h J n d c r Vh u wn 2 3 St OL
e t J r
t
i fo r
o n s t r .l t e
41 n m
HH
h> h n
th
t llll
Kn m
ln t
r > wwn n
K 1n Bw
1 t hn
gh
o n
tatl
M tu
h t r u r l s wS
t x a m
sim u a to rs
cor
i
l ob a l r a t ng s
i t m1
1 a t 1o n
ti
(t
+* i
d 1o i c c
ip lc
r lll a n c
1o
hc e d u c a t i o n a l
sh ll o r J t t tt u de )
ll y
ro u n d
s)
I Tu
ho w
o u p r a 9 t 1s e o r t o
a
t
p ient
Q
y
H o s p i t a l a n d u t h t r r e c o r d s m J ! b e SCa r
c o m e s
l o r +n i p r o v c d m c a s u r e \ f o l l o w 1n g J s t r 1t s o t o u r Ds
d c t r e a s c c o m p ll L J t l u n b
! be A q w
rT, . . dt rn c o n t r u t s
j . Kx J r c e t al 2
o n
h i le
atn e
v e n t 1o n
C r hr
1
,
A
1
2002
Rnhi n5n / M
t 1 H
20 0 (i )
sm J
C\ +
? c
us3
er
h
c
Li _e
H'
ln j [ e
i } e Y l t h J+a r e
cb
N
e
O r
1
a]
ct
J n
t t l t ud
_ .
cn
X *c
T
lls p c r l o
200 1 ,
2009 )
,
( Fl od g r
i al
1cn t
de d by
N . e c l 1) \ \ t h o u t l Bn e p r o \
t h \ c \ J l u a t 1o n o .
r k 1r t 1l c o n
. _
a r c b t 1\ e l y
c l h 19 $ ) t h5 c sU=t st s
s ki
a n y difc
i nn t
J c CL l mt
'
p y
l l o u p l o n g 1t u d i n J l
s t ha t
1 00 3 ) H e r e \ t a p p e a r
hg a t
t
p at ic n s
al
\ en t o
rs e t
c FD = l
w - C FD
. . l
Kn
u t
t e st s
f a ls e
l 1c
tr
u 1n s
ln a n n c (B
munnl en t shl 1ni J c

Abm n
u t, nJ t u c k
1l t
c l g c : n n
t a ( i l 1t a t c t h c t r ,
li st
1<t l o w i s a s h o r t
r
i be
c
d
s
e
h
s w h ic
f
r
h s i c ik n pe r o m
to
ou l os
n no p
t
let o n
cat i onal
' p1mn l vJ J c f ,
So
dt
l
1c t i c c
l"
h h t t h e i r 1+n f
i n Bh 7 h g
l c
he a lt h . A r c m t c o n
h+ m
kn. " l N$e i n t o
C PD
(o
am u c
1 9 {i 7
& W n g 11 t
S l 1a w
>
t 1m 1
h
t n
he o u h o n w
i \ t 1r e
h > 1 1m
1 N K N t ht
nJ
> 1\ > n
l 1m k
\ b l n 1R 1n L I 1 >
i n
J m nhnT
Ahn g
w c n w t
3L
w w H
t n Nt
h> w
1n
lh n
1n
pr e
v c r
pov1Nc
a n J
\t
lt
T h 1\ l a w w p t h t n b w
an s u c h c p n e x c r w n e c
p
o m ts
in
s He r at
in w
\ 11u
n 1p \ t \
l(
hu t hd
gr a l t o
pl
Ta ke
1n n m
dd r e s s t hc
o f Sc t n a n o
n
in
gc M
1n t o
c r
y qucsuon m
u r
ps
d by
r r c
h o u ld h e lp
dc r a m n
:n
d 2
a n
n n u
le dgc
o w
WCor np=cncl cs
l d hk c
w o u
h is
in
a s s 1s t a n c c
ha n k N
ha p t e
ha n Jo hn
m n
B S=
Ac(
D .l v
r e n c e s
Ed u
c a t io n :
ACCt ' Sel J u l l

Ta n
A lle n D
la r ge
F fo
n e r
ll m
c n m
Bo
Cc
li w
Bo
m e n ca n
ht t p
c c e s se
A l &e
1r
Bt r 1l o
A , 1Bn
el
lr
\ l tr d rc
m r \
h e a b %n
l l
o r
f/ c 3
l M
t p r mu
b +m
1
d Ju l l
1r
Ir o
t \ t
dc n
tio n
Ma l r , t mn e
\ la
1n t
1n t c n a n e c
de x
i n
d tc
in e ;
a l la
a s
b le
a
px
C tm
r r r
t l n u 1f 1
Ce
a +n a
Pi rvi ndt x
u r 1
Ca n J d
v
w
he
n n
c n
c e cs
tt r
l und
e t ai s an
p o li
c 1t
SL J t
] h
a t
h a n ge
1< >
f t B1 1n
ht t p
u p h u Cmn
> n w
n n
BW
LJN
l 11L >
l)j
to
to n : s
fc e
t al
ho
ca w
lo
h c }o
u m
T he
r t c n i n j* t
n t
>H
1 t n H h m n
tn
lu n
l : it
v u o n a
a lt
h C t l l a b t t r a t B\ n
l c o n p e wn l
2 0 10
'
kt
Ir
'
W
1t
t \ \ r 1' r l
:)\ 1 l
Br w
m
>u
C mu 3 m
\ l
t a
\ . OmpJt Ld
) n
l Ac9u ra cy o
h ob c n ed
\ \ 1t
l l l t l i nj t j 9
Il II b soc
7 hA
ilw
n e e
in
r l l 1 l w
l Br t l J r 1
l 1
p h\
D \ tL W
H1n.
IH S
/ r 1 B11 I
) t Bt t Bl
. 1 ww mc n t
Bt , r
Jd
hr r lI
tJ
2n w
Tn
o
wo h h t w
J h
j Sv .\ 1t
hh
h u c
l 1l t J t Bc
u 1 r
re
B1 l :
Bt B(
4 5 1 8 8
2 7
in
Br 7
R 1 mm
0 2
n
\
l r L\ M P
1n
Hm
d j r d l A
f m j n
iJ n
J n
IX r
l )
d.
t c n c n m
\ J re
m u
ca t io n
19 9 5
, 1,
>uM
t o n h
A syst t m a t i c
g r nedl t al e d u
; f e l i c t i l
ca n
r t l 1%
> \ \ 1\
p r M Wnn ul W h u w
( ( 1A / Br , B11t 1) d 1 i / 4 J \ :
titi
h t r Lr l Lnn 1 n L c
I 1i n c H N J C M =
11t \ \ \ l 1 1> \
p E Fo
WWT H 2
r rn a n c L
RB
e s
= o n t 1n u l n
1n
J tlL
fo
ln
700 5
nh1 l 1
\ \
x m
1 o l t / 1A
Bq
ll s
Nn n 1 2
>
11
j in a m an
hT m
11 t
Nn
h h l AmBt 1 h
t h l .
h A
I Hh {)
7 27
b h hn
J 1l
20 1
n
o t Br j u 1
pt
f f( x
H a yn
AD
l l l ) mp<t n( A
! r h e t 1 n e r Bc H l M
11
c r In
1 4
1 1n
l ) A lt
MA
m so n
r e l
t r
r i\ >
n \ u r\
l h L 1r t ) 1 1 J H
l / 1 y ( 1[ u l m
1B\ u 32 7 ( 7 4 0 5 ) 3 3 3 5
s, - 1t - J. \ e\ T11ent
1. 1J n
l 1l
\ b
: Jt l t nt \
J n
. H w
rt
1i
0 u r 11{ B
Ja d a d A
c e
h 1f u m
2r
01
JM J
1
o u t i o rn ( \
( a m
t r . 1n c
q 1c
tl c j w
a rn w n a n t >
n w c 1L J
V 2 0 5 7 4 Ht n M
al t\
j sp x
peBahn
u t i t 1o r 1
B Br? l 11
t hc
DA
p h\
h t t p l w w w a hm l u r *
it
f
Ti cLt wed J u l l \
t l c a t 1o n
> , . e t
: 1m l t
1n w
trai
J( J M r 7 a
t s d i e m h Re
SJ n u J u C m
1. H
d h
C a u J l a +t I n
p p
m tu
h J1
1 pu h
l L e1Bf u
In
Re L h e
H w
.l n
T ho
rc \ lc w
0 1l
9a j
n t r at m n
a w n
]o
h(
r t 1r
l lv lt lc s
IL
, Met l 1(
/ l : 5ut t Bt l o11 2 8 2 ( 9 1 8 6 7
C ha n g i n g p hy u
a t:
11 b ! c
m o c
c d 1c a j ] J t 1 o B
m n c d rB
DA
\ 1s
20
A
t lu n
e d u c ]
00 3
occnl f i cat l un A \ a i l a b l e
o r
V Cd K
m B
le t l
f In
o n
t 1o 1i
t r n l 1r n
l t ) L) )
kn
Lrm
bl h a v ] o
DJ
Fa
m a l n ccn a n c e
Bo
n ca n
c e rt i
t n i t c g 1c
1y M d i c t } e 9 ( 3 ) 19 8
t i 11 f
MA
t o n
J > 1\
t il l
[ \
rn
l r 1i
o ll
li
l 1 c c s f o
st \ c n
h 1 2 0 13
a r c
po
h t o l u g\ l 1
C II
L1 m p l c \
irrl l n
%c 5 t l L ) n f L i r F5 m t l \ Phwc 1a ns A \
r t l
ht t p s
M
a r
lc
g I \ t we
\ o
\ 1t 1 I n
8 4
ra
c t a l Im p ac t
r e t r T1n n t t c N
Do
nl
dl
t
al
1 t 1n u l n g
e d t Bc a t i o n
h
d
a n
o t
t r
w o r k \ ho p f
r c ) Un d
r (. N c u
f t 11e
D
s 1n
c n t
h e s 1 m p l t t L1
4 (4 ) Z h z 2 6
e n =a n
p h)
u tx
n n a
lt s
m su
t l L) n I I
ra
m Ca Me s
i v c s ) T h c
sa v e
i Bi Bu l s
U l l r 1e
(11 I
J
n tu
Am
2
D
l\
C o l 1n ( i l t u r C o n t l n u +n g M c t l ] L a l
A > a l l a h l t a t hur l , m i l l 1 e c m e
CME
r ve n u o n
L c +n
d l t a t 10
re
tt
h v hh
Re l e
Ca
e n cs
in
> w w
. b h 12 1u p d f A c e c s s c d
h 1 2 0 13
arA
D a v is D
A Ckn
n v a Ha b h a t
vo r
c HC
c o n n
>
t te
>m
m H m n w
I l r B+ \
F o x RD
hlan
N f l i r L i t
Lm
p E, pu
n aru an
n [ t 1g
t s
tn
c l 1d B. g i l 1g
Rw
am
f Pl By s i c i e n 5
d n1
N o 2 90 0 2
I ' r c r t i c e C e n t e n BBi 1f h r C o 1f r a c r
0 6 Ro L k v i l l c
0
7
1
i
0
N
o
r
1
Mb
/ t l Bq P Bt b1Br a t t o
_} 8
N c w Yo r k ,
1t
G o l d m a n J e us c r J , L a w r i e L ,
c o l l a b o r a t i o n i n f a m 11y h c a l t }1
O n t a r 1o b J s c d s t \ 1d y 1 C t 1Bm t 1i a
,
l I n t c r p r o fe s s i o n a l
c t a :
te
\ m s
Fa
l Bl
i l y p l By s i c i l Bn
d
in g n e e d s a ss e s s m e n t a ss e s s i n g t hc n e e
B r i r i s l B Jc d i e a BJo 1 r T l a l 3 2 4 (7 33 0 ) 1 56 1 5 9 , 2 0 0 2
H ay s RB D a v
fo m
p h y: s\ c
HA
Bt
a r
M t di
d JD
al:
m c t l\ o t l s
1 EB 1u c
c t
Bt i o r 1
c x
pc
3 6 ( 10 ) 9 10 9 1 7
l t h C a n a d a l n t c r p r o h s s t o n a l c o l l a bo r a t i o n :
l h= s ss s / h hr r hs /
a > 1 l a b l c a t h t t p r l n n e h c s ( g c c a
J u l y 9 20 1 1
d
r
h
Accm
su at c
p 3 , md c x n g p p
d v e lo p m e n t
l
H m s Y n \ I G A t h e o n t u s c d f 1c u t y e
e l t c t r w
c
t 1 t l ?l l C
s
l
r
t
o
J
c
u
X
f
c l 1n 1 c a n
st rt u t e
f M
A B
n r
hl o
Ed u
I n t w c ma J
: sc i e n
A
b
a t
re w
Ts
fr
c e d b a
r mu n
F , l Bl e t B t r u
I lu u
T AT h
:m
n n o
1tj l
r t i B1Bt
,
u1
j r 1
u rc H
rt
/ td
'
u ca t io n
p r ( 1 > \ 1onJl 1
1u
Lq
ln
l le u
r 1i B1 B
Fr o n
l , i 1 i I Bn
1 t l Bf (
n w
t Bf l B i 1l
I ' hn c
Ba r s
t o n +
Re s e a
r c
n e
Pr a
to
rm Jn
i\ :
B( r
in
f
e
1 o
di t o r s
; 0 0 3 AH U
ct tce
D E J r G r e e n J S G a l l 1s H A Ac } Umn d e r e ( i
a n d 1m
pr o\ t o u t c o m e s i n t ( t 1 n p b w
u
h t l e a r r u n g c 1 c s
il a s\ l ssm e n t t h r o u g o u
I u c 1 1 u m i n t H e a h A
E
C
o n t 1r u n g
1l o j
{m
R A
an
P r o t H 1 o r
h c t J M A h m H
\ J t l L t \ n
l le .
J m
R :1 m
15 2 0 0 l
2 " 11 ) l
PM
The
c
d 11c
Ah M Ne
l l An e d I h v m
'
N n
H
\ e
1u
t t e B 1r l , t ' r t 1r e\ l L' Li 2 11 1 4 9 5
t c r J Ct t
n h e d the t c ps
H w n
1\
ll
m
L , hu
l n l \ \ 1l n \ > n t
Hnw A
hw
57 0
BBt n m
lo
\ ha ne
u r m
lo n
l m
8 2
n u
at
l j BBj
\n
\ l n nn * nt
l Y Me h mB
lh \ t h n \ a n / \ 1 S \ l \ b \ l d G : l v \ l u J t \ n g m h c a l 1r a n d
m u n m h u n u Bl U
f m Bn n u Bn K 1 h a mu m m BAt
"
l I , Bl h p 1 o j t s \ B(.1 r L\ 2 2 (2 ) : 7 7 8 3 2 0 0
Bu y a l C o l l t g c o l p h ) % l c 1a n \ a n d S\ 1r g > o t \ 7 \ \ : C a n J i
l
M i n \ t n l n c c \ \ t 9 > r t l l ie \ t l \ n r u r d t \ 1 A r \ i l 1 b r
,
( Pu 1\ Br l J y t l B ) h 1u I l u 1}k n u EB 1t 1t
B E Fo x R
1 D e t el-
1 t J n , 1 W\ ) n RW N c t
i
l
1 l
) { ( u l t i B 1 Bw m i l e f B r B r t Bt o 1r
SS D u
docl opment
lt s
I \ \ 1r l
h m n l> n n N u u 1 n d
'
i l 1 t Ar 1l r Bt Bh I i l J/ . \ t o r 1\
ll > n h h h n
BT
o u t c o m e s c v a lu a t t o n
n a
Bf 1r H B
l {B\ u1f r\ e 1) r
k fo
ss to
t Br z 1 i Br g P r o l e w
t h mJ J l J l v
d >
r r r n 1M
g p
t \\
ra
n D a n
o o re
Mr r
h ru l
fc
s tcl a n s
hn
l 1 1Bu
lrW G
t 1 u \
tlt
la n s
e \v o r
ro
u 1n
aw a l > H> w
LWKc t 9 N h
o f c u 11l i t j t 1 Bl B#
19 U 2
3
hb
W H
m 1
ff c
c o n tl n
Pr e
c o l BB b o r a t n e E x p e r t p B n c
l
c 1 e s f o r m t c r p r o f t s s 1o n a
a
W rt o: an C\ & Tt p nel
10 2 4 2 1P E C F u l l w
M
ar ch 1 20 )3
/ KCe / d
D E A fr a m
c es
p o r
th(
P. 1y
c a t i o n
20 1 1 r c e o m p c t e n
cor 1abor aue p r a c t i C e
f h e a l t h p r o f e s s t o n a \ s ] OUr nal o f
e l t1( 1 i t t o n t n t h e h e ( i l i h p r o / e s s t m
o rc
Phy s \ c
o r Bt 1 r l m r 1g
Th t C o n
d+c 1n e : R r l t n T n g F 1n B1 l t m n c a
c T Tr 1 r = $o T T n t ?\ g p n > e 1 1 t t o 1\ C a r t
R t 5 t 1 r c 1 W a s h i n gt o n D C 2 0 1 1
a u
2 3 ( 2 ) 10 9 1 1 5 2 0 0 3
1 x
Xa t ml d e my
tc n
e l t 1c a t t o n
7 5 (5 ) 4 9 9 5 0 1 2 0 0 0
ln
ea
At 1
P^
d 1c a l c d u c a t r o n f o r w h a t ?
M 1l l t r G I C o n t i n u i n g m t
4
2
4
i
1
n
(
) : 3 2 0 3 2 6 19 6 7
u
r
M e r l t r B1 E t t t r c B
K ) : E v a l u a t 1o n o f a n
M t l l r RG Ju h a r 1<11 G e t z
f o r t h e c o n t ] n u 1n g
o n se s y s t e m
d
t c r e s
200 2
H
] o l Bn B1 B
20 0 6
n c n cc
s c le c t l n g
fo r
f t )n n t 1m b c r i l n d l r e q u c
n
y
t o k 11 o w l e d g ( : t r a n s l a t t o n
>
n t
a sse ssn w
i a n e c
u n s
stu d
k1 N L
in
l t c mw l s u s d t o r e f e r
a
fe w e r o f
i n 20 0 6 : a
Bo d y o F h c a 1t 11 11t t r ; l t ur c
Sc 1 1[ c 5 1 (i 2 0 10
l <a l e l ' 1Bt 1p l r n l n l t B1 1o 11
G o l d m a n J Rc v c \ S : F a r n 1l y he a l t
M c \ 1 s ?r J B r a n
h
C a n a d i a n \ n t c r p r o l e s s l o n a l 1n 1t l a t l v e
t c a n 1s : a n c w
1nrerproltss1oln1l C a r e 2 0 (4 ) 4 3 6 4 3 8
l
ie s
pe
n \
d s S Pa r t r i d ge K J 1t Bh h
Bd B Pa l o
t + r r f BBg A D Bd g 1 o s t i c / l p p r o t
tc
W 1l 9 i cy
a m
G r e e n LW K r m
E d u c c Bt i o n Pj
1 o kkc
KA
s c c t lo n a
c r o ss
a n
5 6 3 6 8 3 7 4 , 20 10
G ran t J h
M c K ib b o
Co
h t t p :/ / v > w
m c m b c n il
y a l c o l l c gc
r o
m m
=a
/ po
d M
c c e s se
t a l/ p r g e / p o
h 1 2 0 13
a r c
tn
l/
rc
rt
sl m u
h Lw
b t io
in
n s
V le u
c r
C P: T h c
e n t
a sse ss m
Su p p l l (i 5 T I
te
thc o
u s\
a r
lin ic a l
i c a l E e1t t c e t t i o n 3 ?
ed
2003
Sc o l c s PV H a \ e k i n
c l 1n i c a l s k i l l s \ n
u c a
sse s sm e n t
r 1r r m
Je
Sh o j a n i a K G
o
o n
e w
)r
n n 1n
j,
t 1l e
\ l a y ht
gs
p1 nt
w re c n
1 9 t 7 \ l c G
ca r t
A l e 4 B: i I r
r m
r e m
e H 1 n
T hc
i n de
e r
\n
t Uc
s 1-
1 Ra t h D
t e r am
SOUt h e L
pe r f-
Ir
H
e
\ l1h
r
a v s
su
o m
fo r m
g thc
l le c t u
re
m o re
1 5 (3 ) 6 S 20 0 2
RB X
o ra n 1
d5 r d s f o
m r
et
l : Se m
d 1c a l p r a c t
nccts
r s
a n
c-
f 5j
St c i n
Y S n c l L S : I n
=rt
in
c r e a s in
e e
g p
a r t ic
k m e d ic a t e d u c a i io n
ice : a
c r ac
t iv
le c t u r in g:
t ra t
i n la r g e gr o u p p r e s e
1 ( 1) : 3 7 4 2
fo r
gi e s
t a t io n s ,
19 9 9
S t r a u s S E T c t r o c J G r a h a m I : D c %n i n g k n o w l e d g e
t r a n s l a t i o n , C a i 1a r 1ia n M d i c a l s o c i a t i o n l o 1-
US
Depar t ment
20 0 9
t,
io n
E i 1 1 l c B c u
o n
b1s e
St u t l r e s
e r e
ha
\m
p Bc t
P r a
e v e
lo p m
t ic e s i r1 O
en t
r 1 t r 1e
f Pla n n in g
E c a t 1u 1 t i o n
t
ea m
ly s i s a n d R 1d e u o O r l i r w L e a
W a s h l n g t o T 1 D C 2 0 110
an
le y K S t e v
base d
e n
O f %c e
f Edu c a t i o n
na
Z a ba T S H
s k i ll s
a n d po li c y D
1l
Cou
g
i p a t io
l i c a 1 Ta c he r
Ev a l u
C o c l Br t 1n e D a
u u t c t\ m e s o f c a r e
R m e u 3 C 1X )0 10 9 6 D O ] :
10 10 0 2 1 l S 5 S C D 0 0 10 9 6 p u b 1 2 0 0 9
pro
o
4 1
en t
w o r
14 i 0
e t a l:
c\ nl put cr
l de v e lo p m
n b c r i u s RG
m e
g h t Jh l : Sr
1e s
cw o r
n a
S i lv e r L 2 0 0 1 G u i d e l i n e s f o r c o n d u c t i n g
k s h o p s A v a i l a b l e a t h t t p / l m w s i u m e d E l u /
Do c
r e s a f Fa i r s l d o c t 1m c n t s / c o n d u c t i n g w o t s h o p s
A c e c s s c d Ju l y 9 2 0 1 1
d i c a l p r a c t i c e , . r 00m1t o
E
i
i
l
r
B
c
C o 1t m r n g d B
1o r 1 i n t h t + H e t 1 l t h P r o l s s o l 1s
0
0
2
2
1
1
8
9
03
3
23 ( ) :
Sha w h TE m
l fr a m
18 1 (3 4 ) 16 5 ] 6 8
RE L a D
r c t ic a
t in u in g p r o fe ss io
3 5 ( 5 ) : 4 7 4 4 8 1 20 0 1
Sc h i j n D E , 1i t u Bt t 1Bg r l u R ( T e c t l t l ( 1' r d c i i o n e r To w
l i t Bc h i n g t 1l t 1 L e e r r 1 i t 1g i n r i re
e1 N 14 D e s i g r 1 f o r
P r o l . s s i o r L: S a n I r a n c l s c o 19 9 0 J o s s e y B a s s
Sc h u m
n ce
lrn
se m
in a rs
tcla n s
pr
e n s
D L
L\ t h
st a n
c c n t io n
e t a
Ed u
in g
i n t e r a c t iv e
da r di z e d p a u
1 M
e a su
s k i ll s
F. r 1m
C HI E p r o g r a m
20 10
r 1s e l 1n g 80 (2 ) : 2 4 8 2 5 2
o
l Ca n
in g A
e n t s
r 1n
g t he
c i 1 r l o 11 a n
IL
C ha p t e r
t
U
Cu
r n c tB t n n
pr e p a r in g to
Se c t i o 1t
e 1 e /o p m e n
tB
l
e n e ra
pn
p lc
l p r a c t ic e
ui r l B r i g l : b l o o d 11r e s s B r e
u ) o r l t 1l 1
4l
i t h t l Pr
( Br 1t 1 d
itl
1
Iu
x Bi r r r r
d
t
1
a
i
1
t
1= a c a e f Bt u p o p 1 r B i t / t c l Be i l i n / c t o 1t s
Yo t t 1u BL e
1 n
u 1 t A u p o s . l b1p s t o m a c / 1 c t u 1c e r
f n j t r t d a p a i n f u l s 1i o u 1i l e r o i 11 f a n d c r r r t r 1 g i 1 1 n
u r g t 111 Ao s p i t a l i l d l r r i : s i o n
T kt 1o o r o p er u a r 1d 12 y t J r o l d / 1n d r e u c o r n e s
17
In
IB
ss i o n
(1
co m to r
1\ Ti n
zn
f j
o u t
t 1 d
a m
r s t j o i t Be t 1 y o t r t ii t h 1< u r l 1m B w t Bs
/ 1e
o l c o 11 t r a l 1l h 1 r l r l t o r r l n c B11\ u / t r e
l y
a n t
r a n 1
o u r
h m
r t h ng
e f Bh 1Bo : t J t r t B t g Ar
/ B e
/ Aa 1 l s P e n
\ 1l m
f r ht
b o B1 r
eB
d J u
h 1.
1 1n j r
1/ 1
snt 1ht r1g
r ea
I J 1l
Jed
in
r ma r
h c a l t hc a r L
h Bn
Wu r
r l l 11> (
r c d u e h = JM H
a n
lt y
1R
f ge
d t he q t ]u
s n i Bt t \
11t l u
r tl
( u
t n
ha n
c(
d by
H l dc
7
l Ju u t l Tl l t t I 11l
Bl h l 1 t t l t r : AL / 1l t B ,
$ d 1 1 }
II=
h h
w
ic
Is i
m an a e r
g nm t
q
'
I JI . B
\w \
y t B5e
ye
h o s p it a l
pet
ctT
t in g,
dic a l
r Bt * 1r t B
r f
}l u
\bu
1v
se t
l y
s p e c ia t
m e
G e r w r pr aLt j
t
/ Bi
1t l
po se s
f h o l is t i c
> e c . ba n
l l y l .a
i1
Jr
1i * Bt t \
l t rt e r
11l ) n r l i l / 1 B
A j 1f r ( B/ h t / B U
Ih
n B
15 l
Tl r 14
1 B
Bc ( 1 r l u n
b
l
15
t
u
t
u
a
Ju l t o l
r ay
d
b
l
c
l
j . 1l Be
w r e e n s e r
a
c o l 1g
t ice
b a St ( p r c v e n t a t l v e c a r e t c a m w o r k a n d n 1 3 n a gc ? l d
a l l f a c i l i t a t e d by e x c e l l e n t c o m
mm
adm t m st r a t io n
l i n i c a l s ki l ls
, l U P TO d a t e c
W i t h 1n s u c h a c o m p l e x a r t n a i t i s h a r d l y s u
T q
l d a t i o n s u r r o u n d i n g ge n e r a l
t h a t t hc m e d ic a e u c
p
i
i %c a n t a n d d r f f e r e n t c
t i c e ha s t a ke n m a n y s g n
w
b s t :c w y c a r s ; s o m e o f i t s i n n o a t \ o r $ } W
o v t r t ht
t
f o r m t d t h e b a s i s o f s t a n d a r d e d u c a t i o n a l p r a ed e c u d
G p e d u c a t o r s h a l e p l a y e d a s i g n 1fi c a n t p J r t i n heal
l r e fo r m
( a r e t du c at ro n a
T h i s c h a p t e r w i l l b D n g t o t h e r e a d e r s n o t i c e s w
t hJ t ha e o c c u r r e d i n
c h T n gt
n c w
\ >f t h c
t eh
l t ' ar mn a n t i J u c MT 1 1 t n t i n g e n e r a l p r a a 1 c e C, W
I s g l \ c n t o t he f . c t t h l t t h e r e a r e r n J n \ \ m
\ J n e
m o s t o 0 w h5 t a F p e m
u c %m t 1( n
m tb
t 1u m
u t 1t \
l
1
L
K
\ t ht
Hone\
er
l
l
l
m
m
e
t
L
H
r
w
i
a
t
r
r * Bn n
J
e
.
r p !
p
b
h
l
b
t
c
l
5
r
n
r
c
n
r
J
l
T
r
1
t
.\h 5 r v
\ ho \ 1 \
pr t l s
g
g
p p
\ L 1 t h 1n
n h 1c h t h e r L t 1a
( 0 t hc e \ u n t F
h : ' c 1h \
t h a t L o L I n t r v b J e fin l t l o n a n d t h
K L u r\
rL hn e \l h
'
'
c o m
rm x t u r e
/j BJr. Bcq.+j $A-0j 0j0: ; 1x'

c t Bo n
ac
T G i bbs
co n i
lt
pr
tn
r ar
g e r 1e
u r
n n BBl n
klu
1>
B: t
trtt
rn
I P r I \ l l \ t 1) 1U H
l r t ) rn l ' r u l t w
a bm t
n t r I
l
J
lr
u r
rN
hu h q u $ t
1l
} : > n r l 1l
n n n
tt l
hn hh
in
h>
t h 1\
I [ 4 h l a 1 1
t 1t r r i t n l
,
k . n g w n c r a l p r J 9 t n h n r r G E a n J p n t P e h n t
UK
o l c h e I( u y a l C o l l t g e t ) t G t n t r u l Pr 1C t i t i u n r h
Bn
1w
rB
J Ho
I J
t 1
mr1n1u11B
TL t l \ t
111
u n
l p r a L t i c e J M t r o w i t U\ T\
r t udt r u r 1 r c ti l r L d t u t h e
1h n w w > a h h n m i n t
c n d
p
Re
n tT a
ilt
sto m
in
l i l I"
A \n
l 1r \ \ h p e r
i,Brtl,rr."hnl1.tattbi'v
h>
t L v c
\\
tu
m L n t
kw k
u
a t M HN C
B gc n
c r5l
"
4 d
\, t h c
Pr e p a r i n g f o r g e n e r a l p r a c t i c e
hK h h a w i n
h t t \ L hm g
w rt
In
ht
A n dr e w
>e o p l e s
t u n 1( c
u n L n
t t l 1<
L l
r m n
im
R t hc
he
Mh y
sp u c
L u \ 1
It
t he
st d
i l
Pr u l c
i \
b u t ld r n #
lo
1 l Bo r d
n ( 1t
dw
sso r
:
o
u n
mA' dl t al
a
r
( Jr c
T h h h u C h n g hnaH h u l k i n
7
H
p r o h r h ly t hc
%r s t c h n n p hT 0 1 m n w t h i n g m n m a <w n c r H ma
p 1c e
I n l t s A 1 l v d e L T 1p t 1o n u l l 1 r o 7 t h
s u r gc r
c rt w as
p
p
a ngnr hean p a r a g r 5 p h n
w h n h >r o l c v m r
h un an
h w hh g h w d t h c u n p m n t I n d n c e d l o r t c m h
1n
b. \ \ At l
t ht
e
Lo m m u m t \
o r
de r
to
g1
ht
in t o
r >
t l 1c
1n
e l r\
hi n
w 1
hc
a n
bt11l tl l n
1n
u u L t o h
t w l \ 1t t 1r t a n I n x l h (
u t
g
t a n n p l u r 1 11 1 t r u l h l t
!
al t t nn$
l rY
v d 1!
\ \ l i n \ t l t u t \ o n l u l n i
n J t( d
r c a l 1t l c s u
s t a [ e r 11e n
CUC4 t 1 on
SOmt wh. l t b t A r
1r
g r a d u lJ lw d
du ! 4 n \ t ge n
ho
1n
\ [
lm t
l pr
e ra
k
1L
S and
ke n z w
1c t 1 L t
. l . 1b\t ut ' ncl \ i n

de\ c1L& d a n J B c u l t t h \
,
t ic e
1h
B& \
ill
h u i l t f Li r
r e t
l I )r
u f
t hc lu tu r c
d 1n w r n a u o n a l
R 1L h 1 r d Sc o t t
Tn
t lim t
hl n
BF c
1n
1 d m b \ 1r g b
1n
u n e
hn
W a
lm
hin
t e 1c
h }4 e
n s c lr \
n t r J
hL
In
l pr
1c
s lm e
h a t t h e X J t 1 o n 1 l H t a l t h Se R c L w a s f u r m c d
( 1 4 1 0 t t a l . \ A1&n> t h e h r s t a ( a d t r n l c I )t part
n l c n c o t G e
e r J l P r a t l L c i n 19 d 1n d L \
tntt1JII! t o o k
l d n r s t & \ t o t Pr o Bc \ o r o : GL' nt r Jl P r a c
u p t ht w
t t c 1n l l t 3
T Hd R n A! COl l t . eof G
( n( JPr J_t 1t l t ' n>n( : BcGI )
ye
a r
L1
'
u a s
m ze
f ou n d e d
j C o l it T e
t } 1> s u
o
pm
b ;>
e r t
SL O t l Y n
ct
t1
J r
in
lr> L
'
h d
t h > h r s Nh J } l
r m
h t S Pt 1J l t \ ) } i t nt ' rJl > r J
w a
TL ) t
hr(
J r Bd
> r
t JZ
pb
<(
jj L :
1n
SP=
t i l t.
> t
1n
1t \
W J I{
J 1r 1
:o r a c o r n h i n a o n or s kM s a n d i n t e r e s t s
aru n a
l
l
c
m e dia do c t o r )
t
s u r ge o n
(
o c c u p a t i o n a l he a l t h
de v c l o p m u n t a n d a c c r c d l t a t i o n o : s p e c i a l
a n d t ht
h
1r l t c r e s t s
w hi c h
c n ha n e c
p a t i e n t c a r e ( G Ps w i t
a n
po
17 7( i
J \
1r r o w
ho
to
=hnhur gh BK
in
cv
u n
e 1r l v
a \
> h wn mr
o
d lc
L 1K
hh ho
w r
an
T\
1t b
lu
t\ l t .
Jt l,n
t l\
1n l 1 r i
Gast r oent er oog; gynaecol og
l o gy )
b r o u ght a n m v
d p o t e n u a uy a n
t n l 1a n t c d \ c r v t e c
h u t a l c o )\ a v m a d e 1 t o n e o t h e
T hr s
n m 1 p o t r n u a ll y v a r w d spcci Ykhs i n h r a h h c a r c
k at
l
o
o
v a r in u o n a k o r c a a
o
t
n
n
u
y
gr M c r o ppo r r
d
res
u
c
o
e
t ht
t
l t a r n l n a n l a s s e 5 s m c n
t > n t hi n g
pr
t
f
i
n g
c
w l t h l n t he \
p c c i a l t y c r c a t n p o p p o r t u n 1t y o r e x i
h
c t l u L u t m n a ] i n n o v a L] o n s a n d c d u ( a t ] o n a l r e s e a r c
T he s e
pc r w
c e
ha n ge s
rc t c n t c
v c
n o
ony h a v e
l p
ge n e r a
cu cc
a n
F r u r n a n I n t e r n a t i o n a l }x . r s p > ( t l \ e m a r t y c o u n t r i e s
h a v e a d o p t e d t h s p e ( l a i t y o f g e n e r a i p r a c t 1c e
F r c q u t n t l y k n o w n a s l a Jn 1 l y p r a c t 1 c e t h i s b r a n c h o f
h a k )1c a r e n w
f o l l o w s m a n i d 1f f , r c n t p a t t t r n s e a c h
d
c a r r y i n g 1t s o w n t r a i n i n g p r o g r a m m r s a s s e s s m e n t a n
a c c r d 1t a t 1o n m o d e l s a n d p l a 9 e w t h l n t h e h l e r a r ( h 1c a l
d l c l n c a n d h e a l t h c a r e p r o \ u 1o n N o t a l 1
X ot
d
m
m o
t l s p r n v t d c i n e r s l t y o f ht al t hcar e
t he
o
r
s
e
h
c
a l p r o \ 1d c
l
l
v
s
e
m
\
e n st c
c o m p rc
e q u a
M
a
n y
r c c o g n 1t 1o n o f R
t nArJl p r a c t i c e a s a sFec)J1t
J
r
p
f
r
a
c o u n t n t \ f o 1] o \ > t h e 1 n \ t T s E t a r e t a l l o
ge n c
i
h
f
t
:
e
}d
hc n A t r o m
t iL e
t h n t c i t l n t r c s t hJ t w o u
f
n
a L I \ a n t 1. t s
e t tA cm
en*r, 1l p RJ c T l c c a r e o t e
L\ t
t }\ A). t h t h J \ A J Fin \ d r l v d t \ l o p c d o r a b s e n t s s t e m
4 n r rul f r a n c
w o r
ld
m c
t he
l dt \ \ l
nt c cs t s
p h t l 1a l m
1 r1
spcci al
o
r >
tl
4 t
r > rn J tn > J t
h e c 1K
n >
n lte
l> l\
1l \ , \
he he a r t
tJte
u 1\ \
1e
t nncr ) l Pr JLT1CC
l Au
I n
t rJ
V 1
\ s 1J
ha r J n
o r
to
b > J: l \
u <u J
t lu
fl
t l tr
1n
1J
l B , 1 1 f Bd
o l j }: 1
bh
l rt t l r
1t
l j
1 <l l l \ 1
lu
\ i
1 1
11\1tBy11i 1i
1l
w n e
tw
l r i 11 \
l 1l
1P
H 4g h
1
e
/h
\ \
N
h l t wn t
r mr \ nnwnt
1 n m l eh
h J L11 n U n H h m H 1nd p , n t 1uh o p r m t mont Bq i 1n t l
L un t r 1 t l
N r u m H Ne t h a l St n r L t Bq d1t l r t nt p n
t e m \ t ) 1 t t a n n \ u r k (w o u p p r J L t l L e
)w Tl t h L t n t r r \ )
* e 1 ) w J p )1i L Bl \ i r 1 \ t l u 11 ( r u r J l a n d I n n t T \ 1t ) p r \ L t l L t ) ;
u
I n
l B: l l \ l B 1
1 \
m o re
Mn L a
UK
h,
c Jn A w
F
n e l
in
i tA
lm
a t itm
nn
'
ht h t m i n i 1l t l u t u l l n
] t ) 3 ) p l m e t l g r c 1t
B
n t
1i nBBorr(l BB 3 D ( B{ Bp r a
e1npha\ 1
po
t\
ht
(G a l e
n t c \\
b c\ t h
u n
a
d e r g r a du
it y
co m m u n
te
c u rn cu a
(c o n m
t in g
s e t
t o t c 1c h
d ic a l
m e
y ba s e d
ru n it
it hin
(h l u r r 1 y
n la n n t r
1 ] '
a kc l \ r
c t
G ' s
c n t
c n v 1r o n m
ho s p i t a l
i \ l c a t io n )
ffc c t iv c
rn
du
CC
c a t io n
/i j/ 1UX
a l rv r p s
m c
"
''
fh c a
n ce c /
Sc r
se m
i a l c ] C a n
p ,n
' "
s ho t
a 1 J
ru
+/(-+#^/|xxc=' , . '
Ob w e l l a s o B h o s p t t a B b a b c
ec s
ho l i st i c
con) munr l >
dc
. .
c m
W h e n t hc G
his do c u
m e n t
ga r d i n g
he
ex pand
ts
cLs c
c lu d e
bc
t o
1n
in
to
p la c e m e n
v c r s t t )
c o n t c x t u a l 1z c
hc
the
\ \ r dc r
ble
to
c a
ty
c o m m u m
hc
y pb
c o m m u r ut
l M c d l c a l C o u n c i l (G M C ) r c v 1se d
20 0 3 a n d 2 0 { 19 t h c t r s t a t e m e n t
b y u n n e r s 1t 1c s
o l ge n e r a l p r a c t l 9 t
e n e ra
n e t
pt u
re
d to
an
fo
ts
ce m m
ly
ca r
h e d m
l s t u
he
u se
c t n 1c a
e x
H ahh jc k
3
W
FL
C
3
J
c' . ' ps
P i
C G f
c
rn
f d
'
Ff 1
r,
v p
, l
CC
u e T
dc
lr c
ts t o
o su r e
1+1F
co
a
1
\ b
he
lt
$ a r e iu
l t h e s e d i r e c t 1\
t hc
c s
r ru
r 1t
jo
n r
lt a
h o o ls i n t h c U K u w g n e r B l p r a ( t l 9 c t o w e J t ]) fa ( t lB
t a t e s t u d m t ] c a r n 1n g A n d c o m p a r a t t + c r n o d e l \ > 1 1 \ t
i n u n d c r g r a d u J t c e d u c a t 1 u n t hr oul \ uu t t 1e w u r l d
p la c e d
v i Bt
h Jn
p r o g r a mme
co u n
tn cs
t ic e a n
in
d t he
stJ
d Bn r c J
I\ W t
GP )
c u m m u n Jt
at
r c
o r
ly
1 ci nc
t a n t to
Bn t
rc i iw
be
y i . Bo \ p 1t J 1 I l a s
r n Rt r n a
I n
t 1w
n ( ( c s\ ar
hc
ex
r ri c a n
y fo
ha t
t w
d t9 a ]
t
d lm
pc
d(
t\ J w
ho o l t
n r r a
w o
t 1
t \ bJ t \ l ] t
r t t a c B1t n
I IK
1
J u r \t
d lc a r m n g
a J1
19 9 9 )
m c
I n
dm
n c
le a r n
In
hc c onmunt y
Wur r a c t J
c l i n i c a l v i 1l l s
pn ]u
in
an
a pp r u
pru
ht
1t l .
tJte
h e
In t
t]
rrc
s tt1
::
BG
BB+1Bi 1t \
tru r
>
t u u
Kr
i , l t 1r t
r\ m
n 1 J
lt n
ar)
ed
\r
tua
1n c
d r\ a l
1hn w
br
L o rn rn u
BL\
lt
'
\ L t 1Bu
r
g t h{
1n u 1r
rw
Is
T 1= H
r 1\ u
& Le e de
Ck
he
l Fr at 1 c
i1t
19 9 6
lc a r n c r
he n c e
n t w
( n \ 1r o n m e n
u n
t\
h5
t\
ht
p " p u l 1t
11 1\ l
e r a
hm
t ac
c n ts
lt
} e t
< L L 1H
Rn L
l
ltu
r ) r \\ u 1 t >
L L\
\ .
\t
M u n \t
r 1, u
L u i
t l 1e
lu
<s \ \ 1 Lt 1L h i n g I n \ { l c a m 1
w
h t ( P . . t t 1w t l 1\ u r c T h e ( o 1n
i l l e 1 l e m \ m n 111 e n t BL \ r \ t u l n t
. To
. c
1\ l i
tt
In
t l
1t
tl > \
".
\t
\ \
>
ll n
\ n \ l 1l
he
h,
n r
th > n
l L B\ a n t a
Tt l c n
h[ , tt\ l.
l \ 1i 11 A n l 1 1n L t
g 1e t
I .'
l\ i\ \\
t l
u_
ll l b , \ 1 A t 1u
L u r
( i r e t T1
r\ t
x p er r e
11 \ t t l r m
1n
1n
.n t
p o r cu
uT
n A w
In
ho
t J r\
ir n 9
lu
l L 1l e \
\ t l
in
11 u
1t Jrmng i l l u
t )n n 1
tu rr
r\ tl \
l \ 1 1\ l l l t
b \ rH
ge n
fo
u tc
hn1c al
\ > \ L
l l l t ) l r\ r
t ; t
. \
p p r L \p r
o n t
t c n t ss
I\
\ p
tl
a
1n
I 1 r i 1t
1t 1\
11t s
b r o ( B, i r a n g e o 5 l 1 t Bm t n g
B 1 1 \ Cr ( Ue r e m t \ t l n e n t t o Pr
l
f 5 p t n f l h \ { B h o 1LS
l
u
c s
> 1
tm
r rr
tlln
r L
l l rt
ir e
1b
t t
p :
t
y \
n t n
hrn
\ ld e \
I> J
l prJt
t ) Bm
k t bt
m B
1 1u
pW r
bie c t l v
n m f 1l t
h i n t he ( u l t l m u m t ) u n d a 9 c c s w d h
y a n d t l 1r u \ Jg il
I t Bl a \ l x T n d e u t t m s t r a t e d 1l u t s t d
u
e n t s c n 1cam
h n M
i 1m
t J 1 c 1n t B1e
ila t w
h e ( o 1 nr n t 1mt
fr o m
j %c a lly
a 111o r 1g n Br
c u m m u m ty o
spe c
p a t 1e n t s
u
hc
i t 1s i m
t Bmi ng m
c
Draw
\ a r 1e s
st u
c1
{
( JPt ur <
u r] en
sc
Ai t hought he xT( Cnt aco t 1me( ha(
\ \ c r e
w tt
te
c r ea
a tr
HaA
\l (
l 1 1i B t g r
u 1r
re
h o p r o p o s e d t ha t
m e s ca n
o n s
): e r
o PPo T Tl B \ \ t t e S
19 9 6
p r o gr a m
f B1l r1e s s
r > e n t Bo 11 o
pr
ur hf t
m o
'
t hes e
o u n o
4 a 1
$c
he i r
k n o u l 4g e s ; l 1t s i m { l
t l 1 u /Bo l t n Bn g e
u n c 1 r s r B J1 { l 1 1r g o f
a r t Bt t t d e s
l h e u t o r 1 t r Bg s o l / Be e l f l 1 a n t i
o { I1t l 11/1 Bl b t e s s r n t t
d e e n 1h e u n d{ r J t BBn 11j n g o l s o c i a l
s o c u t l 5e n l c es
f l t c e 1 1u t 1 t l o 11 i r 1i t
i
f
a 1 t J e 1 1> r o n 11t t t n r er j , Bc l o r 5 o
r s r h&+ c
pc
m c
tc
o n t n
p p r op n
Bl e p n
q r\ o + p l a ts
d Le c dc r
an
u I o RE t 1
a 1d a t d
to
c o m m u m t)
gr a p h l c
d=n
w as
c o m m u n 1t )
] earni ng t h r o u F h
LT
of
It
hc a lt h c k r c d u r i n g
c ars
s c t \\o t
ach
pp ro
t 1 K
re
llc n t
e Xp o
| / Hc
h thc
t ei c
\ L
"
'
1t
'
; \
h>
\\ \ l nt
\,
ht \
111,
pr
l 11 1r
to t
hm
A 11L l r l l n e w
hh
L\
n \
\tu
l 11 n t t
\
w.
Re
Be i n :
th \ Jr
tn t p r o
1n \ l . .
t 1g
h\
o n
u 11 [ \ e r s l t y
d t w h a v e H s d h a d e n n n gm
l i l r g t n u m b e r s u = o N n 1\ i n i 1)
an
c,
c tl
."
tt
and
w nN
t r a,
he r )
n =c
O:
u c
t l 1e
dt d
Bl 1c t b e t w
c o n
h1
ht y
c c
sc r v l= c
B\
nn
hl n #
t e iw
nd
d c q My
r c q u 11 e d T h c
b Rl a n c t b e t wc
n n n gu n w H t
t ma n
)w t l t l 1 n c t l $
r i nt n v n 1hM c
H hn n L c
u u > r e Hc e
l
i t 5 i n t r y 1 n t o l 1n d u
ti o n
e n h o \ p t t i\ 1
b \ c d I t a r n r n g \ n t ht r e a l w u r l t l o f
a n el c o m m u n t t y
w h a t e v e r c o u n t r Y t h c s t u d e n t h d o n 1n Hc d
Fr o m a n i n t c r n l t 10 n a l Pt r hl wct l vc \ )w b B1)a n c t
hr m v n t h c n d v a n m g m a n d d>adw1nMBw v i e s
d a 11 m c d l = a l s t u d t n t x d u n o A t x p t T \ \ n c c
gr c a t l ) a n
l
d o \ b > y h a v e c t 1a l
i
n
ic a l s it u a ti o n s
n o r
b
c
r
sm u
q
l
a
r
n
1
t
o
n
t
t
e
o p p o r t u n i 1c s
g c m r i t p ma t t 1 > o r t o m i n t l
w
nn
d t hc
o v c m
n ity c n v lr o n m c n t s
ga r d e d
re
hc r
c 1t
hi s t o
lle c t
r c
o r
po t =
as
m u n i t y m r v ic c
c a n
tt c
u a
l taL k
r ic a
to n
t hc
t c a c l \ 1n
rc
rw
h e q u 1 l 1t 3
v t
pm
to
c u m m u n rt
t ht
Co
t )u t t
c a re
1\
t ll
du c
to
m n m n
1t y
\ o \ 1r e c
hc
i \
c 1l
e
c r
1? n
y th u
f o 1h o c o
c a u ca l o n
th o p o c e d
l n
'
n c u
rty
a n
p at
)
d dn
1e n t s
h c J ] t },
u s af
to
e x
s
i
c es s
t Ju t t b t
Mn 1 9 e s
h e y ah
f >>
Be
\ o
Ti b i $ 1 p 1 h w
Blc (
J r lau o n
A t t Bu
h nn
L u
a \
pr
t 1(
1t \
it \
1n
rl g
HV
a
t u
ll
J \
pp
n e r al
ge
l
t\
ru a\
t h\
1 )r
ro
g1
n o r1
Yo u r 1
Sp e c i a l t y
O 1l l t r k d p r q ) r u
(v o c u t i o n a l )
* oco n
u
I
j
J
1\
p r )t
W / Jr l
ca ro
pr a c tic o
Be
H t
ri \ r r ru
t 1d u
1i
n t u
J 1 ?
1 1u
l r d ln
r c u v i1 r \ t
\ l l l 10
ha p t c
In
1u
1r 1 u i
11
v \o u
rt
gr
am
J N
pr
pr a L t
1c
re
r J
glw
pr
tio n
l 1 10
T h1 p r o \ c
\ L <t \ h n n ] \
L+
in i n # p r a n
\rn m e s
r \ 1 rB \ l
ll
l lJ
U\\ el ,\ pt Ai
rJ l pr
\\
h rn
he
\ \
PJ
c \
pt a n
i c =c
t r 11n n
t o
K\ n
s w
\ 1n > >
C
in
h> h r\
1L
th
&
\\
g t l 1r p r
hv L K
ac t n
a n
n o w
h r o u gh
[ \\
L \
r e \ e 1\ \ n K
te n n
<l l \
h
L \ 1 mu l u m
st n [ t u n x \ i n d
I n d
r rJ+ tl e
h H h u i nu n H c m t h t h c
Lt r t t h\ at c o t ( \ \ m r l e t \ o n
\ t 1 n J
IKA
h o 1' n a l p m
( A 1t 1\ L +u h t l w
r1i 1' r.l l '
Br
:j
Lt n
i J1nt' rul
l 1 Tp e \ t n \ J
au111r \ 1H u \ . 1t
1c
H 11
r \
p u 1l t f \ \
p m t t, \ u
p \
h a t gt n c t a l
p
t he
o t
(T J b l c 6 1)
h b l c Fa r t
l lw c d t h i s
h t R C G P 1n
1n
n Sl On
Rc \
x l a lt \
t s
\ t Jr
%r A n l m e
JPPl l t tl t hr uuh
t l\ r
l 1n k \ wt h t h e I \ \ l l T B J n < 1t \ t r a l n 1n s s t r u c t u r e s
n LI w i t t1 \ n t h t r m
( r J, l uJt e t ) t Jncn< T h e R C G P
r c
tr
an
m L
tu
l c t r J t 1o n
pr o n d t
r
n \
vc
t hmuhout
to
1l 1
rn i l
po d
u n t t r
tt s
a h l l 1t \
:s
u r
w
l
t r a 1 n 1n
> ZLK 1
t r J m \n $
\\ l
l\
t a 1n t v
\\
\\
re
>b
c(4
In t h 1 U K
l p r 1 cl lm
rj' r1f1.i1 l r
d d y
d e rw
tr
y p
trw s
c o u n
ce
l i n ic a l
c
e r
I H
Yc 5 r
rr
t opr o\ l dt ' Ol npwBwmm tt5\h\ 11B

