Sei sulla pagina 1di 31

!"#$%&'()**+,-#+.

/)(0*"*+123)0
.4#%256*78+.((-/+925#:-;"-<-3+<25=6*78
,245$-8+>4*"$+./)(0*"*?+@2(A+B?+C2A+DEF?+,G-$")(+H**4-8+I"/JK*+'2((-J-+L2/32/+>4*"$+./)(0*"*
'2/M-5-/$-+DNOB+6>)5A+&+P4(A?+DNOQ7?+GGA+FN&QO
!4R("*%-3+R08+Wiley
,#)R(-+S:L8+http://www.jstor.org/stable/854234 .
.$$-**-38+FTEDFEFUDF+DN8UB
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Wiley is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Music Analysis.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

!""#$%&'()#%

/#)%!$!"0/+/%
*+),-.,"!//%
)'1!0%

+23456783952%
3><%;:=3%3@<23A%
+3%:;;<:4=%
3>:3%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
>:=%C<85D<%
67492?%
A<:4=%
;938>.8B:==%
92%3><%G293<6%
/3:3<=H%
+26<<6F%:%4<8<23%
E793<%@96<BA%:88<;3<6F%;:43987B:4BA%
3>9=%
5J%
93%9=%
5C=<4I<4%
>:=%6<=849C<6%
:=%
3A;<% :2:BA398:B%
3><54A% K254D:BKHK%!B3>57?>%
253%;5==9CB<%35%6<3<4D92<%
=<3%
@><3><4%
3>9=%9=%:%J:94%:==<==D<23F%
;938>.8B:==%
65<=%
=<<D%
3
5%
C
<%
D54<%
K
254D:BK%
25@%
3
>:2%
93%
@
:=%
J
9J3<<2%
)>9=%
:2:BA=9=%
A<:4=%
:?5H%
254%9=%3><%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%
;5=939I<%I9<@%@:=%253%:B@:A=%@96<BA%4<;4<=<23<6F%
3><54<398%
+
%
J
45D%
:
=%@9BB%
C
<%
<I96<23%
@><2%
:;;45:8>%
729I<4=:BBA%
:88<;3<6F%
E753<%
4<I9<@=%
5J%)><%/3478374<%
!352:B%
L7=98%:26%)><%-:4D5298%
5J%
5J%)><%
'4?:29M:3952%
(93<%5J%
B:3<4%
/;492?% 52HN%
+%:D%@<BB%:@:4<%5J%3><%852349C73952=%
5J%53><4=%
35%3>9=%
:4<:%5J%
!B3>57?>%
?<2<4:B%
D7=98%
+%@9BB%4<=34983%
><4<%
5@2%@54O%
4<D:4O=%
35%DA%
:26%35%
4<=<:48>F%
DA%
;49D:49BA%
@54O%
4<B:3<6%
35%93H%+2%P7=39J98:3952%
5J%3>9=%
253%=<BJ.%
C73F%+%347=3F%
8B5=<BA%
<?58<23498%
+%4<D926%
52%588:=952%:=%:%
=<4I92?%
;5=93952F%
A57%3>:3%+%>:I<%C<<2%6<=849C<6%
@>98>%852P74<=%7;%:%I9=952%5J%1:29<B%Q552<%92%:%
K;952<<4KF%:% 6<=9?2:3952%
8552=O92%8:;F% :R<%92% >:26F%D:O92?%>9=%@:A%3>457?>%3><%@9B6<42<==%
5J%
4:3><4%
3>:2%3>:3%5J%:2%:8:6<D98%8B:6%92%:%).=>943%
:26%=<:3<6%:3%:%
S<2378OAF%
92%:2%:94.852693952<6%
455D%
92%=573><42%
,522<839873H%
3A;<@493<4%
)><%;B:2%5J%DA%;:;<4%9=%:=%J5BB5@=H%
+%=>:BB%69=87==%
&94=3%
3><%=85;<%:26%65D:92%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%3><54A%
:26%:2:BA=9=%:26%4<I9<@%=5D<%923<4<=392?%
4<8<23%
+%=>:BB%3><2%
<R:D92<%
=5D<%5J%3><%D:P54%
8493989=D=%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%
:;;B98:3952=H%
35%8B:49JA%
:26%;5==9CBA%4<C73H%!B3>57?>%
=5D<%5J%3>5=<%
:2:BA=9=%92%:2%<JJ543%
8493989=D=%
:26%69I<4=93A%
5J%
T:=%92698:3<6%
D:A%>:I<%B5=3%I:B9693A%
CA%3><%I93:B93A%
:26%4<8<23%
53><4=%
:4<%=39BB%
<R3:23%
:26%8523927<%
35%C<%<R;4<==<6F%
@54OUF%
52?592?%
><28<%6<=<4I<%
+2%8528B7=952%
=<4957=%
852=96<4:3952H%
+%=>:BB%65%=5D<%:2:BA=9=%
92%
8522<83952%
:%69=87==952%
@93>%
5J%;45CB<D=%
5J%=<?D<23:3952%
92%:352:B%
D7=98H%!26%
+%=>:BB%573B92<%
@>:3%+%=<<%:=%923<4<=392?%
J7374<%
J54%
J92:BBAF%
;45=;<83=%
;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA398:B%
3<8>29E7<=H%
)><%/85;<%:26%15D:92%
/<3%!2:BA=9=%
*938>.,B:==%
5J%
+2%852J452392?%
3><%E7<=3952%
5J%3><%=85;<%:26%65D:92%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=F%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

NZ%

!""#$% &'()#%

#RH%X%

L99:B9?<% NU%

!2%

493H.%

^_.%

.%

+`KH%

]%

&#% "%

.%
a%

P+K%

F+F%

H%

H%

H%

D%
_%

H%

$H+$FF%
9%

9% 9% 9%9%

9HXZ%

G=<6%CA%;<4D9==952%
L7=98%*7CB9=><4=F%
5J%Q<BD523%
"5=%!2?<B<=F%
,:B9J5429:%
ZbbVZ%

L539I<% :% TCHXU%

c.\W% T[FZFbF% +FNFde%

XcW%`[FZFXFdU%
1C% !% #CY!C% 1% ,% #C% 1C%
&%

&%

1%

1%

\F[FZ%
f.YMX[%W%
`bFF% FNFdF%

93%=<<D=%:;;45;49:3<%
35%C<?92%
3><%7=<%5J%3><%;458<674<=%
@><3><4%
5J%=<3%
CA%:=O92?%
)><%:2=@<4%
9=%=34:9?>3J54@:46W%
9=F%92%:2A%=<2=<F%5CB9?:354AH%
:2:BA=9=%
,<43:92BA%
253H%+%2<<6%52BA%
D<23952%
^:BB:8<%Q<44AK=%
<R8<BB<23%
92%
/3478374:B&7283952=%
=376AF%
@>98>%
928B76<=%
D78>%
D:3<49:B%
52%:352:B%
D7=98%
254D:39I<%
5J%
L7=98F%
T3><%
4<;<4354A%
C73%D:O<=%25%7=<%@>:3=5<I<4%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%3><54AHd%
:;;B98:3952UF%
+2%=9D9B:4%
Q<42:46K=%
J92<%
4<=<:48>%
52%3><%=3478374<%
5J%3><%
J:=>952F%
g52:3>:2%
D7=98%5J%h:4<=<V%
65<=%253%92I5O<%
=<3%3><54AF%
254%65<=%,>49=35;><4%
;938>.8B:==%
:26%I:B7:CB<%=376A%
5J%3><%?<2<4:B%
5J%=<?D<23:3952%
-:=3AK=%9225I:39I<%
;45CB<D%
92%252.352:B%
D7=98%
D:O<%<R3<2=9I<%
7=<%5J%93H\%
!26%157?B:=%g:4D:2%
>:=%D:2:?<6%
35%@493<%
:2%<R8<BB<23%
C55O%52%3><%D7=98%5J%!BC:2%Q<4?%@93>573%
:2A%5J%
92I5O92?%
3><%:;;:4:37=%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%3><54AHc%
)><4<%:4<F%>5@<I<4F%
=<3%:2:BA398:B%
;7CB9=><6%=3769<=%92%@>98>%;938>.8B:==%
857B6%>:I<%C<<2%7=<J7BF%9J%52BA%CA%4<B:392?%
3<8>29E7<=%
=<<D92?BA%
69=;:4:3<%
D7=98:B%
!%8:=<%92%;5923%
9=%9BB7=34:3<6%
92%#RH%XF%@>98>%
3><%
852J9?74:3952=H%
;4<=<23=%
db%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

*+),-.,"!//%

)'1!0%

#RH%X.8523H%

f+V;%

ZbbVZ%
,:B9J5429:%
5J%Q<BD523%
G=<6%CA%;<4D9==952%
"5=%!2?<B<=F%
L7=98%*7CB9=><4=F%

L539I<% C% TCHVU%

c.\W`[FZFbFXFNFde%
\.% X[W% `[FZFbFXFde%
V.XcW% `[FZFXFde%
!% Q% 1% ,i%,%
&i%

!% jki%!% #C% 1C%

#%

#C%

&%

QC%

k%

1%

V.lX\%

3%

V.Xc%
3% V.Xc%

3%

V.Xc%

f.lX[W% `bFXFNFdF\F[FZe%

D7=98%5J%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
';H% XXF%$5H%NF%92%=854<%:3%3><%35;%@93>%=5D<%
5;<292?%
>:=%85DD<23<6%
Q492OD:22%
9
3H%(<92>5B6%
C
<B5@%
D:3<49:B%
7;52%
;B:8<6%
:2:BA398:B%
:=%
J5BB5@=W%
3><=<%
:6P:8<23%
;:==:?<=%
9=%:B=5%
573%5J%52<%O<42<B%
5J%6<I<B5;92?%
)><%;458<674<%
852J9?74:3952%
<I<4A%
5;<292?%
9=%3><%
6<49I:3952%
:BB%3><%
5J%
5J%
6<;:4374<%
)><%;5923%
;9<8<H%
92%3>9=%
7=<6%

XZ[\%
LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

dX%

!""#$%

&'()#%

@93>%
93=%
3@5%
3><D<=%
54%D539I<=F%
:3%3><%
=<83952F%
49?>3%
C<?92292?F%
<R;5=<6%
@>98>%
8522<83952%
>:I<%
:%8B5=<%
35%
52<%
:253><4H%
C<%4<J<44<6%
35%
:=%:%
)><A%
D:A%
:26%
CHf%
)>9=%;:43987B:4%
5C=<4I<4%
65<=%253%3<BB%7=F%>5@<I<4F%
:C573%
:2A3>92?%
=;<89J98%
3><%K8B5=<%8522<83952KH%
)><4<%:4<F%92%J:83F%
=3478374:B%
4<B:3952=%
C<.%
<R;B9893%
3@<<2%
:%:26%CF%:=%92698:3<6%
52%#RH%XH%)><4<%
9=%:%>923%
5J%3>9=%
92%3><%J:83%
3>:3%
C53>%:%:26%C%<26%@93>%
3><%6A:6%#C.1CH%Q73%3><%8544<=;526<28<%
65<=%253%
<26%@93>%
3>:3%
85DD52%
J54%
3><%J92:B%
><R:8>546%
92%C%9=%3><%=:D<F%
@93>%
6A:6F%
35%;938>%
I598<%
5J%:W%=<3%c.\H%)>7=F%@><2%
8B:==F%:=%3><%7;;<4%
4<=;<83%
D<B56A%
3><%5=392:35%
1.&%4<3742=%
:3%3><%<26%5J%D539I<%
CF%3><%<2394<%
J9?74<%
5;<292?%
5J%f.lX[F%9=%4<;<:3<6F%
92%K72546<4<6K%
:%D929:374<%
=<3F%:%J54D%
J54DF%
84<:392?%
:C:%J54DF%
=5%3A;98:B%
5J%';H%XXF%:26%;45I9692?%
:%B7896%92=3:28<%
5J%/8>5<2.%
I:49:3952KH%
C<4?K=%
K6<I<B5;92?%
)><4<%
:4<%
53><4%
C<3@<<2%
D539I<=%
:%:26%
C%92%#RH%XH%
=9?29J98:23%
8544<=;526<28<=%
)><%J94=3%
B92<:4%
92%:%9=%=<3%V.XcW%j1C.!.#C.!CmH%
3<34:8>546%
)>9=%3><2%
4<874=%
:=%3><%B:=3%B92<:4%
92%D539I<%
3<34:8>546%
:=%jki.!.#C.1CmH%
/<3%
CF%4<546<4<6%
V.Xc%:B=5%:;;<:4=%
92%3><%
I<4398:B%
:=%=>5@2%
92%3><%
=<8526%
5J%
#RH%
69D<2=952F%
;:43%
Q73%;<4>:;=%
3><%
D5=3%
C<3@<<2%
7;%:445@=H%
923<4<=392?%
X%CA%3><%
8544<=;526<28<%
3><%3@5%;:43=%
>:=%35%65%@93>%
=<3%\.lX[F%@>98>F%
C<8:7=<%
5J%3><%
;938>.8B:==%
5J% c.\F% 25@% 58874=%:=% 3><% 922<4.I598<%
=788<==952%
4<6<;B5AD<23%
92%D539I<%
CH%)>9=%:2:BA398:B%
9=%4<B<I:23%
5C=<4I:3952%
35%3><%
ki.!.#C.1c%
9DD<69:3<%
D539I<=%
:%:26%CF%=928<%
5J%3><%
\.lX[%9=%3><%85D;B<D<23%
8523<R3=F%
f.l%X[F%@>98>%
3><%
5J%
D539I<%
92%#RH%XH%
=<3F%
B:4?<%
85D;49=<=%
:F%:=%=>5@2%
<2394<3A%
!=%C73%
52<%92=3:28<%
5J%
3><%
J743><4%
5J%
=<3%\.l%X[%92%3><%
=9?29J98:28<%
;938>.8B:==%
#RH%N%?9I<=%
:%;:439:B%
5J%
3><%
8:25298%
3>:3%
92%
85D;5=93952F%
4<:692?%
;:==:?<%
C<?92=%
CH%VdH%)><4<%
@<%J926%
=<3%\.lX[%:=%3><%
><:6%
D539I<%
5J%3><%
8:252H%
+2%3>9=%
45B<%
93%
4<JB<83=%
3><%
>:4D5298%
5J%
3><%
35%@>98>%
93%4<B:3<=%
:=%
B:4?<%
D7=98F%
?457;92?%
5;<292?%
:=%:%34:2=;5=93952%
5J%
3><%
92I<4=952%
5J%
3><%
B93<4:B%
85D;B<D<23%
T35%C<%D54<%
;4<89=<F%
5J%f.lX[%92%93=%J94=3%
3><%4<B:3952%
5J%3>9=%
85D;B<D<23%
D:29J<=3:3952UH%
+26<<6F%
D7=98%
35%3><%
D7=98%
5J%
3><%
D5I<D<23%
C<85D<=%
<I<2%
D54<%
:=%3><%
5;<292?%
<R;B9893%
4<3742%
5J%3><%
C%D539I<%
92%CH%Vc%2<:4=H%
!=%=>5@2%
:3%3><%
<26%5J%3><%
B<33<4.%
2:D<%
:26%27D<498:B%
C<B5@%
3><%
D7=98:B%
92%#RH%NF%D539I<%
C%9=%
4<;4<=<23:3952%
<R8<4;3%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%V.lX\F%92%93=%549?92:B%
;4<;:4<6%
CA%3><%4<:;;<:4:28<%
L5=3%
9=%3><%
4<8744<28<%
5J%
><R:8>546%
69=;5=93952H%
>5@<I<4F%
<R34:54692:4AF%
c.\F%
3><%
5J%
><R:8>546%
:%P7=3%
D539I<%
35%3>9=H%
3><%
3@5%
J54D=%
5J%
c.\%92%3>9=%
;4954%
!?:92F%
:4<%69=;B:A<6%
92%B<33<4.2:D<%
:26%27D<498:B%
253:3952%
:3%3><%C5335D%
5J%
;:==:?<%
#RH%XH%L54<%
C<8:7=<%
5J%3><%
5J%<R;B9893%
:C=<28<%
923<4I:BB98%
54%4>A3>D98%
<B7=9I<F%
9=%3><%
5J%
c.Xc%92%3>9=%
:%4<J<4<28<%
35%52<%5J%
3><%
87<=F%
:;;<:4:28<%
8523<R3F%
;49D:4A%
><R:8>546=%
92%3><%J94=3%
35%3><%><R:8>546%
@>98>%
J94=3%
D5I<D<23F%
=;<89J98:BBAF%

3498>546=%
:3%3><%C<?92292?%
5J%3>:3%
D5I<D<23%
:;;<:4=%:=%3><%3@5%B<J3.>:26%
T=<<%
#RH%V8%52%;H%VdUH%
.% 3><%
!=%J54%
3><%65D:92%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
D7=98%
35%@>98>%
93%D9?>3%
C<%
.% +%:D%3<D;3<6%
35%=:A%3>:3%
93%9=%6<3<4D92<6%
:;;45;49:3<BA%
:;;B9<6%
CA%K85DD52%
=<2=<KH%!3%3><%=:D<%39D<F%
52<%D7=3%
4<:B9M<%
3>:3%
85DD52%
=<2=<%9=%5J3<2%
5I<44:3<6%
dN%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

