Sei sulla pagina 1di 10



4QFMMP



,OIHQRPHQRGHOGRORUHHGHOODPDODWWLDQHOODVRFLHWGLRJJL

 *M EPMPSF  VOFTQFSJFO[B DIF WJFOF TFNQSF QJ PTDVSBUB OFMMB TPDJFU EJ PHHJ DIF QSPQPOF JM
QSPGJMPEJVOBQFSTPOBWJODFOUF QFSGFUUB TFO[BEJGFUUJFTFO[BQSPCMFNJ 
 4F IB VOB DJUUBEJOBO[B   RVBOEP BTTVNF J DBSBUUFSJ EFM ESBNNB  TQFUUBDPMP BMMPSB DJ DIF
QSFOEPOPOJMEPMPSFDPNFFTQFSJFO[BVNBOB NBMFFNP[JPOJDIFTVTDJUBJOOPJMPTQFUUBDPMP 
W JM NPEP DPO DVJ UBMVOF WJDFOEF OFMMVMUJNP BOOP TPOP TUBUF USBTGPSNBUF JO VOB GJDUJPO B
QVOUBUF

 .B JM EPMPSF TQFUUBDPMP OPO IB DBSBUUFSJ DIF QPTTBOP JOUFSQSFUBSF JM EPMPSF SFBMF  RVFMMP DIF
QVQSFOEFSFDJBTDVOEJOPJQFSMBQFSEJUBEFMMBWPSP QFSJMGBMMJNFOUPEJVOBSFMB[JPOFBGGFUUJWB
JNQPSUBOUF  QFS MB NPSUF EJ VOB QFSTPOB DBSB  QFS VOB NBMBUUJB JNQPSUBOUF DIF TFHOB MB WJUB
QFSTPOBMFPRVFMMBEFMMBOPTUSBGBNJHMJB


&DPTJMEPMPSF DIFFTJTUFBODIFTFMPOBTDPOEJBNP GJOJTDFDPOMFTTFSFFTQFSJFO[BDIFTJWJWF


JO TPMJUVEJOF  JO TJMFO[JP  DPOEJWJEFOEPMP TPMP DPO MF QFSTPOF DBSF F DPO HMJ BNJDJ  F UBMWPMUB
OFQQVSF DPO MPSP  QFSDI MPTDVSBNFOUP EFM EPMPSF  EJ DVJ IP QBSMBUP QSJNB  GJOJTDF DPO JM
HFOFSBSF VOB TPSUB EJ JNCBSB[[P OFMMF SFMB[JPOJ  DPNF TF MF QFSTPOF  QFS JM GBUUP EJ BWFSF VO
QSPCMFNBDPODVJGBSFJDPOUJ OPOGPTTFQJMBTUFTTB

7JVOVMUJNBDPOTFHVFO[BDIFWPSSFJFWJEFO[JBSFQPJDIEFMEPMPSFOPOTJQBSMBQJ TJGJOJTDF
DPOMFTTFSFQSJWJEFMMFQBSPMFQFSEJSFDJDIFQSPWJBNP TPUUPJMQFTPEFMMBQSPWB$JNBODBOP
MF QBSPMF QFS EJSF JM ESBNNB  MB TPGGFSFO[B  MB EFMVTJPOF  MB SBCCJB  MP TDBDDP  JM GBMMJNFOUP
DJ NBODB JO EFGJOJUJWB MFTQFSJFO[B EFM QBTTBHHJP EBMMFNP[JPOF DIF DJ QSFOEF F DJ DPMQJTDF  BM
EJ M EFMMB OPTUSB MJCFSU  BM QFOTJFSP  DIF FMBCPSB DJ DIF TJ WJWF  MP USBEVDF JO QBSPMB  FMBCPSB
QFSDPSTJ EJ TFOTP *M OPTUSP ESBNNB  SJTQFUUPB(JPCCF F BMMVPNP CJCMJDP JOHFOFSF   DIF
MFUNPEFSOBIBQFSTPDPNQMFUBNFOUFMBDBQBDJUEJFTQSJNFSFFEBSFGPSNBBJTFOUJNFOUJFBHMJ
BGGFUUJGPOEBNFOUBMJEFMMBOPTUSBFTJTUFO[BFEFMOPTUSPDPSQP/FJTBMNJTQFTTPMVPNPNBMBUP
HSJEB  VSMB  TGPHB MB QSPQSJB BOHPTDJB  DIJFEF QFSDI  QSPUFTUB DPOUSP %JP OPJ PHHJ  JOWFDF 
TJBNP QSJWJ EJ RVFTUB GBDPMU EJ FTQSJNFSF MB OPTUSB TPGGFSFO[B 1SJNB EJ NPSJSF GJTJDBNFOUF
NPSJBNPEFMMBNPSUFEFMMBQBSPMBJOOPJ TJBNPNPODIJEFMMBDBQBDJUEJFTQSJNFSFMBTPGGFSFO[B
-BTPDJFUNPEFSOBJOJCJTDFMBNBOJGFTUB[JPOFEFMEPMPSF TPGGPDBMBQSPUFTUB TQFHOFJMMBNFOUP 
BOFTUFUJ[[BFTUFSJMJ[[BOPOTPMPHMJBNCJFOUJPTQFEBMJFSJ NBBODIFMFFNP[JPOJFJTFOUJNFOUJEFJ
NBMBUJ .BOJDBSEJ- -VNBOPTPGGSJSF 2JKRBJPO


 &QQVSF JM EPMPSF OPO TNFUUF EJ FTTFSF VOFTQFSJFO[B DIF BCJUB MF OPTUSF HJPSOBUF  OFMMF QJ
EJWFSTFGPSNF%BDFSUJQVOUPEJWJTUB TJEJSFCCFDIFDVOSBQQPSUPJOWFSTPUSBJMEFTJEFSJPFMB
QSFTVO[JPOFEJQPUFSWJWFSFJOVOFUFSOBFJNQFSUVSCBUBGFMJDJUFMFQPTTJCJMJUFGGFUUJWFEJWJWFSF
DPT
/DPDODWWLDHVSHULHQ]DGLGRORUHHGLOLPLWH

5SB MF QPTTJCJMJ FTQFSJFO[F EJ EPMPSF  WJ  DFSUBNFOUF RVFMMB EFMMB NBMBUUJB  USB MF QJ JORVJFUBOUJ -B
NBMBUUJBJOGBUUJOPOQVBWFSFVOSFTQPOTBCJMFDVJBUUSJCVJSFJORVBMDIFNPEPMBDPMQBJOUBMVOJDBTJQV
HJVOHFSFBMJNJUBSFBODIFHSBWFNFOUFMBRVBMJUEFMMBOPTUSBWJUBJONPEPQJPNFOPHSBWFQPSUBDPOT
EPMPSF MJNJUB[JPOJ DBNCJBNFOUJOFMSJUNPFOFMMFBCJUVEJOJEJWJUB TBDSJGJDJTQFTTPDJQPOFEJGSPOUFBMMB
NPSUFDPOUVUUFMFEPNBOEF MFQBVSFFMFBOHPTDFDIFTVTDJUBJOOPJJMQFOTJFSPEFMMBDPODMVTJPOFEFMMB
OPTUSBWJUB


