Kenworth T800 & W900S

vs
Mack Granite

Kenworth Grille

Mack Grille

Grille
Cost to replace Mack
Charge Air Cooler:
Parts:
$490
Labor:
$262
Total:
$752

Kenworth Hood Hinge

Kenworth Hood Hinge

Mack Hood Hinge

Mack Hood Hinge

Hood Hinge

Cost to replace Mack

Hood Hinge Hardware:
Parts:
$130
Labor:
$75
Total:
$205

Kenworth Hood Slope

20 degrees

10

Mack Hood Slope

15 degrees

11

Kenworth Windshield

12

Kenworth Windshield

13

Mack Windshield

14

Windshield Replacement
Replacement costs
Kenworth with flat glass:
Parts:
$27
Labor:
$38
Total:
$65

Mack:
Parts:
Labor:
Total:

$180
$112
$292

Difference: $228 x 10 times = $2,280

15

Kenworth Mirrors

16

Kenworth Aerodynamic Mirrors

17

Mack Mirrors

18

Kenworth Cab Access

19

Mack Cab Access

20

Kenworth Cab Access

21

Mack Cab Access

22

Kenworth Cab Access Lighting

23

Mack Cab Access Lighting

24

Cab Access Lighting

25

Kenworth Cab Access Steps

26

Mack Cab Access Steps

27

Kenworth Cab Door Seal

Seal attached to door

28

Mack Cab Door Seal

Attached to
door opening

29

Cab Door Seal

Cost to replace Mack Door seal:
Parts:
$50
Labor:
$75
Total:
$125

30

Kenworth Cab Door Hinge

3/8 Stainless Steel
piano-style hinge

31

Mack Cab Door Hinge

1/4 Mild Steel
short hinges

32

Kenworth Cab Doors

3 aluminum
bulkhead design

33

Mack Cab Doors

Formed Steel
design

34

Kenworth Cab Construction

35

Mack Cab Construction

Welded steel

36

Cab Durability
Resale Value for dump truck at 10 years:
Per Ritchie Bros. Auction Results

Kenworth T800
$19,857

Mack CH613
$18,405

Difference: $1,452

37

Kenworth Cab Windows

38

Mack Cab Windows

39

Kenworth Exhaust Mounting

40

Mack Exhaust Mounting

41

Frame Rails
10-3/4 Frame Rails w/ insert

14%
greater
strength
T800

Granite

Main Rail: 10.75 x 3.5 x .375

10.75 x 3.25 x .375

Insert:

9.88 x 2.88 x .250

9.93 x 2.93 x .250

RBM:

3,280,000 in-lbs

2,870,000 in-lbs

42

Frame Rails
11-5/8 Frame Rail w/out insert
vs 10-3/4 Frame Rail w/ insert

525 lbs
weight
savings
T800

Granite

Main Rail: 11.625 x 3.88 x .375

10.75 x 3.25 x .375

Insert:

(none)

9.93 x 2.93 x .250

RBM:

2,572,000 in-lbs

2,870,000 in-lbs

43

Kenworth Air Piping & Electrical Wiring

44

Mack Air Piping & Electrical Wiring

45

Air Piping & Electrical Wiring

Cost of troubleshooting without color-coded wiring:

Labor (10 events): $375
Total:
$375

46

Factory-Installed Lift Axles

Up to 3 pushers installed at the factory
8000 lb to 20,000 lb steerable
22,500 lb non-steerable

47

Factory-Installed Lift Axles

Proper Frame Rails
Sufficient Air Tank Capacity
Sufficient Air Compressor Capacity
Air System Designed & Installed Correctly
ABS-Controlled Lift Axle Brake Option
Kenworth-Supported Warranty

48

Drive Axles
Dana new Heavy Tandem
17.7 ring gear
Wide-face hypoid gearing
Stronger wheel differentials

