INFORMATION YATE oF comecreur TTT Dawn neat ‘superion court crs-teag47ar14 Connecticut State Police Wester Distet Major Crime _|N690 Title, Allegation and Counts Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport, cau povenied The undersigned Prosecuting 442 Aldine Avenue Bridgeport, CT oararroea | fhaunderigned prowscting | “oe d Toe) Gesanat_——] Coote elt Stee of Connecticut, Bridgeport ecu shages that aa TTR atone oa Murder ron ora ic otcrntetere| Bridgeport [August , 2015 State a Murder ee ra OTT Bridgeport [August 4, 2015 sta.50 re ec ‘Murder with Special Creumstances nn — TIS IT Bridgeport [August 4, 2015 530-407) Cl ewoterseate wt ce 7g g — eee Court Action el cS er a i os [Gel cer uy Creme CRacaanar [amor a Pea leh mana ee toe cen 1 2 3 =r pean Five Cove: [Sietene Crean man [Fatt atti tit Se Saree OR gee sae a ae TRI ar TET PEAT arINFORMATION STATE oF connecriouT Sa ‘SUPERIOR COURT (ors-1-00479714 Connecticut Stats Police Weston District Major Crime [N20 Arrest Warrant SSE 2 [state ot Connecticutvs. Navin, Kyle W. ‘To: Any Proper fcr ofthe State of Connecticut By Authority of he State of Connect you are hereby commanded to arestthe body of the witin-named accused. (al that ape) EA. Accused is ordered tobe beught before a ler or assistant clerk ofthe Superior Cour. Dy 8. Accused isnot ented to bi WA. Bor both are checked above, you shall without unde delay bring the arested person before the lr ‘or assistant cer ofthe Superior Court forthe geographical area where the offense f allaged o have been ommited, orf the clerk’ effee's not open oa corxmunty coreconal center within said geographical ‘area or the nearest community corectional cen ino such center exists inthe geographical area, of the Corectonal nsttuton, a5 the case may be, a (6 vai seta 2, 500,000. to “Ys ste) a [1 0. Nor-manclal conatons of lease [LE Conditions of velease not determined by court By the Court ene ee Ps Lae aaa a i Return On Arrest Warrant Sapam Tomnt Fear tla® lz [ais [state of Connecticut “Than an We by Vue of hewn ard Begin Gonplan and ware, Tari We body ofthe wit-vared accused and vad the sume n he beating of sal accused and have sa czused hee in aut or exanaon, ae 659- womt. te ‘ter Gout acon “eaeARREST WARRANT APPLICATION For Court Use Ovi en ne STATE oF connecricur pmuans Eee come al von Na Creteanera74 [Connecticut Stat PolceWestem Disict Mor Crime | NE30 Navin, Kyle Bridgeport extgepont [tae ‘Application For Arrest Warrant “To: A Judge of he Superior Court “The undersigned hereby apples fora warrant forthe arrest ofthe above-named accused onthe basis ofthe facts setforth nthe: Afidavt Below TRAGER CoRR ANNE z Lia] 2p aitfavid I “Te inersigned aan. ang cy snr, depose and says 1. |, Detective Thomas Kiely # 905, am a sworn member of the Connecticut State Poli Department and have been for the last 15 years. | am currently assigned to the Westem District ‘Major Crime Squad at Troop °G" in Bridgeport, CT. | have investigated numerous ctimes including ‘but not limited to larcenies, robberies, assaults, sexual assaults, and homicides. | have knowledge of the facts and circumstances hereinafter related as a result of my own investigative efforts, as well ‘as those of other officers acting in their official capacity who have related their findings to me. 2. On August 7, 2016, Laura Thompson went to the Easton Police Department to report that Jeffrey Navin (DOB: 3/24/59) and Jeanette Navin (DOB: 2/1/60) of 77 Staples Road in Easton, CT had not been seen since August 4, 2015. Thompson is Jeffrey Navin's sister. Thompson stated Jeffrey ‘owns J8,J Refuse Company, and that the refuse along his route had not been collected over the last two (2) days. 3. Thompson also stated te last known contact with the couple had been on the moming of Tuesday, August 4, 2015 when Jeffrey and Jeanette had reportedly visited their son, Kyle Navin in Bridgeport 4. Thompson was accomparied by her sister-indaw, Annie Navin. Annie Navin is married to Wiliam Navin, Jeffrey's brother. Wiliam Navin was unable to go to the Easton Police Department, however, he asked Annie to relay that Jeffrey never missed his route, She also relayed that Jeffrey Navin's cell phone was turned off which was out ofthe ordinary. It was further stated that Jeffrey never told anyone that he and his wife were going on any trips and usually leaves his son, Kyle, in charge of the route while he is away. 5. On August 7, 2015, Officer Lyman called both Jeffrey's and Jeanette's cell phones multiple times. (ai nge ff 27 ge Adet) Finding “The foregoing Applicaton for an arestwarrant, and afidavi(s) altace to said Application, having been submited to and Conaidered by the Uncersigned the undersigned fins rom said afhdav(s) thal there is probable cause to belleve that Sin offense has bsen comrated and tha the aocused commited tad, tretoe, tet probable cause its or he iScuance ofa warrant forthe avest ofthe above-names accused Semel Prue’ [pse/s] ee halen, a[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION pase ate STATE oF connecricur erie sueeRion couRT eebaree PERIOR COL Navn | Bono _Tesiagopon Affidavit - Continued Each time, both phones went straight to voice-mail, An attempt to locate message was sent through, the COLLECT/ NCIC system to surrounding towns to be on the lookout for their vehicle, a blue 2003 Dodge Ram pick-up bearing Connecticut registration 3CY200, which was determined to be ‘missing from the Navins' restdence at 77 Staples Road in Easton, CT. 6. On August 8, 2016, Easton Police Sergeant Spencer applied for an Ex Parte Order to Verizon Wireless for both Jeanette and Jeffrey Navin's cell phone records. Jeanette Navin's Verizon cell phone number is 203-556-5438. Jeffrey Navin's Verizon cell phone number is 203-451-9234. The Ex-Parte Order was granted and the information obtained by the order indicated that Jeanette Navin's last call was on August 4, 2016 at 0845 hours, and Jeffrey Navin's last call was on August 4, 2015 at 1323 hours, It was further noted that both numbers were in "Inactive Status" meaning the phones were not currently powered on, 7. On August 7, 2016, Officer Lyman went to the residence of Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin located at 77 Staples Road in Easton, CT where he spoke with the landlord, Robert Henessey. Henessey allowed Officer Lyman access to the residence to make sure no one was hurt inside. Officer Lyman noted that the house was very clean and there was a "To-Do" list on the refrigerator with various tasks such as unplugging te dehumidifier and tuning off the lights. Officer Lyman noted that nothing else was out of the ordinary. Officer Lyman also noted that parked in the driveway was a white Isuzu work truck and a Mercedes E320. At this time Officer Lyman leamed that the Navin's Dodge Ram pick-up truck was missing from the property. 8, On August 10, 2015, members of the Connecticut State Police Westem District Major Crime ‘Squad (WDMC) along with Easton Police personnel executed a search and seizure warrant on Jeffrey and Jeanette's residence located at 77 Staples Road in Easton. Based upon the condition of the home and its contents, it appeared as though the homeowners intended on retuming. The condition of the home did not suggest that the homeowners were leaving for vacation or even being away for an extended amount of time, such as a long weekend. The beds were unmade, dishes ‘were in the sink, and reading and sun glasses were left on the coffee table. 9, On August 9, 2015, at approximately 1239 hours, the Easton Police Department was notified by Trooper Ring that he located the 2003 Dodge Ram pick-up truck registered to Jeanette Navin. ‘Trooper Ring stated that he located the vehicle at the Exit # 42. commuter parking lot off of Route 16 in Westport. Trooper Ring stated that the vehicle had a shattered front passenger side window Which appeared to have occurred at that location. Chief Shaw and Captain Doyle of the Easton Police Department responded and had the vehicle tovied back to the Easton Police Department. 410. JP Morgan Chase reported the last transaction on Jeanette Navin's account was on August 3, (spoon 2 27 oe Ao) eee eee[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION ae Cee ee ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport cease Affidavit - Continued 2015, at 1331 hours, at the Easton Post Office. Fairfield County Bank reported the last transaction fon Jeanette Navin's account was on August 3, 2015, for a deposit of $235.00 in response to a search warrant that was issued on August 10, 2018 for Jeffery and Jeanette Navin's financial accounts for Fairfield County Bank along with JP Morgan Chase Bank. 11. During the course of the investigation, investigators learned that Kyle Navin, the son of Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin, is empbyed in the family refuse business. Kyle Navin resides at 142 Aldine ‘Avenue in Bridgeport with his girftiend, Jennifer Valiante, 42. Investigators also detemmined that the residence at 142 Aldine Avenue in Bridgeport was purchased by Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin in cash for their son, Kyle. The residence is in Kyle's name. A post-it note in the business ledger/checkbook labeled "Kyle owes" showed indebtedness in the amount of $133,000. 13. On August 12, 2016, Easton Police Captain Doyle conducted a Gun Registration and Pistol Permit check for Kyle Navin. The search revealed that Kyle Navin was issued a State of Connecticut Pistol Permit #1023282 on February 1, 2013. It further revealed that Kyle Navin has two (2) guns registered to fim: A Sig Sauer P29" 40 caliber handgun (SIN: AJUO1140) and a Smith & Wesson 86380 .380 caliber (SIN: EBX6587) 14, Investigators also delermined that both Kyle Navin and Jennifer Valiante have a history of substance abuse. 