"ODIF MB NBMBUUJB  VOFTQFSJFO[B DIF TJ WJWF RVBTJ OFM OBTDPOEJNFOUP TJ QBSMB QPDP EJ FTTB  OPO DJ
TJ SBDDPOUB DPNF NBMBUJ  NB BO[J TJ UFOEF BE BMMVEFSF BM QSPQSJP QSPCMFNB F DPNVORVF B WJWFSMP JO
NBOJFSBNPMUPQSJWBUB
-PTQFEBMF  DFSUBNFOUF JM MVPHP EFMMB DVSB  NB BODIF JM MVPHP TJNCPMJDP EFMMB HIFUUJ[[B[JPOF EFM
NBMBUP DIFJODBTBEJTUVSCB SPNQFHMJFRVJMJCSJEJGBNJHMJFTFNQSFQJGSBHJMJ*MDBSBUUFSFTFNQSFQJ
JNQFSTPOBMFFBTFUUJDPEFMMPTUJMFEJDVSB DIFSJEVDFMBEJNFOTJPOFSFMB[JPOBMFBTDBQJUPEJRVFMMBUFDOJDB 
BDDFOUVBJMTFOTPEJTPMJUVEJOFEFMNBMBUP TPMPFTQFTTPJNQBVSJUPEJGSPOUFBMTVPNBMF1FSDIJPQFSB
OFMNPOEPTBOJUBSJPMBNBMBUUJBVOOFNJDPEBDPNCBUUFSF QFSMBNNBMBUPFTTBRVBMDPTBDIFGBQBSUF
EJMVJ VOFTQFSJFO[BOFMMBRVBMFQJFOBNFOUFJNNFSTP FDPODVJEFWFJNQBSBSFBDPOWJWFSF
(MJ PTQFEBMJ IBOOP VOJNQPTUB[JPOF TFNQSF QJ B[JFOEBMJTUJDB F JM QSPCMFNB EFM DPOUFOJNFOUP EFMMF
TQFTF TFNCSB HJVTUJGJDBSF RVFTUP TUJMF EJ MBWPSP &E  DPNF TF NBMBUP GPTTF TPMP JM DPSQP  F OPO MB
QFSTPOBFDIFCBTUBTTFDVSBSFJMDPSQP DPNFTFOPOWJGPTTFVOJOUFSEJQFOEFO[BTUSFUUJTTJNBEFMDPSQP
DPOUVUUBMBQFSTPOB BODIFBJGJOJEFMMBHVBSJHJPOF
&QQVSFJMOVNFSPEFJNBMBUJPHHJBVNFOUB1VTFNCSBSFVOQBSBEPTTPTJQFOTBDIFJQSPHSFTTJEFMMB
NFEJDJOBBCCJBSJEPUUPJMOVNFSPEFMMFQFSTPOFNBMBUF NBWFSPJMDPOUSBSJPMFDVSFSJTPMWPOPBMDVOJ
DBTJ NBTUBCJMJ[[BOPMBDPOEJ[JPOFEJNBMBUUJB QSPMVOHBOPOFMUFNQPMBDPOEJ[JPOFEJNBMBUP
&TFNQJPEFJNBMBUJEJUVNPSF

3HUFRUVLGHQWURODPDODWWLD

-B NJB JOUFO[JPOF  RVFMMB EJ BQQSPGPOEJSF MFTQFSJFO[B EFMMB NBMBUUJB DPNF VOB EFMMF TJUVB[JPOJ QJ
UJQJDIFEJTPGGFSFO[BDIFDPJOWPMHFUVUUBMBQFSTPOB DIFDPTUSJOHFBGBSFJDPOUJJONBOJFSBEFDJTPDPO
MFTQFSJFO[BEFMMJNJUFFEFMMBDSFBUVSBMJU EFOUSPJMEPMPSF
2VFMMPEJNBMBUUJBVOUFSNJOFNPMUPDPNVOFFHFOFSJDPJOFGGFUUJIBUBOUJTJHOJGJDBUJEJWFSTJ4JEJDF
NBMBUUJBMJOGMVFO[B FTJEJDFNBMBUUJBVOUVNPSF&EDIJBSBMBEJGGFSFO[BUSBMFEVFTJUVB[JPOJ
5VUUBWJB  OFMMB MPSP QSPGPOEJTTJNB EJWFSTJU  RVFTUF EVF TJUVB[JPOJ IBOOP JO DPNVOF NPMUJ FMFNFOUJ
QPSUBOP DPO T VO NBMFTTFSF DIF BMUFSB MB OPTUSB QFSDF[JPOF EFMMB WJUB DJ DPTUSJOHPOP B NPEJGJDBSF
MPSHBOJ[[B[JPOF EFMMB OPTUSB HJPSOBUB F EFMMB OPTUSB WJUB  EFM MBWPSP  EFHMJ JNQFHOJ  EFMMF SFMB[JPOJ TJ
SJGMFUUPOP TVMMB WJUB EFMMB OPTUSB GBNJHMJB  TVMMB RVBMF HSBWB MB OPTUSB EJNJOVJUB FGGJDJFO[B  P MB OPTUSB 
TPGGFSFO[BDJNFUUPOPJOVOBDPOEJ[JPOFEJEJQFOEFO[BEBHMJBMUSJ JOQSJNPMVPHPEBMNFEJDP DIFEFUUF
SFHPMFOVPWFDBSJDIFEJBVUPSJUNFEJDJOF WJTJUF FTBNJ PSHBOJ[[B[JPOFEFMMBOPTUSBHJPSOBUB
-PTUBUPEBOJNPEJVOBQFSTPOBNBMBUBBMEJMEFMMFTJUVB[JPOJDIJBSBNFOUFQJCBOBMJFMFHHFSFPTDJMMB
USBQBVSBFTQFSBO[B
-B NBMBUUJB QPSUB TFNQSF DPO T QBVSB  BOTJB  F QPJ BOHPTDJB F MB QSPTQFUUJWB EFMMB NPSUF  TFNQSF
FWPDBUB  BODIF JO NPEP JODPOTBQFWPMF  EBMMFTQFSJFO[B EFMMB NBMBUUJB TQFTTP MB GBOUBTJB MBWPSB TV
TJOUPNJQJVUUPTUPCBOBMJ FJNNBHJOBFTJUJNPMUPQJHSBWJEJRVFMMPDIFTBSFCCFSBHJPOFWPMFQFOTBSF&
BMUFNQPTUFTTP EFOUSPMBNBMBUUJBWJTFNQSFVOBTQFSBO[B BODIFRVBOEPJTFHOBMJEFMMBTVBHSBWJU
TPOPGJOUSPQQPDIJBSJ4QFTTPDIJNBMBUPOFHBBODIFBTFTUFTTPMBSFBMU FRVBOEPMBEJBHOPTJEJWJFOF
DIJBSB F DFSUB  TJ IB DPNF VOP TDIJBOUP  DPNF TF JM GJMP DIF UFOFWB MFHBUJ BMMB TQFSBO[B EJ OPO FTTFSF
NBMBUJ TJ TQF[[BTTF F MBTDJBTTF BOEBSF JO VO CBSBUSP EJ CVJP  EJ JODFSUF[[B  EJ TPGGFSFO[B -P TUFTTP
BDDBEF JONBOJFSBRVBTJTQFDVMBSF BODIFOFMMBGBNJHMJBEJDIJNBMBUPMBNBMBUUJBEJVODPNQPOFOUF
EFMMB GBNJHMJB EJWJFOF JO RVBMDIF NPEP MB NBMBUUJB EFMMB GBNJHMJB  DIF DPNJODJB B SVPUBSF BUUPSOP BMMP
TWJMVQQBSTJEFMNBMFFEFMMFWJDFOEFBEFTTPDPOOFTTF



-BTUPSJBWFSBEJVOBNBMBUUJBJOJ[JBRVBOEPTJDPOPTDFDPODFSUF[[BMBHSBWJUEJFTTBFTJTBEJBWFSF
EBWBOUJBTVOQFSDPSTPMVOHPFSJTDIJPTPEJMPUUBDPOUSPJMNBMF*NQFHOJ QSPHFUUJ EFTJEFSJDSPMMBOP
EJDPMQPFMBOPTUSBWJUBDBNCJBMBTVBGJTJPOPNJBTJQFOTBBMMFDPOTFHVFO[FDIFMBNBMBUUJBDBVTFSOFM
OPTUSPGVUVSP JQPTTJCJMJBCCBOEPOJ JMQFOTJFSPEJFTTFSFEJQFTPBDIJDJWVPMCFOF
%BRVFMNPNFOUPUVUUPVOBMUFSOBSTJEJTUBUJEBOJNPFEJTJUVB[JPOJJOUFSJPSJJOFEJUF$POPTDJBNPJO
NBOJFSBEJWFSTBOPJTUFTTJ MBWJUB HMJBMUSJEJUVUUPGBDDJBNPVOFTQFSJFO[BTDPOPTDJVUB EPNJOBUBEBMMB
GSBHJMJU EBMMJODFSUF[[B EBMMBQSPTQFUUJWBEFMMBGJOF
4QFTTP JMQSJNPJNQBUUPDPOMBOPUJ[JBEFMMBQSPQSJBNBMBUUJBHSBWF HFOFSBTHPNFOUP FQPJSBCCJB 
SJWPMUBVONPNFOUPEJFTQMPTJPOFFNPUJWB DPNFQSJNBSFB[JPOFBMMBOPUJ[JBEFMMBQSPTQFUUJWBDIFTJ
BQSFQFSMBQSPQSJBFTJTUFO[B $JUBSF"MFTTJB