f }] > J l t t l A a r >
y
p r o t lu
to
t h,
d v
11
t t \ Br J l
a n
a n
h a ( r l r c a t l y a l l u t l c el t o t hc o p p o r t u n Bt t c s
p r
< w a d u a t c t t 1r r i c u l a t o u w g e n e r a l
u c e a n d H s c o n mu n H t o l e a r n r n c d n c a n d u n d e r
s t a n d t h t s p t l a i t y u f g e n t r a l p r a c t 1c c a n d c o m m u n i t y
W h c r c a b u \ 1t s \ t t h 1n t h c c u m c u l a a n d f o r
M t c <n 1n c
l e n g t h o t l [ T1c v a r y r o m m c d r c a + s c h o o l t o
w ha t
m c d Bc l l s c h o o l a n d L o u n t r y t o c o u n t r y Bu t a l l s h o u ld
p r o \ u Bc a s o u n d h 1 s 1s f o r G P t r a m 1n g
A 1 t h c p r c c n t t 1m c w Bt h i n t h e U K u l c r e a s r d
F o
o p p o r t u n 1t y h J s n o w t w t n d e \ c l o p e d 1n t h c n c w
l
b
d a t 1 o n Pr \ wr al Tnm ( 1n t t r n s h i p s ) t h a t r c p c t x t h c
), t h e m c l t B 1l l t 1t \ b r 1n 1
m ph n y t u
t nuun
tj
c n e ral
ho lt\
te
l 1r s
f t hc
ic e
Bt s
FO u n d a t Bo n
t r a l n Jn e fo
+Bn
r c
p B1l 9 a \
1t s
pro
c n t
d1\ ( rs1t
ts
} e o
pa n d
gmcr Jl p r a c t
t b e g( n>r al l t
e n \ 1r o n m
e x a ce m e n t
pro
s w
tT
rc
gJ o
ib t
gi v e n
s c n c c
and
My
t h is
qu n
'
i ar ni ng f o r g L n L T J l p r I L t i L L :
Po s t r a d u a w v 0 9 J t i A) n 1 1 t r l l mn
\ c
pre
Th r
nn u n
h a v e Ba d
w o r d
\ ( ! \ l 1{ [ (
o l
rn m u n J
lt y
c o n 1: \ u n
lr e s
1
p
r i t s t l o c t o r s w l t o w t s ir t o b e c o m c G s ; t l 1c s c
w n n m c w c h v w c a n d v a r ie d n n d i t i s n o t p o v u
c o mp
w i t 1t 1n t B
w
C O P d o r l l 1 i \ c h n p t c r t o p r o v 1d t a
h c n wc t o v c r w M t hc n i a H
a ge n e r a l
pm v
b a c k # r o u B1t Bf o r d n c u s s \ o n t 11c v o c n t j o n a l t r ai ni n p
d
g n 1n i m t f o r g t n c r 1 l p r l c t l c t 1n t )+c U K w i ll b c u s e
n n d s o r +1 c o t 1 b t 1t l h c t i v c i n n o v a t i o n s n t h a t s c l 1c m c
dc
n s d l
o a s r s c M
lo
c o r 11
w c \ c r
t )1t
d 1 sc r
h e r e \ c r m t d i t a l h t u t ls n t s
w J d u Jtc
hl
b
o
h
a
n
\ e h i 1\ t 5 0 11 1 t
so r t o l o p lm r t u m t
t ey pr o
y
y to
s c a n d c n n c h t he r r c w m c n w
an d kn o u c d c
in c m
g
o f h e a lt h c a r e t h r o u g h s o n i c r n o d t [ o f g1 n t r a l p m c t r t c
f a n i 1l ) m c d r c i n c o r c o ++1 m u n 1t a t t a c h n \ c n t
Ho
u oi n h 1 g
l t hc
ta
rr
t r l 1\
t b \ t r \ c Li t 1w
p=
tn
111 BB. t p Bu \ L L I
1l
h\ c
\ \ \ m:\ t ' t t n' ' \
t l Bl
"
l c \l
rt\
L1 r t
i P1 a c t 1c e p l u
u n c ll
s x
(G M C )
Bt ) r c g \ s t r a h o
pe r i o n c o
1n
su
pe n
T ], e
\ ' "
Qu . Im c o n t m ! o t e n t r y r c q m r c ' " c n t s t o t l , e t r u i n
1n g
sc hc n t c s
i l a s a l : o 1, c e n i n t r o d . c c d t h , o u g h
N a t i o n a l G e n e r a l " r \ c t c Re c m r t m c n t O f fi c e
t ln hc m b
J c e . Tr a i e i c a . . N g l 1o u sc v e t s a n d o l lo c a t c s
p p " p n a ce t r 1, n e e s t o s c l e c t c
p o s t s (p . n c r s o n c t a l
2 00 5 N l t [ o n . 1 Re e n , i t n c n t o r ti [ c f o r G e n e r a t " r a c
t c 1 . I m n g 2 0 1 1)
A p , c e n t Th c t , , 1n i n g m i e s 3 y e . " Ho w e : c r , t l. .
f o r t k o m ' " ! c . r s c o . ld s c t l, c p o s h l b i l i t y . f e l p a .
5 l e a n L . t , l 00 S ge n e r 1l l ' " c ( t r a i . c c b
H ' " o
c o u 1, l a p p l
t , \ b m c m N r \ , \ f t l w RC G I b . t
\ \u s
not a n 4' "
. C t o h c o . Tc a p r a c u n n g G IT H o w c e c r
b H . . H ? o c hc I n t n n s l \ . l . H . " h i p h c t u v c n t he
C o l l c c a n d t h c [ , a m ' " , p r o r a m n 1c l t s cur ncu\ um
a. d o s m ' "
p r c = A I fu t . r . Ac e r c d 1t c d G Ps
b c r s 1u p . f t h c C o l l e g e ; i n d e e d sa t
m u st a
,c\ c m m
1Sf mc c o . F l c t r o n . F t h c a H c = m c n t p , o c e ss f o r
gc n c r a F . c \ n l l b c t h c M m c c x a m. ' " \ o n a s f o r
C o ll e s . M m b m
p
pr ac t
1 -
5.
r 1e
"c rso n
S1"
Co m
A hol i i c a p p '
co .
c c n t r c tJ c a r e
p .
l m a j d=j r hT, >,
A t hu u * :, t h r
j,
r>
' " J UUn I n t e J,
h l gh ,
en
'
hi ,g
[ lH\
r tje l . u o
" y u r ,
Jj . . It ( '" J'
n=' "
U.
ll
U m lr
I n,
h J1> , l
r 1,
l.
i L
I. .
so l, i.
s k i ll s
N s iv c a p p , o a c l ,
o r ie n t a t io n
' "
e ach o
o u tco m es
ln
Sc . Tl . N d I [
j h l h , h z B1 l 1h
nn
"
Ir
J r r,
Urn
, H u
l 1n
, 1h
I 1p f n . . 1n i 1l r
t )H , 1> \ >
11. .
i l M n 1l J
J r r 1H l 1 I n . t Jl . . I ,
hn , [
f , l l l J l l y m I n l e m e n t
,
\ 1, l r , \ , \ l Rl t
p
y
u lu rn I. lm l h
upnnbl l n[ l >p=ncl
, 1111 . r
, lll
i.
m l[
J.
d . 1, r a r " " J
. n
' " n pe [m , >,
lm n m b t > ,1
B r 1r w u G n w n l l " 1u . r nmi t 1r RC G
=
20 0 8 ) \ n d
(
,
lil l o
Hl c 1n
m u n it
l 1u
U Pn l > n l
n t ra
" l
ont
h i A l t ho t , gl :
is
h e
h,
n ,
'
t hc
en
pn
" u l l ,
h a t d i n '
g.
h , f. I l o . In
c a r e ' " n n a gc m e . t
%. I
"
a r c st a t =d a s t
19 1
"
" Ri n 1a r y
pc tc n c [
cm n
f t l , e b = Co ' p c t e" y a r c a s a r c s p , ( i fi
c
c a t , R. r i . . d . . d c r t h ,
l. a , rn n
g
g
Do n i a i n s n k " " 1, d g . . Ki l l . . N d a t t i t . De s R .
og
t i o n \ s g w e n [ o [ 1w tac t t h a t t h e s e H x c D m p e t e
cy
a r c a s a r c n o t l . d . p . . d c n t a l . . ge a m o u n t o f o \ c , ]
. p
i s f r c q u c n t ty o b s c w c d A m o r e d c eu l e d d e s c . p t ' " . o f
h o w t hc c ur r ul um i . f . Rt h c r s t r u c t u r e d l s b e y o n d
t h c s c o p e o t ,
c h a p t e r b u t r e a d e r s a r c r e f . . Re d
t o t l RC G P . . b H t e (. 1 \ .
' " p o r g ) o r t h e RC G p
D' ' " n t (RC G P 2 00 8 )
c u r n c u 1u .
T h e s , c o r ' " mp c u n n e s t h a t h a : . e \ u l , c d m t o
a
l. ' "
' "
. .
d , l i \ c r c d 1n s F e c 1i
. '
"
P 1, ' "
a c c r , d 1t . d t r a l m " g p r J t u c e . b t r a i . e d G P. . . d t h
r u
'
Jf n -
lc a r .
W l t hi n
do , n a i n s . f
a s a s p e c i a lt y
s Ix
i:
1 h.
t h>
\ 1B ,
k)
l
t h> l '
t. A 1 ; l
[w
gr
w w n
I J , w n L t 1l u 1n t m w r , > , , 1 m c u
1
l , l L . . l o p m H \ t o l 1n o d c r n n \ > t ho &
1l 1. . t . . Ol l i
l i , l , n n = t he L u r r 1e \ 1l . . H , J n d J : . e : : m , M
t u Bt l )l > r t h RCG P h n \ d w
T ILI p = , l a n >l e\ t H\ n 1 F r t
Bhl 1o t l w e p n r t : o l i o
A l [ ho u Rl , w i ll , l v n 11m = m U h
tl 1\l o1.nl cnt l t
e
p r e s . N t l y 1, r o v Bcl a n ,
H [ron n
u l n c a \ r o n i 1l \ e l u d
t h a t r r c o n i : t h, 1n t i n n l u l l
ni l
iu h i > \ H n c n t s Th > l >
1
h l.
,
. : \ > , p n 1w
>n
..
I 1, l l l >
e t u
So
re
IO
m in a r
Pro le
C! anuT1l el S
Ou t Of Ho u
F Ht e
Se
rs
rs e
r al
Cc u
sc
0 1 Ex a
F ig
a n
<e l 1
10 0 7 / 7 00
o u nlc r
St r
CS
PJ R
e 1
t u n ti
th{
n t BJ
Jt r
r H r
c w m n
Bx
t 1 rl
pa g e
ds
in
a n
o lcr
po r t f o li o f o r g e
(lu
a \ s c s s r +1 t nt s
pm
o
bt
t w
d W l u p 1n
&
A n > 1 J m p l > Hf
. n 4J n
A t 1m
rw
n a
l I
rn 1n L
1n
h> m
h
I= J
1n
> n
in
in t
tu
ke
1n
pm
\ l
\ 1
\ n
u re
cner Jt
m
<
to
pl un
hn
p J
u \t
n n
l u
w H H n
th 1w
u n 11 a
wf l t
hT J
In
Uh Bn
tu
u m
'
m
n
n n tBn l
hs
hJ
u T
r J
.
p
tn h H
u n m v
1n
Hm
J> >n V
H JH
n t c e w
"
\w
h l lst
L.
t r
"
L u
rc
H c
u j \n
t c n c
q \ 1i r
tlw
V >
he
h t
l pr
a
n ew e r
g
an
re a
iv
\n
n t )
M an
1n
' . \ mc n t
\ L\ p m c n t
m
n C h
<
t7
Mh n
\\
1n t
per t 1nt n1
t he
o f
c m a t 1o n a l
t
.
1 M a n
prJ+ W
h c wh o h
t ha t
da rd
n 1o n
h e d e gr c
A
e
Ot
Ul
n r
h N
3 hm
hc
he
n
= o n
w H w & C mH T gh b a t i m k e
k u e
v u t c o m e s
\ i n c r
N u n t r
fo
an
hc hn
he
h
p
t
w c rs t
c L\
c t
t t\ e
u n n h H
m unn
a re
\ e
j C1 t
ch n
h a tn
i
lu
i t 1L t
I W naht
he
c we n t n L c
Hu t n t 1 N n t o H
AKI
e w
t h
1
he
h
n
\n \
g >r
h n eJ
q
c u r r 1, u
n t r J
clL e
\ \ 1n
c u
tT \ \ m
l,1
\ e
e n n
u h
{ l l o
ht
dr
Uc
n u rs
L TK b. L\
J r L
h e le 5 r m
l l , L t . Tt \ L
> N c
Aw
t
\
! t
h I
ru
1n
p lu
e \
& h n w w
l hc
\n
u i r
n A \
m>t l 1 t x
a r s rl \\
n Ta
t\
ch c
n cl
t l1 t
t r 5 1t 1 \ n q
to
e \ \ n
L\
Mt h i mh
t
I UJ
t1 J \
t Hn t
Rm
lu t
lt
L<
ll
h r ( \ t 1q h
\ t
dt
n t > re
\u
l B
h L\ \ p l t J l
c \ t
h \ x <s
n lt
trJ ln LA ,
lLw m
r in Tt l
tJ t n w n t
h H
t5
A \ t
n m
\ t 1,
> r
>n t
t pt
l 1t r w
t lo n
d1f hL111t t c
tu rc
hT
1o n
r c w
1t
in in
t ( l chl n= mt t h, t ) 1O
I n d
xu L
dln
in d u
l p f a c t rc e t r a
n e ra
r m J t m
H t
p u r + f uh
t u
11 0 7/ 2 0 3 7
1 Z 0 7 t 2 C0 7
p a t i e n t fe l l
an \
1o m
n la
er
r ccar ci
h r o u g h t r a l n 1n
d t h a t s p < L 1 B/ L a l l i
19 1) 7 2 0 0 7
I l 0 7 12 00 7
re c o r
Rn
H o i pr t o u s E t h e e p c r 1 c 1: o
to s i
rs is a
tc
Tl > n c c
l a lo
h e i n d m d u J l t r a 1n A c M
c
r
b
o n J l l d docur T1t nt t h a t
p
>
Ju l
l s cn
e o
n o n
( L
tm
)of
o r
d 1a t
r e Tn c
duct m
t.o n al
Jx
pe
Se
rs
T'
0n1( S
F
c
w it h t h e m
ex s . d t m m n g
por c s s] On
n ar
l l
1 0 0 7 12 0 0 7
\ e
t te
Se
m a t l\ t
su m
ID
an
p r or a mTn m
Ev e l
2 a 0 7 /2 0 0 7
Ce
l L o c t u 1 o / s i Br m n l r l
\c
I n s e c t b l l o 3 In w m le r
!e-
n c a
u r t j l 1c n
l o l k o b p
O u l 0 1 Ho u
l T u lo r l a ls l R o i l d l n
g \ l C o u r c /c
t Br + u 1c e r l +i 1c \ l o
Ho
T u :c
Co
C e r t if ic a t e
. C \! c n
n s
Ro u din o
Led
l lo
o rs o
h e a d bn g
N o c u rn c u lu m
Co u
l C o n y o r c l o n B Tu t
o n a l I
ir
t Co n v
s s lo n a
n o
1A ll
s s io n
Q r l QU n t c r 1 P t o t o s s 1o
t o r H o u r s S e s s io n
r l r
0 n ew
En te r
a n
h ed t Bo 6 F E a ch
h m 1 VVC\ t h c h
u n s
h 1p h
tm
1n u
HF 1w
m m
p p h ed Kn o
r kp t nc o
ase
lr
as
as
ed
P BA)
(W
b s o r v a t\o
ho d s p
(c BD )
u s s io n
n o
me
f p ro
as sessm t n t
c e d u ra
k ill s
t r a in in g
(D O P S )
Con
su
O b s e r v ho
o n
P a t Be n t S o l l s f a c t i o n Q u e s h o
M u l t is
a s s es sm e n
1n Bc a 1
t n i c a s u
so r s re
pe m
u se
a re
e r m ro r m e n
po rt
m a in
ly
1n a
h o s p it a l
d ex w cts
a n d c ]c r o n ic a l ly m a r k e d a n
I t is I T t io n s
E r 2 o o m u l t i p l e c ho i c e q u e s
t he t r a e e t o a .
10 ' \
l
a ] m c d rc t n e
f
S
O
m
1c
d
.
c
o
C
1
u
h
I
3
s
M
p
Q )
(
he a lt h i n f o r m a t i c s a n d
a r i t 1 c a i r e a s T B + n z a n d 10 \
he
o n s a ll s e t a t a h 1Fh c r l e v c l 1n t
m
a d m 1r u n r a t 1 o 1
m ( o l lc c t i o n
d
n r J h e T t in n t h A s t m p 1t
Y
c o ur e
&
t e st
su
a m
b;c
'
t o
jy s
' ' "
83r3
Fa i l u
T h e wt s u o n \ b e
a n d t e st
r A\ lm
re
s e s s mc n t
1t e r n
15
des <
>
t>
to
du1r j r
3 1 1 17 1 1
a n
dl
z Ss x . Hi T
L \ \
1 b B1Bl y
B1B1t
1u
R( B F 700 7
T r J 1n
ee s
a r >
M a r g i n a l FM
t u v c md a r c :
rl or
o np
J
e x
>,
t +1 f
>4
1<LBwna p J w
c lr c
mh e n s
p pr o
W H
b r in g
srn c n
t
L\
u b s l \n
n i n t
1 1\
j"
ll
t b r L\ u
j\
J n t J
tl
J t
\ \
C l\
t }u
u s s lo n
gh
t o th
e
ir
HPr
a s se ss m e n t
l/ t
\\
Iw
t r 1in e e
c e to b c e
\ , 1chl n t h t p r a v t i c e
:"
i n
he
1\ e r J
r
n
(C b D )
A e n
D l r u c l o b s L r v t t rA n
s lt r l l s ( D O P S )
;e
. \ l l l t nt
c x t c n s 1o n
Ll
11 1 c
?l
1t c
Cl hc
i 1 , I 1t '
\
C}
t r
a u E
s e t t
c Y e 5a
J C X i me r . Z
\n
\t i
1c
Pr R c l
Pn
ha t
n e et ssar
B1 e
J
y be
n A 'N
> HW
Ca s e ba s e d d ls c
l r =
J W
Th
to n o te t
m a
r W B PA i s t o
in to
B
t at t e m pt i n
i
r e a l w o r ld e n v r o n m e n
gt
i a r i a s o F c o m p > t c n c c d s c r i be d p r e v i
m a t c h t l1c s x
o f a sse s s m e n t
m ( t ho ds
r 1a t e
o t 1s l y w i t h i 1p p r o p
B
It is
a s s s sm e n t
h
o
t
c
a
r
o
a
bio psy
pp
a
1m 1l t i p l t
f e e d b a c k d r i v e n f o r m a t i v e a s s e s s m e n t p r o c e s s ba st d
t h e r t h a n q u a n t i t a t i v e me a s u t
u po n
q u a l it a t iv e r a
h e v i d e n c e i s ga t h e r e d a n d r e c o r de d
a n d w it h in w hic
T h i s n i d c n c e i s t h t n u se d
i n t hc t r a i n e e s c p o r t fo l i o
d fo r m u h tt
o f t hc t r a i n e e a n
t o a s s e s s t hc p r o g r e s s
d
o
d
r
n
p w de s dm
fu t u r e t e a c h i n g a n d l e a r n i n g n e e s a
W
B
PA i s t h o u g:
l co m N t c n c e
m e n t a r y v jdc n c e o
d
a u e ss m m l
1ear ni ng a n
t e a c hi n g
t r i a n gu l a t c
to
h
e n t
t i c a ssI
d
l
e
n
t
u
a
l
t
o
w
a
e
K
l
r
e r in g
o
w hi st
s s a bl e b y c o n c m
i
t
o
s
n
c
n
e
t
e
e
o
m
a ls o a s s e s s e s c
p
W B PA c o n n s a
n t
t \o n a 1m e t ho ds o f c li m c a l a s se s sm e
o f t h e f o ll o \ L1 n g
la tt e r M
36o
an
li n d
c o n tc x tu a
E v a j u a h o n Ex e r c i s e (M 1n > C EX )
1e
or
nccci
p r o gr a rn m e
T hc p u r p o s e
n n a ire
f e e d b a c k (M s F)
o u rc e
bu
H U RK N K
c OT
To o l
h i c a l ly
i n ca l pr a c t i ca l sk i l l s n e c
esS
h c CS A al so c o v e r s c l i
a
u l t a t io n e n v ir o n m e n t
w i t l 1i n t h c c o n s
d
f
v 1 c o t apc d
fo r t r a
C o n s u lt a t io n s a r e o t e n
in in
B
1
a
w h o f ai l c a n r e s
c
t
s
d
d
n
a
n
,
g
i t t
ai
r po s e s .
h
(c s A )
e n
t i5i n g e t
l : t H' ' "
d by
u**
s e s s me n t
ba s e d d is c
ec t o
d*
ed g e Tea l ( AK T )
wl
S lu lls A s s e s s m
anal
o
1m
l vc
m an a
ge
an
)'
t l t B\
hm >
J\ \ > v
12
l Bi { n t
1h
Co
l l : l Bl l l l l o n
C l l n 1(
\ l ng
a b i o \ y t o\
o>
n Bm
>
u n
W m
> w >
J H
n m
u ra
rn t n t
) pp r o , cb
f pr o c e d
1, I
1nt l
nw
1i
Obs t
Ev i l l j i l tl u
rl
'
Tb o l (C OT ) a n d
l s e (M i m C E X )
1v , l t l o r l
E x c 1c
t l 1t ' h m- : l x ( a rl i t t l Ln \ t 1 n t h t ' u \ > l

m 1 H v n a v e w n w n b hm h wwl
n t
1Jl
en>t r n'
h
h n ea n
1 u &2 D i r e c t
bs
tio
e rva
p p t l ca t i on
B re a s t
Co
Pro s ta t e
El e v
A s p +r a \ \ o
C ry o \ h e
re
1 11 t b \
du n n R
to
ffu
c os e
c o m
b ln o d B
m i n a t io n s
ce
u re s
s lo n
c i s Bo n
Jo
Bn
a n
Hom
Pr
re
oc t o sc o
s io n s
n a
ge
a r t c u l a r m
p la
b sc
je
e s a
a n t
n s
du
t to
t im p la n t
c e m e n
km
w o u n
1n s e r 1l o n
Flat e
g a 1n
s u rfa c e
t 1v e
st
1 s u r
e 5
p l
o t
pr
r r 1u l H
rr
}\ >
pe
ro
c Bm e n s
1( J \
ru
r hJr r
a s C Wr t \ e n t
pt
tt Jl
t r
y c o lo g y
r m
o n w
fi t
a n l
rla
:: t
prnhl t ns
e n L OU n
rin
es s
tc
re
c x c r t 1s e
wor kBn c o l l c a g u c s
l
L1Sl n
r lt
r u f
n r
1n t e \
J .J
vx( l h[
1\ u
r lt
pl
1r \
tn
L o r 1r l x '
Il r t L \ 1 t l
p 1t J ] b 1 \ > t i
t
d 1x
u d
h Kt
BJ W w
wl 1uunhw
ly )
o u s
his
>
" nL 1L
I 1L H
( r m 1t
ilt
h
\ L( J l l nt >r
.
u w 1u n
ttl t
r+] Jrk1n
I 1m
t l l l
L i
a n
li n
ic I
a n
n o n 9
Rs
po
/ sr
lin
1L a
h tc
m t m
u su a
tx
lly
rs o
t ui nhn
t \
an
c n 1p u t
1n
t
y t
pe
su c
'
rv is o r s
tn
ly b\
p o r t (C S R )
re
t 1c s a r c
act m
o c
c x
t rain c t
c t e
o d
t r J 1n n g l w n
ir
u sin
a r c a s
an
po rt
re
t s a
)r
l t, ) w
i t ht G p
i n t
hrt
st t
r m
%c
he
tm c a
SU
w n t t
t r l in t r t o
SO r
ho
1n
e x
t s t n 1c c u r c
L n
a rc h
J t
1 l t
hL
t r In
hm
d Y
HH
h>
nl
he W
hc N
t
a n
. r at 1ce
bt
l wul L W
1 =1HLI
1n t
h t 1r 11e
n w
u n
n4u r N t m
r cl m
cn r al
w
,
l \ t
l J DM
w 1t
rre
1 h
'
1b l A
BnJhn
in
e n
knL\\ \l vLtt
1h e I" a
hy h u
le a
d fo
u sB
fo li o
port
sp c c l
hre t
1n
he n
t ea i n c c s
( O\ t n n
rr> n t
ht
g s c a le
t
o n
1 u : t a L h h s p t t a l & ) b t a n d G P a t t 5
h t r t p l ) r t h . \ u lJ c o \ t T t r J Bn ( v \ L \ m . V t e n q 1n
t h A 5 1\ L O r e
S& \ 1HL a r c a
l n Li l i n k t u
Co m
A>
1s
s u
&
rc
p\ r t
At >ww 1 h
1 l l Tm
r t
h1
p rat u u
g t hc 3
r in
&
N
' l
sj
op
f e e d b a c k (M S F )
t io n o
d = f Bm d I r s t
mn t r u l t
in
r\ o
t r J ln L r
ThA
ki n
; c t . > lt) dr w s
'
: . H1c h t . 1 > G
sp
p o i n t r a ti n
t n c
111 n
s l 1m
Fu l
\l se
1\
o r
b i n a t +u
C lin ic a l
t r a in e r s
m o re
bc
se c
sc \ ( n
py
de d
1 ( S d c g r c c l e e d ba c k i s d e s i g n e d
c l i n t a l p r r f o r n a n A e m c a s u r A a s w e l l a s
l a n d a p r o l c s s 1o n a bt b a v 1o u r a \ s c s s M T n t
(a n o n y m
e x c ls lo n
k i n le
d pen
o n e
Ta l a n g
c c l
an
u rc e
ln a
r r 1t r n
co m
d d ra
a n
u Rn g
v rd t
( r u m
1n
v i
f t h> ]a r # t r t e a m u n d p a t r t n t s t o p r o l l d c
t h1r 1n d l v n i 1BJ [ a w t s s r mn t s I t g l \ ( s a w c c p t t o n o f
Ho Le t b ( u w o r k i n g col l c5gtJCS s e ( . ( h c t r a 1n c c a n d h o w
c nv l t
t h c t r J l n ( ( nspond\ t o b t a t t h L . 1 r > i n t ht l r
t i \ e s <e n ( 1a l t o c o i e > t d a t a f r o m a s v a r i e d a
m en t
t
y be
hjL a l
M SF
t t i t \ 1d
m o
pro
cp
py
ra
pr o
du re s
l pro
n 1
T hc
d g lu
>
su d n
M u lt i s o
ta l e xa
re c
\ 1o
t io
tta g e l s b av
E 1 c i s Bo
s :
ng t
si
e x i t m rn a t i o n
ro c e
n o
au t c n za
Cu
p t 1o
l e dr os
h r l p l n R l or mt 1l at e t h e p a t Bc n t s f u t t + r c n c e c i s
a n d f m 1h t M c t h c p r a c t H m m r s e d u c a t m n a l Jcv
m i n t ( D tt N \ ) 1t i s t 1s l Ba l l y w q u l n d o n l y o n i c d u
u t l t mu s t ad d r
h t ' r , l mn i p t ' o d wi t } 1l n pr a c t l ( c ,
e x a m i n n l to n
b lo
a n
e n
e x a m in a
t he s
pr o s ta te
l lo n
o xa m in a
Te s t i n g f o
m o o
n Bl a
go
M a te g o n i t a l
So
mp
dr
(I U N
l c yl o lo g y
a le
Re c ta l
si
n
e xa m
rv tc a
Fe m
of
d u re
u v r
1l s ( D O PS )
E Ig h t c o m p u l s o r y p r o c
h c
c o n su lt a t i o n
1 pro c * d u ra
n o
l m
N
n u n s
h> r c g >
t h
Jt t
he
'
t ,
n u n m n
v rn e
lw
M
.
w w
n n n w n t
h Tt xh1l
t
>r uBcsshna
n w
t w
uk
lce b
Re q
Rr
r
! -
s Bar d n g
p a
and
g)
a m
Lo
] h $> d
c n c ro
ca I
lc a
t 1 t r o 1n r s r m
e t l r1c t B t i o 1 r
1
)
hnh h K k>
ner t , l cat } on (F r o m e 1n g
f
F
A
C
+
a c t
J m c u J R f o r Sp e a l u
a Ge n e a
o e'
R C G P L o n d o n w ith
.
Tr a n n g 1 G e n r a c < e
l
f
Ge n e r a l
j
h
o
C
R
o
e
f
e
Y a
g
p e n a n o t e
Pr a e t A 4 e s )
l
p la
rs
o n
it y
d u c 5 t to
I' n
I lo
cto r s
c B
n
ic
r c v
n c il
1 g n t d 11a t n 1e
d tc a r
l M e dic a l c
o u n ci
n er a
c a
du
ca
f et 1i cal 1i d N c Bl t o t 1
LA
d o c to r s
u 11e e r
O ne
c n u
m
dn gi
C o st
d q u a lit y
an
l p r a c t t c e 1i t 1u c a
2 (2 1, 7 0 7 3 2 0 1 l
h on
to
rr
lo
t ip s
y b a se d
r L o m m u m t
r o 1 o
ge n e r a
u c a tio
n
20 0 2
cB l Te t B c h r 2 4 ( 1 ) 9 12
y E Jo l l y B
r r o t> s l o c r o r s
Ge
20 0 9
o u
19 9 6
T\e c l v c
\ e i ll(
hu
fo
y Ca
J111 1 r
w e
do
G l bh s T W a l s h K
d j
o w ar
c
T he f r
l u \o r
lb
+
il
ln c
l C o t 1n c i l : TBr1t r o
s 1t B1 r e l { Br t l 5 f n r
d
30 16 3 7 1
62
1ESc h TR
co m m u n
Fig
lH
do
do
J1 o r r o l u s
1r r n Bt l t u 1l e r 11e t l c t Bt
19 93 G c n e r a l M m e a l C o
G e n e r a t ' l d1cdl
R r c o m i B c n t i t Bt 1o n s o 11 1n t t t e r g r cu i t 1e1 t e m e d 1c a t
I o n d o n 20 0 3 G c n e r a ] M c d ic a ] C o u
r t 111r d f i u n
1-
iu
c o r l 111l r r r d cBl
il:
n c
o 1 r 1t 1u
Ctn
BAar u ge d
Cp D
g er e rd
pa M
h l c d lc a l C o u
e r al
Gen
e r t if l c a t i o n
re n ct s
1c a ]
m e
t ho
h +o
ll h l Ca
d(
s tu
l prac
ge n e r a
in
t rc c '
n t s
le a
rn
do
r an
i sc
i l ba s e d o n o b] c c t n c t r u c cu r c d c l l n l c a l
B n r i r a Y d r ( n 1 J o t i n m 1 3 15 9 2 0 9 2 3
a t 1o n s
c r o ss o v e r t r a
c x a m 1n
19 9 7
M
u ni d
1n
c 1 c
s&
p 1&
T s
he
o m
RC G P
(S p a r r o \ \
20 3 )
b
u Nq c
an
po r t a n t
im
fo r t hc
de r
r ea
f t hi s
he R C G P l a t t e m p t t o hn n g
l i n k i n g r c a c c r c d t 9a t r o n
C r
ro o f
C PD
o n e
d
i
t
a
n
1
u a l Ie a r m n g n e e d s w i t h
h
1
n
\
w i t
r c c r t 1
d
d
t
en p r o e
q u a ] 1t y a $ s u r c d C P D \ n t h
F . t Be T c a r e a n
, u r a n c c a n d p J t l c n t s5f (t)
u 1c c c x c p s o t r u s t
= IF
c R
i bN
a H
( Fi g 6 2 ) (w
T'
a t 1o n a
it
ar n jn
a
r c
) fn
lpc f
i r c
er e
t h] .
lt
ts in
r a r n 1n
u n t t 1c s
e r a
ge n
& htt p
c o m
s +J n
he
mi t t a l
5 n
u c
n c
pan
tu m o r
1n
<f e t 11(
t e a c
hin g
d Edu
c d r Bo +1
19 9 9
O t fic e f o r G e n
\t m r n t
o n
l pr a n
qu( t \ onna1r c
l Rn
: A
w l i l i
e r al
Pr
c t tc c
k a
c n 1l t m e n t o r
lo lL T La n t
P A
f prA
cc 1a c
1u h 2 11 ] I
PJ
ttc rc
al s Bo x 6 2 )
p po r t
3 3 (3 ) 1 T 1 1 7 6
1s
t n
d c lt
'
lA c t t
st
x l\ t
F Fe r u\ L t n F X
r1 \
r\
t m
r c
lu
t
m
\r
r\x ru n
L\
n J n
<
n \ 1n
n c r a
l 1" a c t
l r \\
T11
n e w
l cc
l \ a
ln h
tion
m r
l 1 s
f t 1 L
hm
h o s p 1t a ]
rt
Su
du c at i o n a l
a tta c
\\ at
c
y E Jo l ly B M
u m
\ t r a m ln
c r L
af
dlt d t
ru
1o
de
r r Li
w m
t rA rn e r
J m rrB
a w r u e n t
lf Jn
J \
d
bL
d
( t r t1
tn
t e \
'
n t t
1t \
an
rc
dt ur ce
ld
Dr
lt )
t l 5 t Rt
\ )
J i l l t )
> \
l
b :n l ,
n e r
J
t t 11
d e w hw
I 1u \ r
l \ 1r 1E
u l l >u r t
) r t \ }I J \ t
: 1 r t H ed
\ Ju n
1n
',
In D
4m
H K
l l i 1 r L A t 11 u t r 1t n Bl r BBr \
hw
1 W
h lh W
I { 1v
1r
t n n e n n N h h L hw
Phc GC
1e l : 11
l rh,
hh
1n
b e e n \ t r y c a r t l j +. } > 1 a TM J 1 t
1 1 1e s p 1 u a l t y u l ) : > m r a r pf 4BB u t p h J \ p r u \ I t { t l 1 l t \
l d c a t n \ i r o n m t n t Bf J r t h t f 1\ r 1 l [ Bp r 1l t r l t ( i Br r t w l t r n
Jt JI J i l e J 1 H e d J( . \ o f l \ l r t 1m a { t u n d
m c d.o l e d u c a t to n
t l r u u J 1 > x H T A( n t r
r t w Br \ h u t t t l
J +D
t l 1c
wo1 d
,
p p lt = d t he
se
A l t } r u u # }1
1n
]n n o \ 5
j n s l
dt
t h e w o r ld i n
l
l
\
e e o p r rr t n t o l qt
t he \ p > [ iJ tt y d m \
o u t
hn
fu
tu
r x
re
s o
tl
\ c
ble
t>
v a n u t l t J + \ t .
t h>
d t
n u rJ
l pr
n u t
yc
ho w
U d c l e l o p
p le
a 1{ m
ll
> ) l\
l l m t i t ) n r l l J n J : > r 1w n \ i n d
\r a \
RA t i c e
a n d i n LB rt \ln
e x im
M 1t }1 I H r i t ] \ l t l o r n n r B
h e J l t h c a r r p r u l t \ l ona\
HMH H
l r r o t l B: I :
f t hn
sw
i m
hw
V U M
G
>
2m 7 u
Mu w n w
n
r n r r 1\
=u
l h
WU N A
W
Rt
t ( >n < w w
w UL A u
l h>
> m
L u wmn
M U >a n i Hy M
hu
pr mt nni ncr
n w j
>t l h 17 N H
hn n
n c
w n
<o
n ch n
2 5
Pr e p a r i . g f o r g e n e r a l p r a c t i c e
Fu
rt
he r
ta-l i ng
Ro y a l c . I 9L :
' " f G w w r d 1 p r a c t m u n c r s (R c G p ) B e i . . g
1ar Bc ti r i o, wr u . r i . . l ' ' " JOr 5p . . i a1 t y
t m i , i n i . . I , 1. . " 1 p . K t . . L o . d o . 2 0 0 7
RC G P
1 , B r c. B l
Ba k .
I; 1 C h . H 1h v r b l ; \ : G m , l e t . G,
2 110 0 Ro y a l C o l l v g c
3 , U K
,
$ zH e f
'
. en t
l 1ar , t i c e
c n c ra l
I C
Pr J c n t i o n c n
Can
cr
a 1r e
Si m
1t 1 t o e , l t , i t r o n m , I t r e1 i r l i g j . n i m a r
y
O \ l ) T d 20 0 1 0 x f . . d U n i v c r s l t y Pr e s s
Y G.
1:
. n
C o x l [ ] r d H . n db . o k . f G . n . . l ! T a c t i c c
I o r d 2002 0 . f . . d U . i . . r . It y " r c M
,
15 1
C ha p t e r
r7
T he hi dde n
Cu
r r
ic
l 1t B 1 d e t
F W H
t?1Op?1l 1t
R o
1i
n o s m
e s
i vln
h ( s p a c e b c t wc
b e b a p P e n 1n g
t 1l ght
Fo r m a l a n d t h e
d u n o f fi c i a l t h e
=r c
h
i n cc n d c d a n d t C p
n c w
hrs
lu
c u
cu m
(H c )
..
Th e o r e t i c a
c o n
d d l sc o n n c c t s
H c thc o F
o s t t x 1s 1c c v e l
o
h t
hr ghl 1ht s t h e p o r e r +t 1i 1l f o r c o n f l t c t s h e t \ c c n w a
l
rn
f aul t i n t m d e d t 0 d r i l l e r (t h c f o r m a l c u r r 1c u u )
f
o m l a1
h
L
o
t
B
m
o
T
a
k
N
a
]
t
e
r
s
a
e
e a m
w in a t
l
e\ ' " k
w s t c m s f r am
a
\ , t fu n
a l l o&Tac 1n
. n s
I n d
i
n
t
t
r
(
onn(
c
t
nl
n\
d
d
l
t
t } 1a t emFhz s{ s c o n t e x t a n
:
w St e r n ( l c m c n t \ I \ a m p l t . ( 1 6
i r t c T d p n :e n c Je s o
t h> \\ h Jt
k y m i uLc es 1 n c l u d c pcdaj o1L, \l A u n t e \ t (
\ n t > \ t
l
(\ n[ tr
b
L
L
J
1
n
L
t
h
rc
t
u gh t ) t
o f w in a t 1 s ] n .
b
t L\ r \
J
1
\
n
u
i
\
:
,
n
i
t
n
r
U u t a n d s t u ( >
fo r e x p lo n n g t hc c o
uc at Bof al l i f e A t \ t s m
t ln u ]t lc s a n
stru c t
'
a c t o n s a rn o r
b y N
F1 o
a c
se
nwdr t Jl p m
) t 1r
l
d t t t cont >) \ \ ot n r H J r 1u J t 1t 1 r 1 J . u t A
1
l
n b
u
\
u
t
t
1J
1
t
h
n
u B w l n ( 1r i t 1\ \ \ , l
a n
andgr ( , UPval
tn
h a t r n fl u c n i
h
t hl n\ t a t b ( = o mc
t he e be c o m e
t hJ t
fa c t o
l t hL
L\
J 11 .
c \
r t
1t >
1n
Bl L1 e n
1
1 B
o 17
\\ \ t
l n L
h J n t , ) rTn
\ \ t
\ \
a n
t \ 1, h
1r 1
l B\ >
t1
'
hj
h>
vn
t i n hm k h
pr u
r
t l
h m
B\
W
u
n J n \ \.
tu r
In
1l
w J
rh
t hn
n h
<
>
w c
Ar e
y.
d
Pu T P o s e f u l
ad dr
1s
&
r e4c11t t ]
1 1\ L
c in u
h . 1. '
ti
ueJ
r N
11
H w HT
H r
u n
mh
t
1n w
te
ces
pi e
p le t e
co m
1S
rm
a n
Fu n h e m 1 0 r e
M k n
t o
U S
N t w
e ts
i ns t r uct
fo
he
1 li tt
b . \ c 1J
el e r
T he r e
ar e
n ew
hn L n m n o f
he c h a pt c n o f
l d h n g ta c u ky
1whcMmns
r HC
N Br wt t t n w H 1t h i n n n Ahal c t l t a t m
L1t =anung 6 S
W
H n m n m n
h m h w h h$h t M
h a bo u t
I cn ,
Im l m
t n u n N h H e he t u m n x w r
t
Ut t ) ) L f t l t e l e r m w
\ w e (, \ \ l N
t l \ l n R\ t u t l 1 l n k J l w \ l t
M
T h = w i ll be t h e n w
TM c n h
nppmt unt t t > h H n m
mt
m n
t o
r e c 1a t e
ll
n 1a n e n
\ c t \\ t
disc m
t n o
VCl \ n b e t w
r (
t im e
o v e r
+n t c n t 1o n a
e l e r
:w
r ta n t
u n
o r
u n
t l
rt
T he
e n c e
r o
l JPL' CT
\)
\t t
n t w
l 11
flu
in \ 1s1 r e
1b
al
r m
im po
is
%c i a1
t he
of
de r a pp
h
d
e r e a lu a
t
f
a
n
l
e
s i al i
d t a ke n fo r gr a n
u t i n e a n
hu
c n c t s
I111
h> } l (
t u
1n
a n
a n
50
) u n v mt t
\ L
L)
he
i n
se
J n t
m J
q u 1F
in
d
e
rs t
it
in fo
1z c
gn
he
e x e r ts
ys
u n re c o
u n se e n
n m
Ah m
e u el
o n te x t
W o r
c n
Xr HH
i x x
T.
j ' Je r t y E G a 1t l b e r g
i c u lu
cu r r
+l
>
tn
'
i n l u
at
In
tt
c ln
c n L c
a st
pt
to
pc
t h Ar
Lv t
a =u mh n
u n d a t ttm
n e tr lt
t l 1t n
i n d
w n
hm
pr c
[ l l l 1 l t > ly
t hn
l\
m nH t
1 B w
h> h
rt
ln
h t h n 1m u r
r t ner
\ \ h a \ t *w
e e d t u t x p ln r c
1n
>mns l >
an d
de t
r l L \ l l t y l> \ c \
hn g
hc I Ic
at
hm h
u dc
t he M
T hc h r d d c n
RCl evamt \
i l c n t i l ic d
v alu e s r e
di n
l'
dc d
r i li r s
t\\
<v
he r
pie s
so 1 a
l F RA
(f c m
m
o
'
3 .
an
ht
dr w
i b\
d m= ; c mmt
c T c n t u l T $ h
a n
an
e r s
h\
fo
in
a ca
lcs
Hc
as a
T bp x
et
hi c s
tw CCN
1 1t \
e n
ltt
m ic
r 1
( (
1o n J
La t
tt.o
ptu
t o n e t
o rt
rn \
lu d t n #
Ne
Zt Jb
t h t s
ine l o
On
1 fo
11t e
to
ha t go
c r a tu rc s
o ue n
rm
rJ
c x a m
ln
a n
1s a
tu
n (
in t
l \ .:
o u r w
he L Jm
n t
l B: r
1 u
t r t
ru
i\. J
r t
p\ l rut hf
B1
u \
l St J W
p>
t{s
1n 1n
u n t
l SL
r :
J rl It
B\
cn t lca
J \ \ 1n
l p5 rt
n t
r m J
1r H u
r t
1+ Ad1.
lo
1n
J l l l\
1< 1 r 1\
\l
1\
1i 1 1\
B1r t
tr
1 1 r 1
1n \ i n B\ 1 1
Ja p
1n
A tl\
l 1)
ft n i t i o
as
K:=
ro
n s a n
ll
tro
m e
p ho
r s
gh
r .
h 1p
in to
t LI n
n J
o m lze L
1n
lJL
]t \
1n
\
t>
\ 1t
r h
0Yl
u 1u
H rm
lt
u n
de r
c s
a re
be
r) ?
'
conl on
hc H C
7 1 w he r e
t
hc f o
X
b
ir
qu
h1 y
l ( = L) l L 1 m
tw o ) dm
rm a
( L1l umn
t Th l ,
hl\
t
:\ t
t.
t tu n
\\ l
t,
n i
'
,
ou t
w
a r c
Xe X
,
ha t d o
A fe w c x
w
a n
n s 1 L) n s
e s
d t he
: t r a 1n
ot
a n
tm
h L
m
1J
Jn
(c
M e
L\
hc
t D.
\J
\n c t \
rm
St at t
) an d
\ &nen. A\ > 1
ha
t
Fo
rm 1
rm i
1 n
c o n co
\ 1\ 1t l 1
J B\ ( r
tI u n
In \ lr
in
t i
1t l t
i'\
Sa u d i A r B t a Sn l n k B Tn \ l U i t a r
l l 1> r > I 1 (
h t r t a l l o 1s 1 h 1t d t n l ( l 1 w r 1 L M t
B
t
t
J t t r 1i l >
e
n
l
L
L
u
p
n t a n y M u d Be s t h T t Ur l W u p \ n t \ B
k
t
r t n s h \ B( h
t
e y
w r k t \ j Bc t l 11 u r y w n l t u u t t \ t T u 1 l t 1g
M
n t H he
T he s e 5 r t n i c s w
in n
a s h H n
o r
11\ t l
l in
ir
.
t \l t d
t
1 u 1l l c
u l LI i n
\ I 1 u 1 l 1L t j l u 1 n
\ r\ m
l (e
J L t u 1l
a 1
h m
hJ
m
t
o
e
n
t
t
t he
NWV t a n t
m n n c c w n u T H a r r t r r J t eJ a 5
n
eq u a
t t 1e
J t t Ln l\ t c r J t u r e
n \ t I l . \ l c <u
T he
pu
l 1i
\ l, \
h1
an
ple s
dt c h
im
shlv
r i +u
o n t
r rn J
1n
n t
m e
l t . 1rn1n
so n i c
cJ /
'
bc
T a b lt
in
ar har
t
f a ll
b n o
c u rr c u
PE
T X W
t m
c 1l c e
1\ 2
b 1d c l e
th r o u
l l a dc
f pr
Ti b i o 1 1 Te
1i
}a
1 /1
n }c
p h c l r ty
1p t
c o u rs e
/ro
v 1[ 1 s
I u gbr
m s h tu
hL
B1n
l l l t\ \
t 1K
c t m t 1n u c s t o
s ln t \ h
h1s. o'
t J ( \
( ir
r t
t hu
he
5C1Ol
c n t
rc c m
\ t m
u x
m > d l\
ht ) p 5 > d
n d t r Rr a d l 1a t c t
e in t
1t d u
ga r di n g
s su c
h H] > d m r k u n p r ,m n J h m
f T Uh d > h p n w m K n J r 1w u m
K n K u m
t 1 o n y J b 1> \ 1 d ( n t l t ! 1 1r r n J t l " n 1n L B L H I J I u J
e 1 a m j ru
1n t c m
l t 1n
d l3 \ \
de
e s
stu
r m a
cn b a s c
d a
\ 1n 111
n s
\ \
hc s i n
sca n
tr l
t a c i t le a m
s n d ho n
a p e 0 \\ J
o f l e mn . O t h e J b
S m c t J t 1f + i j o s t h e r c u s b c n
ar u c
sc t o
r n l
h t t o n o f d 1f l t r
he r n f o m i a l a s e c t s
p
s o c l o l o pj
t h (: A r n t i a t e s
h o et t n l u n c t r o n o n a n
hn
o w n
an
ple
l s
d b
i a
e x a m
n o m
h
1n c c
!o
h c Bo
h a s ha i t s
l a r l i l t s hi n g
cc
h 1c h a r c c o d i %c d F \ 1 r t h e r
o l o r t s on 1 z e s t ha t t h e r e a r c m a n y c x a n l
ha \ c a m w e p r o fo u n d 1 f e c t o n
e n 1h
t
1
n b w s : t h i n k h 1g h w a
T 1c c s
y sp e e d h>m t s
1r t i m
1a
sN
1 Ic \
m o re
t w {H n
fo r m
in
m m
1n
l l 1t e
so a a
bc
v e rsu s
D WT V m a y n o t h 1v u c d t h t
t hc c l e a r l y w a s c o n c c r d n e w i t l 1 t h t
a n d
u n c o n s c 1o \ l s
n o tl =c d
d im c n h l o
l o gy
g h
u n
i o
pm
I n l i r c c t
l e=0n p l a n
h 1d d c n Bu
tc n
bm ro o m
t n b t mLt 1 L 1 n
( D t w c y 19 3 8 ) [ o r
m\ den t al l e a mu \ n g t h a t a c e o m a n 1
t hc
e s
p
l i f t ha s o o c \ c n n i o r t
a n d c la s 7n m m
p m : o u n l
l e a me t h a n t h t f o n n a l o r \ n t t n
o n
d
1n \ c
x t
Dc \\ c l
* hm t l
c
PrvJ1l 1ng 1n l p o r t
ht
53
l c s s l o n a l i n n (l a r g c l y o u i t e p o s l t l v c
o n d a f ' r m i n g ) a n d t ht
g u l r t h a t c x t s t s b c t w c c n t he s e
v a lu e s
a n d
p h y s l c l a n b c h a v l o t l r s (C a r n p b c l l c t a l
20 0 7 ) T J\ d a \ 1t h o r s n t v c r r c f l r c n c c t h e > l c b u t t h e i r
a r t l c l c c l > a r l y h i g h1l h t s t h e d l f k r c n c c t h a t c a n e x i s t
g
b c t w c t n w h a t p h y s t c +a n s s a a n d w h a t t h e d o a n d
y
y
t h u s i n d i r c c t l y ho w
s t u de n t s m a y be
s u bje c t e d t o
c o A+n t r r a i h n g r l c s s a g c d u r i n g t h e i r s o c i a l b a t i o r 1 i n t o
t ht p hy s I c l a n s r o le
rn
a n
o r
XX . : Y: , . : X. :
H C t h * x \ r y h u d e e p L o n L c p t u 1l r o o t s w t t h m t w o
o l
m d c d u c a t 1o n
1' l i
a c a d c n l l c Jl sci pl ne: s o = 1 o g y
NL1Jt
l
\
m
J
[
I
t
r
c
h
h
i
J
u n h c r
o
D c w e ) fo r
n
lo so r c r n t
o t e u n t h c 1t 1 1: x ) r t J n c e o t C o l l a t ( r a l l
\
c \ n 1 p c w r
ea
\n
i g ke yw
u s n
lu
c u r r ic u
O th e r t h a
1h u
n c tt \
t \ pc l l t
1h e 1\ i d d A 1\
fo
rm i
c t Bt 1 1c u l u t T
= u r 1c l j l u m
l ( u 1 r t u l u r n
Th > 1rt f ormt1l
( u t 1 1L u I t J 1n
11l L' l . \ t t nt cu1f l cul ur Tl