418. During the execution of a search and seizure warrant at the residence of Kyle Navin and Jennifer Valiante at 142 Aldine Avenue, Bridgeport on August 18, 2015 detectives located humerous items indicative of substance abuse. They recovered approximately fifteen (15) hypodermic needles and dzens of glassine bags that contained what appeared to be heroin residue mixed with papenwor< in the name of Kyle Navin. Detectives also recovered approximately two (2) dazen empty pressiption bottles for Oxycodone, the great majority of which were prescribed to Kyle Navin, and several prescription botles containing various other controlled substances 16. The Easton Police Department received an anonymous tip on August 20, 2015 from a caller ‘who stated that Kyle Navin had recently been dismissed from his back treatment program at the Pain & Spine Specialists of Connecticut due to his use of heroin. WOMC detectives then executed a search and seizure warrant for Kyle's medical records at the Pain & Spine Specialists of Connecticut, LLC, located in Trumbull, Upon review of the medical records it was confirmed that Kyle Navin tested positive for heroin on June 2, 2015, and shortly thereafter, he was released from ofa i Pele 7[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE oF connecticut cesta ‘SUPERIOR COURT vi be a en aa ello ESTERS sessorar Bridgeport |semt ‘Affidavit - Continued the care of the Pain & Spine Specialists for violating the Narcotic Agreement. 17. Kyle Navin's cell phone records show that between July 22, 2015 and August 11, 2015 there are approximately 198 cellular contacts between Kyle's cell phone, and the phone associated with Confidential Witness #1. In an interview with Confidential Witness #1 he admitted that that he deals heroin and after being shown a picture of Kyle Nevin he recognized him as someone who he deals to. He identified Kyle Navin as."K’ and identified Jennifer Valiante as “K's gir.” When shown a Picture of Kyle Navin's blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500 truck he identified it as being “K's truck" Confidential Witness #1 stated that Kyle went from purchasing $140 dollar a day worth of heroin up to $200 - $600 a day within the last few weeks. 18. During the course of the investigation, investigators learned that Kyle Navin had a strained relationship with his parents, Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin that extended over a course of years, 419. On August 10, 2015, Easton Police Officer Ceccarelli interviewed Susan Haven who stated that, she has known the Navins fer fifteen (15) years. Haven stated that the last time she saw Jeanette was on either Wednesday, July 29, or Thursday, July 30, 2018. Haven stated that a that time Jeanette stopped by her house to use the bathroom around 1000 hours, and she was riding along with Kyle doing the trash since he had hurt his back. Haven stated Jeanette told her many times in the past that she had problems with Kyle regarding his use of painkillers, and his failure to pay his property taxes, and other monies owed. Haven further stated that it was very out of character for Jeffery Navin to leave his route incomplete and not cover the rest of the week. 20. On August 10, 2015, Easton Police Officer Ceccarell interviewed Cheryl Churchil who stated that she has known Jeanette Navin for ten (10) years. Churchill stated that the last time she saw and spoke with Jeanette Navin was on Wednesday July 26, 2015, when Jeanette visited her in her office. Churchill stated that Jeanette was very distraught over the situation with Kyle and was crying. Churchill stated that Jeanette discussed how her relationship with Kyle has been very tempestuous and that she suspects Kyle abused drugs. Churchill stated that Jeanette further explained that they bought Kyle a house, and put the house in Kyle's name. Churchill stated that Kyle was falling to pay the mortgage or taxes. Churchill stated that Jeanette also told her that they were cutting Kyle out of their will and that once the business was sold, Kyle would be on his own ‘without any financial suppor from his family 21. On August 12, 2015, Easton Police Captain Doyle went to interview Dominik and Darlene Vento. Among other things, the Vento's stated they had been in negotiations to purchase the Navin's refuse business. Datlene Vento stated that sometime toward the end of June 2015, she received a call from Jeffrey Navin who sounded anxious and desperate. She stated that Jeffrey was (si page dota ge Aon) _ a eS[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT earn surenion court eee PERIOR COL ‘avn Kyte brsegiet Blooper [estate a Affidavit - Continus ‘complaining about Kyle, and how he is not showing up for work and causing problems with the business, 22. Through the course of this investigation, WOMC detectives learned that Jeffrey Navin had a history of being emotionally and verbally abusive towards his son Kyle Navin, including an investigation by the Department of Children and Families (DCT). 23. On September 29, 2015 WDMC Sergeant Pattberg spoke with Kyle's younger brother Taylor ‘Navin who resides in Mississippi. Taylor stated he last received a text message from his mother on August 3, 2015. Taylor stated that the last time he spoke to his father was approximately one (1) Week before he spoke to his mother. Taylor went on to state that during that conversation his father was complaining about Kyle. 24. Taylor stated the relationship between his brother and his parents was "Not good at all" Taylor described the circumstances surrounding the DCF investigation from 2006.Taylor also added that "its always been ike that," aluding to the tumultuous relationship between Kyle and his parents. 25. Taylor was informed that his brother was a person of interest in the disappearance of his parents. Taylor responded by saying, "When I heard my parents were missing | thought to myself. ‘they either went on vacation, or my brother did something to them.” 26. During the course of this investigation, both Kyle Navin and Jennifer Valiente's Apple iPhone's ‘were seized under a searcn and selzure warrant. Both phones were sent to the State Police Computer Crimes Division vinere both phones were examined utilizing Cellebrite technology. An extraction report was completed for both phones and revealed numerous deleted text messages. The following is a series of text message conversations that occurred between Kyle and Jennifer at various dates and times prior to the disappearance of Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin 05/14/2015 ~-Kyle to Jennifer —But I'm trying to get one positive thing out of today between all these bullshit blowout argument with my dad in this fucking job that | can't take anymore with these trucks at least | made a big payment to the credit union and now my balance is much lower than it ‘was and we can work on puting it down and then will be gone before we know it 05/14/2015 Jennifer to Kyle So fuck him 05/14/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —That's what | said | said all good thing you'e selling your house so in two weeks you can follow me on find a driver who does the roots faster just tell you why and he ‘got all pissed off and started cursing me out again saying all this bullshit that | wasn't even listening a Lf Z mene a : = ashe eed Kiivadiat a fs VIOUS.[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION fenen eyo ‘STATE OF CONNECTICUT eae SUPERIOR COURT Sa A soa. a so oo Navin, Kyle W. _ | Bridgeport Bridgeport |ssnsnss 2 Affidavit - Continued to because | was trying not 0 punch him in the face and get arrested because if| do punch him | won't be able to stop 05/14/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer ire me and find a driver* osrai2015 Jennifer to Kyl2 — agree. I'm your ally 05/14/2018 —Kyle to Jennifer —We need to figure out what the best way to take them down whether it is get some money out of them somehow fuck him at the business the house something ‘we got to figure out Im got tobe real smart and do it quick (05/14/2018 —Jennifer to Kyls --Welll igure something out (05/14/2018 —Jennifer to Kyle hat pos has to be in charge of everyone, everything at all times (05/14/2016 —Kyle to Jennifer: ‘up Investigators recovered this exchange of texts from July 8, 2015: 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —1 really ike that idea 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer new garage hat! allow to stay in our house pay for a full top line remodel and 07/08/2018 ~-Kyle to Jennifer —-And have hundreds of thousands to buy my cummins and you a new car and enjoy life taking vacations, having fun with friends no stress no contact ever again with the bad people (07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —Then welll have the 200k credit union, Weston house and j&j profit (07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —'ve been thinking it nonstop since yesterday 71082015 lite Kyle to Jennifer —-It would solve every single problem and give us a wealthy amazing 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer — hink about title one (07/08/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle hear ya. It sounds very good I just don't know = Sp — “Poof eels Of3'5[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION eee Pape Sirerion count Bridgeport Bridgoport retaoer 2 (07/08/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle Did u put them in place for accusing us of hiding 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer They were friendly so nothing was brought up ha o7iear2015 “Jennifer to Kyle —U should regulate that shit 07/08/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle —Haha for real 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —-™m telling you (07/08/2015 Kyle to Jennifer --Wipe out the infection and get $ for life 07/08/2015 ~Kyle to Jennifer —Its perfect plan 07/08/2015 Jennifer to Kyle don't like that they call the shots 07/08/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle —When they “choose” to be friendly its all good but when the choose" to start trouble i's war 07/08/2018 —Jennifer to Kyle --'m realy sick & tired of them controling everything 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer --1 know right 07/08/2015 —kyle to Jennifer --You have only had to deal with for past few years 07/08/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer -~This has been my whole life Investigators recovered this exchange of texts from July 14, 2015; 07/14/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer --You know if they ‘went away"...We could customize a nice ‘Cummins 4 door 5500 with a small 6 yard packer like Malones and take over J&j 07/14/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —Tht way you me and dogs can fit in truck (07/14/2018 —Jennifer to Kyle —I know love 07/14/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle —It would be nice. (sie page 7 27 pe At) * po/ n/a ee yeaa Lo, Site’ th[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT Ree ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport wsvnaus! 