Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
q{rIff
q{rl:l
qcE
g<--'
(
la.r:{
F{{
--
'
)---reo
1cf
{-curlft - ). $ffiq&{ qqlo Sq|q}"fi6-o,'qfiq6ns-c, 4{cflff{,{sE y{F-s 6ftfrsp-6,
q{a]lry
<l(a-[q-rr{
TETIST
fu{Kfn-b, <t(qrcqr.r{ {r{cr{,irtn6{= "{fru's-:\,
l15-)l'
eqWR+Tt
q(Et-e), quffi
s)--Yb
ffisw{r[s
qft*q{rEr
ffirffi-ec,
qrfi-q
eb-ca'
B<t<qrrr-r'Erqqst-q+:p{Eqq
qq;q1{{r^-"<
qffi
qq-m
effi eqffi-wur<r'rr-8o,
aqtwt6tg-eb, {qlqFrfcs-{
q{l;I E{f{ q-H-sIRs K(cf{r'f{-8q, ffi-{Ill\ii {5Ifq-q1EEIF{$
xs{I{GT
mq-ar,'Ts{FG-8),
elrqrgtr{d q{r{ q}r{
1N:8rD, fnqrgfi-88,
'qrM-A1frqF1-E ulqqi-8s,
rT1:ile--$ E&q1cca S"ttff{ <l
"1wB*1YtrI-91'-Yr{r:jq
atffi-<
ffi:B;,
Gqq-8q,
"6qi9"tr.
w1ffi-65, {qrft{ f{-at
s$'rrqrmrtd<tft{{Efst
(K(q|{rrFI-C'c,
ug{qtll'{
Go-<'b
,n?fe{q$
cb-18
ftfi-so, ryea
q'f<
ft<n-'b), Fm e'q<TB-v:, <l(EImT'EIqE s^{5f{re(kfl-q-se,
J1t6fi{
qu'
rqx< q51
.<MftF.tit'fri-{-su,
ry-<Rq,d-vs, QI{ s a{-q ryrrnot."* oltnt-sq, E-ft{
q'qir q:rrq-r), q1ffi- ro,1wfte qf,-c8
ffii:,
qnfu
qt q{rf{
<tgfcqur't-d
qfr{fd, frqR e
u.|ftrqa#
lc--$rr
ffifr-s
61ffi
@*
elffi<
vlll
wEq
"Et
b8_))o.
ffi
q$q
ql(qrcccr'l-d
<Icqfcc'rfi
fltrfi q{rq-)5),
rft1ft
r$q
.5*s,
d(EfccTrR DrgTl
\tr{m-:lu,
rNlq:))g,
1w+fto ft-)qu
<l(ETEEc.l-{
)))-.,)r.b
fiesn
Titrq-)l8,
ffiT rrrflt
::
mT
&c
&o
<t
ffi
ffiT[-ig fu qt{, )bbb-{)8, qt:ilqil-L)c,
Q,)1{eo
fr{6"erq"&'
ETsFI-Q.tb,
qFfl-Q,Q.b,
e.e)--ie\
q{jr \Tqlrs
FRqrcErErftr{ s q(:"1&
The People of Bangladesh and Their culture
T6{F qqXt<R IF qfrqIE-I frv* qq {(smr.fd rEs e W1& I <t(stcq?t-?r {Wq-{
1z'fff"ru
ffitr {errdqrr[E-{r{ 13dqtrrdl qffi atrff< {r{$ q<( ttq-< qt&< q{rl q{n Tflrff rr'rd
rrffi
F+q
q<et-d <tssrrqrrBr
o<-< r
sEqfr,
q$Irt q-u(s
<6:{F{
qvte qlffl
TgIR-s "tRE{
q<( qs'Jst q.a{ffi \$c6ttE{l\e
rr{rffi
x1&
;TRTB-$
ftrql
TLffe
RacO
tqr{& cfi (race) .FnE<lr{tfio cR"fcstrf <REt ifrq$ T'ff& r pffff qercs e<rQ b?-Rs
srrg& e iEFrfi {eq <lR<rfr-s 6{Rrr{- qrccr eQ f<FtSj'est;$ rffiam fu
m umu
qfGF I Gfiry-q< <|(6it qt& <t q{.w qtG
.E<rir
r
rtqiTl 1frEm r {Ss
W Qccg& r+F{ (Nation)
Elft "itm m c< B"rrc'r{ fi-fr crc sl? \l.n'.c-rr qs6 Enrqn {rdt r GI{6t, qrfu qryr,s qr{ q<s
q-fiEfr"<: 6{itrm Trm? vcvl
l"nfiuru frq EMe afl-rs cl{rf,{ vm, ntafuo Afrq, 6$crnfi14
t+$Br, TEfrs e qEsrt'Fo (dfi q<( ct{qfr srm-{ {c$ qmo &ron q{-qB e wownor 1e
Sense of unity and nationality) r t(trq, qrfr, qtffi, d(qrcqFr qo q<r6 qtB< ;rfq r
"rsnrcr
vrufrarars, ft{rcre fgltfr r e+ cefrgtrff< m
qFri{ 6fri-q< <I<q-T <{s r{ r 6t$Fil, <.f <t <t effie $FIEI (color) rnq'{ TFngrE r <go +f
w 6{rr { Tn&-< qsF E,tlqrq nIe I 6pqq, :rrutFrmv anft q{rqq <Iafi qc.fa r irc<
r
affi
!l,
d
d
*)
sl
t)
4
rt
6l
I
lr
wm
iR
il Jon M. Shepard
SociologtsC6ct Race-et t**in <Cq{, "Race is a distinct
category of people who share certain biologically inherited physical characteristics."
(1981:477) r q{q TCnff qcq q-{c(?UE 6qf q+ frcm qcq qr* fuqRa Ee-*rfi+r<
{rq q|s
ss-$rIrEI fiffi6 ?Tfu f{Ffe, {irct FGr r"
Etqt{,ft-sryrqfurq
{a6a s
Major r
1r'r6fqR
E.B. Tylor
ry*
<ft
lqfiPffi
frca &-tF r
of man-
()) Trs|
(s) o'afi!
q{FI {
1"
({) smft{
('r)$rl{B
(E) q(q-d q
ccfrs
Trs
T,ad
,s<q
rtrnott itmcq{
6--*
Tffi
fiffi
c{ffi }fiT f<ffi,< ffirs T'fIff< OftR'st"t ?Fil qr c{'Irq qE $efl, {qrtfr, 6{Iq, d;tE
fl61r rtv-{ er{fu, m-cca Bo6r5t, sq-{, n& e [ffi{ rq T{q s tfv{ +1&, EItrgR <i cE'rFR ?( s
e
qr{G,onffi
q{RUg mr@g
I
e{1.a
qg ({:FI
T"gfts vH ?6il I
qqv.t
rnff{
6fic'frft-s
c{ffiq{e ail
(E) sr{
(s) o-r+fu
{H
(q) qrnrl {
(<r)
{r{td
.fi
'l
{d
(e)ore#
G) qmil,
E'q,
qditi
,:
(q){o'il
(s)
qlr{ r
qr{fu
(rl)
{pllil
rc{il
(rt) .cmr t
yE-{Ei
(ry
qrscq
| frln-
ap61
TErSi
(s):rertl
qFEEI'!
<fqfim-c.R
rqs
cqfB
*,rrrfr
tor orofiia-cqr <rrr,tn q{Fto QEdilot, qrffiot, Fs-{ qGrot, {$etru., e<( q.frq qtkfl< frq
\{sE
}
<nft
Trn Sts
(s) +-rs'+scr-{
curcrl< <(
<s,
rfr ftq
(E)
I curni<
er.B
Ttrrt s qtql-qrd[D
(rI) nF[r ltr{lr <( <tqTfr e 6{rffi, qlam I-q F<q e c{lBI Bsr s{,r.q-{e {c{ eltc< r qcq3 {l?Irn
lq, {BR nt& q<s. 'irm fircqir org{<zrre
I
1<e1oroft*-*r Uao
Wqn
qfffi
qil'mt
Er{t CErq1
"fgq
<k$ e .tm
181 vmm nr6rl TF ft<tq< qrEE wrt sr'r <r(in r {qr : Td srirfts,
'qrffid-s, iff<', ffi{,
q1q qfrrqft{
T{<t6{
(e,)
Trunft{ q{crn&{
qrgkot
v{{Ifl{ft{, qr'rrri\,
f{Frt,
te< *
qfr"t
1-.i) Tr@rifrrrE-d
qpfr6ffim{
({) -{mr
N?tr<
qlefi
w1& oroftvcq{
@T qTrfft"
*i
e<(qfls
v,q-{rfl
sf<ftAaffcqn Eq-{m
@l
qtryfr+ qmqR'wn
Er
$rffi
qS
I qdiq o.5+,fuCqd
fr6{fgE<
:rs qE
Australoit
(q) T[EtIArm<T,FIE{l s
(s) Tpnftffi<
q-{,
<rffi
<l
fifrfift--Em r
qq {{n<
[q
(<r):nu{rftscq< TRrd
ovn 1r"n& a
ftd
uo[
w6tqmv wl
irykocq? fifu-r q
\rdIl{s-fl
C<ft r qroTftrcq<
qlr
of a mixture of Tl
fil
q'tm-wcE"
qsft ffq-d-s 1fe
()) qft{:rptmms
(q) emftr {rutrnw
Tylor, Dictionary
[.
L- tt
(s)ftr{t<tT+ffiT'frfuhfitI
(F) qrq-< <llrqn q{Fs vt&<:I frr.rq or< qErfi T{yfr< Efr(i q<( cfqrmft{m
(q) ftGfirii< ntcfi {{r{q\o q{r{Er r $rll Bq q<(seflFl Eqiil (vertical) erlG< I
(rt)
fudfcrr {{ Er^ut16rou?I--?
T{t1C< q<(l-Em
Vq-{lR
q-<
arqfg&< I
sr{
Fr<Frffssm<
(R) ft6{rcq-{ qrrfir Buosl {3':c'n r qrq< Tr$ \tr*{g, cttot e<s. ef'E r <qo
qg{
C{IEI,
f.E s nilgl
mfi
<t
fi
{rr
cqrco cAts
.<.