Th L
n u
ll c
c u r r \ t u l l Bm
u r r ic
10 e p e r iptt
l\/
u lu m
I c
T h u u n i nh n d c d
u n +C u l u m
cw w
u lu m
C u r r i a Bl Bn n
S E C TIO N
54
l v lo
p n 1e n f
actu a
m J i n t a in
d t hc i n t e n de d
\
T h i s 15 \ \ h J t t Bn s L h o o l 1 r t h e t c J e h c r s a y s
\ u u m
L u m
11n o t e i n T 1N c
1 t hc h n n a t
1\ b c l n t J u g h t A s \ o L 1 \ \ 1
fi r s t t \ t h a t
c u m B u m h 3 \ a t I c J s t t \ \ Ll d t m c n \ l o n \ 11 r c
t a t T l { 7 u e WC b \ t e
I t m t J W d Bv t h ] t 1 n \ \ n t r 1g (m t 1m
mur c Fl l ahus o r o r aJh b a t c N h c r A w m n h n c n
T he t, )r m J l
c u lu m
u m
ht
ls t
tc
\ ta
l ]c w
an
v ( T su \
l e ss
o r
c o n
B1
s in
ha t a r c
t ho s e so c
t
11o r m \
i la r , b t 1 t 1 t i s i r [ x ) r t a n t t o
i i n c t i o n w n v c e n 1m ro r n l a
c e p t u 1] d s t
l r c c o _n u
r d a n d o pe n y
c
w i d e l y s ha r
l
e s s o bv i o u s
l
11 ( a n
\
t
s
t
n
]
to
\
l
u
c
l
i
n
ia
bt
n s rn a y
d by p
l t
gm
rc co
t l c 1p a n t s
1r
\s in
s tu n
\ \h
l 1F
n cto n J
\ n Bd
he o t he r t lu n t\\ r m
di n\ cns1\ ns m J \ t
mt i nl
\ \ Tu
1-
\ r
hn
ll \
lu
c atc n a
h u .l c
a $
U m t
1n
JL -
l
\ .
t hB
a )
ru
fa m
Hu & c s
f1 c u l l y
is
1 1m l
ht
c r
JJ t
1o s u
hr
hat
t t ri
d l f fr
Hu w
gu
t1
p hn
n l
t io n
ll u
c r r
p
}u
( 1o r r 1u }
l u l + 1 m
fo
In
M tlr { r
i nt
B1' "
\ i ll t J t
t \ B
'
d J I I\
Jr j
h B1}1 4
n i u rl l t J t t
B h 1u t l . Br 1
c a r u
tc
PP r m
> 1
Bi t cL Jr
p l , ) I R(
/ BB
m
]t h,
1l r j t
,
i 1w
l1
J l t mt l t +
B1> e l l Br
lu
u r
hp l (
l t l 11 i n l o t 1w J , t 1r r 1\
a n J / 1j r ui n1ou s o r i r t
o
h]e
u l u 1 e (J \
v B\ 1
O JLA , u u r r
lu )
h e u mi
h l
: t hl n1un 5 b \
hT t
bo \
1t \
b J \ l L t hr r
> \
t t
he
& \ te
ir
he se
t e n
9an
n
t ]a l
h c H C T hu \
b\
1o t 1s
hA
s t 1r
m * ta
p ho r
blc
\ \ B
L ,
1tt \
n l,
l l tf 1l \
lJ
Br 1\ 1\ r r t
hi fn
u r t 1>
>
\ i lr n \
n t
Ah
n [ ln n
I 1 n 1 t B J+ H f 1 \
i t tt 1 t
lUl u
1BH
) Bl 1> \ >
Bl l
1i
bt
i lm
Ul
JH
\ l 1e \ l r \ l \
Bh a t
tr r
l l
1> , i m e \
lr
t lnB
Tt t r t l n B1t
ht
t t
It
lu
t lu
:m
t >J n
t h,H n w t
> l \ >
1\
)n m l \ l
H W %\
\ u m
le
m m
l> 80
t l \ 1111 1 t r
(
Nd t he r e hw
w r
knn
H Hw H
u r
\ L
\\ t
\:
gn
e n \ \ 1\ l 1 u l l t 1r n m g
t l M i l t I y t u t )\ c l o r n n l
l 1m
u J11 n
J 1 1 1\ Bt l n
)dl
B1
f \ 11r B\ i Bt l 1 n
,
Bn
Bj r
In
u B1n 1
he H C
u r \ e ]\ t \
h r j 2 1) B1B l l i \ r . , J1
IJ\
so u 1\ (
\ s o
Fo
t im e
P Ct l r c t
d l l bLrJC1ng
i n
to =J
o\ t r
t ln y
w r u
1 p ho
\\ J
) LCb<r l
r t +nl nd
h1 1 w
( 11u l } j , 4 t t u r )
ll
( u 1l w
U n n d NnB1wun( l r wni nhLr phr 1u t h
w
I n
>
r h t p \ a n i l 1n t c r a 1 t i o n \ w t l h t n
\ }w \ \ ) r l ] \ :
p
(a \ o n t
J
rm a
an
n tct
c sT n c w
h>
cn n Bl n
du
1/ 1 t 1 r
be
ca n
m ln J t l n
t
r n t 1r r
\ \ l l l l l t \ a l t t r n J t l \ e r r ]\ t t e \
t i l t u m \ t T ) h r Lf> \
mme r hJ t h 1n w 11 e t n C n m
p Jn
Br
1N V
[ u t t
d aw
1l
co m e s
t h _J t t h > l e w t h J n \ 1 \ 1 b l A a \ : ?e L t s
l
1
[ 1l u r e LU
]
l
Bm ) tv
n\ >uul ncl . 1l t M
o c J \l l 5 t l 1ln t
t
Al
t cr n1t nch n c
h
t e w r h c
11W n
t hJ t n h % h s n
tu
an t
1P
L W
ta
//y
d be
t to n a
u sl n
tc
m t ] 1t
f t h>
Or
bc q u
l lc (
r e
rc l\o n \
hu
1$ o
w
r r
s ( Lo u s
p lc
\ l
r n
t 1
:o n g
t t r ms
in
1n
n iu r
le a
hi n g
to
In
cn t
e u
c c r c m o 1 ry
, l i
b o !o
up o n
{ rn
c ha
un d
is t i n c t i o n s c a n b e c r i t i c a l i n
T h i s 1$
h
a ls o c a n b c ]l m m n g
e
C
BI
t
h
t
c
d
y
in g
st a n
a s h 1g h ]
u 1d
l
) f
t h c c a se o f p hc n o r n c n a
p 5 r t 1 c u l a r y 1n
l
i n i u t n t s m a
w he r e
l
:
bc
m
n
c
a
r
a
s
c
t
y
t
d
a
g
an
c m gm
l
h
n
t
x
t
n
o
l
d
c
h
t
t
o
z
f
a
1
e
r
m
y
a
l e
d
a
o
h i d de n o n c
)
l
l
l
bcnct
h
c
i
d
u
a
l
l
r
a
\
p
y
n
1
c
(
o
a
m
n
g
Bc w n t w o r
to
a n
r c 5 c r s
r u ,,
a tf t a n
i t
1!
l t s
hm
d1H ( f
c w
Tp u
p lr
t a5
Ia t l t o
sL c
[o m
ts n o
H JU
Sh r j } f m
u Hr
rn
c u
P Bt t e n
b ,t x t
wB u
h 1/I CQ S d r y
d ag u n
rn
r h l s O C C U Rs
he r
t he r du
hc t e r m
u sc t
T her e
pr T o
ho
hin
\n
!m
su
n c l t
J re
lc
1/ o
r rt c
u n iin
l , c 13 /
t h e rc m p l e a n d d l
1o
1l
brc
d /y
1l (
c o n c
l c
u r t r c tp J n t s
u r n L \ 1lu m
. l mc
s a c n
reF
i c sc
H Oh e s
t)
a r r d LT i j u r t
u ,
r lc
] c
hr
t * l u+14XO . dAmt i n
G
rm a
hc l
g H
in
t 1c
W h i l e d c %n
( m c
hn
1\
ha t
1m
n o n
,; L
fo
in
kl y
1t 11 i n
u u 1(
Le o p a r d
( f
bc
l Ic J m
f L-
u1\ CJ 1t . ' &
f c
1q n r o
ar J
rn J v n
Bt r g - n o f t m
o f \ r u cTu r a l p r
w t
9\n
m i l l ( u r r 19 u l u m
l Bl t r
\ \ T O=
tm
t hc
Lm
I] \
1a
to
1 l
'
54 \
l \r h
u n
1Jl
n\
v m
t \ o
n \\ r
lw t
n r
1n t n -
en
tw
c n
co m m
r Bn t u t e
nt hi r
Ur t
1n
r,
I n f o u n
E<l u at c r \
'
i n \ t r u c t o r 1n t c n
I , \ m 1B 1 w .
n d u1n\ Jt i on\
h.
Tlo m
ot henn
t t
t 1n
fu r
hc
el
X, X X. X X =
e n t er
\ hu
do
"
"
1M ' H n w
u 1t 1
J \
t)
r J n1 /
( \ Br
1l
t l 1e
hr
Tt 1u
\ 1l l 1n 1
in t
h id d
ih
c u r r ic t 1 u m
10 0
nal
) .h r
1 ht
T } 1> 1I C ha \ hu t l r a n
ce
e x p l ie it a n d i m p l i c i t p r r s t n
l
t 1l , n k j 11Bu t t b 1\ b o o k T h
il
e t t r m opp\ \ r s i n Ro l l a n
'
h e 1i dd c n
u m n \i
JSSiteLI
(C h a p t e r 16 ) o b s c r
( PA L ) l t i n c t i o n s
It
1r n t t r g
a t io n s o n
ho w
i c '
h i = l c fb r
a s a v c
"
t r a
i n R t h c l Bc , i n C a m p b t II c h i n a n l V o o . (c h a p t e r
1n i t t
t l w r o l t o t h i l r Rc h y a n d
l
p o w e r in
3 1) m a t e r i a o n
t hc r o l t o l t h t l I C i n d e v a l u i
j
t
\
n
o
B
b
rm
t
1
n g
t
n
c
y
ld
i
l t i o n h i p c e n t r c d p a t e n t c a r e a n t < t ]\ c i m p o r t a n c e
'
re a
f b c u lt y
Hc
o f t hc
lo p m
H l r dt
t c \ c
in
c n t
c o u n t t r in
hc
1T
ts
(C h \ p t c r 2 ) di l f 1rcnt i at i on
t ? g l b r m I I) t h c
l
t c la [ c
(
t a u g ht ( w li a t
e
1
t
anl n g
l
I
1
d
t
n
i
1
u
a
r
t
t
t
c
n
c
a
c
r
)
(b s t t 1d c n t / )
h a p pe n s n p
\ n d l i n a l l y i n G 1a t t n ; 1n d St e r n , (C h a p t e r
b
i
u
c
r
r
u
c
1n
'
'
n r at c n a
r o le
e x
r t
p li c i t
n
d
v e
hc H C
u n
pr o le s s io
a n d
l l e c t i ( m i n = u n v c r t 1n g t h c
h i c l c tb r s t u d t n t l e a r n i n g
hs m
HC to
n a
3 c
a c \ }
HC
'
& o :(
1' 3 c &
c A C c
'
h> h J AH =
c t c c1
bl
a u t l o r ty
1n
>l i1y l
)r
E x p lo r i n
c u r r ic u
lu
a sse ssin
1T l
A p p l y i n g t hc H C
t o Is s u e s o : s t u d i : n t l a r n i n g a n d
l i 1c u l t y d c v ]o m c n t i s n o t a n e a s o r r i s k f r e e
en d c
p
y
o u r
I t c a n i n v o l v e c o n s i d e r a bl e t i m e a n d t f f o r t a n d
b t c a \ 1\ i t s t a n d s i n c o n t r a s t t o a u r e t e a c h i n g m o d e l
p
( w he r e s t t 1d c n L\ a r = e m p t y v t s s c l \ e a g e r l y w a i t i n g t o
b e l i l i c d b y t h t k n o w l t l gc \ k i ll s b e ha v i o u r s a n d
v a lu t \ p o s sc \ w d b t h= t r f a c u lt ) r a m i n
g is su e s fr o m
y
y
f
a 1I C p t T s c c t i v c m a
d
t
i
i
b
t
s
r
u
u
t
c
e
p ve an d o tt n
p
y
q
w i ll c n g c n d c r r c s 1s t a n e c
N o n c t h t It s s b y c x p l o n n g
t hc i n t e r fa c e b e t w c e n t h c fo r m a l a n d t he o t h e r
t h
fo r m a l a p t c t \ o f y o u r o w N l t a r n i n g e n v ir o n m e n t s
y o u m a y c o m e t o m o r e d e e p l y a p p r e c i a t e w h a t +s
,
S f u d / 11s f e e l
hc b r o a d e r
lt u
]
lo c a t e d
s oc lo cu
ra
u s
anB
c all
1n
udj r \ s l l (
he w
w 1t
e n \ l To n m c n t
h\n
I n t hi s s e c t i o n w e
o r g a m z a t 1o n s a r e
t h
l i n e p r a c t i c a l m e t h o d s t o e x p l o r e t hq o t h e r
f o r m a l a s p e c t s o f I c a m 1n g e n \ \ r o r l m Lm t s T h i s 1s a n
h
t u c n t i a l s t e p 1n a l 1g n i n g w h J t w e i n t m d t o t e a c h m t
h
e
l
1
]
d
b
s
\\
Jt is a ct u J y c am t
v o u r t r a in e
hl c h
o u t
b e u e d t o v 1r t u l l A \ AT ) t p 1t
d m t h 1\ l x x ) k A n v a t t > l n p t 10
d l o r r t f o r m a p r l e k l \ t l n L \ i r r 1 L\ 1
"
l ) 1s d o o n 1 > d t o l a l \ r e 11 n l > w >. l tB, . Jt r
t k p 1n t o t h t ( j t he r t l 1J n 0( \ r m j l , <u \ 1 e n
t rj
an
t\ 5n111l e
G e r r t n g s t + Br l t 1 L a m c T s ( f : 1l t y i n d s t u d e n t s )
ho u l L I t 1 f a m t l 1J r m t h t h c o \ c m ll cor 1ept ual
\n f
k a w e ll . Ke \ t e n TH (A ; r r m J l
. "
i
t hc
t
o
1
l
l
l
m
n
l
1
u
a
m
.
l
h
J
e
r
b
c
c i
l .lc n
n l1 )
m J
u n tn tt n
lL J lc
t t \, lt n t
a r n \ t
n \ . \ mc n t t h t
\ . <nnt y
Vi b t
hc m L M L
h B[
hn
n
e s r b l s h e
n n t n u
ew
n o rc
co \ c re
upr nyr j 1t >\
hBM
t l 1c
'
'
a lso
n t lo p a n . .
I m ( Se t + o n
U e W 1l b f i : t
s:
ts
vJ Iu H
an
A p p lic a t i o n
t h e hidd e n
hm
N m r m
>h> po t r
1n d n w H
20 11)
hu
nu
v
Bh r n n
H hw r r h
hu u l H K
e m n
n w
OB t h e p
in
he
Hu
m n
m n m lnLca
t a n d n 1t
m
n ia n
u r
h 1n
he
J m \n
m y Gu
1d
i nduhn t h c > a w n t
v w H he h a u n
ho u t
m
w 1t
56
C 1Br r i ( U l u m
Bl B
B1r l o p n l t
" ' " l hi\ t o r y
'
=
X
d i ffe r
h 1g 11l i g h t i n g t he
u l a is
t al c u r r i c
f
fu 1i n
c n e c s bc t w c c n
fo n n a l a n d i n o m
n t h i n gs
a s k Bn g l c a m c r s t o
i d e n t i fy t h e t o p t c
ed
le a r n e d i n m e d i c a l s c ho o l t ha L I w a s n t su p po s
create
to
( D o s J n i 2 0 1o ) s i m i l a r l l c a r n c r s c a n
t t lt c y a r e
t w o l i st s a n d d i f c r c n t i a t t b c t w c c n w ha
h
b e i n g t a u g h t v e r s u s w h a t t l 1c y a r c l e a r n i n g w e r e
l lr c tlm
t l 1 e y a r c 1c a r n 1 n g t h c l a t t e r ( t i i u l a t i o n s a n c
lat t e r
t hc
w he r e
o f
st a n c c s)
. n d
e x a m p le s
: o r 1n c r C o r r e
r c 1 n :o r c c s a n d l o r u n d t n n i n c s t l \ c
se co n
be
c x c r c sc
ha t t he y
tw ec n w
1c
ar e
o w n
am l n
co n
u cc
hl n g
s 1n \ i i a r l l c a r n
b L1t i o
tn
t c ac
a r e
to
the
hat
a n l w
c d u c a t ro n a
h id d e
r o
bs n
e r
ke d
hc l r
t
i y
u +q l B r
c o n t ( n t o
Ca
a
ppn
pau
f pr c
t t 1r B s
Jx u n a t
c n H
n m
hn
c6
dr
n u
a n
4 x h
r a
]o g
d pu
a
u w
td
n u n
r n nA m n
r o u n
u m
In
t u n \ e r < J t 1u n \
d\
\ t \
l l 1n
m 1n u
J nced
t > 1
dm
Jw
c r a
tu n
1il +n
lv
l_n
L 11\
> f
<
tt
su
pp
n u n
tu
l[ = . l
p r o \ 1t l >
In
h > It
U \
+\
ga t i v e
pe r ic n
f p ro le
c fc ( t s
ec
u lt i m a t e
im
it h
s t o r 1c s
dl c n
ly
m a
f t he
d hy
al
m an
he l p
dc r
ha v e
m e
w 1
c an
e c
dic al
t r a
o f
pc
ha s p r o v e d
r c is e
He c t r o n p a p e r
rc
u se
fu l
hic h
1n
e n t
m
ra m at ic e n a c t
e at r e c a n
l 200 4 1
c Bf
a ro u n
ds
>s
ht
f w
n
o
L J N
t o i l t an r
t e r 1f
t he
a r
tu n g
t \r
he t . m
he n
d tn
Lrt
he
ha
\ . Do
n e
1r L L1n
1n
6 \ k 1 <\ p r J \ t
e L\ t
e \ J tn p
lw
J A k
w h m
, \
Tw
n r
H m
r H H t H H WH
It
n o
xt u L v n t t
u n
Lh1
o r
B t hc
hn
he
+n
t h j r u
n n
le a r n
thc ial ot
r ka r
a t c
lc
\\ e
o u n
h1u c
ds
or
l e c L5c ks f o r
l rek
he r e a r e
i r c n t 1c a
1m
he
u n s a n c t 1o n ed
t 1o n a
p
\
d \ \
h t r t t he
D\ s ni 1n c
pn
r o
a r
T he \
1m
Uwk
n e
n t
pr
) r m
f t i c 1c
t a
d mr L ' L \ m
h k
e \
n o
h\
J 1 1n t t l
h
i n g\ do
r t t 1ng
\\ u r
= o r u Br o t m
po n
Lr r
1s t
o t
t h u h t he r e
\ \ a r L s
1e c t
rr
b At n J b i n e
\\
LAat
p J w w Bd+t e<
t(
e r o si o n
hi c a l
u n
Hw
n e
c x
r e ssio n
de n t s
st u
. Ti v .
F o c 11s
m e
a r e a r 1 o u t \ l t.> r
It n
c t
t 1n w
a n
pc
s \ a r
f t h e s t o r i e s 1n
b
e p a r u c u l a r ly
Th
o f Re a d e r s
l
l
c t a l 2 0 10 )
B
e
l
c e
(
a st a r t in g p a
f l
po w e r u as
hu m a n m n g
f
o
i
h
n
O n a la r g e r s c a l e t h e s a r g
l
m
u
> a pp
c
u
l
h c 1n f o r m a c u m
e x a m p l e s fr o m t
m
e a n s t o
f
e
f
t
b e a n c e c 1v
c \ a t 1v e i n q u u y ) c a n
h
S
m an et
c
u
l ha n g e (
o s i t i v e r n s t 1t t 1t 1 o n a c
e f fe c t
a
t
d is c u s i o
t he t o r m
dd t t t o n o n c \ a n \ 1 m i n t
h a % b p t u p \ u r h i n t < h e l tl
Bn
c n t \
w r o n m
1d c a s s i g n a b r Bc
f r o m t hc H C a n d r c ne c t o n
t e ll a st o r y
s t u de n t s
St o n e s
a d i sc u s s io n
n e s t o st a r t
i t u s c t he s e s t o
b
d
f
ac k to
e e
bc u s e d a s a f o r m o
M a y a lso
d
d c a t +o n a ( g r a n r o u n d s
f a c u l t y a n d o t h e r s 1n e u
fo r
o r tu n it y
w i t h t he o p p
t t i n gs
w o r ks ho p ) s e
n ca n
t c t
"
stc n l
m n
t he
to
1e a r r u n g c n
t h e u sc o f
' '
t in g e x e
r h e f o l lo w i n g w n
l 2 0 10 )
h o o l (G a u r b e r g c t a
l
c
s
t dlc a
at o n c m
h
c
h
o
n c e pt o f
t
c
t
w r
s t u de n t s
n
A f t e r l a m il ia r i z l g
b c v e r y u s c f u i h e r e T r a i n e e s m a y bc
d e s c r i be h o w p t o p l c a & d r e s s e d t h e t o o l s
t h e y e q u i p t h e m s e l v e s w 1t h h o \ e t h e y t n t r o d u c c
t h e m s c J\ c s w h e r e t h e y s t a n d o r s l t w h e n t h e y a r e
t 1 Is
1n a g r o u
p w h o s p e a k s %r s t a n d t h c l a n g t 1a g e
u s e d o r t h e r o l e s a s s u m e d b ) d 1f f c r c r Bt r n c m b c r s o l
t h e h e a l t h c a r e t e a m Fa c u l t ) c a n b c a s k e d t o d o t h c
sa m e
C o m p a n n # t h e s e t w o I 1} L s ( A n
e x c [ c 1sc
b e q u t e r w a l m g T h i s m e \ h o d L a n b r u s e d i n p r c
In t hc p r c c hm c a l
c Ln i c a ] a n d
c l t n 1c J < s c t t r n g \
s e t t i n g o n e m a y e x p l o r e t h c r e ]a t t \ e p \ r t 1 i l p 4 t l u n
(c g a 1r t l m c ) o f f a L u l t y \ t r s u s 7 t u d r n t - 1nd1l i r r mt
lle c t i o
a s
m c n 1s
le
c o
ho o l
Lc a r n e r s c k n t a ke o n
l
h
r o
a n t
r o p o lo gl s l o l m e d i c a
o f an a m at e u r
f
v
c
r
b
A
o
e
20
11
l
n
l
H
F
t
c u
u re
)
( a r a rd M ac y a cu t y
in
h
\ e w o f ba s r c c t h n o
g r a p l 1c m e t h o d s s u c a s m a p p g
d
:
a ta
h
o
o
s
t
w
c
m
c
t
e
c
t heeducat t onspaceandob)
the
1m p o
hp
; t
n 1n
c u r n c u lu m
R Br t 1 c T A r n
p=
ho s p i t a l a u
r e s e n io r c li m c i a n s
ff c t a s o ft e n m o
:o r r 1 a t i v c e e
b
e
c o m e dc s c n s it iz e d
l
s im p y
t o r s ha v e
d e d t j c a
le a r n i n g
e nv i r
r
t
l
ts o f o
sc
1n o r d r t o b n n g h o m e t h c n o l \ o n t ha t w c a l l c o n
s
t n b u t c t o t he H c
t h c e d u c a t o r m i g h t a s k 1c a r n c r
h
i
t
c
h
n
t o t dc n t r
t 1 m e s I t a u gh t w i t
a n d r e ne c t o n
A
s h a r i n g 1ear nt
c nv iro n n l c n
' "
n t et
pr e v e
ts
ex am \n c
ers ( an
'"
'
na
e m o t io
s t \ 1 c n
sa fe
. p'
m c l i c a
on
d\ st a n ( c
ha
u
t t
n g \w d
o n(
1n
o r
h c m i e s o f t h 1s
n d t vsr a w
n N4c n A d h n
g
I n mu l 1 s e t udcnt s 1o
h tM
w
mu
"
t l 111) : > 1w h
r m
\ n
i\
Re
\ lt> )
w i
l l 11 \
e o n
ly
a s
Iu l l
B1t dg c l i n i c i a 1s
C H P 1 L R
hy
a rc
hc p r m
a n
Re s i
hv
1r L
rs a t
l 20 1l
s t ?s
po
t
ic r o
) I n t hi s
Ic a r n
ra t n
l in g
d c r a t 1o
r e
re se n
lo r
an
ty
de n t s r c c = iv e a n
bm : c a s c / c c n a n
stu
Ti r
Lc
h t l 1c
t Tc a t i n
an
n
p l c a l l 1t c
r a
ks
ca sc
la t e
l
sec n an o
tw
il
1a
c t
re s
po
n st
o n li n e
co
c c Iv t
scn
stu
de n
ts
as
ke d
p te
a n
in
c t 1v c
sp n
pracu
arc
S t 1c h m ( t h o d s c a n bc
b li n g s t u d ( n t c e n t r e d e x p lo r a t i o n
b u t a l s o c a n bc
t h p c e r g u l da n e c
fo r d i s c u s s i o n i n a g r o u p
n g bo a r d
s esslo n
Re n e \ \
Bht n u l l c u r n c u l u m
d
th
o
c
o
t
m
b
v
n
a n
r
t
c
t
r
e
s
a
l
n
n
e
tea
tc
f
C
h
Bxcn
l
h
t
t
d
o
r
h
e
o
u
t
t
a
a c
e
in g
s t
e ! e t o w a r
b
h
)
t
c
n
c
w ha t
m ig t yo u r
r e s p o n d 1n g l !
p a t Be n t s
)
e d a bo u t t h a t
c m
y o u fa i l t o d i s c u s s a r t t J ( h
l
R n T m > o u r : o r r r 1a l c u r n c u l a r o f c r l n g \ a n d e . p o r r
Tu
1r
c hi n g
Bt r r z t l o r 1 r o
h o w m 1 s s 1n g t o p J c s m1ht ( o m n \ u m c a t e [ n t ' . \ J >,

h1 t I s i n d
t o b a in i a ( u l t y a n d st udt r \ t s a t x m t w
t i t or 5
l
t
t
>
u
1
h
t
h
s
o
t
t
t
t
n
r
h
w
1
Ls
v1 a i
n o t
p
l( e w r
f
B
]
l
u
b
L
l
r
l
u
b
t
t
J
1t
t a p r
This ( a n
!
c o r ce rn
h
wn
cht n
H
k
n
do
w
u n c
n o
n
A h e r a l h w
'
1w
L 5 n
f
k
r
d
r
x
t
L
u
i r1
N o n t t he lc w t ht \
J s m i s t r 1z
l
t
w
t
Lt e \
11a \ c a r o f o u n d J r r 1p 5 t t i n r t \ l l Rp 1n F h u w u
p
JB1 t
x
1 1a l t e \ r u c j t t JI y u \ r r }\ y 7 u B 1l \ t Br r t H n B, B
tl
I
1u w r r l u ( J. i Bl d v l Ba 1 k 1r BBJ o f \ p 1 t L u = \ i I r
1
1
l
l
m
1
t
1
I
B
Bn 1\ 1
o
)J d > \ n t t
c n Bu r
bw
Jr d 1
r c v
l 1k e l y
st
) l f , u J t l t J11 r r r 1 t
d l1
t lt
1 4
l 11 \ I (
\ r
l Br r
r \ l \ t l l 1\
l r 1t r r 1\ t l \ t
]>
In
w s
u n
j Bm
Jil>
t B
r t m
ly
n ew
>
c ] ln
O. . CCO: X X
,
?[ ) r (
r r TL
gle t he m
n o s in
ca n su
bs u m
e a
ll
f t hc
a fc w
co n c e
pt s
p ar t i
p a r t t c 1p a n
co
lly
in
ts
d m u t u a l l y 1n Hu c n t i a l
s o u p t hat
h
n o m i a t lv c
c
g
c u m c u la o f
a l a n d h 1dd c n
Se c o n d t hc
e d 1( a p r J c t l c e
a n
t c r a c t 1v c
cre at in
]n
hc fo r m a l i n fo r m
m c d 1L a l c d t 1 c a t i o n a n d m
H C h a s a n i n c e s s a n t a n d u b l q u ) t o u s p r e s e n c e w i t hi n
l
n w r o n m e n t
e d t 1c a t 1o n a l s c t t l n g s T h e r e i s n o e a m n g e
d
a
1t s i m p c t m a y b e
t s p r e st n c e a n
w r t ho u t a H C
n o
t b u t 1t 1s t h e r e
p n o t a l o r r c l a t n c l y 1n s r g m h c a n
l
a
he H c i s u n n e r s
t he
c s $ T h i r d a n d r e la t e d t
d i n d r :f e r e n t c o u n t n e s
e \ e r e ls e l i n ks p h y s l c l a n s t r a l n
h r d \ a 1u e 5 t }1a t a l l o w
a n d Lv h a t e t L T c o n s n t u t e s t h c s a e
J c 1o n J l m e d 1c a l
u s t o t a l k a b o u t a n . l ut ht nt 1c a n d 1 n l e m
t Bt r o u g h t h e
t h e r e +s J H C w t ? 3 \ n g l t s m
L u l t l 1r c
Fo u r t h
a n d \ t s t r a 1n 1n g
p a r t tL u b r u t t hat c o u n t r
L AC 1 J r et l &t 1ve a c t i n d t h u s a
\ , l t h t ht
w l r L\ n
fu e ls
tt l r m
l
r c tl e
d
\n
p r \ 1 tx
:..' ,bg(\tLal
hi n k J r ut
t t n
\ \ t L\
t
Al
1t
h ke
K
1.
L\
Hw <h \
r r
F\ n
I hh
tT
t t L\ n
a n i
hu M
\ i r r L u m
L t \
li ke
1n
t> \ \
\ \
11
t B1t
\ w
\ 1r
B 1L
an
1n
pu
r ta n t
ca tro n
( ha n
\m
du
r e
am u n
t to n a
i n
l T he
n o u r
a1nng: ur t 1L\ unt >andmmn
Ht p
t t he
r TYL
n wn tuJ H pt
t h > m 1 h 1Jn d a C
1p 4 n
1l 1s t
mt c a l
T h H C \ s
1n t L +
ll\
It is
\ 1\ 1 t \
tn
i 1n g
n \ i r nni t nt
n b n
tt\1
\ ht
l Bt
\\
Im
to
N C
ll a h
Pk
n
su
bt c &
ht n
1i 1 1q l l I \ 1 Bi e t l l
t ) 1I
n1i BJI 1\ BB1n
1 11m
c st n a
\ 111114
f r , I l .
i le
h
t h
c r e n c e
1t
I n 1 W ( r l \ M 11\ 1u l + i l l a t
l:
s t a r 1t u
l o
l u B: l 1 l y [ r l f f l \ Lt l Br > 1\ i n t l \ 1 w
P $ t 1w / l r t B\ I n
l
W
i ( 1111B t l B1 1e \ I \ ] \ Y i l l 1
t B1a t u \ c a b a l k l 1 l l 1w u y
t ) \ > f l l 1t \ t \ \ 1r M
f a c t l L I N Ie l 1 1d b n : : i n p l I 111 \ l B: j 1t
v
d h mn $ h n n u w 1 i w m k K l r B
o l scvcr u da y a n
1
1\
t
i
11\
t
l
1
r
o
(t)n\Ll tl \t1o\
\ l y 1n v B n t
f 1e r n t n
pe r pe tu
a re
u p1B
W t IJ \ t r r b
v o te
ha l le n ge s
c e
d f r a m r n gs c o v e r e d a b o v e t h e r e a r e
v
l a m w o r t 1y o %n a l c o m m e n t Fi r s t t h e H C 1s a
b
a
d
ro d
to a
T h e c o n c e p t c a n bc a p p l i e
s a t 1l c t o o l
h
l
M e d i c a s c o o ls
n u i T] bc r o r h e a l t h e d u c a t i o n I s s u E s
h
t c a c 1 f a r r +1o r c t o b o t h f a c u l t y a n d s t u d e n t s t a n
ld
t he y c o m m o n l y t a k e c r c d l t f o r : o r p e r h a p s w o u
l f a c u l t y a n d s t u d e r 1t s
w a n t t o t a k e c r e d i t fo r S i m i la r y
e n a
d by
d c
an
( o n
as
W )1i l c
l l a bo
b a s c l
t u rc
'
.
1 1c l t t t r
=o m
a n
d It
w a s
ll
o n n e
u s io n s
( fb
Con
d pro
a lo n e
I c
& 0 D
l 1a t h e
in
t w c c t s u b n 11t t t t l s e c a t a l l
y o r vo tes
fu r t he r s c n p t c d c o u r w h c d ba c k T hi s
d c s v a l u a bl e r c i n o r e c m e n t o f c o u r s e
2 0 0 6)
t )1a t
1l u n u t e s o n a n
B1 c 1,
c n
11l e +t t m a
a r n c r s
a lso
a rn = r s
w ec
n a l 1s n
ha n 5
h { w
s( (
t to
(} . a ffc r t y
m o re
d t l Bc r ]
d u m fo u n
c n c o u r 1t c r c
sa w
s c ho o l a n
u s in
g o n li n L
be lp s t u d e n t s
col l a b o
h r c a l c h a l l c n g e s t l 1c f a c e
u se
fl e
s sa
st
c onLept b
rc
hat p e e r
te
ht b
ro u n
a n
to
r e c e n
s ta n
he n
n s
s1
l,
lic a l
ho d
n o
fe e d b a c k a b o
c o u r se
ts t
co m m u n i
r t l 1e
c n v lr o n m c n t
spc n
Pa r t i c t p a
re s to
pa
1n
d e n t s b c l i c v c t }1a t
ci e c t s r o n s m a
y hav e
stu
d a y s c o n t a ] n 1n g a
c h a l l e n g i n g p r cJ f e s s l o
r e s:x )n se
c ase
he ir
m t
st r c a m
t hc
y fc
e v e r
o n c
(Q
ly p r o M
i 1i c l 1
he i r g r a d t
o n
t e c l 1n o l o g y
t 1v
1n
e ss o r o u tc o m e o
paL t
ttn
hc
as
a lu a t i o n
e v
j57
Thchl ddt ncur r i cu] um
I I I p Bl u t J e r s o pu Bl
d
t V O IL E S m
l \ > l l \ K W 1\ l > m t l M Ual 1t ber l S t t B e n
L
o n i n t hc
m
l
m
)
m
n
n
\
t BB> \ \ e r 1 \ p 1\ n n A L
l t 1\ t r r \
B
B
B
1B
l
B
i
rtB
t1on
f
l
Bm l , l > B\ \ t 1r 1 1L \ t l t \ n l I \ l l t t 11f
uune11ni c 8 o 1 5 4 3 5 7 2 0 10
p r Ll e
\ b
Ca
hs n i . A
ro n 5
A c , B, 1e m
Vl cwl wi nt
Un \ l c n H C
B m Bn a r d A I
:r u
\ lp w
1r t h c 1r BQ
rc
Lc
hc
t re
H a fk
an \in
n t
hc s
Ae
s\ i n
ey
l
Rt g J n S , G r u e n R L c t a :
n al
o f a n a t io
l
s
t
u
R
s
e
l
i n m c t l = 1n c :
l o n a l 1s m
r dic i n e
h s t c a n \ / I n 1u t t o b i r e m t 1 A e
o l
hl d d
p y
J:
C o ll i e
Do
sa n t
(b l 1 f
h i rr
r 1B1
E d i c f l t i o n
N c \ e \ b r k , 19 38 ,
Bo o k
1i c ( B1 5 c ho o l
N T 11c r o p 1o t /1t n g s I I t e Br Jt e t 11n

r
Pl r B1 l F St s s : u 1 T it e
u u n t s t 1pp o s e l r o )
h i 1d n
d1 l
E1Peri er1c
cl t n
i c 11l u m
t 1B1c l Br o r s
N c w fo u
Ga u r g
hi ddn
an
cu m
Lu
lu
W hJ
dn
c ;
1 J+1r
Re ge h r G
m c
sT
w u
dc
1 c an
n \
w c
lc
arn
fm
.e
i a
w c
do
kn
o w
w c
t la r
ar
Cn
d M
r r i r u 1N 11F
Macy in
r
Lt
l
y Fa c u t Y
ac
Ed w
li x
r rc u e,
r r 1 h 1g
I Bo s t o
h e s t u l c n t t c l ( h e T
o f p h y s ] c t a n s : T11 C
c e ss
l
l JM t 1i c i n 2 1(S u p p c
Jo
1 o G i r a l
l j : S I 6 520
u n 1 t
m c n A
ro
L o o k A H i t l d e TB
20 1 1 H
MA
hu
u ( J\
ar var
st it u t e
K A dd r e s s i n g t he h id d e n c u r r ic u l u m
l o f B i o t l r ic s
r c a 11 J o t 1 m a
l
r e s e a r c h / 1n
j
arc i
i fi c
In
; 1 i c i r l 1g (Pa r t 2 1: 50 1 5 0 4 2 D0 4
a rc
h n g u n v e i l i n g t h e h r d d c n c u m c u l u m C l Bn
O r T/ s N j i = a
R t r 1 r 1 R e : m r c l 1 4 4 9 20 2 7
20 0 6
t c ac
r Bu t
pro
as
c lc B n
8 5 17 0 9 1 7 1 1
n t
d lca l e
7 :9 200 6
PR L i t z c l m a n D K e t a J T he
Su c h m a n A L W i ] ] i a m s o n
i sc o v c r y t e a m
t c r c d c t c i n i t r a t 1v e
r c l \ t t o n s h p c e n
h
t
t
( a ( hc s
t a
fo w a r d a n i n fo r m a l c u r r ]c u u n l
i l
\
l
t r a n s fo r m i n g t he s o c a e n r o n m e n t
p r o :r s s o n a ts m ,
l
l
r
t
m a l
a
r
G
r
l
o
r
1
l ]ou r u
f
o l a m e d ic a l s c ho o
2 0 10
G o ft , ) n \ \
& Sc i 1Bt i l
m e
2 ; 5 8 59 , 2 0 0 2
n Jrm t n 1
\ f r c1t c u
tc t n
c u r r ic t B u m
cn
s c lc n t
S: T hc
Sa n d s R l l
Pl y f
20 0 6
Fr y c
tr r r
d ]a n l
E Ba t a ld c n M
hir d yc
r e :l e c t Bo n
t
p a : e t 1 p r r sp > d t > r s o f t t Bn
Td a l a y 4 2 0 10 , St J o l 1n
ex
1>
c
t B1 i r r r
t +n n
ne
f
]
in I t F T hc r o C o
l d a l d c t r St e
n
o
t
i
a
f
m
hc o r
s h tp i n 1
r c l 1 t io n
07
5 2 : 10 10 10 14 20
\ 4 7 : 79 5 i 0 2 20 0 7
Dew
ll J E : l t S
dw l p l n g
rc i 1br a n
Fw O Do n
ty
t l 1e = o [ n n
p b e l l EG
pr o t
1c 1B
T a y l o r J S T hc
in
st a n
da r d i
M d t c 1n e
a n
o r a
he
a c st
t 1 e n
&
t 1c s o
r
fo
f sim
l 1l
la
a n ces
d s u ff m
C 1d r u r
te
d P F c t i l 1 r y 3 5 13 4 1 6 2 2 0 1 1
Se c t i o n
Le
ar n
in g
s it u a t
io
C ha p t e r
Lectu
G
T he
Le c
n o m Bc a
t e a c Bu n
t he
t h e ir
an
at
m
p
ha t
e r
ldes t
a n
n c an
a s
an
l]
m c
t 1s e
ff e
c t iv e
he
o w
l t d ge
u n 1v e r s a
d 1c a l t
Ie c t u
in
it o u s m e
n n
ho d
de
ho d s
1v c n
e r
des a
le c
rn
pr o
T C r
&
+l
Aw
rv
t tu
r ll
r u
b n e f g u +d c t o t m p r o \ 1 n g s t u d e n t l e a r n i n g f r o
I t L 0 l d m b n e f By t h e t r c n g t h s a n d l 1m i t a A1o n s
t h e pr o c es es o f le a m i n g fr o m le c t u r e s t he
o le c t u r a
c m r k 111s a n d s t r u c t u w s o l l e c t u r e s a n d s o m e w a y s 1n
o f le c t u r e s m a y b e m a lu a t e d
w h i c h t h e c f Dm q
1/ w
&
s u
Du
T he
n u
o r t
he
Po w
u n
Co v e r
i n ds
>
t bc
r u u n
1,
t r >J
hc l e
, Br
L e cBm i n g
i t 1t a t i o n s
Rj
ro
l / e c Bu s c J
t in e
b . o
J j
r 5 1
(h
l t ur es
bc bo
c a n
n n
an
w o rse
le s s
m c
he
he n t hc ) a r e
st a n
rc L it J t i o n s o
.) r c m c r
r
d
l
h
t
f
[l
H
u n c t 1o n s \ F d e c c l t r p i n g
c 1r
t qu J t c ) t
n o t
u
B m g a
st
\ 1dt nt s 1 o l car n f t h e
u n t l c r 1 t l n L h n g a n d m \ \ t 1\ l t m s
ta \
tr o
a n A
w J
tn
text s
h e h t u \ l e n t 7 w \ L11J g J l n +1 o r c
g m l t t \ \ hxvl \ : t nt ur v s J r c t h v u n l !
: un+ u w B t h e n t h c M u n h w e n o t
l h n L I 1n g \
r eaLI 1n
h w
dJ r d
l)
\u r
n ]c u
h>
ds
Ju
l \ L\
n 1h
a n
phn
n i
Bu
h e
t t
he Y
t u r ,
l> t
w s n
pu rp9
din g
St a n
m
)n
s r s
Wet hu\ 1B
bmr t at r n f n
n 1t Bn
v e
ha p t
ar e c co
l l e c t u r e s I t 1s
lo p a n d r e f r e s h
ge
r s
T hi s
T he y
(B l i g h 2 0 0 1) G
u sa
h(
c a c
o t
S Ed
o n
d m o s t u bi qu
l l i e d s u b je c t
as
o t Bm
ho w t o le a r n a t o p . c o r p r o c e d u r e a s w e ll a s w ha t t o
l c a m a n d t h c r c b y h c l p s t u d c n t s t o r w 1s c a n d t o d e v c l o p
i n t o i n d e p e n d e n t t t 1i n k i n g p r o f e s s i o n a l s L e c t u r e s c a n
me
b r i n g a s u b j e c t a l i v e a n d m a k e 1t m o r e
i n s ho r t
f
l
k
l
l
h
1n g u
A1t cmat i vcl y t e y c a n 1 1
Fo r l e c t u r e s l i k e a l l m e t h o d s o f t e a c h i n g h a v e
hm it a t i o n s
c t u r e s
g kn
e !m
n e s s
t le
le m
at ( o n
ta n t
e)
dr n
1n
u se
p or
he
a r 1? t
tu rH
<e a m
im
b iuu it v
Br
r e s
1n o \ t
u r.
tJ
n t r s
( t t u > 1 t BHe
b u r
pm
>
( t l
rl
t l i l l i [ } r 1,
>
t o
Jt
1 tu
p BL
n n w n n
lw
m 1> ( t l 1 111\
r l J t l V i l t Br \ H
; 1n d
d p h> n
1t Ba f {
t\
Bn m
t } 1t
1n
\t t
1n l \ I l \
n n
l e p , n , te n t
t h m hm
h m
t n
n 1
It
nm
\ r m \w
hM
t l
I by
m c t n s
u Mx
r 1l \ \
t t l l B> n
+!
r1
r M h 1: 1l T
/L
r , V J r t
i l
[lt
1 \
r \
{ /t
tu
r L\
1b
k a r n a r c t w n pr mr t n n H> n > n t h m > > p n n n t t t s h d

hi dd e n p u r p o c Ot w hwnB n r h u w H u n d >> u M
t n g o f a s u b e c t a n d u l t }\ t w 1 \ t m l > n t \ l > l r l l I ) m t T11Bl Br
j
y
1
B m
e 1m
Lw
UVu r
o n
tu rc m
1( w 1 o
su
Pt
n c n w
'
:i
r n
a \
w ad i
w (
pr ovJean e n t l m
] tn
bj m
ac L o u n t s
t x
It
w t
le
plL
p
van t
T ht y
t t AI .
da w
p
In t a n
t h t mc d l l t
o r
be
r o n a
u w
u n 1$
oo
r >\t
O:
l 0n i t n l
I r o
v a
de e p e n u n d u r m n d i n a n d m u n h a n c e
g
d j n i c J t h i n M n 1 h > n Bn r o y i h i n t s
g
y
p
hf : kuk
pe
p(
w sen n
u r
kt
m
]n b o
tu
L H n H 1$
t iv >
nn
r i 1L o r
tl 1al BRlt
c n
%c
1o
a n
a n d g u M Ch n e s
7 }1t
n u
11 1 I t L l l \ > \ H
I U t t XL h
1
B\
N V M
an
ho d 0 1 m
r n sn
e s o
tI
lt i
<
rin
w
a n {
t m LS
h HT 1
a t n ge
n s
g t
t ha t
he
h ho m p a m
Le c
ate s
t \ 1r e s
arc
he r t o t h c
h
h
h
t
t
r
o
u
n g
e hw 1 d s o l
g
n o w
6 2
S ECT 1 OA
t BBn
11n
5 t r m 1t 1o 11s
t r u ct \ \r e
sc
co
n i o n it o r
m n \ u n 1c a t c
the
lv
u e nt
io
r c ac t
d)
ly
d ear
hc
an ti
in tc
de n
st u
t i n gly a n
du n
t\
1 1\ c
ts
st\B
a n o
A
t
a c
F IQ e 1 E l pl a n a t o r y
m o n
he
gst t
de l
m o
de l
m o
t le c tu n n g
a n
t io n s
c \n
20 0 1)
gu c
E m be d d n g Re tn e r a ]
s t u d * n t In t e n bo f m R-
d a p p b t h c k n o w \ x l Kc g a i n e d
b e w m m Tr i L d 3 \ a s e n e s o f
p r o c e s s e s w h i c h J r c c x r > u c d i n t h c Bo +\ Lm r n
p
R
ap F
c n t l y s 1m
p l e c x p \a n a t o q m o d e l o f l e c t u n n g d e r i \ e d
fr o m s o c 1 l B n d
c o sm t l \ t
(B r o w n &
p / y c ho lo M
st u
T he se
\ wn g
l n c nt ns Tr a -
(s c e
hc
c st
y h in
Dc n
ha t
ts t
be
ca n
d du
d fr o
cc
lA m
pu
r t Je
o f t he
r c d ( m
ht f r o n t
bo
o r
n t
t il
g a \ 1g c
re r t o
f i nt
de n t s
S
bc t hc m o re
b J c k t +nd t o
t io n s o
st u
to
te n
ho s\ t
a r 1h c
n
e
h
t
\
\
o
w
d
t
s
e n
1n t t r c s t c d ; s t u
t r ouht t mj ker s ( b r o w n &
b c t h e l c s , 1n t c r c s t c d o r
a n r ?e tu c e t h c p r o b J b i l
A t k i n s l E SS) M o n i t o r i n g c
h e l p a n t 1c l p a t c o t h e r
l
l
a
s
w e
u y o f d 1s r u p t 1o n a s
f f ig S 11
m a n
\ bl 1 t h e l e c t u
c n .
a re
n c J r
\s w
la
r ic u
1e
)m
i n t m r io
u 1g o u t c o m e s
he
u sc
st r u c t u r e
a n
l)
o n
I: )
n s
Ou
[c w
c o n t e n t
in t c
u sc
A bn
r e
t o
st at e m e n
f t he le c t u
te a m
dc
a y be
B
A
o u t c o m es
in
l u d u 1g
Pr
pa
t i o n
in
e z r
sa
s
i\
le
St u
\ Cr u
tu
o
t r a
(>
me i w e s
T hw
c (i n \ e
ca n
r a
Ud e n t s t t m
My
sp >ak
Usr
du
pu
o v r r
to o
vr
du t
u w
n w
n t r r t=
Bn
tu ru
n m
pr o
du w
n
s
m et
J t hc
1u
hu
>
st u dc n
1B? 1 B J
'
tu l
l dw h
Hm
H>
111t
% 11
hl h
"
d en n J
Jn
1n
tm
> t
hm
a n d
1n
hn
1L
u t d
rct o
dc
l d u d hx
m 1
in
u w cb
d r}tc
rc n t
nhh
p
\rt h
2 0
o
F t hc
LOOk1n:
It
(u rs
s e r u o py
1l
\ BJ
t 1\ t
r e
tu
U
u J
s n
r 1 1B 1
H n
lte
td HH m
BBn +
W i
L\
h\ i
\\
1 s i m i 1e s
C \ 1s t r n
t hc
1n
hL lp
l w l \
n n t
nJ
kn
m
l 1l
M N
u rh
tu
m t
r n
Nt
1.
s BBr e m e
iu i s
tts
c hJ n [ e
\\
t u +>
n m
? u i B1i r
t h w
n n
hn
1C t 1\ 1 t 1 c s
\ J n
rc
p ld1
1n
n h
n h n
h n mn v
l> J m
p1
tu N
t \
te n t \
r a
s l B 1 r Br r t B Bp r e
n BB r r n
ru
l t 1T e
gn
5 0
tes
lt v
N1et B ur s
k.
in
t N
n n h
\ .' [
in c m
t t hv
N
h
Jt
&
th n
JH d
h1
'
nx ;
1n 1
t uJt nh
k u
C
c h
rm
a n
tn w
i n c n h v
>.
n t
h mn e N
hv
n
n u
ces
n[
to
nJ
'
t H
tl>L tw
Ir c
t\
20
\ \
I hc ki l l N k
r ' r Bc 1 i n n s
r c a o n
f t'
h > h a m 1H l m m r
e
1n g 7
k H u r e w hH h
t he s c
n
1n d
1
mp u n n s n m
: l c t o u n t I u r 1 t u d > n t p r c l c r c Tl s l o r I n e r Rt h c r t l t J n
>hu
L \ \
n >
11 w H H w
w n
\ h
h n . Hn p
1n n u
1 1\ >
Bn
l\\
u n
h th 1
i r\
p Bc i t y
ca
c 1 B1 B
t ef n \
u s t
u s
1u g i t
te n
1. \ n
h c h c l L\
hr un Bl
l mu r r
l f tBr B1 e) u
es
1t
Te J
1n L t
t 1H t l > b
lj n
u s e
T he
l\
d = mu r r
h e 1i r r Bi t e 1
I n J TJ
a n t
rn Jtn t
\ J N
hll
In
Tn
he
t u p rL
J r r A'
hF
tu
T'
pr\1
n o n \ c r
r r \ t
o r
m (
1 nJ l h M
n w
t n n nl
H . .
t l w %t
( 1
B t B
1m
1I H w
lt s t h
IW
J n
,
A lt e
i n
Wh w
n w n m
ha
t n r
n
..
> \
t 1w
in
r J rn \
w t
) ho n
'
ML\ \ e1mnt )
CHDf wt l y
A ll
M o na
r r
pr omi t
t u t l > 11t \
o r
pu r poe a
u 1 Bl t t +r f l i t
a n
c w u m \
1 TA RN
u r es a n
c u n
blm )
p}
y7t er n u v H
t he \
ht y d
st u m
tten
bJ l
\ \ r
p ha t 1
i n t e r c s t 1n
l de s
hc
an \ \ \ c r
In c u
t hc
la r l \
lcu
k
k i n r n e m u r y w d o n o t t a l k t o o q u i c l!
me
m 1J t 1 o n p r o d t d m t o
a n d d o c h u n k t h c 1n o
P
r e s t n t a c +o n s
s
c
n
f
c
L
t
b
n
w
.
h
n
1n g l u l a n d r c h A \ c
b<
\ d\ st r at \ ng c a n n o
t h a t a r e t o o f a s t o r t L\
1 r k 1n
g m c ln o n
x l b\ t h c \ \
tw
f r 1 l ct ur 1s u s u a 11
n j ri o n
t
B
1
e
a
b
r
i
r
a
Re m e m e r
1u
Xl at c h
. n B
o v
t c n t 1o n s
ga m s t
1t
5o
(r
o u r
( o
Mh
k uch
qu a
an
a n
hn
to
h > a d t r a n wJ r
v o un
hx
in
i t t Jt udt t o \ t u d > n t s
d t \ rn t r
u n \ ) bu r r do m
ble
ca n
t e r e st
pa r t
rt
w d s
re
j s s io
c o n t a ct
in
Yo u r
ll la n d
c le a r a n d
t u rc
m t
be stt t i o n
c n e s s,
a n
de n t s
tu
o u r sc
1L s m
bJ l
\ c r
p rc pJ
Ask )
e c
hc
tu re to
a n
1 1r a
n e n ec s
t he le c t u
he
pe
r e
ha t
st r u c
c n l s
rm
e x
fa v o u
the)
se
i m i t Ji a
c x
t an
g p Bu
Ca n
Ar
r e
o x m 1r
chc rr
co n t e n
c r ta ln
'
w u
t lw a t r e
Hh t c d t hmuh
h mn n
w c
1
h c w k m t he
.
H
e
L
1
5
hunn m
t h> C U
h u/c oB
e \ > bu i n 1 n \ l t c
p r t +\ u \ t 1\ 1\ \ \ I 1t t u l e \
r J t L J mn J t n n h J w t h m u u n n i w m n t A i n m
k m mOHR
n l > J l >v H & w n N t h > J U a n d
, h;
hn\
l e \ t u 1n g +n J \ b A t , m i l L i \ i \ Hm w n \ t l . A [
1n
1l J W C
19 S
H
Nd
t 1 x an J
I h>
l v mm>
1
E
(2( U b )
M5nu<ue
Ti b l e 0 1 T h o
k illa
f l e c t u r l n o Wn a \
Skm
Co
P r e p a r a ti o
s a cc o u n
s tr u c tu r e n n
O pe n
in
Gm
Ex p l a i n i n g
Pr e
l le
n s a
Th e k e y
l in g
se n
to
1n
kc y co
S C O f
An
r m o t ro n
Te l l i n g
C o m Fa n n g
tr a s t
co n
De
gn
du
J n s \
Va h
o l
u s c
e p e ss
th a
to
t \ Bt)
a c
fa c ts
de
u n
lhc
n s
to
e r
\hc
o r
s to ry o
po
co m
a n
m a x im
th e b]
1s
s c
c 1s o
o u
pu rplM
o r
cha n
s h o /I
kn
t
Ls
in
It
* i t f t u 1 p
1\
w A c H r n t s
d\
a s
:Xj
Se e
in
re
t l B
o ll
ke t
l /
Bt J (
t .
r )
in d
\ ht
r l } t t
Bl v J w ( t
t l r 1 B:
l } 1t \
t rTl i n
a J
l:h n
de n
gn
llt
I\ t
t t
\ r1 t
k l r 1A l 1 \
11 r 1 1t \
t l H \ t 11 t n
le
1r
hc t
f le c t u r e
C l a r r ty a n d g e n e r a ti n g i n t e r e s t a r e r t s
f l e c l u n n g s u c h a s p r e p a r a t i o n o p e mn g
li h a
to b e
is
m a tf f c e s a r c
tlm
im
g r n a t 1o n
pa r e d
fu l lo r pa
co m
u se
pr o du c e
Ts
a u d ie n c e
lm
re a
d in g
ll 4 lf }
r l
pu
l da
s m e n ta
f th e
do
re
f the
c o n tr a s t e
a n
re
co m
l t e
de n t s
s tu
p a r rs o
s le e
ra
the
u re
1f
a n
n s
r
re a c t o n s o
a u
a n
En c e
t th e
O\
c a sm n J
It x
tu
Pr \
e n
c a n
qu
e s
llv
1 u e S ho
d b e Me e n t r e t 3
oc l o d
n M
d h e ig hte
an
A En s
h u
1 de
m c u
as ze
err
a t
c o
gT
the
o -
s mi l g r o u p
5 o o
a c u\ t e s
u r > \
w i
Bc
du
su m m J n es
n n
o n e lu \ m n
g t he
to
le c
t u re
u m n \Jn ze
a n
r a ise
e st \o n \
J \ I\ \ n J
li\
Rn J r 1 C J l \ u
In \ \ t e
\ \\
n \ tu r c
I k
h st u l e n ts t o
h L 1r s u m m a n t s
lew
rw
R 1' M
VU ' N
t u +le n t \
1\ B
tu
>, <t\ \
[u
B\
I I I 1n
n nh} h 1 XH
w >
t
Lhr i hmn
t h e o r H1 m}
ll h
u t l t \n e t
l In
B\
uw
li l t e r
r nh
. uu r \ \ 1l
t Bw
t 1L >
1" t I '
It
t u : t 1\
1l e
le ,
tm
tte n
t \
in
\S
\t n c
OB l r n n n w u l e H n
tw i t u l t l B7 l w t t 1\ l \ 1 [h r 7
u l
1 \ (
wo u k
]
+\ s
1l t
\ e
Lh
r 1n
t nng
p r cw e
t h e le c t u r e t c F
t 1r r \ l l r r B. \ l l J l l m
B
1
h>
s om e
Ca n
a i
d pf e pJ
WB > mn n
\ i rrt
1 r u v 1B t
t
de d
l hJ L L t r a \ k
th h t u n
\r
%w l e c t u
o r
r 1\ t
he r
hi c k
arc
\n \
: h
] l 1R\
t ) l I (
fo
b
v
H h Hh
L m \t u n n lH n n n
lln d
11 e d
Lr t n e
.
hnw
St mLt ur e\
bt
I ) 1) t
Tl 0 11
u rn e
a c t r v 1t y Y r e r e l e v a n
1n
ks
o u r st u
t 7st n
n tL I u o n
5 r B} t r t n J \
l J n
u I \ x ) r t 1n t [ u
po r t d> t
A Hm
ll d
JV
r 1r $ y r 1 m1 b I B1
Bb A
u rc
Bu
: wl p N
t d
t 1w
he t w
It h
J n
> t
v i de s
re c o m m e n
p l a i n i n g II i s c o n c e r n e d w r th c l e r a g e
l d l n q t o o m u c h d e ta i l a n d i n d u c i n
g bo
a le c t u r e a s w e : a s a
the l
ge s
:x
e / lo rk o
m o n 1l o r l n
a te
u i d t
d p ro
o r o u tc o m e s a n
s tr u c tu re s n o
g ly
se d d u rin
p a r iso n s
d h e a lt h b u t
e x
f pr o
a c le a r o u
d t l w pur : n>\ \ t l I t \ t J f \ J r e u l w
d
s 1a l t e
4 3 Br Bt e n d e d 1> j r m n _ B) u t \ t ) r 1e \
I t H ) t j B t I 1l c t l
m
o f o u t L o r r i c b t > 1 o r r 1t b J \ \ r J t t ) 1\ k t t r .J t l t c r t h r n
i
dx
cu nt t n t
y lo o s e
a rn e rs
s k BiIs o
Do
y o u r u b )c ( t
d pr > p ar a u o n
o w
ve r
e o r Cp Cn c n c e h a l c a t u r e s t h e
p
d i n g A p o w e r f u l b u t n e l e c t e d s k i ll
g
n m e n
k i l l In c lu d e
:H
Th
k i ll s ?
d pr o v id e s fr a m
an
k i lt t h a n
r s t 11n
t o k e e p th e m
v e
ca
de
l tli e
b l e th a t t h e
ke f p o
d i n g +n th e le
1 tl e n
r u n
a c c o r d in
e s s a ry
i
s ta n
D a n ge
t u a l e n li g h t e
d in g
S h o u ld b e
}a
ke s t
S p e c l f Be s p u r p o s e s
a rn e rs
ra p p o r t
r
o ne s
mc d l c n e
in
g te c t e d
n c
Nec
v te a
p e c i f ic i ty a n
t r b l ls h e
e s
l b u t lo w
1n
l c lle
1n
Po s s
a
Im p o r t a
re s
9 SUCe 1 t
SJ
g e o le
Un du e s
ce
Ea s y t o d o b n d E Re u i r e s
y
q
c t f c e
qu e n
C r e t l to s
c a re fu l fr a m i n
an
c 1 a 1 m C C \J
ca
Re s
a n
p o n e n t s E m b r a c e s r r i a n o l th e
y
u d i o V l s u a td s l l T
sum n n
d de e pe
an
ge s l
k n o v t le d
se
t ro n
po r t
s k i ll
e s s c n tla )
N a r ra hn g
F .r o n
yo u r
m m e n ts
Ti 1k c
o 1e
[ o \
l 1t
n ln n
s d l l t l u l
tu
r> J
1f
yo
M l 1y u n t o n
1t o pr
oc o ,
mm
LJ m L>
pw
1
l)
rL m
uh u
a lo u
w n
un
R.
l <h e r
w o n
1 1 P m p 1 r i n 1 1m
g
Ch o
\ m
2
to p ic
o s e
y ha
) bno
um
f t r i e r r l Jr r
b e e n g n re n l o y o u
ve
to p ic
yo
B
t h is o
a se
t it le t o
t h e le
tu re
g to
q u e s tio
R i n g t h e t hi n g s
n s
i de a s
yo
c
ha
tw
ta
t ic f o
th e
f t h e le
gh
s t r u c t u re o
o r
pe
w ay
Bn
a n
te
t b e le
pat ef 1
&
4 0
ie d
a n
Re ne a
-
Nt e s
m a
"
o rd e r o
su
C le ar
m
t a
p e n m g t h e le c t u r e
n d p r o v i d e Bh e
ht
in
f yo
pn
a re
va
w o m e
po
st s
e x
pla
bo u t
56
p la n J t i o
s
ig n p o
dlc a t c
t n
fx
tn
t 1o n
It
tu
n
1t
a n
W in
r
r c
hc
t BB>
t lr e
'
o r >
in c
tm
>[ b # t t )l c r
W Bw
ptt
g hl y t o
r o u
d \ Br )
ro w
l (
M 1\ >
Ie r
Ln
Is
t n
l ( 1u ;
ll J t
t]
l lo
h>
N 1t
B1Bt \ t l t t 11 \
'
LV l w
W irt n
'
\ 1h
I\ w
Pu
n J
pr n
W l
l\
it
li l e l)
\u
lly
fr a m
e s
fo u r
d l in k s
c o n t a in
fo c i
a n
st r u c t u r e
\ n )p
hJ w
p
1n B
1o v
kh
n tn
r rt e t h d L
I 1Bm
t
<
3 u Bn n 1( 1 F
Br r h t
Bn
a n
uc t
st r
Si
d di r eon
an
1 f Bf t
h L Le
t N 1r
B1
gB
e n
se c t i o n
1pnt r A
r Du
i i ar Ar . 1py T r
pu
11n t )
\ 1
rtr e
r 11 4 3
T I I v
s 1Br
1 n r gleL
1J z
r 1w
t\
a n
lc
a n
B ft
p la
e \
1t t f r
\ 1ur uel 1r ng
n J
B1* ,
t 1o n
c 11
Er
r \ t \ 1 l \ n l. . T
w t h C, n t he m p \ = ) \ \ Bt hc
l l Bn k \ l xt \ \ , . n t h e e \ p t \ n \ t n \ n a n d
l r L tK u l t 1\ c l e 5 t r \ t t
l e
\t l n
Ln \m
lc
em
t hc
in t
+ Bl ,
t 1Bn 1
u t t \ll
p +\ \
il
i r
lt
u \
u t )
l l {c
r br
r r
< r V
t )
II
l 1\ I B1r
r Bt \
it
4[
!on
Bw > ' r
h i B 1 4 B w t Bl l 11+ 1 r r t Br
I t l l 3 B I e e tj e t 43 o l
r \ 1l r y \ 1 v t Bt l B t tl ; r l t ] l B t l B
BB r \ o I 1W
I11h1l l \ 4I \ I J1'p 1 r t r t v Bl , 1 hi t i t / 1t Ip r d
l + Br + 1 r
I l r 1l l + Bl i l r
1r
lr\ d
v rc >
1c
p o r t a n t t u p 1u ?
s j t h ke l y t o O L A t i r ?
t 1s u a
. 1 q l I L L w 1) n l l 1w l t 1 l \ i \ } : I
1 I t t \ u r r 0 11 t t n t l > t l n t l t t r 11 1 11"
x a n i p [t
wn u n n n Wh n h
w ht a d h> w t hm
( a n
st s
he
11 1v
tlir
t 1 Bl
'
n s
tn
e \
Tk
lrn t \
X lsc X
d l L a t c t h e bc g 1 n
p b ru t t o n
hc
to
J 1Bd
w n
i m
r e
d e r s ta n
u n
a n
t f Ba B c 5 n n o t
d 1n Q o 1 t h e
t io n
n a
Fr a mt
# a n y c o r r e c t io n * y o u * t h e f\ r 1 t t m e y o
e x
m o v es :
t e 1s e q u r r r a l e n t o
te
n o
deLnpu' , <'
Bn t c r
p /e
rln c 1
he s
Tr de By 1 u M h t o o u t l u / . . Y o 1l Jo u , a p p r o a c
1
r
t
u
s
s
r
m
t
B
r
t
g
p
f o t At m a 1u Bg e u t r 1 o c a r zc t
1
n
h
(
l
r
h
r
t
c e7 n o
py
n 1, 1l o 1h n l n
j
n t l Ao { 1
A
t r t c r r Be t 11o t l :
A
t
r
cB
e
t
c
o
s
p
p y
E x p l a 1n . n : 1 c o n t > r n t d w i t l i n 1 n t Bndt r\ \ ant l l n t u