2 Affidavit - Continued Investigators recovered this exchange of texts from August 3, 2015: 08/03/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle —Did you ask your mom why she told your dad you were shit talking about comp & your lousy pay (08/03/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer —She said she twisted it (08/03/2015 ~-Jennifer to Kyle He's an asshole then (08/03/2016 —-Jennifer to Kyle —-Did you tell her how you got verbally abuses for having a broken bback & simply asking about tax $ & paycheck 08/03/2015 Kyle to Jennifer —-She knows she was in the office and also closet next room over 08/03/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer — les bra tts’ 08/03/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer: 08/03/2015 Jennifer to Kyle She should control him. That's not right. She's an accessory to the (08/03/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle -~So what's the deal w your pay & tax $ 08/03/2015 —Jennifer to Kyle you don't bug him about it he'll forget about it 08/03/2015 —Kyle to Jennifer Yeah I didn't have a chance to talk to him so | will and push him on ittoday asap (08/09/2015 Kyle to Jennifer —-No more waiting (8103/2015 —Jennter to Kyle —Your mom doesn't know anything? Come on (08/03/2015 Jennifer to Kyle —She's the one who signs the damn check (08/08/2015 Jennifer to Kyle —They'e playing you 0810312015 ~Jennifer to Kyle 1 be they're holding your $300 church check too (1 pon 8 ot 7 page At) SP iucbat Sfp[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION eee .. Surenion cour Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport ridgeport seaman ‘Affidavit - Continued (08/09/2015 —-Jennifer to Kyle ~-Don't feel like you're being pushy. That's your money. When you dont go to work they're on the phone with you nonstop bitching at you. So when they don't pay you should be doing the same thing (08/03/2016 —Kyle to Jennifer —Yup | agree litle gil 08/03/2015 -—Kyle to Jennifer —I would hope not that! be messed up if they were hiding that church one from me all this time 08/03/2015 Jennifer to Kyle~This is how they treat their pen child w a broken back Investigators recovered this exchange of texts from August 4, 2015: (08/04/2015 6:10 PM.—Kyle t Jennifer —What Are you doing? (08/04/2015 6:10 PM ~Kyle to Jennifer~You inside ad get your bike in? (08/04/2015 6:10 PM —Jennifer to Kyjle got my bike inside. I'm just getting a drink (08/04/2015 6:10 PM —Kyle to Jennifer —-Ok just checking love 08/04/2015 6:14 PM Kyle to Jennifer --You hadnt gone to basement have you 08/04/2015 6:15 PM —Jennifer to Kyle —No laundry done earlier (08/04/2015 6:15 PM Kyle to .ennifer Ok thank you litle efficient lover of mine :) 27, Scott Sullivan, the Highway Superintendent for the Town of Westport provided a printout of all the trucks that came into the transfer station from August 4, through August 7, 2015. There were four (4) trucks that used the transfer station on the dates mentioned registered to J&J Refuse. The report indicated that Jeffrey Navin's truck made three (3) drop-offs on August 4, 2016.The last drop off by Jeffrey Navin was at 1228 hours, according to time stamps on the transfer ticket. The records indicated that Kyle's truck, the blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500, did not make any drop offs on August 4, 2018. Easton Police Officer Lyman spoke with Sullivan on August 13, 2015. 28. Bob Meeker, the weigh master of the Westport Transfer Station, noted that on August 4, 2015, at 1228 hours Jeffrey Navin pulled into the weigh scale and was screaming on his cell phone. nine 9 27 poe Alot) “6 120 Laols Bee Le[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT wages ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin Kyle W. | sa ToT (ETERS coepsor Bridgeport Bridgeport oes Affidavit - Continued Meeker stated that he did nct know who Jeffrey Navin was talking to or what the conversation was, about, but it was ‘very heated." Meeker stated that when Jeffrey Navin left the transfer station, he was stil screaming on the phone. It should be noted, after reviewing Jeffrey Navin's cell phone records, the only people he contacted or attempted to contact during this time frame was Kyle Navin's cell phone or the J& Refuse businessilandline number which is located at his home in, Easton. Easton Police Office: Cecoarelli spoke to Mecker on August 10, 2016. 29. During the course of this investigation detectives obtained and analyzed call, text, and cell site records for Jeffrey Navin, Jeanette Navin, and Kyle Navin's cellular telephones. Review of these records demonstrates that on August 4, 2015, from 0920 hours through 1323 hours, Jeffrey Navin, made approximately eighty-ive (85) cellular calls or texts to Kyle, Jeanette, or the J&J Refuse business/nome number. 30, An analysis of Jeanette's records established that Jeanette's last outgoing call was on August 4, 2016, at approximately 0845 hours, and was a two (2) second call to her husband. At approximately (0920 hours, Jeanette's cellular telephone registered as being in the area of a cell tower at 2600 Park Avenue in Bridgeport, which is close to Kyle's residence. It should be noted that Jeanette's cellular telephone had one (1) additional cell tower registration in Easton on August 4, 2015 at 1508 hours. This was not a call, and later found to be a data event. After that time, Jeanette's cellular telephone was never used to communicate with anyone in any manner. 31. An analysis of Jeffrey's records established that he made approximately 63 calls to Jeanette ‘and Kyle Navin throughout the moming and early afternoon of August 4, 2015. Jeffrey's last ‘outgoing call was placed to Kyle Navin at approximately 1323 hours. During the call, Jeffrey's cellular telephone accessed the cell ower at 2600 Park Avenue in Bridgeport, inthe vicinity of Kyle Navin's residence. Cell records indicate that Kyle Navin was also accessing the same cell tower, indicative that he was also at his residence at that time. After that time, Jeffrey's cell phone was ‘tured off and was never used again to communicate with anyone in any manner. 32. The cell records indicate that after 0845 hours on Jeanette's phone, and after 1323 hours on Jeffrey's phone, there were several incoming calls to both their cellular telephones. However, both, ‘Jeffrey and Jeanette's cellular telephones were in ‘Inactive Status," meaning that they had been turned off. 33, During the course of the investigation Easton Police Officer Lyman seized video surveillance from a residence located at ‘33 Center Road in Easton. This video depicts: a vehicle matching the description of Kyle Navin's blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500 traveling east along Center Road at 0911, hours on August 4, 2015 away from Staples Road; Kyle Navin's vehicle again traveling east along (npg 10092 o0g0 Mit) Soar to. 130 L201 A tags ipf30fs rai Par aT icc! hf: a Taz[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT eae eens ‘SUPERIOR COURT a aA RT : Te aT ERAS] Havin Ke | Bridgeport Bridgeport | sata ‘Affidavit - Continued Center Road away from Staples Road at 1256 hours; Jeffrey Navin's Isuzu truck traveling west along Center Road towards Staples Road followed by a black Honda Civic later identified as that of Jennifer Valiente at 1506 hours; Jennifer Valiente's black Honda Civic traveling east on Center Road away from Staples Road at 1535 hours. it should be noted that Jennifer confirmed that Kyle was the front seat passenger in her vehicle at ths time. 34, The cell site activity and text messages exchanged between Kyle and his father on August 4, 2015, together with other evidence developed in the investigation, establish a timeline. This evidence establishes the knewn whereabouts of the phones of Kyle Navin, Jeffrey Navin, Jeanette ‘Navin, and Jennifer Valiente and the locations of vehicles belonging to Jeffrey Navin, Kyle Navin, and Jennifer Valiente. Verizon Wireless cell phone records obtained for Kyle Navin's cell phone indicated the following text messages sent between Kyle and Jeffrey Navin's cell phones. The text message and video times are for the day of August 4, 2015. VIDEO: 0911 hours Kyle's blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500 traveling east along Center Road, Easton away from Staples Road TEXT: 11:40 aim. -~Kyle to Jeffrey —What cleanup are you at? TEXT: 11:46 am, —Kyle to Jeffrey Cleanup address? Can you write it? TEXT: 12:34 p.m. —Jeffrey fo Kyle —Where are you? TEXT. 12:34 p.m. —Kyle to Jeffrey —I™m clicking to answer your call and nothing is there. | can't hear you, TEXT: 12:35 p.m. -Kyle to Jeffrey ~I left. You were dumping then heading home right? TEXT: 12:37 p.m. —Kyle to Jeffrey --That's where I'm headed TEXT: 12:39 p.m. —Jeffey to Kyle —'m not going home til| know mom is okay. TEXT: 12:42 p.m. —Jeffrey to Kyle —-Did you hurt mom? TEXT: 12:43 pm. No absolutely not. Why would you think TEXT: 12:44 p.m, |. go home and get framed for murder TEXT: 12:45 p.m. ‘Oh stop TEXT: 12:48 p.m, im going to the police first TEXT: 12:50 p.m. ~-Kyle to Jeffrey —Ok and reason being? TEXT: 1251 pm. —sletfrey to Kyle —Dave's phone is working fine TEXT. 12:54 p.m. —Kyle to Jeffrey Ok well mines having issues, moms is and jen was able to text, the calling was messed up, TEXT: 12:54 