Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Website price:85.50
I have been waiting for a book like this for a long time. George Chryssides has written a really fine piece of
scholarship about the Jehovahs Witnesses. The book is comprehensive, scientific, interesting, and easy to
follow. I recommend it to students and scholars alike.
Liselotte Frisk, Dalarna University, Sweden
This is a book that gives us a wealth of information about one of the best-known, yet relatively unknown, of
the many minority religions that have spread throughout the globe over the past century and a half.
Professor Chryssides takes us from the origins of the Jehovahs Witnesses right up to the present day,
indicating the changes that have taken place along the way. We learn about the Witnesses beliefs and
practices, some of the more controversial of these (refusal of blood transfusions, proselytising, and
conscientious objection) being discussed in a critical, yet always empathetic, manner. Particularly masterful
is the way Chryssides guides us through the maze of dates and prophecies that have given rise to
confusion not only for the outsider but also for many of the Witnesses themselves. Written with admirable
clarity, the book provides absorbing material for a wide range of readers.
Eileen Barker, Inform, UK
Jehovahs Witnesses is a remarkable feat in both scope and depth of analysis. In clear and fluent prose,
Chryssides explains continuity and change in the Watch Tower Society, exploring everything from its
nineteenth century origins and modern rites of passage to its complex eschatology and twenty-first century
challenges. With this book Chryssides cements his reputation as one of the worlds leading scholars of the
organisation.
Zoe Knox, University of Leicester, UK
Finally, in this long-awaited book, George Chryssides sums up in one volume decades of activities as the
leading European expert on Jehovahs Witnesses. He analyses their historical roots, and discusses
significant recent changes in the Watch Tower organisation. A seminal book, which will define the field of
the scholarly study of Jehovahs Witnesses for years to come.
Massimo Introvigne, Pontifical Salesian University, Torino, Italy and Managing Director of CESNUR (Center
for Studies on New Religions)
Finally - an empathetic but non-partisan history of the Jehovahs Witnesses in sociological perspective.
Chryssides challenges many of our deeply held misconceptions about this fascinating old/new religious
movement.
Susan Palmer, McGill University, Canada
Copyrighted Material
hg
ate
.co
Contents
.co
as
m
as
hg
ate
Introduction
ix
xi
.co
ate
m
as
hg
5 Opposition
.co
6 Organisation
25
49
77
105
125
145
as
hg
ate
The Bible
as
hg
ate
.co
2 Origins
ate
.co
.co
11
195
223
m
as
10 Prophecy
171
245
as
hg
ate
.co
Glossary
275
Bibliography
277
Index299
Copyrighted Material
Copyrighted Material
hg
ate
.co
Introduction
as
as
hg
ate
as
hg
ate
.co
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
as
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
as
Despite the profusion of books on Jehovahs Witnesses, there are few serious
academic studies, and the last substantial work was James Beckfords The Trumpet
of Prophecy in 1975. Much has happened to the Watch Tower Society since then,
and this present book seeks to bring things more up to date. Taking the theme
of Continuity and Change, this study aims to explore the origins of the Society,
how it has developed over the past century and a quarter, and the reasons for
its changes. I have tried to combine historical and thematic approaches or in
scholars jargon synchronic and diachronic methods of study, since changes
which have occurred in the Societys history relate to specific themes.
Unlike the majority of popular writings on the Jehovahs Witnesses, this
study does not aim to criticise the organisation, but to attempt to understand
its origins and development in an empathetic which is not the same as
sympathetic manner. Those who want to find criticisms of the Watch
Tower Societys teachings and practices can readily find these elsewhere. The
background to the research and methodological issues are discussed in the
opening chapter, after which Chapter 2 endeavours to explore the background
of its founder-leader, principally in the Second Adventist tradition. Chapter 3
provides a profile of Charles Taze Russell, and how the organisation he started
distanced itself from Adventism, displaying distinctive features that made it stand
out from other Adventist groups. As Max Weber contended, religious groups
move from being loose followings of charismatic leaders to institutionalised
organisations. Chapter 4 discusses how Russells successor Joseph Franklin
Rutherford brought the organisation from being a loose federation of ecclesias
to a unified establishment. From its inception, the Watch Tower Society proved
controversial in many ways, and under Rutherfords leadership it became
even more so. This may be partly attributed to Rutherfords personality, but
it was also due to the world wars, and the Societys stance on armed conflict,
conscription and patriotism. Chapter 5 explores how the Society fared in these
war years, and particularly how the Bible Students stood against Hitler and
the Nazi regime. Chapter 6 explores further organisational developments and
innovations under the leadership of Nathan H. Knorr, the third president, and
how the Jehovahs Witnesses became better trained for their publishing work.
