!
"#%$'&() *+#!,-.0/12435*+#,#6/1""

7
98:1$//;=<?>>@ A
BDCFEG(HJILKNMOG-POQSRTCIVU?W9XYQ[Z\GRO]^I_`_baYWcCd9IEYMT_'G-RTe
f

IMTXWgIHWJ]-MhEG^WJR

ikj?lnmo prqkstvuxwys+z0{-|yj+qk}T~p#mo sJprp!!lv#j?pqv{-q

F"!("
--7+ +""
"""7F
7S-x7^"!47
n7'!-? y

S""(!-
7": S(0- ""
!^
67
7
 +"
"

(%
7:^7797
7- v5'7 %:  %^
c- -7+
^
7"+"9 
x"F^"
:^
g+
7!-?F-
7S-
:-
0:^
" ^7: ++
!^"y(7O

+
7"^ 1+""
7c7:
c-
"+" ^
5S-77"O 1"5""^Or-"("
S^ ^: F7:^
!
: "v
c77-5 5-5
S 7?Jr- ?
799
":^
7'^7-
"y+"7
Sy1

r-" +777^
+'-^!- 9
 :^"Jy7(-

?+"#?"
 `""y-'!
7"` 
S^k
 -:^v?+
"?%-7
7
7 7'F"
5 ^S-
""7^ 
7^-`-
0
7 :^
!7(:J!

7  
kkF"7 7^
F"- 9- -77^
7"F"
 4 ^
J-"^9
  ^F7F7
!^v-
7^7F: 7-
797^4` -
5-
Jv"  ?9r-4?
7
 ^-k7
7-

 ^4"-
n:^?"

!kx5

s+lvqn}5pqv s!"{(o"mg^j+ jkj!sj}shzcj+7pqvm (p{-qo prnTz0{-jm:lv {^z0{-q7o mJosok{

4j?o1 mFlvvx{^joz0s7m:kv{^ {?5j?qk}gok{^qT{^olv qhov{kj!sj}osJo v{+ s+lvqn}c!gkj+ j?
"7lvo{?uk{-m{ s5"+{(o"mTm:{-{j?qpq!j+lkj?v{O s+{6pqzcj?q!j? {-j+mhs?m^p{^q7oprn6{^
m:{j?""\pqk(lk}5pqvkpr5ws ^{Oo{mo prqkvz0{(o{-s+ s+s+?"j+}5ps+jmo sqvs+zJ?{^q!!psq5
z0{^q7o j+vmj+z0vprqkvj?qk}z0p#( s?+"j!pro%{(5x{^ prz0{-q7o jo ps+qg? u7v{^Jkj+{x{^{-q0lkm:{}
s+z0s{yo kj?qO7+{-j+ m^5ok{^T{-{pqkm:o lvz0{-qo"j?{+u kukpq}5p#m (s{^ prqkov{9k"mo{-7
p}v{^qk^{cs?%"jms+lv"({mSsl5o mp#}5{ov{Tms+#j?Sm5mo {^zVpq-+7

u's5}vj+'ms+lkqk}5pqv

s5"+{^o m%j+{9zlk"Opq6}v{^zcj?qn}Oj+mo v{9z0s7moy(sm:o:{{-(op+{kj?o:szbs+y(s+qn}5lk o pqv

{(5n{-pz0{-qo"m4pqhov{lkvn{-jo z0smvv{-{+u

1p+{z0sm:o
ov{-z[s+q

s5"+{^o m^ms+lvqn}5pqvh s5"+{^o mj? {lnm:lkj+rT{lkprkn{}6prokqkmyo sT+{^{-

j={-j?op+{-mo j+pr7ockjo

j?qk}\zcj?pq7o j?pqmo"j?vppro?u\vp{Okqnmhj+{6j+q

{{- o p+{
"nj+m m:p+{clvp#}vj?qk^{cm:5m:o{-zTov{-

pqk^{j+m{xs?o zcj+m mSj?qn}

}v j+Os+q

ok{

s5"+{^ovp#"0s{- m`ok{%kqkj+nj+o prolk}5{s okj?oF-j?q0x{ {-j+"k{-}Jprocjpr{^q

j?z0s+lkqos+Flk{^u

s5"+{(opromzcj?{^kqkmsSqvsTkqnm9jo9j+^j?qxs?o {^q7op#j+rk

zlk"0kprv{^okj+qcjlvrnqvqv{-}J{^"m:ps+q1u%q5s:o lvqkj?o{^+m:ln"gjS}5{m:p+qp#mlkqkmo"j?v{+

{lkpr pqvms+z0{c!pqk}s+!#"$0j?o:opro lk}5{h^s+q7o s+Fs+J+lkp}kj?qk^{0os
sz

+{-{^o v{s5"+{^o

olvzJvpqvvu
i`pqv{mmy s!"{(o"mnj+{n{-{^qlkm{-}s9}5{--j+}5{mpq{^5n{-qkm:p{?1#j? +{^m ^j+r{#j+lvqk"

+{^kp^{-mm:ln"jmov{%

 ipro j+qgj+z0pr+!ov{S~lnmmp#j?q'& s?osqkj?qn}go v{9tj?kj+qv{-m{
(*)+),uxv{+lvp#}vj+qk({m!m:o{-zcmFs+qhov{m:{ s5"+{(o"mj? {ynj+m{-}hs+qT(#j+m m:p#-j?v{-{-}5nj+"

(s+q7o sxmlk"gjm

&4sns:o

prsqkj?r

:9
<; & )=9>z0{(o 5
s!}kmo sj}?lkm:o`o v{Fov lkm:o'j+qv+{
;pu {+u'ov lkm:oJ{- o s+ pqvy
> s+%ov{
{^qvprqk{-m^uF
@ {^j?lnm:{Fs5"{(o kp+7o
)qo

{^ j+ p
 {^ {^q7o pj+

}5!qkj?z0p#^mj+{'vp+krqks+q5prqk{-j?-
{^qvprqk{^{^"mzJlkm:ozcj?{gmprz0krpr
7pqvSjmmlvz05o ps+qkmpqs+"}5{^'o s
j?vv

ov{m:{pqv{j?Tz0{(o vs5}vm(

j?qk}o"j?{+ {-j?oF-j? {os{^qkmlv {

okj?o1ov{m:{jmmlvz05o ps+qkmj? {'qvs?o
7psj?o{}}5lv pqvs+x{^"jo prsqu lk"
j?qlvqk}v{^o j?!pqv {7lvp{mO}5{(
o j?p{-}!qvs{-}5{`s+7o v{ s5"+{(o- m
}5!qkj?z0p#^mno kjo`-j?qx{+{^ ^sm:o
os%j+7lvp{+u^~{-^{^q7o?(qks+q5prqk{-j?
j?vv sj"v{-mmlk"j+mqk{^lv"j??qk{(o:
s5mkj{n{-{^q{(5vs{}%v pr
zcj? prJs+lnm:{pqT+lvp#}5{}gz0p#m:

2;m:{-{ ?s+j?qs{^ 7p{-

m:p{-m

s?qv{^lk j+qv{^osg^s+q7o s+`j?

A> B

"vpro{-(olv {-m "u %{-lv"j?7qv{(oFs+ 5m

^j?qpz0v{-z0{^q7o1j? vpro"j? qvs+q5
rpqv{j?zcj?kvpqvmkokj?o`^j+qzcj?+{
(s+q7o s{joyz0s+ {4j+-(lv"jo {
j?qk}y s+vlkm:o^-vl5o^lvq5s:o lvqkjo {^?
mo pr {7lvp {mp+qvprn-j?q7o}vs+zcj?pq
7qksr{}5+{oso j+prq1u

)qho

vp#mkj+n{-^kF{v s+xsm{

j0z0{(o vs5}gs%zcj?!pqvJok{9}5{(

+{^svz0{^q7o's?kqv{mmms+lvqn}5pqv
s5"+{^o mOz0s{


 

!#"%$'&)(+*,(.-/$)021
3 -4)5!6 7 '7S?9 -7-S^
g28
5
!g!"+T
J775 (7 7

"7-1r?+" J "!F4"
"
c
7

!^7+?7"

{^ s+ vpro j+ 5mo {^zcm~

C;

lv '
& svlv#jo ps+qkm

{(s+qks+z0p#^j+y!lkmprqk\q5s ^{-}

)qo

-7
7
7T: 

7  -" " :^
:("4-
7
7-
"^ ?