p.m. —Kyle to Jeffrey —Maybe his is newest TEXT. 12:54 p.m, —Kyle to Jeffrey —Newer VIDEO: 1256 hours -Kyle's vehicle traveling east along Center Road, away from Staples Road. TEXT: 12:57 p.m. Jeffrey to Kyle —U R setting me up TEXT: 12:58 p.m. —Kyle to Jeffrey ~-Dad really what are you talking about? osm “rola dani, ora iefseASRESTUARUANTAPPUCATIN spor onmeonor eee ees Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport ramet fd: Contnued TEXT: filme Kyoto eey-mhome ef a poo eros fr your tuck VIDEO: 1506 hours -Jeffrey Navin's Isuzu truck traveling west along Center Road towards Staples Road followed by Valiente's black Honda Civic. VIDEO: 1535 hours -Valiante's black Honda Civic traveling east on Center Road away from Staples Road, 35. During the execution of a search warrant at the residence of Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin in Easton on August 18, 2015, IWDMC Detectives seized numerous exhibits including DNA exemplars. (Voothbrushes) of both Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin, 36. WOMC detectives discovered two (2) bullet holes in the front passenger seat of Kyle's blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500 during the execution of a search warrant on the vehicle on August 14, 2015, ‘The portion of the seat belt which would cross the passenger's chest also had a bullet hole in it, suggesting there was a person seated in the front passenger seat, with the seat belt engaged, When at least one (1) of the two (2) rounds were fired. Further processing of said vehicle revealed that there was bloodike transfer on the front leading edge of the driver's seat. A presumptive test for the presence of blood resulted in positive findings, 37. The forensic laboratory generated a DNA Report pertaining to evidence seized during the Course of this investigation. The report indicated that known DNA samples of Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin were examined and compared to blood like stains seized from Kyle Navin's vehicle. A swabbing of a blood like stain from the front passenger seat, where one (1) of the bullet holes was, located, was examined. This examination revealed that Jeanette Navin's known DNA profile was found to be the source of the DNA profile from the swabbing of the blood like stain from the area of the bullet hole. In a later DNA report it was confirmed that the bloodlike stain found on the driver's ‘seat of Kyle Navin's vehicle tested positive for blood, and that Kyle Navin was the source af the DNA profile found within the stain. 38. Detectives seized two (2) firearms and numerous rounds of ammunition from Kyle Navin's residence located at 142 Aldne Avenue in Bridgeport during the execution of a search warrant on ‘August 13, 2015. Detectives seized one (1) box containing eight (8) rounds of American Eagle .380, caliber ammunition; two (2) boxes of Winchester 380 caliber ammunition, with 68 rounds in one (1) box and 100 rounds in the second box; two (2) boxes of Remington slugs, each of which contained five (5) rounds; a black zip case containing a Smith & Wesson Bodyguard .380 Auto handgun with a laser sight, bearing serial number EBX6587, with one (1) round in the chamber and two (2) magazines, each of which contained six (6) rounds of ammunition; a Sig Sauer hard plastic case that contained a Sig Sauer F229 .40 caliber handgun, bearing serial nurnber AJUO1140, with one (asi page 12527 page Aint) teAGRESTWARRANTAPPLCATION sre op conecricut eater ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kye W. ‘Affidavit - Continued (1) round in the chamber and ten (10) rounds in the magazine and a second magazine containing nine (8) rounds of ammunition [Bridgeport | soto 39, The forensic laboratory subsequently generated a report pertaining to the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard .380 Auto handgun and the Sig Sauer P229 .40 caliber handgun. The report indicates. that both handguns were test fred and found to be in operable condition, 40, WOMC Detectives seized a “LiftMaster” garage door opener from the residence of Jeffrey and ‘Jeanette Navin in Easton during the execution of a search warrant on August 18, 2015. This garage oor opener was located on ‘he wall adjacent to the door way that leads to the interior of the house. ‘The opener contained a bloodlike stain with a visible partial fingerprint contained within the stain. This stain was subsequently tested and produced a positive result for blood. The “LiftMaster” ‘opener was submitted to the forensic laboratory for further testing. The bloodike stain found on the “Liftmaster" garage door opener cover is consistent with Jeanette Navin being the source of the DNA profi. 41. A set of known fingerprrt exemplars of Kyle Navin were submitted for comparison. The results of the examination show that Kyle Navin could not be excluded as the contributor ofthe latent print found in his mother's blooc on the “LiftMaster” garage door opener. Limited detail was found consistent with the left thumb print of Kyle Navin, however, the quality of detail in the latent print ‘was nat sufficient to render a definite conclusion. 42, On August 18, 2015, WOMC detectives executed a search and seizure warrant at Kyle's residence in Bridgeport. Whle processing the basement of the residence, detectives noted that it ‘was apparently under renovation and a large area of the wall-to-wall carpet had been removed (approximately 11x7 feet). The red colored wall-to-wall carpet adjacent to the bare floor was processed with Luminol which yielded several luminescent stains consistent with latent bloodstains. Detectives reported that several of these stains appeared to be shaped lke footwear or footprints. ‘The section of rug containing the stains was removed and submitted to the forensic laboratory for testing. The forensic laboratory report indicated that a cutting of a stain found on the topside of this piece of carpeting tested positive for the presence of blood. The report indicates that the stain is a ‘mixture with both Kyle Navin and Jeffrey Navin being contributors to the DNA profile 443, Through the course of this investigation, an interview was conducted with real estate agent Lawrence Vecchione who believed that at the time of the proposed sale of Kyle's house in April of 2015, there were not any missing areas of carpet in in the basement. 44, Detectives also found small bloodlike stains on the baseboard radiator near the foot of the eee __ “(ls cms leah = vey ye Ys =—F he sols[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT ee ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport ‘Bridgeport [sea mieer Affidavit - Continued basement stairs. Luminescent stains consistent with latent bloodstains were also found on the basement wall adjacent to the stairs near the door to the backyard. Samples of these stains were also submitted to the forensic laboratory. The laboratory report notes that a swabbing of a bloodlike stain on Kyle's basement wall is a mixture of both Kyle Navin and Jeffrey Navin as being contributors to the DNA profile. Detectives also noted that the storm door glass on the fforcmentioned backyard deor had been brolian out, Cimilar broken glase was found during a search of the household trash indicative that it had happened recently. Real estate agent Vecchione again believed that in April of 2015, this door was fully intact 45, On August 5, 2015, at about 1410 hours Kyle Navin went to Park City Tactical, an indoor fring range, located at 1918 Stratford Avenue in Bridgeport. WDMC Detectives Kimball and Pinel obtained a video of this event on August 14, 2015 fram Hector Hincapie, Facility Manager of Park City Tactical. Hincapie showed detectives in-house video surveillance, which showed an individual arriving in a vehicle consistent in appearance to Kyle Navin's blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500. Kyle Navin emerged from the driver's door of the vehicle and walked into the facility at approximately 1410 hours. The video showed Kyle Navin proceeding up the stairs without the ald of a cane to the: second floor of the facility where the range is housed. After visiting the range store, Kyle Navin then entered the firing lanes where he proceeded to target shoot. At approximately 1445 hours, Kyle Navin cleaned up his area using a push broom and a dust pan. During this period, Kyle Navin ‘demonstrated he was able to bend and crouch down to pick up his debris, Kyle Navin then retrieved his range bag and proceedec out of the firing lanes, down the stairs, and retumed to the truck. 46. During a search of Kyle Navin's residence located at 142 Aldine Avenue in Bridgeport on ‘August 13, 2018, detectives discovered numerous items such as a receipt from the Home Depot dated August 5, 2015 at 2036 hours. The receipt was for several items including Clorox, drain cleaner, Simple Green, bug spray, Goo Gone, Tough Tape, dryer sheets, and heavy duty black ‘contractor trash bags. 47. WDMC detectives seized and observed video surveillance from the Home Depot located at $41, Kings Hwy Cut-Off in Fairfield. The video shows that on August 5, 2015 at approximately 1945 hhours, Kyle Navin and Jennifer Valiante enter the Home Depot. Kyle Navin is seen operating Valiente's 2008 black Honda Civic and Valiente is the front seated passenger. The couple entered the Home Depot where they purchased Clorox bleach, drain opener, Simple Green spray, Goo Gone stain remover, Tough Tape, contractor trash bags, dryer sheets, and bug spray. The receipt from this transaction also shows that the couple paid cash for the above-mentioned items and utlized the self-checkout lane at 2036 hours. The surveillance video then shows the couple exit Home Depot and enter Valiente's Honda Civic together. ~ hia ete cna — leon’ _— we onli | a ” = yt ahs Se 1 iets 7 7[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT eee ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport wes mo Affidavit - Continued 48, Based on my training and experience, | know that persons who participate in the commission of a violent crime are often in contact with their physical surroundings in a forceful or otherwise detectable manner. | also know that the common household items that Kyle Navin and Jennifer Valiente purchased are often used by perpetrators who commit crimes of violence commonly use the above type of cleaning products or similar type of products in an attempt to alter, destroy, remove, clean up, or cover up evidence of crimes of violence that involve a physical struggle, the use of weapons and other instrumentalities, excretion of biological material such as blood or other body fluids, and/or the elemant of unpredictability for which prior planning did not contro. 