& EPQP MP TCJHPUUJNFOUP F MB SBCCJB  WJFOF JM UFNQP EFMMF EPNBOEF  BO[J  EFMMB QSPUFTUB QFSDI
RVFTUB NBMBUUJB  1FSDI QSPQSJP B NF  DIF DPTB IP GBUUP EJ NBMF  4POP EPNBOEF DIF DIJBNBOP JO
DBVTBMBWJUBFJMTVPTFOTP FEJDPOPDPNFOFMMBDPTDJFO[BTJTJBBUUJWBUPRVFMQSPDFTTPDIFQPSUBWFSTP
MFMBCPSB[JPOFEFMMBQSPQSJBTJUVB[JPOF
7JFOF NFTTB BMMB QSPWB MB DPOTJEFSB[JPOF EJ OPJ TUFTTJ JO PTQFEBMF  DPM QJHJBNB  TJ JOEPTTB VO OVPWP
SVPMPTPDJBMFTJDIJBNBUJDPOJMUV

$PNJODJBVOBWWFOUVSBVNBOBDIFDJNPEJGJDB OFMCFOFFOFMNBMF%PQPVOBNBMBUUJBTFSJB OPOTJ


QJRVFMMJEJQSJNBFBODIFJSBQQPSUJDPOHMJBMUSJTJTPOPNPEJGJDBUJMBNBMBUUJBDPTUJUVJTDFVOBTQFDJF
EJBDDFMFSB[JPOFOFMMBDPOPTDFO[BFOFMMFTQFSJFO[BEFMMBWJUB RVBMRVFMMBDPTUJUVJUBEBMMFTQFSJFO[BEFM
MJNJUFGBUUBTVMMBQSPQSJBDBSOF

(SB[JF BJ QSPHSFTTJ EFMMB NFEJDJOB  PHHJ TQFTTP MB NBMBUUJB HSBWF IB VOFWPMV[JPOF QPTJUJWB 4J FTDF
EBMMPTQFEBMF NBDJTJBDDPSHFEJOPOFTTFSFQJRVFMMJEJQSJNBDPOEJ[JPOBNFOUJ MJNJUJ DBNCJBNFOUJ
EFDJTJ OFMMF QSPQSJF BCJUVEJOJ EJ WJUB JO BMDVOJ DBTJ  VOJOWBMJEJU DIF OPO QFSNFUUF QJ EJ UPSOBSF BM
MBWPSP6OSFHJNFEJDPOUSPMMJFEJDVSFDIFQSFOEPOPNPMUPUFNQP DIFPDDVQBOPJONBOJFSBJOWBEFOUF
OPO TPMP JM QSPQSJP UFNQP  NB BODPS QSJNB JM QSPQSJP TQB[JP JOUFSJPSF  DPO JM SJTDIJP EJ DPNJODJBSF B
WJWFSF EFMMB QSPQSJB NBMBUUJB -B SJHJEJU EFMMPSHBOJ[[B[JPOF TBOJUBSJB  DIF OPO  DFOUSBUB TVM NBMBUP F
TVMMF TVF FTJHFO[F  NB TV VO NPEFMMP FGGJDJFOUJTUB EJ PSHBOJ[[B[JPOF EFM MBWPSP  BDDFOUVB UVUUP RVFTUP
F GBWPSJTDF JM QBTTBHHJP EBMMB DPOEJ[JPOF EJ MBWPSBUPSF B RVFMMB EJ NBMBUP  QTJDPMPHJDBNFOUF  DPNF
TFTJGPTTFJODPSBHHJBUJBSJDPQSJSFJMSVPMPEJNBMBUP DPOUVUUPRVFMMPDIFEJEJQFOEFO[B EJTPGGFSFO[B
JOUFSJPSFFEJSFHSFTTJPOFQTJDPMPHJDBRVFTUPDPNQPSUB*MNBMBUPDSPOJDPEFWFWJWFSFDPOVOBNBMBUUJB
JOVONPOEPEJTBOJFRVFTUPQVSJTDIJBSFEJEJWFOUBSFVOSVPMPTPDJBMF

'RPDQGHGHQWURODPDODWWLD

-BNBMBUUJBTFNQSFVOFTQFSJFO[BEJEPMPSFDIFDJSFOEFQFTBOUFJMMJNJUFDPOOBUVSBUPBMOPTUSPFTTFSF
EPOOFFVPNJOJ&TQFSJFO[BDPNVOFRVFMMBEFMEPMPSF FQQVSFTFNCSBDPHMJFSDJTFNQSFEJTPSQSFTB B
JOUFSSPNQFSFBGGFUUJ BTQFHOFSFJMTPSSJTPFMBWPHMJBEJWJWFSF BDBNCJBSFJNQSPWWJTBNFOUFJMTFOTPDIF
QFSOPJBWFWBOPMFDPTFEJTFNQSF*M7BOHFMPEJDFDIFMBNPSUFDJDPHMJFTFNQSFDPNFVOMBESPDIF 
GVSUJWP EJOPUUF TJJOUSPNFUUFOFMMBOPTUSBDBTB.BBODIFJMEPMPSFTJJOTFSJTDFOFMMBOPTUSBWJUBDPOMB
WJPMFOUBJOWBEFO[BEJVOMBESP FTFNCSBUPHMJFSDJMFSBHJPOJQFSWJWFSF
*M EPMPSF  VOFTQFSJFO[B DIF DPMQJTDF UVUUB MB QFSTPOB J QFOTJFSJ DIF TVTDJUB OFMMB DPTDJFO[B TPOP
TPQSBUUVUUPJMTFOTPEFMMBTTVSEPEBWBOUJBMRVBMFMFVOJDIFSFB[JPOJTPOPJMHSJEPPJMTJMFO[JPOPOBDBTP
TJEJDFUBMWPMUBDIFTJBNPSJNBTUJTFO[BQBSPMF
2VBMJQBSPMF


-VOJDB QBSPMB JOUFSFTTBOUF QBSSFCCF FTTFSF RVFMMB QPUFOUF DIF IB MB GPS[B EJ MJCFSBSF EBM NBMF *M
7BOHFMPQJFOPEJVPNJOJFEPOOFDIFTQFTTPTFNCSBOPMJDPOBEFMTPGGSJSF*MMPSPBOEBSFJODPOUSPB
(FTMBEFDJTJPOFEJDIJIBHJQSPWBUPUVUUP DPNFMBEPOOBDIFTPGGSJWBEJFNPSSBHJBEBEPEJDJBOOJ 
PDPNFJDJFDIJDIF TFEVUJTVMDJHMJPEFMMBTUSBEBOPOQPUFWBOPGBSBMUSPDIFHSJEBSF QFSGBSTDIF(FT
TJBDDPSHFTTFEJMPSPHSJEPEJEJTQFSB[JPOFFEJTQFSBO[BBMUFNQPTUFTTP
.B EPQP MP THPNFOUP F MB TPSQSFTB  MF QFSTPOF DIF TPGGSPOP BDRVJTJTDPOP J USBUUJ TUSBOJ EJ DIJ DPO
JM EPMPSF IB JNQBSBUP B DPOWJWFSF OPO QJ SFB[JPOJ WJPMFOUF  NB MB TFSJFU DPNQPTUB EJ DIJ UFOEF B
OBTDPOEFSF JM QSPQSJP TFHSFUP & MB SBTTFHOB[JPOF EJ DIJ EFWF SBDDPHMJFSF UVUUF MF QSPQSJF FOFSHJF QFS
SFTJTUFSFBMNBMFFDPOUJOVBSFBMPUUBSF
4JGBOOPTUSBEBUBOUFEPNBOEFOFMDVPSFEJDIJTUBMPUUBOEPDPOJMEPMPSFEPNBOEFDIFSJHVBSEBOPJM
TFOTP TUFTTP EFMMB WJUB *M EPMPSF  VOB EJ RVFMMF TJUVB[JPOJ JO DVJ UVUUP JM WBMPSF EFMMB OPTUSB FTJTUFO[B
WJFOF NFTTP BMMB QSPWB $J TJ DIJFEF DIF TFOTP BCCJB WJWFSF  TF CBTUB VO HSVNP EJ DFMMVMF JNQB[[JUF B
NFUUFSFJODSJTJUVUUJJOPTUSJQSPHFUUJDIFTFOTPIBWPMFSCFOFBMMFQFSTPOF TFJMOPTUSPBGGFUUPOPOQV
TBMWBSMFEBMEPMPSFFEBMMBNPSUFDIFTFOTPIBDVSBSTJ TFDJTJUSPWBTFNQSFEBDBQP
"ODIF(JPCCFTJGBEPNBOEFEVSF SBEJDBMJFESBNNBUJDIFMPGBNBMFEJDFOEPBEEJSJUUVSBJMHJPSOPJO
DVJTVBNBESFMPIBEBUPBMMBMVDF QFSDISJDPOPTDFMJOVUJMFDSVEFMUEFMMBWJUBEJGSPOUFBMEPMPSFDIFHMJ
TUSJUPMBMFPTTB-PGBSJDPOPTDFOEPJMMJNJUFSBEJDBMFEJRVFMMBWJUBDIFMPIBWJTUPVTDJSFOVEPEBMTFOPEJ
TVBNBESF QFSSJUPSOBSFOVEPBMMBUFSSBDIFMPIBHFOFSBUP6ONPEPDPNFVOBMUSPQFSDIJFEFSTJDIF
TFOTPIBMBWJUB$IFDPTBSFBMNFOUFQVEBSMFWBMPSF

