Running head: OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 1
Occupational Profile & Intervention Plan
Touro University Nevada Elizabeth Hares
OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 2
Occupational Profile The client P. Brown is a 76 year old female who lives with her husband of 41 years. The client has two children who are now older adults living in another state and only visit during the holidays. The client is close friends with her two neighbors who are the same age and share the same interests. The client is seeking services after suffering a CVA resulting in left hemiplegia post status 3 months. Since suffering the CVA, the client has right side paresis and a contracture in her right dominant hand that impacts many of her chosen occupations. Before her CVA, the client was diagnosed with Rheumatoid Arthritis, predominantly in the hands and knees. The client experiences stiffness in the knee joints and has a hard time bending over for many activities. The client recently had a fall from losing her balance in the shower and now requires assistance from her husband for safety. The client is not able to drive due to her right side weakness and is scared to get back to driving. The client has a good network of support from her friends at the stroke support group and individuals she has met in therapy, but has trouble attending the group and meeting with friends due to difficulties finding transportation. Since suffering her CVA, the client is having difficulties in many of her occupations. Currently, the client has her husband help her with bathing and grooming activities. The client is able to assist her husband in cooking activities by reading her recipes to her husband and helping create the weekly grocery list. The clients right hand contracture has poor range of motion and impacts many fine and gross motor activities using the right upper extremity. The client has concerns with her ADLs such as bathing and grooming. She is also concerned that she will not be able to get back to regularly attending her support groups, cake classes, and choir concerts. The client does not have difficulties in ambulation and uses a quad cane for balance and right side weakness. The client does not have concerns with functional mobility and is able to move OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 3
around the house without difficulties. The client is modified independent for many activities of daily living such as toileting, eating, and dressing. The client requires assistance for grooming and personal hygiene and needs help from her husband to wash many areas of the clients body due to weakness and poor balance. The client is experiencing problems in her leisure occupations and instrumental activities of daily living. The client is having difficulty preparing foods in the kitchen and cooking for her husband. In addition to cooking, home management is also a problem for the client. She has her husband take care of the house, water the yard, and do most laundry and house cleaning. The client would like to return to ironing and laundry to relieve stress from her husband. Leisure activities with her friends have been difficult for the client due to weakness in the right side, which impacts her ability to drive and get to and from places. The client depends on her husband to take her to her classes and misses many classes throughout the week because her husband works part-time. The client lives in a small, one-story home with her husband. The size of the home enables the client to move around the home without fatigue. The client uses a large shower with an extendable, hand-held showerhead installed, which reduces some of the demands of bathing, but she still requires assistance from her husband to complete all bathing tasks. Since her husband works part-time, she is left home alone without transportation three times per week. The kitchen the client works in is very small and does not give the client enough space to stand with her quad cane and maneuver around the counter space safely; this factor inhibits her occupation of meal prep and cooking for her husband. Mrs. Brown attends cake decorating classes with her neighbor and stroke support groups through her outpatient rehab facility. Ms. Brown sings in her church choir three times a week and enjoys teaching Sunday school once a month. When Ms. Brown has free time, she enjoys OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 4
crocheting clothing for newborn babies in the NICU. The client attends church with her husband every Sunday. She also enjoys reading in the backyard and baking. The client is interested in learning new cake recipes and trying new cake decorating tools and methods. The client feels it is important for her to get back to cooking new recipes and baking for her husband and friends. She feels that cooking will allow her to regain responsibilities in her marriage. The client also is very passionate about attending church choir meetings. This is a place where she receives support and motivation to return to her occupations and achieve her goals. This support is vital in her recovery and going to church gives the client a sense of meaning and independence. The client has stated that bathing without her husbands assistance and getting back to baking and cooking are her top priorities. She would like to get back to bringing new and unique baked goods to church when she attends