49. The Cellebrite extraction report conducted on Kyle Navin's phone showed that within its web history on the evening of August 4, 2015, Kyle conducted numerous intemet searches were conducted for terms and tepics conceming inspirational quotes, Hail Mary prayer, prayers for special help, and prayers for peace, happiness, and life. 50, Cellular telephone records for Kyle show that there were approximately seventy-five (75) calls and text messages with a telephone number associated with Confidential Witness #2 during the time period of August 4, 2016 to August 11, 2015. On August 25, 2015, WDMC detectives met with Confidential Witness #2. Confidential Witness #2 stated that he met Kyle Navin in 2012 through a Volkswagon car club website. Confidential Witness #2 stated that they both had back injuries and that Confidential Witness #2 had been on "pain meds" a long time. 51, It was learned that on August §, 2015, Confidential Witness #2 and Kyle Navin had a thirteen (13) minute telephone conversation with each other. Confidential Witness #2 stated that he believes. that he called Kyle Navin about pills Kyle Navin was going to get for him. Confidential Witness #2 told detectives that Kyle Navin stated that he was “in the middle of chaos" and was “dealing with a lot of family crap" and that “it ooks like his parents were missing.” 52. Confidential Witness #2 also stated that Kyle usually carried a gun on hiis person. Confidential Witness #2 stated that Kyle was proud of carrying it, and he has seen it on Kyle in the past. In the ‘group of Volkswagon guys, Kyle would discuss his interest in guns and going to the shooting range for practice. 53. According to Westport tansfer station records, the blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500, operated by Kyle Navin, made one (1) entry into the transfer station on Thursday, August 6, 2016, at 0719 hours, and off loaded approxmately 600 pounds. Video surveillance shows Kyle Navin back up the blue 2000 Chevrolet K2500 into the transfer station bay. After talking to an employee, Robert Ploof, Kyle Navin begins to unloac the refuse from the back of the truck. He takes out a blue plastic container, then dumps the refuse into the chute, and cleans out the remainder of the bed. Kyle (tg 15h 52 pope At) (ol 30 frais ne Lag hee wea pepe —— pin ea af" ia 900 NOME) as ara[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT age ‘Sureraon COURT Navin Rte encore Badgeport [sce 2 ‘Affidavit - Continued Navin then sweeps the interiar of the bed, gets in his truck, and drives away. Easton Police Officer Lyman spoke with Ploof who stated he does not remember what he spoke to Kyle Navin about that ‘morning 54, During the course of the investigation of his parents’ disappearance, Kyle Navin gave four (4) separate statements conceining the events leading up to their being reported missing. These accounts provided to law enforcement were inconsistent with each other, and inconsistent with known evidence such as telephone records, and video evidence. 55, On August 7, 2015, Easton Police Officer Lyman spoke with Kyle Navin. This was the first of three (3) interviews that the Easton Police Department conducted with Kyle Navin. Kyle Navin stated in part, that the last tine he saw his parents was on the morning of Tuesday August 4, 2015, when his mother and father 2ame to visit him. Kyle Navin stated that he has a broken back and is currently unable to work. Kye Navin told Officer Lyman his parents asked him if he wanted to go ‘out to dinner that night, and he told them his back was in too much pain to go out. Kyle Navin told Officer Lyman that his father stated they might go to New York for dinner. Kyle Navin stated his parents frequently took small trips like that whenever they felt like it. Kyle Navin also stated to Officer Lyman that his father was in the process of selling the refuse business and he believed it ‘was to another refuse company called Vento Refuse. 56. On August 9, 2015, at approximately 1210 hours, Kyle Navin came into the Easton Police Department and was interviewed by Officer Ceccarell. This was the second of three (3) interviews. that the Easton Police Department conducted with Kyle Navin who agreed to complete a written statement. Kyle Navin stated in part, the following, that he has never known his father to miss work without making the proper arrangements to cover the business routes. Kyle Navin stated that the mast recent contact he had with his parents was on Tuesday, August 4, 2015 at approximately ‘noon. When questioned about phone records documenting multiple calls between Kyle Navin and Jeffrey Navin during the morning and early afternoon of August 4, 2015, Kyle Navin stated that the ‘numerous calls between him and his father were about the accounts and routes for that day. Kyle Navin stated the amount of calls is normal and happens on most work days, even when he is out with his injury. 57. On August 11, 2015, at 1820 hours, Easton Police Chief Shaw and Captain Doyle conducted an interview with Kyle Navin. This was the third of three (3) interviews that the Easton Police Depariment conducted with Kyle Navin. Kyle Navin was asked to describe in detail his actions on ‘August 4, 2015, to include specific details of his interactions with his parents on that date. 58. Kyle Navin stated in par, the following, he met his mother, at the commuter parking lot off of iene hot 7 page Andon) aT 77 ah re[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION newts no ‘STATE OF CONNECTICUT roe See 9, 962.969 gb omg ae a Fa Tees Ta Saad — CoS ATTEN oc Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport ‘Affidavit - Continued Route 15 Exit # 42 in Westport and she got into his garbage truck. Kyle Navin stated that as he rove his mother would get aut and pick up the garbage on the route. Kyle Navin stated between 0900 hours and 0930 hours, his back started to really bother him. Kyle Navin stated that he called his father and arranged to meet him at Daybreak Nurseries in Westport around 1030 hours. He stated that his mother got ott of his truck and entered his father's truck. Kyle Navin then stated he {drove to hie houee in Bridgofort. 59. Kyle Navin’s statement claiming that he and his mother were doing his garbage route in Westport prior to his back becoming painful between 0900 hours and 0830 hours is contradicted by the records of Jeanette Navin’s cellular phone. Jeanette Navin's cell phone made a two (2) second call at 0845 hours, to Jeffrey Navin, and was accessing a cell tower in Easton, 60. Kyle Navin stated at 1230 hours, he drove from his home in Bridgeport to his parents! house in Easton to get a check that nad been left on the door for him by his father. After retrieving the ‘check, Kyle Navin stated he drove back to his home in Bridgeport, where he remained for the rest of the day. Kyle Navin also stated that he spoke with his father at about 1320 hours. Kyle Navin was asked what he knows about his parents’ will or life insurance policy and he stated he knew nothing. When asked about what he did the rest of the week, Kyle Navin said that he pretty much stayed home Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday. Kyle Navin stated that he was in a lot of pain, so he just laid around. Kyle Navin stated that he called his father on Thursday, but received his father's voicemail. Kyle Navin also stated that his girlfriend, Jennifer Valiante, lives with him in Bridgeport. 61, On August 12, 2015, at approximately 2020 hours, WOMC Detectives Allegro and Kimball interviewed Kyle Navin at Trcop G in Bridgeport. This was the frst and only time WDMC detectives interviewed Kyle Navin. Kyle Navin stated in part that he works for the family business, J8J Refuse, LLC, and drives one of the trucks (a blue, 2000, ChevroletSilverado, pickup with a modified dump body, bearing CT Reg: 88CP97) utlized for trash collection in Westport. Kyle Navin has his own designated trasi collection routes/pickups and therefore, takes his truck home on a. daily basis to his residence located at 142 Aldine Avenue in Bridgeport. Kyle Navin further indicated that the truck is his only vehicle, so he utilizes it for personal use. Kyle Navin stated his daily work schedule is Moncay, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday. He stated there are no regular collections on Wednesday or on the weekends. Kyle Navin stated that he regularly begins his route no later than 0630 hours, and typically ends between 1300-1500 hours. 62. Kyle Navin stated he normally gets up around 0500 hours, does his morning routine, and then dives from Bridgeport to Westport in order to start his route/eollections. Kyle stated his father and his uncle, Wiliam Navin (who is also part owner of the business) have their own trucks and make (pe 1 f 2 age dnt) ip. 8b aE 2 "eg ti[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION a Affidavit - Continued (ete 1801027 an An) STATE OF CONNECTICUT pr ‘SUPERIOR COURT Bridgeport |scunest_ 2 their own collections on separate routes. He stated they all utlize the Town of Westport transfer station for oftloading the trash. Kyle Navin stated that about one (1) month ago, he fll and injured his back. He further stated that ths fall aggravated a previous back injury, which caused him some physical limitations. Kyle Navin stated that he is prescribed Oxycodone for pain and is contemplating back surgery. Kyle Navin stated that due to his physical limitations, his mother along with other various workore, have occasionally provided him azciotance with the collection along hia routes, During the interview, detectives requested that Kyle Navin provide an account of his whereabouts and interactions with his parents for the week of August 3, 2016 - August 7, 2015. Kyle W. 63. Kyle Navin stated he spoke with his mother on Monday August 3, 2016, at which time she agreed to assist him with his route. Kyle Navin stated he met his mother at Daybreak Nursery in Westport to start the day that morning. Kyle Navin stated that he drove his truck and his mother was the passenger. He stated they completed the collections without issue, At the end of the day, Kyle Navin stated he met up with his father on the Sherwood Island Connector to drop his mother off and then went home to Biidgeport. 