#RH%N%

84<=8HH%

;;%

*)X%
V\J%

VV%

n%
^^F%

939%
+%

^K"H%

HHHHHHH%F!++6..%

+%
+@%
.%.X%"%
..+%
4)H.X%.L.%
W!%
!'K&++%
J%

/"^%

+%

JJ%

5J%Q<BD523%L7=98%*7CB9=><4=F%
G=<6% CA%;<4D9==952%
"5=%!2?<B<=F%,:B9J5429:%
ZbbVZ%
\.NX[W% `fF[FXXFbFNX%
k% ,% Q% ki%1% 1ki% ,i%,% !% #C% #C% !% 1% ,i%!i%#% #%
&i%Q% QC% k% ,i%,i%k% ,% Q% ki%1% 1% ki%,i%
\.lX[W% `cFfFXbFXXFXX%
c.XcW`XXFXFNFdFcFfe%
,i%&i%1% k%

k%

Q% k% #C% ,C% #Y,%

1%

&% 1C% !%

&% 9%Y%&i% k%&i%


&i%

QC%
c.\W% `bFXFVF\FcFfe%

V.lX\W%
TL539I<% CU%
`VFcFZFXbe%

c.\W`XXFbFdFVF\FcU%

:=%:%?796<B92<o%
52<%;<4=52K=%
=<2=<%9=%:253><4K=%
85DD52%
T)><%=:D<%:;;B9<=%
J5BBAH%
35%/8><2O<49:2%
52<%@57B6%>:46BA%
35%J926%
/8><2O<49:2%
5J%
:2:BA=9=W%
<R;<83%
?4:;>=%
O535%D7=98F%A<3%3><A%<R9=3H[U%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
*938>.8B:==%
@:=%6<I<B5;<6%
g:;:2<=<%
@93>%
:%=;<89J98%
D7=98:B%
92%D926F%
3><%:352:B%
D7=98%
5J%3><%
4<;<43594<%
T252%XN.352<U%
J94=3%
93%>:=%C<<2%:;;B9<6%92%
$5@F%>5@<I<4F%
;:43%5J%3><%3@<239<3>%
8<2374AH%
J54%
35%=5D<%5J%3><%
D7=98%
5J%Q:43cOF%
92%*:7B%^9B=52K=%
72<R;<83<6%
@:A=F%
<R:D;B<F%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

dd%

!""#$% &'()#%

<R3<26<6%
54%35%3><%34:2=93952:B%
D7=98%5J%3><%B:3<4%XZ3>%
+2%DA%
=376AF%
8<2374AHZ%
5@2%4<8<23%
92I5BI<=%
@>98>%
=3769<=%
5J%3><%
9225I:39I<%
D7=98%
5J%"9=M3F%+%>:I<%
@54OF%
5J%3><%72546<4<6%
J5726%
3><%8528<;3%
=<3%35%C<%5J%852=96<4:CB<%
I:B7<H%
;938>.8B:==%
L54<%@9BB%C<%=:96%:C573%:;;B98:3952=%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA398:B%
92%
3<8>29E7<=%
3><%2<R3%
5J%3>9=%
9=%6<I53<6%
=<83952%
35%3>:3%
;:;<4F%@>98>%
35;98H%
(<8<23%
!;;B98:3952=%
!=%+%>:I<%P7=3%=7??<=3<6F%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
4<8<23%:;;B98:3952=%
=<3%3><54A%
:26%
:4<%
5I<4%
:%@96<%
J
9<B6%
5J%
4
<=<:48>%
:839I939<=H%
+%
69I<4=9J9<6F%
:2:BA=9=% >9?>BA%
4:2?92?%
=>:BB%69=87==F%
=<I<4:B%
5J%3><=<H%
C49<JBAF%
L:43>:%-A6<K=%4<8<23%6<3:9B<6%=376A%;45I96<=%:% 4:698:BBA%2<@%I9<@%5J%
3@<BI<.352<%
D7=98F%6<:B92?%@93>%3><%=7;;5=<6%:25D:B9<=%:26%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
8493989M<6%
@493<4=H%
944<?7B:4939<=%
CA%<:4B9<4%
!D52?%53><4%:8>9<I<D<23=F%
-A6<%
=>5@=%K>5@%/8>5<2C<4?%
7=<=%3><%>:4D529<=%
5J%3><%C:=98%=<3%35%923<?4:3<%
3@5.54.%
D54<%=9D7B3:2<57=%
69D<2=952=%
5J%>:4D5298%=3478374<KH5a%
+2% :2:BA=92?%
3><%
5J%3><%C:=98%=<3%:26%3><%D7=98%J45D%
>:4D529<=%
@>98>%93%9=%6<49I<6F%
=><%7=<=%
=<3%25D<28B:374<%
:26%6<J92<6%
4<B:3952=%
35%6<D52=34:3<%
3>:3%
/8>5<2.%
;938>.8B:==%
5J%
>
9235%>9=%3@<BI<.352<%
D7=98%92%
C<4?%
92854;54:3<6%
D:2A% 9=%:352:B%;458<674<=%
=><%;45I96<=%
:%6<3:9B<6%
:26%852I92892?%
5J%
=;<89J98%
@:A=H%+2%3><%;458<==F%
<R<?<=9=%
3@5%
@93>%)@<BI<%)52<=K%:26%
/8>5<2C<4?K=% 9D;543:23%
@49392?=F%
K,5D;5=93952%
Kh5434:?YXN)SY*4928<352KH++%
@93>%:%=5D<@>:3%
69JJ<4<23%
D7=98:B%4<;<4354AF%
:2%
^54O92?%
g<JJ%
*4<==92?F%
!D<498:2%
92%Q726554:F%
85D;5=<4F%
P:MM%;9:29=3%:26%<3>25D7=985B5?9=3%
B9I92?%
>:=%@4933<2%
:2%<R34<D<BA%
K*938>.,B:==%
/<3%
!7=34:B9:F%
923<4<=392?%
<==:A%<2393B<6%
/3478374<=%
92%,523<D;54:4A%
g:MMKF%@>98>%;4<=<23=%<R3<2=9I<%
:2:BA=<=%:26%
3><54<398:B%
D:3<49:B%
52%=78>%J:D9B9:4%
@54O=%
:=%)>:6%g52<=K=%
KQ9?%19;;<4K%:26%
@:=%
g5>2%
L8":7?>B92K=%K)><%1:28<%5J%L:A:KHXN%!B=5%=5D<@>:3%
72<R;<83<6%
3><%;:;<4%@>98>%
!B:2%,>:;D:2%
6<B9I<4<6%
:3%3><%4<8<23%
0:B<%,52J<4<28<%
52%3><%
L7=98%5J%S743%^<9BB%T!737D2%XZ[dUF%@>98>%9D;4<==9I<BA%
6<D52=34:3<6%
3><%
4<B<I:28<%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3=%35%3><%
D7=98%
5J%3>:3%
>9=%8>598<%5J%
85D;5=<4F%
4<B:392?%
>:4D5298%
D:3<49:B=%
35%3><%D7=98%5J%3><%:I:23.?:46<%
5J%>9=%39D<F%
85D;5=<4=%
35%
3
>:3%
5J%
253:CBA%
/8>5<2C<4?HKd%
'2<%5J%3><%
J92<=3%
5J%3><%
4<8<23%
=3769<=%
35%<D;B5A%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
9=%*:7B%
;938>.8B:==%
^9B=52K=%:=%A<3%72;7CB9=><6%
@54O%52%D7=98%J45D%
Q:43cOK=%D966B<%;<4956F%
52%3><%)>4<<%#376<=%J54%*9:25F%';H% X[F%
XZb[.XZNNF%@93>%8528<234:3952%
92%XZX[F%:26%3><%+D;45I9=:3952=%
52%-72?:49:2%
*<:=:23%/52?=F%';H%
85D;B<3<6%
92%XZNbH%)><%=376A%
3><%J5BB5@92?%
@93>%
=3:3<D<23W%
NbF%85D;B<3<6%
C<?92=%
Q<B:%Q:43cOK=%
D7=98%9=%?<2<4:BBA%
:=% 4<;4<=<2392?%
34:693952=%
4<?:46<6%
J45D%
3>5=<%
@>98>%
49=<%
35%3><%
8B:==98%
:352:B%
D7=98%
5J%
3><%
=<;:4:3<%
/<8526%
?:I<%

h9<22<=<%/8>55BH%Q73%Q:43cO%
@:=%253%72:@:4<%
5J%3>:3%=8>55B%54%93=%D7=98F%

:26%J54%
92%>9=%8:4<<4%
:%;<4956%
><%85D;5=<6%
@54O=%
@>98>%
<DC569<6%
>9=%5@2%
5J%:352:B%
:26%=3478374<HXV%
726<4=3:2692?%
;938>%
54?:29M:3952%

dV%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

=3769<=%
92%;45?4<==%
:3%3><%;4<=<23%
39D<%
@>98>%
;938>.8B:==%
<D;B5A%
":4?<.=8:B<%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%928B76<%*>9B9;%(7==5DK=%@54O%52%3><%D7=98%5J%L:7498<%(:I<BF%
@>98>%;45D9=<=%
92%25I<B%J:=>952%
3><%>:4D5298%
5J%3>:3%
35%6<B92<:3<%
;458<674<=%
>9=%
D
7=98%
>
:=%
@
93>%
:%
27DC<4%
5J%
@>98>%
:26%
3
5%
6
<:B%
;4<=<23<6%
;45CB<D=%
85D;5=<4%
*<4B<K=%
35%=376<23=%
92%3><%;:=3F%=78>%:=%3><%D:33<4%
5J%8<2349893A%
T35%7=<%k<54?<%
5J%
:26%=78>%
J:D9B9:4%
>:4D5298%
:
26%3><%
=
8:B:4%
=
3478374<=%
3<4DU%
923<4;4<3:3952%
852=34783=%
:=%3><%K2923>%
8>546KHX\%
3574%6<%J548<F%
/8>D:BJ<B63K=%
35%D:38>%g:2<3%
-5@<I<4F%93%@9BB%C<%69JJ987B3%
=<3%
5J%
@>98>%
<23:9B<6%
:%85D;B<3<%
157?B:=%
;938>.8B:==% :2:BA=9=% Q<4?K=%^5MM<8OHKc%
=3:3<=W%
4<I9<@%
92%3><%)9D<=%
34<28>:23%
g:4D:2K=%
"93<4:4A%
/7;;B<D<23%
52%^5MM<8O%
C55O%
D:O<=%
35%3><%
B93<4:374<%
852349C73952%
@>98>%
3>9=%
)><%4<:B%
8528B7=952=%
:C573%3><%
35%:449I<%
:3%=5D<%5I<4:BB%
B9<=%B<==%92%93=%:33<D;3=%
93%
:%D54<%
5J%
92%
3
><%
<R3<23%
35%
@
>98>%
3><%
3>:2%
D7=98:B%
;45I96<=%
B:2?7:?<% 5;<4:%
5J%
5J%
D539I98%
=3478374<%
>:=%
C<<2%
:I:9B:CB<%
3><%
3>:2%
6<3:9B<6%
;4<I957=BA%
=376A%
D:2A%
;:==:?<=H_%
5J%/8>D:BJ<B63K=%
:%D:P54%
+3%=<<D=%35%D<%3>:3%
3><%4<I9<@<4%
D9==<=%
=376AF%
;5923%
:26%=D:BBF%
:=%
92%
@>98>%
9=%3>:3%
72546<4<6%
D539I<=%
=<3=F%
85D;49=<%
B:4?<%
;938>.8B:==%
=<3=%58874%92%
92%93=%;938>%
)><=<%;938>.8B:==%
3><%54?:29M:3952%
5J%3><%@54O%
:=;<83=H%
@
>98>%
9
=%52<%5J%3><%
:26%
92%
:%@54O%
>:4D5298%
D<B5698%
D7B39;B<%
852J9?74:3952=%
D5=3%4<D:4O:CB<%
:8>9<I<D<23=%
5J%D56<42%D7=98H%/8>D:BJ<B63K=%
:2:BA398:B%
!2%<=;<89:BBA%
35%<2:CB<%><4%35%?<2<4:B9M<H%
:4<%=7JJ989<23BA%
3<8>29E7<=%
;5@<4J7B%
5J%549?92K%=<3=F%=<3=%
J92<%
5J%3><%KJ:D9BA%
92=3:28<%
5J%3>9=%9=%><4%8>:4:83<49M:3952%
@>98>%C<B52?%35%3><%;<4=52:%
5J%^5MM<8O%
:26%K;45I96<%3><%J726:D<23:B%
;938>.%
5J%3><%5;<4:KHK[%
D:349R%
=3478374:B%
5J%3><%D7=98%5J%1<C7==A%:B=5%
(98>:46%/H%*:4O=K=%52?592?%
=376A%
B:4?<.=8:B<%
@93>%53><4%D<3>56=H%
=<3%
<D;B5A=%
;938>.8B:==% :2:BA398:B%
35?<3><4%
;458<674<=F%
K*938>%
92%
*:4O=K=%:;;45:8>%
9=%@<BB%4<;4<=<23<6%
92%>9=%4<8<23%
:4398B<F%
'4?:29M:3952%
92%_Q4579BB:46=_%
92%@>98>%
>
<%<R:D92<=%
D7=98:B%
G2546<4<6%
/<3=%
KF%
1<C7==AW%
92%3>:3%
@54O%
92%852=96<4:CB<%
6<3:9BF%
8528B7692?W%
852J9?74:3952=%
)5%:%4:3><4%
D7=98%
KQ4579BB:46=K%
C<%
<R3<23F%
T5J%@>98>%
B:4?<%
D:A%
1<C7==AK=%
92%93=%;938>%
85DC92:3952=%
@>98>%
852=96<4<6%
4<=5748<=F%
4<I<:B=F%
3A;98:BU%
5J%>:4D52AF%
<R>9C93%
253952=%
8>:4:83<49=398=%
34:693952:B%
I598<.%
BA92?%
C<A526%
:26%:%4<J<4<239:B%
352<%
:26%=525493A%
B<:692?F%
T35298UHKZ%
5J%/34:I92=OAK=%
^93>%3><%4<:6<4K=%
+%@9BB%928B76<%DA%=376A%
)><%
9267B?<28<F%
(93<%5J%/;492?%
5J%B:4?<4%
:=%:253><4%
92=3:28<%
5J%:2%92I<=39?:3952%
=8:B<%T:B3>57?>%
B9BB9;739:2F%85D;:4<6%35%/8>D:BJ<B63K=%@54OUH%)>9=%4<=7B3<6%J45D%:%;B:2%5J%B52?%
=3:2692?%35%:2:BA=<%:%D:P54%@54O%CA%7=92?%;938>.8B:==%=<3%:2:BA398:B%3<8>29E7<=%
35%;45I96<%:%;98374<%5J%93=%5I<4:BB%54?:29M:3952H%)>5=<%J:D9B9:4%@93>%3><%=376A%

@9BB%4<8:BB%3>:3%=3:26:46%
=<3%852=34783=F%
3>:3%5J%3><%=<3%85D;B<RF%
92%
;938>.8B:==%
726<4@<23%
92%3><%J92:B%
D569J98:3952%
5J%3><%;4<=<23:3952%
5J%3><%
;:43987B:4F%
=3:?<=%
@>98>%
35%=A23><=9M<%
3><%
5J%3><%
9269I967:B%
D5I<D<23=H%
=376AF%
:33<D;3<6%
:2:BA=<=%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

d\%

!""#$%

&'()#%

1<=;93<%DA%J526<=3%>5;<=F%>5@<I<4F%3><%=376A%@:=%253%4<8<9I<6%@93>%
72:29D57=%
(98>:46%):47=O92F%:J3<4%
=5D<%
4<I9<@F%
:;;45I:BH%+2%:2%<R3<2=9I<%
8528B76<=W%KQ73%93%=<<D=%
35%D<%3>:3%
&543<K=%:;;B98:3952%
5J%
85DD<23=F%
B:76:354A%
>9=%D<3>56F%
:3%B<:=3%92%3>9=%
4<=349839I<%
:26%52<.=96<6F%
:26%
8:=<F%9=%722<8<==:49BA%
>:=%8528<:B<6%:=%D78>%:C573%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?%
:=%93%>:=%4<I<:B<6KHNb%)><%
:73>54K=%
D:92%
9=%3>:3%
3><%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
J<:374<=%
5J%
85D;B:923%
;938>.8B:==%
69=4<?:46=%
3><%D7=98%@>98>%><%I9<@=%:=%<R<D;B:4A%
5J%54692:4A%
KJ7283952:BK%
-<%
352:B93AH%
J54%
:2%:B3<42:39I<%
5J%3><%D7=98%5J%3><%(937:B%5J%)@5%
92=3:28<F%
;4<=<23=F%
4<:692?%
(9I:B%)49C<=%:3%(cb%T#RH%d:U%:26%85DD<23=W%
B55O=%
:3%3><%
J45D%
5J%
5J%
3><%
I9<@%
J7283952:B%
+JHHH% 52<%
;:==:?<%
;5923%
>:4D52A%
J7283952:B%
:3%3>:3F%
>9=%J:94%
T:26%;4<33A%
=9D;B<%
>:4D52A%
:BB5@92?%
/34:I92=OA%
5J%657CB<%
=>:4<%
92JB<83952=%
:26%:66<6%
3><4<%
9=%25%;45CB<DH%
)><%
=<I<23>=UF%
85DC92:3952=%
92%3><%
D966B<%
5J%
D<:=74<=%
:26%J574%
:4<%
3><%
5J%
4<=7B3%
52<F%
3@5F%
B92<:4%
J7283952=%
@93>%
:3%3><%
T:88<23<6%
352<=UF%
;:==92?%
;:4:BB<B%
657CB92?%
3>946H%
5J%352:B%
:%;45?4<==952%
35%3><%
D:P54%
8<23<4F%
92I5BI92?%
HHH% )><%=>9J3%
9=%=3:26:46%
(7==9:2%
J:4<HNX%
=7CD<69:23F%
^>:3%=7??<=3=%
:%352:B%
5J%3><%;:==:?<F%5J%8574=<F%
9=%3><%=8:B:4%
:2:BA=9=%
D<B56AF%
@>98>%
8:2%C<%4<?:46<6%
:=%:%=<?D<23%
5J%3><%Q%D:P54%=8:B<%.% :%J:83%
5J%@>98>%
+%:D%
:@:4<H%)>9=%7=<%5J%69:35298%
D:3<49:B=%
92%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?%
9=%>:46BA%
727=7:BH%
65<=%=5D<3>92?%
727=7:B%92%>9=%=<3392?%
5J%=78>%
>5@<I<4F%
/34:I92=OAF%
92I:49:CBA%
92%3>9=%
8:=<%>:4D529=92?%
3><%D<B56A%
@93>%
3<34:8>546=%
D<B569<=F%
K85DD52;B:8<K%
@>98>%
92%53><4%
5J%3><%D7=98HNN%)><%4<I9<@<4K=%
:;;<:4%J4<E7<23BA%
;:43=%
:2:BA=9=%
3
><%
K
657CB<%
92JB<83952=K%
:26%K:66<6%=<I<23>=K%
T#RH%dCU%9=%><:I9BA%
6<;<26<23%
7;52%
92%@>98>%
><%:=O=%3><%4<:6<4%
35%9267B?<%
3><%D:=3<4H%
B:C<BB<6%
+%92%
)>7=F%3><%8>546%
CH%+%5J%#RH%dC%9=%:%I<4A%
8
4<:374<W%
:%35298%
@
93>%
2
5%
3
@5%
O
926=%
5J%
;<87B9:4%
4553F%
:2%K:66<6%=<I<23>K%T!UH% )><%53><4%4<:692?=%5J%
3>946=F%:26F%;4<=7D:CBAF%
KJ7283952:BK%
>:4D529<=%
92%#RH%dC%4<I<:B%
=9D9B:4%
:BB%5J%@>98>%
>:I<%3><%
;45CB<D=F%
=:D<%=5748<W%:6%>58%:2:BA398:B%
+J%
@
<%
:
=%I:B96%
3
>9=%
5J%
3<8>29E7<=H%
:88<;3%
4<:692?%
KJ7283952:BK%
92%)><%
(
93<%
:2%
>9=35498:B%
>:4D52A%
5J%/;492?F% 9D;543:23%
69=85I<4A%
<2=7<=W%3>:3%
=3769<6%
3><%@452?%
J7283952:B%
+%@9BB%
3<R3C55O=H%
/34:I92=OA%
>:4D52A%
253%;74=7<%3><=<%
J743><4%
C
73%
@
9BB%
4
<3742%
35%
:
%=9D9B:4%
92=3:28<%
5J%:2%
;5923=%
><4<F%
35%J548<%
:%352:B%4<:692?%5J%=5D<%O926%7;52F%92%3>:3%8:=<F%:2%:352:B%
:33<D;3%
:3%@>98>%
+%@9BB%
D:O<%:%J<@%
:6693952:B%
5C=<4I:3952=HNd%
85D;5=93952F%
;5923%
&92:BBA%
52%)><%
-:4D5298%
)
><%
(93<%
+%E753<%:%4<I9<@<4%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%
>5@<I<4F%
5J/;492?F%
5J%;<4=;98:893AF%
:26%3:=3<W%
P76?<D<23%
C<8:7=<%
93%;45I96<=%
3><%B52?.:@:93<6%
j)><m%C55O%9=%5J%8:;93:B%
9D;543:28<%
D<:2=%
@93>%
@>98>%
>:4D5298%
:2:BA398:B%
8:2%C<%726<4.%
/34:I92=OAK=%
=A=3<D%

=3556%:26%:3%3><%=:D<%39D<%3>45@=%
2<@%B9?>3%
52%>9=%D926F%=>5@92?F%
J54%
92=3:28<F%3>:3%@>:3%=<<D<6%35%C<% D5=3%9DD<69:3<%@:=%5J3<2%D5=3%
4<JB<839I<HNV%

)5% 4<3742%35%:% J92:B%<R:D;B<% 5J%8744<23%@54O%92I5BI92?%;938>.8B:==%=<3%


:2:BA=9=F%+%@:23%35%893<%:%;:43987B:4BA%
923<4<=392?%
<R3<2=952F%@>98>%9=%93=%7=<%92%

dc%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

#RH%d%

!%

^H%
^H%
3%

);3%
3%

V.X[W"NFdFcFZX% V.fWjXXFbFdFVm%

V.XfWHXXFNFdFcd%V.f%

V.X[H%Z%Xb%
XFVd% V.X[W%XbF9XFNF\XV.[W3cFfFXXFbX%TV.X[U%
G=<6%CA%;<4D9==952H%
XZf[% CA%0:B<%G29I<4=93AH%
85;A49?>3%

Q%

[%

3;H%

Q+%

If%

QW+% h%

H3H%

h%

kW9%

+%

hI% ++U%

])%

h%Th++U%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%
XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

df%

!""#$% &'()#%

@93>%
54%E7:=9./8><2O<49:2%
/8><2O<49:2%
B92<:4%
D<3>56=H%
LH%
g:D<=%
852P7283952%
:%852I92892?%
Q:O<4%>:=%;45I96<6%
:26%549?92:B%
92=3:28<%
5J%3>9=%
5J%
@54O%
92%
>9=%
3A;<%