T{trl
Eu.sT
r<< qcr
ft;
q6s
{rro
{s
qIil
fcrrq-{
rfrql
ac'rIe{ q
'fF(
qt orrqt-<tnft I Isfl!il
r{EB e t@<
at& wrr6l
>bco {16{
*, + *
srrfi
qlgDl cqfq'l,
rs
cq"r$
othlele
fiS
G) Tq, {fd e <tdrfq (Coon, Gam and Birdshell) frc{lrm rrs-sB.e-l[1st'l r6{cq1 I {EtFraB ftctt, mqrffifu ffifrl, {lrryFt, <rf e mftr I qm[s qnr< qFErq ftcem,
emftr ftcn e crQ'fi qrm qQ c1ft fuIE srtr{
r
q-<.r
CE"II;I
fl
"r<-+fi1
'
il
qBFsrrsir
r rlBmFts
(s)+s?-qftr
({) EtsE-t{t&sl
(tf)
qleffi{, r{d
(r) cr&dafrm:
qrqcTg.
Australoid
ern 1trff .FIr.
qFE
fifta-q* ,'fi
ft
$.qrsaq
(the result
,m
q$E'c<.t
cfi
nntotc< r qf,q-{
1qq-rslrsd (ca$- p.t.
*'ffiil
1rffi
nq.5Y:ay
<sil qe
qrqr{ &tu+, sr
try
<tuTc-q
6ft{tP{s \ltrqfq&fu.+
*flTff<
esB eftft-W"fs ergr< Tfr{F
l1d src{ qrm uE to".n."*-,8r,* firftF," #;#}"'ffi'*o -*
I
a1q6-6qfta.r, Be-{
qerEr<rft
r
BuqK,fr$ qqfqfi'eT{
q
(T)
rsfefts
?frT
v 1q1sqp3
: ef3[e,
'flfrF-sr{,
(+)
({) Wtftn
Esaffi
qfffi
(c) <rq
'
tfrt{
(s) rFrFR-edd
:!
(D) fltt5il E6.r
'
(q) cft.r Eilmrr
(6)
, atQFt
eft{:
({)
T{qkn:t
i:
ql.rcrr1ff
ftfr,fR{
{"ErsFlsi,
fffitrqFrflr s{catr&
".
rqdFrfil
(T)t{tln, Efl
b
qfur{r,Es<qffi e,ftiqlrrs<qfffi
(q)"rl ' ry1ffim e frq-{ts .cn qfm
(R)
'ii
(<)
16rye954ft9,
TE TE ft"Rrfr
s r tFrnfts
1oi
llr'
qfffi
:*
.*
r
, Esfrqq
1q1ffiEg
(T) Es'{ qrnfir+n GB'ilql : ?DFn-er s {R<rrg< qrfrq qfffi
({) ccsn qrrffi+lt ft&'sn) : qfuq-nfu{ wrcaksr, dfuroi, 6s-ir \flzlfr-ot
1
.*"
't
w<rroftq-+c"n&
Grrs ET&q
fl{g
qrr{
qitBqqrqfr-s,mqfffi
:
'.
rl
"rffir*raruffi
({) T{-qtiiltflq
etr"ffifim;l
FEftFrrcffi{
frs{-ffi
qd6 E-s<-qfu
"
<REnrck $T{ s
c(TB
b IqIKFlrt
(o
"Xf
qkdT
; q1Qsilfiqr
{qr{, Qftef}rn
"g{wffi
G) <rt
(s)
ffiq
yr&o, e
fErfi-qEtffi
t-+t-<qks?qr w+r:nff r
: gt!5fr1ft-a 1'r ,r<-+ffnftq qfror< frg q<tqrft
"1{ wg-+r<
(D)
sq'C{rff
QErflER,
E{
*rt&-$t*
fiBFtFE\o
;tl
frftqsIc{ qem
fiffis
Efr"t-,fd,iFrsf,
qqfam qrn
11rfffi"ffi
q<FFqr{tscffifurr
ffiFI
Bw qmfi-s
qrtqfig.F
<6ftTTrrr<tq-
.1.
Racism
q&rS, fu
affi
\r-flq<
ltre
eRlftrt6t
46sa
ql|g<qc{ "r6fl
<6ffifr
1ffi
<.f.<ffi
q.ffi
{t!T r ctfrrqt
qSl
q6q|?I
cri
1gtt6
c.{sslT
fr'
qfffi
qle
T*ff
Qgqratll w{qf{
{<t
q*-
qe
ffi
,fi*cq qft{
7q<
{m
f<Ff6Bl<
Bssfut
Iffi
"fffi
lffi,
ffi
ffi
qffi
Acm c< tl
cq q-gFq{AEi,
q{l
F,rfimr
fr
g
3
aqo a'tfff"tv i
gl-6q-a
I
d
d
d)
d
a
p
d
"f.
fi-qttr
t*'
{ffi
1Ct*l]
qrsTfrns t#
I
${
qFiaffii q-ql
ro
Tsrm
qtcTB-s q'$sK
frm qr++
$IG,rft +Ecurffr< fr.Iq\ol s T{f& cs[q
"l<"\?-{i
BF-<IE 1l-Grcql q<( tfuqfcry< frC{ 'rd 6115g i5{I Ergal s1< ?-? Iv-r$ Efrft.-s Tir6o qTf{
(rfcffR{ t'
.
Ammon) el{rg
tr*i
,.iw
ffi1
1fo
ffi{t$q
"rFqHqm {
at&.Crna
.rsfftrs q"stF|E e qilRs
vqR I qlz"Irffi
<cfr<TflJ<Irq-'r
qffi
A;
rqrs'm( {cqFl.!
qr{td
6 atril
L. Nesturkh.
7'k
g Nesturkli, I&ai
c. Karuzina, Biol
qrftq'ffir rr{s
:Ilil)
qsro't
xalt
<"f{rft lFrcr?trt yr{ $Gn cq cfrrmr igrnrs{ <g E66r ntra&-o Eq,st Gft qr< r $ft{
fr{frr<} E-fs rspm q-{ fim&E qrs roFr wy-< R r qtfq 1Frqrft E. Schmidt-er v1rTfifr
q<(
fip{ft{ t$ frGwFt q'frqd e< {frTFt qen@trq r\rla
r ffitcc< q'frurd q
q.-{crntm nrrcsm curg iFrr r c<t'{ I,nq-d qr-q-fiir qrgs stifi ffirrcq'? {iK
"naqrq srcq?
,rsjstit r+sn qErF {-GrFt I qcrs Filtqs qr c{ rmrd qlflsi c(pt cI(TtrT Gs+'ssl-{ Cs.F{ {.DtiF
cQ rr
ffi
qffir
)tclffi
Tarm 1r-fr- {Es 3Emftr,1,qft< ocr i<<rffi q$ Rrrs c<ft fri .* r vEorfr, qEr*tfu
eF-sl{ Tcfie< cqftaiil wq-+ currE 1mw, of c{6rfm Iq, tt&, c'tt$, {fdr ffifir? cwco) r \meftT
{I(TIsr qtsr qdrq T'rfi"r. f<FnsJ< cs 6sq TN {r gf{-sr 6{e sr qrfr+ar wn <rrmi
61{E rE' q?H BXB< tu ryrn E=F qtfr*{wm "Ft6at T{r ,i.nr fu, 1ca. utffit \{Tqn
{ffi
snftfizq
'nrnBo
qq{
{Vt1ffi
f<Frr6,r firrt
l6"t{
q{t
ffiErqm< frffi wlt&-s vrqrffi frcrncq< T{r(T 1r.q.1 t?rm r-c< q Fr<ns
qtcfi crl T{f&"ls f<FfeJ +<, {fr'r<rc,t< qsffi first e *<afro crgk e,m c<Ff ffi
T{s a'rffav t<ft$r qrt cqr+ {t 6<r{, ryq{-1cil't e {fr'r{r.k qr{qryit 6{t{ qt& {t T$t
o'mrfrrl
9$
.g
a,
6l
p,d
-9
6l
I
\. Nesturkh.
e. .... "The Black race-have Progressed'fartherq from the ape ancestor than the Europeans-Europeans
are more like the Australian aborigiirs, in many respects, in having wavy hair, beards whiskers, and
.l
hair of the body." Karuzina, Biologt For the Nurses. P.255
a Nesturkli, The Races of Mankind. P.98
c. Karuzina. Biologt P.355
Bo $flfi-$
qqffigtq
gffi
ffi
arff
BsT.6 q<(
qlril&-s w<tQ5ffi6q-<
$'rdr .c$ft e
r
* a*l*.,
q<-\9-:R
EEt fr-6< crs qktrrrfi e'm r G<-?<ffir cg.T{ ftE o-*m nQ ; 6q q|{{cffi
qqu'{
sGF
e rRmrm fri-qq <r<r- iTN srflR frrt .ogq fttr qrrrm rb
ffi
"tm
{at{sa
cqm
qfumrq qqi{-s
^ry
{r<
p+a affar
q';6"16+,
1t{
<n"fF {q c{rl
X*
qrrffilltd
q-r<t-+cn-l
t{l"t Trit
rq
qtk
E-sT
rlTcqt JleIfr
FBil NordEf
qrd6F rGl
ry1s
Trtrff'frR e{
Em
frmffd
cttl
1Frelffi
a{
Xffi'r"
qfr:rrr#
ft fr-s r{
ctr'l
())
tEt
"refi <t
s't{l6r
T{gt
eIfrd |
st<-.stl ,sE C{
qRr{rr
E!
d
)bCo
sem 6{
frGj
fffil
Ees'fu e {f
.frftfr-{
T{FFF
"ll{$
Tme'lg
Hf
R-q{ qGtul
e{8
1o-1)
<.f<tfi1.i
orymu
FA
Muslim religion while the most diverse and opposed system of thought developed
within the same
economic structure- Gisbert; Fundamentals of Sociolog- p.254
)5' As quoted by Gisbert. from John Lewi$: I Texr Book of Marxist Philosophy. prepared
by the Leningrad
)\.