Sunday morning Mass. Since these baking classes are important to the client, transportation to and from these classes is a concern for the client, and she would like to find a way to make it to her classes when her husband is working. The client would like to learn more about the bus system near her house and learn the routes and times that would enable her to get to church meetings independently. She feels like a burden needing her husband to drive her to meetings and bathe her, and her goals are centered on increasing her independence and reducing that burden. Occupational Analysis Mrs. Brown is receiving skilled OT services in an outpatient rehabilitation facility that specializes in stroke and hand contractures. The client receives OT three times a week and usually works in a smaller room one-on-one with an Occupational Therapist. In therapy, the client currently performs table-top activities to increase range of motion in right upper extremity. The rehabilitation facility has a large gym to work on gross motor activities, many tables for fine OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 5
motor table-top activities, and modern technology including E-Stim to work on functional extension of the fingers. Mrs. Brown was observed transferring different size beads out of a large box into a smaller box using tweezers. The client had trouble with smaller beads and pinching the tweezers enough to grasp the bead. The activity required that the client flex her shoulder to bring the arm up over the box to retrieve the beads. After retrieving the beads, the client was required to adduct the shoulder to bring the beads on the left side of her body where the smaller box was located. At times, Mrs. Brown used her left hand to hold her right arm up during the activity for stability when picking up the beads. During the activity, the client was experiencing frustration and was trying very hard to pick the beads up. This bead activity proved to be very difficult for the client, and required various types of movement in the involved arm. The client was motivated to complete the activity but was getting frustrated. The client currently has sensory disturbances and weakness in the upper right arm. This impacts her ability to lift the arm or feel where in the hand the tweezers are located. Weakness in the muscles of the upper arm (biceps & deltoids) affects the clients ability to flex the shoulder enough to transfer the beads out of the box. The client compensates for this by lifting her right arm with her left hand. This technique allows the client to complete the activity and still promotes movement of the arm albeit passively since she does not have the ability to lift the arm all the way up. The client is able to use a pincer grasp to hold the tweezers, but her grasp is very weak. Occasionally the beads would fall out of the tweezers because she was not able to hold the grasp long enough to transfer the bead. Out of 25 beads, she was able to transfer 17 within a five minute time period. The client is able to flex the shoulder actively to around 80 degrees, enough to reach table height for the activity. This level of shoulder flexion falls below functional limits and impacts the clients abilities to engage in many occupations. OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 6
Mrs. Brown is experiencing limitations in many areas of her life. According to the OTPF 3 rd Edition, the clients right upper extremity weakness and contracture of the right digits is affecting multiple domains. These domains include many areas of occupation, client factors, and performance skills. The areas of occupations that are impacting the clients daily life are ADLs, leisure activities with her neighbor and friends, IADLs such as meal preparation and house management, and social participation within the community. The client factors that have been impacted by her CVA include multiple body functions. Foremost, the client is having trouble with sensory functions; her decreased touch affects her ability to feel objects textures, temperature, and location within in the hand. Deficits in the sensory functions make fine motor activities such as cooking, crocheting, and bathing more difficult. The clients neuromusculosekeletal functions such as joint stability, joint mobility, and muscle power have also been affected by weakness resulting from the CVA, impacting the clients ability to complete full AROM required for many occupations. Many performance skills are providing barriers for the client to complete her occupations; specific performance skills include motor skills. The client has trouble reaching with the right upper extremity, stabilizing the arm, gripping, and manipulation of objects required for fine motor activities. Limitations in these domains significantly impact the clients ability to engage in her chosen occupations which give meaning to the client. These limitations should be addressed in therapy to improve her quality of life and occupational engagement. Problem List Problems that directly affect the clients areas of occupation are listed below. These problem statements should be used to guide treatment and treatment goals in collaboration with the client. The following problem statements are in order of priority and reflect the clients goals OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 7