K/8><2O<49:2%
:26%*5=3.)52:B%
><%=<3=%
J543>%
:4398B<F%
L7=98KF%92%@>98>%
!2:BA=9=%
:2%:2:BA=9=%
J54%<R<87392?%
5J%3>9=%3A;<%:26%3><2%9BB7=34:3<=%
>9=%
85?<23%8493<49:%
I9<@=%92%:%=376A%
5J%:%B:3<%352:B%@54O%
!
B<R:26<4%
<2393B<6%
/849:C92F%
CA%
K#29?D<KH%
Q:O<4%8528B76<=%
CA%=:A92?W%
/849:C92K=%
J743><=3%
<R3<2=952%
5J%
HHH% 852=39373<=%
!B3>57?>%
K#29?D<K%
;<4>:;=%
92%
3
><%
5J%
D7=98%
>
9=%
3
4:2=93952:B%
352:B%
9D;B9893%
352:B93A%
;<4956%
TXZbd.XZXbUF%
J548<=%
:4<%
2<I<43><B<==%
92%B:4?<%
J54%
3><%
5I<4:BB%
85><4<28<%
5J%
4<=;52=9CB<%
;:43%
3><%@54OH%!3%3><%=:D<%39D<F%3><%4<3<23952%
5J%@>5B<.352<%
<B<D<23=%
92%3><%;45B52?:3952%
5J%3><%65D92:23%
@>9B<%
53><4%
;:43989;:3<=%
J7283952F%
252352:B%
92%
3>5=<%
52%
C:=<6%
:4<%
4<B:3952=>9;=F%
;:43987B:4%
85D;B<D<23:3952F%
92%<=3:CB9=>92?%
=3478374:B%
C<3@<<2%
3><%
C526=%
=<83952=%
9D;543:23%
85234:=392?%
5J%
3><%
;9<8<HN\%
)><%69I<4=93A%
5J%:;;B98:3952=%
573%5J%D:2AF%
=7??<=3<6%
CA%3><=<%J<@%=3769<=F%
6<D52=34:3<=%
3>:3%
72546<4<6%
=<3%:2:BA=9=F%
J:4%
J45D%
9269I96.%
;938>.8B:==%
B58O92?%
7:B%:2:BA=3=%
9235%:%49?96%
54%C<92?%B9D93<6%
35%:%=D:BB%4<;<4354A%
5J%
923<4;4<3:3952%
.% =;<89J98:BBAF%
.% 5JJ<4=%
D7=98%
3><%D7=98%
5J%3><%h9<22<=<%
:352:B%
=8>55B%
:%JB<R9CB<%
52<%@>98>F%
@><2%
2<@%:26%923<4<=392?%
4<=5748<F%
;45;<4BA%
923<4;4<3<6F%
;45678<=%
4<=7B3=H%
/5D<%,49398:B%
h9<@=%
*938>.8B:==%
/<3%!2:BA=9=%
5J%
/928<%93%J94=3%
=928<%3><%
:;;<:4<6%52%3><%=8<2<%92%XZcVFNc% :26F%92%;:43987B:4F%
5J%
)
><%
/
3478374<%
!352:B%
L7=98%
9
2%
7
2546<4<6%
=<3%
;7CB98:3952%
XZfdF%
5J%
;938>.8B:==%
>:=%4<8<9I<6%
:%
6<:B%5J%
849398:B%
D
54<%
3
>:2%
93%
:2:BA=9=%
?556%
:33<23952F%
;<4>:;=%
+
%>:I<%
J
<B3%
52%
=
<I<4:B%
+%@57B6%
588:=952=H%
2
5@%
B
9O<%
3
5%
4
<I9<@%
=5D<%
5
J%
3
>:3%
2<<6<6F%
J45D%
3>9=%C49<J%
3><%6<3:9B<6%<==:A=%CA%Q<2P:D92F%
8493989=DF%
<R8B7692?%
=74I<A%
Q45@2<%
:26%(<?<2<4F%
253%C<8:7=<%3><A%
:4<%72@543>A%
5J%=<4957=%
852=96<4:3952%
.% J:4%
J45D%
93%.% C73%C<8:7=<%3><A%
:4<%253%4<I9<@=%
92%3><%7=7:B%=<2=<F%
C73%:4398B<=%
3>:3%
7=<6%)><%/3478374<%
!352:B%
L7=98%
9
2%
:
=%:%
5J%
J54%
5J%
B:4?<%
;:43% ;5923% 6<;:4374<%
5J%
3
><%
:
73>54=K%
5@2%
+2%
3><%
5J%
8
574=<%
3
>9=%
+%
9
6<:=HNf%
;4<=<23:3952%
4<I9<@%>5;<%35%
3578>%52%8<43:92%
9==7<=%5J%:%?<2<4:B%2:374<F%9==7<=%92I5BI92?%
8523<D;54:4A%
3><54A%:26% :2:BA=9=%@>98>%34:2=8<26%3><%9DD<69:3<%5CP<83%5J%:33<23952F%
72546<4<6%
=<3%:2:BA=9=H%
;938>.8B:==%
*938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
>:=%C<<2%8493989M<6%
:=%C<92?%355%:C=34:83F%
355%J54D:BH%
!2%9D;543:23%
8:=<%92%;5923%
9=%3><%=<3%5J%=<3=%O25@2%
:=%3><%Kl.85BB<83952=KH%
+3%@9BB%
C<%4<8:BB<6%
3>:3%
3@5%;938>.8B:==%
=<3=%92%3><%l%4<B:3952%
>:I<%3><%=:D<%353:B%
923<4I:B%
C73%:4<%253%4<B:3<6%
54%92I<4=952H%
#:8>%D<DC<4%
8523<23F%
5J%3><%
CA%34:2=;5=93952%
5J%3><%53><4H%
9=%93%2<8<==:4A%
;:94%9=%8:BB<6%3><%Kl.8544<=;526<23K%
35%D:O<%3><%
^>A%
69=39283952%
C<3@<<2%
3><%D<DC<4=%
5J%=78>%;:94=F%@><2%3><A%
:4<%923<4I:BB98:BBA%
>:=%<I<2%6<=849C<6%=78>%=<3=%:=%
<E79I:B<23a%'2<% 5734:?<6%85DD<23:354%
5J%3><%D7=98%3><54A%
5J%0:B<%G29I<4=93AKF%
92%:2%
6<;:43D<23%
KHHH% =;<89:B39<=%
35%C:29=>%3><=<%=<3=%J54<I<4%
35%3><%!48:69:%5J%/573><42%
:;;:4<23%<JJ543%
d[%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

:=%93%@<4<F%
3><%;49=392<%
J45D%
=34<<3=%
5J%$<@%054O%
,522<839873F%
3><DF%
KJB7=>92?K%
)><%
35%
*<4B<K=%
8
493989=D%
9=%
3>:3%
l.4<B:3<6%
=<3=%><B;%
:2=@<4%
,93AHN[% =9D;B<%
k<54?<%
9
2%
:%@96<%
5J%
35%<R;B:92%
>:4D5298%
2
52.352:B%
+26<<6F%
I:49<3A%
7=:?<=%
4<;<43549<=H%
&54%<R:D;B<F%3><%><R:8>546%
c.lNZ%
3><A%:4<%5J3<2%
@<BB.29?>%
9269=;<2=:CB<H%
5J%/34:I92=OAK=%
9
3%
9
=%
253%
35%C<%
5J3<2%
583:35298%
58874=%92%3><%8523<R3%
D7=98F%A<3%
J5726%92%3><%583:35298%=8:B<H%-5@<I<4F%93=%l.8544<=;526<23F%
c.l\bF% 9=%:%
=
8:B<H%
^93>573%
3><%
C<3@<<2%
c.lNZ%:26%
5J%
3>:3%
4
<B:3952%
85D;52<23%
O25@92?%
35%
C
<%
3><%
J
54D<4%
:2%
c.l\bF%
:;;<:4=%
:25D:BAHNZ%
3><%l.;:94=%9=%
)><%D7=98:B%<I96<28<%92%3><%:352:B%4<;<4354A%
3>:3%=7;;543=%
92%
=><<4%
)5%3:O<%
:
=%:2%
3><%
@
54O%
@93>%@>98>%
E7:2393AH%
<R:D;B<%
5I<4@><BD92?%
=<3%\.l%X[%
@<%
J926%
3>:3%
574%<R:=;<4:3<6%
849398%
@:=%8528<42<6F%
Q<4?K=%^5MM<8OF%
9=%:==589:3<6%
3><%
1
47D%
@
>9B<%
9
3=%
\.ld[F%
L:P54F%
l.8544<=;526<23F%
4<;4<=<23=%
@93>%^5MM<8OK=%>:BB7892:3952F%
:26%=<3%V.lX\%9=%52<%5J%L:49<K=%3<34:8>546=F%
3><%158354H%'3><4%l.;:94=%:4<%
@>9B<%93=%l.8544<=;526<23F%
4<;4<=<23=%
V..lNZF%
92%!83%XF%=8<2<%VF%
8522<83<6%
@93>%
3><%158354%T<=;<89:BBA%
c.l%Xf%:26%c.lVdF%C53>%
L:49<%:26%^5MM<8O%35?<3><4F%
c.l%XZ%:26%c.lVVF%4<;4<=<2392?%
3><%;:==:8:?B9:UF%
@93>%
3><%B:33<4%
:26%c..lVfF%
:26%c..lN\%
^5MM<8OF%L:49<%:26%3><%,:;3:92F%
B92O92?%
5J%
92%3><%645@292?%
=8<2<H%)><%D7=98:B.64:D:398%
=<3%;4<65D92:23%
=9?29J98:28<%
9
3%
@
57B6%
:26%
5J%
9=%
6
9=87==<6%
:3%
3
><=<%
85DC92:3952=%
CA%/8>D:BJ<B63F%
D:2A%
B<2?3>%
><4<H%
C<%;4<=7D;3757=%
35%:33<D;3%
35%4<B:3<%
><4%6<3:9B<6%
69=85I<49<=%
65<=%253%J7BBA%
^>9B<%4<P<8392?%
3><%l.4<B:3<6%=<3=F%574%849398%:;;:4<23BA%
:=%92698:3<6%CA%3><%J5BB5@92?%
3><%2:374<%5J%3><%4<B:3952=>9;F%
726<4=3:26%
85DD<23W%
3@5%
5J%
352<%
45@%
)>:3%
<R9=3=%
C<3@<<2%
3><%
><R:6=%
3><%
3><%
KM.4<B:3952=>9;K%
j=98m%
)>946%
:2%:@:4<2<==%
5J%
3>9=%
5J%
65<=%
253%
p7:43<3%
;45;<43A%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
9D;BA%
9=%;4<=<23%
3><%
3@5%
52%3><%
=928<%
3>9=%
C<3@<<2%
;:43F%
4<B:3952=>9;%
85D;5=<4K=%
5J%
><R:6=%
3@<BI<.352<%
85BB<83952%
<I<4A%
jDA%
<D;>:=9=mHd5%
)><% B:33<4%=3:3<D<23%
9=%253%347<H%QA%6<J9293952%
l.4<B:3<6%><R:8>546=%:4<%
><R:8>546=%
@>98>%
8
:2253%
54%CA%
C
<%4<B:3<6%
CA%34:2=;5=93952%
85D;B<D<23:4A%
3><%
5J%
3
><=<%
9=%
9
2698:3<6%
92I<4=952H%
><R:8>546=%
&743><4D54<F% 9D;543:28<%
CA%3><%
92%3><%3@<BI<%
J:83%
3>:3%
5J%3><%J9J3A%
><R:8>546=%
:4<%
=<3%
3>943A%
;938>.8B:==% 729I<4=<F%
5J%3><%l%I:49<3AH%
5J%3><%253952%5J%K<E79I:B<28<K%:=%93%;<43:92=%
35%3><%l.%
L9=726<4=3:2692?%
4<B:3<6%;938>.8B:==%
3
><%
>
<R:8>546=%
92%
92%3><%
=<3=F%
;:43987B:4F%
;<4=9=3=%
;45J<=.%
=952:B%B93<4:374<H%
+2%)><%/3478374<%
L7=98%<E79I:B<28<%5J%3@5%;938>.%
5J%!352:B%
KH%H%H%3@5%;8%=<3=%@9BB%C<%=:96%35%C<%<E79I:B<23%
8B:==%=<3=%9=%6<J92<6%
:=%J5BB5@=W%
9J%
35%
3><%=:D<%;49D<%
:26%52BA%9J%3><A%
4<6789CB<%
:4<%
J54D%
54%CA%
CA%34:2=;5=93952%
92I<4=952%
J5BB5@<6%CA%34:2=;5=93952K%
T;H%\UH% )>9=%9=%253%3><%=:D<%3>92?%:=%
3>:3%:2A%3@5%=<3=%@93>%3><%=:D<%353:B%923<4I:B%
8523<23%
@9BB%C<%4<?:46<6%
=:A92?%
:=% <E79I:B<23H%0<3%:% 4<8<23%4<I9<@<4%
3><%852J7=952H%g:4D:2%
;<4;<37:3<=%
<R;4<==<=%657C3=%:C573%3@5%5J%3><%8493<49:%
7;52%@>98>%D7=98:B%4<B:3952=%
35%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%3><54AU%
:4<%;4<=7D<6%
35%<R9=3H%)><%J94=3%
5J%3><=<%
9=%
T:8854692?%
92%;938>%
@>98>F%@>9B<%C<92?%69=39283%
H%3><%C<B9<J%3>:3%:2A%3@5%85BB<83952=%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

dZ%

!""#$%

&'()#%

8523<23F%=>:4<%3><%=:D<%353:B%923<4I:B%8523<23%H%H% H% :4<%<E79I:B<23HHHH% dX%


^>:3<I<4%>9=%69=:?4<<D<23%
D9?>3%C<% @93>%3>9=%:==7D;3952F%93%9=% 253%:%
@93>%
3><%
5J%;938>.%
8B:==%=<3%<E79I:B<28<%
6
<J9293952%
:=%<R;4<==<6%
92%
69=:?4<<D<23%
)><%/3478374<%
!352:B%
@
>98>%
9=%
C:=<6%
3
><%
8523<23%
5J%
:%
L7=98F%
5J%
7;52% ;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:26%253%93=%353:B%
923<4I:B%
8523<23H%
:26%8528<;3=%
849398=%
>:I<%=:96%3>:3%
3><%;458<674<=%
5J%72546<4<6%
'88:=952:BBA%
=<3%
6<49I<%
J45D%
XN.352<%
:
4<%
3
><4<J54<%
:26%
;938>.8B:==% :2:BA=9=%
3><54A%
92:;;45;49.%
:3<%@><2%:;;B9<6%35%252.3@<BI<.352<%
D7=98H%&54%<R:D;B<F%(98>:46%/@9J3K=%
4<8<23%<R3<26<6%:4398B<%52%3><%XN.352<%:??4<?:3<%8523:92=%3><%J5BB5@92?%
5C=<4I:3952W%
K)>:3%:??4<?:3<%
85D;5=93952%
D:A%@<BB%C<%:% I9:CB<%D<:2=%5J%
3
5%3><%
5J%
D78>%
D7=98%>:=%253%J:9B<6%35%
:;;45:8>%
:2:BA=9=%
3@<239<3>.8<2374A%
:334:83%
3><%:33<23952%
5J%=5D<%3><549=3=KH%
)5%3>9=%
9=%:33:8><6%
=3:3<D<23%
:%J553253<W%
K)><%/3478374<%
XZfV%
9
=%
:
%
4<8<23%
35%
=78>%
T0:B<F%
5J!352:BL7=98%
j=98mUF%
:33<D;3% J548<%
9235%
:
%3@<BI<.352<%
3><54<398:B%
D5B6KHdN%
9=%
:%D9=726<4.%
3><4<%
:??4<?:3<=%
,B<:4BA%
><4<H%G2546<4<6%
=<3%3><54A%
@:=%253%6<I<B5;<6%@93>92%
K:%
=3:2692?%
;938>.8B:==%
3@<BI<.352<%
3><54<398:B%
C
73%
@
:=%
6<49I<6%
:26%
D5B6KF%
926<;<26<23BA% 9267839I<BA%
3><%923<2=9I<%
3>457?>%
=376A%5J%:%?556%6<:B%5J%D7=98H%+26<<6F%:=%+%92698:3<6%
<:4B9<4%
92%DA%85DD<23=%
52%3><%@54O%5J%L:43>:%-A6<%T;HdVUF%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%
9BB7D92:3<=%
XN.%
3
52<%
)
><%
D
7=98H%
=<3%
546<4<6%
5J%
X
N.352<%
:2:BA=9=%
8528<;3=%
3><54A%
:4<%52BA%
4<B<I:23%
35%3><%=376A%
5J%D7=98%
92%@>98>%
3><%
72546<4<6%
=<3%9=%
;<49;><4:BBA%
3><%C:=98%=3478374:B%
7293H%
/5D<%849398=%
>:I<%=:96%3>:3%@><2%D7=98%9=%:2:BA=<6%7=92?%3<8>29E7<=%
5J%
72546<4<6%
=<3%
5
J%
3>:3%
=
78>%
:=%
;938>.8B:==% :2:BA=9=%9D;543:23%
D7=98F%
:=;<83=%
C
<%5I<4B55O<6%
54%
)><%
9=%
5
J%
8
574=<H%
39DC4<F%
D:A%
9?254<6H% 85D;B:923% =;<8957=F%
-5@<I<4%34:2=;:4<23%
3>9=%;B5A%5J%3><%849398%
D:A%C<%.% :26F%5J%8574=<F%D7=98%
.% 93%>:=%3<D;3<6%
9=%
2
53%
9
3=%
<
R8B7=9I<%
J9<B6%
5J%
D54<%
3>:2%
52<H%
:2:BA=9=%
:;;B98:3952%
&54%<R:D;B<F%
:%4<I9<@%
5J%)><%/3478374<%
!
352:B%
9
2%
L7=98%
:%&4<28>%
5J%
;<495698:B%
8493989M<6%
3><%7=<%5J%:%4<678<6%
=854<%5J%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
&9I<%*9<8<=%J54%
'48><=34:F%
C<8:7=<%3><%:2:BA=9=%
@:=%3><2%
J587=<6%
52%;938>F%
D5I<D<23F%
';H%XcF%3>946%
=5B<BA%
9
2%3><%
4<I9<@<4K=%
K
H%H%H%3><%
C:=9=%5J%
3>9=%
9=%:%39DC4:B%
@><4<:=F%
@546=F%
;9<8<%
:DC9?793AH%H%HKHdd% $5@F% <I<4A52<%O25@=%3>:3%39DC4<%9=% :% J726:D<23:B%
5J%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
D5I<D<23H%
^>:3%3><%:2:BA=9=%
92%)><%
85D;52<23%
';H%XcF%3>946%
/3478374<%
!352:B%
L
7=98%
9
=%3>:3%
3><%@54O%
9=%8:25298%
5J%
4<I<:B<6F%>5@<I<4F%
3><%8:25298%=3478374<%
9=%8528<:B<6%CA%3><%39DC4:B%
C73%
3>457?>573o%
=74J:8<F%
)><%=:D<%
4
<I9<@<4%
:C573%
3
><%
7
=<%
5J%
:
%4<678<6%
=
854<%
72:DC9?757=H%
85D;B:92=%
J54%
3><%K1:2=<%=:84:B<K%D5I<D<23%
5J%/34:I92=OAK=%
)><%(93<%5J%/;492?F%
8B:9D92?%
3>:3%@>:3%><%3<4D=%3><%K?B5C:B%=3478374<K%
5J%3><%D7=98%9=%K:==74<6%HHH% CA%
-<4<%3><%;4:8398:B%
5J%;4<=<2392?%
:%E7:=9.=854<%
5J%:%
4>A3>DKHdV%
4<E794<D<23=%
5J%
D
7=98%
6
983:3<6%
3><%
5
D9==952%
5J%
B:4?<%=<?D<23%
253:3952F%
4>A3>D98%
92I9392?%
8493989=D%
5J%3><%3A;<%
B<I<BB<6%
@493<4H%
3><%8493989=D%
9=%P7=39J9<6%
CA%3>9=%
-5@<I<4F%
92=5J:4%
:=%)><%-:4D5298%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?%696%253%69=87==%
J<:374<=%
5J%3><%D7=98o%926<<6F%93%<R;B9893BA%
<R8B76<6%3><D%J45D%
4>A3>D98%
:=%
<I<2%
>
:I<%
C
<<2%
393B<%
5J%
=A=3<D:398%
852=96<4:3952F%D9?>3%
=7??<=3<6%
CA%3><%I<4A%
3><%C55OH%
)><%<R3<23%
35%@>98>%
52<%8:2%?<2<4:B9M<%
:C573%252.352:B%
D7=98=%
9=%:%D:33<4%
5J%
Vb%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF% XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