Jacobs
ad
)9. Hoebel,,t
)8. As {ud
(American
Jc
<l(EEc'r'R
IH{
))
c(Te
'
fr.6$Fr$-slfi?{tglE{listftqr+'mFtRflIGcfuFrr{CqR<$t{&T{?cts.w{flqffi<
qrpcqit
sgnqt q1(:1ft--s q{"fft rrgr1 q-{ r qfrq qqelflxl fu (Southern Negro)-fi-{ Ors E-g1
qR5q"f e qrrFt 'fl1 <CE Em 6{Ft
FBfll (Northern Negro) ft1r1 C<ft \fid x1I1@-$ s F6;6
1ft{:{EF
diKFrGK
qrrrF*
qer
qr&omcq< fr-q
r q"F'rcqF, {'r6s<
"ra r{6ti (Liast ape like)
?5N-sq- q
f{t6t +,GI
cq'r{{
ffi
ETK <(
E{i
-s
Fqlt
fMIft-Cm\{fuNq[q(si{<Tjff&Q{l(Tfu{*"-*?eTtT{E'rKrqfe<txa&
q6s ellcr
s'Rr fig< qt tcr frrcrsta-rm orq q< ,"
t, Ttttel:ffir8l
*n6* t{ffil<
Y
qrtfi-s
qR
sfi <r{ {RGsr '{El
{cl srq tp-rsrffi rT
iA rrr,tru-* ,rqgr{ {IqT|ff
T*I
ft 6.{ m o tErilffi Ef{-fuc{ qfi-$s< q{qf{ 6{FIcqa ry trmfico ffic< cqal c{cs
q{rq s c($1nr dFr$-sTF eo r fiEE cq{cs qc< *trye-o E-48-Cs -ron Tqrff ron
'Irc{ I (})
qRFfi (s{, Eq|lq.GK B"fsr"t) sr{q-fi6t sfd <ldqcscq
{aft <t EftFfl q<6r{r <'** 1 nft'E Aq1<1
scql .IlfrR.$ s mfr--+
coq FrRm qTrA r (l) eTt
sr3rr 6q T{((IFI 6qrs
ffi Ie1qr< qa w1qa
gtrecl' .1., .opt m vfoclcurffi-< "ttdo.rrr cf{ Tf{fs r (o) eoE nr."m
T*ry^***
a qtr{Frp1r
46We
smt
w<q6 6ffiq I "1* lq*1
{fr*.c"r Ess {qst{
ry lsxm
"r*.i
qr qst{ $Er{ s q-{ \5rq r*Y* 1'ttfi-<
)bco rrc{ 'mfrrc ?sr{qrst GTNESCO)-q<
'rd c{ fte cm q' e"rrq c(rt.rq Eta{ ilil qcs T{ I T'IrSr{ "rldrl fi{m **ry." 'du
q6s qlrs-{
s{rlfr c{64 qTafi q$ftg qrr[q cs alFqnslK
r
EI
?.Ftfifr, e,r<t fi-6<
qf-ft'- ,{ {K6ttE frs r{{ I qRSrT'Ir&3 6Efs'm<
Eqo{-sf e flCTfu ri$sfd q-{] T{fftAv E"ffqlq
E rBro
oorcn ,rtd- ;TE nrc"r< fcffilFwcq< nrrsr{ "ttdr+J< cu.m aft Trttqy TG"
corq
'ttfrR-s
i
r
**
t<S\q
T,ff51q" ?upt&
qntfi
qs
qeCF$
t"
r-{f
frfl
fto
cqrco
urnre
fllBq \{fmfir<{, GfrsFlTt e
1{+l
srrG uEcq r EFnrcvof< cqnql qr$s fr&f,
qlfral,
<cf<Ifi-fl cq urqorq, q1s 6aFI xrq-q cQ I
L
!,
ffi ffi
wu g*o-**
sqs
ti.
lr
)t.
)e.
'r:
f;.
t
)8.
I
I
i
li
l40l)
Statement on Race"
As {uoted by Hoebel from H. fr. Shapiro, "Revised version of UNESCO
363-68)
PP'
1952)
10'
Journal of Physical Anthropologv' vol'
:O**t"*
EE qt{rfr'tr q$qfrwfa
){.
116{
il
qpr
+rrfiftr
nQ eoql qt
.1-gf+{,T{Jv-trt q6g ,fr{qotl
6s
ffiS.t
*,ti
qfr eBE t
e1q.Rtft( tcft{ rt
,?.
NI"{grvr<
ags q qxDE
qtffiJt rrm{d qq
flTtrcl.ffi (Karl Pearson) Nature and Nature (1990) qr.{ EF< Iln tscs{ Tirt mrg {r< r tlfrr
Tr{ <'GFI *
6{ mr{ "rfr{tT sB\rrltlq {srr{ir q-{ W
"nrs s{If"rB-{s ${$ot< qfffi qttu
<FR Tq ey{E- $1-6 q6q{.6qFt I +{r<-{crd rF fiffi6 {frr<rq q<,{
Trffff< 6{r{rfi< setir
qsrq
q(rfi
<({{B{
<tqryrcnef*r:tr{c{rd Iltfffu
Trfi qt&* er{ qrB BffiEl'tc-s
t{Frsi qrF <'{t snr q<( cq uR+
^-&oE
(frfir)
q{E
Iffi
**
<t(srcqrm
lr{s
c<pFra"nff<
\{rmru-{t dt
{fl
r. r{rq efirt fiftq.-${q' {{rffi 6sli ff<f.X "nem qrsfi q<q ffiiU ttirqtq
"nd cffi {T
erc"'r"t frfr{ {trrt fiq
{ror qr,r <*rr{ T-{rq Etq
slr <fqEfrTr,{ <c-{rriFtftrt mrr qF6 '
lc.
g'ffi
q-${e 4{"rou
I <Rq qlq-ir
qtqpffiq, 7affiqry
qfrr,ct
vu
=mr
<RstrFo
)bqt,1rsb
rtd,l
{
{c$.1q
erq-d ersF{
qzq-r{<
qfftr
e,s-R ?[MR
*
'j
6r $ 6qrs
rrptffir--{t Ess
c
werlBcu c<6c
EEqBr
fo.n
qE Ertr{B-d
\n-{rqrrq cs .ere
<tR?rrc
{rqfcqrR S
q Erptr{d q-qrsc.i
E{ vls o16 * !
'.fffiET
rrft
#rirn
tr'q
cFFl, cDltl
frwrq srg rH
erq? qfi-+trr
{
lcsifiltr<[ a d
ffie<Rd{
Trf{tcq? :rc$ oil
rrrElrq
qw suQ
cft{ qs frrsrqo
Elfr-s-ersrr{{t EIr
<RErccr.rr
qrR wfrv-@fuq
cEt{, <fslfr gFH,l
w+nrefu.c-<qt
{(sfm'c.B
{{
<tE qffiRrcnav{
s aq{.lErc q(EB
T{frlTcq-d elgrirq
I
<t(qEqrtilTl{{ s.Rafr
grsn "rrgq?
q.I1r6 qfu
Efrnr< Bw-<<
Esr{ fies'Fr
Ffu',u E9ftqr{ {r$Cq<ffi {61STI q{
q(rfi {r{I,4R
ry
ffi
.te
fi
{t ({-s qft
qtcqrcFft <uq
sfts
*ps-qlfrgFi?
Tt*
G-['f
"
qrttlfr-{^qTl.AtAqc"f
qrp1ffir-fi B-s< e t6tee Carmt \nIrF51<ry fto< 6qm6rq1 qs(q?
*qTfr* cirCET{ & eo C{c+cq <rq ft-<rrdcf{ rI{ {r* TGFr I lryff* As3{' icallE {Ht'
WtO=
'frq-ff,"ro,
6f<
]c<Fl
TT
rflilq
o*t fffrq
ffith
-ry"**
T*ff*
&ql1 efsn q6?r6 {Grcq I F< &fr sftn< 'fiR <s, nt[sa "$q, {c'l
sE ffil $s sl {c<tr
mrt.:{-s frrtrcqq fi qrc-d vcu urfu +9,5rr Rql{t{ r er{t Tlelrr cR't<Fr&I
qr
{sa--{ q-+cunff r
<t$frfl rylqqFq gvfio
WfrV ef\rlrfrR r6t rfsq'rq $ {drco El{ 9
i
<n t&s {{r4? {f{+t | {Es
<11nftnHu qlorgpc, qf{sitt ft 9$E {rfi era Qi.T< *gqa
e rnt
q<( sl-{-s-<d <cflln q{K 1ffi +r< I qr{ffiae eT
eTR EfiV-Ffug.cq< 'tEiFts Tr{
qfffirq( Tc$
q< *Yl".T.Ft fi'tl {r{'
oH, {slfr g6ot, t<n-r sEretcq-< {[u
qs I
6<fi slit"tFrE qF( EsT{ qeft w[q El Eta{ffifi
w{.rr 6sfu e<( :q,.m{
q<( t<lfrffi ersr< -qcrrq
{34, qr<R, qftfrfts
<t(6TEq-rrd Xcfrn q-{cuIIfo" W,
ot<1w$r
rm gm 1rm*r" {cfitaftl<Rd' tsrs n\5 em arU= r 1<
pm<f ef,{&rtr{ r &
<R<t'F5
"m
;"'{ {s.fs efir{ ,hffi fi.{ Ccfrs ft<-qtefr$ Efm< qt"ffft
*:IYT
&A
***,
T{ffiq.CEi<
qsr<\K{i1s c<Ftq*
)8
Eo qtTJft-s ryrqRe.rq
rs-fir- qrtrrir :rF qrcr.t frE Em. TC.fr R{ q<t 6fr8{ cerr$
c+i<t <c+1, fiE{c.f( RTffi q+E q<.r {tr-<-s Ec{ {carrmr qmcqq
{ffis
{rqrFr
Ecs
ER-cq{
kt
qf{
sC{
.I5T q<
w(
ersK ,Ifirqfus
q{
qs
s{m
<t
rfi
<lcqfcqq< {f{Cs<
())
$x[r
rrr<116r{
<l(qEq?E q-et&T
tr*
{rs qrr
$.
w1+-ttr
o.fS
qeB6q
())) <lcqlcc"t
fu1-qrHffiEq({
<ttc<e frcs qr<
s
:ryqT'&:{
qrr
<5<t
T*
qrerq
se5
ffi
q6q
m.m o-gt
ftfi qffi
rFI c:rr s
ffi
q{In
yaT{lTr$
neTfrrr qc
Atos qfiq
frtfrr {.iER
ftq cc Bsr+l Frffi
6o<q
{r$
(Culture)
ffi 1c9 ,nem ft<Ffl {ftfl T3il efcrrq{ I ottsr('.r{ T]Er qftErs ffierzqT
qfue-*I
c<{
(lo) <lsfrq
T-dl ERrq{ I qls
sfr{
sE<
RersqTr< ftqBr'
ftns{6fl fr63
s xttr< <l-q frfs s-{r r q-d"ff&s slar er6F e q-.fcg-d {pt 6sr{
fi-{ffi s{"r69-d ffirr{E &q Et 6ird o-<l I T{il Tffircrr< u"nmft {frR.t qqr6{ ss <ffi 16{
mefl vt {rs cnrtrc {trr
(\)
ITsa{
(r1
EgrJr(qr{
_
sFr6o {6{
-.