of treatment. 1) The client requires MAX (A) for baking activities due to decreased motor skills and weakness in R UE. The client would like to gain independence in baking activities so that she is able to return to cake classes and start baking for her husband at home and her church. Getting the client back into baking will allow her to attend her weekly classes, increase her social participation, and allow her to gain more responsibilities in her marriage. 2) The client requires MOD (A) with assistance from her husband to wash 4/10 body areas due to RA stiffness and pain in knee joints. The client currently receives assistance from her husband when bathing in the shower. Mr. Brown washes four areas of the clients body and washes her hair. The client has trouble standing while showering and experiences pain in the knee joints when standing too long. Bending over to wash her perineal area and legs are difficult for the client. Mr. Brown goes to work early in the morning, and if the client wants to shower, she has to get up before Mr. Brown leaves so she is able to be clean for the day. Increasing her ability to bathe without Mr. Brown will allow her to bathe with modified independence using home modifications and adaptions. 3) The client is unable to complete laundry tasks due to limited AROM and contracture in the R UE. Returning to house management is important to the client. This will allow the client to take on more tasks around the house, decreasing the stress on her husband and giving her a feeling of self-efficacy. 4) The client is unable to complete crocheting due to a weak grasp and contracture in R hand. The client takes pride in crocheting in her free time and finds stress relief in this occupation. Addressing the performance skills needed for crocheting and increasing her independence for these skills will allow her to get back to crocheting with friends and making blankets for babies in the NICU. 5) Client requires MIN (A) for grooming activities due to limited AROM in R UE and decreased grip strength. Regaining independence in personal hygiene and grooming skills is important to the client. Mrs. Brown would like to brush her hair OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 8
throughout the day or wash her face and hands without assistance from her husband. Being able to groom herself before going to church and cake classes is one of the more important and meaningful goals to the client because it would improve her independence and ability to participate in activities she enjoys. Intervention Plan & Outcomes Long term and short term goals for the client provide the therapist with a way to measure a clients progression. Appropriate goals and interventions for Mrs. Brown address the previously stated problem statements. Below are the goals and corresponding interventions that will be used to reach treatment goals throughout a period of 5 weeks in outpatient treatment. 1) LTG 1. The client will decorate half a dozen cupcakes in her kitchen using A/E with supervision from husband within 5 weeks. a. STG 1. The client will bake a dozen cupcakes MIN (A) using a three step box set and A/E within 3 weeks. i. Intervention A (Modify Approach). The client will choose her husbands favorite cake flavor in a box set. The client will bring in the box set to treatment, and the practitioner will work with the client to setup tools and materials needed to make the box set. In a seated position, the client will prepare the cake batter, pour the cake batter into the muffin pan, and bake the cupcakes. The practitioner will educate the client on adaptive equipment and techniques to use during the baking process such as use of a universal cuff with a wooden spatula to allow the client to mix the batter with her involved hand and arm, stabilizing the bowl with the non- involved arm. Hand over hand technique may be used to promote PROM OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 9
and involvement for tasks that are too difficult for the client. Grading up and down may be needed for the client to complete the activity. b. STG 2.The client will decorate three premade cupcakes MIN (A) using A/E within 2 weeks. i. Intervention B (Restore Approach). Using premade cupcakes purchased at a local grocery store, the client will use pre-made icing in a zip lock bag with a hole to squeeze out the icing onto cupcakes as the client prefers. Food colorings can be used for the clients preference for decorating the cupcakes. Different sprinkles can be placed on the table, and the client can reach with the involved side to pinch sprinkles of her choice using a pincer grasp to retrieve sprinkles and place them on top of the cupcakes. The importance of this intervention is to work on functional reaching during the task and picking up the sprinkles with her involved hand promoting use of the involved arm and hand to decrease chances of learned non-use. If the client has cake decorating tools at home, the client will bring them in to use for the cupcakes. Educating the client on adaptive use of these tools with A/E to use during cupcake decorating will be beneficial and involve more carry-over into the home setting. The use of a universal cuff for her icing brushes or tools can increase the clients engagement in cake decorating. 2) LTG 2. The client will bathe herself MOD (I) with A/E & DME in home shower within 5 weeks. OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 10