3><%3<4D%
K:352:BK%>:=%52BA%:%
)><4<%:4<%3>5=<%@>5%J<<B%3>:3%
=5D<%69=:?4<<D<23H%
B9D93<6%
&54%
:;;B98:C9B93AH% <R:D;B<W%
5J%85D;5=93952:B%
:%@96<%4:2?<%
6<B9D93=%
3>7=%
;4:8398<=%
457?>BA%
!352:B93A%
:26%923<44<B:3<6%
5J%3><%254D:39I<%
:4<%3><%:C=<28<%
@>5=<%52BA%J<:374<=%
35%C<%
+3%4<D:92=%
5J%
=<49:B9=DH%
3><%
C:=98%
5J%
:26%
5J%
8528<;3%
352:B93A%
;458<674<=%
D7=98:B%
54%4<B<I:23%
9=%:%7=<J7B%
<R3<23%
=<<2%
35%@>:3%
8:3<?54AHd\%
:352:B93A%
893<6%<:4B9<4F%
52%3><%:C=<28<%5J%4>A3>D98%
)>9=%I9<@F%B9O<%3><%85DD<23%
:2:BA=9=%
:26%
D7=98%92%?<2<4:B%
5J%4<=<:48>%
52%3@<239<3>.8<2374A%
=3:3<%
4<JB<83=%
3><%8744<23%
35%
-<4<%3><%:73>54=%
D7=98%92%;:43987B:4H%
=:A%93%4<D:92=%
3@<239<3>.8<2374A%
<:4BA%
:%
35%C<%652<H%-5@<I<4F%
4<D:92=%
L78>%@54O%
9=%8<43:92BA%
347<H%
C<%=<<2F%:26%3>:3%
92%4<8<23%
@54O%>:=%C<<2%85D;B<3<6%
5J%4<B<I:23%
:D5723%
852=96<4:CB<%
:2:BA398:B%
.% D78>%5J%93%:J3<4%
@:=%
3><%E753:3952%
@>98>%+%<R34:83<6%
J45D%
3><%:4398B<%
A<:4=%
.% :26%3>9=%
5J%:%K85DD52%
3><%<R9=3<28<%
@54O%
@4933<2%
;4:8398<K%
=7??<=3=%
=3452?BA%
:26%I:49<6%
:%B:4?<%
@>98>%
:%;4:8398<%
92%3><%<:4BA%
3@<239<3>%
92854;54:3<=%
8<2374AF%
5J%
@93>%3><%:352:B%@54O=%
D7=98%3>:3%9=%253%85<R3<2=9I<%
5J%252.352:B%
4<;<4354A%
3><%:352:B%D7=98%5J%3><%
#I<2%3>:3%4<;<4354AF%
:26%>9=%=376<23=H%
/8>5<2C<4?%
35%93=%
@93>%
726<4=3556%
K=<8526%h9<22<=<%
4<=;<83%
=8>55BKF%>:=%C<<2%92:6<E7:3<BA%
>:=%
)><%/3478374<%
>9=35498:B%
5J%!352:B%L7=98F%52<%@493<4%
;5=93952H%(<I9<@92?%
5C=<4I<6W%
+3%@9BB%C<%:4?7<6%
35F%J54%<R:D;B<F%
CA%=5D<%3>:3%35%:;;BA%=<3%3><54A%
:26%
93=%KJ4<<K%
2:374<%
9=%35%J:B=9JA%
"933B<%
*9:25%
*9<8<F%
';H%XZYc%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
'2%3><%
5J%:%3@<BI<.352<%
93%35%:%D<4<%
4<678<%
85D;5=93952H%
:23989;:3952%
:C573%
3><%
8B:49J9<=%
9=%729E7<%
&543<K=%
@>:3%
D7=98F%
>5@<I<4F%
=A=3<D%
85234:4AF%
><%
@54O=%
@>98>%
:26%
5J%
3
>5=<%
8
5><4<28<%
:26%3><%9269==5B7CB<%
85D;B<R93A%
+2%
>:I<%2<I<4%
C<<2%D54<%
6<D52=34:3<6H%
92%6<3:9B%
<R:D92<=%
852I92892?BA%
@93>%
3><%
5J%
92%@>98>%
3><94%
J4<<65D%
85234:=3=%
3><%
=<2=<%
;49289;B<=%
;:43987B:4F%
3
@<BI<.253<%
J7374<%
8:2%
C
<%
6<J92<6Hdc%
352:B%
:26%
;4<89=<BA%
;:=3%
35%
8523927<%
@9BB%72657C3<6BA%
)5%D5I<%:B52?%35%:253><4%
9==7<F%:26%52<%3>:3%
3
><%
+%=7DD52%
=5D<%
4
<B783:28<%
9
2%
J543>%
@93>%
><:3%
852=96<4:CB<%
J7374<F%
?<2<4:3<%
D52=3<4%
@>5=<%2:D<%9=%K)52:B%56<4%!352:BKH%
3><%3@5.><:6<6%
92%
)><4<%:4<%D:2AF%;<4>:;=%I<4A%D:2AF%@>5%C<B9<I<%3>:3%252.352:BF%
92%
9
=%:%
:BB%
=5D<%
D
7=98%
3>:3%
D7=98%
K:352:BK%
=<2=<F%
9=F%
D9=;<48<;3952F%
;:43987B:4F%
D7=98%9=%3><2%
=<3%:2:BA398:B%
35%:352:B%
352:BH%)5%:;;BA%;938>.8B:==%
9;=5%
3<8>29E7<=%
J:835%9BB<?:B%:3%@54=3%:26%=7=;<83%:3%C<=3H%)>9=%I9<@%D:A%3:O<%:%D9B6%:26%
92%3><%J5BB5@92?%
J45D%
/:D=52W%
:=%<R;4<==<6%
g9D%
J54DF%
E753:3952%
D<69:392?%
:=%65<=%
35%K:352:B93AK%
=>57B6%
4:3><4%
!2%:2:BA398:B%
j9H<HF%253%
C<?92%
:;;45:8>%

)><%/3478374<%
:%@96<%4:2?<%5J%923<4:8392?%
5J%!352:B%L7=98m%CA%:88<;392?%
92%:2%5<7I4<%@><4<%34:693952%
:26%9225I:3952%
:4<%92<R3498:CBA%
J7283952=%

B9<=%:=%D78>%
52%3><%<R;B54:3952%
5J%2<@%
923<4@5I<2%
:26%@><4<%
<D;>:=9=%
4<=5748<=%
:=%52%3><94%
54?:29M:3952Hdf%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF% XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VX%

!""#$%

&'()#%

35%3>9=%;5923%5J%I9<@F%@>98>%D:AF%
+%:D%253%353:BBA%
72=AD;:3><398%
!B3>57?>%
@54O=%
92%8<43:92%
34:2=93952:B%
/849:C92%
926<<6F%>:I<%=5D<%D<493%
CA%/8>5<2C<4?F%
+%C<B9<I<%
:26%53><4=F%
3>:3%
:2%>9=35498:B%
J:83%
3>:3%
6<3<4D92<=%
:352:B93A%
4<;4<=<23=%
2:D<%@93>%
@>98>%
3>9=%
D7=98:B%
)><%I<4A%
@:=%
6<I<B5;D<23%
:2:BA398:B%
;4954939<=H%
5J%K:D7=98:BKF%
=7;;B9<6%CA% =5D<%72O25@2%849398F%@93>%93=%852253:3952=%
<I<2%K:3><9=398KF%
>:=%<28574:?<6%
:2%7B34:852=<4I:39I<%
=3:28<H%)>9=%
K:?25=398KF%
5J%:%4<8<23%
<R34<D<%
I9<@%9=%@<BB%4<;4<=<23<6%
5J%
=376A%
CA%^9BB%'?652F%:73>54%
:26%=5D<@>:3%
352:B9=3%
@>5%
;<37B:23%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
';H%XXF%$5H%XF%:%C<B<:?7<4<6%
@493<=%
:=%J5BB5@=%
2<:4%3><%C<?92292?%
5J%>9=%<==:AW%
35%I<2374<%
69I<4=<%
52%3><%
)><%85D;<393952%
3>5=<%
:D52?%
@9BB92?%
5;92952=%
@>9B<%
3><%=8542J7BF%
B<6%CA%
5J%';7=%XX%9=%B9I<BAF%
35%=:A%3><%B<:=3F%
352:B93A%
:26%=<3%
92%3><%
*<4B<%
5JJ<4%
D539I98%
:26%!B:2%
&543<F%
:2:BA=9=%
;B:8<%
j=98m%
k<54?<%
5J%352:B%
923<4;4<3:3952H%
)><%:73>54%
5J%3>9=%
9=%<R34<D<BA%
=376A%
;452<%35%94493:3952W%
+3%9=%:B=5%94493:392?%
35%4<:6%3><%
@54O%
5J%4<;73:CB<%
3><549=3=%
:26%
j9H<HF%*<4B<%
65%253%
@>5%
C53><4%
35%69=87==%
=3478374:B%
4<B:3952=%
:26%J728395292?%
92%
&543<m%
:C=34:83%
I:4957=%
253<%
=<3=H%
';7=%XX%<I<2%
3>57?>%
3><A%
$5@F%@>9B<%+%65%253%@9=>%35%=;<:O%J54%k<54?<%*<4B<%.% ><%9=%E793<%:CB<%35%
.% +%@9BB%;5923%
:=%><%>:=%:D;BA%
6<D52=34:3<6%
5I<4%3><%A<:4=%
>9D=<BJF%
4<;4<=<23%
573%3>:3%C53>%*<4B<%:26%+%7=<6%3><%C<?92292?%
5J%';H% XXF%$5H% XF%35%9BB7=34:3<%
253%923<2692?%
35%;45I96<%
@>98>%@57B6%>:I<%
=;<89J98%
;5923=F%
85D;B<3<%
:2:BA=<=%
B<6%35%852=96<4:3952=%
5J%K=3478374:B%
4<B:3952=%
:26%J728395292?KHdZ%
:%4<B:39I<BA%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
5J%
+%696%;7CB9=>F%
>5@<I<4F%
85D;4<><2=9I<%
;938>.8B:==%
';H% XXF%$5H% XF%92%3><%=:D<%9==7<%5J%3><%P5742:B%92%@>98>%3><%=376A%CA%3>9=%
724<852=39373<6%
352:B9=3%
:;;<:4<6H%T+% >:=3<2%35%:66%3>:3%><%>:6%253%=<<2%DA%
:3%3><%39D<%
><%;4<;:4<6%
93%@:=%;7CB9=><6HU%
:2:BA=9=%
>9=F%254%696%+%4<:6%>9=%7239B%
^93>%3><%96<:%3>:3%
93%@57B6%C<%923<4<=392?F%
253%5I<4BA%
35%
:26F%+%347=3F%
94493:392?F%
5J%3><%352:B%:26%3><%:352:B%:2:BA=<=F%
+%>:I<%
85D;:4<%4<;4<=<23:39I<%
;543952=%
92%#R=%VC%:26%V8H%
;45I96<6%
<R8<4;3=%
+%85DD<23%
Q<J54<%
92%:2%92J54D:B%
7;52%3><=<F%+%@57B6%B9O<%35%<=3:CB9=>%
@:A%
@>:3%+%3:O<%35%C<%3>4<<%4<:=52:CB<%:26%=34:9?>3J54@:46%
@>98>%:2A%
8493<49:%
=>57B6%=:39=JAW%
:2:BA398:B%
726<43:O92?%
TXU%85D;B<3<2<==o%
TNU%852=9=3<28Ao%
TdU%
+%=9D;BA%
D<:2%3>:3%:BB%85D;52<23=%
5J%3><%;938>%
3<=3:C9B93AH%
QA%K85D;B<3<2<==K%
=3478374<%
C<%928B76<6%
92%3><%:2:BA=9=H%
+%D<:2%3>:3%
3><%
QA%K852=9=3<28AK%
:2:BA398:B%
C<%:;;B9<6%852=9=3<23BAF%
@93>573%
:6%>58%D<3>56=H%
!26%
;458<674<=%
9234567892?%
+%D<:2%3>:3%69JJ<4<23%
@57B6%
CA%K3<=3:C9B93AK%
:2:BA=3=%
7=92?%3><%=:D<%D<3>56%
3>:3%923<4=<83%
92%=9?29J98:23%
8493<4952%
;45678<%4<=7B3=%
@:A=H%)><%B:33<4%
9=F%5J%
5J%J:4%D54<%<R3<2=9I<%
69=87==952%
3>:2%8:2%C<%:88546<6%
93%><4<H%
8574=<F%@543>A%
J<<B=%3>:3%93%9=%5J%25%9D;543:28<F%
J54%><%@<B85D<=F%
54%=5%93%
'?652%:;;:4<23BA%
=<<D=F%K69I<4=<%5;92952=KH%^><3><4%
';H% XXF%$5H% XF%9=%92%#%D9254F%
*>4A?9:2%
:=%B52?%:=%93%9=%K352:BKH%
D56<F%54%#C%9=%5J%25%8528<42F%
VN%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF% XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

+2%546<4%
35%4<:6%3><%352:B%
93%@93>%
3><%:352:B%T;938>.8B:==%
:26%85D;:4<%
:2:BA=9=%
=<3%:2:BA=9=U%
35%726<4=3:26%
5J%3><%5;<292?%
D7=98%
5J%';H%XXF%$5H%XF%93%9=%2<8<==:4A%
3><%k%=8:B<F%
@93>92%
3><%:73>54K=%=ADC5B=%
52%>9=%<R:D;B<H%L<B5698%;B:8<D<23%
3><%
9=%K3><%;49D<%
352:B%
:R9=K%5J%3><%
@>98>%
:73>54%
8523<26=%
9=%=ADC5B9M<6%
3><D<VbF%
92%>9=%:2:BA=9=%T#RH%VCU%K;5923%35%
35%3><%3:CB<%92%#RH%V:H%!445@=%
:8854692?%
C<%
3><%KI598<%B<:692?KF%
>:4D5298%
*
938><=%
4
<253:3<6%
35%8B:49JA%
4553=K%
D:A%
T;H%XfXUH%
5J%3><%O926H%
54%
3><%
D<:2=%
3<26<289<=%
@
>98>%
:
73>54%
=5D<3>92?%
CA%
=8:B<.6<?4<<%
9=%4<@4933<2%
:=%!C%:26%
)>7=F%3><%=<8526%253<%92%3><%7;;<4.I598<%
D<B56AF%
kiF%
92%3>9=%@:A%K8B:49J9<=%
3><%352:B%;495493A%
5J%k%92%D<:=74<%N%H% H% HK% T;H%XfNUH%
:=% ,iF%3>7=%
3><%922<4.I598<%
/9D9B:4BAF%
1C% 92%CH%d%5J%#RH% VC%9=%4<253:3<6%
)><=<%253:3952:B%
@
93>%
=
8:B<%
i
VF%
9D;B98:3952H%
C<85D92?%
6<?4<<%
B<:692?.253<%
J54%
5J%852=9=3<28AF%
=928<%3><4<%
:4<%25%47B<=%
<2845:8>%
7;52%3><%8493<4952%
8>:2?<=%
>5@%
=>57B6%
D:6<H%
)
><%
@><2%
:
26%
C
<%
>
5@<I<4F%
65<=F%
:2:BA=3%
3><A%
6<3<4D9292?%
35%!C%92%3><%C:==%5J%CH%V%:26%92%3><%7;;<4%
D:O<%3><%=:D<%8>:2?<%J45D%
ki%
C<3@<<2%
3><%253:3952:B%
I598<%5J%CH% XF%3>7=%;4<=<4I92?%
8544<=;526<28<%
!C%:26%
92%3><%
3><%3@5%D5D<23=%
Q%@>98>%
J54D%
923<4I:B%
8B:==%dF%;45I9692?%
:%B92O%C<3@<<2%
D7=98H%
92%#RH%VCH%
5J%3><%5;<292?%
5J%';H%XXF%=>5@2%
"<3%7=%25@%4<:6%3><%352:B%
:2:BA=9=%
35%
+%>:I<%85DC92<6%
3><%;7CB9=><6%
:4398B<%
92%546<4%
3><%:2:BA=3K=%
#R=%X%:26%V%J45D%
5
J%
#
RH%\%92%3><%
=>5@%3><%=:D<%=;:2%5J%D7=98%:=%=>5@2%92%3><%J94=3%
;:43% DA%
><%4<?:46=%
:=%65%+H%)><%7;;<4%I598<%5J%
:%=;:2%@>98>%
:=%:%7293F%
:4398B<F%
;7CB9=><6%
q%d%35%=8:B<%6<?4<<%
=8:B<%6<?4<<%
3>9=%
6<=849C<=%
:%6<=8<2692?%
cF%
;:3>%J45D%
:2:BA=9=%
3>9=%
=8:B<%6<?4<<%c%35%=8:B<%6<?4<<%XH%!885D;:2A92?%
3><2%=O9;=%7;@:46%J45D%
C<B5@%
>:4D529<=%
92698:3<6%
:4<%3><%J7283952:B%
CA%3><%(5D:2%27D<4:B=%
D<B56A%
3
><%
3><%=3:JJ%
92%#RH%VCW%+.++% :B3<4<6%
-5@%+%9=%
J54D<6%
5J%
:26%
+H%
Th% hU%
CA% ;938><=%
5J%&i%
9=%253%<R;B:92<6H%+2%;:43987B:4F%
3><%J7283952%
3>:3%85D;49=<%
3>9=%D<:=74<%
92%3>9=%
93%
9
3=%
:=%
4
<B:3<=%
35%
7
292JB<83<6%
&F%9=%
852=3<BB:3952F%
85723<4;:43F%
<=;<89:BBA%
B<J3%=>4576<6%92%DA=3<4AF%
254%9=%3><%6<=9?2:3952%
5J%4553=%C7334<==<6%
CA%
3><54<398:B%
93%9=%;<4>:;=%@543>%
3>:3%:%
T+2%3>9=%8522<83952F%
25392?%
:4?7D<23H%
@57B6%8:BB%Q%3><%4553%
4553%
5J%3><%C<=3%923<4I:BF%
-926<D93>9:2%
=928<%93%9=%3><%
><4<F%
3><%J9J3>HU%
9=%
3><%=788<==952%
)><%>:4D5298%
D5=3%
;45?4<==952%
<=;<89:BBA%
;<87B9:4F%
3><%
857B6%>:I<%
h%5J%h%35%+H%^>:3%C<8:D<%5J%3><%65D92:23a%
:
73>54%
!B3>57?>%
5J%:2%<=8:;<%>:38>%:B@:A=%:3%>:26%35%3><%
<I5O<6%K<B9=952KF%:I:9B92?%>9D=<BJ%
=>4<@6%
J54%3>9=%
><%65<=%253%65%=5F%254%65<=%><%5JJ<4%
:2A%<R;B:2:3952%
:2:BA=3F%
C73%
:%
3
><%
<26=%52%+%92%C=%
+% 3>:3%9=%
V.\F%
&92:BBAF% ;45?4<==952%
;45?4<==952H%
@93>%
35%
+
%92%
C
H%NH%)>9=%
=<8526%
+%9=%253%
J45D%
3><%
69JJ<4<23F% 4<=;<83% ;938>%
8523<23F%
:=%
3
><%
3>4<<%
C<B5@%
3
><%
B5@<4%
92%
92698:3<6%
B<I<B=%
5J%
=3:I<%
72<E79I58:BF%
CA%
=ADC5B=%
C=%V.\F%@>98>%
:4<%6<=849C<6%
3
><%
:
73>54%
8:6<28<K%
:=%:%K87C9=3%
@9BB%
CA%
T;H%XfNUH%+%
253%E753<% 54% :33<D;3%35% ;:4:;>4:=<%>9=%<R;B:2:3952%5J%3>9=%4<D:4O:CB<%
=928<%93%9=%>9?>BA%
8526<2=<6%D:3<49:B%
@>98>%9=%69JJ987B3%
J54D:3952F%
<257?>%35%
J5BB5@%
@><2%4<:6%J45D%
3><%;4923<6%
;:?<H%
+3%@57B6%C<%>:46%35%9D:?92<%
:%4<:692?%
5J%3>9=%
D7=98%
3>:3%
69JJ<4=%
D54<%
J45D%
3><%
352:B%4<:692?%
3>:2%
=<3%4<:692?%
92%#RH%V8H%+2%
3><%;938>.8B:==%
=>5@2%
P7=3%=74I<A<6%
#RH% V8F%3><%J7BB%
D7=98%253:3952%
9=%?9I<2%
:3%3><%35;F%92%93=%549?92:B%
@93>573%
J54DF%
<2>:4D5298%
:26%
C
<B5@%
3
>:3%
9=%
:
%
B<33<4.2:D<%
=7C=39373952=F%
8544<=;526.%
69:?4:D%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/% VWXYNF% XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vd%