{^+s+{Tjqk{^lv"j?%qk{(oFs+ +lvp#}vj+qk({Tm!m:o{-zTu

kqv{-m m+{- mps+qs?ov{

7?r7"

?+7 -
n7+S 4^+":-75""-7^

mcj

D >


&  5 o s

o {-m:oh^jm:{+{OpFs5(lkmgs+qj

E;#klv {S!> uv{~

%ys5"+{^o

%p#m

jp#7lvp#}!lk{^{-}ms+lvqk}vprqk s!"{(o`okj?o'lnm:{mo v{}5p x

 {-{-q7op#j?+ov lkm:os+npro m`s+lk{-qv+pqv{m

F@

os(s+q7o snjooproln}5{?u F0{^+s7pqvjqv{^lk j+nqv{^os(sq7o s+{^'onjozcj?kmov{mo"jo {
s?ov{ s5"+{(oFoso v lkmo^s+z0zcj+qk}vm^o v{+lvp#}vj+qk({yv s+v{-z

^j?qTx{Sm:s+{-}gprovsl5o

ov{qv{^{}sj+qkj?7op#-j?z0s5}5{-rpqvTs+%ov{T s5"+{(o- m}5!qkj?z0p#-mSs+Jv ps+S!qvs{-}v+{

s?o v{j?kvsv pj?o{c!pqk}=s?y^s+q7o s+m:o"jo {^+

FG

o s

{lkpr {-}6p#mjml c(p{-qo j+^^lv"jo{0mpzlv#j?os+j?qk}

{^z0vs?umpqv
j

7lkj?q7o

& 4j?Fonjo0p#m

po"jo pr{9z0{j+mlv{Js?Fok{

+lvp#}vj+qk({m:5m:o{-zT mFx{^s+ zcj?qk^{?5pu {+u5jJkoqv{mmFlvqn opsqu

)qgo

v{qv{(!ook{-{m{-(ops+qnmF{}5{-m ( pn{ok{4q5s+"({}

lv '
& s+klv#jopsqkmz0{(o vs5}

lkm:{}o s{-+s+{0ov{Tlvp#}vj?qk^{gm!m:o{-zT`o v{O(sqo sr{-{^s+l5opsqm:pzJlv#jopsqkm(1j+qk}

{(5n{-pz0{-qo"j?x{m:lko"mFs+qT(s+q7o srpqvo v{S~

J s5"+{(o-u

ESP

Environment

fitness

R
S
X
2

action
observation

Neural Network


  k
 !^x
 "!#?$ &%' (*),+' !"-  x/.(

^
-
"-
7"- ^"

?h757^
7 

0 -?^^ Tc:-
!+g"" 
7c-
7S
7"+


 

'5-

+v"
"^"

^O757^-
nx

"-
T^""77^ 7
""^?g-7+
7
"-' -:
 -c
h7:

21

7^"!( k'7'"^`"

7^S- " ^
!75"`
7"+
`7
S -:75
(-
^S^ F^
7
"-
7"-`"-+
F
7 

y"7^:(775-7(
7"

21

5""^ ""c
7 -
7
7  S^F-?J
7 '^+4(""-F ""


4T
5"x687F
9
:S;:y
<>=5,?A@B4C7DFE

q5s ^{-}

HG D
qv{^lv s!{^s+l5opsqz0{(oks!}o kjoc{^7o {^qk}km0ok{
B%{-lv s7{-+srlvops+qj?+spro vz ; EB%JI>"u & j?qk} EB

lvvxs+vlkj?ops+qnm !?p#m0j

!zvps+op#
 }vj?5o p+{

}5p x
 {-szDs?o v{^

LK  M NOKQP

z0{(oks!}kmprq6okj?oov{-6{-+s+{9kj+:o pj+m:srlvops+qkms+

prqnmo {-j+}cs?^s+z0v{^o{%qv{^os5m^!j+qk}gjJmlvkm{(os?1o v{-m{qv{^lv s+qnmj+{yvl5oos+{^ov{-4o s
s+ zj%^s+z0v{^o{'qv{(oFs+ xu 
) q
osTs+ z

B%-qv{-lvsqkmj+{m{^{ o{}szj%mpqv+{'xs+vlv#j?ops+q

qk{(oFs+ !m^u 

) q(sqo jmo-

&

zcj++{mlnm:{0s+F{^!krp#^pomlv5o jm:5m^`jTm:{-kj?"jo {

SRTlvqvpro m%prqhok{Sqv{(oFs+ xkj?qk}Tjqv{-lv s+q

m:lvknsvlv#jo prsqgp#mj?s5^j?o{-}cs+{j+"Ts?ov{

^j?qgs+qvn{y {-(szkprqk{-}Jprocz0{-zx{^"ms+1po"m4sqhm:lvknsvlv#jo prsq

;#klv {y> uvvp#m

Fjo v{qv{^lv s+qnmprqh{-j"hmlvvxs+vlv#j?ops+qg-j?q{^s++{prqn}5{^x{^qk}v{^q7ocj?qn}gmn{(p#j?p|^{

j+vp#}5Jpq7osJ+s!s5}hqv{(oFs+ cm:lk5lkqk o prsqkm^u
+sl5ops+q0pqT
?u

UT

& v s5({-{-}vmj+mFsrs%m

)qvprop#j?p|-j?ops+q1uv{q!lvzJn{-9s?%kp}k}5{^qlkqvpro

"Rpq
m

ok{hqv{^os5mo kjop4x{

s+ z0{-}Tp#m%mn{(prk{}j?qk}Ojhm:lkvnsvlv#jo ps+qs?qv{-lvsq6"v s+z0s7m:sz0{-mpm( {-j?o{-}u

4j""v s+z0s7m:sz0{g{-qk(s5}5{mov{6prqkvl5ogj?qn}sl5okl5oh(sqvqv{ opsqF{^p+7o"ms?j
qv{^lksqhproTjJ j+qk}5szmo pqvJs?' {-j?q!lvzJn{- m^u
!u%j?lkj?ops+q1u

VRqv{-lvsqkm%p#mym:{-{- o {-}T"j?qk}vs+z0?ksqv{9qk{^lv s+qO s+z

m{(oys?

m:lkvnsvlv#jo ps+qossz

{j+"

ov{%kp}k}5{^qJ#j+{^s?j(sz0v{(o {qv{^osxu?v{qv{^os

'7%`6-r(7-:^4 ^^7^$X

YOZ[Z\]_^[^U`[``ba'c[dafeOZOghji[dakglej^UemdBgnmdB^Uo[om^U\iUpOgd^OdqrZ`inOgO^iUs/dUZ[njijcZdaYjZt/uvOgjd\wjc$\[\

 N !

p#mm:lvkz0poo{}Oosj

pqkp"

propmy{-j+lkjo {-}s+qov{o"j+m6j?qk}

voqk{-m mJm (s{+u'k{m (s{hpmJj+}k}5{-}

o s6o v{

MSM

 !#"$ 

jj?"}5{-}6j

K  PHPs+{-j"=qv{-lv s+q

okj?oFnj?op#(pkj?o{-}pq0o v{yqv{(oFs+ xu!vp#mv s!^{-m m4p#m{-n{jo {-}0lvq7o prx{-j"gqv{-lv s+q
kj+mnj?op#(pkj?o{-}cprqTj?qTj+{- j++{s?'{?u vu1-o p#j?#m^u

u%~{-^s+zJvpqkjo ps+qu1v{gj{^"j?{9vo qv{-m mSs+{-j+"

qv{-lv s+qp#mS^j+#(lv#jo {-}67

pqvTpo"m(lvzJlv#jo p+{vo qv{-m m!o v{0q!lvzJn{-ys+o p#j+mpqkp"

}5p!p#}!

prokj?op#(pkj?o{}u

B%{-lvsqkmj+{Fok{^q0"j?qv{-}7Jj+{- j++{voqv{mmpo vpq{j+"0mlvvxs+vlv#j?ops+qu?j+"
7lkj+:o

qv{^lksq0prqJo v{%o s+

pr{Fp#m{(szvpqv{}9pro cjvp+v{-:"j?qv!pqvqk{^lv s+qlkmpqv

(nspqo'( sm m:s{^j+qk}SzJl5o"jopsqSjo'rs{-+{^#mo sy^{jo {4o v{smv pqv%o s {^v#j({
ov{sF{-m:o: j+qv!pqvkj?rs?o v{Smlvvxs+vlv#j?ops+qu

vu%v{j?lkj?ops+q5~{-^s+zJvpqkjo psqg(5^r{p#m {^x{-j?o{-}6lvq7op'jgqv{^oso kjon{-:

FG

s+ zcmm:l c^pr{-q7o0{-xpqhov{o"j+mcp#ms+lvqk}u

G

+s7pqvqv{(oFs+ 5mjo1o v{qv{-lv s+q{^{^kjmv s+{^qyo s%n{j+{-%{ c(p{^q7o1z0{(o vs5}

s+m:sr!pqvT {^pq5s+"({-z0{^q7oS{-j+qvpqvo"j+m!mJmlk"=j+mxs+{(kj?#j+qk(pqv

G

JI

(s+q7o s ?
 j?qk}T7j?z0{v#j!prqkh ux

& pmz0s{{ 0^p{^q7ookj?o

?' s+xs?oJj+z

Bx{--j?lkm{ok{

UT

m:lvknsvlv#jo prsqj+ "kpo {-(olv {zcj++{mFov{{^j?lkj?ops+qkmFz0s{(sqkmpm:o{-q7opqoFs0Fj5m
k m:o^ov{gmlvvxs+klv#jopsqkmyokj?o9+"j+}vlkj?s+ z
}5{-mp+q6pq

pq

EB


j? {0j?{j+}5Ok{m:{-qoS!

