‘SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 2009
WWWLUDDOCKONLING.COM een
Cole cleared; family fights on
CRIME/Answers,
feforms sought after
man who died in prison
is exonerated of rape
BreworraLaceauRn
NALANEHEA OUR
Cory Sessions visited the com:
ery near his Fort Worth home
saturday, celebrating with his
Wife and Kids a judges order to
lear his oldest brother's name
Tis children laid lowers at
the grave of their unele, ‘Tin
Cole, whom they never met. Cole
‘died in prison in 1989 serving a
25,year sentence for a Lubbock
rape he did not commit, refus-
Ing through the sears to ela
‘esponsibility forthe erime an
fo havo his young relatives see
him behind bars.
There would be plenty of time
when he was free, he fold his
Family.
The family hoped for two
decades Tim would find that
Areedom. They spent the ast two
years hoping another inmate's
confession would prove true,
and Friday, Cole's family eck
brated in an Austin courtroom
fas State Distriet Judge Charlie
Baird ordered Cole exonerated
‘On Saturday, Sessions knew his
family’s saga was far from over.
When that gets printed, I'm
going to make sure every sena
for and every representative
Knows what that means,” Ses-
sons sad,
Cole’ family wanted both the
symbolic gesture and firm legal
Tuling ofan exoneraton io clear
‘Tim's name, Sessions said, They
‘would seek a gubernatorial par-
‘don nest, he said,
But it vas also important to
examine the case, and 10 a
Tempt to lear fom the missteps
that landed his brother and all
other wrongly onvicted in
mates in all he sai,
“We need! to find out what
went wrong in these cases,”
Sessions sald. “The only differ
fence is Tim couldn't appear in
our.
‘lawyers and academics
around the state had seratched
their heads atthe unique hear
{ing unfolding in Austin,
DNA testing requested. by
the Lubboek County Criminal
Distrit Attorney’ Ofie ab
most a year belore proved that
Cole had not abducted a Texas
Tech sophomore from a church
parking lot and raped her in an
‘empty lot outside a town,
“Texas has a process to froe
and exonerate wrongfully
convicted inmates, ‘but state
Jaw does not describe how to. Tim Coles shown ina high schoot
photo. Coe, who ded in pson in
SEE COLE,PAGE AB 1999, was exonetated FridayAB suvowsrecmuaa.2009 Lueeock AVALANCHE OURNAL
LOCAL
COLE: Judge's exoneration qf deceased man a legal theory ‘without precedent’
FROM PAGE 1
ocognize the innocence ofthe
dead. Atorneys for the state
and national chapters of the
Innocence Project, a nonprofit
organization thet works to ex
fonerate wrongfully convicted
prisoners, sought a court of
Jnqulty hearing on Cole's case,
‘The court of inquiry —esse-
tally a grand jury by judge —
allowed the airing of Tis ease
fan legal finding. Lubboek
‘courts rejected the request in
August, Baird accepted the
fase a few months Tater and
preliminary ‘hearings oa the
‘matter began Thursday,
ST read that and. thought,
‘This guys entitled to an exon-
eration” Baird said alter the
hearing, Te idn’t matter that
he was deceased.
But Cole atlommey Jeff Black
bum dropped his pursut of
2 Tull court of inquiry Friday
fiternoon. Baird cited protec
tions in the Texas Constitution
against cruel “and unustal
Punishment and that all courts
tere open to remedy such ae
lions to declare ater two days
of hearings that Cole was exoa-
erated and bis record cleared,
Experts contacted Saturday
stressed they coald not imag
fay uigcua cfecaing Gull
‘State Dstt Judge Charis Bad aresdes during acourtheatng dan Aust Gard ordered the excreratcn
‘fT Cole wn cedin prson whlesenvrg ime forarane ne idiot commit,
Jnnocence. But they also did _ George Dix. coauthor of “You're not entitled to get
not kuow how mueh weight the Tonas Practice and Criinal a judielal finding in a matter
lng carried. Procedure, was ‘not familiar just because you're curious,”
"Sufce it to say it's a novel with the gfounds on which the Dix said
legal theory” without pres- Cole attorneys sought the case. In Tims case, atomneys Inid
fedent” said Robert Kepple, But Dix was not avare of Texas out over the two days of hear-
executive director ofthe Texas criminal law tat allowed a ings, the problem was eyeult
District & County Attorneys As: nding that couldnt x an on- ness identigeation. Michele
nin. ‘going situation, he said. Mallin, the Tech student who
vas attacked, was shown a pho-
fo lineup that included ‘hms
picture, Tim was posed differ
ently than the othe, ler mug
Shots offered in the ine,
Gary Wells, an fowa State
University professor who stud
ies evewthess'Mentieation,
festiied during the hearings
that extensive. researeh has
shown that witnesses have
trouble identifping other races,
That becomes even harder
when faced with suggestive
Iineup. A witness would have
naturally been drawn to Cole's
Dictire because it looked dir
ferent
‘Once a witness chooses
suspect, ‘even innocent cuvs
from pleased police offers
«an further cement that they've
picked the right person, Wells
festiied. When’ Cole was
Tater chosen from an in-person
lineup at the police station, the
witness was simply confirming
‘the mug shot she thought was
correet, he sid
‘The case demonstrated the
danger of even innocent people
partieipating in a lineup, he
said Hf they look similar to a
‘uspest ina bad lineup, they
fan discover that thes'te be
come the suspect, Wels said.
‘Seasiona Will return to AMM
tin later to. push legislators
for reforms authored by Sen.
Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, hop
Ing t0 prevent such problems
im the future. Fllis has fied
legislation that would form a
‘commission to investigate
beration claims. He. Work
Wh Lubbock Sem, Rober! Dun
an on legisiation to reform
Stale compensation to wrong
fully ‘convicted Texans and
Include cases diseovered afer
the death of the inmate, Bilis
has also fled a bil to improve
how epewitness identifeation
is gathered statewide, an issue
that has had the past support of
Gos. Rick Perey
Sessions will atch the
Board of Pardons and Paroles
for a recommendation on bis
brother as be works the Leg:
islature this session. And, he
said he'l Work tohelp impove
Tas to eutute what happened
to his brother won't happen
again.
“He was hopeful, Sat
hig brother’ graveside,
“This. isn done,” Sessions
said. “The momentun Is
there:
resernonrecona a8
soniacinmPlixodenrecane 22