sr{ alqffiqcK wqez.o- TF{ <rar{{ IC{reT e&T{.frflTr{ I q< T[$ wr{I.
nf,wlrfir e<( F&eu er\r-Rt c<Ft r l-+Ign qH {r-fir ur"n *u* rqjenrun <R*r$r1aFrrcTT{ ssm
c<qff{
srrqJ q<(
ffiq*t I
tln
s-{t Tts
cn"lI
*tE
Tt
sR
m,I
frqBqrffi
-. .a
ft+ns d
q<q-dtrta%
freaaqeru
Robertson
ff
1qtd
<t$'rcq-r'k
(ru)
ffia
qr{Rsfcc<
fr{-ro-n
atff
{E< e a<a&
)c
qfir{
r-GI isrzq<
Affio
ffi{
(lo) <tvtfr crlrq fr<Trq{ ftB-ftfr frr.m ocr {rq-?rr& fr{run qtrt&-s e qff-{ ffi-frm< c+
Trt rrsrq-{ r qrs 6$Fr a5gq sq-6fti5 fr$rst ffir{ rtrfrd cutl E-{rq Fnfr frfifrmc<< <mt
Ec"rq sr{ qr{trF qos s <-6flT{ fr-<n <"q-6{ qrffi Ecrcq
I
()))
rtt(sf(q-cfi wrc'ffff<
Ttffff{"
,6* aoffi
(Culture)
qqCE rTI @efinition of culture)
qr{rrs ffif
tf6t{ctlr qqpn<
efu
1ftfu" qrft6a<
e1-6
ffi
..{<(
ftfi{fqK {fmqrr{
<Eq 6-{G<
Wq c{lq fr'ta
&1 unqtc{q Tsqlx{ e<(,w{ifi Tr$ EEr w[ qnr,+< ?riRo e nt{fr's EIful
lSuUject
qir{<BRx1G<\!s6
Euffi
Fr{(q.
frBacrfqffixlGr+n1n1s15qq1u1froTgqa
Robertson '6fA Sociolog.{fa[ <rdFI, 'Culture is all the shared products of human society,
comprising its total way of life. Culture includes material & non-material products."
(1980:562) r :TcEIS Frrfsq
erm
cq"ll
sF, ccafr
<q
q:rm
16
nq{q r-F
Eqrnfrro fics-{q
Eo':$Trfrs qqtsfut1
{t qrrq<rft< ,r{l qrra ffiH T'rE .{<( qt .rmB.1flq 6<T{F{t qffiT {u-{
T(TE rqqs w{E'ts qrq frqr+Q rry-sfri qrr
s'c:r
(it
Elr
qrfqffi
physical objects
&
M.
TE q<(
crrrqr {qrrcq<
c(a&
T?IU
r*
*cri
1e r<
tu
Jon
r ffi
lmfr
a<Su
lrtqrFl{'
knowledge, belief, art, moral, law, custom, uni uny other capabilities and habits acquaired by
man'as a member cif Society.'- qdlq, "ciirq3 qo* ric*cu qffis qrE?-qfEqq, 3r{qr{, Er{,
qqTG r"
frgm, fiE-sql, ftGqt, qrqa
sBq cnTm{q
ffi
<Qatv s
).
Em{ats'q(-rB
'
u*mf,
1H
fficett
o.k
rmtr cEitl
l<ars ryrrs
qIreIE-{t
srt ffiF
flIGr
"i{
c(Tfr ],fle <.lsil T{ (Concrete object) 6qird1 Td-<t&, il"rg-ot"rg, <Fta[ iil b-q-q,rq,
*, EFr s flrrl-qmqT a*t*q ** * _"q-* *t
1su,Td;ttb W,a,. c<r.r- 6".EgnE<qq$
=rE
{s cnile rqls tqTBr fir* "td ,
<Ett {F a, eo{fi alqt q e<r6 fa i aA
qfts
"q*
r(TG,
erq <r-ql s fr-qrwrq< {t{rn xts sR 6$-srfit e ur6( (<t w{E tE rr4ruuy
<Erls'
aetfuqrt
{c#
aF*
*eTEw{
1FIEH, .3'=-{E tE q(TtE <ai-cu u-16ag {Iq-qi1l, fu-$tsl+{, E{d-<ryd-Tsr{, itBilG, Ee[
:Eir<t(,^\flr<'i-ugr, t-glrn-a. 6{t{rlr r \trfts-q rr{tTi a-< frqg (abstract)
c{{-+- st{r s
,rlRs.r,
qt{, il&, qq.f tgfifims q<q6rs qcT[cn v{i qsfr Tirt1ffi
Er i c.* sR qs,
\tr<g'lg
ffiE
sl qi-C{ t s<( EqTrtF-s qffi r 6{:tr-4- Cfrr-trtrrmFa, 6{-{-qlq-i[, rrr{t Qg-llfr< qffi
ft c{rq fitml sefi fffl&-s qT6I{ qB&H.s q{q'rs q(TBT {C{r errg
I
o.
r<{t.rqlq|
?
,
,8. Tl{tlt
mrafi{1il{
a
f, cqq.rM
a -tuEas#
c<r<rfrql
Er?f6r{fl <qt {EI 6q, esB {rG r{rs r(T&, frE q&m ?sR< er6Rn e Fst-sr++ e<(
ffi{rfid} T-dt E{'cxa w+g'rg,rqT& r'qr{ario cq&F qao qlro 6q-q fr.s{r{'.q-s6s +-*r ca q
r
er{
@.:
l. rrrqfrl
ffi,
allr
iEr(g r[Er
'
a
,,t
mrrqni*t{.r
'-$n
,::
d(ElrffiT.k
Ir
Ir
k
utf{retrqcqq?qtg'tsarafu
['
h
F
h
h,
qt{6.LT
ts
r
t
h
V,
I
E.
Ttv
ts
?fifr''s qcH
clfi
I'
i.
.?.
F,
F
F
qffi
Td"t.
t. lrqmfrglft FI{-{GE{ rcs q-{E'ls ataG< Vr{l{ qlrs ata& qs rtB.cG qfi6s EF
c(TCa qryq qqqft{ Ftrr }Nrq< Gq w{6rl.a&-errt( q[$ swcwrfrTsrd Ifr <l
\. TE ls x1&-< urfirnr q1616t q{E'ls xa&< uRn e q6r6ffi 65f,T $i'FF
q{Qrrs
e. <Euts r<afr< B{rcrffi R 6iFFr ccn <r qrG qril 1tu <rs "nrf, fus &q orr<
r(TG \tr{, m'.t i qru Erfi {q{t "1fu qn n1 t cqr{ qITfl E{q 6+1i cc' .trr *mL"tr-{ <t Te"[&
{qfi qqq sifiat .h w mr.m <Effi-+ sxtc{, q.'-{-{ <l {qtcdq :rqfl Eq"t +R il
8. Tqq\o ICT&( qqqB-ro t{fl flfult s<l sl'{ t "IEFIIf,GI, w{qrrs q(afua VXfr < x'-+m
aitrqGt qfrfl{ ?Fin {t{ qI I Eqr.ITtt <cn stg 6s, q+EI^I.1\5 \;rrq< ocl'rB EI,?E .i'rq< srcfi.-l
qc{r rsHE
66t e<(fua Es41qs T:Isl=t xc$ "rtdo, Tqfi qs Fd {fs I frEEQ q65as qqfizu<
!keu? BAs qfcl? q fi,fr:m -.{q{ ftT" ql"R{S d I 6qT{ slrdf sftq fte sfcafi st'c$ qf<R
r
F)
I
f"t
lrr
F
{Ffr{
1ffi
fclrw oDm
ryftur<qcq;
Ur{rq-r
hi
bt
5-ry
trBFF
). {E'ro q{qflE Eox q-{cry< c(Te qlio mfta Iffi , qfm ergt q-+lcQll ellft cqe 16
a-65u ercr qt I c+<s qf$A ctTBrF qlft q<(Nils w{galg Eg's r*r+< rqa& {r{cffi 'rfifr
Se<-tm qrfl lt:il&-s ts-dtfq-st{ R6{-6( 1ev n < qs
qs r Ew qilcrd c(T& {r{rti
q. Ew r*r+* rra&
rqrl-d qcrrw*t qftcq
T<fl?Frfi
qrC{Q
h
['
q{E io
rTt q[Tlqq :rr{cc{ qit $rffi <Eqs Ifr"s <U,rs tafu q<( qqqs {Ec+
araft T{t rE I {q{s \B qTE1E Xa&< 1-Cq., cITrI e ?ang.R< rrerd <nrcq r fira e qqIl(
qrqrsqlg qd qq
i'
Fr
c(T&
tt'
{c{R sltv.r
c(Te {eEf, qqIqffi ffi.qE.ftfrn; m.Ft. ftB-q e< t{REg {laqm q$m qnrfi r|qa{
c{Fro -E-ts" e x1B< {c{i q-&r6frcfr{< ,u51 q<R
P
E.
)1
ts
qffi-{
{l$ s :r(TB
?