& u1v{cmx{-(p{my}vsqks?oSkj{9o ss7j?qvp|-{Sok{^zcm{^+{msl5os?jmpqv+{

j+{xs+klv#jopsqvj?qk}hok{^pv s++ {-m mpr{mn{(p#j?p|-j?ops+qp#mqvs?o%kprqn}5{^ {-}h!g {-(sz
vpqkjo prsq6j+^s7mmymn{(p#j?p|-j?ops+qkmFo kjoSlnm:lkj+rlvrk' {^#jo pr{^gs:o vs+s+qkj+` s+{mpq
ov{Jqv{(oFs+ xu {-(sqk}x{-^j+lkm{Sok{Jqk{(oFs+ !m%s+ z0{-}T!
{-v{m:{-q7o jo p+{Jsz
s+qvs

&

j?j5m%(sqkm:p#m:os+4j

{j+"{-+s+!pqvTm:x{-^pj+pr|jo prsqjOqv{^lksqpmj?j!my{-j+lkjo {-}

F{^pron{-:szcmFpro mF s+{pqhov{S^s+q7o{^!os+'j+no v{s?o v{^kj{^"m(u

G

& zcj?{-mpro9z0s{0{ 0^p{^q7ookj+q

v{gj+-({-r{- j?o{}mn{(p#j?p|-j?ops+q6prq

vl5opo0j?#ms^j+lkm:{m}vpr{^"m:pro6}v{-(pqv{cs{^9ov{T(slv m{gs+%{^s+l5opsq

qvs+ zcj?!w

u+vp#m^j?qn{jvsv{^z

B

x{-^j+lkm{jy(s+q!{^ +{-}xs+klv#jopsqS^j?qkqvs?o'{-jm:p

j+}vj+5o'osjyqv{^=o j+mxu+s}5{j?5proJv {^zcj?olv {^s+q!+{-{^qk^{?

p+{cokj?oJs+j

M NHP
"M*  !OKku`v{cp#}5{jTpmyo s6m{-j?""

& p#m(s+zJvpqv{}po

s+Ss5opzcj+z0s5}5prn-jo prsqkmys?ok{g(lv {^q7o

n{mohms+l5o ps+qu\v{-qn{-:szcj+qk({Tkjmgm:o j++qkj?o{-}sgjv {-}5{^o{-z0pqv{}q!lvzJn{-

s?{^qv{- j?ops+qnm(qv{^

m:lkvnsvlv#jo ps+qkmyj? {0( {-jo {-}67j+}v}5pqvqvspm{osT{-j"6s?Fok{

qv{^lv s+qnm0pqo v{x{-m:ohms+l5opsqu4j+"qv{-

mlvvxs+klv#jopsq(sq7o j?pqkmqk{^lv s+qkm0okj?o

{-v{m:{-q7o9}5p x
 {-{-qk({myszDok{cn{moJm:srlvops+qu4+srlvops+qOo v{^q {-mlvz0{m(1vlvoqvs

@

m:{j?""vpqvFov{Fm:kj({pqSj% qv{^p+!xs+ vs!s5}j? s+lvqk}o v{4x{-m:o`v {^!ps+lnmm:srlvops+qu Flv"m:o

zl5o"jo prsq9^j+qx{j?vkrp{}zlko pv{opz0{-m^po mlk^^{-m m:p{4pq!+s5^j?ops+qkm{-v {-m{^q7opqv
}5p x
 {-{-qk({moso v{%v {^!ps+lkm'x{-m:oms+l5o prsqu 
 m m:lkz0prqko v{%x{-m:oms+l5opsqj? {-j}5Skjm
m:sz0{J^s+z0x{(o{-qk({pqo v{o jm:x1z0s7mos?pro my{-p+7o mypqks?oqv{^{}osTn{c"nj?qv{-}
j}5p#^j??u(`s{-qkm:lk{4okj?oz0s7mo`"nj?qv{-mj+{Fm:zcj+?vp{4j?spqv4s`#j+{^1"kj+qv+{m
oscms+z0{y{-pr7o m^!

T

& lkm:{mFov{Fj+lk"!g}5p#m:o prkl5ops+qo s0+{-qv{^"jo {qvsp#m:{

;  >
\po

o vp#m}5p#m:o pvl5opsq

+

D+

po vpqco v{pqo {^ j?



 ;
  

;>
>

s+%ov{j?lv{m9pj+rFprovpqo v{Tpqo {^ j?



uvvp#m4o {-"vqkp 7
 lv{s+

lv#jopsqkmS{^{^nmJ}vpr{^"m:proprq=ov{Txs+vlkj?ops+qm:s6okj?o0

j+qk}

{"kj? +pqv yov{Smlvvxs+5

& ^j?q(sqo pq7lk{cos zcj++{

vs+ {-m mo sFj+ }hjm:srlvops+qh{^+{-qhpqv s+s+qv{-}0{-+srlvops+qu

@lk m:o4zJl5o j?ops+qJp#m4mprz0p#j?`osSov{ 9{-o"j s5}5pqvyo{-"kqvp#lk{%s?4 xvp#"0Fjm}5{(
+{^sn{}o spz0v s+{`ov{v {-(p#mps+qys?v+{-qv{(o p#j?+sprokzcmvsq!lvz0{^ p#^j+s+5o prz0p|jopsq

@

vsv{^zcm^u F{--j?lkm{slv+s7j?xpmo szcj+prq7o"j?pq0}5p+{^"mpo+F{y}vsqvs+oF {-}vlk({ov{"j?qv{

s?o v{Tqvs+p#m{gsqmlk^^{-m m:p+{hj?vvp#^j?ops+qnms?yvlv"mozlvo jo ps+q=j+qk}F{Tlkm:{

Fj?ln"7

j?ov{-okj?olkqvprs+ z0r0}5p#m:o pvl5o{}cqvsp#m:{+u

Drag

roll
yaw

CP

pitch

CG

CG

CP

Lift

Side force

Thrust

(b) Finless: unstable

(a) Fins: stable



  n ? x



'F: `:-5 -7!

7  ^%+:^

F (^7^?
7%7F""
 -"+''5"
7S""
 ^-: ?

6-
7(y^S( -"^"

%:54"7 5^
JS^-
7-"

 v5
J"
:-



!
7"1: #v7
:-5""-77':"+`"5- ^v7 ?x "

h

^
!

  -
!# F""S74'r-

7y
+^ F-77^
7"
" "

y"
?:- 7":^7
-:7F?" 9??:-


6 <>6b??V6: ='y6"=;? 