/DPDODWWLDHVSHULHQ]DGLXPDQLW

$PNFJOPHOJDPTB BODIFOFMMFTQFSJFO[BEFMMBNBMBUUJBPHOVOPIBJMTVPTUJMF7JEFOUSPMBNBMBUUJBMB
QPTTJCJMJUEJGBSFVOBHSBOEFFTQFSJFO[BEJVNBOJU EJRVFMMFEJNFOTJPOJEFMMVNBOJUDIFEJGGJDJMNFOUF
TJQPTTPOPTDPQSJSFEFOUSPVOFTJTUFO[BBMMJOTFHOBFTDMVTJWBEFMTVDDFTTPFEFMCFOFTTFSF
>
7JWFSFVOBQSPWBTJHOJGJDBBUUSBWFSTBSFVOFTQFSJFO[BEJGGJDJMF OFMMBRVBMFTJDPOPTDFNFHMJPTFTUFTTJF
RVBMJTPOPFGGFUUJWBNFOUFJWBMPSJDIFPSJFOUBOPFJTQJSBOPMBOPTUSBFTJTUFO[B
/FMMB NBMBUUJB UVUUP TJ GB QJ EJGGJDJMF F BM NBMBUP  DIJFTUP EJ TBQFS TPQQPSUBSF  QB[JFOUBSF  WJWFSF MB
TDPOGJUUB  BUUSBWFSTBSF TJUVB[JPOJ EJ EJQFOEFO[B EBHMJ BMUSJ SFTUBOEP MJCFSJ  WFSJGJDBSF TF JM WBMPSF EFMMB
OPTUSBWJUBMFHBUPBDJDIFGBDDJBNPSJTJFEFEFOUSPOPJTUFTTJ4JBNPQFSTPOFDFOUSBUFTVOPJTUFTTJ
PJOOPJWJFGGFUUJWBNFOUFQPTUPQFSHMJBMUSJ 2VBOUBEJHOJUBCCJBNPOFMDPOTJEFSBSFOPJTUFTTJ 4JBNP
DBQBDJEJDPNQSFOTJPOFWFSTPHMJBMUSJPMBDPNQSFOTJPOFTPMPVOBQSFUFTBQFSOPJ 
-BQSPWBEFMMBNBMBUUJBQFSNFUUFEVORVFEJNFUUFSFJOMVDF BOPJTUFTTJQSJNBDIFBHMJBMUSJ DIJTJBNP
FGGFUUJWBNFOUF $GSE5POJOP#FMMP

JMUFNQPEFMMBGFEFMUBOPJTUFTTJFBJOPTUSJWBMPSJ
 JM UFNQP EFMMB MPUUB F EFMMBQQSFOEJNFOUP EJ BUUFHHJBNFOUJ VNBOJ DIF MB WJUB EJ PHOJ HJPSOP OPO DJ
DIJFEFPDJDIJFEFJONJTVSFQJEFCPMJJMDPSBHHJP MBDBQBDJUEJFTTFSFTPMJDPOTFTUFTTJ MBQB[JFO[B MB
EFDJTJPOFOFMSFTJTUFSF
2VFTUPWBMFTVMQJBOPEFMMVNBOJUFBODIFTVRVFMMPEFMMBGFEF-FQBSPMFEFMMBGFEF QSPOVODJBUFTQFTTP
DPOJOUFOTJUFDPOHJPJBOFMUFNQPEFMCFOFTTFSF EFWPOPNPTUSBSFMBMPSPWFSJU BO[J MBMPSPDBQBDJU
EJQFSNBOFO[BOFMUFNQPJODVJUVUUPTJGBCVJP
%FOUSP MB QSPWB TJ DBNCJB -B QSPWB DJ NPEFMMB F DPOUSJCVJTDF B SFOEFSDJ QFSTPOF QJ QSPGPOEF  QJ
FTTFO[JBMJ &TTB DPTUJUVJTDF DPNF VOB TQFDJF EJ BDDFMFSB[JPOF OFMMB DSFTDJUB EFMMB OPTUSB QFSTPOBMJU F


OPJDJNPEJGJDIJBNPJOFTTB1PTTJBNPEJSF DPOVOUFSNJOFDIFDJGBNJMJBSF DIFMBQSPWBVOUFNQP
BDDFMFSBUP EJ GPSNB[JPOF  OFM RVBMF DSFTDJBNP QJ SBQJEBNFOUF P OFM RVBMF QPTTJBNP EJWFOUBSF MB
DBSJDBUVSBEJOPJTUFTTJ
-BGFEFMUBOPJTUFTTJFBJOPTUSJWBMPSJDJSFOEFEVORVFOPOQFSTPOFJEFOUJDIFBOPJTUFTTF NBQFSTPOF
QJNBUVSFEFOUSPJMTJTUFNBEJWBMPSJTDFMUP
>
0HHJMFTQFSJFO[BEFMMBNBMBUUJBSFTBQBSUJDPMBSNFOUFEJGGJDJMFEBMGBUUPDIFMFTQFSJFO[BEFMMJNJUFTUBUB
DPNFFTDMVTBEBMMPSJ[[POUFEFMWJWFSFEJUVUUJ4JWJWFJMMVEFOEPTJDIFQPTTBOPOPOFTTFSWJMJNJUJ
*M GBUUP DIF TJ WFOHB FEVDBUJ DPO QPDIF SFHPMF  RVBOEP BEEJSJUUVSB TFO[B  BDDFOUVB RVFTUP GBUUP 
-B NBMBUUJB JOWFDF DJ SJDPSEB  TQFTTP JNQSPWWJTBNFOUF  DIF WJ TPOP OFMMFTJTUFO[B VNBOB EFJ MJNJUJ
JOWBMJDBCJMJDIFTPOPMFHBUJBMMBOPTUSBOBUVSBEJDSFBUVSF4PMPDIJIBJNQBSBUPBTUBSFEFOUSPVOMJNJUF
FBEBCJUBSFUVUUPMPTQB[JPDIFFTTPDPOTFOUFTFO[BQSFUFOEFSFEJFTTFSFTFNQSFBMEJMSJFTDFBWJWFSF
BODIFMBNBMBUUJBDPNFVOUFNQPVNBOP OPODPNFVOWVPUPEBMRVBMFTGVHHJSFNBDPNF OPOPTUBOUF
UVUUP VOUFNQPEJWJUB
>
1FSRVBOUPQPTTBTFNCSBSFTUSBOP OFMUFNQPEFMMBNBMBUUJBDJTJBMMFOBBWJWFSFVOBOVPWBMJCFSUOPO
RVFMMBBCBTTPQSF[[PMFHBUFBMMFNPMUFQPTTJCJMJU NBRVFMMBDIFFNFSHFRVBOEPMFQPTTJCJMJUNBUFSJBMJ
TJSJEVDPOPRVFMMBDIFEFOUSPEJOPJFMBQPTTJCJMJUEJQSFOEFSFEFOUSPEJOPJEFDJTJPOJDIFJMNPOEP
BUUPSOP B OPJ OPO DJ DPOTFOUF #FODI MB NBMBUUJB QPTTB UPHMJFSDJ MB QPTTJCJMJU EJ EFDJEFSF DIF GBSF F
EPWFBOEBSF OPODJUPHMJFMBMJCFSUEJEFDJEFSFEJDPOUJOVBSFBWJWFSF EJOPOJEFOUJGJDBSDJDPOJMOPTUSP
NBMF EJSJDPOPTDFSFDIFMBWJUBPMUSFJMOPTUSPDPSQPNBMBUP
%FDJEFSFEJDPOUJOVBSFBWJWFSFFSJGJVUBSFEJWJWFSFDPNFEFJTPQSBWWJTTVUJBMQSPQSJPNBMF

