Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Barnett 1
newer online marketing mechanisms like social media sites. Due to this fact,
contributions and gifts are also suffering.
By the late 19th century, the elite class of American enjoyed high
culture, which included the arts, universities, and social clubs. Through the
notion of cultural capital, a means to social promotion, beyond money, through
social assets, the elite class could seemingly rise above the lower classes on an
intellectual level and partake in the arts for their own social benefit (Bourdieu,
1986, DiMaggio, 1997). In the past century, however, these rigid notions of class
and art exclusivity have disintegrated, paving the way for the massification of the
arts. Thanks to an accepted understanding of the importance of art in all cultures
paired with new technology and hundreds of thousands arts non-profits, it is now
easier than ever to experience art, regardless of contrived classes, economic
status, and geographical location. Though the opportunity is great for art nonprofits to make a difference in our society, many lack the proper marketing
techniques to truly break into the market and pursue their unique missions.
Arts Administration is a fairly newly defined career path and many
administrators in arts non-profits are not professionally trained to do their job,
but are simply promoted to the position because of their experience and legacy
within the organization. Now these leaders are struggling to understand newer
marketing concepts and to adopt campaigns that include them, instead choosing
to function on a tradition of best practices. How can this marketing crisis be
addressed directly? This report will attempt to address these inherent issues
within the arts nonprofit sector through posing the question, how can small arts
Barnett 2
Barnett 3
agree that using quantitative and qualitative research to guide future endeavors is
imperative to progression.
Current snapshot of the non-profit sector
The past twenty years have seen significant declines in arts attendance by
adults in the United States. This includes visual art exhibits and performing arts
events. There has been study after study proving this fact, but no definitive
reports had looked into why this was occurring until the deeply comprehensive
study completed by the National Endowment for the Arts, entitled When Going
Gets Tough: Barriers and Motivations Affecting Arts Attendance (2015). It
utilized the 2012 General Social Survey, a highly regarded, nationallyrepresentative biennial survey of U.S. adults attitudes, perceptions, and opinions
on a wide variety of social issues, as well as US Census Bureau questionnaires to
identify who is and isnt attending arts events and what is either motivating or
barring their participation (1). This study is so valuable because it is one of the
only to assess interested non-attendees. A summary of implications in the
report states that many arts organizations are being challenged to appeal to new
audiences and preserve old ones while upholding their mission and vision. It also
states that there are several other important factors that drive consumers to
attend or not attend arts events other than the art itself. These motives and
barriers include: socializing with friends or family members, lack of time to
connect with ones culture, to support ones community, to experience high
quality art, not having anyone to attend the event with, having no way to travel to
the event, and to learn new things (2). These motivations and barriers can be
Barnett 4
Barnett 5
from 2002-2012 except New England (XII). The benefit of this survey lies in its
expansive time frame, tracking participation trends over an entire decade,
allowing for a projection of future numbers.
Shifting the Paradigm, jumping off of established research on audience
demographics and participation similar to the above reports, analyzed the
challenge that socially oriented non-profit organizations are facing: functioning
in a time of economic downturn and dwindling donation pools. The report looked
at three organizational processes that encompass this challenge: leadership and
social entrepreneurship, social innovation and technology transfer, and
organizational development and sustainability. The marketing and social
entrepreneurship section of the report proposes that through defining and
adopting a standardized test, a non-profit can track and analyze its social
successes through quantifiable means. Today, the non-profit sector largely
operates through means of best judgment and tradition, failing to assess the
successes or failures of their campaigns. By exercising a model that uses forprofit components to create, sustain, and assess a campaign, these same nonprofits can optimize funding and social impact.
Becoming aware of the issues the sector is facing is important for nonprofits. Yet it is only the first step. Many non-profits do not have access to
professionals well versed in addressing these issues; namely digital marketing
and analytics professionals. Joe Tripodi, Chief Marketing and Commercial Officer
of Coca-Cola Co. offers invaluable insights into new age business marketing in a
Wall Street Journal report. He advocates, "You cannot slide over people in your
Barnett 6
current organization because they have loosely dabbled in these areas. You need
to go to the millennial marketplace for 'natives' who have lived and breathed
these disciplines for much of their lives. These individuals are the ones who will
have the raw passion and technical skillset to connect the mission and vision of
the organization to its public in new and exciting ways. Legacy within the
marketplace is not something to be overlooked. But when it comes to rebranding
and innovating through non traditional branding techniques, non profits must
're-skill' their marketing organizations and build new capabilities in areas like
big data/analytics, digital, social, mobile, gamification and design. These pieces
of advice are coming directly from the CMO of a huge, global for profit, yet their
principles apply directly to the non-profit business sector.