3
a
f,
a
t,
io
I
)b
,qqlst
Civitization
William P. Scott \ilT Dictionary
csrtrIl 6S|-r{I Gr{rS 1W.P. Scott 1988:48) qgI\5I rraTls qsr qs E-4uE mrwm 6{Rm ({{rr{
qq?, Ef}E $q futq, pns qIB e<r E-4s afsffi+, {ff-q, Efffis ,ea( FIssEI
cs{f{
6fu,
Efsoc-{rT{eftSnfrim
Iffirs
fiE zre Modern state (1966:325) E5q c(TB q<( cqrslil qc(, 'fltrfl Frcii-J
orcg fttr {[alt{{, "Our culture is what we are, our civilization is what we use." qd\
\Eirfqil c'(Trt 5 uFirii Tr sR <(qF[ilt rtt <Fq-{ TtR E'R qq qrtrpiir qslq rMaclver
qqe
,Igrstiil :rct$y.tqf
cqT&< rrcvt Ts,srd "ftr fiftm ott or< r qcu c(TG e rslEl q*r6f
qrn
a*r$ <c<
1tlm. {Erqr
>. rtaB q(q q{Ftg Tt-{N< q<fls 1fr, wm wrsr EE rEqg
16 I ,{ Tgl{,fr{ emt6r Rrcr{
qTlqfr-affta {(Et FEd.t Fil?t t crFr+\[Frdt <rGfi
1frETfr e
\
,
(6) E&Id E&fto 1frg[ft Tylor-qir msrt ft{ c(E'tE,6TiF Tinn cc'qr rtr{ ffi s'r{, fr.dE,
Fqt, ft&, Sltq, EQtt g<( qqrrs-{ wrqi R6rrc< Tr{crr w{il;il cqlrlq q{(. qFPrr$ c(Te
r
(q)
rfiqffi
we{
rtaB @ rr{rffi
q-{qG
16
have." q{it rrmd| qrdR r<aG I qEr \fi:{rcq< ql wrR <| Tt qtT{t ?rr{q|3r rfi c{ER wlst
qqudfr[s qrft{ m TEs Rt rlr q|TEEir t{FfS, <t \flrfcti? ff<Tqqfrq cq:EfB rfi @ I qA
I
TITCT{ q{{rlv
ffi.1.q.m
$ twfrq q<q ?Kqf{ ffi' dt <ir( \trr+$tl
f<Iq I sE(rr, cqTG {c3.iq{kc3 qfiD{,,Tsrst qs rr{c{d {fls 16 I
fi<FrsA
r \f,'Er?rm, qf{fm?
EF $Trs?
{tfua
xa&
fr$ llnward state of mind) r rslgr< er&Tqq ryrs r *6 Efra 31'4p4 6qF
frs'{ T{ rata& lfrs rfi;qlqfir'ql roettft qrrfi <Er\o'fifr mrorq ccr.|g {slst Ter6\5F <Ifu$
u1F-sr mcq T{ffiR ,{TBI qq'rq <ril rnt ftE x{e wq56 ttlc1 cer6o qF wqltQ vt {sr iir
fr[F@ Ee mrn Trycr{ FrR-v qq-rrf qFfi Gq r $ d EF & crrk TErs-d qlErd-qlE-dct
@E-cilr
il
mT.lit c-sJsR
crrm x1& @
etFelfGt{l t
rtlfi
re'fe Trdq{df
qrm r qtBil( at
TG $tre ?uR qd
Grs uRci 1lqr
u.
:l-v-Frt
a.
'rnRB
{s{t r .{Bt eafi{
Tsrt qR c*td
qA qc{F
11-gC?
c-s,
Frm st'r-*t
q-s(e
esrlt
qqB< efmlrlit!
TDrr6E',ts
crH<
ettd4l ETTi
{r$
q-{fr{
a. c-s:'rr+
utfi-s 6mbr grf{
Frsoqns qGxtt{
arTfr
rqw
<t
FF{.f
qs? \ns.ft
or* ry{qE eN {
gIFIr<FTI
qq{{d
i
o qspm til
{Titr<tl(, c{, Ef,
E{qr{ qls qG
mrsrrd {r{r{{
.
*o m'cq<
ard
11 i{R m, I
oqaFmn frSl
BEftqr-{ {q-{i
e rFr
fslrsfir rrTr-{
rcrq "le<Ta,${
{ffi<tryFd
<t(Efdq'rkrWq
If
t
!.
t
b
r
I
eaelB
{efrdulv qm trfi qrr aI r q o,Kc atrt"n qm c w1&'a rfrr{6t6 ffi "ff6qsq s \{({rrqct
,tElk frsfrfd qfifrq qdt q{ r q<iB ftq1 aqF{ Eq (Study Tour Group) qNT T{r{ 6$fd{t
(Ec*r :tsrsrd fimfircqc{ cq cqt.t<r frstr e q{B rq[-6 cllW-qBotl \Nf{ rrcs qlrrEe cq
cmrl x1fr (ry, qfuBqqt, {fi<trc, q{, \{'rF,{ stl fr<rq*{.tft) rr-116 cwq lqd qlstt \s6
iFltg'mTql
qsFl <rRrc <en gl stfrs r E,Efiaq <l Eim-r, T{rF aGrtT <t l'GTrrfirrq (cq"qsr\5t
rgfe T({lqfrcsir frc{ r $I{-{R.tte q67s6 frqs I TE6q{ \ssR t{cct i{qfr Ebrsglrq srM
qfrq r qB{fl< <l o,qnfr.rq <fre qq6qq gr,at,
Tfl.t <tr{s qt, stlfit ut MIqrsrr< +l | 6{rl-+qrd fi"rg ffi qem {fr"rm qFm qrq? wrriFi EqER sfr | qerd"rcs, q(fts qsls-\rrrQ qFrEq-<
\r.
a. qilRt qf{{6s< (Mathew Aamold) q(g, qs'T& qcq {tE qefl, <t qtffio qs$, Tl trFQ-q
qe$ r ,sil *461 a;afr+ qirqr I efi e<sB lfu <t Tr1rrs fiffi{ r'fi s.rrFrrc qsrg s-Gr r qR
:l-srsf @ 6st{ frq {fsl, csn
qI
"md <A eflat <| W{ <qt r qbt qq'E afts {R[E.t zil wr*fi
qfi Tc{d csFI\fl-{3t:rr I ,{ {r<.nB{ rwt qlrofum< {R.rkfrfra{ TrscE inta& Tsxrrd q
{irrK "[tr{t, ETIF :lt-C{ Clive Bell qrEcq{ 6{, 'essentialty the civilized.man ii artificial'
r
q{\
r
:l
I
n
a
i
i
!il
I
c-sr:rE{q-{.fFTfr{ }
. a. c-v'lsfrs qfrfl1 s-dl qR r erB Ef+, mfgf* f&< Vq.{fr qv{tfr I !$<l3r sqfifrE 6ts W
EIf$o \5rs{ yqqls qft-s ,{fu.trfr s gqe6q-{Tn 1'1ne1-s,r6q,rxa& frc.m ora zFTa qqT& Tt
FtE-{qrRr {fr{tcqr frrnn rpfi {I{ {t I .{{c{t lt"rls fiN,d1.pr-<r{qR Fir]<l erGrrffi qs irmq
r'(Tis <T fqas-{K {"r-i frur< TirF 6{rFr fr{fr'S rrrsr6 '[TI rrTs qt r frEffir qrfu-csrr{ cq<
qvs< sst \$brt$-{ TH 6{rs qt csT; stq:rqrr< TIcTfr,-s
{ry, qtG-qqq s{rr< ,rrraG-o qcm*
qffi
qfirs(
qss
qF,q-{
qB< IqTT< s qrnE, v1q& e
cm
orrq r<Ft <q "ffr'tFb qrq r
qnl<Ht glq'q{m ersH c,rcroE un
{ql Ru'rma $"ffi eHrsl
e; rfejsR FI dt qfry{c G 6sER ry<qe cf$ s-{C6 {Ird r g.r<, Csfm fiT .fd !TtqTE-$
ITitrTt(, q{, c"{4, Ersffi$ qrErf ffi \ffir cc.r.R mr$ a-* rrqrql $v <u at r nqF+
q-<n $,rcqt T(ncE,t
E"IF?F qflq eTQ l--{ffifrsw 6{rrg orqq Trr I q,llr"rm, q-g.JsB *.
i
ffirsrnt st${"f <lfu <I cort wqu q$q E-{v cq-r.|< rrdFfg !l ffisI| qe{& {sil qs Iq6t s'{cs
B-Cs cqrfi rra& sgBr qE Rq sH qt
.I1 s'tt a-s, rtfr'-{ csrcfr o-cil-&mfqt qfr srt ys-{Ws-qr< qEg <c61 qsq{ cT
6T'c{FKi{ ffin (E'fi E{rfr $r "fifv GEIr5rE <r 6ffirn c(Rrw{ {t assemble <r{cs efErGr,
fiF-q+tsrc{ 1-,R.'{ TrEa <r rfrsr {Fl rircs E{ c{A {qrsa q6s c.HE+t {rm lt
q <'Kcqq f-vqft-t (4.1. Toynbee) <rqcE{ cq,
q<q slrEi r{Qs qr{,
"rfo'rc6r* \-q-dfi TgDI
*'utaT Pr<l 'IIfu, ,ry {6[ir{l{ vdt xqffi qtEI \5r$rd6f Tirr{ qt r gfti fr6qs 6qy5a 66p6ag
mm "trffi e<( cqrq-qfr's 6qrrm Tds-ql-rdrrE-{q'r-s$etul EflT4rfr FrCq q<( o-*rs Drcq ftE
{ c{&-qfuo ffi e ffi qq6q aqq qrrs EH qt r q6S ,rs:sf }1-q{r "{As <ne a<aB
r
lo
Bo ril$E-s
frclq
{e Effil{awl.R
fkcqz-qcq rqr*rd
glg, UIEI, nFF
qr$ sF5, ETr{
qqBs
q<( q\5
qftqwil
*fta
ftq6}e
firfrcr "f6g I q<.frfr? qfts mqwhitehead, :rl Hobbes-T Tru, xtraB-o E"rtcr* q{ q<( ffi{q qqB-w utBrc e{tm E-F
st-{.B' {{ sefu-
qftrl
}dfrc,lrl rrrnr-qt{i wHlg En r 6s;Frl, qrqrst q{
't&-F
'rfi
'6rcqs
\rr{
Trtr{"<6,
r{&<r {BF FT{ {ft${ <s <dq{ r twt<aB-+ TFr{F Cq'$l
ro. x'J&< 'rB r{t< <t qo <tq 6{Rt ql c<r+ ltaG< eoB xeryr <r o{ qirmR$\st TCs[q
c(1frro "r{f&s s-{l TH {I r 6rFf6il t"f.[Es qrsrrcq sejEl Ksffig qF qfrd, ftE fi"{Tst{
ata& rrqrq K(rI $g q{ { r q e|ir6qt Cq$rc1{r ftfrq ,{Ierrrr$ q-41frs Tr-{Rq {6, ft-E
EqTr{ iTtcT&-s e]q(na eq-{ qffiFtro fuft ftfrq sh
qrrtrrGtrslGrir ftFs Rrqr{ fiR
"rq
q<(
qrroqtor<Q
qmft{
erq&rfi
avlBr+ "IRA, w{imi rtTcr< cqTEAgE- crrRrqq
"rm
eatsim qffi{ q.r& 6{r{rs "rfles F<rFr slfi c*Er-d qqt, sm, d, E{ti{ .{<i.q&&rq oR"t
<rr{frq r uft qqt D-FI ({, cstEl ,Rlil <me ta& ,ffig q{ Tf ;
TaIII I qEI s?k{t-<t
q6s
q5g
il
[.mTTf$65s4 rff
Tsfrc {Ei"1.glfi,
sfts=r
+<EI{
{FITffd TRM{ d
st&, I
qf<ErTq{Gr[Er'
rrq
q-<&,
q,rrf,{
frrrE
E&Gre, j
Tt(wfirt{ anr<sr"t (erm "tirf<t ba vl't) TE{ qm <rrr sGH I wq< <t(qgcr.Er rr{rffi
cqffi \{ttr
<l(qfcqT.k effftct ll{rsr Qqa {-fick e6ft q64641 rFirrc qr<
ryro {itv
<l(qRErEr qi{ qrrrq {ss es6 Offi ftrqqm q.F[ {q${, qFmtftd r{E rwq ftqffi{
qft q.Re q?s F{t qm r aIIF-d q{l{ qdTrr{I
1ft r wo< * otto<|ffQ qg,is <t "fr<fwfz< fRa
q&v
Tl?q
r @ \rrcm ftfr-sfr asn Esq r Ersq<
vftq-< q{r{ c"f.rt r vlQ rFil st's 6{
TR
rlaFt ilqt$ qfrmm qH "rcil Try rfd urtss Etqt({t? "tqqsB fi$dct
{.rr
TB r Sr< ffir "ltesfr
&t? q<q Et-{rt-{ 1R <rm Tr<<n rfr rrqr{ r q"rrd qmrG-ff{fstR qefuq ur<iR e<( qr{fi-
il
?Fm {fm-q r
w1$rtr
fi{ ql
q{Fdf(g,cvi Td-<|
frrt{
iR{rq T-{F
(Steering wheel)
q&
{Rqftrcfd
{tcErfficfi il!