U r 1d c r \ t a n n 4 L t j n \ l \ t s u t r t Ru h r r 1> \ \ L 1 ) r 1
o t her s
]r 1 r m n t 1r \ f > 1\ 1r \ :
u
[ Jf t B
w B
B> r r 1 a t J
Bv
n c ( t l u r l s 1n t B
n Br r > t y p t o f A r ) I H 1 1l t J 11 r \ + b n J l 1L \ i 1\
s d l e r Ba t a
n e w
t
! a r n e cl
e x
o u J lc
r r 1B J n B Bg e n i e r Bf
a s
y 1 f 1 u
/v
. O"
b lo p te s
Su
ht
tr
1\
pl
m e
w ) cl
p fs
cc
fc f n
LB
r
U(
>m
d ra
n s io 1
c o
u ,
l n
J r r r 1 r Jr r L i
a re
t hs -
en
g bc
"
"
t ine a t r e
l 1
:X
tu re
c tu r e
Bl
re s
^
t he
rsto oo
y I h 1n
C U / \ rr L } ' /
1f
ro
in g
G h re t h e l e
"
C h e c k t h a t t he
o t c h a n g e Bt
uv
dc
u n
gah
o n
p !o
la i n in g a r c in t e r e s t a n d
kc y v a r i a ble s o r e x p
h
l c a r a c t e r i s t i c s b y m e d ic a l
a r c v a lu e
h
c la r i t y T e s e
d a t t e n d e c s a t m e d ic a l
t r a 1n e c s a n
s
u n de r g r a du a t c
l d e t a l 2 0 0 0) T he
B o w n 20 0 6 C o p e a n
c o n c r c n e c s ( r
t i o n is
g e n
l
in a n e x p a n a
la t t e r r e p o r t t h a t 1n t c r e s t
c as e s
f
e x a n i p lc s
o
s
c
u
h
c
t
d by c x p r e s s i v e n e s s
h
x
e r ie n c e
h o n a n el a p p e a l s t o t c e p
' ' "
.
de l o f
h
m
o
c
t
d
i
n
t
A s i n d 1c a e
lc a r n c r s
t hc
o f
V
1a
y
fe at u r es
lc c t u n n g
b u s in e s s o f
s e n o u s
Pre p a re th e
Th m k o f a g o
c ture o
f the le c \ u r o
c tu re
k a y f
g e d u e e tho
s tr u
a s t r u c tu r e
i i Xi + x
-
2 r) { / 1
1. n17J &c \ J i 1l t 1u
Tw
a ro u
be
p e c tft c id e a s a n d fa c l D o n t r e a d
h R e a d i n g c a n b e c o m e a d o la yl n g
m u c
r in
ve
e s a n
rl
c l e rl e m
r s
is
t \he
a n
hc
c o m prc
ve
t h e o bje
i rl
to
u a bo u
u s e
\ he
c l fy
po
Re a d
Re a d fo
'
id e a s
o in
to yo
v e r c o n te s
ha te
f a c ts
u a re
Se t o u t
Pro d u c e
'u
s e 11 i
Fr e e a s s o cia te
W r it e d o w
n l p :c
rl
t 1
II
V t } l B / Bi B v
/B
1v
lAlt n
, u
r 1t t
u r
H \ 1\ t c n
o r
Bl v
t l ( rl\ 1
r1
t Lm
\ ly,
br it j
ke y p o
stgn
in t s n o
p o / t ; rr
c >
\i
m r s m
p t \ ; \ s 1z t
an
l i n k s T h c 1\ t t c
glt t c t i n g
n c
ts t r
m o
l o v e r
to
i n
tt i
r o
l1
n u t
i l t he le c t u
l1 o c c u r s
m a
t r
re r
ia l
Kw
1r 1f o
f ' ' p l 1 i n 1 n g 1s p l 1i H
Tr \ 1 n s h l 1r r g t h t m c s
N W N r
At
he a lt h c a
l
m e dic a
s tu
re
N n
'
r is
hc
L IA a r
to
in
gc
bo
1r
rle r e s tin
f
dt
u v c r
>H
gc
n c r l iz i n
ar c
v i su a
l h c a l t l t = .1
1n a
l le a r n
t r s
m e
n n
d ic a l
tn u
d
ch o l
a n
r c l 1t s o n v i s u a l t
u c s
ll n k d t h r o u g h V l \ u a l i1
sto r e d an d rc t n t v t d f
ro m
tio n a r t
r t 1\ c s t u d ' n t s A n l
o
T11t
r
l
l
\
nt
'
,
r
m
t
e
l
o
n
t he
g
. .
k n o \ e t l e s l g n i n g J v 1s u a l r t p r e s e n t a t i o n
m a n y lt v t u r c r s
\ o w N u n t lt r t J n d ln
g a s w e ll a s pr o v id
c a n d e c w n o n e
d
d c e p e r u n c r s t a n ch n g t o o n c s s t u d e n t s
tn
i de a s
pra
a n B
d p r o c e d u w t ha t
m o r e li k t B
) t o bc
an
du
t to
c a
n a
dv
l
ic e
u s e
D 1J g r
t r a t o n
1 n t Ta n e i
3n
o o
ys
w 3
pc
t r t . o n s ; 1r
<j t h e m
V,T
am s
r >
u \ tn
b )e
il
Jm
ht
r c
te
l B>
Tj : r 1 t
d 1
JH
1 1 1t
r e n L c
u n
''
"
rc
he
w A
t h c \ t u d c n t s a r t l m , l . . . . . . 1l u s
f ! U U \ \ J n l t h r n t o lo o k 1 n t e m \ t l y
t o l u u 1 Fo r i n t i s h u t u p
\ 1d e o
r > o r d 1n }
\ \ l 11 L h l c J
1n d l , J t e
.
\ lbjt
ll>
l l \ 1+r B
1 t ) 1> l t
r r B B\
J>
1 1 1r ,
r\>
h > uu] t t
t ,
bo o k
1J m
+l J r 1 \
+ d r ,t
1n
h i l st
po
s u r r Br 1J m
l>
ha i
\\
e n
h 1l t t
dt
1\ c
blt
J \ J 1 a
J r c
i uul d b A at t >nl ( d
t u rc s
a u
i o n s
ts
Ex h y
tu d e
a s s u m e
th e
f i le s
ir
Va r y in g
de
st u
T he r e s n o t h i n g w
Kn o w l e d g e e x p l a i n
Ic
kn
ss
ro n
tn
\ b ke
t \
hu
1
l t . t rn t
1r \ ,
1h >
h
Bu
I l i n k l h,
r \
t ir t e
e d g e
so m e o n e
a n
Bu
i t do
it h
e x
pe rt
du
re s
r o
c e
pro
es
fo llo w
n o t
n 1 t\
t L\ n \
hu
as
ll
ys
k onel f \ \h
hc
m J t e n a
k Bn g 1m
m a
I s m
he
st u
m
u r e s
o r e
po rta
i m
o r e
de n
l car n
ts
n
n t
M
o
tn J t
h t 5 1n
Jm
tJ t
1t
w
t
t
1u n \
1L \
l0
t e r a = tl v e
n s
(F x l \
he l.
bn t
\ 1
ReJJ1n Qu e 1 m
tu re
t \
1 J5t
k\
\\
v n m c
sb
i n
to
> UO
gr
o \
(\ [ R Q)
On
hr e e
hat
o re
E t e
'
be
( a n
a
( a n
fo
o r
ls o
u r
H a ) , t ud1e F r , \ b l c Tn s 1 n t e r p r
p
( ht 5 h Y n t a t o t J c l\ n l c a <
M Ic
l J k > JH n mh $ t
Ot
h HW
tm
o w
r u sc
& J u
c e s
hu
itt
Jl l l j : I )
u H
o r
u r*
Hn H H \ l w h A m
ZUj 1
a r r +t l
tho
x c = a x T J mX a X
J re
t o
c o c e r
\n
]t l
t : 1e \
\ u r t
ha s
o n c
Hn
t ir k t
u n
ll
h a t b e c a L1s c o n e h a s a l e c t u r e c l a s s f o T 1 h o u r o r m o r e
By v a r y in g
o n e h a s t o t a l k fo r t h e w h o l e t i m e
sb
s t u d e n t a c t 1v l t l e s d u n n
I
a
n
r n e w
c
c
u
r
e
o
n
e
g a c t
d e n t s a t t e n t io n g e n e r a t e i n t e r e s t p r m r d c
n u
o
p
p
o
t i e s fo r s t u d e n t s t o t h i n k a n d o b t a i n s o m e f e e d b a c k
l
o f t h e i r u n d e r s t a n d 1n g
B u t t h e r e 1s a c o G t T h e
l e s s t l m c t o t a l k So t h e r e t s a q u e s t 1 o n t h a t
t u r e r ha
an tl su i l l
u u
fs
ro o
t iv it y
l c dge a b l
o w
n w t
I n
dia
0 0
th e y h a v e t h e k n o
id e a s
h m t Ot n h mn n g
th e y ha
w i
t h1
a n
la e
rm
a c
n m
p le
c o m
dt
%l t n l r n h M > n n w n H t \ l > v e t
w
\ \ \ n 1H \ l 1o p '
h a n d o \ 1t s u l t h > l t Bl l It \ t u r 1 1l l t l
l c t u r e r h t u l d r r w t t h n > t BH t v H u n J m h t
de A m o n to m
m h n i n c h u n > : H
u n n l t hm
w L
n s
fo
d D e n n ic k
a n
ts
1n
t h e ir h e a
Rn
: in c 1 u u ?i r a t
io
id e
t ha t
h u ll c t p o i n t s a n d s u m m a r i e s
bn e f a n d r e a d a ble f r o m t hc ba c k o f
l
s h o u ld t r c s r m p c
l i s t o f h u ll e t p o m t s
t he c la s s D o n o t m c r l y r e c i t e c
k t h e b u i l e t : x ) 1n t j i n a m c a m n g f . l w a
o o t h e s l i d e It n
y
I f t ! c 10 u s t r a t i o n s a r c 1m p o r t J n t g 1\ e t h c s t u d e n t s
If
t i m e o ! L o k a t t h t m a n d ] f nt c t \ i nBF r o p t t h e m
11l w
o t a
d ia
m e
m e
hm do
so m e o n e
the
o n
qu
pro
l r t
m m o n
ls
= t 1 1
Co
bc fo u n d
So
1110 5 l
n t o u
I ta n t t o u t s s t a t e t h e t a s k s o r
B1 u l p r o b l e 1 r As
b
<
c i n s t h a t a r c t o bc u s e d ] n t h l e c t u r e 5 o t h a t
pro
d
st u
e n t s d o n o t h a v e t o r ( f e r t o t h c s l i d e t ha t t h e
l e c t u r e r i s u s i n g U s e f u l a d v i c e o n t hc m c o f m e d i a
IN K A >K N N
n c es
Ti Bs k s
pmc t l c o
111ngc
\ (
1s
lia
lc r c
rc
tc
t 1o
r m a
gr a m s,
l ke y
re
lt
m nc c s
n v n
lr r u
hm t
L e \ \ 1t >
w m
w +n
p n wn L n
no t>h
t p lw
i h
rr o
ll t
A n c x w n w n Ot
Tm
t L 1 s mM i n w h i c h a m t
ITu r c x 1 m p l c
> / u l\ m p t t
t
hqnou
n m
Hr m M
a '
1\
n h
he
hc
p p hc d
to
l nt l
nanagc t 1wnt
N r c la t e d
a
sc t
T l Be p r o b l e Bn
}l n e d a n d v
d
an
lin ic a l
T h
r ec o
c o n
1l t e s t s
Pr o
a t
t 1s c
1n
stu
\ c n t ro
e 1
hc
de
u n
rs
h ic h
q \ r> st io n is
r e a s o n 1n
\ 1s n
t ha
n ct
r c \1 v w
pv
ct w c s
i n L h 1c h a
disp ro v e d
[r
1n
is
de
m a
a n
Pro g n o
So
a
pp
It
1s
Fro
te c
so
e a
im
t he
yo
pr
a n
1n
p le
c a m
ar t
stm
u r c
dc
st u
he
re
r e
s u m r T1 a r
p le
tu
n t
au
to
t a
w T u (1 u w
ke
d 1e
It c t
n
t l
a n
] m
p lc
n u
4 \ 1t
]n
f t hc
do m
he e t
a n d
h a n Rc i n t h t
r c t h c 1c L t u
a n
h o u n m B u x h 2 0 1h c r t \
B l 1g h : 2 0 0 1) B r o w n a n d h b
1o n 12 0 0 3 3 a p d D e n t ( Z( X ) I
J
1s
st r u c t u re
m a
n 1n
ix t u
a m
st r u c t u r e
lt s
c a n
t c r e s t 1n
l ly he l p s t h >
n su a
h c b t Atn
t t
lm
o n
o n c
1dcnt t
ca n
O ft
st r u ct u r e
aj l y
to
i t
g fu
blc
ba se d
a r c
bu t
sa
st r u ct u r
m
t u r es
hes
dn
1u n
r o a c
bo \
t 1w
f yo
t r
rc
TT1 o r c
o r
qu
m n n m
i n / 1g 1t )
c a n n o t
an d
Bo
bu
rc w
'"
l d
t s n t \ ll
lybe N n n
r e lle t l i t Jn
hu
t t
h t tt
[Ba
1n
1c ,
y lv
t u n
fo
u n L
o u
p\
1: i J
n w
ht T
S\
bL
t 14
L\
1l t l
1n
h L t l \ ] t
p r L) \
kn t
t }\ , ) A l
> J
( 2 0 0 1) C a r t t t l
r H n
l 1 11 r t n
u m
m m
t
Rc
p
1n
r u \ ld e
l
o n t
> ,
' "
"
i1
y t e ll )
'
Ru
1\
t
\
\
t
ps
r m u m
d r u b e l la w i t h
a n
MM R
o n
1 1t
II
"
l b
I\ l \
h5 t
1\
t lr>
A
n
t>
> l
B> r l n
v a c c in a
tio n s
rw
l\ > t
lt
\ 1t
J r L
le .
' ' \
tu
m
t \ 1d e n t
i n
r ln
R t 1a t t n
e \
hL
c h u v H
hc
T he
g le L t
m
u r m
c n h
1\
r l
h
l
n n
I\
Y \
..
ni nh
B11> t l t 1 l e \
I >v t h w
t v i l 1J t o r
1t 1LI #t . l wwal
N n
u i 1r d
il
it
tr
Hw
lw \ t
g 11 l n z t
1\
tc
ha n
a
tu
yste
0n t t n
tk
to
M o m
t L > L 1 l u a t e
he
t u sed
e aM
n v h
1s
5 r c
p 1n
1 I L 4u et i t 1
h e l 1 u r e r L\ i n t e d
1
0 0 1) DP1 t e t h e s e
t h c m o s t w id v s r e a d
p
cu r.
ha
t
r Jt 1n
I' \
le .
u n
& \ an w
p - 1r . '
sw
k t u n n g t h e q u c t w n n a 1n
4 n J i n Hw
hE e t m n J m B J m
Ul w w c N t N n N
m
NJ w m c
I hn w >m
l upp\ ) ) nt t d
P>
5 2
\ al mt 1n
L
\ u
cLt unn
t u Lt e n t
B1 1 J \ n
I h
1n
w
s'h
I't
I B \
l l t h 1h q
v e rs
\ i e Le s
pr u \ t l
(: . r . Rw
Bm
1i 11l l m \ C l t W n t
l > J HHJ
t he
tn
fo
o r
n L\ t
A l
t hr e
l t {x
uat n/
( l o r a t i v e )
l u ro
m m a ry
v n \ 1 r L \ n mt n t
Nl
hm
n M
Ev
w a
b a d b u t n o t h o w t o i m p r o l e T h e i r v a l u e 1s
j b y t h e q u a l i t y o f t h e r a t i n g s c h e d t 1 e t h e
d
N r s u n a l c h a r 1 c t c r 1s t l e s o t h e r a t c T S t h e 1 n t n n s l c
f L u l t y u f t h t \ u h it v t a n d t h c q u l <t t \ \ 1 6 t h c l c a m 1n =
go
u r
t Tr u
ke e p (h e m t ha i
o r
tm
e n
t m n tro
u rre n
Su
tc \
B\ e r a
po
in at es
h av s
pr e
gy
s is
R e p e a t lt e r a t i o
s ld e s
[ ndl , Jt l nR
n ( c
i o lo
e s ae s
Pr e v e n t io n
he n
d w
t an
ro
l l 1n
Ma n a ge m
a m c r t io n
p ide m
d Eu
in o
D o f jn it io n
h c :w r s p ( T t i v t
b t %r s t o u t l i n e
t
d o u
a n
o f e c
re
n l
b r ie f
m i n o r Bf w e
S ym p t o m
c o l l l mo n t T r o r i s
,
1h 111 r
uv u
o n
e a s le s
pc rsN
m o re
UK
S tr u c tu
is
t hr o u gh a m i x t u r e o r a r u
g
h a p s s :x w l a t i o n po t c n t l a l l t hi s i s a n
y
\ n t c r m t l n
g a p p r o a c h o r s t u d t 5
h u c \l kc t he
s e qu e n t ra l a
p p r o a c h i t c a n s o n l c t i m e s b c d i l f ic u l t
t o fo u o w
m
o r
Tr e n d s
o r
lly A
kn o w
o ra
dlc
au
na
C h 1l d r e
t \ ho y o r o ;
O n ly
g t hi s
s u m t l l a r ie s
p l b a 1 d
e xam
An
tw o
In t r o d u c t io
hc n
ro a c h
l
c l a s 1 [c 1 1 p p
de n t s
l p e r i o d ic
he r
ra
ha t
hc N
TBt
ts
hc
mc t h
e a c
f t l\ c
o u
w he n
l fi ?r c d
a rc
de
tu
lly
to assu m e t
Or
in
r rB n
c \ i su a
u o n
re sts
is
p r o bl1 m
dcd
m +r e n
T i re
hi c h
h i c h a p r cr bl c m o
t e d a n t i fo l lo w d b
e
y a c ha i n
l o s e t he
e t ho d
so
to
te
In
In
s o lu t io n s
an o u s
q l e n r i el l
se
Pr e s e
c n itr p
th
hx
in L ti
de
n 1
1l
be i n g
. to
tw
h lo c l u r o {s } o n t h o l o l l o w i n o tl o m t
p lo o s o r o l o t o
r
v / ho le le c tu r e s w o e
On t h e
A g ro o a l r o n gly
4
Cle a r
In t e r e s t n g
Eu y t Y t a k e
TTu
gh t p r m
Re l e v a t o
A 2
dn
o kn
c o u rs e
yY u f o y Y u r h c
1 4p r n
S m
r n
ta
l ro m
n o to s
//
J<> J r
ay C
in
J J
'
} 1t
r m
le c t u r e
tl
t u t \
1\
} 11\
u r
1t
rb
Jh
1>
fh
t Bu n
pr mt 1 e
u r
1t t
l I )1 r
J m
ll
t 41
l 1 J r 1i :t
: Mh
a n
uL u v
B n
in t l
d t he
lt w
pru
u l 1d t r
n oi r s
v >
1r >
tt
t Bv t
< wn
t n
h in
ll
l} l n g
l l r 1t y
lt u
t u r m A t 1l t 1
u w
t
Jn
L N
u M
Ln t h t
E; 1hu1n n tc m
u m
ht l p \
H 1J y h e h u
m n
p r u b \ h ly
t l 1r t
t N
H ltn m
1u r n M
u n
I\
It
u u n m n
e ; 1r 11l n
s t n J L t t 1w
l hB k e y
i rl t B r t \ t
1 t t l ru
11>
B: >
u rn
a r m t\ #
i Br 1d
An
1t m n
VM
d H
M ud
d
in
r hap
1n 1 p m \ e t
l by
n t h t i Bk t
o n h t t 1
bJ
u n
\ \\
n n
n t
1v
Hn
tu n n
'
h mn
St 1r + t r r ; t r y
le \
p 1w
I n tl
o 11
da
prm
he
h 1e \
ta
co
hx 1
u n
c m e n
l tt v
4
So
n g
t
ts
tm
a n
>
stu
t 1+r
de
"
n t s
t ant
c wn n g
r +n n
in \ B
h od N
n n
pr n h h h t ht
\\
Tl , \ n
Ru i l t
n m
tu
i n u
Uu
A n W
lt t \
n
e h t m H a n d , 001 01
pLnnmB h l H a n F c
> s
le \
LE
f l , I 1t
> n
1m
1 l e Bt L I w
n >r
h r n Lu b e g n
1hBLAnq m
n a he r
2 4 2 3 1 : 4 4 2 110 1
n 1
tn u 3 4 3 4 4 0
9 M3
L nM
1n
d IU
Lo nw
tm
h DL
h wwn M G
St o n e r
J K Su t L e N u t ct \ w1ng a p H V W X m C 7 t M v t F
v J hLnc n n n c L h c > B( c L t n = nh=J l h x u w
) t 1r J n 1l o l G e 1Be r Bl I n Br r r i t Bl A Jt d l t 1114 15 (b ) 4 t
3 7 1 2 U0 0
C ha p t e r
Sm
l l gr o u
p
S J Du
te
hDn g
ac
in g R M
r n
Con r a
Se c t i o B 2
L ea
l
h l r di c a
Sm a l l
cn
du c a t o
e<
pr e s e n
he r
n u m
tt at
.1
in stn
c t t ) n a
hi n g
im p o r t a
f g r u wt n g
1t n t
u sc
rs can
r c
ps
gro
ro nn
\ 1
o r
ht a l \ bc a r c
in
b c g\ n m n g t o u n r a l c l t hp r e a s o n s
h
av e a p o sl t n n
c : fc c t o n le a r n i n
m a l l g n Lu p s
g
w h! s
k
c e
(v a n B l a n n s w 1n e t a l 2 0 1 1) T h e s e
r fo m l a n
e
p
t h s o r o t n h a \ 1 o c 1r a l a n d c o g n i t i v e b e n
LJ t e b o
s t u di e s
B
Sm o w h a \ 1 o u r a l t w n c D( s i n t I u d > p r o m o t 1n g
ts
c %
s o c i a l c o h e s l o n a n d a u t h c n t 1c t t
t 1o n
y
lc a m c r m o t n a
i
f
c l u d e f a = 1h t a t l n g c l a b o r a t 1o n a n d
u \ c t, c n c i t s n
Co g
st r u c t r o n a
1n
in
fo r
l at e
de r
re
u t
)c 1 s ( a n
gr o
hl n g
be
c o in
mal j r oup
f z c t l 1L t e
e z J f , r r r BJ t
c
Sr r 1a H = r r 1u p s
gn
n Jp t c a t
ex
p ]O r c
Wi t
m n
l . i 1. j : *j p J c Jj l )
t il t :
k> y
p r a t t it
( 1 1l l t t
e rn
p t,
ga
h t he
Lh c
hc o
Bu
l l B t ll >
1U \
Yt r
1 4 rr i
h e s t p a m t ha t
( o u ld
d p a t ho l o
co n ce
gy
h ( a l t h (. a r c
: ' v c to
be r
n u m
an
set
1n \ t r u
t t n rn
I> \
t Bo n \ \ 1t
ll
B: t
lm
B \
l Bt
hu t
l l\
/ t rt t
t t r B l B 1\ t
llw ,
u rt
W it
t tc
st u
de n t s in
a rn ers
a
n u m
1 c o n fo
ber
s!
lo a
'
De
/
dl c s
st u
a re
gr o
e t
se s s i o n
rn
r b
su
g ge s t
p t 1m
ai
s ho u
ld
ha t g r o u p
,
t he
Ho He r
F
o t co n o r m to
p hc ' d
bc
I n de e d
t he
a b le
ffc c t n
lo c
c x
n e n cc
pc
'
h d e t e T Tn
\\1 E
sm a
l y fa c i l l t a t c
'
1n 1n
h t ht
hc
o n tc n t
p te
Jc
' ' L : 1 CJ 0 L CU
i n j L U H
u gr o u p
= l " X=1=: X
m
h la r ge r
sm J
ll gr o
u c
si z e
he r
m a
n u m
ber
U r
J\ 1 l c
h o u ld
X X X
( 1 e _di f
F
i
l
h
t
r
\
a
m
) L c
p c \ t e sr u u p t s t o o
7 m a l l u r t hc m J t c n T l i s \ e r
r d t o te a m
s t r a . gh t t o t \ t h 1 n & ( . o l t A l s ( 1 n b c l Bn u m l h b n c e s ho u l d
b e \ t n 1\ k 1n \ l e t c n n +n i n g t h c n \ 1n t b c r o t s t u d c n [ s 1 n J
11 , \ h j l l c n t t r t h t heJ l t h. Bm L u c J t o r
\ i [ 1J l ] M e u p
e \
Lu
It \
e r
t 1\
o n
t\ n t
be i n g -
hw
h w t ht
J h c n
u w
he le a n
an
d oh t e m
\ ee t H l B> \
n BBB
+r 1 o
in
:
u n
\t
vc s
w n
>
t l t Vi
\ , t
l 1 \ 11 t c n
th
tw
\ n w
t 1c c
J t l l r r# \
d a n d t h u n h n n t hn H > h f h u h t u n h n
L1rge r w o u
p c Hn g A D h m n My nhr l l Rn n w
ht l (
'
\ n m
t r
pr i o r
cau on
e ig
in g
a n
he
le
ru
Th e
go a l
] eJr n<n
l e. i m1n
p lt
gr a t e
in
l f r o m m u lt i p l e
s m a ll g r o u p o n
a to m y
p hy s i o l o g y
m at c n a
re aso n
In tc
pt s
du
he
T1a t c n a
( ( ) 1J P t
e \
li n i c a l
h 4a t i o n s
l t e l Bt
t 11J t
tu r
r i * r 1r J
pt
i n t e gr a t e
c
st
n es
nc f i t s
tlal
du c a t o r s
an
pc N
ha n t h a t p r o
:n } t e n
n w
b1
ho
w n tc
B
n o
m t n t ar
bi e s
g e w +t
t L\ r ( n t M
t n Br i
e n t
c n a
+n s t r u L t i o n
k ha \
ly
ci t
a n
ga ge m
tl
h l n R \ . l t h In
t 1a l h e n r f n \
vnj l l
Jr >
e n
m J M r J 1 11 e
p lt
l e d $c
o w
he n
e n
sc t u n
t (. a (
h e p Bt c
r ec en t
au t
gf u ll!
. . . . . .
tea
aut hmt l c
o re
t he
Vh a t
e m
m o re m ca m n
l} r o u p
<
pn or
o t io n a l
n a
to
The
to
t hat
i eru2l
h
l ly
kn
A d d Bt 1 o
T 1
% u
a r c
r e c o u r se
o r
t 1o s
m es s
he l p
i
rc k
1e E
d 1e s
st u
ket ent
a lso
as a
s l t u a t io n
n ce
in g
r n
l 1 h ! l 1\ \ \ u 1 \
1 C
uvJ
1h
Il \c
te
l u +t > b
m t H t1 c on ac l
sm
\ l
gro u p
hr w
S E C T IO N
70
Lea
Si BmBl i or
i 11
a 1By
f t }\ t
l i ke ly b c
d p u r po
an
need
Is
bo p t i m
f i 1l
sc
l Fu
t iv i t y
ac
a re
p o r t a n t t h a n l u 1:i l11n g
t he se
" PO, S1bl c

fu l
sc
Po
s e t t in
a c tm
ty
cxt r1mt l y
hac
to
he
1n
t 1\ c
a c
r . 1c ]
t y p ic a
pJ
tl
( u
an
u n
l l a rg e gr o
d p tl r
p le c t u
t he r
n o
po tc
c n c o t Br a
ge d
b c n c li t
t i a bc n c
to
t q
fo r m jp
a\
n a
%t
y bt
nu
1=
k,
l 1 r Rr
s Tu u p
p ar t tu
arl
) r e le
t h 1n
se s \ lo n
sm a
in
ll gr o tJ
p
t ead
\ei
ng
f a r n i i a r w i t h a l l
u t le
a
" r
s o m e t hi n
g t he
be c o m e
w hi c h a r e
a p p ly fo r t h (
i s t h a t l ear nt r s
ing
p r in = l p lc s ,
t l 1r c (
c h lra c tc r
st lc s
Fo r c x n m l c c l t c c t l v c t c a n \ b a s e d l a r m n
r
p
g
(C ha p t c r 2 1) a l l o w \ f o r l a n . c r g r o u p s t b r o \ 1g h t h c
fo r m n t r o n o f s m a l le r s u b r o u s w h
t c a = hi n g
lt
ln tht
g
p
se t t i n g a n d c a n c a n a l
iz c o n
t h e s e t l 1r c c s l g n a t l 1r e
p
c h a r a c t c n s t t e s w 1t l 11n
c a t h s u b gr o u p
]n dc L d o n c o l
t h c m o s t o ft e n C l t
m a x o n s f o r L o m b i n ii n
g le c t u r e s
m t h s m a ll
g r o u p s 15 t h J t I t t s
1t l
n o l'
to
n \o r e c o m
ll g r o
t his
n it
ppo r tu
bc
r 1l a y
c o n te n
a s in a
t i r 1g s ; a g a i n
sc t
p t r m i z c m o t i v a t i o n a n d c n t o t 1o n a l c t r g a gc
i t [t t h e c o n t e n t I n d e e d t h c s i i c o r t h e r o u
p
g
,
Im
du f in g
l io n s
p le a c t i v e p a r t i c t p a t i o r 1
c
n t d c d fo r t h c c o g n i t i v e
r ex am
d a s s rn a t c s a n
to o
m e n t w
le ss
sc
su
t }1c
1c a r n c r s ba v c
t o t h e s e a u t h o r s i : t i l e s m a l l gr o u p l a c k s
c o n 1po n e n t s
t b c t e a c h i n g 1c t i i Ly w i l l
A c c o r d u rg
can
res
f t h c l r p r o fe
s si o n l
a
t o
]c a r n c r s a r c e n c o u r a ge d t
o tak
e
f o r t h e i r o w n Jc a r m n g (s e l f d l r e
x , n l b 1)i t y
n s
ct cd
It 4 r m n g o r s e l l r e g u l a t i o n c g a d c q u a t L p n p a r a t i
o n
o r t h e u r t a l l g r o u p a s k i n g q u e s t i o n s d u n n t h
g
c
o l )o w l p r e a d i n g s a l t e r t h e s m a l l r
s ( sto n
g ou p
s , c l o r 1 h a s c o n c l u d c d ) a n d Je a r n c r s a r e t n c o u r
aged
t o u s c p r o bl t m o l v l n g r n l m n e c t t o n s k 1i I s r n a s i
m i la r
le d r n c r s h a v e t h e o p p o r t u n t t
> c 1n
m a l l gr o u p
y to
l
dl v c o p i m p o r t a n t I n t c r p ( r s o n a l a n d c o m r n u n c a t \
o n
s h u s t ha t t h e y w i l u c i n t h e i r f u t u r e
pr a c t w
St au
g r o u p t c a c h t n g a ls o o l f c r s t h c o p p o r t u m t y f o r t e a c h m i
t o t n o d e l p r o c s s l o n a l 0s m
r e s p e c t f o r d 1f i r e n t
o
l i v e s >o
p )c
e x am
re
Wh e n
T he
hc
he
dJf j i t
d e pe n dm
Ls
se n t c
w
a
bo
\ e
gr o
hc
sm
br
c x
o u
in
r t 1s e
bo
r at t
po
l l gr
sm a
o u
l thc
1s
ha r a c t
Fu
+n o c t r c M : u r c c
l s ) fo r
g t lu
in
de r c d w > thm
*
. a. t >mat ms
to o
an
he r
fo
w it
rm at
an
tl
hl n g
ld h>
h1s
srn a
hc
jJ
u u
it h
r u u
c n
p ll (
c o 1n
1n \
*tn
ps
pp o r tu
be e
A d d 1t
n i
hu
i r 1= c
1r
bc
Jt (
( o n tt n t
kin g
t r a in t c s
a s
h>
t r u ( tu rs
w d1v
r t
u w >
he
d a
t o
tca(
In (
]u d t
f 1t -
J n
fu
( o rn >
.J
a r1 m
h 1n x
e X
tn
p\T
dn
l ABJ b
l i +H * r t i n t
t n w
lu
g {u ]
m a n tn
le a r
Fo r r
r e
n t r
fro n
o r
t 1v e c n
hc
he
ha t
hw L
rca
bA ss to n s
It a m
l
c 1n g s
ts
ho
in
ld
la rgA r
t e
teac
in st ru c to r
bc >o n d r e c a l l i n g
t o a p p l y t h i s c o n t e n t 1n
t ha n
l a r ge r g r o u p
n
l l Gr o u p
p p l!
t > x t
b l 1n
p1
ll gr o u p
( o n t e nt
a
se
m o re
tt in
ha lle n ge
sc
t 1t ) n J
hu u
SL
L tl n s
J It
> \
1 d
rn
l e J r J r(
111
t t 1n
gs
a n
1n c
A\
n a r
to
Hr u
l\
Bt
t h t
p w
I J 1\ l A
1r l l
1L
A>
w \
Uw
t Bu t
tu l
t 1\ 1n
n t r n t
l\\
h ld
m J
ll
\ L)
J n
u u
u 5
u m
n t e n
a n
tL. A
p V wl L \ n
m
n c
J ir
he
t\\
sm a
T a r
J l ht
st r
c \ t r a n tv
hv
l l gr o u p
nm
r t TI l T
11J \
B1 n
I\
Ih
>:
]u
r b
ct
I eJr mn)
l r r t 1 1\
r 1l l) l 1u
l1
tu
Bn t r \ \
1n
gs
t hc
l b ul t v Bt ) r I nwwc t \ unJ l
p\ Br pmt \ b v m t d l ( a l
l \ i r i t h e A n t c t . 1 S t a t s
t
a n d c is c n hc r c
t pt c I II!
l u t i > U t h e r t cJ, . h1n
l m1 n J t
h 1) I cct L1r A I d
, u
hu
ll
r B1J
[ a + n \ 1l J
r 1 10 r >
t.
m o v e
M an n e r
sm a
e n a
sm
sm a
ht f a L t
n r i rt 1H u )
x p u r t . u l Tr l
)
d rr1ut 111l l \ \ l 11 r > l > 1r 1 i > r \
be
a n
t r
rn c n t
ga g t
p t s t ha t
e r
F 1n a l l ) :
m e n t
w r1 t o
1 :x
H Jn a
e n
co n c e
t ca c
\ \1A ]
n t c n t
gr
ha pte
m o t es
ge
rce
T he
prt
h t :o r
d i s cd
sin c e
h c p r en
c r
e m a n a
\ (T m
1tim
pro
Ic a r n
(w h i c h
st r a i g
nt t ns 1\
fo
co n t e n t
t r 1s t l c s
in
so n
ese n t e
f t h c ]e a r n
v e
be
to
g pr
se ssio n
sr g n J t u r t
co n te n t
he
l l gr
f t h
1n c o r
st a c
c o n s1
.l 1 e t \
u n
t.
at s
his fo
po n
a rc o n e o
fu l l y
Ca r e
ps
t u m s h o u ld b c n m a n l
p
y gu i d e d
o b +e c t t \ c s
A st c o n ar
r a
f t he
he
zr e
r m
1n
ar
fo
c o n t e n t
sr n
a c u rn c u
go a s a n
io n s a n
(s ) f o r c h o
re aso n
t e a c hi n g In t o
by le a n i n g
1s
ll 9m
t o u sE sm a
n i \ 1r i
ll
B\
l } 1i i Br
l\ l m
n J
ll w
:
\ 11i 1 B
l Bt \ f r l B\ f l u N 1
JB
1r l t 1 B,
u rB
h l\
1'
''
Bt
h 1BB
a n t
l B D, .
1t m M U
1U
: \ +\ l
l o l 1 l
'
'
aski n b r u d m
l 1l N
lt pm
in l o
d i:lc
l 1i n R o r n i a t \ e x i s t
o r nht l l w o u p t c a
Fo r 1n m
n g in u J c
proMc m
b 5 w t l It \ r n i n R ( 1 1 L ) L \ \ t Hn s c t l ] t a r n i n j . ( C I L ) a n d
T h i s t o n w n t 1 1Je
t c a n h a s c d hnr ni n m
w nd
:
F
l
h
T
t
i
u
l
]
t
o
\
r
o
t
t
L
r > a d > r I s c n ( o \ 1r a
h
s
t c
p
p
A
n m n
\ t 1r a
t:
a t
t h>
rc w c u
t . l b lt d n
n o
le
ro
t lt
t t hc
l tt \ [ m
bcl n
a so
t m
I n C ITL
T l ly
l pn
hapt cr
tn PB t h s
tu r
hc
1n
ltt l r
po
to
1, l > \
p RL w
x1xr t
o n
t }\ > ( o n t
l n
f n u [t t a t o
t i l t 1mt n 1c t u r 1\ 1
\ t Bm m
tn
t o r n rl l c n
t\
t h t \ > w 1u n s h a r \ n $ t h c l r s u s t t t n l a t t r r t
x p tT
I n T BL t l \ i n x t r \ l L t o r t y p i L 1ll y
t 1w
l
r
v
i
o
t
ho t h
c
\
p
t a c 1] \ t J t l 1 \ n \ n d \ \ b l w t t n t t t r t \ p e r t l \ t t h c ta t t e r
o f t e n p r m 1d c d t h m u g h b m h u n n n Mv c
c n
to ry
c o +n
a n
d p hy s l c J c x a rr u n a u o n
h it m .i s t # c n c r a t i n g a
pr o
pa n
c o n t r a st i n
a n d
an sw ( r
Cmphass
t ( a c iw r r rl a
d t ] o
n a
p la t M
o r m a
t B
1e
e st io n s
a mn
o n
n o t
l qu
qu
h o n s
s U Bn m a r
pr o v id e
J' B L
a n d
slo n
o r ( 0
r crn a r
c o n un c n t
\\ r
a n d
pt t
lx
a n d
s \ \ lu n
qu
Iu
1n
c \
l r u c t o
n a
tho d
m e
DVD
\ : ra
Rn
t echnol t !
su c
m o st
r n st r u L u o n a
c x Ls t
1n
tn c s an
ht
c m
i s
= u
fu ]
a rc
o r
hc r
aro u n
sm a
o u
[v
l r r 1p o
c ea r
ll w
1n \ u
9 1)
h t x i s ha v t
M 1r
ho ds
m e t
p (T a b l t
FBn
m c t
h m l to
n w t
n u n r
go
u r
teac
rn
t ly
r t a n
ls
lu l
Jo
st
t hc
a n
De
Se
he
CW
B
e d
t J L
'
D,
( C11
r . e
lw
! r,
Ft
j r I
fi c
v w
/i
p l
P r U v 1d c
1 J'
lt,d
trl(
r(
f
,
rr
Tr r
it.
r r r Bu i 1 u f
'
ly
l f
/ :l
r
r
YL
11
I '"
lc
/ 1f
1'
1 J
r r 1J l
'
i tt
t t nt o)
d r
e a
rn
1 e ie s
o Jsed
(I
th o
ghl pr o
o i 1p
Tc r a 1/
m a
(e g
te
la
: e
ke
L J
vr
Ro
P/
Tr F l e c n o c e
Co
F l s
t 'n
o r
dA d c
e s
a e r s Bo n
p f
J COR t c
1? r
'
d op
d r
c w
on 3
l \
le e t
s t Bs
J J C S N
s J
e J
(d w 1 l p c : u F
JJ J 1
tjn
H h
3)
j
a
n ,
\ t
o n
d qu
e s Lo n )
i o \ r a T p a t u cj = 1 \ t s t o , \
r n)
BF
!W
rr > f
fl
tB ' j
1[l
\L \ t
lr H
'
J f
l ir
r t
r= J
Jr r
"
r rn 4
( \ l 1f 1u
u ' jr
dJ
t f
:i
Bt
J t 1r n
u c
o u
(e g p a F e r
c o u n le rs
5l a nd ar d z c d
c a so
c e l r 1n
r o LJ
f n e
Iv
lBw
* m a
d r
9"
tf J B }
pO
c ru
1c r
tr J
d pJ
J 1 r
'
fu l
c f
1, 1f
l 1H
s u cc e s s
(r e q
o n
Te , /
! / /
E, t T
Fa t
ta te
p
T.
K(
D e m
5 al (
r a
.l g
na
d S CU R S C N b o a r d \
t [w ty
n h c 5 l t h c a m t d u L a t t o n Ah c c a s e h s c d s t n c t u r c d
d 1 s c u s s t o n 1 s p r o h b l ) t h e m o s t L o m r 71 o n a p p r o a c h
Lcar nt r r e a d B u t a n d t h e n p r s e n t J l t r t n t i a s c
a n d \ \ o r k t h r o u g h a s t T 1 t 3 o f t a s k s w h c h c o u ld i n c l u d e
T a b l e e 1 T l p * o
u rn a
in t e
ob l
a L
lhc v
A c t u a l p a l B= n t b
bu
fo
S u r r o g a t e p a t 1e n l
La se .
St
u l :t l (
r 111
11i 4
n \ \ k
1h
llw
p
k s S k Bll s s u c h a s t h c o m m i n u t e
f
l
v
e
[
l
B
t
N
2
c
l
i
l
b
a
c
9
9
t
e
c
a
r
L
u
r
(
t
]
r
c
a
a
c
t
Lt pt or (
) n
y
p
d
h
h
a
e
r
h
.
t
t
1n s t n a l t w o u
t
e
c
p w t t 1n g s n t i s m c t Bo
h
p n ] c s f o r u n c l e r s t a n c l i n g a n d t h e n c v a u a t c s (o r
( o m e s t o a n c d u c a t t o n J l d i a n o s i s o r ) t h c ]c a r n c r a n d
g
p r o v l d c s n e x t s t e p s f o r t l Bc t r i mp mv c mc n t
hc
an
hM
hc
lu
1s
bu
l J l a g 1o s i s
r c n t lJ
ln t \
n m
t h h ho o k A
N n t l T B L \ t h c
t m t t o r 1\ a l a t l l i
i rn
l hh
d t on t r umn g a t r c a t m e n t p h n n t hc C B L
a n d T 1}l
Fo r m a t s [ 1m c s t y p 1c a ll y a l l o c a t e c l f o r t h c
mahgr oup 1n n r u c t o r t o t ar dy n n N r t i n t t e a M n g
t nt wecn P I; L l \ l
b lt
1 \ u
ci
r { ul r 1
n u t
co n w n t
t ln c t i o n
o n a
Ao n s [ r u c t ln
n o M s a n
r r n ; 1t i o n
[1,> \ l r )
o n
q - e s s
ra sc
d c
u r tp
t\ c
72
S E CT 1 OF
ect i vel y
to
o w
ll gr o u p
sm a
i n
n Bi l Bg s i t Bu t o s
Le a
ct a
s e s sio n
hi n g
t eac
du
co n
im po r t a n
IW ==
RI NG I
f o r t h c s m a ll g r o u p t e a c h i n g s e s s i o n 11a s
t he r t e a c h i n g
l
m a n y
s 1m i a r i t ie s t o
p r e p a r a t i o n fo r o
Fi r s t ,
h
e
s s io n s
s
i
l
i ke la r g e r gr o u p t e a c i n g
sess o n s
d e t e r m i n e t h e l c a r m n g o b }c = t i v e s f o r t h c s e s s i o n
B e c o m e f a m 1l i a r w i t h s t t 1d c n t s t x p t n c n c e (i f a n y )
he r a s p e c t s
w it h t h( c o n t e n t be i n
g d 1s c u 7 s c d f r o n t o t
fo r
l
o f t h c a i r r i c u l u n \ K n o w w h a t s u c c e s s o o k s li ke
t he s e s s io n
Pr e p a r a t i o
o w
'
ha t
: g"u p
s u c c Es s
lo
fo
k s 11k c
hc
to
gg
Ea c h
j <t nnBng
c }1o I c d
c an
o r
r u
Jw
v t
\ sj o n
ll
11 \ t
t l r>
o n t
u r
p t i rn
lly
\ \ l
l m rA
n 1u
t t
l\
ct
} t h\
\ a
tr
Cm
An
prn
v l tjt
lt w
l > y
w lt 1
dTM
by
t lw
\ 1 Bt l r \ t
\ 1r
d fo r
ha t
rs
tt
B1 1
Bc
Bu 1i R
nnpJ Hunt
c x il l m n u t l u r 1
c m
hc
sm
1t
< le
i r n c r
11 1\
1 1
t a t to n
t \
tu
r a ll o n
l 11
\ t }
r 1t l 1 l
ln t\
ix
h 1m
n n m
l 1t l l \
1\ >
hm
l y l \ 11
t h > >1l > m e
ir
t l\ u
p \i r p t r\
k >y >j r
Bn r n n
> \
m v
I 1t h c
r N
hu
ha n
tn
p c t 1t n
as
t hc
l> 1 l \ Il l l \
li
l \ l 1t 1\ 1l t l B l l t L t
h u w h l h i n t hu
W c d { B n o t J1u w > \ r r h ] r > \ > t )1 \ l t h > \ t k t
s c s sl o n
T
t e a l 11BJ1g p o i n t s s h o u l d r t : t Bl l l r t l l l t r \ t u r 1ll t t l \ l 1> t l m t
s c )1e d u l e t i f o r t h e b n 1 i ll h o u
r w s s l u r i 11r \ l t e t l p r u v l d
i n g t r a c h t r b w i t h 1 c u i n l r ht n u v t
h 1g )1 l y t 1t n t
u r
j
o n s u n n n g h s t l o r th w u s m n m n h 1d m n n m hu u r e s
a n u o r M i l hn g h w u s s m n
w
n in
(
u s\
1 0
E X
l t r p le
1u l v
1n \ t n +c t u r s
I : > => N
LR
J l l 1x
u r
v e
be gi n
1n m \
stm n
sm a
t
o
r u cto r
ll g r o u p s e s s i o n t s v c r )
I n c f e c t i v c s c s s 1o n s t h e 1 n s c r u c t o r \ n ll
im po r t an t
s t a t e t he go a ls a n d
t v p 1c a l l ) s c t t h c I t a r m n g d \ m a t e
b 1 s ic
so m e
gr o u n d r u l e s
a n B p r L \ e 1d c
u h j r c t 1\ c \
a n d u n Rc = e p t a bl e
J L c c p t a b lt
w h i t
l\
w h 1. h \ \ u t h n c
c
h e h a \ 1L \ \ 1r ( e < \ r n \ i n g l a t e o r h o l d t n g s i l c t u r
S
a r t 1m Fin ) r t J n t b J US d
\ e r h \ t l L \ n \ ) ( r , \ 1n L B n l l m
l
h
l
l
t
re
a
u
s
c
e
l
}
t
s
t
\
11a
a
v
L
c
u
r
i
m
1
r
u
> w
p y
gr uup
I
h
h
h
l
H
l
w
t
\
t
t
t
e
v
r
i
1
r
n
o
1
J
J ta L n t L t L
\ t w rtt e e t in g \
.
g
t n. (' d qut wl or 1\ r 1( T \ l t t P Bm 11 t l 1 l t
1r l 1n \ t r \ j L I ] \ B 11 1l
, 1p
v r y h t j p : u 1 t t l dt \ t
pe
be
r t in r n t
rw
t .l >
pr o
im
T he
b j e c t l v c s S e c o n d k n o w y o u r a u d 1e n e c ( t h e Ic a r n c r % )
Fo r t ?x a m p l c w h a t h a s b n t h c
a n d t h e c u m c u lu m
l e a r f e r s p n o r e x p e n e n c e u T t h t 11e c u n t t n t t o b c t i 1s
'
m a l l w o u p c s \ 1 o n 1n t h c t u r n t u l u m
c u s s c d 1n t h
W h a t 1 o p I c o r c o n c e p t (s ) r n 1 h t b c p 5 r t BL t 1] 1r l ) L }1J l
] e n g 1n g f o r t h e ] t a r n t r s ' l l u r d t n t u n t b n i 1l 1J r w 1t h
t h s t r u c t u r e o f t h e
r n a l l w o u p t e a L I1l n x b e w l u n t A
}
l
d
Rn \ t r u L 1o n T l n + +t c n 1 l \
l
t
o
r
e
l
s
c s sl u n
t
u
m
e
+
c
m c
b B) u t t h F I \ \ l \ \ t w \ t n L I
L
T
h
d
t
f
J
\
s
1
Bn
(
o
s
r
o
s
n
n u m x
an
1
.
u
d
t
t
1 u \ n i p l 1\
t
t
h
a
L
=
{
n
s n t
t
o
n l r t
1n w
sess o n
F V Y 1M
hc
he
r Y 1r w
se ss o n
T h 1s c a n b e d o n e b y c o m p l e t i n g t h e s t a t e m e n t B y
l c a r n c r s w i ll b c a b l e t o
c n d o f t he s e s s i o n
k c e p 1n g 1 n m i n d t h a t s n a ll g r o u p s e s s i o n s a r e a n
h
o p t r m a l p l a c e t o a s k l c a m e r s t o d e m o r 1s t r a t c h i g e r
d
o r d e r s k 1l l s
s u c h a s p r o h l c m s o l v i n g r c tl c t t t o n a n
c l i n 1c a l r e a s o n 1n g T h e r e a d e r 1s e n c o u r a g e d t o r o l l o \ \
2 0 10 ) o n c o n s t r u c t 1 n g g i \ a l s a n d
m a t e n a ls (H u
e t t
t
hat
b
d
ll gr o u p c a n bc d i f f e r e n t a s e o n
d
h
f hc g r o u p m e m b e r s a n t c c o n t e n t
t h c d y n a m 1c s o t
l t t e n t io n t o t h e gr o u p
be i n g c o v e r e d s o c a r e f u a
a c h i n g s t r e n g t } 1s a n d
d y n a m l e s a s w e ll a s y o u r o w n t e
E m p ha s i z i n g
c c ss
l
s
u
o r
1m p o r t a n t
1s
w e a kn e s se s
ef f
r
a
s
s
e
c
e
y fo r
d a p pr o a c h ts n
t hc le a r n e r c e n t r e
h
r
o
a
c
h
t he
a
I n t 1s
pp
se ssio n s
s m a l l gr o u p
t iv e
f
d
s
r
e qu e n t
e
n di n g a n d p r o w
t e a c h e r s e e ks u n d e r s t a
t
m e r a n d t he gr o u p
l
a
d
e
a
d
u
m
h
n
l
t
e
1
h
f t e db a c k t o e p
th e
ce rn s
Kn
t im
i n a d v a n c e s h o u ld i m p r o v e t h c
r e pa rin g
sp e n d s p
h s e s s i o n T h e a t t i t u de a n d
i o n a n d no w o f t c
o r g a n i TJ t
ns t r
r b a l) o f t h c +
r b a l a n d r 1o n v c
b e ha v i o u r (b o t h v e
l
l
e m e n t s f o r s m a l l gr o u p
i
c
i
c
a
t
r
t
c
s
f t hc m o
t o r is o n e o
1n t h e a c t u a l s e s s i o n
e s 2 00 3 )
c c e s s (J a q u
u
s
h
i
n g
teac
l d b c o n t he B a r ) ze r
t l 1e f o c u s s h o u
c h is t o i n t r
e ffe c t iv e a p pr o a
w e b c l i c v c t l 1a t a n
d l e t le a r n e r s
a
n
o
n
t
s
5
t h c %r s t s e
d u e r y o u r r o le a t
h
c
a
y o u o u t s ide o f
t he y c a n r e
k n o w b o w a n ] w h e n
l
u
e
s t io n s o r
a
c
d
q
i f t he h a v e a d i t i o n
i
I l l1
Am
Thc
l
c c rn c n s
lm
u H n w n
h
W P m N n c a s oppOMd
n
n
e
l
e
p
U m n w n m n n w n h a n p a 9u c u
h Hr nHnB m m N c
m
HL\ t ms har ncr s w hc
h N a w g e n Hr o n n ww
n w
n h w
H m
m n
/ e
S t PB
rtl
1l
0u
>
1r v
1 IS 1L
P t fn g t / w P U P
1Bn
hn
h i s bJ l a n \ T 1n c l u t l = n 1 +l k i n g
Va
m t\ ll w u \ t
p x > h \ l u n W t t le s l o r m a t tv c u s i n g a rl t
1t l \ \ n s \ t > m
l t arnt ' r s t 1p fo r s m i c a n t l A r
t l\ i\ t w t
y
l
l 1ul d1r1 n 1u t 1p Be \ l n 1ll v u u r M : i o n s h l t h 1c a r n c s
(t g \ l w y r u L l 1\ > i \ w o d e a t t h c v e r y c n \ l i m ( e a d o
I It t r > a = h ht x h io n )
S\ \ l n
w it y s
t \ 1r 1t l r m
>
t Ie a
d e l t hc t e a c hc r a s le c t u r e r
h
e
r a s I J L r lr t a t o r
\ W Et l t e v =
is
v
t
l
c
s
m a l t g r o u p s e s \ 1o n i t m
t h a t +n a
a y at
t m i c a b c dl r t i ul t t o d i s t i n g u i s h t h e t c a h t r f r o m t h e
l c mt r s F o r 1n 3 t r u L t o r b r o u g h t u p 1n t h e l c c t u r c
f o m l a t o f t \ 1 \ f\ 1n g i n d tc , J r m n g m a l l g r o u p t c a c h l n g
t Dc l 1l t s k t l l s c t t o a c q t r t r c S o n i c t e a h
c a n bc a d i
c e rs
h l ! c f f e c t n c i n l a r ge g r o u
w ho a r c h l g
p s e t t i n g s (e g
I t c t u r e s ) a r c n o t s k i l l e d a t s m a ll Gr o u p t e a c h i n a n d
In
he
r e so r t t 0
in
in
le
n n n 1
ll g r o u p
ld b e i d t
Do
t ass
n o
la r g e y
p le
e x J n l
fo
ble
r ta
wr
an
t f\ 1 t a t e a c
if n o t pru
%c d
n u
te a c h n
o u
hi n g
t c ac
g TO J P t e e t
sm a
u n co m
u n
m o
t a c
ctu re s
sm a
ds sh o u
Fo
e c
i l.
n ee
rm n
d w it h t he
h t g h l \ e f l\ x
r e pb
a c u
dt l r c
he
u a
d( d
v l
LV 1t
ssc
1n
t o t o c f fe c t r v o
h i g h ly
t h s t lc
ft c
ct
n e c
lc c
u m
tu
rt r s
m a
y be
d s c u s s \ o n
t e a chin g p o m t s
etc
pc
d1r t 1or 1s o r h o w t o c o n \ t T k c T
w i t ho u t
US 1 N t h e p o d t u m m t h Po u c r p o 1n t s l i d e s
T a b l e 9 1 g i \ e s s o m e g c n t r a l g u l d c +n c s o r t i p s o r t h c
s m a l l gr o u F t e a h e r
W e t h e \ c t h a t s m a ll g r o u p i n s t r u c t o r s n w d t o
d gr o u p d ! T 1a m i e s t o b c s u c c e s s f u l i n t h i s
d
e r sm
m
f
h
n
o
r m at
tc z
PJn1Ll ar 1y w h e n t h c m s 1 o n 1s Fo l n g
h
l
t l m a l f a s hJo n
i n o
e ss t
S c h o 1w s c t a l 12 0 0 0 )
1n 3
d c r 1 b g e s t hz i gr o u ps o f t e n u n d t r go t h a t c a n
he l p t
G J n D
ll gr o
<T n 2
he
t eac
T h e s e fo
st . t s
u r
: V \ 1 1I ( )
It
is
L To
1' t
h tT
1t
c u
he
c o
i L tx
.B w
Jr d
r r 1u
u n
u > a
ll r o w
)T
1 J r u 1
n t n t \
u 1e t
lu
to r
B o t }1 1B ) i
1 v
e \
pr>
(a t t i
n t \
ri
t 1
U w I L r n a t 1d
trJ
\\
/ t r
t i :t
> t
te r
l BdLBer)
c n v l r o n mc n t
Te a c h i n g
fo r m a t s ' v
b o t h lc
n c 1
re
re
o u r c e s
+ i L 9 (
m a
sm a
l l gr o
st l i ke
%t f r o m
lt y T o d o
ps
bc
d fa c u
i t 1s t
c \ a
1n
tt k c
C\ a
m e t
h\
h Ls
a t 1o n
( a n
in
fo
1n
t e
a c -
a n
lu
a n
o t
t 1o n
s TTL I I I g r
he r
fr o m
h l n g 1n
lu J t i o n
t( ac
lu
n e
l e c t t d
c o
/ s4)
ca n
a n
er s
bc
his
e n u es
to
in
as
1n
J m
m 5 n n c r
r 1L e r n \
\ u
l t 1t 1u
r w
L\
tu
l'
u \
n u
) In t
le
ir n t r 3
L ,
l lc L
teJ
Bt
l 1(
11\ } / \
r\
L\
\\ n
A
l\
hi n
iJ
h 1n g
1m
&
a u
> \
l ln cn
Ba L
u u r sv
J n
t lw
r a \
i b\
ti m e
o u
ly
p
lt \
Yt
r t '"
t \x Iu c
J t \. n
L L1 t a
t
J
he
i
d ot
d{m
e n
o n c
lo n g
tm
de
c lu
c a =
to
rm
sc 5M 0 N
Yv J n t
n o t
a tt e
fo
e \ s
su n
o r e \ J lu 5 t t
n c w
he
to
a -
c n t
Lr
l ) J . k ( 1t l \ t n
n 1u l l t p l r
L 1\
1 \ 1t e
J : B\
t \
Br
rl t \ w
1 r 1,
l l t [ , \\
> w w
'
a t 1J t l u n
w rt
ht
e v e n
u B\ a
ll # t \ t u p
h t h i r n
I)
1m
t
ly
Bn
l r t Bn
t l e L t 1\ e
k l l l t i (w
\n
HB tn
il t l
l
p
i r
t L\
in
a B1\
* m
1\
lct r
tm
w r l\
rntnt t l
l lt
l\ J
n \l) r e
1t e
t 1a b l e
an
Bt
teac
\c
v a
li d
he r
Re
n
n
p> o t
hw w
u n
lu
u m
71t
h 1
hh
Hw
hu w w
p v B h
n
v
hn
H kt c
hm
o r
m n
. 1 WL
hs m
M o n
a
1 c wi n g
+np Lwmnw
ohLun
v dc
Lh r e c t
ahquat c
P n w n g H 1J H g r o u p
h in N t he d
h J L L n mv h \ n wn h N c u A h n w w w h a s
w n hw
m
m n he h n w M m c J c hn m e a c e c p t
N
h
o n t t n u n A Un p r o v c mc n >h e r e a d e r
L\\m n a n
n w r m
r n u u r
c t t m m \ 1M L a t l u n
t lm
t l 1J t u B
H H I
rr
e B l wt n e n e
, \e
B\ l \
l L b l t a m I L \ h
.:> l
'
11tt\hltl\t\
l l r 1 ) Bl 1: l 1
l \\ = J ;
:f > w
an i
1r \ c \
'
n n
t 1f
( 1n 1 Br Bt H r
h a t t w a ( t Bv l t y
a n d t he I l t t c r
ptJ
b B]l t >
t lrt
a AL >
'
IJ
t in p
t \ a \ 1a t 1u n
\ ?r m \
c tu
ke c r j t c n a l o r p a r t ic ip a t io n
T h i s m a y a c t u a l ly fo s t e r t he i r
c r
p o s s i ble i n v i t e s m a l l g r o u P l ea
to
i t 1p a t c
t J r K j Bn j
1%M
u r
dt b\
Tt 1 5
t } cr
p r r l >
W
1
d
b
e c
aL
)
in w ru
(i n f r a s t r u
ac
d e t = r m m i n g c r i t e r i a s o t he y f e e l
l o r t h e i r Ic a r m n g a n d s u c c e s s o f t h e
m s p o n s 1b l c
In
: r o u p E x a l n p l e s o f c n t c n a a r c a v a 1] a h ]e e l s e w h e r e
is
i
t
l
t
a
i
o
n
t s t a b l t \ h +n
g c r 1t c n a l o r s m a ll g r o u p e v a u
h
r
e
a
c
1m p o r t a n t t o a l l o w n c x 1 b i l i Ay l o r s m a ll g r o u p t e
d
h
s t y tc
p r o v i d e c Bc a r g u t d c l n e s t h a t b o t h t e a c e r s a n
le a r n c r c a n u n de r s t a n d a n d n o t sc T u p a su m m a t i v e
part
\ l ' ) r 1)
o u
u r r 1L u
Un t r 1 t >
t tu n
1. r r r 1 r 1g
p t J
r 1c e
rn u L
o o
de rr
u n t je r
L 1n
Li n
l tj
hc
arc
at
1 u
r>
r 1 z t 1f g
= u rn
Sm a
de qu
ts t
rc
'
p l 1c i t t o t h c <c a r n
ip a t io n W h e n
t ah
m n
br y
n t
n m e n
p a r t 1c
ll t s
pe c t iv e
rs
pc
ne c
i n la r g e p a r t
(:
im po r ta
1\ r mt \
c v a u a t io n
n C
o f t hc le a r n i n g e n v i r o
a n d p e r s o n n e l)
chr act cnst 1t \ o a n cf t Lt l \ e s m J .