!""#$% &'()#%

#RH%V%

!%

kC%
k% ki% !C%!% !i% QC% Q% ,% ,i% 1C% 1% 1i% #C% #% +&% &i%
X% iX% CN% N% iN% .d% qd% V% iV% C\% \% i\+% .c% qcXf% if% CB%

N% X% N%f% f% c% qc%X%
qd%
+%
F+%K%

K%

HHHHHH% .%
..%

FX+%K%

Th5J%hU%

kW%

ki%k% !%

c.NX%

H%aK%

&%

\%

X%

h%
$%

\%

k%

##% *k%
1Ck%

&%

!% +%

1%

QC%

QC%

ki%

,%

d%

N%

+%

*.N%

Q%

c.Xc%

=d;%

N%

+h54%++%

N%

f%
b%

Q%

4J*%

_N%

QC% Q% 4%

Q%

&i!%

!i%Q%

ki%

Q\.ldf%
.c.ldZ%

T85D;B<D<23% 5J% c.NXbU%

D7=98%
@93>%
=<3%85D;52<23=%
92698:3<6%
92?%35%3><%
253:3952F%
;938>.8B:==%
CA%C5R<=%35%
@>98>%
:4<%:33:8><6%
=<3%2:D<=H%*<4>:;=%3><%D5=3%C:=98%69JJ<4<28<%
C<3@<<2%
3>9=%
9=%3><%@:A%92%@>98>%3><%D7=98%9=%=<?D<23<6H%
4<:692?%:26%3><%352:B%4<:692?%
+2=3<:6%5J%J5BB5@92?%
3><%C:4.CA.C:4%
5J%3><%352:B%4<:692?F%
3>9=%
=<?D<23:3952%

VV%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%
XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

35%C<%
I598<%5J%C=%X.d%9=%3:O<2%
3><%7;;<4%
:%=9D;B<4%
=34:3<?AW%
:65;3=%
923<4;4<3:3952%
)><%7;;<4%;:43%3><2%
:253><4H%
B5@<4%
52<%D7=98:B%
7293F%3><%:885D;:2A92?%
;:43=%
@>9B<%3><%:8.%
5J%/8>5<2C<4?K=F%
;4<=<23=%3><%><R:8>546%c.lXbF% :% J:I5493<%
9=%3><%8544<83%
3>:3%
3>9=%
=7D%35%c.XcH%!2:BA398:B%
@:A%35%
;455J%
;:43=%
85D;:2A92?%
.% 9=%:D;BA%
.% @93>%
35%93=%><R:8>546:B%
3><%5;<292?%
85D;52<23=%
4<=;<83%
=<?D<23%
4<874%92%D7B39;B<%
CA%3><%4<=3%5J%3><%;9<8<F%@><4<%C53>%><R:8>546=%
;45I96<6%
9=%3><%C:=98%
J54D=H%
I:49:3952KF%
+26<<6F%4<;<393952F%
K6<I<B5;92?%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
92%3>9=%
D7=98:B%
85D;5=93952H%
;458<==%
9235%7;;<4%:26%B5@<4%;:43=H%)><%
Q:4=%V.\%T#RH%V8U%:?:92%=<?D<23%
2:374:BBA%
92%
B5@<4%;:43=%;4<=<23%:% 2<@% ><R:8>546F%c.ldZ% T&i.ki.!.!i.Q.1F%
5J%=<3.8B:==%
3>9=%
=<3%8B:==%9=%3><%85D;B<D<23%
254D:B%
c.l%XbH%
546<4UH%
(<D:4O:CBAF%
3><%D<B5698%
6<49I<=%
J45D%
5J%3><%852=<E7<23%
;>4:=<%
)>7=F%3><%:885D;:29D<23%
5J%3><%:23<8<6<23%
3><D<%
CA%34:2=;5=9.%
TJ5BB5@<6%
;>4:=<%CA%85D;B<D<23:3952%
3>:3%
254%696%+%65%=5%92%3><%:4398B<F%
@93>%
><4<F%
3952F%
3r[UH%+%65%253%@9=>%35%=7??<=3%
:3%3>9=%<:4BA%;4<.XN.352<%
3<4D=%
92%=78>%=A=3<D:398%
@:=%3>92O92?%
/8>5<2C<4?%
:26%923<4I:B%
O2<@%:C573%85D;B<D<23:3952%
=3:?<o%>5@<I<4F%><% 8<43:92BA%
C73%
)><%4<B:3952%
3<4D=H%
34:693952:B%
<I<2%92%3><%D5=3%
D:A%C<%K:C=34:83KF%
8523<23F%
5J%
:%C49<J%
6<D52=34:3952%
4<:BH%":3<4%92%3>9=%;:;<4%+%@9BB%5JJ<4%
93%9=%252<3><B<==%
92%D54<%9DD<69:3<%
=<3=%D:A%C<%:==589:3<6%
@:A=%92%@>98>%85D;B<D<23.4<B:3<6%
@:A=H%
:B=5%>:=%D7B39;B<%
3><%;<23:6%
5J%C=%V.\%;4<=<23%
)><%7;;<4%;:43=%
\.ld[F%@>98>%
:=%
93%9=%9DD<69:3<BA%
D7=98H%+2%J:83F%
92%3><%=7C=<E7<23%
D:29J<=3:3952=%
4<;B98:3<6F%
5J%&i.k.ki.Q.1%
=>5@2%92%#RH%V8F%CA%3><%852J9?74:3952%
T254D:B%
852=9=392?%
5J%\.ld[%
+)cUH% )><%3@5%J54D=%
546<4UF%:2%92I<43<6%
T=;<89J98:BBAF%
34:2=;5=93952%
:=%:%D:P54%
C<8:7=<%5J%93=%45B<%
:R9=%923<4I:B%
923<4=<83%
92%3><%6A:6%k.QF%:%=9?29J98:23%
:=%;:43%5J%3><%
D<B5698%?<=374<%
5J%3><%92939:B%
:26F%92%3>9=%8523<R3F%
85D;52<23%
J45D%
3><%
C
:==%
69=39283%
:26%
3498>546F%
7;F%ki.Q.kF%
4>A3>D98:BBA%
674:3952:BBA%
+%
D<B5698%3498>546H%
35%;938>%8B:==F%35%3><%J94=3%
@93>%4<=;<83%
@>98>%9=%96<2398:BF%
92%
5J%
3
><%
3
52:B%
3
><%
:
73>54%
5J%
5C=<4I:3952%
35%
3>9=%
5JJ<4%
:2:BA=9=%
=
7;;543%
:2:BA398:B%
>9D%253%:%85D;B<3<%
3>:3%
+%:D%?9I92?%
>9=%k.352:B93A%
349:6F%
>5@<I<4F%
3><=9=o%
253<F%
92%
>:I<%B933B<%
-<%@9BB%
25%657C3%
3>946%
5J%:%D:P54%
349:6H%
C73%52BA%
3><%
B5@<4%
69JJ987B3A%
<B<D<23H%
:6693952:B%
3><%
B58:392?% 4<E794<6%
D7=98%D:A%C<%D<23952<6%
5J%3><%=<3%=3478374<%
5J%3><%5;<292?%
'3><4%J<:374<=%
c.NX%
:%
:26%3>9=%=7C=<E7<23BA%
3><%
>
<R:8>546%
9=%
><4<F%
&94=3F%
85D;52<23%
C49<JBAH%
93%
92%C=%Z.XXF%@><4<%
3>:3%
5J%3><%D7=98%
=74J:8<=%
:=%3><%7;;<4.I598<%
D<B56A%
C<?92=%
/
<3%\.ld[%9=%
:=%c.lXb%92%3><%
>:=%3><%=:D<%4>A3>D98%
=>:;<%
5;<292?%;>4:=<H%
#R=%X%
@93>%
3><%;<23:6%\.lX[F%69=87==<6%
92%8522<83952%
@93>%
:==589:3<6%
=3452?BA%
5J%3>:3%=<3F%><28<%>:=%3><%=:D<%353:B%
:26%NF%=928<%93%9=%3><%l.8544<=;526<23%
93=%
923<4I:B%
8523<23H%/<3%\.ldfF%3><%3<254%D<B56A%5J%C=%V.\F% J54<=>:65@=%
5J%3><%
@>98>%9=%
:3%3><%
f
.ldfF%
I<4A%C<?92292?%
85D;B<D<23F%
<R;4<==<6%
:4<%c.lXb%:26%
@><4<%:D52?%93=%;49289;:B%
852=3937<23=%
=<83952F%
6<I<B5;D<23%
:=%+%>:I<%
5J%
3><%
D7=98F%
c.XcF%3><%;49289;:B%
5
;<292?%
85D;52<23=%
J54<?45726%
:=%@<%65%
5J%';H%XXF%$5H%XF%@<%J926F%
92%3>9=%
D7=98%
!26%J92:BBAF%
92698:3<6H%
5;<292?%
92%:BB%3><%D7=98%:J3<4%3><%XZb\%=52?=%5J%';H% cF%/8>5<2C<4?K=%=9?2:374<F%
:BD5=3%
J54%/8>5<2C<4?%
#=.,.-.Q.#.kF% ><4<%34:2=;5=<6%
7;%=9R%=<D9352<=F%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%

XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

V\%

!""#$%

&'()#%

2<I<4%
3><%><R:8>546%
92%93=%B93<4:B%
J54DH%
;4<=<23<6%
+%=7CD93%
3>:3%3><%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%4<:692?%
T@>98>%=>5@=%52BA%52<%B<I<B%5J%=<3%
:26%9=%253%923<26<6%
=3478374<%
35%C<%:%KJ929=><6K%
9=%85D;B<3<F%
92%3><%=<2=<%
:2:BA=9=U%
3>:3%25%;938>%
:4<%
:26%
92%
3
><%
=
<2=<%
3>:3%
:6%>58%
5
D933<6F%
852=9=3<23F%
85D;52<23=%
D<3>56=%
@<4<%
253%C457?>3%
9235%
+
3%
:
B=5%
5
C=<4I<=%
3><%
8493<4952%
5J%
;B:AH%
3<=3:C9B93AF%
=928<%:2A%34:92<6%
=<3%;458<674<=%
92%3><%<2394<%
:2:BA=3%
7=92?%
;938>.8B:==%
;9<8<%@9BB%
85D<%7;%@93>%
4<=7B3=%
=9D9B:4%
35%3>5=<%
><4<H%
;4<=<23<6%
)5%8523927<%
@93>%DA%=74I<AF%
+%253<%3>:3%=5D<%5C=<4I<4=%
>:I<%J<B3%
3>:3%3><%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
:4<%355%D<8>:298:B%
:26%3><%8528<;3=%
355%
;458<674<=%
3>:3%:2%:2:BA=9=%
=>57B6%253%C<%5I<4BA%
85D;B<RH%^>9B<%+%:?4<<F%92%;49289;B<F%
92%93=%<JJ543%
35%<B7896:3<%
3><%D7=98F%+%J926%
93%69JJ987B3%
35%726<4=3:26%
85D;B98:3<6%
35%<B<D<23:4A%
3><54<398:B%
=3:3<D<23=%
3>:3%
:4<%4<E794<6%
J54%
5CP<83952=%
:2:BA398:B%
@54OH%
,52=96<4%
3><%J5BB5@92?%
<R8<4;3W%
!26%=5%@<%:449I<%
:3%3><%J5BB5@92?%
5J%?5CCB<6<?55OW%
K)><%353:B%
;:4:?4:;>%
923<4I:B%
8523<23%
5J%:%;8%=<3%
9=%4<;4<=<23<6%
3><%
923<4I:B%
:2%546<4<6%
I<8354F%
CA%
27D<498:B%
3>:3%
3><%
27DC<4%
5J%
5J%
923<4I:B=%
<:8>%
8B:==H%H%
:44:A%
69=;B:A=%
L9B2<4%8523927<=W%KT+J%3>9=%C55O%@:=%253%@4933<2%
@93>%3><%:96%5J%:%
!23>52A%
93%
=>57B6%
>
:I<%
)><%4<J<4<28<%
35%
K:%
85D;73<4%
9=F%5J%8574=<F%
85D;73<4K%
C<<2UKHVX%
:26%
9
3%
9
=%
:==7D<6%
3>:3%
3><%
4
<:6<4%
@9BB%
=
>:4<%
3><%
4
<I9<@<4K=%
69=;:4:?92?F%
2<?:39I<%
5J%=78>%6<I98<=HVN%
35%=78>%85DD<23=%
9=%35%=;<87B:3<%
5;92952%
LA%52BA%4<=;52=<%
5J%3><%@493<4%
4<8<23%
7;52%3><%>:C93:3%
67492?%
A<:4=H%+2%3>9=%8:=<%93%=<<D=%B9O<BA%
3>:3%
><%>:=%C<<2%6@<BB92?%
726<4%:%I<4A%
B:4?<%458O%92%'73<4%L52?5B9:H%/74<BA%
O25@=%
3>:3%
2
5@%
@54O%
@93>%
6<I98<=%
<I<4A52<%
D:2A%
;<5;B<%
457392<BA%
85D;7392?%
.% :%35;98%
35%@>98>%
.% :%;:;<4%@>98>F%
+%@9BB%4<3742%
:3%
3
><%
<26%
5
J%
3
>9=%
C49<JBA%
;:;<4%
:=%+%@9BB%25@%4<I<:BF%@:=%@4933<2%
@93>%3><%:96%5J%:%85D;73<4s%
-<4<%@<%>:I<%
:253><4%
92=3:28<%
92%@>98>F%
:=%+%>:I<%B<:42<6F%
D7=98%3><54A%
:26%:2:BA=9=%
8:2%C<%
@>98>%
>9?>BA%8>:4?<6%@93>%<D53952F%<=;<89:BBA%@><2%96<:=%:4<%;4<=<23<6%
3>4<:3<2%
8><49=><6%
C<B9<J=%
:26%@<BB.92?4:92<6%
5J%I9<@H%
;5923=%
+2%:%=9D9B:4%
93%>:=%C<<2%:==<43<6%
3>:3%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
65<=%253%6<:B%
I<92F%
;938>.8B:==%
@93>%
:26%
9
=%
4<B:3<6%
35%D7=98H%+2%:%4<I9<@%
5J%
85D;5=93952:B%
;458<==%
52BA%
4<D53<BA%
)><%/3478374<%
L7=98%<2393B<6F%
K)><%(7B<=%5J%/84:CCB<KF%:2%
5J%!352:B%
:D7=92?BAF%
:252AD57=%@493<4%J4:D<=%>9=%84939E7<%@93>92%3><%:4<2:%5J%923<42:3952:B%
4<B:3952=W%K^>:3%=<3=%3><%!D<498:2%
:;;45:8>%:;:43%H%H% H%9=%93=%353:B%B:8O%5J%
8528<42%J54%>5@%3><%85D;5=<4%@54O=%54%@>:3%><%D:A%923<26%>9=%D7=98%35%
3><%>9=35498:B%
<R;4<==H%H%H%HK%&743><4%
:B52?F%3><%4<I9<@<4%
<2B:4?<=%
;<4=;<839I<F%
K^<%:4<%
J45D%
:%69=3:28<%:%*7493:2%C:8OB:=>%:?:92=3%
<R8B:9D92?W%
@932<==92?%
D7=98:B%
=928<%3><%@:4KH%)><2F%92%:2%<8=3:398%
D9R374<%
5J%
#745;<:2%
6<I<B5;D<23=%
:26%87B92:4A%
><%;458B:9D=W%
?<5B5?98:B%
D<3:;>54=F%
$53%8523<23%
35%4<?:46%
D7=98%
:=%52BA%
3>:3%
@>98>%
9=%253:3:CB<F%
*45J<==54%
&543<%
J743><4%
4<678<=%
3><%
5J%
J9<B6%
>9=%
35%:%?4933A%
5J%
253<=%
J45D%
92I<=39?:3952=%
6<;5=93%
@>98>%
92=347D<23:3952F%
:88<237:3952F%
4>A3>DF%
3<==9374:F%
3<D;5F%
6A2:D98F%
<I<2%=<E7<28<%>:I<%C<<2%C59B<6%:@:AHVd%