a. STG 3.The client will complete grooming activities at sink SUP using A/E within 3 weeks. i. Intervention C (Compensatory approach). The client will be seated at a sink in the bathroom. Using adaptive equipment, the practitioner will work on functional ROM using a wash cloth to wash the clients face using the involved arm. Adaptive techniques may be used to enable the client to hold the towel to complete face washing. An arm mobilizer may increase the clients independence when washing her face and brushing her hair. Having the client stabilize the involved arm with the non-involved arm during face-washing and hair-brushing should be promoted as a compensatory technique for the client to complete her grooming tasks at home independently. Education on simple home modifications should be incorporated into treatment, such as pump soaps and shampoo, suction pads for grooming tools, electric toothbrushes, and easy-to-open lotions and toothpaste. Having the client use compensatory strategies increases bilateral upper extremity involvement. b. STG 4. The client will bathe 8/10 body areas SUP using DME and A/E in shower within 3 weeks. i. Intervention D (Modify approach). Since the intervention setting is an outpatient rehabilitation facility, teaching the client motor control and use of adaptive equipment for showering can increase the clients skills when bathing in the home setting. The client will be seated in a chair and will be recommended a compatible shower chair for home-use. Sitting upright, OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 11
the client will use a loofa that contains a string around the sponge that will go around the clients involved hand. The client may use her left arm to stabilize the involved arm while completing this activity to promote use of the involved hand and arm. If the client is not using the left arm to stabilize the involved arm, bilateral use of the upper extremity is recommended when completing bathing activities. Using this loofa, the client will practice washing areas of her body that are currently giving her trouble. These areas include the lower legs. The client will practice reaching for simulated bathing materials such as soap, shampoo, or a towel. The practitioner should encourage the client to apply soap or shampoo with the left arm and scrub the body with the involved arm incorporating the use of both upper extremities and functional reaching in the activities. Since the client has fallen in the shower before, educating the client on safe transfer techniques in and out of the shower would be beneficial. Recommending DME and A/E such as a shower chair, handle bars, and a non-slip shower mat can increase the clients safety during shower transfers and bathing. Evidence for Interventions The interventions provided for the client have been supported by current research focusing on interventions for stroke populations. A majority of the research has been conducted on contractures resulting from stroke, hemiplegia, and the effect a stroke has on the quality of life for these individuals. For Intervention A, a modify approach was taken to enable the client to complete baking cupcakes with less activity demands. The modify approach requires OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 12
modification of the environment and use of adaptive equipment to substitute a skill that the client is having trouble with. According to Ways of Living: Adaptive Strategies for special needs by Christiansen & Matuska (2004), activities can be accomplished in more than one way. Training in the use of adaptive equipment can improve and maintain occupational performance (Christiansen & Matuska, 2004). Some commonly used adaptive equipment for stroke patients include electric mixers, pan handle stabilizers, apron with front pockets, and use of a wheeled cart. The use of adaptive techniques such as stabilizing bowls by securing them in between your legs while you stir and using a cart to take fewer trips during the cooking process decreases the activity demands. Evidence of adaptive equipment and techniques in the kitchen will provide support for further techniques and equipment recommendations for Mrs. Brown during Intervention A. These techniques provide the therapist with a foundation to grow upon, providing more client-centered adaptive techniques and equipment that meet the needs of Mrs. Brown to complete baking the cupcakes. For Intervention B, a remediate approach was used to promote improvement in the clients AROM in the shoulder during functional activities. A contracture has formed secondary to CVA. Promoting use of the arm and hand will improve movement and motor skills within the involved side. Incorporating the use of her favorite occupation as a way to increase AROM is important in the intervention, providing the client with an end-goal to work towards. Grading of the activity should be completed to ensure the client does not experience failed attempts which may result in decreased self-efficacy and learned non-use. According to a study conducted by Schaefer, DeJong, Cherry, and Lang (2012) Grip Type and Task Goal Modify Reach-to-Grasp Performance in Post-Stroke Hemiparesis, different movement patterns may be elicited through different grip types and task goals (Schaefer, DeJong, Cherry, & Lang 2012). The study looked OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 13