L h st at i l r e l 1 \ t t d 1n p5r ent ht C
t
S
p
Y r m i n g q 1l 1p m c r n b c r \ f t e l c x t l t r r \ r n t a n d I n t 1 c t
: 5 t i c r n 5 0 m e t x Pe r t t n t e a i l x ] > t ! ( d > \ A l u p r t l l t l L1 n
<h p a n d c s t a b l n h r u l ( s )
Sr n
p r o gr a i n
be l o W
te =
gr o u
e v a u a t io n
e rs to
suc c e ss
c n t
gr o u
c x
t ra
lt y dc v e lo p m
Fr o
1n
t t
to
N
<nt
u n
hi L h
l m
l t l 1
h t <p t lw
t l\ 1 r u le
r n e m bc r
p J t 1\ n t c 1l r c
m rs)
r n
ha n
hc
an
n
hc
m o ls
H t :l e u l t y p a r t i ( 1 p l
n e
ht yonJ
t 1 u r \ R1n
li t
hm
\n
vt r , \ l
m vn
w a
ys
: t h
t 1u n
h \o
chq
\
W r
l \ be
u t
he
\ m po r t un t 1
c wn n u n h x n h n
Kl Us
t ha t
1 ! u t c l a
po
d c 1W L d >
7 ? i?l u l ! BBB ! i B1n l ! o 1n
s a Y 1 aa N
Zd
U TL O U 4
dF!
P s n b ) ) (
IU i
au
J o n 5 e & !u
u n tu
os r
M 4A s
CU
1 J NI a
"
t[c
l J n J 1o 1
'
H j
11l
10 o x l m s
a eJ u
t /X
t t JL q n J
t:J :U
0I AJ 1
l BnJJot t 4)
Bi 1Bm
. 1! Nv Bt t 1. '
t \ , CJl " ' JS
rubN
o t e t J r u ) o u l t u n Y t l l 1 o n & B[ o n 1 B t a
l us1! 1nl t oup s n d o 1 1 1 [ 1 o l r & .t UOr l l c 5
J n J p 5 n ln m
. p! J e
' J o t 1! u nt ua l t
l
1 c d d or ut l u a ul
q o u n s Ys ' J C J N
O I SO
U
P
O
P
C\ AF J S
1
J
J
T
P
C
U
)
E
P
U
O
)
p n J Fp o u 4 J A
u tn in
5c
!u \
U I TC U J a
Jt
ddo
O A1 t t u 1
XN
u L 11 l t
t lu
)u u
qY
t !8 1[ q
'
c 11 . 1 n
1q Y
C. 1 t Y 1 s
dd
p t !u
po
t Ru
U S U
TC
Rl SJ o n d s l u r
w
z o [ sdu
'
u Yb
d d i L 6
P 1! SV w # p
u n 1 o n d s
1J D 1
\ u
Nl a ( Y 1 a s l a A a u s N : V
N W J J r O o 1 p o u HJ
l
l
\
1t t p a l J p l u t ) 6 1 1 e ) q
\
O
!
S
5
J
J
U
gN c i a D
6 >' ' [ 6 6
:
>
I
c
J
5
J/ 1i i ! J/ B , Y} 1 v l f r
P! 10 1 H u w 0 0 T { o 1
N J M q l a ' J OU U O U W a
wp. J1
P
N
t [ l C U PS 6 0 0 1 x t n+ J
1
a
F
t o
1 t ) VJ 1 S J P
'
'
u1
. , n ql t q 1
t Yr
l>
jjr
B !A
pn
1 11r r 11l qo l p r ? l
5e
I &J o n d
a
J 1 1t l \ r l P l O J C U l ' LU T{ X 1
1 AO u > U L L r o P a U- y 1 0
p
Bo p o u p o W J n A
m uB W
1u m p q J W V W 5 o u s l
F
P S BU \ A f t r J B\ \ r t n [ J l \ 1 U
0 J p t s Y w !o u
d J o \ 1P! u I 1 Tc 1 )
LJr ut uSl l l { . l u 5 > &a t U p t J O U 1) U 1 u r \ ! u &
Y1 S J R U U
i a t r P [ tru & q uj t l s o u P ! U J O J
c w r J u Y s s o J s u A F I &J o n d
J I ) C I L L 4 I S \ \ l C S 10 P 3 1 1 1 ) \ c l n
d o 1 = 1 1u r s S 1 J 1 U 0
j P q C J 1 p t c ! S p Y e J c u p a x d l l J l 1 U T
e u p
r l lo u
o u
paAl odYp m ! r q
J p i ar p ta 5 c u p Je
p
s u
LJ l p
y J p JB
sn
so
5u
pJ
[ jo
J sn 5 J a ss
Ar "
Uf r t u 1 1
u \
)J Iu
"' o u
'
J V1 A
M I
o
i00 0 o
1L c u s
r t Y
a i w
l lu
\ c u
pa J
S J W U W H F A{ HJ q J o a u
l r J1 n u p n u u S c 1 u c t [ 1 o n d
o u
d Jo ) \ \ } s n d d
[
p ST. nc\ ! ou LL T a r o Y o J d J o \ { p 1u & Y x d e u e . i o u s E u p

/
s
r a E 6 t 8 6 60 9
r
1
5
B
a
o
m
195 1 u 1u 1o o 1 i a 1 s 1u s 1J n J 1 r
AEn n
J DH
'
30 [ [
C ha p t e r
C hn i c a l
kM s
c en
hin g
t eac
r e
J S K er
In
tro
du
c t io n
W ha t
c o n n st c n t
s L , ll s
S 1 X , a l 1z c d
t c a c l, i n g
fo r
c 1?n t r c o r f a u l , t y
b l l c p r o . \ d c s t hc l d c a l s c u . . g fo r
i nl 1t 3t m r a m u o n c r s t . Hm c a l a . d . o . t c . h . i c a l
, \ n y s u c h fa c t l m
s k 1l k : . In , l c a l w p r o u T u " g p 5 t w ' "
l
d
b
l
ld
b
h
t
a
r
o
u
n
a
J
a
.
.
.
c
t . e c n t h' ' " d3
h
c
,
s ou
f
d
h
h
o
h
t o se
t c o r g a . m u o . (s e r o p \ a n
o f t c t= e rs an
& L a , 20 ] 0 )
15 c a r s h ' ' " c . n . n o r n 1o \ h . l . . n c . . m
T h c 1=
Ad: " "
e\ . Nl.
' "
o . r k n o \ l c o . In ) . N d h o .
.
hc t hc r
st . n
Fr o
St a H l ( K o i , n
U o n s p . t 1. R1t \
i ut
, f.
I n u t u t c . . f . l , t ] K 1n . . n t l . . l
d l 1) A . O r l , r H
A 1 20 30 3 f . 1] . "
n th.
Th
F= t y
l ml
, u r , "
t at i un . /
l.
Rn
tw l lu
ch u l l en l , v
J:
ru t .
1r
he m
e x F e n 1s e f . .
pr o" dc s p e _
he a l t h c a r e s e r i c e s t o p a t i e n t s
a. d co m "
"
\ c s ( D c . t 2 00 1 S e . P , a . & L r , 1 2 0 10 )
T 1. . s u c c d s s , f , c l \ n K a l s k 1l l s f a n l n r c l , c s o n i h r c c
k . ! [" t ' " g " g " h ! o f t h e f a n l , t Ie a d c & h , p a n d
F
. . d li . . n a a l . f r at r uc . n T h e y . c e d
' ' " m. . t
t . . Bc . ' ' " bl c . " l p . . \ . 1 d . J . r & o f t . . m n s 1o
. n J l , l v lt . \ , 1 \ "
" .' "
. N t o s t a f f a
s e J F hi c a l
\" " b . u
A . l , m . J l . k , l l s c . n t , c c a n b d c %. e d 1n c r m s o f
\c s
cr
B . . ln
ri. .
? H I 1I J 1. "
c 1 1n1 >. l , k , l l .
Se c t i o n 2
L e a r n in g s i t u a t i o n
l i n i c a l s k i l ls f a c i l it i e s
hy is t he r e a n e e d
are
C l i n i c a l s k i ll . F. c i \ n
a l l t h o s, " ho d c l w
n o
11u l , u
an
1u gh s t . N d . . d , o f c l . Ic a l s k i l l s
c o r e t o b o : l , t h c d c . c l o p m c n t o r s a r. H. . l t h . . r e
p r a ' " t i e n c r b a n d t l, c d c l n c q o f q u . I i t y c . . . Io ,
Tc . c h , n g
1n
IJ
lh''
"
h. . . l
,"
\. .
nr
e I
H.
I. \
Ie , t ' \ v
.
mo
r e.
l l\e , e n t
, \
f i ,w n
t l y,
M / 1?
"l
r sr o u p7
r . = mc
nl
p \c n
w nt
at
ZOl l ) Ev e r y l j
ll\ y
g 1\ \ n a l
rc
sNs
n t
to
l l e v e l (K c r
o r ki n g i n L U l b b o r a
n a t io n a
o r
tw
m a n d h M n g noct t t h e n c ed s o f bo t h c u r r e n t a n d
f u t u r v h c 1l t l \ L J r c pr . \ 9t i t l omrs
A h u b n d m c Ha c nodcl h a uc bl c o n e c &
c n m 1n & s t a n d .\ r t \ m r o s s r g i o n s a n 4 )w a l t h c a r c s c t
\T 7 u p w [ t c a n e n a N c s t a n d a r cl s o f s k i ll s p r a c
ting
t 1c c t o \ w \ <c i n c r c d a t a n y ] c v c l r e g i o n a l i ) n a t i o n a l l y
o r i n t c r m t io n a l l.
A m o b t l c 1a c Bl 1t y w h i t h 11 a s t }1c s t a n d a r d fe a t \ 1r e s
in
o f %x c d b c t l t t t c s c a n p r o v i d e a d t l i t i o n k b e n e fi t s
h
l
+
l
h
t
)
c
w m l s o t t r 1 \ c 1t i m t a n d t e a m t r a i n 1n g i n s n \ a
Mh n g a n M u c a u o n a l s c n l c e i n r c n i o w
ca re u m t s pm
i n t c r n t p t i n g p a t ie n t c a r e
a n d 1n r a l a r c a s w t t h o u t
\
k i ll s s c e n a r i o a n d c n s \ Br 1n g f , (
d b4
ss
tk
i n t c g r a t c t l i n t o t l 1c p r o c e
I
i
t
e n t s (SC C C h a
l
a
a
l
e
r
t
l
p
m
Si 1n \ 1l \ t t 4
pt
2G)
tc ach n
c e n c
s k
g ' "
s u p po r t h n k o
j c v c l o p t h = 1r
i
stu d t n ts t o
in
pr c p
1r n
S p e c i a l is t
qu ipm
en
c n
d
o
1m , r a
f Ou
lu
ki lls b
d
t 1c n t s a n
In
d d 1n
n o
l 1t t e s
r u t 1c
1o
ge
r \ 1
c \ de n e c
dl n g
l
1d c
o \
s 1m u
r J n tl c
hhl y c o m p l e x t c 9 h n Bc a l s k1 l l s
t chmq- JCS T h e r e 13 1n c r e J s 1r l g
u J
lm
r 1r a Bq
h t o rs ca
2 00 4 ) A
/ 1m
Ko tB r s
1a c k
d i u m il d c lt t ) s \ m
c n
n r Ti n
u t i lit
t e st syst c n ts
to
im
1n c r c \ s c
a n
u se
d c l 1v c r y
c ar e
T h e r e 1s
)n
pr
n t
bc m g
arc
1n
r i sk t o
hc
u s e o
tec
s p c e i a ll y
la t r o n s c
s u c h a s la p a r o
de n
c v 1
hJ n
\ a ric t
pic
t hes
f 1o w %d c l 1t y
g n 1t t v
c o
cc
sc o
t hat
c c
k 1 ll s
an
h o u l d bc p r o v t d c d w h e r e
l
a m o i t c f o r e a c h o f t h c d 1n 1c a l s k i l s s c M l o n s ( s c e
C h p t e r 2 5) S1m u b t Bo n Ls 1 p o w e r f u l 1c a m r n g t o o l
s u p p o r t t c a ( h l n g 1n c h n 19 ) l
u rc d t o
\ . 1 c h 1s o f t e n
m e
No
C o n s u lt a t ro
S pe c
1 S
Si m
lat
' 1 l F r
e c
J>
r e
] a t
Bo n
fu r (
J LI T-
ca
fJ r
l u
a &
L u m s lBn
dept nt l cnt
n u t
ly
u f1
u n
r c o
ru
Sa la i
n J r 1o \
f> \
u \
>
n 1 r d
b>
A u n \ Bd r r > d
in
t d c n t 1b > t j
l t aml n1
t i l t J I u R= $ u
y u l t l t II I H
J t 1t 1 o t r 1( \
l b u t l 1 t e c l 1n Bt J l
tu
J B\ t
i 11 r
i m
Bi 1
lx
1t i n t e L
a n
jn
rsc
in t e
r e st
ic a t io n
c o m m u n
i n
e a
s ki J
hin g
d v c lo p
to
i n m a in ta in in
p e r t 1s e
T his
t o rs
f a c i l Bt y
t
t )W
Ls u s e
to
g part
tea m
1t s
t a s
a e
t r a ln ( r s a n
e n su r e
c a n
m a x im u m
c a
1t
pac
ha t
d S1m
t he S
h n o t m an dat o q t o
y u s t fu l t ho u g
d
b
h
a t 1o n a a n d c l i n i c a l e )
c
u
c
h
h
t
o
a
v
e
w
o
h
b
l
l
l
o
u l d b c a dn s x l [ o r c t
s
cu ty
M o s t sk 1 s
az
hn1cal t \ p c r t 1s e m t h d h e a l t h s i m e c c o r = =
v e r
Ls
f a c u lt }
t 1s e
t
heir
i s
l
p
Fa L u l t \
h 5 t L ]l n l
tt
hc ) hJ \
m
r l c w
r L l t
r o le e \ c n
m Lx
\n
s 1m
t cd
lc l
s e
i l L) n \ w l t o h 5 \ e ? h a r r d unde&t asdm
l \ k l l 1\ \ r t a n d w h i t t t v h n 1c a l I n d =
l
k
h n 1L 5 s l li \ J r e \ t h J t t h L \ \ J n d e \ c l o p J F r W
lc
5m
ln
\ l u t L Umt S
A
a
c
h
T h e \ l e \ , r w \ 1u n \ t 1
hn h h e l h h 1 n A h w
L 1H
re
m ,
, r r wh h
.i )
lt &
n u en
x1
>
l l l 11H
l 1n l t a l
1 t
it h
pc rt
pp
c x
lw
l 1\
c x
e x p c n ( n c c In
ho w m
u
nccci
a
t
r
e
a
r
p p e t h e le ar
o r t h c s t m t l l a t 1o n
n in
f o r a n d h o w m u c h t B1c y s h o u ld p a r t l u p a t e i n t hc h e
t
T h e y a l s o n e e d t o be t r
a s a fa c i l i t a t o r o r a s s e s s o r
a in e
j
f s i m u l a t o r s 1n w h
t o bc fa m i li a r w t h t h c u s = o
at n
o
f o r m a s p a r t o f t h e s i m u l a t i o n l e a r n i n g e v e n t Fa n
7
d b y a d m 1n 1s t r a t t v e
n c e l t o b c s u p p o r t e
acadn
l s t a n t h e la t t e r o f w h o m 1
su
o r t a n d t e c hn ic a
w
\
ll 5
t h( y
t ilt
Fa c u l t y h a v
u n
( 2 1X 15 )
bJ W
bj e c t l v t
ki ll s
i c i a n s w 1t
\ t u 1 t l 9 n r e J t e t l b u t J u 0 11 t B1 e Jn\ t l \ t r nt ' nt t \ : t l w
l e a r n r r ( 1 c d Rn a r + n > t u l 2 110 7) n B1t J t l 1t a r e , 1\ I L J
B b u l d tw \ on B[ j r t f j a t ( H 1 l t 1 J r m r e J t r \ l l n l t a l
t 1u n : t
l s k i l ls
t he
la t i o
sim u
l\
d w m o to r an
ra
r t isc
ex
C li n ic i a n s
ttx
e s
t o n
c x a rm n a
l i s t f a c u ll y
ia
1/ <
3 1
e B^
'
p r o c e du
C li n
n l n v a slv c
a s a
p )1y s 1c a l
i s a d e fi n i t e p r e r e q u i s i t e f
o' "
u(
k
M
l
s : acy
c hn i c a s
c e s s f
f
f
i
f
d
e
r
e
t
n
b
t
r
o
y p e s o f fa c
T he r e a r c a n u n e
u ]t
yu
c h n i c 1 ski l l
*
C l i n i c a l s k i ll s e d u c a t o r s w i t h c x p c r t l s e i n
m e n t
c e r t r e s
an d
Fa c u l t y
rs s
s kMs
m m u n ic u o n
1l i s t o r y
h o u l d r c l l t s t t h c r c t l i t y o l p r a c t i c t 1n r c l a t t o n t o
h l e s E n v t m n +r c n t a l
m l i . Al \ q u l p m c n t a n d c o n x u n \ 1
( 1 n s i l n u l 1t i o n
c u E s a r c ( r u L l a \ h r 1 J m c r c n g a s c r n c n
] n c r c a s in gly
w hc t hc r a s a n o \ 1 c c o r e x p e r t
ts
tril 7
Co
W ES 2 0 1 F
t ]w
s k i ll s
lA
\ t
( Kn r
Sk i ll \ \ \ p \ 1 t
12
t l h t 1\ e e \ 4\ l Z LX ) Z )
1\ \ t 1e
n l
eJ W
s wmn
C # P T E R
k i l l be i ng de l i ve r
e v e l 3-
se t t in g
care
ed
di
: f cr
cn t
he
Clin ica l
10
s kil l s c c n t r e
77
hin g
teac
al t
Ta b l e 1 0 1 E x a
o r co n t e x t
T h c d e li v e r y o f c li n i c a l s k i l ls i n v o lv e s c o g n i t i v e p s y
d a : Fe c t 1v t c o r l l p o r t t n t s
c h o t 1o t u r a n
A t e ( h n i = J l s k 1l l i n e o B\ n s m a i n l y p r o c e d u r a l s k i l l s
p le s
f te c h n ic a l a n d
t e c h n ic a s k ills
n o n
M rt u
g blo
n n
d p r e ss u
ba1( : l i f r
r e
su
T e c h n lc a I
(B L S )
p po r t
ki n g
d pn
a n
o n t rz a t to n s
d e a r m n g o p p o r t u m t l c s a r e r c q u i m d t o
s p cci
d r c h c a r s e t l t e s t s k 1l l s i n t h = t ii n i c a l
c a ll y d e \ c l o p a n
e n v ir o n m e n t
( Sa l a s 2 0 0 5 ) I n l i n k i n g b o t h
s k i l ls
hl
G
K
t
a
z
o
u l \ s c t a l 120 0 4 ) d e m o n s t r a t d
o
s
h
e
r
t
e
o
t g
e
h
l s k i ll i n s u r g c r t t a c h i n c o m
t
c
c
a
l
n
a
e
n
i
i
r
n
h
t at ea
g
g
g
t ng o t c t 1n i c a l s k t t l s
t r e s k i l l s e n h a n c e d t h c l eam
tn
a r ea
1s
l d r iv e
n a
r e 1s m r
de n
r e
h o m o t o r z f a a f f e c t 1\ e ) m
r e d u c e s t he m r dm c e o f a d\
0
d
pr e ] a ho v
pr
a m
o n
ly be
ce
\\
B1r o
1s
o u
w
ai ncd
h j c in
gh p r e p a r
e r sc
stm u
l a t p d L 11m
l l tw ha v c
ca
] ski lls
c e n t re
d c lr b{
au o n
r a
t ti
he
e n
In f o r m
Te
k i ll s
m an a
ge
me n
c o m m u n lc a b o n
am
o
S rt u a b o n a l
s k i ll s
a ti o n
m a n a
l \
J jj \
d r c ll a b le
C V u n dc
ar
DOI
qu
9 e n tr ( / ( a n
1c t t r ( >
a
du
20 0 7)
1\
pa
c ci + n
lx
rt
ca n
li t y
u n
\ 1
pm
9>q
rt
il c
t
ge m
en
De c
\s l o n
a w a re n e s s
m a
kin g
t t\
u
hc
rs
k il l s f a c i Bi t i e s b o t h %x e d a n d m o b i l e u n i t s
ha v e b t e n d c v e l o p t d a s a r e s u l t o F c h a n g e s i n h ( al
M o s t d e v e lo p e d
t a r r
p r o v r s 1o n ( s s c n t w r g 2 0 0 2 )
f ol l ow a s y s t e m o f s h o r t i n p a t i e n t
o o 1I n t n e s n o w
a d rT 1s s t o n s w + t h s h i f t wor kl ng a n d c h a n g J n g r o l e s a n d
P e n t s a r e t h e r e
s l u ms w n h l n t h c hc at hcar c t e a m
f o r e m o r e r e l i a n t o n r o b u s t c ha i n s o f c o u n lca t io n
7 1 T h is
l
9
9
1
: o r t h ( l r q u a l i t y o : c a r e (s c h c r + b i e r e t a
ha s a f f e c t e d b o t h t h e q u a n t i t y a n d q u a l i t y o f s t u d e n t s
C li n i c a l
liru
ca
e x
pc
r 1c n c e
(T h 1s t Be w
wh a t s h o u l d
c lin ic a l s k il ls
a it e
t eac
we
e n v
ir o
& J o r d a n 19 99 )
h in
e n t
n m
a
1
pa r t o f t h e p r o f il o f a n y
T
c
J c hin g i n a c h n i c a l s k i ll s
p
s c t t 1 n & L a n p r m \ d e t n de nc c f o r a p o r t f o t 1o a n d c a n
L t \ cl 0p t eahl ni v \ : w r t 1s e m t h c l 1s t o f 5 1 m u l a t 1o n t o
p r r p 5 r e 1e \ r n t n Bo r p r 5 L t l L t
( l 1n \ l l \ k 1 l l \ a n B t m u h 1o n c a n b e t 1s e d f o r !
d 1 t i e r r n t p u r p \ w \ J n u mb e r o t L \ h l c h a r t g 1\ e n b e l o w
Tc
a c
hln g
l \
1s
1a n a
n o w
l pr
a ;
s&cl [ i c
t r t 1o n t r
11r
( Kt r
\.
<l v \ 2 t x ) )
n u \ 1L t
J r J r1
Bt 1
\
( a n
X
o n
pr tn
LnhJn\
an
J r1
rL T
t B
t r rL
u J k
o w n E ho w
L hn t9 a l t
pra Lt
1' d
b t 1
:x n w M
S e r v i c e d r iv e
r o
r e a
( a
n a r d e t a l
h a t b e ha
st
hln i
t ea l
tt
kn
e t a l 20 0 3 ) T h i s
t hr o u gh p r o f w u o n a l
h i l b A e n t r t s Th r o u g h J l u t u \
t io n
t
h
. e a r r ( r r a t > r } n t h e p J 1j e n t t J n p r c p J r t t b t
o r 1 l e 1 e a ] t 1l L a r > c 1m r o r l l 1) L n t ( M
c l m 1c l a n
C ll m
he
o f
(L e o
e v t n t s
e v c n c c
1c a
p le
f o r p r a c cre c
o n
s s 1o n a l s M i
c l ar J c z
e x a m
(c o g i 1t i v e
pre parati
i n c r c as \ n
1n
o
&
a so
f(
lle r
C lln
re
Ta s k
e x a m in a tio n
Pr o c e d u r a l
h e a r s i n g s k 1l l s
20 0 4 1 T n t r
d r iv e
An
c e n t res
rs
ha t
ce t
hc h ha v
e n t
Ed u c a t io
T he
h r e e 1T l a 1 n a r c a s
o f c B
1n i c a l s k i l l s
o u t l i n e d b e l o Lv
a r e
de \ e lo F m
h
r :
n n Rr
T h e
c f
p h ys r c a l
a ( a r e ne ss
a n
e ac
h n ic a 1 s k ills
S Bt u a t l o n a l
e d
n te c
H i s t o r y ta k j n g
Communi cat i on
k i ll s (T a b l e 1 0 ] ) D i f f e r e n t
hc s a r c n e e d
t o a c l l i t a t c t hc d e v = l o m e t
a p p r o { 1c
n
p
h u m a n f a c t o r s ( G l a v 1n & M a r a n 2 0 0 3 ) T h e r e
o r t he s e
t ha t n o n t e c hn i c a l s k r ls a r
o f t e n t h e f ir s t
1s e v 1d c n c t
d
v
d
t
t
t
a
e
r
s
v
e
f
h
o
c
n
t
e
e
n
a
a
n
t e re lo re
s i gn o
p
t ea
n i a
No
k ills
\
t
o
ta
a\
l 1\
t lt
e n \ l
ll
a
u n
Lrl l\
n L\ \ YL t
\\
he
\ \ t
It\
Th > m
t Aw>hr r
r e \
lw
r t
P I J L t 1t m
H 1 Bw n t n t
ho u
'
\rt 1
n c r /
in t
to r
hc a m
ht
to
m m 1 HS
p
c n t
n cw
r i
c t lse
m
) ( J1 1
4 \ e \ n t n g t o \ l o \ e I \ L p u n L t u r c a s t ( e h n i c J l
1? \ \ t 1t l
k l l l h l Bt l l i n K u p m L \ \ n \ t n t u \ g a n d p r e i n n g a
B\ B\ Br n t 4 1\ t l t l w n \ \ r : \ \ t t R \ \ \ I t t h c p r L K t ? i u w o n a
1l t m h e t t h d p a w n t r n g l
w a rd n n u
s n M Hm
lm m c n t \
P o [l t i c a l d r i v e
pr
ac
tit
lu n ( rs
w I
rs
II }l a v t
l}t
1T 1
r >
llatBtl
t ll r l
tt
i l r\
JB1t eLI
\ r \ l \ l p 1t l \ ) l 1 l n
r P
. d o f L t ] m p > t c n t t p r Bt l r t o
l 1c r e a l i t y u f 1e a l \ h e i 1r c p r : 1\ t . t t ( S J n Yt n > \ J l 2 1 1
Sc d l a = k
Ko l m 2
F n N L h m n t h> w h m hw n
l ki l l
d
n u t m n M L hn n B
l
t
<
o pm g
v
s
tu w a
a m o v r
hk
hni
t
1l
M
lM a n d
h
t
t
J
h
u r a t e g
t o e n hn n e c t c q u
y
7
2
0
S
0
N
)
t o 1n c w i l / e t h e i r c o s t e l [ c e t i v e r r t 3 \ (
sta n t a r
t l
x t
1 \
I V l \
UB =h n n i J k n h c a n h e a c h i e v e d
h
t h r u u K h w i v H n R c h u n i n b u p p o H i n ehnuul s lu m
w h k h r n r hhv h i m r m 1n t h u r m v n t h n c t o p a r p a c
i n i\ H I n t c r a t t l v t
Pa t l t n t w t n a r \ o t h \ u l i n k i n g b o t h
hhm
r n w n
t. .
h. It a l
. . I
n o n tec
'
E x n n t pte I r o r i s i o n
i e s . i \ m a +. N d hi c a l
pr o
t ic '
p' "
an e
1l s
in
id c r a t i o
"
it l in g
v '
.
w
>
lc a n l i . r g p . c k a g
'
c m
. .
hic
d
H o w s ho u l
l s k Ms
c hn i c a
XWi t h
t uf '
' "
ve. "
"
r c ]a t , o n
p u r p. 5. c le m
r e gu l a t i o n
n , c l, n s
\ c' " un( t ur c p r \ c t i c c

: p , o t e c t n c c q . I l'
I I 1. c k . f u . "
t.
dl e . Ti c k , n i . q .
c . t ' " ks h , p t o , c n
sn . .
i d Eo P" ' " i
I' r o c c 5 S . I . r .
ba s , d e v e n t
"
R D TSI G X
. .
ki n8
c 1. .
ca l
Eof
pa r t
a pp r .
pa r t i c i p '
es
1-
Id
p .
p t , D c . I. p " "
. p J ka ge f o , G P
c hes
T he r e i s
. o .
E x a . . p! ,
' "
F,
c. c
p.
r c c, p ti.
Nc t "
Ni , t s
"
i . In g a s
"
i. g . t a "
d" d
T K X
L.
C l i n , c a l s l , Us
le , n . . g
"
r.
p l . Tf .
. Ct . "
pr o ' " l
p o i n t ]'
n .
1.
t. .
Re a t i o n t o
.n l .
P.
' "
P . I "
"
t l' ' "
L A I Nr
in
:.
Ti . .
f t he
de d
r es ea r c
m
u l at
t ean ls
he o n c s t h
a n u m be r o f e d u c a t i o n a l
l
l
l
l
l
i
T % e
i
i
tr es
i
l
c
s
e
n
s
c
n
c n ca
cJ . g
. N dc r p i n
. e l u d e bchJel oun' "
Co g n a 1 " c o n s t r u c t m s m a . d
l c a , m n g c x . . N p l e s o r w h t c h a r c gi r m
r e tl . . Tn c
be im ,
The re
arc
1, o \ "
'
"
L, I I , I .
..
" "
l l v . '
"
I"
1n
"
..
, m . Nc e
. Ee
l i n i c . 1 s k i ll s c n . I r o n m e n t h o w t h e t e a c h i n g
d o u t I s d e p c . d e n t o n t h e ] earn
a n d le . . i n g a r e . . r r i .
f
I " o u t c o m e s Fo r t h e s c s s Lo N a s p a r t o t h e m e r a
m '
.
h= a r s a l
I n d iv i d u a ls
e le m e n t :
re
hic h
' " ' " Un' " y
. n
nr
cn t
Re a l i t y l %d c l i t y
. n
e n s io n s w
. . i . m u l a t ' "
T i ..
'
o \ . 1c
"
Re %n c m
en t
Iz a t i o n
. Rg a .
1.
in to
pai c .
l b K D L
sa
t h . . Ki l l s f a c i l i t
I. p i n g " " . y " f - "

"
"
t h . . p p o r t u n i t y t o s a f e ly t r y ' "
d d . . l . p . c " S t e ms f . . Th = i r i n t . g r a t i "
1. d .
w e t eac
d n t i %e d I I d i m
G a ba ( 2 0 0 4 ) i c
. ee
b k,
h n ic a l
Nn
U cd w .
C , Lw
m' " . n
H. ' "
' "
1m
" n H
hu n N
. 1
t,
I.
1.
. e
'"
'
th l t o
r .
l
k , 11.
Th
t hc
o n a w m n \ u .
. . e
w 1' m
4 , H,
h h
hk h
nc n
"
I.
"
m ,H .
. n' " ypc
\ n . t d n ts
bm
s 1, n
n c
i
m
u
o
h to r
h o w n h c Rs c . d
an
d R, r
Th e n m
t, c
'
l'
. \ l M
"
I H ..
}\ t
o u
Im
Hc
l car ni ng t u
c t tv c
la t 1 d t
i g
s im u
hc
l a t 1o
it h a
s t ++r u
n c X= r c i se w
t
sim t lla \o
to
d [e e d b a c k 1 '
a n
do
c u r n e n 1. 1
hc
w o
r 1 t
h(
i sl x
ls
e v e n t
in
to
f t h e 1r p e r (o
r m
h i n g p r o c e s s w h e t h e r i t s It a r n
k ill o r p a r t ic i p a t in g m
o n t e c hn ica s
h
c
o n te x t
l
r
e
c a
r he a t
( 19 S 5 ) l i s t e d t h r e e
t eaf ung o : t c c h n l c a l s k i l l s :
G a gn
u t o n o m
I n t e r v e n t io
Fe e d b a c k f r o
IB
At
be
o u s
p }u
t ho
s A
h>
a r >
u u
to
jr,
e w
S> t
r act l( e
in
m o st
yt
1t b
U
,i
i :r
t l m
r o u t
lo
i n
pe
r sc
He
to
in
gr a t
w it
c t l\ e
blc
r n r
ll>
\ J rn t
; r u u
thm
h Bn M
ur 1.
r e
1n\ ol \ t t l i n
}1 e > \ \ 1 L } n
r u n
n Bp
l l l Bt t >r 1t
r J>
r lv
t a in
r >t J ef 1t
r >
Jn
pw
1w f u
PC e
dr
u :
t u n n
t B
B11p
pr
r L
L e \
1\
r 1 11t .
T)
de
n t1
1t
}l
t\
c >
u n t r e r
a n
> h
J L t [L \
hm
1l B\ r
an
gr e e d t im
r o
le s
su m m an J c
gr
lf pc e t s a n d
b u i ld i n g
se
ra c
pr
c ss
tu t
t ic e
o n
fe e dba c k
hin g
s e s si o n
m e r sio n
t he c o m
p le t
I %H
'
t t 1> \ l 1 I :,
t t i l t \ l l PS
io n
an
e n t
Co
ki l ls
n s
t iv
ru c
sk
i l ls
tea c
f e e d ba c k
hin g
t eac
en t
D i s e n ga ge m
f a a l 1t a t e
se s sio n
an d t o
h e w o r k p l a c e D1s cna?emmt
a l e a n e r t l a s t m m e r s c d h 1m
o
t r a n s
fe r
o f
i l
c ru c a
1s a
ft e r
r h e r s e l f 1n
l ear n1ng
T h 1s d u m g a g m e m
e n t
s t a ge
e n a b le s t hc l e a r
t o d ts a sn
t e f r o m t h e } e a 1t h c a r e
p r a n 1t t o n t r r o l e t a k e n a s a l c a m e r Fe e d b a c k e n a b l e s
Th c te a m e r t o = o M
b o a st a n dar d
o r hF H c h 1m
a n d d e n t 1f
d
k
w dm
a
n
L
scr
enB1s
e
J
n
e b n
!
m
: \ \ hAw mu. l nLs a r e g 1 \ c n t i m e 1 o r e l 1 c \ e t h e i r
per t t r mJnec \ w t h t h e W
fe e d b a c k
o f J
r u c tu r M
: 1e e t ( l n , h 1 \ t i n t h d e \ e l o m c n t 4\ t h e s e s h l 15
F
D l t t r r e n t m Ld c l t
bc
. n s l mc t 1 i '
c k
t t t t t n e Lt v ( t u p t c r 4 d l (T J b l e 10 " )
I h n :s Tt N 1. He : r w r a n w n c L v n J 1 m t h e s u m e s s
l
t h r u ' . . 1 n . A n J t o \ t udc n t 1d c n l t y m
u
s t h e li n ks
h e t w w n kn o u ; v N t h u m
h b 1 L n n i p or t an t b r
t u t + \ r \ t u \ lc b n L t t h + t r r l c \ n c h c d m t c a l s k il l s
t e a
sta
ge
ski lls
u Ut \ t wmn
Su b w \ Bu
A u b e l i 1l
S k r l l\
W M
hM
:n t B n
t n
t B- i r B
t j
l l i r 11 1r l 1 a i
n Bn
T 1,
B:
IM
[\ '
"
1whr J
u n
IH
1H n
unhnn
>
t n
it m
c\
pp r u
w
1i h
h
i l ll
ac
hic h l n v N
p r i Bt t l w
rate
to
n o v
ve s
\ t n \\ t u r \n
ic
es
in
d u
n ru =t u rc
a :
r 11L u l l i a
de s
d im
Hr
hc
t m
u r
. .
: ' 1 w
'
l l
\h
'
\
, \
OT d w
I m
t e I LI
n y w
11 ?
>LLJR r o c
t n
c
o
c 1 r et o
c : n
%1
L\&
l1n i c a l
S I S FR
n an d
n o n m \
n u \rm
PM
t tlt
1--
t \ Bw r
\m
hu
H n
r unt
t B11 d
d m.
>
hn
Lo n w
n m
ds
t i fy
br le m
o r
de s i gn i n g t h e
a u to m J t\ c
t n n n < t
H] r
W J( l r l h
\ e
iy
Tu
>
t u u 5r
U U
1e a r n
t o
s h ll
sc :
e n o
L\ n
Th t
b .c
ho
im
Pr e p a r a t i o
hn ic a l
n t sc e n a rio
ly de v e lo p
u s
d Pr a c t l s= fo
an
le s
to
R e %n e
l earn1ng t o
r a
b o ul d b e ] n t r
w o u ld ll kt
[ en u
- u g h o i
Ah o
l cr mf B t 1 m
e n a
e n
st
te c
a c t 1> ] c y
rd u \ e
St u
r e
1b e
Re
Lu
c e
ar t s
on e n t
p rBm
1
p ha s
t J\ e
c o m
p a t 1e
ha s e s
C o g n i u e e p 1a s e C o n s c i o
l a c i ll t a t o r
\ \ it h c u e s f r o m
r o
t
t eac
ide
Re
an
an c e
t ca=Cng
tre
c e n
in
m o rse
fr a m
lu d t a s ho r t
st m c t u r c d
Pe n o d o f d c b r i c f
c a n 1n c l u d c r e
q u i r i n g le a r n e r s
n
k il ls
l c r o Fs k i l l s l r o
r k p l a c e 11 ,
ra n s
lr a ssesxm c n t o
hn ic a l
to
hc
c e
n v ir o n m c n t t o t
n
str u c t u r
Bn
ha n
e n
c o n t e x t
In
c o n sn
al w
u se
E1 &
1m
le
>hD
r
t isq
r ln
i n
h n i c a l k i l l\ \ e J Ch l n g
g n 1l c t \ e \ \ evcl opt l
,
an t \ o rc c o
w t
H h a v e a n n i p Nt
c o n \ i L\ e t e d
i ry tw
o n
an
a ti
he
SC ' M F n
ww \ f
emnns
e n d
:w
e \
in
\\
\s
&
n t
in
C o gn i u v e
o
n Tc n t
sc 9 l c v c l o p
H} dr not ot
D
h
r e y f u s br o D
1l Js T c
\e r \
Ut e c t j e e k
(2 ( M S)
on d a
o r dc v ( l0 p m n t
l
s
f o
v
e
o
l
e
i
f
v e
l
c
b
p e r t i*
dc s c r j t
t = p wi
T a b l e 10 2 E rf e d lv
fe
fe
db1ck
l f e c tl v e
li
La c k
to the
l s c fo s e
ffe c t iv e fe
dba c k
To o g e
p o s s i b le
Based
te a
p h ra s
n o n ]u
De
t e
La c k
s c r t p tw e
dge
t ge
n o
r e s pec
n x i e ty
p e r s o n a b1 a ho n
c o m m e n ts
la n g u a g e
s pe c t f rq
Fb c u s e d
t rr o
W ha t a r ( t h(
l s k i ll s
c lin i c a
nl
n e r a lu e
T he
o n a c ti o n s ;
c o n s t r u c t B\ e
g Ae l
1n
s e
e n
to o
o n
m an
te t
u a
a n
ap
th e
a s pe c t s a t
de
bc r
d s in
hin g?
e ac
tren
n ti m
arc
re
t t
c u rr e n
h 0c h
ar e
re n
ds i n
he
u se o
h a p ) n g c l i n ic a l
No t foc u se d
d ff e r e n t
c u r r e n t
f
i
l
t S w
i
t
i
e
f
c
a
lJ
s
l s ki
c l i n ic a
t h e f u t u r e o f h e a l t hc a r
e
i lt i m p a c t o n
a n el w
n
c a t io
e x p o n e n t i a l g r o m h i n t he
a
n
n
b
e
e
h
\
T he r e a
d e li v e r y
k i l l s f a c i i t t c s a n d ] n t h e p u bl i c a t i o n s
n t o f s
e v c lo p n r c
r s i m t J l a t i o n i n t h e s e p u r p o s e bu i l t
bo u t t h c u s t o
b e m o r e r o bu n
e ds to
H o w e v e r t he r e n e
, i. .
d m e lo p m c n t s t o e n su r e
i
h a n t hc f o ll o w n g
re se a rc
d
d
h e i r a d e v a l u e S c o t l a n d h a s t a ke n
a r di n g t
c la n t y r e g
fo r c l j n l ca l
l
a t e gi
d e v e lo p i n g a n a t i o n a s t r
t h c l l d 1n
h
e e ds m t
p r 1n c 1p ] e s o f
li n k e d t o he a l t h c a r e n
s k i ll
g e og r ap
a n d
a l
f a c e c s s b o t h p r o fe s s t o n y
e u a lit y o
tl
ta ]
m en
n e r a rr e
r e d J b l h ty
in
ln
0 3
(T a b l e 1 )
d ba c k
f p la n n
c o n s rs te n
rn
d rr e c t
o n
m e r
m e
p r ia te
ca
5 2 00 7)
il y (N H
Sl x
ds in
tr en
ii n i c a l
kill s
teac
hi n g
are
he r e
T B b Be 1 0 3 L e
v e
ls
p e r t is
ex
L J: t : e
Le l
s :t u a t o n a
k, a' , O
G de
be
c n
n q
b J e
fo
rc e i)t o n
bJ
ac+o
l n
Pe
T
'
t)
c f
a l tr ;
e \ 1L t H \ >
c w
.
EJ 3
Ex p e r t
rJl l
l J
lu h w
Um
r 1 t r'
yl
bu
u n
d r
L\
1> M
Il m
ltc
to
Bo
c a s h lb r
e \ \
h W e
n J N Cl l
r l
t lL e
1e s
re
J re
mn h t w n
d c Ae
cr eJt e
T he
t 1u n i
w d
Jre
h as
h e c \ d c nc e .
r ] c t 1c e
o r g a n 1u
c n
he J l t h L
Li l l \
ilit
k 1l l s b
lt v
U1 t t A r A n
n
\ i
c5
h e n u mb r
L\
Hw n h
I _J r { \
J n
i 1l r b
&
im ;
lm
ha
re
pr
ix
du r a l
T} u t
pmt cwnJl s
1, t cnt l ht
a rv
ur epn1nc N
gn
t
c n
t tu t
50
t he sJ
he h
e n
t he r
n w
hc ar c
l 11
: I 1r
v 1 r l J 1rn ) l 1
:Ir
r b p t Jr
Of
1JU I
A n J l y hm l W W
n ovi 1
mh
Hc d
L tn n
l l ( 1l t h \ 11 > > n \ t r t \ m 1 1> n t \ h \ \ I n
hhB t =d t h L n c e d : n r
\ t 1r n t r 1i r l l n H l n h t i l t l t L r c ( 5 h . I " r u t t a l 20 0 4 )
I
Se h r I I 4 mh L ha v e M c n u h c d h c h a u m r h e hwh
m m
h n i t M sk1l l i n 1 m n s , hw h e Mh c n e
n n
n v m n n w n >Bm
hur c t al 20 0 3 1 St udi e anal ysuq
th
n
h
r
in L n w n t
in
Of
c onql h
m n n vo rk
pw =
NV
l i 1 i tn
)n
t Bu w h n
u se
t l u u b on
w hu
K H
B\ r , + l +l t
tT '
u n
o n
f H
t H n
in
n J n J U
r 1
r 1 l B Jr
'
VC
I r i l u 1l r v
i c
asper
Ii m
B
h
Jt
" :i
:r l
C , fJ H J
CCr Bm
1I
Le v e l 5
"
"
'
t J f . J A
a ( J
L1
l.
'
ce
pc
r t \ 1n 1t \
J r t l u n L( 1
o m J
. .
p pt\
T L !
P :A V
T h c Jd\ t nt
: wt
k [ I
p o m b h5
o n ly
u r
1y > t
n m n r
l hv
BH h
t h>
hu t h
Bm
in
w Lv
la m
N
t
r
T hc m a
ind
t 1n c o n t r o
C I A P T E R
v ar
rd c n c e
to
as
lt s
v c
> R 1 K l u 1b
i n i
pa u
pau
o n
b Li t t h i s t r r a y b e d u t t o t h L 1 f a c t t h a t a s e t
safe t y
y
d o n o t h a e t h c t o o l s t o m t a s t l r c t hc e i g h t s ki l l d i m
e t c a n n v o r k ( S t o u t & S a l a s 19 9 7 )
bl o m o
Dim
f te a
e n s io n s o
c n
w e
C li n ic a l
k i ll s
ce n l re
J' t k + m e 1 A x
t io
Pc rfo
n a
t l 1c i n c r e a s i n
g t m p ha s is o n t ho n e e d t o p r o v i d e
p l i c i t e v i d e n c e o f c o t t p e t c n c e fo r t h c p u r o s e s o f
p
Rc v a l i a t i o n
a n d r c li t t n s u r c
r n o r t r c se a r c h fo c u s in g
,
o n ide n t i r i n
y g p r e d i c t o r s o p e r f o r m a n c e , e s p e c ia l ly i n
rc B
a t io n t o t hc e ffe c t s o f
s t r e s s a n d f a t i gu e w i t h t h e
u s e o f s im u la t i o n
(H o w a r d e t a l 2 0 0 3
e x
c n
m w o rk:
aw a re n e bs
W ha t
m o n ito n n
h ip
l n
[r t e r p e
rs o n a
Co o nj
rs
8 1
r m a n e c
Le a d e
hi n g
W it l,
A d a p t a b i l i ty
S Bt u
teac
d te
a m
i 1n
m a n J
d fe e d ba
gc
n s?
rT1e n
l i n i c a l s k i l ls f a c i ]i t l e s fo r t ( a c h i n
f ac
R C l in i c a l s k i l ls
s d o n o t rc
p l a c c c l i n ic a l p r a c t i c e : t h e y e n h a n c e t h e
l c ,l r n c r s s t a t e o f
T he y
p r e p a r e d n e s s fo r p r a c t ic e
A
p r o v i d e a s a l e e n v i r o n m e n t l o r d = li b e r a t c
r a c t ic e
e la ti o n s
h e li m it a t i o
a r e
i t i(
a
tio
C Omu n ' " a
on
De
m a l
c ls o n
i s a l s o a s h i f t p a r t t L . 1l a r l y i n m c d r c i n t t o
w a r ds
nei
d t o d c c c l o p l e a d e r s h s ki l l s b o t h e d u c a t i o n
t he
ll y t o r e e n g J g e t h e r o f e s s i o n i
a l ly a n d c l t n i a
p
n st r a t e
f
g 1c d e v e l o F m ( n 1 o t h c o r g a n i m t i o n
T he
re
o r rn
a n ec
in
s im u
Fe e t n
c hn c j
d le z
sh
TU
peet
le +-
1n
bein g
1s
to
S e a S 7e T
li n
z s c
1n
u se
t cach1n m 1 6 t h e
p l a c e ( F Be ld ( t a ]
:l s
1d S T RT
.ca
e st
qu
io
d
a
fr c q u
o re
ppr
pn
t n t
at c
t r a 1n t n
2 0 0 1 S t u d e n
bo
u t
ly in
J SF d L Ts
'
ts
hc
lr
n o \ lc e s
T rx
deopTnml
pc rt
SUFPned
w rt uz
du m
5t : s
i ri
(t h >
t 1u n
Jw
r c m
1n
u Bn
\ 1r
n u
l 1l)
t u J
HH = r J
JI
n m
r
e
lt l )
n tt
h hN
l1
J
I I :Bl W
T ht
an
U w
d Wh a b e
n
hm l
l
o n t
bt n
\ n
( t ) [ 1t t
x
he
\ua
a n
1n
h m n tu u
la t l u
b
l am
(Tl
Iw
pr , m
lu
u Bc
w e
h l 1n
a n
Bl Bt r
u n
n n
hw
n
J1
l f 1j !
l 1 1L
1)1i
H t n n w
H m n in
Hn
P!
>> n
h> >
1:\ tt l H \tl"
h>
h
a r n 1n
be
T he
r e
Is
Is
n o c
pe
w o r
rn t c
a so
k p la c e f r o
ha t
he c li n ic a l s h lls
c
gr a t e d i n t o t he
t
]n
pr e dic t
c o nc e r n
ha t
su c
tm
1\
u e
ll
c t
\l
\5
k 1 [l / t 5 = 1h t w s W 1 r i b t 1 o n t 0
t h t p e T s o n n e l a n d phucr l
B B1n n r
Con s
2 0 10 )
9 hm
J \ l t 5 h t n pr o Je m
dm J
m
n u nn
1h > t >
n n n w n
n u w
J he h m
1 : e Bl l 1r H
'"
'
I'
\L
t o
pE
r u 1n
e s
t he v d n h m t M c 1c hucs
hm h h x u n Mc a n d
u n m g 1
H n e 1 N t o t h c n o r kp la w
Iw \ m l e \ i \ 1\ i t n c l i n i c \ i s k t u s
t t
h n h
h ns
ec
h n h n h n e h h H n he k u n t n n w n N t c c h n i
M n J w n m hi l l H . k nh > h e w h n n c r w n g ev dc nec
h i \ i n c n s u n RS
l t h > h n p o Mn N h n k n k
d k i l l M ht t e
ci l i t l es
m n
m l t o r s i n h t t 1t m y l w j r d v n m
( [ By h l o p e t u l 2( X ) 7 ) h a s a l u t h t n
' l i dent t T \ ) l w r t o r m 9\ n i t h y \ 1s i n #
t l1
l
tB i t ltm
n n rl n
hc
to
1 1 111 11 1 11 V
1a \ l w
rc
Pe
r >
in
b t i t y
l a r l y l o r n o v i c e le a m c r s w h e n t h e y o b s e r e
p r a c t i c e s 1r 1 t h t l r w o r k p l a c e t h a t d i f f e r f r o m t h e i d e a l
w a n d J r d t a t 1 g h t 1n
k i ll s a n d 5 1m u h l o n w t t i n g
t he
T ht r c J r c a ls o c t r r u l d e r a h l e L o s t a 5 t e d \ \i t h t he
v
'
to
n e e
1t
a s
hc
ds
c o n ce x t
n t a ls o
rs
t r Ln
pa r
u r
r e Jt l a m s
( o n 1p e t c n e c
la t e d
n rn c
be ha > l o u
f t echnul o I1 J \ hl hl 1 l l t > t l t }\ L
d 1r 11( a l \ k l l l \ e J u t J t 1 \ l \ t L ) l w
d i r fc
< K J [
o r
la r p r o g r a rn
rj c u
hl c \
so rn e
l us auht u
jr o
c n v
(K r
chl l cngc
T1 a j o r
h 1\ 1r \
1 1$
lln c c s
K :h l b > r t 1 \1m L I l \ k W l : Sr 1 BBt u r Br i 1