Central to the Jehovahs Witnesses worldview is, of course, the Bible. Chapter 7
discusses the Societys methods of biblical interpretation, and the translation
work that resulted in the organisations New World Translation a project with
Jehovahs Witnesses
as
as
h
as
h
ga
te.
co
ga
te.
co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
as
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
which Frederick W. Franz, who became the fourth president, was particularly
involved. Most, if not all, religious organisations involve two important aspects:
how to live ones life, and how to worship and perform rites of passage; hence
Chapters 8 and 9 deal respectively with these two themes. Religions also
typically promise important goals, and hence Chapter 10 deals with prophetic
expectations, and the Societys views on biblical chronology which underlie
these themes on which there is much popular misunderstanding. Finally, the
last chapter examines a number of outstanding problems facing the Jehovahs
Witnesses today, and how they perceive their future and the future of the world
in the light of their understanding of scripture.
A fuller discussion of methodology is in the first main chapter, but a number
of smaller points need to be mentioned by way of clarification. In the course of
writing a major publication, most authors seek comments and criticisms from
a variety of sources, and this has here included Jehovahs Witnesses themselves.
While their comments have enabled me to consolidate this book, I should
emphasise that their suggestions have been considered, but by no means always
been adopted. There are inevitable differences between outsiders and insiders,
and this has sometimes involved difficulties about how one expresses ones ideas.
In some places I have stated that the Watch Tower Society forbids or prohibits
certain practices, and Jehovahs Witnesses have pointed out that they do not
themselves prohibit anything, but rather it is the Bible that does so. While I
understand their position, I cannot endorse it, since other Bible-believing
Christians would think differently, and a congregation has the power, which it
sometimes exercises, to discipline its members.
A further terminological issue arose when Watch Tower researchers
examined my text, and recommended that I should use the expression Jehovahs
Witnesses hold that Rather than The Watch Tower Society teaches that .
This is a complex issue to which that is no ideal solution. For a start, one can
only use the term Jehovahs Witnesses without anachronism when discussing
the period after 1931 and even then, as my discussion will make clear, not all
Witnesses initially followed this convention. On the one hand, I acknowledge
that it is only people who can hold beliefs, not legally incorporated institutions.
On the other hand, not all Jehovahs Witnesses know all of the Societys
teachings a point which became thoroughly apparent when trying to unravel
their biblical chronology in the course of my research. In general, therefore, I
have used expressions like Jehovahs Witnesses teach that where I believe it
is a reasonable expectation that such teachings are known and widely held, and
phrases like The Watch Tower Society teaches in referring to ideas that are
expressed in their literature. Obviously, this is not a clear distinction, since in
many instances Jehovahs Witnesses affirm what is in their Societys publications.
A further problem relates to the Watch Tower Societys teachings regarding
the Bible. Not only is the Society committed to accepting biblical inerrancy,
Introduction
as
as
hg
ate
as
hg
ate
.co
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
as
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
but it has its own views on the authorship and dating of biblical books, which
go against current trends in more liberal biblical scholarship. For example,
the Society teaches that Moses wrote the book of Job, that Paul wrote all the
letters attributed to him, including Hebrews (which makes no claim to Pauline
authorship), that the gospel writers Matthew and John were Jesus disciples
bearing those names, and that one single author by the name of John penned
the gospel, the three letters bearing his name, and the Book of Revelation. For
simplicity of exposition I have employed oratio obliqua in my text and avoided
clumsy circumlocutions like the letter to the Ephesians, which the Society
attributes to Paul. My task here is not to call into question Jehovahs Witnesses
understanding of the Bible, but rather to clarify it. Any readers who wish to
pursue questions relating to biblical authorship are advised to consult a reputable
Bible commentary, of which there are many.
The Watch Tower Society has used different editions of the Bible in its
publications, and continues to do so even today. In quoting the Bible, my practice
has been to quote from the King James (Authorised) Version when providing
exposition of older events and people, and quoting from the 2013 New World
Translation when the Societys own version is needed for exposition. Older
versions of the New World Translation are only used when quoting the Societys
older publications, thus leaving quotations intact, as the reader should expect.
It should be clear that, in expounding the Jehovahs Witnesses own ideas
on theology and biblical exegesis, I am not endorsing them. For the sake
of readability, I have refrained from constantly prefacing exposition with
Jehovahs Witnesses believe that or similar expressions, but again used oratio
obliqua. Similarly, the word pagan in the text is not to be understood in the
scholarly sense of earth-centred spirituality, but as false religion, and I have
followed the Watch Tower Societys convention of using lower casing. Although
scholars of new religions are often referred to as cult apologists, I am relying
on intelligent readers to discern between Watch Tower teachings and my own
personal opinions.
Regarding biblical matters, as time has progressed biblical knowledge has
tended to wane. The older Watch Tower literature seems to assume a detailed
understanding of the Bible which it would be unreasonable to expect today.