ffi q<(q.rFH
{qqTlrT{I :r{
qqn eQ wrre ltll
TGr errrfi qrl\ {
^.-,
r<FrsoFr
tr{s
qil
{6 "fl.Il"llft{m
<rCErCqf.E
aff
ffi
8fr-aq r)ctd
e-Isf'ctRsl c
EIq-E{T{r atq
el
6qrra
tnri
qffi,m,{
cqt FTsI,
qfi, qfi
i
I
I
!
i
i
I
r
!F
t
F
I.
h
L
I
r
t
F
n
h
F
p
Ir
r
ir
r
r
h
F
i
q-5 s rr1fr
dsTrccr{ir
r.)
ql{s E&t,
qEfi qftqr{ qd(
"IlqT{r-"ttwa s
'fIqQ.<Kqrd a-GF{
fu{s frrR q-{6rn qrqw <I ElbF {rcet
c'r$ q<( fgr "rr-firr fri(rq.<ro {B nwa
',rE{F +;rF cq{t rfs r ;Irt6{.flf-"rri ea <F{rfr c<ft
qrFrrwri v*.<tF< GXE.I ttrome ctsF.ls tH, c<o q{ !3r bR< ofcq <Kqf{ qr I ,{Tq-l'ft.i
crrtiir M c<gl, tq{ {F q<( fi <t ?rqd eEft mert qcq-< qtftol Err qfi frLTzq I w<rator{
{B-{B Er*< EIEBF <t frrq{ qcr r{<rq s-(iFr I s:6q !ffir. Ed< "nor <rfr-rg mrlr w r cqtr.Br
c{rtril 6src{t qqc6q fr6.;q <rc< Ew&re fiE{ mrrFr ${ cqql qR r qrrrqterl e<( {lfrd rl.["&q<
fuF <iRrc.t <t& scrd q mrm HElr 6TsF T{t sF r B@{i G QFIfr( {ffid q-srm frfi? <r<-{r<q
ffi5s Epffi:ffif tr$ "rmt <t&R qtft$i<Gne
1ft ctrrrt r smraq \fl{t{r+t qq Fffiq
<REIcC?fir qfE-olsf q?FFEr
"m,
ryea
sls,
\516[,
fi
ffis
frffi,
wfl< errqqircrcq
qrrnir
ftrr<
\e
{E rwrrq=r q+F q(.t, .qmfr q$ Tsft[q{ qmrs 116 TE, {l1'c, utfrq, ert
RcGt
$ft-flfr ctr<?fi
st[Eq{
E(-<
ffi
c{r<r
q(rlir{ <rft qm )q
q{.RT
vq&'04, RTfl {frK, S6llutot af e<( 6nE{-dI fi'trcrrs Eflrfl sGFr I 1a-dmtl
qrrffi
eQ
{qqll+cm {tr{ qBfi{ nq&n I otT a.{qt cqlt {H 6q, ,{ i{< EFettT iem {d+.{
T'5q ems-{ e<( {fl-{ qffl<-q{$1-{ 'tfdp F-C<-{ r sr< rd< n1.6q 6ffifiS $ .csB-t o:tt rrl-s "rt
cFtret"t rt-{q vT'ffi r .ct T{rrs fre{ s6f{ cEInr-dt frr.rs rr{ R-t {ryqqr{ ffirq-ffSr{ yf $l
{5g "ttq1"ilfi "ftfrF TtrrFr rri6q1 r eBt qt wfrq
{qqaM {ls-, ?rq{ TGt
'qfffu
at(sEcrEr qR-ott t {l{c sl{t <tcst r orfl et sl{m scfi FCE {r{d s1-1 et+t t T'rtr{ | <t(qf
{qffirffiI
q{r{
r,
I
l-
F
F
F
F
r
i
It
snl'crfu'e
ffin
qt cri-c.K rryfi-ocq 6Er{r <t(EI q{rsrft qF qsrrpm seft ?rl(Et<r &*sr qs o-<t sta r q{\
fu fis trtqsGrs sr{It fiq fim cqrr<F-$t ilrqt <rq, {H {m r ffi rar+< qfift&, qr6n ft&,
eflffi, IFA, (+E e qsr{E ffi qrrc.t< c(Tfrr ?<fit] I qqfgte frftn ffirq< 6qt-<Fft8,
6qrw, q,lfr, ffi {rrl< fi',I qQ <t(Errm'{ r qiil q&rs q<( fiGH ryrsi c{jn EF[n[, Trfif, rff{Kl,
r.r.
BuTKfiT ffiqtwrt
qtqtcErc.t
ffi$ toira crT[q< afuqi<Ta flo o T.i qnlrh-< qdffi,. firr.i ts araGr+:rr+c<
qslg
I
ctqqrfi; ffiq< Eqq-<, ffi fiqt,{tfr,f TmB qffi<til oryrn< qrrm 116$ qrrdr ffiq
QS {c{r q{
{revrq,
qq
quk
CI6ffi q16fq-{
m'l;1 q@ t ({:l;t-
mfl
ffi
r( c(TG? q
fi<G1o ,q[Tcq
ryqNk{ fiE
,fdg
Q dqqrcq'c.F
qFfi"ilft
1a
I
ffi{
Trl"rs.qlorrf, fr'S
qbrs; qrd qrslR3
"m
{Rffi
frcvi,ft
cat-qtd
6rin-
qEG\5
tr erfr qo'l
qiErChir
qrst{<rcq-{
fn
Affi
afrfil
:
fiCfl< "lqtr,a
R{6<-*ld
frqow{qt{
o<i
r,SffiRt Nafuro **-6 {IT[e r $frq a1(Enq"r6 5q\9_l ofilfCqr 6;r-y[q-{ ftmil
nz{r {Gr6q $6 <.zq r i+trq s*Il effii ,r*rrn wrtii s$rc{r cs6s errv(q ,
w+ ogq
\Tqrq {r{qFr v6fi c"II& s'Tsf qt<rq r qk q?F B]B
"l{J
qvIItGr
Erflt
"rq VTIfra ctft rqEI <Enrir
sil'R I EiR< {ffr--srdl, (;[rra,iq, canff qrqlq, e rr{6, <lq?i6T cr{< mdq ffi
fie EN
qnEq sqqT aql;I tRc r amfrG< 656 rlctrelk$ <lqF eft
<ry{ qrq, fu{c e wdr Ifu "me
{El&-{r aftcsrq fi<q qcfrfrrs @t "rtdoJ ornp ?qftr {Ml, con.tre, !ffi,
tr6, qrn<q{fuq qi
qwq crle-tffis (egalitarian) T{ I q {tgq Ei frg, oor
"nd-oi aa'r& r {(qrfir.Er
fr's, fra fr ffi oft< qr$ <tc +-c<r* r q mrrd-?r e,ft ft-"tqr qrr i'rir c'f@ Es .* * i *ru
{ rrqt ,ad frfrizu Oft{E erltrr, qfgt s:rst s Efrq6 Efuree "ntroi <mfe r qp1, .1.q{, T{EI
qd"qt wqq qlTqq'm <ffis r <fre qq"p1s T{n
@tac c"rmrE u$a eBr{ 'I{q ,{T-{16 cEI,i
q{
ltloGc"r6{ sr{fr r <6nrca Fnw,
s c,Fft
&fr-+ircry frrF qfr-st ilrr[e r g{-csrh e-qa qfifrru
frqil "[dor q$ft{
qqd
QE <.f
tr.'+f qq?
ccr r enfi qtrrl I
qTfift[qR q qqq
ffirr-T,fr qFt.o-i-rl cqqrsq e fi6-qw q"ftfrcoe rsfrq mtt v{ r lrrg, ts, qf<rq, cq.r{t EI<l cilrt
cerm qtCfl1'I qfcs< ffi5n {llfq q{r sil {l{- 6rc-{fr, rflq-{tqvt, 9rsl-'tFq EiTI6frs{R aarl qq|{l
;1-{ 1 qatr$Q <sftilff ffisw 6fi,
csB mE cqfre qm? q[dr$Q qFl,rjfRs Gftqar cRcf ircrq
rqd;'rnvl
fit$;
{rD-sqs-t sm fr(Rs En 6s 6fl-a erq{fu6o ffiqrrr 6*qrqffiRe qofko
onfuas crq!'qI6fi I
<isEi-rq-r'K
t'
q;PI(?BT{ E<FEfr-{l
qgrgEI I (rI:H-,I
{r{csi qfr{&s
fl
iF-GFI
!t-FI
16S1-q
E[q fir<{E
qs r fttr ftcr
qfir<tvF
,6g'{1
ara
T
I
<ICEITMT{iI TTN
I
i
**ry
t
I
ryrl
<tqslr16rm
{K.fftfu<.fq{rdftfrI r:.,,
h
i
..,.:,,:j
tr.<{ E{fd
I
I
i.-
Cq-s
!t
qqscq
qFI{.r
erufrs Rtft<-+rurcq
ltrq
qsq
ii
EGt
6W<l{'
1rr< r
q<( {frq\rfd
'ttfts qqfrqst
:i''.,tt,
:.