A1n 4l t r s t d r B\ 1i
} 1 r l 1e l l f o l d f t B1t i Bl m BBr 1W e Bi { e
t L t n Br \
w
07
l E / 1Bc ( Bf t o 11 5 t r 1e $ E d l n b t l r g h 2 0
+d \ 1L J t l 0 n
o 9 t J t 1 0 n o F h- cdj t 1l
A 1e e1w
f1
d e v lo p \ n g
r ct t
lin
il c a
k Bt l s
c e n t re s
Bt Bt 1 o t 1 i n l n n Bi u Bi t i l u c a Bi c+ t B
d l e y P S i Bn u
6 Cr J , B r a
M c d lc a l I t l u t l t l 0 n S> r H
20 0 7
Unj trstandl n
A5M E
G
Ke r } H o gg
ed
K
W alsh
; { 1t c 1 Bl
'
DcBr t ml ' nt
do
7 1) c
rc
2 1s t
c c n
hc o
gu b
i 1h
'
'
" Q ,
o f fi c e
c ry
f he a lt h
u o n o
t to
ss l o n a l s i n
pr o fc
c a re
l fo
d a t 1o n
u n
t \ 1n n l b t i o n
pa t ien
15
Ko
D
rev
fu
H l.
' ' "
. .
rc5'
r l
S E E x p c r t 1s c i n r c J l w o
92 ,
7
79
S r r J d Ut s 2 6 15 ) 7
_
1s
..
20 0 5
Bu r k e J h t c A 1l l s t c
F ie l d M
1c a
1n
n o v e
p pr
o 1c
to
Jo
A
QM
care
G a gn
lm
a n
G ln
d w
o r.
1 1t t o n
s o
1r A c
Lr
a n u rw
c Br
\ fa
g hu
t tw a t r n
s lo
Hi
1 J t r u m>f 1 t
o u r 1(
t 1v n
t xer t 1 0 3
> r
(\
15 l f l
Ke r
t (x
tu r
L u n
H a
luJ
15 V 1
f 1 j BJ \
(
J 1
o n
> \ a
A 1r d l t
h b nJ f
( lln
Jnb<- r i sB
dm
>
J . l J
te r
l) w
du
r \
tr
J l r Bl n
j N
, l
1J 1
Ri n
s \n
o r b in t o
r 1n
Hn
20 00 N
n v lc
tio n
(lo
r 1a
XX
"
"
l A c a d e m y Pr e s s
lt
i 1t
Jy
" "
r n ri n 1 o
pr
th
>
4)0
J. . b t n
l,
/r t
n A
l 1)
l \
\ 10
ed
m v c r s 1t
g pr
1 E, i u
f I hn
o e s s1o n
d1
t Co
=
pe t e n
"
c e
IL
C h i c a go
a t ro n
C h 1c a g o
o ls at
'
t 1e n t
l 17
0. I l
1.
l Kl
B11
: ( 10 I
\ u n u
ln c
lt t\
Kn l
'
J 1 1L 1
1 t l / 2l
\ \ b r t E . I 11
Bi
1 r J ?1
11 1
1 15
\ , J l ( B\
;> \ lj
I'
i r r i 111cnt \
1 B1 l
l 11
s e ss m
B 1( 2 1 '
ls
'"
Jl
1 n 1k 1 )
t io n
tm "
2 11117
uJ 1 t J t 11) n
l n
B:
w Jr tj
ll5t
\t.\\t
1 20
l (1 l
\i \
l-
t 1\n
\ \
Bt
r J Bn
t tk L
'
t L\ t m
pm
\ e
l o1i n\ Bl df QdBn
A1 5
111 1n 11 0 1
1n n 1
bto
t iv e
n o v a
c a l pr o c e du res
C Tr an$f or m1ng
k D C J n c y
Q l u 11i t y 5 a
t r a t l vc
s a h t y m p
2 0 09
1fB 4 2 4 - 12 8
S Bm
w C
[n
t to n
u c a
> a r t n c r s 1u p s f o r c a r e
o t h n d
N H 5 E d u a t mn t o r s c
l s k il ls st r a t e gy
] t h c 5 c o l t L 1s h c t 1 n 1 a
u h n R fo n . a n
0 07
L 1 H U t 1 t e S u n 1 1 r Bn 2
d
J C h p ( 1 ! 4 A 1 1b m ^
N } l E L H 1 J t 1\ l n l u r S = o d l n
d
B
L E n 1 ! u 1 t 1 o n d l f l t e p l o r o / 1t
l 1 1d r i n e r l m r
I J u
"
0
1 00 0 2
1
\
I
1
1 : L 11l s 11 r l t
m o l , 1 tr , 1l r i t ( 1
t t u t u r c t r e n d s Bn
\ u n 1 PJ \ b p r e \ = n t a n L
Rt l n J (
c n \
1 Bf J l J N l h
l
t i i 1 [ t o r 1s
D t p tzr
l / \ u>s \ l n
t J
l p 2 10 2 1 1
A f r , / i 1 t 11 f ,
200 0
r Jn
p 11
\ >
tl
11 r A A r H j B 1 u
> n , t Bt J H
r > n
/ 1 J +l ( u
ln m
kr t h IJ \
e \
c t m
in
"
nt XXnHX X = '
M c G a Fh.
m e
p JM
a r n in
1 J 1 t u 1J
d Bu c u m L u l u m M t J d B1 E e 1 t
0
3
0
3 ( Su p p . J ) s q 6 4 2
a J
HOa r d S K G a b a D S m i t h B E c t
t
i
s
e T p dt P r n > t
d
c
r
s
u
\
f
S l m u t a u o n st ud o r e s t e
4 5 J3SS
A m J f h e j 1 j JD r Ht i ) I 3
a c = s t h c s 1o Jo = 1s t s
t hc
Bc
19 9 t ) u
r a n
'
"
.\ c [ t h 9 r r a
/ 1e , 11/r C 1r r r
n st o n
Le a&
13 o
a n
19 8 5 H
Nc w \ br k
d 4
t to n
rr u
l n
& s n f , By
1 11 1y
t Bv c
slm u
M e dtc5 l E
20 0 3
9 0 ( 5) 5 8 5 S S
r u z 4 s r l r ( s r ?
u r
le
an d
ing
c ste
f f c c t Bv c
UMin $ h i n R t o
1
d
U o y d D +c e r a s s r s t p
i
n
t
r
a
n
l
l
c
g
c r1 m c a l s k i s
1u 1
El l e c
o st
J N
t c
18 3 19 3 2 0 0 7
D
t c a
'
634 2002
6 7 628
h 1( t r l t o u 3 ( )
. 1 l E 1
C T= a ( h m g
c h 0s o n
le n n u t
G
J
l
s
l
u
r i c a [ s k i lls
K o ti s G a u o
ln g in \ u g
c s .c a r n
tn p r o v
i
j
l
s
i
k
d s t u d)
v( s
co i n j(i
n d o m t< c
d pm
spcct 1v c r a7 4 : 2 7 7 2 0 0 4
d c
( 1
ry 4
he
ito r
x h
:e
20 0 7
tu w
t ic
r c
t ' ' " lt h :
2o o o 5 t a t i o n
Lo
ru
o r g B11u t 1t i 11
Br 1
Co
in r
11
1v 1a r
r t r J i n l rlS
C H A PT E
R
S, r o p i .
, ry
So o
D.
Sl u r "
D.
19 9 7 K l u
,
:. 1J h
5c
1d .
1n
.. . r
A.
Fl
. t - ' "
Sm , II S
lm
,
hc n
( ) : 3 3 8
3 39
St o l , t U S. l a . 1 E n l ,
t a l: Si, "
In i o .
g t.
. Nm
u r
1n
u '"
p l,
W E ll.
3 3 : (i 7B 6 8 5 199 9
. L R. , i " "
B S.
J W i l. .
n ac
Ey o
t' "
"
83
hi n g
h . . g. I n
: H i g h . Ta k "
d rc a l p c , f . . " "
"
l i . i . A l . 5s c H ' " ' "
j , 1M A
p ro g"
,
2 8 3 ( 13 ) : 17 4 8 1 7 4 9 2
0 00
W u , d I . . It h O r . N i
W H O : P. t
. T io .
g
t
T h,
20 10 W H O u b l i .
p
,
c c . tr c
] 82 , 19 9 7
W w l .
1. c m
C l i n i c . l s k i ll s
1 , 1, r c . Ri .
, ic
to . '
'
H) ,
"
\ w " g , 1. . I , c t t " ' "
1w . Rk
1
r
Q , , y ie S. . I e r y 1n 11 . . 1t 1, C a r r
c u r r 1 , 1. n
13 ( 6 ) : 4 17 4 2 1 2 0 0 4
U .
c F n u t lc ' , t i.
u.
. 1g .
j o r S , m 1, 1. . Ti u , 1
r , l r . c ln
"
\,
y [.
A t i -
Fe t y
B e ds i de t
Se c t i o
Lt
'
c B
hi n g
eac
Bt
i [ u e 1t i o 1ts
l fe c t i v e
In tro du
t hc c
t eac
v ie w
ts is im p o r t a
at le n
h i n g a t t hc b e d s i d e c p rt o n r i z e s
o 6 m t d l c a t r a in in g s t u de n t s a r t
C li n ic a l
ca
t io n
fo
v e lo
r t hc d e
c o n t ac t
m e n t
o r
ith
c lln ca
la s s i
k i J] S
pr
t to n J
m
lta n
c o n m
ho u
it s
r e (Bu i r e
ho
1n
t tca c
h n g
r tco m in
J n
f a m l <i a r
u n
St u d e
gs
ro u n
n ts m a
v a
t o
da Y
f_
cT
lu
o
c
t n
ht
he
c x
r 1c n e c
ts
p p r o p r 1a t c
b e i n g ta r ge T
/ tu
dn
15
ca d c
st a r t s a n
st u
de
ta \
ca n
t s 90 t
s t p a Ae c
< Fm
/. l
'
1T
'
d c Ja l
c n
e + T Vi l t p
r
\ plt(
v 1d m
a n
be ds id c
t
n cc
ha t
eJ r
lly
ha v t
a y p a r a d o \ Bc a l l y
f o r h e d s r d e t c a L h 1n g
d c n l g r o u p J t t t n 1n
u 1e
TJ N n
oc! $i r o y
/
w rm
Qe n b
u
'
a / 1g
1 by a
tl Be 1o
11
c O n m +e n
s re
Pr t p
Pa t t e
L IO n
\n
w 1t
w J rd
1H h
W JL
t\ i n B: p r o
hu
h n w h n h r n h 1 h n H 1n
n n d h D M ho o k
W
c a r l y > NM
h n n JL u u n wni n mr n >
m
he
'
u n rn
'
u rn
m c
te
: t
in
p n n n lc s
n i agiM
n n x
o r
c J
e B a
n
c a
)a
tt
Er
d t ea n b l
! i a
iu
\\ t
t 1n g
\t lt H t t
\n \
he
\ t 1
P&
AN
1' J
t \\
rt u m
Bn
r t tc \
t\
1 Tt e t l
n t \n n
S\
HJ k
h> > m
n
pa t e
in
hn
o n
n h
l l 1t
h l h t y t ha t
nr el
ho
u 1hu t c
u ar
h 1u
ta
co
ke W
m s t lt u t \o n s
T hc
T\ L I U Td
t o
\ L1
d - l mc
c\\
nhnR o n
I t 1l H
y n d
a n
a h
l o
t5
De
d m n
ld b v
1o
chi ng
m J\
dc
u w
hc r h e M h c a r c s t an
hcm
w c
'
b arn
at L>M
h 1u q
He n
1Lhi n hr1nRt o g e t
>
a
r
I h
1at ht hn1l M
hn
u t
5tc
l u u u tw
tw
tw l t ) r r p
J>nmn1t hn
p hys
1r a t
Wa
1 k a r n i w t r md
i t s c n v i r n 1n m t
i r
i \ i 11 \
rm
t j 1> , I p r i j b l t m
pt in M w m rt u
c 1n n
b e fo r e
pc
c h 1n g h o \ p r t a l s
p1u
d e s p Bt c
t
n o t
( Sc a h r o o k
t ml r o n mc n t
20 04 ) I r u p p r o p n a t c c o m m e n t s b t c
d 1s c o u r a g e a n d a l 1c n a t c
c e [l 1 t 1 0 r 1s m a
t hc
d ha
) fe e l
be e n
p m du c
tn
fe s sio n aJ
at
r e n s a n in g
B
f
0
0
0
2
l
u
t
o
h
r
t
t
a
c
1
r
c
e
e
S
n
h
e
t u es an d e m pat y ( p
d
f
i
i
i
s
r
e
u
r
e
n
r
t
a
o
o
m
q
dc gr c ( o f p r e pa r
m ix to w o r k a
d
v
(
i
o
v
n
e ac h par t y
i c a t io
c o m u n
t iv a t e d
m o
D ir e e t
Ie a r n i n g
( n t
st u
to
nnuht >d
a n n t o tT
ry an d
pa
Vh o p r m k h
p l 1yr \ l o l o g y T h i
s pm
p
l B> h
BBt
in
va u a
w e
Ne
ll b
B e ds i de t e a c hi n g
g p m
sm
kv c
hc J s id
t s in t
hn
is
ro
<
1\ t n t s
h n g St u
t t c
i c a +u
h .i b l y
ni cdu: J s c h o o
t n
n n
Bu h
v w
hc o p t i m a l
s h o u tL I L o 1n
tx
s n
5 Lh m
a n ti
a t io m
tu
p lw
pr w
be r
p ly w i l I1 t
c
h vo an
n u m
pp
hc
e m
st r a n
\ r r t she t
t
w
T he y
gt
d
l
h e p r o x n n N o r n u r n g Mn r a n d he
h e n p t 1t t 1n g p c r w n a l q L1c s t 1o n s t o n
i 11 y Be c l a n x l o L1s \ r u n x u r c o f t h
c lr
hc
q u ic k ly
ds
it h in s t r u t t io n a l r c a <o n i n g e n a b le s
da p t t il e c li n ic a l t e a c hi n g s e s s i o n t o
s t u d e n t s ( r b y 19 ) 2 )
in g
r e a so n
o
n t e
lt a n
c n t lc ls n \ o
st T
a n l t
1t t
ha t
hc
ft
a r
tu m o
h i j p u l
1r a
e \ a TT i 1 u +) n
htl
WC i e r
s
d l! J
:s rr Y c
hu
Fo
1r n
1. 0, ! Ed .
in
n t
ru
ppre
u ]
t
ro
c 1a t c
le
hat
hu
e t
d ba s t
hl <t a r )
ta
an
ho
n t e
: kn
P LT
tc n e c
ed g e o f pa t i en t s ; a
d r ll n e \ s f r o m e x p e r i e n
no
ed g e of th c
he i r s o c ia l
tm
re a
c u
ed g e
lu d i n g
o w l
in c
ge t t
ht
qu
rc
p lc
J 1t
o n
1e \
J n
J 1
nt \
n t
h n Bl
o
st a
ge
s
o
pn n
o f
k e d i n t he lc
a m
c 1 p
t e a c f un g ,
1n
g p
ro c ess
n n c e
ha F s b y
pr
to
Fl
ble
g t he
t 1s m
so
hi
I n o t
bv
he
pp
Fa t
r o ac
le n t
t o
he
a tt e n t io n
Bn
H e
w Th
a n i
e T i\>t t
lt1
t n t Uu J
t 1 n
t wi n
J w
In
hm
To
e se n
l c 1 t 1n
he
s 1 t u J t 1o n
ted
bn
to
N 1d e r
n (\ \
l pr m
t I
pr
1n
r
k h
r f ?ndl ng t L)
hng w
t n c
r so n \
t t
>o
SW
i t 1o
tu
m
lc
\ a n
e n
hx
n h n
k h
I m
I n<e
u m n Hh n
I u Hw
cm
rc
po m
h v h n wc
w n t
'
f 200 1
tc m
MJ Rn mmn d
Bt e e l
p a t i en t
of
he i r
I U N w h h n g Wn p t s t h c
h e 1 n h w > r n V n . T n e o f a
M h m ht Ev h
H n n hnn d
Oe t h c c J s c
u >J h n M N
m h oh m v
k n m hx l g c a n d
h
n
o rJ e B m
m d c h 1n h c r g c n c r a h z c d
pe l n m
H de
A p p r o p r i a t e k n o w le d g e
pJ H r
t \n :
J H
A p pl u p
El pcm n J
r en e s s
at
es
Im
N
h t?
l t\ .
U L Ad
Kn h
hn
lr
aw a
an
r al
vo
r t
s t u u c n As
1Vmhhn
0l
1j 1l L
a n
1 n
r r bt i n
dt
in
tio n s
t \
c x .\ m
kecp1n
>t e
am i l i ar i t y wi t h di se a s e
o f pro to u s pat ie n t s
'
/tu
en e
g st u de n t s
d 1c a t 1 n g t s
a s a n
in
tn
lu
u u o a
ce
co n t e x t
t he
o f
ak\ ng
de ls fo r w u dt n t s t s pe
y c a r \ o l t h c L o u r \ t \ L\ 1t
dt munwr 11t t ' a p p r L p n l w
t h>
i nt e g r a t i ng t h c p a t i en t '
h ba c kg r o u n d k n o w le d g e o F
c lin ic a l
s c ie n c e s
a n d
c li n i c a l
e n t
n w e
b e e n d s c r ib e d
li n i c a l t u t o r w i ll
e l ge o r l ea r n c r s : a n u n d e r s t a n d i ng o f t h c
d e n t s p r e s e n t s t a ge i n t he c o u r s e a n d o f t he
m c u lu m
r e q u i r e m e n t s f o r t . 1a t s t a e
g
t 5r a u e H
1u
i ci ne
c o n t e x
J SPet j N t h
G 0 -
v th
o wl
st u
wl
o m n
w tt
in
o wl
1 f 5e t
1ro
c a
l e d ge ha v
o w
a \
ll m
t X
n o t
o r
o n ln
ba s i c
ca
bv
\ 1g n t
r c i
m a in s
fi n k
rs
ed g e o r me
l p r o b tc m
s c ic n c e s
o wl
a n
k 1n g
n a
cr l !
hc
\ts
n s t c r
w a r
ll a n 1
l 20 0 3 )
al
( 00 1)
d tu to rs as
t io
a n
hm
c o n su
(f ft ct i vel y f u n c t i o n i n g
a p p s u r hy 9 9 4
w
h 11s i n d Jt t Bt u9l t > ( ( r u > \ \ L t J l Z t y } s )

d c o l l e a ; u e \ ( 2 0 0 0 J dt \ Lr 1t w K \ H k . L j 1n 1 J l
w
:; \ k
: rd tl\ t
& o 1 d 1n > r ( 1. t r r ] ( x j < l b i 1
P h y a
t ca ;
\\ e r
N
t
t e a c hl n g m a y be
doc t or ( B u s a n c
de n t w
K 1l m
s
h 1n g b y pcei al 1n d
d L L t l o p 1n F st udt nt
s k 1 ]l s
t c ic
t u Tc
1M
stu
d t Kn
d h
h o s p it a l
o r
n -
Sj d o
hi c h
d tu to
r Bc n c c
tru
n s
fo
to ta
l l la y c d
J n x 1e t i c s a r t
J Ll !
Tu
t\ci
t u n l t Y 1o
Ex p c
: a n y n . 1Al t q u a t i c A . ' ' " l t

i
St ucl t nt , p o s \ t u n t ht m\ c l ( S t o Lv a r d \ t h t b \ L k o l t h c
o u n d t h c t w d s 1l t t u 1 \ o r t t p r r t 1= \ ri t i o n
w hi lt
g r o L1p r
d
m i \ n t l p o l l 1 v c n n v c r x a t io
h
n t B o lle 1 1 \
c
o
n
c
r
e
o
m
n s
d A l t L1 r b 1 h o b s t n a n t t u w r w i ll lw
t
w 1 t h p J t tc n b a n
o f t h i s b h \ \ 1 m 1r n n , l b e 1 1 c t o
r d r t s s t hc
a\ e3 w
l
1
l
t
d
a
1
1
t
t
n
n
r
M
u
h
t
t
c
e
n
n
a
l
v
a
e
c
t he
t
bJ a n
Op p
ro n n lc n m
li n ic a l
t lu i n
c am n e c
it u n it t u m pa n \>d b
d t? e h 1 v l o \ 1r
y c li n ic a l
t ht m s c v c s
1n t r m l u c e
h
o \ 1l t \
t
o
b
s t il t t
r
o
t
an d
tu
l
l
s t \ t 1n # t h c p t t r } o s t o f t h c l r v i s t
a
r
t
c
t
s
y
n
t
c
i
p\ l
So r n c m r y t e c i r n t n n i d a t c d b y a n u n h n h a r c n v l
an
su
85
\ 1n t t r t ; 1
n r
ahl i
C hic
>H a\ t h
t
l
\
n
l
J
y t t l li n k
u i r r m > B1t
1\ {i ng
1n h w
n w nm
k Ms
h n k Jl i nk s
mn
tu m a
n w rc t
HHo =
hu
n u
av o
id
d e 1 mn r mn g
h m
he m
h dc
&
HH t h e
in
hm
hm
e vr r
t o s t t t (h n t s o n t h e
h
t e y a r c u n p c h n t in
u n i n appnmh h a s
in n ppro p rh m
hor t L m
'
"i
h av
"
e . .
t it u
h"
"
d.
Im
"
I l y,
Ct .
P, : .
l.
nr
" . "
O S Pi t a
PP "
F t l"
"
t.
"
1i, c
. t o .
.
i.
Th .
Lo
hu
tu
d' "
Tu t o r s
p a t i.
Tu
. t'
"
'
D e liv
er
A p l,
Ft w
st r a t e gi e s
'
n o
to .
a.
l i . k . d c y c l e s h a s b e e n d - D bc d [C
a
i . i t hc s t u d e n t s I. m i n g f r o m
"
'
( F i g 11 1i
I.
"
tf.
a t i, "
"
Th . . 5 , 1. . .
Du c .
t"
h,
' "
P, : "
'"
tio n
a r el
a n d br : i ng t o
h , y ' " go : "

f o r l e a . In g B . 1.
to . cc
ha t t he y a ,
a . d t h . O PP O r t '
b c i . . I n g s t u d .
c' ' "
Re
" l \cs "

. Ts
I' "
C 0 . 19 9 3
. . I t , m o d , r,
c n l ro n s
" 1. Bt,
h. u d h
Be ds ide
C H A P E R
ga t
he r e d i s
r e v ie w e
io n s o r m
cept
dc
t ic n c c
n i ax
ir m
w it
y c le
d in t c r p r c t d a ri d a n
y
n g s a r e c l a n li c d T h c
z e s t h c v a l u e o F Ah c t i ne
isu
h t hc p a t t e n t
t ht t e x p la n l t i o
an
mi s p
ta n
r s
6 0 b
ex
s
pe n
p
t
0 Su
to
in to
c he r
l carni ng
e v to u s
pr
y c le
t x
pc
Fin a l l n
r e n c es
10 F c
fe
r lc
Pre
: t ?=
Z P
Da ra t o
r
Ti e
3 0
s e
n d s
bc a
d o tt l
OU T
V 13
v n s tn
3
t1
k l l 1s
( u rn c u
lt\n
!u m
e
r
1p
l th e
o r th o s e &y o
to
t c o m e
a n
e l
o i
'
o q e
do
pa :
c w
c B
c to r
c 1
c u r r ic u
yo
u r
n \
tu d e
w c
ll
a n
Fl u y e
d pro
a n
do
s i tiv e
a n
c o n s tr u c
trl o
ts
fr o
yo
u r
pe
rt
po
t +l c
t t w a s lc 3 3
l
p r c p Y rc fo
t o
T> ' " : u r i
11 N i r 7 (
t 1
quc l 1on,
n : u v a l u At t e
rr d
Ou
st u
de
w o r
lrc
yo
n e xt
u r
be d s ide
t h t c r per s
c r :
ta
t\
o w T\ s
ht
0 0 l \ e s
1;
lru
t u d o n l o w >i 1 l t >1
glvo po
L U C I L S S fu
11 P r c p
p ro
vn
in
a n bv/u r
c tio
ha t
[h o b tu d o n l s
n s
d b i 1c k to
wl
lu
du
io
c at
bj e c t i v e s o f t he m e d i c a l
by
c a n
e x p e r i e n c e d t o d i f fe r e n t e x t e n t s
a n y s t a g e o f t h e c u r r i c u l u m v h 1l e t h e y a r e
t h e w a r d s ( F Bg 1 1 3 )
he
n t s at
Li n g
ba s e d
1n
du
be
t io
ca
n a
l i ni ca l sk t l l : F o r t um o r st ud e n t s t h e r e a r e
oppo
t u m t l e s t o b e c o m e p r o %c 1e n t a t n o r m a l p h y s i c a l
pr
e x a m 1n a t i o n w h r l e m o r e s e n i o r s t u d e n t s g a i n
g
I
t i c e i n e n 1t i n g a b n o r m a l p h y s i c a l
s
WM \
d o c t o r i s a b Be M d o
o oq ? r
or
at
r p e m m Ti . #SbamB * Fax
rpe r w
Fr a ct c
C m -
h 1 '
W. i T M
an
Ce a s o p e \ e t T Lm
1
Cx n p : 1 n i N
o1 -
CCmj v e
w\
1 c t
r ur n g
1n
d r m \ a <
Ct u UN n u bo n
\ r t h1 d o c t o r
1
W ilh
unJ+t au1r g
W i th w
W rt t w V Bw
Bu
1 1
pr o l o a 1 lo n a l
r h n ph i w m w d n * l g j r
n ur st i t ndng ot the do c t or
An
s t a n c re a n d
m a l 19 c lm ic a l
tF -
4 IX I 1u .j g 1 n
Th 1 d o c \ o B *
I e n d s r c ia l
b i l i c cW
w u te a l l t u d o s -
I oA$W
h\ l l h
a r h l U l \ J L f t)1 B1
$ Cw +> u
'
r ol
e h t he
s e r v i ce
p [1tu d e fo r
p or s t d e v e l o pm e n t a n d a
d e m o n s t r h o n o l o pp r o pBBa te t r a n s fe r r b l e s k i ll s
F l g 1 13
T h e 12 l e w
m n
o u tc o m e s
ght
t io
c cl b a c
11 R e f le
T ip s t o im p r o v e b e d s id e t e a c h in g
R R i * R I 12 0 0 3 \ d e c r 1 b e s 1 2 t } F t o
o t e e t re c t n
y t l 11 l >1o
ta u
L n
Rr
h ho
n : p r o v l cj c
9 D c br lA :ln g
k n o w l c g c i s s y n ch c s i z c d w h i c h p r c p a r e s t he
w o r kin g
t s f o r s e e i n g a s u b s t q u e n t p a t i e n t (F i g 1 1 2 )
s t u de n
t lo
rn m d r
bc
w i Bt L
hin g
drr1: j
ro c (
7 In t r u
be gin s w it h r c nc c t io n
,
a r e c n c o u r d g c d t ot ons l der t h c i r r e c
t
s
n
c
t
u
s
e n
v he n
t h e l i g h t o r Pr e v i o u s
m
o n
l t i n t t r 1c U
CX PC
c lin ic
l
a t t o n c o n t 1n L1e s w i t h t h e u n c l { r s t a n d i
c
r
x
E
n g
p
ences
i m e s a t c r c n t l e v e l s a c c o r d i
c lim c a l c x p c r t
n g
o f t he
d e n t s s t a gt o f l e a r n i n g a n d i t s i n t e g r a t i o n
t hc M u
n
l\ o
c rv l
t e ac
mm u n i
fo r
st u
d(
an'
ca N o n
s k
n ts t o
p r a c t is e
l i JBi c Bl r et uol l t.
co m m u
cn b
ud
e x i
p o r t un M
k i l ls
n ic a t io n s
cal l o b
ser
t h
ve
isi n
f
It r o c e d ur n e n c p c 1n = t ur c , a n n u l at i on o
d
n
a
l
n g
a r t e r i a l b lo o d ga s s a r n p
a p c n p hc r a v e i n
i
r
c
a
i
h
c l
b }a d d c r c a t h t t c r i z a t i o n a r e p r o c e d u r e s w
dt n t s t o
m o st w a r ds fo r s t u
r e a d i l y a v a i l a bl e o n
c l
cr i
ri nt
m an
d is c u
D
h er
d r t t ar mg e n 1 1l t .
b r s t u di n t s t o o bse r
F b o t t o f t h e s e
1rest i ga1i on cur

p po r tu
it i e s
ss a sp e c t s o
a n
an y
at
\ s l on
r d
wa
f c l in ic a l
- al
pa
l t i o n s a v a il
a b le
l0 r a
tt a9h
ar t i me w i l l i
n c v1 t a
hl y
va r y
l
o
ne c e s \ ity e
f
Wi l
,
b O
c o n c i
r t i cu l
t e a c h i ng
Pp or t
ll s t u d e n t s s e c a ( o r n a r b
p a lt r r
ux ol
b
L
o
t
i
p c r o n a l d i g:t a l a
g o o ks o r
pa t e n s
\ sis t a
nt
(P D A s ) c a n b e u s e d t o d o c u m e n t p a t i e n t \ w e n a \
nd
f
h
l
t e e a r n in g po i n t s
t o ke e p a m c o r d o
(Davi & D e
nt
19 9 4 ) T h e s e c a n b e r e v i e w e d p e r i o d i c a l l y a n d f
u t ti r
e
t o ma k i ng go o d an y dc l i ci t s
t s i on s d i r e c t ed
ha t
e n su r e
e a r c
ty
1. H .
p r a c t ise
v ar e
ng \ t
n1
T ht
.'
F
W
X ,
st 1
. : , l . ) I _ . \. {NI . G
oi 1 Bl ul rt ' r i el ' l . nt er p r e t at i on of 1 A'
l a bo r a t o r r e p o r t s a n d a c c = s s r n g s c ic n t i ' c pa p t r s
A l ist o l t a s ks t o be p e r fo r m e d o r p r o c e d u r e s t o b
e
f o r r c b r e n c e a r c e x a m p le s
d o u t i s u s u a l ly a c o u r s e
o b s e r v e d a n d c a r r 1e
r e qu i
r u / s s i o} 1t ] 1, k i l l s. 11c u bst r vat 1on of bo l h Jun i or r Twn t . t uc l cn t s ' r o % c i en c y i n a n y o f t he s e t as k s i s
a n d s e n io r
d o c t o r s i n t h e i r \ \ o r k i n g r e la t i o n s hi p
t he n s c o r t d i n t he i r c li n i c a l r e c o r d bo o k
n t h o the r
h e a \ t h c 1 r c p r o f e s s i o n a l s s h o u ld h e l p
st u de n t s
d c c lo p
a pp r o p r ia te
p r o fe s s i o n a l
B' I B( ) } i \ l Ld A \ L T) : L A H . X G
be ha \ t o u r
h c p a t i en t ' p r e s e n t i ng c o m p l ai nt c a n b e u s ed as
r a r 1 sj . l s ; i 11s. a n y
o f t h c a b i i t i cs a c q u i re d T
f o c u s o f a p r o b l e m b a s e d l e a r n i n g e x e r c i s e 1n
1 he
1n t h e w u r d
e t t 1n g w i l l b c o f v a l u e i n o t h e r d o c t o r
ba s i c s c i e n c e s a n d c li n i c a ] s c i e n c e s c a n
w h ic h
p a t 1e n t s t t u a u o n s
i n t e gr a t e d
r t 1 d e \ 1 1d r Al c: . p
s a nd
p r o p n at e a t t 1 t u d e
e t h ic a l d i le a s c a n bc o bs e r e d b
y t he s t u de n ts
1n t h e i r w a r d a t t a c h m e
7 l n \ ( ( l rl i
n t s
e
lt
nr
er
en t
pr
A U t he
p
se
a spe c ts
a c 1t T t a s z n
r et 1c o
n t e x t
t im e t o
to
pr
c 1 n
he r
r at
e se n t c
XOUr aged
si t a
be
cJ N
dm d u a l
]n
a c t 1s e
to
] Bm
h1 n
l> c t
1n
re t u r n
in
u r
ht
he
c o n t e x
hc p u
rc
l!
hc
ht
A p r e s c r i be d lt s t
L+
St udLnt s \ h o t 1 j d
\ \ a r
d du
] s k l l l \ fu
rt
n n
g pr
y b e I1 id
m J
to
J m t
o u t
he
a c
hle \
co n
d in
he
stu
d d-
i n t he m r d
o r 1s t o b e d y g u 1d e w t h t h e l earning
e m e d fo r e l c h
n at e
he r
\ l t l IL l
.
g in g le
in a n a
T ] :
a r n
in g
Se c Ta bl e } J
Ti b h
T1d1Bnr
1 1
h gm
or
d i n ic d
U C
hm 1
Te
a c
V M d h
4m
Ub1
Ev 1 lu
r n
)
rn
1l r 1u
F T ( Ji n
t n e
te
r1 { i l
( r
pt
u Bll
1r
re
d ssu b
lu
nt
h he
1 Tk
Y l \ l L c
n t
k m g h a bc m
J n i n w
1s
n u n t
n w
nhxa
hr
st u
w c t
i l cd p J N
d e n t s in
ks
han ng
t nh n e > Ht
w a n t h i n w r a c t 1o n m t h
C m , nnl N h t s
> t N c v m n a k by o b s c m n
C nH in aL m e N
N n h r C h 1 o r s d n d by
m n
> 1 Mt
h in g
h. Jf l r
h e h n Jl
i l\
1w
Pw
Bj n
i9
c t in
m e n
t l 1 r Bn
h>
n n
l t>
i\ \
pt
r1
\ l nl n
to
\:
m tln lB
u n e
\ e .l r t
c 1\ \ r c s
n tl sc
l f u 1r t ! c t e d l u
1r f \ l n
sl
Sl m l> n
be
t a
l ik
1t
taL
ted
h( d
ce r
t o a W i 1r d
t a in
n \lm
fm
be
11
\\
pAr \ (
t t \ ent
f t jl n
= J l\
eJ c
be
bed
d-
Rc
hu g
tea
t re s t
C F ig
11 7
Th e r
1 me r = o n
Cf B i s
e
t T
t c r
p r s
t=
be e n
A pa
t ien t
c o n
d D
a t t m
c u ssc
dm
d b)
h5 \
ts
m a n a
Pr o fe
to
pr
c lo
dc
R FAx
S t u d c l 1u
bl e
hm
w J
rri
u t h
a n
d c l i r uc
c M
en i
l}
re
i +m
n u
t1 e
kn
w i t
t w
t a sk
lm
! Bw
le d ) : (
u w
1n
n
r
jlj
t 1l
Bu l r (
fu l
re
O n
hr
li t t
rH 1
f >r
t n Br r
\ }
l,
t
s cT
hr n <
to
'
t
e
Fol l)
t e +c
Be t h
r e
o
c
l S
e n \ i r c -
tm
z c
A lt
I . e
r TJ e Tl c h
e s
(w e
! k v
1
C L
s
r =. C=3
\ l
be -
\ ,w
1 A T 1t
0 -
CX
1 J
ta
"
&
J n
\B
Br w
[
1\
I>
l 1\
l tr
: {-
it l t
l l
, \
l\
t\
TheT
te a
\\
t e .
\ :C
1: ( . c
r _bt t r
\\
r tl
, c\ l nt t . t \ n. ! cn\ r .
4 I
t t 1 1.
} \ 1n
> J
I l l 1l
Bt n
>
J r t \ 1r t
in
t h
1 1n
B ,
in
Bl
m J n l H \
r1
r c. \ ( d, r e P L .
) 1n l l
, \ 1rBin
h \ 1\
Ne r 1
\J m
<t
t
Bl >
c h\ n h n
Ee \
l l +\ : \
1\ c l r
1l ihu5
1t l
t1
1n
1n
ht s l W h J c
t e \.
[ W\ n \
\ e
he lp t k v
r
L\
:c
11
d \ \ J r d Ix l w d t c J , h Bn g t h e m u 1 t
c l u p t n g d l n t = J l b k l [i 1 T he
t 1 ho u l t l
A l ! t :.
\ 1t
P J t 1> n t
r r l i n i t 1n
r LT n t l b : , l t
rtu t
tm
( h *a
lw
t hc
e o
l tu
e
0n
l n
2 t x 1' ) R J
p p.
t 1u n
l t 1 1J f
n t
a rn
r o YJ
J s J d > r L W5 r r 1
h .1 \ t u J> n t \
t } l } : r 1, \ J r r t j n
1 t B(
\
A. c m
a s s e ss m e n t
t At?
in
t ,t
r t
ca
T he
\.
pr
p j t if
bx
J 1
r B }
Tt
( l a r ,\
o n
s c
k en
.
F r , Vd =
( D O PS) ( SCh Fe 3 S P c T i - . = n c r + L C
a s s e s s Ti LT
)
t t h e c a se
j de ln e n
r r 1 f i t
:e
fo r m
b)
m lr u u o n
po r t
te1c
t 1fy w
d by \ \ n n c h
on e
Ami n1bi c
c se n
c f i
f h j
an1 l u Jl m
Bde \
to
p m
t a
f h
h Lh
ts
c n
fm
co n
r 0
d l f 0c u Jt
a n d
u o n
50
r e
ta
c n
bsc
o r t u n rt\
pp
}m
sz
S. i u
r o u
in
k i ll s
CB
t1
stu
o v 1
kin g o r
a ll a t t he
he
D n
To J m
V ,) r
he
t he
n m
n r n t
s 1o r u
de \
\ J u .)
t o
p 1lr o
o r
. r pru t J n shl l a n d k p o \ . d
Bu t h c . r Ae d s t d t t m h n 1q u e t
fr o m
p-
La
hi st o
e 2
f e T e Ti
ti
L1
a t
o n
6 e 1T
d mmz e
d ge
sul l e s t u d e n t
St u d e n t
c im
r e c c +\ e
to
es
be en
1n
i B .
+h f +J .
d 1d c n
Jn
p c / :-
h a t ha
t a t Bm
p Te
Ae
l o er w
Pr n 3 1 f-
m
t o
A H&
0 7 1n
1c n
i n
cT1
mmn e ,
C. ? e e t k
he p
th
to
bc
m cm
r c f eJ
1o
b Y\
:@
o u n
en
u r J w
hl n
be n t h[ tu r
\ an e
he
111 l r e
J \tlr
n n
.
rr n t
h
J
n (
pp
Tc n t \
tu
J
he
t \
.
ni J
ts V
\ . t nc
I, n1al
<1t 1 .
Ta b l e 1 1 2 A p p l y i n g t h e t h r e
Ti
ks
li
m e
l n [c
a c
+ i c Be
l te
t te
a c
he
a c
c l rc lo
tc o m e
s M o d l
e fo r te
a che rs 1
n the c ll
n ic1 l On v l
Appro a c h t
ro n m e n t
o te q c h:
n g: Do i
t h e t h in
ng
Te o c h o
g r ig h t
o u
r o 4 1
hi n g
S ho v t rrr
In p Y t l e n t t c a c h m g
O L1t p a t i e n t t e a c h I n g
Te a c h i n g
d to w
a n
t th e b e d s id e
W o rk ba se d
a ss e ssm g n
r e le v a n
P r o v id i n g fe e d b a c k
s in
le
th u s i a s
e n
a rds
t to
l le a c hi
ng
p r ia te te a c h in
le v e ls
in
ba
se
a n
d p a ti e n t
l e a c hi n
g
l l fi n d
g I d e a l ly
Tu T o T s
sho u
ht s la c k o F c o n
ld b e b n c c d
s rst c n c
5o
ha t
on
ht y
a re
ar
d bx
: e 1i l
stu
d t ez} Ung o f t > r s

I ea. l ng h J c h : o r
hc or r n t e s s
at t a m
m a H n
p a t 1e n
bo t f,
]n
le a r m
j < o Bp 5 r t
qu
a n el
t } 1i
1\
t ut or
t
du
L u
IU
u M U
a rB
hB
tu
bjt
b>
: J 11l l
d>
m t 1c \
t } 1e y
h ht
A
t lu n
re
\ \ e r e
te J
J
hl n g
p p r u :l
l\ t \
u \ t t
J
lo r
re J \ o n \
b5 w t<
> J(
1)
han
o
(j
ppo rtu
ty
J r d
o t Ba
n l rjj
u st
\ t r t e1 Lb
h> p la n
v a n e
/ c 1 n t l y u t l l l 1 l d
i w n > fi t f r o m \ \
m
c2( t c
l <
a t e l) p r e p a r c d n d
V a r Br J
u n d e s o t ) d
ta k
u m
t 11u \ t
tu
\\
\rt
Rd
u m
h HW m M
g th s
He c l 1 n
a n
to a c h m g
o n
vl o ilk n o
En g a g i n g
d u c a ti o n
Bn e
al
K Pl a n
+1 s r r a
n in
be d s i d e
teac
15 8 : 4 9 3 4 9 5
h i n g M e d i c a l Jour na1
,
19 9 3
S R C r u m s RL S
t c i n c r t Y Ro l
e m o d c l 1n
g
k i n g Ah c m o s t o f
a p o w c T fu 1 t
e a c hi n g st r a t e
gy
B r Tt A: A ; f e B 1Bc 11 1 j
o u r n a t 3 3 6 7 18 7
2 ] Zo o s
D a \ i s h t H D , n t JA
. C o m
p 1 n s o n o F s t u d e n t 1 a r r +l n
g 1n
t hc o u t
P a t l c n t c l \ n 1 c a n d H a r d r o u n d J
e B d
E LI u c 1 t l o 11 2 S 0 S 2 ] 2
19 9 4
D m t J D J \ 1s M
G e 1 m s r B Br Te 1
/ \ p r B tu u 1
G t 1 1 , t e l o r Cl nt n T
h ro n
D L n d e e 2 0 0 8 u n n c r
s t)
n i D u n . lt v
( e n t r r t u r h l ( d 1 Ed
u c ah o n
( j ent r. \ l M \ \ l 1 J l ( ( \ u n L I l T o n o r T
s d a T o r s
L o n do n
Z( X 1 L; >nt r . 1l 11e. LJl (
e ss
m a
Bb
r.
It
\ 1t
tu
m l
m e
n w tJ
L U
L\ \
b\
tR
bJ \ = LI
t .
1\ l
n \ \
w te
l \ 1,
11
1
1L1 n
1 n
\ tH
N t\
lu
tL I t
Fn S Fr
rt
r t
he
\ i
m
s
L n 1t e n L &
\
&
tt c J t \o n
n t 7 J t t t r \ t l i r 1) :
A :r J
rc
s tr e n
pe c te d
C ru
J d \ J n
Se lf
u n
b.
1 1 lo n 1 l
d o i n g t
Co
n c B le s
p
s s io n a
p r o f*
r o n
c a re
u n e x
m om en
f a m 1h a r m t h t h e a F p r o a c h t o p h y s i c a l
t a u g h t m t h e c h n 1 c a l s k 1l l s c e n t r e a n d
wh c h t h e l
e v e ls
r c i Bu i r e d o f s t u d e n t s a
o f e x t t he v a D o u
s t a ge s
o t h e m e d 1c a l c o u r s e
S t 1 m
p p ly i n g p n
g g o o d p r o fe
Gr a s p i n the
g
o n e s \ \i
ig ht p
d e v o lo m e n t 1
p
n tc a c h rn
u
M e n l o r Bn a d
g n s c o k in
l
c li n ic a
pp ro
M o d e llin
ke r
fo r le a c h
in
rrl e rs
arn ors
Know
\\ ea
le
The
Jm
A\
l 1B
I s n = c s
1B\
\\ \\r
h l u 1h
+t B
1r
k l \ \ r . It
\ e
lu p t n g
>\
l lc
n \ r
h e n u n h u H n g w h hng w
r 1l t l l Br t \ T b 111 1 S <w
tn t
u n
l l w 1) M I \ m w l l : l T Bt n c e t l i l I c n t h t r a t t g l e s lb r
l e i l r t l n H i Bn d l r e t l u r m a n L > l e C l l n i r l 7BB1( / 1r r
2 3 Z l i 2 0 1) B
,
A JBr n c J h i E r
h a
Ht m
i \ l > I i nl L J t
: W 1
1a t i s B
1/ rppt rni n m b d \
l 1n * ) h . t 1i u B1 I t Au L Bf t ( JI I 3 t i I l = S l 8
2 0 ( 12
JO , S B\ > [ b 1t r l U JA v \ n d > r V l e u t e n C P M ,
,
I +m t < [ ( ; M T b t
per >pt l un\ u l d l t e n d 1n g t l t l \ m r 7
u l t l 1> r u l e t ) > t
r \ i \ l t n t s a \ t c J L l \ 1 r \ u l t 1n t l e r w l c l u J t t
\
K l ln
t
li n iL d t
M u
jr
r 1t \
e B1t c t 1 1
1 B 1N e B Br i o 1l 3 7 2 4 1 2 i 7
2 f x 13
l \n
ht
te
n t Tw
SM
l ) t 1m
N } I S. t h >
\ti
th
. Pt (t at l \ t' d w
1
1r c
c t a l ; T = j 1c hi n
g
l b 1w d t c a h c r
( tl r1Bl l ! (1UBr1t r1 3 5 : 4 3 7 4 13 20 0 1
b
w r
y S : W h 1l
do c
t o f br e s
198 7
\\ n
Ro
o d
c o n b u lt a n t
t t , l Br r is h M
Ju
t w
Ju n <l \
1Be t B1 ] o r i r Ju t [ 2 9 4 : 1 t / o \
\n
N a ir B R , c
N c L\ T o
e
hu
JL H e n s le y
ghla n
o u
s m dc n t
? A
t
c o n \ u lt a n
ye
d
D F W h a t i $ a go o
t Bl Jo
i
d
c
h
M
e
B r i t is
ie w
t t r r rBr
an
w o
in t c r p ro
fo
dic a l,
%n a \ y c J
R st u
A le x
p r id e a u x D
h in g :
t eac
in
he
den
an
ts
ist n c t ge n
lc w s
h n c ;1\
o T1 c
hospi tal :
t t 1c
hm
Bo
de r H
hc a l ch
c are
Ll e r
c t
wi uc. l t i onal
e n \ 1r o n n l c n
a n i
; f
S: T\ e e l
1i 1 Tt
i c
lx
\ m
pro
\ e
M e d i c t Bl
b el de
t i
P S 10
2 5 : 11 2 ] 15 2 0 0 3
tc ac
h 1n g
a n i
v o u
Le
ina l
t n st t r
i o
1n
t he f u
tu re
\m
ra
w ar
l t he r a p y
in i t ia l
an
f ( hc
e d i c a l s c ho o l
re
po rts
C r o sby J
F\ 1r n a c c J ,
fo r
u tco m e s
,
lc
a r n tn
e t
a l:
t hc
T h c Sc o t t i sh
m e
dic a l
gr a c
o r tc n
i 1
s Te h 1n g t 1 i t Ar c b r + c a
UK
D
4
u n de e
1t v o 3
L
er B r o &TCmr A F E G 1B 1{
E
u
ro pe
Ed u c a t 1 o n i n
2 0 0 5 A s s o t 1 ) n o r \ 1edca1
d r o t 1n d
k
t e a c h in g w a r
RE c s J : H o w t o d o i t T a e a
2 9 5 4 2 4 4 2 5 19 8 7
B r 1 r i s h <l t I 1 l ] m l
Pe r r y D . I t t e a ( h c s
Rr mc s S F r c e t h D M c c r o r 1e
Ra m
to r
1n : c r
rs
l a n d : a f o u n d a t i o n tf o r
lu a t c in s c o t
M e dic a l
a c t it io n e r s
d r c t l c 9 t 1v c p r
tent an
c o m pe
6 14 3 2 0 0 2
Tr f Bc 1Be r 1 4 13
]:
p at i e
D H ear d s ct a
l
ac km o f c
O
J
r
e
c
l t he
SPe n
l
im e o f t he r o e o
d o(
cn t
c lin ic a l
a l
do c t o
r o l e fo r
0 00
E i 1Bc i l r Bo 1 3 4 : 8 2 0 8 2 6 2
Ra m
G
s in l p s o n J
m J 1n t a t m n g a n
n t \\
e ra
patio n a
d u c a t l o r a
19 8 7
h o s p i t a i s a n d f i 1c n d l
i
n u rs n
o n
o cc u
l s t u d c n Ls
M A : C li n ic a
St a b r o o k
a s i n gl e
l c l im a t e in
n l S
07
t Z 9 S: 10 1
r m e
r n in g
fc s s io n n l le a
d le a n
du
m t he e
i n g: a
tat c
t ie n t
M d i ( t1 l i d
St a n l e j p : St
o
u c t Bt o n
r u ctu r in
1t i e s
pp o rtu n
be
rm
c a l lo n
6m
d jc a 1 s t u de n t s
000
3 4 85 1 8 5 7 2
le a
n ds fo r
w a r d r o u
c r e at e
d A Jt t l t c a l E t 11
in
ca n
a t 1o n
gs
3 1: 4 2 5 4 2 9 19
K S e t a l Te a c he
k n \ I B A la m
w c n n c h M D Ja c s o
t he
f b e ds i d e t e a c h i n g o n
l c a m c r s Th c e f t c c t o
m
e
m
c
h rs
k 1l 1) : c l 1n 1c \ J n t e a c e
c l 1n 1 c l \ 1 s
1
0
1
2
f t 1t c 1 l t Sb 4 6 8 52
r s as
C ha p t e r
lat
l 1u
o r
c ar e
In
du
tro
c t io n
O.
t he
a s
'
'
e 1e ' " 0
d h c a ll hc a
e n ts a :te .
. Tt e
"
npa
e x e rt in
t c
y p l. c e
1n c , t 1, e s .
a"
,e
..
lw
, o
"
'
h a ll
gc Fo r
to
d. y
Di c . 1
s m .
l i . i . I f a c , l i t i c s fo , t c " h , n g p u r p o s c \
A d , a . c e s i n m e d , c , I t r . . Tm u n t a n d c h a . i n
G g pat
t e m s o r h e a l t h c a r e d c h. c q h . . . I c d 1 o a 1110 1 o t o w , d s
a. d cm n '" u n
, . c r c a s e d a m b u t . To r v
y c . r c Co . sc
i
h
l
t
T
n
e
c
\
s
a
c
J
.
.
c
.
\
sc m t hc t y p e o c l i . . Ca l p . . b
q
I c m s bc : . g . m . . n t c " h , n g h . p , t a l - . Rd s T }, c s c
l c n at cl y ' ' " c l l " dcr go1ng ' " t c n s c
pa t ' " n t s ' ' "
p, u
li m
. . L c
fo r
hi n g
. . u r so , a n u m
se n t
a . Ar i= t
es m
Hi c h
..
b.
. Rc
am
Iy
F
"
fr . q"
"
f s pe c ia lt i e s
s t a f f r o "
"
r ie t y
u lt i p . f . Io n . [ c l i n i c s w h e r e
f d i s c : p l : . c . c c p ' " . Ts t o g e t h . r c g A n o . c o l o gy
c l" "
. h , c h m . y 1. c l . d . S. r g e n r . Di . T h . Ra p y a . d
m , 1, " I . n c o l o w
ca r e c
or
, n' " t . z ' " n ' " m c n t
r c p ' " ' " ' " g c o . diu . . s
. h, c h . J ! b e t o o a d . a . c c d o r t o o ' ' "
, a l fo r w u dc n t
]c 3 , n . . ' " ' ' " ' ' " S
+ . c a r . " h . . s n o w h " "
Io o k t o d i f f . r . . t
.
' " u c s
t o j i . d . De q u a l e n u m b e r s . f p a t " " \ . . T h
m l c a ] p , o b1c m s . r t . l , l . Fo ' ' " l . w a d .
apF o pn a . c
'"
Se c t i o n 2
Lea r n i n g s i tu a t i o n
c ar e t e ac
1. Tl . . t . " Hi . g I" " i t . j . :

1a t . Ry c ' " ' " u . s a r " p r ,
u s M . : t cac , i ng
! bc ,n g
D en
n e \ dv r e s o u r c e s
bu l a t o r y
am
pa
ad.
I d e n t .f y i n g
A . b . Ra t o r ) c a
hin g
e ac
: ' " ' " . s P' '

a ls, c
B.
p
he r
d. .
lt .
d , O]
t ot
' ' "