49

Mack Axle Differential Access

50

Axle Differential Access

Cost of 4 hours Additional Labor
to R&R Mack Axles:
Labor: $300

51

Engine Choices - Kenworth

52

Engine Choices - Mack

53

Engine Choices - Mack

Oil Change Interval
Cummins ISM/ISX:

25,000 Miles

CAT ACERT:

30,000 Miles

Mack ASET:

10,000 Miles

Cost of 40 Additional Mack Oil Changes:

Parts & Labor:

$4000
54

Kenworth Engine Position

55

Mack Engine Position

56

Engine Position
Cost of 1 hour Additional Labor for
an Overhead Job:
Labor: $75 x 10 times = $750

57

Kenworth Power Steering

58

Mack Power Steering

59

Power Steering
Cost to replace Mack Steering Assist Ram:
Parts:
$ 700
Labor:
$ 375
Total:
$1,075

60

Kenworth Radiator Size & Options

61

Mack Radiator Size & Options

62

Kenworth Coolant Hoses & Clamps

63

Mack Coolant Hoses & Clamps

64

Coolant Hoses & Clamps

Loss of
Towing
Revenue
Bill
Cost To Replace Proprietary Mack Hose:
Additional Parts:
$8
Additional Labor:
$0
Total:
$8
(Roadside Service:

$300)

(Downtime:

$1500)

65

Kenworth Air Intake Options

66

Kenworth Air Intake Options

67

Mack Air Intake Options

68

Kenworth Exhaust System

69

Exhaust Mack

70

Exhaust Clamping Aft of Turbo

Cost to replace Mack Turbo:

Parts:
$1,475
Labor:
$ 275
Total:
$1,700

71

Kenworth HVAC Mounting Location

72

Mack HVAC Mounting Location

73

HVAC Mounting Location

Cost of four additional hours
labor to R&R Mack HVAC Unit
Labor:
$300
Total:
$300

74

Kenworth Power Distribution

75

Mack Power Distribution

76

Mack Power Distribution

77

Kenworth Cab Interior - Dash

78

Mack Cab Interior - Dash

79

Extended DayCab

80

Kenworth Cab Interior Storage

81

Kenworth Cab Interior Storage

82

Kenworth Cab Interior Storage

83

Kenworth Cab Interior Storage

84

Mack Cab Interior Storage

85

Mack Cab Interior Storage

86

The Mack Factor

Problems per 10,000 miles

HALF
J D Power reports average number of problems
experienced per 10,000 miles.

Kenworth
Mack

9.6 prob/10k mi
18.6 prob/10k mi

Kenworth has half the number

of problem occurrences.

87

The Mack Factor

Downtime
J D Power reports average unscheduled downtime
days per chassis per year.

Kenworth
Mack

3.8 days
4.6 days
0.8 days difference

$1500/day x 0.8 days/year x 10 years

= $12,000
88

The Mack Factor

Item
Parts Labor #Times
CAC
$490 $262
1
Hood Hinge
$130 $75
1
Windshield
$153 $75
10
Door Seal
$50 $75
1
Resale Value
1
Wiring/Piping
$38
10
Diff Access
- $300
1
Oil Changes
$25 $75
40
Overhead
- $75
10
Assist Ram
$700 $375
1
Coolant Hoses
$8
1
Air Filter
$40 $19
15
HVAC Access
- $300
1
Turbo
$1,475 $225
1

$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$

Total
752
205
2,280
125
1,452
380
300
4,000
750
1,075
8
781
300
1,700

$14,109
89

The Mack Factor

Maintenance:
Downtime:
Resale Value:

$14,000
$12,000
$ 1,400
$27,400

90

The Mack Factor

Item
Parts
Oil Changes
$25
Assist Ram
$700
Turbo
$1,475
Windshield
$153

Labor
$75
$375
$225
$75

#Times
40
1
1
5

$
$
$
$

Total
4,000
1,075
1,700
2,280

$9,000

$ 9,055

91

92