,.
..
Ce[:r,
cfiqqcT&? wgmt v6
Frcn. qcr
ftc{ qrrc
fr
T-{tffiil q!a.I
t
I
cqr9
tr efi qc "tfrrg \oeIt EffiT q.[Ttc.f '|vrfr< qaFr q.rrs3r qqN firq'q{af {cfr{
rw{ qlss
qrQ 1q
e{Gfl? Uffq {qf* T{f,g'rF qqfr <tqER c{{ R{ ?rql GTtFcrcffn{ Fiffi om* e<(
rm "rr<tcs qrr6"i frfrX {cfrn {ft-xtcrs rr{F Tr{r< qNI, sl5mt{ '{<( ErqE <d'sen
,{rs't{<toi-< qlft fir{ qfcrt
h
h
h
F
<{&-TR
I-
F:
h
h
qg
<rdr-{Er E6-Erfr
q-{ctfoc< q
th
h
t,
h
itr
E:ryqf:r
C(T&
crsa es6 \trqlsr x3q1{ E{w{ I qrqrrffiFt cqT.<l(Erd EITC{< ci(T&-s fi-{{
<{
fi
qfi-r'l
{(dTI frqrr<
EF q,EI s xlEI "rcal frfr{ Tft-fiq$, 'qfr-q|Bfu
$ffi".f qFrgs qfs-{ q<( rq1fi-s6 fi{fq sTCs ql5qq I q T5rC{ .e"IfF fi-{f,rdft
"rq6<
t{ElT EEI6<<
q-f;F6q ro$ 14il{ qrc e<Iqr<q-g
w{q$tlfr qTE ffi \x$t tcq6 q{Sqq T6g{ q<( ffi
qffift ftBftea Frfi cq'{ r ,smrt?
qgirg qr | 6{rH- q-G11-d
'tir e6t nImtft etl w1$ft Tf{ {fcrt,
fr.stoill, <rqffi qtu-{ct, Frg,.fiffi, c(fts, trqoqrd csche inqrfr'sr{qTm
{r{cs< qffi
<I'rs e|sr{ "Mrs m{I {I{ r <rt{<s qr{cfrff slrs {M mqr frt irT {rtr{ q-$F qc\o-':K
iF-6iF[ 1 ftf6;q q6{ q1M qeffd :rc$ frry<{'fmf< \raqf{ q<( ?<rrrydrs 1ry qlr<t fff<
lwtffm
qg{ qlq -r4flrfi {E-d
EFr q'ffi frr-<r{< \trr{r+t t{q[q n( arqq F-{F lffts r qlgJfrs fuEmq
qr r ftrc ftc< <tsEt slfl, qlRsl, Eo+qI, {l1Ej q<< sl\',fu <'{or[s ?rqrtt :F]qts s s'r{{KR
afrr<tvF
r
Ew:nqrft-s
tr
*r1E-+ ft<rll &e{d E-<ffi ft{-{tuflfi q{er6rf q& 619..t csq.-.t .tg.rs
wn EB-crtfts <ft+, r{slq-{ e futTtft{q e-fo r Eqrsq{q <I$t{ E{frcr{
fr'glrff qlcsl rTfc{ q'Sv{ EEftr ilers Bmt ap.t T-c( I qfir.k TtTc< c-4s{ e .hffi e-aq
Tlq"il? qltrr<-d
ldqfr ! Eq
{lm{ EI-<I "rffi< {DTI s'[{ r sRr qftq'R scn< B-cqq \BIT, Q(r<& Frqrs tr.n{ft Tr?rFIfiR
q5q{ FR I {{(Fl.f ${ Trsqt{ qffid
1ffi +r< q<( q< fi.fi{fi qrq-m Divide and rule-(t
.
{I{rF <rslfr< Affi <1 q;rrs4 C'fi6i-{E{ +0" of-nru ft-r-rq6<
1B or< I
{Rr{rs Tqt qr{, {cf{ frEn< qrqr*r {r{{ csB frq, csE {c,Frr6r, ffieq ftq<t E$t{ ftE
qrBrrsk
ql"or q-orq eri {R6r{
r qfrffi q-<r? qsQ ffi.t- <IqqrFi-rkr
rffrre'fcq
trt(r
"tR6-s
qflqr qftnote,ss t,q[qT.t<t s-{Ik6t qfr*t q-q|q frrE ofe T'Gr {l{
EB :Ilnr{
I
\r
eI
8I
cr
.
$ae
il'tfrs,
{(srccr.Rt
{r$,
e,flfrq
4
I
rroftTcl< *d
\rrFIrE{t T:{Cs
rrqrftma.{
qFrfi,
'fIrfi
trqr{f,f,
R srFil r eilqilE
I ltafr<
S(
ft
6<RtI{? <"F<lrq-{
q eElglaQ
ft ft {B em'{r orc<7
<rc?F[,
q(frsBw +x:
"{Ers DqF
ftrri
T-{rffi c,n{r+tfiJ
6q-Tfi-T?R, {
lrla{
q($,{
ailq-5q 1R" d
-qtFFsr{, s&'l
qrtrtEr{ qrl {
u ut+ crqp +C
c<r,Erl
t
t\
D
a
fl,
qr{cT{
e w1ft
rprts'
I T{tff" c$atEls
t I s-csrfrrs1"rfff<?<FrSiEt3'+nr
e I TEFrcrsltrff<r{Frs,Ergqq-<
8 I Fre{lrnfi<f{FtSiBmq o-<
c r q&st-res-+tqtff<kFr$jBtaqm
v r rra& <qcs yfr ft
q r TE$6 q<( \tr{E'ts ltlG< TC{i
'tt{sl M{ fi
b I csFI strs <mz EqR<q qls
)
q6
tq*r.
1fr crr<n I
cn-<ru
cqE.l
{q<9f(flIE-{lT.d
acf |q{Trs[q <-crzs
6!
+.frmq
aurffi a{:
)
<rJll's
t
I
al
s*d
E|TI,r{d
lftuff
. Rs,ei
{tffis m.p{
rRTfmTllsr,${it e
aq&
la
p
frtr{s{rqrtB'iV $(q{tntefurqt :
". sr*
$ $fi< 6RrE E'w-xrqfr+ cltqfiw.F t? ?rGK ryfi cnaq 'trs r frE Frc" Fm cq
ETTF.sGI c<
t-
t
i
lr
h
Ftrf{
i.
ir.
pc<?
F
fb
t
li
I
?
5
T
dn llnI<
EaF{c|+ qd
a
a
F.
L
i
I
r
:
I
I
-l
D
J
EI
6)
t.
ffi
<tqm
cqce
'
qlT<i l'
::'
't.:
frq
fiftr
TMrfu q<(T*str
q{ q<\q fr f+r
r.s
q*rqftffi
Eo:nqtfr+
v{tl<r{cl-+cfi:
r, r {Ifielrt{ et{rdl t(FI Ttrfic{t{{
q${t, el{f{ am
ptrft*
Es*' frcr qrfiwfu q{tr ercr{ If{fi<
1qfu 666160,
1nfug
ffiflr
q{t <mrr<qF<m
r..
rflrgn Bq sqrqs
qrrr$
qIEI I q
wr
qIqT ffi\e<rBl
<ETI
E{ r :rrtrfiigdrT
\ryernRm
"
eflrrefi r
'nsan 6{:Fr
a. qte ; $66'ilsam
ql?F
?ra
qEfi cslBie m
Terl{cc"r re
q<( rq t.dstscr, frB$cq< Tfrffi E6sf
\qr{rd
flfi
d?
q&-{ {fs cfu q<( +fg I wufrr.F, :[pfffi]ffi?;n+ q${EGr r <rcofrrcc< {-s
cw{;Rr Fqfi TE?ETGa rc cftfle :rs
iFn I
St
$?
Gre-{
.{qV {rflTe,
qc{ qI6F
TFtl,
qlr,W{
q-{He ,irm
ErgFf{tTs q:[
Tmft
qGF
q'E
{ffiqr
ffigg,,qr
lqqlq T-{F{
c't[scq rfrrmg
qHa <rft
{@i
Y&{u, il
qrrne
frc.F qr+.{r*,l
dq, qld
Tr{ ql'g1ril {
'
e$r q{
stgtrcrrffi
frrm qn
cqrd-
:nqf{fr,-aIp,rtfr
eil sIfr 6s nrlG <tt-lv, 1Q erof*- <frls ataB q<q qrryi'ts ar=JG I T,gtrs'
Jl(a&< {c{r y{m, carf"f.ilfr, ?vsfia fgJtfr{ tr{ Br$N.[{l'fr l qFrR q-<rEirts ara& <arcu
qE-*f
ffirS
ffi
{rt
qr{{qtEl-{{
qgUr{
rTr,fi&-+,
s qapal errBi
qffi
-
6ilrl
r*rr{
crrn trcm d
qfiq
e Enr+6
IE.qq.
ffil
E{sryTq
clu,
{c& qaroq{
iEGFI I
.SW{
Trr<H
cfu
fiI(E
CIFFH
rtl(Ettq'rqir
rEs s c(TB
r.1
<t E"rcqqt "rfrr,T,6sB c{IE Er+fi iFcFT I rTq, {EIrfi q<q 6il$s 6stqtls scffi 'rfrm
fiFsst T'r<Fr I rffi?t c{s{.fl:l-{rfuq? qlr q-{R <t qfu(r+ilQ (Iqt RE Tfr e"rq TR eMo qr+co
qr*F {i[.K <rEcl e umfr o1Cm r qlcq frq irqq Efu qI6< qtss, q{e st Rlt <ensR EF
sIfrT E"flir$ T{1 ry{ Ss. T.6r{ftq wFit FT{ qr<rth {cE I qrrcs fr[EH 5FR
"tlnF frfi?
?Fct mrrt il"st q*fteq I <gpss \{tr6{fu{ Q<rt erc[E {&.ftret Tl frfi{lqfd flC{ ,{H[q
f$fi{q
h
r-
i,
h
!
i
h
t
f.