)qOv{-!prslkmFsxk

& Fjmm:ksqho s0s+l5o n{-:sz

"!{-j?

r{j? qvpqvj?+spro vzcmJprqn(lk}5pqv

qvpqvk


 ~

jp#}5{ j+qv+{s+ {^pq5s ^{^z0{^q7o

;$# >"4+srlvops+qkj+



n{-qk}5lvlvz

o"j+m

u1v{Js5"+{^olvp#}vj?qk^{9}5szcj?pqOp#mmprz0p#j?Fo shxs+{(kj+j+qk(pqvpq

okj?o`xs?o9prq!s++{m:o j?kprp|^pqvFj?qSpqvk{^ {^q7o%lvqnmo"j?v{4m5mo {^zTuip+lk{

s+{^ !p{^

&4s+"j?z

EBsqm{^{^"j?'}5p G0^lvroy{^"m:psqkms?ov{xs+{(kj+j+qk(pqvsypq!+{-:o {-}



z0prqkvj?qk}

p+{-mj%kjm:p#

s?n s5"+{^o}5!qkj+z0p-m(uv{z0s?o prsqs?j s5"+{(op#m`}5{^kqv{}9!ok{o j+qkmj?ops+q

/; w > nj?qk}gok{y s?o"jo prsqcs?ok{yxs5}5gj+nsl5oov{w prqhok{

BT; F
> ov{Sov lkm:o
s?ok{9{^qk+pqv{-mvp#"Ov s+x{^`ov{s5"+{^o^; 
> ov{J}5"j?cs+ov{jo z0smvv{^ {{(5{^o{}
joov{ UK *N &% N$PHP$M N  ;  &
> prqslv+krhok{Jsvxsmpo {J}vpr {-(ops+qTo sov{Joklkm:o^
;
>4o v{
% %jN +{-qv{^"jo {-}0!0o v{ykqkmj?s+qkSok{y7j\j5p#m(5j?qn} ; > ov{SP (')%ON 
s?`pro"mF^{^q7o{-s?+"j7pro

vpro "k7jkj?qk}T s+j5{m(uniks+lv%s+"({-mj+ o%lknsqjs5"+{^oprqkpo

+{^qk{^"jo{}7gov{Skqkmj+s+qvov{9vpro "Oj5p#m(ukk{9j?qv{yx{(oF{^{-qov{9}vpr {-(ops+qhok{

k!pqvTj?qk}ok{Jsqv+proln}5pqkj?j5p#ms+4o v{0s5"{(oprq6ov{07j s+`v#j?qv{Jp#m

O K 
 * %    , +s  +ov{(s {-mxs+qk}5pqvj?qvr{FpqSo v{vpro "5 s++v#j+qv{
pm7qksqcj+mo v{ P ('$
 P
 j
 K 
4
 s+ -u\
 v{-qc{^pro v{^
s.-p#m{jo{-onj?qcS}5{-+ {^{m

ov{9}v j+J{^5{^o mjJos7
 lv{sqov{ s5"+{(oo kjo-j?qO^j+lkm{o v{S s5"+{(oo solvzJv{p'pro
pmyqvs+oSmo"j?v{?u1v{0j+z
o vslv+ vp#"o vp#mos+7
 lv{j+ o"mp#mo v{0}5p#mo"j?qk^{x{(oF{^{-q
ov{
& j?qn}go v{wu
s5"+{^oyp#m

7qksqJjmo v{

1200

mach 1

CP: ft. ahead of CG

Drag: pounds

1000
800
600

mach 2

mach 1

mach 3

mach 4

mach 2

mach 3

10

400

12

200
0

14

10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000

Altitude: ft.

10000 20000 30000 40000 50000 60000 70000 80000 90000

Altitude: ft.

(b)

(a)




+7
  
 [ * /$ *  
xx"! 1




mach 4

x

1^c(

^
?^x?:-r-"- 
-
7!
": -`'^""
!+`+7-y74(7 

J^y?:-S ^
7!(F4:-"4-+v"
^n+74"
n7: v1-#5

 75
^y""
 F-"+y
gF-7 S^
?J" -7"c%^
F"
?-x-: ? -
-5-4-?

  ^F"-
?-!:-5" "'^+"7

+7FF:-J
7  ^
J+:-S^
!(""
^7 \""9r
7^

F: 74^7+(+S^ -?

  ^ k+:-5 -?4-
75"-
74 "
%-7-4 


7
7 !^
!9':(Fy"+9-:(
 (:7 !-""
7+7

9: 5"" y--" 6 ^ h 
^y7J"
O-47^-7 
+"  ^""

)qk+lv
\k{^q

jv+o v{kqvqk{-}0 s5"+{(op#mm:o j+v{n{^j?lnm:{o v{

; - >Sp#mqvs+q5|^{-sk`jOo s+7lv{gp#mS{^qv{- j?o{}

&p#mx{^kprqn}Jov{%

s5"+{^o^m

4;m:p#}5{>ys+"({hs?

ov{hkqkm9okj?o^s+lvq7o {^"j+ o"mok{}5"j?os+7lv{?'j?qk}o{-qk}vm9os6z0pqvpz0p|^{
; - > uvp#m

wu

m:prolnjopsqS(s+ {-mnsqk}vmo sjn{-qk}5lvlvznj?qvprqk%}5sqS s+z

pr' {(olkqosTo vp#mym:o j+v{{7lvpprkplvz

}5s!{-mhqvs?okj+{Onqkm(j+mhpqk+lk{
s5"+{^oo sTn{lvqkm:o j+v{?u

qvs+qv|-{^ s

o v{hpr#o

pro m`vpqv+{+-o v{Fn{-qk}5lvlvz

nspqoprproSp#m}5p#mo lvx{-}u \
 v{^q

Fov{

s

&

-po

{^qk}osTs

ok{0s5"+{^o

wV-j?lkmpqvok{

p#mgj+v{-j}s?o v{

-j?lkmpqvco v{s5"+{^o

os0{^{^q7olnj?olvzJv{?uvvp#m%mprolkj?ops+q(s+ {-mnsqk}vmoscjx{^qk}vlvlvzbj?opro mlvqkm:o j+v{
lvv pr7oy{lkprpv plvzbxs+pq7ov{^ {0j?q!6}5p#m:olv kj+qk({p'-j?lkm{proyo s}5p+{-{jj
sz

ovp#mm:o j?o{?u

%rovslv+hok{s5"+{^o%}5s+zcj+prqgpmmpz0pj+oso

+lvp#}vj+qk({vsv{^z

v{Spq!+{-:o {-}cx{^qn}5lvlvzT5ok{s5"+{^o

T

p#mm:p+qkpx^j?q7o rz0s+ {}5p c(lkos+FoFs {-jm:sqkm 7ok{ypq7o{- j o prsqkm

n{^o{-{^qhov{ s5"+{(oj?qn}co v{joz0s7m:kv{^ {j+{yvp+vqvsq5pqv{j?j+qk}(s+z0kr{^!j+qk}

ov{s5"+{^o^mx{^kj!ps+^s+q7opq!lvs+lnm:9"kj+qv+{m'okslv+vsl5ook{(slv"m:{%s+1j
osgm5mo {^z

kp+7o}5lk{

j+p#j+v{-m4okj?oj? {{^prok{^%qvs+olvqk}v{^^s+q7o s+s+%qvs+o}5p {- o 0s+km{^ j?v{

;{?u vuxj?pF}v{^qkmpro?5lv{-1sj+}5}v j+v5{(o"u >"u

i`plv{0m:vs%mSvs
ov{}5p 0
G ^lvro6s+mo"j?vpp|-jo ps+qj? p{-ms{^o v{h^s+lv"m{0s?

jm:ln^({mm:lv
j?roproln}5{?u`iksz

npr7o0s+0o

v{kqkr{mm s5"+{^o^u

)qklv

{Oj5F}5 j+p#m0vs?oo{-}j+j?pqkm:o

#o9o s6j?xs+lvo+5 +?#o^1o v{g s5"+{(oJj?vv sj"v{-myo v{hms+lkqk}kj+ p{^

;j"!>j+qk}O}5"j?0 pm{-mm:kj+kr+ukvp#m}5"j?0pqk^{j+m{-mok{Sos7lv{9{(5{^o{}Ts+qTok{

j+qk}-45zcj?!pqvpro4z0s+ {%}5p c
G (lvroo s


s5"+{^opqov{yjj?qk}cvpro "0j5{-ms+FjS+p{^q

(s+q7o svpro mj?o:opro lk}5{?u)qk+lv {+1F{%m:{-{okj?oj?#ms}5lv prqko vp#mx{^ prs5}ok{}5p#mo"j?qk^{

 w j+qk}  &pqk^{j+m{-m%x{--j?lkm{ov{0(sqkmlvz05opsqs?lv{^-j?lkm{-mok{

wosJz0s+{%nj+"x7zcj+!prqkov{y s!"{(oFprqn( {-j+mpqv+lvqnmo"j?v{?u #o {^!++?#o^!}5 j+

mo"j?o mosT}5{-^{j+m{Jjmov{0j?pn{(s+z0{myr{mmy}5{-qkm:{+1j?qk}6ov{  &mo {-j}5prz0p+"jo {-m
kj+"0o sFj+ }kmo v{
 wnmso kjoo v{ s!"{(on{(sz0{-m{-jm:p{-4o s^s+q7o s+u
n{^o{-{^qov{

ivs+

& ovp#mz0{-j+qkm`okj?o

ov{koqv{mmlkqk o prsqj?l5o s+zcjo

p-j?hm ^j+r{mo v{0}5p 0^lvroTs?

ov{To"j+m=pq {-mxs+qkm{os

ok{

n{-:szcj+qk({Ts?o v{xs+vlv#j?

ops+quFoov{x{^pqvqvpqvFs?5{^s?
rlvops+qov{To"j+m=p#m {^#jo pr{^
{-j+m?u
 mok{0nsvlv#jo prsqpz
vs{-mj?qn}prqn}5p7p#}5lnj?#mkj+{j?kr{
os%(sq7o s+ok{s5"{(oosvpv{^
j?roproln}5{-m^ov{o j+m=x{-^s+z0{m
vs+ {-m m:p{^4kj+ }v{^-u%roks+lv
k+lv {%Spqk}vp-jo {-monjoFj+ns{
+!+#oco v{o"j+mj?j+pqx{(
(s+z0{m{-jm:p{^- v s++ {-m mxpqy{-+s+

rlvops+q=^s+q7opq!lv{mSo s

x{O}5p 

(lvron{^j+lkm:{ok{%(s+q7o sr{-1p#m

(s+qnmo"j?q7o{^q7o{-pqvJj?qhlvq5j
z0prp#j?nkj?o1s?7ok{4mo"jo {m:kj({+u

voqk{-m

m'lvqk(ops+qJonjo4 j}!