Vc%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

:BBF%3>:3%25%C55O%52%:2:BA398:B%
*<4>:;=%3>9=%9=%3><%39D<%35%=:AF%528<%:26%J54%
92%3><%:2:BA=9=%
3>:3%2<<6=%35%C<%85I<4<6%
5J%:2%
8:2%85I<4%:BB%3><%?45726%
3><54A%
@54OH%)>:3%)><%/3478374<%
!352:B%
L7=98%65<=%253%6<:B%<R>:7=39I<BA%
9269I967:B%
5J%
3>:3%
:26%=5%52F%65<=%253%9D;BA%
@93>%K92=347D<23:3952F%
:88<237:3952F%
4>A3>DKF%
^<4<%+%35%3:O<%=78>%8493989=D=%
3><=<%
:=%K729D;543:23KH%
93=%:73>54%
4<?:46=%
:=;<83=%
:=%:2%5;<4:354%
5J%><:IA%
=<<O%<D;B5AD<23%
+% @57B6%9DD<69:3<BA%
=<4957=BAF%
:=%C<92?%=>:BB5@BA%
92%3><%2543>%
5J%!B:=O:H%+%69=D9==%
>5@<I<4F%
3><DF%
<E79;D<23%
5J%
3><%E7<=3952%
5J%;45B52?<6%
852=96<4:3952H%
:=%72@543>A%
L54<5I<4F%
4><35498:BF%
:3%C<=3%T<I<2%@><2%3><%
9=%O2533A%
35%:2:BA=9=%
K85D;5=93952:B%
;458<==K%:=%93%4<B:3<=%
C<%69=D9==<6%
92%:%8:=7:B%
:26%52<%@>98>%
8:2%>:46BA%
9=%>9=%5@2%:2:BA=3UF%
85D;5=<4%
@:AF%:=% 696%574%4<I9<@<4H%)><% <R3<23%35%@>98>%:2A%:2:BA398:B%;458<==%
35%85D;5=93952:B%
;458<==%@9BB%:B@:A=%C<%D553%35%:%852=96<4:CB<%
8544<=;526=%
<R3<23F%+% J<<BF%<=;<89:BBA%92%3><%:C=<28<%5J%=3452?%<I96<28<%8528<4292?%
:=%9=%3><%8:=<%@93>%:352:B%D7=98H%-5@<I<4%D78>%52<%
D<3>56F%
85D;5=93952:B%
5J%=376A92?%
696%253%>:I<%3><%;49I9B<?<%
3><%J:83%
3>:3%/8>5<2C<4?%
D9?>3%
6<;B54<%
>9=%J94H=3%
)><%/3478374<%
L7=98%:3%3><%39D<%><%85D;5=<6%
;:3>.C4<:O92?%
5J%!352:B%
:%J:83H%
@54O=%
:45726%XZb[F%93%9=F%2<I<43><B<==F%
(<D:4O=%
,528B7692?%
=3:26%
-:I<%:BB%3><%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
65<=%72546<4<6%
^><4<F%
3><2F%
356:Aa%
;938>.8B:==%
4<D:92%
35%C<%652<a%+%>:I<%
C<<2%B:96%35%4<=3a%15<=%253>92?%
2<?:39I<%
5;92952=%
92%
:3%=<I<4:B%
35%3><=<%E7<=3952=%
;5923=%
:B4<:6A%
DA%?<2<4:B%
=7??<=3<6%
4<=;52=<=%
92%:2=@<4%35%3><%J94=3%
5J%3><=<%
3><%J54<?592?%
69=87==952H%L54<%=;<89J98:BBAF%
92%:%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
>:=%C<<2%739B9M<6%
93%9=%8B<:4%3>:3%
:B3>57?>%
E7<=3952=F%
;938>.8B:==%
3><4<%
:4<%3>5=<%
5J%J4793J7B%
5J%69JJ<4<23%
9269I967:B=F%
I:49<3A%
@:A=%CA%:%27DC<4%
93%@>:3=5<I<4F%
J54%
4<:=52=H%
@>5%>:I<%:C=5B73<BA%
25%7=<%J54%
I:4957=%
+J%52<%=<<O=%:%?<2<4:B%
4<:=52%J54%
3><%<R;B9893BA%
>5@<I<4F%
2<?:39I<%
4<=;52=<=F%
3><%
3><4<%
9=%:%3>4<:6%
3>:3%
472=%
:%D9=;<48<;3952%
3>:3%
4<=7B3=%
J45D%
3><DF%
3>457?>%
J:9B74<%35%69=<2?:?<%3><54A%J45D%:2:BA=9=%92%:2% :;;45;49:3<%
@:A%:26%:3%
!%698>535DA%
3>:3%
:4<:%5J%
D5D<23=H%
=<<D=%35%D<%35%C<%C:=98%92%3>9=%
:;;45;49:3<%
D7=98%4<=<:48>F%
+%@9BB%<R;4<==%
92%3><%=9D;B<=3%
9=%3>9=W%L7=98%
:26%52<%3>:3%
3<4D=F%
92%
9=%:C=34:83o%
D7=98%:2:BA=9=%
9=%85284<3<H%
)><%;5@<4%5J%:%3><54A%
4<=96<=%
3><54A%
93=%:C9B93A%
:%?<2<4:B%
@>98>%
:2%:2:BA398:B%
35%;45I96<%
=3:3<D<23%
C:8O?45726%
:?:92=3%
:%4:2?<%
^>9B<%:%3><54A%
5J%=9?29J98:23%
D:A%C<%D<:=74<6H%
D:A%=7??<=3%
:2:BA398:B%
:3%I:4957=%
B
<I<B=%
5
J%
3><%B<I<B%5J%D9273<=3%
=3478374<F%
923<4;4<3:3952=%
928B7692?%
93%D7=3%=39BB%
93=%?<2<4:B93A%
:26%93=%:B55J2<==%
J45D%
6<3:9BF%
;4<=<4I<%
:2A%;:43987B:4%
D7=98:B%<R;4<==952H%
L78>%5J%3><%8493989=D%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
9=%C:=<6%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
5J%3><=<%
3@5%J:8<3=%
5J%3><%=376A%
5J%D7=98:B%=3478374<F%
3><%52<%
7;52%:%852J7=952%
3><%53><4%
#I<2%:3%3><%=9D;B<=3%
B<I<B%
3><%;45?4<==952%
J45D%
3><54<398:BF%
:2:BA398:BH%
35%
>:=%
=
5D<39D<=%
C<<2%
'2<%
4<I9<@<4%
5J%
)
><%
/3478374<%
3><54A% :2:BA=9=%
9?254<6H%
5J%
!352:B%
K)><%_2:D<_%=39BB%
3<BB=%253>92?%
:C573%
L7=98F%J54%
<R:D;B<F%
85D;B:92<6W%
3><%=<3%<R8<;3%
93=%=9M<%:26%93=%;5=93952%
52%:%B9=3H%)>:3K=%:88<;3:CB<%
35%:%85D;73<4F%
.%
3><%6<45?:354A%
'J%8574=<%
4<J<4<28<%
35%K:%85D;73<4K%
;<4>:;=KHVV%
E793<%:=96<%.%
=<3%2:D<=%@<4<%
35%C<%:C=34:83%
:26%2<734:BH%
857B6%
6<=9?2<6%
6<B9C<4:3<BA%
$53>92?%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%

XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vf%

!""#$%

&'()#%

>:I<%C<<2%@54=<%
3>:2%
@93>%
35%>:I<%C746<2<6%
=<3%2:D<=%
5J%;:43987B:4%
6<=849;354=%
=78>%
:
=%92698:3952=%
5J%
=
7C=<3=%
:%=34:3<?A%
:3349C73<=F%
8523:92F%
=;<89:B%
3><A%
D9?>3%
3>:3%
>:=%5J3<2%
C<<2%:65;3<6HV\%
+2%?592?%
J45D%
35%3><%;:43987B:4=%
5J%:2:BA=9=F%
:C=34:83%
3><%:2:BA=3%
D7=3%
3><54A%
6<896<%;4<89=<BA%
>5@%D78>%5J%3><%3><54<398:B%
35%
:
26%
>5@%
35%
:;;:4:37=% :;;BA%
93%
=
5%
93%
3>:3%
J
93=%
3><%
9
DD<69:3<%
D7=98:B%
=937:3952H%
3>9=%
923<4;4<3%
,B<:4BAF% 6<;<26=%
7;52%9269I967:B%P76?<D<23H%+% D9?>3%6<896<%35%=34<==%85D;B<D<23.4<B:3<6%
:=%92%DA%:2:BA=9=%
5J%3><%5;<292?%
5J%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
><R:8>546=F%
';H%XXF%$5H% XF%
=928<%
+
%O25@%
3
>:3%
3>9=%
9=%
J<:374<%
3><%D7=98%
<:4B9<4F%
;4<=<23<6%
9D;543:23%
3>457?>%
92%:%I:49<3A%
5J%@:A=%3>:3%>:I<%35%65%694<83BA%
@93>%3><%=74J:8<%
85D;52<23=H%
!253><4%
=<3%D<3>56=%
@57B6%69=85I<4%
5J%3><%=:D<%
:2:BA=3%
7=92?%
;938>.8B:==%
D:2A%
=3478374<=%
C73%D9?>3%
6<896<%:3%=5D<%;5923%253%35%<D;>:=9=<%
3><%85D;B<D<23%
4<B:3952%
54%35%6<:B%@93>%=<3=%5J%D:?29376<=%
=D:BB<4%3>:2%=9RH%/39BB%:253><4%
.%
.% D9?>3%A9<B6%353:BBA%
I9:%3><%
5
J%3><%KC:=98%8<BBK%
:;;45:8>% =:AF%
8528<;3%
69JJ<4<23%
2
53%
3><%
><R:8>546%
:=%:%=<3%:3%:BBH%)><%
4<=7B3=F%
;<4>:;=% 92I5BI92?%
5J%=78>%K:B3<42:39I<K%
<I:B7:3952%
5J%
:%D:33<4%
J54%
9=F% 8574=<F%
:2:BA=<=F%
;45J<==952:B%
:26%
85?93:3952% P76?D<23H%
+% @57B6%25@%B9O<%35%6<:B%@93>%=5D<%9D;543:23%
4<=967:B%852=96<4:3952=F%
.%
92%
=<3%
D
928B7692?%
;45CB<D=% ;938>.8B:==% :2:BA=9=% 54F% 54<%;4<89=<BAF%
;45CB<D=%
.% :26%;5==9CB<%
4:9=<6%CA%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
2<@%694<83952=F%
92%4<=;52=<%
35%
3><%E7<=3952%
+%4:9=<6%
:C5I<%:=%35%@><3><4%
3><4<%
4<D:92=%
@54O%
35%C<%652<H%
3><%?<2<4:B%
5J%3><%923<4;4<3:3952%
5J%
&94=3F%+%@57B6%B9O<%35%6<:B%@93>%
;45CB<D%
4<=7B3=%
5C3:92<6%
8<43:92%
C:=98%
92%
:2:BA398:B%
CA%;<4J54D92?%
5;<4:3952=% ;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=F%
92%;:43987B:4F%
3><%5;<4:3952%
5J%=<3%96<239J98:3952H%
/<3%96<239J98:3952F%
5J%
=9D;B<%:=%93%:;;<:4=%35%C<F%7=7:BBA%<2?:?<=%:%27DC<4%
D54<%85D;B<R%
92%
3><%
6
5D:92%
5
J%
:2:BA398:B%
6<89=952=F%
;49D:49BA%
=<?D<23:3952W%
3><%6<3<4D92:3952%
5J%3>5=<%D7=98:B%7293=%3>:3%
:4<%35%C<%4<?:46<6%
:=%=3478374:BH%
92%
3><%
=<3%96<239J98:3952%
:26%
:4<%
)>7=F%
:2:BA398:B%;458<==%
=<?D<23:3952%
923<43@92<6H%
k<2<4:B%
4
7B<=%
5
J%
:4<%>:46%
3
5%85D<%
92<I93:CBA%
=<?D<23:3952%
CAF%
C:=<6%7;52%<R;<49<28<%
@93>%3><%D7=98%5J%:%;:43987B:4%
:B3>57?>%
?796<B92<=F%
:4<%:B@:A=%
:I:9B:CB<%
35%3><%>:46<2<6%
85D;5=<4F%
:2:BA=3H%
*<4>:;=%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
:352:B%
D7=98%=39BB%
5JJ<4=%
3><%D5=3%
69JJ987B3%
8:=<=H%
!%C49<J%
J45D%
3><%
J94=3%
B72:94<%
@9BB%=<4I<%
35%9BB7=34:3<%
3>9=%
*9<4453%
<R8<4;3%
;9<8<%5J%
#RH%\C%
:2%
C:=<6%
3
><%
253952%
5J%
C
:=98%
T#RH%\:UH%
;5923%
T;H%\bU%;45I96<=% :2:BA=9=%
7;52%
:%
7293%
@>98>%
=
<4I<=%
9
2%:%D539I98%
:
26%92%53><4%
8<BBF% ;938>.923<4I:B%
8:;:893A%
92%3><%@54O%35%;45I96<%
:26%852392793AHVc%
C:=98%
8:;:8939<=%
7293A%
)>7=F%3><%J94=3%
9=%
3><%
92%
349:6%
3><%
@>98>%
9=%
8<BBF%D:4O<6%
CH8H:F%
:7?D<23<6%
;9:25%852J9?74:3952%
J574%
92%
39D<=%
3
><%
D7=98H%
Q
:=98%
8
<BB%
C
%
9=%
3
><%
5=392:35.B9O<%
4<;<:3<6%
5;<292?%
TCH8HCU%
6A:6%&i.1i%
;B:A<6%CA%3><%I95B92HVf%Q:=98%8<BB=%B:4?<4%3>:2%3><%6A:6%54%
3498>546%
:4<%B:C<BB<6%3<34:6=%
52%#RH%\CH%&54%92=3:28<F%
3><%J94=3%
5J%3><=<F%
3<34:6%
:F%
3><%B:=3%J574%
253<=%92%3><%=<I<2.253<%
85D;49=<=%
;9:25%J9?74<%
Tf.N[UH%^93>%3><%
5J%3><%JB73<%
<234:28<%
92%CH%d%52%!F%C:=98%8<BB%CF%3><%D9254%
9=%25@%657CBA%
3>946F%
@>9B<%3><%=788<==952%
5J%C:=98%8<BB%:% :26%3<34:6%:%
4<;4<=<23<6F%
852=9=392?%
8523927<=%
C<2<:3>%93%92%3><%;9:25%;:43H%)><%3:9B%5J%3><%JB73<%
B92<%92%C=%V.\%
C:=98%8<BB%C%:=% !.&VT.!UH% )><%3498>546%
><4<%9=%C:=98%8<BB%8F%
92854;54:3<=%
V[%

LG/+,%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

!$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

)'1!0%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

*+),-.,"!//%

#RH%\:%

&B:4<H%
k<9?<H%

tV%
YHQ<@55%

.%
]H%
:=<% "%..,r&%
Q<@<?3Tg%
!%

h95B5%
.<BBH3%
H%
=(<93:3952H%

H%HHHHHHHHH%
]]%

/793%1BD;3<4%
X*%

T%

Q#@%

!L%
:D%

+%

+%

]%

]%

D2D93%
1<2%^<92V<2%

<<5U%

+%

]%

]%

B9%

+% h.%

+%

.%

64% L%
.%

_526%

++g"%!Fa_%

^5%
.%

9.%
_+QL%

+HH%
.%

+B+%

+F%

2_>3%

3492O3F% ?9=3%
!2H?2%

kH%

;:%

.%

_%
+9%

RJ<%
s]%

<F%
_9%

+$%

.%

"%LK%
F% _"%

.%

9%

G=<6%CA%;<4D9==952%
5J%Q<BD523%
L7=98%*7CB9=><4=F%
"5=%!2?<B<=F%
ZbbVZ%
,:B9J5429:%

9=%
5J%3>9=%
&743><4%
=<D9352<=H%
4<:692?%
P7=39J98:3952%
:2:BA398:B%
34:2=;5=<6%
7;%<9?>3%
3498>546%
5J%3>9=%
3498>546%
Td.dU%.% 253%3><%B93<4:B%
3A;<%
CA%3><%4<8744<28<%
;45I96<6%
.% 3@98<%92%3><%I95B92%B92<%3>:3%C<?92=%:3%3><%<26%5J%CH%\%52%!cF%@><4<%3><%
92%4<?9=3<4F%
=<4I<=%:=%:2%:R9=%92%3>9=%
J54D%5J%C:=98%8<BB%CF%&i.1iF%
549?92:B%
:%><R:8>546:B%
!=%3><%C:=98%8<BB%:2:BA=9=%
@93>92%
852=34783%
J9?74<H%
=ADD<3498:B%
69JJ987B39<=%
8<43:92%
>5@<I<4F%
C<?92%35%84<<;%92H%)><4<%58874=%:%2<@%
;458<<6=F%
:%92%
35%3<34:6%
@93>%
35%;5=93952F%
92%3><%
3<34:6%
4<=;<83%
;9:25%92%CH%\F%8544<=;52692?F%
CH%$5398<%3>:3%
93%8523:92=%
C:=98%8<BB%:%92%93=%549?92:B%
CH%XH%)>9=%9=%B:C<BB<6%3<34:6%
8H%+3%9=%
J54DF%
:;;<:4=F%B:C<BB<6%3<34:6%
ki.#H%+2%3><%;9:25%92%CH%c%:%2<@%3<34:6%
C:=98%8<BB%8%
=928<%93%8523:92=%
35%3><%;4<I957=%
C:=98%8<BB=F%>5@<I<4F%
8522<83<6%
:=%
3>:3%
3><%3<34:6%
9=%5J%3><%=:D<%3A;<%
T+3%=>57B6%:B=5%C<%5C=<4I<6%
T34:2=;5=<6UH%
5J%C:=98%8<BB%92%I95B92F%C=%\.cF%
J54D=%
3><%3<34:6%
TV.fU%J54D<6%
CA%923<4B58O92?%
52%
:253><4%
3<34:6%
=39BB%
573%92%3><%;4<I957=%
69=87==952HU%
&92:BBAF%
:;;<:4=%
;5923<6%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VZ%

!""#$% &'()#%

#RH%\C%
&BH%
CH8HCt%
h2H%

TCH8HCU%
1i%

9&i%

&i%

*25H% ki%#% ,% X1% QC% ,i%k+ki% #%


Y3<34:6% :%

CH8H:%

&iX%

,+%91% QC% ,i%k%


T3<34:6%

TCH8H:U%

:U%

CH8H8%

CH8HC%

CH8H8%
9CH8HC%

!%

&BH%

&i%

h2H%

1i%

+&i%

!%

1i%

!% 9QC!% &i%

&i%

#% ,% +1% QC% ,i%9k%


*25H% fki%
+ki% #%
T3<34:6%

TCH8H:U%
CH8HC%

:U%

&i%

,% 1% QC% ,i%k%
T3<34:6%

TCH8H:U%
CH8H8%

CH8H:%

1i%

&i%

CH8HC%

:U%

CH8H8%

&BH% !%

,% ,% ,i%Q%&iB%

h2H%

!C%

*25H% ki%&i%!ki%

#%

CH8HC%
"CH8H6%

tCH8H%

k%

#+%

1i%

&i%1%

#% 1i%&% #% &% 1C% ,% 1% QC% ,i%k%

i%

\b%

3<34:6% 6%

1i%

Y%

CH8H8%
3<34:6% C%

3<34:6%C8%8%

D<:2=% C:=98%

3<34:6% :%

8<BB%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

3><%=8<2<F%B:C<BB<6%3<34:6%
92%CH%cH%+3%@9BB%C<%69JJ987B3%
6F%3><%<26%5J%3><%JB73<%
J9?74<%
<
2394<%
D5I<D<23H%
35%J93%
9235%
5J%
3
><%
3><=<%
J<:374<=%
:%85D;B<3<6%
:2:BA=9=%
52%#RH%\CF%C73%
5J%@>98>%
:4<%92698:3<6%
)>9=%C:=98%8<BB%:2:BA=9=F%
53><4%
J<:374<=%
:=%93%?5<=F%C73%93%65<=%253%
:=%J:4%
@9BB%253%C<%69=87==<6F%
9=%<JJ<839I<%
:26%923<4<=392?%
:=%:%@>5B<H%#RH%\8%
J<:374<=%
@>98>%
3><%D5I<D<23%
=>5@%3><%KC:8O?45726K%
?5I<42%