.
c 1. .
t he h o s p , t a \
M . Op p ' " ' " l , S
vcn . cs m
a.
cal ,n '
,"
" t ' " at 1o'
. 1m
' "
fo r r
. . d, Ul o
\o n .
m .
y be
i l a bl e t o
' ' "
s. rt e
S. "
1. I Ci m.
. "
d , d b y O i h . . H. . l i h c a r c p , o f e ss i
o t h . py - p a t i . u \ t he r a p y
"
g p hy n
En
dosc o p
su i t e
em , e n t o
rc m
NCr w
ass ess ' " t
gi ca l
e s t in g
sm
h : . g , m t ' " , c s 1n
D.
t e n u e s (B a , d a t b
200 5 D . n t c t a l 2 UR] J
a ' ' " . t
t ca .
U m B.
d"
"
M l.
n n t , 1b t . .
IJ .
' "
"
I).
. t
'
t tx n
.H
. !
11n , l
t
' ' "
' "
20 1 I
n t
'
Jj
'
. .w
..
'
1 F
Tl , \ ?
"
l n 1. I Vt
to
n o1
blu
in
t w
.
iH HHHM m >v
.
/ I..
g e' "
. i Hr . '
' "
'
"
J 1 p ' " ' " c . b n 1, r r
'
'"
a ' "
"
" "
'
IF
'
"
"
"
pro
a m m c
in it is
Wh
J J
\ n c "
"
"
. "
' "
1"
'
'"
\ ) l ' lh
' "
H H t 1> .
1r
l i n i , n l . Ki l l ,
l ni ,
"
a\
1e.
wn
t \ n \e n t
t ng
t 1 >l l l 1110n , g1 t nr c n t
j
l>
nn
s ct i n
I r n in
gs
r n e
i t h i n pat ie n t s in
b
\n v c st
'
i ga t i o
n s
h a n dlin g
in fo
n n a t 1o n
am
bu lat o r y
ln
is p a r t
s e t t in
car e
ho w
gs
in
c o n t n u t 1m
he
e ve r
h e r H C P s a n d c o n 1T n u n i t y s u p p o
& G l s s c r 19 9 3 )
A m b u l a t o r y c a r e l carni ng c a n
o p p o r t u n it ie s fo r s t u de n t s t o ga in
tin
co n
o n t ex t
of
ca r
es ou r c e
patie
'
l oc
al
t r
fo
cx
he ir
ro
(S t e a r n s
t s e r v ic e s
t <1c r c
in c lu d e
re
p c r ic n c c
in
id e
e c
r e
J-
Fp
c x a rn
e s
in
t io
De
s ig n
for
lv e l ip
gJ
3 l j
e n L
Rc l e o 3 e d i c a e d
m b a c o C a (
c n t r e > CTCJ
1
a mt o F
1o
o a
j e
o \
c t
r c
}i n
to
St u r e
: a c 1h t
ca r e
a lr e J
dy
h Jr
W J
B1 l n
T he A CT C
}1o
n e e
s 1o n
rt
a n
d po
\ s Bb
de+nunr at e ?a
r o u
t in
o u
t> n
)d }BJ
h p a t wn t u r
d e d f o r < r n a l l g1 o
v
u 1g
c a n
su
pe
"
av
ai l a
n ot
es
t u
&u
b r Ct
r e v is o
n
toget
ide s
ro v
u se
ful b
ac
c Jr
tv
m c n
c u
C0
a
a n
:4
3 c 1
ts
a
e s
= z
5.
3e
Su
d p
tr 3
a c c o m m o Ga ! o 1
J e
M c
n e e
t +e e
&
C T c
a n
c Jm
c o n s
s tc
r e
a T
CC
> cm
e n
a n
t r
lh
s a s t C
3
c t t T
W i t
ls
u t '
t\ a
\e
[
\ \
t:
? 1 ,
\ n
11
<:
'
d \ . \ \ e LL1 \ t '
B ! 1t
\) \
Pr
\
1 1\
\ 4 Bi t
l duBBt {
a l l t \ } t 1> \
1u
\ t
il i r
h Br
B.
l t Bt l Bv
l1
>
m
l\
l \ 1 Bl
At
W Bw
t y
\ lw
\ A e
t \n
Yv
\t \L
i L Bt l \ \ \ l l
l\
1h l t \
I\ i n #
\
\\
l )t
r go
t t ) u \l \ c
u m x
lt n s
be
Bi n
a n
e n
c m
at nbu
w
atd
pportuni ty
l
W i t \ t h e \1
chHXl
ing
M
U
h
i
u
d
t
n
s
J
e
p
KO
w \ 1\ e n t h
hc l p s M u d c n t 7
n
w
v u H y N m n
w
m
o a u w x d mn w r v uw w u r cxJwnnHut i mn bkuhk Hnr ee: Hnnn LunuLn\ \ \ \ mwnmn Nm
l A\ +1ULr o r g J nn s vy M t r n h SWw
a
te c
C[ +1bar r asbmcnt o r t \ n 1c c o n s t r a i n t s
i p p r L i a t c d
t h e d l d i c i\ t e t l a n d h \ n t c t u r e d
t tB
C l l n i c i a n \ w i t h a n i n t c r e s t 1n t t B1chi ng c a n h a s k e d
t i m t i n a l e a r n t Tr l r i > n d l y l 1 v i r o n m c n t (L a
m t , r k e s p t L i a l t t a = 1i n g s e b a i L m s i n t h e A C C
i
[
0
o
c
2
1
1
n
)
,
n w
"
in
h e r l 1> a l t l t \ 1B ( B , \ l l r d w \ r t \ \
l Bt l l l l
a \ rw l h n l P A l i n l \ A BW
c l Bn i t
t l 1 1\ prut >Lt t t l B l l \ 1t \ } \
t u 1c >l > mn h n h Bh > t H p n n u w
ly u r
t l c r lu r
lt w n t
E !o
s J
p B
ro \
t ti n
q t 1i r e d
fo
1n
1r =
l ? j t j } a ) ( a n 1 \ e * t u r l t \ t }w
1
w t t l p r B rt lr n l \
o p p o r t u n i t y t u r n e t $ / L [ t e d p a \ B> r r t
r
d
f
l
w t t l l n m r t Bb l e d
J
e a r 1l 1i :
r e . c v a n t t o t } Be ) r s t a :
\ B 1 1>
t l B1Br \ w 1n Bi
a r >
v l 1{
r : o t a t t B>
c lm ica l t u t o r
r e
t ,
& A
a c
d p r o a mme
i 1l a t o ) p J t e f i L <
n
A n A C T C (D t f J t e t
am
d i o g r a p hs o
c a n bc m a de
r a
sat i onL\
pr
k ills
e s
a e
a
ad dlu
hn iq u
1 A1: OA' a c
1n
r a
r t s
tec
Tw
k
-
du
c e
po
Z 1n l c g
f - t i nc
r e so u r c e
h e a \t h c a r c
t o
r a to r
t 1o n
f-
ttend
be m ad
s u p p le rn c n t a r y r e s o u r c e s c a n
e
m m a r ie s o F c as
h
s
u
s
a
c
c
u
s
c
A
e
in t hc
d t o a t t e n d f r o m t ht
a t ie n t s i n v i t e
t he
p r a c t i c a l l Y a ll l ear ni ng o u t c o r 11 e s c a n b e e x p e r i e n c e d
18
i n a m b u l a t o q c a r e t e a c h i n g v e n u e s (s e c C h a p t e r
i
d
O u t c o m F b r se d e u c ] t o n )
i s m o r e l ik e ly t o
v e n u e
f f i m 11y t h e a m b u l a t o r
r ov
i
1h a
tet
1(
l
a
v
a 1 a bl e
fr o m b a s le s c ie n c e s
i
f or p r a c t r s i ng s k l l s p
i t h e q u i pme n t
r o c ed h
t
s
d
u pp B y of
e
i
r
p
a
c
o
s
t
o
l
no
h
r
.
a
p
c
y
s o h
c or d
uc h
i
bl lit y
h
d pro
an
ho
t u to r s w
re n t
ac
n a t io n
g diffe
tate am o
L a bo
a t i on
to
a re
ppro
ts
c ar e
p 1J n
e s
h o l is t i c
it y
p a t ic
tn u n age m c n
o t
f p a t ie n t s i n v it e d
w i t h t hc h e l p o
Ba n k o f p a t i e n t v o l u r 1 t e e r s
D9
'
rl
tht r
1d L n
lht
t 1u
St if
t\ t L h rr 1J
l \ t l c 1\ \ o n o f
\ t ro n
L r
t \ Jf
L d
\ (
pp
:O P m
l \
) ] l
l r l t bl n
th u
L n
b u l T1u r
y
lm
Ta b le 1 2 1
Th e E P IT O M I S E
a c ro n ym he l s
p
s tu de n ts
t o l o o k 1o r a l l l
e a r n i n g o u tc o m e a In
a n y p a t ie
n t e n c o u t
n
s r t u ("
9\ n c l
1dr mng
lin i c a l c o r l t a
(G h l C 2 0 0 0
w ar
ds
cal
p r o bl e
\s
ho
m s w
c are
a n r b u la t o n
]
n u n
l
o p :
c li n i c a
rc
r n t o v a
hh
t lv w e
ll
t iv c
Ho s p i t a l
hn i
s t u de n t s
; o in n l o n c
o
st c
fo
tt te s
ri
In
dge
Ae b
)i n
cl n
m 3
s IA T
st u
de
Ln
i ca
Of
tm m
r e a
1 ca
c l
l ye
e x
pe
o re
n t s ( a n
a rs
Js a
Jl
e t
d n
n 1c n t
In
tat \
r n
No n e
w arn
<t u
p la c c
p p r o pr
h e n lc
he
r Be n c t
hc
ppr
ha\
\n
ro u t m e
b L
t l\
> n
c \
dAn
to
he lp
an
t ex
r u c t u r > c
ear
A
st r u ct u r e
l car mn p p
a r n b u Lnor
a r
fj
t&
c n
dt
in R
r n
u l 1
f )
c( n
tx
( 1d A
}1
r t t 1ni t l t
v
t lw
$ \ J )
n m
) t
I 1b l t
1u r t
r nt
AB
t t t t \ t t rt \
Hl
>
1i \
hu M
to
h hn
c lm ic a
f the p a ti e n t
a n
d yo
lf
u rs e
t t
he
ir
t
o
n m ar
hc l r c lin
d 1c t u t o r
r o
1c a
r ev
le
e x
je \
s o n
ho
pe
e
\n
o n \ u
cJ
n d
J
ld b e
n e n c e s
e n
t o p
t he
T he s e
in
n u m
t .J t
n n n c
\o n
L\
i th
he
at t e n
din g
sta
p M WW
n c w
ra
d \ <w
phs
it h
he
J m u n
h w
A tm m U V n
L Lu u A M 1 h m
an t
{ 1 t j
r >: i n m
l r>
1t 1t 1 r 1 \
Bi
J 1
ht l l B
h w
Ct u t t nhnt har n1nBo
>
n
Jl 2
Hn h
h
U H HW
l n e d t o t he v J r m u a t w n h m v n H n h
p
t he y l W = T s t \ 1t l n t \ a r r r l t I t r t L \ l t
L
: v
\ e
B
h a t t l t t l yo \ t s 1 '
re
hh B h
ta L hL 1w
m
h > e n Ud J
HVH
>
r n
t \u n \
H 1n H h
Hw
H t
w
t
n w M
M
t hc
Nn n mw n
Br l 1
L\ \ n
Sc o m
pt t n
l b l n
m e n
lt i d i s c ip l i n a r t e a m
y
m u
a n
fl e c t o n
fo r p n
re
"
It
lt s
l 1e
a l\\
ts
FD
1L 1p - t e
nt c n h
u l \
r l l 1\ 1 11 111 1 118
bu
n c n c e
de n
st u
: r \ \e w
+p r
l Ju d g e
o f p r e s Br n b o j t 1 s k s t o
b e car ned o u t
h u b t o n ; t t l ng c a n t *
w
e
n
t o st u de n t s
g
J \ 1n \ l u d e
rn
b l 1l
c tm ic a
1n \
200u
l l
re s u
ha n d li n g
ba s ic
o
n s o
re s
s rs
a n
te r p r e t a t i o
in
A ] B\ t
n u (
lA a
Bb
P4 r t
Si
m en
d u ca tio n
d p r o \ r de a fg a n d fe e d ba c k
n l n r c
1r \ 1 1
11
st u
1n
li m
e r c
e x t e T s tv
a n 1
t \ eF da)
dc p z r
p Jt t e n c
k i lls )
t he n d o c u m e n t t h i
e r e x pc n c n ce s u n de r e ac h
le a r n i n g o u t c o m e
p o 1n t a n d r e f l e c t o n w h a t f u r t h e r
l( a r n t n g n e e d s t h
e y c a n
n o w 1d e n t i f / a n d h o w
t he y
w rll a d dr e s s t h
e se le a r n i n
d
n
D
g e e s ( m t & D a \ s 1 9 9 5i
(T i bl e 12 1 a n d F i g 12 I )
L o g bo o k s m a a l s o be
u se d t o a s t h e r a n ge o f
y
c l m i c a l c o n d it
io n s
w e n
an d
i de n t i f
i
o
s i
s
s an
f d ]a gn o
s c ie n c e s
e
T ht y
u n
Fr a 1S1 f 1 \ L i t h s u n u l a t c d p a t l t n t s a n d m
c h n 1c a l s . l l s c e n t r e a n d
1n t h t
t x po su r e t o
at i C r t S m 1 h t b u
t n \ 1 r o n mc n t o f a n
be m
b rb
ge
l o n s
m u n ic a
ct1
v i d c r Tn
g t o l s \ 1l t a b l e
d t r gr a d u a t c
a t a ll s t a
gt s
L e s s c x p t m necci s t L1 d e t
o f le J m n g
n s w hu a
r c st il l
d e \ e l o F m g 1 h e t r c o m m u m c a t 1o n a n d e x a m 1n a
t \o n
p TJ L u s c t h e s e m t h t d e c a t t d t c a h
/ k r ll s c a n
c
1n g
f t h e A C T C h h +c h r o v d
e n \ 1 r BJ n m e n 1 o
l c s a
b
p
c a n
i n fo r m a ti o n
l 19 8 4 )
t a
c n
t t n
f rtT
tu
pau
B'
ar c su
c a r l'
t(
a r de
ongr h a v e
n o
n m
pt i o n s
m an a
Ea r l y
r i c u la
l Bo n
te c hn t c a l r o c e d
p
u
(c o m
e x a m i n a l Bo n
in v e s t l a
g
er
d T qu i ry
s an
y s rc a l
l rr \ t
w h t n s h L ) U 1 a m 1 u \a t o > y
hc p r o v id u >
w a c hi n g
th i c
bl 1f l
h i n (]
\(
c> ( 1n
1n
l lc
.s
h to tL
ru Y
r n t
U rl n \ (
'
tw r
an
it
c F
u c J gu
c s
hwmng Of Bu m r r
h Si n N a h u s i n g
m n i t h c OU& Hwn t d w a r t
n m
h n k H n v e wg n m n a n d p r c o p c r M i v c
h
t hc d .y
hu r gc r y u n H
a n d BF u m
u p
uh S N n t Zm w
w
h 1 u h
M
w > w
hnh tl h
n n
I I '
IM H
> 1 w m
h at
t hd
h at
yu u
hd y u
S t \ 1\ \ t
w a
m T
qu
n ts
C a \ e \ t o t \u i r l u t t r i n a
he h m M n g S N A WS Wh i c h
a n d a n s \ e t r i p p t o a t t1
pr e se n t
u n
de r
io n
M & 1c t u t \ x
c n w
u r dgw
7
.
h e a tl h
d u s d e r ly in g p r in c ip le s
a nc e
l e a tb tu de s e t h a l s
v l rM a pp r w
l e ga l r e s p o n s b ib es
so e nee s a n
9
10
V{ m a Fpr o p r e
r ea s o n n
Fls
o
1 1
E P lT O r l I S E Jo g b o o k l i n k s
f th e S c o t t 1s h d o c t o r
1- a
r r k
r r ow
a l
}s c
ob
i an
e l ec
ow n
t hc
hc
t h
di
a ub
t or
n a g
] s\ u t
or
n m a kn
g dn*
hn
ic a
ex
pe
ag n o s t s
1 i 1u c
ns l b
pt
Ro
sa
B t + r r L pr c d
- i
w]
C\ r
S.
It
r e c t ed
Pa t i e n
# l.>
l 1r 1t 1a t l \ >
t > v( n t to
( 19 ' " J)
b t Bt l 1 b e f u
.llt l t e
t B\ tl r
r >
( Iw
l tn
h 1l w
Il ld
lt
3
4
1i n
"
u
1c
t N
Rd
1 ]
Y B1
l \ c l \ )l B
a r 111n
i r uunc l t l 1u
'" '
"
"
l 1 1H
h
r
ll n
1 1 hj
r (Ji
n f
t 1i
lL
<
10
1l
m lt> t
il ll
th
: oi m
'
l o
A \
Fr
C
n
s O 1S
E tN
r n R
CU
h>
l 11
1n h t
l I I \ h>
U \ 11w
it h
Il I \
P 1t l t
t il
tl
JBnl 1L1t t r r
or ki ng t l t c r c
n t
ir
It
t l l BL \ t 1 n
to
tw
u L t i v t ic s
o vc r
u n
hc m
1r c e n =
dc r r e s o u
sc ee s
ith
rce
l 1nJ m w
p p I r U Ior a n a d o n A t a a
Att n h sh
:
u u k B he
m a
1n a d v a n c e t o i d c n f/
" '" ' "
'
. a t > L I i n i > i \ B s t a n w h o n l i h t b e a bl e
n ra
:yX
P
a t
1 o
I \ 1l
\\ t
!I
\ 1\
\
L u l l rl
LH u Iu t i n
b e ( n
1'
Os e
t u t l e 1t t \
On
'
es
1?
d b t i met ah t t l
r t h t t1 , t l t m , I J N ( I ) J
u \ w
d > \ ( r
tco m
o u
d n
'
li t
t L) D o -
d J Sn
n t ng
H h
u
sn- nar i es
n t
c ] t hi n k i n g m a
y lx :m
d p o s t c \ c n t dt U/ mn\ w
c t a B 19 9 7 )
b p sky a n d t
c a n t a k e t he
not t s o
c As o
am
' ua r d
H i g h e r [w
a n
R.
Pr r
te
c u r n c u tu m
to th e
a ny ve n u e
1n
n e n c e
hn d 1 ng s
ca l
d
de f o r pe r s o n a l d e v e l o p m e n t a r a
f
bl
e s lo s
r
a
e
n
s
t
a
r
t
m
e
f
r
o
d e r n o n s t r a t i o n o a pF p
dge m e n t
den ts
1 pa n n g
qu t
th
wr
d.
a]
by t o n
e me
stu
ph y s t
an d
t l f cr
ag n o s i s
ma
c
st o r y
pr ec e p
a t 1cn t
he
a n d iu
s e r ik e
a pt l u
An
12
and
tu
p ltt
In
t hc
n c w
tt ac
hi n g
g
ppo r t u n it y
an
C H a i
l d h e b t h t P r c p a w d f o r t he
jo b IL do
t o hc t hc s c m k r c l i n i c i u n i
n t hc
ht T L o
s l 1a w
1 IL d a y
he y
do c t
t h t ht i n
\ \i
de n t s
ho
r o
pat 1t ' nt car c
g r a rn
ll l t
''
On
"
a s
J u n io
a t
g s s o n
ho
r t
n o
a s to n a
lc .
hc
su
d d e n lv
\t c
)u
ke
l i n ic a l t e a c hi n
g
st a i r c a n b
c he l e d t
o
p
ha v i n g 1hc o
p p o r t u n \t
t o t a
n 1o r
Uf g h e
cT
tc ac
tr
lt h c
Ol <t t >s
Li r y
prJ
c up
1t
>
b! s r j t B ,
D
a c
ki n
t o
t h
t h r
J ]
ap
he
J m
xj
in
r ia
pn
J n
t n 1 \a t o F
r c sc t
l)
J v u
Ro u hn e p a hc
Ju
L\
e\
r n
le
ctu
\ 1
l 1> t A
LBh l >
t tbt r J
Br
ll\
ar11pl
u n
r> n n
I I\irn
tw
r t'
v a
lu e
Bn
"
e c
li n i c a l
i a l is t
ro
he r e
t o
n ( s a n
ble
m s
i tl b e
c o n se n t
c a n
st u
t his
to
de n
c
t s
l in ic
te
m o
hist o
de l
p a t ie
s e
tr ea tm
bl e
st a
t s
a r e
ln
e n t
li n ic a l
si
n o t
gn
ho
s w
ly
base d
c u rr e n t
sy st e m
ex
pe
n e n c e s e n c o A1
n t s
pprH
\m
mo
r e
c t r\
<e
.
'
F er t u t o nn
U&m\ ( Xl p r a c t c( c
1 11\ nJ t 1 L\ n
\
1 v n 1 Br
\ t l l L +r
tu
\
t
ur
nu d
h 1\
en t
se m
h es e
s.
in
o n s
se s s i on s
d p h!
mmp l t 1 . I[ n , s c t c p
r L d u r m.
Lt \ n t 1 h n \ t t h a t t J \
R Gt he r o le o f t u t o
J n
\n
t o r
a n
LI
t hc t r \ \
carni ng I se c
h . pt
er
16
n 1r
n n 1
H H
I N
t V H H
Pr i nhnwnhcnnpwhn t unnni ay t a k e
hl l ewnt
h nh
n c
o u
t p a t ie n t
r t
hn ic
Un s c l ewd p a t C
\ t ll tle
1\
e nt
\ u
at c
he r e
\ d ' c t t n\ 1 l u \
a c t iv e
e n
h e AL -
n n
tt)r
d t hc
a n
d le a r n
an
t i r lg
wn u e }
1UWWCr
l;t \
r t J r 1t
Hh n A HHJ
pn
l 2 0 0 1a ) T h e
M 1m
c -
L) tt
/
e se n
be i n \ 1 t c d a t t h e a
p p r o p r 1a t e i l m e I n t h i s m o d e l
he p a t ie n t s c o n t n b
u t 1o n c a n m o r e r
e a d i ly b e f _
e d
o n st u de n t t
e a m in
g n e e d s T h c t u t o r s ho u l d b e a
t o Pr c J r e t he S
e s s i o n fo r m m
p
n m l t d u n t 1o r u l
a d\
t a ge m a d \ a n c e a d
n
s ho u l d h e l
p s u d e n t s t o i n t e gr a t e
t he c hn t c a \ c x e n
c n c e t o l
r
t e r i p :l
t t at ht ng pr Lr J1n1t i 1
1\ t
t et
d e rgo
J\ t
p pr
ho u lcl b c a s k d
bc [ o r e a t t e n d i
n t
h appro
L. I
, l
f h c 0e n t \
pr
<t s
ap
ts
c an
s s i o n a ls
1n t
l T he
y
(D e n
Lt tt l u n r s
t 1 n
B l
hJ r o p \
rr
de n
M B
. . . .
'
u n
> t l r 1a m
pH
at
\v 5r
bu
o n t n
pr o fe
a re
d by
tc
B a n k a t ie n t
s
p
ll y
h l n g k l ll s b y
d
y
d
t
o
o
c a c h 1n g s e s s r o n s
c
h
c
n
c
: 1
g
g 1v e n b y a s c n 1o r
b n r %n g m a t c r 1a l c a n b c
t u t o r Pr e p r r a t o n
u se d t ffe c
h
l
u > e l! t o lw p t e m t o l e a r n m o r e a b o u t m e d i c a l
e du
L t 1 o n a n i t o 0 n t r n t a t > l h e m t o t h e t c a c h 1n
g r o l e (s e e
o p m c n t s e c t i o n 1n t h i s c h a t
S T d e \ e
p c r)
e\ c
tn
it
ar r angcmt
w it
hJ n han
u su a
ta ff
r s
Ra t h e r
stu
he m
hc
s n
1n
h c +p
t o
t i l iz
Pa t i e n t s
'
b ic
m ay
ts
S e le c t e d
p a t ie n t s
ks w h (
lo y t hc st im u lu s o f h
av in
g
t h c i : w o r k la c
e p r o v Bd c d
p
t ha t
o TS
e n ic n
tu to r t
o
lO C .
, w
q u ir
re
a n
c as e
n 1o s t
t in (
r o u
hl n g
h in g d e p e n d s
C o lle a g u e
st u
tc J
chc l r
w . .
devcl t }p1n a
ln
lt n i c a l
o u t
L l r
e sn
a rc a w
lJ b( l c
hu
e 11 t
A m b u la t o
t1
ho w
w il y
nn
u r
m i By
ng
n
he
an r
11 1,1t \
I1
h u la
t he
n u n dw
l t Th l t
\ he
our wd
I LM
rt
l a t i\ e ly
H v
w n
I [ T W
Tt r L
t he nunhc r N
R
e x
p r i ene
t
ru o n u
\\
h=
a k > a n a U v c a p p r m L h t o hm n n E
m n Mn n g v u i n a h n i c = a n b c a
'
Hi l l d v a r i e t y
r a \g h t l o n v a n \ e \ P \ T \ e n \ e
o n r
\t
n t 1n \ b c r
yo
l
w
e n
e* g
tu d e
e s
t s In
rw w F
1#
l <a
1 A
J u n Bo
s tu
Sin g le
s tu
de n t
de n ts
S l Bh n g
n ts
yo
co n su
Fr e q u
de l
d e ls
m o
d d e p e n d in g
u se
he
o n
de n
t s
de t
m o
h in g is m u c h a p p r e c i a t e d by s t u de n t s
h o ( a n o b s c r t t h c p a t r e n t c o n s u l Aa t r o n a n d m c e r a c t
c o n fi d c n t h w 1t h t h e c l 1n 1c 1a n a n d
p a t l c n t s bu t t h e y
%a . t 1 h c c . u n c t t o s e c p a t t i n t s ] n d c p e n d
m a y n o t
ent i c s s c o n Dd e n t s t u d e n t m a > f c e l vui nt r abl c I n
t h 1s s e t u n g a n d m a y n e c
e n c o u ra e m e n t to
a r t rc 1
te ; m ore
o r e
t c n
Bn t 1m
pr r v
h i pl p a
W it
p5tl(
Ab
t Bn
se n i o r
to
>
a (1 l \ >
r s
c o n su
t u
to
tw
t l
pr
n c
( 1J
Bt
l 1u
t
to
pa e
w n
m r
in
N c
dlL J j
1c
fu
to
ca n
t rn
d(
m o re
stu
c ro w
n ts a rc
bs e r v e
to o
p t 1n g
d e n t s w i t h y o u in
d i f fi c u l t t o o r g a m
a n
d e d i n t o t hc c o n s u lt in g
d h e a r t h e c o n s u lt a t i o n
a n d c li n i c ia n i s l i m it e d
h bo t h p a t i e n t
m a y fe c i t h r t a t c
it
dc
t u
lo
de
n t \
o
n t,
n (
pJ
u n d e r
su
m J v
de n
he
ts
ko
c n [s
St u d e n t s
c o n su
pa
irs
ar t s
in
lt a t
Ln e n
re
m o
sit
in
to n
ta
a c e
n c
ke
he
de l
t
w i
h t hc
p a t 1c
he p a
t
i n
l 1n i u
o r
a n
a n
T he y
tien ts to
1e w
ter
t he
a n o t
he
o
n
1n
e a w ho le
d m d 1 1a ll y o r
ro o m
1n a t t o n
ex a m
bse n
t o
ga i n
i Fl g 1 2 2 1
t 1t n t
In t > r
m w
o
u t
t Jt o r
1 \
r 1 k
JI o J1J \
pe
it l
t 1 l r 1 1B
\ 1n
r \ 1> \ \
1 rl J d
) 1\
1\
llt
1,
bu
a n t
1\ t t
i rl
.\J t
fe e l
Rt i : i r l l
11t 1\
t rl
to
n
tio n
r r 1 1\
b > t , 1r t
t nr 1: , t r J1n t
BBt
de l
bl e
51
52
r
,
\t n t
1 J 1l l 1i 1
( l v J B\ 1 l ( l l l t , t 1 1 15 )
n
Z
a
O
(
) l BJ t 1t B: < t l 1 1 l t l r t 1 \ t ! 1l l
t
r l ) t i n 1 r r J \ B t l \ \ l t > n r 1r 1 J l ( l 1
1
,
r i
t 1 t l t r \ 1Bl ,
+t u t t T l l \
Bt
A n
t he r
l> l
hn n
Nm n
n u
> m
n t H
1m
h t ll
ha w
p a t wn t
] t t t 1d l H
H
ht
t he n
hw
4 ll m
n
t
F lg
md o
de l
m o
tu
be
n ct io n
n m o
th e
A r t cl
d { Tl
m o
v 1e w
}l
to
xw
d
1n
t p t n dc n t l
y
a t
t t 1d c
u r
P J t wn t
II = J A: 1 ) >
t l r rrl
Re p o r t ba c k
t l
t u t l Jr \
W a lt r
\ u
b Be
lt a t i o
c o ns u
w u
e i t hc
12 0 1) 2 1 dt \ \
ul l o J>Jr mr \
t t 1e
f o r c ( s J( J r m n = S u r r 1> s t u d > n t \
Bd z t e d l A h n Pt T ur r m
n u n d r r n bv 1\
p J r a t e r o o r n 1 J \ u r b b l t t r > \ t 1 l l I n t l
. n Jt
m ay
ll e l
ra
AOlj t a:U(-s
d
ts
r c n
m l n ("
r mo l \ [
m s
hJ Ch
\ \
51 0 1
trc e
ll n u m o f
t h e p a t 1r n
v
m a
rn
de n
st u
t he
1J d
f 9U
A pp r e
se n io r
r \o
/ n ) Umb r \
C l
th lh(
u r
rr , '
l/
Fa
Jf
J h
go
d b y t h c l a r ge
au
r a c t i o n w i t h t hc p a t i e n t m a y
t
i
e
n
s
a
n
l
c
l
m
h
T
e
t
c
e n ce
T h c u 5 c o f a s t u d y g u i d e o r l o g bo o k
a l s o b 4 i n h l b 1[ A d
d e n t 1c a m t n g m a y b e h e l p f u l f o r
d
n
e
t o d i r e c t 1n e p
d pau
t ly
t io n
B re
to -o n e te ac
n e
e n
tt
stu
in
l i n ic
In t e r a c
c r 1( n c e
S it t l n g
O
ca n
hu
l a rg e r g r o u p
r o o H1 a
a n
in g
G ra n ds ta n d
ns
B re a k o u t
m o
ro u ll n c
\l a l i o
the b o u t o n fo
iry
1o
r a i d
r \ 9 lp
lld b o l o
+ v
TL
u r
ut l
'
a rc
ll
u r /J
Ha
Re p o r t b a c k
m ode l
de l
to
to
n s
s t u d e n ts
m o
lt
sta
c lin ic
t i c e s h ip /
D o rf < b
p a r a Ere l
c o n s u lta h o
de l
m o
ve ra
A ppre
de l
m o
se
tu de
1n
B r e a ko
n io r
Se
dc pf n d n o
b ' c fo r y o u
c l 1n 1L
t p a t t o n t c l 1n l c s
o u
1c
12 2 B r t
pu n
ko
B1
d t t n l ty a f t e
u
r
<m
t he
de l
s t u {j c n t s s e e
c o n su
ll a l lo
p a ti e n t s
9o
at
o\ er
he
C H A R T
IE R
i g
c r J
se \
bc
a v a
are
r LT O N 1 S
i la b lt
he
d\
tu
n t s
m a
c reate
he
lin
lc
ia n
c an
9o
to
de n t s r e p o r t o n
T h e s t t 1 d e r 1 t s 1a v e l i m
tu
he J r t h c s
12 3 )
be n e
an ce
e ac
he i r i n t c n l c w
e an d s ace t
p
o
t
n t
a t
t he i r
l f e e d ba c k o n
Pa t ie
iv i d u
[it f r o m i n d
(Fi g 12 4 )
in
r o o m
o w n
tu rn
(s c c
d by
t a ki n
: +xB =-
b.
u m e
vera
ll
t h'
' "
i de o
pr
b . Bl y
pa c e
hc i ,
a n
c=
r es ' " s
sA
able
Ur e = n
an
to
e e r
ca n
l c boo)
z\ z
C li n ic a l
5 1J p
d b y ha w
t
he
c n u
t u t or
qu e
an
po
rte
d by
d d i t 1o
g
T he
tu to r
n a
ppo
am i
p r o gr a m
st u
l le a m
r t t 1n l t
fcv d ba c k
di
ln
fu
i n v e st
ig a t
v r : (j
fo
1 K )X b
li n i c a l
a c t 1L1 t i e s w
a s w s sm e n t
he
im a
sc o
p 1s t s
tn t c r
i o n s cu l t e s
n l e asu re m e n t
hch
a n
L I TI
l de
an d c o n se n t b
y
gi n g p r o
m a y 1n c u
c t s s i t se
lf
(e i t h e r c l i n i c i a n s
re t at i o n
r r a
v ascu
o r t e
\ &
o r
po r t i n g
prc m
e dic a l
r a
e n
o t
s e s s 1o n
\ L1
n u r sr n
n u -
r a
fo r
e w
in t e m
d i o gr a p h e r s
o r e n
g sta
a n
dc
a n
d 1o +-
o r
he r s w a l 1s t s A dd 1t t o n a l r e s o u r c e s w h i c h m i h t b e
g
a v a l &b lc t o h e l
p s t u d e n t s t o i n t e gr a t e t h e i r l e g
a r o u n d t he s e c fl o \ e
m i g h t i n e tu d e c a s e h i s t o D e s
t
=an
/
/
c r t _
cr
br
<
51 5 2
P r P2
p Bb en *s
s en
m ,
d i o lo g y e n d o s c o p )
la r a s s e s s m e n t c a n be
u s e d if s t u de t
n s a r c dir e c t e d t o t h
c p a r t ic u la r l e a r n i n g
o u tc o m es
a v a i l a bl e m
e a c h a n d i f s t a ff a r e a b l e t o
sp e n d s o m e
t i m e t e a c htn
g s t u d e n t s c a n f o ll o w a
s t r u c t u r e d lo b
g o ok an d in ter ac t w i t h a
ati e n t in
c
l n
pr
ex
c a n be p r o n de d bv i n w t e d
p a t ie n ts
T s f a m 1h a r m t h t h e l e a r n i n g o u t c o m e s
u m t h c o b )e c t 1v e s o f t h e t e a c hi n g
n e e d s a n d e x p e c t e d le v e l o f p e r fo r m
le =m
L
"
o r
u (
S t
: m
d f.
p r f on
en t
- l
Fig
the
de n t s
a s st u
"
. .
m t c r v ic w
an n
'
..
car t
d
o u p o f p a t ie n t s \ s t n v t c d t o t h
c c v t n t
A sc le c t e g r
h
u
l
o
t
gh d c a l t n g m t h r e a l p a t i t n t p r o b le m s i s
h a
w hic
d 1n a d \ u n c c a s b t i n g o t \ 1s c d o n s t u d
o u n ce
St r u c t u r e d e J m
a i c l m i c a +m T o
d in g s
re co r
xx.
,
I N A ( I I N I(
L : V t
le-
b t 1l a t o r y
de l
m o
n
s l J e r v s
by
s
C
,
01
'
P1
/
52
(p t i
82
Fl g 12 3
Su p e ry l s 1n g
COn s u l
ta ti o n
j l . n <Je r
rn o
d e B; i t L I
t j upBryt srt Jn
n t5
pr a c ls o
H- =# *
'
10 0
SCT i o N
d jJ gr a m
m o
d e ts
Learn ng s i t t Be t o l u
m an a
p r o c e du
m e n t
ge
an ato m
res,
r ) J' \ ( ; N )\ : IC A
I N A I I ( r ] OAl
I 4 1 A l Y I ( \ J : ( [ : 1 ) . (
ic a l
lc c t i o n s o F r a d io r a h s
g p
S t L1d c n As s h o L 1l d l
k
a s o be
p r o +n p t c b y t h e i r l o g b o o
t o in t e r a te
t h e i r l carni ng b
g
l
i
a
r
a
e
f
t
y rc cru n ec to m
e x pc rc n c e d
c 1s c w h e r e
h
by d i r e c t i o n s l o o t e r
o r
r c v
js c
o r c o
In
gio
re
s o rn c
p i t a s b a v c
a n
l i n i c a l s ki l ls
f t hc U K c o m m
r e d e v e lo p e d a s
n s o
t rc ot m
t n
u m
be e n
t y sit u
d ho k
tr
g i o n a l d l a gn o s
re
(R D T C s J
t c e n t re s
I n t he
se
f a c l il t l e
t it
1 a
b u l a t o r y ba s is T h e s e c e n t r e s c a n p r o v i d e s t u d e n t
s
i t ie s t o e x p e D e n e c o u t p a t i e
w i t h [d e a ] o p p o r t u n
n t
c
+n i c a l i n v e s t i g a t i o n s a n d d a y c a s e t h
su lt a t io n s c
er a
py
fo u r W c c k s t
r u c t u r e d c lin ic a l
a n d s u r ge r y A
at t a
r o v i d e n e \ e le a r n i n
m i n t i n t hc R D T C c a n p
g
opp
la t o r y a n d c o m m u n i t c
b
d
u
n
a
l
o
n
f
u
s
(
o
i
i
c
s
tu n t c
y a re
( D c n t c t a l 2 0 0 7 ) T h ( s e e x p e r Be n c e s c a n b e e n ha n c e d
by s u b s e q u e n t p la c e m e n t s w i t h a l o c a l ge n e r a l
am
I N 1 111 l
A l t ho
'
gh
\\
l :: \ l l \
l '\ l [
ly
cu rre n t
de r
i liz e d
(Se a b r o o k e t a l
] 9 9 8) a t t ] c hm
\ n t s t o day sU r e r
g y u n i t s (D SU s ) c a n
P r o > i d c o p p o r t \ 1m t i c s f o r s t m c t u r c d t a i
c c 1 n g f o ilo w
in g t hc
p a l . 1e n t i our ney ( H a n n n h & D e n t 2 0 0 6 )
u n
tec
m u
hn iq u e a n d
&+opc r at i v c c a r e c a n b c p r o v i d e d i n a
hj p r o fe s s i o n a 1 c n \ 1 r o n m
A s t h c n t l m be r o f
c rlt
u su a . ry o
a t e a c
Va
tl \ es
(H a n n a h
r o o
c o m
n o t 1s
ro
& D
200 6
r o -
TWCl . e
F
n t o
l 1g g s )
t a
fo
ps
in
gr
dm
0 D
n sc o
ll
y b e tm
m a
ie n t
be e
e t
c li n ic a l
d e s c r i be d
a
n
bj e c
r ibe d
19 9 7 )
tc ac
hin
(D t
n t
1 U L V C 1 U
L a
st ru c t u r e
be c n d e s c
c t a l 19 9 8
Se a b
p lc m c n t c d w i t ho u t
( R u d k 1n
c a r t
lo p in g
D S T4 }1 a \
ha v
a m ] n c s
hi c h
t o
l l i t i s r c la t v e ly e a s t o
y
i n c lu d c a \ a n e t y o H c a r m
e n \15o w e
h 1n g s e s s i o
p r a c t ic e
t eac
c ar e
fa
Kn
p r
20 0 3)
J \
0 3
1,
tt
1 eBs pd a
c e ts o
$1
L: f f
a d
h no
rw
k m
'
D r w
O P r 1.
s g A 1 a
B ui 4 n
t l j t ro
< ! 11 Jt j
11
W u B h T
l J
Ds w
r1 t
1t \ t J i l l s (
1i
hh
m fo
Bn
n e
'
tm
j1 /
t j
u .h
. l 1J
n : l J
u
1w
Jt J{
1t
. 1 1l r n
4w
m wu
w n
t l
k fr m
i\\
11
h i uw
hn
h c i d e a l wu i n
h 1n
1 0 r
M u
t ut o>
LN
n t
le m
n t
h h
A n h w
\ t s\ m t n
r c v 1m
t t Bd L r 1
t u t( l r
In
hs { npm
t in
Ot
hu
n M
k m
r
e
v in
at o
9 U1
/ H u ke t h
be
t T kc
to
2tx hs
N 1
' l 1o r r t v l t w
by t h t t \ l t n r
b mh mv >
nt
'
a n t
ta sk
h \ Bl a t u r y
H r Bw
m u r
= i r c
>a l o h u ( 1k
in
iw
ia t i u n
a w c w n w n
l r s t ( 1r
hd LI u
CL o n \ p l i \
j c
Av >hh ment i 11 N
tn
J 1r
w
F \ nc e
n f
nn >J
m
1t '
\e
u<auk
h Mj r
= 1J
n B
Hen t
U I,
t c '
uui ai o
* n
H t n? i
E 1 n j rtv
11 1
i
I I
5 e f +
N u r h u
ne h
d 1 11
t 3
.
B
l l 1q
5 HJ
w w
w Y= W
Bc
ir
Up
1 U 0
hin g
I}
AI L
P L L LC
\\
'
ct
l\
o u t
w e it w
* e \ mn
1t 1
: t
lw t lm c
f 0r
l
1 u l h lt
4 l n
m gc t
rn im
l1u
11 0
al ZW N
*t 1 # l \ l \ t + k
r t
=n m
c a rt
'
y t a ke t he l
Dc n mn
htlt
h tT k ll \ t
r m g Ah p
>
t il
rr l a
hc r
i \ cu
\ r s\ r
h n
t s
Bp t \ W s
s ho .
e. .
Id b c
1 ot
. l l c.
s io n
t.
D t o g . i d c t lw 0 5 . Ch
d. .. t c o n t p c t c n c y
d1 a. c ,
i .c
. S=
r c . . l ua b l
r : . .t c c t i o .
an
a io n s m
h e i r lc
"
Rn
"
"
. : ..
a ls o
o r t o e v a lu a t e
, c
.d
st
t o ide n
hic y c d
e. t
t i fy
. I
an
t he
n 1o r c
onr
p' "
d'
A l t e . A t i v e l y s t u d e n t s c l i . I c . 1. Ki l l . c a n b e a s s e s s e d
(s e e C l 1a p t c r 3 8 P. . f . " " e a . d w o r k p l . c c a s s e
b . [ t h r s m a y b e n 1o r c d i f fi c u l t g i . . n t h c t i m e
n 1c n t )
t c \ w . " b . 1. To r y c a ' " ct t i , g
co n st r a m t s .
,
i ni - E X : No r c, m = t n l 20 03 ) - \ ul ti pl c, s h . Rt ,
f o c u . e d a ss c s , n 1c . t s . t c h n , c a l . k i l l . Fo l l o w c d b y
1. E db a . k a r c e a r n e d o u t b y a . A r i c t y o f a ss e s s o r s
d . Ri . g t h c ' " . . Hm c . t
pr a c e . Ra 1 sk i l l s ( N. rc i ni &
s t u de n t s o r t r \ . . c c s . b il i t
y to
c a r r y o . t a . i d c m n g c o f p r o c e d . . c s c a . Bc c l . s . l y
a s s e s s . d u s 1n g a s t r u c t . . c d SC O r e s h . c t a n d
I C
i , c t ob s c n . t 1on
B. . c h 2 0 0 1 T h c
b a c k t h e n g' " c n
s t . d c . t s ( L 1p s k y c t a ] 199 9 )
, l 1c r o s k i l l s f o
d c . Ts u k e t h c . . U . U " t o s e . k s e l f a s s e s s m
, t J H . . d f e e db a c k
o ppo n -
v e l.
a t io n
la l
a n 1 bu
o r
Lo
'
' "
R e Fe r e n
' '
g o t t o I"
b u l.
"
"
. .
ed ..
ld bc i n v .
De \ . l o p i t
N S. " K o . . l H c t . l T h e y
H+. d . I , t u d c . Ts 1" "
g f" "
"
["
To .
.
"
a 11. . t . .
. 1 ," t n
d g"
3]
I p'
ai
rn m a r
bc ,
1"
J,
. .
l r, i d.
at uL t
"
"
y p'" g
"
A D D"
"
F . .
G L St .
. M s
c t
1 1 r
2 5 3t 1 4 7 1, 7
p J T1d ' "
. v ro u s
1r , !
h"
"
t i cu t i on
ur c,
ap p r
1j [
"
"
, , / 1.
ly
. n, "
"
1t .
a.
], i .
l, l n # p m B r a ' "
I hy
ni
n" .
H.
n\'
oa c h
"
Ta l l
to
t:
. . H\ ,"
1 la l o r y
. n1 ..
t >, , h1 nH
n .
. n,
1o 1
I \
2 t )
bt , le v c n t
" i
r "
c 1r e c 1n
bc
1cs
an ,
l ua n \
1ng
I , 1t r : , 1l .
"
J'
"
" Ce
lv
a ll y . c e n 1n w
A t,
h : Rhm
'
Qe
. R"
. c a
2 4 3 1 200 9
1, "
. .
t c d . In . g a l
h.
ces
Rh r d .
b hl , y
n c ,
"
d e \ e l o & d Rt t s m p o n a n t t o c \ a ] . M . 1t 1 , " L. . g
f c c db a c f r o m p . u . . t s . f f . . d \ t . d . . t , T i ' ' ' ' ' l t \
0U ra ) a . .1
m a y bc p l e a w n +. 5 s . Rp s i n g ( IJ , n t H . 1 2
t
F
t
.
. "
u
u
}
.
:
o
f
m
n
.
.
T
r
h
]
.
l
t
r
n
.
.
,
.
w ,
c p
p W
pr o g r a' " m c .
"
1s
n u 1n
A C =C
t e a c h in g
care
Su
. .
a v an c ty o
c o . s u l t a t 1o .
Ev a l u
d ' ' " t i ' ' " l o p p o r t u n i t i e s . " i l a hi , i n t hc

A C T C c a n b c d . c l . p c d f u r t h . . By , c l i n i . . d i r e c t o r
, , l 1o c a l , c u o , d i . . t . Th . p . t i c . Ts a u . . Di . g t h c b . k
o r m v i t . d . . l . n t [ c r s . . c l t h c m o s t . f %c i e . t u s c o f
1" "
c o ll c a g . "
t l w r hc a l t hc . " p r o f c ss l o . s
Re c
T l w r c a r c a , I" " g e s t o , d i . A t s c ho o l s i .
h
i
,
g ha s
. i z i . g t l n i . c r , a s i . g r o l e . Rn b . I a t . Ry c a r e t c a c
. Nt
"
f a c i li t a t e l c a r n i . g i . c l u d. . s t r u . t . r . d
f m o d e l s t o m a . Ag c s t u d e
i n t e r a c t i o n i n v a r i o u s s c t t i " gs t o m a x i m u m
' "
p"
: cl cv c l op mc
st ai
St r . Te g i
1. g b . k a n d
r ev
d,
l I , I, " i . J 33 3 19 3 ; 1, 2 (10 2
ts
10 2
S E C T i O ha 2
l
D
JA
e n t
Ho w
hm g
a c
n g
s i rm B
b p 7k> h S Ti y lu
1 1c \ k e t h E A
1n \ ( l n c t .
Lra
D c v l o p l n F t hc t e J c l1 l n g
t c a ( h i n a n a m b \ 1 b 1 o r y (o u t p
r t 1r e d t 1h Bc l t e r 2 5 4 8 8 4 9 1
1o
trr
c e n
l tlc n t
J Sk c
S N a t hw
n t
am
0n
0 D r isc o
200 8
pe l t ie r D
a r r a
in
u n
dc w
Lr
d m
i r tg
t i v e r c v 1c w
du
ex
pc
1b n
n io r
Col l t
r G
a l ML l c a 1 C o
e n e r
0 09 G
h A
an n 1
in
dJ
c t
d c +1 c g e n
l u c a Ai o n
T }t c
TA
tt o n
c r i1t e d
d ic a l
l o gb o o ks
tl rl l l }1 t B1l l
t o r
gl a
e n e r a
l M r d 1c a l C o
JA
e n t
su r
u n it
ge r y
tu
di
ts at t
19 9 3
c 1l To 1r o
u n
b L: l a t o r y
nm
s
r r o
oc
Lo n do n
to r s
l o p t n g t t a c hi n g o p p o r t u n i t i e s
T r C l i 111c a 1 T& B / 1e r 3 : 18 0
c
ar
So w d m
d e n RM
st r a t c
i c s
S PI C E S
S D
cu m
1n
m o
iu
cu
W R So
u n n
dc
1o p m
d e l A 1 d rBc u l E d
rn c
c n
u c d t l o 11
du
a m
G 1l l m
l l e c t Bv
su c s o
bu la t o r y
66 5 4 5 5
PG
ca re
ca t io n a
u n
p ]e
m c
d 1 c 1n
c c t 1\ e s a n
m e n t 5 t 1o n
he
Si m p s o
1 S: 2 8 4 2 9 7
l car n1n
a n n 1n
1n
ic J
te ac
c tr 1 r m
hr
\ 1r , 1u
a n
a m
CH
a n
R e g a n Sm
b u la t u
s t r at t pHS
19
St e
1n t c
r J
p r r a m s .u r n
l l BJ c 1B1n g Br1 1 L /
i n t
c r\
1 r r 1l r 1
pe t e n t
am
a rn
I)
e n
bu b
t
u
J T J L B1 1n ,
l \ r t l l 1n t
n
an
in
lt
.
\\
i n
t al:
Te a c h i n g
bu lat o r y
a m
tu
Ie
r l> \
L c\
\
\ 1r n
t , I l B.
.t
'
tm
1r t , ) B
t\
Pn d c
ru r a
L \ 1r r i
bal l
34 55
n e r a
u n
e t
it
Tc a c hln g
l T h e Sc o m s h
he
dic a l
dat ro
u n
fo r
A l e d 1c a l
t 1o n e r s
11 m
5t. S
t a
1n
i n
l ge
t
pr w
D
\n
t o r y c a r e 1s
hm g a n d pr ac
[ 993
)c
1r 1o r 1
bu b
l pr
i a re
Bu x
l ge
1 1 u t 11
L
ce a c
5l b\ C m J e J u
b] J
o \ \
fo
p r 1 = t \ t l i\ n * n
\ t e 1, 1l E , 1u
n n 11\ \ t \
a l:
et
200
14 3
1r ro Ji
t to n s in
He
n t \
I:
md 1 g m
1 E B1 u
lt J
\ .
r o s
gc
Sc o t l J n d : a f o
e f l c c t 1v c p r J c n
te
5 n
L W
u r
o u t c o m e s
G I1 s s \ l
JA
n \ u
da p ti n g
n t o c h a n g e s 1n c l i n ic a l p r a c t ic e
2 0 :2 2 2 2 2 6 19 9 8
htr r
1 4 13 6
t r e n
t 1m c
mt dl t . 1l \ t \ But n\ \
pr oa r f 1 +n( h J r und<r r JAl Jt >
V
]
1
Att\ t r ll
0
l > r 1n J
D u n M rn N Z A lt i [ 2
27 1 1
N
H
C o r i b r c n A h t r n u AUn1t
e x a m s in
ls t c
da y
t s in
tn
Fur na c e j
de r gr a d u
A f 1m
.J l
j : T i ) r d A1 d
it h hl G
W o : fo r d J
h M
d p h y s ic a l
c a t to
c
lc J m
7 ' d ( Aw
7 Te
it
L\ s o n
den
du
JG
c o m
r s o
La
st u
o c t o r
Sc h a a d D
GM
lm
19 9 8
a n
d ic a l
t t
1 f dF+c ne 5 2 4 3 2 5 0
L at t a L M
2 ( N) 3
l
d q u a l i t y c a r e A 1u t r a l i a 1 1 m 1 d N e l u
a1 d J o 11 r r u r 1 o f S u r g e r y 6 7 : 8 83 8 8 7 19 9 7
19 9 1
K r a c k o \ S K Pa c k m
pm
o r e
c
g p
l( n c
e d +c a ]
u n
C ha r a c t e n
48 I
1 3 51 4 7 o
tn r
R e g a n Sm
Mr 1t r BBt T u
19 S4
I r by D h : R a -
h,
e e
u n
Se a b r o o k M A
18 4 2 0 0 6
H
2 1
k . l 11 l dw
a r n in 1 l a t o r y
17
\ 99
o l
\f
C a r t y V B* D a y s u r e r y
l l M C E R u d kJn G E ,
d
t i o n , M r 1i c a 1 E u c 1t o n
t he n e x t ge n e r a
1n
f %c
Tt t l
il
u n c
l Br
\ l
w W K e lle r l m l A n e ffe c t iv e
Re g a n s : n i t h M , Yo u n g
d e l o f 1 m b u la t o r y
Ac a c h n g m o
a n d u : fi c t c n t
5 99 200 2
d
M
1( 1 1r e 7 7 5 9 3
l i 1 i i n r c
c d \ 1c a t l o n , c
M
D
o c s a
ll M C E C a r t y V
Rt Bd k i n G E O D r i s c o
r g e r y r r Tt p a c t o n
d
u
s
a
]
n
c
y
a
r
n
m
r
h
ro
t c ac
BB+
11 e
a n
: o c t 1 s c d h t s t o r 1c s a n
d t r i a l Te a c h i n g
i t u t i o n a l r a n l o m i s e
c a r e : m u lt r i n st
2 50 2 0 07
4
2
4
19 :
l M d r c Br 1t
a i 1d L e a n i Bn g l r
>A
em m e r
1Bt u l Jr
r t
11
32: 390 3 9 5
hc
1
L
Tar 1t i n 11 ) 1t e t l n 1i n
m e
i n \ f n 1t c t 1 1e 5 : 2 10 2 13
tu
d l c 1l
m c
(Or Ju
n e n cc
dlc a l
u sE o
tc
hi n g
t c B+c
\ l r d w i J l 18 [ 2 1, 15 3 1 6 4 , 2 0 0 6
t r1
F in c h c r R\ I E
P t n ga r o L N
M o tt C
rm i l l
JA D a v i s M H (e d i t o r s ) : G r r 1r Bg 5i 1r e11
A p r a c t i c a l G u i d e f o r C l i n i c a l Te a c h e r s C e n t r e
f o r M e d i c a l Ed u c a t i o n U n i v e r s t t y o l D u n d c e ,
G D
\ 1p 1
g M
s e t t 1n
A M EE D
e n t
e n t o n
l\
h R : M lm
lc
\ m r k p h B r l t t i e t 1 n s $t $ s r 1Bt 1r l t S n n
N o r c i n i J , Il u r L h V
G l Bi 1p 3 1 S c t \ t la n d 2 0 0 7
l
o i / I A FE =
t t 1: t c t t t f o 1. t B r o
2 9 : 3 4 1 3 4 5 , 20 0 7
[w
<
hn
L D u i y f D e t a l T h > 1 m n 1 C EX
N o r c l n 1 J J l <b L k L
AnBu h Of
% r u e < Mn q h n n JI k m
m e t ho d
+m p l t
n t
L a r c
D c t a l : D c s lg n
l
m c n t a t \ o n a n d c v n u l t i o n o f a i n c dic n l
d
c
u = a t 0o n p n ) g r a t l r m c u s i n g t h c a m b u l a t o r y
d t o g n o s t t c a n d t r e a t m c n t c e n t r e ; 1e t l i c t Bt l : c h e r
n t
st u
20 0 3
De
dt
4 2 :o
c t a
te
ke
m
t?
l T h e :u
l pr
m o r e
dic al
3 2 00 8
ptm g
gr a t d
n c ra
K D
t lce ta
ti ce
d
c
ra
ll c l
r u r a
ic a l
t \c e
; f e J i c i Bl
C ha p t e r
In t he
vo r
eJ I
P s
In t r o du
io
ct
it y
c o m m u n
o u
pe r
1 Ea
r B
i r 1g
s ll ua
T he t e r t i a r y c e n t r e
h ighl y d e v e l o p e d
"
f e r r a l %l t c r s t o k e e
T %e t w , ' " p a l
p
%l t c r s a r c t h e p r m a r c a r e s s t e m a n d
y
c o m m uni
y
b a s e d s p e c i a li s t s e r l e e s T h e f o r m e r i n
c o r : o r a t e s a
w ide
r a n ge
o f h e a ]t h c a r e
p r o v i d e r s c l i n i e s he a lt h
re
w ar
ds
1s
ca r e
F5 t r e n t
co m m u n
to
in g ga p b t \
\ +1 d e n
gl y
i n cr e asin
= lm
it y
e e n
i\ s
hc
m o v
T his
c t s
ign
lr o
in g
c o n
t r i b L1t e
ho s p i t a l
s
to
br o a d ba s e d
bo d i e s a n
he
cu r
d b v prnhss onal
t ht
d
h
b
r
e
c
w
e
1n
a
n
t
t
c
a
e
r
h
h
i
t
J
a
r
o s p it a l
y
le a m m g t
d
l
b as e d c o u ? c a i 1 n n g n i e 1 c J s c h o o l s t o s e a r c h f o r
1 1 \ \ in 1c h t o p r e p a r e 1 h e n t x t
ge n e r a t io n o f
new n t e s
f
r m a n e
h
l
l
t
u
o
o
1
n
c
i
o
o
O
w
s
s
e
n
c o m m u n ity
s
r
o
do c t
C
B
\
E
1
d
t
c
a
o
n
u
r
e
md
i
L
]
(
)
im e d
n c u lu m
d\
Ate
LK
o r
iza tio n s
ga n
c o n su
lt i n g
fr o
ca r e
T hu
i l ! Ba
c o +T m u n
medi T.
du
v e r n m i n
t a Ian
dn
o n
go v
d is t r i c t h o s p i t a l s e t c T he la t t e r m
e d r c a l s p e c i a l i st s a n d t h e o u t r e a c h
c e n t res
su c
a s
ho
m e
ba
se
l
b
e
y
e rn m e n ta
a
d p a ll i a t i v
fw
h e d e c l s 1 o n r o d i sc h a r g . t h e p a t 1 e n t
m J n y o t h e s e c 1r n e e s t he
t r J d l t t o n .J I d N t o r
b
t
u
1
t
m
f
r
e
l
t
i
o
l
n
s
L
*i
u p
n o t a F p l!
F
a n d p5t w n u
m a y be r e f e r r M
t o a s c he n t s
o r
o e n
ai
d e %n r d l o c a l
m e m be r s
o f
fr o
a c io n
go
C BM E f o c u s e s o n t he c a r e
p r o w de d t o
b o t h b e f o r e t h e d e c 1s +o n t o r e f - t o a t e r t i a r
ho s p i t a l
e s
lce s
tu r
c r
sc r
pa t tc n
\ \ h3 i
p r a c t ic
cc Ntres
a n
s t 1c
In
ca m
b. s e t / j , a c e t o o r br e t condJr ! l m 1 h o \
u n y n n e n t e d m t d l ( a l ( j u L a t 1o n
v n t h
F J C c l
(
i
n
b
e
s
b
b5.
,
Ad \ j n
d
t
t
b
u
r
1c
r
u
a
a
T
n
(
rt
o h
d
hei
l
Lh
d
f
:
l
l
t le
n > e
e
\ u
u i 1
L U + 11r + u n 1t \
a d dr e s s n
a n d . +i > p i u
g r j l = t t u l i , r } 1n t B1 i t A o i l 1r + l l Bl 1B[ l
O)r r, rr . unJt , m- 1AB d e d u A J t 1o n 1\ u : \ > n T BLl t e \ \ 11
Pc e
r r e v it W
inun
It
11 i l o
Hy ah a u c
p
n lm
u L L o \ rn
r u
dn
bl t t t ) j t n y o
tt r d lrtn n m
tu
n
1\ >
1n
l 4 ) . 1l
y t h B: >
,
t 1l
\1
r > 1t t
t 1c
I l l 1 T\ \ Bm
W \ L
tm
.\
U r \
111 \
U I1 .
0c
l t B\ e W n m
i h t t *i
l a rs
tu
d l u bt n
rt J n t
\ \
r i 71 e r
r 1\ >1nbt r \
t n
An B N
L\
C B\ IE i n p n m J n
It i s
d 1 h c r c n c e b4 m e e n t h e
LI t h c
h eal
: r 1 mJ n c a r t . 1 r J p n n m
r e te r i m
t h c h r t &1 n t e c o n t a c t
t h>
\ 1 m 1n u n \ ( \
h l t h
t he he a lt h
n
t t t p It
t J n
lu
r r \
1whL1t m
in J
v m
ro tJ t h
+n
h t hc p n
1\ e
n u 1r
d in
y Jhn
h t p r 1v
o f m
r n
f io
10 4
S E C i 10 0
gc
gc /c
l f a m t ly
t\
m o
ho
f a c to
h e a l th
o rn r l l u n r t y
11 s \
la
Pa t ie
ts
lti n g
c o n s u
ho
d l 9 1n
c o n
c li n
m t n
ic s
r]c s
in
o r
h c r c
n t i n u it y
co
k o
w e c
dv
a rc
W h ic h e
B\ \ r s
m e
l n
at
io
ro
se m e st e r
year
o r
to
hc
o r
m o re
i t h bo t h
1\
IS c h o s e n
st r u c t u r e
v e r
di c a l
m e
d i sc r e t e b lo c k
f p e r h a p s a f u ll
t a ge s
d
a n d disa v a n
gc
ho r t
r a r
po
d 1c 1n e
a ;
B1U a 1
10
Th e
ro ta tio n
]B p l a n n e d o r H n t a t
a l s o 1m o l e
a
i t h c c o n i r r 1u n i t y T h i s m y
pr ac t tc
h 11s a n d m
l
s
a
l
t
c
Jn
c
t
le v a n
i n t c n s rv c i n s t r u c t i o n i n r e
h
lo c a l
t
c
m
l
r
C
lt h c a r e clc n e y
t h( s t r u c t u r e o : he a
h
x
e
s
u
c
f
t
h
p o s u r e fo r
ir s
e
h
1s t
:
t
1s
l
l
1
c
t
a
u
e
s
y
m u m t y
p
b
d d i t io n a l u s e f u l t a s k s m a y e hn kc d
stu de n t s M an y a
t
s
s
v
t
1
h
m
t
o
dme] O
c h a s do i n g
1o t h e s e r o t a t i o n s s u
r l o c a l r e s o u r c e s o r h e a l t h f a k ] i t 1e $
ba v c
c c n tru s
f a m il y
o r
m o st c o n te m
ir 1
l t hc r
o c cu rs
ha l f d a y p e r
l pr a c t ic e
e ra
ge n
p p e a r s in
la
ic u
an
t l l 1c
ls
ha pp
care
lm s
m e s
COn munl t
s
i m m t i o l Bs
r c Bn 1l BBg s
A pr i mar y
F Cc
sc
I p r B1c t l c
\ 1l l a
]o n
w c
a n t
P OS b
c
T
'
fo
se s
n o
r J1
c u 1 a c ro s s
bc
u n
c 11 o n
bL
J ti
lo
l p a
ca l c
c c
n e ra
s c
rc l c h
rp
m e n
da
d l t 1o
n a
c nr r c nc bd
lu
t n o
t 1J c 1r
e 5 5o
in
l u r
1 /y a
bo
c c
'
a\
a l l a h c
ga
T h c 5 n g st r u c t u r e o C B M E a r c p n n t l p a lly
de t e d b y t h e a t m s o f ch c p a r t ] L u l a r ( o m p o n c n t
bc d e l n t r c d T h c w ( a n he
to
o f t hc
c u m c u lu m
d t \ T d e d i n t o p r e d ] n Bc a + a n d c l i n i c a l a l m )
a rc a
L c m c h Bl
h e a l t hc a r e
t
u n
u se
p td e
Bn 1o
p a c t Uf M n
t c an
a n d
lo )
u n
Pr t ' \ t nt 1Bt 1\ t )1t J] t Bl
d>
> H
ta n
h t h > h>Jh h m r e w m
d f 4n l mn n u h J B K H m
h l p U p r u
ha \
>
w n
in w r d ct
mnnt r
a$
Lia
l in
N r
te r
> \
uw
:i c
Br r r a r y t a r t
l r
t lc n ts
o r
n iz a t i o n s
a rn
tha
ge
n e
T he
r t
bt
>
l r e 1\
IIIL
praL tlttu
I l B 1\
hl l l R
>
J rc
o u
n u m
be
tt
N LT \ 1 I "
tl\ > \\
t 1\ t
t 1u
n \, \
n Mt
r 1I
in
n n n
c rt e
go
Ltn n m u
co m m u n
an
ps
s +T s
t o
ba s c d
o c hc T
J L
t n Nn c n t
\ t r yk
t u \t h
h
u n m
N h l
4m
: N 1h
he
pn
&
6L
n t )
hh m
nd
t pn m
a ly
1n
n n
n m
u n
Jt
w w
d c M on n
J c rs r J J u J t e
d n mn c
a r e c +e
t l r n \
To lu
a rn a
rw r \
bo
h > # 1P \
in
1n
ht
care
c o m l l \ \ 1n i t
y 1u w i t a \
c ru a r
o l n t n \ 1n \ t
\ \ 1r r t c u
h> h m p M
a y l3= i n r t la t io
t
c a re
lu
Hn p o
o r t h
y bJ
\o
w d
\t
be c
.l
rm n
po
au \ c
n t
a b u \ 1t
c t 1t c
tea
hc p r i n u
d t 0 %ll
\ 1s c
s tt \ 7 a r e
ln
i s s t i ll t
ar ca
hc
1n
NdNJ
hc J [ h
d cw r F J
p r i n 1J r y
tu
ist n J t e h
r
4 fh M
t J
v mh v
J Ht w
is
J tu
e o
u i sp rd
\ c ammB b m
A t t h e c n n e r Nt
\ 1L t e
qp
dc n
stu
U n l o
the r
f t 1u
h e ( U, t enc t v a m
t t
t TJ w
1n
d ic i n
g l c \ a m pit
CU\ l A7c o n d o n
hqhh
\
c t a lt y o
I w1n
t h r e e U> w h r e h h m v t h > hopnl k s