' - $0 1 3 - )5!6 < $
* "F!

21

`7 1^

'7

?!^ (
^77?'+:

lkj?pqk^{j+m{-mpqS}5p c(lvroyp#m

y(
 "'7?4-77^
7""-


lkm:lnj?

}v{-mpr"j?kr{gn{^j?lnm:{Tpro

 "?'y7(-(?"F ^4"
?+-


j?s%ms+ml c(p{^q7o%m{^{-(op+{

"
1^ -
7
7^
! 
^ :^++
!^"

v{mmlv {Sjo%o v{Sx{^prqkqvpqvs?

-
7-77^
7"+""

FG

{^+sl5ops+qos%}5p {-(oxo v{4m{-j+ "

prq7o sTjhjs+"j?v{9 {^ps+qs+o v{gms+l5opsq6m:nj+({+u %
( sF{^{^-xo v{0 s!"{(oS(sq7o s+'o jm:

pmFj? {-j}59o s!skj+ }cprqgov{yx{^+pqvqkprqk
\j?vz0{^zJx{^"ms?ov{pqvprop#j?knsvlv#jo prsq0n{-:

s+ z

m:sns!s+ 

j6s5^j+4zcj?!pzcjvu 
) q

okj?oo v{T{^+sl5ops+qm:o j+r#mj?qk}(s+q!{^ +{-mSos

s?ok{^Fs+"}vm(v}5p {-(o{-+srlvops+qg}vs7{mqvs?o%{-+{-qh{(o%mo"j?o{}hsqgo vp#m+{-c"kj+r{-qv+pqv

o j+mxu qv{FjTo ss{^"(sz0{ovp#myv s+v{^zYp#mosTzcj++{So v{pqvprop#j?o j+m{j+mpr{-j+qk}

ov{-qpqk^{j+m{ov{}5p c(lvroj+mok{Fx{^s+ zcj?qn({s+vov{xs+vlkj?ops+qpz0v s+{m(u)qok{

K  N   K

{(5n{-pz0{-qo"mn{-sF{c{^z0vs6mlk"j?q

 " 
M !OKj+vv

sj" u)q5

mo {-j+}s+o !prqkos9{-+sr{jS(sqo sr{-s+o v{%nqv{-m ms5"{(o}5p {-(o?+jz0s{%m:o j+v{
+{^"mprsq0s?1o v{s5"{(op#mlkm{-}hprqkpo p#j?osJzcj?+{ov{lvro przcj?o{o"j+mz0s+ {j+-({mmpv{?u
v{srspqvm:{ o prsq}5{-m ( pn{mok{mprzJlv#jo ps+q{-q!7p s+qvz0{-q7olnm:{}os{^+s+{'ok{
(s+q7o sr{-^?o v{}5{(o"j?p#m4s+`vsj9lvp#}vj?qk^{y^s+q7o s+{^4prq7o {^"j+ o"m4pro cok{mpzlkj?os^
j?qk}9ov{{^!x{^ pz0{^q7o j+7m{(o lvs+{^s+!pqvjqv{^lv"j?5qk{(oFs+ ^s+q7o s+{^s+okpmo"j+mxu

 61F!k<S4 : 61k




61F ?

  -/$)0 3 -4)5!6  $)
* "# 

mOj?q{^s+l5o

prsq{^q!!psqvz0{^q7ogF{

j+}vj+5o{}s+ov{J~

 J-

lkm:{}\o v{=t

pz

/9!qkj+z0p-mhs!}v{^ 
@

i`p+7o

% s5"+{(o7T p#Swylvp"nm:{-qhs+ 
) qo {^ s+ vpro j+ 5mo {^zcm^ut

+^S^

-5-"?

YOZ[Z\]_^[^Od$smd t a_dqUeOncUgrjqBn[p[gaojgZ^

-'^

7-:^

(---

$X

F?

pzp#mj?q0sn{-qms+lk ^{?+s {-(o:s+ pr{-q7o{-}

kp+7o(s+q7o

osm:x{-^pcj

sxm5mo {^z

kp+7o}5!qkj?z0p#-mmpzlkj?osproJok{j?vppro

s?j?q!c(sz0v{(5pro?u7t

pz

vs!p#}5{m4j{j?p#mo p

m:pzJlv#jopsqs?ov{y(sz0v{(9}5!qkj+z0pFpq7o{- j opsq9x{(oF{^{^qo v{j+pr"j?z0{?v s+klv#m:ps+q

m:5m:o{^zTlv{^no j+qv5m(5jo z0smvv{-{++j?qk}

npr7o(sqo

s#m(u+v{yj?{-s5}5!qkj+z0p4s+"({m4j+qk}

z0s+z0{^q7o"msqgo v{ s!"{(oF{^ {y-j?#(lv#j?o{-}glkmprqkJj}5{^o j?p{-}g+{-s+z0{(o p#z0s!}v{^s?ok{

T

%!uivslv{^"m:ps+qnms?!ov{s5"{(o1proS}5p

 {^ {^q7okq9^s+q5n+lv"jo prsqkmx{-{4lkm:{} ^lkr
~

;mzcj?{^kqkmA>"7lkj+:o {^kqkmE;mzcj?{^`m:op>"j?qk}Jqvsykqnm(+pu {?uo v{%j+(olkj+

kqkm^+kj?rnkqkm

kqv{-m m's5"{(o^u+kpmm{(os+s5"+{^o m'j?sF{-}lkmoss+nm:{-{o v{x{^kj!ps+'s?xok{~

jo}5p x
 {-{-qo{^{^#ms?`prqnmo"j?vppro?j+qk}cv s!p#}5{-}0jJm:{7lv{^qk^{s+`pqk( {-jm:pqvS}5p 0^lvro
o j+m5mproJvp#"Jos{^s++{Fpqk( {^z0{-q7o j??u %
 kmpzlv#j?ops+qkm1lkm:{}

<D

:@j+m5s+o

}vj+zcm

?ovs }5{-prq7o {^+"jo ps+q0proTjopz0{mo {^s?5u+ Sm{-^s+qk}vm^u

 "

 # 5   " 5
!5 

opqsrftvu!wqGxuGtyxPrftzkznq6r${}|~rPqIv
rfqR|Fq6yxPq6q6q6trf8r!yqIv
pitch
rP-zy\qGx;Ut-rPw
{nxPpt-yqp{}vq6y
zkqIrs}$-rPqJX6JqIrPNvbU|fq6uX
yaw
t-y\|i{> q-Gxfp\qiuGtyxPrftzxf{k]qG:|FxfqIl
roll
xfpquGtyxPrftzkznq6r~rfqRuGqI{kq6|N-q6uGxftr
pitch
rate
t8rfqR-v{kyD|#rPt-xfpqrPtvu!w-qIxIb|
throttle
yaw rate
t-yva$tD8r!|fqIy\|ft-r!|ixfp\8x\rft{}vq
commands
{nyt-rPTxf{kty8lt-xJxfpquGrPrPqIyDx
roll rate
u
t-rP{nq6yDxPxP{kt-y{nx!u!pJ1rftzkz}X

rP8xfqt8~t-rP{kqIyDxP8xf{kt-y#u!p$8yq8-8y
u

-zkq#t-UxfxPu!wi |f{kq6|fzn{k-y-zkq
u
throttle 1
IxPpqiuG\rfrPqIyDx~xfprPt8xfxfzkqslt|f{xP{kt-y
u
t8xPpqtrUxfprP\|FxfqIr!|I-zxP{nxf\vq-
throttle 2
8y\-qIzktvuG{nx;{kyxfp\qv{krPq6uGxf{kt-y
throttle 3
t8\{k-pDxI1op{}|/{kyvx-q6uGxftr{}|
rft\8DxPq6NxfprPt-pNxPpqi|f{k-]t-{}-z throttle 4
altitude
p{}vqIy-y\t-xfvx)y{nxP|t8vxfp\q
yqGx;Ut-rPw
xft
\rftvv\uIqJyqIxPprft-xF
volecity
xfzkqilt|f{nxf{kt-yt-r)q6u!p/qIy{ny\qivqG