/DPDODWWLDOXRJRGLULFHUFDGLVHQVR

0HOJWPMUBDIFMBWJUBDJFTQPOFBMMFTQFSJFO[BEFMEPMPSF TJBNPDPTUSFUUJBSJQSFOEFSFJONBOPMBOPTUSB
FTJTUFO[BEBMMFTVFGPOEBNFOUB DPTUSFUUJBEJSFBOPJTUFTTJDIFDPTBDPOUBQFSOPJ BSJEFGJOJSFJMWBMPSF
DIFIBOOPQFSOPJJNQFHOJ QFSTPOF EFTJEFSJUVUUPTFNCSBSJNFUUFSTJJOHJPDP&TJDPOUJOVBBWJWFSF 
TF OFM EFTFSUP EFMMB EPNBOEF QJ SBEJDBMJ TJ SJFTDF B GBS TCPDDJBSF SJTQPTUF WJB WJB QJ FTTFO[JBMJ  QJ
TFNQMJDJFQJQSPGPOEFFDPTTJSJDPNJODJBBWJWFSFJOVOBMUSPNPEP4FEBMEFTFSUPOPOTQVOUBOVMMB 
BMMPSB JM WJWFSF EJ PHOJ HJPSOP EJWJFOF VO EJTQFSBUP TPQSBWWJWFSF B TF TUFTTJ F BMMF QSPQSJF WJDFOEF VO
NPEPQFSNPSJSFBO[JUFNQP
1FSUVUUJJMEPMPSFVOFTQFSJFO[BDIFUPDDBUVUUFMFGJCSFEFMMBWJUB PDDBTJPOFQFSVOWJBHHJPJOUFSJPSF
DIF NFUUF JO MVDF JM TFOTP EBUP BMMB WJUB GJOP B RVFM  NPNFOUP *M EPMPSF  TFNQSF VOFTQFSJFO[B
UPUBMF  DIF DBNCJB J TJHOJGJDBUJ PSEJOBSJ EFMMB OPTUSB FTJTUFO[B DIF EJ GSPOUF BMMB TPGGFSFO[B QFSEPOP P
BDDSFTDPOPJMMPSPQFTPFUVUUPEFWFFTTFSFSJTJHOJGJDBUP$IJNBMBUPHSBWFNFOUF OPOQFSDFQJTDFNBJ
TPMPJMQSPQSJPDPSQPNBMBUP NBUVUUPEJTEFOUSPMBNBMBUUJBMPTQJSJUP JMFHBNJ JQSPHFUUJEJWJUB
1FS RVFTUP MB UFSBQJB OPO QV FTTFSF TPMP QJMMPMF  NB DPNQBTTJPOF OPO TPMP DPNQFUFO[B  NB BODIF
BNJDJ[JB DBMPSF VNBOJU DGS$FDJMF4BVOEFST


3HUFRUVLGLIHGHGHQWURODPDODWWLD

4QFTTP JM EPMPSF EJWJFOF VO WJBHHJP WFSTP MB GFEF  P EFOUSP MB GFEF  EJ DVJ TJ SJDPOPTDF JM WBMPSF DPO
OVPWBQSPGPOEJU1FSDIJDSFEF MPDDBTJPOFQFSSFOEFSFQJQSPGPOEB UBMWPMUBQFSTDPQSJSF JMQSPQSJP
SBQQPSUPDPOJM4JHOPSF JMQSPQSJPMFHBNFDPO-VJ JMTVPBNPSF2VBOEPOFMEPMPSFDJTJQPOFEJGSPOUF


BM$SPDJGJTTP FTJSJFTDFBDSFEFSFDIFRVFMMBMBQJSBEJDBMFFQSPGPOEBFTQFSJFO[BEJBNPSFDIFNBJ
TJBBDDBEVUBOFMMBTUPSJBVNBOB BMMPSBJMEPMPSFSFEFOUP FEQPTTJCJMFTUBSFEFOUSPEJFTTPFHVBSEBSF
JO GBDDJB MB NPSUF DPO QBDF F DPO TQFSBO[B 1FS RVFTUP $JDFMZ 4BVOEFST  MB EPOOB DIF IB BWWJBUP
MFTQFSJFO[BEFMMFDVSFQBMMJBUJWFEFMEPMPSF QVEJSFMBSJTQPTUBDSJTUJBOBBMNJTUFSPEFMMBNPSUFFEFMMB
TPGGFSFO[BOPOVOBTQJFHB[JPOF NBVOBQSFTFO[B
%JGSPOUFBMMBQBTTJPOFEFM4JHOPSF JMDSFEFOUFDPOEVDFMBTVBSJDFSDBEJTFOTPBQBSUJSFEBMMBTJUVB[JPOF
JODVJMBNBMBUUJBMPQPOF.BMBQBTTJPOFVOQBTTBHHJPEVSPFTFWFSPOFMMBWJUBEFM4JHOPSF WJTTVUP
OFMMBDPOTBQFWPMF[[BFTQMJDJUBEFMMBTVBEVSF[[B
*M4JHOPSF(FTOPOBOEBUPCBMEBO[PTBNFOUFJODPOUSPBMMBQBTTJPOFFBMMBNPSUF NBHBSJGPSUFEFMMJEFB
DIF%JPFSBDPO-VJ*MEPMPSFTQFTTPHFOFSBEFOUSPEJOPJJMCVJPFMBEJGGJDPMUEJQFSDFQJSFBODIFMB

GPS[BEFMMBNPSFDIFDJBDDPNQBHOB
1SPQSJPQFSRVFTUP BQQBJPOPJOBEFHVBUFBMDVOFSJTQPTUFEJGFEFUSPQQPGBDJMJFTCSJHBUJWFDIFWFOHPOP
EBUFBMEPMPSF BMMBNBMBUUJB BMMBNPSUF
/FDJUPEVF
-B QSJNB  RVFMMB EFM EPMPSJTNP  DJP EFMMFTBMUB[JPOF EFM EPMPSF DPNF TF TNFUUFTTF EJ FTTFSF MB
EJNFOTJPOF ESBNNBUJDB EFMMB WJUB F MB OFHB[JPOFEJ FTTB DPNF TF MB TPGGFSFO[BTNFUUFTTFEJ FTTFSF
VONBMF BWFTTFWBMPSFJOTDPNFTF%JPGPTTFVO1BESFDIFTJDPNQJBDFEJDJDIFTGJHVSBFEFWBTUB
MVNBOJUEFMTVPGJHMJP MVPNP$PNFQVJM%JP1BESFEJ(FT$SJTUPHSBEJSFDPNFPGGFSUBDJDIF
NBMFQFSMBTVBDSFBUVSB  .BOJDBSEJ Q

-B TFDPOEB HJVTUJGJDB[JPOF  RVFMMB DIF GB SJDPSTP BMMB WPMPOU EJ %JP  DPNF TF %JP QPUFTTF FTTFSF
MBVUPSFEFMMFTJUVB[JPOJESBNNBUJDIFPSSJCJMJJODVJDJTJWJFOFBUSPWBSF
5BMWPMUB TJ EJDF BJ NBMBUJ DIF MB MPSP TPGGFSFO[B  TFHOP RVBTJ EJ VO QSJWJMFHJP EJ %JP  DPNF TF MB
TPGGFSFO[BBWFTTFVOWBMPSFTBMWJGJDPJOT.BRVFTUPDPSSJTQPOEFBMMJNNBHJOFEJ%JPDSVEFMF DIFOPO
RVFMMPEFM7BOHFMP5SPQQPGBDJMNFOUFFWFMPDFNFOUFTJBUUSJCVJTDFBMMBWPMPOUEJ%JPVONBMF VOB
NBMBUUJB  VOB TPGGFSFO[B  VOB NPSUF JOWJUBOEP DPT B VO BUUFHHJBNFOUP EJ SBTTFHOB[JPOF GBUBMJTUJDB &
DPTTJDPOGPOEFJM%JPDSJTUJBOPDPOJMGBUPQBHBOP .BOJDBSEJ Q