64. Kyle Navin stated on Tuesday, August 4, 2015, he planned on meeting his mother and father at the Daybreak Nursery in Westport. Kyle Navin stated he was running late, so he arrived at the nursery between 0630-0840 hours. At that time, Kyle Navin's mother got out of his father’s truck and into his truck so they could begin Kyle Navin's route. Kyle Navin stated his father then left to {go begin his own route, 65, Kyle Navin stated aroun 0830 hours, while collecting trash he started to have unbearable pain in his back. Kyle Navin stated he then made a decision that he would not be able to finish out the rest of the weeks' worth of work, and that a plan was made for his mother to finish the route for that, day. 66. Kyle Navin stated that in order to do $0, he would have to get his mother the route paperwork (list of customers / addresses) from his home in Bridgeport. Kyle Navin stated that between (0830-0900 hours, he and his mother began to drive towards his home in Bridgeport. Kyle Navin stated the drive took about twenty (20) minutes. Kyle Navin that when they arrived, he went into the house to get the list from inside his office while his mother waited outside in the truck. Kyle Navin stated that when he went inside, he reportedly did not see, or have any interaction with his liven, gifriend, Jennifer Valiante, but speculated that she still may have been home. 67. Kyle Navin stated he got back into his tuck and he and his mother drove back to Westport. At 1000 hours, Kyle Navin stated that he met up with his father on Deerwood Lane in Westpor to drop off is mother. Kyle Navin stated his mother got out of his truck wth the customer lst and went into ve fxn 2015 a acd 0/30, beeARREST WARRANT APPLICATION rare op connecTiCUT See ‘SUPERIOR COURT Affidavit - Continued his father's truck. Kyle Navin stated he then drove back to Bridgeport and arrived at his home ‘around 1100 hours. 68. Kyle Navin stated that bstween 1145-1200 hours, his father called him to remind him that an envelope containing his paycheck had been taped to the outside door ofthe garage at their home in Easton. Kyle Nevin stated that he drove his tuck upto Caston to retieve it and then returned to his hhome in Bridgeport by 1230-1245 hours. Kyle Navin stated he was only at the house in Easton for about one (1) minute and there was no one else there. Kyle Navin stated he never went inside his parents’ home and claimed he does not have keys to their residence. Kyle Navin stated that last time he physically saw both of his parents was when he dropped his mother off to his father on Deerwood Lane. 669, Kyle Navin indicated that his father was in communication with him a lot on Tuesday, August 4, 2015. Kyle Navin stated that his father was not tech savvy, that he had an older, ‘fp style phone, ‘and did not send text messages often. Kyle Navin stated their communications routinely consisted ‘of conversations over the phone. At this time in the interview, detectives confronted Kyle Navin with a series of text messages that had occurred on Tuesday August 4, 2018, between Kyle Navin and his father. The content of these messages shows that Jeffrey Navin was actively seeking information from Kyle regardng the whereabouts and overall well-being of Jeanette Navin, who by Kyle Navin’s account had alteady been dropped off at 1000 hours, by Kyle Navin to his father on Deenwood Lane in Westport. 70. When detectives read the text messages between Kyle Navin and Jeffrey Navin aloud to Kyle Navin and requested clarification regarding the content, Kyle Navin offered a series of explanations that ranged from his father overreacting because he was unable to get in contact with his mother, to his father’s phone having issues and not functioning properly. Additionally, detectives noted that Kyle Navin's demeanor and rosture had visibly changed. Detectives noted that Kyle Navin became stoic and spoke in a soft, monotone voice and had a very flat affect. When detectives countered any of Kyle Navin s explanat ons with the slightest amount of suspicion or implausbilty, Kyle Navin 's routine response was to purse his lips, shake his head "No", and say, "I don't know’ or to simply ‘elect not being able to remember / recall the actual text message itself. 71, Kyle Navin stated on Wednesday August 5, 2016, he did not go to work, because no trash Collections were scheduled for pickup on Wednesday." Kyle Navin stated he had not heard from either his mother or father at all that day. Kyle Navin added that it had already been determined "late Monday" that he was nct going to be working on either Thursday or Friday. Kyle Navin stated that he went to the Bridgeport Shooting Range on August 5, 2015. Kyle Navin maintained he was atthe range for only fourteen (14) minutes and claimed his back hurt so badly that he could not stay (1 p90 19002 ge Aa) 8[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT Bae tse SUPERIOR COURT Fo Beads sea. s03 eidtgor Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport eae Affidavit - Continued very long. Kyle Navin furthe” stated that he possesses a valid CT Firearms Permit and has two (2) registered firearms: A Sig Seuer 40 caliber pistol and a Smith & Wesson "Bodyguard .380 caliber pistol. Kyle Navin stated that he only fired the Sig Sauer while atthe range. When asked about his personal maintenance of the pistols (ie. cleaning habits, storage, etc..), Kyle Navin stated he is Usually pretty anal" about cleaning them, however, he did not fully clean the Sig Sauer following his trip to the range on August §, 2015. because he was “beat” 72, Kyle Navin stated on Thursday, August 6, 2015, he received a call from his uncle, Wiliam Navin, sometime between 1300-1400 hours. Kyle Navin's uncle told him that no one at the Westport Transfer Station hed seen his father or his truck that day. Kyle Navin's uncle then asked him if he knew if his father was working or not, to which, Kyle Navin responded he had no idea. Kyle Navin stated this is when the "mystery/curiosity" regarding the whereabouts of his parents began 73, Kyle Navin's statement that the August 6 inquiry from his uncle concerning his parents is when the “mysterylourisity" regarding the whereabouts of his parents began in contradicted by his statements to Confidential Witness #2. On Wednesday, August 5, 2015, Kyle Navin told Confidential Witness #2 that 1e was dealing with “family stuff’ and that his parents were missing 74, Kyle Navin stated on Friday August 7, 2015, his paternal aunt, Laura Thompson, reported his parents were missing to the Easton Police Department. Kyle Navin added that over that weekend ‘August 8, 2015 to August 8, 2015 he met with Easton police officers and provided them with answers to their questions in order to assist wit this investigation. Kyle Navin indicated that he has riot heard from, spoke to, or seen either of his parents since Tuesday, August 4, 2015. Kyle Navin stated that he does not know or have any information about where they are, or could be. Kyle Navin denied having anything to do with his mother or father's disappearance. Kyle Navin then denied having killed his mother or his father. Kyle Navin was asked to participate in a polygraph ‘examination to which he willingly agreed. However, when offered a polygraph on Friday August 14, 2015, Kyle Navin refused. 75, The cell ste activity and text messages exchanged between Kyle Navin and his father on ‘August 4, 2015, do not accord with Kyle Navin's statements to law enforcement. For example, on ‘August 42015, between 0820 and 1001 hours, Kyle Navin's cell phone was accessing a cell tower located at 2600 Park Avenue in Bridgeport, in ciose proximity to his residence. Then between 1020 hours, and 1319 hours, the cel site actly from Kyle Navin's cellular telephone shows that he traveled in the following manner, Bridgeport to Westport, to Easton, to Westpot, to Easton, and then back to Bridgeport where he remained untl 1456 hours. At 1487 hours, Kyle Navin's cellular telephone shows he traveled to Easton and returned to Bridgeport at 1649 hours, where he was eS ** of 20 hrs we il geen — oie Te rane fa rai oo Palais apFo)S.[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION FE oe Rone er Sere SUPERIOR COURT Navin ye Peon Badgepon [arta Affidavit - Continued accessing the cell tower located at 2600 Park Avenue in Bridgeport, in close proximity to his residence. 