#RH%\8%

&BH%

c.NX%
c.NX%

Yc.NX%
&i% 1i%

h2H%

c.NXf%

c.lVV%

c.MXf%
&i%
&i%

1i%

&i%
C% ,i%k%

*25H% k"% #% ,% 1% QC% i% k%ki#% ,% 1%

c.ldc%
c.ldc%

c.ldc%
!% QC% !% &i%

!%

&BH%
&i%

h2H%

1i%

&i%

&i%

1i%

&i%

ki%#% ,% 1% QC% ,i%k% ki%#% ,% 1% QC% ,i%k%

*25H%

Tc.NXU%

Tc.NXU%

c% lXft%

c.lVd%
&BH% !%

,_,%
!C%

h2H%

k% r&i%

1i%

&i%1%

,i%Q% &im%

8m%

k%
#% i%
!%ki%
*25H% &i%
&9<% &% 1C%,% 1%XC%,i%
1.%

c%d%
k%

&i%

#%
1i1%

c.% d%

c.ld%
c.ld%

c.lXb%

LG/+,%!$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%
XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

tc.lXf% J5BB5@=%
92% JB73<%

\X%

!""#$% &'()#%

35%65%3>:3%
:26%92%3><%
:BB5@=%
J54%
:%=<?D<23:3952%
3>:3%
9=%:%?556%
:33<D;3=%
;458<==%
6<:B%
D54<%
3><%
5J%
3><%
C:=98%
JB<R9CB<%
3>:2%
8<BB%
=<?D<23:3952%
;49D:49BA%
KJ54<?45726K%
)>9=%=<?D<23:3952%
9=%P7=39J9<6%
5J%3><%
35%:2%:2:BA=9=%
<2394<%
:2:BA=9=H%
CA%4<J<4<28<%
92%:%@:A%
+%@9BB%
@>98>%
+3%;458<<6=%
92698:3<%
J743><4%
J45D%
=5D<%
D5I<D<23F%
:B52?H%
5C=<4I:3952=H%
&54%<R:D;B<F%
JB73<%
C:=98%
C53>%
3><%
:26%I95B92%
><R:8>546=%
;4<=<23%
.% :%=3452?%
.% =<3.8B:==%
c.ldc%92%JB73<%
:26%=<3.8B:==%
c.lVd%92%I95B92%
>923%
3>:3%
3><%
><R:8>546%
9=%3><%J726:D<23:B%
92%3>9=%
7293%
D7=98H%
5J%3><%;9:25%
/<?D<23:3952%
65<=%253%
3><%
J5BB5@%
4<=3.6<3<4D92<6%
5J%3><%
C:=98%
8<BB%:2:BA=9=%
J9?74<%
;458<674<%
.%
C
73%
92%
I
9<@%
5J%
3
><%
89487B:4%
2:374<%
5J%
3
><%
B92<%
67<%
3
><%
9DD<69:3<%
3
5%
T#RH%\CUF%
.%
:%
69JJ<4<23%
!B=5%
3><%
92%
#
RH%
\8%
3:O<=%
9235%
4<;<393952=%;<4D93=%
4<:692?H%
:2:BA=9=%
:885723%
3><%
3>:3%
92=347D<23=%
:26%85DC92<%
92%I:4957=%
923<4:83%
9J%
)>7=F% @<%
@:A=H%
4<:6%
3><%
J94=3%
><R:8>546%
J54D<6%
:26%I95B92F%
3>9=%
35%C<%=<3%
c.NXH%
CA%
;9:25%
;45I<=%
)><%=:D<%=<3%8B:==%9=%4<;4<=<23<6%
92%;9:25%:B52<F%
><R:8>546%
:26%
CA%3><%J94=3%
:=%3><%=<8526%
><R:8>546%
J54D<6%
92=347D<23=H%
)><%5;<292?%
:?:92%
CA%3><%3@5%
D7=98%
9=%3><4<J54<%
=:374:3<6%
@93>%
3><%
=5726%
5J%
3>9=%
52<%
3><%
5J%
><R:8>546F%
=;<89:B%
@>5B<.352<K%
><R:8>546=HV[%
-<R:8>546%
c.NX%92%3><%
K:BD5=3%
c.lXf%J5BB5@=%
;9:25%
:=%92698:3<6%
52%3><%<R:D;B<H%
)><%4<B:3952%
C<3@<<2%
3>9=%><R:8>546%
:26%93=%
93%
:
=%
5
8874=%
92%
3><%
I95B92%
B92<%92%C=%\.c%@9BB%
C<%=>5@2%
92%
c.lVdF%
85D;B<D<23F%
8522<83952%
@93>%
#RH%\J%
92%3><%
D7=98%
:%J54D%
5J%c.lVV%
T;H%\\UH%&92:BBAF%
5;<292?%
:%><R:8>546%
@>98>%
:==7D<=%
:2%9D;543:23%
45B<%92%3><%
:;;<:4=F%
=7C=<E7<23BA%
@93>%
93=%
c.l%XZH%
D7=98F%
35?<3><4%
85D;B<D<23F%
!J3<4%
3><%52=<3%
52%3><%=7=3:92<6%
5J%JB73<%
!%TCH%dUF%@>98>%
3><%B92<:4%
C<?92=%
=3:3<D<23%
5J%><R:8>546%
9=%:2%<8>592?%
58874.%
c.ldcF%3><4<%
:885D;:29D<23:B%
4<28<%
5J%3><%=:D<%=<3F%J54D<6%
92=347D<23=H%
)><%=:D<%=<3%4<874=%
CA%:BB%3>4<<%
@93>%
5J%c.ldc%8522<83%
C<?92292?%
QC%92%;9:25%92%CH%VH%-<4<%3><%3@5%J54D=%
D<:2=%
5J%@>:3%@:=%8:BB<6%C:=98%8<BB%8%92%#RH%\CW%3><%3498>546%
<R:83BA%
CA%
+2%3>9=%
3><%
3498>546%
852=96<4:CB<%
C<8:7=<%
93%
:2:BA=9=%
?:92=%
=9?29J98:28<%
&i.!.QCH%
9=%4<:6%
92%3><%
8523<R3%
5J%
:%=<3%
@>98>%
9=%J726:D<23:B%
3><%
D5I<D<23H%
3>457?>573%
)><%7;;<4%
5J%
3><%
92%CH%\%25@%
>:=%
:%85D;B<3<BA%
69JJ<4<23%
;:43%
;9:25%
852J9?74:3952%
+3%
9
=%
:=%c.ldF%3><%
5J%
c.ldcH%)><%4<:692?%
9=%=7;;543<6%
:=;<83H% 4<:6%
85D;B<D<23%
:=%A<3%
52<%=5%K=9D;B<K%
3>:3%
93%D9?>3%
C<%5I<4B55O<6%
54%
CA%:%8493<4952%
72I598<6F%
3:O<2%
J54%
3><%
8493<4952%
5J%4<;<393952H%
+2%3><%
8:=<%5J%/8>5<2C<4?F%
93%8:2%
?4:23<6W%
C<%8B:9D<6%
3>:3%
9=%:%J726:D<23:B%
D7=98:B%
92%:BB%>9=%
=74<BA%
4<;<393952%
;458<==%
253%
92%3><%
5CI957=%
C73%
5J%
3><%
D5=3%
:439=398%
:26%
D7=98F% 4<;<393952%
=<2=<F%
4<;<393952%
=7C3B<%
O926H%-<4<%c.ld%9=%4<;4<=<23<6%
253%52BA%
92%3><%;9:25%B92<%C73%CA%3><%
J54D<6%
:26%3><%
J94=3%
253<%
5J%3><%
I95B92%
=<?D<23%
CA%3><%<2394<%
;9:25%
;:43%
B92<F%
@>98>%
9=%3><%
=:D<%
8B:==%
:=%3><%
J94=3%
253<%
92%3><%
>:26%
5J%
3><%
;938>%
49?>3%
T+2%
;9:25H%
3>9=%
=>543%
+%>:I<%
53><4%
588744<28<=%
5J%
3><%
<R8<4;3%
6<B9C<4:3<BA%
=7;;4<==<6%
D:2A%
C:=98%
><R:8>546=%
92%546<4%
35%:I596%
:2%5I<4BA%
@>98>%
;4<=<2392?%
85D;B<R%
:2:BA=9=%
@57B6%
69I<43%
:33<23952%
J45D%
!=%=>5@2%
52%3><%
?<2<4:B%
9==7<=HU%
<R:D;B<%
T#RH%\8UF%

c.ld%9=%4<;4<=<23<6%
3@98<%
D54<H%
!=%c.lVd%9=%85D;B<3<6%
92%3><%I95B92%
93=%85D;B<D<23F%
:=%:%
58874=%
;:43F%
c.lNXfF%
J54D<6%
=<?D<23%
CA%:BB%3><%92=347D<23=H%
g7=3%C<J54<%
3>9=F%><R:8>546%
c.lXb%
:=%3><%
J94=3%
><R:8>546%
92%3><%
>:26%5J%3><%
3>9=%
9=%:%
:;;<:4=%
49?>3%
;9:25F%CH%cH%!?:92F%
.% @93>%
><R:8>546%
3><%
J7283952=%
5J%@>98>%
35%93=%85D;B<D<23%
:=%@<BB%:=%35%
4<=;<83%
\N%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\K%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

.% C<85D<%
3><%
53><4%
92%3><%
D5I<D<23%
><R:8>546=%
8B<:4%
92%3><%
D7=98H%
=7C=<E7<23%
^><4<:=%3><%C:=98%8<BB%:2:BA=9=%
=>5@2%92%#RH%\C%@:=%6<I<B5;<6%92%:%B9?>3.%
3><%:2:BA=9=%
:26%K8523<R37:BK%
=>5@2%
92%#RH%\8%9=%
><:43<6F%
D:22<4F%
=;523:2<57=%
:C573%:=%=;523:2<57=%
92%@>98>%
:=%:%855O92?%
B<==52%52%3<B<I9=952F%
3><%92=3478354%
3><%
:26%85DC92:3952=F%
J7BB%
@<BB%
3>:3%
3><%
=>5@=F%
=3<;%
CA%=3<;F%
92?4<69<23=%
O25@92?%
92%
69=>%
9=%
3
><%
5I<2%
35%
:26%
C
<%
:3%
3
><%
<26%
5
J%
3><%
85D;B<3<6%
=:J<BA%
4<:6A% ;>535?4:;><6%
+2%
:
%
=9D9B:4%
3><%
92%
#
RH%
5J%
3
><%
=<3=%
9
=%
8
52693952<6%
\8%
;45?4:DD<H%
@:AF% 4<:692?%
CA%:%
6<3:9B<6%
5J%
3><%
<2394<%
5J%
@>98>%
92%
3>9=%
85D;B<3<6%
:2:BA=9=%
D5I<D<23F%
;4<=<23:3952%
@57B6%
D
5=3%
4<=7B3%
92%
+%@9BB%
D
:==9I<%
=<3392?%
8<43:92BA%
9269?<=3952H%
=:AF%>5@<I<4F%
3>:3%
3><%D5I<D<23%
.% 253%:2%92=9?29J98:23%
9=%C:=<6%7;52%<R:83BA%
=9R%><R:8>546=%
27DC<4%
92%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
8:=<%.% 35?<3><4%
@93>%
3><94%
'J%3><=<F%
85D;B<D<23=HVZ%
3@5%
5J%
3><%
D5=3%
:4<%
92%
3
><%
3><%
D7=98W%
K:BD5=3%
@>5B<.352<K%
9D;543:23% ?9I<2%
5;<292?%
><R:8>546%
c.NX%:26%3><%K:BD5=3%
8>45D:398K%
><R:8>546=%
c.ld%:26%c.ldcH%)><%
=9R3>%
c.l%
2
53%
65<=%
7
239B%
CH%[F%@><4<%
93%9=%3><%
><R:8>546F% XdF%92896<23:BBAF%
:;;<:4%
C:=9=%5J%3><%8:252%3><4<H%!=%@9BB%C<%5CI957=%25@F%=<?D<23:3952%
92%#RH%\8%9=%
6<3<4D92<6%CA%4<;<:3<6%588744<28<=%5J%3><=<%=9R%J726:D<23:B%
=3452?BA%
><R:8>546=H%!% =<?D<23:3952%
5J%3>9=%O926F%@>98>%=<<D=%35%C<% <=;<89:BBA%
92%
3><%
8
:=<%5J%
:352:B%D7=98F%C73%D:A%C<%:;;B98:CB<%
:;;45;49:3<%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
C<%3<4D<6%
:%
:=%69=39283%
J45D%
3><%
<B=<@><4<F%
D:A%
K35;.65@2K%=<?D<23:3952F%
9BB7=34:3<6%
\
CH%
KC5335D.7;K%
=<?D<23:3952%
CA%#R:D;B<%
+3%=>57B6%C<%8B<:4%3>:3%3><%3@5%3A;<=%5J%=<?D<23:3952%
:4<%253%D737:BBA%
<R8B7=9I<H%#RH%\6%9BB7=34:3<=%
3>9=W%^>:3%@:=%8:BB<6%3<34:6%
:%92%3><%C:=98%8<BB%
#RH%\6%
h2H%
*25H%

9%

&i%

1i%

&i%

&i%

ki%#% ,% 1% QC% ,i%k% ki%#%


VV.K%

YV.X[%
V.X[%

92%#RH%\6%:=%=<3%V.X[F%3><%;49D<%
J54D%
5J%@>98>%
9=%
:2:BA=9=%
T#RH%\CU%9=%96<239J9<6%
$
53%
6
5<=%
V.X[%58874%
9
2%
3><%
>
549M523:B%
9
3%
jbFXFVFfmH%
52BA%
;B:2<%><4<F%C73% 9=%:B=5%
J54D<6%
:=%:%=<?D<23%
CA%;9:25%:26%I95B92%85DC92<6H%!=%=>5@2%92%#RH%\6F%93%
:B=5%58874=%:%3>946%
CH% X%:26%CH%NH%
39D<F%:?:92%92%3><%>549M523:B%
;B:2<F%B92O92?%
)><%53><4%:=;<83%5J%3<34:8>546:B%
9
2%#RH%\6%9=%3><%
=>5@2%
67:B%
54?:29M:3952%
588744<28<%
5J%=<3%V.NVF%3@5%34:2=;5=93952:BBA.4<B:3<6%
J54D=%
@>98>%=>:4<%C:=98%
8<BB%:F%3><%K:7?D<23<6%
349:6KH%)>9=%3<34:8>546%
9=%;45D92<23%
3><%
3>457?>573%
J54%
92%
CH%
93%
@
><4<%
=<3=%
3
><%3<R3%
@546%K-549M523KF%:%C93%
D5I<D<23F% <R:D;B<%
XbF%
5J%@546%;:92392?%
@>98>%<R;B593=%
3><%=ADD<3498%
:26%=3:CB<%;45;<439<=%
5J%3><%
@>5B<.352<%
3<34:8>546H%
#RH%\<%;45I96<=%
:%J743><4%
4<J92<D<23%
5J%3><%3<34:8>546:B%
92%#RH%\6F%
:2:BA=9=%
3><%34<:3D<23%
5J%9269I967:B%
8B:==<=%
@
>98>%
@57B6%
C
<%<==<239:B%
:;;45:8>92?%
;938>%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

\d%

!""#$% &'()#%

35%:%4<B:39I<BA%
)>9=%<R:D;B<%
J587=<=%
3><%
:2:BA=9=H%
7;52%CH% XF%9?25492?%
85D;B<3<%
<B:C54:3<%
=3478374<=%
5J%3><%;4<I957=%
+3%69I96<=%3><%
5I<4B:;;92?%
=<?D<23:3952=H%

=<I<2.253<%
9235%
3@5%
3><%
J94=3%
:26%3><%
1%92%3><%
B:=3F%
3498>546=F%
;9:25%
B<:I92?%
J9?74<%

:%=ADD<3498%
@>98>%
93%5887;9<6%92%3><%3<34:8>546:B%
92%
D966B<F%
:2:BA=9=%
;5=93952%
#RH%\6%:=%@<BBH%+2%3>9=%4<:692?F%
1%9=%8522<83<6%
35%3><%4>A3>D98:BBA%
=ADD<3498%
C:=98%8<BB%C%T3>:3%9=F%4>A3>D98:BBA%
@93>%4<=;<83%
35%3><%
85D;52<23%
=ADD<3498%
=<I<2.253<%
35%J54D%
C:=98%8<BB%8H%)>9=%69I9=952%
5J%3><%=<I<2.253<%
;9:25%J9?74<U%
4<I<:B=%C:=98%8<BB%:%:?:92%92%85234:=3%
35%C:=98%8<BB%CH%-<4<%93%9=%
;9:25%J9?74<%
:%K69D929=><6%
5J%=<3%8B:==%
:%4<;4<=<23:39I<%
3@98<F%
349:6KF%
4<;4<=<23<6%
C<85D92?%
5J%72546<4<6%
=<3%3><54AH%
d.XbF%35%7=<%3><%P:4?52%
;938>.8B:==%
#RH%\<%

h2H%
*25H+ki%

X%..h%
#%

CH8H:%
Td.XNU%

,%

1%

QC% ,i% k%

CH8H8%
Td.dU%

CH8HC% TNRU%
Td.XbU%

+2%3><%J92:B%
#RH%\JF%8544<=;526<28<=%
C<3@<<2%
l.4<B:3<6%
><R:8>546=%
<R:D;B<F%
:4<%69=;B:A<6%92%6<D52=34:3952%
5J%3><%=9?29J98:28<%
3>:3%=78>%4<B:3952=%
D:A%
.% C73%65%253%2<8<==:49BA%
.% :3%3><%B<I<B%5J%6<3:9BH%#R:83%
<R>9C93%
<R>9C93%
:B@:A=%
:4<%92698:3<6%
:445@=%
3>:3%P592%
;938>.8B:==%
8544<=;526<28<=%
CA%657CB<.><:6<6%
3><%3@5%6A:6=H%)>7=F%3><%3@5%l.8544<=;526<23=%
:4<%:==589:3<6%=3452?BA%
CA%
923<4I:B%
8B:==<=%X%:26%NH%+23<4I:B%
8B:==%d%92%c.lVd%9=%D:38><6F%
253%CA%:2%
>5@<I<4F%
:6P:8<28A%92% c.lXfF% C73% CA%3><%252.85239?757=%
,i%:26% #H% Q:=98% 8<BB%
3><%KD:P54%3>946K%
J45D%
C:=98%8<BB%:%:26%3><%KD9254%
3>946K%
5J%C:=98%
85D;52<23=F%
8<BB%CF%:4<%=>5@2%
52%3><%<R:D;B<%
:=%@<BBH%
+2%8528B7=952F%
+%<R;4<==%
3>:3%
93%9=%253%;5==9CB<%><4<%35%85I<4%:BB%3><%
DA%4<?4<3%
3>:3%
85D<%35%D926%92%8522<83952%
@93>%
3><%?<2<4:B%
=7C35;98=%
35;98F%K*938>.8B:==%
/<3%!2:BA=9=%
5J%K:74:B%4<B<I:28<KF%
@>98>%
9=%
)56:AKH%)><=<%928B76<%3><%E7<=3952%
.%
D:33<4%5J%<:4.34:9292?%
8B5=<BA%:==589:3<6%@93>%3><%9D;543:23%
;<6:?5?A%
92%3><%
8:=<%5J%<:4BA%
:352:B%
@93>%
93=%
<=;<89:BBA%
9D;543:23%
D7=98F%
3@<239<3>.8<2374A%
498>%>:4D5298%
:26%923498:3<%
5J%@>98>%3><%D7=98%5J%
I58:C7B:4A%
=3478374<=F%
9=%=74<BA%
3><%D5=3%
/8>5<2C<4?%
85D;B<R%
4<;4<=<23:3952H%
+%@57B6%B9O<%35%=:A%:%@546F%>5@<I<4F%
:C573%J7374<%
J54%
3><%7=<%:26%
;45=;<83=%
5J%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=H%
6<I<B5;D<23%
&94=3F%:%4<8<23%
3<8>25B5?98:B%
6<I<B5;.%
D<23%5JJ<4=%
J54%4<=<:48>H%
+%=;<:O%5J%3><%:6I<23%
5J%3><%
923<4<=392?%
;5==9C9B939<=%
@>98>%4<26<4=%85D;73:3952:B%
J:89B939<=%
:88<==9CB<%35%:2A%
D984585D;73<4F%
=8>5B:4%
@>5%9=%923<4<=3<6%
<257?>%35%B<:42%>5@%35%7=<%3><DH%L:2A%:=;<83=%5J%
852=96<4:CB<%
5J%3><%<R9=3<28<%
5J%
:2:BA=9=%
D:A%726<4?5%
6<I<B5;D<23%
CA%I9437<%
3>9=%
:26%93=%923<4:839I<%
'2<%8:2%<2I9=952F%
J54%
:%
3<8>25B5?A%
8:;:C9B939<=H%
<R:D;B<F%

\V%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

#RH%\J%

V.%

k<9?<H%
h95B5:<<BBH%
(<=93:3952H%

PD93% 1D;3J<4%

#%

1.H%

/Q<@<?3%
:=<=U%
Tg%
Q@%

S9:I9<4H%

T%

1<2% ^<92:6<2%
D:2D93%

U%

!2H?<2%3492O3F%

?9<B3%

;;%
5%

VXWt%
b%
3`.%
/%

2:,>3<%
6<X4o%

L526%

9%

5%

?<2%:<.%

ZbbVZ%
,:B9J5429:%
"5=%!2?<B<=F%
L7=98%*7CB9=><4=F%
G=<6%CA%;<4D9==952%
5J%Q<BD523%

98d%
c.lXf% 92% ;9:25%
C=% X.NW%

98N%

989%
,i% k%

ki% #%

,%

1%

CH8H:%
c.lVd% 92% I95B92%

C=%\.cW%

CH8HC%

CH8H:%

Y%
,%
&i%1%
C% kF% &i%1iX%

98B%

98d%

,i.#% T98dU%

98N%
8544<=;526=%

35% &i.1i% TCH8HCU%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%
XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

\\%

!""#$%

&'()#%

@93>%
:439J989:B%
:2:BA=<4%
;5@<4J7B%
=<3.85D;B<R%
923<BB9?<28<%
:=;<83=H%/<8526F%3><4<%
4<D:92%
35%C<%92I<=39?:3<6%
D54<%
:26%923<4<=392?%
=78>%:=%
D:2A%
?<2<4:B%
E7<=3952=F%
3><%6<J9293952%
5J%K8<2349893AK%
3><%:352:B%D7=98%5J%3><%h9<22<=<%
92F%J54%
<R:D;B<F%
8B:==989=3=H%
3><4<%
9=%D78>%D7=98%=39BB%
35%C<%=3769<6%
=<3%
&92:BBAF%
;938>.8B:==%
7=92?%
D<3>56=H%
)@5%4<;<43549<=%
85D<%35%D926W%TXU%3><%34:2=93952:B%
D7=98%5J%3><%B:3<%
XZ3>%
:%4<;<4354A%
35%@>98>%
+%4<J<44<6%
:3%3><%C<?92292?%
5J%3>9=%
8<2374AF%
;:;<4F%:26%
D7=98%3>:3%
4<8<23%
C<%=3769<6%
92%:%J4793J7B%
=<3=%
TNU%D54<%
D9?>3%
@:A%I9:%;938>.8B:==%
:26%4<B:3952=H%
$')#/%
XH%L:33><@%
K,52J<4<28<%
L7=98%!2:BA=9=F%
h5BH%dF%$5H%XF%L:48>%XZ[VF%
Q45@2F%
(<;543KF%