1FSTPOBMNFOUF SJUFOHPDIFTPMPMJNNFSHFSFMBQSPQSJBWJUBDIFTJTQFHOFOFMMFGPS[F OFMMFQPTTJCJMJU 


OFMMF SBHJPOJ EJ WJUB P OFMMB QSPTQFUUJWB TUFTTB EJ FTTB OFM NJTUFSP EFMMBNPSF EFM 4JHOPSF F OFMMB TVB
WJUBDSPDJGJTTBFSJTPSUBQPTTBDPTUJUVJSFMBGPS[BQFSBGGSPOUBSFMBQSPWBRVFMMBEFMMBNBMBUUJBFRVBMTJBTJ
QSPWB
-FTFNQJPEJ(FTJMSJGFSJNFOUPQJHSBOEFFEFDJTJWPDIFQPTTBBWFSFBEJTQPTJ[JPOFDIJDSFEF/PO
DEPMPSFDIFFHMJOPOBCCJBDPOPTDJVUPJQJVNJMJBOUJ JQJBTTVSEJ JQJDSVEFMJ2UDPDLQRQHVLVWH
SLXQOXRJRVHQ]D'LR'LRLQ&ULVWRKDDELWDWRJOLLQIHULGHOO
HVLVWHQ]DHSHULOFUHGHQWHQRQHVLVWHSLFLHORFKLXVR
PDDQFKHODVLWXD]LRQHGLLQIHUQRHVLVWHQ]LDOHGLWXQQHOGLVRIIHUHQ]DFKHQRQKDILQHGLPDOHLUULPHGLDELOHSXzHVVHUH
YLVVXWDFRPHOXRJRFKHqVWDWRDELWDWRGD&ULVWRHGXQTXHFRPHRFFDVLRQHGLFRPXQLRQHFRQOXL/DSRWHQ]DGL'LRFKH
VLPDQLIHVWDQHOODFURFHGL&ULVWR FLRqQHO&ULVWRFURFLILVVR qSRWHQ]DGLVDOYH]]DFLRqFKHGLVSLHJDHQHUJLHGLYLWD
QHOFUHGHQWHFKH GDQGRLOQRPHGLFURFHDOODSURSULDVRIIHUHQ]DHXQHQGRVLFRVuDO&URFLILVVRYHGHDJLUHLQOXLDQFKH
ODSRWHQ]DGHOO
DPRUHSLIRUWHGHOODPRUWHODSRWHQ]DGHOODUHVXUUH]LRQH/DFURFHqDOORUDYHUDPHQWHFDSDFHGLIDUFL
FRQRVFHUH'LR 0DQLFDUGLS 

-B EJHOJU DPO DVJ (FT IB BUUSBWFSTBUP MB TVB QBTTJPOF  QFS PHOJ QFSTPOB DIF TPGGSF VO HSBOEF
NPUJWP EJ DPOTPMB[JPOF VOB EJHOJU VNBOJTTJNB  DIF HSJEB QSFHBOEP  NB OFMMPCCFEJFO[B BM NJTUFSP
DIFDPOEBOOBMBWJPMFO[B NBDPONJUF[[BFDPNQBTTJPOFDIFTVEBTBOHVFTPUUPMBTGFS[BEFMEPMPSF 
NBWBJODPOUSPDPOQBTTPSJTPMVUPBMMBTVBPSB BMMBQQVOUBNFOUPDPOBMNPSUF.JIBTFNQSFDPMQJUP
JM GBUUP DIF (FT OPO TFNCSB BGGSPOUBSF JM EPMPSF DPO EJTJOWPMUVSB  NB DPO QFOB /FM HJBSEJOP EJ
(FUTFNBOJMBSJQVHOBO[BDIFFHMJQSPWBQFSJMEPMPSFDIFMPBUUFOEFNJTFNQSFQBSTBRVBOUPEJQJ
VNBOP F DPOTPMBOUF JM 7BOHFMP DJ QPUFTTF QSFTFOUBSF (FT OPO IB BNBUP JM EPMPSF  DPNF TFNCSB


UBMWPMUB GBSDJ DSFEFSF DFSUB DVMUVSB TQJSJUVBMF EPMPSJTUJDB (FT MP IB BGGSPOUBUP QFS PCCFEJFO[B BE
VO EJTFHOP EJ BNPSF  WFSBNFOUF QJ GPSUF EFMMB NPSUF 0HOJ QFSTPOB DIF TPGGSF QFOTP QPTTB FTTFSF
DPOTPMBUBEBMQFOTJFSPDIFBODIFJM4JHOPSF(FTTBMJUPTVM$BMWBSJPDBEFOEPUSFWPMUF IBHSJEBUPJM
TFOTP EFMMBCCBOEPOP EFM 1BESF  DIF  DPNF EJSF MB TVB TPMJUVEJOF EFTPMBUB EBWBOUJ BM EFTUJOP DIF MP
BUUFOEFWB$POUFNQMBSFMBTVBQBTTJPOFFWJWFSFMBQSPQSJBQBTTJPOFDPO-VJNJQBSFDIFTJBJMQFSDPSTP
QJDSJTUJBOPDIFFTJTUB MVOJDBSJTQPTUBQPTTJCJMFBMMFOPTUSFEPNBOEF
1FSDIBMMFOPTUSFEPNBOEFDIFOPOTPOPUFPSJDIFFTQFDVMBUJWF NBWJUBMJMVOJDBSJTQPTUBQPTTJCJMF
WJUBMFFTTBQBTTBBUUSBWFSTPMBOPTUSBJEFOUJGJDB[JPOFDPO$PMVJDIFDPOPTDFJMEPMPSFBDDPMUPQFSBNPSF
"MMPSBBODIFJMQSPQSJPEPMPSFWJFOFBTTVOUPJORVFTUPBNPSF FSFOEFTPTUFOJCJMFJMDBNNJOBSFBMCVJP 
TPUUPJMQFTPEFMMBQSPQSJBDSPDF
%BM NPNFOUP JO DVJ JM 4JHOPSF DJ GB JM EPOP EJ WJWFSF JM OPTUSP EPMPSF EFOUSP JM TVP  DBNCJB JM NPEP
EJ BGGSPOUBSF MB TPGGFSFO[B TJ TNFUUF EJ TPQSBWWJWFSF B TF TUFTTJ  F TJ UPSOB B TDFHMJFSF EJ WJWFSF TJ
TDPQSPOPEJNFOTJPOJOVPWFEFMMFTJTUFO[BQJQSPGPOEF JNQFOTBUF-BQSPQSJBWJUBDPNJODJBBEFTTFSF
QFSDPSTBEBVOBDPSSFOUFEJGJEVDJBOFMMBNPSFEFM4JHOPSFQFSOPJMBTVBQBTTJPOFBMUSPOPODIFMB
NBOJGFTUB[JPOFQJBMUBEJUBMFBNPSF$IFTJTQFSJNFOUBOFMMFQJDDPMFDPTFEJPHOJHJPSOP TPQSBUUVUUP
DPNF GPS[B QFS BGGSPOUBSF MB HSBOEF QBVSB DIF JM EPMPSF QPSUB DPO T $PT  HJPSOP EPQP HJPSOP  TJ
DPOTUBUB DIF J QBTTBHHJ DIF QFOTBWBNP DIF OPO TBSFNNP NBJ TUBUJ JO HSBEP EJ BGGSPOUBSF  JO FGGFUUJ
MJ BCCJBNP BUUSBWFSTBUJ MFTQFSJFO[B QJ NJTUFSJPTB  RVFMMB EJ TDPQSJSF DIF JM 4JHOPSF OPO DJ GB NBJ
NBODBSFMBGPS[BOFDFTTBSJBQFSBGGSPOUBSFMBQSPWB$PT JQFOTJFSJEJGFEFDIFBCCJBNPBTUSBUUBNFOUF
JNQBSBUP OFJ HJPSOJ EFM CFOFTTFSF  EPQP MB QSPWB TPOP VOFTQFSJFO[B DIF TJ TDSJWF OFMMB OPTUSB BOJNB
QFSDITJTDSJUUBOFMMBOPTUSBWJUBUVUUB
*ORVFTUBQSPTQFUUJWB JMEPMPSFTJUSBTGPSNBJOBNPSF DIFMVOJDBQSPTQFUUJWBDIFQVEBSFTFOTPBM
EPMPSF
2VFTUPWFSJGJDBCJMFBODIFOFMMBWJUBFOFMMBNPSUFEJ(FT/POMBDSPDFFOPOTPOPMFTPGGFSFO[FQBUJUFOFMMBQBTTJPOFF

TVMMBDSPDFDIFIBOOPSFTPHSBOEF(FT NBMFTBUUPDPOUSBSJPMBWJUBEJ(FT MJOUFSBWJUBEJ(FTUSBWFSTBUBEBMMBNPSF 


TQFTB OFMMBNBSF  DIF IB EBUP TFOTP BODIF B RVFMMBCPNJOJP DIF FSB  DIF  F DIF TFNQSF SFTUFS MB DSPDF 4USVNFOUP EJ
UPSUVSBFEJQFOBEJNPSUFDIFVPNJOJDPNNJOBOPBEBMUSJVPNJOJ MBDSPDFBQQBSFTJNCPMPEFMMFTJUVB[JPOJEJTPGGFSFO[BDIF
EJTVNBOJ[[BOP TJNCPMPEFHMJJOGFSJEFMMFTJTUFO[B/POMBDSPDF NBDPMVJDIFWJBQQFTPWFSBNFOUFJNQPSUBOUFFEFDJTJWP