76. On August 12, 2015 at approximately 2115 hours, WOMCS Detectives Kiely and Bombace ‘conducted the first of two (2) interviews with Jennifer Valiante at 142 Aldine Avenue in Bridgeport. Valiante stated that she hae been dating and living with Kyle Navin for approximately four (4) years, 77. Valiante stated that on ether Thursday, August 6, or Friday, August 7, 2015, she found out that Kyle's father did not go to work for his trash company. Valiante stated that she found out that Jeffrey did not go to work because Kyle's uncle, William Navin, called Kyle to inform him. Valiante stated that she is pretty sure that Kyle then called his father’s phone but he did not answer. Valiante stated that Kyle called his father's phone at another point and left a voice message. Valiante then stated that about one (1) to two (2) days later (Saturday or Sunday), Kyle's aunt, Laura Thompson, ‘went to Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin's house with Easton Police to search for anything suspicious, Valiante stated that Easton 2olice told her that there appeared to be a packing list or to do list which made it seem as if Jeffey and Jeanette traveled somewhere, or were planning a trip 78. Valiante stated that on August 4, 2015, Kyle woke up between approximately 0530-0630 hours, to go to work. Valiante statec that she slept until approximately 1000 hours, and that Kyle was still lat work when she woke up. Valiante stated that she remained home all day and maintained her normal morning routine such as freshening up, making coffee, and walking the dogs. Valiante stated that Kyle arrived hom2 between 1200-1300 hours. Valiante stated that it could have been earlier but she did not remerrber, and that Kyle was home early from work because of excruciating back pain. Valiante stated that when Kyle arrived home, he showered, and then they watched television in the bedroom. Valiante stated that at some point, she took her dogs for a walk, for approximately thirty (30) minutes to an hour. Valiante stated that she did not remember if she went to the store and that she possibly went to the Fairfield Chase Bank with Kyle. Valiante stated that after the bank, she went on a bike ride in her neighborhood for approximately one (1) hour. Valiante stated that she then went home and watched television with Kyle and the dogs in her bedroom, 79. Valiante stated that she id not see Kyle Navin's parents on August 4, 2015. Valiante stated that Kyle Navin's behavior seemed normal but changed once he found out his parents were missing. Valiante stated that Kyle Navin was stressed, worried, and confused by everything, Valiante stated that she does not believe that Kyle Navin is aware of his parent's whereabouts. 80. On August 21, 2015, at approximately 1022 hours, WDMC Detectives Kiely and Bombace met with Jennifer Valiante and her attorney, Eliot R. Warren, at the Westport Police Department in order to conduct the second of two (2) interviews with Valiente. Valiente's subsequent interview page 24 182 page At) 9 ns raat % rae rr safes WE 5[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION ‘promo fant STATE OF CONNECTICUT Boerie SUPERIOR COURT Fito bet ssa aes ee Tas a aT Taina apa | CaS FAST [peg Navin, Kyle W. | idgeport Bridgeport |scvnutcr 2 ‘Affidavit - Continued revealed several discrepanciss with the facts Valiente provided in her original statement. 81. Throughout the interview, detectives asked Valiente multiple times to recall as much as she ‘could from August 4, 2015 ir as much detail as possible. Valiente's thoughts were fragmented and ‘she would recall additional information at diferent times throughout the interview. Valiente stated in paar, that che woke up around 1000 hours, and went about her normal morning routine. Detectives told Valiente that there was avidence which indicated Kyle Navin was home in Bridgeport at 0920 hours. However, she told them that she did not remember Kyle being home at that time, and stated she would have stil been sleeping. Detectives told Valiente that cell phone records indicate she called Kyle Navin at 1010 heurs, and she told them that she was probably calling Kyle Navin after she woke up. 82. Detectives asked Valiente about an eighteen (18) minute phone call on August 4, 2015, between her and Kyle Navin at 1117 hours. Valiente stated that during her phone conversation with Kyle Navin he told her that he was going to finish his route early and then stop at a few customers’ homes, mainly ir the Westport and Weston area to check on a few things. She also stated that Kyle Navin menticned meeting up with his father somewhere along the route in Westport in order to discuss a cleanup. She stated that a cleanup is an extra pick up for cients requiring removal of items of trash, in addition to their normal household trash, 83. Detectives told Valiente that Kyle Navin also called her on August 4, 2015 at approximately 1900 hours, and she stated that Kyle Navin would have been on his way home from work at that time. Detectives asked her i! Kyle Navin had any reason to be in Easton at 1300 hours, and she stated that he had no reason to be in Easton at that time. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin did not ‘mention he was coming from Easton when he called her at 1300 hours. Detectives asked Valiente if she recalls Kyle Navin talking to his father while at their Bridgeport house. Valiente stated that she did not recall thi, but it was possible Kyle Navin was outside talking to his father on his phone. 84, Detectives told Valiente that she was seen on video driving her Honda Civic in Easton on ‘August 4, 2015 and she stated she did not remember why she was there, She then stated that it might have been to get a check that was left at Kyle Navin's parents’ house in Easton. She stated that she was unsure if it was Monday, August 3, or Tuesday, August 4, 2015, but she believed it was approximately 1440 hotrs. Valiente stated that she drove Kyle Navin to his parents’ Easton house and when she pulled into the driveway Kyle Navin got out and went to the back of the house to retrieve a check that was taped to the back door. Valiente stated that she never exited her vehicle and only tuned around in the driveway. Detectives asked Valiente why Kyle Navin would hhave to pick up a check at his parents’ house when he was working with his mother earlier that ‘moming. Detectives asked why Kyle Navin's mother would not just bring the check to work since Sarr[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION eae soon Surerion coun Navin ew Bde Brigepor [scans Affidavit - Continued ‘she and Kyle Navin were gong to be working together. Valiente stated that she did not know why this was and stated it did not make sense. Valiente did not mention the fact that she was following Kyle Navin who was driving tis father's truck. 85, Detectives showed Valiente a picture from video surveillance depicting her vehicle following behind Jefirey Navin’ fathers truck, a 2007 leuzu NPR dump bed bearing Connecticut registration 730393, on August 4, 2015. Valiente now stated that Kyle Navin asked her to follow him back to his parents’ house sometime between 1400 and 1530 hours, on either Monday, or Tuesday. She stated that Kyle Navin will occasionally ask for a ride back from his parents’ house to drop a truck off. She stated that has occured between three (3) or four (4) times in the past when a truck was having mechanical issues. Detectives asked Valiente why Kyle would be driving his father's truck and she stated she had no idea why Kyle Navin was driving his father’s truck, Valiente later stated that she remembers Kyle Nevin telling her that his truck was having issues so he was using his father's truck. Detectives asked her where Kyle's father was if Kyle Navin was using his father's truck and she stated that she did not know. She stated that she recalls seeing Kyle Navin’ father's truck parked out in front oftheir house when she walked the dogs. Valiente stated she believed she walked the dogs in between when Kyle got home and when ‘they went to get the truck.” Howeve she corrected herself and steted that she meant to say when she followed Kyle Navin back to his parents’ house. 86. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin will normally come home from work, shower, and change his clothes. However, she could not remember if Kyle Navin asked her to follow him to Easton on that day prior to showering. Detectives asked Valiente the route she took driving back to Easton. She stated that she took a right on Brooklawn Avenue and then eventually crossed over the parkway at Exit # 46 by the GE building. She then stated that they continued up Sport Hill Road into Easton and eventually took a left, but could not recall the specific street. Valiente stated that they did not ‘make any stops and went directly to Kyle Navin's parents’ house. Valiente stated that when they arrived, Kyle Navin parked the truck in the back right comer of the driveway, She stated that Kyle Navin got into her vehicle and she drove directly to Chase Bank in Fairfield 87, Valiente stated that once they arrived at the bank, Kyle Navin used the ATM, and then they ‘drove back to their home in Bridgeport. Detectives asked Valiente what time they arrived home and ‘she told them that she believed it was around 1430 hours. Earlier, Valiente told detectives that they left Bridgeport at approximately 1440 hours. Valiente asked what time she was seen on video passing a home on Center Road in Easton and detectives told her it was approximately 1500 hours Valiente then stated that she could not remember what time they arrived home. 88. The Easton Police Departnent seized bank surveillance video from the Chase Bank located at (1a tge 29 fp ot) Of3off5[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT ater ‘SUPERIOR COURT Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport wean Affidavit - Continued 2272 Black Rock Tumpike in Faifield. The video captured from August 4, 201, at approximately 1654 hours, depicts Kyle Navin using the ATM. Detectives asked Valiente what vehicle Kyle Navin hhad to drive when they retumed home from Easton in her car. She stated that he would have had his blue truck. (@ blue, 2000 Chevrolet-Silverado, pickup with a modified dump body, bearing CT Reg: 88CP97). When detectives asked where the truck was she stated that she did not know how Kyle Navin got hie blue truck back and that che wae “stumped,” She later atated that i was possible that Kyle Navin's truck was parked at their house on Tuesday since she does not remember Kyle Navin picking his truck up at any point. Valiente was asked about Tuesday night August 4, 2015, and she stated that she might have gone to the store on Tuesday night but could not remember for sure. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin did not go out on Tuesday night; instead, he just relaxed at the house. 89. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin had his truck on Wednesday August 5, 2018 because he went to the gun range during the morning. Detectives asked Valiente if she recalled going to any stores with Kyle Navin on that day. Valiente then stated that she remembers going to Home Depot that right for Draino to fix the upstairs sink which was clogged. She also remembers buying cleaning spray to clean up after the dogs who were throwing up at the house. She stated she remembers spraying Simple Green on the dining room carpet and the bed where the dogs threw up. Detectives then asked Valiente why they bought bleach and she stated that she did not remember, but ‘assumed it was for laundry. She stated that Kyle Navin might have picked up the bleach for his laundry, and that she and Kyle Navin do their laundry separately. Valiente stated that she did not remember using bleach because of “all the stuff they had going on Wednesday." Detectives asked “what stuff they had going on Wednesday and she told them she did not know why she had just said that, it was a mistake. 90, Detectives asked Valiente when she found out Kyle Navin’s parents were missing and she told them it was either Thursday, or Friday. She stated that Kyle Navin's uncle contacted Kyle Navin and told him that his father was not at the dump. She then stated that it was Thursday, August 6, 2015, when she found out. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin went out on Wednesday to check something for a customer and then went to the shooting range. Detectives asked Valiente how often Kyle Navin goes to the gun range and she stated that it was not too often, Detectives asked her if Kyle's back was in so rruch pain why he would be going to a shooting range. She stated that she agreed it was odd, but dic not question why he went 91. Detectives then asked Valiente if she uses any illegal narcotics and she stated "No," she only lakes what she is prescribed Detectives asked her if Kyle Navin takes any illegal narcotics and she stated he only takes his prescribed pain pills. Detectives asked Valiente why they found so many used heroin bags at their house. Valiente stated, ‘What heroin? There shouldn't be heroin.” (1s pgn 24 2 pg At) —« Leal ani Bypanh™[ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION anen a o ‘STATE OF CONNECTICUT cena SUPERIOR COURT Woe EE ws sos earsien Ts Ga a RT EA SISRATTTOOT occa Navin, Kyle W. idgenort fics 2 ‘Affidavit - Continued ‘She stated that she did not know why it was there and would not allow itn ‘my house.” She stated that iit was Kyle Navin's she would be shocked. Valiente stated that she used to be an addict over ten (10) years ago, but currently only takes Zanax and Suboxone. Detectives explained that based fon the amount of heroin packaging found at the house Kyle must have a serious drug problem. Valiente stated that to her knowledge Kyle only takes his Oxycodone pills. Detectives asked Valiente where Kyle Navin was getting the moncy to support his drug habit. She stated that she did riot know where he was getiing the money from, but if he wanted to hide something from her, he could 92. Detectives asked Valiente about Kyle Navin's parents cutting him out of the family business and she stated that they were only getting rid of Kyle Navin's route, so he could get his back surgery and have time to heal. When asked why she did not mention following Kyle Navin back to Easton in, her initial statement she staled that she forgot to mention it and did not intentionally leave it out. She stated that she was unsure what day it was when she was intially interviewed. 93. Detectives asked what Kyle Navin was wearing on August 4, 2015 and she stated that Kyle would have been wearing his work clothes which consist of a J&J refuse T-shirt and tan or green Carhart work pants, with tan or black work boots. Valiente stated that Kyle Navin has several different colored J8J refuse t-shirts to include bright yellow, maroon, and black. It should be noted that the Chase Bank video captured from August 4, 2018, depicts Kyle Navin wearing a bright yellow J&J Refuse t-shirt, tan pants, and what appears to be work boots. 94, Detectives asked Valier if Kyle Navin normally turns his phone off and she stated that he does tumn it off occasionally. When asked why he turns it off she stated that he does it out of respect if he's going to a doctor's office or meeting with a client. Detectives asked Valiente if Kyle Navin turns his phone off every day and she stated “no, not every day." When asked if Kyle Navin turned his phone off on August 4, 2C15, she stated she did not remember. 95. Detectives asked Valients how many guns Kyle Navin has and she stated he has two (2). She stated that Kyle Navin has a Sig Sauer and a Bodyguard. She stated that she likes the Bodyguard because it's good for her to rrotect herself while at home and told detectives she knows that gun is. a .360 caliber. She stated that she has shot the Bodyguard gun at the range before. Detectives, asked Valiente if Kyle carries his guns on him and she stated that Kyle Navin usually carries his, ‘gun. She stated that Kyle Navin does not carry his gun every day, but will take iti they go for a walk in the neighborhood. Detectives asked if Kyle Navin carries his gun to work and she stated ‘she does not believe he does. 96. Detectives then asked Valiente to submit to a polygraph examination. Valiente's attotney then a bate meal SOME 3645ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE oF connecricuT poor ‘SUPERIOR COURT Fo ESS 202 cease Tae oa a = is Ton TT — SESE TT OAT ocr Navin, Kyle W. Bridgeport Bridgeport cso 2 ‘Affidavit - Continued stated that he was not big on polygraph tests, and at this point did not feel it was productive. 97, Jennifer intially stated that she gave Kyle a ride to Easton that aftemoon, but makes no mention of Kyle using his fatver's truck. After being presented with surveillance photos from Center Road in Easton Jennifer then confirmed she was operating her black Honda following Kyle, who ‘waa driving hia fathers Iouzutruck back to Staples Road in Easton, 98. On October 29, 2015, at about 1500 hrs. Thomas Kerrigan, his son Brian Kerrigan, and a hired helper Pablo Gutires, were working on cleaning up Thomas Kerrigan's property located at 85 Norfield Road in the town of Weston. The property is wooded and contains an abandoned residence which has been uraccupied about 10 years. 99. While moving debris with a Skidsteer machine fitted with a front bucket, Kerrigan disturbed a pile of brush and leaves. He distributed the leaves and other debris over the property. This debris contained a blue tarp with slver duct tape. When the debris was moved, the contents of the tarp were revealed and Kerrigan observed what appeared to be human bones. Also located on the property was an abject consisting of a series of dark colored plastic contractor bags taped together Which too had been disturbed by the machine, The bag emitted a strong odor and contained ‘maggots. Kerrigan contacted the police and executed a consent-to-search on the property. 100. Thomas Kerrigan's son, Brian Kerrigan is acquainted with Kyle Navin and has known him since 2007, but has not been close to him lately. Kyle Navin has been to this property inthe past. 401. Investigators responded to the scene and began processing it. The contents of the tarp and bags were transported to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. Detectives obtained copies of known dental records for Jeffrey Navin and Jeannette Navin and submitted them to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. 102. The contents of the cortractor bags were determined to be human remains, A comparison of the known dental records of Jeffrey Navin with the contents of the contractor bags determined that the recovered remains were ‘hose of Jeffrey Navin. Also included in the contents of the bags was a 4J8J Refuse T-shirt. The body was intact but in a state of decomposition. The body was wrapped in ‘a blue fleece blanket and the legs were bound with 3 inch painters tape. A projectile was recovered from the pelvic area of the remains, 103, The contents of the biue tarp were also determined to be human remains. A J&. refuse T-shirt was found with the remains. X-ray examination identified an object consistent with a bullet in the chest region of the remains. This projectile was recovered. A comparison of the known dental Lal OE ES cagrazet = (Sfole aoe : V ][ARREST WARRANT APPLICATION STATE OF CONNECTICUT aie SUPERIOR COURT Ta AT aaa TT Navin, Kyle W. Brcgpor Affidavit - Continued records of Jeannette Navin with the contents of the blue tarp determined that the recovered remains were those of Jeannette Navin. 104. An examination of the remains of Jeffrey Navin was conducted by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. The metical examiner concluded that the cause and manner of death are pending further investigation, 4105. An examination of the remains of Jeannette Navin was conducted by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. The medical examiner concluded that the cause and manner of death are pending further investigation, 108. Throughout the course of this investigation, there has not been one instance in which Kyle has fever reached out to investigators to inquire about the status of this investigation. All contact with Kyle has been initiated by investigators in an effort to locate his parents, 407. On August 4, 2015, Kyle is the last known person to interact with both Jeffrey and Jeanette Navin. 108. Based on the foregoing information, there is probable cause to believe that Kyle Navin has ‘committed the crimes of murder, in violation of section 53a-54a of the Connecticut General Statutes (efftey Navin); murder in violation of section 53a-S4a of the Connecticut General Statutes (Jeannette Navin), and the crime of murder with special circumstances in violation of section 5da-54b(7) of the Connecticut General Statutes (Jefffey and Jeannette Navin in the course of a single transaction.) Sopp He Tel xelp5