52%3><%/9R3>%
!227:B%
5J%3><%/589<3A%
J54%
L7=98%
;;H%ZX.\H%+2%3>9=%
4<;543%
L<<392?%
:3%0:B<%T$5I<DC<4F%
@493<=%
5J%3><%K?4<:3%
92%
)><54A%
XZ[dUF%3><%:73>54%
69I<4=93A%

3><2%
KH% H%H%3><4<%
@:=%852=96<4:CB<%
92%
=7CP<83%
D:33<4KF%
?5<=%52%35%=:A%3>:3%
852J54D93A%
.% 35%=5D<%6<?4<<%
D<3>56%
54%53><4F%
3><%I:=3%D:P5493A%
5J%;:;<4=%
64<@%7;52%&543<K=%
5J%72546<4<6%
=<3=%:26%/8><2O<4K=%
5J%352:B93AKH%
3><54A%
3><54A%
NH% !BB<2%&543<F%)><%/3478374<%
L7=98%T$<@%-:I<2W%0:B<%G29I<4=93A%
5J%!352:B%
*4<==F%
XZfdUH%+6<DHF%)><%-:4D5298%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?%
T$<@%-:I<2W%0:B<%
*4<==F%XZf[UH%
G29I<4=93A%
dH%^:BB:8<%Q<44AF%
/3478374:B%
&7283952=%
92%L7=98%T#2?B<@556%,B9JJ=W%
*4<2398<.-:BBF%
XZfcUH%
VH% g52:3>:2%
92%3><%L7=98%5J%#6?:46%h:4<=<KF%L7=98%)><54A%
Q<42:46F%
K*938>Y(<?9=3<4%
h5BH%
X.N\H%
/;<8347DF% dF%XZ[XF%;;H%
\H% ,>49=35;><4%
:26%*458<==%
92%*5=3.)52:B%
-:=3AF%
K/<?D<23:3952%
L7=98KF%L7=98%)><54A%
h5BH%dF%XZ[XF%;;H%\V.fdH%
/;<8347DF%
cH% 157?B:=%g:4D:2F%
)><%L7=98%5J%!BC:2%Q<4?%TQ<4O<B<AW%G29I<4=93A%
5J%,:B9J5429:%
*4<==F%XZfZUH%
fH% (<92>5B6%Q492OD:22F%
!425B6%
M74%
14<9%SB:I9<4=3998O<%
';H% XXW%/3769<2%
/8>c2C<4?W%
!352:B93:3%
C<9%/8>52C<4?%
J499><2%
T^9<=C:6<2W%&4:2M%/3<92<4F%XZcZUF%;H%Z[W%K1:=%
:BB<%k<=3:B3<2%
:7=%<92<D%S<42%M7%<23@98O<B2F%
J926<3%
:78>%92%69<=<D%
h<4J:>4<2F%
:BB<4%!CB<9372?<2%
9=3%6<4%#4cJJ272?=:C=8>2933%
!2@<2672?H%
!7=?:2?=;72O3%
/3398O%
D93%=<92<2%M@<9%?B<98>%:D% Q<?922%<R;529<43<2%
)><D<2%CM@H% L539I<2F%69<%
723<4<92:26<4%
@9<6<4%
D93%
:%CM@H%C%C<M<98>2<3HK%
<2?<2%S522<R%>:C<2H%/9<%Dc?<2%
[H% 1:I96%"5<CF%K!2%!2:BA398%
5J%g:;:2<=<%
S535%L7=98KF%)><%L7=98%
h5BH%
/376A%
&547DF%
+hF%XZfcF%;;H%dd\.Z\H%
ZH% *:7B%&H%^9B=52F%K!352:B93A%
:26%/3478374<%
92%^54O=%
5J%Q<B:%Q:43cOK=%
L966B<%*<4956K%
*>H1H%69==<43:3952F%
LH%Q:O<4%T=<<%2H%N\%C<B5@UH%
T0:B<%G29I<4=93AW%
XZ[NUF%:26%g:D<=%
XbH%L:43>:%LH% -A6<F%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
)@<BI<.)52<%
)><%/793<%';H%NZ%:26%3><%
-:4D52AW%
/O<38><=%
GL+%(<=<:48>%
,5D;5=93952:B%
T!22%!4C54W%
*4<==F%XZ[NUF%;H% XXH%
XXH%!425B6%/8>5<2C<4?F%
@93>%
)@<BI<%)52<=%TXUKF%92%/3AB<%
:26%+6<:F%<6H%
K,5D;5=93952%
"<52:46% /3<92%T$<@% 054OW% /3% L:4392=%*4<==F%XZf\UF% :26% ,B:7695% /;9<=F%
Y%XN)S%Y%*4928<352KF%
Kh5434:?%
*<4=;<839I<=%
5J%$<@%L7=98F%h5BH%XdF%$5H% XF%&:BB%.%

^923<4%
XZfVF%
;;H%\[.XdcH%

XNH%g<JJ%
K*938>.,B:==%
/<3%/3478374<=%
92%,523<D;54:4A%
*4<==92?F%
g:MMKF%
g:MM%&54=8>72?F%
h5BH%XVH%
XdH%!B:2%,>:;D:2F%K,45==92?%3><%,7=;W%)><%/8>5<2C<4?%
S743%^<9BB%
,522<83952KF%
5J%0:B<%G29I<4=93A%
:26%3><%S743%
,52J<4<28<F%
=;52=54<6%
CA%)><%L7=98%"9C4:4A%
^<9BB%&5726:3952%
J54%
N.\%$5I<DC<4%
XZ[dH%
L7=98F%$<@%-:I<2F%,522<839873F%

\c%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%VWXYNF%
XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

*+),-.,"!//%

/#)% !$!"0/+/%

)'1!0%

XVH%*:7B%^9B=52F%
5;H%893HF%;H%9H%
X\H%*>9B9;%(7==5DF%K/3478374:B%
92%^54O=%
"<I<B=%92%*5=3.)52:B%
L7=98%:=%#R<D;B9J9<6%
0:B<%G29I<4=93AH%
CA%L:7498<%(:I<BKF%19==<43:3952.92.;45?4<==F%
XcH%g:2<3%
^5MM<8OW%
-:4D5298%
:26%14:D:398%
/8>D:BJ<B63F%
Q<4?K=%
T$<@%
":2?7:?<%
1<=9?2%
-:I<2W%0:B<%G29I<4=93A%
*4<==F%XZ[dUH%
XfH% 157?B:=%g:4D:2F%
)9D<=%
Nb%g:27:4A%
XZ[VF%;H%\cH%
"93<4:4A%
/7;;B<D<23F%
X[H% /8>D:BJ<B63F%
5;H%893HF%;H% XNXH%
XZH%(98>:46%*:4O=F%K*938>%'4?:29M:3952%
92%1<C7==AW%G2546<4<6%
/<3=%92%Q4579BB:46=KF%
L7=98%)><54A%
h5BH%NF%XZ[bF%;;H%XXZ.dVW%;H% XdVH%
/;<8347DF%
NbH% (98>:46%):47=O92F%(<I9<@%5J%)><%-:4D5298%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?F%
,744<23%
$5H%N[F%XZfZF%;;H%XXV.NZH%
L7=985B5?AF%
NXH% +C96HF%;H% XNdH%
NNH%):47=O92%
54%D9=B<:692?%
9=%92:8874:3<%
@><2%><%=3:3<=W%K-<%J926=%
3><%8>546%D:4O<6%
@93>%
92%#R:D;B<%d%_:25D:B57=_%:26%B<3=%93%?5%:3%3>:3K%
:2%:445@%
T9C96HF%;H%XNdUH%^>:3%
+%@453<%
@:=W%K/<3%V.[%4<D:92=%
=5D<@>:3%
:25D:B57=%
><4<%C<8:7=<%93%65<=%253%J93%
9235%
3><%=9D9B:493A%
=8><D<%j@>98>%>:6%C<<2%69=87==<6mF%C73%93=%4<B:3952%35%\.c%
-:4D5298%
H%H%H%F%;H%\ZUH%
TD<23952<6%
T&543<F%
:C5I<U%@9BB%C<%4<8:BB<6K%
'4?:29M:3952%
NdH%+3%=>57B6%C<%;5923<6%
573%3>:3%
25@><4<%
92%)><%-:4D5298%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%(93<%5J%
9=%93%=3:3<6%
9=%:352:BH%
3>:3%
3><%@54O%
/;492?%
NVH%(5C<43%,4:J3F%
K,4:J3%
52%&543<KF%)><%L7=98:B%p7:43<4BAF%
h5BH%cVF%$5H%VF%'835C<4%
\NV.d\H%
XZf[F%;;H%
N\H% g:D<=%LH% Q:O<4F%K/8><2O<49:2%
5J%
!2:BA=9=%:26%*5=3.)52:B%L7=98K%92%!=;<83=%
/8><2O<49:2%
<6H%1:I96%Q<:8>%T$<@%-:I<2W%0:B<%G29I<4=93A%
*4<==F%XZ[dUF%
)><54AF%
;H% XfZH%
NcH% !BB<2%&543<F%K!%)><54A%
5J%/<3%,5D;B<R<=%
J54%
L7=98%)><54AF%
h5BH%
5J%
L7=98KFg5742:B%
fF%$5H%NF%&:BB.^923<4%
XZcVF%;;H%Xdc.[dH%
NfH% )><%3>4<<%
5J%)><%/3478374<%
4<I9<@=%
L7=98%35%@>98>%+%4<J<4%
:4<W%^9BB9:D%
5J%!352:B%
Q<2P:D92K=%92%*<4=;<839I<=%
5J%$<@%L7=98F%h5BH% XdF%$5H% XF%&:BB.^923<4%XZfVo%
(98>D526%Q45@2<K=%92%g5742:B%5J%L7=98%)><54AF%
h5BH% X[F%$5H% NF%&:BB% XZfVF%
92%*<4=;<839I<=%
;;H%dZb.VX\o%#498%(<?<2<4K=%
5J%$<@%L7=98F%h5BH%XdF%$5H% XF%&:BB.%
^923<4%
XZfVF%;;H%XZX.NXNH%
N[H% k<54?<%*<4B<F%,5DD7298:3952=%
=<83952%5J%g5742:B%
!D<498:2%
5J%3><%
L7=985B5?98:B%
h5BH%d\F%$5H%NF%/7DD<4%
XZ[NF%;;H%dfd.fH%
/589<3AF%
NZH% /<<%!BB<2%&543<F%K-:4D5298%/A23:R%:26%h598<%"<:692?%92%/34:I92=OAK=%
#:4BA%
L7=98K%92%/34:I92=OAW%
,<23<229:B%
*:=B<4%TQ<4O<B<AW%
5J%
#==:A=F%<6H%g:22%
G29I<4=93A%
,:B9J5429:%
*4<==F%XZ[\UH%
dbH%)><%45@%><R:6=%
:4<%c.lVc%:26%93=%85D;B<D<23F%
c.lNVH%/<<%g:2%
L:<?::46F%
K/8>c2.%
19<%
C<4?=%
NZF%-<J3%
VF%XZfcF%;;H%d[\.%VNVH%
g>4?H%
l@c5BJ3524<9><2KF%L7=9OJ54=8>72?F%
3:O<=%
3>9=%
35%C<%3><%D:92%
45@%:26%4<J<4=%
35%3@5%I:49:23=F%
>9=%$5=%[c%:26%[f%
L:<?::46%
>:I<%3><%=:D<%72546<4<6%
><R:8>546:B%
T;H%d[ZF%9C96HUF%C53>%5J%@>98>%
8523<23F%
I9MHF%
c.lVZYc.lN[H%
dXH% 157?B:=%g:4D:2F%
(<I9<@%5J%g:2<3%
L7=98%u% "<33<4=F%
h5BH%c\F%
/8>D:BJ<B63F%
5;H%893HF%
$5H%dF%g7BA%
35%K4<8<23g!L/%
XZ[VF%;;H%NZV.cH%'2%;H%NZ\%><%4<J<4=%
<R8>:2?<=KF%
CA%
@>98>%
><%:;;:4<23BA%
D<:2=%k<54?<%
*<4B<K=%85DD7298:3952%
92%4<=;52=<%
35%L:43>:%
5J%>9=%C55O%T=<<%2H%N[UH%
-A6<K=%4<I9<@%
dNH%(98>:46%/@9J3F%
K/5D<%!=;<83=%5J%!??4<?:3<%
,5D;5=93952KF%
*<4=;<839I<=%
5J%$<@%
XZfcY&:BB.^923<4%
L7=98F%/;492?./7DD<4%
XZfcF%;;H%Ndc.V[H%
ddH%1<229=%,5BB92=F%
(<I9<@%
5J%)><%
/3478374<%
(<I7<%6<%L7=985B5?9<F%
h5BH%
5J!352:B%
L7=98F%
6<%8<33<%;9u8<%<=3%72<%
cXF%$5H% XF%XZf\F%;;H%XVd.\W%KH%HH% :B54=%E7<%B<%J526<D<23%
LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

\f%

!""#$%

&'()#%

H%H%HK%T;H%XVVUH%
6<%39DC4<=%
:DC9?793<%
6<%B:%_1:2=<% =:84:B<_F%57K%8<33<%
dVH%+C96HF%;H% XVVW%KL<D<%:345;>9<%6<%B:%;:4393952%
<
=3%
6<%
3573<%
=3478374<%
<I96<28<F%
;:4%B<%4A3>D<KH%
?B5C:B<% :==74<<F%
)><%$<@%k45I<%
d\H% k<54?<%*<4B<F%*:7B%":2=OAF%K!352:B93AKF%
1983952:4A%
5J%L7=98%:26%
h5BH%XF%;H%cfdH%
L7=989:2=F%
dcH%!425B6%
(<I9<@%5J%)><%/3478374<%
$5H% XbZF%g72<%
^>933:BBF%
L7=98F%)<D;5F%
5J%!352:B%
XZfVF%;;H%VX.dH%
dfH% g9D%/:D=52F%K/8>5<2C<4?K=%_!352:B_%L7=98KF% )<D;5F%$5H% XbZF%g72<%XZfVF%
;;H%Xc.N\H%
d[H%^9BB%'?652F%K-5@%)52:B93A%&7283952=%92%/8>5<2C<4?K=%
';7=%XXF%$7DC<4%XKF%
h5BH%\F%$5H%NF%$5I<DC<4%
!425B6%
+2=39373<F%
XZ[XF%;;H%XcZ.%
g5742:B%
5J%3><%
/8>5<2C<4?%
[XW%;H% XcZH%
dZH%/<<% k<54?<%*<4B<F%/<49:B%,5D;5=93952%
:26%!352:B93A%
5J%
TQ<4O<B<AW%G29I<4=93A%
,:B9J5429:%*4<==F%XZcNUF%;;H%Xb.XcF%:26%!BB<2%&543<F%K/<3=%:26%$52=<3=%92%
!352:B%L7=98KF%*<4=;<839I<=%
/8>5<2C<4?K=%
5J%$<@%L7=98F%h5BH% XXF%$5H% NF%&:BB.%
^923<4%
XZfNF%;;H%Vd.cVH%
VbH% '?652F%5;H%893HF%
;H% XfbH%
VXH% !23>52A%
1<8H% XZfZF%
L9B2<4F%KQ53:29M92?%52%D7=98KF%(<8546=%:26%(<854692?=F%
5J%)><%-:4D5298%
(93<%5J/;492?F%
@93>%
;;H%XN[.ZF%:%4<I9<@%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%
D:2A%
4<J<4<28<=%
35%)><%/3478374<%
L
7=98H%!=%
J54%
!352:B%
3
>9=%
5J%
;<2:28<%
923<D;<4:3<%
+%=7??<=3%
3>:3%L4%L9B2<4%C<%4<E794<6%
35%D<D549=<%
!4398B<%
573C74=3F%
p7:349<D<F%
"9I4<%*4<D9<4%
5J%(:D<:7K=%)4:93<%
6<%"K-:4D529<%
:%=<=%
(<6793<%
-7939<D<F%
,>:;934<%
$:374<B=%
T*:49=W%XfNNUF%K1<% BK!88546%6<%B:%/<;39<D<%H%H% HKF%:2%<D92<23%
*49289;<=%
852349C73952%
35%3><%:289<23%
:26%>52574:CB<%
5J%?5CCB<6<?55O%
92%D7=98%
34:693952%
3><54AH%
VNH%!3%3><%<26%5J%>9=%I93495B98%
L4%L9B2<4%
=3:3<=W%
J:I574:CB<%
4<I9<@F%
K*<4>:;=%3><%D5=3%
85DD<23%
3>:3%8:2%C<%D:6<%52%3><%C55O%9=%3>:3%93%=<4I<=%:=%3><%D5=3%85D;<BB92?%
3><%7=<%5J%85D;73<4=%
92%D7=98:B%
3>:3%
>:=%A<3%:;;<:4<6KH%
:4?7D<23%
:?:92=3%
:2:BA=9=%
-<%4<J<4=%
35%)><%-:4D5298%
'4?:29M:3952%
5J%)><%(93<%5J%/;492?H%+2%;5923%5J%J:83F%
+%>:I<%@4933<2%
92%8522<83952%
@93>%:2:BA398:B%
:B3>57?>%
D:2A%85D;73<4%
;45?4:D=%
:26%3><54<398:B%
3>:3%
C55O%@:=%<R<873<6%
=:I<%J54%
=3769<=F%
<2394<BA%
CA%>:26%D<3>56=F%
:2%<B<83498%
:
%
:26%
<B<83498%
<4:=<4H%
3A;<@493<4% >9?>.3<8>%
VdH% !252AD57=%
4<I9<@%
5J%)><%/3478374<%
[%
L7=98F%)9D<=%
5J%!352:B%
"93<4:4A%
/7;;B<D<23F%
L:48>%XZfVH%
VVH% (98>D526%
Q45@2<F%
5;H%893H%T2H%NfUF%;H%VbcH%
V\H% /<<F%J54%
)><%L7=98%5J%
!BC:2%Q<4?F%
V.XZ%9=%
<R:D;B<F%
157?B:=%g:4D:2F%
;H%\VF%@><4<%
6<=849C<6%
:=%K:%D9254%
@93>%
:2%:66<6%D:P54%=<I<23>KH%
349:6%
VcH%)><%253952%
5J%KC:=98%8<BBK%9=F%5J%8574=<F%k<54?<%*<4B<K=H%/<<%>9=%/<49:B%,5D;5=93952%
:26%!352:B93AF%
;;H%Z.XbH%
VfH% +%>:I<%5D933<6%
3><%
J45D%
3><%
93=%;938><6%
253:3952%
+JF%>5@<I<4F%
/;4<8>=39DD<%
:2:BA=9=H%
9=%3:O<2%
:3%J:8<%I:B7<F%3><2%
93%J93=%
9235%3><%;938>.8B:==%
=<3%:2:BA=9=%
@93>573%
69JJ987B3A%
.% 926<<6F%=7;;543=%
93%.% ><4<%:26%3>457?>573%
3><%@54OH%
V[H% /<3%c.dVF%3><%^5MM<8O%><R:8>546F%
9=%:253><4%
K:BD5=3%
@>5B<.352<K%
><R:8>546H%
/<3%
c.NX%9=%3><%
3><D:398%
92%
><R:8>546%
5;<292?%
Q<4?K=%/3492?%
p7:43<3F%
';H%d%TXZbZ.XbUH%
VZH%)><=<%><R:8>546=%
:4<W%c.ldYc.ldcF%c.lXbYc.ldZF%c.lXdYc.lVNF%c.lXfYc.lVdF%
c.NXF%c.lXZYc.lVVH%'2BA%c.NX%9=%93=%5@2%85D;B<D<23H%

\[%

LG/+,% !$!"0/+/%

This content downloaded on Sun, 23 Dec 2012 19:04:21 PM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VWXYNF%XZ[\%

Potrebbero piacerti anche