With the academic teaching of religion extending far beyond theology and
biblical studies, as it once did, even among colleagues one often finds scant
knowledge of the biblical narrative. To facilitate understanding of some of the
Watch Tower Societys teachings, I have at times provided exposition of some
of the Bibles contents. If I have erred on the side of over-explaining, I can only
apologise to those readers whose knowledge of scripture surpasses that of the
majority of students, and even some colleagues.
There is a normal expectation that a twenty-first-century author uses
inclusive language. While I have endeavoured to do so throughout the text, there
Jehovahs Witnesses
as
as
h
as
h
ga
te.
co
ga
te.
co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
as
hg
ate
.co
m
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
Copyrighted Material
Copyrighted Material
.co
Index
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
hg
as
.co
ate
hg
as
.co
ate
hg
as
.co
ate
Amos 28
Ancient of Days 27
ancient worthies 90, 258
angels 27, 57, 76, 86, 93, 107, 148, 1545,
184, 200, 226
animals 32, 69, 151, 153, 187, 1912, 220
anointed class 956, 130, 1323, 141, 143,
184, 194, 21920, 226, 235, 238,
252, 256, 258, 267, 26970; see also
144,000
Antichrist 227
antisemitism 11314
apocalypse 334, 119, 239
Apocrypha 135
apologetics 22
apostasy
of JWs 11, 17, 20, 83, 193, 197, 227,
266
of the church 34, 52, 589, 86, 96, 106,
145, 148, 186, 195, 202, 255, 271
April Fools Day 195
archaeology 150
Arianism 154
Armageddon 5, 20, 93, 100, 107, 118,
144, 170, 171, 184, 194, 215, 226,
23941, 247, 256, 258, 259, 261,
269, 2713
assemblies 94, 102, 120, 135, 142, 195,
2079, 212
Assembly Halls 2078, 272
atonement 44, 47, 53, 72, 145, 1567, 161
Day of Atonement 38, 41, 70, 132,
208
Awake! 92, 123, 142, 164, 178, 188, 190,
191, 192, 195, 246, 249, 251, 264
ate
Babel 197
Copyrighted Material
Jehovahs Witnesses
Copyrighted
Material
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
Bornkamm, G. 150
Bowen, Christopher 34, 45, 237
Bowen, William H. 2645
brainwashing 17
Brenneisen, E.W. 77
Brooklyn (as headquarters) 10, 18, 67, 84,
86, 100, 131, 134, 189, 207, 283,
247, 250, 264, 268, 270
brother (as term for male JW) 20, 53, 54, 98,
129, 138, 139, 180, 224, 250, 268
Brown, Ian 16
Brown, John Aquila 334
Bryan, Elmer 68
Bultmann, R, 150
Burgess, A.E. 77
Byatt, Anthony 13
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
as
hg
ate
.co
ate
Babylon
figuratively 6, 39, 52, 54, 57, 75, 93,
175, 1969, 234, 269, 271
historically 26, 2930, 33, 36, 83, 87,
111, 151, 1969, 216, 22930, 236,
2545
bad associations 11, 105, 141, 176, 246
Balfour Declaration 114
Ball, Rose 66, 73
baptism 5, 20, 30, 46, 54, 56, 74, 78, 96, 109,
121, 127, 133, 135, 138, 179, 1813,
195, 207, 21016, 221, 252, 271
Baptist churches 35, 42, 46, 75, 88, 161, 213
Barber, Carey 269
Barbour, Nelson H. 289, 33, 345, 456,
51, 59, 161
Barchas-Lichtenstein, Jena 14
Barclay, William 165
Barry, Lloyd 268
Bates, Joseph 38
beasts 267, 30, 35, 37, 44, 93, 100, 234; see
also mark of the beast
Beckford, James 1, 10, 272
Bender, J.J. 56, 160
Berger, Peter 21
Beth Sarim 89, 236
Bethel xi, 8, 16, 18, 52, 57, 67, 78, 812, 84,
86, 100102, 113, 134, 142, 171,
189, 207, 233, 250, 264
Bibelforscher 113, 11516
Bible Students 1, 8, 25, 41, 46, 513, 567,
73, 75, 7980, 845, 91, 1056,
10810, 116, 1256, 151, 160, 198,
202, 206, 20910, 213, 2256, 234,
245, 269
Bible study 49, 54, 57, 61, 66, 133, 137,
173, 206, 218
birth control, see contraception
birthdays 90, 105, 195, 199, 200201
blood transfusion 12, 16, 105, 187, 1913,
2667
Blunden, S.O. 68
Board of Directors 66, 68, 141
Bohnet, J.A. 65, 79, 161
book study 137, 206
.co
300
Copyrighted Material
Index Material
Copyrighted
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