 $SJTUP OPO IB PGGFSUP MF TVF TPGGFSFO[F  NB IB PGGFSUP TF TUFTTP  IB GBUUP EFMMB TVB WJUB VOPGGFSUB B %JP USPWBOEP MB
QSPQSJBHJPJBOFMMBNBSFHMJBMUSJFRVFTUPMIBGBUUPTFNQSF OPOTPMPTVMMBDSPDFMBDSPDFJMDVMNJOFEJVOBWJUBTQFTBQFSHMJ
BMUSJ OFMMBNPSFFOFMMBEFEJ[JPOF .BOJDBSEJ Q

/PO SJTQPOEF DFSUP O BMMB MFUUFSB O BMMP TQJSJUP EFM WBOHFMP MBGGFSNBSF DIF %JP WVPMF MB TPGGFSFO[B EFMMVPNP %JP
WVPMF MB MJCFSU EFMMVPNP F MB TVB VNBOJ[[B[JPOF %JP WVPMF MB GFMJDJU EFMMVPNP  VOB GFMJDJU USPWBUB OFMMBNBSF F OFM
EPOBSTJ OFMMPTQFOEFSFMBQSPQSJBWJUBQFSHMJBMUSJ EVORVFVOBGFMJDJUDIFTBBTTVNFSFBODIFMFTPGGFSFO[FFMFUSJCPMB[JPOJ
6OB EJTUPSTJPOF EFM NFTTBHHJP FWBOHFMJDP EJGGPOEF MJEFB DIF MB WPMPOU EJ %JP DPOTJTUB VOJDBNFOUF OFMMB DSPDF 
OFM SJOOFHBNFOUP EJ T  OFMMVNJMJBSTJ  EJNFOUJDBOEP DIF OPO RVFTUF EJNFOTJPOJ EJ QFS T TPOP DJ DIF JNNFUUF OFMMB
DPNVOJPOFDPO%JP NBTPMPMBNPSF MBMJCFSUDPODVJVOBQFSTPOBTDFHMJFEJBNBSFFEPOBSFMBWJUBBDDFUUBOEPBODIFMF
TPGGFSFO[F F EVORVF MF VNJMJB[JPOJ  J SJOOFHBNFOUJ EJ T  MB DSPDF
 DIF RVFTUP DPNQPSUB /PO MB TPGGFSFO[B  NB MBNPSF
TBMWB/POMBDSPDFEJQFST DIFTUSVNFOUPEJNPSUF TBMWB NBMBWJUBEJDPMVJDIFWJTUFTPTPQSB MBRVBMFEBODIFTFOTP
BMMBDSPDF Q

/FMMB QSPWB EFM EPMPSF  MB OPTUSB WJUB EJWFOUB QJ FTTFO[JBMF F MB GFEF QJ QVSB /FM NPNFOUP JO
DVJ BDDFUUJBNP EB %JP DJ DIF FHMJ DJ NBOEB EB WJWFSF TF EB %JP BDDFUUJBNP JM CFOF  QFSDI OPO
EPWSFNNP BDDFUUBSF BODIF JM NBMF &TDMBNB (JPCCF HMJ DPOTFHOJBNP MB OPTUSB WJUB OFMMB GFEF OVEB
EFM QPWFSP  GFEF TFO[B DPOTPMB[JPOF  TFO[B MVDF  TFO[B TQJFHB[JPOF  NB UPUBMNFOUF BCCBOEPOBUB BMMB
DFSUF[[BDIFDPNVORVF%JPBNPSFFEDPOOPJ
/FMNPNFOUPJODVJ(FTTVMMBDSPDFQSPOVODJBMFTVFVMUJNFQBSPMF1BESF OFMMFUVFNBOJBGGJEPJMNJP
TQJSJUP TFNCSBEJBTDPMUBSFQBSPMFEJSFTBJOFGGFUUJTPOPMFQBSPMFEFMMBNPSFQJHSBOEF
/FJHJPSOJEFMCFOFTTFSFFEFMMBTFSFOJU PDDPSSFFTTFSFEJTQPTUJBNFUUFSFMFQSPQSJFFOFSHJFFMBQSPQSJB
GJEVDJBOFMMBWJUBBTFSWJ[JPEJDIJEVCJUBEFMMBCPOUEFMMBWJUBEJDIJOPODFMBGBQJ EJDIJOPOIBQJ


SBHJPOJEJWJUBFEOFMCVJPUPUBMF-BQSFTFO[BEJDIJDJWVPMFCFOFEJDIJTDFHMJFEJTUBSDJWJDJOPBODIF
TFO[BBWFSOFBMDVOPCCMJHP QBSMBEFMMBNPSFEFM4JHOPSFQFSUVUUJ4QFTTPTPOPMFQBSPMFTJMFO[JPTFDIF
UPDDBOPJMDVPSFFEBOOPVOFOFSHJBJOBTQFUUBUB

(XFDULVWLDHIUDJLOLW

*M 7BOHFMP EJ (JPWBOOJ  OBSSBOEP MFQJTPEJP EFMMVMUJNB DFOB  MP JOUSPEVDF DPO RVFTUF QBSPMF BWFOEP
BNBUPJTVPJ MJBNGJOPBMMBGJOF/PJDSFEJBNPDIFJM4JHOPSFBCCJBBNBUPJTVPJFDJBTDVOPEJOPJ NB
OPOSJVTDJBNPBDPHMJFSFMBQPSUBUBEJRVFMGJOPBMMBGJOF
-BQBTRVBDJBQQBSFTPMPDPNFEPMPSF DPNFGBMMJNFOUP DPNFTDPOGJUUB&MPDFSUBNFOUF HVBSEBUBEBM 
QVOUPEJWJTUBVNBOP.BQSPQSJPRVFMGJOPBMMBGJOFDIFSFOEFMB1BTRVBVOBNPSFEB%JP TFDPOEP
MB NJTVSB EJ %JP & RVFMMB NJTVSB DIF OFM 7BOHFMP TPMP MF EPOOF TFNCSBOP BWFS DPNQSFTP F DIF
TFNCSBOPFTTFSFJOHSBEPEJBDDFUUBSF
-B 1BTRVB QBTTJPOF  NPSUF F SJTVSSF[JPOF EJ (FT DIF OPJ DPNQSFOEJBNP RVBTJ FTDMVTJWBNFOUF
DPNFEPMPSF TPGGFSFO[B VNJMJB[JPOF OFMMBTVBOBUVSBQJQSPGPOEBBNPSF"NPSFDIFTJEPOBTFO[B
USBUUFOFSFOVMMBQFST OFNNFOPMBWJUB"ODIFOPJTBSFNNPTUBUJOFMOVNFSPEJRVFMMJDIFBJQJFEJEFMMB
DSPDF QVSTFO[BTDIFSOPFJSSJTJPOF BWSFNNPEFUUPB(FTTDFOEJEBMMBDSPDF JMNPOEPIBCJTPHOP
EFMMBUVBQPUFO[BNJTUFSJPTBDPOUJOVBBVTBSFMBGPS[BDIFIBJNPTUSBUPOFJUVPJNJSBDPMJTDPOGJHHFOEP
MBNPSUF NPTUSBOEPDIFMBWJUBQJGPSUFEFMMBNPSUF
& (FT JO FGGFUUJ MP IB NPTUSBUP  NB MP IB GBUUP BUUSBWFSTBOEP JM EPMPSF F MB NPSUF  GBDFOEPMJ TVPJ
FTTJ GBOOP QBSUF EFMMB TUPSJB VNBOB TUBOOP EFOUSP MB TUPSJB EFJ QPWFSJ F PHOJ VPNP  RVBOEP TPGGSF 
QPWFSP(FTIBWPMVUPWJODFSFMBNPSUFFJMEPMPSFOPODPOVOBUUPEJQPUFO[B NBDPOVOBUUPEJ
BNPSFDIFQJGPSUFEFMQPUFSFDIFTPUUPNFUUFJMNBMF&MBWJUBSJTPSHF JOVOPSJ[[POUFEJWJOP
%VORVF JM $BMWBSJP  QSJNB DIF FTTFSF MB TUPSJB EFMMJOHBOOP  EFMMF JOWJEJF  EFJ SBHHJSJ VNBOJ  QPMJUJDJ F
SFMJHJPTJEFM4JOFESJPFEFMQPUFSF MBTUPSJBEJVOBNPSFUPUBMF TPMJEBMFDPOUVUUJJEPMPSJEFMMBUFSSB DIF
TJDPOTFHOBBMEPMPSF DIFGBEPOPEFMMBWJUB
-&VDBSJTUJB DPOBMGPS[BEFMMBNPSFDIFDPOUJFOFFDIFHFOFSB USBTGPSNBMBWJUBDJDIFMBUSBTGPSNB
MBDPOTBQFWPMF[[BEJVOBNPSFHSBUVJUPDIFMBSBHHJVOHFVOBNPSFDIFOPOTJSJDFWFQFSNFSJUP NBQFS
NJTFSJDPSEJB-&VDBSJTUJBJMTFHOPEJRVFTUPBNPSF4FDJBGGJEJBNPBEVOBNPSFDIFDSFEFOFMWBMPSF
EFMMBOPTUSBWJUBFTJEPOBBEFTTB MBOPTUSBWJUBTJUSBTGPSNBDPOPTDJBNPQFSFTQFSJFO[BMBGPS[BDIF
DJWJFOF QFSBGGSPOUBSFMFTJUVB[JPOJQJEJGGJDJMJ EBMMBWFSWJDJOPVOBQFSTPOBDIFDJWVPMFCFOF DIFIB
GJEVDJBJOOPJ DIFDPOHSBUVJUWVPMFBDDPNQBHOBSTJBMMBOPTUSBWJUBTBQQJBNPDIFRVFMMJTPOPJDBTJJO
DVJTDPQSJBNPJOOPJVOBGPS[BJOTPTQFUUBUB RVFMMBDIFOFDFTTBSJBBODIFQFSBGGSPOUBSFMFFTQFSJFO[F
QJEJGGJDJMJFQJEVSFEFMMBOPTUSBWJUB