,
l t kus l o r t r = i n i n i a n t i l o u r t l 1 w h l c l 1 h n s
m t y a l t h c p r i m a r y lo A u s
rns
p m 1\ J r y
\ t i i nLl l . Jt e t h J
u he t r n
u r
( BM L A t l
bt
t ht
gr o
po r
p a r t ic u l a r s p e
r a l p r a c t r c e / f a m i ly m
I n t l t l + 1l m \ l t I t l w
l e J r m n R \ \ r > hu t
m e t ln
su
Tn 1\ \ r
pJ C
tt J\
a rc
l \ t 1w p l t 1t 11t \
J HL n p l H
h
h
m
m
m
1
n > w TI I
cl l r w
tun
t In
pa
To l e
K=
d m r
to
d b
h e a l t h L e o r k c r s 1n c h e a r c a A n o p p o r t u m c y t o e r ie f
h
1s a l s o
e l p %1 l o
c s
n
(
t
n
c
h
\
i
r
c
e
t
rcf
l
t
ct
o
n
p
a n d
]c a m 1n g a n d c o n d u c t
s t t 1d c n t s
c o r u o lt da t c
Tht s e , Ues t l ons a r e r e m n t t o
c \ a lm t o n
\ e a n u
d
u a t e a n d p o st gr a du a t e
u n de r r r a
C B XI E
o r
c 9 o m a
a n
1n
t hc c o m
Ta b le 1 3 1 C o m m
Tv p e
ity b a
u n
t CBME
D l s c r c t e b lo c k
sa
m e d ic a
Adva
n ta
lm
s lo n e x
m c r
A ll o
ge
n e r
a l
du
1l o n
ca
(c B M E) In g e
de
e r ie n
ce
fo c u
t lo
s e n bre
o n
D Is
Re q
J res
d i ff e
b le
e ta
n se
to
m en
h 1p
rs
r e la
h o n h 1p
Ad
de
Po
s s 1b l l l t y o
b e fo
n
n u
ty
ro
re
Ca n
u sin
l te
a n
Ca n f o llo w
ta ti o n
ge
con du c
SCc
l w e f e e l l n i] f o r th e
o o r d a a h o !i d a /
r te r a
ge
a cha n
Ea s y t o
Co
a re
s tu
ru r
a l n n d re m o to
e v a lu a
ti o
d a
a n
p a t Be
1d lffe
Sc a s o n a
Ca
den t
te g r a te e a
in
s tu
e f t Ca
p ra c tic e o
Im pa ct o
a s o n f
en
ts
e nce 5
ti m
fe
w
je
a c
p r a c t ic
1n
da t
a cco m m o
rm n
'
e o
e r e e
ce
v 1t r 1 a n c
o r
w i
r i
cl i .bfBt. f o
YBea+t ,
Ie
[
r r i
J r l : l>
To l e a
In
rn
/ t rJ
}
1l
tfj
n c r m
Au
1n
r J
r 1n t > r
t 1 r x
ft
PC
I 1f m
)
n J
l r
'
on
the
r ei
1 \c
re
qJ
r ho
r J
i n d
f t B, V i v J t > r
1, 1 5 \ r t 1 c l > r 1t / t
B
1 1r
h Bf
j r 1t
r Ti u
y Bn
ha
r J r 1t
l t l p rB d 1:
Su
A
r + r 1 t t Tf t 1
l pJ
l 11 f t
( l p ll m y
l e
F(
<x
ence
pa c t ha
ve
im
g tr m
Fact +ce
o n
g fo r the p re c
b rin
co m e o r
in
pto
c o n f, c ts
r ot ar 1
ab c
a l be
t h a n th e
Ft e
&
a
l
e r
r lr
a r Bt
l l lr
f ( Jf \ (
th e
s m
D/ r e c u f r n
g tra n s po rt
tJde
l J o
h e
e a
pe
o
C SC
n e
St
g a l e
m e
E T
1
cer Tg
po r u
1m
a se d
e s
e 1 e
o T E l co
le s s
a s
<x
/ . . al e
en
pu
\ 1t
>
1 r t 1 r 1t
f o rt
1n
t l Y'
U r ( ?r \ tly
t\
n u
Sc h
n o
l o f \ 1o d 1
Ii ll
he m O
o r t
\ \ r Jn pt 1' " l \ \ asubTCUPOt st udent s
t l\ t
J \
Fl 1nLj r , P r J . l e 1 R u r a l C Amm m u n 1t \
C
1u n \ \ p :. t t ) J F 1l n J e m L n 1\ r r \ \ t \ 1 n \ u s t T 1 l i a
l >u . T1Ti >>t t a k t . 4. i \ Jnt J ' o t t h c b r u d . u t 1e n t
'
i t l n rr
J t hv X
ln
LI nt l n( - J nJ L
ll B} l 1L
o3 e
Ph p l n
Un
l t 1t <1. 1p l l r u
11
l b je
COr CL q e l
+c n
z m
e d
Dl
. f 1
cep v
Ti n
te
a n
th a c b
l n
c J r e cont f \ t
\ \ t
1n u
f e c t
fe e
ap
e c e$ ot
n n > n Hy H W nl l uwnn
t h Z u n M n HJ J n n e n n v 1n t h
th A ma
w n un
tc
pe
e x
J,11tr1nr.1\B]r}:
It
'
th e
[c 3
3J l b e
c t
o n w
h( p n m J n
fr u n l J
r r 11 n
/. / a
It > a l t h )
t Jn
d fu
a n
r J: > r
c m
( ( r m m u m t 1c \
( i t ol n t t <r at > l >
u w
c n
a s Fe c
n co m e
s e s s 1o n
d Cr e
re
:t
C Or C J r r e
r i a l a p p e a r 1e . s t
1S
e ar
d p u b ! c h o l. d a l s
ga tw im pa c t
r, : a / b e
L
l
t u de
f th e l
t 1m e
1c r
de
in
pr nc\ cJT
5c
b a s e d d Sc p l l n e
Stu c
e s o
r s t L +d e n
y 1a r d s
s p c c l f 1c
r o
l o
fo
on
ca n i n e
Ca n b e
cu
U s u a l ly
d at
acco m m o
5 a s
ta ge s
r ta
t ;
s l a
a n
va
gn f
co n
O l te n h a s
dv
re n
s ch c
s
In t e
to
La r g e
pr a c tic e
E a s y to t i m
t pr1
n e ra
ges
s tu
w s
i t: y
u n
\ \ \
l 1 11 r
l\ l . V n
r
r ll \
1J I 1 \
\ 1
1N l
J rc
1 H J N l ! : > 1\ \ > 1\ t
Hm
r n n lr n t
Hn Hr R
u 5
r r 5
1t l
\ +\
'
n 1r J
tL
l 1k e l \
Tt
\ 1n L hl ,, l \n
n n
hm
re
R d
t\
I \
1t m
to
\ \ \ r n mu n 1 t l <
h 1\
h>
hN
\ n
d
r u
x\.n\ti La n t
J t t c
1n
Hgn
The
hJ
n ic
n t
tt
to
a n t
a n t
w o
r e
<
le s
o tl
gu
a w
u
g w m1
w w
1 0 5
S E C T IO N
10 6
Ta b le 1 3 2 C o
Ed u
ca
t lo
p a r is o
f a c to
e BT l i n g $ i t l t a t i o B1s
n o
e x
te
d e d CB M E
Se q u
rs
a n
ro t a
d t e r t ia r y
t l a I t e r t le r y
e n
Co n t a c t
w ith
a
l
r o s s s e c ti o n a : s n
p a t i e n ts
p o m ts
s i m i la r
s lu
the
As so o n a s
de
Ex te
n s
Gre a te r
f h ig h
f pa b e n t s
lhe
in
r e la
ss
w a)
a n
Stu d e n t
Acc e
b s p e c 1a
'
ls
e1
lh
h a v e le a r n t
n ls
'
ess c p a\
Se
d e Y p me n t
su
c 1m 1c a
De
f te a ch
o1 o
ga
pe
to
e a sy
rv i s i n
c o n te x
Sp e c i a li s t
su
Sgnl f l cant
t o JU N I O R
r
g for fJ
u re
Le a
ct ce
ra
Ac bl
e ; v a lu e
EVa] t 1 on
. e
f t hl b
F 1p d r
t hn th>tr
a f d dc \ c lo p
t o
Ix
pro w
:\ J s s h o w
a m m c
n t
PRC C p c r f t ) r r +1 Aw t t > r 1n
h o \ p l t a ] b J \ > t i pt T\ (W \ r l (
p rz m
r \
In
d r
t w > e r B t .1
k ) 1I \
> J o f
> x t t r,
dt
a h
t J
nt
d p > r ) u r l J l L Iu J l l t \ \ r t
> t i ( 9 U U P \ T h w , \ rl t \
Bo
1\
r 1r l
pe n
1v
h J t t ud t
l ( 14\ l l
0 r
ls
bu la l u r y
o u
p J t Bc
> x
ri t In (
lw
ir "
I n c
f te
B/ F
g a n f1e
'
i ll
i h t l y
po
tm
u \ 11 r t
1t l p l (
\ u I 1 l 11 I 1r \ 1 t A
LJ t
i n t u t i L d 1a t
M I( L c h s
gl
\ en
,
\ \
te
Is n m
1t >
rc
in
par t
c i pa
bon
a r
J r e
\m
Jt
&
he
ts
N :e
F
e
cc r
t"
t1 e tl
t I
w t
h> h n h n t
n n
Jt\r n
t n h t
e n 5 c s
re s
h1\
l
ke
1n
u r
c e s
e n
n Jr
ql 1w
h
ent r i
+11i n a
rr
Ln
hJ t
sm
to
t t h
l1
HJ
A h ho
n -
nh1i
h N
c r
v n 1e n t
t r.
C B\ TE
1H i l 1 c s
l l
t ha t
to
m
gh
he
d nw n
q m . u h 1 H i n w w m
M < : h de . 1 u t
\ m a=
w
n rw u irr 1
Hh n
1 H\ 1 wM
hnH
cl n cz i
and
r i n\ +ou, _l r ul \ 1s
w n
S S
chJl l cr 1, t
Je\ LI ' ' Pm,nt

t
LZ
in
l qu J h
r e s c u r
l C/ F e T 3 Yg
st e
rt J n t
e f
e3 =h
r e
c1r i c an s
so r
v o rk
as
l L{ s
ce
5 n .
\ \ t 1t
\\
/ s
ac t ce
hJ l p r r 1 m m e
l l n 1o
e r
\ r n r t mn
h d
paCnn\ t c
;l r a n
4\
( B\ \ l t
r e wt t r
in
/ fz
c a
ga
p r s s r bl c t L\
\ 1, ( e M
\ 1\
N 1z
t l t 1t
J l 1n J
r>
Dk
e e
c : r t a rn
1/
\ \ \ 1\
Pr r n a
) B
I n
hH
l 9 H H H vl l l
sa m e
t h e ye
c c
Lean
It
)
J
Se e
1n
a d
n t s
111 4
ly
chn
Ul u)
rn \ 1
ach n
Ahhnuh
m a m
s a fe
b :e s
con e e
ec
a d
n m
a i ne
on m en
( I
P r a t t 1l JH H H H , h
HM =
5 U A wf u
W iU 1 i n e
c& e r
R e Ya d A m
o r s d e :e g a t e
t
a rn
on
d ex t ended b m
e n a
to i t l c T c
r o :e
t \ J m1 n J t l L \ n \
a n
e d c aj s a
n n
"
'"
rm
p e rv i s o r
su
St ud
c l 1n c t a n s o n
g
t
a m o un t o
h g h CO ST e
1n
p = e / Fu r t h e r d e e l s
o l e r
or
&
co m m
pe r y i5 o r s
su
w a rd a s
e o n
Fa c e t o f a c e
p e r t Bs e
n e
p e c ta ti o n s
Re g a r d t i m
tt t u d e
s s t o Su
aceh
s i n g ie s e r i n
t h e s p e c l f c f t 1n c t i o m n g o i o n e t e a m
the y m o v e lo a n o th e r w a r d a n d
d l s c o l i n e V l
ded c BME
X, q . ' | ; ,
p s ho t
de n ts f e e l
s w e : s tu
p as
ll
t h e i r ) ll n e
in
n s
t a t io
ro
H i g hl y f i lt e r e d c a s e m l x ;
le x I ty
s e v e r i ty a n d c o m p
t io
H n mn
rm
- : H,
..
a n
u n
Nm
ut on L 1t K i
ha t
N n wt
hc
st u
dr
1t udc nu.
X k t =
n t
Je
k
lu tr g
c ha
u J
c 1l l u s
an
ir
dc n t
t t\ r
t nn
ce r
l ll
\ 111
t he
ll
r u m n
a n
ut
r c c r u tt
tu
t a \
r at
he
st u
l m i c 1s
p c c t c d t ha
tr
t is
hc
n t x
i T1 a
r ecogni t i on o f
l lu
n t ia
t x t r a
t 1c
Se c
n c r a t ro n
he
tu
tl m
Tn
an
c a rc r
pr o v iu
he i r
t\
ahl ng
t t
in
h i s a s t hc t r
r c do c t o r t o
t
: 1o o
at endi
b
e\ m
l\ i
a w
c.
1'
Bwd
hq
l 20 0 8
de
\ t u
' " t nb' Jt l n

nccci
to
sr u
( an
5 na t t
IH
w 1 )
hc
) It
t o
IM
pp e
l> J r n
hJ
tru
t t
p5r t1
ht
Ie n
cu
m u l t
l re
a r
1n
t im u
Jt w n t
t m w
\ . 1m c
t 1r n
MJ
n n
'
fu
u n <
h
t
f u r j h e r ho u
Al l o w
t 7
b> c l
dc n
J, >
Jm
f J t Hn y
'
n u c
u se
.n a n
c an
T he r e
to
d u l c
be im p le m
arc
c o n su
l o gbo o k s
se
a n
lt
w 1t
re
he
Bu 1
m es
m i
ta
sti c
s s io n a s
p a t 1( n t s v i h o a r e r c f c r r c d
p p o r t g r o u ps o r lo c a l he a l t h s c m c e
an
se
e n t
ir e m e n t s
p r o fe
be y
m in im u m
a s se s s m
qu
ne e
m c a su r =
p ly
st m
c o n st r a i n e
Jr
hn
a ss G r a
L1r
ro c
t s
at t e n
m e et in
gs
d 1n g
T hc
l ea
en ts
t 1n
bu t
p pr o pr
1a
s \
r y
T hi s
fo r
re s
} Ughi e f f e c t i v e
st r a t e
a s
t o w n
ob] ec1ves
c e ar
t r\
as
gh t
sk s
te
m en to rs
M a
lso
L e s
is
ou r
gy
r T
re s
1
'
ff e
c nv tr o n m
f le a r n i n g A
ppom
c n t : ca l t o su 9 c t s s
ga t n s t
( 0 St
ac c
ds
n o t
to
1o n s a r e c a s H r
ha t c a n b e u
le a r n in g T he s e
d pee
o t
t he
1n
t o o ls t
a c t t v +t
eac
l l C BM E p r o g r a m
te
ro o m
if
g gt < t
c oo r
l i n i c a ll y
= n v l ro n m c n
e n
m an
lt i n g
su
d
fo r
fH
e s
& a i1
C f = d? e
. A e e s _ e l
Oe f t e
h : ue nt
r 11 > J (
d t ha t
t he s e
. ' " " c h
f u l p r i n u le s l o
r
p
lz =
an
u u
ht
t
sl u o e n t s
H oll
L x
s a \
+n c r e. 1c \
cu
(\ \ ? h m
Re a w
1r
1 1\
73
I J r c
LT
bl e
e ta
lo c a l
b a s i s l o r t he SU C C E SS o f t h
e s e 1s s t u d c n t d l r e c t e d
i n g w he r e st u d e t
n s ha v e f
ex1bt t o m e e t t h c 1
e t
l v p a \ c 1\ c o b s e n a t t o n b y t h c
p
Ex p e n e n e c \ Ln t h
e
u n dc u r a b le
A ll t h e s e a r
d
r
i
e
i
C B\ I E p r o p a m T s i n c a t e s t h a t i t m a y
1 t o m c r c a s c p r a ( t 1L e = a p a ( l t y b y
p l w 16 c
t h e s t u c l c n t s 1n u w f u l c o r i 1 p o n e n t s o t h e
r uent
t im
s it e s / s e s s i o n s
pa n y In =
t 1r c
e n c o u r a ge
i st r a t o r t o
fo
n it i o n
rm c r e c
l t i p lc le a r n i n
g
m \ J v cm
dc
a a
d l t l \ i m : x ) r t a n t t o St r u t
h c l e a s t n c Ra t i v c r n i p a c t o n
i u
t un t h s
t p a c t c n t s t h J t ( a n b c s e e n I f t hi s i s n o t
m hc r o
u
n
th
dl n\ c an +m a y d c u d t t o d l s c o n l i n u e
h
c
t
CJ d
th
f
%n a n ( 1a l c o m p e n s a
r c 4 u l r e M Rn 1 i = a n t
t n t
hav
ki l ls l i s t s a n d s e %
p c c
ho r n t V l s l t s W o r k i n V
hc
a n
n C
gn
'"
djt i n c t /
su
r e gi o n
uhc t r
k s
Te a l h i n g t l c
r t c o
rc \ o u rc c s
dm in
n u
den t
an
c o u ra e
g a c a dc r n i c s t a f l t o w o r k
c
c o i n n i u n it
y s e le c t e d o r t e a c h i n
g
de n t
st u
an
t he
jW
it y
c o m m t 1n
En
a in
w it
ts t
I a cio n
pu tt
c x
ic
r i1 n in
p lo y
n ate
Rr \ e
n a
i s
Em
de n t
\ Dc v t
t h>
pprc
n t
ht
io n
y t
t r \ l
snt l f nL t
l C B H E p a t l L
n 1r J
n l Av
tu
rpw
st u
ii
ts
art
l hy p a t rc
u n
an
r c 7t
in c t
w e
do c t o r s
1 i r 1t t
4
lin
it
re
l h ha w
"
St u
id c t
rov
n t s
'
if
t hc
a lt hc
'
h p a t l t
[ 11 r n a g c
h a t
ht
a n
rt hin
he
a t t a c \e 9
bt \ t u s
J n
s\t l v t
! p
c 11 t
ex tr
r t hc
"
'"
a c 1o '
s itu
p a A1L n
n s
io
E\ a l t l a t
t 1= l p
p 1r
hi n g
o r
L u / l\T
rl u n 1
part
i l l tw
5 w
o c c u r r c l 1L c
aL
ab a t e
d d
e
br a t 1
ian
l\
as
se t t)
13
liN
h 1s
te
rst
c t
Th c
:T t ) t 11
s
aL t
'
I n t he
ri
du n h
1 11 v
h l
n n r
>n
> m
t w
hl \ l L c
\\
h , \ 1 1t
I h> d
t H
w n
i n
r > t
h1 l
lu
H e
t he u n
n
r n w
nvNve t he h o l t
>
\ n J n 1t
lu
i l t \ t 1l
1r t t l t t t l t < m
p J
t nt >r Jt eJ
1 m ht y
'
n h}
,
he
mn
ll
h> n n mt Hr
t m
n e m
NJ
Hn n N n R n wh ;
he h n k u
r L
hm
tm n to a
t 5 lg t s o
heat h
W r
u c
hc
m n
c M n n r n $ n1 t mn Ot t he wht y or t hm s c r wc e
h 1w x p x t a
a u n n > > m p w w n w n l w m o bn n g w
U m q u Jh n ; o n d a n d > r
w n
w r t lw m
h 1h t c
ah c ht =m c a n d u n h w
H x w w t hA n n w n c p
,
n >
f
lo c a i h e a l t h
pr
ese n c e o
n cw
dc
st u
to t
n ts
ic e
St 1l
fa c i l i t y
i t rc s ,
w o r
ho
as
so u r ec
it h
r ea
p r o je c t s c
i
l s t s a n d s i m i la r
ho r t e
st u
de n t
du
( Fr e n k
c a t io n
Ho
doe
Le
av e n u es
he
u n +v e r s r q
to
Cm
co u r a
T he r
c z
sh a r e
y b
n c
%t T
in
c lm
an
t m
ca
dc m
m at c n a s
ca n
e n
Ba
a ca
r c
de m
e x
pc
l t
to
i cs
\ 7
n (n
c( s
y li b r a n
d-
p a r t rc r p a t c
+n
o r
ga m
:i o m
J a t ro n s
t0
l b le
rn a
ac ( - t s s
11t b t 1?s t
to
a v a i a
Thu
p plc
su
h
y bt t h r o u g
an
1n
hi s
in t e r
I r a m \ 1s 1t
lo p c d C D R0 M
tu to n a
Dc a l l y d c \ c
o n c r c n c e d t du t
t 1o n J
se m
o n s
h = u w u d l t a r 19 e > d u I J t l o r 1 t e , 1l r l n l t } A\
U
(D a t d B d z c r { r U m l ( t y w u n 1 L t ) r 1l r T1
l
l
t
>
\
n
l
i
n
d
f
\
t
>
r
L
r
>
J
l
J
n
e
b
:
>
d
J
1Jt s
St u
n 1c a t i o n )
S o r n e 1 r a y ( T t j F y > a r A BBBr z t Bj t W t b w b t l \ t t Bt 1> r % r 11 I \
ni \ l d f t t J p e u l J l t \ t u r > l i l li \ } t ) 1t r \
p r e e r wJt d1
d J t t x t ht ) o l J1 c t r u n 1t r t u l I r t \
r n a y c h w s c t u r r J
j i u l > J Jt J b . t u l t 11J l l 1i H t 1t 1. ) i n }
b
\
Jl w
d
t
u
w
r
s
e
o
an
n c t ( s o
c o m
h r o u g h lo c a l
i mpor t ant
a n cJ
ha
u n
lhc
n c e
l e lo
do
l m
c u rn c u u
s c lc e l lo n
c 1J n
pm
e n
c o m m itm e n
( . Ommunl t
ha v
st c t io n w e
be e n f o c u s i n g p a r t i c u
m e d i c a l c u m c u la
e v e r
fo r
bct \ \ t en
rn u n i
t\
C BM E
L
l\
L I 1
he
1n
t lt e
1s
l u m
t\
[5r
t ln
1, 1L a l l \
n
1 h 1u
e x c e
m e n t
\ c m
l he a lt h
t
n o t io n
n c t \
tv
pu
hat
gt t
\ c
an
o n t re s
dc r p i n
y pre
m
tx
>i u
r t u n 1t 1c s
ft e n t e n sl o r s
d loc al
C
s
su c c e ss
st n c e m
n a t io n a
1L d l
ppo
ll x
l :n Jhc y
ha n i s n
to
%
a
arK
t h1s
tJn
u n L t
Kn H
pn
1c e
l 1n
ht
a r e
ll c y
sc r
T hc h r s t
i\
l le n
Th t r c
c r
Ii n g
hc
\\
H C H h e n n 1 U n w wJ
l w l v m h l m Ln
M h m H
r w
hm h
dc
J r t wJr , . h M t d w a l w u d e n t s C S FE
! t h L i r p r t L l i n t L a l ] c J m i n g c a n c n gw
l e a 1 t c k 1n ge s u
n r c \ t a r L I\ t h J t t J n
Iu , l >
m o u c r 1l
ro \
w e
Lv
ha t h n
1 B1 \ U
o st
J t t L } n u t a u n 1v t r s r t
\ r A
pJ rt
a s
l go
Ho
r e c i a t io n
c a n
p t ro n s
re c
1 l L \ 1 n +n
h r Ll u h
ll t
a r n rn
o m n n 1n 1T \
Iu
tl
ct s
n J t 11) n a
pt
fu
im u a
C B H1E
b u c h )r
in t e r ac ti on
o n e
tc
o n e
f t h e he a lt h
G a t n 1n g a n a p p
d
d r e s s t he s e
a
t o
a n d m e t ho d s
m t 1n i t 1c s
p o ll c) a r e
o v e rn m e n t
an d
v
pe
aj
1r m t s
to
1m
h p a t l e n ts
w it
rr t n t
d u w h! t h c
r e e s c i n b c p u t t o B: t x )
T he s e s a m e r i
u
n d Bn R o B t h t
t
i
n
h e a l t h s c r 1c e T h i s m a y l e a d t o Jo
i n f r a st r u c t u r e r ( q u ) r c d
b
T h c p r +n u p l c u l r c d u n d a n L y s t m p u r t J n t i n r r
U o n
lu c i
h rp
o vl n c r
Ho\f
i
Ja r l y o n c l i n i c a l te a m n g
t hc
h
a
n
t
s
l
1n
ha \ e b r o a d e r a
gr a
a c c e ss
spe c 1
c s
o r
q u 1r c
so u r c e s
t o n
s i te s
l a l l oo t
\r1 d
T l 1u s f a r
n { w
1 B 1 1 B1 u 1 v m
54t 1ngs
fo -
Lt r u \ m
a c a
tt tn
u r c e s
r m
d c st
he ir
st
b 1s e d p r o gr a m m e s
bo t h
n b c b e n e fi t t o
c o m m u f rF
w T
fr o
d he a lt h s c n l c e r e s e a r c h a n d
h i s w o r k l o 1n t l y T h i s
u n d e r t a ke t
to
ttn
a n
u c
s h
gc
ds
r n a
co m m u n it
Bn
c o m n ru m
l 20 ) 0 )
u m \ c r s rt
d 1r u c a
t h t h i s t h e fu
p c r sp
1j /:
ac e c ss
d
I n a d d i t 1o n t o t h e h e a l t h s c r 1c e p r o \ 1 1n g
fo r t h c
o p p o r t u m t res
v a l u a bl e c l i n i c a l e d u c a t i o n
to
\\
c t a
t he
ly
L Ic
symbi ot i c
d gu l d a n e c
he a lt h s e r i c e
a ss st
can
u \ (
l t i p le
m u
1l c r l J
s s o 1a
le
ro
tL rp
to b o
t
r > 1A v v 1
s u p po r t a n
hc
m a n a ge r s
t io
i fo
by d i n ic i a n s
o n ly
n o t
m a n a ge r s
u s e fu l by t h e s e
i i n d e v e lo p
i
t
c
Be y o n d t h a t t h e s e a c t r v 1t i c s c a n b e c r i a
i c
h t o c o n t r b u t c t o a n d c r 1t ( Bu
1n g s t u d e n t s a b 1l 1t y b o t
tex t
n
h
o
c
c
t
i in
t
t h e p c r f o m a n c e o f t h t he a l t h s y s c n
1
a +11
(
t
a
i
n
d \ m u l t i p r o le s s o
o f a Io c a l c o m m u m t v a n
e
p r o du
1l c a l t h f a c i l
\ c pf c
nt t w
d c s c r j bc o
l of
a resu t
1t i c n t c a r
v c m c n
pro
t t i w
h e a l t h fa c i l i t y
m \n y
i n t he ir
bc yo n d p
tm
a n
du c
c o n
fo r
in
1c c
ps
ec o m a
p o wcrf r 1l
to r
n c t
p resc
d 1t s q u a l i t y
au
ac t n
can
n i e a n 1r t g
h e hc a l t l1 s c
bc
de n t s
se r
se n se
tu
n o t iv
h nL hn
n m c n t
cu
hB
a t
1u t
H 1o
ha t
l hv J t h
l n 1
MBu
en a
Nc
n e
ts
J X CS S
w u n e
pp
a t
jn
c o n \ c n l e t \ t t . 1n t
pB
ll>
in
r e 1n t ) t r
\ B Ji
J> J r n 1r 1j : \ t l l Jt r 1l + I r 11> L u J 1\
l W Jt )l I J I { L L = t )1 111 ( J r 1> w l ) [ t t
m u n i t y m u s t be p r o v rd B t
l e a r n c o u r w w o r k t o ( Bt t r 4 1 l l o l 1l r r r l t l r r n i r \ H
s t y l e s i m d t o u \ c x p e t w d n u l l 1Bm t l Bn
l i c l 1n o l u g y s h u t 11d l i l o b > \ Bw : l J B} p r o p r l ; 1t e l )
1 1) p It
r . l t ) w r t h a n s i m p l y l l r t )1e \ i k t 1 . BI B\ i 11B I t u r > \
w a c h i n g t e h wn c wn L e n u d o r n h r r m 1 n vl J>y
p > Bd e a v e r y u \ c f u l t o i t t ( L t l v t t m 1l l u r l i n k t n
c u d c n t s f r u m m a n y s l t e \ t u \ t a d 1c r b i \ t t l t r t i n i \ t 1 \ 1t
y
o r l o c u w d a t o n e d Bs t i 1n t s i t e
t ie s
Jo
h Bg b
$ta
)t
Mn ,
n 1 11\ 1m
11n
1w
rn
ms
wh u h n M
l hM
H H t rm
mn ,
>
1t e \
w
h 1n r n r r h mh n
hw
n
n e n >
Jl
t m.
mL t h m,
1 h n h t w t u n r t T kc n
p
N A nM > 1h1
d n u x h c Jl
>meBl ul n n c w Ol h Jl n o r k
ThBm1nbr
H m n l unkhwt el whF
n
In
e
i
l l o n l y b B t l l e t t i e t l r t he t t 1\ Be n t c x p e r c + c
ocal
t
h
h
iB h m
p o M t H v o n c h M n 1w Cci hmcd
bll
:h n
w i
1
1\ 1
"
;%%.
.
i'"
lty
lt l n
5n
tte
t l \r o u g l :'
so c ia
ti o n
In
n t he
lu
ve rn m An
ne d
t ai
lc (
le M
i il l go
nt
bt
mJ y
l u\
'
pu t e
t l1c
n t Bt r s
c lin i c a l
vi \ory t
" d
d u c t io
tro
ha v e
ns
to
i ve
c x
ncc s o r w
r it t e n
( t
b s c r v e d by
X; i o
Hr u .
can
pt r it
a so
ZX i
t1
Ii gh t
..
\r
\\ L
klb r L
t 1t
d5 t J
l be n t ht s
m a i n t l l n 1n
nd
n t 1a
1o t t
se
rN
po r ta n t
t e r m in a t i
on of
p r t gn
l o n g l t u d 1n a l d a t
a
is
it
u n tlt r st a n
a n ti a n
n 1t y
dl ( a +
ho o l \
d 1n g
l t bc
ho w b e i n
g
gm z l n g t h i s
h
e y a t t c t T1 t
t A
p
nlt n
em
\ \ 1n t l b1c
d
i
l
m
c
a
$.
t
C
1
l
l
t d u c a t 1o n
= lJ y
r
e
d l\ \
t L r } e A t h Eq u i t y N e t w o r k (T H En c t
'' " $
t hcnecommL1n+t \ o r g ) 1 \ a s m a ll g r o u p o : i n n o
\
\ \
l hm\ l s t h a t a r c 9 o m m 1t t c d t o t h t s
n t d t c a
p
i n
+T1 e
s(
ar \
n u w
r( c o
e l a t 1\ n \ l u
m m u n \t Y r
as
<.
: t ui n a
\ \
d in J c t
13e
1m
1b
p ]e
m e n t a t io n
i
i
anc
y
C 1; M E i s a l
so a n c x
c e ile n t
o bs e r v e t h
e r o le
or
lo
lc
hi c a l o r l e a l a n a l i s
g
ys
t hc s l ud c n t ,
Obj e
"
o pp o r t u n it
y fo r s t u d e n t s
j n ic ia n s o u t i d
s
e t he c lin ic
,
Jl n
r ic u u rn
do c t o r
p la n
n ers s
im
pac t s
t he i r
o T1
ho u ld p a y
t s w h o ha l
fa m \ ] y
an
s o c ia
h e gr o \ \ i n g
d c hi l dr e n
A Co m m u n i t t
y x p c n e n c e m a y bc d
by t h e w h o l e
fa m i l y t o de t c r m
m e t h e b e n e f it s
a n d di sadv a n t a e s o f
g
li v i n g a n d W o r ki n
g m s u c h a Co mr n y n y a f t e r r a d t 1
g
t i o n bu t t h i s r
e q u i r e s s 1 m fi c a
n t a dd 1t t o n a l e x
g
pen se
n uu n
bc r
de n
st u
att en
tion to t
pa r t n
e r s an
de n t s a f c t y T hi s rm
y e n m l e du c a J p g s t u d e n t s
bo u t t s su e s o f s a fe t r a i e l
carcf111y r Tu Y N G p y sa c a l
n s li s t o st u d e n t s 1
n c o m m u n 1t l c s M h e
\ To le f c e is a
s) gmDant I SSU E man . 1m: h c n s k c D t h c St u d m t o f
\ \ p o) u rc t o c o m m u
u c J b!e h as H r an d
w
aSSI WW; St u d e n t s t o d e l l L \ 1 t h r e b m e b n o n
c
l u r J l Lhn; C d n l f r s i ? m e l m n
f
f
t
J
m
r
e
m
m
e
.
1
r
[
v
t tt e h r t t l m c S t u d e n t s t hJ \ e c l 1T 1t \ c n 1r b m a n c e
h l 1e > [ n t c m \ - L\ t c h c m e n t t o \ e r a k a n d t h e
: 1 &\ ) bl l 1t \
c\ &ct - d 1r m t h e m St u d e n t s a l s o
l f [ 11 t 1n t A t o t t t 1\ c
t u l e t a m 1l y o r
o 11 14 u n w < l l
st u
l3
de
ft e
1o n
e n
an
to co n u
i
d >nunt ) t s
t 1
}n
m J
 ) l\ t \
t t tl >
. T.
r
:, b
9 t wt 1 n h , SL J n r t ul t
Id r \ t m J n t u l u r n
> d
ht t \ \ cL' n t h e
l p n \l
I LIU L J t l L \ n
m k
l ll l
>
}B] p
Jo 1 \
l r t Bt ( J l
w w w
l > a rt
hm
Pr a L
1BJ \
.t j ,
A J L1 a
i t f
t 1\ 1l w a
Br
u h
yh
t t ll
hn
\t\
t ! >nt \ &ni B
l t l\
n > U1+r r \ 1
lr\
>
>
u \
t \B
It
l ,
\ t 11, c r w 1
i h e tw
n L
n 1o st
1n L n 1, u J
ee1&( t J, t 1r ) \ u} t 01eprt )t L\ uun
: r
o n
c i \ :E 3 e
L \ l.)
:m
c
)1
kh
t )r\ d m
n h
ln
t lrt
1t
'
B> &
\ \ 1 t
tn r
t h 1w
\ \
t t
h e 1r
< I"
\ th
lw
u n
n w vh
hm 1
o n J n
H> t
Hvd
C ry d
\\
tu r
<
;c h
k n \ \ w l \ x l gc
n w
n m
am
n n s
B u >
: 1) n l c ( r
inh
H= r
cc
a1
1r 1g 1n
<e n
hc t u d r M s
d1
h ( ( r r
JJ
Bs
t :'
u r c e s
k i l ls
nt p
\ y
Kr u p
y h
m m u n it
Co
i n g ly p u p u b r
lts
u c
l ?c
l l( \ l e d u = i \ t io n
du t
t h= m c t l i c a l t
ls
m et
t lm
\n
ha n bl i n s ba s e d
n it y r
h
t iu n r e se a r c
in m t hc
re
co m m u m t
q u ir e s
d\c a
du
io
L 1t
Tt
lv e s in
1c l 1 n
lc l
q \ 1i r
ll
in
}u
k e h LJ l d L
\ 1 n
he
Or +mzauons
fo
e \ c
Be
aer .
m te rn
T 1{ E n
He a l
o r
c k n
i s
c t
co m F a w
o n
l\
t it u t i o n a
1n
i g n i fi c
t tw
ln
ha n gi
an
s o n d
p e r 1D
Ex p o
hJr
h o
TI ( (
a n tn
l m , Li n
n wr
n H
tr
SUt ct sshl
ha n ge
s
an d
f r
l i
tl\ t
LhJ nt
w
H he + n : wm
I nJt r r nunB t BBm
3 7 0 5
5 UHX.
lo r
as a
ba l
b n d R( c
a nl
m (
d u ca t ro n : t hc r e p o r t
d c ljm c a l c o u
n i t y ba se
d ic a l
o m rn u
t he
rse
W a l( c
\ l
l, i
a n
U , La n g e
L , W o r l e y p, P r i d e a u x
ta ke
i
e ra l prac t c e
s u l t a t i o n s i n ge n
co n
w
ht
e1
pr ac
t l t io n c r s a r c
h c eB/ E d r 1c a
1t o
pr e c
lu
cu r n cu
Eth1
a 1o r 1
u n 1t
E 1B1 c t l 1 : o
c \ a m
\
t L1t
o n s
r r m
o r
u J +c c R
5 n
t i Ll
wh
m c
d 1(
L\ r
"
st u
de n t s?
T h e Pa
gr J
te
l pra ct
c a t 1o r i
'
lin
li
l l e l Ru r a l
ic a
; $t d i c a l
1c e
a n a
y 1o
r a
se
o n e
10 2 3 I 0 5 8
1t m n
2 0 10
Hs 3
e t
hn
ho
r t
s tu
un er gr JUt e
u n 1n
w t t 1n
d)
me d i c
B\ U
110 4
L 1W
c n
rn c
dhJ
st u
n t s at
2 Br w
n m n
12 S 2 0 0 2
a u x
o -
er a
a l e du
Pn d t
tc
in
n cw
1 1 Bl b A 1 5 : l l
l t ' ar n n
&r t or ml nc
1n ] t 1\ \ n
ie n
hl p
di c a l
m e
a l:
e t
a n
ru r a
1n
! b as e d
1r
E\
1 r c v
l ge n
34 : 5 5 8 5 b 5 2 0 0 0
ba se d
P Rc j a t
o r e y
c o m m
p t in g
tim e
m o re
4 2 ( 1) : 6 9 7 3 , 2 0 0 S
Wb r l e y r S 0l a gy C p n d c a u
C o jrT 1m u m t y C u m c u u m
rs
l BA f =
s t r c
m ny
he N t t w o r k Tt )u a r d 7 " m t \
d c L I c J n p r m l d c J t \ Br ur 1
n Ac
X,
t r c' bol 1r t cs
c o m m u n it
a n d
su p po r t
l de a s
J r L n f t h c C I; 1n l t
fw
o u
ba N o
a n
c x an n
k1n pr ohl t ms a s o p p o r t t 1m t t t
l i n d p r J c t 1L 1 l s o l u t l l 1 n \
1o
r
e
J t m n
c
1n \ o
r b
'
A r a n do m u c d
r ac tl(
a ]
Bi n i ( a l n\ t t hod i r l # c n c p
\
t
b
i
e
r
u t t r e d c l m l 9 a 1
t
v
i a l b a $e c l o n o j e c
c r o s o v e r t r
B M 3 1 59 2 0 9 2 3 9 9 7
n a u o n s
t 9 u cn
h ?
l Can Lt%
a rm
he c r o < \ o n o f
ic n l
h o & < t h 5 t t h c pnnL' l pl ts o u t l i n t d ] n

1t 1
r e 4 u tr t d
d
i t f a ll s
t h 1s c h J p t e r ( a n h e l p i n n m a t o r s t o a v o 1 r T a l o r p
fc t d bJ ( k fr a m
a n d i n c T e a c t h c l l k e l l h LH M o : p u s 1t l v e
a
\tr r a
o l
d j \ t i o n A l t 1111o 1n L B pCr , On- pOWt r b c c a u \ (
c o s Ts o F s u p
t B t it t
t h e l o \ e s t u d e n t t c 1c h c r r a t i o a n
h
a c e o m m o da
a
s
d
s
u
c
i
e
c
n
w a
d
por t in g stu e n ts a t a
a n d
sta lt
d
111c
c
+
1c
a
d
;
t r a \ c \ fo r st u \ c n t s a n
ti o n
l
h
o
o
n
gy
c o n 1 m u n l c 5 t 1o n t t c
1 n f o m 7 J t t o n a n
re
N y a n g a i r i I $, c
in c d
l bo x
rn a n
et
prc\ s n t t
0
5 2 (S) : 4 6 7 4 ?0 , 2 0 ]
l cad1r\ l np 1n Lt \
lc t lv c
in v o
o n
a n
E,
e r
J t
n h p ' " c n ; c r n w r r d be he f A a d e m i c
2 586 20 0 9
M r e1i e i n e 8 4 (53: 5 8
C a n s t u d c n t \ c a r n
E J o l ly l l M o d e [l M
t hc v M o u
xJn
i n Bc a ] y (
stu
crt a s
to o
Jto r
b 1/
p r = t i( t i
B M E J he d t o
T h e r c a r c m t n v b m1 s o r c
J \ l iv t r
\ t c n 1c d t u
\
c u r r i c u l a r J 1n \ \ i t l
1t h c r
in
an
m Lt n l t y
L L o r c o m
t h L R \ w i n g i m p o r t ; i n
h A a l t h \ y s t t 1l
d 1 2 1s t c c n t u r )
n
lh t s
rL
S e
l
I n t hc p n n c i p a d
'
U m i n aN
E I ' c l le t r c
it
l e mn h w w d m n T t n
n r t
A d
bBe
b ou
hc n
c t
Ht m l A t
c e s sc
d 1 D
ece n l
bc
he
c o m m u n
it y
b M F c l c t t i G t t a l : 1a 11d b o o k
t I [ h ta gz o u
o
t c hn l t d
E d r 1c { Bt i l l T he o r y a n d 1' r n r t i
B(
i
3ed
i
ce
c o r r l Jl +t 1[ t y
k Pu b l i c a t i o n s
2 00 0 N e t w o r
In
ho u l d t e a c h u n d c r r a 9l u a t
m
c m e dic a l s t u d c n b
g
r u r a l c o n l r m Bm t j
c s M r d i c 1l ] o n r n { 1 o A Bs t r t 1i a
17 2 : 6 1 5 6 17 2 0 0 0
,
s
C ha p t e r
14
S
.
i 11g
d BT t
t \ t )I t
R o 1i r l
an
r e m o
lo
io
c at
n s
L .c o t i r k e
1 B1 \
t 1u t l t t
Ru r a
t(
o n c1
t J1
n (
c o m
t r) J
(-n1r\ u. 1 1t 1c
d n d
( \ \ Ft . ' " ncr
r r
pr
Hc
go
l n r
n t
In
t r
T hc
Lr
n 1r a
Iu
M
y
hc r s
L ciu n
tc c
l Lxat i on
r c m o t t
1d: Jl
ln
l \
se
t t in g lo
practl
v a n c t
can
fu l
in
a n
m c
anx=:
l p h y s 1c
ru r a
tu
i o r
JU n
fo
bcm
v e
, 0
+a n
Th
1c
t.
(c
u r r a
u n
d 1c a l
m c
c a l p r a c t r c t
ha
t o
dt
st u
in
r a
& Ro
sl
n ts
u r
a n
in
h l =l 1
+e
t t in
t
rc c r u ttm e n
2 0 0 4 Ro
du
= a t 1o n a
se n i o r
t0
le a r n
r J l
lu
\ a
fr
e t
Po
o rz 1 c t
n t s
t r r
>
1 20 0
IBt a n c h r
20 u
2 0 0 4 G t w r t 1x n
n h e y & M u r d ) L h 20 10 ) A d c
A m c r 1c a n s t u t l j t 3 I t i t n
o X u h
Pc
\ \ b r lc )
t J 1l e {
t 1fw d
n t l
gr a t
f)
t t
1n
st u t t n
(fb
n co w
p r a t t rc c
h>
. > 1d
p l i Ct
tc
w t t
i t
r 1n
( a n
r u r a l r c rn
t\
>
ha
\
n 1
ha
d \ 1l u. l t 1#>s 1 ) l r ur Jl
> d B\
\ o Jl l >
I( 4
l \
t J
n r \
( 1n
r r c r
t \
t lrl\
\u
]t
ca l
nc r r
Br
b t o 7 t ud
\t\ ,
r J l nr t
tL)r
t e J Chl n
s
r c 5 L
hu
tn
1u
w ]t
tu
wd e
r a
st r o n
t ac
hin g
an
g Bc
L\
t t he
n t
1l
L
t c a
Tr c
L>vr enh1
l\
c r a
u \
ll
ga r ds t o
e s Th c T e
r e
\n
\ w1 e n c
a r n \n
sc o r e s
l t ar n1ng
.
\l
c n t er u
d EU t l m t
He r h
a d u a l r o le
w c
t cach1N e f 1/ K c n e h
a n i
I r bi
&
k c t J l 1) 9T
c c n
1\
tm
a r L 1u n
2 ( 1A) B)
A [
1
t
t1
. 1 n
m J
t ng
n\ l
l tt
ROUr kc
n
1 1\
pr aL ti tio
a b 11c
ht
1n
2 0
dt
ru v 1
n r r1
1 Am
=hy
>t
tt 1
t 1 t
l f a r t l i By p l r y u
d ic a l
t c a c b c r \ (\ a
d
l
c
l c l Ij t e r a t u n J
Br r
MM
t t t n 1t
( tu l l \
'
m t t l r 1l t \
Jt 1t
n u 1l l l 1 l 1t h
"
r \ t Bl t l
l BI HI
Bt
i n \
11 l P > w p t u
1 >\
n > r d
<\ t t l r r
f \
l
r
ll \
n a
s t a s t Bc
a n a
' u r a
e r
w e
I 2 0 13 )
\
l \n R
e l t \ . 1e
l I l LI
I B\ \ h
\n t
h c r u r I I 1n c J l
b L t t1 p a t i e n t
1> \ I.
d r n t q A r n r d n J l w } n n 1h > w J n d I n J n h h e n t h r u
s o u J l r Bq p c Br m b l t t y t B t r l i l i 11> t i t \ Bl t l 1 rq t B \ t \ t u t l t 7 1
. 1> r > t B\ > ) 1r > r \ \ 1 \ t 11t t t <t \ l
1B j d \
U u n s a n d In
I n ( r c J \ r n i r 1 11l ] b > r \ J l 1 r 1 t t l l J l l > u r 1t r h 11 > > \ I H T 1( r 1\
e
d
a n
l t \ 1
ll J ll t r
g ho
s e t t 1n
pe
p t L\r
rn u L
\ n
r c l 1m t e
B 11 1
J I lB J t
1r
pEt \ t pt L\ r \ i t r t \ l
a n
a tie n
s in an
$ l g n 1fl L
J \
r n 1n
"
t BT k A r
r t \ 1eu
L t
m c
pr ' " LLn qu5l 1t
X d
G p prm
1 2 (j l I )
t J
JRJ )
i n d
R t B>
> \ 1d > l \
lc a
r +e n ( c
11 tr
I 2 U r )5
e t
e t
X :
n t la
u r
WJ
a ] 20 0 6
ct
w er
l 2 0 0 5 Ru
d p
1n
a n n
p
o f n 1r . 1 p r e
h , t he w h a t t hq
w
f
h
o
o
d
der sta n in g
ha d n o c l e a r u n
l
c c p t o r
l l c u m c u .u m t he t r r o e z 5
v
d in t o t hc o e r a
t a u g ht ' t t t
de ' n e d
ha d n o t
c he r
c l J n 1c a l t e a
.
un d
h a d li t t l e
stu de n t s
t
d t B1 a t u n t l e r g r a d u a c
1ear n d u n r 1 g t b e 1r
\ \ h a t c he t n c e d t d t o
,n g o
m
a
1 0 0 3
a d d t t 1o n
I
n
)
(B k c r c t a l
J t t J L hm t n t
[
h
e
n
\
1
1r a l
h
t
,
a
d
f r , ) m s t A1t l c n t s f o u n t
t i o n o f ee db J k
l
k c 2 0 0 5 3 Tht r c. ' ' " h \ t a
a
Jt
t rs
l t t e r a t u r t ha t s h o w s t ha t r u r J l m c d r c a ] l e a r n
l
]
o r be t t c r t h5 n
s
J
w
c
d
a
s
\
o
l
r n 1n & s t J g c
e
v an e t! o f
h( r
I e a r n c r s o n m e d i c a l ) a r m n a t 1u n s i n d LJ t
u r ba n
(z
w s
o m
r > s ld c
n e c
ke
u r
a f c c
d n a l do c t o f s
k i l ls m
l
s
d c l mm c a
i t h br o a
l
h
a lc n g e
c
ca re
t
r u ra
a n
B1 (
tc
lt
r 1 1l r r m o
r u
. ltl v
t l J{ p c
"
U
t
\ 1m
l\ t
l \ l i \ 1\ n t n d n \ I d
p
p
l l \ 4l l l t \ r n t r a r t L
m > \
\r \
.
t 1u
hc n
p r i o r t o t he
t ia
t o s e t t he
a r r i a
t age
fo
r a
d r e s p o n s M h t 1c s s h o u ld
) r s h Lt r t l y t h c r c a f t c r ( K e l l
t h y L
y
c x p he
wJ
t
o
i n d l v ldu a l
W i ll ha v t
l
u n
o
a
s
++\
g
c ar mr
t h\
10 nc
1+
'
n t " l i L
Al u u l l y
'
>
\
r
h
c
c
g
m
p
1
t t
p
T
i
" " o
L n : Er n s
L 1a I p r u b l e l n s
o r
tt
u Le 1
i
J
P
b l rr g
.d
l i3 c u \
1n
h e \ t ar nt T T h c m t d l L a d o c
u t t
r o la
s
t io r l
eta
a n
m an
m e
r hc
ru ra
:::
w
(J
>j
n0
. r
A <,
'
lns
,1
p.. tl nt
q u ir e
o u > i +r g
hL
hc
\t t
7t \r
t u
pat
ie
c a rl
b 1t
Ca r e
ll p la n
t
t in g
Se t
l 20 0 3 z in k
t a
i d e a l fo
IS
i L H
sm a
an
Ca
an
d l i c x i bl e s c h e d u
d An d t o o
n ee
ie
to
pt im
a c c
iz e
it i o
ssio n
it is
r c
la t i o
c o m m u n t i e
s
s io n a rsm
to
b o t h t hr o u h o u
g
t an
d v i s a b le
a si
n s
hlp
to
se t
t t
he
e c
be
"
o t ru
OU T
l p
re c e
p lo
ru
re s
a u D e
t ud c nt
t\ c
a n a
o n
Pro
ap
os eb a s p H ) '
f
1
1t c
& 1?
"
d tn e
r *
B W
te a
r g8
t r e la t i o n s hip s in
bse r e h o w
p ro f
li z a t i o n a l l o w r u r a l t e a
a n
so c ta
ar n c r s ( a n o
l c o m part m An ta
bl n c y e t k e e
p se p a r a t e
pat ien t
s ib i l it ie s a n d s o c i l
a
r e l a t i o n s h i p s 1n
r u ra l
an e
c o m
Th e C
A I a m
er s ro
lt
a r 1
<
Cn s t r a t e s t u r 1 > t >
m
p
n t j
j B1 Bt 1 t t f t
J 1i d
l BB1 1 m
lr lt
t l r 1t l t t
r Bt
t 1
Br
Bt
il
> J 1W
tn
DS
1u t \
4 a n d W J C Hi n
H T hn
in u j
Ke
l u l <
m u v
i nLh11>
Pn wn t
Lh n
N B1r h
wh
t H
Bl Bt v h r
H
dnt
r n
n 1
u n
5n
w t t \ tw
lht
t\
0 43 -
t l tJ
car e
c
fl e x i bl e p e r s o n a l l r o f ( s s ] o n a l b
o u n da n e s i s o f
a Ju e i n
p
a n y s o c ia ll
i
n
t
r
e
d
c
o
h
n
n
b
t
c
e
e
y
s c t t 1n z
o t
r u ral a n d
u r b a n ( R o u r k e & R o u r k e 1 99 8 R
k
l
19 9 3 )
o u r e e t a
a n y r u r a l m= d i ca l t e a c h e T s a r e a l so + n \ oh ed i n
l o c a l l e a d c r s h t p r o l e s Ru r a l c o m m u r u t l e s a s s m a l l e r
m 1c r o c o s m s
o Ten
p r o \ d e o p p o t u n i t 1e s o r 1u r a l
m c d tt a l do c t o r s t o
o n ly i n
m i k e a d i f e r m c e
n o t
1n d 1c t d u . 11 a u c n t s l i \ e s b u t 1n t h e l c c a l h e a l t h
ste m
p
i n d t hv ( 0 1d e a l ty t A e
u n i t y as a w h u lc
\\ l l
n
1e a d e r s f u p B u t
t
n l! w i t n e t h i s c e u ru s
\ \ 1l l
l
l
i
t
u
r
J
1
1
u
w
e
:
p L
th e s u d e n l o
H
pon
( n
=_316
he
de d e d i c a t e d
ap
c are
d disc u
p a t ie n t
o r
ll
e n
te a
t a
l 19 9 5 1 p a t i e n t s s t a f f a n d
p r c c i a t = 9 o o l s c h e d u l i n g
n t
o c
r L
1t n
(St s w a r t c t
d o c t o r s a ll
a w e
n Br a
h o o l s (wal t er s
sc
a t ic n
h o u ld
d r t pons\ bi i t l t s t h a t
an
J t 1o n
e rl n
J o t in o
c rs
m
5
\c
1o 1
\ h
h l
n
re
r e v
r\sponsl bi i tl ts
= a rt
1
\ 1
lt \
u\ t
LLT
i= a l
r l )
11$
, '"
e\ 3
o r ie n t a t i o n a s
r u le \ n t h t
h
<
t
n
t
,
T
1
= = p t io n a r e a
t
e
l \ Jy
t K " . l p
h
b
A LI
) t L P r = C L Pt O r i n t "
11b s l g n
U ill
l 1LJ u 1 p
ppr o a c 1
m c
, hbemt ' \
d ic a l
/ i 1
he s e
tn u
e p c rs h
t t 1 ?l e
he r m
h e i r %u n y
1 16
C T IO N
T hlx
t c a c ]\ c
bc
c a n
1 a l l c n g i n g
h a vT hc
r s
Lar mB1Bi t dl i t )
ha n
a c tc r
l 1c
pt
ru r a
ln i a
lm
ski
t t acl \ 1ng l o c o
ic a
l ls b
D
l lo a d s
ire c t
a n
dl
g prt
s n t n t 1o n s
t L1 p l t \
o n
1n \ c r e s t
11
T he r e
t
hc
lc
ts
10
a m
c r
Ba 1o
Id e
b s t t t u t c f o r t h L d 1r e c t o h s e r
o f
t h c d 1r c c t d c m o n s t r J t 1o n
M EDs
t if y t h e k n
r o le i
c n
le d g e
o w
b*
a n
k ills
qu
re
td e n t t f y l m n \ t a t t o n s a n d d e m
D e m o n s t ra te d a gn o s h c a n d \ hc
\d e
t dy p e e
b fy p a r h c u l a r
Dm
n a
\m
}-
de
u s e
De r o n s t r a e
1d e
u i
nt r f l
in
te
r v ie w i n
tlc
h a ll e n g
a n
k i l l s to
tho d s
rn
c n
A dlo
ll
S h
1d ( 1 n t /
r
ho
to
pra
be
ffe
Bl t &
lo
v l it h
c l lc m a n a
0 Bc u &s
yo
ba
uv
d p r a c t 1c
se
f fe c t rv e
t h ic a l
a n
fr o
u ltt e s
b e rs
m e m
w it h
k ill s
a r u ra
f t he
e a n
ts
pa ue n
u
o m
c
a
r
ru
a t r c pn
r c st \ m
a n (
fy
a n
l> a r n e r
as
m u n 1t y
n o te
It
ba
he
d p a t ie
se
l/ c o m
p a t 1e
ho
es
D a il
a r n 1n
v l
t h e y d iff e r
t c a r e w i th m
m un
c u
a lt h c a r e
c a
l f a JT u By p h y m
\ r * e ly t r a
Fc
a n
t s fr o m
fo
ppro pru tu
f
\n
nt re
d d is ta
c o n s u lt a n ts
la n s
p 1 t 1e
n s fe r
m c n t a
m e s a n
+ ru ra
9 sl
05 tio n
\n
o u r (
a n
<&e r
Yc o m
the d h e
r eer nng
m u n Bt y
n ts
d re a \m
pra
r e s o u rc e
lt h p r o f e -
a n
il y p a t i e n t
lt u r a l
a n
te a
a s -
c ai l
b e
d -
poor t
an
l er ay
\o t e r h a r y c a re -
c e n tr e s
e s
c tic e
a \ a b l e ;a c
t t ng
{ b
Bn
jl o
w K
j d!
/ i
r r 1i u f l
la
c a n rr la i o a
c. L\ b: f J
o f
d1 /
d f f B< r u
lrl p
fn
F1ttJnt=l l
0 4J
i 1p p r o
u n d
b tra
iB u
t,
1u y
)u
a n
p r BB1 t t
r; t b
T\ o <J 1 1 \ t Bm
Ui -' b f u
U t r > d a t u
r t 4
* 1 Bc J t
fK u
d tn
1
1\ u
fl\1
L o \i n
11I H
!t B\ p r o
1l
rw
l r)
:1 j , 1F
LH
.d
* n
lu
ln
n
Umnl unBt y"
m o
Bl \ t \ c
t \hu
l ry
t
t n
. 1 d
u n lq u
\l F
te k
l \ho p d bt\n \s
* n
c o m m
t : : \ \ w o Bo s m c l u d m g u s E o l
+ d \ t 1o a r u r a 1/ c o m n \ u n :l t y = \ t l n g
l h f e l u l \ u Ie a
tB
n e t c
rn \n
w
d s
f
i \ \ m r = h \ lJ r n
: / p o r o n 1 1 l l B 11\ ( ' n B ) r y B\ Bf t [ 1r , yo u r p l t n t , # t y
d h e
u 1i f \ Bl d u L u r n m \ Bn 1l y i n t l i l c d \ P r a c \ 1c e a n
l d e n l Bfy a r r d t j 1 p I r 1r r l ( u l B1l w l a t 1r \ r j \ B1BBll! r \ t }t l
l ra 1m ly i l n t l 1N n t \ \ l i n m n \ \ l n \ \ H j l a n d d * n d x
B
l d e n t l fi w M d Br l B lo p b l r 1 \ 1A u l l ) # t t J b B B BBn A u H ! B ( m
h
t l t a d m \ m s t r a \ ro n a n d c o e g
lF
D o m o n s r a <e p o b 1t 1 o BBBl l t u d t B * t d v 1 cl r k 1n u t 1<l a l l o B111 h t p * w i t w i l t t r \ , * a ,
fe
1 1 io n *
M o d Bhe d f r o r n
1t
M ED S
w wi 1
d q l * d +o m BB u A
t t
t * tth
?M)S
r u ra
t
o m m u n i y
</ c
a n
e
e v ld e n c
p ra c t ic
o n e .
1d c n t l
he r
k tlls
n a t e ly
p p ro p
p ro g r a m
r e s o u rc e s
, unt l l 1l f J : 11: at l h*1t )
to p r
L i
d u c a l j o n t rj
ro
$ c o mmu n
tlo
ti o n
c o m m u n ic a
dt
l e d ge
o w
( a
u rt rt s
c +1 J
Id w t J fl
c a
ra
H id
b l*
m m u n rt y
ll c o
a s s e s s in
u n
e a c
ro t at io n
l t he
e s
re s o u rc
r e
d d r ff i c
a n
e s
kn
c r
+HXX H /
ru ra
o f
o v e r
iv
c t
b o
i1 d v o c B t e
H e a lt h
Dc
a n
r
co
f fA c t r l
l dnt l l
tM
be
l l> a r n
c a r
to o
1 1m m l n F
r u r
Co
a n
li a
n c A c
r t he
st a r t
he
a t
t \\ )n
'
B
)l
r o fc r r a
o t he r m e
a n
lc
r a
a ti o n w .th a
e f fe c t r v e c o m m u n ic
d le
a n
a r
d it
heal hcar e
tr a t e g o o d
o n s
em -
Au
r r e v ie w
pe
ra
d fo
ir e
u s e
o n s tr a te
1d e
Im
d p t 1 d In t o
t io n
su
a n
>n
he lp s b o t h
n 1t y
o r ( o m n m
b\
lc
po
1: n
o r
he
o
bt a n d in
pan
di
\> r
tc ad

Medical Teachers

Caricato da

Informazioni sul documento

Copyright

Formati disponibili

Condividi questo documento

Condividi o incorpora il documento

Opzioni di condivisione

Hai trovato utile questo documento?

Questo contenuto è inappropriato?

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

Medical Teachers

Caricato da

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

FO u r t h E d i t i o

' " '" P+r '

WO&HP. ACE$ SSESs M EHT

C o n t e n t St r a t e gi s t : L a n ma 1a 11u n l 1' >

per mi ssi ons

h Phn eMAS Bsc (Hon s)

ephil O&rII(Ol on)

d BSc(Bfo os ) HSc Pb0

OClinPsychol 1FBPs S FHU

J o h n B l i g h Bsc MA MMED MU f RCp Hon FAca dMEd

i n g Bsc MaCha II 0 FRCPE

aA(Hoiu ) PCCT f Aca dM[ d

BSc OPhl l HonDro ool

t MMEDMO FHEA FRCS(Ed)

Ph0 0ip Psych

BSc FhD CPsycho l

t MSc mo MRCG(Hon) 18Ps s

SFHU l Bua dMEd

d y li ache MCH: RCS FACS pia (l du)

Bsc M0 ltncm FRC$P FRCPE FHEA

Of MOf &CR(El as)

Pml essor D e p a r t 11c n

aA(Hn s ) k 1([d) MB* 01pHsw Ca tf

MOPHD FRCF{Lim D Edin )

t s aSc MB CHB PHD FRCP I HEA

0 CCn (EM) MCl inSc i FCFp m

l* k CCFP * CliFSd FCFP

BSc MECHB oacoG MRCEP m

i M8BS MMED MPH

Phk MED em ons)

MaeS BSc Phn OSc

FCE F&CP FRCP

l t e BSc Mees Ph0 MMM

west cmi zed

i . . ?nf t rcn9cs a r e J t t r 1t l ng a u & e n e ) t o m

f k e y p r e s e n t o t i u n s a t 1nt cmat i onal

Con\ &i ' nL1\

cur r1cul uni

det s ons Jbj ut

phnes a t r a dMon a eurr i =ul un1

row.t l l f 1J Jl t ,J.l l (Br,J

Eeur t f 1gct hods

1BA n r n f y C o n 1 0 ahnor mal l t y Su b l e c t \ I 1J !

CUr r i cuun1 pannn1

<d > n J1 e s 1n 11e e t h $ S r B I ( e J M u { d 1r r , n

gemr al pr a9t l t ( po\ t \ J\ t p1md

1neJ m c s +1 1n pcei ahst

o' " scas

nss h' nl cnt

l1ulti B1i >\\oiLt' t Bu> M l t \ \ ( MC

T h > m a j o r y o l e x a n n i n g hod>si nchr

>r u>wnuhH unhBt

rt' ' "}nl /Bl

1Nyhl l Bwnt l nun

v hnh nuur ahan

1' H > T HL HHH

L\ ! ob( wr \ ee. 1 dsc s m ' nt t d\

hr ' ' JJt n.

TE, k 1" U l "

( ' ' "

' ' "

' "' "

munnl en t shl 1ni J c

kn. " l N$e i n t o