.co
ate
301
Dabney, A.B. 79
Daniel 268, 324, 367, 436, 48, 58,
148, 150, 155, 191, 226, 22933,
2389, 241
Darby, J.N. 589, 228
Darwinism 151, 153
Dawson, Andrew 19
deacon 80, 1257, 130, 139; see also
ministerial servant
deaconess 126
Copyrighted Material
Jehovahs Witnesses
Copyrighted
Material
302
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
.co
ate
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
.co
ate
death 26, 35, 42, 43, 44, 61, 64, 73, 75, 110,
153, 1578, 1723, 1834, 193,
195, 201, 212, 217, 221, 249, 258
DeCecca, Giovanni 87
Declaration of Facts, aka Wilmersdorf
Declaration 11314
demons 169, 1845, 187
Devil 100, 114, 155, 199, 2545, 257, 259
disassociation 11, 13
discipline 2, 18, 1289, 139, 253
disfellowshipping 11, 12, 19, 21, 46, 100,
101, 112, 13941, 174, 181, 190,
193, 2534, 265, 266, 268
dispensationalism 30, 589, 612, 228,
256, 258
Divine Plan of the Ages 58, 61, 69, 211, 231
divorce 21, 105, 115, 181, 182
door-to-door ministry see house-to-house
ministry
doubles, theory of 34, 228, 232, 238
drugs 140, 171, 176, 249
Copyrighted Material
Index Material
Copyrighted
Gilead School of Ministry, aka Watchtower
Bible College of Gilead, 1345
globalisation 15, 112, 245
Gobitas case 100, 112
Golden Age 92, 97, 114, 136, 18690, 237
Goodrich, Roy D. 189
Gordon, David 20
Gospel Age 30, 39, 69, 713, 228, 23032,
238, 256
Governing Body 4, 12, 18, 133, 1414, 164,
169, 172, 1745, 180, 193, 209,
242, 248, 252, 266, 26870
great crowd 90, 936, 1323, 142, 143,
184, 194, 219, 220, 226, 247, 250,
269, 271
Great Disappointment 38, 45, 50, 229, 231
great multitude, see great crowd
Great Pyramid 624, 232, 233, 251
great tribulation 93, 95, 226
Greber, Johannes 16970
Grew, Henry 414, 50
Gruss, Edmond C, 12, 1356, 255, 237
Guard, F.G. 83
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
as
hg
.co
ate
303
Copyrighted Material
Jehovahs Witnesses
Copyrighted
Material
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
as
h
ga
te.
co
Karaites 378
Ksemann, E. 150
Kelly, Richard E. 18
Keturah 712
kinds, theory of 153
King, Christine 117
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
as name of a month 97
as personal name of God 167, 199, 207
as transliteration of YHWH 1634,
1667
Jeremiah 3940, 63, 69, 95, 232
Jesus, see also Christ
historical 14950
teachings of 30, 378, 42, 70, 76, 83,
106, 117, 123, 124, 128, 137, 157,
159, 179, 182, 184, 191, 2067,
213, 220, 252, 255, 269
Jewish Age 59, 62, 71, 228, 23033, 256, 268
Jews
calendar 37, 967, 156, 218, 22831,
234, 238
festivals 4041, 202, 2078, 218, 221
law 41, 69, 157, 192
under Nazis 10, 11316
restoration of 33, 3940, 107, 227, 232
Joachim of Fiore 32
John the Baptist 71, 74, 156, 201, 211,
215
Johnson, Paul S.L. 7984, 86, 189
Jolly, Raymond G. 84
Jonadabs 946, 99, 1323; see also great
crowd, other sheep
Jonsson, Carl Olof 32, 2678
jubilee 89, 229, 231, 2368
Judas Iscariot 101, 126, 132, 220
judgement
investigative 26, 95, 256
last 268, 334, 38, 40, 42, 73, 945,
100, 215, 226, 2558, 26061
judicial committee 128, 13940, 181, 248,
253, 264
judicial reproof 13940, 181, 265
jury service 175
.co
304
Copyrighted Material
Index Material
Copyrighted
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
as
hg
ate
.co
.co
ate
305
Copyrighted Material
Jehovahs Witnesses
Copyrighted
Material
as
hg
hg
ate
.co
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
ate
.co
306
Copyrighted Material
Index Material
Copyrighted
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
h
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
307
Copyrighted Material
Jehovahs Witnesses
Copyrighted
Material
308
.co
ate
hg
as
.co
ate
hg
.co
as
hg
hg
as
.co
ate
ate
.co
as
Unitarianism 42
United Nations 88
Ussher, James 29, 35
ga
te.
co
as
hg
ate
.co
as
hg
ate
as
h
Copyrighted Material