L
F
r.
F
F
F
F
v
I
I
l-
fu
'rfr<dq
qTEt
rrtTCTd
$<
F
F-
V-
r
I
F
t'
3
'[
'tb
Bw $srfr-s
q:rrqfuF
ytru,
qdM
{RIqI
cfi r
''
m,
q-{ft{
c46[{et
s vG<e q<
nl-q1 1 x}qq
<rq'-{s
ffiq
E{q\5,
Irfi
"rm9flft rfr{
qE{? frHit
qwffl, mlqiilil <I{qRAI{ C'fcrcq r<6qfcd mGs, fretq qr< 6ffi9"n-fi qq&Bs-t
1fuC"fCmn
otfrq qnlk-s o-I,Tm
ecr* qltgag af xa&a ercFr"ngre I qvp
'rryrq
ry
fr{Trq{ r {Im< rBffi B-p qrq r frrn cftd qrq , t* *So ryr E{B <r(qrcq-rk qffiq qqlq
r
E6rRr
{I
Frw,
r inFnzftr
c'T(s'GfilCrt(8
qqrcq<
ffiq
qq:T&-r.$
qlfr.1-{{rq..r<,
Vr{
c,rrE
Bpu*q'Tsr{ErFqX:
s r ffir+rm {gtEqlilir ctsTRr-{ rfr{urEl 6qfi
qffiq
sgl:
rTt(TFs
Er$
?FiT I
'
rfife? s
EsTe rr6Ffit,?tffi{,+q
r 6F.r{ ch-crm
ft+r
qffi
@
frffi? firBn grum"r 6q{ ifr{fd Fr<n e qijnl qlTre-s Wur< v-16nn qffi{
{fr1rrrr {rq ,{<i?F {frqr{, T*ff fr-{r{r qf-<ffI{ esa fr<R ffin d@ iqtft* wrstrr
flrf&-s
<ffi
'
r qR<tL-sil
-ffiq
qfiK6{aer$
qiuI{-q{firq
"';iffi
ffie
frS
ffiF
rmffi+ im'!6 ri$ qk-+s< qfi-$t( {cE-6-{ q-rq{ r arrslfrs qfl{-$rq|{ Tr_c{fi fr-s,Iq 6q.{.
qrm r rreft&rs qfut q-{et&fiftrt qprca{ |
.q?H
q{
qcan
qfrffi a-rb r Frtla cffif,(t qffi{ qrr[q r 6rfi- Frtrs computer irir{R
ffiq
<r:fro
qIFT{ ES Til T
qlqqrft-Te=Iftr:
q.
ftfi: t
Eers-{6t
qfqcq r 6
**1qftiopfr
Eq-c<q q? qFiFt
{. {FEfi{
6rg!rcq|rr, q$f
dq$|a
6qiK
r.lrr
c+qlfi
cffi
ftFrfu'
aill
fuirrg
AE
I.
(TtiI,
ffi.
C{T A
-.
FNt ftrrqe
4. arqqL<tl
<tfters c{Ffrcfi
frcqn< q'r+{ ril
<I(nf(ftilir c(T& trefi qren R Tr{F< ftfis64 q.frft( fifrA wfrq qffi{ pr6 r q:mh1
'qffi-6, qlfl&-s, rm?qBo,fr{r+d.'frra E6 EFnF? qw {q{qq {<rr qE I qft1fuE 6ry6
rtB'ftqlfi trfr,efiR rlr4gq qnl&iurrm
g-ql< <rqqK qcq r Bw.qcr{ftE qygsr
Frq
1reqtrB
\g{tq {{BE I
fifir{{F{t ffircr( E\,lIq{iA <rffisn <Frfl <fftw m{t qIrq I Tq gIfrFr,
EC*I{ Arg
I q{rfl qFrpqir ft+q {q1q qH e s"Ifftd Bq< erv=R ilrf[qr
qrrrcq | 6fret
qlvygftq s I
Ti"m,{ql;t s3[ q(
*{ra
G*I
frc
t'B
Gt{tltr
{(srcczrl-d:rEs e
xa&
tb
qsr-$Aq e qfo+ n-{l sErcq mrafu+ 6-<r{ "rffi{ q'nq r f,TG o'rl?FB rmct Ecr<1fu ,e<
fi?BI qq.r{ s!il s[6il
$. qr{{|-{ftq, : :rt(qrcqtrl{ qrqf <Rkt< q|ftels Ufu <e I ir<rsfft. e ffi{<refft t{rn
<lftkrs c{t'trcqt't, trnfr4 s 1B nafu | q< T'reI qTqIfr-<T--sfi <lgc{ r 41-q{t-,{ftrqr W {c{
ffi{,
frcqr.{< q5aE aqTB-s S"nnrq q{Eq< mr{ .n-{{c<.J T-trR I mFI, c'tFH.GF fier-{-gr
qrlrt-{ ErF {t
r frcq.ft q.FBclEft \$'tt(e I e<r* $nro frg, q6rI krqT.i <qslfi qcq
fiq
qT{qrft-ir-s[A<
$$rl ft{r+d
"tc[
ffi
{ffi
{REf{-{ sfrsqrl q{q(rtrt : {(qlCE t qftq q<k aE 3ryqd{t{ Efm CqrK q-{{fg< qs6
SF.&strB q$ cqr.r< $f< ofq e-rcs fiq{ r qr{rs :qIfurc< Tr<Iq,.E{cs {fm{ | qrs
c'6{q{F s qffi-6 rym 't& 1ft "fm, AIqqIEK {r"{ qffi.qfm, sfm{ orl,qn EqIl q-q
-q{r<i{ s-cE ql(TF+ r{rd sr ffi o1frafia q16q
c. ffgt e "rrr1frr+ 6{trtEql't , qrsdrfuo frfrA qwrcq qnrrch< cqrr< mq-{r mrr< <rtr<
c?r{t{-{lr qq.t fi-(q{ | cE'rfi a1Q-6 6r66s {lrst:[c$ \{Hrs qm'fi c{H-65 qFicq{ ,,q9q qFfi{Er
q-<-fiEl q.frft< '
e frfu {t(TCs nfu" cq'{[ Tfcq I qr< c{tfim'{ lt\5mrrs? ntryc{ ,{s cfi.k
ftq frq fi-s q+l rqrq or c<Ft "1fu <l sI s'F cl(T&-s fta61 tRra5{ \rrn
s. qq.t : fisfr5amq EF{dT{? q-fl q*'{6t erB rrigTr ft1s rt<ir r fr&-{ cE-m ilil {{m{
ri{ftr qr{ TIT{r{ qr{.E s'r{ | qNrfi-?r crrq< q{fi{K(cBr effi'qct $4" frffi mIIt q{c{ {r{
fir6qq Grrs qcirs qrqT.t srcct qrrfi r ,s\,-rr{ s:rcfi {tqr6{ ,{$
Ttm. c(,TB{ fuE"rnn w{J
rt.
rqrcqo,rr<Fr
$s<*
, <6q|q {rtt {6f$Vrl-< frBg m-q {(TB-s \ilq'|;t qEfr{, qr$ q1;lIF qFIf<
6q6, 6;q-fr6p e.eqft q:qrd vrr+<. qqq qqrfi frrt< EfroI irq{ ffifq | 6{frs, ffi,
ffi, 6qEr (sFr, "r6-{frrot ffi< q{R lDH aqaBe ft<aqv 1ffinnxfta
q" fr'{tr{ :.\{l<fro $t frtlsrq<:{ft I qf{il utt <t 4t Ut, ..q< elvf< EF-{'6. + o&{iFs sR
ccrrs, kFXs \B:TlE-{rq c?rrs qtfiil frq Q r fr{frr+<' eQ.{c{ xtr:1t'm
6{FF {t csH ffi
t{r.rr m E,fffi{ qr {{rq cerr{ qfl qfiH frref{ slE <<Iq I qsrr{ <l(qrrq-c'rd cl(TBs
r<C{ "ftr.6l qr+pr<{rs-{ s{r<ft qtrot c{RI Ea{R
um
B"ns qnqtGg frfr{ o.rrcq <r(ryrq-rfir cr(Tko ffTc-d< frfu{ qwrcq <l c<Ft tffi
D. rt [d{FI
cilwq
{r{ <I?rF qGr, aqT&s qffica<:qfum q'FKI m{ q:rfm< fiqe WEfrt, frsi{ sl'fl e
aia&, &fuq e:Jitrc<t( <t qmlcrm qTil rretq', tt qtlrcE-< "rfrE]rrs rrit <rRI sl mr EIkc{ aI
ffi uIirfl sffi erqq <,-fi, {qfr q{' r qq{RE{ G.{ Vrq ql $q r EB qr Cso fi-qcq< Frog
s5q
eo
Bw.
ffi
tl
<cq
,e
fl$fi-t' c{rqfrqr{
a'r
qfiuT
{efr6 FFE
fu lfrt* *
qF
[ ftl
qtiAID-{t' <t{
<1frffi.cd
s<
(MCQ)
dAry
"rlftn
liaG'
Ot-m
fi"INf
<-{rcq
@ lofr
(E-{l sGFi?
Ettcq es <l8q q< mE|e (Tribes and Castes of Bengal; crqiE Co
@ R'qra
@ Tdl;rrr<c{ @
@
"Our cuulture is what we are,.our civilization is'what we use" "Slffit {t 644?
qFriil <t {,{qrd <R sr cslsl-- Effi eml
@ ffo'E-q<
@
@
@
@T*ft<qm
<FRfd TflrCE{?
C$rrfir{s1ttff
crfiFGil, qrce{Isi,
qt,EGsTfle O In"rfrI['Ire
'Hereditary genius'qq6<
.@
sdpffiqs
"ut1&
<ce
{E
Ttf-"t
<l
d?FG<
$6qffif
)lr{
@offi'ffi
T'it-
} a{Fm "rildq
$\ee+,"-
+rE-e<
)o r ,sFsrqKI CrFIcIroK qtffil
@ q"m.r<
@ q[6aTF
@
l{<.rfl,
c<il
"l{o6"
qs{t
qesr, etffiv
"fi$tq{[{I6t
$rr{dfrerftl
@ry-
@*",.'ft
r-e-E
st{r
"ntrtfiEfifi(
cE-ql
ltft
\, lg
8lq
crq
vtiF
lttl
brq
ar{ l)ot!