 !#"$%'&() *)+),-$/.102
xfqIrP]{kyq6$
!
3
46587:9;46<)5 2 7>=)469;?(9 2 3 2!@BA2!C 7 0D2/C 7FEG7 2 4IHJ7 0D2 9;43F? 2 7
~)- :s- d
2!A2 9:KL7 @BM/2NC 7 2PO 7 0 9;4RQDS 0T@ 7 CU@ 5 O Q-7<VE!K 2 9XW .10D2N@ 5Y

pqIrPq {}|xfp\qTxfp\rft-xFxfzkqTlt|f{n
O Q-7U3P4R5 C:@BC 7 C 4IH7 02 9;43F? 2 7XZ C 4I9 @B2 57FEI7 @ 4R5\[\7 02 9FEI7 2
xf{kt-yt8xfp\rf\|Fxfq6r 6 {}|lxfp\qJ8zkq
46H3 0 EI5DS 2
@ 5]4I9 @B2 57FEI7 @ 4R5\[^)_a` [D7 02 3!Q9:9 2 587J7 0 9;467:Y
t8JyqIx;etrfw(t-vxPvxy{nx ~(
7;< 2
O 4 C:@ 7 @ 4R5]4IH 2 E63 0L2 5S @ 5 2 [7 02 E6<b7 @ 7;Qc 2 [EI5c#7 02
A2 <B43 @ 7dK46He7 0D2 9;43f? 2 7 @ 5g7 02 c @ 9 2 3P7 @ 4R5g46Hih @ S 0 7XW
8y\ 8 v

-zkq(t-tr ]q6-y\|#xfp\8x
.10D2PC:2A E6<BQ 2PC EG9 2O 9;4 O EISEG7 2 c7 0 9;4RQS 0 7 02 5 2 7>=)469;?
xfpqNuIt-yDxfrPt-zkzkqIr)8yDxP|)xPprf$|;xPqIr
7;4 O 9;48cQD3 2 EU5 2 =g7 0 9;467:7;< 2 3!4 M/M E65Dc#jk7 02 E M 46QD57
xftL-q6yqIr!xPq -vt8)T
46Hl7 0 9;Q C 7!mHn469 2 E63 0L2 5S @ 5 2 W
{nxPprP\|;x6)opq]$8r!8]qGxPqIr uGtyxPrftz}|p\t-r/xfpq(uGt-yDxPrftznzkq6rN{}|/lqIrP]{xfxfqRxPt
xfp\rft-xFxfzkq\-u!wv8yqIy\-{kyqrft xPprf$|;x6

3

o1

o2
o3

SCALE

o4








*,+" $<



F?

v{0s+ { o pr{s+o v{c{^!x{^ pz0{^q7o myj+myo sT}v{(o{-z0pqv{v{^ov{-S

j(sqo sr{-o s6m:o j?kprp|^{ok{0kqv{-m m{^"m:ps+q
qv{^lv"j?lvp#}vj?qn({Tm:5m:o{^z

kj+mJo s(s+q7o so v{Toklkm:ocs?y{-j"s+ok{Ts+lvc{-qv+pqv{m

prq6s+"}5{^oshzcj?pq7o j?pqok{ s5"+{(o- mj?qv{Ss?j?o:o"j+"

Dg}5{-+

{^{m s+z

& ^s+lv#}{^s++{

%Ts5"{(o^u`s6}5sm:skok{

s?o v{h~

-provpq

j?qk}mp#}5{-mpTj+qv+{

o v{Jopz0{Js?pqvprops+qosTvlkqvsl5ov{^q

j?'s?ov{Jlv{-kj+mx{^{-q

D9}5{^{-{%nslvqk}vj+Jpqk}5p#^j?o{m'okj?oo v{ s5"+{^o4p#m4j?xs+lvo

{(5n{-qk}5{}uvv({-{-}5pqvo v{

osJolvzJv{j?qk}hp#mov{-{^s+ {^s+qkmp#}5{^ {-}hj^jo"j+m:o s+vkp%j?plv {?u54j+"T

=
& qv{^os

UT

Fjm{^j?lkj?o{-}gpqjmprqk+{%o p#j?xo kjo^s+qkmp#mo {-}cs+`o v{s+spqvs+lkvkj+m{-m

Fo9o

?u

prz0{ 
?ov{hs5"+{^o9p#m9j?o:o j"v{-}

mo j+p+7oynjo

D?h{^{^o9s?

sov{n m:o

o sj6j+lvqk"

"j?ponjoprlvp#}5{0prosqj

kp+7o-uv{lv{^o

j?qk!m9j? {lkrj?qk}ok{

{^qvpqv{-mj? {p+qvpro{}u

!u

Foo

pz0{

G


xo v{Js5"+{^ox{^+pqkmpro myj+m ({^q7ojm%o v{J{^qvprqk{-mj+{9nsF{^ {-}o s

lvov lkm:o^u

u

vu

Foo

pz0{

ov{s5"+{^o{-j{-mo v{9#j+lvqk""j?pj+qk}Oo v{^s+q7o s+{^x{^prqnm

os0z0s5}5lv#j? o{%o v{oklkm:oj+m}v{-m ( prx{-}gpqm{-(ops+qhvuj^^s+"}5pqvSo sJ{7lkjo prsqT5u

\vp{y^s+q7o

s+pqvov{ s5"+{^osqv{s?`os{^{^q7o ms5-(lv"mjoopz0{

;j<>  s-{^v({^{}vm DJ}5{^{-{-m^5prqvp#"T^j+m{ov{S^s+q7o s+{^kj+mFj+ pr{ }u

; g
> ok{s5"+{^o{j+"v{mklvqks+l5o-vprqvp#"h-j+m{yov{S^s+q7o s+{^kj+mmlk^^{^{}5{-}u
)qO{^prok{^%^jm:{+vok{o

p#j?p#ms+{-%j?qk}hok{9j?ropro lk}5{s?ov{9s5"+{^o%jox{-^s+z0{m

ov{koqv{mm%m (s{s+o v{qv{^osxu

)q9j%
pqk({{

{-j+#j?lkqk"^o v{Fs5"+{^oFs+lv#}(sq7opq!lv{4j#o {^vlv qvs+lvo'j+qk}S(s7j+m:oo sj?xs+{^{+u

j? {6s+qkr(sqk({-qk{-}pro\ov{

(sqo svnj+m{?Fs+{ c(p{^qn(ov{o p#j?#m

{-{Jprz0pro {-}os {-j+"kprqkgvlv qvsl5o^u1vp#mvoqk{-m mz0{-j+mlv {9p#mj?`okj?op#myqv{-{-}5{}o s

{^qk^s+lv"j?{{^+sl5ops+qnj? Fks+ {-m m(u(s{-+{-^ o v{^ {4p#m1j#j+{s5^j+rzcj?5przcj+{-+ps+q

prqTo v{9qk{(oFs+ gF{^p+7omkj+^{9(s {-mnsqk}5pqvosgov{nsrp#^

 

  kkok{

nsrp#^s+v+{^{-vpqvj+r+s+lv{^qk+pqv{-mjo`lv+o v s?o:o {?u pqk({pop#m1+{-{j+mo s"j?qk}vs+z0

+{^qk{^"jo{yqv{^os5m4okj?omj?olv"jo {o v{^ps+l5o vl5o"m(5o vp#mxs+p#(pnx{v {-m{^q7oprqhok{
lk"j=nsrp#^({j? r}5s!{-mqvs?oTm:s+{Tok{6o"j+mnvl5oTx{-^j+lkm{

k m:oh{^qv{- j?ops+qnm(u

ov{c s5"+{^oyp#mSmsTlvqkm:o j?kr{+1qvsOx{(o:o {^nsrp#^Opmp+{-ho sOn{0k{m:{-qoSpqov{gprqkpo p#j?