After establishing the history of arts non-profits as well as establishing
where the sector stands today, it is important to look at marketing theories that
have been adopted, tried, and deemed successful within the for profit business
sector and marketing theories proposed for non-profits. I will compare and
contrast these theories and attempt to fit them within the non-profit sector.
Marketing and Public Relations Theory
Alexander Laskin (2011) authored a report that acted as a critical review of
current PR models and their empirical tests, and proposed new and improved
scales of public relations to further the excellence theory of public relations. The
Continuous Public Relations Model presents five scales on which organizations
can plot themselves to analyze their current practices and compare and contrast
them to other like organizations, whether for profit or non-profit. These five
Barnett 7
individual scales can also be compared to each other, to present a wide range of
information on the organization in a visual format. There are two dimensions to
each scale, positioned on opposition poles. The five scales, Laskins Figures 1
through 5, are as follows:
Role Scale:
Barnett 8
Timeframe scale:
Barnett 9
Barnett 10
Barnett 11
Barnett 12
Securing best practices online is a sure fire way to increase Word of Mouth
(WOM) marketing, or Word of Mouth marketing. WOM spreads especially
rapidly through social media and the Internet so it is pertinent to discuss it in
further detail. Martin Williams and Francis Buttle (2013) wrote in the Journal of
Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing, WOM can be defined as informal personto-person communication between a perceived noncommercial communicator
and a receiver about a brand, a product, a service or an organization WOM
gains persuasiveness through the higher perceived credibility and
trustworthiness of the communicator (285). In strategically utilizing social
media, blogging, digital marketing, news releases, and other new media as
defined by Scott, WOM should increase significantly. The study collected its
information through 16 in depth interviews of various individuals in a range of
departmental roles, including members of the marketing department, the
corporate gift and bequest sales forces and line management as well as through
other means of primary research (289). One important finding that emerged
from the research was that managers in nonprofits tended to act in independent
and uncoordinated ways that they believe may promote PWOM, even though
WOM specifically is not a measured objective (290). Through the themes that
emerged from all of the data collected, the team established what it referred to as
the Eight Pillars of WOM model for nonprofits: Donor WOM, Brand/Product or
Service WOM, Communications WOM, Key-Influencer Network WOM, Referral
Network WOM, Supplier/Alliance Partner Network WOM, Employee Network
WOM, and Organizational WOM. The study determined that, though WOM
appears high on the agendas of most nonprofits, unsophisticated means and
Barnett 13
lower tier players like volunteers are used to carry it out. Additionally, each
departmental unit interprets WOM differently (302). These inconsistencies
prove that non-profits are not taking WOM marketing as seriously as they should
be. WOM should easily and consistently fit into a non-profits strategic
communication and marketing plan.
Robert V. Kozinets (2010) focused specifically on the link between social
media and WOM, showing how marketers employing social media marketing
methods face a situation of networked coproduction of narratives (71). Through
studying over 80 blogs for half a year, the study established four communication
opportunities presented through social media: evaluation, embracing,
endorsement, and explanation. The consumers taking part in WOM marketing
are individually and communally influenced by character narrative,
communications forum, communal norms, and the nature of the marketing
promotion. Thus, a new and distinctive narrative model is formed, which proves
that marketing messages and meanings are systematically altered [by the
consumer] in the process of embedding them in their own narrative. The
narrative model suggests definite, pragmatic implications for how marketers
should plan, target, and leverage WOM and how scholars should understand
WOM in a networked world. The need to comment upon certain people,
products, events, and organizations is a need that is engrained in the social
nature of todays culture. Thus organizational WOM campaigns that tap directly
into this natural behavior could be invaluable to an organization. This study
Barnett 14
offers Narrative Response Strategies associated with WOM devised from this
research.
Social media is the largest sector of online marketing that non-profits can
tap into to drive marketing campaigns. According to the research report,
Customizing Social Media Marketing, when designing the optimal social sharing
mechanism for Facebook, managers must look at four tradeoffs: Reach vs.
