vA8lA1lCnAL Anu WLlCP1Lu 8LSluuAL ACACPLS WlnLer Academy 2008 Culde: rof. S. Mlual AmlL Agrawal ueparLmenL of Chemlcal Lnglneerlng ll1 8ombay 1 lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras !"#$%&' lnLroducuon Lo lLM Weak lorm of roblem rocess of lLM MeLhod of WelghLed 8esldual lece Wlse Lrlal luncuons lnLerpolauon luncuons numerlcal lnLegrauon varlauonal rlnclples 8aylelgh 8lLz MeLhod 2 %&#)!*"+#%!& #! ,%&%#' '$'-'&# -'#.!* /,'-0 S1A81Lu : lor solvlng llnear problem ln solld mechanlcs Cu88Ln1 : lor solvlng non llnear, dynamlc, LranslenL problems. lecewlse appllcauon of a varlauonal and welghLed resldual meLhod uomaln dlscreuzled lnLo nlLe elemenLs ulerenual Lquauon converLed lnLo algebralc equauons uslng lnLegral approxlmauons 123456734 1889:37; ,'- 1889:37; Covernlng Lquauon ulerenual ulerenual LlemenL ulerenual llnlLe Soluuon LxacL ApproxlmaLe LlmlLauons CeomeLry, 8.C. LlemenL 1ype lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 3 <'1= ,!)- !, 1 >)!?$'- ulerenual Lquauon Weak or varlauonal Lquauon Conslder Lhe dlerenual equauon: for 0 < x < L 8oundary Condluons : Muluplylng Lhe ulerenual equauon wlLh a LesL funcuon : v 1wlce ulerenuable whlch sauses lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras lnLegrauon by arLs 4 <'1= ,!)- !, 1 >)!?$'- lnLegraung equauons Lwlce by parLs: Weak lorm ConunulLy requlremenL of soluuon weakened 8oundary condluon aL x=L lncluded ln Lhe varlauonal equauon 8oundary condluon [ x=L naLural 8oundary Condluon 8oundary condluon [ x=0 Lssenual 8oundary Condluon lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 3 @'&')1$ >)!+'AA Covernlng ulerenual equauon ls known a) Assume a Lrlal soluuon 1. ulscreuze Lhe domaln lnLo dlerenL elemenLs 2. ApproxlmaLe Lhe eld varlable over Lhe domaln (lnLerpolauon funcuons) b) Sausfy Lhe 8oundary Condluons c) Sausfy Lhe dlerenual equauon wlLh Lhe Lrlal soluuon (Lrror ls known as Lhe resldual) d) Mlnlmlze Lhe resldual over Lhe whole domaln Lo obLaln seL of algebralc equauons lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 6 "&%,!)- )!*B "&%,!)- 1C%1$ $!1* Covernlng ulerenual Lquauon: 8oundary Condluon: u(0)=0 & a) 1rlal Soluuon: u = c 1 +c 2 x+c 3 x 2 b) Sausfy 8.C.'s: c 1 =0, c 2 +2c 3 L=0 c) 8esldual: 2ALC 3 +q d) Mlnlmlze 8esldual: C 3 = -q/2AL llgure 1: unlform 8od Sub[ecLed Lo Axlal Load lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 7 .'1# +!&*"+#%!& %& 1 A!$%* Covernlng ulerenual Lquauon : WlLh C = 1 for 0 < x < L/2 & C = 0 for L/2 < x < L 8.C. : 1= 0 x = 0 1 = 0 x = L a) 1rlal Soluuon: b) 8.C. : Saused c) 8esldual: d) Mlnlmlze Lhe resldual 8(x) = 0 ?????? lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 8 -'#.!* !, <'%@.#'* )'A%*"1$ /-<)0 ! 8esldual made zero ln an average sense ! WelghLed average of resldual ls zero ! 1rlal Soluuon= _C l f l where f l 's
are known ! W [ are arblLrary non zero lnLegrable funcuons ! SelecL as many welghung funcuons Lo geL enough equauons ! LxacL soluuon sauses each and every welghL. lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 9 -'#.!* !, <'%@.#'* )'A%*"1$ !"##"$%&"' )*+,"- ulrac uelLa welghL funcuons W [ = (x-x [ ) 8(x [ )= 0 8esldual made zero aL nlLe number of polnLs CrLhogonal Collocauon ./0-"1%2' )*+,"- uomaln dlvlded lnLo subdomaln W [ = 1 ln = 0 elsewhere lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 10 -'#.!* !, <'%@.#'* )'A%*"1$ 3*%4+ .5/%6*4 )*+,"- W [ = lmplles mlnlmlzlng wlLh respecL Lo C l )*+,"- "7 )"1*'+4 W [ = 1, x,x 2 ,x 3 ... l.e. lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 11 -'#.!* !, <'%@.#'* )'A%*"1$ 8%#*692'4 )*+,"- Welghung funcuons do noL have any consLralnL (degree wlse) W [ = f [ where f [ ' s are Lhe Lrlal funcuon 8esldual made zero by maklng orLhogonal Lo Lhe Lrlal funcuons L.g. : W 1 = W 2 =
lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 12 -'#.!* !, <'%@.#'* )'A%*"1$ lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras llgure 2 : Soluuon of u.L. wlLh dlerenL M.W.8. ( Zlenklewlcz C.C., 1aylor 8.L.) ADEF:G3H2: %2IJK934 :L I;J 9JMHFD34 H2 I;J MDEF:G3H2 G3FJ NJ9: >:H2I +:44:736:2 O )JMHFD34 G3FJ NJ9: 3I 83967D439 8:H2IM @34J9PH2M O )JMHFD34 G3FJ :9I;:K:234 I: 7:G84JIJ MJI 13 @1$')=%&A -'#.!* ulSAuvAn1ACLS ! ulmculLy ln chooslng Lhe Lrlal funcuons ! Selecuon of Lrlal funcuons when geomeLry ls complex ! Plgh compuLauon ume !:; <= >?=@!>)= <A B.C;8 D=:E F>@) :;G F=) ! ulerenuablllLy of soluuon lowered uslng weak form ! need Lo sausfy Lhe essenual boundary condluons ! SysLemauc derlvauon of approxlmauon funcuons lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 14 1& 'C1->$'O Covernlng Lquauon: Where a(x)= 1+x g(x)=1+4x 8oundary Condluons: u(0)=0 u(1)=0 WelghLed 8esldual: Weak lorm: lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 13 >%'+' <%A' +!&#%&"!"A #)%1$ ,"&+#%!&A a) 1rlal Soluuon 1) ulscreuzlng Lhe domaln lnLo elemenLs ulvlde 0 Lo L ln Lo n parLs lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 0 0,2 0,4 0,6 0,8 1 0 0,1 0,2 0,3 0,4 0,3 0,6 0,7 0,8 0,9 1 W1 W2 W3 W4 W3 W6 uomaln S h a p e
l u n c u o n
CharL 1: varlauon of shape funcuons ln domaln 16 >%'+' <%A' +!&#%&"!"A #)%1$ ,"&+#%!&A 2) Approxlmauon over an elemenL uslng Llnear Lrlal funcuons lor any elemenL e , are shape funcuons Shape funcuons are conunuous, llnearly lndependenL Soluuon conunulLy aL sub domaln endpolnLs guaranLeed lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 17 >%'+' <%A' +!&#%&"!"A #)%1$ ,"&+#%!&A b) Applylng Lhe weak form aL Lhe e Lh elemenL Lquauons wlLh welghL funcuons W e and W e+1 would be non zero WrlLe Lhe equauons ln form of [k] [l} = [c} [k] known as Lhe elemenL maLrlx, symmeLrlc ln naLure c) Assembly of elemenL equauons Comblne all Lhe elemenL maLrlces llnal form [A] [l} = [b} [A] : suness maLrlx , sparse maLrlx [l} : dlsplacemenL vecLor [b} : force vecLor lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 18 >%'+' <%A' +!&#%&"!"A #)%1$ ,"&+#%!&A Soluuon obLalned uslng llnear Lrlal funcuons 1o lmprove accuracy lncrease no. of elemenLs. lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras x llgure 3: Soluuon uslng plece wlse conunuous Lrlal funcuon (8eddy !.n.) 19 >%'+' <%A' +!&#%&"!"A #)%1$ ,"&+#%!&A uerlvauves of soluuon are lmporLanL lnformauon abouL physlcal varlables of lnLeresL : heaL ux, sLress Soluuon can be lmproved uslng more no. of elemenLs or hlgher order Lrlal funcuons lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras llgure 4: uerlvauve of Lhe soluuon ( 8eddy !.n.) 20 lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras &1#")1$ +!!)*%&1#'A CoordlnaLe sysLem Lransformed from global(x) Lo local(c) Crlgln aL cenLre of elemenL -1 aL le end node and 1 aL rlghL end node ConvenlenL ln " ConsLrucung lnLerpolauon /Shape funcuon " numerlcal lnLegrauon 21 %&#')>!