Dilemma Responses

Directions:
Identify Pro Stealing claims (should steal) by circling it and
labeling it ProC
Identify Con Stealing claims (should not steal) by circling it and
labeling it ConC
Identify Reasons by underlining them and labeling them R

Which morality stage is the

response? Why?

Heinz should not steal the medicine, because he will consequently

be put in prison. Stealing is a crime and is not worth the
consequence.
Everyone has a right to choose life, regardless of the law. If someone
was lying on the sidewalk injured on the other side of the road, but
there was a dont walk sign, technically it would be breakign the
law to go help them, but they deserve help just like Heinzs wife
deserves the right to live like all people. Heinz should steal the drug.

Heinz should steal the medicine, because he will be much happier if

he saves his wife. If he doesnt steal it, his wife will die and he would
be miserable. If he does steal it, there is a chance that he wont get
caught and he can live happily with his wife and even if he does, he
will still get the benefit of saving the person he loves who can still
visit him in prison.

The law prohibits stealing making it illegal. Also, the pharmasist has
the right to charge what he wants for the drug and requires the
apporpriate amount of money for it. Heinz should not steal the drug.

Heinz should steal the medicine, because saving a human life is a

more fundamental value than the property rights of another person.
Even if it wasnt his wife who was dying, Heinz should still steal the
drug to save anoter life even it it means sacrificing his freedom. Life
is a universal human right.

Heinz should steal the drug. It will show his wife how much he loves
her. All of his friends and family will think he is the best guy ever.
News reporters might even write a story about what a loving and
devoted husband he is. He might even become husband of the year.
He should definitely steal the drug to save his wife and look
awesome.

50/50
Correctly Identify Pro
Stealing claims (should
steal) by circling it and
labeling it ProC

45/50
Recheck your
identification of 1-2 claims
and reasoning
The author might

40/50
Recheck your
identification of 1-2 claims
and reasoning
The author might

35/50
Recheck your
identification of 3-4 claims
and reasoning
The author might

30/50
Recheck your
identification of 3-4 claims
and reasoning
The author might

Correctly Identify Con

Stealing claims (should
not steal) by circling it and
labeling it ConC
Correctly Identify Reasons
by underlining them and
labeling them R
Correctly explain which
morality stage is the
response? Explain: Why?

not always start

with the claim
Remember: ProC
= should steal
Remember:
ConC= should
not steal

not always start

with the claim
Remember: ProC
= should steal
Remember:
ConC= should
not steal

not always start

with the claim
Remember: ProC
= should steal
Remember:
ConC= should
not steal

OR

AND

AND

Refer to your notes to see

which morality stage
matches best
Or
Make sure you fully
explain why you chose
that morality stage

Refer to your notes to see

which morality stage
matches best
Or
Make sure you fully
explain why you chose
that morality stage

Refer to your notes to see

which morality stage
matches best
Or
Make sure you fully
explain why you chose
that morality stage

not always start

with the claim
Remember: ProC
= should steal
Remember:
ConC= should
not steal

AND
Refer to your notes to see
which morality stage
matches best
AND
Make sure you fully
explain why you chose
that morality stage