at sixteen adults with post stroke hemiparesis and their movement patterns when grasping cylindrical items using a 3-finger or palmer grip to achieve a task goal. This task goal was to hold or lift the item. Results from the study suggest that even with arm impairment resulting from a CVA, reaching and grasping performance can still be modified on how and why the object will be grasped. Learning about how different movement contexts influence performance poststroke may assist therapist in planning how and when to practice during task specific upper extremity training (Schaefer, DeJong, Cherry, & Lang 2012). This study can guide the practitioner working with Mrs. Brown on the specific end-goal being achieved during the reach and grasp activity. For this intervention, the end-goal is to reach toward the sprinkles and pinch some of the sprinkles to transfer onto the cupcake. Is it recommended to observe how the clients grip may affect the clients ability to reach during a functional activity. These observations may have further implications on future treatment sessions. For Intervention C, a compensatory approach was taken to allow the client to reach her grooming goals. According to Christiansen & Matuska (2004), the compensatory model emphasizes achieving independence in occupations; clients with persistent activity limitations should be educated on compensatory techniques for performing occupations meaningful to the client. The therapist should incorporate use of the involved extremity. Having the client stabilize the involved arm using the non-involved arm to complete activities promotes use of involved extremity and may be used for activities of daily living and occupations that are important to the client. Usually compensatory techniques should be used with clients who have poor prognosis for return of function and involve techniques that work around the affected extremity. The technique used in the intervention involves using the affected extremity but compensating for the lack of the clients ability to flex the shoulder. This is achieved by stabilizing the involved arm OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 14
with the non-involved arm. This is not a traditional compensatory approach because the involved limb is still being utilized in the task, although the task still requires compensation from the non- involved limb to increase ROM. For Intervention D, an establish approach was taken to complete bathing activities in the shower. Emphasis will be placed on a motor-control theory. According to Christiansen & Matuska (2004), treatments guided by motor-control focus on the practice of functional tasks as a way to organize motor behavior (Christiansen & Matuska, 2004). Using the motor-control theory, the practitioner will modify the demands of the bathing activity, such as having the client in a seated position to maximize the clients motor performance. When using the motor-control theory to guide treatment, it is important to practice the activity in a natural context. For the client, addressing all components of bathing that are giving the client difficulties is most effective. For example, the client is having trouble washing the perineal area and both legs. Working with the client on all components of washing the legs is more effective than working on one task required for washing the legs including applying soap to the loofa, scrubbing the legs from top to bottom, and washing off the soap using the hand-held showerhead. The Post-stroke Rehabilitation Guideline Panel (1995) recommends that clients who have functional deficits and some voluntary movements of the involved arm be encouraged to use the limb in functional tasks. The motor-control theory will allow Mrs. Brown to establish motor-control, sensorimotor relationships, and improve functional performance (Christiansen & Matuska, 2004). Intervention Outcomes The outcomes of the intervention that the client and practitioner aim to achieve are increased improvement in occupational performance and quality of life. Improvement in the OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 15
clients occupational performance addresses the clients current occupational performance to find a way to promote engagement in occupations through different techniques e.g. compensatory strategies and adaptive equipment. Achieving these outcomes will allow the client to complete her bathing activities without assistance from her husband, enable the client to complete grooming activities on her schedule, and engage in her chosen leisure activities. An additional intervention outcome that treatment aims to achieve is an improvement in quality of life for the client. It was important for the client that she is able to not rely on her husband to get ready for the day or bathe herself when she is in the mood to shower. She also felt it was important to be able to spend her free time cake decorating and crocheting at home when her husband is at work. By addressing the clients goals for increased health and functioning through self-care capabilities, the client will become more satisfied with her daily routine and increase her quality of life and feelings of self-efficacy. Precautions and Contraindications Some precautions that must be taken into consideration when treating the client are secondary diagnoses such has her RA, shoulder pain, and fall risks. Careful review of the clients chart should be done before choosing appropriate treatment activities because the client has comorbidities. Mrs. Brown has difficulty with movement of the involved shoulder; it is advised to mobilize the shoulder joint before ranging the movement of the clients involved shoulder. An additional precaution that should be considered is the clients fall risk. The client has difficulty with balance when standing due to right side weakness and has a history of falls in the shower. Before starting shower activities, scanning the environment for safety risks is advised and education on safe shower transfers and mobility should be given to the client. OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 16