$1#%!& ,"&+#%!&A uepends on CeomeLry & number of nodes lndependenL of Lhe problem Pave followlng properues l. ll. lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 22 %&#')>!$1#%!& ,"&+#%!&A ! number of nodes = n = number of funcuons ! Crder of funcuon: n-1 lnLerpolauon funcuon for node l : lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 23 &"-')%+1$ %&#'@)1#%!& &JQI:2 +:IJM RD3F93ID9J LvaluaLed aL n+1 equlspaced polnLs n Lh order polynomlal evaluaLed exacLly by chooslng n+1 polnLs 1rapezoldal 8ule n = 1 Slmpsons 8ule n = 2 lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 24 &"-')%+1$ %&#'@)1#%!& @3DMMS $JKJ2F9J RD3F93ID9J LvaluaLes n Lh order polynomlal exacLly aL (n+1)/2 polnLs 8equlres lesser base polnLs as compared Lo newLon coLes for same accuracy. Where c l are Lhe rooLs of Legendre polynomlal n+1 (c)
lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 23 Mlnlmum oLenual Lnergy, LeasL Lnergy ulsslpauon 1oLal oLenual Lnergy (l) sLauonary wlLh respecL Lo any small dlsplacemenLs (sLaLe varlable [u}) u for whlch l ls sLauonary ls soluuon l.e. l=0 for every u lor muluple degree freedom sysLem glven l are dlsplacemenLs for l = 1,2,3.n lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras T1)%1#%!&1$ >)%&+%>$'A 26 A#)%&@ >)!?$'- Lnergy Lquauon( varlauon)= lorce Lqulllbrlum Lquauon (u.L.) lorce Lqulllbrlum : Lnergy ConcepL: SLraln Lnergy : oLenual Lnergy: 1oLal Lnergy: Mlnlmlze l lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 27 llgure 3: SLreLchlng of sLrlng under consLanL force T1)%1#%!&1$ >)%&+%>$'A lor xed x value of u whlch mlnlmlzes l(u) lor u Lo be soluuon l should be zero lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 28 l = 0 ls valld for every u 8oundary Condluons: L.8.C. naLural 8.C. Luler - Lagrange Lquauon lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras T1)%1#%!&1$ >)%&+%>$'A 29 T1)%1#%!&1$ >)%&+%>$'A Luler Lagrange Lquauon: Weak lorm: lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 30 T1)%1#%!&1$ >)%&+%>$'A WPLn A vA8lA1lCnAL 8lnClLL LxlS1, MW8 Anu vA8lA1lCnAL A8CACP A8L 1PL SAML 8C1P 8ClL uCWn 1C 1PL SAML WLAk lC8M Cl LCuA1lCn lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 31 )1U$'%@. )%#V -'#.!* Assume a Lrlal soluuon Sausfy Lhe Lssenual 8oundary Condluons LvaluaLe Lhe LoLal poLenual wlLh Lhe Lrlal soluuon SeL up equauons by = 0 for 2 = HI JI K L ; (varlauon ln dlsplacemenL ls due Lo change ln coemclenLs) lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 32 A"--1)U 1&* +!&+$"A%!&A lLM approxlmaLes Lhe soluuon uslng dlscreLe elemenLs and funcuons. Calerklns MeLhod on llnlLe LlemenL uses Lhe weak formulauon Lo generaLe seL of algebralc equauons. Laslly programmable uslng lnLerpolauon funcuons and numerlcal lnLegrauon . varlauonal MeLhods makes Lhe funcuonal sLauonary wlLh respecL Lo Lhe dependenL varlable . lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras 33 )',')'&+'A llnlLe LlemenL MeLhod Zlenklewlcz C.C., 1aylor 8.L., 1989 1he meLhod of welghLed 8eslduals and varlauonal rlnclples, llnlayson 8.A., 1972 lnLroducuon Lo nlLe elemenL MeLhod , 8eddy !.n. 34 lunuAMLn1ALS Cl llnl1L LLLMLn1 ML1PCu : varlauonal and WelghLed 8esldual approaches AmlL Agrawal, ll1 8ombay WlnLer Academy 2008, ll1 Madras CuLS1lCnS ??? 33