Relevance, Strangers vs. Friends, Push vs. Pull, and No Incentives vs. Incentives
(8). The study looked at over 750 Facebook marketing campaigns to analyze the
social sharing mechanisms that encourage consumers to share information
about a product with their friends. The report suggests that managers consider
these four tradeoffs when making strategic decisions involving reaching a public
through their online campaigns and that the key to successful social media
marketing lies in customizing the campaign to the product or in the case of a
non profit, the event, exhibit, fundraiser, etc. (10). In discussing various
marketing theory and mechanisms, it is helpful to look at a real small scale arts
non-profit organization. The Alamance County Arts Council is a small non-profit
located in Mebane, North Carolina. Its mission is to be committed to shaping the
cultural identity of Alamance County by making art a tangible presence in the
lives of its citizens and to enhance the quality of life by engaging people in a
diverse array of art through the delivery of programming and education, and
through the provision of facilities, advocacy, promotion and funding (About Us,
2014). According to the organizations 2013 990 form listed on Guidestar, its
revenue less expenses for the year were -$69,139. Its total net assets or fund
Barnett 15
Barnett 16
Taking all of the above considerations into hand, filling in the gaps of
current marketing practices by struggling arts non-profits, I developed The
Hybrid Marketing Model for Arts Non Profits shown in Figure 1.
Barnett 17
Figure 1
Barnett 18
Resources
The success of a strategic communications campaign lies within an
organizations workforce. To attract, develop, and maintain workers who believe
in the organizations mission, understand its direction, and are able to carry out
operations efficiently, creatively, and communally is imperative. Administrators
within an established art non-profit may resist to serious change within the
organization for many reasons, some valid. Thus it is important to recognize this
possibility and address it head on, through authoritative meetings and seminars
about the benefits of the model and of the Internet, in order to spur true change.
Activities
Once this workforce is acquired, an open flow of communications between
organizational committees and departments will ensure the purpose of the
communication campaign and its implications are not lost in translation or
misconstrued, factoring in the Senges Learning Organization concept. During the
golden years of the newspaper industry, the journalism and marketing
departments would not communicate at all, but rather compete with each other.
If that were true of the public relations and marketing departments within a
single organization today, it would prove counterintuitive. Realize the value of
open communication, integrated both horizontally and vertically, in order to
establish a workforce of likeminded individuals, confident and proud of the group
efforts to reach the mission. Maslows Hierarchy of Needs (1943) chart says that
responsibility of an important job along with recognition helps to satisfy their
higher-order esteem needs (Schermerhorn, 314). If an individual has a true say
Barnett 19
in the organization and feel valued, they will be that much more invested in the
goal.
Output
The strategic communications plan is the core of the entire model. A
strategic communications plan is the bible by which an organization functions
and communicates with its publics. A comprehensive plan includes: goals, target
audience, strategy, tactics, timeframe, and a creative concept that ties all
elements together. This plan must account for current trends in communication
and for WOM, as advocated by Kozinets, Williams, and Buttle. Current trends in
communication include social media sites like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
Snap Chat, and Word Press. Through the fulfillment of the strategic
communications plan, which employs a widely accepted evaluation method like
Laskins, engagements both online and in person and increased donations will
result.
Effects
The ultimate goal of any business plan is to increase sales and profit. The
ultimate goal of this hybrid model, as with any non-profit, is to increase
engagement thus increasing donations. This goal aids a non-profit in fulfilling its
mission.
The Hybrid Marketing Model for Arts Non Profits will only prove
successful if managers understand and commit to each of the factors discussed.
The model will fail if even one factor is ignored or not followed truthfully. Non-
Barnett 20
profits cannot afford to carry on with business and marketing processes blind to
new media. For the sake of the arts and its continued livelihood, managers must
embrace the times.
Conclusion
A non-profit structure is built nearly identically to that of a for profit
structure, the difference lying in the allocation of profit. Thus, the marketing and
public relations principles a non-profit applies to its operations should be similar,
in order to maximize publicity and profit. Scholars agree that the sector is
struggling to attract and retain audiences, which is leading to declines in
participation and funding that could be combatted through the adoption of
certain models and theories into its strategic plan. The change must start within,
as advocated by Senge, permeating the organizational culture. This means, all
employees must actively accept change and fulfill their role in executing and
analyzing modern progressive techniques. These include models such as the
Continuous PR model, which evaluates a company based on a series of
continuums with different publics at each pole, the Modern Marketing Concept,
that advocates for a purposeful relationship between market orientation,
customer satisfaction and financial gain, and the Systems Thinking Theory,
which encourages an organization to act as an evolving entity that survives off of
interdepartmental communication. Means of meaningful marketing mechanisms
include Word of Mouth marketing, which takes place both internally and
externally of the organization, and social media marketing.
