Is Coca-Cola Kosher? Rabbi Tobias Geffen
and the History of American Orthodoxy
Adam Mintz
‘The sity ofthe American Orthodox ebbinte to enhance Jew
ish ie through its involvement withthe broader American com
tunity sake fr granted today. Yet forthe immigrant Jewish
ominiy ofthe ely wentith entry, ich abbini influence
was forthe most part distant dream. The American rb whether
ducted n Europe or in the Unite Sates, rately posse the
Connections or credibly necessary t influence the outside com
‘runt One important exception was the success efor in the
‘aor and oss Rabb Tobias Gefen to convince the exeates
of Coca-Cola to make the necesaychangsin the formulation of
‘stamous beverage sot would mes the standards of Kash. The
Story of Rab Gefen and the beginnings of hs abini super
sim of Coca-Cola fe an exly mode ofthe way ia which the
Orthodox abbinae adjusted o changing cumstances in onder
to sere the Jewish community of America
oem in Koyo in 87, Tobias Gefen ws asd ina trad
‘ional Lithuanian ewish home wit is emphasis onthe sty of
Torah? Ara ten, he tied under the enowned scholar Rabi
Blak Shapiro an aterhe recived ain ordination fom76 | Adam Minte
Rabbi Zvi Hitsch Rabinowitz and Rabbi Moshe Danishevsky of
Slobodka. In 1898 Geffen married Sara Hene Rabinowite, the
daughter of a prominent Jewish businessman in Kovno. In the
wake ofthe Kishinev pogrom of 1903 and other eruptions of an
tisemitism in Eastern Europe, the Geffens decided to emigrate
{o the United States, ignoring criticism from friends and rabbis
who felt that Rabbi Getfen should have taken a local rabbinic po-
sition?
During theie fist months inthe United States, Rabbi Geffen
worked in a Lower East Side sweatshop ovned by relatives of|
his wife. A brief stint as the rabbi of a neighborhood synagogue
proved inadequate to support their family but a subsequent posi-
tion asa traveling fundraiser for Kovno's Kollel Perushim proved
fortuitous. During a fundraising trip he was making to Canton,
‘Ohio, leaders of a synagogue there were so impressed by his re
‘marks that they hired him on the spot to serve as ther spiritual
leader: Among Rabbi Geffen most notable achievernents during
his five years in Canton was the mending ofa deep rift within the
local Orthodox community, which he accomplished by serving
simultaneously asthe rabbi of two rival synagogues. In 1910, un-
able to adjust to Cantons dificult winters, Rabbi Gefen accepted
the pulpit of AdantasShearit Isral Synagogue. He would remain
therefor the next sity years
When the Getfens arrived in Atlanta, the city had a Jewish
population of about 4,000 out of a general population of 50,000,
‘A majority ofthese Jews were lke the Gelfens, of Lithuanian or
Bin. At the tutn of the century the only Orthodox synagogue in
Atlanta was Congregation Ahavath Achim, However its policy of
permitting men who worked on Shabbat tobe called tothe Torah
Provoked the departure ofits more devout members. In 902 this,
group that broke away established Sheaith Israel Synagogue.
Rabbi Geffen quickly made his presence felt. He improved
and streamlined kashrat supervision, initiated the communitys
first organized effort to raise funds for needy European Jewish far
ilies, and founded the city’s first Hebrew school A staunch Zionist,
1s COCA-COLA KOSHER? | 77
Rabi Gefen was leader ofthe Aata ranch of Mizrachi the
tlgous Zionist movement aswell a the Keren Hayesod nd
the Jesh Nationa Fund He also asst Jewish puones
‘lant federal pentetry and ministered to lewsh sede
falloned incl raltary cape
Contato the insular ing of Eas European rabbis Ge:
fen maintained fvendly relations with local Reform rabbi Da
‘od Man and even delivered the benediction tthe deistion
"Maree symagoue: Many yeas ate in fe 965 he gave the
Benedition tte prauation execs ofthe Jewish Thec-
Cal Seminary of America en two ofhis grandsons were among
the graduate’ For all the interesting and noteworthy Hems on
Rabb Geller impressive resume, twas his Coca-Cola Tena
for whichhe woud become best known?
Cocu-Coa wat founded in 85 n Colunbs, Georgi by
John Pemberton asa coca wine, Late that year, when Fulton
Counly, Georg passed Prohibition legislation, Pemberton re
sponded by developing a carbonated, nanacobalc version of
Hs coca wie Te beverage was named Coca-Cola beet the
simulus mixed inthe drink was coca lesves rom South Ameria,
the source of cosine niall each se of Coca-Cola contained
ne milgrams of caine. However, the cocaine simul was
temoredin go Asamarltingtcrigu, the sue orl of
oct Coa reputed tobe known by only afew Coca-Cola x-
scutes: the orignal ie ress it the al ofthe San Test
ankin Alia”
In his Coca-Cola Teshiva, Rabbi Geen wrote that a 935,
an inquiry was adresse to me concerning the well Known sok
rink Cvs Ca which s manufactred nthe oy f Alta
Georgi It osher for inking during the ene Yar and oo
Pastove
"The surviving correspondence rom this episode, whl
forunatly consisting ony of eters at Rabb Gefen ected
and ot the nese wre, Nonetheless nde that Rat Gefen
tad infact become invaved inthe Coa-Cola ise considerably78 | Adam Mints
tater than 935" His eae comrespondenceon the sbject
testo ns when Rabb lho Kochi, ab ofthe Orthodox
Jewish Community of Pitsburg wrote him: ing oyu
tnform me concerning he kosher stats of Coca Col. For
2tthis point many ofthe people at dining Coca Cola without
Proper abbiniccericaon an claming tat ts kosher Pese