Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Hamline
10/5/15
IsSolitaryConfinementCruelandUnusual??
By:AmonHartley
Howwouldyoufeelifyouwereina80feetroomfor23-24hoursaday?In
solitaryconfinement,yourroomis80feetbyaverage.Youspendupto23hoursaday
thereandgetmaybe1hourofexercisewithnooneelse.Youcanonlyspeakthrough
theU.SMailandlimitedvisitors.Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8th
amendmentbanagainstcruelandunusualpunishmentbecauseprisonersdontgetto
interactwithothers,prisonerssufferfrompsychologicalstress,andinmatesareseven
timesmorelikelytohurtorkillthemselvesthaninmatesatlarge.
First,Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8thamendmentbanagainstcruel
andunusualpunishmentbecauseprisonersdontgettointeractwithothers.
Accordingto
http://www.npr.org
,
Mostinmatesheldinsolitaryhavenocontactwith
theoutsideworldotherthantheU.S.mail.
Thisquotemeansthatprisonersrarelyget
tocomeincontactwithhumans.Theyonlycancomeintocontactviamail.Thisproves
thatsolitaryconfinementviolatesthe8thamendmentbecauseprisonersdontgetto
comeincontactwithotherhumansexceptmaybetheguards.
Next,Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8thamendmentbanagainst
cruelandunusualpunishmentbecauseprisonerssufferfrompsychologicalstress.
Accordingto
http://www.smithsonianmag.com
,
Amajorityofthosesurveyed
experiencedsymptomssuchasdizziness,heartpalpitations,chronicdepression,while
41percentreportedhallucinations,and27percenthadsuicidalthoughtsalllevels
significantlyhigherthanthoseoftheoverallprisonpopulations.
Thisquotemeansthat
mostprisonersinsolitaryconfinementhavesymptoms.Theygothroughlotsofthings
insolitaryconfinementbeingalone.Thisprovesthatsolitaryconfinementviolatesthe
8thamendmentbecauseprisonerssufferfrompsychologicalstress.
Finally,Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8thamendmentbanagainst
cruelandunusualpunishmentbecauseinmatesareseventimesmorelikelytohurtor
killthemselvesthaninmatesatlarge.Accordingto
http://healthresearchfunding.org
,
Peoplewhoareinsolitaryconfinementare
vulnerableoratrisktosomementalhealthdisordersincludingschizophrenia.Isolated
individualsmayexperiencehallucinationsanddelusions.Theymayalsobecomevery
paranoidormaydisplaysomeothersymptomsofmentaldistress.
Thisquotemeans
thatbeinginsolitaryconfinementcanmentallydamagesomeone.Itcanmakethem
losetheirmindsandtrytoattemptsuicide.Thisprovesthatsolitaryconfinement
violatesthe8thamendmentbecauseinmatesareseventimesmorelikelytohurtor
killthemselvesthaninmatesatlarge.
Insummary,SolitaryConfinementisaviolationofthe8thamendmentandis
cruelandunusualpunishment.Itsnotgoodforpeople.Theybegintolosetheirminds
andnotbeabletointeractwithhumans.Furthermore,27percentofprisonersin
solitaryconfinementhadsuicidalthoughts.Overall,SolitaryConfinementisaviolation
ofthe8thamendmentbecauseprisonersdontgettocontactwithothers,prisoners
sufferfrompsychologicalstress,andinmatesareseventimesmorelikelytohurtorkill
themselvesthaninmatesatlarge.