Barnett 21
The research that has been put forth analyzes for profits and non-profits as
completely distinctive from each other. This report will intentionally blur the line
between these two entities and prove that the principles of business marketing
and non-profit marketing should be, and are the same. My report delved deeply
into business marketing models and theories, looking at non-profits through
these lenses. It is through this understanding that non-profits can truly break
into the digital communication age and revolutionize a dated practice of
marketing. Only then can non-profits truly pursue their unique missions and
visions.
Barnett 22
Works Cited
"About Us." Alamance Arts. Alamance County Arts Council, 2014. Web.
Alexander, Laskin V. "Public Relations Scales: Advancing the Excellence
Theory. "Journal of Communication Management 16.4 (2011): 355
70. Proquest. Web.
Anonymous. "C-Suite (A Special Report) --- A New Marketing World Requires
New Skills." The Wall Street Journal [New York, N.Y.] 10 Mar. 2014,
Eastern Edition ed.: R.2. ProQuest. Web.
Bourdieu, Pierre. The Forms of Capital. J. Richardson (Ed.) Handbook of Theory
and Research for the Sociology of Education. [Greenwood, N.Y.] 1986:
241-258.
DiMaggio, Paul. Culture and Cognition. Annual Review of Sociology 23
(1997):263.
Doyle, Charles. A Dictionary of Marketing. Third ed. N.p.: Oxford UP, 2013.
Oxford Reference Online. Web.
Gainer, Brenda, and Paulette Padanyi. "Applying the Marketing Concept to
Cultural Organisations: An Empirical Study of the Relationship between
Market Orientation and Performance." International Journal of Nonprofit
and Voluntary Sector Marketing 7.2 (2001): 182-93. Business Source
Complete. Web.
GuideStar. GuideStar USA, Inc, 2015. Web.
How a Nation Engages with Art: Highlights from the 2012 Survey of Public
Participation in the Arts (SPPA). Rep. National Endowment of the Arts, 26
Sept. 2013. Web.
Kozinets, Robert V., Kristine De Valck, Andrea C. Wojnicki, and Sarah JS Wilner.
"Networked Narratives: Understanding Word-of-Mouth Marketing in
Online Communities." Journal of Marketing 74.2 (2010): 71-89. Proquest.
Web.
Mataira, Peter J., Paula T. Morelli, Jon K. Matsuoka, and Summer Uehara
McDonald. "Shifting the Paradigm: New Directions for Non-profits and
Funders in an Era of Diminishing Resources." Social Business 4 (2014):
231-44.EBSCO Host. Web.
Barnett 23
Schermerhorn, John R. Exploring Management, 4th Edition. John Wiley & Sons,
Inc., 2014. Print.
Schulze, Christian, Lisa Schler, and Bernd Skiera. "Customizing Social Media
Marketing." MIT Sloan Management Review 56.2 (2010): 8-10. Proquest.
Web.
Scott, David Meerman. The New Rules of Marketing and PR: How to Use Social
Media, Blogs, News Releases, Online Video, & Viral Marketing to Reach
Buyers Directly. Fourth ed. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, 2010. Print.
Senge, Peter M. The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning
Organization. New York: Doubleday/Currency, 1990. Print.
United States. Department of the Treasury Internal Revenue Service. Form 990:
Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax. GuideStar, 2013. Web.
United States. Internal Revenue Service. Statistics of Income. Charities and Other
Tax-Exempt Organizations, 2010. N.p., 2010. Web.
(nonprofit one sheet)
When Going Gets Tough: Barriers and Motivations Affecting Arts Attendance.
Rep. National Endowment of the Arts, Jan. 2015. Web.
Williams, Martin, and Francis Buttle. "Managing Word-of-Mouth: A Nonprofit
Case Study." Journal of Nonprofit & Public Sector Marketing 25.3 (2013):
284-308. Business Source Complete. Web.
Barnett 24