Sei sulla pagina 1di 3

EmilyKing

Chapter12,Spanking
FHS2400,Period5
Spanking:Ifyouwere(orare)aparent,wouldyouconsideritviolenttospankyourchildwith
anopenhandonthebuttocksifthechildweredisobedient?Toslapthechildacrosstheface?Is
itacceptabletospankyoursmallchildtoteachhimorhernottorunintoabusystreet?Tospank
becauseyouareangry?Isitacceptabletospankachildwhoiswearingawellpaddeddiaper?
Whataboutslappingachildshands?Ingeneral,underwhatconditionsdoyoufeelitis
acceptabletousephysicalpunishmentwithachild?Istheageofthechildafactorinyour
decision?

IfIwereaparent,Iwouldneverspankmychild.Ibelievespankingisnotanappropriate
formofpunishment.Whenchildrenarespanked,theydonotconnectthepunishmentwiththe
undesiredbehavior.Instead,theythinktheyareabadchild.Instead,parentsshouldusenatural
orlogicalconsequencesthatgoalongwiththeaction.Forexample,ifthechildstealsatoyfrom
theirsibling,theirpunishmentshouldbetoreturnthetoy,apologize,andpossiblydosomething
nicefortheothersiblingtomakeupfortheirunkindaction.Thatway,thechildwillbeginto
understandhowtheiractionsaffectothersandseethingsfromdifferentviewpoints.Thisskill
willbevaluabletothemthroughouttheirlivesastheymakedecisionsonhowtheywillact.
AnotherreasonIwouldneverspankachildisitiseasyforthepunishmenttogetoutof
hand.Atfirst,aparentwillpromisethemselvesthattheywillnotspankoutofanger.However,
thispromiseisdifficulttokeepwhenachilddoessomethingexceptionallyhorrendous.For

example,ifachilddecidestoplaysoccerinthehouse,knocksovertheTV,andbreaksthe
screen,theparentislikelyextremelyangryandwantstopunishthechild.However,thebest
thingfortheparenttodointhatmomentisstepawayfromthesituationanddecideareasonable
punishmentfortheactiononcetheyhavehadtimetocooloff.Therehavebeenseveralcases
whereparentsdonotdothisandspankingtheirchildleadstoafullonbeating.Thisleadsto
destroyingthechildsselfesteemandtheirrelationshipwiththeparent.Insteadofgivingthe
childguidanceastohowtoimproveinthefuture,theparentisonlysendingthemessagethatthe
childisbad.However,thechildmostlikelydidntconnectthatmisbehavingwasgoingto
destroytheTVandtheyneedtolearnfromthenaturalconsequencessothebehaviorisnt
repeated.AccordingtoTheMarriageandFamilyExperience,80percentoftheperpetratorsof
childmaltreatmentwereparents(Strong&Cohen,2014,p.456).Thisshowshowhighofarisk
parentsareforabusingtheirchildren,especiallyconsideringhowprevalentofanissuechild
abuseis.Naturalconsequenceshelpthechildtogrowasapersonwithoutfearingtheirparents
anditcanpreventchildabuse.

WorksCited
Strong,B,&Cohen,T.F.(2014).TheMarriageandFamilyExperience:Intimaterelationships
inachangingsociety(12thed.).Belmont,CA:Wadsworth.

Potrebbero piacerti anche