Session 1. Gamble, guess or investigate: pracess and criteria for system selectior ‘Strategy for long-term development of Public Transport in a large city: the case of Saratov Pavel Kuznetsov , Deputy General Director, Saratovgorelectrotrans, Saratov, Russia Ynaxaewize xosnerit! Tlossoxste noGitarouapyrs pykososcreo UITP 3a npesocranmennyi0 Mie sosMOxHOCTE surerymiimy wa Konrpecce. [Ipexte ncero, HecKOsKo cnow © sHavennn 1 pom UITP, a vaicxe 06 noKpetmell Noepakke gexTexbuOCTH 97OH yaaxaeNcot opraaursauuu. Ye MWOrO et pabora UITP anpaysena isa poureane cama axxyantitix npo6xen B obepe eGuiecrsemuore tpauenopta, OTOpHIe, FAK NOKAGEIBGeT MPAKTINXA, KMAIOTCR OOMUNN JAE PALIN CPIM, KORTHHEHTOR, hnomuraveckanx cucre, Kora oiaxowuinsea c marepwanaom UITP, nySuananat 8 xypHaTe «Public Teansport International», coxaaetes sueweraenite, To Hee 3To Hanncaxo Zui Poccwm, 1018 ‘Moero possiora ropoaa Caparona, Eaiunt canes npodiie\st H MeToub! WX penTeMna, H wonysaeubte peaynsrarst “Tema nantolt cocem ~ process and criteria for system selection . Tina wac stor eiiSop aakmouaercs He R TOM «170 HMCHRO 1e:14TED, €.8-TOM, ATOGB «ENA IMpeae soero cnineerpoars» 2 ofuiectaerssi tpanonopr (PT). HeoGxoxanen nommruseckas Bost 1H mupecruponantie Gombunnx cpexere, Cam no ceGe phiiok Tpawemoprasie mpoGeMt KPymKorO ropora ne yperyaapyer. Coapewensati Caparon sisieTcx mpuntepox Toro, ro OxILIRET s10Gofh Kpyniet Topo pit ;baKTHecKOM EHOpUpoRAUINE TpaneMopTHO! npoGnews, HeaocrarouoeTH unnectimutt 8 oSinecTBertinal tpaslenopT: yanNts, opts 4 axe NewexoAMble TPOTYSpH1 TopOAR = ‘5 ona Gowri aRTOnIAapKORK, IOPOTH — ceLNOMIaN ABTONOOHTEHAX NpOGKa, YarRCHM KOON Mu B canow naviute NYT Moxepairsaroin roponcKoro oGulectBenoro Tpewcnopte. Mt pecnoaaraen nomvoctblo usHOMeHHOH W YacTHSNO JeMoHTEPOBaHHOM (8 KOHUE TipoutToTo wexa) ‘panpainiofl m Tpomietiycnon cers (142 uae x 120 moe) H crapbist Hosur cocranoM (240 ‘panes 1 180 xponieliGycos). Ene 8 1983 roay xa MenkSypucoil xonbeperiom UITP tpannall Gusr npososrnamen conpestensiM -H Mepcnexrimitim BIMXOM TopozcKoro ouleerBeAKOrO TpaxcTopra, r7aBHOtt anuepuiaTHaoll sactuomy asToMobILN. ‘Caparos ~ tpanatiestit ropox. Cro act aaaaq (@ 1908 roay) Oxia nymew Ypameal wa saexrpaveckol Tire, a 70 9roro B-TeYeIMte ewe 20 Aer pans Ghia KomnbIML DteKTpHCtecK ‘paubali p Caparose mpoekruponasca 1 erpouaen Geauruiiccunas umaenepann Moet «ce NocTpoeno xaautule Tpawnaiiioro ynpanute:Ms, KOTOpoE 3A CTO steT HH pay Me Ment eBoero pemasnaenin — a celivac mn ueM pacnoaaraeted — Capatosropo.textporpane (oronpescirraiui). Tpartnaiinas cers crpoustace u paspupa.tack. BMECTe € rOpOOM. Capatos npencranier coOolt Tarmmuyio Hutocrpamuao x PeKoMeruiaunsnt UTTP erpanan, Boctosok’ Eapoust (JIpesaeneras secnapanna 2004 roaa) 0 neoGxormmocr# coxpautenKs 1 poonmrx rpasnatiiun cere, Tlepewuexenime » xekxapantum pexcmenammn ® norHoR Mepe ‘cooTseTerayior Haus TxaHaN no HopNamcaxm nepesOsOK B Caparoue. Coxamuasca » Capatoxe Tpauenoprnas cityauix oGycnosena pazom npwuu. Tpencne cero, 370 Tlonomese ¢ HaCceANPONEPEROIKAMH, ONO HEY:OBNETHOPUTEILHOe, HO cOBEpINEHHO rorimnioe «t ateKo He caMoe xymmiee, Tak € wawuia 90-x roxos Tipanurenersow PO we Tocynapersennoi JIysolt Giuit mpm arom, yetaonmmnue Gecnnerunit mpoesn wa oGulectvenom -Tpatierlopre Ana orpownCrO ‘Mesa. xaveropuii Tpaxnan (no $4 pean xateropiif, cocrasnapmiX 2 conoxynnoctt, Goxtee 50% scex axnTenelt erpastt. Henomente Tix saKowoR HH eM He pwuaHcHpoRAiock, a HewcTIOAente xepaioe KONTpomApyIONDMK ‘npasooxpantrrensinivit oprauavat, Cneunibiika oOaecTueunoro TpascropTa TaKoN, ITO OBeCtTesHTS ef pertraGensYocth, Jake ApH YeNOLAN cro TONMOK H weeoGuIeH oTUNATES seTpYAMTEMEHO, AB Yyenoniiex Gore’ Fen HoAoRHIION SecntsTHOcrH Mpoetaa MpocTo esosMoxHO. Mywmuumasnse ‘uraera r.Caparona, kak H sIpyrax Fopoaon Po, Obue noctasenes Mepest BEIOOPOM: = gorMpopars ropoaexoit oGimecTue:IsiH tparcnopr (10 B TONIOM OGxeMe BooGuIe GsxTo epoaMoxi0);