Frequency and Duration of Treatment The client will attend outpatient treatment for 60 minutes twice a week for 3 months. Grading Treatments During treatment, it is beneficial to the client to grade the activity up and down for a just right challenge. To grade up Intervention A, the practitioner may have the client set up the tools and materials needed to make the box cake set. This may include retrieving eggs, measuring cups, and measure out the oil for the batter. The practitioner may also have the client stand to complete the activity to work on endurance while standing at the kitchen. To grade down the activity, the practitioner can have the client verbalize the items needed for the activity and the practitioner can set up the tools and materials. The practitioner may have the client use an electric mixer to mix the batter instead of manually mixing the batter for the cupcakes. Grading the activity will allow the client to complete the activity at an optimal performance level that meets the clients skills. Primary Framework The primary framework that will be the foundation of intervention planning will be the MOHO model, which includes the clients volition, habituation, and performance capacity. The client is experiencing difficulties in her occupational performance, and the MOHO model focuses on the clients motivations, routines, habits, and the influence of the environment on the clients occupational performance. Mrs. Browns motivations, daily routines, and environment influence her performance. Her motivation to be more independent in self-care and current OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 17
performance capacity affect her ability to achieve increased independence. Her desire to attend church meetings and use of her home modifications to complete bathing activities can improve her overall occupational performance. These factors are taken into consideration when creating a treatment plan for the client to provide a client-centered and holistic treatment. To make goals realistic, client-centered, and achievable, these factors must be considered to meet the needs to the client and keep the client motivated to return to treatment and achieve her treatment goals. Client & Caregiver Education Providing education to the client and her husband is a vital part of treatment. The clients performance can be improved with adaptive equipment and DME. Education on the equipment and its use can affect the clients engagement in these occupations. Providing education to the clients husband will enable her husband to be more involved in treatment and provide assistance to Mrs. Brown at home if the client requires help with the adaptive equipment and its use. For the client to transition from reliance on her husband to modified independence in her self-care activities with adaptive equipment help from the husband will be needed. Education on safe transfers during bathing is vital. If the client wants to be more independent in bathing, she will be bathing without supervision and will need to be as safe as possible. Recommendations for grab bars and a shower chair should be given to the client and her husband. Response to Intervention To measure the clients progress in all treatment goals, formal assessments and questionnaires are utilized. The clients progress towards ADL goals will be measured by the ADL profile assessment to measure the clients bathing and self-care skills. Using the personal care section of the ADL profile will allow the practitioner to observe the clients skills in bathing OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 18
and grooming. The ADL profile can be completed in the home setting or in a rehab setting. To measure the clients satisfaction in her leisure activities such as baking, the COPM or Stroke Specific Quality of life scale can be utilized. The COPM and Stroke specific quality of life scale can be used as an outcome measure to assess the patients quality of life for leisure and social roles. These assessments may be given at the beginning of treatment to create a baseline for treatment goals, and then given again for re-evaluations or discharge.
OCCUPATIONAL PROFILE & INTERVENTION PLAN 19
References AOTA. (2014). Occupational therapy practice framework: Domain and process (3rd ed.). American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 68(Suppl. 1), S1-S48. http://dx .doi .org/10 .5014/ajot .2014 .682006 Christiansen, Charles, and Kathleen M. Matuska. "Adaptive Strategies Following Stroke." Ways of living: adaptive strategies for special needs. 3rd ed. Bethesda, MD: American Occupational Therapy Association, 2004. 241-257. Print. Schaefer, Sydney Y., Stacey L. DeJong, Kendra M. Cherry, and Catharine E. Lang. "Grip Type and Task Goal Modify Reach-to-Grasp Performance in Post-Stroke Hemiparesis." Human Kinetics 16 (2012): 245-264. EBSCO Host. Web. 29 May 2014.