6WLOLQHOYLYHUHODIUDJLOLW

"WPMUFBWWJFOFDIFQFSTPOFNPMUPNBMBUFPHSBWFNFOUFTPGGFSFOUJTBQQJBOPJSSBEJBSFVOBMVNJOPTJU 
VOBHJPJBEJWJWFSFFVOBDBQBDJUEJBNPSFDIFJMTFNQMJDFDPOUBUUPDPOMPSP JMSFTUBSFBDDBOUPBMPSP
BODIF QFS QPDP UFNQP TJ SJWFMB FTTFSF VOFTQFSJFO[B TQJSJUVBMF F VNBOB EJ QSPGPOEP BSSJDDIJNFOUP
RVFMMF QFSTPOF IBOOP TBQVUP JOOFTUBSF MB TPGGFSFO[B OFMMBNPSF F GBS QSFWBMFSF MB QBTTJPOF EFMMBNPSF
TVMMBQBTTJPOFEFMTPGGSJSF&DJUSBTNFUUPOPMJOTFHOBNFOUPHSBOEFMBNPSFETFOTP FMBWJUB JOUVUUJ
J TVPJ BTQFUUJ  IB TFOTP RVBOEP EJWJFOF VO DBQPMBWPSP EJ EPOB[JPOF F EJ BNPSF 1FSDI BMMPSB  VOB
WJUBCFBUB&MBCFBUJUVEJOFQVFTTFSFTQFSJNFOUBUB TVMMFUSBDDFEJ$SJTUP BODIFOFMMBTPGGFSFO[B OFMMF
QFSTFDV[JPOJ OFMMFBGGMJ[JPOJ .BOJDBSEJ Q

$SFEPDIFVOPEFHMJBTQFUUJDIFQJDPMQJTDPOPMFQFSTPOFDIFWJWPOPFMBWPSBOPDPOOPJ TPQSBUUVUUP


DPMPSPDIFOPOTPOPDSFEFOUJ JMOPTUSPBUUFHHJBNFOUPEJGSPOUFBMMBWJUB
"ODIFOFJNPNFOUJJODVJJMEPMPSFDJEJMBOJBMBOJNB JMTBQFSFEJOPOFTTFSFTPMJFEJQPUFSJNNFSHFSF
MB OPTUSB QJDDPMB FTJTUFO[B OFM DVPSF EJ %JP DJ E VOB TFSFOJU DIF OPO  JOEJGGFSFO[B BM EPMPSF  NB
QJVUUPTUP  MB QFSDF[JPOF EJ WJWFSF JO QBDF DPO MB WJUB *M WJWFSF SJDPODJMJBUJ DPO MB OPTUSB FTJTUFO[B 
RVBMVORVFTJBMBTVBDPOEJ[JPOF EJDFDIFEFOUSPEJOPJWJVOTFHSFUPDIFUPDDBDPMPSPDIFDJWJWPOP
BDDBOUPMBUFTUJNPOJBO[BEJVONPEPEJQFOTBSFMBWJUBEFMMVNJMUEJDIJBDDFUUBMBWJUBDPN TFO[B
BSSPHBO[B F TFO[B QSFUFTF TVMMB WJUB EJ DIJ IB DPNVORVF JNQBSBUP B DPHMJFSF MF SJDDIF[[F DIF TPOP
JO FTTB F DIF OPO EJQFOEPOP EBMMF DPOEJ[JPOJ NBUFSJBMJ EFM OPTUSP WJWFSF QBSMBOP EJ VOVNBOJU OPO
HJ SBTTFHOBUB  NB QJVUUPTUP NJUF  QB[JFOUF QBSMBOP EJ VOB GFEF DIF  OFM TFHSFUP EFMMB DPTDJFO[B  OF
DPTUJUVJTDFMBDIJBWFEJMFUUVSB
4J USBUUB EJ VOB UFTUJNPOJBO[B NPMUP JNQPSUBOUF JM DSJTUJBOFTJNP BSDJHOP F UBMWPMUB EPMPSJTUB EJ DFSUJ
OPTUSJBNCJFOUJOPOQVTVTDJUBSFMJOUFSFTTFEFMMFQFSTPOFDIFWJWPOPBDDBOUPBOPJ
-B OPTUSB FTJTUFO[B EJS DIF D VOB TQFSBO[B DIF MB WJUB WBMF MB QFOB EJ FTTFSF WJTTVUB DIF TJ QV
SJDPNJODJBSFPHOJHJPSOPDIFOFMMBWJUBWBMFMBQFOBEJGBSFTVMTFSJP$IJHVBSEBWJWFSFRVFTUFQFSTPOF
EBDSFEFOUJOFM4JHOPSF DBQJTDFDIFEFOUSPEJMPSPDVOTFHSFUPDIFMJJMMVNJOBFMJTPTUJFOF'PSTFB
QPDPBQPDP BUUSBWFSTPMBUFTUJNPOJBO[BFMBQBSPMB QPUSBOOPDBQJSFDIF(FT$SJTUPNPSUPFSJTPSUP
QFSDIJTVPJEJTDFQPMJQPTTPOPWJWFSFGFMJDJFEBSFVOTFOTPBMMBMPSPFTJTUFO[B





%PNBOEFEFOUSPMBNBMBUUJB
-BEBUUBNFOUP QFSFTTFSFQPTJUJWP OPOEFWFFTTFSFVOBBDDFUUB[JPOFQBTTJWBFVOBTPUUPNJTTJPOF
BMMB NBMBUUJB  NB VO BUUFHHJBNFOUP GMFTTJCJMF FE FRVJMJCSBUP DIF QFSNFUUF BM NBMBUP EJ TBMWBSF J QSPQSJ
WBMPSJ F EJ SFBMJ[[BSF TF TUFTTP OFMMB NJTVSB DPNQBUJCJMF DPO MF MJNJUB[JPOJ JNQPTUF EBMMB NBMBUUJB 
DBNCJBOEPJMTVPNPEPEJDPNQPSUBSTJBCJUVBMFTFO[BQFSRVFTUPBOEBSFJODSJTJFEJTHSFHBSTJ&RVFTUP
BEBUUBNFOUPQBTTBBUUSBWFSTPMBQSFTBEJDPTDJFO[BSFBMJTUJDBEFMMBNBMBUUJBFEFMMFTVFDPOTFHVFO[F
VOQSPDFTTPBWPMUFWFMPDFFEJNNFEJBUP BWPMUFMFOUPFHSBEVBMFJODVJMBSFBMUEFMMBNBMBUUJBOPOWJFOF
SJGJVUBUBPNFTTBUSBQBSFOUFTJ NBJOUFHSBUBDPNFFMFNFOUPDIFIB QBSBEPTTBMNFOUF VOTJHOJGJDBUP
FEVOQPTUPOFMMBEJOBNJDBEFMMBWJUB 4BOESJO- 1TJDPMPHJBEFMMBTBMVUFFEBMMBNBMBUUJB EBJOUFSOFU





Potrebbero piacerti anche