nsvlv#jo prsqu+v{-{^s+ {??pro4plkp"!S}5sz0prqnjo{Fo v{%xs+vlv#j?ops+qj?qk}Jkj+rovs+ {-m m
osj?"}yjm:sl5ops+q1u-sj+s+p#}okpmv s+v{^zTj?+(sq7o s+{^"mko kjo{(5vpvpro{}yovp#mnsrp#^
{-{x{^qkj+rp|-{-}h7hm:{^o:opqvo v{^pvo qv{-m mo s0|^{^ svukkpmks5({}5lv {{^qkmlv {-}hokj?o%ok{
(s+q7o sr{-4j+mFqvs?o% {^j?"}5{}0s+%}vs+pqvJqvs?o vpqvvu

4;pu {+uo v{Tqv{(oFs+ 5m

v{mpzlkj?ops+qnmlkm:{}\6mlvvxs+vlv#j?ops+qkm9s??+6qv{^lksqkm

{-{0(sz0ns7m:{}6s+yvp#}v}5{^q

>

lvqkpo"m `j?qn}hj+mm{(oosTm:sTo v{0qv{(oFs+ 6^s+lv#}

s+qvh^s+q7o s+o v{So v lkmoprqTo v{S"j?qv{n{^o{-{^q

j+qk}

-

Fjmy}v{(o{-z0pqv{}pq6{j? To{-m:opqvhonjoovp#m"j?qv{ks5}5lk^{-}

s+{j+"T{^qk+pqv{?u
) o

#G

m:l 0^p{^q7o}vp
 {^ {^q7o pj+

ov lkm:oos0(slvq7o{^"j+(o%m:p#}5{s+"({m(kj+qk}hms+{o v{o jm:xu

mFjm9}5p#m

(lkm m:{}

pqm:{ opsq

'{^+s7pqvOj(s+q7o sr{-}vpr {-(os9o v{cnqv{-m m

s5"+{^oFjmFos!s0}5p 0^lvro%j?qk}Tj?qpqk( {^z0{-q7o j?{-+s+l5o ps+qcz0{^ovs5}hFjmlkm:{}prqnmo {-j+}u

{0n m:o9{^s++{}j6(s+q7o sr{-sov{7lkj?o{-:kqvqv{}

s5"+{^o^u
qk^{gjms+l5o prsqo s

ovp#m{-j+mp{^o j+mOj+ms+lvqk}xo v{{^s+l5opsqj+mo"j?qnm:propsqv{-}hoshok{Jz0s{}5p 0^lvro
kqv{-m mFs5"+{^o^u

90
finless w/ guidance

80

1/4 fins w/ guidance

Altitude: ft. x 1000

70

full fins no guidance

60
50

1/2 fins
no guidance

40
30
1/4 fins
no guidance

20

finless
no guidance

10
0

10

20

30
Time: seconds

40

50

60

 Uk  ? 
$


v


HxUxh/
$* L! 
 ? k - 
 6
/

$  x  
x/5 '7"
! ('7^7(7F!( 7^1:

. 8%"^"":+'7"""
!+"^FF^7F^

5 ""7
7:^7# +" ^

S7 ""F!(F"S^
7 0:--' 0S
7- v'-7"h!( 

7
7
 ^
!7
7": 7S
! ^
?J7 !^
J7
7-7 S!

7 :

6b?7
< ?


& ms++{}ov{0o"j+ms+%(s+q7o srpqvgov{

++v +O{-j?lkjo ps+qkm^u 

 qvs?o v{^

7lkj+:o

{^nqvqv{-}

s5"+{(oSpqj+vv s!pzcj?o{^

D+5+{^j+rlnjopsqkmSF{^ {h {7lvp {-}

o sm:lk-({mm:lv

,I9(sz0kj? {-m'o v{j?ropro lk}5{-mokj?oo v{yj+pslkm

o"j?qkmprops+qJosok{kqkr{mm s!"{(o-u!ip+lv {

s5"+{^o m0 {-j"prqmpzlv#j?ops+qu \

 provsl5oglvp#}vj?qk^{?o v{lkrrkqvqv{}s5"+{^oc{j+"v{m
vlv qvs+l5o4j?o4j?vks5pzcjo {^

I?5++?#o^?v{-{j+mo v{kqv{-m m^lnj?o{^kqvqv{}+j?qk}Jkj+r#

kqvqv{}= s5"+{(o"m9j+rj?pFn{^s+ {h {-j"vpqvOvlv qvsl5o^u %

( sF{^{^-`proqv{^lk j+qv{^os
+lvp#}vj+qk({o v{

7lkj+:o

{^kqkqv{-}j?qn}kqv{-m m s5"+{(o"m}5sS {-j"0vlv qvs+lvoj?qk}{^v({^{}ok{

D

lvkqvqk{-} s5"+{(o- mj?ro po lk}5{!05++?#oj+qk}c !++?#o^{m:x{-(op+{-r+u#o {^vlkqvsl5o^
ov{s5"{(o9p4x{^prqos^sjmojoJjvp+k{^9{^s5(propq=j6r{mm}5{^qnm:{kj?os+%ok{
joz0s7m:kv{^ {?7ov{vpv{^Fvlv qvs+lvoj+roprolk}v{%s+Fo v{ykqv{-m mFs5"+{^o4o j+qkm:#j?o{-mpq7osj+q
j?xs++{-{o kjo%p#mj+nsl5o?Jz0pr{m4kprv{^Fo kj?qhokj?o%s?ov{nqvqv{-} s5"+{(o-u
i`plv{+jm:vs%mok{Jx{^nj7pss?4ov{Js+lky{-qv+pqv{m}5lkpqvjglvp#}5{-}'npr7os
ov{Tkqkr{mm s5"+{^o^u4v{^s+q7o s+{^zcj?+{mm:z0s!s?o "nj?qv{-mos
{^qvprqk{-mJokslv+vsl5o0ok{

kp+7o^uFvp#m0+{-nqv{6(sq7o

j?v lv5oS"kj+qv+{mprq6ov lkm:o9jo9mn{-{-}vms+Flko sOj+"

i`plv{

\po

?mvs%m

-s+ok{hj?

vs+lvo9+lvp#}vj+qk({+ov{7lkj?o{-:kqvqv{}

olvzJv{j+mms7sqOj+m
ov{

j?qk}

B

O^j?q

7lvp#"!-j?lkm{Jj?plv{+u

ps+lkm9s5"{(o m9proj+qk}proks+l5o+lvp#}vj+qk({+u

j?qk}

-=mo"j?oosc}5p+{-{

s

lnj?o{^kqvqv{}j+qk}kqkr{mmcs5"+{^o

o v{Ooklkm:ocs?yok{

s+%p#m0 {7lvp {-}x{--j?lkm{6j+q7

m0{^{-

{-+{^q

o v{gkj+r#kqkqv{-}

s!"{(o9m:o j+:oo s

}5{^{-{-m^u 
 mprqkJlvp#}vj?qn({?vxs?o

s+z

"-

j+qk}

j?oh+{-m:zcj+j+lv{-mglv

osOvlv qvsl5o^u %s?o {okj?oj?ro vs+lvo v{0kqv{mm^s+q7o s+{^yFjmv s!}vlk({}!6lv:o v{^
{^+s7pqv6ov{
lnj?o{^kqvqv{}^s+q7o s+{^-`o v{Okqkr{mm0^s+q7o s+{^Jqvs+ocs+qv=ms++{mj

z0s+ {y}5p c(lkoFo jm:xvvlvo}5s!{-mmspo hz0s{ys+vopzcj?xn{-:szcj+qk({+u

100

1/2 fin unguided

degrees

Throttle %

98

96

94

1/4 fin unguided

1/4 fin guided

finless guided

92
2

90

10000

20000

30000

40000

50000

60000

70000

80000

90000

10000

20000

30000

Altitude: ft.




k




40000

50000

60000

70000

80000

90000

Altitude: ft.

(a)

v"  ? +!
TB !S$ L- n ?

(b)

1^y7 75-

 "
 hc7S"-
?- 1`^O "^"5
7%7S5 "
?%+7-4


^%70-9J"

7 J( 97c"-g-O7" "F! r c
7-
-"(
74"-
?-v5"" ' 7
7?:!^
7-
"'7-
J\-x^:-5'^-

^
! r-%-^

-"
g"
7-
n^#5"-!("7^"

"-
!-:(-
7

21 ^
!5'

^
!J7:("F("n7
":^n-77^
7"%+"-7
7 "


7-7 S!( !

7 ^
!S!-7
7
 S-
:-
S

-
!c^4%7+

^-
c-"7:(4y- F 7y""+
"-
:- +77-
"%+"

-
7h^54' S

r-F!( !

7 ^
!!
  ^F-"-
:-


 +'F!
""
- 7-7-J" r-

77^ !

7 "-
 7

^+S-#

?7,??: =' 5%6

v{0s5"{(o(s+q7o s`o"j+mp#m{-v {-m{^q7o j?op+{Ss+Fzcj+q!O{j?'s#}6vsv{^zcmm:lk"jm
zcj?q!l5j+(olv pqvv'kqnj?qk^pj+v {-}5p# o ps+qj?qn}sns+op#^monjohj+{"kj+ j o {^ pr|-{-}!j
(s+z0kr{^qvsq5rpqv{j?pq7o{- j opsqx{(oF{^{-qgm:5m:o{-z
o j?{%s?lkmpqvS

^s+z0xs+qv{-q7o m^u7v{y( po p#^j?nj+}5j?qv

& s+{-o"j+}5pro prsqkj?!{-qv+pqv{-{^ prqkyj+vv sj+"k{-m'p#mo kjoFpo4-j?q0v s5}5lk^{

j^s+q7o s+{^'so v{-m{m:5m:o{-zcmprovsl5o{lkpr pqvs+ zcj?x!qvs{-}5{%s?m:5m:o{^z

x{(

kj!prssv ps+y!qvs{-}5{Ss?^s+ { o(s+q7o s`x{^kj!ps+-uxk{J{^5n{-pz0{^q7o"m%pqo vp#m

kj?x{^}5{^z0sqkmo j?o{To vp#mgj?kprpro!m:sr!pqvjkpr5v{(p#mprsq'vp+5}5pz0{^qkmps+qkj+
qvs+q5pqv{-j+(sq7o s+o jm:xu

n{7lkj+5pz0ns:o"j?qk^{4p#m`ov{
kqv{-m m+{- mps+qs?'ok{(lk {^q7o~

{-mlvro'okj?oo v{%}5p

 {^ {^q7op#j?oklkm:o4j?kvs7j+"9s+'ok{
%s5"{(o%p#m{-jm:pv{+u %
 #m:sknkj!pqv0jc^s+q7o s+{^

okj?o-j?qT(sz0v{(o{%ov{Sms+lvqn}5pqv9 s5"+{(oFz0p#mmps+q0pqhmpzlv#j?ops+qJkj+mks!p#}5{-}j+rlv

j?v{pq5s+ zcjo ps+qhj+nsl5oo v{9x{^nj7ps%s?'ok{9 s!"{(o%o kjoyslv#}qvs?oys?ok{^ pm{x{
jj+pj+v{?u

)qov{gl5olk{+F{gv#j+qs+qzcj+7pqvo

ov{9^s+q7o s+{^prqksJsqv+{-F {-^{^p+{

v{co"j+m

j+qk}

z0s{0 {-j+pm:op#pq

-=j?lv{-mjmpqvvl5o-nj?qk}

T ; >
;>Fpqkm:o{j+}hs?

osj5m

j+{^qk{^"jopqv0^s+q7opq!lvs+lnm(s+q7o s1m:p+qnj?!ov{Sqk{(oFs+ gps+l5o vl5ojvpqkj+g+{-(os

prqn}5p#^jo pqvOv{(o v{^Js+Jqvs+oJ{j+"{-qv+pqv{m:vslv#}

o vs+o:o r{hkj+" T
 o s

j6v {-m{(ors

ov s?oo{ns7m:propsqu!kpmm "v{^z0{ypx{jo r0mpz0vpok{S(s+q7o sxnj?"}5Fj+{s+qok{
{j? s5"+{(o-u
qk^{gj^s+q7o s+{^s+9ovp#mSqk{^

o jm:

p#m{^s++{}1sprs!^lkmSsq

j+!pqv{^q!!psqvz0{^q7o"j?!kj?"j?z0{^o{- mj+qk}pqk(sxs+"jo prqkqvsp#m:{%j+qk}pqk}0m:sSokj?o4ok{

(s+q7o sr{-Jp%x{6s ^{-}o s=l5o prp|^{Oj=svlkm:ohj?qk}\+{^qk{^"j?m:o"jo {^osmo"j?vpp|^{

ov{c s5"+{^o^u`vp#mkkj+m{0prx{h^pro p-j?os6s+lvSlko pzcjo{J+s7j?s+o j+qkm:{^ pqvok{
(s+q7o sr{-osJo v{S~

j+qk}co {-m:opqvproprqTj?qTj+(olkj+s5"{(oj+lvqk"u

4<,?:
)qcokpm4kj?x{^-!{vsns7m:{jSz0{(o

vs5}s+F{-j+qvpqvj+qgj+(op+{%lvp#}vj?qn({%m!m:o{-z

}5!qkj?z0p#^j+r0lkqkmo"j?v{+nkqkr{mms5"{(o!Tlkmpqv0ok{J4q5s+"({}

s+Fj

lvvxs+klv#jopsqOqv{^l5

s!{^s+l5o prsq0j?+sprokzTu

lv{(5x{^ prz0{-q7o m4mvso kjoo v{{^+s+{-}lvp#}vj?qn({m5mo {^z
pmj?v{oshmo"j?vpp|^{ov{nqv{-m ms5"{(oj?qn}T+ {-jo 0prz0ks{pro mkqkj?j?ropro lk}5{S(sz
kj? {-}osov{glvkqvqk{-}`m:o j+v{0+{- mps+q6s+ov{hs5"+{^o^u`k{c{m:lko"mSmlv+{-m:ookj?o

qv{^lv s!{^s+l5opsq6p#mSjOv s+z0p#mpqvhj+vv sj+"

s}5p c(lvroSqvsqvpqv{-j+^s+q7o s+o j+m5mSpq

ov{ {-j+s#}u

 F<>6


61F ?

Bjopsqkj?

^p{^qk^{iks+lvqn}vjo prsqhlkqk}5{^

vp#m{m:{j?""hj+mmlvvxs+o{}hpqTkj+:o%!co v{

)+) + 
IIvvj?qk}To v{9`{(vj+m (%p+k{^}5lk^j?ops+q s!s+"}5pqkjo pqv Fs7j?"}hlkqk}5{^

+"j?q7o ~ 
& 
? I?5?ukk{cj?l5o vs+"mFs+lv#}rp{9o sO+p+{m:x{-^p#j?'onj?qv5mo s
 pwylvp#"km:{-qOs? 
) q7o{^ s+ vpro j+ !m:o{-zcm {-+lvp#"y(srsku o s 4s+kpm^s+#j?xs+"jo prsq
+"j?q7o

D

7?

>

j?qk}hpq7j+rlnj?v{jmmp#mo"j?qk^{pqhovp#mFv s {-(o^u

#6b5 61616 ?

2X0F67
7
7"7
!8-(:
 -X+ ^ -!S^+x 
7 -
 ?
0 (
!^v -
!^"-
79+!^"
7:(-
nT-
-

-%^" %

4"5- +

-
ny ?(

 2X

!8

%?"5  '^c7-F-: ?n"
7 ^ 5-%+1 ?-n+5 ^
?!^"

4"
 g  ?^

? F-



2X

"
n% F+ k^
7# v4#n ?
7"%^%:"r-

n

-^+"11?+ ^x4"?

+k^
7k
n"
+k2X7
"-"
1"
?7

*X
H1

/0


  
 

+""

-
y7-
"^
! 
++"

8

+"
!-
^ ? ^#!+"#!
74F

  F

F-  J?+-
7"
kx% 
 ""
:^"+-
^" c"
 :-5"7(?-

 


2X

 

7-+"7 +^  +( 

J+?^
7"
k g47


7 ("-
+7-O
7"+"-+
n

? F-H1

2X

x 
7 -4"5-4 
  !^
?F--7+""
"""x'7
7 c^
x7^4^
h  

2X

J^(y  ?+7-1-+

(0F"+:- 0F '^+
? 7"
- "-

^?"F17""5"7^"
4- +
7"""5'7%F
 ^`x -F^



n"
7 ^x4"5-F4
(!8-?

47

?

2X

J^(5  J?+-
7"
k!% 1?
7:-" -
7 5 ! ?^F
c-5-

!
 ^+-"7^"
n-k-7+

(+x":7
7 ^?"5^



 
^7^"
#

^x -4^47

?"1y

>1

2X

+
7"""-''F
 

mX

"-
n` O":(?+
7 `4
6 :( (6:^

$

2X

"^^%"
 y^-"
c n% k k " k"" +
^`

-%
 
7^
7-+-
"
7"`

#%^S^
7
h

?^?

F"
7^7"^+-

:-
""'

XJ-^